Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Gray Areas Hitting Crypto Clients Now: Staking, Wrapping, Lending & De Minimis
Transcript
- 0:03and welcome to today's program, Great Areas Hitting
- 0:07Crypto Clients Now, Staking, Wrapping, Lending,
- 0:11and Diminimous. I am Alapoli Castro, Director
- 0:14of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:17the Beverly Hills Bar Association, and today
- 0:19I am delighted to introduce our speaker, Philip
- 0:21Behrendt. Philip is the chair of BHBA's taxation
- 0:25law section, as well as the newly formed blockchain
- 0:28and Web 3 law section. He's an attorney at Hoffman
- 0:32-Salken -Toscher -Perez, licensed in both California
- 0:35and Germany. He advises clients in civil and
- 0:38criminal tax controversies, international money
- 0:41laundering investigations, and voluntary disclosures
- 0:44involving defis, NFTs, and other crypto assets.
- 0:49Philip is a frequent speaker and author on issues
- 0:51involving tax, cryptocurrency, and their crossover.
- 0:55We can't wait to hear what he has to share with
- 0:57us today. So I'm going to turn it over to him.
- 1:00Thank you, Ella. So why is the title basically
- 1:072017? Why is it hitting now? 2017 was the first
- 1:12big peak year in crypto. Most people are familiar
- 1:17with that. It was more or less a wild rest. 2021,
- 1:24the next peak year, became more structured. First
- 1:28accounting software as well. But it was still
- 1:31more focused on getting the accounting correct,
- 1:35getting all the data together. Now we have the
- 1:38next peak year is 2024. We have this year also
- 1:43with many institutional players coming to fruition.
- 1:47And now we are talking more about the nuances
- 1:50in tax law, rather than just accounting and getting
- 1:53the data together. So we are now talking more
- 1:56and more about what is, how is staking being
- 1:59taxed, how is wrapping being taxed, lending,
- 2:02and so on and so on. So thank you, Ella, for
- 2:05the presentation. So just move on to what we
- 2:08are actually covering. I want to focus on these
- 2:12four big areas, staking, wrapping, lending. and
- 2:16potential de minimis rules. They are known so
- 2:18far. And if we have time, I want to move on to
- 2:22broker reporting. It's coming. 2026 will be the
- 2:27first year where we see 10 -90 -90 -8 for the
- 2:302025 tax years. So everyone should be ready for
- 2:34that. Everyone should know that bases will not
- 2:38be reported on the first 10 -90 -90 -8. What
- 2:41kind of transactions are not included in the
- 2:4310 -90 -90 -8? so that you avoid some of the
- 2:46surprises that might otherwise await you. Accounting
- 2:50rules, especially wallet -by -wallet accounting.
- 2:56The IR exchange to a wallet -by -wallet accounting,
- 2:59and despite everything you might see on Facebook,
- 3:03LinkedIn, or other social media, wallet -by -wallet
- 3:05is still in play for 2025. It has not been postponed.
- 3:10There are some relief notices. For documentation,
- 3:14but not for the accounting method itself. So
- 3:16we will go a little bit into that stable coins.
- 3:19What does the genius act mean and in general
- 3:22NFTs which are Becoming more and more a hot topic
- 3:27again So here's the disclaimer nothing new no
- 3:31legal tax accounting or investment advice and
- 3:35It's highly fact dependent in crypto more than
- 3:38in any other fields often. You have to know what
- 3:42does the protocol say. Just because your client
- 3:45tells you it's webbing doesn't mean it's webbing.
- 3:48Same for lending. I recently had a client open
- 3:52me a message saying he was webbing his tokens.
- 3:56When we looked at his wallet, it turned out that
- 3:58he was not webbing the tokens. He was actually
- 4:00only swapping for webbed tokens. So that was
- 4:04a complete different beast. So make sure that
- 4:07you get the facts correct. Where are we seeing?
- 4:15So we are mostly involved in audits and litigation
- 4:18and where the outcome for successful taxpayer
- 4:22return depends on this person foremost completeness
- 4:27of records. Have all wallets, all transaction,
- 4:30make sure that you didn't miss the basis or over
- 4:33claim the basis. Make sure that you categorize
- 4:36them correctly. Make sure that you shake the
- 4:38dominion on control of certain type of wallets,
- 4:41pools, multi -sig wallets, multi -signatures
- 4:46required. But another issue is realization. Taxable,
- 4:51non -taxable events, character and timing, what's
- 4:55ordinary, what's capital, gain, transfer lots
- 5:00and bases, so wallet and wallet integrity. cross
- 5:05wallet carryovers, wrapping, then the basis counting
- 5:09specific ID versus FIFO is the documentation
- 5:12in place as the basis documented and in the end
- 5:16valuation at the time of the transfer or whatever
- 5:19timing applies. We will focus mostly on these
- 5:23two realization and character and timing because
- 5:27that's where the music plays for the fields we
- 5:30want to cover today. So where are we standing
- 5:33right now? And I don't necessarily mean where
- 5:36we're standing with the IRS, but where we're
- 5:39standing legislatively, executive powers, the
- 5:45White House is heavily involved, as many people
- 5:47know. So on July 3rd, 2025, US Senator Cynthia
- 5:53Loomis introduced the digital asset tax legislation.
- 5:59She's almost doing it year by year. together
- 6:02usually together with Senator Gillibrand. So
- 6:05it's usually the numerous Gillibrand act if you're
- 6:08looking that throughout the last years you find
- 6:10very similar legislation introduced year by year.
- 6:15In on july 2017 25 25 president's working group
- 6:20on digital asset markets that was introduced
- 6:23earlier this year came out with its recommendations
- 6:26for various fields including tax for strengthening
- 6:30American leadership in digital finance technology.
- 6:34That report is in your materials. And also in
- 6:38your materials is September 29, 2025 report from
- 6:41the staff of Joint Committee on Taxation, where
- 6:45they basically prepared the report for Congress
- 6:49because on October 1st, 2025, there was a full
- 6:52committee hearing. You find the link here to
- 6:55rewatch the committee hearing. It's worth watching.
- 6:59Professor Anna Nalen is there, who knows her.
- 7:03So there are four experts who gave mostly very
- 7:07good opinions. And in the future, Representative
- 7:12Max Miller, a Republican from Ohio, announced
- 7:15that he is working on a bill addressing digital
- 7:17asset taxation. So we are waiting for coming
- 7:21more. And of course, Treasury will issue guidance
- 7:24and regulations. So jumping into staking, where
- 7:28are we right now? So right now, we had the Jarrett
- 7:33cases. We have still one Jarrett case pending,
- 7:37technically. And we have the revenue ruling 2023
- 7:41-14, which addressed staking, timing, income,
- 7:45and dominion of control. And we have the general
- 7:47IRS notice, which is probably the most important
- 7:50one for 2014 -21, which basically says, digital
- 7:56assets are property. It's often repeated, but
- 7:59it's not often, the consequences are not often
- 8:03carried over steadfast. So it's the most important
- 8:08principle. It's property and nothing else. So
- 8:14what did the IRS say to staking? It's included
- 8:17when you have domain control, meaning if you
- 8:20can claim it, if you can transfer it. At that
- 8:24time, It has to be included in your taxable income
- 8:29at its ordinary gain at fair market value at
- 8:32the time you got Dominion on Control. And later,
- 8:37sales swaps are capital gains. Dominion on Control
- 8:41has the issue that you also have constructive
- 8:44receipt principles applying here. And there is
- 8:47where the... the IRS revenue ruling was not very
- 8:52clear when and how it applies which leads to
- 8:54a number of problems because when the IRS talks
- 8:58about staking it almost sounds they have one
- 9:00staking principle in mind and that is solo stakers
- 9:03but staking is not equal to staking we have different
- 9:08form of staking and solo staking is just one
- 9:12of them and probably the most famous was the
- 9:16Jarrett case So who is not familiar with Jarrett?
- 9:20The issue there was whether staking rewards are
- 9:23first taxable, up and received, or when they
- 9:26are sold. The DOJ tax division authorized a full
- 9:30refund of the $3 ,793 at play, plus interest
- 9:36for the tax year 2019 to settle the case. The
- 9:40Jarretts wanted to have an opinion on the merits,
- 9:43but the district court in Tennessee holds it.
- 9:47Because the IRS or the DOJ issued the refund,
- 9:51the case was moved. We filed the case for a later
- 9:56tax year last year. Same court, so we will see
- 10:00how that plays out. But the DOJ tax division
- 10:03also says there's no reliance on the refund letter.
- 10:06The decision is not to litigate the case. It's
- 10:10not a decision on the merits. The Gerrits, as
- 10:15well as the revenue ruling, have one in common,
- 10:17and that is that it's solo -staking. So what
- 10:21does that mean? The taxpayer purchased and maintains
- 10:24the hardware. They have to put in the 32Es for
- 10:30one stake to begin staking, and they receive
- 10:33100 % of the staking rewards. They are running
- 10:36the validator nodes themselves. So they have
- 10:39to run. the security. They have to make sure
- 10:42that it's there. They have to make sure that
- 10:44they have the hardware. They have to make sure
- 10:45that 24 -7 internet connection. So because if
- 10:49they are chosen as one of the validators and
- 10:53they cannot maintain their job properly or because
- 10:57the internet connection failed or for other reasons,
- 11:00they can get not only the staking reward slash
- 11:02but also their stake of 32 ETH. So that might
- 11:05be That's why many people are not choosing solo
- 11:09staking, not only because they don't have the
- 11:10technical knowledge, but also they don't have
- 11:13the technical equipment that's necessary. The
- 11:16one thing that takes that apart from all other
- 11:20forms of staking is that it's solo staking, the
- 11:23taxpayer is the one who retains the list wall
- 11:25and the signing keys. What does that mean? Generating
- 11:29and securely storing, validating, operating a
- 11:34validator node. requires the signing keys and
- 11:36the signing keys is the one you use to sign on
- 11:40-chain operations basically. Any transfer you
- 11:42are signing off on with your signing keys. You
- 11:45are the only one who holds that and you are the
- 11:47one who can make that transfer. And you have
- 11:50a withdrawal key for staking meaning it's used
- 11:53to withdraw one staked ease and once this becomes
- 11:58available you can withdraw it and for that you
- 12:01need the withdrawal key. If you have, for example,
- 12:05staking as a service, because you don't want
- 12:07to run the node yourself, you want someone else
- 12:10who has the technical knowledge or the technical
- 12:12equipment to do it, then you can provide the
- 12:17ease to that provider, and they are staking for
- 12:20you. And they are giving you the staking rewards,
- 12:22lesser fee, and they are maintaining the security.
- 12:25They maintain the 24 -step internet connection.
- 12:29But you are giving up your withdrawal. your signing
- 12:34keys, so they are now making the signing for
- 12:36you. The taxpayer retains the custody and the
- 12:43withdrawal keys, but if they order with the withdrawal
- 12:48and it goes through the provider, do they have
- 12:51constructive receipt at that point or not? It
- 12:54is unclear, and it becomes even more unclear
- 12:56when we are going to pool -stake it. Here, you
- 13:00are not even the one with the You are giving
- 13:04your ETH to a pool, to a pool contract, to a
- 13:07pool wallet. And that pooled wallet that receives
- 13:11ETH from all kinds of sources, they are the one
- 13:15who either operates the node or gets engaged
- 13:19by the data provider. So there's no need for
- 13:24the hardware, of course. And you don't have to
- 13:27come up with all of the 32 ETH. eligible for
- 13:33your share of the pool rewards, but 32 ETH is
- 13:38a lot, so not a lot of people can just put in
- 13:4032 ETH. But what does that mean here? Once the
- 13:46pool contract or the pool wallet is eligible
- 13:49for withdrawal, does that mean the taxpayer has
- 13:53constructive receipt? Probably not, probably
- 13:57it is once it hits. the wallet of the taxpayer
- 14:01at least that's the easiest and administrative
- 14:03way to do it because at that point you see it
- 14:06on chain and you don't have to make any assumption
- 14:10of when can he restore was he eligible for restore
- 14:14etc etc but all of these things were not contemplated
- 14:19when the revenue ruling came out so where are
- 14:23we standing we are standing with the jarrett
- 14:25case in court no opinion on the merits in for
- 14:29the 2022 case and still pending the 2024 case.
- 14:34And we have the Joint Committee on Taxation who
- 14:39basically said the IRS has not provided guidance
- 14:42that explicitly addressed whether timing and
- 14:45sourcing rules that are similar to other types
- 14:48of income apply to staking. So they acknowledge
- 14:53that we do not really know. Or at least the IRS
- 14:57has not provided the necessary guidance there.
- 15:00So the taxpayer has some uncertainty. Also, the
- 15:04President's Working Group acknowledged and suggests
- 15:08that Treasury and the IRS should review prior
- 15:10guidance and consider clarifying, modifying,
- 15:13or reversing it, depending on to what conclusions
- 15:20they come. But for staking, the President's Working
- 15:23Group was focused mainly on another issue and
- 15:26that are grantor trust status for ETPs that stake.
- 15:30What are ETPs? ETPs are exchange traded products
- 15:33and they are often set up as investment trusts
- 15:37that aim to be taxed as grantor trusts. So that
- 15:42status lets the fund be a simple pass -through.
- 15:47Investors are treated as directly owning their
- 15:49slice of the coins or tokens. And they typically
- 15:53get a form 1099 and not a K1. So what happens
- 15:58if they are not qualifying? If those limits are
- 16:01broken, the trust is usually taxed as a partnership.
- 16:06And investors then get a scheduled K1. But more
- 16:09importantly, they are faced with more complex
- 16:12reporting, more timing differences, potential
- 16:16difference in types of income. So it's a harder
- 16:19reporting position for the taxpayers, especially
- 16:21for foreign taxpayers. So why is staking the
- 16:25staking point? For grantor trusts, they have
- 16:30special rules for being engaged in businesses.
- 16:33And staking may look like running a business.
- 16:37You're actively validating the network, earning
- 16:39rewards, bearing slashing risk, et cetera. It
- 16:43can also seen as varying investments, changing
- 16:46the funds with return profile beyond passive
- 16:48holdings. So there's a lot in play. So these
- 16:53two points can threaten the investment trust
- 16:57and rental trust treatment. And so far, the IRS
- 17:01or treasury has not provided guidance where the
- 17:06line is between treating for staking and rental
- 17:11trust. So stakeholders want clear guidance on
- 17:15whether crypto ETP that stakes its assets can
- 17:19still be a granted trust. Until then, as I answered,
- 17:24many funds might avoid staking to protect paths
- 17:27with simplicities. And that can certainly not
- 17:30be the goal. Other ask the president's working
- 17:37group. So they basically provided what stakeholders
- 17:42want. They are not providing what the White House
- 17:44necessarily want. But they say stakeholders ask
- 17:49for clear guidance on other topics as well. For
- 17:52example, whether staking activity constitutes
- 17:54a trade or business for federal income tax purposes
- 17:57and related questions including whether staking
- 18:01gives rise to income effectively connected with
- 18:04the conduct of a trade or business in the United
- 18:08States. So if staking, meaning running as a validator,
- 18:13is conducted through people, servers, and the
- 18:16US, it might be seen that the rewards you are
- 18:20earning can be effectively connected income.
- 18:24That's because the node that validated the transactions
- 18:29is located in the US. And if the activity and
- 18:34infrastructure outside the US ECI exposure generally
- 18:38recedes and it's subject to agency and P effect.
- 18:44It's a little bit too complicated here, but that
- 18:47is one issue that is one of, yeah, that's one
- 18:53of the issues. Stakeholders seek clarity. Others
- 18:56are whether staking gives rise to unrelated business
- 18:59taxable income under section 512. So for exempt
- 19:02organizations, staking yields, UBTI, if it constitutes
- 19:06an unrelated trade or business or is debt finance,
- 19:10while passive holdings without operational activities
- 19:13tends not to. It's an unresolved fact -dependent
- 19:19area. And whether staking gives rise to income
- 19:24from commercial activities for purposes of section
- 19:27892, staking that looks like active validation
- 19:32can be commercial activities. and so is flexible
- 19:36despite 892. So whereas purely passive asset
- 19:43holding is more likely to remain exempt, again
- 19:47guidance is very rare here. So another point
- 19:53is whether income from staking is treated as
- 19:56fixed, determinable, annual or periodic income
- 19:59to foreign taxpayers. Staking reward generally
- 20:03resembles service income. So sourced, that would
- 20:08mean if that's the case, it would be sourced
- 20:11where the service occurs. So if performed, most
- 20:16likely, if that is the case, you would look at
- 20:18where there's validation services performed in
- 20:24the US. And they're typically ECI. And if performed
- 20:28outside the US, they're foreign sourced. It might
- 20:35be easier to just look at where the taxpayer
- 20:40is located, but as of now, you might have to
- 20:44look where the note is located, which is not
- 20:46always easily determinable. So the source of
- 20:50income from staking rewards is one of the sore
- 20:54subjects right now. And whether the receipt of
- 20:58airdrops, hard forks invalidates investment trust
- 21:02status. and whether staking benefits from the
- 21:07securities or commodities trading safe harbor
- 21:11of section 864. So the 864C2, the trading safe
- 21:18harbor, covers trading in stocks and securities
- 21:21or qualifying commodities for your own account
- 21:25without being treated as engaged in US trader
- 21:28business. And also here it's not clear whether
- 21:32staking can claim that safe harbor. So there's
- 21:37a lot in the staking world that goes on behind
- 21:41the scene and where we need more clarity and
- 21:44that is certainly a subject where treasury is
- 21:49currently very engaged in and is looking at.
- 21:54Another subject for individuals especially is
- 21:57the transaction of simple wrapping a token. You
- 22:02are not familiar with crypto wrapping a token.
- 22:05It's like checking your code at a global. You
- 22:09hand over the original code, the native token,
- 22:12and you get a claim ticket to the webbed token.
- 22:16And you can use or trade while the code is held
- 22:19safely. And unwrapping is giving back the ticket
- 22:23to get the same code. Assuming that's the...
- 22:28Wrapping contract of the cloakroom is trustworthy
- 22:31and truly one -to -one, otherwise there's a de
- 22:34-pack and a lost code risk that goes too far
- 22:38into its weeds. The main purpose of wrapping
- 22:41is using a certain token on another blockchain.
- 22:44Tokens, for example Bitcoin, can only be used
- 22:47on a Bitcoin blockchain. Bitcoin is trading only
- 22:50so they don't have DeFi protocols. Ethereum,
- 22:54on the other hand, has a number of default protocols
- 22:56which allows you to web or to do other things
- 23:00more commonly associated with the traditional
- 23:04finance industry. And so you might want to use
- 23:08your Bitcoin to participate in these default
- 23:12protocols. So then you can web your Bitcoin,
- 23:15can get a web Bitcoin on the Ethereum blockchain
- 23:18and can use it there. That's the whole purpose
- 23:20of webbing. The President's Working Group acknowledged
- 23:29that it does not state a current rule. Instead,
- 23:36it flags the issue and asks Treasury IRS to issue
- 23:41priority guidance on whether these transactions
- 23:43are taxable events. And again, not the White
- 23:50House is really asking, but on behalf of stakeholders,
- 23:53stakeholder wants these guidance, clarity, if
- 23:57wrapping or unwrapping is taxable. And by implication,
- 24:02that has a multifaceted consequence. So what's
- 24:07with the basis? If it's a non -taxable event,
- 24:09you're carrying forward your basis, your holding
- 24:11period. The character should carry through if
- 24:15it's a non -recognition rule. Whether or not
- 24:21wrapping is a taxable event matters a lot, especially
- 24:25for accounting. And it's a very, very common
- 24:29transaction. It's one of the most used transactions
- 24:33out there. Another one is digital asset lending.
- 24:39And digital asset lending is maybe not as controversial,
- 24:45but it has some pitfalls. If the IRS wants to
- 24:51go that way, that's what I want to make you aware
- 24:54of. So one person follows digital asset lending
- 24:58functions, as you can see here, often like traditional
- 25:02lending. So instead of a bank, you have a lending
- 25:05platform, but you have investors who basically
- 25:08put tokens into a pool and from that pool, both
- 25:13borrowers can loan digital assets. One of the
- 25:18issues is whether or not the investors have a
- 25:21trade -off business. If we were mistaken, that
- 25:25has multiple consequences. And if we are looking
- 25:28at the Commissioner vs. Gretzinger as some older
- 25:31case, which basically describes trade -off business
- 25:36as being with continuity and regularity, then
- 25:43it might be the case that if you're doing it
- 25:45continuously, large -scale, profit -moderated
- 25:48and blending with a more or less active management
- 25:51that you are meeting that test. You have other
- 25:55cases out there, Higgins versus Commissioner
- 25:57from 1987 and Whipple versus Commissioner, no,
- 26:02Gretzinger from 1987. Higgins is from 1941 and
- 26:07Whipple versus Commissioner is from 1963, but
- 26:12Higgins basically said where investment manager
- 26:17management is not trade -off business and the
- 26:20ripple says that well it's the same applies to
- 26:22corporate promotion activities. So there these
- 26:27these trade -off business nuances you have to
- 26:30keep in mind when you advise investors and digital
- 26:33asset lending. Another topic is the interest
- 26:39they're receiving. What is that? Are you reporting
- 26:42it on schedule B as interest or somewhere else?
- 26:45And it's not interest. It's an ordinary fee.
- 26:49Despite if you would look at if you would lending
- 26:51money, it might be interest, but you're not lending
- 26:53money, you're lending property. It's an old case
- 26:56of Deputy versus DuPont from 1940, which basically
- 27:01described interest as compensation for use or
- 27:05forbearance of money, not property. So fees for
- 27:09lending digital assets are ordinary income keen
- 27:11to a borrower fee rather than interest. And another
- 27:17point is the initial investment. Is that a taxable
- 27:22event? It would be pure loaning money. No, it's
- 27:27not a taxable event. But it's not loaning money.
- 27:31And you're giving up your complete tax ownership
- 27:34in some sense. Because the borrower can make
- 27:37and do with that asset whatever they want. You
- 27:40have no control over it anymore. But... No gain
- 27:47or loss should be realized at inception where
- 27:50the contract requires in -kind return of identical
- 27:54assets and substitute equivalent payments so
- 27:59the lender's rights are not materially different.
- 28:02That's the standard under cottage savings in
- 28:06the 1991 case. And recognition risk arises only
- 28:11if terms permit cash settlements or non -identical
- 28:15return. Basically. So the securities lending
- 28:19paradigm and provost from 1926 supports this
- 28:25non -recognition view. Many people jump to 1058,
- 28:30the security laws. But yes, the rationale applies,
- 28:33but the statute does not. The non -recognition
- 28:37logic of 1048 is the same. It's an identical
- 28:41return, substitute payments. no reduction of
- 28:44risk or opportunity. So that supports the non
- 28:47-recognition by close analogy, but 1058 itself
- 28:50generally does not apply because most digital
- 28:52assets are not securities under 1236 c. And if
- 28:58we are looking at the stuff of the Joint Committee
- 29:01of Taxation, they basically say exactly that.
- 29:051058 applies only to loans of security as defined
- 29:09in 1236 c. So many digital assets fall outside
- 29:13of 1058. Defoil loan terms are heterogeneous,
- 29:19low uniform market standards, so that can complicate
- 29:21the treatment. So you have to look at the exact
- 29:24standards or exact loan terms. But the JCT also
- 29:32notes that pre -1058 law or its reasoning might
- 29:36offer non -recognition theories. for digital
- 29:38asset loans. And while they are not really naming
- 29:41what the pre -1058 loan is, the law is, we can
- 29:48just assume that they are referring to provost
- 29:52and cottage savings. And the president working
- 29:57group, or better, the task force stakeholders,
- 30:04they recommend Congress to extend 1058 to fungible
- 30:11digital assets. So that would be their solution
- 30:14to solve that issue. Then we have the Minimus
- 30:19Vaults. The President Working Group bought that
- 30:23up. It was already part of the Loomis -Schuleberg
- 30:27Act, and so now Loomis Act to, say, suggest a
- 30:31600 -dollar the minimalist rules that you don't
- 30:35have to track it below that or tax it below that
- 30:38similar to foreign currency and the president
- 30:41working groups instead suggest something like
- 30:47to exclude small and hard -to -value receipts
- 30:51like miner, air drops, forks or death staking
- 30:54and mining trickles where timing, valuation,
- 30:59control make compliance disproportionately burdensome.
- 31:06Yeah, also that like a source subject during
- 31:11the congress hearing if you're watching, especially
- 31:13Elizabeth Warren took issue with that. Her argument
- 31:18was securities don't have such a rule, de minimis
- 31:21rule. She was ignoring the foreign currency style
- 31:24too, but leaving that aside. I'm not sure if
- 31:28it... offers that much relief, because even if
- 31:31you do not need to track it for one text here,
- 31:36you might have to track it to the next text here
- 31:38for bases. If you're above the $600 minimum or
- 31:44whatever the easy rule would be. So it might
- 31:50be not the relief many people were looking for
- 31:56in my opinion, but It will definitely offer relief
- 32:01for people who are not trading a lot or trading
- 32:03only for small amounts like your Starbucks coffee.
- 32:09Then the President's Working Group has a number
- 32:13of other recommendations and asks. One is the
- 32:16wash sale rule and related rules. So that would
- 32:19add digital assets to 1091, the wash sales rules.
- 32:24coordinating with 1259 which is constructive
- 32:27sales and 1092 which is the straddle rules to
- 32:31prevent mismatch and double counting. Then they
- 32:35want to consider a carve out for payment stable
- 32:37coins which are defined as a genius act to avoid
- 32:41friction on cash equivalent usage and amend for
- 32:47475 to include actively trading fungible digital
- 32:51assets for dealer, trader, to the mark -to -market
- 32:54parity. Then we have the broker reporting, which
- 33:00they want to enable e -furnishing with customer
- 33:05consent more easily, clarifying the correction
- 33:09workflow, explore basis reporting on inter -exchange
- 33:13transfers to preserve lot integrity, basically
- 33:16require reporting when digital assets are paid
- 33:19to trade or business. There's a number of things
- 33:24there and mostly I agree the 1099 VA reporting
- 33:28is, as of now, not very efficient and very burdensome
- 33:33so everything that can make that easier and more
- 33:37straightforward, especially for the taxpayer
- 33:38who receives the 1099 VA in the end, will certainly
- 33:43be helpful. Then we have the cross -border transparency
- 33:47which implements OECD -CAF. OECD project to enable
- 33:55cross -use -diction crypto tax data exchange.
- 34:01They would have to make, if you want to comply
- 34:04to CAF, you would have to make a number of adjustments
- 34:08to current guidance. But one other subject is
- 34:14creating a foreign digital asset account reporting
- 34:17regime. So aligned or merged with 60 -30 8 cap
- 34:22d or the f -bar rules into a single form to reduce
- 34:25duplication confusion. We have the easy payment
- 34:29stablecoins. The Genius Act recently came out
- 34:33and needs to well the Genius Act itself has no
- 34:37tax rules. There are a lot of considerations
- 34:39that go into tax rules for stablecoins that we
- 34:43will explore later but basically implements a
- 34:46payment stablecoin framework and define redeemability,
- 34:50issuer obligation, distinct from investment tokens,
- 34:54clarifying tax characterizations of payment versus
- 34:57investment, withholding reporting rules under
- 35:0060, 45, 1099 DA rules. And the Treasury Department
- 35:07on October 1, 2025 issued proposed rulemaking
- 35:14and asked for comments. for many aspects, including
- 35:19taxation. So the comments, I believe, are due
- 35:23this week. So we will see how that goes. Then
- 35:28we have a corporate overlay book tax camped.
- 35:33So the corporate alternative minimum tax of 15
- 35:35% to adjusted financial statement income. The
- 35:40question is basically, do I have to report the
- 35:44crypto fluctuation? takes it into account for
- 35:47the camped rules. Also here Treasury already
- 35:53reacted and noticed 2025 -46 and 49. They partially
- 36:00withdrew prior guidance, proposed regulations,
- 36:03not prior guidance, proposed regulations, and
- 36:06we proposed some regulations. Basically the interim
- 36:10guidance lets companies exclude unrealized crypto
- 36:13gains losses from there. Adjusted financial statement
- 36:17income and pick them up at sale. And then there
- 36:22are some housekeeping. So we fresh the IRS FHQ,
- 36:28which is quite old and maybe outdated to be to
- 36:32conform with current rulings and regulations.
- 36:36And centralized public guides touch points. So
- 36:42before we go. into the other topics i want to
- 36:50see if we have questions and if not i want to
- 36:52encourage you to ask questions i don't see any
- 36:56so unless susan is stopping me i will just continue
- 37:02which brings us to the 10 60 45 broker reporting
- 37:08and the most important part is it is coming 2025
- 37:14will be the first year which will be reported
- 37:18on 10998 beginning next year. And here it's important
- 37:23to notice that it's for now growth proceeds only.
- 37:27So we don't have bases. It's optional for many
- 37:32exchanges and they struggle to implement it.
- 37:35It's a very tough ask for them. It was a very
- 37:38short time period to implement it. We know it's
- 37:43sensitive. inflation reduction act, but the exact
- 37:46rules we know since 2024, July 2024 for centralized
- 37:50exchanges. So there's a lot to do and the 10
- 37:56-90 -90A reporting will be a lot. So it is expected
- 38:04to be more than all other information reportings
- 38:06combined in volume. So be prepared to receive
- 38:11these reportings. So 2026 and beyond, there will
- 38:16be basis reporting, but you cannot really rely
- 38:19on the basis reporting. It's not like a Schwab
- 38:21account, like where let's say Coinbase always
- 38:25held the crypto asset, but it might come from
- 38:29an on -chain wallet from your taxpayer into Coinbase.
- 38:33So the transfer and he carried over the basis.
- 38:35Coinbase doesn't know the basis at that point.
- 38:38So they can just presume the basis. So it's not
- 38:43like a Schwab account where you buy and sell
- 38:46from the same account all the time. Cryptos is
- 38:50movable, easily movable, and that makes it attractive,
- 38:55but it makes it also hard to report for one single
- 38:59institution reports the accurate basis. So there
- 39:03will be first year no basis and after that often
- 39:09incorrect or incomplete basis information. Then
- 39:13we have who is a broker? Who does report? There
- 39:17was a little bit confusion because of the term
- 39:18digital asset middleman. The IRS is of the opinion
- 39:23that defy brokers and they define what defy brokers
- 39:30are in the December 30, 2024 regulations and
- 39:37they have been removed. Congress first ordered
- 39:43treasury to remove it and a few weeks ago treasury
- 39:46removed these guys so defy will not be reported
- 39:50so only centralized exchanges will report beginning
- 39:58next year so you have a big blind spot there
- 40:01everything that's not on a centralized exchange
- 40:03you have to ask your client for the information
- 40:06and even for the reports you are getting you
- 40:09have to ask if it's correct or not So there's
- 40:13some transitional relief, especially for the
- 40:16solding. But one other aspect you want to be
- 40:20aware of is that some of the gray zone transactions
- 40:25that we covered and others, like wrapping liquidity
- 40:28provider transactions, staking transactions,
- 40:31they will not be reported. They are exempt from
- 40:34reporting by now, as of now, due to notice. I've
- 40:40noticed 2027 -2025 should be 2024 -5057. So please
- 40:48correct that in your records. It's not 2027 yet.
- 40:51But these transactions are not being reported.
- 40:55Be aware of that. You have to ask your taxpayer
- 40:58for these kind of transactions. Then the next
- 41:02one is the basis and wallet by wallet reporting.
- 41:11The accounting is tough enough. It's one of the
- 41:16most difficult parts in crypto taxation, getting
- 41:21the accounting correct, getting the data together,
- 41:24being able to read the data. And one other aspect
- 41:29that was basically common use was the universal
- 41:34wallet approach. What does that mean? It means
- 41:37that you have wallet A, B and C. and you are
- 41:40buying in wallet A one token, you're buying in
- 41:45wallet B two tokens, and you're buying in wallet
- 41:47C three tokens, and you are now selling from
- 41:51wallet C three tokens. If you're reporting FIFO
- 41:56on a universal wallet approach, you would take
- 41:59what is the basis for wallet A and B instead
- 42:02of wallet C to calculate your basis. And that
- 42:08is simply because it is so easily movable. So
- 42:13that was something that was standardly done.
- 42:17The universal pooling of bases. And when the
- 42:23IRS issued their broker regulations in July last
- 42:28year, they included a number of rules for 10
- 42:36.01 and 10 .12. Don't ignore the broker regulations
- 42:41just because they're broker regulations. They
- 42:43have a number of accounting rules in there for
- 42:45brokers but also for individuals that tell you
- 42:49how to report crypto transactions. And one of
- 42:53these rules is regulations 1 .1012 -1j and for
- 43:01acquisitions and dispositions on or after January
- 43:031st 2025, so already in place, it's wallet by
- 43:08wallet accounting. If you don't specifically
- 43:11identify the units, it's also FIFO. And by specifically
- 43:17identifying the unit means that you have documentation
- 43:20in place, latest at the time of the sale, that
- 43:24identifies the unit that you're selling. If you're
- 43:27using a broker to sell it, you have to report
- 43:30that to your broker. In fact, many brokers are
- 43:34right now not in the position to receive these.
- 43:40documentation of these orders that you want to
- 43:42have a certain unit used. But if you don't have
- 43:46the documentation latest at the time of the sale,
- 43:49so not by the end of the text here, not doing
- 43:51the text reporting, but latest by the time of
- 43:54the sale, you cannot use spec ID, specific ID,
- 43:58but you have to go to FIFO according to the IRS.
- 44:02Certainly a point that will be challenged, whether
- 44:06or not set regulations is valid at that point.
- 44:08But that's the position the IS takes at right
- 44:12now. And there's a lot of social media accounts
- 44:18or even LinkedIn accounts from semi -professionals
- 44:22or even from professionals I have seen that claim
- 44:26that that wallet by wallet approach has been
- 44:29postponed late last year with certain notices.
- 44:34But these notices have never postponed the...
- 44:37see wallet -by -wallet accounting itself what
- 44:40they have postponed and for 2025 only you can
- 44:43see it notice 2025 -07 if your custodial broker
- 44:48can accept specific ID instructions you can make
- 44:53the adequate identification in your own books
- 44:55and records that was the relief the IAS offered
- 44:59not see getting rid of a wallet -by -wallet account
- 45:02it's still in place another point more for if
- 45:11you're deep into the rules of the internal revenue
- 45:14codes the change from wallet to wallet accounting
- 45:18to universal accounting and vice versa or from
- 45:22five or two spec ID it's not considered a method
- 45:29change under 446 481 so you don't have to get
- 45:37IaaS approval. So basically what you want to
- 45:42look for 2025 transaction if you have crypto
- 45:46clients you want to make sure that they are wallet
- 45:49by wallet compliant. There are rules -2024 -28
- 45:59revenue procedure that basically gives you a
- 46:04lot of leeway how you make that transition from
- 46:08universal approach to wallet to wallet account
- 46:11basically what they say is any reasonable allocation
- 46:14method suffice document probably the most important
- 46:22part document as was always with this crypto
- 46:26document which brings us to stable coins we have
- 46:32the genius act which was with a lot of news past
- 46:42this year. And as I mentioned, it doesn't have
- 46:46tax reporting rules in it, but it has some interesting
- 46:53consequences for tax reporting, especially in
- 46:56connections with 1099DA, which already considered
- 47:01how to make stablecoin reporting easily by allowing
- 47:05an alternative method to report them, meaning
- 47:11an aggregated reporting for qualified stablecoins.
- 47:17But the terms qualified stablecoins in the 1099
- 47:20DA 6045 section 6045 regulations are not identical
- 47:31with payment stable coins in the genius act.
- 47:35So basically payment stable coins in the genius
- 47:38act say that they need to be redeemable for fiat
- 47:44backed or that they need to be redeemable for
- 47:47fiat currency. The issuer is obligated to redeem
- 47:50for a fixed amount of money the the totes and
- 47:56as of now at least as far as i know There are
- 48:00no payment stablecoins really around because
- 48:03even if we are looking at USDC or USDT, they
- 48:07all have either a certain limit on what you can
- 48:10redeem or very high conditions or requirements
- 48:16under which you can redeem these kind of coins.
- 48:20And others are like DAI, which will never meets
- 48:30the payment stablecoin requirement because there
- 48:33is no institution behind it that can redeem it.
- 48:38But these are all stablecoins that might qualify
- 48:44for qualified stablecoins unless 1090 .98 was.
- 48:48So we will see how treasury handles that. Because
- 48:54right now we have basically three levels of stablecoins.
- 48:58payment stable coins in the genius egg, there's
- 49:01a qualified stable coins for 1099 reporting and
- 49:04you have all other more or less stable coins
- 49:08that are neither outside genius egg, outside
- 49:141099 reporting relief. These are often what's
- 49:20called an algorithmic or hybrid stable coin algorithmic.
- 49:24So stable coins are usually backed by Fiat currencies
- 49:29in US Maybe I should go a step back stable coins.
- 49:33The purpose is that they are reflecting exactly
- 49:36the value of a certain currency usually USD US
- 49:41dollar and they are pegged to the US dollar.
- 49:43They're still fluctuating. They still are worth
- 49:4699 .73 cents per token or one dollar and 0 .003
- 49:56cents So they're still fluctuating around the
- 49:59dollar, that's just the nature of the beast.
- 50:03But they're pretty much pegged to the one dollar.
- 50:06And we have seen it with Luna, for example, a
- 50:08few years ago, that that peg can get lost. And
- 50:14that's why the payment stablecoins require that
- 50:18redemption, so that you really have that one
- 50:21-to -one peg, in fact, and not just in theory.
- 50:26But Luna, for example, was an algorithmic stablecoin.
- 50:29So what they did is they had a parallel token
- 50:36and they burned and minted the parallel token
- 50:41to buy and sell the Luna stablecoin to keep that
- 50:47stablecoin stable. And at some point it broke
- 50:51apart. So they didn't back with fiat currency
- 50:54or other assets. they just tried to keep it algorithmically
- 50:58stable and sorry that had to fail at some point
- 51:03anyway but it did fail tremendously and there
- 51:06were a lot of wells burned at that point so yeah
- 51:14that's what we are handling crypto stable coins
- 51:17with now we are waiting for treasury to provide
- 51:19guidance especially in regards to 1099 reporting
- 51:23But as of now 1099 reporting already considers
- 51:28stable coins but not identical to payment stable
- 51:32coins. That's exactly what I've just talked about.
- 51:42The treasury defines a payment stable coin as
- 51:44a digital asset used for payment settlements
- 51:47where the issuer is obligated to redeem at a
- 51:50fixed monetary value. into maintained stable
- 51:53value. And if you're looking at Circle USDC,
- 52:00if you're looking at the terms and conditions,
- 52:02it's section 13, claim on funds. And for Teza,
- 52:08another very famous stablecoin USDT, it's section
- 52:114 .1, assurances and redemptions. You can see
- 52:16that they're most likely not meeting that requirement.
- 52:21These are some of the most used stablecoins.
- 52:25And as mentioned, another one is DAI, which is
- 52:28MakerDAO. It's a decentralized protocol behind
- 52:32it, so they don't have an institution that can
- 52:35redeem it. So it will be interesting to see if
- 52:40USDC or USDT have to change their terms and conditions,
- 52:45or if they are already considered payment stablecoins
- 52:50for money. point of view, it is unclear. And
- 52:53then you have here the broker reporting and qualified
- 52:56stablecoin rules, which allow aggregated reporting
- 52:59of a certain threshold. If a broker uses the
- 53:05optional reporting method, it may aggregate designated
- 53:09sales per stablecoins. And so usually you have
- 53:14the 1099 reporting for each transaction. And
- 53:18here you can aggregate stable coin transaction
- 53:21because the purpose is since you're fluctuating
- 53:24so closely you want one dollar you're not able
- 53:27to make any gains or losses with stable coins
- 53:29anyway. There are some margin traders out there
- 53:33but the normal trader will not make money with
- 53:37stable coins. So that's why you have the aggregated
- 53:41reporting rules and you have other aggregated
- 53:43reporting rules and 1099 reporting for PDAP,
- 53:48de minimis, and NFTs will not go into that. But
- 53:53these are the mechanics we are working with.
- 53:56And then we have non -fungible tokens. If I miss
- 54:02any questions, let me go back. So we have some
- 54:07questions. And before we go to NFTs, I want to
- 54:09use the time to address that. So for estate planning
- 54:12purposes. How do we enable our clients to securely
- 54:16share their crypto keys with their chosen successor?
- 54:21That is a good question. I'm not an estate planner,
- 54:28so I have not really encountered that issue.
- 54:33Usually, my advice is don't share. Under any
- 54:36circumstances, don't share, even not with me.
- 54:39You don't want to share your keys. but either
- 54:44there might be multiple ways out there for using
- 54:47and I'm just speculating right now. Maybe there
- 54:50are better users out there and whoever knows,
- 54:53welcome to try and send me a message. I will
- 54:58forward it to the person who asked. But one might
- 55:04be to create a safe file system where you have
- 55:09a trusted provider who you. gives a password
- 55:12to that file. Same with going to a bank and putting
- 55:17maybe a printout of these keys in there. But
- 55:23yeah, I agree that is an interesting question.
- 55:28So the IA is the next one, Alexander. IA said
- 55:31two and a half years ago, I think, that taxpayers
- 55:35are responsible for keeping track of their taxable
- 55:37income, including basis in sale of digital asset.
- 55:42not centralized exchanges and not decentralized
- 55:45exchanges. That's correct. That's still the case.
- 55:48Just because Charles Schwab reports for your
- 55:54interest in some kind of securities doesn't mean
- 55:58that you are not responsible for reporting the
- 56:01correct amount. If Charles Schwab is wrong, you
- 56:03have to correct the 1099 on your return. The
- 56:07same is true for centralized exchanges and decentralized
- 56:10exchanges. So you are responsible for the accurate
- 56:13information, not Coinbase, not anyone else. These
- 56:18reports are just helping you. And I hope in a
- 56:21few years we will be there to really help you.
- 56:26And then next one, actually, USDC, et cetera,
- 56:31aren't payment stable points primarily because
- 56:32they don't meet banking requirements. Yes, I
- 56:35agree. They have three years to be compliant.
- 56:38Banks are attempting to launch compliant coins.
- 56:41Okay. If we used to be compliant. Thank you,
- 56:44Alexandra. Thanks again. Yeah. So was Sita asked,
- 56:58so what happens after someone dies? I'm not sure
- 57:03what you mean, but if you refer to the keys again.
- 57:09It usually follows the normal procedure like
- 57:12with bank accounts. Your heirs or whoever receives
- 57:16it through probate or trust or whatever is the
- 57:19one who is owning the crypto. I'm aware of many,
- 57:26many cases where people lost their access to
- 57:30crypto because the person who had the keys died.
- 57:35A very famous case is a person who there exists
- 57:40something like cold storage where you have it
- 57:43on a separate device and not on your on -chain
- 57:51wallet and there's a person who threw away that
- 57:56device and he lost a little or he smoothed away
- 58:02that device when bitcoin was very low in value
- 58:05and then when bitcoin exploded he tried to redeem
- 58:08that that device and couldn't find it especially
- 58:13yeah there's a loss of a lot of unclaimed unknown
- 58:18property right now in crypto world which frankly
- 58:23you will not be able to redeem If the keys are
- 58:27lost, that's the purpose of the keys. You are
- 58:30the one responsible. There is no institution
- 58:32that can help you redeem the key. The purpose
- 58:37of crypto is getting rid of the middleman. The
- 58:41downside to it is there is no middleman who can
- 58:44help you if you lose your keys or your assets.
- 58:49So yeah, if you're losing your keys. unless you
- 58:54find some way to redeem it, then you're out of
- 58:58luck. Maybe one day when we have quantum computers
- 59:01and we will be able to break the security behind
- 59:06Bitcoin, maybe then you will be able to redeem
- 59:09it, but I'm afraid that once that is the case,
- 59:11the value will drop as well. So just... Oh, Alexander
- 59:19just said, there are some great new procedures
- 59:22for probate avoidance, but protection, cold storage,
- 59:26key password with fiduciary, safe deposit box
- 59:29with hardware, et cetera. Yeah, cold storage
- 59:34is the same issue that you have with every other.
- 59:38You still need the keys if you lose the cold
- 59:41storage or the keys and you're out of luck, but
- 59:43keeping passwords with fiduciaries, there's an
- 59:46option if there's services out there. It might
- 59:48be the case that there are services out there
- 59:50that keeps it safe for you. So we are out of
- 59:54time quickly for NFTs. There are different rules
- 59:59for creator and who is just swapping them. There
- 1:00:05are inventory considerations you have to have
- 1:00:07if you're a creator or if you create them even
- 1:00:10on a trade or business basis. There are holding
- 1:00:14periods. There's a collectible angle. the IRS
- 1:00:16came out with a notice 2023 -27 which said that
- 1:00:23they believe if they apply a look -through approach
- 1:00:26and if the NFT represents and reflects an item
- 1:00:35that is considered art or any other collectible
- 1:00:37under the rules then they will consider that
- 1:00:42NFT to be a collectible as well. I find that
- 1:00:45very questionable, and the ABA addresses that
- 1:00:48issue because it bases on section 48K, and 48K
- 1:00:56in the end says, or other tangible objects. So
- 1:01:01that would mean that you have to classify the
- 1:01:04NFT as a tangible object. It might be difficult
- 1:01:07in many cases. But the notice seeks comment,
- 1:01:14and it was never finalized. They said that while
- 1:01:17the finalization process is pending, they will
- 1:01:21apply their view already as a look -through approach.
- 1:01:24So far, I have not been confronted, at least
- 1:01:30not seriously confronted, by any IRS auditor
- 1:01:33who says that NFTs are collectible. I hope that
- 1:01:36stays that way. But there are good arguments
- 1:01:39why it shouldn't be collectibles. And at that
- 1:01:43point, I want to thank you. Thank you for your
- 1:01:46participation. I'm too old. And have a great
- 1:01:53afternoon, all of you. This concludes today's
- 1:02:00presentation. Thank you so much, Philipp, for
- 1:02:02your time today. And thank you so much to our
- 1:02:03audience. Have a great day, everybody.