Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / "Crimes Against Humanity"? A Defense of Dr. Anthony Fauci
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feels so much more happiness. Truth, Usian wisdom
- 0:33will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start
- 0:40thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. It's so
- 0:56frustrating to live in a culture that so often seems to define itself by its
- 1:03enemies. It's not as much who am I, What are my values?
- 1:07What do I think? What do I stand for? It's who are they?
- 1:12Why are they evil? Why must they be destroyed? It's everywhere a
- 1:19culture of cruel people who want to be a hero, and so everywhere they
- 1:26look, they point and they say, there's the villain. And if we
- 1:30want to see examples of this, we have to look no further than the
- 1:34Christian Bible. God, for some reason, creates his own arch nemesis.
- 1:40What purpose could that possibly serve except to allow God to play good guy.
- 1:48I shall defeat the wicked. I shall crush the agents of absolute evil,
- 1:55the one who comes to steal, kill and destroy. By the way,
- 1:59what is say and killing and stealing and destroying, It's going to be us.
- 2:04And so God comes in and he saves the day. And there's a
- 2:09whole culture of people who are like this, And I am struck. I
- 2:15am just jaw droppingly a stoneded at who they have decided the villains are.
- 2:23Everybody's a villain, everybody's coming, everybody is waging war. It's an assault
- 2:30on decency. It's an assault on their liberties, it's an assault on their
- 2:35religions, it's an assault on them as human beings. And so they rise
- 2:39up and they strap on their capes that are made out of you know,
- 2:44bath towels and shit like that, and they take the sharpie and they draw
- 2:47the superhero symbol on their chest and then they go out and make TikTok videos
- 2:53about how evil they are. How in the hell has doctor Anthony Fauci become
- 3:00a villain in anybody's story? Now this isn't well, I've disagreed with him
- 3:06or I have concerns about something that he has said. This isn't a nuanced
- 3:10perspective about a public servant. This is vilification. Strip away that man's medical
- 3:19license, arrest him, put him in jail. Hang Anthony Fauci. Holy
- 3:25shit, And these are supposed to be the righteous ones, the good guys
- 3:30in the story. I just look around and think, I cannot believe this
- 3:35is actually happening. And then I'm struck by how little most of us know
- 3:40about Fauci himself. We know him in a general sense, we know some
- 3:46basics about his life, but how much do we really know. Well,
- 3:50I'm not going to do a deep dive, but let's profile the man.
- 3:54Let's introduce each other to the man, because with knowledge comes perspective, and
- 4:01perspective is critical, I think, to living an honest life. Born in
- 4:08Brooklyn on Christmas Eve, nineteen forty, Anthony Fauci was the son of a
- 4:13pharmacist. Anthony was an athlete and right away a history buff. His grandparents
- 4:20had immigrated to the United States from Italy in the late nineteenth century. He
- 4:27has a Catholic background, but even though in twenty twenty three he still used
- 4:32the label Roman Catholic. He told the BBC that he doesn't really do or
- 4:40think anything Catholic. Here is an audio clip from his BBC interview last year.
- 4:48You don't practice anymore? To you? Why? A number of complicated
- 4:56reasons go on. We have a whole corridor. First of all, I
- 5:02think my own personal ethics in life are I think enough to keep me going
- 5:11on the right path. And I think that there are enough negative aspects about
- 5:15the organizational Church that you were very well aware of. I'm not against it.
- 5:21I identify myself as a Catholic. I was raised, I was baptized,
- 5:26that was confirmed. I was married in the church, my children were
- 5:29baptized in the church. But as far as practicing it, it seems almost
- 5:32like a pro form a thing that I don't really need to do. Anthony
- 5:38Faunci got his Doctor of Medicine from Cornell University. He joined the National Institutes
- 5:44of Health as a clinical associate in the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases
- 5:50the Laboratory of Clinical Investigation, or the NIAID. He was director of that
- 5:59organization by nineteen eighty four, offered the job of Director of the National Institutes
- 6:05of Health. On many occasions, and on all of those occasions he passed.
- 6:12When he was asking an interview by The Guardian in twenty twenty to define
- 6:16his life, he said, my career and my identity has really been defined
- 6:23by HIV, and I'll tell you what that means. Bauci was a lead
- 6:30researcher during the AIDS crisis of the nineteen eighties. By the way, there's
- 6:35a compelling book about the AIDS epidemic published in nineteen eighty seven. It's called
- 6:42and the Band Played On. It was written by a journalist named Randy Schiltz.
- 6:47HBO made it into a movie starring Matthew Modine that was nineteen ninety three,
- 6:53and the book and the film expose the Reagan era silence, the deafening
- 7:00silence about h IV. All of the religious moralizers, you know, the
- 7:08Jerry Folwell types. They were out there preaching that this was the gay play,
- 7:14It's a gay disease, punishing gay people for their gayness. The PBS
- 7:21broadcast American Masters did a profile of the AIDS crisis in the eighties and the
- 7:27backdrop for the response here's a clip. And we were one of the most
- 7:31hated communities in the country. Say the word AIDS in public. You know
- 7:38that took the president's seven years, Reagan. The polling showed that homophobia just
- 7:43kept rising during AIDS. There was a backlasher was just getting worse and worse.
- 7:47Now that's absolutely accurate. Of course, Ronald Reagan was a practicing and
- 7:53public Christian, and there's no doubt he was not a fan of LGBT people.
- 8:00Likely didn't consider gay people legitimate, certainly not gay marriage, perhaps even
- 8:05access to public health because God was punishing gays. I mean, who really
- 8:11knows what was going on in his mind, but I think it makes a
- 8:13lot of sense, especially seeing that Ronald Reagan didn't say a thing. He
- 8:20didn't reference AIDS once until nineteen eighty five. Remember that AIDS was first recognized
- 8:26in nineteen eighty one. His first public address about ADS didn't happen until nineteen
- 8:35eighty seven. For most of the AIDS epidemic of the eighties, Ronald Reagan
- 8:41was stone silent. One of the challenges of that decade was chronicled by a
- 8:48historian, a woman named Jennifer Bryer. She wrote about how the Center for
- 8:52Disease Control and the National Institute of Health, along with epidemiologist and public health
- 8:58advisor all across the country and around the world. They're all trying to get
- 9:03a handle on the AIDS epidemic. Many of Reagan's conservative advisors wanted to fit
- 9:09the response to what many considered to be God's judgment the gay plague in a
- 9:16Christian framework, And it was so often that they wouldn't even put HIV and
- 9:22the AIDS crisis on the Reagan agendas for him to speak about, or know
- 9:30about, or address. Not even the numbers, the statistics people infected,
- 9:35the casualty and mortality rate, Nothing about any of that on the presidential agenda
- 9:43for the first half of the nineteen eighties. Nothing. Doctor Fauci was there.
- 9:50He was an advisor to the Reagan administration, and at first he was
- 9:56really in the crosshairs of the LGBT community for the government's silence during a public
- 10:03health crisis. There was a guy named Larry Kramer, an AIDS activist and
- 10:09gay rights advocate. He roasted Fauci for being too inexperienced. He was not
- 10:16the right person for the job. He was just another agent and a do
- 10:22nothing White House. In nineteen eighty eight, Larry Kramer called Fauci a murderer
- 10:28because quote your refusal to hear the screams of AIDS activists early in the crisis
- 10:35resulted in the deaths of thousands of queers. Now Kramer would actually go on
- 10:43to live a pretty long life. He died at the age of eighty four.
- 10:46Only recently. In fact, and during the time near the end of
- 10:52the HIV crisis and in the decades following, Larry Kramer and doctor Anthony Fauci
- 11:00became friends, good friends. Here's Faunci reflecting on Larry Kramer. This is
- 11:07from the Logo YouTube page from three years ago. So Larry was the most
- 11:13iconoclastic, theatrical passionate group, and he introduced himself by writing an article with
- 11:24the headline an open letter, No, I called you a murderer, an
- 11:28open letter to an incompetent idiot, doctor Anthony Fauci. So in the realm
- 11:33of attention getting he got my attention. Larry started Gay Men's Health Crisis with
- 11:39his colleagues, but he also started Act up in New York and I got
- 11:43to get involved not only with Larry, but with activists, young men who
- 11:48really wanted to change the direction of where we were going and put much more
- 11:52resources and attention to this emerging plague. What did your friendship with Larry teach
- 11:56you? As I extended myself to listening to the activists, I found out
- 12:03that they were absolutely correct, and although they had to resort to theatrical disruptions
- 12:11to get the attention of the scientific community and the regulatory community and the federal
- 12:16government in general, I realized that I would have done exactly the same thing
- 12:20as they did. So I transformed from the object and the target of their
- 12:26activism to being an activist with them. And it was Larry Kramer himself who
- 12:35would stand up to defend doctor Anthony Fauci when he called for masks and distancing
- 12:43with COVID nineteen. His former critic was standing by his side to protect public
- 12:50health. During that Reagan era, Fauci was frustrated. He and his fellow
- 12:56scientists were desperately trying to break through until they finally persuaded Reagan to engage with
- 13:03some kind of government response. And it was during that response, it was
- 13:09during the solutions that came at the end of the nineteen eighties and into the
- 13:15nineteen nineties, with Fauci at the forefront, the opinion tied among much of
- 13:20the gay community started to shift. Let me go back and play another short
- 13:24clip from that PBS series. This was last year as Fauci was sitting in
- 13:31a room with age activists Greg Gonzalveez, Peter Staley, and David Barr.
- 13:37I developed long term friendships with the activists, who was sort of like soldiers
- 13:43in the same war. I can't precisely remember when we actually first met.
- 13:50We were all positive. It was early eighty nine. We would have been
- 13:54how old I was, twenty eight? How was a baby. We didn't
- 13:58get involved thinking, oh, we're going to get it and we're going to
- 14:01look at drug regulation and clinical research. We wanted treatment because we were sick,
- 14:07and the only place where there was any possible area to get any treatment
- 14:15was through the clinical research system. And that's what led us to you.
- 14:20You were a target, A major target, was the head of ADS Research.
- 14:24You can actually see and hear the evolution of doctor Fauci's understanding of what
- 14:31was going on in the gay community in the nineteen eighties. At first,
- 14:35all the shouting and the protest and the noise, I think overwhelmed him until
- 14:41he began to listen and engage and better understand and then a line. In
- 14:46fact, it was Fauci who became a mediator between AIDS victims and the scientific
- 14:52community, and he worked feverishly to increase access to experimental tree eatments, pushing
- 15:01the government to amend its requirements to expand opportunities to try experimental remedies. Now
- 15:09was Fauci's response perfect, of course not. We all know that disease response
- 15:16is a moving target. He made a famous mistake back in nineteen eighty three
- 15:20suggesting AIDS might be spread by close contact, as in a family household.
- 15:28So if you were in an enclosed space living with your loved ones, perhaps
- 15:33you could brush up against someone or have some other casual contact and possibly contract
- 15:39HIV. That wrong opinion was published, ultimately debunked, and Fauci had to
- 15:46reverse himself. But he wasn't an agent of lazy hysteria. He was a
- 15:52human being who was a scientist facing a massive problem, humanity's problem of HIV.
- 16:00Anthony Fauci was the primary person behind the President's emergency plan for AIDS relief.
- 16:07This provided ninety billion dollars in research and is estimated to have saved around
- 16:15twenty million lives through pandemic control in more than fifty countries all around the world.
- 16:25Today, as we all know, HIV is still with us. It
- 16:29is transmissible through sex, or blood transfusions or needle sharing, et cetera.
- 16:36It has claimed over forty million lives in the last forty five years. Around
- 16:42forty million people live with HIV, most of them living in Africa. There
- 16:48is still no cure, but preventions, early diagnosis, and developed treatments have
- 16:55made AIDS much more manageable. In fact, most people with HIV can and
- 17:00do live full, long, even healthy lives. Doctor Anthony Fauci is one
- 17:07of so many scientists who transformed this runaway killer epidemic into something that we can
- 17:15prevent and manage. Here's Fauci from twelve years ago speaking about AIDS on the
- 17:23HIV gov website. Vaccine is going to be part of a combination prevention approach.
- 17:30We already have within our grasp the tools, if fully implemented, to
- 17:37really turn around the AIDS pandemic. We have very effective prevention modalities from behavior
- 17:45modification to condoms, needle exchange, mother to child transmission, circumcision, topical
- 17:52micro Besides pre exposure prophylaxis. And the most recent dramatic, game changing observation
- 18:00that was made very recently from an NIH study that was a multinational study but
- 18:07sponsored by my institute, was what's called HPTN five two, which was the
- 18:12trial that showed that the earlier you treat an infected person compared to waiting a
- 18:18little bit till their disease progress, not only do we have what we already
- 18:23know is a beneficial effect on the infected person, but a dramatic, truly
- 18:29dramatic decrease in the likelihood that that person will transmit the virus to their sexual
- 18:36partner. And that is a game changing study which proves that treatment itself can
- 18:42serve as a form of prevention. Bauci's public health work would go on to
- 18:48address things like the swine flu and ebola outbreaks, and then of course we
- 18:55saw COVID nineteen when I came back. We shall do the COVID chapter of
- 19:02the Fauci story. Our profile continues next. I'm just taking a little bit
- 19:14of time on this podcast to talk about doctor Anthony Fauci, the man who
- 19:21has become the villain of so many stories, unjustly and some people will say,
- 19:26well, Seth Andrews is just biased in favor of Fauci, so he's
- 19:30going to do a favorable profile. But I don't think it's quite that simple.
- 19:36I think we can take a more objective look at his life and see
- 19:41a public servant who doesn't deserve the hates and the awfulness and the cruelty and
- 19:47those who want to discredit and even jail him. It's just crazy to assert
- 19:52as such. As we have discussed his public service work in the nineteen eighties,
- 19:57nineties, early two thousand, Now we want to talk about COVID nineteen.
- 20:03The first cases of COVID detected between October and November of twenty nineteen.
- 20:10Doctor Fauci brought onto the White House Coronavirus Task Force in January twenty twenty under
- 20:18Donald Trump. He became the face and the voice at the podium, updating
- 20:22all the rest of us and there we had more controversy January twenty first,
- 20:30January twenty sixth, and February seventeenth. It was Fauci who said publicly COVID
- 20:37nineteen was not a major threat to the American public, or it was a
- 20:42low threat. But the situation was evolving people needed to take it seriously.
- 20:49Of course, his critics latched onto that low threat claim and they have run
- 20:56with it. The idea is that this flaky doctor couldn't make up his mind,
- 21:02didn't know what he was talking about, or outright liede. He switched,
- 21:07he flipped, he's unreliable, possibly part of a COVID conspiracy, and
- 21:14that gets us into all kinds of other stuff like the Wuhan lab leak conspiracy
- 21:21theory, for which there is no evidence. There's just no evidence for it.
- 21:26By March of twenty twenty, Founci predicted that COVID would infect at a
- 21:32rate of ten times the seasonal flu. And then he said something that his
- 21:37critics would latch onto again. In March, he said everyone should not walk
- 21:44around in masks. He was worried about a mask shortage. Faunci elaborated in
- 21:52an NBC interview three years ago. Here's what he said. Now. Early
- 21:56on, when we were in a situation in which there was a real concern
- 22:00about the lack of personal protective equipment on the part of the health providers who
- 22:07needed it, who put themselves in harm's way every day to take care of
- 22:11people who were ill with this virus that we were thinking we would run out
- 22:17of masks and other things for them, so the recommendation was not to wear
- 22:22a mask because of the shortage of it. Two things happened. One,
- 22:26it became clear that we had enough of equipment so there was no shortage.
- 22:30It became clear that cloth coverings that you didn't have to buy in a store,
- 22:36that you could make yourself, were adequate. And Thirdly, and probably
- 22:40the most compelling thing, is when it became very clear that anywhere from twenty
- 22:45to forty five percent of people who were infected didn't have any symptoms. So
- 22:49the risk of your being in contact with somebody say well, you'll look good,
- 22:53I look good, we're not infected was not the case that you could
- 22:57be spreading at asymptomatic. You put all of those things together, which had
- 23:03us evolve from saying maybe we should hold off on masks because we needed them
- 23:07for the healthcare work, as to saying, now everybody should be wearing a
- 23:11mask when they're outside and should be trying to distance. That's one example of
- 23:17evolving as you get more data and you get more information. As the masks
- 23:22became more available and Fauci then made his strong recommendations for mask wearing for all
- 23:30of us. The Fox News crowd has been far too eager to sound bite
- 23:36Fauci in unfair ways. It was Fauci who advocated government mandated shutdowns of many
- 23:44public spaces. And if you thought he was the bad guy before this is
- 23:49when he really started to receive the hates. He became an enemy of liberty,
- 23:56government overreach, conspiration see an attack on American freedoms now, conversations about
- 24:06those who lost their businesses and their livelihoods with those shutdowns. I think those
- 24:11are legitimate conversations. Many people have never recovered personally or financially, and I
- 24:18think that's fair to say. But a highly contagious COVID nineteen virus was catching
- 24:23like wildfire. People were dying. Some could argue that if we had all
- 24:30abided by restrictions and masks and distancing and good sense for just a hot moment
- 24:38in this culture, the pandemic, it would have died away in a matter
- 24:44of just a few weeks, if only we had been able to all cooperate
- 24:51with our preventions. But I will leave those discussions for you to continue in
- 24:56the comments section. July of twenty twenty. This is just a few months
- 25:02after he was on the task force. Trump already turning on Fauci. By
- 25:08the fall of twenty twenty, Conservatives were pushing back on all of it,
- 25:12distancing masks, back scenes. Of course Donald Trump. I think he wore
- 25:18a mask, maybe once or twice. Remember it had the presidential seal on
- 25:22it. But after that, no masks, no distancing denial about the dangers
- 25:27of COVID. And then Trump got COVID. Fauci goes on sixty Minutes and
- 25:34commits the crime of saying told you so. Here's a clip from Inside Edition
- 25:41about the Fauci Trump blow up. This was October of twenty twenty, the
- 25:45month before the presidential election. The war of wars between President Trump and doctor
- 25:51Anthony Fauci is heating up. Last night, doctor Fauci was on sixty Minutes
- 25:55saying he wasn't surprised that mister Trump had contracted the virus. Today, on
- 26:00a call with campaign staff and some members of the press, the President let
- 26:03loose on the nation's leading infectious disease expert. President Trump is trashing doctor Anthony
- 26:10Fauci today, calling him an idiot. In a call to his campaign staff
- 26:15that reporters were allowed to listen in on. People are tired of hearing Fauci
- 26:21and all these idiots every time he goes on television. There's always a bomb,
- 26:25but there's a bigger bomb of your firearm. Trump's fury came after Fauci's
- 26:29sixty Minutes appearance in which he criticized last month's White House Amy Coney Barrett event.
- 26:36Were you surprised that President Trump got sick? Absolutely not. When I
- 26:40saw that on TV, I said, oh, my goodness, nothing good
- 26:45can come out of that. That's got to be a problem, And then
- 26:48sure enough it turned out to be a super spreader event. Fauci also revealed
- 26:52that he's protected round the clock by federal agents because he and his family are
- 26:57getting death threats. Hard to believe, isn't it. People don't just disagree
- 27:03or criticize express concerns in an adult way. We're talking about a whole culture
- 27:10of people protesting with their signs and posters and placards proclaiming that Fauci is a
- 27:15criminal. Arrest Fauci, Hang Fauci. Those hashtags have been flying around the
- 27:23internet. He is in the minds of so many public enemy number one,
- 27:30and again we see a culture of cruelty which defines itself by its enemies,
- 27:37and how many of those enemies are really good people committed to public health and
- 27:42safety and humanity. How did they get to be the bad guys in the
- 27:48Maga story? It's so frustrating. And then we come to the very recent
- 27:56how Select Committee on the Corona Virus where Fauchi makes his appearance and gets the
- 28:03joy of being interrogated. Actually wasn't an interrogation. It was just a monologue.
- 28:08It was a ranting, frothing series of outrageous accusations by Georgia Representative Marjorie
- 28:17Taylor Green. As much as I hate to listen to the sound of her
- 28:22voice, check out just a little bit of what she said. But let's
- 28:27also talk a little bit further about the type of science that you represent.
- 28:33Nih scientists made seven hundred and ten million dollars in royalties from drug makers,
- 28:40a fact that's been hidden. Let's talk about the fact about is it right
- 28:44for scientists and doctors getting paid by the American people government taxpayer paychecks to get
- 28:51patents where they're paid millions and hundreds of millions of dollars in royalty fees,
- 28:57especially when the NIH and these government agencies, most powerful agencies in our country
- 29:03are recommending medical suggestions and advice and making up guidelines like six feet distancing and
- 29:11masking of children. Do you think that's appropriate? Do the American people deserve
- 29:15to be abused like that, mister Fauci, because you're not doctor, you're
- 29:19mister Fauci in my few minutes, No, I don't need your answer.
- 29:25I want to talk about this right here. Trajection. I reclaim my time.
- 29:30I reclaim my time, mister Raskin, mister trumant, order, just
- 29:36in terms of the rules of decorum, are we allowed to deny that a
- 29:38doctor is a doctor just because we don't want him to be a doctor?
- 29:44Yes, because in my time, that man does not deserve to have a
- 29:48license. As a matter of fact, it should be revoked and he belongs
- 29:52into prison to spend. Of course, you heard there the voice of reason.
- 29:56How refreshing it is to have Congressman Jamie Raskin out of Maryland in the
- 30:02room. But Marjorie Taylor Green was not finished. I'm going to subject you
- 30:07to one more SoundBite. This is her in the hallway after the hearing he's
- 30:11guilty of mass murder. I mean Erfaucius as absolute monster. He should have
- 30:17his medical license revoked and he should be charged and tried for crimes against humanity.
- 30:22Now this is the same woman who went on another ran back in February
- 30:27against another physician. As there was a Senate subcommittee hearing on Capitol Hill about
- 30:33COVID with doctor Peter Marx, the director of biologic's Evaluation and Research at the
- 30:41Food and Drug Administration. He was talking about how the COVID vaccine had saved
- 30:45millions of lives. Marjorie Taylor Green goes, now, it wasn't. And
- 30:49of course we have to listen to Green because she's credible. After all,
- 30:53she was once a former CrossFit Jim owner and he is just a director of
- 31:02biologics Evaluation and Research at the Food and Drug Administration and a board certified hematologist
- 31:10and oncologist. Anyway, Marjorie Taylor Green was saying the vaccine caused everything from
- 31:15strokes to heart attacks to miscarriages two turbo cancers, which is a nothing term.
- 31:22It was actually used way back in the day in an experiment, a
- 31:26random experiment with mice to study inflammation in the body has nothing to do with
- 31:33anything, certainly cancer. But of course Marjorie Taylor Green's talking about tarabout cancer.
- 31:40You hear this woman and you just shake your head and you say,
- 31:42how is this even happening? I mean, it's not just the tenor of
- 31:47her voice. Does anybody else feel that you hear that sound and you just
- 31:51want to drive into a retaining wall, just end it. And it's not
- 31:56just the tenor of her voice. And I'm a voice person, right just
- 32:00listening to the sound. It's the condescension and the cruelty and the supposed credibility
- 32:08coming from a person who is as smart as fish bait. She doesn't even
- 32:16have one ore in the water. The woman is several tacos short of a
- 32:22combo. If she was any dumber, you would have to water her three
- 32:30times a week. Now, nobody's saying that the scientists and scientific organizations and
- 32:37the process has been perfect. Nor am I saying that there have not been
- 32:40bad agents and people who have done stupid stuff. And one of the protests
- 32:45from many in the anti FAUNCI crowd has to do with this leaked email from
- 32:51the National Institute of Health. An advisor to the NIH A guy named David
- 32:57Morans apparently was trying to evade public records requests by using his personal email for
- 33:06NIH business, and he is listed as an advisor a top advisor to doctor
- 33:12Anthony Fauci. They work in separate buildings. Fauci says that he does not
- 33:15operate in a critical capacity when it comes to making public health policy. He
- 33:22referenced this on CNN as he spoke with Caitlin Collins. The other thing that
- 33:29came up today is was focused on the US and how a deputy of yours
- 33:32att the NIH bragged about evading federal records laws and deleting emails to where they
- 33:38couldn't be produced to reporters and members of the public Hoover requesting them. And
- 33:45you talked about this. But what changes do you believe that and I should
- 33:47make to ensure that these open records requests, which which we believe are fundamentally
- 33:52important, are not purposefully obstructed by officials. Well, first of all,
- 33:59Caitlin, let me say that the individual who did that was wrong. That
- 34:02is unexcusable and inappropriate, and that is not the way things go with the
- 34:07NIH. That is an outlier and not typical at all. Of the hundreds,
- 34:14if not thousands, of very hard working, committed people at the National
- 34:19Institutes of Health. So I hope that the public and the audience doesn't realize
- 34:22or doesn't come to the conclusion if I might say that one single person who
- 34:29did something that is totally unacceptable and very inappropriate, that that is reflective of
- 34:35the thousands of people who are doing their job and are committed to the health
- 34:38of this country. Now, it's interesting to see our reaction to a statement
- 34:44like that, and I think it's you know, it's almost a social experiment.
- 34:49What do you think about COVID and COVID preventions and the vaccines and science
- 34:54and fauci and general and how will those perceptions, positions a pin biases effect
- 35:00whether or not we believe him. Of course, the Marjorie Taylor Greens of
- 35:06the world are going to say it's all a massive cover up and he's a
- 35:08piece of shit, and the NIH is just a big, you know,
- 35:13star chamber of conspiracists who are trying to kill people with turbo cancer, and
- 35:22people like me, I mean, I'll admit it. I'm like, this
- 35:23guy's a fifty year public servant, a credible scientist, you're a flawed human
- 35:29being. But do I think he's part of a cabal of COVID conspiracies trying
- 35:35to kill people or cover everything up? Do I think he's not working in
- 35:38the public interest. I don't buy that. I just don't buy it.
- 35:43I think he's a good man and he sure deserves a whole lot better than
- 35:46to be threatened with death. People are saying we're going to kill you.
- 35:52Not just you, we're going to kill your wife, We're going to kill
- 35:55your children, And for that reason, he can't go anywhere without security.
- 36:01He was asked about this at the hearing and became very emotional speaking about his
- 36:07family. After that, on the same day, he had a conversation about
- 36:12the death threats with CNN's Caitlin Collins. I have testified literally hundreds of times
- 36:19over the last forty years over Congress, and there's always been differences of opinion,
- 36:23differences of ideology, criticisms and things like that. But the level of
- 36:29vitriol that we see now just in the country in general, but actually played
- 36:35out during this hearing was really quite unfortunate, because the purpose of hearings are
- 36:39to try and figure out how we can do better. So that next time,
- 36:45if and when we are faced with a pandemic, we'd be better prepared
- 36:49and we could benefit. If mistakes were made, we identify them and we
- 36:52try to correct them for the future. That's not what we saw today,
- 36:57as shown by the clip you sh with Marjorie Taylor Green. I mean,
- 37:01that was nothing about trying to do better. Unfortunately, and you know you
- 37:07testified there at the end about the threats that you and your family are still
- 37:10getting even to this day. And for those who don't know, that was
- 37:14your wife, Christine, who is esteemed in her own right, sitting behind
- 37:17you there, And I just wonder if you ever thought that you would still
- 37:21be getting threats like that, credible threats against your life, even now two
- 37:27years out of government service. You know, it's very interesting. It's a
- 37:30pattern, Caitlin, that whenever somebody gets up, whether it's a news media
- 37:36you know Fox News does it a lot, or it's somebody in the Congress
- 37:40who gets up and makes a public statement that I'm responsible for the deaths of
- 37:45X number of people because of potlseas O some crazy idea that I created the
- 37:51virus. Immediately you gets, like clockwork, the death threats go way up.
- 37:57So that's the reason why I'm getting death threats. When you have performances
- 38:02like that unusual performance by Marjorie Taylor Green in today's hearing, those are the
- 38:07kind of things that drive up the death threats because there are a segment of
- 38:12the population out there that believe that kind of nonsense. For the last segment
- 38:17of this broadcast, I want to go beyond the scientists that I'm not just
- 38:22talking about doctor Fauci or frontline virologists like doctor Peter Hotez, who has also
- 38:30been threatened with death. I'm going to talk about the culture that is fueling
- 38:34all of this vitriol. There was an article published by the Association of American
- 38:40Medical Colleges. The article titled why do so many Americans Distrust Science? I'm
- 38:49going to read it for you next. On twenty twenty two, the AAMC,
- 39:04the Association of American Medical Colleges, published in article about this crazy culture
- 39:09that we seem to live in where people are declaring war on science and scientists,
- 39:16and I wanted to read it for you for the last segment of the
- 39:20broadcast. It's titled why do so many Americans Distrust Science? Written by senior
- 39:27staff writer Patrick Boyle. The reading of this article takes about twenty minutes.
- 39:38Medical science is creating miracles and losing trust. It's emerging from the darkest days
- 39:46of the pandemic with both life saving discoveries and a crisis in credibility. Although
- 39:53confusion and hostility are defining features of the past two years of COVID nineteen,
- 40:00the crisis of trust in our society didn't start with COVID nineteen and won't end
- 40:07with COVID nineteen. It's not about a disease. It's not about Twitter,
- 40:13it's not about facts alone. Stephen Joffey, Interim Chair of the Department of
- 40:19Medical Ethics and Health Policy at the University of Pennsylvania, warns it's not just
- 40:25a COVID thing. Rather, the pandemic provided a fertile environment for myriad social
- 40:32and technological forces to breed confusion and distrust. Those forces ignite epidemics of misinformation
- 40:42against pillars of society, among them our systems of justice, education, science,
- 40:47and democracy. Timothy Caulfield, research director of the Health Law Institutes at
- 40:54the University of Alberta, Canada, says trust in science tific institutions has taken
- 41:01a huge hit. Janet Woodcock, MD, and Principal Deputy Commissioner of the
- 41:08Food and Drug Administration, says, the whole strength of science is that people
- 41:14who have different ideological bends can do experiments, transcend their prior beliefs, and
- 41:21try to build a foundation of facts. Now we have whole groups of people
- 41:27who don't believe that. Moving forward, scientists working on high visibility health projects
- 41:34are more likely than ever to find themselves operating within an infodemic, an overload
- 41:40of information about a problem, much of it wrong, that makes it harder
- 41:45to solve the problem. Science leaders and government and academia say that meeting the
- 41:52challenge to regain credibility requires a deeper understanding of several conditions. The forces and
- 42:00factors behind distrust, which include a public overwhelmed by too much information, growing
- 42:08polarization, disinformation campaigns by domestic or foreign corporations and governments, a media environment
- 42:17that rewards outrage and outlandishness, and the increasingly public nature of scientific research.
- 42:27The people who spread and who absorb misinformation, who include those who set out
- 42:34to find the truth but get confused or outraged by misinformation they stumbled into conspiracy
- 42:40theorists who gravitate towards stories that confirm their suspicions, and organized groups that pedle
- 42:49disinformation for profit. The motives behind disinformation, which is a form of misinformation
- 42:57that is deliberately deceptive. Those motives include politics, arousing opposition to the other
- 43:05side, profit making money by pushing bogus scientific products, social advocacy, raising
- 43:13support for a cause that cuts against the scientific consensus, and even foreign affairs
- 43:20sowing distrust in an adversary's government. For example, reports by the European Parliament
- 43:27and the Center for European Policy Analysis concluded that Russia and China spread disinformation about
- 43:36COVID nineteen's origins and COVID nineteen vaccines in order to convince people in democracies that
- 43:44they cannot trust their health systems and to exacerbate tensions in Western governments. Timothy
- 43:53Calfield says, disinformation strategists are quote weaponizing scientific on certainty and trying to create
- 44:01distrust. They're trying to create information chaos. When it comes to measuring the
- 44:08impact of the attacks on medical science, opinion polls have ironically produced results that
- 44:15confirm what anyone wants to believe. Some polls show that science and medicine defined
- 44:22broadly, retain high overall trust in the United States, right up there with
- 44:29the military. Where people turn skeptical is when scientists draw conclusions about issues that
- 44:36pluck sensitive courts, namely telling people what to do. The Pew Research Center
- 44:43reported in February of twenty twenty two that twenty nine percent of US adults say
- 44:50they have a great deal of confidence in medical scientists to act in the best
- 44:54interest of the public, down from forty percent November twenty twenty and below the
- 45:01ratings before the coronavirus emerged. One troubling consistency demonstrated in a poll by Gallop
- 45:10is that Republicans have been losing trust in medical science for years, while trust
- 45:16among Democrats hold steady. The more people see science as another politicized field,
- 45:23as many people see the movie industry in mainstream news, the more they will
- 45:29dismiss scientific findings that clash with their worldviews. Sudib Perik, PhD and CEO
- 45:38for the American Association of the Advancement of Science says, we now have a
- 45:43significant minority of the population that's hostile to scientific expertise. We are going to
- 45:52have to work hard to regain trust. Lack of trust in health authorities can
- 45:58hurt people. US Surgeon General and the World Health Organization have declared that health
- 46:04misinformation is a threat to public health because it leads people to ignore science based
- 46:09recommendations about behaviors, to practice and to avoid. At the FDA, Woodcoxe's
- 46:17risks even to basic communications about food and drug safety. She states, if
- 46:23we say this food additive is safe, there are going to be people who
- 46:29just say we don't have any credibility. There will be people who say they're
- 46:34lying. On a global scale, scientists fear that the spread of misinformation will
- 46:39make it impossible to successfully meet other public health challenges pollution, climate change,
- 46:46and future epidemics, among others. The forces and factors that drive distrust.
- 46:54People are overwhelmed by information coming through their uters, phones, and televisions.
- 47:01Sometimes they can't sort out all the breaking information about critical health issues. Even
- 47:07Lindsey Lininger feels it. She's a public health scientist and co founder of Dear
- 47:14Pandemic, an online forum created to help people navigate the COVID nineteen information overwhelm.
- 47:22She's also a mother trying to protect her children. Quote there is all
- 47:27this decision fatigue for parents. Should my kids wear masked as school even if
- 47:32they're not required? Should I get them vaccinated? Complicating the task is that
- 47:39some of the misinformation is designed to confuse and divide people. Journalist Jonathan Rausch
- 47:45says one way to do that is to flood the zone with falsehoods and conspiracy
- 47:52theories and to cause mass disorientation. Uncertain on how to tell what's true and
- 47:58false. Lining Her observes, people rely on proxies to guide them. You
- 48:04say, this is not my expertise. I'm going to rely on somebody whose
- 48:07expertise this is. Who are the people I trust? What do they say?
- 48:14Lininger turns to peers in science. Those not in science turn to trusted
- 48:21TV personalities, bloggers, friends, and community leaders who might share their political
- 48:28and social values and assess the information through those lenses. The country is growing
- 48:35more socially divided and politically polarized. As a result, people increasingly get much
- 48:42of their information about the world, politics, science, foreign affairs, and
- 48:46more from people and institutions that confirm their beliefs and ignore sources that run contrary
- 48:54to those beliefs. This harms health efforts. The Surgeon General's Advisory says misinformation
- 49:04tends to flourish in environments of significant societal division, animosity, and distrust.
- 49:12The divisions and distrust make people more open, even eager to accept information that
- 49:19discredits the beliefs of people on the other side. Diane ben Scudder, founder
- 49:25of a group focused on psychological manipulation, says, they like feeling part of
- 49:32this community. When you give them facts that say it's big medicine, big
- 49:37pharma, big corporations feeding you lies, they want to believe its lies.
- 49:44Climate change illustrates the struggle to win over skeptics and a polarize society. Many
- 49:50liberal leaders have zealously taken up the cause of combating climate change as a core
- 49:55issue. Conservative commentators have responded with fury and stoked fear in their audiences.
- 50:04The clash has spiral to the point where the science doesn't matter as much as
- 50:07the politics, as each side feels that agreeing with the other would constitute abandoning
- 50:15their tribe. Vera. Dunnenberg, PhD, Associate professor of cardiothoracic surgery at
- 50:22the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, says, perhaps the most serious threat
- 50:28to science is the politicization of scientific facts. Once a scientific issue becomes politicized,
- 50:37it gains its own life. Trust in institutions is eroding. All government
- 50:44and private institutions that develop health policies suffer harm from news reports about research scandals
- 50:52such as fraud, conflicting findings among scientific studies, and dismissive pronouncements that everyone
- 50:59should just trust the science. As Jonathan Hite, PhD, a social psychologist
- 51:06at New York University, says, when people lose trust in institutions, they
- 51:12lose trust in the stories told by those institutions. In vaccine hesitancy, public
- 51:20trust, expertise, and the War on science, philosophy professor doctor Maya Goldenberg
- 51:25contends that some people oppose vaccines in general, not because they don't know enough
- 51:31about science, but because they don't trust the institutions that recommend vaccines. When
- 51:39it comes to COVID nineteen, some researchers found that in countries where citizens reported
- 51:45a high level of trust in their government institutions, overall, people were more
- 51:51likely to follow mitigation efforts such as masking and getting vaccinated. At the same
- 51:57time, however, the ever changing scientific knowledge about the disease triggered confusing and
- 52:04sometimes contradictory messaging from authorities, which reduced trust. Adding to the erosion is
- 52:12increased access to scientific research, which allows people to find science that supports what
- 52:19they want to believe. When everyone can become their own expert, it's easy
- 52:24to wave off declarations from science institutions as flawed or driven by hidden agendas.
- 52:32Perhaps the most common tactic of disinformation campaigns is making people doubt that scientists have
- 52:39reached a consensus on an issue. All it takes is providing a few people
- 52:45of questionable expertise to disagree with all those credible experts. Doctor Sander vender Linden,
- 52:54who is a social psychology professor at the University of Cambridge and the UK,
- 53:00says, we can say thousands of scientists agree, but they say,
- 53:05here are all these important people who disagree. As soon as we introduce a
- 53:10contrarian perspective, people lose all sense of the weight of the evidence that supports
- 53:16the consensus. For years, tobacco companies paid for research that sowed doubts about
- 53:23the overwhelming consensus by independent scientists that cigarettes cause cancer. Vander Linden has researched
- 53:34the practice of climate change deniers. To stir doubts about the consensus on that
- 53:39issue. They create reports that say some scientists disagree. Many times the denier
- 53:46scientists have no expertise in climate science, but lay people don't know that the
- 53:53art of science gets turned against science. The power of science lies in continuously
- 54:01challenging what scientists think they know. We have hypotheses, we test them,
- 54:07and when the data showed that those hypotheses aren't right, we change them to
- 54:13the public. All that adjusting and contradicting of findings raises suspicions of incompetence or
- 54:20worse. In our polarized world, changing your mind about something based on data
- 54:25is evidence of cover up, conflict, or corruption. Not long ago,
- 54:32this iterative process ran largely out of the public eye. Assistant Professor of Medical
- 54:39Ethics at the Pearlman School of Medicine, doctor Holly Lynch, says, for
- 54:45a long time, it was scientists talking with each other and debating these things
- 54:50at conferences and in scientific journals. Now the public witnesses many of these discussions
- 54:57thanks to pre publication access to science research before it is fully vetted. The
- 55:04fast spread of research findings, including contradictions of previous findings through the Internet and
- 55:09social media and online discussions dissecting or even ripping apart. Research. Science is
- 55:17becoming more and more accessible, which is a good thing in one regard,
- 55:22but that has put on public display this process of debate and iterative approaches to
- 55:30figuring out what is true. This has been a game changer. Groups profit
- 55:37from disinformation. Sure, some disinformation comes from conspiracy obsessed tweeters with too much
- 55:44free time, but those people get lots of material from well funded groups with
- 55:50practical objectives make money, win elections or advance causes. There are actors in
- 55:59this plot to have motives other than being angry. There are people who are
- 56:04interjecting themselves into this dialogue in order to accomplish other objectives. Companies have attacked
- 56:13government advice about COVID nineteen protections and treatments in order to sell alternative, unproven
- 56:20products. For example, some providers continued selling the anti malaria drug hydroxy chloriquin
- 56:28as protection against COVID nineteen even after a study touting its benefits against the disease
- 56:35was retracted. In other cases, companies use misinformation strategies to protect their profits.
- 56:43Joffe at the Pearlman School of Medicine points to oil companies that produced studies
- 56:49casting doubt about the impact of their product on climate change. There has been
- 56:54a concerted effort from some quarters to undermine trust in science for private purposes.
- 57:02Sometimes those purposes include advancing social agendas. A report by the Center for Countering
- 57:10Digital Hate based in the UK, found that twelve anti vaxers are responsible for
- 57:16almost two thirds of anti vaccine content circulating on social media platforms. Amid the
- 57:27COVID nineteen vaccination backlash, anti vaccine organizations enjoyed an increase in contributions. This
- 57:37all means that doctors, health professionals, and researchers need to better understand the
- 57:43nature of the credibility challenge so they can craft effective counter measures. Those measures
- 57:50range from physicians strategically responding to disinformation on social media, to institutions working with
- 57:58trusted community leaders to educate the public, to government agencies thwarting information warfare.
- 58:07Because, as Jacqueline Mason, director of programs at the nonprofit Media Democracy Fund,
- 58:14told the Conference on Disinformation and the Erosion of Democracy about disinformation campaigns,
- 58:21quote, this isn't just for fun, and that is the end of the
- 58:29article. At the end of the day, I guess I have an agenda.
- 58:35I wanted to come to the defense of doctor Anthony Fauci and scientists like
- 58:40him, doing important work and deserving so much more than the venom and vitriol
- 58:49and vilification that they have received out there. Nobody said they're perfect. We
- 58:53are all human beings, but they are definitely the good guys in our story
- 59:00and they deserve allies like you and me. Thank you so much for listening.
- 59:08I'll see you back here next time. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook
- 59:13and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and
- 59:17t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources,
- 59:22and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website,
- 59:28The Thinkingatheist dot com.