Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / 274: How to Write so Busy People Respond. Todd Rogers
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to speak like a CEO, my name's Oliver Ostam here to help you become a top 1% communicator.
- 0:05Have you ever sent an important email and got nothing in response?
- 0:10This week I sat down with Harvard Professor Dodrouches, co-author of Writing for Busy Readers
- 0:14to uncover why most messages fail and how to fix them.
- 0:18Toto's behaviour of scientists who spend years studying how people actually read or rather
- 0:22don't read and how to write to the busy people respond.
- 0:26He used to steal years of research into six principles that make writing better, clearer
- 0:31and more engaging.
- 0:32If you want busy people to respond to your messages, this episode's for you.
- 0:36Tom, thanks for coming on the show.
- 0:39My pleasure, I'm a big fan.
- 0:41Thank you.
- 0:42Sorry, Mai, you're Harvard Public Policy Professor and I wondered why write a book about writing?
- 0:48You and my children and everyone else.
- 0:52I started at least Jessica Lasky think was my co-author on this book.
- 0:57We have worked on mobilizing voters, we've worked on increasing student attendance, worked
- 1:04on other kinds of interventions and as we realize that across these different domains
- 1:09you're always writing to busy people, stage zero of all these interventions that change
- 1:14behaviour is getting through to busy people who are almost always skimming and almost
- 1:20always their goal is to not read what we're sending them.
- 1:25So we decided that time we should organize a sort of first order book like stage zero is
- 1:31how do you write for busy people?
- 1:33I love that because I write a lot, I'm a writer, I read a lot, I get a lot of incoming
- 1:39of course and I think a lot of the writing advice out there is not really for the real
- 1:43world, it's for academia, it's for beautiful prose, for writing books but in the day to
- 1:49day that's usually not what we do, right?
- 1:51We live in a different world but people just operate on speed readers, right?
- 1:55And so and and then it gets even worse when you think about if you're writing something
- 2:00that's really important to you, let's say it's an inbound to a guest you want to have,
- 2:05you know, a guest on the pod or some important thing, we will spend a lot of time crafting
- 2:11it and I think our intuitions almost always push us towards adding more which ironically
- 2:17encounter productively makes it less likely it's going to get read.
- 2:21Yeah, the more you tell people the less they understand, the less they care probably.
- 2:26That and man, have you opened an email from a cold email, you open it and it's four
- 2:32paragraphs and you're like, I'll deal with that later, whereas you did, and we all know
- 2:37what happens.
- 2:38Yeah, exactly.
- 2:39We all know what happens then.
- 2:40So what's the purpose of writing, why do we write at all in the day and age of, you
- 2:44know, just leaving each other voice messages or, you know, texts and so on, why write
- 2:48emails, why write longer texts?
- 2:51That it's the first time I've been asked that question in that way.
- 2:54I'd normally the answer would be we write for two purposes.
- 2:57One is to clarify our own thinking, which is, you know, at the end, I figure out exactly
- 3:04what I was trying to say and that's amazing.
- 3:07And the second is this magical thing of getting an idea from my head asynchronously
- 3:13into yours.
- 3:14Those are like the two purposes and they're totally different.
- 3:16And I think we often inflate them and we will write these long things.
- 3:20And at the end, it's super clear what we want it.
- 3:22And we assume you're going to go on that journey as a reader with me and it's not.
- 3:25But you actually asked this slightly different question about like, well, compared to all
- 3:29these other ways of communicating, why write instead of a voice mail or something like
- 3:33that?
- 3:34Yeah.
- 3:36I mean, I have, I have a very strong answer to that.
- 3:41I think for me, like a strong, why do you, why do you think we, we, when you are deciding
- 3:46to communicate with someone, why write instead of leaving a two minute voice mail?
- 3:51It is.
- 3:52So I don't like receiving them, so I don't send them.
- 3:55I think when someone sends me a one or two minute voice mail, I think three bullets,
- 3:59I could scan in a few seconds, this costs me a minute or two.
- 4:02And if you get 10 or 20 a day, you're talking half an hour and hour, I don't want to do
- 4:06this.
- 4:07So I don't do, do to others what I don't want them to do to me, but I do, however,
- 4:13as I've sort of an AI integration, where you use chat GPT voice integration.
- 4:16So I speak my emails more and more on my text messages.
- 4:20So they're in a very conversational style, but it is faster than typing.
- 4:24So I hope I get the best of both worlds, but I'm probably someone who can speak relatively
- 4:30precisely, but it's also rubbish, rubbish at typing.
- 4:33So for me, that's, that's a good way.
- 4:35But short answer is, I don't want others to send me long voice messages, so I don't
- 4:39do it to them.
- 4:40Right.
- 4:41I think that's exactly the answer I would come up with except that I wouldn't start with
- 4:45what I like, which is golden rules, a good way to start.
- 4:48But the reason you don't like it is because it's hard to skim a voice mail.
- 4:53It's hard, it's hard to move fast through it.
- 4:55And the entire thesis and like mission of the work Jess can I have been doing is we should
- 5:01write in a way that makes it easy for readers to go through it quickly as quickly as they
- 5:06want and be able to navigate jumping around.
- 5:09Whereas with the voice mail, you have to listen to the whole thing and you don't know the
- 5:13structure because you can't see it.
- 5:14And so you kind of are committing, forcing the person to spend the entire two minutes listening
- 5:18to it.
- 5:19Whereas if it was, even if it was transcribed, they could jump around and get through
- 5:22it in 30 seconds.
- 5:24So the idea is writing is easier to read to consume than listening.
- 5:27Yeah.
- 5:28Perfect.
- 5:29Yeah.
- 5:30That's so good.
- 5:31And let's take this step by step from a reader's perspective.
- 5:33Let's say I open my inbox and there are 20 new emails on average.
- 5:38How many would I, as the average person out there average knowledge worker, let's say
- 5:41or average academic, how many do I actually open and read?
- 5:45The average person receives over a hundred text messages a day.
- 5:49That's that's text.
- 5:51And you and I probably receive less because we're not on the younger half of the spectrum
- 5:56of me, but although I hope we are, let's say we are the, but that on emails, it depends
- 6:04but some estimates are about 150 functional emails a day, not just span.
- 6:09And so how you get through them, I mean, it depends how much you're committed to them.
- 6:13But when you think, take the reader's perspective, I mean, they are inundated with communications.
- 6:20And it is a fun exercise to think how long would it take a person to read this if they
- 6:26were reading every word of it?
- 6:29And I was.
- 6:30Yes.
- 6:31And then if you're a leader and you're communicating to your teams, multiply that by the number
- 6:35of people on the team.
- 6:36And it's not just that they're less likely to read it if it's hard to read.
- 6:40It's that if they do read it, it's an incredible productivity tax, whereas you could have made
- 6:45it easier for them and save them all time, which is actually go straight to the bottom
- 6:49line productivity.
- 6:50Yeah.
- 6:51Exactly.
- 6:52So let's assume half of emails are never opened.
- 6:53I think that's a, that's a number from your book, right?
- 6:55You looked into this.
- 6:57And the other half, do we read them?
- 6:59Do we scan?
- 7:00Do we skim?
- 7:01What's the difference?
- 7:02All right.
- 7:03So I think people, I think it's worth starting with exactly your question, which is people,
- 7:09assume people are not reading, word by word, line by line, paragraph by paragraph, all
- 7:14the way through.
- 7:15That's not how anyone reads.
- 7:16The way you can, when they're busy and you can test this by checking yourself, go
- 7:20read an email and see how you read it, you jump around.
- 7:24And so if you start with that as a premise and it's sort of the orientation that we take
- 7:29in this research and we've done dozens, maybe hundreds of experiments and we pull from dozens,
- 7:34maybe hundreds of books and papers, the, the idea is if that's how people are reading,
- 7:40we should learn how they read and then write in a way that accommodates the way they read
- 7:47because we want to make it easy for them to scam.
- 7:49We don't want it like the world is as it is.
- 7:51We're not going to compel them to read it carefully and I just want to make it easy for
- 7:55them to navigate and work their way through and get the key info we want to send to them.
- 7:59Yeah.
- 8:00So if we don't do this, essentially our emails will not be read, will probably not be actioned
- 8:05upon because usually we send someone an email and we want something from that person.
- 8:10It's not just, hey, here's some information.
- 8:11We want to reply.
- 8:12We want to confirmation for something.
- 8:14We want to sell something.
- 8:15We want to have someone on the podcast and of course if we write as if that person would
- 8:20be reading rather than scanning or skimming, you know, probably not really successful.
- 8:26So how do we, how do we address this?
- 8:30I know there are six principles in the book that you have developed based on your research
- 8:34that if we adhere to those, the chances are much higher that our emails will actually
- 8:39be ectodiple.
- 8:40Yeah.
- 8:41Let's go through them.
- 8:42I'm happy, Sue.
- 8:43But I do want to broaden it.
- 8:45Perfect.
- 8:46Everything we write, whether it's text messages, reports, proposals, evaluations, all of these
- 8:53forms of writing are being read by people who are busy and skimming.
- 8:57And so you and I are talking about email because it's the most obvious practical application.
- 9:01But I work with companies and governments across the spectrum and around the world on whatever
- 9:07it is they're writing, because everyone has this problem, that the way we're taught
- 9:12to write, it does not accommodate the way people actually read.
- 9:17Makes sense.
- 9:18Makes sense.
- 9:19And today, I think if someone, let's say your business sends you a very long document,
- 9:24you almost consider, they don't want me to read this because some terms and conditions,
- 9:29the contract, they, you know, they'll read the small print.
- 9:31So it makes us suspicious those long texts.
- 9:33Yeah, I love this cartoon in a New Yorker where it's the devil reviewing the work of an
- 9:39underling.
- 9:40And you can see the picture like there's flames everywhere in the cartoon.
- 9:43And there's stacks of paper and the devil's reviewing it.
- 9:46And he says, this is impossible to read.
- 9:50If it has technical phrases in jargon, it has convoluted sentences that are excessively
- 9:56long.
- 9:57I'm very impressed.
- 10:01Yeah, it's less likely to read.
- 10:04It's also unkind for those who read it.
- 10:06It's just like a burden you're imposing on them.
- 10:09Yeah, exactly.
- 10:10Exactly.
- 10:11So, you know, I heard this phrase that you should value your reader's time more than
- 10:15your own.
- 10:16And I think that's a good guideline.
- 10:17Yes.
- 10:18That's incredible.
- 10:19I've never heard that phrase.
- 10:20I really like that.
- 10:21Yeah.
- 10:22So let's go through the six points of all.
- 10:23What's the first one?
- 10:25Okay.
- 10:26I mean, the first, let's say, less is more.
- 10:29And there's this famous quote that is the blaze Pascal, the French mathematician wrote
- 10:35in a letter where he said, I'm sorry, this letter is so long, I would have written you
- 10:40a shorter one if I'd had more time.
- 10:44And what's great about that is it says two things.
- 10:47One, it is worthy of apology that this is so long.
- 10:51I had burdened you with this.
- 10:53And it takes more time to write less.
- 10:56And so, Jessica and I have run lots of these experiments where we will, like the probably
- 11:01the funniest of them is working with one of the large US federal political committees.
- 11:05So, either the Democratic Party or the Republican Party, one of them reached out to me and
- 11:09was like, hey, we're going to send this email for to 700,000 donors.
- 11:14What experiment should we run?
- 11:17And I was like, why don't you arbitrarily delete every other sentence?
- 11:21So it is incoherent, right?
- 11:24And we have readers.
- 11:25We hire a couple people, a couple hundred people to read both and they agree it's incoherent
- 11:29because we're just arbitrarily deleted every other sentence.
- 11:31And it's still increased donations almost 20%.
- 11:34And we have lots of other ones where it's like, you communicate elected leaders, 7,000
- 11:41of them and you cut it in half and it doubles response rates or you're hosting a webinar
- 11:45and you edit it yourself and I put a constraint that it's going to be half as long as you wrote
- 11:50the original final draft and it almost doubles.
- 11:53Basically, more, more is less, less is more.
- 11:58And it is tough because we have to make judgment calls.
- 12:01Not it's easy to cut words, omit needless words, sure.
- 12:05It's easy to delete instead of saying in order too, we should just say too.
- 12:09But the hard part of the requires judgment, which is as managers and leaders, we have
- 12:13we have people who report to us and I teach in my exact classes where I will say, have
- 12:18you ever said to someone who is writing to you, you need this to be half as long or
- 12:24a quarter as long and everyone raises their hand?
- 12:27And the reason that is hard for people is because it requires judgment.
- 12:30You have to make decisions.
- 12:32What is actually the most important thing?
- 12:34And including a lot of things is actually an indication that you have not prioritized.
- 12:38Yeah, exactly.
- 12:39And I say there's a lot to my team and others that let this be 20, 30% shorter and leave
- 12:45it up to them to decide because it kind of feels that they're pushing it to me in order
- 12:48to spend time to actually go through the word by word and I decide whether this word should
- 12:53be in there or not.
- 12:54Can I just rewind to what you said because it makes total sense to me that shorter
- 12:58performs better, but shortened in coherent, why does that perform better?
- 13:02That I don't get.
- 13:03I mean, you're pushing on a kind of subtlety that makes this funny, which is shorter and
- 13:09coherent.
- 13:10Well, then we're just testing short long.
- 13:12Shorter versus longer, shorter is better, but then make it in coherent too and shorter
- 13:18still dominates.
- 13:19That's what I mean, the humor of it is that like it just turns out that everyone's
- 13:25skimming.
- 13:26They weren't.
- 13:27They can't tell that it's in coherent because they're busy skimming it anyway.
- 13:29Okay.
- 13:30You have to actually read it to know it's in green.
- 13:31Of course, no one does.
- 13:32Yeah.
- 13:33Got it.
- 13:34Got it.
- 13:35It's just so good.
- 13:36I mean, we can do a little rhetorical thing, which is like think about your inbox.
- 13:40What are the attributes of messages?
- 13:42That make some get immediately responded to and read and some postponed in the one
- 13:47that is six paragraphs long.
- 13:49I am always going to read tomorrow.
- 13:51Yeah.
- 13:52Exactly.
- 13:53And that's the one I don't get a chaser for.
- 13:54And say, hey, just bumping this up your inbox, which is also terrible sentence, which
- 13:58I don't like because it, you know, there's a reason I didn't respond, right?
- 14:03Yeah.
- 14:04So that's that's something I would recommend.
- 14:06Okay.
- 14:07Understood.
- 14:08Less is more, more is less, totally on board.
- 14:10What's number two?
- 14:11Well, I want to like preface all of this like an overarching frame is you said, what
- 14:16if you value the reader's time more than your own?
- 14:19I like that.
- 14:20I like that orientation.
- 14:22Another orientation is what if it was always our fault if the person didn't read, understand
- 14:28and respond?
- 14:29Because I think we often have this almost compliance orientation with communication where
- 14:34I just need to get it over the wall to you.
- 14:37And then it's on in your court.
- 14:39And what if we actually own what it was on us?
- 14:42It's our, it's my fault you didn't read it.
- 14:44And then all of a sudden it radically shifts the way we approach this.
- 14:49Yeah.
- 14:50I mean, as a book author, my thinking was always the readers always right.
- 14:54If the reader gives me feedback that this paragraph is boring or I don't get it, they
- 14:58are correct.
- 14:59Inherently, it's nothing I can do about it except for writing it shorter and clearer.
- 15:03Yeah.
- 15:04I, the reader is always right.
- 15:06And there will be people who will lament.
- 15:12Are we a whole culture in generation not able to read or write anymore?
- 15:16And what about the focus and intentionality that comes in writing a long thing and reading
- 15:21it carefully?
- 15:22Yes.
- 15:23Yes.
- 15:24And of course, you know, beautiful literature and poetry good for leisure and whatnot.
- 15:31So when you and I are talking about practical writing where there is a concrete, like firm
- 15:37level goal, how do we effectively do that?
- 15:40Okay.
- 15:41So the second principle is make reading easy, sound straight forward, but the idea is lower
- 15:48the grade level reading.
- 15:49So in the United States, the median, the 50th percentile US adult reads at a ninth grade
- 15:55reading level.
- 15:57And so when we write in ways that are grammatically complicated and use gratuitously complex
- 16:06jargon or vernacular, I was intentionally trying to illustrate it, but I got lost in
- 16:11it.
- 16:12But when you, when we write this way, it may be grammatically correct and your English
- 16:16teacher may have approved of it and even said nice job, but it turns out it is cognitively
- 16:21taxing for those who can't understand it, so they're going to quit on you.
- 16:25And it also is inaccessible to a large fraction of people.
- 16:28And so the idea is write in simple short sentences with common words.
- 16:34I ran an experiment with Jessica with Vice President Kamal Harris when she was the attorney
- 16:38general in California where we re-road an attendance, like a forum that goes out to hundreds
- 16:44of thousands of families in California, and it was written in legal ease that was impossible.
- 16:48It wasn't written for humans.
- 16:49It was just written for lawyers.
- 16:50And I ate right.
- 16:51Lawyers are people too.
- 16:52I should always qualify.
- 16:53They're their viewers.
- 16:54Absolutely.
- 16:55Lawyers are welcome.
- 16:56Yeah.
- 16:57To listen to this podcast.
- 16:58Yeah.
- 16:59But let's not let them guide our writing.
- 17:00Right.
- 17:01Exactly.
- 17:02But, but and turns out just dropping the writing level to fifth grade reading level almost
- 17:07increased the effectiveness of this absence intervention, getting kids to go to school
- 17:10more by 40%.
- 17:11I mean, the idea is just like, right, so it's easy to read.
- 17:14That's the straightforward way.
- 17:15Right.
- 17:16A lot of people would push back and say, oh, Todd, you're dumping it down, right?
- 17:19I have my audience is smart.
- 17:21They can understand this.
- 17:23Yes.
- 17:24I believe that your audience is smart, and I believe they can understand it.
- 17:30But the idea is the more cognitively taxing, the writing is to read.
- 17:35The more likely people are to postpone doing it, or to skip it all together, and so the
- 17:41idea is just you are fighting their likelihood of quitting before understanding what you're
- 17:46trying to convey.
- 17:47And if you easily make it, the more likely they will be to actually persevere, or at least
- 17:52even in the six seconds they give you, understand what the key message was.
- 17:56That's right.
- 17:57I mean, yes, they can understand, but they won't because, you know, my theory is the brain
- 18:02is an energy hawk, right?
- 18:03Two percent of the body mass per 20% of the energy consumption, and it is therefore
- 18:07wire to conserve energy, which means that anything that's cognitively taxing, you know,
- 18:13creates resistance in us, and why create resistance and debris that doesn't make any
- 18:17sense.
- 18:18And interestingly, that argument tends to work with a sort of scientifically minded community
- 18:22who are often very jargon-heavy, right?
- 18:24It was, I don't know, we understand this, and if I come with that sort of scientific
- 18:27argument about brain mass and so on, they're like, ah, okay, yeah, I get it.
- 18:31It's a scientific reason for it, so that helps me in my work as well.
- 18:36In behavioral economics, and I'm a behavioral scientist, this broader field of behavior
- 18:41change.
- 18:42So there's a phrase which is unnecessarily complicated, but that we are cognitive
- 18:46misers.
- 18:48And then basically we have this limited attention, and we are super protective of it.
- 18:53And when we look at our text thread, if one of them is like a block of words and another
- 18:58is one line, we're going to be down.
- 19:00Yeah, exactly.
- 19:01Exactly.
- 19:02It's just not effective.
- 19:03So we just have to accept it.
- 19:04The world as it is, not as we wish it to be perfect.
- 19:07Let's move on to the next principle.
- 19:09The third is design for navigation.
- 19:11So so far we said less is more, make reading easy, design for navigation.
- 19:16And what design for navigation means is that let's internalize and accept.
- 19:22Most readers are not going to read it the way we wrote it.
- 19:25They're not going to read first line to second line to third line linearly and read
- 19:29every word.
- 19:30Instead, they're going to do what's called scanning, and you were alluding to this earlier.
- 19:33They just dart around, jumping around, trying to just orient.
- 19:37What is this about?
- 19:39What are the different sections?
- 19:41And if you design for navigation, you end up just adding structure to make it easier
- 19:45for skimmers.
- 19:46And we've run experiments where you have a six paragraph thing.
- 19:50And if you add two headings, every two paragraphs, just a little heading, like this section
- 19:54is about this, this section is about that.
- 19:56You more than double the likelihood that someone clicks on and reads past the second paragraph.
- 20:02The idea is just you want to fight the likelihood that people will be deterred from engaging
- 20:09with whatever you're writing.
- 20:11So one way to make it easier is to design for the reality that they will be navigating
- 20:15nonlinearly.
- 20:16And so there's a bunch of little subprincipals to that, but the big picture is just how
- 20:20we make it easier for the reader by making it navigable.
- 20:24So no wall of words, but inevitable text, lots of bite space, sub headlines, some different
- 20:31stuff.
- 20:32Should we use design, bold, italics, to make it easier?
- 20:36It's, I mean, we'll get to that, but I do think design is the way to think about it.
- 20:40This design for navigation really is, we're not talking about the words anymore.
- 20:44Now we're talking about structure.
- 20:47So I often do an exercise where it's like, you can't edit any of this.
- 20:50The lawyers have said this is done.
- 20:52You're not allowed to change the writing.
- 20:54How would you make it easier for people to navigate, and they're like, well, that's
- 20:57structure.
- 20:58Let's use formatting.
- 20:59Let's also do what the US Army started doing decades ago, and it's now spread around
- 21:04the militaries around the world.
- 21:06It's called bluff bottom line up from bluff.
- 21:10And what I love about that is it doesn't just help all readers know where the bottom line
- 21:15is and all writers know where to put the bottom line.
- 21:18But it especially helps lower status writers when communicating up because there's a big
- 21:24pressure to be deferential and respectful.
- 21:27And in the military, we ran into each other in Kandahar and the mess, and we talked about
- 21:32your high school football team, and it was a real fun story, but I have something I need
- 21:36to report to you.
- 21:37Like that throat clearing is probably, if there isn't an explicit norm about an expectation
- 21:44of the first line as the bottom line, there will be these tacit norms that lower status
- 21:49people need to have a lot of throat clearing respect in writing, which makes them less
- 21:52effective.
- 21:53Yeah.
- 21:54So it's not just get to the point, it's start with a point, which of course is the opposite
- 21:58of what a lot of us have been taught, right?
- 22:01You show how you got to the conclusion, especially lawyers and other professions do this automatically.
- 22:07That's how they have been trained.
- 22:09But of course in modern communication, that is, it has not just suboptimal, but it kind
- 22:13of turns the principle on its head, right?
- 22:16We want to start with what's most important because we have to assume people don't read
- 22:20to the end and therefore miss the point.
- 22:22Yes, except there is not a single right answer, just like for all of writing, it really depends
- 22:30on context and expectations.
- 22:32And so you can't do bottom line up front in a lot of settings without coming off as too
- 22:38aggressive and too direct.
- 22:40And so what I like about the way the US Army does it is they have just codified, this
- 22:44is the regulation, this is how we write.
- 22:48You are not being too aggressive or too direct bottom line up front.
- 22:51But if you and I in our first communication, your first line was, I want you on our podcast
- 22:58period.
- 22:59I am this, I am Oliver and so on and our podcast is whatever, instead of some nice thing saying
- 23:05was nice to meet you and whatever, normal human communication typically has introductions
- 23:11and flattery and kindness.
- 23:14So it doesn't work everywhere, but the idea is you just want to make it navigable to
- 23:18pull the key info away.
- 23:19And one of the things that we're working on a Harvard Business Review article on is,
- 23:23is how organizations can go about setting these norms because these norms can make it easier
- 23:28for everybody, readers write and writers.
- 23:31And we just need to be explicit about them and it doesn't even matter that they be unified
- 23:35and uniform across organizations, but within our team will all be better off if we write
- 23:40with the same expectations.
- 23:41That's a really good point.
- 23:43I mean, one person who does this in his organization is Jensen Chuang, the CEO of Nivedia, the
- 23:50most valuable company in the world.
- 23:51And he has this principle of T5T, top five things.
- 23:56So every Friday, I believe he gets an email from his 60 direct reports with their top
- 24:03five things.
- 24:04And that is a very clear structure.
- 24:05It's the same for everyone.
- 24:06It allows him to go through it quickly.
- 24:09He says,
- 24:10I love that.
- 24:11I did not know about that.
- 24:12The top five things.
- 24:13I'm writing that down.
- 24:14I like the, in contrast to that, one of the other most valuable companies in the world
- 24:19is Amazon.
- 24:20And they also have a very strict writing culture, but it is not the top five things.
- 24:26They write these six page memos and meetings start in silence with everyone reading them.
- 24:31And so again, there isn't a right way to do it.
- 24:34It's just we need to make sure that we're all aligned on what the expectations are and
- 24:38what the norms are.
- 24:39And so that way it makes it easier for writers.
- 24:43And more importantly, as both of us have underscored, easier for readers.
- 24:48Exactly.
- 24:49And it's a different case if I want to build suspense, if I'm telling a story, if I'm
- 24:53holding a presentation, I may not want to give the bottom line first because I want
- 24:58to people lean in and listen to it and follow me and have that aha moment.
- 25:04So an email, I totally agree with you.
- 25:06I think bottom line up is great, but sometimes we want to build suspense and withhold the
- 25:11solution of the key point we want to make in order to capture the audience.
- 25:16Just like everything else that it is not clear that there's one way to do it.
- 25:21And one of the tensions that I don't think there's a resolution to.
- 25:25There's not an easy one is what if you want to set up suspense and it requires a big
- 25:31preamble and a big set up for a big fraction of people, you're going to lose them completely.
- 25:36You're not going to get through.
- 25:37But those who do get through it, maybe more gripped, more engaged, more motivated, more
- 25:42persuaded.
- 25:43And so there's, you can see this optimization trade-off that adding all the details, contours,
- 25:50context, story will make it more persuasive for those who do read it, but fewer will.
- 25:56And so there's just, there's no right answer.
- 25:59Yeah.
- 26:00Absolutely.
- 26:01Great.
- 26:02Number four.
- 26:04This one is, excuse me, this one is probably the most obvious and straightforward, which
- 26:10is use enough formatting, but no more.
- 26:12And what we have seen in a bunch of experiments and also in surveys, people interpret bold
- 26:18underlying and highlight as the most important text.
- 26:22The writer is saying to the reader, hey, meta information about the writing.
- 26:28This is the most important thing.
- 26:30Now if you flip over being a reader, you're like, good news.
- 26:33Man, they told me I don't have to read this.
- 26:36This is the most important thing done onto the next thing.
- 26:38And so it's a double-edged sword, which is if you bold underlying or highlight something,
- 26:44people are much like almost two times, three times more likely to read it among the rest
- 26:50of the words, but they also feel licensed to not read anything else.
- 26:54And so it's a, use enough formatting, but no more.
- 26:57That makes total sense.
- 26:58What about colors?
- 26:59I usually use yellow and my newsletter to underline key points.
- 27:04One of the unexpected negative consequences of having done this book and talked about
- 27:10this material untold times is that now people send me everything they send to me.
- 27:18I think I put a really painful burden on the mountains for writing in a certain way.
- 27:24But also, one of the good things about that is that it shows me the way they have come
- 27:29to understand what we're talking about.
- 27:31And one of the surprising things was that people interpret this use formatting judiciously
- 27:37idea that they, they bold things, they underline things, they highlight things, they font
- 27:43color change, they font size change, and it starts to look like a piece of modern art.
- 27:51Like it's just like crazy, hard to read.
- 27:55And I think there's a second order implication of this, which is, I think, and I don't think
- 28:01it's just aesthetic.
- 28:03I think that you should probably only use one kind of formatting because otherwise it's
- 28:07hard for the reader to know among the many things that you have used different formatting
- 28:11on.
- 28:12What are you saying to them is the most important because if you just use one, the contrast
- 28:16is signifying that.
- 28:18But if you use red font and underline and then something else you highlight, I don't know
- 28:23as a reader, what you're trying to tell me is most important or what you're emphasizing
- 28:28or whatever.
- 28:29So basically the, the TLDR of that is the too long didn't read of that is I think we should
- 28:34use one and be careful about always from the perspective of the reader.
- 28:39You don't want to send mixed signals.
- 28:41I understand.
- 28:42That makes a lot of sense.
- 28:43I guess we have to revise that and take another look at it.
- 28:46I'm sensible.
- 28:47I'm falling.
- 28:48I'm curious.
- 28:49This one.
- 28:50Tell readers why they should care.
- 28:52It's such a statement of the obvious, but so easy to overlook.
- 28:55I am writing.
- 28:56I've spent a lot of time writing this proposal.
- 28:59And I know why I think this is such a good product.
- 29:05And instead of taking the perspective of the customer or the client or the citizen or
- 29:10your employee or whoever or your boss, I'm talking about why I think it's awesome.
- 29:16And emphasizing why you should care is just means again, everything is from the perspective
- 29:21of the reader.
- 29:22But I want to be really careful like you write what you think needs to be said.
- 29:27I am not arguing you should change.
- 29:32Others might.
- 29:33I'm not saying you should change why you write.
- 29:34I'm saying to the extent that you're going to emphasize something, look at the set of
- 29:38content you've included and pull out and, and focus on the one that the, the, the items
- 29:45that the reader might care most about, you're still entitled to your own priorities and
- 29:49your own goals.
- 29:51But within those, make sure that you draw attention and emphasize what the reader cares
- 29:55most about.
- 29:56And I, it's a statement of the obvious, but it probably, you know, we could do a podcast
- 30:01series on just this incredible value of just shifting the orientation to being like,
- 30:09this is not about me.
- 30:10It is entirely about the recipient.
- 30:13And so let's try our best, even though we're bad at it, to imagine what it's like to
- 30:16be on the other side of this.
- 30:18So do you have an example of someone who did this really well or did this terribly?
- 30:22Sure.
- 30:23This is a classic study in social psychology that isn't about writing, but I think you
- 30:29can get the point instantly.
- 30:31It's really hard to take other people's perspectives, but we think we are good at.
- 30:38And so there's this study where we, the, the, the, the, the experimenter asked participants
- 30:45to shoot, to tap out a prominent song.
- 30:49And they will assign the song.
- 30:50It'll be happy birthday and to be like, tap it.
- 30:54And then another person will be listening to the tapping and the participant is supposed
- 30:58to estimate the likelihood that the participant knows the song, right?
- 31:04Like I'm, I'm, and so we're, it's this perspective taking challenge.
- 31:08Definitely.
- 31:09Here's what happy birthday sounds like tapped out.
- 31:12Okay.
- 31:13Now that you all, you heard it, the listeners will hear it.
- 31:20Obvious that's happy birthday.
- 31:21I would think 95% of people and I, and I'm pretty confident.
- 31:25It's so obvious that that's happy birthday.
- 31:28And then of the participants, less than 10%, less than 10% because you can't unknow.
- 31:34And so it's like the challenge is, it is hard to take other people's perspective.
- 31:39That's maybe obvious.
- 31:40It's hard to put yourself in someone else's head.
- 31:42The problem is we're actually really bad at knowing how bad we are at it and that causes
- 31:47even more problems.
- 31:48Oh my gosh.
- 31:49We're really bad at it.
- 31:50So I didn't expect it to be this bad, but that is, that is really terrible.
- 31:54And I mean, if I signed, send someone an email, say, I'm essentially asking for their time.
- 32:01And of course, if I take that perspective, they want to know what they get out of it
- 32:05in return.
- 32:06Right?
- 32:07And if I'm not clear and upfront about it, the default is to stop reading.
- 32:11Right.
- 32:12Yeah.
- 32:13Yeah.
- 32:14Yeah.
- 32:15Yeah.
- 32:16Yeah.
- 32:17Bringing it back to reading instead of tapping of birthday songs.
- 32:18Yeah.
- 32:19Good.
- 32:20Good job.
- 32:21Okay.
- 32:22Last principle.
- 32:23The last principle is make responded easy.
- 32:25Look, you'll catch a theme in all this.
- 32:27The entire idea is we should add a round of editing to everything we write where we
- 32:33ask ourselves, how do I make it easier for the reader?
- 32:36Because when we make it easier for the reader, we are more effective at achieving our goals.
- 32:40And it's kinder to the reader.
- 32:42And in this case, make responding easy.
- 32:44If there is an action, we are asking someone to take the easier we make it, the more likely
- 32:48they will be to actually do it.
- 32:50And I am a behavioral scientist.
- 32:52This is, I'll say 50% of behavioral science is some version of.
- 32:57If you reduce the number of steps, be it but much more likely to do it.
- 33:00If you change the default so that if they do nothing, the thing we want to happen happens
- 33:05and the thing that's good for them happens, if you change it from an open ended question
- 33:10to a yes or no question, be it but much more likely to do it.
- 33:13If you offer them three potential times, the schedule and meeting instead of saying,
- 33:19and works for you, be it but more likely to actually lock down the meeting.
- 33:24The idea is just, we should reduce friction wherever we can, pre-populate things, reduce
- 33:32steps, provide checklists.
- 33:35Make responding as easy as possible.
- 33:37Interesting, because if you put it that way, it's common sense, but why is it not being
- 33:41done?
- 33:42It could be this perspective-taking problem, I think that again, imagine we own that
- 33:49if they're failure to do what we're asking them to do is on them versus on us.
- 33:55It's our job to make it likely that they do it and that they read it.
- 33:59You can see this in a lot of policies, you can see this in, who's awesome at it, is
- 34:03all the tech companies.
- 34:06Sign-up is super easy and there actually was a regulation that came out last year.
- 34:11We're filming this in 25.
- 34:13They came out last year and I don't know if it will survive, but where the executive
- 34:18branch is considering in the United States, requiring that it be as easy to cancel something
- 34:24as it is to sign up for it.
- 34:27Interesting, they're often more steps involved in pausing your subscription or terminating
- 34:34it.
- 34:35I remember that from Amazon, I think I canceled one and I canceled an Apple subscription
- 34:39as well.
- 34:40Very easy to sign up for and incredibly difficult to find the opposite end of the purchasing
- 34:47spectrum and just pauses for three months or something.
- 34:50That is an understatement.
- 34:51It was really hard.
- 34:54It's really hard.
- 34:55You know it's somewhere, but you keep looking at 10 minutes later, you found it because
- 34:59it wasn't the last possible menu, but there you go, that's how they do the business.
- 35:06I'll put it down and I think it's unethical to make it harder to get out of than to sign
- 35:10up for it, but I understand why a lot of firms do it.
- 35:15It's really easy to unsubscribe from some of these things.
- 35:18If you call during this 15 minute window using a phone and then you answer 17 questions,
- 35:26then it's super easy.
- 35:29Who doesn't want to do this?
- 35:32I was wondering if there is a difference in the writing style between more senior people
- 35:37and more junior people.
- 35:39Have you looked into that?
- 35:41Yes.
- 35:42There is research on this and I don't think it will surprise you that when you're writing
- 35:49down the hierarchy, you are more direct and more concise and when you are writing up,
- 35:55you are more indirect and more wordy.
- 35:59The irony is that it doubly burdens lower status people.
- 36:04There are already lower status and they're less likely to be read, like you're writing
- 36:08to the secretary of state and you're in the state department.
- 36:13The busiest person I presume in the state department is the secretary of state and the
- 36:17norm and expectation is that you're going to be writing even more long-winded indirect
- 36:21things.
- 36:22Again, another reason I'm glad we moved towards the end wrapping with this, from an individual
- 36:29perspective, we should add around eventitating to everything we write where we ask ourselves,
- 36:34how do I make it easier for the reader?
- 36:36Because it makes us more effective and it's kind of the reader.
- 36:39But at an organizational level, we should just be intentional and I think at minimum, even
- 36:43prompting a discussion, what norms do we want so that they're not drifting around and
- 36:49different people have different norms and new people take a long time to figure out what
- 36:52they are?
- 36:53We should be explicit and intentional and consistent.
- 36:55You described in video and Amazon, they have extraordinarily different norms, but they
- 37:00are coherent and consistent and enforced so that anyone coming in and anyone in it knows
- 37:06what they are and it makes it easier for writers and readers.
- 37:09So maybe you can give us a glimpse into your Harvard Business Review article that hasn't
- 37:12been published yet.
- 37:13What do you recommend?
- 37:14It's an average company out there.
- 37:16They say, okay, I hear you talk that makes total sense, it would be good to standardize
- 37:20this because then everyone just doesn't the same way and everyone gets more efficient.
- 37:24We don't have to worry less about status and all the other things that don't really
- 37:28matter in terms of the business impact.
- 37:30What should we do?
- 37:31Well, we're still working it out and I don't have it in front of me, but I can think
- 37:36of three very quick ones.
- 37:37What is this?
- 37:38Like, okay, we should set norms and explicit about writing for busy readers, right?
- 37:43The six things we talked about basically make it easy for the reader, right?
- 37:45We may as well be explicit, intentional, create formal and informal expectations that you're
- 37:51going to take time to save me time.
- 37:55Another, which is not even about the writing, but what kind of communication goes through
- 38:00what channel?
- 38:03You often hear from business leaders and leaders everywhere that different people in
- 38:09the organization use different channels for different kinds of things.
- 38:12Do I need to wait?
- 38:13Was this in Slack?
- 38:14Was this a memo that you said?
- 38:16I think you texted me about it.
- 38:18You may as well have norms and consistent expectations so you can have consistent practices
- 38:23which helps again writers and readers.
- 38:24What goes through what channel?
- 38:26The final, I mean, there's a bunch, but the final one that I think may be relevant again,
- 38:30not about the writing, but about the organization norms, setting consistent expectations explicitly
- 38:36about, okay, what kind of delay in response is acceptable for a question in Slack, a question
- 38:44in an email, a question by text.
- 38:49And if you can't abide by it, then you just say, I can't get back to you in the 24 hours
- 38:53we expect, but just want to let you know I received it, right?
- 38:56Because it's so much is lost and be like, hey, did you get that?
- 39:01And I guess it shouldn't be too little time, right?
- 39:05Because we don't want people to check Slack every hour.
- 39:07We want them to get on with the big things that move the diet for us.
- 39:10Yeah, there's this great research on email urgency bias, which is that readers who are also
- 39:17responders to emails have expectations that they have put on, they believe that their
- 39:24sender expects a faster response than they actually get.
- 39:27And so they feel bad and they feel pressure and they feel stress and not responding quicker
- 39:32because they're just completely not aligned understanding of what the realistic timeline
- 39:36is.
- 39:37And so again, you can, like, I'm thinking about productivity and effectiveness, again,
- 39:41burnout and stress and work-life balance.
- 39:44Also, we may as well just have consistent norms and expectations.
- 39:49And what he says, we're interesting that it's not, so we have to invest a little more
- 39:53time to make it easier on the reader.
- 39:55And I was just thinking that on average, it's probably everything that's produced in
- 39:59a business is written by someone is probably read by a number of people.
- 40:04Maybe it's four or five people on average, so it does make total sense for this one person
- 40:09to do it right so that four or five other people, safe time and cognitive energy.
- 40:15Exactly.
- 40:16I think that's right.
- 40:18It's, I think it's critical necessary, morally required that we try to be kinder to
- 40:27even if it's just one reader, but it multiplies up when there's multiple readers.
- 40:31I think it's also, I mean, people will naturally, it's hard to hear about writing right now
- 40:37and not think artificial intelligence.
- 40:38Well, you know, chat GPT is going to do all my writing.
- 40:41How does that affect any of this?
- 40:44And there's one very quick, completely self-evident response that I think people will resonate
- 40:49with.
- 40:50It is that if you want a human to read what you are writing, then everything we're talking
- 40:57about is relevant and important.
- 41:01If you want to, are human to read it, you want to make it easy for it.
- 41:04How it gets produced, whether it's you alone or you on an AI, copilot or just the AI,
- 41:10it doesn't matter to me.
- 41:11We are focused on the reader.
- 41:13And if you have a human reader, then the idea is how do you make it easier for them because
- 41:17then you'll be more effective.
- 41:18Yeah, and you need to understand the principles of good writing, otherwise you can't judge
- 41:22what chat GPT comes up with.
- 41:24Also if you feed in your own strong writing and say this is what I'm looking for, you
- 41:29create your own GPT, for instance, right, that of course helps to get back what you
- 41:34want.
- 41:35I'd love to hear from you what annoys you most about AI writing when you see it.
- 41:39And I'm sure you see a lot from students and others.
- 41:42I'm guessing, but wouldn't be surprised if some people use it without reflecting too much
- 41:46on it.
- 41:47You're exactly right that we do get a lot of writing where people kind of, because they
- 41:55don't know what is optimal, defer to the way chat GPT is writing.
- 42:00This must be better than what I would have thought.
- 42:02Chat GPT and the LLM's 10 right now to use fancy language that I think is unnecessary.
- 42:10They tend to be wordy.
- 42:12They tend not to be as well structured in terms of formatting as I would like.
- 42:18But I will say that in my newsletter just last week, so I have had a large language
- 42:24model that we trained and we have on my website.
- 42:26We have three or four hundred thousand users where we, it's an email coaching tool where
- 42:30you just, it's free and you just paste your email and it rewrites it as if you were using
- 42:35all these principles.
- 42:36And the LLM's model is amazing at it.
- 42:38It's basically a personal GPT except it's sort of public facing.
- 42:43And chat GPT was just never good at doing these things.
- 42:46But chat GPT recently, last week, announced Canvas where if you're entering something and
- 42:51you want to, if you say, do this in Canvas, it will pop out.
- 42:56And Canvas has a couple of toggles to tinker with their grade level reading so you could
- 43:01simplify the writing level and the conciseness.
- 43:04And it's getting better at this structure for navigation.
- 43:08But again, it all depends on context and norms.
- 43:10So like these things will never replace without the actual human context.
- 43:15You know the expectations, you know the norms, you know the person you're communicating
- 43:18with, you know what they think of you.
- 43:20Like all of that is necessary for effective communication, but these are incredibly
- 43:23useful tools.
- 43:24Yeah.
- 43:25I agree with that.
- 43:26And I think the, what I do is I give it the structure I would like to use.
- 43:30So for instance, I say write an email with using the what, so what, now what structure
- 43:36I say or write a text using the my story, I'll story the future structure or whatever
- 43:40I want to use.
- 43:41And it's then my expertise guiding the AI.
- 43:44It's my personal pet peeve with AI is the set and structure, it's whether it's this
- 43:51or that.
- 43:52And then it starts with the main clause and it's just such a terrible set and structure
- 43:56because this is, you know, writing advice I've received a long time ago, but better
- 44:01to start with the main clause because the reader knows immediately who does what and then
- 44:06you can add a subordinate clause if you want.
- 44:08We're getting quite technical here, but what you see a lot in writing is people have these
- 44:11long subordinate clauses and the reader thinks like, who does what?
- 44:15What is happening?
- 44:16So you have to read the whole sentence and that leads to the exit, the default, I don't
- 44:21want to read this, this is too complicated and, you know, convulate it.
- 44:25Oh, man, I'm so glad that you raised that and anyone who is listening good for you
- 44:31for sticking with sentence that includes the subordinate clause.
- 44:34Yes.
- 44:35But here's the, here's the way we think about that, which is you want the reader to be
- 44:39able to understand the sentence in one pass through.
- 44:42And if you have a sentence where the first half of it doesn't make sense until you get
- 44:46to the end, they have to go re-read.
- 44:49And that's when they, when you add cognitive effort and that's when you're going to lose
- 44:52them, they're going to quit.
- 44:53So exactly the intuition you're describing is all in line with how do we make the, at the
- 44:58level of the sentence, how do we make the sentence easier to read in addition to everything
- 45:03else we've been talking about?
- 45:04Exactly.
- 45:05So people move on to the next sentence and then the next sentence and the next sentence.
- 45:08That's the job of the sentence.
- 45:09Make sure people go on to the next.
- 45:11Let's bring the central end.
- 45:12So this is, this is amazing.
- 45:13I could talk to you for hours and I was wondering, there's always the final question I ask.
- 45:17What's the best piece of communications advice for everyone listening?
- 45:22It will not surprise you to hear me say the best piece of advice that I have is we should
- 45:26add a round of editing to everything we write where we ask ourselves, how do I make
- 45:31it easier for the reader?
- 45:32Because when we make it easier for the reader, we are more effective at achieving our goals.
- 45:37It's also just kinder to a reader.
- 45:38Yes.
- 45:39Let's be kind to the reader.
- 45:40Thank you.
- 45:41Where can people find out more about you and the GPT you just mentioned, for instance?
- 45:45Our website, writingforbusyreaders.com, writingforbusyreaders.com.
- 45:49I also have a newsletter, hopefully we've put the show notes, some link to some of this.
- 45:52Absolutely great.
- 45:53We will do that.
- 45:54Perfect.
- 45:55So thank you so much and thank you all for listening.
- 45:57This has been fun.
- 45:58Thanks for having me.