Latest / Bloomberg Law / For the First Time Mother of School Gunman Found Guilty
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: We find the defendant guilty of involuntary manslaughter, Guilty of
- 0:14Speaker 2: invo manslaughter, Guilty of involuntary manslaughter, guilty of involuntary manslaughter.
- 0:19Speaker 3: Jennifer Crumbley found guilty of four counts of involuntary manslaughter,
- 0:24Speaker 3: one for each of the students her teenage son murdered
- 0:28Speaker 3: in a shooting rampage at Oxford High School in Michigan
- 0:31Speaker 3: in twenty twenty one, a historic verdict the first parent
- 0:36Speaker 3: in the country ever directly held criminally responsible for a
- 0:40Speaker 3: school shooting carried out by her son. Prosecutors argued Crumbly
- 0:44Speaker 3: was responsible for those deaths because she and her husband
- 0:47Speaker 3: ignored her son, Ethan's mental health struggles and bought him
- 0:51Speaker 3: the handgun used in the shootings, even disregarding school counselor's
- 0:56Speaker 3: concerns about Ethan's behavior. Just hours before the attack, she
- 1:01Speaker 3: walked in high school when just the smallest, smallest of things,
- 1:07Speaker 3: couldn't have stayed, couldn't.
- 1:09Speaker 4: Have helped Hannah and Tate and Madison and Justin.
- 1:14Speaker 3: Crumbly took the stand in her own defense and testified
- 1:17Speaker 3: that she didn't see herself as a failure as a parent.
- 1:21Speaker 4: I trusted him and I felt like I had an
- 1:24Speaker 4: open door and he can come to me about anything.
- 1:28Speaker 2: I mean, I fell as a family where the three
- 1:30Speaker 2: of us were really close. Of course, I looked back
- 1:34Speaker 2: after this all happened, and I've asked myself if I
- 1:38Speaker 2: wrote do anything differently, and I wouldn't have.
- 1:41Speaker 3: That remark was repeated during the jury's deliberations, and after
- 1:46Speaker 3: eleven hours, the jury found Crumbly guilty of involuntary manslaughter
- 1:51Speaker 3: four times for the four deaths. Craig Shilling, who's seventeen
- 1:55Speaker 3: year old son Justin was killed in the shooting, said
- 1:58Speaker 3: Crumbly would not be sitting in prison if she had
- 2:02Speaker 3: done her job as a parent.
- 2:04Speaker 5: And this is your twice to have a child, and
- 2:09Speaker 5: you cannot choose to not take care of your child.
- 2:11Speaker 5: You cannot choose and not nurture your child. You cannot
- 2:13Speaker 5: choose to take your own interests over your child, especially
- 2:19Speaker 5: when it comes to mental health.
- 2:22Speaker 3: Ethan's father, James Crumbly, will also be tried for involuntary
- 2:26Speaker 3: manslaughter at a separate trial this month, and Ethan was
- 2:30Speaker 3: sentenced to life in prison in December after he pleaded
- 2:33Speaker 3: guilty to murder, terrorism and other crimes. Joining me is
- 2:37Speaker 3: Frank van Dervoort, a professor at the University of Michigan
- 2:41Speaker 3: Law School. So the first big question is were you
- 2:44Speaker 3: surprised when the jury came back with the four guilty verdicts.
- 2:49Speaker 1: I would say that I was mildly surprised. This was
- 2:52Speaker 1: a difficult case for the prosecution to make because their
- 2:57Speaker 1: burden was to show beyond a reasonable day out that
- 3:01Speaker 1: there was a direct linkage between missus Crumbly's actions or
- 3:06Speaker 1: her failures to act, and the shooting without having an
- 3:11Speaker 1: intervening occurrence or factor, And in this case, I thought
- 3:16Speaker 1: it would be a very difficult case for the prosecution
- 3:19Speaker 1: to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that standard because of
- 3:23Speaker 1: the intervention of a fifteen year old whom the state
- 3:27Speaker 1: itself tried as an adult and said he was fully
- 3:31Speaker 1: responsible for these acts. And so I am somewhat surprised
- 3:37Speaker 1: that the verdict came back the way that it did.
- 3:40Speaker 3: Tell me how the prosecution built its case, The most
- 3:44Speaker 3: important piece is of it.
- 3:45Speaker 1: Well, what they did is they took the text messages,
- 3:49Speaker 1: you know, the journal entries in the boys, you know,
- 3:52Speaker 1: handwritten journal, and combined that with the fact that a
- 3:57Speaker 1: short time before this, you know, purchased the gun only
- 4:01Speaker 1: days before this incident. And so I think the prosecutor
- 4:05Speaker 1: painted the mother as being someone who is just out
- 4:09Speaker 1: of touch with what was happening with her son, that
- 4:12Speaker 1: he was in this sort of downward mental spiral, and
- 4:16Speaker 1: that she should have been aware of that. And despite that,
- 4:20Speaker 1: the parents went out and purchased this handgun, which they
- 4:23Speaker 1: then stored in a negligent fashion so that he could
- 4:27Speaker 1: get access to it, you know, sort of unrestricted. And
- 4:30Speaker 1: so I think it's that unique set of circumstances that
- 4:34Speaker 1: the prosecution built the case on and focused on.
- 4:38Speaker 3: Yes, And one of the things that prosecutor Mark Keist
- 4:41Speaker 3: focused on during an hour long cross examination of Crumbly
- 4:45Speaker 3: were some texts from her son just months before the
- 4:49Speaker 3: shooting where he said he was seeing demons throwing bowls
- 4:53Speaker 3: and asking her to text him back. Let's listen to that.
- 4:56Speaker 6: Well, your son texted you that he was seeing dem
- 5:01Speaker 6: in bulls flying off the shelves. That was in the
- 5:05Speaker 6: spring of two. When you recall it evidence right, correct,
- 5:09Speaker 6: You don't dispute that that was on your thoughts. No,
- 5:12Speaker 6: you don't dispute that at some point you read those messages.
- 5:16Speaker 3: No, I believe it was at his sentencing that Ethan
- 5:20Speaker 3: said that his parents were not responsible for what he did.
- 5:24Speaker 3: And the defense wanted to call him to the stand,
- 5:27Speaker 3: but they weren't allowed to.
- 5:28Speaker 1: Yes, so he didn't testify because he still has a
- 5:32Speaker 1: fitth Amendment right. His case will certainly go on appeal.
- 5:36Speaker 1: Even though he pled guilty. There's going to be an
- 5:38Speaker 1: appeal in which they make arguments that certain of the evidence,
- 5:42Speaker 1: perhaps even that some of the charges should not have
- 5:45Speaker 1: been brought or were barred. And so that's why he
- 5:48Speaker 1: didn't testify.
- 5:50Speaker 3: For the defense was the brunt of its case. Jennifer
- 5:54Speaker 3: Crumbly's testimony.
- 5:56Speaker 1: My impression was is that she was trying to show
- 5:59Speaker 1: that there were were many areas where the prosecution hadn't
- 6:03Speaker 1: met its burden, that there were a number of reasons
- 6:06Speaker 1: that the jurors might have said not guilty in this case.
- 6:09Speaker 1: And so you know, that was a strategy that they pick.
- 6:13Speaker 1: You know, one second guess that strategy. But their approach
- 6:17Speaker 1: was to say, there are lots of reasons here, ladies
- 6:19Speaker 1: and gentlemen of the juries that you could find that
- 6:23Speaker 1: she's not guilty and you should find that. So that
- 6:26Speaker 1: I think was their approach.
- 6:27Speaker 3: When a defendant takes the stand, that often becomes the
- 6:31Speaker 3: focus for the jury her credibility. And here's what the
- 6:35Speaker 3: jury for person said about Crumbley's testimony on the Today
- 6:40Speaker 3: Show this morning.
- 6:41Speaker 2: At the time, I tried to take her as she
- 6:44Speaker 2: gave herself, but once we went into deliberation, it became
- 6:49Speaker 2: clear that she wasn't a super reliable witness in this case.
- 6:55Speaker 1: I think in this case, the mother had to testify.
- 6:57Speaker 1: I think that, you know, from a practical standpoint, you know,
- 7:01Speaker 1: the jury needed to hear from her. You know, she
- 7:03Speaker 1: didn't come off as the most sympathetic person apparently, but again,
- 7:08Speaker 1: you know, what should take place in a trial and
- 7:11Speaker 1: what the court will instruct the jury is to you know,
- 7:14Speaker 1: you've got to set aside your emotions. You've got to
- 7:16Speaker 1: set aside that sort of thinking and really focus on
- 7:19Speaker 1: the facts of the case and focus on the evidence
- 7:22Speaker 1: that was presented. So it is what it is. They
- 7:25Speaker 1: look at her, they judge her credibility, They you know,
- 7:28Speaker 1: decide whether they think she's genuine and telling the truth
- 7:31Speaker 1: or if she's in some way trying to mislead and
- 7:33Speaker 1: then they make their decisions.
- 7:35Speaker 3: So one thing she said that struck me. I don't
- 7:38Speaker 3: think I'm a failure as a parent, and she wouldn't
- 7:41Speaker 3: have done anything differently. And apparently that last statement was
- 7:45Speaker 3: something that the jurors kept coming back to as they deliberated.
- 7:51Speaker 1: Yeah. Right, And if a person's in that circumstance, you know,
- 7:55Speaker 1: how do you not second guess yourself? Right? How do
- 7:57Speaker 1: you not go back and say, you know what, would
- 7:59Speaker 1: I then different? Would I've pulled the trigger lock out
- 8:02Speaker 1: of that plastic bag or whatever, you know, packaging and
- 8:05Speaker 1: put it on the gun? Would I have taken steps
- 8:08Speaker 1: to secure that gun in a way that my son
- 8:11Speaker 1: couldn't get a hold of it. I think anybody would
- 8:14Speaker 1: do that, right, So, you know, that's the risk you
- 8:16Speaker 1: take when you testify in your own behalf. On the
- 8:18Speaker 1: one hand, the jury's got to hear from her, I think.
- 8:21Speaker 1: On the other hand, it's a huge risk, and you
- 8:24Speaker 1: can say something that either you know, just may it
- 8:27Speaker 1: be well presented, or it may be presented in a
- 8:29Speaker 1: way that makes you look cold and uncaring for a
- 8:32Speaker 1: person who has been through what she's been through to
- 8:35Speaker 1: not say, yeah, I really did make mistakes. There are
- 8:39Speaker 1: things that I could have and should have done, and
- 8:42Speaker 1: if I had it all to do over again, I
- 8:43Speaker 1: would do differently. We would hope for that sort of insight, right.
- 8:47Speaker 3: A lot focused on the foreseeability of Ethan's actions, and
- 8:52Speaker 3: her attorney said, how could anybody imagine that something like
- 8:57Speaker 3: this would happen, that their son would do something like that.
- 9:00Speaker 3: But the jury had to find that it was foreseeable
- 9:04Speaker 3: in order to come to its verdict.
- 9:06Speaker 1: So the jury had to find beyond a reasonable doubt
- 9:08Speaker 1: that there was a direct line from the mother's either
- 9:11Speaker 1: actions or omissions, and in action a direct line from
- 9:15Speaker 1: that to the shooting. There was a lot of focus
- 9:18Speaker 1: on foreseeability. But when the Court of appeals, the Michigan
- 9:22Speaker 1: Court of Appeals decided the earlier version of this case,
- 9:25Speaker 1: when it went up before the trial to the appellate court,
- 9:29Speaker 1: they talked a lot about what layers call proximate cause.
- 9:33Speaker 1: And so the fact that you have a fifteen year
- 9:36Speaker 1: old that inner beans in this that breaks that direct
- 9:39Speaker 1: line from her act or omission to the shootings. I
- 9:44Speaker 1: was surprised that was not more of a focus, and
- 9:47Speaker 1: there was so much focus on the sort of source
- 9:49Speaker 1: of the ability rather than this direct connection, and the
- 9:52Speaker 1: judge instructor she talked about that in her instruction, they
- 9:55Speaker 1: have to show directly that there's this linkage, and cipated
- 10:00Speaker 1: there would be more focus on that. By the defense,
- 10:03Speaker 1: I expected to see more focus on Ethan as an
- 10:08Speaker 1: independent actor, and one wonders whether that might have changed
- 10:13Speaker 1: the outcome.
- 10:14Speaker 3: So the jury four person did say that she was
- 10:17Speaker 3: swayed by the fact that Jennifer Crumbley was the last
- 10:21Speaker 3: person to handle the gun that was then used by
- 10:24Speaker 3: Ethan in the shooting.
- 10:26Speaker 2: And I think the responsibility of securing the weapon ben
- 10:30Speaker 2: falls on.
- 10:30Speaker 3: Her, So perhaps they saw it as Crumbly being the
- 10:35Speaker 3: one that could break the chain of events, but she
- 10:39Speaker 3: failed to do that.
- 10:40Speaker 1: So it's certainly one element of it. Right, you had
- 10:43Speaker 1: the last opportunity to prevent this. But if I were
- 10:47Speaker 1: the defense lawyer, I would say fair enough. But still
- 10:51Speaker 1: you have a fifteen year old boy who certainly without
- 10:55Speaker 1: the affirmative permission of his parent, took that gun out
- 10:58Speaker 1: of the house, hit it in the back pack, took
- 11:00Speaker 1: it to school, hit it from school. Officials then went
- 11:04Speaker 1: into the bathroom, changed clothing, you know, put a mask
- 11:08Speaker 1: on and that sort of stuff, put his hood up,
- 11:10Speaker 1: and then walk through the hallway shooting people. I would
- 11:13Speaker 1: expected to see the defense really focus much more on
- 11:16Speaker 1: his action and say, yeah, even if it's true that
- 11:20Speaker 1: she failed to secure the gone, this is an independent
- 11:24Speaker 1: intervening factor that breaks that causal connection between what she
- 11:28Speaker 1: did or didn't do in the murders.
- 11:30Speaker 3: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show, we'll talk
- 11:33Speaker 3: about what Crumby is facing its sentencing and her husband's
- 11:37Speaker 3: upcoming trial on the same charges. I'm June Grosso and
- 11:41Speaker 3: you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 11:43Speaker 4: Can every parent really be responsible for everything your children do,
- 11:48Speaker 4: especially when it's not foreseeable and this clearly was not
- 11:52Speaker 4: foreseeable to Missus Crumbley.
- 11:54Speaker 3: Jennifer Crumbley's attorney, Shannon Smith, told jurors that convicting her
- 11:58Speaker 3: client would say a dangerous precedent for parents and that
- 12:03Speaker 3: no one could have foreseen the school shooting. But prosecutors
- 12:07Speaker 3: argued that Crumbly was responsible for her teenage son's shooting
- 12:11Speaker 3: rampage at Oxford High School in twenty twenty one that
- 12:15Speaker 3: left four fellow students dead. Prosecutors said she and her
- 12:19Speaker 3: husband had ignored her son Ethan's mental health struggles, bought
- 12:23Speaker 3: him the handgun used in the shootings and failed to
- 12:25Speaker 3: secure it, and prosecutor Marquis Cross examined Crumbley about her
- 12:30Speaker 3: son's troubling texts and journal entries.
- 12:34Speaker 6: You don't deny that your son wrote in his journal
- 12:38Speaker 6: that he asked his parents for help. You don't deny
- 12:41Speaker 6: that evidence, episode No, I don't.
- 12:43Speaker 3: After eleven hours of deliberations, the jury found Jennifer Crumbly
- 12:48Speaker 3: guilty of four counts of involuntary manslaughter. I've been talking
- 12:53Speaker 3: to Professor Frank Van Dervoort of the University of Michigan
- 12:56Speaker 3: Law School. So Crumbly and the defense try to point
- 13:01Speaker 3: in other directions, especially at the father, basically saying it's
- 13:06Speaker 3: not my fault, it's really his fault. Yeah, he bought
- 13:09Speaker 3: the gun, he didn't secure the gun. Obviously that didn't work.
- 13:13Speaker 1: You know, it may have worked been a better approach,
- 13:17Speaker 1: I think had they been tried together. But by separating
- 13:20Speaker 1: the trial, it just looks like she's trying to deny
- 13:23Speaker 1: any responsibility rather than say, as a matter of law,
- 13:27Speaker 1: forget the facts. As a matter of law, you've got
- 13:30Speaker 1: an intervening factor here that really broke that causal link
- 13:33Speaker 1: between her her failure to secure the gun and you know,
- 13:37Speaker 1: the child taking it to school that day and shooting
- 13:40Speaker 1: its classmates. It just strikes me as a line of
- 13:43Speaker 1: defense that maybe could have been rethought.
- 13:47Speaker 3: So then you think she has several issues on appeal
- 13:51Speaker 3: to raise.
- 13:52Speaker 1: I think so I anticipate there's going to be an appeal,
- 13:55Speaker 1: and I think that there will be some issues raised
- 13:58Speaker 1: that are going to be, you know, in significant issues.
- 14:03Speaker 3: Now the husband's trials, we mentioned his trial is coming up.
- 14:07Speaker 3: Do you think that in light of this verdict, he
- 14:10Speaker 3: may try to, you know, go for a plea deal.
- 14:14Speaker 1: That's always a possibility for sure. They may be looking
- 14:17Speaker 1: to try to resolve the case, you know, short of
- 14:20Speaker 1: a finding of four counts of involuntary manslaughter. You know,
- 14:24Speaker 1: maybe they'll ask for one or something. Interesting question whether
- 14:27Speaker 1: the prosecutor would you know, the prosecutor's probably feeling confident
- 14:31Speaker 1: now that they can get another conviction on all four
- 14:34Speaker 1: and may not offer that as an opportunity.
- 14:37Speaker 3: Especially since he is the one who actually purchased the gun.
- 14:40Speaker 1: Right So you know, there are some factors for him
- 14:43Speaker 1: that are at least as troublesome as things that the
- 14:46Speaker 1: mother did or didn't do. He did purchase the gun,
- 14:48Speaker 1: I mean, he knew the gun was there, and you know,
- 14:50Speaker 1: I think a couple of the things in his favor
- 14:52Speaker 1: that she had the kind of almost callous, certainly unthinking
- 14:56Speaker 1: response when the school contacted the parents about him looking
- 15:00Speaker 1: at the bullets. I think it was on the internet
- 15:02Speaker 1: and she said, you know, haha or whatever, they just
- 15:05Speaker 1: don't get caught. In hindsight, that seems incredibly callous, right,
- 15:10Speaker 1: you know, in the moment, maybe not so much so.
- 15:13Speaker 1: I think there are some things that she had, you know,
- 15:15Speaker 1: working against her, that maybe the father doesn't have working
- 15:19Speaker 1: against him. They will, no doubt they. You know, mother's
- 15:23Speaker 1: already been convicted, and she was the last one with
- 15:25Speaker 1: her hands on that Country's the last adult who had
- 15:28Speaker 1: the opportunity to prevent this, and she didn't do it.
- 15:31Speaker 3: Legal experts are talking about this case as a precedent.
- 15:35Speaker 3: Do you see this as providing sort of a template
- 15:38Speaker 3: for prosecutors to go after other parents if their children
- 15:43Speaker 3: are connected to criminal acts like shootings.
- 15:46Speaker 1: You know, I don't anticipate this is going to have
- 15:48Speaker 1: a lot of in on prosecutor's decisions. I think the
- 15:52Speaker 1: facts of this case are so you know, sort of
- 15:55Speaker 1: out of the ordinary, are so unusual. I just don't
- 15:58Speaker 1: think you're going to see a flood of cases like that.
- 16:02Speaker 1: As a legal matter, parents have always been held civilly
- 16:06Speaker 1: liable for some aspects of their children's behavior, you know,
- 16:09Speaker 1: for many, many years, and criminally there have always been
- 16:14Speaker 1: some responsibility on the part of parents in relation to
- 16:17Speaker 1: their children. What's unusual about this case is the severity
- 16:21Speaker 1: of the charges on one area. You see this sometimes
- 16:24Speaker 1: as school truancy. We went through a period of time
- 16:26Speaker 1: a few years ago where a number of parents around
- 16:29Speaker 1: the country were charged because their older children were not
- 16:32Speaker 1: getting to school or their younger children were not getting
- 16:34Speaker 1: to school right, So parents were charged criminally with not
- 16:38Speaker 1: getting their kids to school. That was the thing for
- 16:40Speaker 1: a while. So what's unusual about this is not so
- 16:43Speaker 1: much the legal doctrine as it is, you know, just
- 16:46Speaker 1: the severity of the charges. But again, the unique set
- 16:49Speaker 1: of facts in the circumstance I think is not going
- 16:52Speaker 1: to open the floodgates for those kinds of more serious charges.
- 16:56Speaker 1: I think culturally it may have more impact than you
- 16:59Speaker 1: know as as a legal precedent, because I think a
- 17:02Speaker 1: lot of parents are going to look at this and say, yeah,
- 17:05Speaker 1: you know, make sure that the guns are secured, make
- 17:07Speaker 1: sure that we know what's happening with our children, our teenagers.
- 17:11Speaker 1: And you know, that gets harder and harder for parents.
- 17:13Speaker 1: You know, the Internet and the dark Web and violent
- 17:16Speaker 1: video games and all of the rest of it. You know,
- 17:18Speaker 1: adolescents have always had secrets from their parents, right, They've
- 17:22Speaker 1: always had these kind of separate lives from their parents.
- 17:25Speaker 1: And part of what's happened in our culture is that
- 17:28Speaker 1: some of that separate life has gotten more serious, more
- 17:31Speaker 1: dangerous potentially, And so I think the message to parents is,
- 17:37Speaker 1: you know, you've got to really redouble your efforts to
- 17:40Speaker 1: know what's going on with your children, be aware of
- 17:42Speaker 1: what's happening in their lives, and to take precautions to
- 17:47Speaker 1: make sure that they don't get access to guns and
- 17:50Speaker 1: that sort of thing.
- 17:51Speaker 3: Some legal experts say that they worry that the case
- 17:55Speaker 3: will be a way for prosecutors to force plea deals
- 17:59Speaker 3: from parents, and that might cause more racial disparities in
- 18:03Speaker 3: the criminal justice system.
- 18:05Speaker 1: Again, I don't I don't see that happening so much.
- 18:08Speaker 1: I don't anticipate that there are going to be a
- 18:11Speaker 1: lot of these cases file. My guess is that only
- 18:14Speaker 1: if you have these the rarest of circumstances, where you know,
- 18:18Speaker 1: in this case, sort of the planets aligned, if you will. Right,
- 18:22Speaker 1: the kid was having serious emotional problems. The parents didn't
- 18:26Speaker 1: recognize that, didn't respond to that. But you know, there's
- 18:30Speaker 1: the salacious aspect of this where she was involved in
- 18:34Speaker 1: an affair, and that was talked about in this trial.
- 18:37Speaker 1: So you know, the prosecutor could really paint a picture
- 18:41Speaker 1: of a parent who's disengaged, who's who's not aware of
- 18:45Speaker 1: what's going on, and then purchases the gun, takes his
- 18:50Speaker 1: kid to the shooting range, and then doesn't adequately secure
- 18:53Speaker 1: that gun and protect the public from what might become
- 18:56Speaker 1: of that gun. One of the things that's interesting to
- 18:59Speaker 1: me about this is miss in the wake of this case,
- 19:01Speaker 1: has now passed a law that you know, you have
- 19:03Speaker 1: to have safe storage of weapons, which a number of
- 19:06Speaker 1: states have. So I'm not sure today if this were
- 19:10Speaker 1: to happen again in Michigan, you'd see this level of
- 19:12Speaker 1: severity of charge. You might see something much more like,
- 19:16Speaker 1: you know, a failure to properly store a gun charge
- 19:19Speaker 1: that I could see happening, right. We've seen that in
- 19:22Speaker 1: Michigan before we go back twenty years, you may recall
- 19:25Speaker 1: in Flint, Michigan, about twenty years ago, there was a
- 19:29Speaker 1: parent who had a handgun in a shoe box underneath
- 19:32Speaker 1: a bed, and a kid got hold of that gun
- 19:35Speaker 1: in six year old and took it to school and
- 19:37Speaker 1: shot a classmate in Flint. You know, so it's not
- 19:40Speaker 1: unprecedented that a parent would be charged, you know, in
- 19:44Speaker 1: similar kinds of circumstances. In that case, it was child neglect.
- 19:49Speaker 1: I believe worked for the charges that were brought, which
- 19:52Speaker 1: had lesser penalties than involuntary manslaughter charges. So I could
- 19:58Speaker 1: see prosecutors charging those kinds of crimes, right, And that
- 20:03Speaker 1: has happened I think at a time, or we saw
- 20:06Speaker 1: that in Virginia recently. I think it was Virginia where
- 20:09Speaker 1: the little kid took the gun to school and shot
- 20:12Speaker 1: the teacher. And you saw in Illinois there was a
- 20:15Speaker 1: case the fourth of July shooting down there where a
- 20:18Speaker 1: parent was charged because they assisted their child in getting
- 20:23Speaker 1: a gun, but again not charged with homicide related offenses.
- 20:26Speaker 1: But that's their offense. I could see that happening.
- 20:29Speaker 3: How much of this verdict was about the prosecution doing
- 20:33Speaker 3: a better job than the defense, having better theories and
- 20:37Speaker 3: strategies than the defense, you know, with all the resources
- 20:41Speaker 3: that the prosecution has.
- 20:44Speaker 1: I mean certainly, you know, it's almost always the case
- 20:47Speaker 1: that the state has many more resources than the defendant
- 20:50Speaker 1: in any case. I mean, that's almost universally the situation. Right.
- 20:55Speaker 1: The rarity is where there's a level playing field in
- 20:58Speaker 1: that regard, right, I mean, you know, you think about O. J. Simpson,
- 21:01Speaker 1: you think about you know, Michael Jackson, you think about
- 21:04Speaker 1: Donald Trump. Right, they have a sort of level playing
- 21:07Speaker 1: field because they have access to the normous amounts of
- 21:10Speaker 1: money and resources. But in the average case, I mean,
- 21:13Speaker 1: there's no difference. I don't know what speaks to that
- 21:16Speaker 1: beyond I think this school officials. There is certainly some
- 21:20Speaker 1: perhaps some failures on the part of the school officials, right,
- 21:23Speaker 1: And there's some frustration that governmental immunity protects the school
- 21:28Speaker 1: system and some of those officials. And you know, so
- 21:30Speaker 1: I think there is some in the community, there is
- 21:33Speaker 1: some frustration about that the schools not being helpfully responsible
- 21:38Speaker 1: you know, in situations like this, it's not at all unusual.
- 21:41Speaker 1: You know, just as the parents in this case might do,
- 21:44Speaker 1: and as she tried to do on the witness stand
- 21:46Speaker 1: point the finger and the other, you know, in another
- 21:49Speaker 1: direction to say, you know, it's not really my fault,
- 21:52Speaker 1: it's someone else's fault, or at least we share the
- 21:55Speaker 1: blank to reduce the culpability. So I'm not surprised by that.
- 22:00Speaker 3: Can the parents of the fourteenagers go after the school civilly?
- 22:05Speaker 1: There are governmental immunity issues that have to be overcome.
- 22:09Speaker 1: So it's the ratchets up the level of evidence that's
- 22:12Speaker 1: necessary for the hold the school financially responsible and civilly liable.
- 22:19Speaker 3: She faces. It's eleven years on each count. Do you
- 22:23Speaker 3: think the judge will run those concurrently?
- 22:25Speaker 1: Well, I think the statutory maximum is fifteen years for
- 22:28Speaker 1: this case, and I anticipate, yes, that they would run concurrently.
- 22:32Speaker 1: I don't know of anything in this case that suggests
- 22:34Speaker 1: that they should be consecutive sentences.
- 22:37Speaker 3: Jennifer Crumbley will be sentenced on April ninth. Her husband
- 22:41Speaker 3: will go on trial this month. Thanks so much for
- 22:43Speaker 3: joining me on the show. That's Professor Frank van Dervoort
- 22:46Speaker 3: of the University of Michigan Law School. A note. Michael Bloomberg,
- 22:50Speaker 3: the founder and majority owner of Bloomberg LP, the parent
- 22:54Speaker 3: company of Bloomberg Radio, is a donor to groups that
- 22:57Speaker 3: support gun control, including Every Town for Gun Safety. Coming
- 23:02Speaker 3: up next on the Bloomberg Lawn Show, The stage is
- 23:04Speaker 3: set for Dartmouth basketball players to unionize and become the
- 23:09Speaker 3: first ever labor union for NC DOUBLEA athletes. This is Bloomberg.
- 23:16Speaker 3: The stage is set for Dartmouth basketball players to unionize,
- 23:21Speaker 3: although it's a long road ahead, perhaps years before they
- 23:24Speaker 3: become the first ever labor union for NC DOUBLEA athletes.
- 23:29Speaker 3: On Monday, a National Labor Relations Board regional official ruled
- 23:33Speaker 3: that the basketball players are employees of the school, clearing
- 23:36Speaker 3: the way for an election. All fifteen members of the
- 23:39Speaker 3: Dartmouth men's basketball team signed a petition in September asking
- 23:44Speaker 3: to join Local five sixty of the Service Employees International Union.
- 23:49Speaker 3: Dartmouth says it will appeal the NLRB's decision. Joining me
- 23:53Speaker 3: is Alberts Solar, a partner at Skerensky Hollenbeck. How would
- 23:57Speaker 3: unionizing change the lives of of the Dartmouth basketball players.
- 24:02Speaker 7: So, you know, it's an interesting concept and this is
- 24:05Speaker 7: a fight that's been going on for many, many years.
- 24:08Speaker 7: And so what happens is that if you unionize, and
- 24:12Speaker 7: if these student athletes are deeded the employees, then what
- 24:15Speaker 7: happens is, I think it's collectively bargain and negotiate different things,
- 24:20Speaker 7: for example, the compensation of any the treatment by the coaches,
- 24:24Speaker 7: the travel schedule, how many hours they can practice. That's
- 24:27Speaker 7: the course of their deemed employees. Like any other employees,
- 24:30Speaker 7: who unionize, they'll have the power and they'll have the
- 24:33Speaker 7: ability to actually negotiate better terms for how they conduct
- 24:36Speaker 7: the quote work, in this case, the participation in the athletics,
- 24:39Speaker 7: so they have more control over their daily participation in life.
- 24:43Speaker 3: These players are not being paid, are they. I mean,
- 24:46Speaker 3: they're not getting any kind of compensation from Dartmouth at
- 24:49Speaker 3: this point.
- 24:51Speaker 7: Yes, So this goes back. Let me give a little
- 24:53Speaker 7: bit of background on that because it's a really good
- 24:55Speaker 7: and important question. So the idea of amateurism, the idea
- 24:58Speaker 7: of the NC DOUBLEA and the nateur athlete was really
- 25:01Speaker 7: a made up concept. It was a definition that was
- 25:03Speaker 7: really created when the ANCUBA was founded to really hold
- 25:08Speaker 7: student athletes to a non employee status, so that schools
- 25:12Speaker 7: then wouldn't have to pay compensation as a normal employee
- 25:15Speaker 7: would get paid. You go to work, you get your paychecks. Hear.
- 25:18Speaker 7: What they were trying to do is NCAA wanted to
- 25:20Speaker 7: control over what they called student athletes under a concept
- 25:24Speaker 7: of amateurism, which was really a made of terms. So
- 25:28Speaker 7: traditionally throughout history, student athletes have not been paid money
- 25:32Speaker 7: for their services. But the idea here was that the
- 25:36Speaker 7: universities and the educational institutions were providing in education. Now,
- 25:41Speaker 7: for the schools that offer scholarships athletic scholarships, then the
- 25:46Speaker 7: compensation really is the fact that you are receiving a
- 25:50Speaker 7: quote free education in exchange for your participation in sports. Now,
- 25:55Speaker 7: the Ivy League schools including Dartmouth actually don't offer athletic scholarships.
- 26:00Speaker 7: Reality is that the students athletes at the Iday schools
- 26:03Speaker 7: are receiving nothing more than the right to just participate
- 26:07Speaker 7: in the sports. Obviously, we can't minimize the educational aspect.
- 26:11Speaker 7: It's very important. These schools are a lot of them
- 26:13Speaker 7: are great. They're very renowned institutions, and I think that
- 26:16Speaker 7: the student athletes receive a great education. However, the problem
- 26:20Speaker 7: is that there are many schools that derive enormous amount
- 26:24Speaker 7: of revenue and money and notoriety, millions and millions of
- 26:29Speaker 7: dollars tens of millions of dollars a year from their
- 26:31Speaker 7: athletic programs, and so the problem there is that they
- 26:36Speaker 7: are benefiting really off the backs of the student athletes
- 26:39Speaker 7: who many times, to your question, don't get paid anything.
- 26:42Speaker 7: And there have been, you know, important documentaries highlighting the
- 26:46Speaker 7: fact that a lot of these athletes many times don't
- 26:49Speaker 7: even have the money to live their lives day to
- 26:52Speaker 7: day or week to week. And it reminds me of
- 26:55Speaker 7: a couple of documentaries I saw where some football players
- 26:58Speaker 7: from prominent schools had to ask for coach for money
- 27:01Speaker 7: for food. So it raises a very interesting question. But
- 27:05Speaker 7: the short answer to your question is that, no, they're
- 27:07Speaker 7: not being paid to quote play the sport. But for
- 27:11Speaker 7: the schools that offer the athletic scholarships, the ideas that
- 27:15Speaker 7: you're receiving the education in exchange for participation.
- 27:18Speaker 3: But Dartmouth is not one of those schools. And Dartmouth
- 27:21Speaker 3: even said during this four day hearing that the men's
- 27:25Speaker 3: basketball program loses money. So if the men's basketball players
- 27:29Speaker 3: are considered employees, then because of the education they're getting,
- 27:33Speaker 3: then what about the students who play in the school
- 27:36Speaker 3: band or other organizations? Are they employees too?
- 27:40Speaker 7: That's a great point, June. That's exactly what the slippery
- 27:42Speaker 7: slope here is. I personally don't believe that they're employees.
- 27:46Speaker 7: That's my personal view because if that's the case, and
- 27:50Speaker 7: in the case of the Dartmouth basketball team, you had
- 27:53Speaker 7: the school noting that they lose money, Well, if that's
- 27:55Speaker 7: the case, then if they're deemed employees, I don't know
- 27:59Speaker 7: what business would ex this that loses money. So the
- 28:01Speaker 7: result of that is going to be that Dartmouth ends
- 28:04Speaker 7: the basketball program, which they may not care about doing, because, frankly,
- 28:09Speaker 7: the idea of these schools are not sports powerhouses. It's
- 28:11Speaker 7: not like saying in Ohio State a USC where they
- 28:15Speaker 7: drive hundreds of millions of dollars from the football from
- 28:17Speaker 7: the basketball team, and so it's a very unique situation.
- 28:21Speaker 7: I think making all student athletes or deeming them employees,
- 28:25Speaker 7: I think it's dangerous because, as you noted, each sport
- 28:28Speaker 7: is different and each school is different, so there are
- 28:32Speaker 7: many student athletes that will go, for example, to an
- 28:34Speaker 7: Ohio State to play football because the Ohio State USC
- 28:39Speaker 7: the UCLAs of the world. They are football powerhouses, for example.
- 28:43Speaker 7: So a lot of the student athletes actually go, not
- 28:46Speaker 7: necessarily for the education, although it's a benefit, of course,
- 28:50Speaker 7: but they do want to go to the pros. They
- 28:51Speaker 7: do want to make it to the NFL. So if
- 28:54Speaker 7: you think about it, your point is spot on. What
- 28:57Speaker 7: this creates is a huge issue for a slippery slope
- 29:02Speaker 7: of where do we draw the line. One of the
- 29:04Speaker 7: articles I read makes a very important point. For example,
- 29:08Speaker 7: if I am a student athlete at Dartmouth or any
- 29:10Speaker 7: of the university and not student athlete, but I'm in
- 29:14Speaker 7: the music program, well, the music program will have concerts.
- 29:17Speaker 7: Those concerts might be paid, so Patriots might pay a
- 29:20Speaker 7: ticket to go hear me play. Well, if I'm a
- 29:23Speaker 7: student and I'm in the music program and the school's
- 29:25Speaker 7: making money off of it, do I unionize? Do I
- 29:28Speaker 7: have to then be myself an employee? Do I have
- 29:31Speaker 7: to get paid? So I think it's a slippery slope
- 29:33Speaker 7: because it is important to remember that universities are primarily
- 29:38Speaker 7: educational institutions and the sports traditionally, we're a form of
- 29:43Speaker 7: marketing to allow the schools to earn more prestige. And obviously,
- 29:47Speaker 7: the programs that win in sports are national headlines and
- 29:51Speaker 7: the brand of the school increases tremendously. But I don't
- 29:55Speaker 7: know necessarily that that makes any of the student athlete's employees.
- 30:00Speaker 7: The articles I read actually use the word well hear
- 30:03Speaker 7: they're participating in sport were compensation, And I'm not sure
- 30:07Speaker 7: what they meant by compensation unless they're referring to the
- 30:10Speaker 7: schools that do offer athletic scholarships, Because as far as
- 30:14Speaker 7: I'm aware of concern, student athletes are not being paid
- 30:18Speaker 7: to play the sports. So I'm not sure where they
- 30:21Speaker 7: get that notion from. But your point is well paid
- 30:24Speaker 7: and it's correct. I mean, does that mean that the
- 30:26Speaker 7: music students get paid? Does that mean that the swim
- 30:29Speaker 7: students get paid? Jude, Many of these programs don't earn
- 30:32Speaker 7: any money, and even at the more athletically recognize schools,
- 30:37Speaker 7: you know, the Ohio States against schools like that. Maybe
- 30:40Speaker 7: swim doesn't. The swim program doesn't generate any money. Whatever.
- 30:44Speaker 7: Other teams that aren't football, that aren't baseball, they aren't basketball.
- 30:48Speaker 7: Maybe they generate nothing.
- 30:49Speaker 3: Here's what the NLRV Regional director Laura Sachs wrote, quote
- 30:54Speaker 3: because Dartmouth has the right to control the work performed
- 30:57Speaker 3: by the Dartmouth men's basketball team, and the players perform
- 31:01Speaker 3: that work in exchange for compensation. I thought that the
- 31:05Speaker 3: petition for basketball players are employees within the meaning of
- 31:10Speaker 3: the National Labor Relations Act, and I know that the
- 31:14Speaker 3: players say what matters is not whether the sport turned
- 31:19Speaker 3: to profit or whether the team turned to profit. What
- 31:21Speaker 3: matters is if the program brings in revenue, and also
- 31:25Speaker 3: whether coaches have control over the players. I find this
- 31:29Speaker 3: problematic as well, because you could say that professors have
- 31:32Speaker 3: control over their.
- 31:33Speaker 7: Students, exactly the point I was going to make, So
- 31:36Speaker 7: I don't agree with that. First of all, her quotes
- 31:39Speaker 7: a little bit bizarre because, as I noted, I'm not
- 31:41Speaker 7: aware of the student athletes receiving compensation unless you're talking
- 31:45Speaker 7: about the name, image and likeness part, which I'll touch
- 31:48Speaker 7: on in a second. But the idea here is I
- 31:51Speaker 7: don't agree because I don't understand what compensation they're receiving,
- 31:54Speaker 7: and also, the athletes don't have to play the sport.
- 31:57Speaker 7: They're not being required to participate in the football program,
- 32:00Speaker 7: for example, or the basketball program. They are enrolled as students.
- 32:05Speaker 7: So for example, if the teacher and the instructor of
- 32:08Speaker 7: professor says to you, the student, you have to show
- 32:11Speaker 7: up to my class three days a week, and you
- 32:13Speaker 7: have a midterm on this date, and you have to
- 32:15Speaker 7: go to office hours on this date, well, they are
- 32:18Speaker 7: technically controlling the curriculum, and they are controlling the manner
- 32:22Speaker 7: in which the students need to fulfill their academic obligations.
- 32:26Speaker 7: Does that make the students employees? I don't believe so.
- 32:28Speaker 7: I don't think it does at all. And again with
- 32:30Speaker 7: respected students and or the student athletes, they're not receiving compensations,
- 32:36Speaker 7: so I'm not sure where the labor board gets that idea.
- 32:39Speaker 7: Do I think that they should have to be treated fairly, Absolutely,
- 32:43Speaker 7: I think everybody student athletes should be treated fairly at
- 32:47Speaker 7: a university. I'm just not seeing where the compensation comes in.
- 32:51Speaker 7: And to your point of very slippery slopes. Because the
- 32:55Speaker 7: teachers and professors are technically controlling the conduct of the students,
- 33:00Speaker 7: are they employees? I don't believe they are.
- 33:02Speaker 3: Is this the first IVY League school where this has
- 33:05Speaker 3: happened or is it the first school period?
- 33:07Speaker 7: There was another I believe Ivy League school that did
- 33:10Speaker 7: this before, but the proceedings were actually paused, and then
- 33:14Speaker 7: this is the first one that I'm aware of where
- 33:16Speaker 7: they actually had a ruling and now they're going to
- 33:18Speaker 7: go back and continue the other proceedings. But again, remember
- 33:22Speaker 7: that this is for private institutions, which raises the whole
- 33:26Speaker 7: other issue of how do as a public university deal
- 33:28Speaker 7: with this. But I think that the general challenge to
- 33:32Speaker 7: the NCAA and this idea of amateurism and whether it's
- 33:35Speaker 7: their employees and whether they can receive compensation and unionize.
- 33:39Speaker 7: This has been going on for a long long time. However,
- 33:41Speaker 7: this Dartmouth case is the first time where you had
- 33:44Speaker 7: a regional labor board actually come down and rule and
- 33:47Speaker 7: make a decision. And I think it'll be appealed because
- 33:50Speaker 7: it's too significant. It's a monumental type of decision that
- 33:55Speaker 7: I don't think was well thought out because of all
- 33:59Speaker 7: the issues that you when I have touched on where
- 34:01Speaker 7: it opens up a floodgate of different issues. Not every
- 34:05Speaker 7: school is situated the same not every student athlete wants
- 34:07Speaker 7: the same thing, Not every student athlete is out for
- 34:10Speaker 7: the same goal. Some want an education. But I do
- 34:13Speaker 7: want to just touch on one thing that I think
- 34:15Speaker 7: is relevant here is that I want to make sure
- 34:18Speaker 7: that folks don't confuse this issue with the name, image
- 34:20Speaker 7: and likeness issue, because they are related. If you remember
- 34:23Speaker 7: back in the day the universities, and this changed recently
- 34:27Speaker 7: and now the student athletes have an ability to actually
- 34:29Speaker 7: benefit and profit from their name and image. But back
- 34:32Speaker 7: in the day you would have football players and basketball
- 34:36Speaker 7: players appearing on video games sponsorships, the school would show
- 34:39Speaker 7: their image and be paid a lot of money by
- 34:41Speaker 7: national brands by advertising and content. So there it's a
- 34:44Speaker 7: totally separate topic, but it is tangentially related in that
- 34:48Speaker 7: no one has a right to exploit somebody's name, image, likeness,
- 34:53Speaker 7: and their skills to their own benefit without compensating the students.
- 34:57Speaker 7: So the idea that you can unionize and be found
- 35:01Speaker 7: to be an employee, I think does go hand in
- 35:04Speaker 7: hand with this attempt to rectify this problem. Where I'm
- 35:08Speaker 7: a student athlete, I'm very very highly regarded. The whole
- 35:12Speaker 7: nation knows my football skills and they have my name,
- 35:14Speaker 7: my image, my likeness everywhere, and I don't profit from that,
- 35:17Speaker 7: but the schools sure do. I mean, you can imagine
- 35:20Speaker 7: the amount of money these prominent athletic programs have. They
- 35:24Speaker 7: need to share that, they need to give stipens to
- 35:26Speaker 7: the students. They need to make sure that the student
- 35:29Speaker 7: athletes can actually be going day to day, pay for
- 35:32Speaker 7: their food, pay for their housing. Again, not all schools
- 35:34Speaker 7: offer athletic scholarships, so for the ones that don't to
- 35:38Speaker 7: kind of take their name, image and likeness, not compensate them,
- 35:41Speaker 7: and also not even give them a stipen. I think
- 35:44Speaker 7: that's where the notion of unfair treatment arises, which send
- 35:48Speaker 7: leads to these ideas of unionizing. I think if schools
- 35:51Speaker 7: did the right thing and treated people fairly. I'm not
- 35:53Speaker 7: saying all of them, but the ones that are taking
- 35:55Speaker 7: a little bit of advantage from the student athletes, I
- 35:57Speaker 7: think this wouldn't be that much of an issue.
- 36:00Speaker 3: More of these legal battles ahead. Thanks so much, Albert.
- 36:02Speaker 3: That's Albert Solar, a partner at Scurrency Hollandbeck. And that's
- 36:06Speaker 3: it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember
- 36:09Speaker 3: you can always get the latest legal news by subscribing
- 36:12Speaker 3: and listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and
- 36:15Speaker 3: at Bloomberg dot com slash podcast, slash Law. I'm June
- 36:19Speaker 3: Grosso and this is Bloomberg