Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Gender-Affirming Care Bans and the Constitutional Case for Rational Basis with Bite Standard
Transcript
- 0:03Good morning. I'm Kenneth Petroulis, the current
- 0:06chair of the Foundation's annual rule of law
- 0:09writing competition and a principal at Petroulis
- 0:12Fiduciary Services. For 17 years now, my wife,
- 0:16Dale, and I, believing that the respect for the
- 0:20rule of law is necessary now more than ever,
- 0:24have sponsored this competition. Today, I'm delighted
- 0:27to introduce our speaker, Piper Henson, and our
- 0:31program moderator, Matthew Kanan. Piper graduated
- 0:35magna cum laude from Southwestern Law School,
- 0:38where she served as editor in chief of the Southwestern
- 0:41Law Review and the academic chair of the Moot
- 0:45Court Honors Program. Both of her Moot Court
- 0:48teams earned best brief honors at competitions
- 0:52at the ABA National Appellate Advocacy Competition,
- 0:57Boston Regionals. She was named best advocate.
- 1:00Her team won the regional championship and moved
- 1:03on to compete at the nationals. She also served
- 1:08as a Dean's Fellow, Research Assistant, Teaching
- 1:11Assistant, and Extern to the Honorable Otis D.
- 1:15Wright II at the U .S. District Court for the
- 1:19Central District. During her final year, she
- 1:22participated in the Appellate Litigation Clinic,
- 1:26where she helped draft appellate briefs and argued
- 1:28a case before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
- 1:32Matthew D. Kanan is of counsel to Ruttenberg,
- 1:37Cutler, Groomer, LLP, where his practice focuses
- 1:40on trust and estate disputes, conservatorships,
- 1:45probate and trust administration, and civil appeals.
- 1:48He holds the distinction of being a Certified
- 1:52Specialist in a State Planning, Trust, and Probate
- 1:55Law by the State Borough of California Board
- 1:59of Legal Specialization. And now, Matt, let's
- 2:02get started. Hello, everyone. Good morning and
- 2:08welcome. It is my great pleasure to moderate
- 2:13this presentation by Ms. Hinson, who is our winning
- 2:17author for this year's rule of law writing competition.
- 2:21Her article is about is entitled biting back
- 2:26against animus gender -affirming care bans enacted
- 2:29with animus are unconstitutional under the rational
- 2:33basis with bite standard Some of you may already
- 2:37know what all of that means and for any of you
- 2:39who don't you're going to find out Before we
- 2:43begin though I think this is a really interesting
- 2:47topic. It was one of my favorite papers that
- 2:51I have ever read in the more than a decade that
- 2:53I have been judging this competition. I don't
- 2:56tend to speak freely in superlatives. So I want
- 2:59to start by asking you, Ms. Hinson, what inspired
- 3:03you to write about this area of law? Sure. If
- 3:09we can skip a couple slides. So just so everyone
- 3:12can see, so I well, first off, thank you for
- 3:15having me. This is such an honor to be here and
- 3:18to get to speak about this article that I'm so
- 3:20proud about to have written and to be talking
- 3:24about today. When I was in law school, I was
- 3:27in moot court, as was mentioned, and my first
- 3:30moot court competition. Was the Wagner labor
- 3:34and employment competition in New York and it
- 3:36focused on a transgender basketball player and
- 3:40that to me was a new area of law that I had not
- 3:44been. I just hadn't known about it at all and
- 3:47so that got me interested in the topic and then
- 3:50at Southwestern they offer a transgender law
- 3:53class and so I took that class with Professor
- 3:56Amanda Goad. And I found that there was. this
- 4:01really just a huge area of law that I had so
- 4:04little knowledge about and I had so much to learn
- 4:06and so that's what really got me kind of passionate
- 4:10and excited about this area and I thought there's
- 4:14a there's a real void in um in advocacy I think
- 4:18because Because it's just sort of new, it's all
- 4:22really kind of started in 2020. And so I took
- 4:25that as a, this is my opportunity to get involved
- 4:28in this newer area of law. And it's something
- 4:31I'm now very passionate about. If we can skip
- 4:35to the next slide. The big spark for this article
- 4:41though, was when I finished that class. my wheels
- 4:45were spinning and I was in law review. And one
- 4:48thing that they they ask you to do is write a
- 4:51law review article, a student note. So I thought,
- 4:54okay, this is an area of law I like, let's dig
- 4:57into it. And I noticed that there was a sort
- 5:00of set a divide in how courts were treating certain
- 5:05certain challenges. Gender affirming care bans
- 5:10had been challenged in court and there was a
- 5:13divergence in how the district courts were handling
- 5:15it versus how the circuit courts were handling
- 5:17it. And so that was really interesting to me
- 5:19because I thought maybe there's another solution
- 5:23aside from what these two levels of courts have
- 5:26been applying. Do you want to just take a moment
- 5:28and define for anyone in our audience or later
- 5:31rebroadcast who is unfamiliar with the term gender
- 5:35-affirming care? Sure. There's actually a bunch
- 5:38of terms I think we should talk about. So next
- 5:40slide if you would. I think the first two terms
- 5:44to get sort of clear on are cisgender and transgender.
- 5:48A cisgender is a person whose gender identity
- 5:51corresponds with the sex that was given to them
- 5:53at birth versus a transgender person is someone
- 5:57whose gender identity or expression is different
- 6:00from their sex assigned at birth. Next slide.
- 6:05Gender identity refers to a person's internal
- 6:08understanding of their own gender. or it's a
- 6:13person's how they're identifying and your gender
- 6:16identity is typically what you're given at birth
- 6:20so that's determined by external genitalia and
- 6:23that's not what you think it's just what the
- 6:26the world has decided on you. A transgender person's
- 6:31gender identity differs from the sex assigned
- 6:33at birth and so that's the sort of big distinction
- 6:36whereas a cisgender person's gender identity
- 6:38aligns with their sex assigned. at birth. Next
- 6:42slide. So gender dysphoria is the feeling of
- 6:49discomfort that transgender people might experience.
- 6:52This is where their gender identity differs from
- 6:55their sex assigned at birth, and this is the
- 6:58unease and dissatisfaction that results from
- 7:01that feeling. It can lead to depression, anxiety,
- 7:05and self harm and have a very harmful effect
- 7:09on anyone's daily life. Next slide please. So
- 7:14what is gender affirming care? This is the big
- 7:18topic right now. This is what the article really
- 7:21focuses on. And gender affirming care for transgender
- 7:24minors is a big spectrum. It can vary from socially
- 7:29affirming changes like changing your name, your
- 7:32clothing, and your pronouns. all the way up to
- 7:35more comprehensive measures like puberty blockers,
- 7:38hormone treatments, and sometimes and rarely
- 7:40surgery. Next slide please. So this is the WPATH,
- 7:50the World Professional Association for Transgender
- 7:52Health is sort of the the main authority on care
- 7:56for transgender minors, and it's established
- 7:59gender affirming care treatments as the proper
- 8:01standard of care for gender dysphoria. This is
- 8:06used to treat children who suffer from gender
- 8:08dysphoria to improve their outcome because when
- 8:14transgender minors are not allowed to receive
- 8:16gender affirming care, it can be detrimental.
- 8:20As I mentioned, self -harm, but it it can be
- 8:23attempted suicide or completed suicide, which
- 8:25is obviously the worst case scenario. Next slide
- 8:28please. So the gender affirming care treatment
- 8:35has been been under fire recently with states
- 8:39enacting gender affirming care bans. So these
- 8:43bans are prohibiting transgender minors from
- 8:45receiving these life -saving treatments such
- 8:48as puberty blockers, hormone therapy, and on
- 8:51occasion surgery. So what I noticed, though,
- 8:53is this is not going unchallenged. Parents and
- 8:58advocates for trans minors have challenged all
- 9:00these laws in court, and they are mostly filing
- 9:04preliminary injunctions to stop the enforcement
- 9:08of these state laws. Next slide, please. This
- 9:15is just some general big picture background information.
- 9:19The UCLA Williams Institute is a really helpful
- 9:22resource that I used quite a bit in my article.
- 9:26As of 2025, they estimate that in the United
- 9:30States, about 724 ,000 youth identify as transgender.
- 9:35And this number is kind of about, it's about
- 9:372 to 3 % of the population of minors, and that's
- 9:41age 13 to 17 years old. And they have particularly
- 9:47high rates of poor mental health outcomes compared
- 9:50to their cisgender counterparts. So, for example,
- 9:55before all of these, these gender affirming care
- 9:58bands started popping up, which really happened
- 10:01in about 2020, 2021, the Center for Disease Control
- 10:06and Prevention, conducted a survey in 2017 and
- 10:10found that more than a third of transgender high
- 10:13school students were attempting suicide in the
- 10:19past 12 months. And that was a rate four to six
- 10:23times the rate of their cisgender counterpart
- 10:26and peers. And that is a pretty big difference.
- 10:29And so to me that shows these treatments are
- 10:33helpful and they can help prevent really, really
- 10:37Harmful outcomes, and these higher rates of attempted
- 10:42suicide are likely from the social rejection,
- 10:45the lack of support from parents and bullying
- 10:48and all the things that go with a stigmatized
- 10:51group. Next slide please. So I mentioned these
- 10:58state laws banning gender affirming care. These
- 11:00are all Within the last couple of years, and
- 11:03so in particular, as of 2024, at least 26 states
- 11:09have enacted some form of gender affirming care
- 11:11bans for minors. We will talk about the Supreme
- 11:16Court case soon, but we'll just keep going. Next
- 11:20slide please. So, so I mentioned this is one
- 11:26of the things, you know, the challenges that
- 11:28have been coming up. Most of the challenges are
- 11:32coming in the form of an equal protection challenge.
- 11:36So they are bringing them these preliminary injunctions,
- 11:39which, as we all know, requires the four elements.
- 11:42You have to have a likelihood of success on the
- 11:44merits. The plaintiff will suffer irreparable
- 11:47harm. The balance of equities supports the injunction,
- 11:51and it's in the interest of the public interest.
- 11:55These core challenges all really hinge on that
- 11:58first element, the likelihood of success on the
- 12:00merits of the claim. Next slide please. So, as
- 12:07I mentioned, the courts have really struggled
- 12:10with which standard of review to apply to these
- 12:13equal protection claims. Next slide please. Now,
- 12:19the main three standards of review are The 3
- 12:23big ones, we have rational basis review, intermediate
- 12:26scrutiny and strict scrutiny. Rational basis
- 12:29is our most deferential to state laws and state
- 12:34legislatures. Intermediate scrutiny typically
- 12:37for sex based classifications and then strict
- 12:39scrutiny is our highest standard and it's the
- 12:43hardest to satisfy. Next slide please. So what
- 12:49has happened is. Typically, not all, but most
- 12:53district courts found there was a quasi suspect
- 12:57class for these gender affirming care bands.
- 12:59They applied intermediate scrutiny and the laws
- 13:02did not pass. So they were finding and granting
- 13:05these preliminary injunctions because it didn't
- 13:08satisfy intermediate scrutiny. Next slide. And
- 13:14then. By and large, with the exception of maybe
- 13:18one circuit, the courts of appeals are, they
- 13:22found that no, there isn't a suspect classification.
- 13:24There's no quasi -suspect classification and
- 13:27they found that rational basis was the proper
- 13:29standard and they were reversing the preliminary
- 13:32injunctions. So they, again, they applied this
- 13:36very highly deferential standard of review to
- 13:42the state laws and found that no, they satisfy
- 13:46it. So next slide, please. This deferential standard
- 13:54of review is concomitant with the presumption
- 13:57of constitutionality. So as a challenger, uh
- 14:01seeking to roll back a state law or federal law
- 14:05overreach against a protected constitutional
- 14:08right the higher scrutiny would basically serve
- 14:12like a burden shifting presumption and would
- 14:14be a great advantage to the challenger uh that
- 14:18the the burden of proof beyond the government
- 14:20to justify its law rather than a burden of proof
- 14:23beyond the challenger presumably with less resources
- 14:25than the government to disprove the validity
- 14:28of the law Yes, and that's one reason that when
- 14:33they get to rational basis, because the burden
- 14:36is on the plaintiff, it's tougher to satisfy
- 14:40because less resources, that's the uphill battle
- 14:43for them, and there's a presumption that the
- 14:46government has legitimate interest. And typically,
- 14:50if you go over the history of the cases and you
- 14:53analyze many of these in the paper, if rational
- 14:57basis review is found to apply, It is essentially
- 15:01the same as saying that the law will be found
- 15:03constitutional, but not always, right? Correct,
- 15:07yes. And you're going, that's what you're coming
- 15:08to. Yes, which is, yes, this is where my idea
- 15:12comes in. So. Well, first off, talk about the
- 15:17elephant in the room, which is US versus scrimmety,
- 15:20which was the case that came down from the Supreme
- 15:22Court last year in June. So it was from a Sixth
- 15:26Circuit case, which had held that this gender
- 15:29affirming care ban SB1 does not classify on the
- 15:33basis of sex and decline to recognize transgender
- 15:36people as a suspect class because they're not,
- 15:39quote, politically powerless, nor a discrete
- 15:42group. So when it went up to the six or when
- 15:46the Sixth Circuit case went to the Supreme Court,
- 15:48they affirmed that decision. So they affirmed
- 15:50the rational basis review standard of scrutiny.
- 15:53And they said that the SB1 classifies on age
- 15:57and medical use and not sex or transgender status.
- 16:00So this case did resolve the split as far as
- 16:05whether it's rational basis or intermediate scrutiny
- 16:07based on a sex classification. Next slide. But
- 16:14what it kind of left open, I think, is this animus
- 16:19argument. It didn't decide whether an animus
- 16:22based rational basis with bite claim could still
- 16:25succeed against a particular ban because their
- 16:28focus was all about the sex. Discrimination classification
- 16:32and. I think that because these gender affirming
- 16:36care bands are enacted with animus that the correct
- 16:39standard of review is rational basis with bite.
- 16:42And under this standard of review, these gender
- 16:45affirming care bands are unconstitutional. Next
- 16:49slide please. So the rational basis with Byte
- 16:56standard overview is not is not used a lot. It
- 17:01is sparsely used, but it sort of was announced
- 17:05spontaneously from this case from 1985, the city
- 17:08of Claiborne versus Claiborne Living Center.
- 17:11And in this case, it was basically it involved
- 17:15a a group home that was catering to mentally
- 17:20disabled individuals, and they were trying to
- 17:24get the permitting for their facility. The City
- 17:29of Clayton was requiring them to get a special
- 17:32use permit that they weren't requiring other
- 17:35buildings to get. So in this same area, there
- 17:39were apartment buildings, sorority houses, dormitories,
- 17:43lots of other multi multiple individual homes
- 17:48or or uses. And so the Supreme Court, they examined
- 17:53all the reasons that the government gave as far
- 17:56as why they were requiring the special use permit.
- 17:58And in the end, they kind of they were able to
- 18:02eliminate every rule, every reason that they
- 18:04gave. One they had said was to avoid congestion
- 18:08and too many people, basically. But then the
- 18:11court said, well, you have a sorority house and
- 18:14apartment buildings, like you're going to have
- 18:16congestion from those other uses. So that doesn't
- 18:19work. And it sort of went through, you know,
- 18:23example by example. And they said these are not
- 18:25legitimate interests. And in the end, the court
- 18:29said that there's no rational basis for believing
- 18:32that this living center would pose any special
- 18:36threat to the city's legitimate interests. Further,
- 18:39they said, irrational prejudice is never a legitimate
- 18:43state interest. So they applied rational basis
- 18:46review but it still had a little bit further
- 18:50scrutiny and even the concurrence in in Clayburn
- 18:55noted that this is really something more than
- 18:59just rational basis and they they called it second
- 19:02order rational basis review. So the concurrence
- 19:06recognized yeah it's rational basis but it's
- 19:08still more and Other cases that have applied
- 19:11rational basis with BITE, they know it's rational
- 19:16basis, but they will still say, it's a little
- 19:19bit more than that, isn't it? The concurrence
- 19:22from Justice O 'Connor in Lawrence V. Texas,
- 19:24she also recognized this is actually a little
- 19:27bit more. So it's never really been flat out
- 19:31said this is rational basis with BITE, but it's
- 19:33been acknowledged by the Supreme Court. And of
- 19:36course, between Lawrence and Cleburne you had
- 19:42rumor against Evans where Colorado's amendment
- 19:45to was struck down notwithstanding the rational
- 19:48basis review And if for anyone who since that's
- 19:52not in your article the site for that is 517
- 19:55us 620 1996 case Yeah next slide So, I've been
- 20:05talking a lot about the divergence in the courts,
- 20:07and I have Alabama and the case that went up
- 20:10to its circuit court, the 11th circuit as an
- 20:13example, and Echnist Tucker versus Marshall,
- 20:17the Alabama district court found that. its gender
- 20:20affirming care statute violated the Equal Protection
- 20:24Clause because it said that the Act prohibits
- 20:27transgender minors and only transgender minors
- 20:30from taking transitioning medications due to
- 20:33their gender nonconformity. So it found sex -based
- 20:37classification and applied intermediate scrutiny.
- 20:41Then when it went up on appeal at the 11th Circuit,
- 20:45the court held that transgender status is not
- 20:48a quasi -suspect class and doesn't trigger heightened
- 20:52scrutiny. So then it reversed on rational basis.
- 20:56Next slide, please. So this is my argument that
- 21:02rational basis with bite is still one other option.
- 21:06So even without finding a suspect classification,
- 21:08you can still apply a form of heightened scrutiny.
- 21:12And this This standard exists, it's not applied
- 21:16all that often, but it does exist and I think
- 21:18it can be used when in particular there is. A
- 21:24statute that's enacted with animus. Next slide
- 21:28please. Before you move on to this slide, I want
- 21:33to join some dots for our viewers and listeners
- 21:35that as a matter of timing, your article was
- 21:40published before the Supreme Court decided the
- 21:45Skrimeti case that trans discrimination was not
- 21:49gender discrimination. So regardless of our personal
- 21:53agreement or disagreement with that proposition,
- 21:57what you are seeking to do is essentially continue
- 22:01your advocacy that there are still ways forward,
- 22:06but this is a significant development since you
- 22:09went to press. Yes, the Supreme Court decision
- 22:13came One week after my article was published,
- 22:17I knew I was on a tight timeline because I had
- 22:19heard oral arguments. And so it was important
- 22:23to get the article published ahead of it because
- 22:25I didn't know what they were going to say. But
- 22:27I think that this is still a really valid path
- 22:31because I will say when I started thinking about
- 22:36this idea, I did wonder, should I go and argue
- 22:40for intermediate scrutiny and say that that,
- 22:42you know, should I go that route? But as I was
- 22:45researching and thinking about it more, and I
- 22:49was just trying to think of another way, because
- 22:51I was seeing what happened in the courts already.
- 22:53We were already seeing district courts applied
- 22:56intermediate scrutiny and the circuit courts
- 22:59by and large were reversing. So I was anticipating
- 23:04that that could be affirmed by the Supreme Court.
- 23:06And that's where I I was in law school, so I
- 23:09had just learned about a lot of this constitutional,
- 23:11all the standards of review. And so this was
- 23:14fresh in my mind of, well, maybe this is a way.
- 23:16Maybe this is a way to still find them unconstitutional,
- 23:21but not in the same way we were trying before.
- 23:24So I've been trying to think outside the box,
- 23:26and this was the idea for this. But this is sort
- 23:31of the roadblocks are it's unclear. It's sort
- 23:35of untested. It's been applied. you know, probably
- 23:3810, 15 times in Supreme Court cases. So how to
- 23:42establish animus? That's a trick. It's not really
- 23:45defined anywhere. There are several law review
- 23:48articles and legal scholars that have kind of
- 23:52honed in on certain things. Dale Carpenter is
- 23:55one that I used quite a bit for my article. I
- 23:57relied on his work. He sort of sort of picked
- 24:02out a few things and One way we can do it is
- 24:05to scrutinize the text of these bills, the context
- 24:08of, like, who drafted them and what was happening,
- 24:12the process, the general impact, and then the
- 24:15government's claimed purpose, I think, is another
- 24:18thing to think about. Next slide, please. So,
- 24:23in my article, I identify two ways, two big ways
- 24:27I think you can identify animus in gender affirming
- 24:29care bans. The first is that the purported reason
- 24:33that they give is not the actual reason. A lot
- 24:37of these laws will claim that it's to protect
- 24:40children from experimental treatments, but then
- 24:44they will still allow exceptions in the statutes
- 24:47of how other minors can get the same treatments.
- 24:51So to me, that undercuts that argument. And then
- 24:54the second big reason is this context argument
- 24:57that you have the same state senators or representatives
- 25:01are the lead sponsors of multiple anti -trans
- 25:04bills proposed in the same year or nearby years.
- 25:09Next slide, please. So this is an example of
- 25:15one of the claimed purposes that I think is faulty.
- 25:20Alabama's gender affirming care ban, their claimed
- 25:23purpose is to protect children from experimental
- 25:26medical interventions that have no proven benefits
- 25:29and carry with them substantial risk of long
- 25:31-term irreversible harm. Their act specifically
- 25:36talks about that. So it says no person shall
- 25:39engage in any of the following practices for
- 25:42the purpose of attempting to alter the appearance
- 25:45of or affirm the minor's perception of his or
- 25:48her gender or sex if that appearance or perception
- 25:51is inconsistent with the minor's sex." Okay so
- 25:54that's that's what the bill says. Then if we
- 25:57go to the next slide, this is one of those exceptions.
- 26:03So this doesn't apply to a procedure undertaken
- 26:07to treat a minor born with a medically verifiable
- 26:09sex disorder, disorder of sex development, such
- 26:12as being intersex or another disorder of sexual
- 26:15development determined by a physician. So, in
- 26:18effect, this exception allows for cisgender minors
- 26:23to get these treatments that they're claiming
- 26:25are untested and experimental. And like the district
- 26:29court had said, I believe, in the Echnist Tucker,
- 26:34it was allowing It was just not allowing transgender
- 26:37minors to get these treatments. That's where
- 26:39the distinction comes from. And this is how you
- 26:42can see that their purpose is actually a farce
- 26:44because if you're saying something is dangerous
- 26:47for minors, it's either dangerous or it isn't.
- 26:51And these exceptions show that it isn't actually
- 26:54dangerous. It's interesting how the same procedure
- 26:56can be experimental and dangerous when it is
- 26:59done in aid of a group of people that is different
- 27:03from traditional appearance norms, but perfectly
- 27:08safe when it is to validate those traditional
- 27:11viewpoints, isn't it? Yes, exactly. And that's
- 27:14where you can kind of see, okay, I'm starting
- 27:17to see animus building here because that doesn't
- 27:20check out. So next slide. So that's one, that's
- 27:27the first way I found. The second way is the
- 27:30context. And this is, I did sort of a study of
- 27:35as many states as I could, but this was one that
- 27:38stuck out to me. The same state sponsor for a
- 27:43gender affirming care ban was also the same state
- 27:45sponsor for an anti -drag performance bill. In
- 27:502023, in the 94th General Assembly in Arkansas,
- 27:54State Senator Gary Steverfield was the lead sponsor
- 27:56of these two transphobic laws. So this is just
- 27:59one example. There were many, but in my article,
- 28:02I bring up a couple others, but this is one.
- 28:06So next slide, please. I'm talking about context.
- 28:13So when we look at the actual language in these
- 28:16bills, there are a lot of parallels that you
- 28:18can kind of see. They're just mapping over the
- 28:20same language and putting them for two different
- 28:23purposes. So, for example, in the anti -drag
- 28:28bill that the original language, albeit not the
- 28:32final language in the bill, but one of the drafts
- 28:34talked about this highlighted language where
- 28:39it exhibits a gender identity that is different
- 28:42from the performer's gender assigned at birth.
- 28:45Now that's something we talked about earlier,
- 28:46which was the terminology of your gender identity
- 28:50is different from your gender assigned at birth.
- 28:52That's what a transgender person is. And that
- 28:55language was pretty similar to the gender affirming
- 28:59care ban language. You can see it echoed again
- 29:03in the highlighted section. gender that corresponds
- 29:06to his or her biological sex to identifying with
- 29:10and living as a gender different from his or
- 29:12her biological sex. So again, it's only focused
- 29:16on this like the banning part is if you're living
- 29:21in a gender that's different from what you were
- 29:23assigned at birth, that's the bad thing. And
- 29:25so that's why when we look at the language of
- 29:28multiple bills and it's echoed in all of them,
- 29:31it's not probably about the thing it says it's
- 29:34about, it's about it's coming from animus instead.
- 29:38I think you've offered Piper some great tools
- 29:42for colleagues here who may have to litigate
- 29:46or perform the act of judicial review of these
- 29:51types of laws in a post -scrimetti world. Not
- 29:56everybody who reads your article or who is watching
- 30:01or listening to us today will have the extremely
- 30:04important task of being an advocate for these
- 30:08rights. But as it is an increasingly prevalent
- 30:13and popularly accepted part of society that trans
- 30:18people do not have to live closeted, it is increasingly
- 30:24likely that members of the bar, the judiciary,
- 30:28and the public will encounter an increasing diversity
- 30:33of people in their lives and practices. And I
- 30:37think you also have some practical advice for
- 30:40all counsel. judges and scholars of this area
- 30:45that you wanted to share with us as kind of a
- 30:47secondary takeaway from your article and from
- 30:50your learnings in the trans law class. Did you
- 30:55want to pivot to that before we wrap up? Sure.
- 30:57Yeah, so I think one thing that I wanted to accomplish
- 31:02today was to teach some terms that I think are
- 31:05helpful. If you use language that is correct,
- 31:08then I think that really helps move the conversation
- 31:11and this issue forward. I'd say one of the biggest
- 31:16takeaways I took from the class was that I, as
- 31:19a cisgender woman, I identify as a woman and
- 31:22that's what I was identified at birth. I have
- 31:24a lot to learn when it comes to the transgender
- 31:28experience and and the non -binary experience.
- 31:31I'll include that as well. So to me what one
- 31:34thing that really resonated is it's important
- 31:38to say things like I have included on my slide
- 31:40that my my pronouns are she her and I think that
- 31:44can be a really helpful thing to say when you
- 31:47meet a new client or when you have an interaction
- 31:49with anyone. If you talk about your pronouns
- 31:52every day it becomes less unique when someone
- 31:56who maybe doesn't have something that's a clear,
- 31:59you know, an obvious pronoun, so to say. So if
- 32:05I say it, and I say it every day, then all of
- 32:08a sudden it's not unusual when someone else says
- 32:10it. And so I think having that in your regular
- 32:13dialogue can really help to make everybody feel
- 32:17more comfortable. I think we're finding that,
- 32:19like, a lot of times you'll say my partner instead
- 32:22of my husband or wife, because if you say partner
- 32:24instead of the gendered, it becomes less unusual
- 32:29when anybody says it. So I think those kind of
- 32:32language things can be really helpful to make
- 32:36everybody more comfortable, anyone who is trans.
- 32:38And then I would say also ask them and use their
- 32:42pronouns. If they tell you they are they them,
- 32:45use them. It's very low effort and it can have
- 32:49a huge impact on a relationship with a person.
- 32:53So my biggest sort of like, if you learn nothing
- 32:56from the presentation today, try to make that
- 33:00subtle change because it can have a really big
- 33:02impact on people's lives. My takeaway is it's
- 33:07not enough. simply to refrain from committing
- 33:11overt aggression, there are things that we can
- 33:14all do to make our daily lives and the daily
- 33:17lives of others around us also free of implicit
- 33:22or micro -aggression. And there are active measures
- 33:26that actually do not require a whole lot of effort
- 33:30from the large number of cisgender people in
- 33:36our population. that can make life better and
- 33:39more accommodating for those who are transgender.
- 33:43Before we close, I do have an audience participation
- 33:45question from our very own fearless leader, Ken
- 33:48Petroulis, who has tirelessly organized the writing
- 33:51competition for... even longer than I have been
- 33:55involved in it. He said drag performance has
- 33:58been celebrated in popular culture like the famous
- 34:03film Some Like It Hot with Tony Curtis and Jack
- 34:06Lemmon and Tootsie with Robin Williams. Surely
- 34:09the anti -drag performance law didn't pass, did
- 34:12it? I don't recall. I don't have that information
- 34:18right here, but I think some of them have passed,
- 34:21but I don't... know by and large if the one I
- 34:24put in here has. I try not to politicize my presentations,
- 34:29but that is a crying shame. Yeah. Well, I think
- 34:33the big picture is that I think no matter how
- 34:37you feel personally about being trans or that
- 34:41existence, that existence in life, you can recognize
- 34:46animus because of the fact that there are these
- 34:49clear indicators that It isn't about safety or
- 34:54any of their purported reasons. It's by the same
- 34:58people. They're using the same language. And
- 35:01anyone can recognize that as just a legal argument.
- 35:05And so I think no matter what it is, if we see
- 35:08these patterns, you can still apply rational
- 35:11basis with bite to other things. I just think
- 35:14that this is a winning way for combating the
- 35:18gender affirming care bands. But I think it can
- 35:20be applied in a lot of ways where you can see
- 35:23the same actions are being taken against a specific
- 35:26group and you can tie it all back to animus against
- 35:29that group instead of a purported reason. Well,
- 35:34I appreciate you for staying hopeful this could
- 35:37be one of those cases where the more you know
- 35:41the easier it is to give up and you've done anything
- 35:44but you've given us tools for how to go forward
- 35:47and I hope that as your career progresses from
- 35:51here that you actually get the opportunity to
- 35:53apply this in practice, whether you do or do
- 35:57not, you have contributed to the intellectual
- 35:59body of work that others who do will rely upon,
- 36:04surely. Any concluding remarks, Ms. Hinson? Sure.
- 36:09So if you want to go one more slide. Yeah, so
- 36:14this is sort of the hopeful path that I think
- 36:17we that If people are working on this right now,
- 36:20or if you have an interest in this area of law,
- 36:23I think that thinking outside the box and thinking
- 36:26about other standards of review, other, you know,
- 36:30other ways to win that have happened, you know,
- 36:32that we have done in the past, try them again,
- 36:35because I think we're in the era of we just need
- 36:39to try something. And if it doesn't work, try
- 36:42something else. And that's kind of my thinking
- 36:44is this might be the backup argument, but let's
- 36:47try the backup argument. There's certainly other
- 36:50special interests for whom that has worked. Perhaps
- 36:54more regressively than progressively. Yeah, I
- 36:59still I'm hopeful. And I think that, you know,
- 37:03I researched and read Boston versus Clayton County
- 37:07and that to me was an opinion where it was not
- 37:10the expected result, but there are ways to win
- 37:14and get things accomplished if you find the right
- 37:17argument and you find the right path. And so
- 37:19I think of rational basis with bite as a path
- 37:23to get there. So I hope that this is something
- 37:27that inspires people to. to look into this area
- 37:30of law more and to, yeah, to maybe write something
- 37:33themselves. But at the very least, I hope everyone
- 37:36has learned something and I hope you're open
- 37:38to continuing to learn as I am open to continuing
- 37:41to learn about this as well. I'll say in our
- 37:44last slide, I have resources. There we go. These
- 37:48are three resources that I used a lot in my article
- 37:51and I think that they're very, very helpful.
- 37:54They're a lot of the transgender studies are
- 37:56done by the Trevor Project and the Williams Institute.
- 37:59So if you're interested in more information,
- 38:01these are three great places to start. Or my
- 38:04article. I can start with my article. Well, Ms.
- 38:06Hinson, I'd like to thank you again for writing
- 38:09that article and submitting it to our competition.
- 38:12Thank you for being here with us today. I'd like
- 38:14to thank our audience and the rest of the committee
- 38:17from the Beverly Hills Bar Foundation. I wish
- 38:20everyone a wonderful rest of your week, weekend
- 38:23and a happy Fourth of July. Thank you for being
- 38:26with us today, everybody. Thank you.