Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E028: State-Led Legislative Innovation with Joel Revill
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that the last
- 0:03trade is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:14management platform built on multi institution custody.
- 0:17We serve high net worth individuals, institutional
- 0:20investors and financial intermediaries with the best in
- 0:23class suite of products which include multi institution
- 0:26custody, a spot Bitcoin fund, Onram Wealth for Rias and
- 0:32private wealth services for high net worth individuals.
- 0:35Leveraging our partnership with Bit Go and other industry
- 0:38leaders, Onram's Multi Institution Custody is a first
- 0:41of its kind institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:46institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:50unique permissions have been met.
- 0:52Our multi institution vaults utilize cold storage, key
- 0:55signing and authentication at the direction of the client to
- 0:59maximize security for client assets.
- 1:02This pioneering approach to custody is the foundation of On
- 1:05Ramp's financial products which reduce counterparty risk
- 1:09associated with trusting a single institution.
- 1:12To learn more about how On Ramp can help you secure a new or
- 1:16existing Bitcoin position, please visit our website at on
- 1:19rampbitcoin.com, where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:23connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:28music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:31the biggest bag of odorous excrement ever assembled in the
- 1:36history of Doctors 1974? 1987. 92972000 and whatever we
- 1:44want to call this, it's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:47We can't help ourselves, I say, when we.
- 1:50Sell, hey, I say when we sell. Gentlemen, welcome back.
- 1:58Short week recorded six days ago.
- 2:02Had Thanksgiving. How was everybody?
- 2:04Thanksgiving. Good holiday season.
- 2:07It's great. I was up in the Northeast, so
- 2:09it's always nice being from Texas to get out of Texas
- 2:11climate to like actually feel a season or a holiday.
- 2:14So it was nice. It was like cool, 30-30 degrees,
- 2:18so it was very, very fun. Yeah, it was a great, great
- 2:23Thanksgiving. A little bit slow getting back
- 2:25into it, but you know, going to make the most of this month
- 2:29before Christmas now. Jesse had a Texas Thanksgiving.
- 2:33Is that your first Texas Thanksgiving?
- 2:36Good question. I suppose so.
- 2:41Well, yeah, first one since moving back at least.
- 2:43And yeah, I had my folks here and you know, had to do a bit
- 2:46more hosting than than I had anticipated I guess.
- 2:51But that's that's the holidays for you.
- 2:53And then you got to get back in the works wing.
- 2:56Jesse, Marty and I were chatting about we all have to get
- 2:58together and then maybe we just open a bottle of wine and have a
- 3:01live recording when we're all back in Texas together and
- 3:04figure out the our our 4th guest, Maybe they join us and
- 3:07just do a live recording session.
- 3:10Hey, you had me move down here, Michael, and then you're never
- 3:13here. You're always in the Northeast.
- 3:15Don't put that on me. I I would there would be.
- 3:18I would I would like nothing more than to be in Texas but you
- 3:20know. When when you're you have in
- 3:23laws and on the holidays, you got to figure out where to, to
- 3:25make everybody happy. So yeah, I'll be back soon
- 3:27though. Yeah, it was a brisk
- 3:29Thanksgiving down here in Texas. Nice, relaxed one for me.
- 3:32The family came to us. I was in bed by 9:30 Wednesday
- 3:37through Sunday. It was a great, relaxing
- 3:39Thanksgiving break. But alas, it's good to see that
- 3:44everybody had a Thanksgiving. We're joined by Joel Revel, CEO
- 3:47of Two Oceans Trust. And a pivotal member of the
- 3:52blockchain Select Committee in Wyoming, which has created more
- 3:55than 30 ground breaking laws around regulatory structure of
- 4:01crypto assets. Wyoming is probably one of the
- 4:04most forward thinking states when it comes to Bitcoin and
- 4:09digital asset regulation. We're very excited to have you
- 4:12on the show today. Joel, thank you for joining us.
- 4:15Thanks. Great to be with you guys.
- 4:18I think just jump off. To learn a little bit more about
- 4:22you, your career before you ended up at 2 Oceans and working
- 4:28with the state of Wyoming to push forward these laws.
- 4:31What? What were you doing before you
- 4:33got into this weird, weird world of of Bitcoin and digital
- 4:37assets? And what gave you the confidence
- 4:40to sort of jump in and put your reputation behind this asset
- 4:44class? Yeah.
- 4:47Thanks. Well, I grew up in Wyoming, so
- 4:48I'm back back home in my home state, but I spent my first 25
- 4:55years of my career elsewhere. I started in the investment
- 4:59banking group at JP Morgan, transitioned a few years later
- 5:04to investment management, where I spent the bulk of my career.
- 5:08Most recently, I was a portfolio manager at Citadel and returned
- 5:14back to Wyoming. In 2017 to I guess probably for
- 5:20personal reasons and then also to launch to Ocean Trust based
- 5:26here in Wyoming and it was during that time that I I was
- 5:33pulled into the digital assets and it was really I would credit
- 5:38the state of Wyoming for that the first foray into.
- 5:46Wyoming's efforts was through the the Blockchain Select
- 5:49Committee, which I was appointed to by Wyoming Governor Gordon
- 5:55and have served on that committee for the past past four
- 5:58years and then as part of. Wyoming's forward lean into
- 6:07digital assets to Ocean Trust has received a novel no action
- 6:14relief from the Wyoming Division of Banking, allowing us to
- 6:17extend our qualified custody status from traditional assets
- 6:21to to digital assets under state and federal law.
- 6:25So we've been sort of pulled into the the world of crypto
- 6:29through both the public sector and private sector.
- 6:33Yeah. And I think Wyoming's a very
- 6:36fascinating case because in Bitcoin, we talk a lot about
- 6:39jurisdictional arbitrage. And when that topic's brought
- 6:42up, it's typically under the context of international
- 6:46jurisdictional arbitrage. But it's become abundantly
- 6:48clear, particularly over the last three years, that there's
- 6:52Interstate jurisdictional arbitrage within the United
- 6:55States alone. And you have two ends of the
- 6:59spectrum. You have New York.
- 7:01And particularly the NYDFS putting out the bit license I
- 7:06believe in 20/14/2015 and it seems like Wyoming saw what New
- 7:12York did and said, hey, we think there's a better way to do this,
- 7:16a more free market driven way to do this.
- 7:18And so I guess that whether it was a direct response to what
- 7:24New York did or the recognition that?
- 7:27Regulation is needed to give people more clarity what what
- 7:31sort of the driving factors of Wyoming putting their heads to
- 7:36the their nose, the grindstone and really thinking about
- 7:39creating a regulatory environment that is friendly
- 7:43towards bitcoiners and people looking to spin up Bitcoin
- 7:46businesses. Yeah, I think there was, there
- 7:50was elements of both of those factors that you mentioned.
- 7:52And then additionally there's a couple of other factors,
- 7:57something that a lot of folks don't know about Wyoming is that
- 7:59it, it's it's been a leader in a lot of areas.
- 8:04I mean, going back in history, Wyoming was the first state to
- 8:07allow women to vote and that was done several years in advance of
- 8:11of federal legislation around that.
- 8:14Wyoming created the first LLC, it's a little known fact.
- 8:19And again years before other states such as Delaware adopted
- 8:22the the idea of an LLC. So.
- 8:25So Wyoming tends to be on the forefront of a lot of a lot of
- 8:28issues, and a lot of these issues come from a desire to
- 8:37create opportunities for people to build businesses.
- 8:41Create economic opportunities in a with a sort of libertarian
- 8:44slant to it which I think kind of leads to the to the second
- 8:49factor which is that I think Wyoming saw an opportunity here
- 8:54for an asset class that that the the benefits are very obvious
- 9:01the reasons for the federal government to.
- 9:06Sort of squash innovation or at least push it offshore are
- 9:12obvious and somewhat frustrating.
- 9:13And so Wyoming saw an opportunity to to step in under
- 9:18the right of a state to do so and and begin to provide some
- 9:21legal and regulatory clarity. Joel, that's really fascinating.
- 9:26I didn't realize that you grew up in Wyoming.
- 9:28Do you think that helped in your predisposition and like
- 9:30understanding Bitcoin, or from like a libertarian perspective?
- 9:34Because it it's I was starting to jog my memory thinking of
- 9:36like at least in Texas growing up here seeing Texas be a leader
- 9:40along with Wyoming in in my mind it makes complete sense because
- 9:43this is just basically based on the roots of like you kind of
- 9:46the the knowledge and the the culture that has always been
- 9:50that I've known. And so I'm curious, like, did
- 9:52that make complete sense when you move back?
- 9:54It's like, of course Wyoming would embrace this technology
- 9:57because they've done everything else since I've I've lived here.
- 10:01Yeah, it does. You know, I can't, I don't know
- 10:02if that if that kind of personally has driven me towards
- 10:06the the adoption of this of this new asset class, but I think it
- 10:10definitely makes sense for Wyoming if you understand
- 10:13Wyoming's history and and what Wyoming has done sometimes.
- 10:21Where there's a void or a vacuum, Wyoming will step in.
- 10:24Sometimes it will be in direct response to something that
- 10:28Wyoming disagrees with. That's being done elsewhere at A
- 10:31at a federal level. So it does, it does make a lot
- 10:34of sense that Wyoming would be doing this.
- 10:36It fit. It fits with the the DNA of the
- 10:38state, which is kind of in contrast to some of the other
- 10:43states that have taken the polar opposite approach to to crypto
- 10:48in general. Specifically, New York is the
- 10:52the most difficult state to do any kind of crypto business in
- 10:57because of their bit license requirements.
- 10:59And that stands out to me as really the the, the, the
- 11:05opposite of embracing innovation because they've already set up
- 11:09prohibitive regulatory requirements for allowing
- 11:13innovation to develop at all. So thank goodness there are
- 11:17Wyoming's and and Texas's out there that are taking the other
- 11:21approach. The the other thing that's
- 11:23interesting on the contrast is like this whole proof of work I
- 11:26I remember, I can't remember she did it publicly or privately
- 11:28with Senator Lummus talked about the mineral rights and
- 11:31understanding kind of like the the the scarcity aspect of it
- 11:35and having to manage that treasury and thinking about well
- 11:37where do you put your capital and to preserve wealth and
- 11:40similar in Texas with oil that there's this natural kind of
- 11:43understanding that there are finite resources on this planet
- 11:46and your state and the constituents tied to it and to
- 11:49get that. Like you, you might want to
- 11:50trade that for another asset. It better be as scarce or have
- 11:54some kind of value attributed to it versus what we know, as you
- 11:59know, inflating away currency at this current rate.
- 12:03Yeah, that's it's I I thought that was a great observation the
- 12:07senator made and and it it it's probably no coincidence that you
- 12:12know two of the leading states, Wyoming and Texas.
- 12:16Are come from a background and a context of commodities and so
- 12:24that's I think there is something to that connection.
- 12:30And to dive into the particulars of what Wyoming has put forth in
- 12:35terms of laws that embrace digital assets and make it a
- 12:40good place to do business, what was the approach?
- 12:45For the committee, when you when you guys first started out, what
- 12:48was sort of the landscape you identified and how did you sort
- 12:52of break everything up into small pieces and begin to write
- 12:56legislation that that enabled business to to come to Wyoming?
- 13:02Yeah, right. So the first thing that needed
- 13:04to be done was to define the the asset and then to to codify that
- 13:09asset in our commercial and property laws.
- 13:11So there's there's been now over 30.
- 13:15Laws that that that address digital assets generally.
- 13:20Probably the most important law early on was Cenofile 125, which
- 13:26appended the Wyoming Uniform Commercial Code to include three
- 13:29new types of property, digital currency, digital securities and
- 13:35tokens. That then kind of creates these
- 13:39definitions and this initial framework from which regulation
- 13:46can occur by the Wyoming regulator, the Wyoming Division
- 13:49of Banking. It provides A framework for the
- 13:55courts. So one of the other new sort of
- 14:00initiatives that emanated out of this blockchain Select
- 14:03Committee. Was standing up a new court in
- 14:06Wyoming, a Wyoming Chancery court and then it also allowed
- 14:10us to build additional legislation on top of that.
- 14:13And then it's just maybe a couple of other key pieces of
- 14:18legislation. I'm I'm sure you and your
- 14:20listeners are all aware of the and a novel new bank charter
- 14:25that was created in Wyoming. A special purpose depository
- 14:28institution or or speedy. As it's called, and there have
- 14:34been several speedy charters that have been granted by the
- 14:38State of Wyoming. Of course that the Fed has not
- 14:42granted a Fed Master account to to a speedy yet.
- 14:46And my colleague on the OR former colleague on the
- 14:50Blockchain Select Committee, Caitlin Long, is the.
- 14:52Founder and CEO of one of those Speedies who is now doing battle
- 14:57with with the Fed over over the the Master the Master license
- 15:04so. That was a key piece of
- 15:07legislation that is is sort of in suspended animation awaiting
- 15:12movement from the feds. Wyoming also created the first
- 15:17Dow LLC Decentralized Autonomous Organization and we continue to
- 15:22amend that that legislation as we learn more about.
- 15:29Putting in the proper legal framework around Dow's, we are
- 15:35working on a couple of recent pieces of legislation.
- 15:40Last year, the legislature passed the Wyoming Stable Token
- 15:44Act, which authorized the state of Wyoming through a Commission
- 15:48to explore issuing a stable coin.
- 15:52So it would be the first state issued stable coin in Wyoming.
- 15:56We're calling it a stable token. And a piece of legislation that
- 16:01we're working on right now in the current session would
- 16:03clarify the treatment of digital assets or any asset really in
- 16:10the event of bankruptcy. So it's been a been a, you know,
- 16:14headline grabbing issue of late with the failures of financial
- 16:18institutions and what happens to client assets in the event of
- 16:23those failures. The piece of legislation that
- 16:26we're working on in Wyoming would make it clear from the
- 16:29sort of initial client agreements with the financial
- 16:32institution that those assets are held in trust on behalf of
- 16:37the client and not to be commingled with the financial
- 16:40institutions other assets and providing guidance for the
- 16:46bankruptcy court that those assets shouldn't be.
- 16:51Drug along into the bankruptcy estate that they should be, they
- 16:54should remain the the property of the clients.
- 16:58So we'll see where that that piece of legislation goes that's
- 17:02that's currently being drafted. Now it it really seems like you
- 17:06guys are are a decade ahead in terms of actually providing the
- 17:11regulatory structure and and and guidance about what's allowed
- 17:15and and how things fit. You did mention in there the the
- 17:20distinction that that Wyoming is making between crypto
- 17:25securities. And I forget what you called the
- 17:27the other category of of crypto currencies, commodities.
- 17:32Yeah, currency securities and tokens, Currency securities and
- 17:36tokens. So I I imagine that's a a
- 17:40contentious issue and probably an evolving topic.
- 17:47But do you feel like since you guys have been engaging with
- 17:51this proactively that you have reached a point where there is
- 17:55some sort of clarity that that you think that other regulatory
- 17:58bodies should catch up to, you know for example, the SEC in
- 18:02terms of how they're delineating these categories?
- 18:07Yeah, absolutely. And it it is I guess
- 18:10controversial in the sense that we've provided one set of
- 18:13definitions and and whether whether that is what becomes
- 18:17widely adopted, you know up for debate.
- 18:21All of our pieces of legislation we've been or I should say most
- 18:27all we've been fine tuning through the course of of
- 18:30amendments in in subsequent years and we and we continue to
- 18:33do that. I I do.
- 18:36I do think in in fairness to the agencies the the the definitions
- 18:43need to start with legislation. And so I think it, I think it's
- 18:46incumbent upon the the federal legislature to get some
- 18:54legislation passed such as the Lummus Gillibrand bill that's
- 18:58been proposed. That would provide definitions
- 19:02and provide a road map for the agencies to then properly
- 19:07regulate these these these new assets.
- 19:13Yeah, I think, oh, go ahead. I was gonna say the interaction
- 19:17between the state legislator and the federal legislator is very
- 19:21interesting to watch play out. We were in Houston a couple
- 19:23weeks ago and Caitlin was on stage.
- 19:27It's like explaining the knock down drag out fight that
- 19:30Custodia has been engaged in with the Federal Reserve and
- 19:34that's just observationally a really interesting point of
- 19:38contention that the states are having with the federal
- 19:41government right now. And that's the big question in
- 19:43my mind is who's going to lead the way here.
- 19:46And as you just mentioned, there probably does need to be some
- 19:49definitions put forth by the federal legislator, but.
- 19:55I'd like to think that the Federalist ideals that this
- 19:58country was founded on are able to shine through with this
- 20:02particular industry and we can have states like Wyoming lead
- 20:07the way. But it does seem like there is a
- 20:10very aggressive posture from the federal government towards
- 20:13States and the custodians battle with the Federal Reserve is
- 20:20really highlights that contention.
- 20:22Yeah, there's there's an obvious tension there.
- 20:25And and I understand the tension.
- 20:26I understand the motives of those that are charged with the
- 20:31the federally chartered banking institutions and their desire to
- 20:34control the banking system. But I also believe that the
- 20:40states rights are critically important and A and A and
- 20:44critically important part of our country's history.
- 20:48The right for the states to maintain their dual banking
- 20:55system is I think more and more threatened every day.
- 21:01And we're we're losing a really important part of of our
- 21:05financial history and and an important part of innovation and
- 21:09creativity addressing more local needs.
- 21:13You know here here in Wyoming with kind of our our background
- 21:18in in commodities into agriculture oil and gas
- 21:22etcetera. The community banks serve an
- 21:25incredibly important role and the the the ability to innovate
- 21:31and and create our own banking charter should be preserved.
- 21:35But the you know up to this point the the the federal
- 21:42agencies across the board have have done their best to prevent
- 21:48that innovation from from advancing.
- 21:50And again, I I understand the tension and I understand their
- 21:53motives, but it's just a it's an unfortunate position that that
- 22:00the the feds have have elected to take and hopefully Caitlin's
- 22:05successful, hopefully Wyoming's successful.
- 22:10Yeah, one thing I think worth noting and I don't know enough
- 22:13about this, but I'd be curious to old to like if you have more
- 22:16specifics to go and it's on the around the stable token act
- 22:19because I think. Well, we don't, we don't talk a
- 22:22lot about like stable coins and and there there's some
- 22:25innovation there they'll be able to interoperable send you know
- 22:27dollars at any point in time, day night.
- 22:31But the thing we talk about on this podcast is like
- 22:33counterparty risk and where the dollars ultimately live.
- 22:37And then what are the different ways that you know?
- 22:39Potentially, you know you can have it seized, turned off, at
- 22:42loss of access. It still exists, but to the
- 22:45extent you do have to engage with, you know, stable coin,
- 22:49stable tokens. It makes a lot more sense to
- 22:52have it bankruptcy or remote and then backed by a state versus
- 22:57right now what we see with like the circles of the world that
- 22:59are JPMC tied. I think Blackrock's investor,
- 23:02there's a lot of this. I think most of stable coins
- 23:06right now are parked in treasuries.
- 23:08And so there's this inherent risk of, you know, tied to a
- 23:11certain asset based on the, you know, the increase or decrease.
- 23:17And the the price and are you left holding a bag of you know
- 23:21what could be less than worth a dollar per coin or per stable
- 23:24token. So be curious on like how you
- 23:26guys have thought through it because it sounds like a a
- 23:28better model. And then where it's at because
- 23:31it seems like another version of where Wyoming's really
- 23:34understanding like how do you actually build the right
- 23:36structure for the consumer to be protected versus like here just,
- 23:40you know, pile billions of dollars into this thing and then
- 23:42let's hope it stays consistent with the price of the dollar.
- 23:47Yeah, it's a, it's a it's a really interesting project to to
- 23:52have been a part of to be a part of.
- 23:55So what just to a little to wind back a little bit the history is
- 23:59that so from from the legislature, the Commission was
- 24:02created. The Commission is comprised of
- 24:05the governor, the treasurer, the Secretary of State and then the
- 24:08three of them in turn elected for subject matter experts to
- 24:13round out this seven person Commission and and and I'm I'm
- 24:18one of one of the seven and so as a Commission we've been
- 24:23endeavouring to issue a Wyoming stable token.
- 24:28We hired a director about a month or two ago.
- 24:34We've engaged a law firm to help us with the sort of legal
- 24:40interpretations and constitutional interpretations
- 24:43of a of a state issued stable token.
- 24:47And we're we're moving forward there in in my mind and I'm just
- 24:53you know one of seven commissioners, but in my mind
- 24:55we, I think we need to demonstrate two things.
- 24:59One is that we have a unique way in which we are viewed from from
- 25:07a legal and regulatory perspective.
- 25:10So there should be no question that the Wyoming stable token is
- 25:18a is not a security and it is not a Wyoming issued currency.
- 25:25It is a stable token and there there should be no kind of legal
- 25:30or regulatory question about that.
- 25:33The second thing that I think we need to demonstrate is a a clear
- 25:38and transparent proof of reserves.
- 25:42You know, getting to your point Michael about some of the less
- 25:47than transparent and risky assets that some of the reserves
- 25:54have allegedly been invested in. So Wyoming would would through
- 26:00our treasurer's office be managing the reserves in a in a
- 26:05very transparent way, you know providing audits and attestation
- 26:11of of the reserves available for the token holders.
- 26:16So we'll see where that goes. It's you know I, I, I, you know
- 26:20appreciate the fact that it's it's not a topic that that you
- 26:23address regularly. But in some respects it's it is
- 26:27a a significant innovation for the for people around the world
- 26:36to have access to essentially AUS dollar payment rail that
- 26:43they wouldn't otherwise have access to because they're
- 26:45blocked from either U.S. bank accounts or from holding U.S.
- 26:50dollars. This allows anyone with an
- 26:53Internet connection potentially provides anyone with an Internet
- 26:57connection to have access to to U.S. dollars into into U.S.
- 27:02dollar payment rails. Yeah, I think it's a great
- 27:05point. It's one I never even thought
- 27:06of. Like if if you get censored from
- 27:07your JP Morgan Chase account for whatever reason, you're just out
- 27:11of your bank account access. And we've seen this happen time
- 27:15and time again, like the fact that you can have access to
- 27:17another, you know, banking partner or ability to get access
- 27:20to dollars. Even as AUS Citizen, we're
- 27:23seeing more and more of that happen.
- 27:25Yeah, the the, the stable, the stable tokens in general has
- 27:29have always struck me as like a like an intermediary innovation
- 27:33like. The, the metaphor that comes to
- 27:37mind is, you know, when we went from the the digitisation of
- 27:42information, we went, you know, we went from, for example, film
- 27:50back in the day, you had to go to a movie theatre to watch a
- 27:52film. And then you know, we had
- 27:54digital media physical formats that developed cassette VCR
- 28:02tapes. And then DVDs and that allowed
- 28:06for Blockbuster to develop and become a thing.
- 28:10But that of course that wasn't the end state of this
- 28:12digitization of information. That was a stepping stone and it
- 28:16ends in in digital streaming. And to me the stable coins,
- 28:21stable tokens seem like a like a innovation that allows for like
- 28:25a a new form of rail. For Dollar Settlements, when
- 28:30ultimately this may you know the digitization of value may be
- 28:33leading to, you know a a more transformative and comprehensive
- 28:42overhaul of what form of currency are you using as your
- 28:47savings account and transacting in in in my opinion, ending up
- 28:52in. And Bitcoin being the preferred
- 28:54savings account for for folks that they would then use the
- 28:57lightning network and so on to transact in.
- 29:00But but of course that there's plenty of of room for massive
- 29:05innovation and transformation of existing rails in in in the
- 29:11meantime and with this intermediary stepping stones
- 29:15phase of stable coins leveraging.
- 29:19Leveraging block chains and connecting that to dollars,
- 29:22which is still what the world wants it, it seems like there's
- 29:26that's going to be a a mega trend for the next couple
- 29:29decades, even though I think ultimately that you know Bitcoin
- 29:34supersedes them. I think that's a great point and
- 29:40I you know without making a judgement on what our ultimate
- 29:48reserve currency is in in this world it would appear at least
- 29:54in the near to medium term that people are going to want U.S.
- 29:58dollars and people need U.S. dollars and and and as a result
- 30:06I think that while we wait for the the the world's sort of
- 30:14ultimate decision on what is the best store of value and what is
- 30:19the best kind of reserve currency.
- 30:22While we wait for that to happen there's there's no doubt that
- 30:26the demand for U.S. dollars will continue to be significant if
- 30:30not potentially grow with the with with the adoption of of
- 30:40U.S. Dollar back stable stable tokens
- 30:43And again that that it it's it's serving a lot of people in an in
- 30:48a very important way and providing them access to to the
- 30:52dollar and to payment services that they wouldn't otherwise
- 30:56have access to. And it it's some really
- 31:01interesting stats that that you know our friend Nick Carter
- 31:08shared with me which just goes to the point that the the market
- 31:12cap of of stable tokens or or stable coins might be relatively
- 31:18small in comparison to crypto generally the other layer one
- 31:25tokens. But if you look at the velocity,
- 31:29the transaction volume and sort of the the dollar velocity
- 31:33stable, stable coins are actually significant share of of
- 31:40the market 7080% now of the velocity of digital assets is is
- 31:47in stable points. It's a it's a really I I think I
- 31:54think your point was a good one. I think it's a it's a really
- 31:57important intermediary step that probably becomes the way that we
- 32:08digitize the dollar because again this is just one person's
- 32:12opinion. But I don't think that a a
- 32:14central bank digital currency is tenable in the United States.
- 32:18I think the ability to censor is too great for the for the US to
- 32:24accept. And so I don't, I don't see that
- 32:27happening in the US and therefore I think that stable
- 32:32tokens or some derivation of that in the future is is likely
- 32:36how we digitize the dollar. Yeah, I go ahead Mark, I'm.
- 32:40Gonna say it's very interesting because it puts the US
- 32:44government particularly in this weird position where the success
- 32:48of stable coins has acutely highlighted that there's a lot
- 32:51of demand for the dollar globally and the the innovation
- 32:57of sending these stable coins over.
- 33:00These block chains is undeniable.
- 33:03The quickness of settlements, the ability to send it
- 33:06internationally at a moment's notice is a step function
- 33:09improvement in the wiring infrastructure that exists
- 33:13today. But with that being said, to
- 33:15date, the people leading the charge in the stable coin world
- 33:19are what we would deem in a lot of way, pirates that really
- 33:25operate outside the purview. Of the US government, tether
- 33:29obviously being the biggest example, the largest stable coin
- 33:32in the world. And now they have a massive
- 33:36treasury balance sheet which holds a lot of treasuries.
- 33:39So they're somewhat systemically tight.
- 33:41Not systemically, but if they grow large enough, they they're
- 33:45great. Bidder for U.S.
- 33:46Treasuries. It's it's in the interest of the
- 33:48Treasury. Yeah, the point being is that
- 33:50the US government's in this awkward position where it's
- 33:53obvious there's a lot of demand for dollars.
- 33:54Stable coins are. Providing utility that helps
- 33:59supply that demand with dollars internationally and yet they
- 34:02don't have complete control over it.
- 34:03So I think that's a big question with stable coins, stable tokens
- 34:06moving forward is how does that particular market vertical
- 34:11evolve as much as they would the government would like all these
- 34:15stable coins to be very tightly regulated.
- 34:17Seems like the free market is like, hey, we prefer these
- 34:21stable coins provided by what you may deem as pirates.
- 34:25As shown by the the price of tether.
- 34:27Historically I I did a deep dive on this like four years ago and
- 34:32historically the the average price of Tether is like 1.001
- 34:36dollars, which is to say that there is a little bit of tiny
- 34:40premium for Tether because it, you know, it allows access to
- 34:45people who are unbanked and so that that's your way to to hold
- 34:49dollars. And it also there's a little bit
- 34:52of of a desirable quality for the pirate nature of of tether
- 34:57in the sense that it's less sensible than than the dollars
- 35:03held in the bank account and that's desirable to some people.
- 35:06So it's a funny thing that like because they're outside of of
- 35:10playing playing completely nice with the US banking system, the
- 35:15the market has actually. Showed a vote of confidence or
- 35:19or or desire for those attributes, which is pretty
- 35:22funny. It's basically the utility
- 35:24function, right? Like Bitcoin's price
- 35:26appreciation is that desirable aspect of its utility against
- 35:30other, you know, currencies. But I think what, Joel, what's
- 35:34so fascinating it hadn't dawned on me, is we have a lot of
- 35:36discussions here about, you know, this intermediary part is
- 35:40a part that like, we we, it's probably the most important,
- 35:42'cause you can't get to the end state without getting through
- 35:44the intermediary. And like, what are the
- 35:46trade-offs? And the this CBDC, like we
- 35:51effectively already are on digital tokens.
- 35:54If we think about it where they're just like really crappy
- 35:55because we can only send them between 9:00 to 5:00 and you
- 35:59know it costs 20 bucks and you know it gets a black box, you
- 36:01don't know when it's going to land.
- 36:03And so it's a wire, it's the banking system.
- 36:04And so tokens start to add to, like the OR the.
- 36:08Whatever the crypto, why there's been demand for USDC and Tether
- 36:13have provided utility there. And I think we all agree and
- 36:18that the market's probably starting to agree that like we
- 36:20go to this interoperable nature and it's, it provides more
- 36:22utility and we're seeing more of it globally.
- 36:24The problem is as we've seen with the SP VS of the world and
- 36:28I don't want to put Binance there because Binance has been
- 36:30fine, but FTX is, is in this new world counterparty risk and
- 36:37brand identity starts to matter because failure actually can
- 36:40really happen. Failure is like a thing that.
- 36:43Historically we've seen with banks it's like, OK, somebody
- 36:45gets bailed out a made whole. But this whole like Wild West of
- 36:48digital assets goes back to what we start to talk about of like
- 36:52free banking reputation. And it's like, well, OK, so
- 36:54we're going to a world where you're using these tokens and
- 36:57now to Jesse's point, will tether has certain attributes.
- 37:00Well, what better counterpart is then?
- 37:01Is there a state as your free bank or the state back in your
- 37:05your token, which hadn't really dawned on it, always thought of
- 37:07like, OK, we'll have JPMC and their consortium of who they
- 37:09hold the coin. And maybe it's another firm that
- 37:12establishes it similar to free banking on the currency.
- 37:15But what if it's a state that's making you whole or saying that
- 37:18these dollars are backed here and if it fails or there's ever
- 37:23question we'll be able to you know make that that seems a lot
- 37:26more interesting in my mind than going to a third party that's a
- 37:31you know private entity. And I think to the last point
- 37:34like we're Joel's referencing is with this intermediary part,
- 37:37it's like we have trillions of dollars I'd have to get in.
- 37:39And so there's going to be some form of intermediary spot,
- 37:43whether it's through bank wires or stable coins that are going
- 37:46to be held depending on the period that's up to the end
- 37:49person and where they're moving assets and how they're thinking
- 37:51about into Bitcoin or anything else.
- 37:54But these will be a functioning part for the next 10 years, at
- 37:57least in my mind of how, like people will transition over from
- 38:00like analog to this quasi digital currency before moving
- 38:04into Bitcoin. Yeah, those are all great points
- 38:08and I I agree. And you can see it's somewhat
- 38:15it's being done somewhat quietly, but you can see among
- 38:19the existing payment networks how much activity is taking
- 38:25place to essentially create private loops of their own
- 38:33stable coins. So you know, Onyx at JP Morgan,
- 38:39PayPal has issued its own stable coin.
- 38:42The Visa has numerous different initiatives that they're working
- 38:48on. Citibank has some initiatives
- 38:51that they're working on. I saw an announcement recently
- 38:53out of Deutsche Bank that they're working on something.
- 38:55So the idea of tokenizing deposits or tokenizing trade,
- 39:03you know, letters of credit or trade credit, it's it's all sort
- 39:07of the same idea. It's it's using distributed
- 39:11Ledger technology to create a more efficient payment rail
- 39:15that's backed by some asset, you know, dollar, U.S. dollar
- 39:19reserve or otherwise. And just, you know, is is the
- 39:24best way to do that through a private network controlled by 1
- 39:29private institution, is the best way to do that through a state
- 39:36or is it through, you know, federally issued tokens such as
- 39:40a CBDC? So I I think that that we're
- 39:44going to, we're going to get to watch that from from the front
- 39:47row over over the next few years how that plays out.
- 39:50Yeah, it it's it's exciting that it is kind of free market
- 39:53capitalism right now and in terms of all these various
- 39:56stable token products coming to market and it and make no
- 40:00mistake they're coming to market right now because.
- 40:02Because of how profitable it is to hold treasuries.
- 40:07You know, if if you ingest a dollar and turn that into a
- 40:11treasury yielding 5%, but you're promising a dollar back to the
- 40:15holder of that token that you're minting money.
- 40:18And that's what Tether has stumbled into now as interest
- 40:21rates have risen. And and every bank would love
- 40:24this to, you know, stand up a new, a new product line, a new
- 40:29vertical to to mint money in this new exotic way.
- 40:33So you know we had to benefit from from watching that free
- 40:38market fight play out And in in my opinion, hopefully, hopefully
- 40:43that free market landscape continues to evolve without
- 40:47without the government coming in and saying no, you're not
- 40:50allowed to. It's going to be a singular CBDC
- 40:53because I believe the free market delivers the best forms
- 40:57of innovation and and so it's exciting on that front.
- 41:01Joel, I wanted to ask about. Real quick, Jesse.
- 41:05Before, before that, just one thing.
- 41:08We just stumble on how Bitcoin becomes like a global reserve
- 41:11asset. Because as I was thinking about
- 41:12this, it was like, well, if you're going to back it by
- 41:15dollars and then eventually if the dollar's depreciating or
- 41:19reputational like somebody doesn't make you whole, then you
- 41:22leave that system and you go to the next partner.
- 41:24It's like, well then. Maybe you want a better asset to
- 41:27bet back at 20 percent, 10% and then I was thinking well who
- 41:29would do that? I was like well Wyoming would
- 41:31probably do it first to have 20% in BTC and then 80% dollars like
- 41:35starting to think through. But if that ultimately is where
- 41:37where this goes and that that's how you start to build the
- 41:39credibility of you know if that's where this heads and you
- 41:42build the credibility of your dollar backing into and then it
- 41:46will goes from a 1% allocation to you basically it's it's 100%
- 41:49backed by by Bitcoin. Well, I think to that point,
- 41:54Jesse, what you're saying about. Entities like Tether holding
- 41:57Treasuries on their balance sheet and minting free profit as
- 42:02their stable coins are only redeemable for $1.00 one to one.
- 42:09That's could be a ticking time bomb too, if U.S.
- 42:13Treasuries, the man for them internationally begins to wane
- 42:18materially, which seems like it may be happening like the you
- 42:21find the situation where. It's a good trade now, but it
- 42:25potentially may not be two years, three years down the
- 42:27line. As we know, rates are up above
- 42:295%. We need to refinance a third of
- 42:33our national debt over the next two years.
- 42:35What? How does the market react to
- 42:37that? Does a recession come quick
- 42:40enough to justify a lowering of rates, which makes that
- 42:43refinancing of all that debt more palatable?
- 42:46There's a lot of these questions and landmines on the horizon
- 42:50that I can see. Yeah, I I think in like Tether's
- 42:54business model, you have to hold to maturity to make that make
- 42:56sense because you can't be like selling, you know, like when
- 42:59interest rates rise and then suddenly the value of the
- 43:02treasuries you're holding drops. You can't, you can't, you know,
- 43:07realize that loss you got, you have to hold to maturity.
- 43:10So I think they they probably have to do that and they're
- 43:13probably banking on you know enough demand for the number of
- 43:18tether in existence just keeps going up and to the right.
- 43:20So you can sit on your older treasury bonds into maturity
- 43:27while buying new ones which are issued at the increasingly
- 43:30higher rate. As as the that sort of that
- 43:33spiral plays out and the yield the market requires for holding
- 43:39a a treasury bond increases then Tether benefits from that.
- 43:43The the irony there is that the the user of the tether is the
- 43:48one who is losing out the most because they get, they gain the
- 43:54benefits of this payment rail, but they suffer the debasement
- 44:00of the value of their tether, their U.S. dollar, without
- 44:06getting the benefits of holding U.S.
- 44:07Treasury. So it's kind of funny that in in
- 44:11to Michael's point that might be how you backdoor into you know
- 44:15some entities offering up stable coins that are increasingly
- 44:20backed by Bitcoin. And if you can withstand the, if
- 44:22you have the bankroll to withstand the volatility that
- 44:25comes with that, that ends up outperforming even the the US
- 44:29Treasury scenario in the assumption that we're, you know
- 44:32we're entering a a a period of inflation greater than the yield
- 44:37on on U.S. Treasuries, because that has to
- 44:39happen in order to inflate away the debt.
- 44:42You. Can see yourself blend.
- 44:45Yeah, we kind of went off the rails, but you could see how
- 44:47that you would blend part of the treasury return coupled with the
- 44:50Bitcoin allocation. So it's not an offset if you
- 44:52like, you're depreciate if you're being and this is kind of
- 44:55like the battery stuff, yeah, you're validating.
- 44:57Something we've been debating for like 6 months.
- 45:00Yeah, but this is like state. This is state level.
- 45:03This isn't a private this would be like but yeah I hear you and
- 45:07and that's different that I was gonna ask Joel was and and
- 45:12thinking about this like you know Michael talked about and
- 45:15Marty talked talked about Interstate jurisdictional
- 45:18arbitrage and you know we're seeing international plays El
- 45:25Salvador trying to become a a home of innovation for for
- 45:30Bitcoin in particular and do you see that do you see this as like
- 45:35a as a a major initiative for Wyoming to differentiate itself
- 45:41in terms of the future of commerce in the state versus
- 45:45other states. And what comes to mind is the
- 45:49effort, the various efforts that California made to to make
- 45:53California the the native home of the Internet or even Delaware
- 45:58to be the the home of corporations.
- 46:01Is this, is this a play that Wyoming is setting itself up to
- 46:04be a, you know, a major player in this landscape for the 21st
- 46:10century? But yeah, that's certainly the
- 46:13motivation for the the state to to be proactive around the
- 46:19legislation and and the regulation of of this asset
- 46:23class. But I I think it it's kind of
- 46:27just one layer of multiple reasons why Wyoming becomes an
- 46:33attractive place for either builders or investors in in in
- 46:39digital assets in in addition to the sort of forward thinking
- 46:45legislation and the thoughtful regulation I mentioned, we we've
- 46:51also stood up recently the new Chancery court.
- 46:54But you also combine that with the Wyoming LLC laws.
- 47:00The Wyoming has among the best, if not the very best, privacy
- 47:05laws in the United States, asset protection and creditor
- 47:10protection laws, and no, no personal or corporate income
- 47:17tax. You know, in addition to capital
- 47:24gains and trust in the state tax, so it's very, very low
- 47:27taxes in in the state of Wyoming as well.
- 47:29So this is, to me, just kind of one more reason why if you're
- 47:34building in this space or you're investing in this space, Wyoming
- 47:38becomes a very logical place in which to do that.
- 47:46Thank God for Wyoming. We need a no.
- 47:50It's truly important that I think that's one thing.
- 47:53Historically, in Bitcoin, if you have this massive opportunity,
- 47:56the whole conversation we're having around regulation is
- 48:01important. But it's also funny because we
- 48:02have this incredible technology at our fingertips that allows us
- 48:07to erect a new financial system with properties that are again a
- 48:11step function improvement on the incumbent.
- 48:15System that that we're trying to transition away from.
- 48:18And yet there are regulators at the federal level really don't
- 48:21get it. Even at individual state levels
- 48:23that don't seem to get it. Or their donors line their
- 48:27pockets in a way that makes it so they will never get it.
- 48:31And it's a big confidence game at the end of the day, in my
- 48:36opinion, particularly with this Interstate jurisdictional
- 48:38arbitrage, we need states like Wyoming, Texas, Tennessee.
- 48:43Florida to stick their necks out and say no, we're going to be
- 48:47open to business here. We're going to allow people to
- 48:49innovate. We're going to allow the free
- 48:50market to lead this innovation because we recognize that the
- 48:56state is not going to be leading this innovation and I I don't
- 49:00think it should be discounted. The the act of sticking the flag
- 49:05out there, it just instills confidence in others to say,
- 49:08hey, they're doing this, Wyoming's seeing a lot of
- 49:10success and. Bringing in a lot of businesses
- 49:14into their borders. And I just, Joel, on that note,
- 49:18I just want to thank you for all the work that you and the
- 49:20committee have done to really stick your necks out and push
- 49:23this forward, just if anything to instill confidence in other
- 49:26states. And on that note, do you view
- 49:29what the committee has put forth in Wyoming as a blueprint for
- 49:33other states to adopt, or are there more intricate nuances at
- 49:38individual state levels? That would prevent somebody from
- 49:42adopting this as a blueprint. No, I would hope that and we
- 49:47would hope that other states will adopt what Wyoming has done
- 49:51and that's already happening. We're seeing it with other
- 49:56states. And Texas is making a great name
- 50:00for itself in in in doing a lot of the similar work that Wyoming
- 50:05has done and and we hope that honestly I'm I'm you know I
- 50:11don't I don't sort of comment this I have a traditional
- 50:15finance background we're on the on the private sector side we're
- 50:18building a firm that is very much meant to.
- 50:25Look and feel like bringing digital assets into a
- 50:30traditional finance platform and I'm I'm I'm hopeful that there
- 50:35will be federal regulation at someday.
- 50:37I hope it's thoughtful, but but I think that having legal
- 50:42clarity and federal regulatory oversight.
- 50:46Is is critical for the US to remain competitive in in
- 50:51innovation and it's critical for the success of this asset class.
- 50:57And and I just you know just to get kind of technical for a
- 51:01second on we just look at the look at the price of of crypto
- 51:05since the since the finance overhang has been removed from
- 51:09the market. So you know, I think.
- 51:13I I I think the the more clarity we get from regulators the the
- 51:23the healthier this asset class is going to be.
- 51:26Now there there could be an they could overshoot in some way and
- 51:31screw it up. But I I, I have faith in.
- 51:36In the process that that eventually they're going to get
- 51:39this right and and this innovation and and they should
- 51:43and that that's going to position the US in a in a great
- 51:47place. I just hope they hurry.
- 51:51Yeah, totally agree. I I hope that, I hope that the
- 51:55US gets to enjoy the same benefits of being the home of
- 51:58the Internet with with blockchain, Bitcoin in
- 52:04particular. And yeah, I you know, I.
- 52:09It would be the biggest fumble of all time.
- 52:11I mean American citizens hold the most amount of Bitcoin
- 52:15compared to the rest of the world individually I'll say I'll
- 52:18say something a little controversial in in the Bitcoin
- 52:20community. I I I don't think it's you know,
- 52:23I I think it's part of what on RAMP is embracing or accepting.
- 52:27Is that my view is that for Bitcoin to become the, the path
- 52:35for Bitcoin to to to win it involves embracing some amount
- 52:40of regulation in order for the mainstream to be comfortable
- 52:44enough to adopt it. And you know, 'cause that's how
- 52:48it ends up in people's pensions, in people's four O1 KS and and
- 52:51and that is antithetical to what the, you know, earliest crypto
- 52:58anarchist adopters would like. And and and there's this sort of
- 53:04vestigial belief that you know, if we hold out and everyone will
- 53:09have to bend the knee entirely to Bitcoin.
- 53:13Yeah, that's that might be right.
- 53:15That might have that might happen if if, you know, there's
- 53:18absolutely no compromise whatsoever and bitcoin's
- 53:21mechanics continue to play out and the dollar continues to the
- 53:24base. However, I think there's greater
- 53:27risk in that path because of the possibility of persecution or
- 53:33draconian backlash when Bitcoin wins without any sort of
- 53:40regulation. And so I think in incorporating
- 53:43regulation and and part of that is is increasing adoption among
- 53:49regulators and and and senators. I think that is a a path, a more
- 53:59conservative path that that involves some amount of of
- 54:05compromise, but really it's about evolving, it's about
- 54:08growing into the type of asset that the mainstream needs
- 54:12Bitcoin to be in, in order to have it on their balance sheet.
- 54:17And so you know, I I think it it's a bit of a controversial
- 54:20statement in the Bitcoin community, but I think that
- 54:23regulation is the some amount of regulation and hopefully it's
- 54:29the Wyoming type of regulation is Bitcoin's best path to
- 54:34success. Yeah.
- 54:36And just to just to add to the controversial statement, I'll go
- 54:38as far, I'll go even further and say it's the only way Bitcoin
- 54:41succeeds is through regulation. And the reason why is from an
- 54:45order of operations, the way they get the capital in is
- 54:48through a framework and structure.
- 54:50Now on the other side of it, are they going to be happy with what
- 54:52they unlocked and and it's and it's permissionless nature,
- 54:56probably not. But that's that's on them like
- 54:58we we need. To play the part we have to do
- 55:01the things we have to create the products and vehicles to get
- 55:03capital in. And then on the other side of
- 55:05it, what they think they're creating or or going to control.
- 55:09You know, I think TVD on how that ends up.
- 55:12But yeah, I think that's an important function that Jesse's
- 55:15outline is like we have to, we have to make this look like we
- 55:19talked about this backing into Bitcoin as a reserve assets like
- 55:21well, stablecoins are here. Eventually people wake up and
- 55:24it's like, well, what am I holding?
- 55:25Maybe I need to choose to return a little bit.
- 55:27Now your base. Is 99 one?
- 55:29And over time it's 10%. And next thing you know, it's
- 55:31just accepted that this thing is backed by Bitcoin.
- 55:34And then maybe you're using Bitcoin over time and maybe
- 55:35that's 30 years from now. But you can start to see a
- 55:38framework for how that actually happens.
- 55:39And there's trillions and hundreds of trillions of dollars
- 55:42of capital that have to flow from the hard asset or whatever
- 55:44the asset is into some intermediary into BTC.
- 55:48And that's where all these things have to coexist.
- 55:50There's no world where hundreds of trillions of dollars just
- 55:52jump into Bitcoin and you're just like, oh good, now we're
- 55:54now we're good to go and and and there needs to be regulatory
- 55:58framework for people to hold those stable tokens comfortably.
- 56:04But Marty disagrees. Yeah, I will hardly disagree.
- 56:06This is define it as money. Let the free market take it.
- 56:11I mean, there's already pensions holding Bitcoin.
- 56:13There's already endowments holding Bitcoin.
- 56:14Like if you have the will, you will find the way.
- 56:18Many people have done it already.
- 56:19Billions of dollars worth of capital has been allocated to
- 56:22Bitcoin on behalf of institutions.
- 56:24It's just. We have the wimps out there that
- 56:26are waiting for Daddy government to give them the OK.
- 56:28I don't think you should wait for that, because if you give
- 56:29them the OK, they're gonna want their cut and their cut's gonna
- 56:32be too big. Marty, do you think there's a
- 56:35greater chance of persecution or draconian backlash with your
- 56:40preferred path? Certainly.
- 56:43But if bitcoins are going to succeed to the level that we
- 56:46hope it will succeed, people need to grow some nuts and
- 56:50realize that when laws are unjust, they should not be
- 56:53followed again. To step up, instill confidence
- 56:56in others, and say this government's turned into a
- 56:58tyrannical, A tyrannical operation.
- 57:02It's just wholeheartedly we have what is going on right now at
- 57:06the federal level with all the printing of the debt we're at
- 57:08the looting, the Treasury stage of the end of the empire.
- 57:11Should not bend. Bend the knee to these drunken
- 57:16tyrants who are drunk on debt and they need a way out of that
- 57:20debt problem. Bitcoins gonna be a good way out
- 57:22and I think we should push back against the regulators and hand
- 57:26the decisions back to the States as much as possible, right.
- 57:31I yeah. Maybe that's the form of of
- 57:33battle that that you know is worth fighting the.
- 57:36Stanford MBAs aren't aren't willing to fight, you know?
- 57:40Well, the Stanford MBAs are generally not willing to fight
- 57:44this battle. I.
- 57:45Will say that, Oh no, it's it's entirely true.
- 57:48The Stanford MBAs are you know still living in the Obama
- 57:52optimism about the federal role and and I think that I sure hope
- 57:58that we get some more free market competition from Wyoming
- 58:03to to Tether to El Salvador. You know you have these
- 58:07different forms of of experimentation that are
- 58:11happening and and only possible if you don't have a top down
- 58:14dictate from you know the the singular entity telling you what
- 58:18how things are gonna be. So on that front, I agree,
- 58:23Marty. You know it's gonna end up
- 58:24telling us how it's gonna be the Elizabeth Warren.
- 58:27All right, we should transition. We should.
- 58:30We should transition to. The I'm sorry.
- 58:36I Joel, I didn't. I didn't.
- 58:38I didn't make you aware. But my my oldest hopped into bed
- 58:41with me at 3:00 AM and I went to bed at 12:30, so I'm going
- 58:44around 2 1/2 hours of sleep riled up.
- 58:49Marty's alter ego 's coming. Thanks for tuning in to the last
- 58:55trade. If you're enjoying the show and
- 58:58want to dive deeper, check us out.
- 59:00At on rampbitcoin.com, where you'll find a full suite of
- 59:04institutional grade research and analytics including our recently
- 59:08published white paper, Bitcoin's full potential valuation and our
- 59:13new tool, the On Ramp Terminal. Now back to the show.
- 59:18No, is I mean there's a good transitionary period like period
- 59:22to talk about Two Oceans Trust and what you guys are doing.
- 59:24I mean this is the service that 2 Ocean offers to your clients
- 59:29is probably one of the last bastions.
- 59:32For individuals, particularly high net worth individuals to
- 59:36protect their wealth in the in the world, that's getting
- 59:40increasingly chaotic. Yeah, Yeah.
- 59:43And actually to just to add to that one part of like tying the
- 59:47last segment into this is for sorry I have a dog because I
- 59:51don't know if you can hear it, but it's basically like high net
- 59:55worth individuals and capital coming in.
- 59:57If you don't have a framework for how do you legacy plan, They
- 1:00:00just won't come in. We we know some of them already
- 1:00:03like ourselves that have hundreds of millions of dollars
- 1:00:06that unless they know how to put the capital, the the Bitcoin
- 1:00:10from a custody perspective. But that's only half of the
- 1:00:12battle and knowing who your counterparty is there because we
- 1:00:15know how that's important. But then the secondary part is,
- 1:00:19well, what is the framework? How do you map the existing
- 1:00:23framework from revocable trust, your revocable trust and legacy
- 1:00:25planning to this new asset so that it's there if it's a
- 1:00:29generational asset like we all believe.
- 1:00:30And if that's not there, then people's capital doesn't come
- 1:00:33in. And so not to tie back to that
- 1:00:36conversation and tie it to what Joel's doing is what and it's
- 1:00:39important to bring the framework from the old world, the the, the
- 1:00:43traditional world and how do you map it to this asset in a
- 1:00:45professional way so these individuals can come in and
- 1:00:48actually plan around it. Right.
- 1:00:52Yeah. Well, and that's there's an
- 1:00:54interesting. Tension that exists between the
- 1:00:58traditional way of managing assets through generations which
- 1:01:05you know we we have sort of trust and estate planning and
- 1:01:08there's a there's a natural there's a sort of an inherent
- 1:01:12tension between that and this original ethos of crypto being a
- 1:01:18self sovereign asset and the the reason is because to.
- 1:01:25And to unlock the benefits that come from strategic planning and
- 1:01:30and those those benefits are you know kind of clear succession
- 1:01:34planning, avoiding probate, minimizing your your tax head
- 1:01:43from kind of a trust in the state planning perspective.
- 1:01:47So that can be done at a state level that can also, you know,
- 1:01:51be a federal gift tax exemption. The privacy and the creditor
- 1:01:56protection, all of those benefits are unlocked through
- 1:02:01through kind of sophisticated the strategic planning, but
- 1:02:07requires that the individual setting up these plans
- 1:02:12relinquish some level of control over the asset and and that's
- 1:02:16that kind of inherent tension against this notion that it's a
- 1:02:19self sovereign asset. So that's.
- 1:02:22The fun stuff that we get to explore with clients on a on a
- 1:02:25daily basis, yeah. And how how have you seen that?
- 1:02:31Like, I guess there's there's really the two sides of the the
- 1:02:33market that you serve as the existing client, which is
- 1:02:36probably easier, right? Because it's like this is like
- 1:02:38every other asset, here's your counterpart, here's where it's
- 1:02:40stored. But then it's really that area
- 1:02:43the market that comes in that's native that has accrued wealth
- 1:02:45that's like wait now you want to you know take delivery or or
- 1:02:49position where the assets custody because of the actual
- 1:02:51like legal requirements from setting up trust and how does
- 1:02:56that conversation generally go? Yeah, so as you pointed out
- 1:02:59they're they're kind of over generalizing here, but there
- 1:03:02there are sort of two client types that that we work with.
- 1:03:07The 1st is the call it kind of crypto native client who they've
- 1:03:12created their wealth through crypto and there's really not a
- 1:03:17a learning curve. Around the asset itself but
- 1:03:23there again gross over over generalization here but there
- 1:03:29may be less understanding or or less education around succession
- 1:03:34planning and and being thoughtful about asset
- 1:03:40protection and. Tax planning and so that's that
- 1:03:46that's that kind of tension that that exists which is getting
- 1:03:52those clients comfortable with the idea of a a sort of more
- 1:03:56institutional approach to to custody and introducing a third
- 1:04:01party trustee into that relationship which which is
- 1:04:04necessary to unlock those benefits.
- 1:04:06On the other hand, we have clients that have come from kind
- 1:04:09of traditional. Wealth generation that are
- 1:04:15looking at this asset class for the first time.
- 1:04:19They understand the sort of need for trust and estate planning,
- 1:04:23for succession planning, for asset protection, but have
- 1:04:27questions around the digital assets.
- 1:04:30How safe are these assets? How safe is the custody?
- 1:04:36Can My Portfolio withstand the volatility?
- 1:04:41That's you know, inherent in the, the prices of these assets.
- 1:04:44And so there's 22 very different conversations that we're having
- 1:04:49with these, with these two types of clients.
- 1:04:53And on that last note on performance, I think it's a good
- 1:04:57opportunity to pull up the research piece if you have it
- 1:05:02handy, Logan, to really dive into these numbers.
- 1:05:04We were discussing it before we hit record, but we talk about.
- 1:05:10About these numbers a lot within the Bitcoin industry, but it
- 1:05:13seems like there's still a disconnect between the return
- 1:05:18profile of Bitcoin historically and the understanding of that
- 1:05:22return profile in the investment management space and.
- 1:05:26And and Marty, what is this document we're looking at?
- 1:05:30It is the revisiting the case for Bitcoin, which is a a.
- 1:05:36What was the letter? A blog post put out by TU Ocean.
- 1:05:41Joel. Yeah, maybe Joel.
- 1:05:43Piece we wrote back in May, it was actually a follow on piece
- 1:05:47to the original piece we've done a year previously and the the
- 1:05:52catalyst for it was the you know the crypto winner, the big sell
- 1:05:55off in in digital assets. And so we thought it would be
- 1:06:00interesting to go back and revisit the analysis we had
- 1:06:03done. In in in light of the of the
- 1:06:07sell off you know so you know if you dial the clock back to May
- 1:06:12Bitcoin and you know the various other crypto were were near
- 1:06:17their lows and Despite that fact there was still a very
- 1:06:21compelling argument for the inclusion of in in the case of
- 1:06:25this paper it's Bitcoin that we we focused on.
- 1:06:27So a very, very strong argument for the inclusion of Bitcoin in
- 1:06:31a traditional diversified portfolio.
- 1:06:36And that's. What are the?
- 1:06:36Advantages there, Joel? Yeah, so twofold, really.
- 1:06:43There's one is, is the performance of Bitcoin.
- 1:06:48And I, I, you know, think you had a, a table up that you were
- 1:06:53just showing. But if you look at the price of
- 1:06:56Bitcoin relative to, yeah, that's it.
- 1:07:01Relative to gold or relative to the S&P 500?
- 1:07:05Back over a three-year, A5 year or a 10 year period.
- 1:07:10Even back in May when it was well off from its highs, Bitcoin
- 1:07:18was well off from its highs. It had still on a compounded
- 1:07:22annual basis, significantly outperformed these other
- 1:07:25traditional asset classes. So that's kind of #1 and then
- 1:07:30#2, which I think is a A. Very much misunderstood part of
- 1:07:37of the of the argument. Well, here let me just because
- 1:07:41you've got it up on the screen, let me, let me let me jump back
- 1:07:45and just if you keep it right on that chart, this is an analysis
- 1:07:50we did which is we started with a traditional 60% equities, 40%
- 1:07:56fixed income portfolio. That's on the far left of the X
- 1:08:00axis, so 0% Bitcoin 6040 portfolio and the three lines
- 1:08:06represent three-year, five year and 10 year compounded annual
- 1:08:09returns. And then we reran the analysis,
- 1:08:15adding ten basis point positions to Bitcoin up to a 10% position
- 1:08:22in Bitcoin. And you can see the significant
- 1:08:25impact that the the allocation to to Bitcoin had on a
- 1:08:30historical basis. Even a small allocation like say
- 1:08:34you know, 5% allocation to Bitcoin on a on a 10 year basis
- 1:08:42almost doubled the returns, the annualized returns and again
- 1:08:50that was. When prices were significantly
- 1:08:53lower than than they had been or where they are today.
- 1:08:57So the second argument here is volatility, and this is the
- 1:09:04piece that I was mentioning is is somewhat misunderstood.
- 1:09:08Bitcoin, to be sure, is a volatile asset.
- 1:09:10And it's more volatile than the other traditional asset classes,
- 1:09:14however, because it is. Has carried historically a very
- 1:09:20low correlation with traditional asset classes, adding a portion
- 1:09:26of Bitcoin to a diversified portfolio.
- 1:09:33You know, at the levels we're talking about between sort of 0
- 1:09:36and 10% not only didn't increase the volatility of the portfolio,
- 1:09:42but in some of the smaller allocation amounts it actually
- 1:09:45decreased. The overall volatility of the
- 1:09:48portfolio, so even though you're adding a more volatile asset
- 1:09:52because of the lack of correlation to the other assets
- 1:09:55in the portfolio, the overall portfolio volatility actually
- 1:09:59decreased. And for those that spend their
- 1:10:05time looking at at at these sorts of things, you're you'd be
- 1:10:10familiar with the sharp ratio which is a measurement of return
- 1:10:15versus a unit of risk. So it's a, it's in my opinion
- 1:10:19the best, the best measurement for risk adjusted returns and
- 1:10:24this is a sharp ratio, so 36 month trailing or three-year
- 1:10:28trailing sharp ratio which is the amount of return you
- 1:10:32generated over the preceding 3 years versus the amount of risk
- 1:10:36that you assume during that period of time.
- 1:10:39And the higher the sharp ratio, the better and a benchmark
- 1:10:45generally. Is you want to generate a sharp
- 1:10:48ratio consistently greater than one.
- 1:10:52So with with with Bitcoin this is just Bitcoin alone.
- 1:10:58You can see the sharp ratio has been historically above the
- 1:11:02orange line here, which is the the 1.0 sharp ratio horizon. 77%
- 1:11:11of the observed periods you would have generated a greater.
- 1:11:16A sharp ratio greater than one and the median of of these
- 1:11:21observations was a 1.6 which in and of itself is a fantastic
- 1:11:26sharp ratio. Just owning Bitcoin has
- 1:11:29generated a much better sharp ratio than than traditional
- 1:11:34assets. And so as a comparison and and
- 1:11:37generally you kind of think of the market as being around A1
- 1:11:39sharp but the that 6040 portfolio that I mentioned
- 1:11:43earlier was. You know, it tends to bounce
- 1:11:47around that one mark. So Bitcoin all by itself has
- 1:11:52generated better median sharp ratios over time.
- 1:11:56But when you add it to the 6040 portfolio and this graph you've
- 1:12:02just pulled up here shows that same concept which is the far
- 1:12:06left of the X axis is 60% equities, 40% fixed income and
- 1:12:11then as you move across the right.
- 1:12:15To the right we're adding incremental allocations to
- 1:12:18Bitcoin. You can see what happens to the
- 1:12:226040 portfolio to the sharp ratio by adding these small
- 1:12:27increments of of Bitcoin. And you know, I this is, you
- 1:12:32know, not for your bit Bitcoin maxi crowd, but if you're
- 1:12:37thinking about a a traditional wealth manager or traditional
- 1:12:42high net worth family. And you you look at the the gain
- 1:12:46and sharp ratio that that you can pick up from going from zero
- 1:12:51to just a two or a 3% position. What you've done here
- 1:12:56historically is you've actually decreased your volatility and
- 1:13:00substantially increased your returns by adding a small
- 1:13:03portion of Bitcoin to a diversified portfolio.
- 1:13:07And and you know again looking at the 10 year or the blue line
- 1:13:11on this graph going from. A10 year historical sharp ratio
- 1:13:17of seven of .77 up to up to A1 that's that's very meaningful
- 1:13:25and again that was at a point in time when Bitcoin was on its
- 1:13:29lows. So we'll be we'll redo this,
- 1:13:32this analysis maybe at one year again and it's just interesting
- 1:13:38to watch this over time, but a a very compelling argument.
- 1:13:42For traditional for you know, traditional wealth managers.
- 1:13:45For traditional high net worth individuals, they're just
- 1:13:48investors in general to to consider adding a small portion
- 1:13:51of Bitcoin to a portfolio. Yeah, that that's that's the
- 1:13:54most comprehensive sharp ratio analysis I've seen with Bitcoin.
- 1:13:58And and it it presents the whole case.
- 1:14:00I particularly like how you break out because too often it's
- 1:14:04just a sharp ratio. But you broke out, you know,
- 1:14:07here's the performance side of it and you see that on the graph
- 1:14:10it it's quite linear. Increase of of Bitcoin
- 1:14:13allocation results in better portfolio performance over all
- 1:14:19of your selected time periods. And I and I guess that's how
- 1:14:22BlackRock ended up running a similar sort of analysis and
- 1:14:25landing on the optimal allocation of Bitcoin 86% or or
- 1:14:29whatever it was because that's you know that math plays out in
- 1:14:34that way. So you you got the performance,
- 1:14:37pure performance of it but the volatility piece?
- 1:14:40And and doing the analysis of just of just volatility and how
- 1:14:45increasing you know a percent or two allocation to Bitcoin
- 1:14:49decreases overall portfolio volatility, that that's the Holy
- 1:14:53Grail that's everything that you're looking for in in
- 1:14:56portfolio construction and and all wealth managers have to do
- 1:15:00is just read this analysis in order to understand the case for
- 1:15:05Bitcoin in a in a in a well-rounded portfolio.
- 1:15:11It's so counterintuitive to the narrative around Bitcoin.
- 1:15:15Yes, Bitcoin in isolation is highly volatile, but as the pure
- 1:15:20Bitcoin chart showed, the median sharp ratio is well above one.
- 1:15:26But you can see if people don't really dive deep into what's
- 1:15:30actually happening here and they just look at it at a surface
- 1:15:33level, they can see the volatility and maybe assume that
- 1:15:36it. Doesn't add any benefits to the
- 1:15:38sharp ratio of their overall portfolio.
- 1:15:41Well, it's all about sizing too. That's just the crazy part about
- 1:15:44the volatility case. It's like just size it
- 1:15:45appropriately where the volatility doesn't matter.
- 1:15:47And then we all know once you have some exposure, it's it's
- 1:15:50kind of when the floodgates open.
- 1:15:52Joel, the the thing that I really appreciated and it's a
- 1:15:55great report, but it was the timing of it.
- 1:15:57It's we very often it's very counter to like when you see all
- 1:16:01the education research comes out, it's when the market's
- 1:16:03flying. And I just remember it's the
- 1:16:05summer and you're kind of you're building and nobody's talking
- 1:16:07about Bitcoin and there's very little your research and reports
- 1:16:10and it came out, it's like, hey guys, this is still here.
- 1:16:12This is the time you should actually be paying attention,
- 1:16:14you know, educating yourself and also allocating.
- 1:16:18So that'll always be implanted in my head.
- 1:16:20I just remember the summer when everything was quiet and it was
- 1:16:22like all this stuff is, nobody's talking about it and you guys
- 1:16:24dropped that report. A career of investing.
- 1:16:29I've developed a strong superstition around it, so I
- 1:16:32actually think I reverse jinx the market by by putting that
- 1:16:35out. That might have marked the low.
- 1:16:37So we appreciate, we appreciate your service.
- 1:16:42Our wives appreciate it. Yeah a a lot better than Bank of
- 1:16:49America put out like a pet peeve analysis of of mine at the very
- 1:16:53top of the last bull market. They they ran their analysis on
- 1:16:56on what's the multiplier of capital inflows to Bitcoin and
- 1:16:59how much that how how much each dollar of capital inflowing to
- 1:17:02Bitcoin increases the total value of all Bitcoin and they
- 1:17:07came up with like a a multiplier of like 100 and 120 X something
- 1:17:11like that But but what they're looking at is the sample of you
- 1:17:15know. Bull market mania.
- 1:17:17So, you know, and then they're extrapolating that across across
- 1:17:20time. And so we know that still shows
- 1:17:23up. People say, oh, Bank of America
- 1:17:24says that every dollar that flows in increases the value of
- 1:17:28Bitcoin by $120.00. And.
- 1:17:30And that's just not true. It was true for a very finite
- 1:17:34moment in time at at the worst possible point in time to be
- 1:17:37doing that analysis, which is of course when they did it.
- 1:17:41Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:17:43When that analysis, when that when that analysis gets accepted
- 1:17:46is sorry. No, I'm sorry Michael.
- 1:17:49I was just going to say that the the, I think one of the the
- 1:17:54important drivers of that analysis we did was correlation
- 1:17:59and and correlation itself moves over time of course and I think
- 1:18:05that because. There is a lot of attention paid
- 1:18:09to correlation when there are draw downs.
- 1:18:13There's a perception that Bitcoin is a risk.
- 1:18:16It is a risk asset, obviously, but but when?
- 1:18:19When there is a risk event and all risk assets are sold,
- 1:18:23Bitcoin is sold and there's a deleveraging effect that that
- 1:18:28affects all risk assets. And so I think the even my own
- 1:18:33perception, I think just people's perception of the
- 1:18:35correlation is much higher than it actually arithmetically is
- 1:18:40because it's you know for for a couple of weeks every year these
- 1:18:46risk assets all move in lockstep.
- 1:18:48But it's the other sort of 50 weeks out of the year when and
- 1:18:51we've seen a lot of it over the last few months, haven't we,
- 1:18:54where the equity markets and and crypto almost seem to be going?
- 1:19:00And an inverse relationship and and it there really is a very
- 1:19:05very low sustained very low correlation between Bitcoin and
- 1:19:10and these other assets which is a wonderful thing to have in a
- 1:19:14portfolio for generational wealth.
- 1:19:18Yeah, I was just going to allude to what the report made me think
- 1:19:21of as we had Chris Hyper who leads to the research team at
- 1:19:24Fidelity on a few months ago and this is one of the things he I
- 1:19:28was really excited about once the benchmarks were established
- 1:19:31in the wealth management community of like the certain
- 1:19:33percentage allocations and that was just like you just check the
- 1:19:36box is really when the the floodgates you know open for
- 1:19:39capital to come in and so it's just 1% return or 2%.
- 1:19:44So it sounds like that's similar in line with your, your your
- 1:19:47kind of like thesis on where kind of the market starts to
- 1:19:50understand you know a small allocation can really outperform
- 1:19:53the market? I think it really depends on the
- 1:19:56client Michael. You know I you know for the for
- 1:19:59the Bitcoin Maxis. To be sure if we extended that
- 1:20:03graph out past 10% the. The returns and the sharp ratio
- 1:20:10keep going up and to the right. So it is this is this is not
- 1:20:16meant to and and by the way I have an irresponsibly high
- 1:20:20allocation to Bitcoin personally so.
- 1:20:23Joel, I've heard. I've heard it goes up forever.
- 1:20:26I've heard it goes up forever. But I I I can't confirm so but I
- 1:20:32think if you know when when we're talking to clients who you
- 1:20:36know our typical clients who are ultra high net worth families
- 1:20:40and and foundations. And they're investing in an
- 1:20:43endowment style of investing which is to to have a diverse
- 1:20:50set of uncorrelated asset classes that will generate some
- 1:20:55income for the foundation's needs or the family's lifestyle
- 1:21:00needs. But then sort of outpace
- 1:21:02inflation over a very, very, very long period of time that
- 1:21:05that's the goal. And when you're talking to
- 1:21:08clients like that, then when, when you can make an argument
- 1:21:11that historically across these 35 and 10 year time periods, not
- 1:21:17on not only are you increasing your returns significantly your
- 1:21:22your numerator, but actually at a 2 or 3% position in the
- 1:21:25portfolio, you're actually decreasing your risk, your your
- 1:21:29volatility, your your denominator.
- 1:21:32So that just becomes an easy argument.
- 1:21:34You're getting a win on both the numerator and the denominator if
- 1:21:38if history continues to repeat itself.
- 1:21:41Do you do you feel like there's been a a shift or or do you see
- 1:21:44a shift coming in terms of this becoming the accepted wisdom
- 1:21:47that you know the the math is out there that that people are
- 1:21:53at this point potentially being irresponsible for having a 0%
- 1:21:58allocation to Bitcoin when the math suggests that A1 or 2%
- 1:22:02allocation makes a ton of sense. Do you feel like in the in I
- 1:22:06guess broadly in the wealth management industry that the?
- 1:22:10But this is finally percolating through no I don't.
- 1:22:17I I I believe it. I know you three do and I I
- 1:22:19suspect most of your listeners do.
- 1:22:21But no, there's a, there is still a healthy healthy amount
- 1:22:25of skepticism amongst the traditional traditional finance
- 1:22:29folks. And you know and I think a lot
- 1:22:33of it is the the narrative that the the Elizabeth Warrens of the
- 1:22:41world are are putting out there. The, you know, it was used to
- 1:22:44fund terrorism narrative. You know there's been a lot
- 1:22:49there's been there was a lot of publicity around that and
- 1:22:52unfortunately there's been very little publicity about walking
- 1:22:55back the false analysis that went into that statement.
- 1:22:58But so no, there's still a lot of of skepticism but I I see
- 1:23:04amongst the traditional high net worth investors but that's
- 1:23:10bullish to me like that that's you know again going back on my
- 1:23:15career there's a couple of things that you want, you want a
- 1:23:19lot of people who are still negative on on an idea and you
- 1:23:26want volatility. And so that's you know these
- 1:23:30things that that you might look at on the surface and say are
- 1:23:34negatives those those actually to me are that's the kind of
- 1:23:39potential energy that still exists in this in the prices
- 1:23:42here. Yeah, that creates the.
- 1:23:44Enjoy what you just I know we talked about a logo for the pod
- 1:23:48but the the on ramp terminal that what you just described was
- 1:23:52the genesis behind investing in that tool to showcase to
- 1:23:56institutions wealth managers or clients.
- 1:23:58Why there's not a bunch of error between zero and the current
- 1:24:00price of Bitcoin? Because.
- 1:24:02To the uninitiated, they're just looking at it.
- 1:24:03And to Marty's points, like the common trope of, you know, past
- 1:24:08results are not indicative of future returns or or however the
- 1:24:11phrase goes, it's like that thought that, well, OK, so this
- 1:24:15is the return profile if it continues, but why would it
- 1:24:17continue? And we all know why it would.
- 1:24:19But somebody else needs to go and do that research and see all
- 1:24:22the different. Core fundamentals, how they're
- 1:24:25just going only in One Direction, whether it's mining,
- 1:24:27hash rate, nodes, transactions. So, yeah, we'll get you over
- 1:24:31that access because we'd be curious as you think about it
- 1:24:33from an institutional perspective, what are other
- 1:24:35metrics that individuals you think are going to be interested
- 1:24:38in seeing we can start to incorporate to give like the
- 1:24:41right tool into the market? Yeah, Michael, I'm happy you
- 1:24:44brought that up because I wanted to interject and say, yeah,
- 1:24:47let's deal, Matt, in this. Like past performance is not
- 1:24:49indicative of future returns, but like.
- 1:24:52Just look at the set up here. I think the estimates are like
- 1:24:5480 to 150 million people globally adopted Bitcoin in
- 1:24:59earnest. That's a very small percentage
- 1:25:02and probably over overestimating the total amount of people
- 1:25:07actually hold Bitcoin. We're still very early in this.
- 1:25:10There's 8 billion people on the planet, governments are proving.
- 1:25:14To continue to be fiscally irresponsible moving into the
- 1:25:18future, the world is becoming more interconnected.
- 1:25:21You have this peer-to-peer digital cache system that can
- 1:25:25connect the world. And then on top of that, I
- 1:25:28really don't think, and Jesse, this is your favorite topic, but
- 1:25:30people don't understand how many Bitcoin has already been
- 1:25:33distributed, the market and the fact that we have another
- 1:25:35halving coming up in five months that's going to reduce the
- 1:25:38supply inflation that's being introduced to the market every
- 1:25:42block. And those factors, whether
- 1:25:45people want to recognize it or not, more and more people are
- 1:25:48learning about Bitcoin, becoming more confident in it, putting
- 1:25:50their savings in it. There's less Bitcoin being
- 1:25:53distributed to market and governments are proving to be
- 1:25:57woefully irresponsible with their fiscal policies.
- 1:26:02And I I also would add to that you know, but very good list of
- 1:26:08of kind of the the the bold case thesis.
- 1:26:14I would add to that that I, I do think that legislation and
- 1:26:19regulation it's grinding slowly, but it is going in the right
- 1:26:24direction. And the the Lummus Gillibrand
- 1:26:27Bill is you know maybe it doesn't pass in the near term,
- 1:26:33maybe it doesn't pass in its current incarnation, but I think
- 1:26:37that it it will eventually. I think that we'll probably see
- 1:26:41stable, stable token legislation soon you know in the next year.
- 1:26:48And I think that that over the course of the next year we're
- 1:26:53probably also going to see a spot ETF approved.
- 1:26:58And so I just I it's it's for our clients who are investing
- 1:27:04for periods that are in in kind of decades and you think about
- 1:27:10what's going to happen from a legal and a regulatory
- 1:27:12perspective it it is damn near inevitable and once that happens
- 1:27:19then I think the opportunity for for these handful of digital
- 1:27:26assets is significant. And you know I think I think
- 1:27:30that you know my my personal view on Bitcoin is that it maybe
- 1:27:38it doesn't replace the dollar in in my lifetime, you know as a as
- 1:27:44a reserve currency. I think the importance of the
- 1:27:45dollar is probably is demonstrating that it's
- 1:27:48sustainable. But I do think that it replaces
- 1:27:52gold for sure. I think it becomes the reserve
- 1:27:55asset of choice for for investors looking for a hedge
- 1:28:04and and I think you know, I don't know if it's Ethereum or
- 1:28:07something like it that's programmable that you kind of
- 1:28:11think of not as a currency or as a store of value like Bitcoin.
- 1:28:18I think you think about it as an operating system.
- 1:28:20So in the same way that we sort of look at investing in
- 1:28:24Microsoft today, I think that's how we'll think about protocols
- 1:28:28like Ethereum. It's it's an operating system.
- 1:28:32It's it's a program. And so I I these digital assets
- 1:28:36I think have a very asymmetric set up right now for all the
- 1:28:39reasons you listed. Joel, from your cohort from a
- 1:28:43previous life, what percentage do you believe knows that
- 1:28:47there's only 21 million Bitcoin? I I think this like answer is,
- 1:28:55is one of the most bullish things.
- 1:28:57Yeah, it's only about 30% and that probably is is, is.
- 1:29:02Being very kind, I think that you know 1/5 to 1/3 of the
- 1:29:06market at best who's controlling capital knows that there's only
- 1:29:08a 21 million Bitcoin. You know there's.
- 1:29:12If that's not bullish, I don't know what is.
- 1:29:15And probably 10% of those realize that 19.5 million have
- 1:29:19been distributed to the market already, right?
- 1:29:22And and very few realize there's a having coming, which is the
- 1:29:25most exciting part. We have to really figure out how
- 1:29:30we're having efficient market theory, doesn't it?
- 1:29:34When? Oh, it sure does.
- 1:29:36Everybody knows it's gonna happen and then it happens and
- 1:29:39it goes up and it's like, Yep, that wasn't supposed to happen.
- 1:29:42I was. I was taught, I was taught at
- 1:29:45Stanford. They taught us weak form
- 1:29:47efficient market hypothesis and and I always thought that
- 1:29:51something was off about this because.
- 1:29:54You know how how were how were any how was anybody a a a better
- 1:29:57than average investor. You know how did how did Stan
- 1:30:00Druckenmiller do so well for decades if if every if there was
- 1:30:05a level playing field and you know all information was
- 1:30:08incorporated into into prices accurately.
- 1:30:11It's just not reality. That's not human nature.
- 1:30:14And then here comes Bitcoin to like amplify this this problem.
- 1:30:19And sure, it manifests as understanding asymmetry.
- 1:30:22But that the efficient market hypothesis doesn't allow for
- 1:30:25understanding asymmetry. And so boom, it's a shot across
- 1:30:29the bow for that whole hypothesis.
- 1:30:30And yeah. Joel, we learned last week was
- 1:30:35kind of, it was mean knowledge to Marty and myself is that the
- 1:30:40having is like Christmas to Jesse.
- 1:30:42And so now we have to figure out what our having event will be
- 1:30:46because it's going to have to be special.
- 1:30:48We can't let every four year Christmas.
- 1:30:51Come and go without doing something special.
- 1:30:53So we'll have to plan around that.
- 1:30:54We'll we'll let you know, I'll make a note in my calendar to
- 1:30:58send you guys a fruitcake. That would be amazing.
- 1:31:05The. There's a lot of people planning
- 1:31:07having parties already. I'm like see how much hash rates
- 1:31:10coming on the network. You're gonna you're gonna be
- 1:31:12having a late having party by by the time it comes.
- 1:31:15It's actually the market update of the week.
- 1:31:18I read a newsletter last night. It is.
- 1:31:20I know we talked a lot about mining last week, Jesse, but I
- 1:31:22didn't run the numbers on the hashray growth.
- 1:31:24Hashray's grown 27% in less than three months between September
- 1:31:286th and last week. It grew from like 383 XA hash a
- 1:31:33second to 450 something I believe.
- 1:31:38Brutal, brutal for miners. And another incredible example
- 1:31:43of there's a there's a fully transparent metric that shows
- 1:31:47you what people are doing with their dollars.
- 1:31:51Their CapEx spend right now, they are investing in this thing
- 1:31:54and you don't, you don't get that in any other asset class.
- 1:31:57You don't get to see transparently what's really
- 1:32:01happening in terms of investment into gold or any other
- 1:32:04commodity. You piece it together, but here
- 1:32:07it is, you know, unfudgeable. Yeah, and I mean just to put.
- 1:32:13Bring that one up. That would be interesting to
- 1:32:15just throw up on because I I just pulled it up.
- 1:32:16I hadn't seen that look at the minor revenue.
- 1:32:20Yeah, minor revenues going up. It was above 40 million
- 1:32:23temporarily with the mempool congestion last week or a couple
- 1:32:27weeks ago. But no, just to put this in
- 1:32:29context, 27% growth in less than three months.
- 1:32:32What took 14 years and eight months to get to a certain
- 1:32:35point, the network just added more than 1/4 of that in less
- 1:32:37than three months. It's pretty insane.
- 1:32:40Yeah. It's like AUS government debt.
- 1:32:45Yes. Yeah, we. 6 trillion annualized
- 1:32:50over the last few months in the additional debt.
- 1:32:53Incredible. Surely sustainable.
- 1:32:58Very scary. It's that's, I mean we don't
- 1:33:03have to die. Well, that'll be a whole another
- 1:33:05half hour discussion that we don't have time for.
- 1:33:07But I do. I I I think people are expecting
- 1:33:11it to go longer than it may go. The debt situation, that's all
- 1:33:17I'll say about that, but. Joel, thank you so much for your
- 1:33:23time today. It's been an incredible
- 1:33:25discussion, Your experience in the traditional finance world
- 1:33:30and now the work that you've done in Wyoming into Ocean is
- 1:33:33extremely insightful and I think the listeners of the show are
- 1:33:37going to get a lot of value out of this conversation.
- 1:33:41Well, thank you. You're generous with your
- 1:33:43compliments. I, I, I appreciate having this
- 1:33:45chance to chat with you guys. Thanks for including me.
- 1:33:48Yeah. And I just want to apologize for
- 1:33:49letting the tiger out of the cage earlier, going over to
- 1:33:52sleep. It's good to have that back and
- 1:33:54forth though. It's good to have a little spice
- 1:33:56in any podcast. Yeah, that was great.
- 1:34:03Oh, no, Joel, appreciate you joining.
- 1:34:06And I think there's really a need it's it's something we're
- 1:34:09trying to embody an on ramp of like I don't know,
- 1:34:12professionalizing is the right word.
- 1:34:13Maybe it is, but it's just. Thinking about how do we bring
- 1:34:17these concepts to the market in the way that they want to
- 1:34:20meeting them where they are, whether it's through custody,
- 1:34:22education or conversations like this.
- 1:34:24I think that they're really rare and it's just because we're so
- 1:34:27early, there's nothing really special about us.
- 1:34:28It's more that we're just early. So putting all those together
- 1:34:31right now, it's a little bit foreign, but over time, it'll
- 1:34:33just continue to be the norm. So I appreciate you joining in,
- 1:34:36coming on and giving us your expertise with the space.
- 1:34:40I appreciate what you guys are doing too.
- 1:34:42Thanks for including me. All right.
- 1:34:45We'll see everybody next week.