Latest / James O'Brien Daily / Will American’s choose Trump again?
Transcript
- 0:02This is a global production.
- 0:06Hello and welcome to another installment of my daily podcast, full of the best bits of news, discussion and discoveries from my LBC show.
- 0:18We begin with Shabana Mahmood, who has achieved the almost impossible.
- 0:22She has managed to please none of the people any of the time.
- 0:27I normally when a politician does something unpopular or something that is portrayed in some corners of the media as unpopular or something that reaches public opinion as being unpopular, then there is a yang to the yin, isn't there?
- 0:45There's a balance that for every everybody who hates something, there might be a couple of people who like it.
- 0:50And for everybody who adores something, there might be a few people who absolutely hate it.
- 0:59And for reasons that I don't think we got close to pinning down yesterday, Shabana Mahmood has absolutely fluffed it.
- 1:08That was close.
- 1:08Keith, you got your finger on the button, I hope, today.
- 1:11So sometimes I'm heading home and it occurs to me that we had a really good phone in, we had a really good time together, we did a really good show, but we didn't actually answer the first question I
- 1:23came up with.
- 1:25And yesterday I think that that happened.
- 1:28Extraordinary contributions to the conversation about slavery and reparations.
- 1:32I'm genuinely proud of that.
- 1:34So thank you to everybody who helped push that one along.
- 1:37And we had a really good conversation about Shabana Mahmood and the fundamental injustice of telling people who do really, I would say, beautiful work.
- 1:46Actually, as somebody who currently relies upon carers, and to be clear, it doesn't matter whether they are state funded or privately funded, quite often the agencies that are doing the caring will be private sector agencies being paid by
- 2:01public sector institutions.
- 2:03So there's no distinction to be drawn here between people who can afford to pay or people who have to pay, actually, whether they think they can afford it or not, simply by dint of their assets.
- 2:12There's absolutely no political distinction to be made here in society.
- 2:16Even I imagine some of the wealthiest people in the world in this country paying for carers to look after their loved ones will be relying upon people who are recently arrived, because that is how the sector is constituted.
- 2:29A sector absolutely riven still with vacancies, with shortages, staff shortages.
- 2:37So I think we nailed something important yesterday that I'd previously missed, which is that focusing upon care workers is a bit of a red herring.
- 2:46It's an emotive decision that she's made because care workers tug at the heartstring so effectively.
- 2:53How do I know that?
- 2:54Because they flipping tug at mine.
- 2:56I'll tell you and the idea that we're telling them, particularly the ones that only arrived two, three, four years ago, that the five years you were expecting to do before feeling secure and safe and welcome here would be
- 3:08extended in some cases to 15, 15 years.
- 3:12And she's backed down on that for care workers, but not really for anybody else, which is a grim thing to do in many ways, albeit that I called for it and I welcome it.
- 3:23In one sense, it's introducing this idea of value beyond finance while denying the idea of value beyond finance across the broader policy.
- 3:34Just think about this for a minute, 50 grand and above, and you'll find it a heck of a lot easier to get indefinite leave to remain than you would if you're earning under that figure.
- 3:46It's an arbitrary number.
- 3:47She's picked it.
- 3:48And I can just about get my head around how some people might be comfortable with that.
- 3:54You know, I don't care what they're doing, I care only about what they earn.
- 3:58As Oscar Wilde famously opined about cynics, they know the price of everything and the value of nothing.
- 4:06And Shyvana Mahmoud in many ways has taken Oscar's observation, Oscar's aper sous and applied it to the whole of our society, or at least the foreign born bits of our society.
- 4:18Because if you currently earn 50 grand a year, if you currently earn below 50,000 pounds a year, then you probably, except in purely fiscal terms, I don't think you feel like a second class citizen, do you?
- 4:37I mean, I know that you have less financial freedom than people who earn more than you, but your access to, for example, public services is not diminished by your lack of funds.
- 4:49I mean, if you are earning a lot less than £50,000 a year, your eligibility for universal credit is not diminished.
- 4:56It would be mad if it was by the fact that you're not earning much.
- 5:01So I can't think of any other cohort of our community who is rendered second class in the eyes of our society by what they earn than recently arrived migrants.
- 5:16If you were a refugee fleeing a genuine hellhole, let's just for the sake of argument, talk about a genitally mutilated woman fleeing the Taliban.
- 5:28All right, just, just, just to keep it absolutely crystal clear that this is someone deeply deserving of our care and protection, if you were fleeing an absolute hellhole in the final days of John Major's premiership, ask your parents
- 5:43if you don't know what I'm talking about.
- 5:45If you were fleeing genuine persecution, hideous persecution in the final days of John Major's premiership and you somehow managed to get here.
- 5:58Under Shabana Mahmood's proposals, you wouldn't have independent leave to remain yet under one analysis.
- 6:07Well, no, under her proposals, under Shabana Mahmood's proposals, you would not have the right to remain.
- 6:13You wouldn't be able to feel safe or secure.
- 6:15You wouldn't be able to go to bed at night knowing that there's not going to be a knock on the door in the morning telling you that, you know, you've got to sling your hook.
- 6:23You think I'm exaggerating?
- 6:24Meet Windrush.
- 6:25Meet Windrush.
- 6:28So if you earn under £50,000 a year and you're foreign, you're a second class citizen, you're okay.
- 6:35If you're not foreign at the moment, you're not going to be denied access to anything except sort of material and private sector purchases.
- 6:44And if you're a care worker, then you don't need to worry about the cost or the scale of your earnings because, oh, what you do is really valuable.
- 6:56So if you're not a care worker and you live in this country at the moment and you're not foreign, you're not a second class citizen, don't worry.
- 7:04But if you are a care worker and you are foreign and you're not a care worker, Sorry, if you're not a care worker, you're a second class, I mean, this is the thing that I find so insidious about
- 7:17this.
- 7:18I'm just gonna sort of reprogram my brain because I keep misspeaking.
- 7:21All right?
- 7:21Do you mind?
- 7:22Will you just excuse me for one moment?
- 7:24Indefinite, indefinite.
- 7:25Indefinite, indefinite.
- 7:26Indefinite, indefinite, indefinite.
- 7:28Malcolm Gladwell says you have to do something a thousand times, but that even by my standards that would make for a fairly boring radio show.
- 7:35So it's indefinite, indefinite, indefinite, leave to remain.
- 7:38Indefinite leave to remain.
- 7:40Stop saying independent.
- 7:42What I think.
- 7:43And sometimes I get this stuff horribly wrong.
- 7:45Sometimes I stumble into remarkable rightness.
- 7:50But the overriding non migrant element or non expat element of what Shabana Mahmoud is this.
- 8:00It creates two tears.
- 8:03Not in the way that Farage and his mates like to lie about the police, but it creates two tiers.
- 8:08It is apportioning value to people in ways that are not logical or particularly nice.
- 8:17You earn less than £50,000 a year.
- 8:20It doesn't matter what you're doing.
- 8:23It doesn't matter whether you are doing work that society would grind to a shuddering halt without.
- 8:30It doesn't matter whether you are doing work that literally keeps people alive.
- 8:34It doesn't matter whether you are doing work that oils the wheels of society for people earning a hell of a lot more than you, it doesn't matter that if you're doing a job without which the people earning a
- 8:44lot of money and making big contributions to the treasury wouldn't be able to do their work, it doesn't matter what you're doing.
- 8:51Unless you're a care worker, you are second class.
- 8:56You are less than the people earning more than £50,000 a year.
- 9:02And the same is true, of course, of that actual, of that actual job.
- 9:07If you are doing anything, then you are of less value than a care worker.
- 9:13So you look at your finance and you look at your job description and you are now, we are all now living in a country where you are a less valuable member of society based on entirely arbitrary distinctions imposed
- 9:29by a politician, right?
- 9:31But I don't think it's actually today the most important element of what happened yesterday, you know, it's a philosophical complaint that doesn't affect most of us.
- 9:40In fact, you know, unless you're either a recently arrived foreigner on less than or soon to arrive foreigner on less than 50 grand a year, or you are somebody doing a job that you consider to be really bloody
- 9:54hard and very important, but you're getting paid less than fifty grand, then it doesn't matter, does it?
- 10:00Because it's not happening to me, it's not happening to you, it's not happening, happening to us and ours.
- 10:04But the simple rule now that you are second class.
- 10:11Listen, of course I'm well aware that we live in a hierarchical society and the more money you've got, the easier life is and the better you're treated by almost every corner of society, the easier things are in almost
- 10:22every imaginable way, but not formally, not delineated.
- 10:26No one's ever put a number or a threshold on it below which you are less than.
- 10:31You are less than.
- 10:33I hate that.
- 10:36I hate that.
- 10:36I don't know why I hate it.
- 10:39It just feels to me to be really dangerous.
- 10:43A lot of the jobs that I think society needs most are quite poorly paid.
- 10:49I'll say that again because I don't think it should be a controversial comment.
- 10:53A lot of the jobs that I think our society needs most are quite poorly paid.
- 10:59And Shabana Mahmoud today, by association, renders everybody doing a job that pays less than £50,000 a year fundamentally less than the others, not earning less than, but worth less than to our society, right?
- 11:20And then the other element of it, and the one that we should probably talk about.
- 11:25Which quite rightly makes you wonder why I've spent so long talking about the thing that we're not going to talk about.
- 11:29Well, you can talk about this if you.
- 11:31I just don't think it's as acute yet.
- 11:32I don't think it's going to be felt as deeply yet, except by the people to whom it is happening but hasn't happened yet.
- 11:40The other element of this is why she's done it.
- 11:45The 10 billion quid figure is an absolute nonsense and it's really easy to explain why it is an absolute nonsense.
- 11:56So she claimed that she would save 10 billion pounds by introducing this policy.
- 12:02There would be a 10 billion pound drain on our public finances if these people were left within the indefinite leave to remain system that Shabana Mahmood inherited.
- 12:15This was based on.
- 12:16This is really important.
- 12:17I'm going to do my best to explain it.
- 12:19A nine and a half billion pound fiscal cost of migrants currently working on social care visas staying here after those visas expired and most of that nine and a half billion pound lifetime fiscal cost would rise after they
- 12:35retired in 30 years time.
- 12:38So she says by denying these people independent leave to remain, we save ourselves the nine and a half billion pounds that they would cost us when they retired and needed pensions or needed looking after, needed, perish the thought,
- 12:54the kind of social care they've spent 30 years providing to you and me and our parents and our grandparents and possibly our children.
- 13:03How look at these people here, providing social care for your nan.
- 13:07Do you know that in 30 years time after they've completed these 10 hour days for the best part of three decades, do you know how much it's going to cost for them to get what they've been doing for
- 13:16you?
- 13:16Too much, says Shabana Mahmood.
- 13:18Let's not let them live here, let's not let them stay.
- 13:21And even though it's morally rancid, it's fiscally incompetent because that figure, that nine and a half billion pound figure, completely ignores the very simple fact that even if it takes them 10 years to achieve independent leave to remain,
- 13:39then whatever cost they bring in is going to be the same 20 years later or 10 years later as it would be if it was 30 years later.
- 13:47So it's not only hideous and profoundly un British.
- 13:52I don't want to say unchristian because it would sound like I was having a swing at Shabana Mahmood.
- 13:57I don't know her religious history or her religious background.
- 13:59And you know that that's not how I work.
- 14:00But I was raised a Christian and I live in a Christian country.
- 14:04And you don't need to know a lot about Jesus to know that he cared about the most vulnerable people in society.
- 14:10And therefore, one presumes, cared quite a lot about the people who look after the most vulnerable people in society.
- 14:16But not Shabana Mahmood.
- 14:18Because that figure, that 10, well, nine and a half billion pound figure rounded up by Shabana Mahmud to 10 billion pounds, was not only 30 years away, but completely ignored the fact that the same cohort of people would
- 14:32contribute an estimated £9 billion over that 30 year period.
- 14:37So this ridiculous woman today gets attacked by nasty lying newspapers for climbing down on a 10 billion pound saving that never existed in the first place.
- 14:52You see what I mean about pleasing none of the people, none of the time?
- 14:55The 10 billion pound figure is bogus.
- 14:58It's false.
- 14:59It not only completely ignores the fact that that figure would be run up by people currently wor working in the care sector whether they stayed here for 10 years, 20 years or 30 years.
- 15:10But it also ignores that the nine and a half billion pound claim that it's built on absolutely ignores the 9 billion pound contribution that these people would make in the interim.
- 15:20So it's approximately 6% of £10 billion that she is supposedly saving.
- 15:26And if you insert the low earning migrant worker into the same cohort as the highly skilled migrant worker, then over the same period of time, the few million quid that you're saving is completely eclipsed by the 150 billion
- 15:42pound net contribution that highly skilled migrant workers will make over the same period of time.
- 15:47Why do I do this?
- 15:48Why do I flipping bother?
- 15:49Does it reach the sides of your understanding?
- 15:52Do you get it?
- 15:52Can you count?
- 15:54Because Shabana Mahmood can't.
- 15:55The editor of the Daily Telegraph can't.
- 15:57The editor of the Daily Mail can't.
- 15:59They can't count.
- 16:00There is no 10 billion pound saving.
- 16:02And the British media today is almost exclusively dedicated for attacking Shabana Mahmood for abandoning a 10 billion pound saving.
- 16:10How can you climb down from a mountain that doesn't exist?
- 16:13Do you care about this stuff?
- 16:15Can you count?
- 16:16Does it matter to anybody anymore?
- 16:19The facts, the facts, the facts, the figures, the numbers, the stats or perish the perish, the thought, the people, the humans, the mums, the dads, the carers, the children, the people, the neighbours, the colleagues, the friends, the helpers,
- 16:37the nurses.
- 16:39You don't care about them.
- 16:40You should care about the numbers.
- 16:43But we don't.
- 16:45So it is not Only a policy.
- 16:47Here's the maddest thing of all.
- 16:49Right, the maddest thing of all.
- 16:53It's a policy that's been introduced to appease people who might otherwise vote for a far right party that would do the same policies.
- 17:01Think about that.
- 17:02It's really important.
- 17:03Why has she done it?
- 17:04She's done it to appease ignorant, xenophobic voters who don't understand the simple mathematics that I've just explained to you and hate seeing Brown faces in John Lewis Christmas adverts.
- 17:15She's done it to appease them because if she didn't do it, she's worried that they might vote for a party that would do the things she's doing.
- 17:23That's the definition of insanity.
- 17:25Albert Einstein never said that.
- 17:27The definition of insanity involves doing the same thing over and over again in the hope of a different result.
- 17:33He never said it.
- 17:34I'll give you a definition of insanity.
- 17:35Doing something disgusting because you're worried that if you don't do it, somebody disgusting might do the same disgusting things that you're doing in order to appease the people who want the disgusting things done because they're too thick to
- 17:45count.
- 17:47That's Brexit Britain.
- 17:49That's Brexit Britain.
- 17:52And Shabana Mahmood is doing this.
- 17:55Not Nigel Farage, not 30p Lee, who has the look at the moment of a man who spends every morning sandpapering his own head.
- 18:04It is being done by a Labour Home Secretary.
- 18:09And I mean, I don't think this will come as a major surprise to anybody, but it won't work.
- 18:17It won't work.
- 18:17People who understand things will hate it.
- 18:20And people who don't understand things will be conditioned and gaslit to hate it because they're already swallowing absolute crapola about 10 billion pounds.
- 18:30So people who can understand what's going on will hate this policy because it's inhuman and un British and statistically bankrupt.
- 18:39And people who.
- 18:40Who don't understand this policy will hate it because the Daily Mail and the Daily Telegraph and your friendly neighborhood far right broadcasters are all telling you that she's somehow sacrificed £10 billion of your money upon the altars of
- 18:52open borders.
- 18:54It's beyond a word I can't say on the radio, however angry I might be.
- 18:58It's beyond that word.
- 18:59It's beyond Rolex.
- 19:00It's utterly, utterly rancid.
- 19:02This one of the worst things that's happened in all my years presenting current affairs programming on the radio, because it is an utter detachment from observable reality.
- 19:14And it's being done by a Labour Home Secretary and it's not about, oh, we are.
- 19:19Well, I can't even be bothered to look in idiot's corner.
- 19:21Let me just speculate.
- 19:23Overpopulated, out of touch.
- 19:26You don't understand this.
- 19:27Why I don't even bloody live in Chiswick, which is one of the texts I get quite a lot.
- 19:31And even if I did still live in Chiswick, this is London.
- 19:34This is the most multicultural, multicolored city in the world.
- 19:37Do you think you can walk through London without seeing lots of different colored faces?
- 19:41Even if you live in flipping Mayfair?
- 19:43It's a multicultural city where if someone needs looking after, the person doing the looking after is probably more likely today to be foreign born than they are to be British born.
- 19:53So what's Shabana Mahmud done?
- 19:55She's made everybody's lives meaner, shorter, nastier and I don't know why she's done it, unless it's that theory.
- 20:05Unless she is trying to appease ignorant, unpleasant, ill informed people.
- 20:10Because if she doesn't somehow appease them, then they might vote for some really nasty characters to do exactly the same thing.
- 20:18Why do you think she's done it?
- 20:20Talia is in Estepona.
- 20:21Talia is there still.
- 20:23Have you phoned me before?
- 20:24Did I ask you a question about Go Karts last time you rang me?
- 20:27Yes, and it is still open.
- 20:29Right, carry on.
- 20:30What made you pick up the phone today?
- 20:33Well, a couple of things.
- 20:34One is I am going through the visa process at the moment.
- 20:37My husband is British, I'm Italian, have two British children.
- 20:42We want to go back for family reasons.
- 20:44And so I'm going through that process now.
- 20:47All of, all of the cars I have are in my favor.
- 20:49I've been able to do it by the savings.
- 20:52It's all been good and it's still been really difficult.
- 20:55But when yesterday I came back home, you were talking about this and I heard it, you know, I thought, what a pity I couldn't ring in because I have a theory, a hypothesis of why this has been done
- 21:07and it's related to rejoining the eu.
- 21:10I think one of the hard lessons that we've learned from Brexit is that the UK can't function without immigration.
- 21:18So what happened was once the EU freedom of movement was cut off and all of the care worker nurses that were going in and out of the UK from Spain, from any other countries that was cut off, then
- 21:32immigration had to come in anyway from other countries.
- 21:36And I think that making it harder for people from Other countries to come in at the moment is going to open up a gap where maybe, hopefully EU workers can go straight in.
- 21:51I think that's my theory.
- 21:53It's like a medium term where the gap is going to be filled by EU workers.
- 22:02Well, Blumen, heck, I mean, that puts me on a.
- 22:06I mean, I need a little bit of a run up for this one.
- 22:10So I think you're wrong.
- 22:12I mean, I think you're hideously and horribly wrong.
- 22:16But I wish that I.
- 22:17No, I'm sorry.
- 22:18Cause it may affect you.
- 22:19This.
- 22:20I just.
- 22:22I mean, number one, they're not going to be bringing freedom of movement back for fellow European Union members in this parliament or I don't imagine, in the next one.
- 22:31I haven't upset you, have I?
- 22:32I think that.
- 22:33No, no, it's not.
- 22:34I think it's going to be in the next manifesto.
- 22:36Yeah, but this would be them saying, we'll, we'll.
- 22:39Because this would apply to everybody.
- 22:41And then you're saying, well, if we bring back freedom of movement, then European Union citizens will get a swerve on the rules that are in place for everybody else.
- 22:49Yeah,.
- 22:50They won't apply.
- 22:52Yeah.
- 22:52Because.
- 22:52Well, I, I am, I'm also.
- 22:54I love your thinking.
- 22:55I love the way your brain works.
- 22:57Because this is.
- 22:57Yeah, well, I'm a thing of beauty.
- 22:59Okay, well, there you go.
- 23:00Actually.
- 23:01Yeah, I'm a psychologist, so I, I got a degree from a UK university, so I tried to do it via the working visa.
- 23:10Yeah.
- 23:10And it's really, it's, it's hard, you know, so much that I thought.
- 23:14No, thought this.
- 23:15I'm just gonna go the other way because it's just a little bit complicated because you go to, to agencies and they have a certain number of openings because you have to earn a certain amount of money.
- 23:26They only have a certain amount of openings, which makes it obviously much harder to get because you have to go over that threshold.
- 23:33When I think that making that threshold harder or making less appealing, if you want to do, if you really are in a country and you really want to go to the uk, you'll jump through the loops.
- 23:43But if you're thinking, well, shall I go to the UK or shall I go to Germany or should I go somewhere else a bit more friendly, then you might just do that.
- 23:50And then the requirement, maybe there'll be more openings which will make people come in.
- 23:55Now if the manifesto for next election is, let's start, you know, single market rejoining, then there's going to be a massive, massive opening for people like it was before Brexit.
- 24:07You know, Spanish nurses that would go there learning this day for a few years, come back home and all of that.
- 24:13And then, of course, you need to make it now less appealing,.
- 24:17Otherwise.
- 24:18Immigration figures are going to go incredibly high.
- 24:21Well, number one, they're not.
- 24:23If you're.
- 24:24If you're.
- 24:24If you're.
- 24:25If you're a mobile young worker in Europe, the UK is the last place you'd come.
- 24:31You'd be better off.
- 24:32No,.
- 24:32It is, it is in terms of job opportunities.
- 24:35Well, it is now.
- 24:36Yeah,.
- 24:36I know.
- 24:36I'm talking about now.
- 24:38Of course it is now.
- 24:39And that's not going to change anytime.
- 24:40No,.
- 24:40It is now, because you have to jump through the loop.
- 24:42No, it's not.
- 24:43It's our economy.
- 24:44I mean, there's our job vacancies.
- 24:46You'd be better off in Poland.
- 24:48That's why so many Polish.
- 24:49People have gone.
- 24:49Back.
- 24:50I completely disagree.
- 24:51And.
- 24:51The.
- 24:51Second.
- 24:52Thing,.
- 24:52The young people that I know, I'd like this argument.
- 24:54Because I want you to be right.
- 24:56But the second reason why you're wrong is that this policy was introduced when Keir Starmer was Prime Minister.
- 25:03And Keir Starmer was absolutely adamant that there was no way we'd be rejoining the European Union in his lifetime.
- 25:09In this manifestation.
- 25:10And Shabana Mahmood is a part.
- 25:11No, no.
- 25:12In his lifetime and he was Prime Minister.
- 25:16And Shabana Mahmood has rejected Andy Burnham's warmer words about closer European integration.
- 25:22And John Healey, the Chancellor, has rejected Andy Burn warmer words about closer European Union integration.
- 25:27So while one element of your theory might be right, and we are, regardless of the objections of people like Shabana Mahmood and John Healey and previously Keir Starmer, Andy Burnham may actually grasp this nettle of ineluctable logic and
- 25:40move us back towards the biggest single market in the history of humanity that we used to be one of the single most intrinsic parts of.
- 25:48That's not why Shabana Mahmood has introduced the policy that she's introduced.
- 25:53I mean, I can't prove it any more than I can prove that I'm right, but I think if we were to take a quick referendum on it, the idea that she's trying to appease people who might otherwise vote
- 26:02for a far right party that would introduce exactly the same policies covers a lot more bases than your dream.
- 26:08And my dream that she's doing it as a precursor to reintroducing freedom of movement of Labour for European Union members.
- 26:16Time for a short break now.
- 26:17Afterwards, the Best callers in the business.
- 26:27Two more things, important things.
- 26:30Thing number one, Andy Burnham is on board with this, right?
- 26:33It's.
- 26:34I don't know if it's sort of low level misogyny for me to pin all the blame upon the woman in the Home Office.
- 26:39Andy Burnham is the Prime Minister.
- 26:40If we were still doing the Bob, the Burnham optimism barometer, which was abandoned because it kept giving 10 out of 10 results because we chose the wrong method of measuring averages, although all of my colleagues deny that, I
- 26:54don't think it would be 10 today.
- 26:55This is Andy Burnham's government.
- 26:57This is Andy Burnham's Home Secretary.
- 26:59This is Andy Burnham's policy.
- 27:01Make no mistake about that.
- 27:04When he was campaigning in Makerfield, this ludicrous phrase of Faridge's.
- 27:10Is that an unnecessary.
- 27:11Do I need to say ludicrous phrase if I'm saying Farage?
- 27:14I don't really, do I?
- 27:15But anyway, I think trying to call him open borders Burnham when his Brexit, of course, caused an absolute explosion in immigration, albeit that when he was campaigning for Brexit, he was saying that we should take more people from
- 27:27precisely the countries that we're now taking more people from.
- 27:29Weird that, isn't it?
- 27:30It's almost like he's a supremely dishonest individual.
- 27:33But Burnham responded to that by reminding people that he was in the Home Office when Tony Blair was Prime Minister and was in charge of overseeing returns.
- 27:42He makes political capital out of how comfortable he is with quite draconian policies.
- 27:48And there's nothing de facto wrong with draconian policies if they are logical and consistent and fair.
- 27:57But the policies that his Home Secretary has introduced are none of those things.
- 28:01And part of the reason for that might be that she is attempting to feed an insatiable appetite.
- 28:08You know, the ill informed, largely xenophobic attitudes towards immigration among people who never stop talking about it.
- 28:15It can only really be cured by knowledge and understanding.
- 28:19You never cure the bigots because they live for the hate.
- 28:22But the other people who simply believe things that aren't true because they're told them all the time, like the 10 billion pound figure today.
- 28:29The only way to assuage their concerns is to make sure that they understand the truth.
- 28:35Labor given up on that.
- 28:36They gave up on that long before Keir Starmer got into Downing Street.
- 28:40So here's theory two.
- 28:43Here's theory two, right?
- 28:46They are doing it not because they're trying to appease people who would otherwise vote for far right parties who will do exactly the same thing.
- 28:56They are Doing it in order to appease people who would otherwise vote for far right parties who will do much worse.
- 29:06And if you let that penny drop, you might find yourself feeling a little bit warmer towards the whole hideous idea than you did one minute ago.
- 29:16I don't know how much attention you pay to the sewers of social media, but there's a character called Rupert Lowe who I think is probably best known for phoning the police when some charity rowers were sighted off the
- 29:29coast of Norfolk because he thought they'd somehow sailed there from, I don't know where it would be Boston, I suppose.
- 29:37He is proposing all sorts of, I mean, very 1930s Germany kind of policies.
- 29:44And Nigel Farage, of course, has to tack even further to the right.
- 29:48So the idea of removing people from this country who have every legal right to be here is now on the political table in the United Kingdom because Brexit was so successful at assuaging and dealing with all of those
- 30:02attitudes.
- 30:03So if you had to construct a defense for Shabana Mahmood, it would be, well, we've got to lance these boils now.
- 30:12Even though they are boils full of the pus of ignorance and xenophobia, we have to lance these boils because if we don't, those people are going to vote for parties that are going to do really disgusting things, that
- 30:26are going to do Nazi adjacent, pre Holocaust things.
- 30:33And if you believe that's possible, you should be a bit, I don't know, maybe we should be a bit kinder to Shabana Mahmoud and Andy Burnham today.
- 30:42But it's still a boil full of the pus of disinformation and xenophobia, you know, and if you lance it today, the way boils work, my apologies if you're having your 11s, is they fill up again, don't they, Keith?
- 31:00They fill up again.
- 31:02Anna's in Edinburgh.
- 31:03Anna, what would you like to say?
- 31:05Hi there.
- 31:06Thanks for taking my call.
- 31:07You're very welcome.
- 31:09I listened to your phone in yesterday and I have turned this question over in my head about why she's done it.
- 31:15Me too,.
- 31:16Because we're affected, just to be honest.
- 31:18My family defected.
- 31:19My husband was due to apply for indefinite leave to remain next year.
- 31:23He doesn't earn enough.
- 31:24It's now been doubled.
- 31:27And he's not in the.
- 31:28The sectors where he would be a higher class citizen than he is in the sector.
- 31:32No, he's not.
- 31:33He.
- 31:33Owns his own business, unemploys.
- 31:34People.
- 31:35Down with that sort of thing.
- 31:36Down with that sort of thing.
- 31:38So my.
- 31:40What I think it is.
- 31:42And you hitting.
- 31:43On Andy Burnham's on board with this?
- 31:46I think this is the government admitting that they cannot make things tangibly better for the majority of people in society, but they can make things swiftly and tangibly worse for migrant families.
- 31:59And I think that that is the thing that will appease the xenophobes, the racists, the people who go, well, you know, why are they getting something?
- 32:10Do.
- 32:11You, though?
- 32:11I mean, let's say you're right and that's the plan.
- 32:14Do you think it will work really.
- 32:18Well?
- 32:19I listened to a call yesterday on Sheila's, on Sheila's calling and it was a woman who was going, well, you know, I'm just trying to get back into the workforce and, you know, I don't feel any particular way
- 32:31about race, but, you know, maybe this will help me.
- 32:33There's.
- 32:3426,000 vacancies in the care sector.
- 32:36Well, no nursing alone, God knows how many in the care sector.
- 32:39So I.
- 32:40Do think that people do think that, you know, I don't understand what punishing my family who have done everything that they can to comply with the rules.
- 32:52I don't understand what, what people will think will benefit them from that.
- 32:56However, I think.
- 32:57The cruelty is the point.
- 32:59The cruelty is the point.
- 33:00But when this woman who rang Sheila yesterday doesn't find it any easier to get another job and your husband has his indefinite leave to remain arbitrarily postponed for an extra five years, where does that support go?
- 33:16Well, it doesn't, does it?
- 33:19But then that kind of leads on to my second point, is that while there will be no saving, what she has done is she has added insecurity to all of our households.
- 33:29Yes.
- 33:30So we had planned.
- 33:32So we've got two small children and we knew that, you know, while my husband pays tax, while he pays his National Insurance are charged and he pays into the NHS and all the rest.
- 33:41Just for the benefit of the tape and quite possibly for the benefit of the woman that you mentioned.
- 33:45Remind us what the National Health surcharges.
- 33:48It is £2,587 50 every time you renew.
- 33:53And he pays that whether he's ill or not?
- 33:56Yes,.
- 33:56Every year.
- 33:58He pays that Every two years.
- 33:59Every two years, the full.
- 34:02That's to.
- 34:03Have access to the nhs.
- 34:04So just shy of three grand a year, he has to find, after paying tax from his net post taxed income just to have access to the nhs.
- 34:11And there will be radio presenters and newspaper columnists who still call him a health tourist.
- 34:16Yes.
- 34:18So the full Cost of renewing Your visa is £3,994 50.
- 34:23The breakdown of that being £1,407 to the Home Office and £2,587.50 to the NHS surcharge.
- 34:32So what this is going to do to my household with just one visa to renew now for an extra five years, that's £11,982 that my household now has to find that we expected that we wouldn't have to find
- 34:46next.
- 34:46Year.
- 34:47And he's being persecuted for not earning more at the same time.
- 34:52So the people who are going to be hit hardest by what it currently costs to be in this cohort are precisely the people that Shabana Mahmood decided to add to the burdens of yesterday and exclude from some of
- 35:04the paths that people earning a heck of a lot more money would be required to walk down.
- 35:09I think if you earn over, I mean, you'll know this, but I think if you earn over 115 grand a year, then it's three years.
- 35:16You only have to wait three years.
- 35:18Yep.
- 35:19And then there's the other things that 125,000,.
- 35:23125,141 a year, as well as highly skilled migrants, such as those on Global Talent or Innovator Founder visas, can qualify after three years.
- 35:32Yeah.
- 35:33And then there's the other taxes that our family pay.
- 35:36Like, I couldn't, because my husband's here on a spousal visa.
- 35:40I couldn't take any more than six months off work for maternity leave because I have to earn the amount that I earn in order to sponsor him to be able to reapply for his visa.
- 35:51Got it.
- 35:52So there's all sorts of things that happen to, you know, to families like ours.
- 35:56But kind of going back to the point is that what she has now done is she has essentially set a precedent for milking the cash cow, which is migrants and their visas whenever is needed.
- 36:09Because who's to say that next year this isn't going to change again?
- 36:12Who's to say next year won't be 15 years or 20 years?
- 36:15Who's to say that when my husband, when my kids have grown up and decided they're going to move abroad to live, you know, that my husband's still not going to have indefinite leave to remain and therefore right to
- 36:26travel anywhere?
- 36:27Who's to say that this 11, nearly £12,000 that we're going to have to pay out, that's going to mean that he can't travel to see his aging family?
- 36:35Who can't, incidentally, get visas to come and visit us here.
- 36:40But that's.
- 36:40My kids will no longer be able to go and visit their family overseas.
- 36:44He will probably likely not see his parents in the next few years because we have to find us money.
- 36:50And while there are people like you who think this is horrendous, there will be people who are listening to this with glee.
- 36:57But what are they celebrating?
- 36:58Just your pain.
- 37:00Yeah.
- 37:01Because the cruelty is the point.
- 37:02And that's the only way that I've managed to come to any understanding whatsoever of people who admire Donald Trump.
- 37:08So I can't really sit here and tell you not to be so mean, because the cruelty is the point.
- 37:1396,000 adult social care vacancies in this country at the moment, according to the Skills for Care report.
- 37:202025, 2026.
- 37:21So, you know, anyone thinking this will help me get back into the workplace is either lying or horribly misinformed.
- 37:31And is she right?
- 37:32I don't want Anna to be right.
- 37:34Can you see another point, another argument?
- 37:36What about the Nazi argument?
- 37:38What about, it's like a Vichy regime that Shabana Mahmood is presiding over.
- 37:42We're going to mitigate the worst excesses of what the actual Nazis would do.
- 37:46If we don't do this, if we don't treat these people appallingly, then those who like the cruelty.
- 37:51Whoa, wait until you see the cruelty that the other lot are offering up.
- 37:55Is that it?
- 37:56Is that what we're reduced to as a nation, as a population doing horrible things to foreign people because we're frightened of what the really, really nasty people will do to them if they ever get into power?
- 38:08And crossing your fingers that this will be just cruel enough for the characters that Anna is describing?
- 38:14Or are we all completely missing the point?
- 38:17Is there something a lot less sinister and a lot more palatable going on?
- 38:21Time for a short break now, but when we get back, we'll be moving our focus to another huge story from today's news agenda.
- 38:36This wasn't on my list, actually this morning, but obviously I've got the screens up in the studio and I'm looking at the situation in the United States of America.
- 38:46And I've got to go back to a question that I think I promised I'd never ask you again.
- 38:51It seems pertinent given the context of the conversation that we had in the last hour about trying to appease xenophobes.
- 38:57And it may be, I just want to be clear, it may well be there's another rationale for what Shabana Mahmood is doing.
- 39:04And the problem is that the one she offered up, the 10 billion pound saving, is absolute Rolex.
- 39:11That's the real kicker here.
- 39:13It's why I opened the last hour talking more about that than I did about the actual impact on people.
- 39:18Because the rationale she has offered is false.
- 39:23And that means that Occam's Razor becomes turbocharged and you are left concluding that all that's left must be the truth.
- 39:32Or at least the simplest answer must be the truth.
- 39:35Combination of Ockham, William of Ockham and Sherlock of Baker street there.
- 39:41And that's the thing I find really quite saddening.
- 39:45As a patriotic person raised very much in the Catholic and the Christian faith, I find it really saddening to look at what my government, a Labor government, is doing to human beings in the hope of appeasing people possessed
- 39:59of opinions that are vile and false and built entirely on lies.
- 40:03So you can see why I'm thinking about Donald Trump, can't you?
- 40:08In the aftermath of that conversation, did you see the footage of him at the Reflecting Pool?
- 40:15I mean, I've drawn bigger crowds than that.
- 40:21And here's my curse, right?
- 40:23That we live in a world where the people who care about the truth are constantly admitting the possibility of being wrong.
- 40:35Yeah.
- 40:36So the people who care about the truth will be checking their sources and admitting their mistakes and acknowledging other opinions or desperately reaching for balance.
- 40:50The people who care about the truth, or the people, of course, who have been absolutely cowed into obsequiousness by the people who don't care about the truth, are always offering caveats.
- 41:04They're always offering conditions and balances.
- 41:07Oh, well, of course, on the other hand, many people think that leaving the European Union will make us richer.
- 41:15Well, of course, on the other hand, many people think that migration is not coming now, but that's stupid journalism.
- 41:23You might as well say many people think the king is a lizard or the moon is made of cheese, for quote, balance, end quotes.
- 41:31And I mention that because I looked at the footage of Trump at the so called reflecting pool and I just thought, and everyone's laughing at how few people are there.
- 41:41And I thought to myself, well, perhaps it was the camera angle, or perhaps the.
- 41:51The press pack was there and the big crowd was behind the press pack.
- 41:58Or perhaps it was just a speech for journalists.
- 42:02And then you sort of think, why are you doing this?
- 42:04The man is mad.
- 42:05The man is absolutely bonkers and hideous.
- 42:08Why are you rationalizing him?
- 42:10In a way, you think about how he treats other people who are telling the truth.
- 42:15Truth.
- 42:15You think about how Donald Trump treats.
- 42:16I think this is the liberal curse, the great liberal malaise of our age.
- 42:21As you watch Donald Trump treat Volodymyr Zelensky with ill disguised contempt in the Oval Office.
- 42:28And yet, as a liberal commentator, you find yourself thinking, well, I don't think anybody should be treated like that.
- 42:35Even the very worst people deserve the most basic requirements.
- 42:39You've got to give them a good hearing before you can point out that they're lying.
- 42:44You can't just sort of shut the door on them.
- 42:48And I did it again, I did it again yesterday, looking at this bizarre spectacle of him doing his final campaign speech at the Reflecting Pool, about which he frequently talks utter and undiluted gibberish.
- 43:0120 minutes of his speech talking about the renovation of a pool.
- 43:06He's lied about it being vandalized.
- 43:08He's lied about, I think.
- 43:09Did he lie about people dying in it yesterday?
- 43:11Can we check that?
- 43:12Because, again, I'm sort of haunted by this fear that I've fallen for AI or that I've fallen for manipulated imagery.
- 43:22Whereas Trump's entire political movement is built upon lies and manipulated imagery.
- 43:29You know, the things that he says about Europe are extra.
- 43:33I mean, just lie after lie after lie after lie.
- 43:36And the reason why I said we'd stop asking the question that we're about to ask is that I think we sort of ran out of energy almost, or we reached a point where the answers were so dispiriting that
- 43:54you stopped wanting to hear them.
- 43:55But the other great curse of the liberal isn't just empathy, it's curiosity.
- 44:02Do you ever wish you were less curious?
- 44:06Do you ever wonder what it would be like to, I don't know, do a job like this and never think about things?
- 44:12Just, for example, to come out and say something like, oh, Gordon Brown sold the gold, not to have any understanding whatsoever of the fiscal rationales for doing so, what other countries and central banks were doing at the time,
- 44:26what the reasoning behind it was, what role it plays in the great survey of what Gordon Brown has done and did as, as Prime Minister and as Chancellor of the Exchequer.
- 44:38It must be curiously liberating just to come out with these meaningless platitudes as a substitute for actually thinking about things.
- 44:47So you could say, for example, oh, Trump derangement syndrome, and you spare yourself the energy and exertion of actually thinking about things.
- 44:58Trump derangement syndrome.
- 45:00And now, of course, all the people that use that as a pejorative are either pretending that they never supported him in the first place, or writing ridiculous people, but obviously unintentionally hilarious columns for the Daily Mail about how
- 45:11the bloke that they wanted to govern this country is actually gonna lose the next election.
- 45:15But it's nothing to do with all the people that thought that he was the Messiah.
- 45:20You know, the absence of curiosity.
- 45:23Of course, I mostly wish that other people were more curious, but I do wonder what it would be like not to be curious at all.
- 45:31This isn't self aggrandizing.
- 45:33Curiosity isn't a particularly important quality in our SoC.
- 45:39It doesn't make you rich.
- 45:40But my goodness me, to be utterly incurious must be a wonderful existence.
- 45:46To actually think that meaningless and often false platitudes are a substitute for thinking about things and trying to understand things and to be rewarded for it.
- 45:59In a society where illumination and education are increasingly devalued, where you can quote, prove anything with facts.
- 46:08It's mad, isn't it?
- 46:09We should make a list.
- 46:10I say this to you every week, we should make a list of those things.
- 46:13Gordon Brown sold the gold.
- 46:16They need us more than we need them.
- 46:18Trump derangement syndrome.
- 46:20Drill, baby, drill.
- 46:21These are just phrases that spare people the inconvenience of having to think.
- 46:29And what sets us apart from the animals is our ability to think.
- 46:34It's almost as if there are swathes of humanity that choose to be bovine.
- 46:41And that brings us to Donald Trump voters, whose absence of curiosity, of course, often leaves them terrified of non existent threats.
- 46:54That's one of the great prices you pay for being utterly incurious.
- 46:58The blowhards and the, the commentators and the politicians often don't feel that fear, they just engender it in the minds of their followers.
- 47:06JD Vance isn't frightened of anything that's going on in Europe.
- 47:10He doesn't think that there's a threat to our free speech.
- 47:12He knows it's up to hogwash because he is an urbane man married to an Indian woman.
- 47:16He's not frightened by multiculturalism, but he knows that other people can be frightened by multiculturalism.
- 47:21And he knows that there's a lot of money and a lot of power to be made by frightening them.
- 47:26London is a no go zone.
- 47:27He knows that's not true.
- 47:29Donald Trump knows that's not true.
- 47:31But they make money and they make power by pretending that it's true by frightening people.
- 47:37Yeah, Roddy's absolutely right.
- 47:39Not only should we make a list, Eleanor, but we should laminate it as well.
- 47:42The list of fig leaves.
- 47:44The meaningless platitudes that incurious people subscribe to in order to spare themselves the exertions of thinking.
- 47:53Project Fear.
- 47:55Oh, hang on.
- 47:55Jamie's put a few together.
- 47:57Yeah, they're all bit Brexit.
- 47:58Y Jamie.
- 47:58Nothing wrong with that.
- 47:59Pot, kettle.
- 48:00Project Fear.
- 48:01What does that mean?
- 48:02Nothing at all.
- 48:02But I can shout it at people so I don't have to actually understand things.
- 48:06Brexit means Brexit.
- 48:07What does that mean?
- 48:08Nothing.
- 48:08But I can shout it at people who understand things in order to pretend that they're wrong and I'm right.
- 48:12Take back control.
- 48:13What does that mean?
- 48:14Nothing.
- 48:15Trump derangement syndrome.
- 48:16What does that mean?
- 48:17It means you're right and I'm wrong.
- 48:18But I can shout it loud enough and pretend that it's actually the other way around.
- 48:21Around.
- 48:23Unbelievable.
- 48:25So can we do it again?
- 48:29Can we do it again?
- 48:30How did he get back in?
- 48:32I, I, I always, always, always think of January 6th at this moment, and, and that's why I've never fully parked this question.
- 48:42Even as you watch rats leave the sinking ship, most of which, of course, will not acknowledge their role in getting the ship afloat, they'll just move on to the next nostalgia, like they did with Brexit, like they did
- 48:53with Boris Johnson, like they did with Liz Truss.
- 48:56They'll just move on as if Donald Trump.
- 48:58Their massive support.
- 48:59The big headlines spouting about how much they love Donald Trump and how one of the main reasons why they love him is because he upsets all the right people.
- 49:06They'll just move on blithely to the next pile of nonsense that they will inflict upon their readers, their viewers and their listeners.
- 49:13Two tier policing, meaningless, incurious help if you are an idiot.
- 49:20And the kind of demagogues and pundits and broadcasters I'm talking about are they love idiots even as they hate them.
- 49:30Because that's what their political power and their livelihoods depend upon, persuading less educated people to believe things that aren't true.
- 49:39And that's why we keep coming back to that second term, because everybody watched January 6th.
- 49:48Everybody watched Donald Trump essentially ignite an attempt, an assault upon American democracy.
- 49:59Everybody watched that and they put him back in power.
- 50:05And I still don't get it.
- 50:08Emily said something to me right at the beginning of the campaign and she'd gone to the United States of America.
- 50:15And Maitlis and her colleagues are all over the midterms, as you would expect on the news, Agents Lewis and John and Simon Marks, the ringmaster for tonight's coverage.
- 50:25We'll be catching up with him in an hour and a bit.
- 50:29She said something to me and it really stopped me in my tracks.
- 50:33I think I was probably, perish the thought upon an anti Trump rant at the time.
- 50:37And Emily came on the line from the States where she was canvassing opinion among voters and she just said, it's all about the price of petrol.
- 50:44Petrol.
- 50:45It's all about the price of gasoline.
- 50:46And I thought, it can't be.
- 50:49I don't care what petrol costs.
- 50:51If you've watched a president, a defeated president, launch an assault upon the cradle of your own democracy, then surely that is going to Trump, pardon the pun, absolutely any.
- 51:05And of course it doesn't.
- 51:07It doesn't.
- 51:08But I don't think in my lifetime I've ever seen it quite as big as this in a Western democracy.
- 51:14Millions and millions and millions of voters ignoring the fact that the man they're voting for sought to attack and undermine and destroy the very Western democracy in which they live and send him back to the White House.
- 51:27So for the 19th time, for the 90th time, quite possibly for the 900th time, as Donald Trump prepares for embarrassment, I think perhaps in the midterms, quite possibly humiliation, the only thing you can say with any certainty is
- 51:48that he will present it as either a theft or a victory, and he will be lying on both occasions.
- 51:55If and when it goes very badly for Donald Trump, it will be either a lie about being the real winner or a lie about being somehow deprived of the victory he deserved.
- 52:05That's all you can say with certainty.
- 52:06You can say two things with certainty.
- 52:08In world politics at the moment, if you want to know what Vladimir Putin wants, have a look at what, what Donald Trump is doing.
- 52:15And if Donald Trump passes judgment on something, he will be lying.
- 52:20That's it.
- 52:21Everything else is up for grabs, Everything else has gray areas, Everything else is negotiable.
- 52:28So how did it happen?
- 52:38Jez is in Richmond.
- 52:39Jez, what would you like to say?
- 52:41Oh, hello, James.
- 52:42Thanks.
- 52:42Thanks so much for your, for your program.
- 52:44You always sort of enlightened my days.
- 52:48Thank you very much.
- 52:50Right.
- 52:50So I'm hoping to cast some light on or potentially a little window on your question.
- 52:58My cousin lives in Manhattan and we've pretty much grown up together, but he's sort of been based in the US for the last sort of, you know, he's six years younger than me.
- 53:07He's been basically born.
- 53:09That.
- 53:10Okay.
- 53:10So he, he actually, I, I had a conversation with him last week, because I was in New York and we had this conversation about Trump and I said, gosh, you know, he's, he's, he's, he's terrible.
- 53:22Yeah,.
- 53:23Just, he just, he's an inveterate liar.
- 53:26And I said, he can't be trusted and look what he's doing to the world.
- 53:29And my cousin said, well, I voted for him the last two times.
- 53:32Wow.
- 53:33Two times.
- 53:34I mean, one time you could probably understand.
- 53:36Two times is, is, is extraordinary to me.
- 53:38And I sent it to you as well.
- 53:41I couldn't believe it.
- 53:42Said I wanted to explore a bit first.
- 53:43Yeah, he basically, he's a trader.
- 53:47And so he said that the, the ups and downs on the market really suits him.
- 53:53And, and I said, well, what about, you know, people who are being sort of bombed senseless, or what about the, the other numerous negative things which are occurring on this planet and which this guy really, you know, contributes
- 54:09quite massively to?
- 54:10And he said, I don't really mind about that.
- 54:13Because I'm making so much money,.
- 54:15Because I'm making so much money.
- 54:16I think we're quite naive, aren't we?
- 54:21That sort of blew a hole in me because he went to Tufts, he went to an Ivy League university.
- 54:25Highly.
- 54:26Educated.
- 54:27Highly educated.
- 54:28Doesn't.
- 54:29It.
- 54:29Education doesn't equal empathy.
- 54:30I think it helps, but it doesn't.
- 54:32It doesn't.
- 54:32It doesn't.
- 54:34At that point that him and his mum.
- 54:37So the family aren't listening.
- 54:39Don't worry, you don't have a distinctive voice or name.
- 54:44I realize that him and his mom have that attitude.
- 54:48And the buck wins.
- 54:49It doesn't matter.
- 54:50So because the economy is objectively performing quite well in the States at the moment, and lots and lots of money is being made by a tiny, tiny number of people, the cost of living, of course, is a lot
- 55:00more relevant to a lot more people, and that's the major reason people are giving for removal, removing their loyalty from Trump.
- 55:06But all of what we might call the moral stuff doesn't matter.
- 55:11I don't think it exists anymore.
- 55:13I think that there was a time, even in the uk, when someone did something wrong or a politician did, they fell on their sword.
- 55:21Unfortunately, unfortunately, the way that things are working, people can do whatever they want and as long as they sort of shout loud and throw everyone else out, then you can get away with it.
- 55:35And you're right, it has bled across the Atlantic.
- 55:38If it started in the States, maybe we've got our own sort of homegrown version of it, but of Course, the massive majority of people will be poorer as a consequence of Donald Trump being in charge for the second
- 55:50term.
- 55:50So your cousin's rationale doesn't explain people who aren't traders.
- 55:55But it possibly takes us back to that old Steinbeck line about there being no such thing as poverty in Dust bowl era America, just temporarily frustrating millionaires.
- 56:06Very good.
- 56:07It is, isn't it?
- 56:07Because that's what they do.
- 56:08They think they'll have a little piece of that sweet, sweet pie that your cousin is eating if only Trump stays in power for a little bit longer because he keeps promising them that and they keep falling for it.
- 56:17And I keep asking the question of how can people fall for this?
- 56:20That's the best answer you'll get as someone who is getting very, very rich without actually being an actual part of the financial corruption that's making all of Trump's closest associates and family members much, much, much rich.
- 56:33Future Sam's in 7 Oak.
- 56:34Sam, what would you like to say?
- 56:35Yeah, James.
- 56:37I've always had a fascination with American politics, and Trump is someone that continues to astound me to this day.
- 56:48How he even got in 2016, he was able to con his way through to the White House in 2016.
- 56:55We all thought that never again after the.
- 56:58Well,.
- 56:58No, we did.
- 56:59They didn't, did they?
- 57:00I mean, he left power and, I mean, largely because of the price of fuel, I think, or because of cost of living sort of issues.
- 57:07Cost of living.
- 57:08But.
- 57:09Then January 6th happened, and if ever I would have put money on the party being over, it would have been on January 6th.
- 57:17I really.
- 57:18I think it's a good job I didn't.
- 57:19But if there was an opportunity to put £100 or £1,000, depending on whether or not I was gonna tell my wife about it, that's it.
- 57:27Now for Trump, it's absolutely game over.
- 57:29He's never coming back.
- 57:30I'd have done it on January 6th.
- 57:31And here we are.
- 57:32Are here we are.
- 57:33Yeah, but, James, you're spot on there.
- 57:35You said it was the cost of living at the time.
- 57:37I remember watching cnn, I went to bed about midnight.
- 57:41I had a bad feeling that things were going to go wrong because on cnn, a lot of people were talking to the reporters off camera,.
- 57:48Right?
- 57:48And a lot of them were saying that we voted for Trump.
- 57:52Many of them were actually telling their fellow work colleagues that they voted for.
- 57:58They're going to vote for Biden, but they voted for Trump.
- 57:59So I knew.
- 58:02So that some things probably, he will probably get in.
- 58:04But what surprised Me was I remember there was a report about there were a couple of hundred voters turned up at a poly polling boot in Pennsylvania.
- 58:15And I remember Trump putting on Twitter that they're stealing the election.
- 58:18They're stealing the election.
- 58:19Yes,.
- 58:20But I thought it was.
- 58:21They were there for Kamala.
- 58:22But probably that wasn't.
- 58:23That.
- 58:23That wasn't the case.
- 58:24It turned out not to be the case.
- 58:26But the reason why I think he got back.
- 58:27The reasons why I think he got back.
- 58:29James, I was just speaking to your researcher.
- 58:30Yes.
- 58:31She put me through one, I think Biden, the Democrats should have got rid of Biden earlier than they did.
- 58:38Secondly, I don't think, and I'm a father of two daughters like you, James.
- 58:42Yeah, but I don't think that America are ready for a female president.
- 58:48So it could have.
- 58:48Yeah, but that you see with this is.
- 58:50I file this one under excuse, not explanation.
- 58:53Because it doesn't explain to me how they could forgive all of those.
- 58:56I mean, that should be another laminated list, shouldn't it?
- 58:59All of the things that, that we thought.
- 59:02I thought that the Access Hollywood tape would finish him.
- 59:05Same.
- 59:06Same here.
- 59:07But if January 6th didn't finish him, then what on earth would?
- 59:11And we're going to come back to flipping cost of living.
- 59:13It's literally all that.
- 59:14Matters.
- 59:14That's right, James.
- 59:15But, James, I'll end on this note,.
- 59:17Sam.
- 59:17I have never been able to understand the American voter predictions for.
- 59:22Predictions for today for the coming elections.
- 59:26I think that the Democrats will win the House of Reps, but they won't, unfortunately.
- 59:32They won't take the Congress under the Senate.
- 59:34They won't win the Senate.
- 59:36Yeah.
- 59:37I mean, you could be right.
- 59:39The polls, as Simon Marx was at great pains to remind us yesterday, you can live by the polls and die by the polls.
- 59:47Thank you, Sam.
- 59:48Thank you for the kind words as well.
- 59:51Just my daily dip into the mindset of the kind of people that we are simultaneously fascinated and repulsed by.
- 59:59Here's Alex.
- 1:00:00The more you insult Farage and reform, the more we want to vote for him.
- 1:00:03Keep going.
- 1:00:04What kind of person would send a message like that to the studio?
- 1:00:09And then you find this message.
- 1:00:10We want to name our children after jazz greats.
- 1:00:13We have named our daughter Nina after Nina Simone.
- 1:00:16And you sort of think, madam, have you any understanding whatsoever of who Nina Simone was and what she stood for and where you think she might sit on racist politicians for?
- 1:00:29Well, happily, she told you, a tireless civil rights activist.
- 1:00:33So hopefully your daughter will live up to the name that you've given her and completely reject your rancid politics.
- 1:00:38Thank you, Alex, for that message.
- 1:00:41And we're done for another day.
- 1:00:43Huge thank you to all my contributors for some truly special conversations.
- 1:00:47I'll be back on LBC tomorrow from 10 or right here shortly afterwards.
- 1:00:52This has been a global production.