Latest / Automotive State of The Union / CarMax Goes Older, Rivian Reuses, Resale Finds New Buyers
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Wednesday, April 15th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Kyle Mounts here hanging out with Michael Cirillo today. Hello.
- 0:09We're talking about CarMax going older, Rivian reusing, and resale finding some new buyers. Here I go. The people really wanna know who I am- Mm... and who I be. They stop and stare- MC hasn't- They see me, they believe.
- 0:19It's been a while since you and me did a show... don't need to repeat. Run up on me, watch how you leap. That's because P- Paul, Paul watches them after and he's like, "That can never happen again."
- 0:28[laughs] Paul's like, "Ah, don't worry. P- I promise wherever I'm at, uh, you're gonna be there."
- 0:33Paul's actually headed to hang out with some young entrepreneurs, actually high schoolers I think, uh, that are thinking about business in a new way.
- 0:41Our good friend Glenn Lundy, uh, who is, is taking a homeschool group through some, some business stuff.
- 0:47So, uh, we'll, maybe, maybe we'll get a little insight from him over the next couple days e- exactly what's, uh, uh, what's doing that, uh, what's doing with that.
- 0:56We're, we're gonna have to pick his brain and understand how different it is speaking to a room of dealers and then speaking to a room of high school students.
- 1:06I, I'm gonna venture a guess that one's more attentive than the other. [laughs] You just, I'm just gonna leave that there for the people, you know what I mean? [laughs] That's messed up. That's so messed up.
- 1:19No, we love it, we love it, we love it. Uh, we got business to do. Uh, speaking of business to do, there are Pitch Tank at ASOTUCON applications available. You can go to autopitchtank.com. It ends today.
- 1:32We're cutting it off. If you submit it tomorrow, that's cute and everything. We appreciate your submission. I love learning about your company, but we're cutting it off today because we gotta get these people there.
- 1:42Uh, we've got, uh, more than double the applications of what we can actually have at the show. So if, if you applied and, and you're trying to get in, look, we gotta get semifinalists.
- 1:52There'll be nine semi- semifinalists, but, uh, keep the applications coming through the end of today. Go to autopitchtank.com.
- 2:00And if you're not applying or you are a dealer or you're an industry partner, anyone else in between, we still got tickets.
- 2:06There's still just a few hotel rooms at the main hotel, even though there's four or five hotels around.
- 2:12Uh, but you should come to ASOTUCON presented, uh, in part with Reynolds and Reynolds and Gubagoo, and a ton of other partners that are allowing us and helping us put this thing on. You're gonna wanna meet the others.
- 2:23ASOTUCON.com. We're already way pacing ahead of how many people were coming last year, so come find the others, you know? Yeah, like help us break the fire code again on this building. Yes. Oh, that would be fun.
- 2:38[laughs] Oh, my goodness. They'll be like- Hope we don't die... "No, just a couple of two, three people. It's fine." [laughs] "It's fine."
- 2:43Hey, next Wednesday, uh, we've got an ASOTU Edge webinar hanging out with Randy Modos, uh, from PayJunction and Don Andrus talking about stopping leaving money at the register, a dealer's guide to smarter payments.
- 2:55It's smart, practical, easy things that you can do to regain a couple bucks. You can go to asotu.com. Asotu.com, not ASOTUCON, uh, and scroll down just a bit. Register for that webinar.
- 3:07And even if you can't make it, you'll get the, uh, full video recording and you can watch it on demand on your own time. You know? Yeah. Yeah. There you go. Did you see this producer note? Oh, what's this producer note?
- 3:20I think you guys co-host more than MC and Paul do. Interesting. Do we ha- We, we've got a record going? Oh. Is there a tally? We should have a tally. Oh, we should tally that up. All, all I know is that, like,
- 3:32the lower third that has your names is in a higher position than the lower third that has Paul and Michael's names. Yes. [laughs] That's the only thing I'm going off of. [laughs] We need a band name.
- 3:42Like A- MC and K- K- KCM- It's, um, d-... M. [laughs] It's fine. Let's get into it. Let's get into it. Uh, CarMax is leaning into lower price, higher mileage inventory to looser, uh, to le- uh, to...
- 3:57And, uh, looser credits to tackle affordability, meaning they're allowing more, more credit bands, uh, to jump into their, their financing option. Wall Street, however, is not buying it yet despite solid earnings.
- 4:10Shares slid as investors question the cost and timeline of the turnaround. CarMax stock dropped 14% after their earnings call even with results meeting expectations.
- 4:20The company is pausing share buybacks to preserve cash for a turnaround strategy. Uh, the, one of, the biggest strategy here is they are looking at older, higher mileage value vehicles to meet the affordability demand.
- 4:32Now upwards of 35% of their inventory. CFO Enrique Mayormora, uh, said, "This year, we have, uh, absolutely increased our sales of older cars to meet the customer where they wanna be met on affordability." Mm. Mm.
- 4:50I think it's a good thing. Now, look, w- we've been talking so much about affordability. It's nice to see somebody's prioritizing it. Right. Right? Well- Um, I mean, what's your take though? Yeah.
- 4:59Increasing inventory of lower priced, higher mileage value- Well, so-... vehicles...
- 5:03what's, what's interesting here, right, is, and, and I can see why on the earnings call, there's, there's so much profitability in the higher priced vehicles, both from price and the financing side.
- 5:14And, and so much of, of CarMax's bottom line is on the financing side of the business.
- 5:19And when you go lower price and you have a bit more risk due to credit portfolio, you know, shareholders can get question, uh, can kind of question that.
- 5:27But as far as throughput or having a broader market, making your own market, this is a place where honestly I don't see a lot of dealers leaning into, uh, and I don't see Carvana leaning into low price.
- 5:41I, I just went to their site really quick and, and you've got kind of these, like, quick buttons that you can hit. Mm-hmm. Shop all, sell trade, finance, research, SUVs.
- 5:51Then you get 2023 and newer, under 50,000 miles, and then the next one still visible is under 20,000. So it's clear that they've got enough- Uh, under 20,000, under 30,000 vehicles.
- 6:05Um, you know, 16,000 matches out of, let's see, 87,000 vehicles are under 20,000. So I- if I'm a dealer, I'm just, like, trying to match the inventory availability so that I can- Right...
- 6:18meet that lower price customer's requirements. Yep. Makes sense. Makes a whole bunch of sense. Uh, we're gonna keep moving.
- 6:26Rivian is tapping into its own retired EV batteries to power its Illinois plant, partnering with a company called Redwood Materials in a move that cuts energy costs and grid reliance while hinting at a bigger long-term infrastructure play.
- 6:39Once completed, the factory will draw power from 100 plus reused EV batteries in a footprint the size of a small parking lot. The setup will reduce reliance on the power grid, especially during peak demand.
- 6:52It is expected to deliver 10 megawatts, uh, of energy, roughly equal to 1,000 home battery units. Ooh. Pretty wild.
- 7:01Uh, CEO RJ Scaringe said, "There's hopefully a lot more, and there's gonna be a lot of batteries we'll have access to." Uh, we actually have talked to Redwood before.
- 7:11They're a battery recycling company focused on rebuilding installations like this. So we, we got to, I think, Nathan, that was w- out, when we were out in LA, right? Did I say with?
- 7:23I meant, uh, we've talked about them a bunch before- About them... on this show. About them. Yeah, yeah. Yeah.
- 7:27So, uh, yeah, I th- I think this is a cool move by Rivian and, and we've had questions on what are batteries gonna do.
- 7:34Well, a- and we've, y- you know, you, you rewind the tape a year or two years as we really started getting into this EV discussion, and it, the, the question has always been, well, what does this mean for sustainability?
- 7:46We know how much it takes to mine for the minerals that go into EV batteries and how sustainable is that? But it's cool to see, wait, there, there's kind of a double whammy here.
- 7:56There's a sustainability issue, and there's a bolstering the economy, uh, through companies like Redwood that are doing, uh, a sustainability play, recycling batteries. Um, so I, I think it's kinda cool. Yeah.
- 8:08It, it's cool to see where this might go. It, it'll be interesting to track.
- 8:11Well, I think this is, you know, we, we've kind of wondered, like, what's the supplier matrix, what other jobs are EVs and batteries gonna create that we know the fingers of auto go, go, run very, very deep, uh, when it comes to gas and oil and all of the, you know, like, uh, all of the production needs that, that these OEMs have.
- 8:30And so this is just- Right... another way to, like, get, get fingers into other parts of, of industries and, and build new companies around it.
- 8:38Um, and, and recycle these things that, that, you know, everybody had questions. What do we do when they're done in the cars? So... Hmm. Speaking of getting your fingers into other parts of the industry. Hey.
- 8:50Oh, that's the segue. Segway. That's the wrong one. I was so close. I make fun of Paul all the time for the wrong button. I'm so sorry. [laughs] Get after it. Well, well, [laughs] yeah, get after it. Check this one out.
- 9:03The global resale market is surging as affordability pressures push consumers towards secondhand goods, creating a powerful new customer acquisition channel for brands.
- 9:13The global resale market is projected to hit 317 b- b- b- billion by 2027, up from 256 billion in 2025. 84% of resale shoppers use secondhand platforms to discover new brands.
- 9:2858% of shoppers who first buy a brand secondhand go on to purchase new items from that brand. We've got a quote here from, uh, McKinsey's Colin, Colleen Baum.
- 9:39She says, "This is an interesting way for higher price point brands to acquire new customers." I would say so. Interesting. What's your take? I... And h- here's my take, is they could've just asked Otto a while ago.
- 9:51[laughs] Right? I mean, this is, this is, uh, uh, something that, uh, especially with CPOs, a lot of brands have leaned into.
- 10:00And I think that if, i- if you are, uh, you know, considering how to go after, uh, net new, net new cons- consumers or, or get them into your new car brands, prioritizing CPO outreach and, and understanding that that might be an entry point to customer lifetime, uh, lifetime value is, is something that I think we haven't...
- 10:23Like, the OEMs understand this. That's why they created these CPO programs. But a lot of times we just see them as, like, lower priced options or switch units. But, like- Right...
- 10:33h- how do you make an advertising campaign that introduces CPO as a way to get into your dealership's customer life cycle and then promote them into that new car life cycle, which, which typically has a higher level of retention, right?
- 10:49Yeah. I think now more than ever, we need operators, uh, n- not just, uh, I m- just in the world's economy as things are shifting very quickly.
- 10:57We need operators that can see a straight line from point A to point B and go after it.
- 11:01And what I'm hearing you say is, like, there is a definite straight line from CPO to fixed, back to variable, like, to acquisition, back to variable.
- 11:10Y- you know, there's lots of conversations that we're seeing throughout the industry about, you know, how do I acquire off the street, and how do I do this? And I just see the straight line.
- 11:17It's like, well, push CPO, get those things maintained regularly by certified technicians in your store so you have the whole maintenance history.
- 11:26Then at appropriate time in the customer journey, offer to buy that vehicle back 'cause you already know it's gonna be, you know- Yep... maintained well and so on and so forth.
- 11:34There's your acquisition, and then it's back into variable, plus your- Well, and I would say-... loyalty... for those CPO customers, like, treat them like a new car customer. Right. Sales to service handoff.
- 11:45Like, oh, do I give first year free service to my new car customers? I should create a, a, a replicated CPO program because- Yeah...
- 11:53the chances of them coming back to service are much higher than maybe, you know, an off-brand used purchase.
- 11:58So, how do I essentially line up my, my new car process, delivery process, uh, you know, service, s- sales to service handoff, um, retention process.
- 12:09Basically, keep them, keep them very equal because it's, it's clear from these outside brands, these, these companies that are looking, uh, you know, that are, like, clothing brands that are starting to recognize, hey, we need to go after these customers that maybe bought on these secondary platforms, that this is a great way to do so.
- 12:26What you just brought up brings me back to my first car purchase, which was a 1996 Saturn SC2 coupe. Ooh. It was made out of plastic. Yes.
- 12:40Uh, and you know, you know what it, what it brought me back to was when I asked the guy if, if they could, like, wash the car off for me, 'cause it looked like a dust storm had rolled through, and he was like- It's a used car...
- 12:49"You only paid $7,500 for this car." Oh, no. Yeah. And I was like, "Ah..." And you just brought me back to that, because there is the opportunity. And I bet you that is happening more often than we want to admit.
- 13:00But because we are advocates for the dealer body, that what you talked about, Kyle, I wanna just, like, double-click on, because the emphasis there of treating every customer like they're buying new, doing the handoff, r- realizing- Yeah...
- 13:13this guy should've been like, "This cat's buying a Saturn SC2 coupe. He's gonna need a service handoff" [laughs] Right. Yeah. Yes. More than anybody. Exactly. And, and to treat that so.
- 13:22Yeah, don't, don't treat your used cars as, as, as secondary options, because they are your path to, to a n- new car customer flywheel. Acres of diamonds right in front of us.
- 13:32Acres of diamonds, we're giving to you, giving them to you this morning. Check that into your process and see what you can do with it. Also, uh, autopitchtank.com.
- 13:41And hey, if you're not coming to a SoDo Con, what are you even doing?
- 13:47[upbeat music]