Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / So Your A CAMEL Code 3 - Now What?
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:35Hey everyone.
- 0:35This is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:39And today I'm back with frequent guests and my team members at Credit Union Exam
- 0:44Solutions, Steve Farr and Todd Miller.
- 0:46Guys, how you doing this afternoon?
- 0:50It's hot here in Montana, just like the rest of the U.
- 0:53S.
- 0:53Yeah, we're hot and muggy.
- 0:55Yeah, hot and muggy here in Virginia, where I'm at today.
- 0:58Yeah.
- 0:59And if you believe in global warming, you say, gosh, it's hotter than normal.
- 1:03And if you don't believe in global warming, you say, hey, it's just July.
- 1:07So I'm not going to pick which side of the camp I'm in, but those are the two camps.
- 1:11But yeah, it's hot.
- 1:12It's hot indeed.
- 1:14All right.
- 1:14And so intros for those folks who are not.
- 1:20Frequent listeners who might be new to the show.
- 1:22Let's have an introduction.
- 1:24We, let's go Todd Miller first today.
- 1:27I spent just a little bit over 34 years with NCA.
- 1:30I retired in July of 2021.
- 1:33I can break my time in the NCA down into three parts.
- 1:36I spent basically a third of it as an examiner and a problem case officer,
- 1:41a third of it as a regional capital market specialist, and a third of it as
- 1:45a director of special auctions dealing, supervising problem case officers and
- 1:50regional capital market specialists.
- 1:52So between those items, a good part of my career was spent with what NCA
- 1:57would call troubled credit unions are large and complex credit unions.
- 2:02Very good.
- 2:02And Steve?
- 2:03Yeah, I was 30 plus years at NCOA and break my career into two parts.
- 2:08The first 15 years were out in the field, predominantly as a problem case officer
- 2:14and mainly a West Coast based that Working with those troubled institutions.
- 2:19Then I went into the central office into the division of risk management
- 2:24where I got to work on just a variety of projects over the years.
- 2:29The enforcement manual, the corporate resolution was, it was a big one,
- 2:34the risk based liquidity facility.
- 2:41Yeah, we all spent a lot of time dealing with.
- 2:43Troubled credit unions, whether it was director of special actions, problem,
- 2:47case officer, corporate resolution, writing the enforcement manual and
- 2:52it was a lot of fun doing that.
- 2:53We talk about that a lot here and it's a good that's a good fit for
- 2:57the conversation of our topic today.
- 2:59And this podcast will be called something like, so you're a code.
- 3:05So you're a camel code three.
- 3:07Now what?
- 3:08And as we dive into this, Steve, I thought maybe you could give us some
- 3:12stats on recent trends in camel code threes, which, of course, come from
- 3:18which I've talked about here a lot come from NC ways share insurance briefing.
- 3:22But what can you share with us on what's going on in camel camels codes?
- 3:27Most recently?
- 3:28Yeah, the the trend isn't it's a short term trend.
- 3:31I just looked at your end 23 and then the 1st quarter and the
- 3:37actual camel threes number went from 776 at the end of the year.
- 3:44To 760 report is of March.
- 3:48The assets went up from 160 billion to 177 billion.
- 3:53And I said, that would probably be one of the numbers that seemed pretty obvious
- 3:56and that we're seeing more bigger credit unions ended up with the camel threes.
- 4:02Yeah, that's very true.
- 4:04The quarter by quarter I've looked at this.
- 4:08Pretty much ever since leaving N.
- 4:09C.
- 4:09U.
- 4:10A.
- 4:10That briefing and two slides on the briefing.
- 4:13The one of the ones you're reading from is one of my favorite ones to look at because
- 4:16it really reveals where things are going.
- 4:18And it's like the 10th quarter in a row when Camel threes have gone up.
- 4:22And the point you made.
- 4:24Is spot on that smaller credit unions, camel codes, there's not much change.
- 4:30It's the bigger codes going from ones and twos to threes.
- 4:33And in more recently, maybe, and maybe this upcoming quarters, we'll
- 4:37see threes going to fours cause camel codes tend to move one, one grade
- 4:41at a time, although not always but it's those large credit unions that
- 4:45are driving the numbers right now.
- 4:47And you can see it in the stats and we've seen it in our conversations.
- 4:51When you're a code one life is good.
- 4:53NCUA may come see you once a year.
- 4:56They may not depending on your size when you're a code two, same kind of thing.
- 5:01But when you're a code three life tends to change a little bit.
- 5:04Let's talk a little bit about how things change at NCU from N C's
- 5:09perspective on Camel code threes and how that might change for a credit
- 5:14union that's downgraded to a three.
- 5:17I think you start out with what does a code three mean to MCUA and without
- 5:21reading their whole definition from the camel letter, there's a couple
- 5:25sentences in there that really inform MCUA supervision process, for code three,
- 5:31composite, They say credit unions in this group exhibit some degree of supervisory
- 5:37concern in one or more components.
- 5:39But then at the end of the definition, this is what really drives NCUA
- 5:43supervision process with code threes.
- 5:46It says risk management practices may be less than satisfactory relative to
- 5:50the credit union size and complexity.
- 5:53And so when you get those things, it raises a supervisory concern.
- 5:57from NCOA's level, it heightens their supervision.
- 6:01They're trying to assess.
- 6:02They don't think it's going to fail at this point, but they're trying to assess.
- 6:05Are you willing and able to fix these issues?
- 6:08And what they're trying to do is prevent an issue that is starting to go south
- 6:13from actually going south and crossing the border into an unacceptable level.
- 6:19Once you're a CAMEL 3, MCUA supervision goes up quite a bit, and actually
- 6:24MCUA, they publish their National Supervision Policy Manual, and their
- 6:28practices with respect to CAMEL 3 and CAMEL 4 credit unions are
- 6:34actually not redacted in this case.
- 6:36There's lots of pieces of that supervision manual that might be
- 6:39helpful to credit unions that Okay.
- 6:41So you'll notice that it's a little bit more in depth in this section.
- 6:55The, A follow up exam once a year.
- 6:57So you're going to get two visits a year from your examiners.
- 7:01That second one is generally going to focus on the doors.
- 7:05There's some exceptions to that which we can talk about in a little bit.
- 7:10But the biggest thing is your time and effort in dealing with your
- 7:14examiners is going to increase.
- 7:16So they're going to give you things to do and then they're going to
- 7:19be in your hair every six months.
- 7:22Making sure you're actually doing that.
- 7:25Very good.
- 7:26Steve.
- 7:26Anything you want to add to those comments?
- 7:28No, that's as fine as that's what the that's what the manual says.
- 7:32So that's what you can certainly expect them to try to achieve.
- 7:36Try to achieve.
- 7:37Yes, I've alluded here.
- 7:38Sometimes they may say they're going to come back that frequently, but their
- 7:42own reports show that the code threes.
- 7:45Contacts, they tend to get done about 67 percent of the time.
- 7:50And those start dates used to be when you and I were doing exams guys long
- 7:54ago, it used to be end date to end date.
- 7:57They've given themselves a little bit of flexibility and correct me if I'm wrong.
- 8:00It's from end date to S to start date.
- 8:04So they just have to start the exam within six months.
- 8:07Do I have that right?
- 8:09You have that correct.
- 8:11Okay.
- 8:11And the other thing I'll add from the definitions, the one sentence that
- 8:14always sticks in my mind that sometimes NCUA rarely NCUA raises, but when
- 8:20CEOs read it, they get frustrated.
- 8:22The code three definition of management includes a sentence that says
- 8:27management may be, management and board may be unwilling or unable to
- 8:31correct the problems that are present.
- 8:33And sometimes when a CEO sees that sentence their hair will stand up
- 8:39on the back of their neck and NCA tends to downplay that side of it.
- 8:43But those are pretty chilling words for a code three, the first time they see it.
- 8:48And as you say, they show up twice as much to.
- 8:53twice as frequently to to assess their own risk.
- 8:59But that has a drag because it takes a lot of your time
- 9:01preparing, et cetera, et cetera.
- 9:04So what else your code three, what else do, what else can we share?
- 9:07One of the things that are going to go with this is you'll get a document of
- 9:10resolution as a code three and documents of resolution have completion dates.
- 9:16And generally, and this is generally going to be true, they're going
- 9:20to set those completion dates to tie in with that next exam.
- 9:23So you can expect to have completion dates and they're going to expect you
- 9:27to resolve problems within that 180 day period because they're going to want
- 9:31to come back and they're going to want to assess, have you corrected issues?
- 9:35Are you making significant progress?
- 9:38So if you get a document or resolution, While examiners are supposed to be
- 9:43flexible in negotiating terms for those document resolutions and corrective
- 9:47actions and due dates, you might find your examiner a little bit inflexible about
- 9:52those due dates because they're going to want to put due dates that coincide
- 9:57with that next visit 180 days from now.
- 10:00And that can be logical from the perspective of them wanting to be able
- 10:04to measure because in their systems, under the new merit system, if you
- 10:08have three document resolutions NCOA has to say it's finished or it's not.
- 10:12Log it off.
- 10:13They can write that it's substantially finished or finished, but in their
- 10:17systems, they now have the ability to track it, which may be why we're seeing
- 10:22them so much focus on that timeline.
- 10:26And, thinking of a conversations we had where a credit union was
- 10:30asking, getting asked to stand up an enterprise risk management solution.
- 10:34Program from start to finish.
- 10:36The examiners in the meeting said, it'll take you two years to do this,
- 10:40but the let, but the time they gave him to it was linked to that next
- 10:43follow up, which doesn't seem logical.
- 10:46The method to that madness, is because they know they're coming in and they want
- 10:50to show that there's progress or not.
- 10:51Yeah, there is one exception to that hundred and eighty days.
- 10:55And if you're a cardi gene that has significant record keeping errors
- 10:59or significant VSA violations, you will see them in 90 days.
- 11:04And that doesn't matter what your CAMEL code is, whether it's a 2 or
- 11:08a 3, you're not going to be a code 1 with significant record keeping errors,
- 11:12probably not a code 2, but maybe.
- 11:14But for those two specific areas, significant VSA violations and
- 11:19significant record keeping problems, you can see an examiner every 90 days.
- 11:24Just for that record keeping issue and the BSA has a pretty low
- 11:28tolerance for record keeping problems.
- 11:32And the BSA is because of the link to the importance of that program, terrorist
- 11:36activity, money laundering, and they have an agreement with FinCEN saying that they
- 11:42will treat things in a particular way.
- 11:44Either a document resolution or a letter of understanding, of course the record
- 11:49keeping problem, because they don't know if there's a risk to the fund.
- 11:52If you don't know what your balance sheet is, right?
- 11:54It's really that simple.
- 11:56I'm sure Todd and I shared this that we had no sympathy for
- 12:00when we came into a place and discovered record keeping problems.
- 12:04It was like, you got a record human problems, you're going to pay to get
- 12:07them fixed as quickly as possible.
- 12:10And, that was 1 that that, that I just what didn't negotiate on that one.
- 12:15We got to find out what the numbers are.
- 12:17And so that I think that's really important.
- 12:20Yeah, zero tolerance on record keeping for sure.
- 12:23And we've seen some instances of that.
- 12:25In my conversations with NCA folks that they've seen that and when they do their
- 12:30briefings of camel codes, the board will often ask what is it that's triggering
- 12:34that and operational and accounting issues has come up on a couple of instances.
- 12:38You got it.
- 12:39You got to get the basics down before you Focus on anything else in accounting.
- 12:43Accounting is the basic, they will beat you up on that for sure.
- 12:46You're managing your members money.
- 12:48You should know where it's all at.
- 12:49It's a fiduciary type thing.
- 12:52The other thing is when you have record keeping problems, it just opens the door
- 12:56to fraud and all kinds of other things.
- 12:59Just even clerical mistakes, with ACHs and feds and returns, if you can't do
- 13:04record keeping, you can miss deadlines and cause losses just because of that.
- 13:09And just one other thing with the record keeping and the BSA violations,
- 13:13NCOA actually has separate tracking systems just for those two issues.
- 13:18And, supervisors get reports on that every single month.
- 13:21Here's our outstanding record keeping and BSA problem children.
- 13:27No, makes sense.
- 13:28Makes sense.
- 13:29So if you're a code three in addition to the examination, you mentioned
- 13:36you'll get a document resolution.
- 13:38The likelihood of also getting what's called an RDL or a regional
- 13:43director letter is at or near 100%.
- 13:46I would say any thoughts on.
- 13:49On the concept of regional director letters and because sometimes our
- 13:53clients will get that and they'll be surprised that they got a letter.
- 13:57They had a good exit meeting.
- 13:58They said they're going to do everything.
- 13:59And then lo and behold, they get a letter saying, Hey, you better take this
- 14:03seriously from the regional director.
- 14:05Any thoughts on regional director letters as it relates to code 3s.
- 14:09At the time of my retirement, at the time I retired, that was a standard
- 14:13practice in the western region.
- 14:15That regional director, you got a new code three, she was going to send you a letter.
- 14:20I think part of that is, there's an expectation on the board when
- 14:25you get Problems related to a code three that the board is going to get
- 14:30involved and actively hold management accountable for resolving issues.
- 14:35And the board is expected to exercise appropriate oversight and
- 14:40that regional director letter is.
- 14:42The way for the regional director to tell the board, Hey, you need to pay attention.
- 14:46You need to take this seriously.
- 14:48It's to support and emphasize the examiner's rating of a three that
- 14:53there are supervisory concerns here.
- 14:55There are weaknesses in your risk management systems and
- 14:58you need to get them corrected.
- 15:00There really shouldn't be anything surprising in that letter
- 15:03because it should, it's going to paraphrase what was in the exam.
- 15:06It's going to be drafted by the examiner who wrote the exam because they're going
- 15:09to have to follow the policy to issue it.
- 15:11It just it just kind of naturally follows.
- 15:14And the other piece that follows with this is, depending on your asset
- 15:18sizes, the code three, you're probably going to fall under this whole monthly
- 15:23reporting to your examiner to you're going to be sending them financial
- 15:27statements, board minutes, board packages.
- 15:30Every month in most cases, if you're over 250 million, it's absolutely required.
- 15:36It's optional in other cases, but almost every examiner supervisor,
- 15:41they're going to make their examiners pay attention to what's going
- 15:43on in all of their code three.
- 15:45So while policy requires that over 250 million, any code three can pretty much
- 15:51expect that there's going to be monthly reporting to your district examiner.
- 15:57And we've seen that either placed in a document resolution or just asked
- 16:01for in the, in an email but the right place for that would be in the report
- 16:06to make sure that the board's aware that it needs to happen, correct?
- 16:10Since they went to merit, we seem to be seeing it in the report almost
- 16:14all the time, either in the overview or in the document or resolution
- 16:19section or in that RDL letter.
- 16:22It was always optional for examiners, how they communicated that request
- 16:26to the credit, whether they just pick up the phone and say, from this
- 16:29point, start doing it, or they will just tell management that on site.
- 16:33But since they went to merit, it seems to be showing up in the report formally
- 16:38in most cases on our code threes.
- 16:41Got it.
- 16:43And federal charter versus state charter.
- 16:46Any thoughts on how that might influence being a code 3 if you're
- 16:51a state charter insured by NCUA?
- 16:55For credit unions over 250 million, it doesn't change at all, whether you're
- 17:02a fiscal or a federal, and COA is still going to be involved in those follow ups.
- 17:07There is some flexibility given for those credit unions under 250 million
- 17:11out of state charter that can push that 180 days out to a little bit
- 17:17longer period with ARD approval.
- 17:20Their policy allows for a waiver of those contacts in a state charter,
- 17:24even a federal, but that requires some paperwork, some ARD approvals,
- 17:29some regional director approvals.
- 17:31They have to say this party does not represent any risk to the share
- 17:35insurance fund, and I don't see many RDs actually signing that very often,
- 17:41unless they have a great deal of confidence in that state regulator.
- 17:45And the same works for a we'll get into that when we talk about code
- 17:48four is in the next podcast, but there are other waivers that can happen
- 17:52that that while theoretically, they may be allowed, they're probably
- 17:55not happening that frequently.
- 17:58In a perfect world, a credit union is going to stay a code one or a code
- 18:02two, if they slip into a code three.
- 18:04NCOA is coming back in six months and I know the answer to this
- 18:09question, but I'm going to pose the answer or pose the question.
- 18:12So you downgrade me to a code three, March of 2024.
- 18:18You're telling me you're going to come back in September, start the
- 18:23exam by the end of September, 2024.
- 18:27I have three document resolutions.
- 18:30The dates all come and go by that point in time.
- 18:34NCWA comes back September 30th, has a exam, two, three weeks in a follow
- 18:41up exam, two weeks in September.
- 18:43You get the report by the end of the year, maybe, hopefully and you have
- 18:48a conversation with your examiners.
- 18:50Here's the question.
- 18:50So that's the context.
- 18:51Here's the question.
- 18:53When you come back for the follow up exam, Will you upgrade me?
- 18:58Possibly, but probably not.
- 19:02Possibly, but probably not.
- 19:03So it, it's not, it's like the, there, there's a waiver for that.
- 19:07It can be done.
- 19:08There's nothing that says NCUA cannot do it, but it's not really the norm.
- 19:13True statement.
- 19:14It really depends on resources that examiner has to conduct the follow up,
- 19:19is that 2 people and they're just looking at the door, or do they get 2 or 3 other
- 19:23people and can they look at the door and look at all the findings and maybe look
- 19:27at your business plan if they have time and resources to make that follow up.
- 19:33Expand that scope beyond just the follow up on the door, then
- 19:36there's a chance of that upgrade.
- 19:38Let's say they do like a mini exam, 80 percent of an exam or 70%.
- 19:43There's some number in there where if they have time and resources to look at things
- 19:48in depth, there's a chance that they will upgrade you if you're deserving of it.
- 19:54In most cases, though, they don't have those resources.
- 19:57They're focused just on that document or resolution.
- 20:00Maybe some of the findings and they're basically just going to say, Hey,
- 20:05we need to review these other areas at a full scope exam before we can
- 20:09upgrade you is they're going to be their response most of the time.
- 20:14And what we're seeing with time report or the time it takes for
- 20:17MCUA to issue reports today.
- 20:20I think in most cases in the current era, they don't have the resources
- 20:25on a follow up to expand it.
- 20:28To the point where they can look at enough stuff to upgrade you,
- 20:31even if you're deserving of it.
- 20:33So that's why I said, probably not in the current environment.
- 20:38And I just did a little bit of math on that.
- 20:40So you come in, you get downgraded to a 3 in March.
- 20:44They come say they're going to come back and start it in
- 20:466 months in a perfect world.
- 20:48Maybe they'd be done with that contact.
- 20:49They get you the report in 2 months.
- 20:51So you got 6, 6 months on another 2 months.
- 20:55So we're talking 14 months at that 14 month point.
- 20:58You're told you're not getting upgraded.
- 21:01Meaning they have to come back in another six months.
- 21:03So really when you get downgraded to a three, it means you're going
- 21:07to see him three times in 20 months.
- 21:09Yeah, probably.
- 21:11Probably.
- 21:12You're the one, Mark, who reads NCUA's business plans in detail.
- 21:15We used to have this whole thing.
- 21:16You want to see, code threes and fours resolved in 24 months.
- 21:21Is that still part of their annual business plans and goals?
- 21:25I didn't read last year's that close.
- 21:27It used to be there though.
- 21:29Yeah, I think it is there.
- 21:30And and code fours was 12 or 15.
- 21:3324 months, I think 24.
- 21:35Okay.
- 21:36I got a funny when we talk about code for us.
- 21:38I got a funny story for you on code for resolution from back in the day.
- 21:43But yeah, it's I believe that's still out there.
- 21:45So their goal would be at that 3rd 1 right to have it upgraded.
- 21:49Perfect in all reality.
- 21:51And If things have gotten worse, that's when you start finding out that you you
- 21:55maybe went from a three to a four instead of the goal of going back to a two.
- 22:00All right, guys, any last thoughts on camel code threes?
- 22:03I think that points out the importance that door.
- 22:06That is kinda new because you became a code three is
- 22:10addressing that core problem?
- 22:13Is that, that's, that is the goal is if you're new to a three and
- 22:16haven't been before, there should be an issue you all know is coming and
- 22:20that that door will fix what it is.
- 22:24'cause sometimes you do it, but you don't get the results that were expected.
- 22:28And then it doesn't really fix the problem, but then that is the goal is to
- 22:34correct those problems really quickly.
- 22:36But so it doesn't escalate.
- 22:37Yeah, and you do what's needed in that door you get the results.
- 22:42Might lead to another, it could lead to another door,
- 22:46but that doesn't necessarily.
- 22:49Mean that door means you're going to because a code 2 can have a door code
- 22:521 can have a door, but it doesn't mean that it's 100 percent done.
- 22:56The other thing for directors that are listening and maybe even
- 22:59for CEOs that are listening to as directors, if you get a code three in
- 23:04a door, you should have some type of tracking reporting system in place.
- 23:08That your management team is making progress on resolving these doors.
- 23:13You're a CEO, chief operating officer type individual responsible
- 23:17for correcting of that door.
- 23:20You should be developing reports to let your board know that
- 23:23you are making progress on it.
- 23:25So it goes both ways.
- 23:26You should be demonstrating that we're resolving this door for our
- 23:30boards and as board members, you should be holding your management
- 23:33accountable for progress reports.
- 23:36On those doors and holding your management accountable for addressing them.
- 23:40And if, even if NCOA doesn't ask for it formally, we've seen it asked for
- 23:44formally, we've seen them asked it when you send it to the board, put
- 23:47it in your board packet, et cetera.
- 23:48But that's a great point.
- 23:49Those establish the expectations, but then verify.
- 23:53Right.
- 23:54Very good guys.
- 23:55All right.
- 23:56I appreciate you sharing your wisdom as it relates to camel code threes and
- 24:00next week we'll have a follow up to this which you might guess is now that
- 24:06you're a code for what does that mean?
- 24:07So thanks guys.
- 24:08Appreciate your time as always.
- 24:11Have a great day.
- 24:13You too.
- 24:13Listeners.
- 24:14I want to thank you for listening as always.
- 24:16Hope you'll listen again soon.
- 24:17This is Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.
- 24:26Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 24:30your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 24:33of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 24:38If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 24:41out our services at marktreichel.
- 24:43com.