Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / IP, Image, and Design: Fashion Law Fundamentals Unzipped, Part II
Transcript
- 0:03Hi everyone, I'm so happy to be back here. So
- 0:09this is the second section, second kind of webinar,
- 0:13which is a wonderful webinar, by the way, of
- 0:15our new section, the fashion law, that I'm happy
- 0:18to chair. And here we have some of our most active
- 0:23members that are so much in the industry that
- 0:27we'll be able to give you a lot of insight and
- 0:30a lot of things that you can use during your
- 0:33practice and you can be really super useful.
- 0:36So let me introduce them. The first is Fabiana
- 0:39Zangara. Fabiana Zangara is a founding partner
- 0:42of Zaccalo. She's based in New York, and she
- 0:45works in Los Angeles as well. And she has an
- 0:48extensive experience in base. in employment -based
- 0:52immigration matters, so basically she takes care
- 0:55of companies, fashion companies, for example
- 0:58people that are key managers or directors of
- 1:01the company, they need to move here and there,
- 1:02from Europe especially, and she's able to take
- 1:05care of it in a wonderful way. She was previously
- 1:09in a large international firm in New York, and
- 1:12she holds JD from University of Rome and immigration
- 1:15law from Cardoso Law School, and she's a lawyer
- 1:17both in Italy and in New York. Then, Uduak Oduk
- 1:22is a fashion entertainment lawyer, is a former
- 1:26fashion model. And she's the founder of Fashion
- 1:30and Law, which is a boutique firm that serves
- 1:33fashion, music, film, and digital media industries.
- 1:36So she's a veteran in this industry. And she,
- 1:39I'm very happy to have her on board. She's a
- 1:40fantastic member of the fashion section. And
- 1:44she developed a lot of kind of content, both
- 1:50in San Francisco. place right and the west coast
- 1:55and so she was modeling law curriculum and created
- 1:58a first fashion law course in the California
- 2:00State University in Sacramento where she's based
- 2:03right. She advised on intellectual property licensing
- 2:06and talent agreements and cross -border deals.
- 2:10In particular with the Afro Beats music industry
- 2:13and she's a recognized speaker at institutions
- 2:15like SXSW sorry he's a long one and the Fashion
- 2:19Law Institute and the Wharton School. Then last
- 2:22but not least, my friend Vicky, Victoria Burke.
- 2:25She's a legislative reform advocate and privacy
- 2:28attorney that represent plaintiff in class action
- 2:31involving data breaches and consumer privacy
- 2:33violation. She authored the Speak Your Truth
- 2:36Act, which I'm very proud of you, Vicky, groundbreaking
- 2:40legislation protecting survivors of sexual assault
- 2:45from retaliatory defamation lawsuit, which has
- 2:49been enacted in multiple states and is advancing
- 2:52toward federal adoption. She's an adjunct law
- 2:55professor and author in the US Supreme Court
- 2:59H &M versus Unicolor case that I'm sure you very
- 3:03well know about that. And she bridges law, policy,
- 3:06and life experience to safeguard truth, autonomy,
- 3:09and voice. So guys, I think it's enough for me.
- 3:12And I can't wait to hear your beautiful presentation.
- 3:15Thank you to all. Thank you so much, Alessandra.
- 3:23Shall I? Okay, good. So nice to meet you, everybody.
- 3:30My name is Fabiana Zangara, and as Alessandra
- 3:33was saying, I'm the founding partner of Zaccalo,
- 3:37a full service immigration law firm based in
- 3:39New York. It's truly a pleasure to be here, and
- 3:43I'd like to thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association,
- 3:46the Fashion Law Section, and its president, Alessandra,
- 3:49for this wonderful opportunity. During my career,
- 3:53I've had the pleasure of working with many creatives
- 3:57from the world all over, from photographers to
- 4:01models, fashion designers, entrepreneurs. And
- 4:05what I love the most is helping them transform
- 4:09their vision into career opportunities in the
- 4:13United States. And today, I would like to share
- 4:17how immigration law interacts with fashion industry,
- 4:21sometimes as an obstacle, but more often as a
- 4:25bridge to build new opportunities in the US.
- 4:28And to start, let me ask you two questions. How
- 4:32many of you know someone in your fashion circle
- 4:36that started their journey here in the US on
- 4:39a visa? Or, on the contrary, how many of you
- 4:43know somebody that had to leave the country because
- 4:47of visa issues? I cannot see you, but I assume
- 4:51that many of you know someone that had to deal
- 4:54with visas. And that is exactly why immigration
- 4:59law matters in the fashion industry. Because
- 5:03behind every campaign, behind every collection
- 5:06or every show, there are people who needed a
- 5:10visa to be there. And in order to be more practical,
- 5:14I want to discuss with you and I want to show
- 5:16you some numbers about the global fashion market.
- 5:20So let's move on to the next slide, please. So
- 5:24those are the numbers for the global fashion
- 5:27market. In 2024, it was valued at 1 .77 trillion.
- 5:36And by the end of 2025, it is estimated to be
- 5:40worth 1 .84 trillion, which is approximately
- 5:441 .63 % of the world GDP. And by 2030, it is
- 5:51projected to be worth 2 .26 trillion. Those are
- 5:56huge numbers. But to remain in the US, let's
- 6:00take a look at some numbers from New York. So
- 6:05New York is definitely one of the undisputed
- 6:09capitals of the fashion industry. Just think
- 6:13about it. Approximately 900 fashion companies
- 6:17have headquarters in New York. And let's take
- 6:22a look at some numbers here. So over a population
- 6:25of 8 .4 million and a workforce of 4 .2 million
- 6:31in New York City only, approximately the 6 %
- 6:36of the workforce, which is 180 ,000 people, work
- 6:40in the fashion industry. And these are huge numbers.
- 6:45And that is why there are some basics that we
- 6:48cannot ignore. The first basic that we cannot
- 6:52ignore is, if we can please move to the next
- 6:56slide. The first basic that we can ignore is
- 7:02the fashion industry is global and therefore
- 7:06mobility is an essential part of the fashion
- 7:10industry. But also without proper visa strategies,
- 7:16opportunities are lost. and no visa, no jobs.
- 7:21It's that simple. And that is why immigration
- 7:25is really important, because it turns borders
- 7:28into bridges, bridges to new opportunities for
- 7:32talent from abroad here in the US. And I'd like
- 7:36to share with you two stories from my clients,
- 7:40actually. The first one is Elena's journey. So
- 7:46Elena started, if we can move to the next slide,
- 7:50please. So Elena started her journey here in
- 7:55the U .S. Elena is a brilliant Italian fashion
- 7:58designer. So she started their journey on a J
- 8:01-1 visa that is a trainee visa. eventually was
- 8:05able to secure an O1 visa that is a visa for
- 8:08people with extraordinary abilities and to self
- 8:11-petition her green card. Right now, Eleanor
- 8:14runs a famous studio in New York, fuels the local
- 8:18economy, and was able to secure partnership with
- 8:23very famous brands such as Nike, Adidas, and
- 8:27other famous brands. On the contrary, Amada's
- 8:31journey was a little bit different because Amada
- 8:35is a brilliant fashion model from South America.
- 8:38She came to the US with a tourist visa, looking
- 8:41for job opportunities, even though her visa did
- 8:44not allow her to work in the US. And so she was
- 8:48forced to leave the country and lost momentum,
- 8:51but also lost job opportunities. So what is the
- 8:55takeaway from those two stories? a proper visa
- 9:00strategy we like even talent can lose job opportunities
- 9:04in the US and so some of you may ask okay but
- 9:09what are the most common visa options and what
- 9:12are the visa options for somebody that wants
- 9:15to work in the fashion industry. I'm not here
- 9:20to be boring. We're not going to talk about the
- 9:22different visa requirements. I'm just here to
- 9:26mention some of them and I'm sure you are familiar
- 9:29with some of them. There is the O1 visa. that
- 9:32is kind of an haute couture visa because it's
- 9:35designed, it's tailored on your extraordinary
- 9:37abilities. Then we have the H1B, we have the
- 9:41J1 visa, we have the EB1A, the E2, the L1. But
- 9:47so how do you decide what is the best visa option
- 9:52in your case? So there are two different things
- 9:57to take into consideration when it comes to visa.
- 10:01The first one is the purpose of your trip. The
- 10:06purpose of your trip really makes the difference,
- 10:09but also the evidence that you have available
- 10:12really makes the difference as well. For example,
- 10:16for creatives, having evidence of press coverage,
- 10:21exhibitions, awards, contracts, it's essential.
- 10:25On the contrary, if you are a company willing
- 10:28to sponsor a visa, then you need to consider
- 10:31your ownership, your international presence,
- 10:33the number of employees that you have. So the
- 10:37takeaway here is one size doesn't fit all. There
- 10:40is not just one visa, but everybody should develop
- 10:44their own visa strategy and be focused on the
- 10:47evidence that they have available. So it's not
- 10:50just one visa, it's different visa strategies.
- 10:54Okay, let's please move to the next slide. So
- 10:58I'd like to talk right now about the most common
- 11:02mistakes and pitfalls and misconceptions. So
- 11:08the top three mistakes that I see, especially
- 11:10in the fashion industry, are first of all, waiting
- 11:14too long. Timing is of the essence, especially
- 11:18today, and having the right strategy in place
- 11:21really makes all the difference. So I cannot
- 11:25tell you how many clients wait until the last
- 11:27minute to think about their visa and to apply
- 11:30for their visa. So this is a waste and this may
- 11:35trigger not just delays, but may trigger losing
- 11:39job opportunities in the US. So don't do that.
- 11:42Take some time to... work on your visa case,
- 11:45and as soon as you realize that you need to travel
- 11:47to the U .S., it would be great to start working
- 11:50on your visa. The second most common mistake
- 11:53is under documenting. So sometimes professionals,
- 11:59especially talent and creative, think that talent
- 12:03speaks for itself. Unfortunately, this is not
- 12:07the case. USCIS doesn't know anything about the
- 12:10case, and they need evidence, such as, again,
- 12:13awards, contracts, press, to prove your extraordinary
- 12:16abilities or to prove how stable is your company.
- 12:19If you don't do that, this may jeopardize your
- 12:22case and trigger delays or, especially with the
- 12:26current administration, requests for further
- 12:28evidence that may lead to denials. So it's really
- 12:31important to collect as much evidence as you
- 12:34can in order to build your case. You need to
- 12:37treat your immigration petition like your immigration
- 12:42strategy as a brand strategy. It should be consistent,
- 12:47reliant, and backed up with evidence. The third
- 12:50common mistake is traveling without the right
- 12:53visa. It's definitely easier to secure a tourist
- 12:57visa. And if you are a citizen from some of the
- 13:01countries that allow ESTA, that is a visa waiver
- 13:04program, it's definitely easy to enter the country.
- 13:08But under those visa categories, you are not
- 13:11allowed to work. And if you do so, this may jeopardize
- 13:14your future entry in the United States. So it's
- 13:18definitely... not worth the risk. Now, when it
- 13:22comes to misconceptions, I have selected three
- 13:26that are really common and come up all the time.
- 13:30The first one is you need a sponsor for every
- 13:34visa. And this is not the case. I've mentioned
- 13:37before Elena's journey. So she was able to self
- 13:40-petition her green card, that is the EB1A. So
- 13:43for some visas, sponsors are necessary, but not
- 13:47every time. The second common misconception is
- 13:52if you're not Gucci, you do not qualify for a
- 13:55visa with extraordinary abilities. And again,
- 13:58this is not true neither. Why is that? Because
- 14:02we are able to prove extraordinary abilities
- 14:05at every level. You don't have to work just for
- 14:07a luxury brand in order to secure a visa or to
- 14:11prove your extraordinary abilities provided that
- 14:14you have evidence, good evidence to prove them.
- 14:17And last but not least, another myth is you need
- 14:22to invest a million in order to secure an investor
- 14:26visa. That is false. We were able to secure visas
- 14:31for our clients and they have invested a much
- 14:34lower amount. Remember, the law only requires
- 14:38the amount to be substantial, does not specify
- 14:41a particular amount of money to be invested.
- 14:44So the amount is substantial if depending on
- 14:49the project and depending on the business plan.
- 14:52So we cannot determine before whether you are
- 14:54eligible or not, but definitely investing a million
- 14:58is not mandatory. Now, I have selected for you
- 15:04a few current challenges for talent and fashion
- 15:09companies, especially right now, today. So the
- 15:14first one is unfortunately longer processing
- 15:17time because immigration petitions right now
- 15:22are under strict scrutiny and sometimes like
- 15:26an increasing and a growing backlog may trigger
- 15:29longer processing time. So this is definitely
- 15:32one of the current challenges. The second one
- 15:36is higher USCIS filing fees. Just to give you
- 15:40an example, the O1 visa is the most common visa
- 15:44or among the most common visas in the fashion
- 15:47industry. And before, the filing fees, the USCIS
- 15:53filing fees related to O -1 visas were $460.
- 15:57Right now, if the sponsor is an employer with
- 16:01less than 25 employees, it's around $830. If
- 16:05it's a sponsor with more than 25 employees, it's
- 16:09much more. So this is definitely a challenge
- 16:12for talents, not to mention that if you want
- 16:15to opt for premium processing, there is an additional
- 16:18fee of $2 ,805. So like higher filing fees are
- 16:24a current challenge. And this is strictly connected
- 16:27to the third challenge, finding a sponsor, because
- 16:30right now, model agencies and companies may be
- 16:36a little bit more cautious and skeptical when
- 16:38it comes to sponsoring new talents. And then
- 16:42the fourth and last challenge that I want to
- 16:46mention are tariffs. That is the elephant in
- 16:48the room. because tariffs, of course, raise costs
- 16:51on imported goods and have a negative impact
- 16:55on surging and sales in fashion. So those are
- 16:59the four core challenges today. And okay, but
- 17:04how do we overcome the hurdles? And here are
- 17:08three pieces of advice that I give to my clients
- 17:12all the time. First of all, plan your collection.
- 17:16Having the right visa strategy would avoid delays
- 17:20because, as I was saying, timing is of the essence.
- 17:24So work on your visa strategy. The second advice
- 17:28that I would like to give you... is mix your
- 17:32looks, meaning do not focus just on one visa
- 17:37type, but try to consider multiple visa options.
- 17:40Speak with an immigration attorney that can guide
- 17:42you, because by doing this, perhaps, and being
- 17:46flexible, some doors that may have been closed
- 17:50may be open for you. So like considering different
- 17:53visa options may definitely be a good thing for
- 17:57you. And last but not least, showcase your best
- 18:00pieces. Spend time on collecting the right evidence.
- 18:04Work on that because like your cases should be
- 18:08treated as like plenty of evidence should be
- 18:12collected to support your achievements. USCIS
- 18:14doesn't know anything about your case. And those
- 18:17immigration petitions are kind of storytelling
- 18:20where you need to explain your story to the officers.
- 18:24If you don't do that, that may be an issue. And
- 18:27as I was saying, this may trigger delays and
- 18:30requests for further evidence. And now, to close
- 18:34this conversation, I want to share with you a
- 18:38thought that I share with my clients as well.
- 18:41The future belongs to those who are ready to
- 18:44cross borders and embrace new opportunities.
- 18:47Thank you so much for your attention. It's been
- 18:51a pleasure to be here. Please feel free to contact
- 18:54me if you have any questions or you need any
- 18:57advice. And I'll now leave the floor to my colleague,
- 19:02Uduak. Thank you so much. Thank you so much.
- 19:06What an awesome presentation, Fabiana, and great
- 19:08way to take the baton and run with it to focus
- 19:12in on the talent model more specifically and
- 19:16on a domestic front. So let me start first with
- 19:20saying my background as introduced former fashion
- 19:23model. turn fashion and entertainment lawyers.
- 19:26So I had an opportunity to really view things
- 19:29from a diverse perspective, but not only that
- 19:32diverse perspective, but also see the intersection
- 19:35of fashion, film and music all coming to play.
- 19:39And where I want to begin is the question that's
- 19:43often always asked of me. And that question is,
- 19:47how do you get into the fashion industry? How
- 19:48do you become a fashion lawyer? And specific
- 19:52to models, please, if you could advance the slides
- 19:55to control of image. So specific to models, the
- 20:01first thing, and just generally as the fashion
- 20:03industry is, as a lawyer, it's important to understand
- 20:06that we're in the business of fashion. So you
- 20:09have to understand the business, not just the
- 20:12law. And specific to models, focus on control
- 20:15of image equals control of value. So what does
- 20:18that mean? In the fashion, modeling industry,
- 20:22a model's image, their likeness, their photos,
- 20:24their name and persona is their product. So whoever
- 20:28legally controls how that image is used, licensed
- 20:32or sold, ultimately controls where the money
- 20:34and power goes. And as a lawyer, it becomes your
- 20:38responsibility to know agencies, platforms, media,
- 20:42and the law so you can properly manage the contracts,
- 20:46publicity, and digital risk associated with that.
- 20:52So focusing in on the legal issues across the
- 20:56fashion value chain. Well, I think we just initially
- 20:59talked about the basic fashion value chain as
- 21:02a way of knowing that. So there are four stages
- 21:04of the basic fashion value chain. Number one,
- 21:07raw materials. Number two, design and manufacturing.
- 21:11Number three, distribution and retail. Number
- 21:13four, the auxiliary services. I'm zooming in
- 21:15on auxiliary services for purposes of time so
- 21:19that my colleague Victoria will have enough time
- 21:21to cover her part. So for auxiliary services,
- 21:25we are talking about marketing, media, trade,
- 21:29associations, product testing, advertising, and
- 21:31consulting. Then we get into the legal issues
- 21:34across the value chain that are associated with
- 21:37each stage. I want you to look at auxiliary services
- 21:41specific to what we're dealing with, advertising
- 21:44law, right of publicity, influencer liability,
- 21:47and unfair competition. Zooming in even more
- 21:50on that, what are the typical clients that you
- 21:52will be serving? Typical clients that are in
- 21:55that space, brands, retailers. advertising and
- 21:59marketing agencies, media and that includes publishing
- 22:02companies, influencers models, testing and certification
- 22:06providers. Let's talk a little bit about where
- 22:09to find fashion models. Often people focus on
- 22:12traditional spaces and the reason that that's
- 22:14relevant for you as an attorney, as you're thinking
- 22:17about representation or getting into fashion
- 22:20law as a whole. is you don't want to limit it
- 22:22to just traditional spaces. You want to look
- 22:24at digital platforms, AI, and future modeling.
- 22:27And why is that important to broaden your understanding?
- 22:30Because when you understand where models come
- 22:32from, you're now focusing in on the sourcing,
- 22:36which determines the rights that you're going
- 22:38to protect and the safeguards that you're going
- 22:39to build into your contract or contract negotiation
- 22:43for the model. So for example, if you are looking
- 22:46at traditional spaces, then you necessarily will
- 22:49invoke the California Talent Agencies Act. And
- 22:52what does that act do? It requires licensing,
- 22:55approved contract forms, trust accounts, and
- 22:57fiduciary duties. We'll get a little bit more
- 22:59into that. So it's so, so important to know where
- 23:02fashion models can be found and how that ultimately
- 23:05affects how you negotiate. So let's transition
- 23:08to the first core relationship that a model encounters
- 23:11in the industry. The very first one is the model
- 23:16agency relationships. Oh, I could tell stories
- 23:19for days. But in the interest of time, let me
- 23:22focus in on one of the key issues we see here.
- 23:26In this particular instance, when you look at
- 23:29France, France categorizes models as employees.
- 23:33The UK categorizes models as independent contractors,
- 23:36and the US does the same. But with that comes,
- 23:40needless to say, a lot of abusive practices.
- 23:43Some of it you probably have seen or heard in
- 23:46the news. So what have we done to try to remedy
- 23:50that for the first time in a very, very historical
- 23:53way? You have New York that is enacted, New York's
- 23:57Fashion Workers Act. And what it is is a very
- 23:59comprehensive act that gives rights to models
- 24:04in a way we haven't seen before. The rights include
- 24:06deal memos, contract access, capped agency commissions
- 24:10at 20%, overtime pay after eight hours, meal
- 24:14breaks, and the list goes on. let me actually
- 24:17even get it focusing on a few more things. It
- 24:22used to be you go for a job assignment and then
- 24:26next thing thing you know might take another
- 24:28six months before you get paid. The New York
- 24:31Fashion Workers Act allows you, as a model, mandates
- 24:34that you must be paid within 45 days of completing
- 24:37your services. And deductions require consent.
- 24:41So agencies can no longer sort of deduct everything.
- 24:43And by the time you get it, you barely have anything
- 24:45to show for your work. There are term limits
- 24:48on the contracts. Contracts are limited to three
- 24:50years. You can't have automatic renewals without
- 24:53written consent, which used to be the case before.
- 24:55a lot of abuses in that way. In terms of artificial
- 24:58intelligence, which we'll cover a little bit
- 25:00on, you need written consent. And that's required
- 25:04for creation or use of digital replicas or AI
- 25:07images. A big, big issue. health, safety, and
- 25:11harassment. I can't tell you all the many times
- 25:15you're backstage changing, whether for a New
- 25:17York Fashion Week show or wherever the location
- 25:20of the show is, and you just have random people
- 25:22just walk backstage. They don't really care.
- 25:25They think somehow by virtue of sometimes purchasing
- 25:28the ticket to be VIP or whatever, it gives them
- 25:30access to come into the dressing room, which
- 25:32models have a problem with, but for a long time,
- 25:35their voices have been ignored. It's sort of
- 25:37like your clothes hanger, change clothes. and
- 25:39go and nobody cares really what's happening to
- 25:42you. So New York is sort of taking care of that
- 25:45part among other things. It requires that you
- 25:48have a right to safe working conditions, breaks
- 25:50and freedom from discrimination or harassment
- 25:53as a whole. California doesn't have a carved
- 25:55out New York type fashion workers act, but it
- 25:58sort of protects models through labor and employment
- 26:02laws, which we'll talk about briefly. So. Having
- 26:05said that, another key one is the Coogan Laws.
- 26:10Coogan Laws is specifically focused on, it's
- 26:14named after child actor Jackie Coogan who earned
- 26:18millions in the 1920s only to discover as an
- 26:20adult that his parents had spent nearly all of
- 26:23it. His lawsuit led to California enacting the
- 26:26first Coogan law and ultimately, and that was
- 26:28in 1939, and ultimately a lot of states have
- 26:31adopted it. I'm going to zoom in on California.
- 26:34New York has adopted it, Illinois, Louisiana.
- 26:37in Mexico, but zooming in on California, California
- 26:41requires a blocked trust account, and that's
- 26:44required for minors in entertainment and modeling
- 26:46contracts. And then what the percentile amount
- 26:49that will be withheld or expected to be withheld,
- 26:5215 % of the gross earnings that must be set aside,
- 26:56that must be, that amount must be deposited within
- 26:5915 business days of wages and applies to child
- 27:02performers, including models as of January 1st,
- 27:052025. So part of that is an expansion to include
- 27:09child influencers in online content. So we're
- 27:13making a lot of progress there, and there's similar
- 27:15laws specific to the Coogan law in other jurisdictions
- 27:20as set. So what is the practice tip for you to
- 27:24really zoom in on that? ensure that when you're
- 27:29drafting those contracts, they're auditable,
- 27:31auditable agreements. Also ensure that the enforceable
- 27:34protections for minors really zoom in on minors.
- 27:37There's a lot of abuse. I got into the industry
- 27:39at 14 years old and I can tell you a lot of what
- 27:42I saw, you know, we would be all gaps in right
- 27:46now. So it's very, very important that you focus
- 27:49in and protect minors as you negotiate these
- 27:52deals and ensure that they're those enforceable
- 27:55protections as well. All right, so let's transition
- 27:58into photography and models and intellectual
- 28:02property rights. Photographers as a whole own
- 28:05their copyrights and models rely on the publicity
- 28:08rights. So there's always been a huge struggle
- 28:11with respect to, okay, what does that really
- 28:13mean for model rights? And more specifically
- 28:18states that have adopted a right of publicity
- 28:21with the specific conflict to our California
- 28:23with the California Civil Code, Section 3344.
- 28:27New York has adopted, Tennessee has adopted,
- 28:30Indiana has adopted, as well as for all those
- 28:33states I mentioned, including post -modern rights.
- 28:35Other states don't necessarily have that. So
- 28:38you're dealing with federalism to some extent,
- 28:42actually to a large extent, federal law, which
- 28:44one trumps, does federal law trumps state law,
- 28:47copyright law, is certainly more significant
- 28:50than state law with respect to writer publicity.
- 28:54For writer publicity cases, I wanted to highlight
- 28:56a few key ones to underscore the challenges with
- 29:00that and then talk about a little bit of the
- 29:03takeaway there. Russell versus Marlboro Books
- 29:06is a case that came out of New York in 1959.
- 29:09The model's photo was used beyond the scope of
- 29:12her signed consent. The image was altered and
- 29:14reused again. The legal issue there was whether
- 29:17the use of photographed outside the limits of
- 29:20written release violates New York's privacy and
- 29:23publicity rights. The court there denied the
- 29:26motion to dismiss, found that the release did
- 29:28not permit altered or additional uses beyond
- 29:30its scope. And so then we move onto the Canby
- 29:34Enterprises versus Matthews Matter. And that
- 29:37particular case was where a website had reproduced
- 29:40copyrighted erotic photos of models without permission.
- 29:44And the plaintiff there owned both copyright
- 29:46and publicity rights. And the issue there was
- 29:48whether a state right of publicity claim under
- 29:51California Civil Code Section 3344 is preempted
- 29:55by federal copyright law. The court reversed
- 29:57that under summary judgment motion and held that
- 30:01Section 3344. did not preempt because likeness
- 30:06rights are different and distinct from copyright.
- 30:09Then you got the O 'Neill case as well. In that
- 30:11case, that was a photographer that sued a model
- 30:15for posting his paparazzi photo on Instagram.
- 30:18By the way, that's becoming a very common, common,
- 30:20common scenario. And the question was whether
- 30:25in reposting the paparazzi photo of oneself,
- 30:28is that copyright infringement or fair use? And
- 30:30the court found that, you know, it was essentially
- 30:33infringement and she could not use the... Actually,
- 30:38the court didn't find that. They settled that
- 30:40issue. But when that issue keeps coming up, we
- 30:43see that federal copyright trumps the right of
- 30:47publicity. Similar... cases as well for the Ariana
- 30:52Grande situation and also the exposure photo
- 30:55agency involving Bella Hadid, as you can see
- 30:58in that slide. Practice tip here when you're
- 31:02looking at negotiating this specific type of
- 31:05deals, focus on licensing both the copyright
- 31:07and the publicity rights, ensure to define the
- 31:11scope, the media, the term, reposting, and AI.
- 31:15Let's go into another key brand relationship,
- 31:18and that is models, brand, and legal compliance.
- 31:21The issue here is usually involving the FTC.
- 31:26It's involving also how models are posting, specifically
- 31:30how they're collaborating with brands to ensure
- 31:33that they limit legal liability, but at the same
- 31:36time do what they're supposed to do. Models have
- 31:39been really expanded in terms of the definition.
- 31:42It's not just fashion models now, it's influence
- 31:44as it's celebrities. Several cases to look at.
- 31:47I just gave you a synopsis, but the citations
- 31:49are in the slides, so please reference that if
- 31:54you want more details. Fire versus Kendall Jenner,
- 31:57that was where the FTC disclosure failure and
- 32:03deceptive advertising. That was a very big case
- 32:05that ultimately, not only made headlines, but
- 32:09got Kendall Jenner into trouble because she was
- 32:14hyping a fire festival that did not happen and
- 32:18basically was fraudulent and had deprived people
- 32:22of lots and lots and lots of money. So essentially
- 32:27the thing there was FTC disclosure failure equal
- 32:30deceptive advertising. The Altra versus Michelle
- 32:33Fan case include involve the copyright infringement
- 32:36for unlicensed music in YouTube videos. And if
- 32:39you're going to use music in videos, even as
- 32:42an influencer, you do need permission for that.
- 32:44The Petunia case saw a fashion model on social
- 32:47media advertising for a brand. They worked out
- 32:50the brand deal. But in the process of her using
- 32:53the hashtag for brow boost versus brow brow boost,
- 32:57it turns out that she was infringing or allegedly
- 33:01infringing on the trademark of the defendant
- 33:03who sued. And ultimately, that matter was, I
- 33:06believe, settled. So practice tape there. Build
- 33:09a compliance stack. Make sure you have your trademark
- 33:12clearances, especially if you're working with
- 33:15talent. Ensure that the copyright licenses are
- 33:19declared. Ensure that there's FTC disclosure.
- 33:22And, of course, include those necessary indemnity
- 33:25clauses so that you don't have a client that
- 33:26has to deal. with those kind of issues just by
- 33:29virtue of occupying exclusively an influencer
- 33:33role. All right, so let's transition into the
- 33:36models, discrimination, and health laws. In that
- 33:39particular case, the issue there is industry
- 33:43that pressures unhealthy body standards. Of course,
- 33:47unfortunately, what flows from that is also issues
- 33:50of harassment and lack of wage compliance. In
- 33:54France, we do see a situation where France has
- 33:58been very aggressive in ensuring that if you
- 34:01are going to have an image of a fashion model,
- 34:05it shows that there have been alterations done
- 34:09and you properly label that in fact an alteration
- 34:13has happened there. For that, we look at some
- 34:21of the cases that might be helpful. I would say
- 34:25even when a modeling engagement is structured
- 34:27as a photo shoot, just generally as a practice
- 34:30to think about, or an influencer campaign always
- 34:33treated like a workplace. apply wage safety and
- 34:37harassment prevention standards, require all
- 34:40vendors and agencies to comply with California
- 34:42labor laws. And so let's specifically run through
- 34:44a few of those labor laws, AB 2338. Actually,
- 34:50I'll just focus on two for time purposes. AB
- 34:532338, and that was enacted in 2018, effective
- 34:582019. The focus there was model safety and harassment
- 35:01prevention training that passed. So now talent
- 35:04agencies must provide sexual harassment prevention
- 35:08and retaliation training to models before job
- 35:11placement. I'll also focus on AB 2539, even though
- 35:16that did not pass, but the goal was to try to
- 35:18get us to a place where we have better laws governing
- 35:22health, safety, and body image standards. The
- 35:26idea there was that it would have required nutrition
- 35:28or health education and transparency around photo
- 35:31retouching. Then we've got California label code
- 35:35section 201 to 204, and that's timely payment
- 35:40of wages. Most of you are probably familiar with
- 35:43that. There's AB5 that recently passed that would
- 35:46technically have models seen more as an employee,
- 35:50but it doesn't apply to printing as well as runway
- 35:53models. All right, so let's get into wrapping
- 35:57things up with looking at AI and its impact on
- 36:00models, and hopefully that leaves enough time
- 36:02for Victoria to speak. I just want to highlight
- 36:05a few things here with models and AI and digital
- 36:08rights. The issue here is AI tools replicating
- 36:11likeness without consent or compensation, and
- 36:14then how do you discuss the scope of publicity
- 36:17rights, which remain. really, really unsettled.
- 36:20And there are several cases to look at as well.
- 36:24One key one is the Kyland Young versus neocortex
- 36:27case, the 2023 case where the dispute was over,
- 36:30unauthorized. likeness and use in a reface app.
- 36:34That's still an ongoing situation. Another one,
- 36:37just no litigation, but made headlines, and you
- 36:39can see the image there, which is the Jing Nang
- 36:42Zhang incident, where the artist and model essentially
- 36:47had unauthorized deep fake likeness published
- 36:49in AI tools. Practice tip, AI is a big thing.
- 36:53Insert those AI clauses in contracts. Clause
- 36:55clauses should expressly cover explicit consent.
- 37:00digital replicas, revocation rights, and labeling.
- 37:04Let's see a little bit of the controversy that's
- 37:06been happening as a result of that is AI modeling,
- 37:09the world's first digital supermodel, and a lot
- 37:11of models are concerned about what that means
- 37:13for their jobs. And of course, if you're negotiating
- 37:16appropriately, then you know that you're carving
- 37:19out those right of publicity rights and being
- 37:21able to ensure that that model gets paid by virtue
- 37:24of the image being used to train AI, for example.
- 37:27Same with the AI modeling guess scenario, which
- 37:30is a huge controversy where you had this particular
- 37:33agency, Sarah Finn -Valora, create this image
- 37:37for guess purposes, for guess the brand, and
- 37:40using it as commercial editorial. in a fashion
- 37:44magazine Vogue, of course, it raised a lot of
- 37:47concerns about not only beauty standards, but
- 37:49the replacement of models. Recent times in the
- 37:52film industry, we've seen the Tilly Norwood that's
- 37:55made headlines in recent times. and what the
- 37:58implications are for image and likeness, set
- 38:00after issue in a statement saying Tilly Northwood
- 38:04is not an actor, has no life experience to draw
- 38:06from, no emotions. And there are already rules,
- 38:10just like we saw in New York, that are mandating
- 38:13and making it clear. that if you are going to
- 38:17use images of talents for AI purposes, synthetic
- 38:22talents, you have to negotiate a completely different
- 38:25deal and also get consent. So compensation and
- 38:29consent are critical. And another really, really
- 38:32big issue that we've seen in the music space
- 38:35is the AI. AI artist Zania Monet, who recently
- 38:39signed a multi -million dollar record deal. And
- 38:41I think for me, the key thing is just addressing
- 38:43the issue of AI monetization. What does that
- 38:46mean? What does the compensation scheme look
- 38:49like? And how do we carve it out looking at the
- 38:51core way that we essentially monetize intellectual
- 38:56property? So licensing and assignment of rights,
- 38:59what does that look like? I think that's where
- 39:01attorneys will really have to grapple with things.
- 39:06Then conclusion, practice deep summary. I've
- 39:08already talked about those. In essence, distinguish
- 39:13copyright from publicity rights, draft precise
- 39:15verifiable contracts so compliance can be tracked,
- 39:19and enforce compliance with FTC labor and health
- 39:21standards, monitor digital use and AI replicas.
- 39:25In fashion law and in fashion modeling law as
- 39:28well, images value and auxiliary services are
- 39:31where lawyers lock in that value for the clients
- 39:34they represent. Thank you so much. And on that
- 39:36note, I will pass it on to my colleague, Victoria
- 39:39Burke, to cover the legislative aspect. Thank
- 39:42you. Well, we're noticing more and more with
- 39:49fashion apparel that a lot of the issues are
- 39:52being addressed in legislation. They'll introduce
- 39:57a law or something to correct an issue that's
- 40:01been ongoing. And one of the biggest driving
- 40:04forces of this new, you know, tidal wave of legislation
- 40:10and addressing the fashion issue is fast fashion.
- 40:13And you have probably heard of fast fashion and
- 40:16all of its issues. But one of the critical issues
- 40:20is it's mass producing. a lot of apparel and
- 40:24garments and so they're trying to figure out
- 40:26how do we deal with this because it's using up
- 40:28a lot of environmental sources, it's using questionable
- 40:32dyeing and different ingredients and you know
- 40:36they're trying to keep track of for health reasons
- 40:38and what happens to the fashion and so we're
- 40:41seeing this with the first law is California
- 40:44AB 405 and it was enacted this year and it's
- 40:48the Fashion Environmental Accountability Act.
- 40:52And this one is important because it's having
- 40:55fashion sellers are required to disclose their
- 40:59supply chain and that hasn't really happened
- 41:02before where now you're having to disclose like
- 41:06who exactly is handling the dyeing of the clothing
- 41:10or the finishing of the printing and the washing
- 41:12and their techniques that go into it there hasn't
- 41:16been this level of oversight or delving into
- 41:20exactly what goes into the manufacturing of the
- 41:23clothing. And now they're having to report it
- 41:26to the Department of Toxic Substances Control
- 41:28and the State Air Resources Board. And they would
- 41:31have to submit these annually. The tier one suppliers
- 41:34are where they are starting. But that's something
- 41:38that as a fashion retailer, you got to think
- 41:41of, have we taken into account what is happening
- 41:44at every stage of our clothing. Could be that
- 41:48maybe you use a different country and just kind
- 41:51of trusted their manufacturing process and didn't
- 41:54really pay that much attention. Maybe you paid
- 41:56attention to what dyes were used, what chemicals,
- 42:00but maybe didn't realize like... different states
- 42:03might allow certain things and it might have
- 42:06negative implications down the road. And now
- 42:08there's accountability that's coming along with
- 42:10it. It's kind of catching up with the fast introduction.
- 42:13And you'll see a lot of laws are coming in through
- 42:16California because California is pretty much
- 42:20fast fashion centered and fast production versus
- 42:25New York, which is more runway. in that type
- 42:29of fashion. So you'll see the laws sometimes
- 42:32will reflect different issues as the states come
- 42:36across it. And if you can go to the next slide.
- 42:40And you'll see that this is a great demonstration
- 42:43of the impact to the environment from fast fashion.
- 42:48If you can see and zoom in, this is like the
- 42:52clothing dump in the Atacama Desert in Chile.
- 42:55So basically, companies are having people just
- 43:00use their clothes and just like, instead of like
- 43:03keeping them or reselling them, they're so cheap.
- 43:07A lot of people are just discarding them throwing
- 43:09them out. And so a lot of times if they don't
- 43:11sell one season or if they have extras left over,
- 43:15or however it can be, they'll have all these
- 43:18like articles of clothing and what do you do
- 43:21with them? And so one of the ways they have found
- 43:24of disposium is literally taking them to this
- 43:26desert and just dump them there because the country
- 43:29has made a contract that this is something, you
- 43:31know, economically they benefit from. However,
- 43:35this is a photograph from space. That's how big
- 43:37it is. You can actually see the amount of clothing
- 43:40from outer space. It's getting out of control.
- 43:43So that's why a lot of states are wanting to
- 43:48address some of these issues. Next slide. And
- 43:53so California has introduced SB 707. It was enacted
- 43:57in 2024 and it's called responsible. textile
- 44:01recovery act and it's going toward what do we
- 44:05do if all these like extra clothing and so much
- 44:08you know, manufactured goods from fast fashion
- 44:11is just flooding in. So the program is meant
- 44:13to divert like textiles from residential and
- 44:16commercial waste and figure out another way to
- 44:19dispose them. So one of the ways is this law
- 44:22is encouraging producers to create a plan of
- 44:25how to collect, repair and recycle their products.
- 44:28Different companies you'll often see might offer
- 44:31you incentives if you bring back your clothing
- 44:34that they will give you a discount at their store.
- 44:37to continue shopping, but therefore it will likely
- 44:41be recycled, some of this clothing, or they'll
- 44:44try to figure out a different way to use it.
- 44:46And the bill was first introduced to apply to
- 44:49apparel and textiles that were unsuitable and
- 44:53reuse in their current conditions, such as footwear,
- 44:56swimwear, undergarments. And so you would not
- 44:59be able to resell these, ordinarily at least,
- 45:03unless to a very niche market. So therefore,
- 45:07how do we handle disposal of these products?
- 45:10And some of the key mandates is that they will
- 45:13have producer responsibility, and they'll have
- 45:18to check in and figure out how to institute different
- 45:22resource recycling programs that will recover
- 45:25it and manage this. Next slide, please. Now,
- 45:31New York has been trying and trying and trying,
- 45:34trying, trying to have similar laws. One of them
- 45:37is called the Fashion Sustainability and Social
- 45:40Accountability Act. They've reintroduced it multiple
- 45:42times. Having had my own law passed, I have learned
- 45:47at different states sometimes it takes multiple
- 45:49times to be introduced before it's finally passed
- 45:51into law. But this is another one where it targets
- 45:55the supply chain and it's introducing transparency
- 45:59and due diligence. So as someone who is involved
- 46:03in the legal field with fashion, you want to
- 46:06consider it. When you advise the client, you
- 46:09have these plans in mind when going forward because
- 46:12they might have to present them like, OK, so
- 46:15you're, you know. producing all these clothing
- 46:18from where? How are your suppliers getting their
- 46:21chemicals and what do they do? You want to have
- 46:25it laid out at least as oversight that you advise
- 46:27the clients and be aware that certain states
- 46:30have implications from these and they might have
- 46:32fines if there isn't compliance and the more
- 46:36states that tag on these laws and they're a little
- 46:39bit different, it kind of leads to hard to navigate
- 46:43to make sure like we're compliant in one state,
- 46:45we're not compliant in another because there's
- 46:47no federal law yet for something like this, though
- 46:50they are trying. Next slide please. And then
- 46:56you had the Federal Volunteer Labeling Act, and
- 46:59this is proposed, not enacted, and it would establish
- 47:03EPA -led sustainable apparel labeling program
- 47:06at the federal level. Now, this is interesting
- 47:08where you're kind of letting the fashion suppliers
- 47:13and sellers do it themselves, like introduce
- 47:17their own guidelines of like, we'll label it
- 47:19and we'll say it. But one of the issues with
- 47:22a law like that is you might have heard the term
- 47:25greenwashing, where they'll be like, our clothes
- 47:27are recyclable or made from recycled products.
- 47:30But it doesn't really say how much a recycled
- 47:32product you have to use in order to qualify to
- 47:35be able to say this. What if you have one percent
- 47:38of your clothing or the aspects of your clothing
- 47:41are actually recycled materials? So can you say
- 47:44like this is from recycled materials or this
- 47:47one is like very safe? We have seen this issue.
- 47:50There's the with vegan leather is one of those
- 47:53that it's often being pushed as like an alternative,
- 47:57but vegan leather. some of you may not know is
- 47:59petroleum based. So the oil companies think like,
- 48:03yes, let's push this as like the greatest thing
- 48:05because like it's easier to recycle petroleum
- 48:08goods than it is some other goods. And so you'll
- 48:11see different ones will say we're environmentally
- 48:13good, but you have to look at who is promoting
- 48:16the environmental good. And it's a lot of times
- 48:19it's an interesting like background company,
- 48:22like maybe the oil industry is actually behind
- 48:24it. So you'll see certain types of goods being
- 48:27pushed. but you have to think of who's pushing
- 48:29these goods and who is the one who wants the
- 48:31labeling and what does it actually mean, this
- 48:35labeling, because it might not actually be as
- 48:38it's said, it might not be environmental. And
- 48:42then on the other end, you're having a different
- 48:44type of reaction of something called green hushing,
- 48:47where people are getting worried about being
- 48:50sued different companies for false claiming like
- 48:55we are great for the environment. And some people
- 48:57are suing as this is false advertising and misleading.
- 49:00And so some companies are worried about being
- 49:03sued. And so they are starting to do green hushing
- 49:06where they're not mentioning all the programs
- 49:08that they're doing to have their clothes recycled
- 49:11or the materials they get from because they have
- 49:13fear that they're going to be overly broad or
- 49:16overstated. somehow end up into litigation, which
- 49:19multiple companies have seen. So it's an interesting
- 49:22thing when you put it back on the companies,
- 49:24which is basically, if it's voluntary labeling,
- 49:28it could incentivize consumers to make conscientious
- 49:31choices. But then again, you have to look into
- 49:34who is controlling the label and if they're controlling
- 49:37the rating, are they actually benefiting from
- 49:39the rating system? Like I said, the petroleum
- 49:42one. Next slide. This is an interesting one.
- 49:48This is from California. It's SB 62. It's Garment
- 49:52Worker Protection Act. What's interesting is
- 49:58that in California, you wouldn't believe how
- 50:02poorly some of the workers are treated. You don't
- 50:05need to even go to a different country to find
- 50:08workers being abused. And I've done a lot of
- 50:11pro bono work also for the apparel industry.
- 50:15And it's interesting to see that a lot of abuses
- 50:18do happen in our own city. For example, in one
- 50:23case, a contractor in Los Angeles had paid garment
- 50:28workers as little as $1 .58 per hour. because
- 50:31they're doing piece rate wages. So maybe if you
- 50:34have an intricate outfit that takes a lot of
- 50:37sewing and you only do like one an hour and you're
- 50:40paid like a dollar something an hour to get it
- 50:42done, you're only making $1 .58. No matter how
- 50:45long you work on it, it's like, oh, you only
- 50:47get paid for that one item. I mean, if you're
- 50:51making like little itty bitty. things that go
- 50:54very fast, you can make more. So now they're
- 50:57making it so it's like you still get an hourly
- 50:59wage and you don't have to rely on just piece
- 51:02rate. And that's just what's enacted in 2022.
- 51:06So changes are coming, but they're taking a while
- 51:09to get there. But again, if you see, California
- 51:12is leading the charge on that. And that's because
- 51:15we have so many fashion, you know, producing.
- 51:19like I was going to say, not sweatshops, but
- 51:21factories here. But we still have to police them
- 51:24and look carefully. And one of the ways that
- 51:26we're doing that is through legislation. And
- 51:28again, as a fashion lawyer or someone advising
- 51:33someone, you want to be careful about who they
- 51:35employ for the labor. Make sure they're doing
- 51:38the practices that should be. You'd be amazed
- 51:41to find out that they have full understanding
- 51:43of what is required by law, but they are actually
- 51:46not doing that. Next slide. Switching gears a
- 51:52little, this has been a proposed law, the federal
- 51:55design piracy protection. This was proposed but
- 51:58never enacted for federal protection of fashion
- 52:01designs because you see how many types of fashion
- 52:04designs are on the runway and then all of a sudden
- 52:06they're at 4 over 21 and all these other ones,
- 52:09shian .com and they all look alike. This was
- 52:12intended to help. extend like a copyright protection
- 52:16for three years for fashion design products.
- 52:19The problem is that there's such a quick turnover
- 52:21that wasn't in season today, it's not in season
- 52:24tomorrow. So whether or not people would want
- 52:26to register their designs or pay all that money
- 52:28to do that, if it's maybe a design that's not
- 52:30going to go anywhere, it ended up not being like
- 52:34enacted. I think there is a lot of pushback and
- 52:36also in an industry where Even the people who
- 52:39are against, you know, counterfeits do tend to
- 52:42borrow sometimes from each other. Like, where
- 52:45does inspiration begin? It's very hard. I mean,
- 52:48current copyright laws protect pattern designs.
- 52:53If something could be removed from an outfit
- 52:55and like if you could hang it almost like an
- 52:57art in that kind of design, then that's protected.
- 53:01But it has some protection, but not complete.
- 53:04Next slide. What's interesting is Michigan has
- 53:10been one of the first states to enact an anti
- 53:13-counterfeit law that was enacted in 2024. It
- 53:17makes it a misdemeanor to knowingly purchase
- 53:19or possess counterfeit goods. This is a change.
- 53:22Usually, the consumer is not held accountable.
- 53:25It's those who are selling it to the consumer.
- 53:28This is the first change in the U .S. in the
- 53:30first state that has enacted. It's surprising
- 53:32to be Michigan. I would expect a different state,
- 53:35but you have to be aware. now if you're in Michigan
- 53:38and you go somewhere and you're like you are
- 53:40knowingly buying something you could have like
- 53:43a be fined up to a year in jail to probably depending
- 53:46on how much you are buying and so this is one
- 53:49of the first times that they're actually putting
- 53:51this on the consumer. Next slide. And this is
- 53:57also, Italy was one of the first to prohibit
- 53:59sales, import even personal possession of counterfeit
- 54:02goods. And so this, they will enforce it against
- 54:04tourists. And I was just in Italy last month.
- 54:07I remember telling my friends like, don't buy
- 54:08anything that you think is counterfeit. Like
- 54:10they have laws against it and they have like
- 54:12really high fines of like a thousand euros to
- 54:1512 ,000 euros. And like, we don't want to get
- 54:18tied up in this, but it's interesting. Like the
- 54:20U .S. is starting to shift to the way Italy possibly
- 54:22is looking at things of holding consumers responsible.
- 54:26knowingly pretty much buying it. I don't know
- 54:28if it has to be knowingly but like with the standards
- 54:31in Italy but it seems like they're moving toward
- 54:33if you're buying in certain areas like let's
- 54:35say Santi Alli in Los Angeles you might know
- 54:38that these are not where let's say the typical
- 54:41high fashion brands sell their goods. Next slide.
- 54:48New York City, this was not enacted, but they
- 54:50did try to make the purchase of counterfeit goods
- 54:53illegal by consumers where they would be punished,
- 54:57the consumer who did that, but it did not go
- 54:59anywhere. Next slide. That is all for my presentation.
- 55:12I believe we're going to take questions now.
- 55:21Okay, so it looks like we just have one question
- 55:24that's currently in the queue. It pertains primarily
- 55:27to AI. So J. Dodari begins with the concept that
- 55:38non -humans do not have a right to publicity.
- 55:40So AI models not based on real people must have
- 55:44no right of publicity. AI created works, okay,
- 55:48only have copyright and human -generated components.
- 55:51What legal regimes do you view as available to
- 55:54keep a third party from using an AI quote unquote
- 55:57model? Trademark unfair competition or something
- 56:00else? Yeah, I'll take that question and certainly
- 56:04my colleagues can chime in as well. three -prong,
- 56:10the question on whether I'm reading it, whether
- 56:13the public will be very receptive to AI models.
- 56:15I think yes. I think we're already seeing that,
- 56:18for example, the AI modeling, the shoe dude .gram,
- 56:22the world's first digital supermodel. If you
- 56:23go on Instagram and look at the comment section,
- 56:26the public is so receptive. It's like, whoa,
- 56:30sign me up. How do I? So specific to fashion
- 56:35models. On the one side, fashion models obviously
- 56:38have an issue with it, it directly undercuts
- 56:40them. And if you're not actually licensing or
- 56:44negotiating those image rights specific to AI,
- 56:48obviously there's a problem. But for the public,
- 56:51the public seems quite receptive to it. Now,
- 56:54with respect to the other questions you ask on
- 56:58what the legal regime would be, I think you still
- 57:01go back to the legal frameworks we have. Let's
- 57:03start with copyright. If the work is original,
- 57:08then you still have to deal with the copyright
- 57:10infringement issue for purposes of do you have
- 57:13consent? Do you have a license to or is it an
- 57:16assignment of rights for that copyright? If you
- 57:18don't have that, then you have to concern yourself
- 57:21with infringement issues specific to AI. Is the
- 57:25AI being created original? For example, in the
- 57:27Tilly Norwood example, the creator of that keeps
- 57:30insisting that AI is art. And the idea that the
- 57:34creative industry will have such strong reaction
- 57:38doesn't make sense because AI in and of itself
- 57:41should be recognized as creativity. and should
- 57:46be protected accordingly as well. So there's
- 57:49a copyright framework to think about and use.
- 57:52I don't think writer publicity may fit as well.
- 57:55I don't necessarily see that fitting in as well.
- 57:58However, if we look at trademark and look at
- 58:01the standard of likelihood of confusion, I think
- 58:03you can take the likelihood of confusion, especially
- 58:05with your analogy on what if you put it in a
- 58:09pornographic setting. you can use that and say
- 58:12there is a likelihood of confusion on the brand
- 58:15as a source identifier of the initial brand you've
- 58:17created. And now somebody's copying, basically
- 58:20hijacking that and creating an identical brand
- 58:23that causes confusion and using it in the way
- 58:26that you're talking about as well. I think you
- 58:28also look at possibly trade secrets. trade secret
- 58:34law, depending on how that AI is generated and
- 58:37the data that's used to train the AI model as
- 58:40a whole, one could argue that the contract and
- 58:43confidentiality clauses in the contract impacts
- 58:46the outcome and so should be protected. That's
- 58:49another vehicle. I think the final vehicle is
- 58:51default back to tort law. If you're harming my
- 58:54reputation or saying things that are defamatory
- 58:57or putting me in a false light, certainly I would
- 59:02I think that's a very, very good vehicle to use
- 59:06for purposes of pursuing litigation and making
- 59:08that party stop. So that's how I would respond
- 59:11to that, Victoria. I was going to add on to that
- 59:13about one issue I could see possibly down the
- 59:16line is false advertising. If you are doing like,
- 59:19let's say, an AI generated model who is wearing
- 59:21makeup, if the makeup looks like it's making
- 59:24their eyelashes extra long or doing something
- 59:27that is like enhanced that actually cannot be
- 59:29duplicated on a real human, then I could see
- 59:32that there might be potential issues because
- 59:35I believe it had been, correct me if I'm wrong,
- 59:37in the past of models where they have to disclose
- 59:40if they did any enhancement. or anything where
- 59:43it wasn't actually, if they did any kind of editing
- 59:47behind the scenes or to make the makeup look
- 59:51like it was doing something more than it is.
- 59:52So I could see that down the line potentially
- 59:55being an issue with AI, if it's like claiming
- 59:58the model is like showing the product can do
- 1:00:02something and maybe it actually can't realistically.
- 1:00:06Yeah, and I see the subsequent question, Jay,
- 1:00:11on basically no copyright. Yeah, I mean, but
- 1:00:14you do have the bundle of rights and the reproduction
- 1:00:16right and derivative work as well. So I mean,
- 1:00:20you could make an argument. The point is, how
- 1:00:22do you potentially argue for purpose of AI? You
- 1:00:26could argue derivative work, even though, yes,
- 1:00:29the AI model is not necessarily an original work,
- 1:00:35but you could argue derivative work or go under
- 1:00:39the reproduction right, I would say, for purposes
- 1:00:41of evaluating the approach on the copyright law.
- 1:00:44Obviously, we're still trying to figure out what
- 1:00:47to do and whether the copyright vehicle is a
- 1:00:50good vehicle. But I think that's a possibility
- 1:00:52to consider. And I think you had another non
- 1:00:55-humans have no privacy rights. Yeah, non -humans
- 1:00:58have no privacy rights. That's true. But If you're
- 1:01:05using tort law as a vehicle, you're essentially
- 1:01:08arguing reputational harm because your analogy
- 1:01:11was that you have someone that uses, based on
- 1:01:15what you said, put in a pornographic setting
- 1:01:17an avatar. For example, what if someone took
- 1:01:20a recognizable avatar not based on a real person
- 1:01:24and put in a pornographic setting. If it's not
- 1:01:26based on a uh on a real person and yeah that's
- 1:01:29a different analysis i would agree with that
- 1:01:31but if it is based on a real person obviously
- 1:01:33then you could go after uh using defamation law
- 1:01:36but if it's not based on a real person that's
- 1:01:39a very interesting area and scope to figure out
- 1:01:42and and that would be interesting i guess you
- 1:01:44could look at it from i think you'd probably
- 1:01:48maybe look at it under the umbrella of the creator
- 1:01:52themselves and maybe trademark law and unfair
- 1:01:54competition, 17 to 200 under California law might
- 1:01:58be a vehicle to look at if it's not based on
- 1:02:01a real person. All righty. It looks like we're
- 1:02:08done with questions. Thank you so much for your
- 1:02:11time today and for sharing your knowledge and
- 1:02:14expertise with our audience. I'd like to also
- 1:02:16thank our audience for joining us today. Have
- 1:02:19a great afternoon everyone.