Latest / No Way Out / Neuroweapons Are a Reality: Cognitive Warfare and the OODA Loop | James Giordano, PhD
Transcript
- 0:00James Giordano: Really, what is a nervous system?
- 0:01James Giordano: What is a brain?
- 0:01James Giordano: I mean you have to consider the brain and a nervous to be a system of orientation and a system of It relates the interiority of the organism to the of the organism.
- 0:14John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 0:15John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple, then.
- 0:17John R. Boyd: There is no way out.
- 0:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, welcome back to No Way Out.
- 0:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm Brian "Ponch" Rivera.
- 0:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Three years ago, Dr.
- 0:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: James Giordano sat down with us and told us the is the battle space of the 21st century.
- 0:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Doc G is back.
- 0:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Dr.
- 0:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Giordano is professor emeritus of neurology, and ethics at Georgetown University Medical He currently serves as special advisor to the of the Assistant Secretary of War for Radiological, and Nuclear.
- 1:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He is also head of the Center for Strategic and Weapons of Mass Destruction Studies at the for National Strategic Studies, National Defense University in Washington, D.C.
- 1:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now you know why we use acronyms in the military.
- 1:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There, he advises the Department of War, the Staff on biotechnology, neurocognitive warfare, Intelligence, Unmanned automated Systems, Quantum Technology, and National Biosecurity.
- 1:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And in his own words, he is a huge John Boyd fan.
- 1:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: One note before we get started, about 40 into our conversation, his connection He came back from his desk at National Defense where cameras are not necessarily allowed.
- 1:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the rest of the conversation is his voice only.
- 1:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In his words, by the way, he's been told he has a great face for radio.
- 1:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Dr.
- 1:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: G opens up with a note about his role, so I'll it straight to him and we'll get airborne.
- 2:00James Giordano: Yeah, so in my current role, I do an awful lot of with the Department of War.
- 2:04James Giordano: And so, of course, everything that I've talked to you here today represents my own views and opinions necessarily reflect those of the United States the Department of War, or the National Defense
- 2:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Three years ago, you were on here with us and shared with our audience that the brain is the space of the 21st century.
- 2:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What has moved from possible to operational since then?
- 2:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What has changed in the last three years?
- 2:26James Giordano: I mean, I think the main issue here is that our primary peer competitor, our Trans-Pacific peer competitor, is advancing brain science and brain technology at a rapid rate.
- 2:36James Giordano: I mean, their conversion from what would be into what may actually be a workable construct, an construct, is about 40 calendar months.
- 2:45James Giordano: Now, if you compare that to what we're doing here in the States, probably the most advanced research initiatives are those that are being put forth by DARPA, the Advanced Research Project Agency.
- 2:54James Giordano: And those tend to work within about a 60-calendar time frame.
- 2:58James Giordano: So although at first blush, it would seem, well, you 40 calendar months or 60 calendar months, that's not a big delta.
- 3:04James Giordano: It actually is.
- 3:06James Giordano: Because what that allows is two basic things.
- 3:08James Giordano: First, it allows things to go from the research bench into what is ever going to be the new battlescape.
- 3:14James Giordano: When that battlescape is kinetic or it just depends on what we're talking about.
- 3:18James Giordano: That's number one.
- 3:19James Giordano: And number two, it allows that phase of testing to be is it scalable, fieldable, useful?
- 3:26James Giordano: And if not, adaptations can then occur.
- 3:28James Giordano: So by the time we're ready to sort of engage, we're several at least months, if not years, behind what be a viable paradigm or set of protocols for that level of operational engagement.
- 3:41James Giordano: So that's the first point.
- 3:42James Giordano: The second point is that there are a lot of things that are happening in mainstream bioscience and that are characteristically oriented towards call the low-hanging fruit of the benevolence of The idea of making people's lives better, more making their lives more capable in terms of reducing the predicament of illness and injury, And the whole field, the whole palette of tools that are viable, for example, in personalized medicine, precision personalized medicine, are essentially These are all duly usable to create precision So more recently, one of the things we've heard is the use of artificial intelligence in three primary ways.
- 4:28James Giordano: Number one, to be able to be used to develop new various new peptides, new combinations of only drugs, peptides, and biologics, but to devices that may be capable of tremendous biomedical utility, and value.
- 4:46James Giordano: But then you can flip that.
- 4:48James Giordano: Once again, we've heard that artificial intelligence be used to generate novel forms of peptide folding, develop new ways of engaging gene editing and synthetic biology to make certain types of microbes, such as viruses, even fungi, anew or modify existing entities so they now make them far more pathogenic, far more far more transmissible, and very, very In other words, matching the pathogen to a or phenotype.
- 5:18James Giordano: And the third is that, of course, last year at the States General, at the UN General Council, the United General Council, President of the United States that we'll be using artificial intelligence to monitor and surveil other countries' compliance and adherence the Biological Toxins and Weapons Convention.
- 5:36James Giordano: Perfectly valid and I think of great value.
- 5:39James Giordano: However, we also have to be aware that what's ending happening is that other nations, primarily our peer competitors, here most notably China and Russia, also now begin to employ their AI in those ways that now deceive our AI.
- 5:54James Giordano: So now you're getting an AI versus AI in the and biotechnological milieu.
- 6:00James Giordano: And as a consequence, you're seeing an operational front of engagement, and in some cases, of competition and conflict.
- 6:10James Giordano: So those three aspects taken together, again, not ways that are mutually exclusive, but that are unity, I think create a very, very different of not only what is capable in terms of bioscience and technology, but what is very viable, what is valuable, and of course, at this point, what is actually
- 6:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you brought up something here about the 60-40 months.
- 6:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh the environment, and what I'm tracking the environment's changing faster than can respond to it.
- 6:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we've had a lot of folks come on and talk about perception action loops, ecological psychology, free energy principle, active inference, processing.
- 6:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So understanding how we process, how we reality, how we decide, how we act, how we learn, how we adapt is absolutely central to this I think that's what you called it, right?
- 7:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is it correct?
- 7:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 7:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So can you walk us through a little bit about brought this up the last time we're on the show the I think I don't get the name right, dOODAc.
- 7:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's uh disposition with the OODA loop and You rewrote that or you worked that into a article.
- 7:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I have it, so I can bring it up here in a moment.
- 7:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But can you walk us through why you're going to that and starting with disposition and how relates to everything you just brought up?
- 7:28James Giordano: Yeah, well, I mean, I think it it's fundamentally to reinstitute and reiterate the value of Boyd's OODA I mean, it stood the test of time.
- 7:38James Giordano: And of course, coming from where it came from, I you know, John Boyd being a very intelligent guy, and just limited to sort of what's happening operationally, but understanding cognitive processes and how they created a very simplified model of the way human and perhaps other brains that are engaged in these of cognitive processes really engage the overall approach to what may be decision-making pursuant to or inaction.
- 8:04James Giordano: So the idea of observing something, orienting to that orientation to what may be prior memories and making a decision based upon weighing out those options very, very quickly, and then acting, well, that that has preserved the test of time.
- 8:19James Giordano: The simple OODA loop, very, very valuable into but of course, in even in Boyd's writing, the idea the OODA loop does not exist as a standalone entity, exists far larger within a larger cognitive construct really looks at any brain, any nervous system as a time machine.
- 8:36James Giordano: And I think that that's a really good way to put it.
- 8:38James Giordano: The way brains work, the way nervous systems work, even simple nervous systems, is they relate what's in the present to things that may have been learned the past.
- 8:49James Giordano: And the way neural systems encode, at least in part, is what's referred to as Bayesian encoding.
- 8:56James Giordano: In other words, you're getting reinforcement for that are similar, and an absence of reinforcement or for things that are not necessarily similar.
- 9:05James Giordano: So what we tend to do is we tend to gig on, we tend to orient towards those things that are familiar to us based upon our similarity with known entities, known events, known outcomes.
- 9:16James Giordano: And then what we do is we make our decisions and about what's in our present state as a consequence of pre-existing conditionalities and contingencies.
- 9:24James Giordano: In other words, dispositions.
- 9:26James Giordano: So dispositions feed into even the way we observe the And in fact, that existing D or B, whether it's or whether it's true biases, flavor the things we look at it and how we look at various things.
- 9:41James Giordano: I mean, it happens to all of us.
- 9:43James Giordano: What will I pay attention to?
- 9:44James Giordano: What is sentinel to me?
- 9:46James Giordano: What do I recognize based upon my prior experiences is going to be a value of me to even orient my vision to in observation before I orient my cognitive processes to some sense of what it is that I'm looking at?
- 9:59James Giordano: Then I have to make some sense of it.
- 10:00James Giordano: So I then look at what this thing is, make some sense it based upon my knowledge of the thing, again, based on my prior inferences, intellect, intuitions.
- 10:11James Giordano: From that point, I begin my decisional process.
- 10:15James Giordano: What can be done in response to this?
- 10:19James Giordano: And based upon those prior dispositions and how those have then fed forward to guy prior actions, what I do?
- 10:27James Giordano: And then I do it.
- 10:28James Giordano: But then ultimately, what I'm also doing is I'm waiting for the consequences of those actions to do one of two
- 10:33James Giordano: things: either reinforce my extant dispositions
- 10:36James Giordano: some level of consonance, or to invalidate those dispositions through a process of dissonance.
- 10:43James Giordano: And based upon that, I'm either going to retain my dispositions and biases and have them fortified, or are going to be threatened.
- 10:53James Giordano: And once those things become threatened, a number can occur.
- 10:56James Giordano: In other words, now I can get true what's called dissonance, and that can cause me stress and that can me particular vulnerabilities and volatilities in I think and act.
- 11:05James Giordano: Or what I'm doing is I'm taking that information and I'm utilizing that information to now incorporate that a larger knowledge set, and I'm now developing some of practical wisdom.
- 11:14James Giordano: In other words, what I thought may have been true before, or what I thought may have been portending what may be outcomes based upon a decision.
- 11:21James Giordano: That's not necessarily so.
- 11:23James Giordano: So I now need to change my thinking schemata in to this, revise that thinking schemata, revise what it is I'm observing, how I'm orienting to it, and what my decisions are, so I can now generate a new action So that dOODAc looping is, I think, an embellished of Boyd's initial OODA loop that comes out of Boyd's themselves.
- 11:46James Giordano: And what my colleague Diane DiEuliis and I have really just sort of played that out a little more fully, embellished it to some extent in terms of what we know about neurocognitive processes, and then fit that within the framework of how this would work operationally.
- 11:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm curious here, are you separating we'll use disposition separate from orientation?
- 12:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the way we look at orientation is it's it's a generative model.
- 12:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's built on our genetics, our culture, and our experiences.
- 12:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um what I'm hearing from you, and I want to make sure our listeners and I understand this is are you separating that now?
- 12:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are you saying that that's outside of orientation or that's still part of orientation?
- 12:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you're just amplifying to our leaders that, this is critical in understanding an agent environment relationship, how how we're coupled the environment.
- 12:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you comment on that a little?
- 12:32James Giordano: Sure.
- 12:33James Giordano: Well, very often what you find is that orientation depends upon what the observations are.
- 12:38James Giordano: So orientation following observation basically that I'm orienting to something that uh I've observed, good enough.
- 12:47James Giordano: But the issue then becomes what am I observing in the place?
- 12:52James Giordano: How is it that I'm generating these observations?
- 12:54James Giordano: What am I choosing to look at?
- 12:56James Giordano: And that's where those predispositions end or biases, biases come into play.
- 13:01James Giordano: And I think even the problem with using the word biases is that it tends to have uh a negative connotation.
- 13:06James Giordano: In this case, not at all.
- 13:08James Giordano: Those biases are simply that.
- 13:10James Giordano: They are predispositions that may flavor or we observe.
- 13:15James Giordano: And those observations then feed into our In other words, how am I orienting to those things that I am observing?
- 13:23James Giordano: But what is it that may actually influence or drive my observations to begin with?
- 13:29James Giordano: So in any particular observing field, in any what we call observatory field, there are going to be certain things that become more sentient or more salient to an based upon a number of things.
- 13:39James Giordano: And those factors include their dispositions.
- 13:42James Giordano: I'll give you a perfect example.
- 13:44James Giordano: So again, both you and I, shipmates, former maritime Navy and Marine Corps.
- 13:51James Giordano: So if something resonates with you in terms of your experience being a shipborne sailor, the sound of a engine, the sound of aircraft engines, you're gonna take a look at that.
- 14:04James Giordano: All right.
- 14:04James Giordano: So, you know, you and I have talked previously about of the things I do as hobbies and whatever, as I ride or used to fly airplanes.
- 14:11James Giordano: I hear an airplane, and if that airplane sounds like a military airplane to me, I'm gonna look at that versus the sound of, let's say, a commercial airliner.
- 14:20James Giordano: Why?
- 14:21James Giordano: Because I have a predisposition to think, okay, that to me like a military airplane going into burner.
- 14:26James Giordano: So I want to see what kind of an airplane that is.
- 14:28James Giordano: Does it sound familiar, something I used to fly or Same is true if I hear sort of a rumble down the If I were not a motorcycle rider, I wouldn't be to the fact that, well, okay, you know, is this who's riding a Harley with good pipes?
- 14:39James Giordano: Did somebody put good pipes on something else?
- 14:41James Giordano: Same kind of thing.
- 14:42James Giordano: So my predispositions flavor or influence to observe.
- 14:47James Giordano: Once I'm observing it, now those observations then feed into my extant orientations.
- 14:53James Giordano: So here we can think of dispositions as something instigative, whereas those orientations, secondary to are exactly that.
- 15:03James Giordano: They are orienting, and those orientations then relate back to some of those things that those prior may have infused and enthused.
- 15:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to continue on this.
- 15:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's an idea that orientation may be an that we may be connected to the outside world in some way.
- 15:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think you did wrote a paper on this a while Can you talk a little bit about that?
- 15:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is is orientation, and I like to use the is that disposition, how we look at the world.
- 15:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you can you build on that or or challenge me on that?
- 15:32James Giordano: Yeah, well, I mean, I don't think there's any challenge there at all.
- 15:34James Giordano: I mean, I think you're absolutely right.
- 15:35James Giordano: I mean, the the issue in this point is well, what I mean, as you know, there's a lot of discussions about what consciousness is, what is the nature of Let let's move away from that for a moment.
- 15:45James Giordano: I mean, one of the things that I'm working on with a of mine in Germany, Professor Niko Kohls, is uh what we consider to be a fundamental question that may in come through the back or side door of the issue.
- 15:56James Giordano: Really, what is a nervous system?
- 15:57James Giordano: What is a brain?
- 15:58James Giordano: I mean, you have to consider the brain and a nervous to be a system of orientation and a system of It relates the interiority of the organism to the of the organism.
- 16:10James Giordano: It relates the past of that organism to the present and in some cases orients it speculatively and to its future.
- 16:17James Giordano: And obviously it can do this by virtue of also orienting to dispositions, memories, and codences of time and So again, the idea of the brain as a time and space I think, is a very useful rubric as a very, very useful uh sort of learning construct to be able to adhere to.
- 16:35James Giordano: Whether or not we can argue as is something, is something fundamental, is it something that is I think also reflect reflects back to the idea that if we go back to the heuristic of brain as time and space machine, we have to then ask, well, what is the brain How is it doing this?
- 16:56James Giordano: And so you have to recognize that there are three, but we consider to be very plausible mechanistic actions a brain or nervous system require.
- 17:04James Giordano: Number one is that it does work as a generator of some sort.
- 17:07James Giordano: It's generating, obviously, various types of activities, and processes that are involved in forms of computation.
- 17:15James Giordano: And those computations ultimately are to be able to allow and engage cognition.
- 17:22James Giordano: And as you get iterative forms of cognition, that can become forms of consciousness.
- 17:28James Giordano: Fine.
- 17:29James Giordano: But there are some other issues that may be involved.
- 17:33James Giordano: Could the brain also work as an antenna or the brain as a physical structure, once it achieves some configuration, some architecture or some set of architectonics, grabs things.
- 17:50James Giordano: Various forces that are present in the natural world, from inside of that organism and from outside, but it in some way, and perhaps channels it into some mechanism.
- 18:01James Giordano: So the idea of the generator working in tandem or in with what may be an antenna or an antenna resource is plausible, is viable.
- 18:12James Giordano: Could these things work in a way that might be mutually exclusive?
- 18:15James Giordano: Perhaps.
- 18:16James Giordano: Could they also work obviously convergently?
- 18:18James Giordano: Yes, very much so.
- 18:20James Giordano: But then we can get something that's even perhaps more passive than that.
- 18:23James Giordano: Is it possible that the brain is really a receptacle?
- 18:26James Giordano: That like any receptacle must have certain certain structures to hold whatever it is it's going to hold.
- 18:33James Giordano: But then once it holds that within the form of that and those architectonics of its structure on a of levels, well, the thing that's inside it takes on the form and in some cases the functions of the box of the receptacle.
- 18:49James Giordano: Is it possible that our brain, once it reaches some state of architecture, then achieves some upon what that architecture is able to capture in of various forces of the natural world?
- 19:04James Giordano: And here too, is this existing as a single set of and processes, or is it existing in some way and interactively, convergently, with antenna functions and generative functions?
- 19:17James Giordano: And for for us, for Dr.
- 19:19James Giordano: Kohls and I, what we've done is we tried to entertain of those possibilities, both singularly as and what that might imply and perhaps portend, and as in various forms of combination.
- 19:31James Giordano: Antenna and receptacle, antenna and generator, and receptacle, generator by itself, etc.
- 19:39James Giordano: In looking at what nervous systems do, I think the idea of the nervous system providing some level of to the exterior world, inclusive of not just what is spatial world, but temporally, represents a a set of capabilities that any nervous system has to be able to work as a system of relationality, space, time, exteriority, that is able to base past experiences as a fundamental resource, a repository from which to or engage the present and do so in ways that are towards particular decisions and actions that are going to influence not only the present, but the future.
- 20:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think there's a strong connection back to here.
- 20:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He wrote a lot about uh MTS, mind time space.
- 20:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I do want to point out something that when we about orientation, we're not talking about brain, the the matter that sits sits between our ears.
- 20:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't equate that to that.
- 20:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We we look more like look at it as though it's of for e-cognition, and maybe you can talk bit about that as well.
- 20:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But it's not central to what's between my head.
- 20:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's where I put the boundary around my or wherever I want to look at that particular OODA loop.
- 20:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that orientation is that for e-cognition.
- 20:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're we're embedded within the environment, part of that environment, we're extended in Is that consistent with the way you look at between a mind and brain?
- 21:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I want to bring up something else.
- 21:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I read recently that uh people that receive transplant have sometimes have memories from person they received that heart transplant from.
- 21:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's what we're getting at here.
- 21:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh can you talk about that?
- 21:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that is that how you kind of look at this?
- 21:15James Giordano: Well, let's break those two out.
- 21:16James Giordano: All right.
- 21:17James Giordano: So let's take a look at that second point about memories being received from a heart transplant as subsequent to the primary discussion, which is really what's with regard to the way brains work.
- 21:27James Giordano: Clearly, nervous systems are embodied.
- 21:29James Giordano: And I don't care what that body is, I don't care if body is uh essentially, you know, a very, very organism, if you will.
- 21:38James Giordano: A worm.
- 21:39James Giordano: Or something far more complicated.
- 21:42James Giordano: A mammal, a primate, a human.
- 21:45James Giordano: Nervous systems exist within a body as embodied Those nervous systems essentially grow up with as part of that body, and the experience of Of is going to be the environment or ecologies across time occurs based upon the filter that that embodiment I can only know the world, truly know the world in the subjective first person as experienced by my nervous in my body.
- 22:20James Giordano: You can tell me what it's like to be you.
- 22:23James Giordano: You can relate certain things that you've gone or you feel to me.
- 22:28James Giordano: And I may be able to perceive that, but ultimately my person understanding is always going to be through the filter, the bandpass filter of my own experience as in me.
- 22:43James Giordano: This is what the philosopher Thomas Nagel has to, as sort of that sensation of what is it like to be a bat?
- 22:50James Giordano: In other words, one only knows that level of It is, in many cases, what the neuroscientist is referring to as the feeling of what happens.
- 23:01James Giordano: And that feeling of what happens happens within me.
- 23:04James Giordano: So again, to reiterate, even if you tell me a certain way, or you're telling me something is I'm not necessarily sharing the experience.
- 23:15James Giordano: I can't experience it as you.
- 23:18James Giordano: I can only relate to it as me.
- 23:21James Giordano: This is what in sort of older phenomenological philosophy is referred to as the distinction between explanation the second and third person and understanding in the person.
- 23:32James Giordano: We understand per German phenomenology, we understand, in the first person subjective, because consciousness our cognition is in fact always subjective, intentional, and transparent only to us.
- 23:47James Giordano: And even when I can get things explained to me, I have to then relate that back to something I've done, some some memory, or some experience.
- 23:58James Giordano: So what ultimately happens is that understanding, true understanding, is always fed through and interpreted the filter of embodiment.
- 24:09James Giordano: Okay?
- 24:10James Giordano: Point number one.
- 24:11James Giordano: Point number two is that the idea of embodied is a reality that, again, the functionality of occurs within whatever is going to be that Now, break break here for a moment.
- 24:27James Giordano: We could get into some very interesting, and I think grounded as well as esoteric discussions about what that portend for non-human consciousness and perhaps non-organic consciousness, such as that that may for example, in a machine system.
- 24:42James Giordano: And we could talk about that in a moment, because I that there is some value in the idea of differential and what embodiment means in terms of occupation of space, not necessarily just an anthropomorphic body, or even a mammelo, or even what I might call of organically carbon-based body.
- 25:02James Giordano: But the other question then is, well, what about to that subjective self?
- 25:08James Giordano: So now let's get into that other issue about heart patients.
- 25:11James Giordano: Heart is an innervated organ.
- 25:12James Giordano: The question then is, well, what do we get when we get a transplanted innervated organ?
- 25:19James Giordano: Might we be getting some level of neurological from that organ that then feeds back into our system?
- 25:27James Giordano: And how articulate, how ornate might that feedback be?
- 25:33James Giordano: Is it possible to be able to actually generate entire I mean memories of time, space, occurrence, I don't know.
- 25:45James Giordano: I mean, I I I'm curious, I mean, I think that a level of skepsis might be called for here.
- 25:53James Giordano: Is it possible that an individual who receives not only a heart transplant, but perhaps any innervated organ might have a sense of that organ's presence because innervated organ now contributes back to the nervous in which that innervated organ is now a part?
- 26:14James Giordano: Well, now you're dealing with sort of this older this sort of Heraclitan concept of parts and how they would relay.
- 26:21James Giordano: And I think that there's something to that.
- 26:24James Giordano: I mean, clearly something that is contributing to a system may have some element of presence and effect upon that nervous system.
- 26:32James Giordano: And if that nervous system is a system of cognition and feeling of what happens, I would expect it it would be at least feasible, if not very possible, that organ might contribute something back to the of the experience of having that nervous system and a unique part of that nervous system now put back it.
- 26:53James Giordano: Again, how ornate, how sophisticated, how granular are those sensations?
- 26:59James Giordano: Might there be entire memories of the other from whom that transplant has been derived of their I would be a little skeptical of that.
- 27:08James Giordano: Okay.
- 27:09James Giordano: Might there be some change in the way the individual who is now bearing that transplant feels, emotionally feels, perhaps has a feeling of self?
- 27:21James Giordano: I think that's very plausible.
- 27:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let me ask you this.
- 27:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I didn't expect to go here today with you.
- 27:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's get a little woo-ish for a second.
- 27:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'll get back on track.
- 27:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So if we are looking at the orientation as an and we bring in this uh this heart, uh, and it attunes us to something else in the environment, and we'll call that outside information.
- 27:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's some research happening now on the space from Michael Levin that again, going back what you brought up, but is it entirely that that heart now helps us attune to that's in the environment?
- 27:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we'll we'll come back to uh the cognitive aspect here in a second.
- 27:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let me that question again.
- 27:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So by adding a new component to our orientation, a heart in this case, that comes with some type attunement, that's part of an antenna that we we talked about previously.
- 28:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That antenna, that orientation, is connected to or looking to the environment.
- 28:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And John Boyd wrote outside environments, and and today we're learning more about something known the platonic space from Michael Levin, our in biology that are looking at this thing out that's kind of controlling us or has some influence on us, and it may have some connection.
- 28:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So by adding this component to us, calling it the heart, it it may provide us another way to tune the environment.
- 28:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a it's an attunement mechanism, right?
- 28:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it's entirely possible, and again, this little wooish for this conversation, I get it, uh these uh histories can be captured in some of global consciousness.
- 28:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're stepping way out of the space that we wanted to talk about, but I'm just sharing that with you as a as a thought and want to hear if you have uh idea or thoughts on that.
- 28:52James Giordano: You know, I I'm not gonna say it's it's a reach.
- 28:54James Giordano: I think that there's I think there are certain things we can well grasp.
- 29:00James Giordano: I mean, so if we certainly like a person's reach exceed their grasp, talk about reaches and grasp.
- 29:05James Giordano: I think there are real grasp graspable verticalities what we're talking about here.
- 29:10James Giordano: I mean, when you when you take something and put it a communicative system, I mean a nervous system is a system.
- 29:16James Giordano: The idea that whatever it is you're inserting into system may affect the pattern of communication and the system's awareness of how that communication changing, I think that's very graspable.
- 29:28James Giordano: I think the idea that anything that changes what be the receptacle, the antenna and or the generator by adding or taking parts away could certainly also not only the function of that system, but also person of subjective perception of that system's And then, of course, for organisms that are cognitive and that have some level of reflection of their cognition, that have consciousness, I think that may be subjectively apparent.
- 30:00James Giordano: I think if we start to go a little bit further than that in terms of could this also then change individuals' perceptions, their capabilities, you start to perhaps the Pandora's jar of what may be psi phenomenon.
- 30:12James Giordano: You know, I think you know if we look to example for of Dr.
- 30:17James Giordano: Dean Radin's work, very, very good work.
- 30:20James Giordano: I I think that what tends to happen with nervous systems is, of course, nervous systems, as we know, are precocial at birth.
- 30:29James Giordano: In other words, you have more connectivity than one actually need, and then as a consequence of lived which then essentially codifies patterns of mechanisms within that nervous system, you see a pruning of that precociousness in terms of structure then begets function, and function begets Is it possible that some individuals' nervous systems for a broader range of functions that we may consider to be paranormal on the outside of that normal Gaussian distribution?
- 31:03James Giordano: Yeah, perhaps.
- 31:04James Giordano: And I would think that's that's very realistically so.
- 31:07James Giordano: Some of our own work, for example, with regard to cognition has demonstrated that.
- 31:11James Giordano: Is there anything supernatural to it?
- 31:13James Giordano: No, I I I I tend to askew that, but my thought is that certainly it is, quote, para-normal in the literal of what is sort of para on the limits of what is to be statistically normal for the way most individuals would have cognitive processes.
- 31:30James Giordano: Is that cultivatable?
- 31:32James Giordano: Perhaps.
- 31:33James Giordano: Is that modifiable if you modify a nervous system?
- 31:37James Giordano: Perhaps.
- 31:38James Giordano: Might we then see that these types of changes to a system through either addition or subtraction of its architectures, structures, might lead to changes in function, and those changes in function might not only be viable, and it was functionally viable, but also and perceptible?
- 31:59James Giordano: Sure.
- 32:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, let's do this.
- 32:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I know we spent a lot of time on we'll call orientation.
- 32:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's at in my view, it's critical that leaders how we perceive reality, what we understand neuroscience, and and they need to take a little bit of time to to digest that, predict the processing, you know, how perception, the work, things that we just covered.
- 32:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We but we're attacking the system now, and I'm bring up a slide here about the cognitive and its dimensions that uh you've And I want you to talk a little bit about that uh and and what that means.
- 32:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So maybe just bring that, share that with you, All right.
- 32:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let's let's move this conversation into this and why what we just talked about is important we look at uh this type of warfare.
- 32:39James Giordano: Sure.
- 32:39James Giordano: So I mean you've you've kind of launched us, real pun intended, into the domain of cognitive quote, warfare.
- 32:46James Giordano: And at present, I mean right now as we're recording uh there's some ongoing debate about what cognitive is, or is cognitive warfare a thing, or is it just, for example, psychological operations or operations on steroids, like PsyOps or meso on Is it influence operations with a new twist?
- 33:12James Giordano: Well, I mean, I think that the answer to that is, well, yes, I think there are components of that.
- 33:16James Giordano: But I think that understanding the cognitive domain being multicomponential, I mean, to understand how the cognitive domain can be both a as well as viable target of and for influence on a of different levels.
- 33:37James Giordano: Obviously, we've known this for a long time.
- 33:42James Giordano: This is not earth-shatteringly new news.
- 33:44James Giordano: I mean, we can take a look at, quote, influence uh anywhere from what I will call simple propaganda, idea of propagating, little propagari to create, to move to propagate something within the mindsets, sort of functional cognitive realities, or at least of certain individuals and collectives.
- 34:05James Giordano: That's old.
- 34:06James Giordano: Very old, the idea of various narratives, various being used to be able to stimulate not only the processes of thought, but the emotive aspects of and the intentional, motivational, the cognitive aspects of cognition.
- 34:24James Giordano: Again, very, very old.
- 34:27James Giordano: But what I think is changed is the level of capability and granularity by and through which the domain can be accessed, assessed, and affected.
- 34:40James Giordano: We have to consider any organism, uh any organism that has a nervous system to be uh a triune.
- 34:48James Giordano: I mean, clearly that organism is biological.
- 34:51James Giordano: And again, I'm talking here about organic I'm not talking about AI, for example.
- 34:57James Giordano: Again, a wonderful discussion that could spool off uh a whole bunch of mental aerobatics.
- 35:03James Giordano: But if we take a look at organic organisms, we know they are they are that.
- 35:09James Giordano: They are organic, they have a biological reality to they are biological entities.
- 35:14James Giordano: But you cannot engage that biological entity realization of its environment, and that environment is social to that extent.
- 35:26James Giordano: In other words, it exists within a relative set of and that systems, those systems create a social a social environment by which that organism is with other organisms of like as well as dissimilar type.
- 35:45James Giordano: And they're doing it in certain ways that have particular structural rules, formatives, et cetera.
- 35:51James Giordano: Fine.
- 35:51James Giordano: We understand that.
- 35:52James Giordano: And again, this happens from literally almost the of the individual's birthing through all of its levels of relative socialization and interaction with and non-conspecifics.
- 36:04James Giordano: What's going to be beneficial, what's not going to be how do I need to act around family, friends, etc.?
- 36:10James Giordano: What things in my environment, in my social can I interact with in a positive way?
- 36:15James Giordano: What need to be interacted with in a more cautious Fine.
- 36:18James Giordano: The interlocutor, if you will, the liaising piece between the biological and the ecologically or environmentally, quote, social systemic aspect is that cognitive and expression domain or dimension, which is the dimension.
- 36:33James Giordano: And that psychological dimension is the thought inclusive of feeling, and those things that then executes or doesn't execute, which is behavior.
- 36:43James Giordano: So we can take a look at any organism as a functional Three parts.
- 36:48James Giordano: Obviously, the biological basis of that, the aspects of both reception and expression that exist in and vested and nested within some environment that provides the social dimension.
- 37:04James Giordano: So the cognitive domain, appreciating the cognitive as that ongoing interaction in real time of realities, becomes very important.
- 37:16James Giordano: Again, is this brand new?
- 37:18James Giordano: Absolutely not.
- 37:19James Giordano: It is not.
- 37:20James Giordano: I mean, we could take a look at some of the work in medicine of George Engel talking about a model of medicine, and that's axiomatic to that model.
- 37:30James Giordano: But what is new is the engagement of various toolkits methods to be able to assess, access, and affect each those domains independently and conjunctively.
- 37:47James Giordano: So again, my area of subject matter expertise, if you is in the neurocognitive or in the sort of dimension and domains.
- 37:57James Giordano: And the figure that you you you illustrated for us comes from a paper that my colleague Dr.
- 38:04James Giordano: Robert Schmidle, Lieutenant General Robert Schmidle, Corps, and I wrote, that we have published in the Small Wars Journal.
- 38:11James Giordano: The idea of reconceptualizing that domain, the domain, as those three parts, also provides what I call sub-targeting domains that very realistically, in 2026, are viable and are valuable as targeting One can target, for example, the biological aspects of an organism to affect their neurobiology, in ways that influence the cognitive dimensions processing, emotions, that then can guide One can influence the psychological domain through like narratives, memes, tropes, symbols, semiotics, that can then affect an individual's psychological to is occurring as a consequence of their underlying So again, what we're seeing allows the ability to assess each and all those domains, access each and all of domains, and something that has become realized that really then changes this idea of cognitive into a characterologically distinct be leveraged as warfare.
- 39:33James Giordano: So apparently I'm running it now through my desktop, of course I'm at NDU, so we don't we don't have allowances.
- 39:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That\'s fine.
- 39:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 39:42James Giordano: So if you want to continue, we can just pick up and do the voiceover.
- 39:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You do have a face for radio.
- 39:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Dr.
- 39:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: G.
- 39:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to go back to your uh cognitive domain for a moment and just point out a few things.
- 39:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're looking at a um image from uh John Boyd's work, and I'll share a few other um slides here in a second.
- 40:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But key to this is the the agent performer coupling, the system, the embeddedness of uh of we're talking about.
- 40:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when you're talking about genetics or biology, um to me that's genetics, right?
- 40:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's genetics.
- 40:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um you have social in here and psychosocial, I which I want to make sure I can get this correct.
- 40:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is psychosocial just basically our culture, and maybe a little bit of our biology?
- 40:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Or can you define that a little bit more and with social?
- 40:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because I want to make sure I capture this the way.
- 40:32James Giordano: Yeah.
- 40:32James Giordano: So so let's embellish a bit on the whole what is So to sort of limit biology to genetics, I think, is on a number of different reasons.
- 40:43James Giordano: First and foremost, because one's genetics actually does not determine linearly one's biological Genetics realistically can be considered to of a blueprint.
- 40:52James Giordano: And the expression of that blueprint, it its its actual formation, the existence of what may be on that is determined by ongoing interactions with the essentially throughout the lifespan on a variety So when we're talking about biology, yeah, we're about genetics, we're talking about genotype, but also talking about expressed phenotype.
- 41:12James Giordano: And that phenotype, again, occurs on a variety of from the cellular all the way up to the systemic.
- 41:18James Giordano: And it's those ongoing interactions on a variety of and levels with environments throughout the some cases during what appear to be more critical than others, that are going to determine how those are differentially activated to then get the expression of structural and functional phenotypes, which then to anatomy and physiological processes.
- 41:43James Giordano: And those physiological processes run the that are actually physical, in other words, existing the level of physics, through chemistry, through biology, anatomy, etc.
- 41:54James Giordano: Okay.
- 41:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 41:55James Giordano: So biology is more than genetics.
- 41:56James Giordano: And here, too, I think it's critical to understand even something as fundamental as the expression of genes is reliant upon an environmental interaction, internal interaction within various aspects of the body, and various factors in the environment that then may be causative or in some cases inhibitory to the of first and particular genes and gene products.
- 42:24James Giordano: So the bidirectionality of the biological is continuous at a variety of scales, levels, and throughout the lifespan.
- 42:35James Giordano: This is what has been referred to as nature via The original concept was one that was first mentioned by Adam Smith, the economist.
- 42:45James Giordano: And then I think more recently has been embellished a wonderful book of the same title by Matt Ridley, via Nurture.
- 42:52James Giordano: So when we consider biology, it's very important to biology beyond mere genetics to represent genetics as in some way, an important and componential part in but certainly not all that there is to that biology.
- 43:07James Giordano: Point number one.
- 43:08James Giordano: Point number two, the idea of the environment being and multidimensional here too is crucial.
- 43:15James Giordano: And I mean that literally.
- 43:16James Giordano: It creates a crossroads by which those internal factors, that in some cases may be predispositional, as genetics, are then activated or inactivated or dormant as a consequence of particular prompts of the external and internal of environmental across time.
- 43:36James Giordano: When we talk about the psychological domain, what we're really talking about is how an individual receives and both sensorally as well as cognitively perceives information and then encodes that information into the schemata of their cognitive processes, and then how cognitive processes ultimately will drive behaviors that are expression.
- 43:59James Giordano: Of those cognitive emotional states in response to environmental prompts on a variety of levels.
- 44:06James Giordano: So what we're seeing is that the organism's component are essentially biopsychological, and the organism, of that embodied organism, represents the componential remainder of that triune.
- 44:23James Giordano: And again, those things are essentially inextricable.
- 44:26James Giordano: I can never take the organism out of an environment.
- 44:31James Giordano: It is always in an environment and it will always to that environment, inclusive of with other organisms of the same type.
- 44:41James Giordano: Even if that choice is, I don't want to relate to any organisms, that's still a social relationship.
- 44:46James Giordano: It's just a negative relationship.
- 44:48James Giordano: So we have to appreciate that that really does a functional triune.
- 44:55James Giordano: The organism is those three things in one.
- 44:59James Giordano: And they are multidimensional.
- 45:01James Giordano: Obviously, things from the environment, inclusive the environment, can be processed psychologically to then into that organism to affect their biology.
- 45:11James Giordano: Changes in the individual's biology can be sensed, experienced, and therefore flavor not only first phenomenological experience, but also the expression what that experience may foster, generate, and therefore prompt, that is, behaviors.
- 45:28James Giordano: And those behaviors engage the environment, inclusive of social environment with conspecifics and So again, it's very, very difficult, and in some cases, not only functionally impossible, but to pull those factors apart when considering the of how organisms exist and engage throughout their in the sort of real-world consequences, and contingencies of what would be the embodiment and of that organism.
- 46:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I want to do this.
- 46:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm going to share a couple of slides with you mainly mainly our audience to talk about the of the OODA loop, because everything you in my view, can be explained through Boyd's And to do that, I want to start with the These are some older sketches from John Boyd.
- 46:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm just going to highlight a few things on the side here.
- 46:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And if you can't see those, uh, for those of who are so unfolding circumstances.
- 46:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: At one point, John Boyd actually put unfolding from the environment inside of orientation, like you described, right?
- 46:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're talking genetics, cultural heritage, uh excuse me, cultural traditions and previous mixing with unfolding circumstances from the He has that in there.
- 46:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He's always had an environment within the OODA And I think the way you drew it recently in your recent article is spot on.
- 46:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, we've got to keep the environment part of the OODA loop.
- 46:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And once people start drawing the linear which he actually did sketch, and he said you draw it like this, because that's the orientation drives everything.
- 46:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That generative model, those things you determine how we perceive reality, how we sense, how we learn, how we adapt, how we decide, how we act.
- 47:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm going to build on this some more.
- 47:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um again, we're seeing another iteration of Boyd's uh work with orientation in the center.
- 47:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, of course, this is the one that's hanging up at uh when you walk inside the um uh library at the uh Marine Corps uh um not history, but the Corps uh Equantico.
- 47:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 47:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you can see this one, this is pretty standard.
- 47:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and then you get into some other ones here.
- 47:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is the one that Chuck Spinney brought up, I want to bring this up uh and make a point.
- 47:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Chuck Spinney makes it very clear that there are only two points that come in contact with the world, and that's observations, which are which Boyd identified as uh our sensory organs our actions, those actions that we take.
- 47:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So within the original the way we should be the oodaloop, it has an environment, uh, which is absolutely critical to understand how we engage the external world.
- 48:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We can't do that with the linear process that people draw um the OODA loop with.
- 48:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So here it is.
- 48:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you talked about genetics.
- 48:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um the way I understood it is you're bringing in the environment, which Boyd called new Um we're engaging with interacting with the that new information's coming in.
- 48:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh it's it's hitting on our previous experience, you're billing on that, and you just described what orientation is.
- 48:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh did you not?
- 48:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that not what you just shared with everybody?
- 48:27James Giordano: I'd like to think so.
- 48:28James Giordano: I mean, I'm a big Boyd fan.
- 48:29James Giordano: So I mean, i i if I were going to put on cheerleading we'd have a big B on the front, right?
- 48:35James Giordano: Yeah.
- 48:35James Giordano: I mean, look horrible in Bobby socks, and please, want to show any leg.
- 48:38James Giordano: But yeah, I mean, I think as I've said before, both uh on our discussion, in our discussions and and in print, I mean, in many ways I think John Boyd was prescient.
- 48:46James Giordano: He was able to see into aspects of cognitive science were really not yet well delineated, well-described, or even well known based upon the investigational that were available to him.
- 48:59James Giordano: Number one.
- 49:00James Giordano: Number two, let's face it, I mean, I personally have a scientist for almost five decades.
- 49:05James Giordano: And if you do science, I mean, two things are You're either gonna be proven right over time, or at that your observations, predictions, and been viewed as relatively correct and standing the of falsification validation.
- 49:21James Giordano: Well, you can be proven wrong, right?
- 49:23James Giordano: I mean, Boyd has stood the test of time.
- 49:25James Giordano: And what's happened with any good theory is that the the core of that theory remains essentially unchanged.
- 49:31James Giordano: You can bolt things onto it, you can take certain things off, but the core remains integral and integrative a variety of in of iterations.
- 49:41James Giordano: And that's held true for Boyd.
- 49:43James Giordano: So again, I mean, I'm breaking out my Boyd pom-poms.
- 49:45James Giordano: I'm a big Boyd fan.
- 49:47James Giordano: Yeah.
- 49:48James Giordano: What what we've added to that, what Diane Deoulis have added to that in terms of anything that's not even necessarily new, perhaps a novel take, is the of those predispositional factors to What happens is the the idea of orientation is not just subsequent to observation, but is in some way, fancy word, propedeutic.
- 50:12James Giordano: In other words, it's almost introductory to observation.
- 50:16James Giordano: It begs the cognitive question, what do we What do we choose to observe?
- 50:24James Giordano: And those processes can be multifold and very often are based upon predispositional factors that at least sensory biases, framings, filtrations, that engage perceptual biases, framings, filtrations, that create sort of this pre-orientation, if you will, that we call dispositional biases, that will or at very least prompt observations.
- 50:54James Giordano: Yes.
- 50:55James Giordano: What am I looking at?
- 50:56James Giordano: How long am I looking at it?
- 50:58James Giordano: What do I consider to be relative signal versus noise or at least sort of ambiguous observations that figure into what might be my quasi-calculus to things I need to orient to.
- 51:12James Giordano: And in fact, that was very important, yes, certainly Boyd.
- 51:17James Giordano: But what we try to do is to really clarify that based our understanding of Bayesian processes to neurocognitive mechanisms, and then how that can also be affected, for example, by various types of engagement.
- 51:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, you know, we had Karl Friston on the and the free energy principle with Bayesian uh, predictive processing and active inference.
- 51:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And when we walked him through the original Loop sketch, uh, one we just kind of shared a few moments ago, the generative model being he said that you know that's isomorphic with inference.
- 51:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the dispositional piece, I don't I think it's a way to explain what John Boyd with orientation, which is to you know, fractals on here and attractors and affordances things like that.
- 52:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Once you start talking like that to leaders, you're their heads explode, right?
- 52:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I believe what you did is you gave him a way understand Boyd's real OODA loop by saying dispositional thing out front, these dispositions drive the next oriented or drive the next oodaloop, right?
- 52:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Rather than we don't first observe, then orient, then decide, then act.
- 52:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Our orientation determines how we Our predictions, uh, it it can actually flow.
- 52:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We use it to understand uh TBI, PTSD, which might have another connection back to things that familiar with, and we could talk about that here in a second.
- 52:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But am I right in saying more than likely you had to use, and you did this in 2011, I believe, to help leaders understand that orientation everything.
- 52:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that why it's there?
- 52:46James Giordano: Well, I mean, let's face it, I mean, it depending on it is that you're reading of mine or that I wrote with colleagues, it's written for a particular audience.
- 52:54James Giordano: And you know as well as I do that if you're pitching to an audience of military leaders who are thinking in terms of of these constructs as being valid and of potential value in military contexts, you're gonna language that's relevant and important.
- 53:10James Giordano: If I'm writing for a more neurocognitively oriented the language might be somewhat more different and be resonant with terminology and concepts that are be part of that using toolkit.
- 53:21James Giordano: And let's face it, if you're then going to go a little further and you're gonna begin to write philosophically and start to talk about philosophy of mind, philosophy of cognition, if you're gonna start to talk about and what that's all about, here once again, some of the terminology is gonna be more germane to that camp and is going to be used in those ways that are far more of what's gonna be relative and relevant to their So when we were using those terms biases and I think it became important because it framed it the working realities of the context of If one were to look a little bit more deeply and start to unpack what it was we were talking about, as we to do, and in fact what we then did is we built upon reference both to our own work and to others.
- 54:05James Giordano: But, you know, again, this becomes somewhat more in terms of who's doing what in the field and how concepts and constructs then relate to the things we were promulgating.
- 54:13James Giordano: So, yeah, our our use of the term biases, again, qualified what bias meant and dispositions, referred to the fact that we were talking about a sort of a of a Bayesian process that goes along with the way processes engage, such that familiarity of prior then constitutes, if you will, uh a particular framework, biasing, weighting.
- 54:43James Giordano: And this thing gets into some other concepts, such as Hebbian weighting and what that means, the fact that you may have a system, for example, in organisms that's not necessarily a von Neumann system, but more of a Neumann system where different components of what might be considered memory are distributed more widely and as a consequence must come together, and then those things then create at least some type of construct that would then drive what an individual observes and how they it that then feeds into their orientation.
- 55:14James Giordano: And to repeat, I mean, not to sort of be totally I mean even a simple example.
- 55:21James Giordano: Both you and I have been around airplanes for a long, time.
- 55:26James Giordano: You hear an airplane, I hear an airplane, that's drive our observations because we may think, sounds like fill in the blank, particularly if it's unique.
- 55:35James Giordano: The person on the street who's not around airplanes gonna be able to distinguish what represents a bird from a civilian bird, a unique sounding military going into burner versus not, and they may not even So it's not just a question of, well, what am I For them, that may be relative noise.
- 55:55James Giordano: It's not something they're even going to differentially observe.
- 55:58James Giordano: Whereas for you and I, and perhaps others who were so in the past, those dispositions may then drive our So for us, what we were really doing is we were taking the orientation step, which was subsequent to applauding Boyd and going, you know, these orientations are also predispositional based upon prior the brain working as a quote time machine, and that's we do.
- 56:27James Giordano: So yeah, I mean that that's that was our underlying for that.
- 56:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I love it.
- 56:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The uh the again, the big takeaway for the is orientation and environment are critical in John Boyd's OODA loop.
- 56:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um we the way it's drawn right now, the way it's shown um is is pretty accurate.
- 56:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's just missing two points up here.
- 56:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll draw those real fast.
- 56:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Other than that, you you've got you've got the uh oodaloop in here.
- 56:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh John Boyd identified through reading the production system and and things from uh um War II about command, excuse me, control as and bottom-up.
- 57:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and here you have this slide we have middle out, bottom-up.
- 57:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit about this and how it uh affects us in cognitive warfare?
- 57:10James Giordano: Yeah, I mean, so again, this is not only cognitive warfare, but the type of ways that in individuals So if we look at quote bottom as those things that foundational, structural and functional, now we're at those things that are physiological, anatomical.
- 57:25James Giordano: Clearly, our biology affects our psychology.
- 57:30James Giordano: In other words, I'm not being a reductive materialist, but one can certainly make the statement that on a variety of different levels is at least if not directly substantive, towards our psychology, we feel, how we feel, what we know.
- 57:48James Giordano: And of course, that psychology, those psychological then drive aspects of our behaviors that ultimately are expressive in how we engage, what may be our interactions with others, other things, other persons, other etc.
- 58:04James Giordano: So we can take a look at this saying bottom being fundamental, essentially most intimate to the as an embodied organism to those things that are biological.
- 58:14James Giordano: Vector between inside and outside is the domain, psychological in terms of both as behavioral, and ultimately the expression of those are going to have some type of externalized impact, effect.
- 58:28James Giordano: That's the social domain.
- 58:30James Giordano: Knowing that, clearly these domains can also entities.
- 58:36James Giordano: So one can work from the outside in andor from the inside out, or affect the middle to be able to have some and influence on both.
- 58:48James Giordano: So for example, neurobiological targeting, example, what our group has referred to as will directly and explicitly affect the nervous system per se to affect the functions of that nervous system, which certainly can modulate, affect cognitions, and behaviors.
- 59:09James Giordano: So by targeting physiological effects of the of an organism, that physiology can affect a variety of their constitutional elements, inclusive of the way they think, the way they feel, inclusive the way they feel in their body.
- 59:26James Giordano: In other words, do I feel well?
- 59:28James Giordano: Do I not feel well?
- 59:30James Giordano: And in my feeling well or not well, how am I And that can then affect not only their psychological in terms of how they perceive their phenomenological but how they act and how they relate to others.
- 59:44James Giordano: I can then take it the other direction.
- 59:46James Giordano: I can work top down and I can engage social targeting, something as broad as literally an environment, an environment that's relatively inhospitable, etc., uh exacerbating existing environmental conditions, affecting social dynamics, creating forms of social tension and conflict.
- 1:00:11James Giordano: And by so doing, I can then affect individual reactivity.
- 1:00:17James Giordano: I can perhaps instigate in an environment factors, that may be perceived as threatening.
- 1:00:26James Giordano: And in so doing, I can then instigate or elicit and perceptions of dread.
- 1:00:33James Giordano: And those sensations and perceptions of dread can then essentially be correlated with physiological what types of things are not only involved in the but in the physical expression of that cognition.
- 1:00:50James Giordano: Here, the proverbial fight or flight response, once going back to what neuroscientist Antonio Damasio to, is the feeling of what happens inside me.
- 1:01:00James Giordano: So we see how engaging the three dimensions of the domain can be essentially exploited to be able to various target vectors and then gain various solutions that will affect one or more of those entities to be able to have a desired outcome in what the cognitive domain is and affecting the biology, the psychological dimension, and or the expression and engagement.
- 1:01:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I wrote on there uh TBI down at and I'm going somewhere somewhere with this.
- 1:01:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you talked about the environment, uh social So let's put this in another um uh domain, if you will, leadership.
- 1:01:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If I create the environment uh where it makes feel safe to bring their full self to work, we that psychological safety.
- 1:01:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, that's that would that's a that is that I can create that environment as a leader.
- 1:01:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm kind of going somewhere with this.
- 1:02:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um at the bottom there, you have uh targeting.
- 1:02:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let me walk through uh uh traumatic brain So we have breachers, uh, we have folks uh that the military um have multiple concussions that contribute to traumatic brain injury.
- 1:02:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It alters the way they perceive sans decide and So um uh from the lens of TBI, um can you take from understanding concussive events and method, uh cognitive warfare approach or method does something very similar?
- 1:02:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and if I don't know if you can talk about but uh I'm throwing that out there as um uh is a way to replicate a concussive event to create the conditions that those veterans who suffering from TBI and later on PTSD uh can you that condition through a weapon?
- 1:02:53James Giordano: Well, I mean, let's face it, I could be the answer is simple.
- 1:02:56James Giordano: Any weapon, any means of contending or dealing with that can influence their thought, their emotions, and behaviors in ways that are more consistent with what want them to be.
- 1:03:13James Giordano: So once again, if I wanted to actually affect a brain, I could certainly affect a brain.
- 1:03:23James Giordano: I mean I can put a round through somebody's head, and going to definitely affect their behavior.
- 1:03:29James Giordano: Yeah.
- 1:03:29James Giordano: I can whack them across the head with a stick, or I do that in ways that are far more insidious, perhaps or even exceedingly overt.
- 1:03:38James Giordano: So the idea of what things might be able to be leveraged as biochemical weaponry that affect the neural these are neuroweapons.
- 1:03:48James Giordano: Here, think of drugs, bugs, toxins, and devices.
- 1:03:52James Giordano: And to that last domain, devices, we certainly have appreciate the use of selected forms of directable to affect neural function.
- 1:04:04James Giordano: And of course, as you may know, some of the earlier of that some ten years ago, were defining some of injuries of individuals who had downrange of energy devices as immaculate concussions.
- 1:04:16James Giordano: In other words, they exhibited the signs and symptoms of a concussive injury absent what appeared to be the structural insult of a concussion.
- 1:04:26James Giordano: And this was due to the effects of those directable whether they were sonic energies or things along the spectrum, that were able to significantly disrupt neural cell and neural network and node integrity so as to able to disrupt cognitive processes inclusive of the emotional aspects of cognition that were important to a range of behaviors, occupational avocational behaviors, or just daily functions of daily living.
- 1:04:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But it is very likely that these things exist
- 1:05:02James Giordano: Oh no, no, it's not very likely.
- 1:05:04James Giordano: I mean it it is it is a reality.
- 1:05:05James Giordano: These represent a clear and present threat as by governmental agencies, certainly much of my own together with a number of other colleagues, have that the technological and scientific utilizing various forms of energy that can be directed in weaponizable ways has been something that has been for at least the past 10 to 15 years and certainly represent weapon systems in iteration.
- 1:05:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So something else we've been covering on here a bit is uh constraints led approach and studying the environment, the constraints in the environment to influence the outcome, right?
- 1:05:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So think of like mission command.
- 1:05:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We, you know, we have an intent, uh, we're the what, but we're gonna let the performer or discover the how, right?
- 1:05:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So to me, when when we start looking at uh action coupling, ecological dynamics, psychology, uh, free energy principle, active and constraints-led approach.
- 1:06:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And what we just talked about, that social uh can be done through some type of constraints.
- 1:06:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think you brought up narrative uh memes, and things like that.
- 1:06:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um does that resonate with you?
- 1:06:15James Giordano: Oh, yeah, without a doubt.
- 1:06:16James Giordano: I mean, you know, again, we we can sort of look a bit back to 2008-2009.
- 1:06:21James Giordano: DARPA had a program which was called Narrative Networks.
- 1:06:25James Giordano: And the idea of the narrative networks was to appreciate the biopsychosocial reality of those individuals who essentially be targeted, whether they're collectives of individuals, and what types of be done to affect their cognitive processing to be to alter their decision-making processes, their affect attitudes, values.
- 1:06:49James Giordano: That was some of the early work that the program manager at that time was Dr.
- 1:06:53James Giordano: William Casebeer, a very, very highly trained scientist.
- 1:06:58James Giordano: And a lot of that work was based upon some of the work dealing with the effects of multidimensional In other words, what types of things could be used to individuals' cognitive processing in ways that their emotional valence to then instigate particular values, and actions.
- 1:07:21James Giordano: And if we take that further, the more we learn about the way neural cognitive systems function, even in terms of some some real subtleties, color, orientation of various types of images, various types of again, memes, tropes, narratives, each and all of things can be utilized as part of a larger sphere which is cognitive warfare as a multidimensional space that can hit each and all of these different and dimensions, either selectively or in some And these can be rendered in ways that are very I mean kinetically.
- 1:08:05James Giordano: The idea of utilizing, for example, a quote or direct and overt propaganda to be able to then individuals and collectives' volatility to violence be used clandestinely in operations that we went on there, but we don't quite know the who done it, or covertly, where in fact attribution in terms of was something done or not done becomes problematic, and as a consequence, very, very difficult to because proportionality of response is based So for sure, the idea of cognitive warfare being working within the cognitive domain, is able to address each and all of these aspects, these dimensions, the the psychological, and the social, and do so across a of potential engagements, non-kinetic to kinetic, to overt.
- 1:09:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to bring it into uh I believe this Um bringing AI into this fight, I think that's or human machine teaming or however you want to look at it.
- 1:09:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh but can you walk us through what you're trying to uh get leaders to understand through uh machines or AI to help with this uh accelerated OODA loop?
- 1:09:21James Giordano: Aaron Powell Yeah, this is some of the work that I'm doing with Dr.
- 1:09:24James Giordano: Elise Annett, who's working here with our group.
- 1:09:27James Giordano: I mean, some of the previous slides you showed came out of some of the work that I was doing uh and still am with with Dr.
- 1:09:33James Giordano: Bob Schmidtl uh in cognitive engagement and cognitive The work that I'm I'm doing with with Elise Annett really is focal upon the interaction of human and machine primarily iteratively autonomous agentic AI.
- 1:09:50James Giordano: You know, I I think the issue here is that we know, within military context, that Department of Defense 3000.09 mandates that humans be in the quote loop at that point by which artificial intelligence systems are operative in the engagement of some command and functions, particularly those that involve action.
- 1:10:17James Giordano: The question then becomes how So we have to appreciate that there are many aspects of the proverbial loop.
- 1:10:25James Giordano: There's being directly in the loop, multi-stage, continuous.
- 1:10:30James Giordano: There's intermittent looping where the individual is sort of on the loop but not in.
- 1:10:36James Giordano: There's near the loop where the individual, the human brought into the loop at key elements, key junctures particular functions or the evolution of particular towards ends.
- 1:10:46James Giordano: And then there's the human out of the loop, where now the machine system is completely autonomous, wholly across a range of processes that then ultimately lead what may be computations towards execution of The truth of the issue is that this this too exists a relative spectrum.
- 1:11:05James Giordano: We here in the United States and among many of our technological, and military allies are solidly and and uh formidably committed to the humans being at the loop, if not in the loop, and being involved with to human-machine system interaction.
- 1:11:24James Giordano: But the truth of it is, is how that actually occurs I really needs to be somewhat more flushed out.
- 1:11:32James Giordano: So one of the things that we're very keenly aware of is that as you move ever more towards iteratively and agentic forms of AI in these settings, or perhaps in any setting, what you're seeing is perhaps a parsing where you see human judgment and authority and machine computation towards some level of, again, hybrid lateral as well as vertical, which may be considered form of protocognition.
- 1:12:04James Giordano: I'm not talking in any way about consciousness, cognition based upon cogniting certain actions based upon sophisticated computation, uh computation, that lead to executive functions.
- 1:12:18James Giordano: So again, what we're seeing is that cognitive ecosystem whereby you're getting particular machine-executed that may be assessment and analytic, providing to a human user to execute judgment and authority, to hand back to a machine system with regard to types of orientations that may be relative observations.
- 1:12:45James Giordano: Humans then engage the observation to orientation to field, and then may then parse that capability back over to a machine system for action.
- 1:12:56James Giordano: So once again, at present, that cognitive ecosystem is becoming increasingly reliant upon machine be able to fine-tune observations, in some cases to signality from ambiguous background quote, noise.
- 1:13:14James Giordano: Yeah.
- 1:13:15James Giordano: But the human is ultimately responsible for parsing creating various values and values deciderata upon observations.
- 1:13:24James Giordano: Those observations can then be fielded over to a system to clarify those observations and to yoke those observations to a variety of much more narrowed that the human may then have to engage.
- 1:13:40James Giordano: The human then goes from those orientations to decisions as part of a humanocentric system, and then may upon a machine-based system for the articulation of actions.
- 1:13:53James Giordano: That's the current ecosystem.
- 1:13:54James Giordano: However, increasingly what's happening is very much reliant upon those machine systems across only each one of the componential aspects of the OODA but each one of the actual functional processes of the OODA loop.
- 1:14:12James Giordano: So what we're seeing is that machine systems are being involved not only in discerning particular things that need to be observed by the discernment of signal versus background noise and ambiguity, but in all phases of clarification, as well as various phases, types, and clades of orientation.
- 1:14:37James Giordano: However, what we're arguing for is that throughout all of these multiple phasic dimensionalities of and orientation, the ultimate decisional authority must rest with the human, whereby ultimately that decision to engage a set of actions can then be co-registered a set of machine systems for clarification of those We view this as a model of synthesized communication and control that we call synthcom.
- 1:15:14James Giordano: And that's what you see in the lower portion of this Our proposed cognitive ecosystem represents a and integrated cooperativity of human and machine whereby levels of computation and cognition are in integrated across multi-dimensions, multi-phases, and levels.
- 1:15:37James Giordano: And of course, one of the ways we're doing that is a relative Fourier type analysis of what goes into each one of those computational processes towards what the decision to then pass an observation to an And then within each one of those Fourier transforms, using what's what's referred to as fuzzy logic or fuzzy set theory to be able to identify key variables and that can be differentially weighted.
- 1:16:07James Giordano: And when a particular tripping point is then each one of those particular dynamics in each one of phases, it brings the human into the loop.
- 1:16:16James Giordano: So rather than simply saying we get to a given binary go or no-go, where the human is brought into the loop, it represents a far more multifactorial analytic and computation by which the human can be brought into the loop based upon differential quantitative and weighing of key factors that are necessary with to the observational decisional aspects of observation orientation, and ultimately decision as a towards action.
- 1:17:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Years ago at the Naval Safety Center, now Naval Command, we walked through how mishaps occur and we use John Boyd's OODA loop and combined that uh the the Cynefin framework.
- 1:17:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when I see um machines, when I think about um and think about constraints led approach and some things and habits of mind, we want that guidance and control pathway that bypasses that uh aspect of the oodaloop to occur.
- 1:17:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And by the way, Karl Friston said that we spend of our time engaging in that that pathway of the OODA loop because we're not always in a Not always.
- 1:17:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um so when the context is I'll use the language of the Cynefin framework.
- 1:17:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When we're in a complicated domain where the between cause and effect is known or knowable, uh generally we can bypass that deliberate part, We we don't we're not seeking any novelty.
- 1:17:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's what this kind of um points to me.
- 1:17:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Have you looked at using any of the aspects to help understand context and help leaders where this works?
- 1:18:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:18:09James Giordano: I mean, again, if we're gonna get that way into the how are we how are we parsing out what are those and variables within what may be that fuzzy set that need to be incorporated within that set as necessary to be to be part of that Fourier transform?
- 1:18:24James Giordano: In other words, if we're looking at the Fourier of any particular set of subprocesses, right?
- 1:18:29James Giordano: So you you take a look, take a look at the OODA loop, So observation itself has an OODA component to it.
- 1:18:35James Giordano: So of an observation, what am I observing orienting to and making a decision to stay observant that?
- 1:18:43James Giordano: And ultimately that action is I'm locking on, right?
- 1:18:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:18:47James Giordano: So each one of the OODA loop components has sub-OODAs it.
- 1:18:51James Giordano: And again, what we're essentially saying is you can something called a Fourier transform.
- 1:18:55James Giordano: In other words, you can you can break out subcomponents of what might be that curve of the OODA loop into And then each one of those has subfactors and components.
- 1:19:07James Giordano: And those factors and those variables can be and you can then create those identification of those as part of a fuzzy set theory.
- 1:19:16James Giordano: In other words, they're not binary per se, but each of them is going to have a relative weighted value such that when a particular threshold in that value exceeds what I'll call X, then it becomes or salient.
- 1:19:31James Giordano: That by itself is not necessarily enough to trip the go or no go, but when taken with other factors in quote, fuzzy set, may then create enough of a effect to then say go or no go.
- 1:19:46James Giordano: So what we're what we're developing is a fuzzy model, a Fourier transform analytics of the OODA the OODA loop that can be incorporated with human teaming that essentially matches, is equivalent human cognitive systems do on a variety of scales So you have uh a much more uh intrinsic pairing of human system that's engaging OODA and the machine system that's engaging OODA, inclusive of the dispositions and consequence weighing, that can then be combined far more integrated and integrative system, truly that is synthesized.
- 1:20:29James Giordano: It's breaking down certain parts of the existing thing and bringing them together in a synthetic way that far more synthesized and viable and valuable command and control when humans are interacting with types of systems in these ways.
- 1:20:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So one of the things we've been looking at is the perception action loop, you know, the uh skills which is right here.
- 1:20:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So skills would be that pathway inside the So when we're talking about creating the in the environment or the constraints, what is doing is helping us build the implicit control as athletes or the folks that we're That's the pathway we want them to build up, We don't want them going into a game uh doing this stuff down here.
- 1:21:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um basic technical skills, if you will.
- 1:21:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When it comes to in in situ, when they're in the game, those technical skills and non-technical are these right up here, right?
- 1:21:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's what we want them to uh we'll call it habits of mind.
- 1:21:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're not gonna call it the muscle memory but habits of mind.
- 1:21:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're trying to build that pathway up.
- 1:21:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So what this allows the human to do in sport is the novel connections that are happening and to them better.
- 1:21:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, I believe that's the same thing we want with machines, is we want machines, we don't want down in here.
- 1:21:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I think that's what you're saying.
- 1:21:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um because that's not how they they operate.
- 1:21:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That the human in the loop dominates this aspect of the OODA loop.
- 1:21:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is are you is that tracking with how you look at it?
- 1:21:58James Giordano: Yeah, I mean, essentially if you take a look at which I like very much, you want to keep the human on upper aspect of that.
- 1:22:06James Giordano: I think that's very important.
- 1:22:08James Giordano: What you're using the machine for and the way you're the machine system is continuity of arrows between the upper domain, implicit guidance and control, and domain, which is unfolding interactions with the in real time.
- 1:22:24James Giordano: What the machine system is able to do is to provide has been colloquially referred to as machine depth analytics that then allow for a greater informing of what may be implicit guidance based upon certain of variables that are important to inform that guidance.
- 1:22:43James Giordano: And that becomes true bidirectional cooperativity.
- 1:22:46James Giordano: So what you're getting is a reciprocally complementarity of the machine, human machine as a true dyad.
- 1:22:56James Giordano: It is truly dyadic.
- 1:22:58James Giordano: And working towards that dyadism requires that sort of dialectical synthetic process where certain both have to be reconciled to be able to come in something that is greater than the simple sum of its parts.
- 1:23:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's a phrase coming out of ecological They call it uh education of attention or of attunement and attention, right?
- 1:23:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's this right here.
- 1:23:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're gonna teach the machine what to pay to, right?
- 1:23:28James Giordano: Trevor Burrus, yeah.
- 1:23:28James Giordano: That's exactly it.
- 1:23:29James Giordano: In fact, that that's where we that's where we were a lot of this, because we're so we're so to the idea that you're creating a new ecology when establish this true diad of human-machine dimensional very dynamic interaction.
- 1:23:44James Giordano: That is a new ecosystem, right?
- 1:23:46James Giordano: Right.
- 1:23:47James Giordano: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 1:23:47James Giordano: I mean, literally.
- 1:23:47James Giordano: I mean, you we're taking the word oikoslogos, and rational accounting of that.
- 1:23:53James Giordano: So that oikos logos, that that ecology has to uh account for both of the members of the household, if you the human component of the household and the machine of the household.
- 1:24:06James Giordano: You can't do these things separately, but to integrate them, that really is what you're doing.
- 1:24:11James Giordano: So again, I mean much of the work that came out of uh philosophy and ecological psychology, I think is to understanding what this new ecology and ecosystem the human-machine diet is going to be, whereby the process represents the vector by which those things are working together.
- 1:24:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's probably a lower energy approach to train a machine to pay attention to things in the to the sensors, than it is to do that for right?
- 1:24:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is is um I mean it f let's go back to aviation.
- 1:24:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh when we're flying, when you're taking a new through uh BFM, uh you come back and realize that their you know their their situational is this little box, right?
- 1:24:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you got to get them to open up to see uh what actually happens so they can pay attention to going on the next time they're out there.
- 1:24:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that takes a lot of energy to do.
- 1:24:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That takes years, it takes a lot of money.
- 1:25:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We know how to do that.
- 1:25:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We can train a machine how to do that.
- 1:25:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so that's uh I think that's where you're going with this.
- 1:25:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm just using that analogy that when in this is you know, that that education of um of is what we're trying to do by coupling the with the athlete, right?
- 1:25:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't want to do cone drills, we want to put a um a real person out there that they're gonna against or play basketball against or whatever it may be.
- 1:25:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's the same thing with machines.
- 1:25:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We gotta give them the the context, the to to build that uh education or yeah, education of attention up so they can make more sense of changing environment.
- 1:25:38James Giordano: Aaron Powell Exactly right.
- 1:25:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 1:25:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But you're getting that for by the way, I think what's the uh Lieutenant General's name again uh at ASU?
- 1:25:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:25:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean uh you know, we we work with uh network, we've uh had um Rob Gray, who who's right out of ASU on ecological psychology, ecological and constraints led approach.
- 1:25:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that seems to be the center of all this.
- 1:25:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I I see the overlap with what you're saying what they're saying.
- 1:26:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And to me, I I think this is an awesome opportunity to bring all these folks together and go, this is how we build a high performance organization with machines and humans, right?
- 1:26:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And foundationally, and this I'm biased a great way to explain that is the real OODA loop.
- 1:26:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We can we can use that as a foundation to build and go, look, perceptual perception action is inside the OODA loop, it's right here, right?
- 1:26:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's this this pathway there.
- 1:26:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then our skills development is right here.
- 1:26:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, we understand that.
- 1:26:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That means we have to create the conditions in the environment to get what we want.
- 1:26:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So think mission command, intent-based and all that.
- 1:26:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what we're trying to do as leaders is the conditions, set the constraints to skills that implicit guys and control skills up.
- 1:26:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Again, I'm just saying, I'm saying that out If there's any value in the OODA loop, it's bringing these disparate domains together to help how you build a high-performing organization and how you defend against what's going on in the world around us.
- 1:27:06James Giordano: I mean agreed.
- 1:27:06James Giordano: I mean, it it and it it's all it's it's not even I mean, I think it's all contextualizable to whatever or situation you're putting that in.
- 1:27:15James Giordano: So whether it's training individuals, whether it's leadership skills, or whether you're developing what be the dyadic componential aspects of human I mean that they all they all figure well in into this.
- 1:27:28James Giordano: So again, I mean the cheerleader outfit comes back on, I'm doing the John Boyd dance.
- 1:27:33James Giordano: Prescient, not only in terms of what humans are doing in those unique situations of rapid turn and burn, the stick and rudder around in ACM, uh combat but I mean also very prescient to the fact that this sort of represented the next frontier of where cognitive were going with regard to not only what humans are to do and how we're appreciating what the cognitive can offer in terms of human behavior in a variety of occupational and avocational contexts.
- 1:27:59James Giordano: But also the interaction of human and machines way machines are doing their computation to cognitive and what that then infers.
- 1:28:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Aaron Powell Hey, last question.
- 1:28:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I kept you here for a while.
- 1:28:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You brought up leadership.
- 1:28:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm going to ask you this leadership manipulation and cognitive warfare.
- 1:28:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is there a big difference?
- 1:28:17James Giordano: Well I I think one of the goals of cognitive warfare is leadership manipulation through the engagement one of those dimensions, either singularly or in to be able to affect attitudes and values that are going to be important to the cognitions and the leader that are then expressed to those the leader is leading.
- 1:28:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I tell you what, I appreciate your time Definitely want to spend more time with you on lot of this.
- 1:28:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think there's a lot of overlap with the we've had on the show from the ecological aspect, and then of course the active inference Bayesian updating, predictive processing.
- 1:28:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've had uh 180 some episodes uh since we and I don't see us stopping anytime soon.
- 1:28:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And right now we've been exploring cognitive Anything else for our audience?
- 1:29:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Anything else you want to share?
- 1:29:02James Giordano: You know, I I think one of the appreciable points is the cognitive domain is applicable across the range of CPRNE.
- 1:29:09James Giordano: I mean, we talk about cognitive warfare and and perhaps cognitive security, which I think is side of that.
- 1:29:17James Giordano: If we know there's cognitive engagement and influence, what can we do to fortify what our group refers to as four R's, what is going to be the reception, resilience, and response to these types of cognitive And that's cognitive security.
- 1:29:34James Giordano: I mean, that that's a lot of the work, for example, that Matt Cannon is doing with the Cognitive Security But I think what's really important is that this is not just a singular kind of provenance of quote cognitive per se, but these cognitive factors and cognitive are also very operable across chem, bio, rad, even explosive forms of warfare engagement, because they affect and are affected by existing narratives, attitudes towards each and all of these various and the toolkits of waging belligerence.
- 1:30:09James Giordano: So we see the CBRN spectrum as being dynamically with the cognitive spectrum, not only as an aspect of warfare and engagement, and perhaps the psyops along with it, but also with regard to the larger the global narratives that are important to like policy, doctrine, governance on a on a scale is very influential to the conduct of peace and operations worldwide.
- 1:30:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Wow.
- 1:30:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Absolutely fascinating time to be uh alive.
- 1:30:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I know there's so much more we can go into.
- 1:30:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh where where can everybody find your work and and uh what's coming up next for you?
- 1:30:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Any new articles coming up anytime soon?
- 1:30:52James Giordano: Well yeah, we got a lot of things.
- 1:30:53James Giordano: We're churning out a lot of stuff.
- 1:30:54James Giordano: I work with a wonderful research team.
- 1:30:56James Giordano: You know, my thought is research is all about the we and us, it's not about the I.
- 1:31:00James Giordano: And I have the great fortune and wonderful blessing of working with some very, very, very intelligent people.
- 1:31:06James Giordano: You know, we put out uh a weekly informational series Strategic Insights that's coming out of the Institute National Strategic Studies here at National Defense coming out of our group.
- 1:31:16James Giordano: And you know, we're we're trying to publish widely, we try to get our stuff into Small Wars Journal and to other sort of peer-reviewed journals that are to the military and intelligence literature, but also to the scientific literature and the philosophical because I think the the the nature of what it is that doing appeals to those broader audiences writ large.
- 1:31:35James Giordano: And again, if people want to get in touch with me, they can reach me either at james.j.giordano.
- 1:31:39James Giordano: at ndu.edu, or they can reach me at james.giordano at
- 1:31:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Perfect.
- 1:31:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh your name's come up several times in the last few weeks.
- 1:31:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've had uh, let's see, Slif Svitlana uh on from uh Ukraine.
- 1:31:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh she's been doing some work on on uh looking at what you've been writing.
- 1:31:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We had Sara Russo on, and of course we've had uh Oriane Cohen on, and uh her episode will be on soon.
- 1:32:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So your name's been popping up all over the place and appreciate you coming back on.
- 1:32:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'll definitely have you back on soon.
- 1:32:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But for now, hey, thanks again, Doc.
- 1:32:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we'll I'll keep you on here for a moment.
- 1:32:14James Giordano: Yeah, it did it's a privilege and an honor.
- 1:32:15James Giordano: Thanks so much for taking an interest in my work.
- 1:32:17James Giordano: Bye.
- 1:32:18John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 1:32:19John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple, then.
- 1:32:21John R. Boyd: There is no way out.
- 1:32:22John R. Boyd: Unless we can eliminate the feature just cited.
- 1:32:29John R. Boyd: Well, problem though, we don't know how to do this.
- 1:32:32John R. Boyd: There is no way out.