Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage an Employee Who Plays the Victim
Transcript
- Lucas: You know that employee — and every manager has had at least one — where every single conversation turns into a list of things that happened to them. Missed a deadline? The client changed the brief. Forgot to loop in a stakeholder? Well, no one told them. Bad review from a peer? That peer just has it out for them. Luna: The victim narrative. It's exhausting to listen to, and it's even harder to confront because you don't want to seem like you're dismissing their experience. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why so many managers avoid it. It feels like you're being the bad guy for saying 'actually, some of this is on you.' But the cost of not addressing it is real. I was talking to a friend who runs a thirty-person marketing agency. She had a project coordinator — really smart, good with clients — but she was the poster child for learned helplessness. Every Monday morning standup, she'd lead with what went wrong last week and whose fault it was. Luna: How did the team react? Lucas: At first, people sympathized. But after a few months, the team started to avoid collaborating with her because any project she touched came with this fog of negativity. The actual productivity hit was maybe ten percent, but the morale tax was massive. And my friend realized she needed to step in. So we walked through a framework that I think works well for this situation. Luna: Okay, let's hear it. Lucas: Three steps. First, name the pattern — but not in a confrontational way. You don't say 'you always play the victim.' You say something like 'I've noticed that in our last few check-ins, when a project hits a snag, the explanation often focuses on things outside your control. I want to talk about that.' The goal is to make the pattern visible without triggering defensiveness. Luna: And if they immediately get defensive and say 'but it really wasn't my fault'? Lucas: That's where step two comes in — shift the language. You model a different way of framing the situation. So instead of letting them say 'the client changed the brief,' you ask 'what could you have done to anticipate that change or adapt more quickly?' You're not saying they caused the problem. You're moving the conversation from blame to agency. Luna: I like that. It's subtle but it changes the entire direction of the conversation. Lucas: Right. And step three is set the boundary. This is the part managers hate most. You have to be clear about what you expect going forward. Something like 'Moving forward, when we hit a snag, I want us to focus on what we can do next rather than whose fault it was. If you need support to make that shift, I'm here. But I need you to own the solutions.' Luna: So you're not just letting it slide. You're giving them a clear path forward, but also a clear expectation. Lucas: Exactly. And here's the thing — sometimes the victim narrative is a sign of a deeper issue. Maybe they're overwhelmed and don't know how to ask for help. Maybe they've been burned before by taking ownership and getting blamed. So part of the conversation is leaving room for that. But the line is: you can empathize without enabling. Luna: That's the balance, right? Because I think a lot of managers swing too far one way — either they get harsh and say 'stop complaining,' or they just absorb the negativity and never address it. Lucas: Exactly. The harsh approach kills trust. The permissive approach kills accountability. The middle path is what we just described — name the pattern, shift the language, set the boundary. And it works. My friend's project coordinator actually turned around. It took about three conversations over six weeks, but she started coming to standups with solutions instead of problems. The team noticed. Luna: That's a win. And I'm guessing her own confidence grew too, because she felt more in control. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's the real goal — not to punish someone for having a victim mindset, but to help them see that they have more power than they think. That's what good management does. Luna: You know, if this episode helped you think through a conversation you've been avoiding, that's exactly the kind of thing that keeps us going. We keep Manager Mondays ad-free — just real talk about managing people — and listener support is what makes that possible. If today was worth a coffee to you, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: And we mean that sincerely. Even a small gesture signals that this kind of content matters. So thank you to anyone who's ever chipped in. Back to it — one nuance I want to add about the victim narrative is that it can be contagious. Luna: Oh, absolutely. One person constantly framing things as unfair can shift the whole team's culture if you don't address it. Lucas: Right. And that's why the manager has to act early. I've seen teams where the victim narrative became the default explanation for any failure — and it completely killed innovation. Because why try something new if you're just going to blame the circumstances when it doesn't work? Luna: That's a great point. So the cost isn't just morale — it's also risk-taking and creativity. Lucas: Exactly. So when you have that conversation, you're not just doing it for that one employee. You're protecting the whole team's culture. And the longer you wait, the harder it gets. Luna: How do you know if it's a genuine victim narrative versus someone who's actually in a really tough spot? Lucas: That's the hardest question. And I think the answer is: you don't always know upfront. But the response to the conversation is telling. Someone who's genuinely struggling will engage with the 'what can you do' question. They might not have answers, but they'll try. Someone who's locked into the victim identity will resist that shift — they'll keep circling back to what happened to them. That's when you know it's deeper and you may need to escalate to performance management. Luna: So the framework itself is also a diagnostic tool. Lucas: Exactly. It's a test of coachability. If they can't or won't engage with the shift in language, then you have a different problem on your hands. But nine times out of ten, people just haven't had someone point out the pattern before. They're not malicious. They're just stuck. Luna: And that's what makes it a management conversation worth having.