Latest / Epic Fury: The US-Iran War Podcast / Iran War Day 43: US–Iran Talks Begin, Hormuz Crisis Deepens and Ghalibaf’s Warning
Transcript
- 0:16Galabaf brought the school bags when Iran's parliament speaker
- 0:20boarded the flight to Islamabad on Saturday morning.
- 0:23He carried blood stained school bags and photographs of the
- 0:26children killed in the US strike on the Men of Girls Elementary
- 0:29School on the first day of this war.
- 0:31He placed them on the plane in full view of the cameras.
- 0:35Iranian state media filmed them and broadcast the images.
- 0:39The photographs of small faces from Minnab, a port city in
- 0:43Hormesgan province, were carried into Islamabad, secured
- 0:46diplomatic zone alongside the technical briefings, the
- 0:49sanctions documents and the nuclear position papers.
- 0:53It was not a gesture of grief. It was a negotiating position, a
- 0:57moral opening bid and a message to Vance and Witkopf and Kushner
- 1:00before the first word was exchanged.
- 1:03This is what we brought with us. This is what we represent.
- 1:07This is what we are asking you to reckon with.
- 1:10Iran's 71 person delegation arrived in Islamabad carrying
- 1:14the visible evidence of what 43 days of this war cost Iranian
- 1:17civilians. It is Saturday, April 11th,
- 1:212026, day 43 of Operation Epic Fury.
- 1:25Today is the day the Islamabad talks have begun.
- 1:29JD Vance, Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff are in the same
- 1:33building as a boss. Arachi and Muhammad Bagger
- 1:35Galabaf, Pakistan's Prime Minister, has called this a make
- 1:39or break moment. And the highest level diplomatic
- 1:42contact between the United States and Iran since the 1979
- 1:45Islamic Revolution is underway. Not face to face, not yet, but
- 1:50in two separate rooms with Pakistani officials shuttling
- 1:53between them. This is episode 43 of Epic Fury,
- 1:57the US Iran War podcast. Follow on Spotify and Apple
- 2:01Podcast to stay with this story as it develops.
- 2:05Let's get into it. The format of the talks is what
- 2:08diplomats call proximity talks. The two delegations, the
- 2:11American team led by Vance, Witkoff and Kushner, and the
- 2:15Iranian team led by Galabaf and Arachi, are in the same hotel.
- 2:20The Serena Hotel in Islamabad secured diplomatic quarter.
- 2:23They are not in the same room. They are not looking at each
- 2:27other across a table. They each have a separate
- 2:30meeting space. Pakistani officials, Prime
- 2:33Minister Sharif, Foreign Minister IS Shakhtar and Field
- 2:37Marshall Asim Munir physically carry messages between the two
- 2:40delegations, translate positions and manage the negotiating
- 2:44dynamic from middle. Vance met Sharif in a bilateral
- 2:48session on Saturday morning. Before talks formally began.
- 2:52The Iranian delegation met Sharif and other senior
- 2:54Pakistani officials separately. Both sets of bilateral meetings
- 2:58were held before the proximity talks commenced, a standard
- 3:02diplomatic sequence designed to let each side brief the mediator
- 3:05on its initial positions before messages begin flowing between
- 3:09rooms. Pakistan has direct experience
- 3:12with exactly this format. In 1988, Islamabad hosted the
- 3:16Geneva Accord negotiations on the Soviet withdrawal from
- 3:20Afghanistan, in which UN mediated indirect talks between
- 3:23Pakistan and Afghanistan produced a landmark agreement.
- 3:27The proximity format is not a sign of weakness or failure, it
- 3:31is the standard diplomatic mechanism for negotiations where
- 3:34the parties have deep enough mistrust that even sitting in
- 3:37the same room is itself a contested question.
- 3:40AUS official and a regional source told CNN that the two
- 3:43sides are expected to agree on an agenda for the talks through
- 3:46Pakistani mediators first and then move to face to face
- 3:50discussions later in the day. Whether that face to face
- 3:53session materializes will itself be a significant development.
- 3:57Arachi arrived in Islamabad in the early hours of Saturday,
- 4:00stepping off his plane and walking a red carpet flanked by
- 4:04an Iranian flag, smiling, receiving a bouquet of flowers
- 4:07from Pakistani officials. Images published separately on
- 4:11his Telegram account showed him standing on the delegation plane
- 4:14next to the school bags and photographs of the men of
- 4:16children 168 killed on the first day of the war when AUS strike
- 4:20hit a girl's elementary school in Iran's Hormuzgan province.
- 4:24The school bags were carried on the Iranian flight as a
- 4:27deliberate political statement. They are the artifacts of the
- 4:30war's opening civilian atrocity, the moment that crystallized for
- 4:34Iranian public opinion that this conflict was not a precision
- 4:37military campaign against the regime's weapons programs, but a
- 4:41war that reached into Iranian classrooms.
- 4:43The juxtaposition of those two images, the smiling diplomat on
- 4:47a red carpet and the blood stained bags from the children
- 4:50of minib, captured the full tonal complexity of what the
- 4:53Islamabad talks represent for Iran.
- 4:55A country that was bombed for 40 days, that lost more than 2000
- 4:59of its people, that lost its supreme leader in the opening
- 5:02strike, that watched its universities and petrochemical
- 5:05plants and airports burn, is also a country that has chosen
- 5:08diplomacy over continued warfare and is sending its senior
- 5:11officials to negotiate under the conditions of a ceasefire.
- 5:14It's simultaneously describes as a victory.
- 5:17Arachi in those images is both a man presenting evidence of
- 5:20atrocity and a man walking confidently toward a negotiating
- 5:24table. Both things are simultaneously
- 5:27and authentically true about where Iran stands today.
- 5:30Galabath landed at Nurkhan Air Base outside Islamabad with the
- 5:34rest of the Iranian delegation, 71 people in total, according to
- 5:38Iranian state media Tasneem. The delegation includes not only
- 5:42the main negotiators but also, in Tasneem's words, technical
- 5:46and expert committees for necessary consultations.
- 5:50That delegation, size 71, dwarfs what any previous Iranian
- 5:54negotiating team has brought to a diplomatic encounter with the
- 5:57United States. For comparison, Iran's
- 6:00delegation to the original JCPOA negotiations in Vienna numbered
- 6:04far fewer. The scale of Saturday's
- 6:07delegation is a statement of intent and a statement of
- 6:10preparation. It signals that Tehran is
- 6:12treating these talks as a serious, comprehensive
- 6:15diplomatic effort rather than a preliminary exchange.
- 6:18Iran has sent nuclear technical experts, economic officials to
- 6:22address the sanctions question, security advisors to address the
- 6:25military dimensions, and political officials from
- 6:28multiple branches of the state, including the parliament.
- 6:31The breadth of that delegation is Iran saying we are ready to
- 6:34negotiate everything on our terms and we have the people
- 6:37here to do it. It is also, from a practical
- 6:40standpoint, a significant advantage over the American
- 6:43side. The Trump administration has
- 6:45sent three people, Vance, Witkoff, and Kushner, whose
- 6:49combined nuclear technical expertise is at best untested.
- 6:53Whether that technical gap matters on the first day, when
- 6:56the agenda itself is the question being negotiated is one
- 7:00thing. Whether it matters in subsequent
- 7:02sessions, when the specifics of enrichment levels, centrifuge
- 7:05numbers, and IEA access protocols are on the table is
- 7:09another. Munir receive Vance in a suit.
- 7:12He received the Iranian delegation in combat fatigues.
- 7:16That detail, reported by multiple outlets and widely
- 7:19noted in diplomatic analysis, is not incidental.
- 7:23It is a deliberate signal from Pakistan's army chief about how
- 7:27he perceives his role in this process and about what each side
- 7:30needs from him to the Americans. Munir presents as a statesman
- 7:34and diplomat in the civilian attire of a peace broker, a man
- 7:37who speaks their language of institutional partnership,
- 7:40bilateral cooperation and long term regional stability, the
- 7:44suit says. I am a responsible actor, a
- 7:47reliable partner, a man you can trust to deliver a deal to the
- 7:51Iranians. He presents as a military peer
- 7:53in uniform, acknowledging that Iran's military establishment is
- 7:57present in Islamabad process through Galabaf and the IRGC
- 8:00shadow presence, and that Pakistan's military understands
- 8:04and respects that register. The combat fatigues say.
- 8:07I recognize your authority, your chain of command, and the
- 8:10military dimensions of what you are being asked to agree to.
- 8:14You and I speak the same language.
- 8:17It is a sophisticated piece of physical diplomacy by a man who
- 8:20has been the single most important back channel actor in
- 8:23this entire ceasefire process. The person who kept
- 8:25communication alive between Washington and Tehran in the
- 8:28final hours before the Tuesday deadline, who ran the two phase
- 8:31ceasefire proposal past Vance and Arachi simultaneously, and
- 8:35who ultimately brokered the pause.
- 8:37The choice of clothing? Is Munir communicating without
- 8:40words that he understands both rooms he is standing between.
- 8:45Pakistan's goal for Saturday is explicitly modest.
- 8:48Officials have described the aim as realistic to get the United
- 8:52States and Iranian negotiators to find enough common ground to
- 8:55continue talking. Not a deal on Lebanon, not a
- 8:59framework on the nuclear question, Not a Hormuz
- 9:03operational protocol, Just enough agreement on an agenda
- 9:07and a process to justify saying the talks are continuing.
- 9:11That is the floor, not the ceiling.
- 9:14Pakistan has set a modest goal because it is the only honest
- 9:18goal available. Former ambassador Masood Khalid
- 9:21described the atmosphere as poisoned before the talks even
- 9:24began. And the school bags on the
- 9:26Iranian delegation plane are a vivid illustration of why the
- 9:30atmosphere is poisoned. The mistrust is real, the gaps
- 9:34are wide, and yet both delegations are in the same
- 9:37hotel and Pakistani officials are walking between their rooms.
- 9:42That is more than existed 6 days ago, when the war was still at
- 9:45maximum intensity and Trump was threatening a whole
- 9:48civilization's death. Reaching even that modest floor
- 9:51requires managing the Lebanon dispute, the hormones closure,
- 9:54the competing narratives of victory and defeat, and the
- 9:57specific toxic legacy of Witkoff and Kushner's pre war
- 10:01negotiations with Arachi and Muscat in Geneva, which ended
- 10:04with bombs rather than a deal. Vance warned Iran on Friday as
- 10:08he departed Washington not to try to play the United States
- 10:11during the negotiations. He said the US team is looking
- 10:15forward to the negotiations and that if the Iranians are willing
- 10:18to negotiate in good faith, the United States is willing to
- 10:21extend an open hand. That phrasing, open hand
- 10:24extended but do not play us, captures the American posture
- 10:28precisely. It is simultaneously an
- 10:30invitation and a threat, which is also approximately the
- 10:34posture the Trump administration has maintained toward Iran
- 10:37throughout this conflict. Trump issued his own commentary
- 10:41on Saturday. He said the Iranians do not seem
- 10:44to realize they have no carts. He said the Strait of Hormuz
- 10:47will be reopened with or without Iran.
- 10:50He said his main goal is to ensure that Iran does not
- 10:53develop a nuclear weapon. The claim that Iran has no cards
- 10:57is worth interrogating because it is not a negotiating
- 11:00position. It is a negotiating error.
- 11:03Iran demonstrably has cards. It has the Strait of Hormuz,
- 11:07which remains partly closed and which the United States has not
- 11:10been able to reopen by force despite 43 days of intensive
- 11:14military operations. It has the ability to continue
- 11:17strikes against Gulf state infrastructure if the ceasefire
- 11:20breaks down, threatening energy markets that are already in
- 11:23structural disruption. It has the political fact that
- 11:26any final agreement must survive domestic Iranian scrutiny,
- 11:30meaning that the IRGC and Common A must validate whatever Iraqi
- 11:34signs. And it has, as Iran expert Trita
- 11:37Parsi noted, the change terrain of a conflict in which Trump's
- 11:41failed use of force has blunted the credibility of American
- 11:44military threats. Iran's cards are not military.
- 11:48They are diplomatic, economic and political.
- 11:52The claim that they have no cards is the kind of statement
- 11:54that plays well at home and badly in a negotiating room,
- 11:58because the Iranian delegation in the Serena Hotel knows
- 12:00exactly what its leverage is. Those three statements set the
- 12:04outer boundary of what Washington is publicly
- 12:07presenting as the negotiating parameters.
- 12:09That is a maximalist American opening position that, if
- 12:13maintained without flexibility, leaves no room for the creative
- 12:16ambiguity that a deal would require.
- 12:19Iran's stated red lines for the talks include Iranian control of
- 12:22the Strait of Hormuz and a ceasefire in Lebanon, precisely
- 12:26the two conditions the United States has not agreed to.
- 12:29A senior US official denied reports that Washington had
- 12:32agreed to release frozen Iranian assets held in Qatar and foreign
- 12:36banks to ensure Hormuz reopening.
- 12:38Those assets, estimated at 10s of billions of dollars, are one
- 12:42of Iran's core negotiating demands.
- 12:45The denial confirms that the US has not made any financial
- 12:48concession going into the talks. Arachi, arriving in Islamabad,
- 12:53demanded that the US accept preconditions before talks
- 12:56start, a position the White House immediately rejected.
- 12:59The gap between demanding preconditions and refusing
- 13:02preconditions is the opening gap of the first negotiating day.
- 13:06Pakistan's job is to find language that lets both sides
- 13:10say they got what they needed to begin talking at all.
- 13:13This is a function Pakistan has performed before, in 1988 during
- 13:17the Soviet Afghan negotiations and in multiple rounds of quiet
- 13:21back channel diplomacy in the decade since.
- 13:24The Serena Hotels proximity talk format with Munir physically
- 13:28walking between rooms is the operational expression of that
- 13:31function. Whether Pakistan's institutional
- 13:34experience with this kind of mediation is sufficient for
- 13:37negotiations of this complexity and political sensitivity
- 13:40involving AUS vice president, an Iranian parliament speaker, a
- 13:44nuclear dossier, A Hormuz dispute and a Lebanon fault line
- 13:48is the open question of Saturday.
- 13:50But if any country outside the two parties is suited to this
- 13:53task, Pakistan's claim to that role rests on this week.
- 13:57The Strait of Hormuz remains partly closed.
- 14:00Iran's semi official news reported that the straight faces
- 14:03sinking. Risk for mines lay during the
- 14:05war, making reopening technically complicated.
- 14:08Beyond the political dispute, whether that is a genuine
- 14:11technical limitation or a diplomatic excuse is contested.
- 14:15What is not contested is that the oil market, which priced in
- 14:18a 13% drop on Tuesday night, is watching Saturday's talks very
- 14:22closely. If the talks produce a concrete
- 14:25Hormuz protocol, oil prices will fall further.
- 14:29If they produce only a vague commitment to continue talks,
- 14:32prices will partially recovered toward pre ceasefire levels.
- 14:36The legal complexity of who was actually authorized to make
- 14:38commitments on behalf of Iran is not resolved by the delegations
- 14:42presence in Islamabad. Gallibaf is parliament speaker,
- 14:46a former IRGC commander and a political figure with
- 14:49significant power within the conservative establishment, but
- 14:53he does not have the authority to commit the IRGC to a course
- 14:56of action. Arachi is foreign minister with
- 14:59diplomatic authority, but the IRGC has repeatedly acted
- 15:03outside the civilian government's preferences
- 15:05throughout this war. Continuing drone strikes against
- 15:08Gulf states after the ceasefire was announced.
- 15:11Halting Hormuz traffic in response to Lebanon without
- 15:14coordination with the foreign ministry's public statements.
- 15:17The real authority in this process sits with common A1 must
- 15:20validate any agreement that comes out of Islamabad.
- 15:23Khamenei approved the ceasefire statement through the Supreme
- 15:27National Security Council. Whether he has also authorized
- 15:30Arachi and Galabaf to make substantive concessions on the
- 15:33nuclear question, on sanctions and on the military presence
- 15:37question is something that the delegations in Islamabad know
- 15:40and that the outside world is not.
- 15:42The fact that Galabaf, not posseshkian, not a civilian
- 15:46official of the executive branch, is leading the
- 15:48delegation is itself a signal that Common A has ensured the
- 15:51IRGC political wing has direct oversight of whatever is
- 15:55negotiated. Whether that is a sign that
- 15:57Common A has authorized real concessions under IRGC
- 16:00supervision, or a sign that the IRGC is present to ensure no
- 16:04real concessions are made, is the ambiguity that will define
- 16:08whether Saturday produces progress or stalemate.
- 16:11The question of whether anything agreed in the Serena Hotel has
- 16:14genuine institutional backing from the IRGC, from Common A,
- 16:18from the entire Iranian state, is a question that will
- 16:21determine whether any Saturday agreement means anything by
- 16:24Monday. Outside the hotel, the world
- 16:27that depends on the outcome of these talks is not standing
- 16:30still. The Strait of Hormuz remains
- 16:32partly closed. Oil markets are volatile.
- 16:35The 13% price drop on Tuesday night has been partially eroded
- 16:39by subsequent days of ambiguity about whether the Strait is
- 16:42actually reopening. Gulf states Saudi Arabia, the
- 16:45UAE, Kuwait, Qatar and Bahrain continue to face the risk of
- 16:49continued Iranian strikes if the ceasefire breaks down.
- 16:53Lebanon civilian population is absorbing ongoing Israeli
- 16:56strikes that have killed at least 10 more people this week,
- 16:59including emergency workers and conditions that the UN has
- 17:03called horrific. Iran's 93 million people are
- 17:06living without reliable Internet, with disrupted power,
- 17:09with empty government ATM networks and with the
- 17:12accumulated trauma of 43 days of the heaviest bombing their
- 17:15country has experienced since the Iran Iraq war.
- 17:18The global shipping industry is waiting for a Hormuz protocol.
- 17:22Energy markets are pricing and outcomes they cannot yet see,
- 17:26and developing countries across Asia and Africa, whose food
- 17:29security, fertilizer supply chains and remittance economies
- 17:32are all tied to the Gulf in one way or another, are watching
- 17:35Islamabad the way they watch weather systems that determine
- 17:38whether the harvest comes in for all of those constituencies.
- 17:41The modest goal that Pakistan has set just keep the talks
- 17:45going, is not modest at all. It is the necessary precondition
- 17:49for everything that follows. A world that is watching the
- 17:52Serena Hotel on Saturday morning is not watching for a historic
- 17:56announcement. It is watching for the signal
- 17:58that these two parties can remain in the same building,
- 18:01communicate through intermediaries and agree enough
- 18:03to meet again. That signal, if it comes, will
- 18:07be worth more than any communique.
- 18:09There is a further historical dimension to what is happening
- 18:12in Islamabad today. Vance's visit to Pakistan is the
- 18:15first by a sitting US vice president in 15 years.
- 18:19The last was Biden in January 2011. the US has no confirmed
- 18:24ambassador to Pakistan. The ambassadorial post has been
- 18:27vacant since early 2025. The Islamabad talks represent
- 18:32one of the first instances of direct high level engagement
- 18:35between the United States and Iran since the 1979 Islamic
- 18:38Revolution, a 47 year diplomatic rupture that has persisted
- 18:42through hostage crises, proxy wars, nuclear negotiations, and
- 18:46now an open military conflict. Whatever happens in those two
- 18:50rooms at the Serena Hotel, the fact that Vance is in the same
- 18:53building as Arachi and Galabaf is historically without modern
- 18:57precedent. A vice president visiting a
- 18:59country where the US has no ambassador to lead nuclear and
- 19:02ceasefire negotiations with a country the US has been at war
- 19:05with for 43 days is a measure of how extraordinary this moment
- 19:09is. It is also a measure of how much
- 19:11of the institutional architecture of American
- 19:13diplomacy has been hollowed out or sidelined in ways that
- 19:16complicate the complex, sustained, expert, intensive
- 19:20work that a durable Iran deal requires.
- 19:23Trump set a Vance on Friday before he boarded his flight to
- 19:26Islamabad. I wish him luck.
- 19:28He's got a big thing. It was a rare moment of
- 19:31presidential understatement, that understatement.
- 19:34He has got a big thing, maybe the most accurate thing anyone
- 19:37has said publicly about the Islamabad talks.
- 19:40In those two rooms at the Serena Hotel, the next chapter of the
- 19:44most economically disruptive military conflict of the 21st
- 19:48century is being determined. The Hormones protocol that will
- 19:51dictate whether oil markets recover or remain volatile.
- 19:55The nuclear framework, if any, That will determine whether Iran
- 19:58rebuilds its enrichment capacity the moment the ceasefire ends.
- 20:02The Lebanon arrangement, if any. That will determine whether
- 20:05Hezbollah continues to absorb Israeli strikes throughout the
- 20:09ceasefire window and whether Iran uses that as justification
- 20:12to walk out. And somewhere in the subtext of
- 20:15all of those negotiating threads, the deeper question of
- 20:18whether the United States and Iran can find a political
- 20:21foundation stable enough to prevent the next war.
- 20:24Pakistan is carrying the messages between those two
- 20:27rooms. The world is watching.
- 20:30If this podcast is helping you make sense of what is happening,
- 20:33please take 30 seconds to leave a review on Spotify or Apple
- 20:36Podcasts. It makes an enormous difference
- 20:39to how many people find the shell.
- 20:41This has been episode 43 of Epic Fury, the US Iran war podcast,
- 20:46Your daily briefing on this conflict Day 43.
- 20:50The Islamabad talks are underway.
- 20:53Galabaf brought the school backs.
- 20:55Munir wore combat fatigues for one side and a suit for the
- 20:59other. The straight is still partly
- 21:01closed. Trump says Iran has no cards.
- 21:05Arachi demanded preconditions and Pakistan is carrying
- 21:09messages between 2:00 rooms in the Serena Hotel that contain
- 21:12the people who may or may not be about to end this war.
- 21:16We will be back very soon.