Latest / Consumerpedia / 37 - Why You Shouldn't Buy a Home Warranty
Transcript
- 0:02You spend a lot of money buying your house.
- 0:04So why not spend just a little bit more to protect yourself,
- 0:06from expensive, repair bills, peace of mind.
- 0:09That's what home warranty. Companies, promise substantial
- 0:12savings. If something goes wrong with
- 0:14your furnace, fridge, Plumbing or home appliances sounds great.
- 0:18But all too often, it's not. I'm her Weiss bomb that
- 0:21consumer, man, a contributing editor at checkbook.
- 0:24Dot-org, welcome to Consumer pedia at checkbook.
- 0:27Dot-org, where the nonprofit that helps?
- 0:30Zoomer select Services, avoid trouble and save money because
- 0:33we don't accept any advertising or take money from any business.
- 0:36We recommend you can rely on checkbook, dot-org to be
- 0:39completely independent and objective.
- 0:42Now, here's the host of consumer pedia America's consumer expert
- 0:46the consumer, man, herb Weiss bomb.
- 0:49In this episode, we're going to explain why checkbook advises
- 0:52against buying a home warranty from the high price to the
- 0:55common gotchas checkbooks executive editor, Kevin
- 0:58bressler's here to run down the many False hair.
- 1:00So let's start with the bottom line.
- 1:02You don't like home warranties and you consider all of them.
- 1:05Every single one to be a bad buy.
- 1:08We here at checkbook. We for decades now has been
- 1:10urging people not to buy home warranties.
- 1:13These plans, their ads, make them seem like they're wise
- 1:15purchases, but they're typically just terrible deals for most
- 1:19consumers. And in fact, often when I'm
- 1:21asked about, you know, what's the biggest money?
- 1:23Wasters for consumers out there home warranties, they're always
- 1:27near the top of the list. And why is that?
- 1:29Is it the Cost is it the coverage the ads?
- 1:31Make it sound like these policies, can save you a lot of
- 1:33money. You know they promise to provide
- 1:35Peace of Mind against unexpected expenses.
- 1:38But buying these things will not mean that you still don't have
- 1:42to pay for problems in and around your home.
- 1:45So, the warranty companies in their ads.
- 1:47They make it seem like you'll never pay for a home repair
- 1:49again, right? But it's really not that simple.
- 1:52I mean, to start with, you have to pay for the warranty plan.
- 1:55There was a monthly premium there that ranges anywhere from
- 1:58$300 to Thousand dollars or more per year and for most homes,
- 2:03it's going to be six hundred dollars plus per year, fifty
- 2:06dollars a month. And then you're responsible for
- 2:09what they call a trade service fee that typically cost 75 to
- 2:14150 dollars for the initial service, visit for each claim
- 2:17you make. So each time you have a problem
- 2:19and they send someone to your home, you have to write a check
- 2:21to that company for 50 to 150 dollars.
- 2:24And then if the warranty company denies your claims and they
- 2:27often do then you still have to pay that At service fee, or you
- 2:31can't get out of that, you know, over all these plans are not
- 2:34really inexpensive at all. They're pretty big expenditures
- 2:36for most of the people who buy them.
- 2:38And as with any insurance or service contract, the company
- 2:41selling these policies, they're making a lot of money off of
- 2:43this. Yeah, so in fact, you're very
- 2:45likely to come out far behind financially.
- 2:47If you buy one of these plants you're going to end up spending
- 2:49a lot more than the benefit, you'll get out of them.
- 2:53The companies that sell these things, they price them so that
- 2:55they always taken a lot more Revenue than they need to pay
- 2:58out for example, We looked at SEC, filings for front door,
- 3:02which owns American Home Shield and a few other major home
- 3:05warranty companies. We saw that for the nine months
- 3:08ending in September 20 22 it reported revenue of 1.3 billion
- 3:13dollars and nearly all that was from selling these types of
- 3:16plans but it's cost to provide services to its customers.
- 3:20You know when they actually had a problem and had a claim and
- 3:22somebody had to pay for it that was only seven or 57 million.
- 3:26So really what's happening here is that for that time period
- 3:29from Outdoor paid out only about 57 cents for each dollar.
- 3:34It took in to cover claims. I mean, that's a huge margin in
- 3:38terms of profits especially compared to a lot of insurance
- 3:41companies out there most insurance companies, pay a lot
- 3:43more than 50, something cents on a dollar.
- 3:45It's up to the 80s or whatever. Yeah, it's a sign that a lot of
- 3:49people are buying these plans and wasting money.
- 3:51They're putting far more in in terms of the premiums they have
- 3:55to pay that the costs they have to pay to these plans then
- 3:57they're getting out. I mean far more than what
- 3:59they're getting. Now, but of course, you could
- 4:01argue that paying for piece of mind is worth it to avoid,
- 4:03getting hit with a huge repair, bill down the road, that's what
- 4:06people worry about but you know better than that.
- 4:08Yeah, I mean, these plans, they often promise that if an
- 4:10appliance is too costly to fix, for example, that the company
- 4:13will replace it or that if your furnace breaks down and they
- 4:16can't be repaired, that they'll replace that also, it seems like
- 4:20they're covering you from these really big expenditures that you
- 4:23might want to kind of, you know, by some insurance to protect
- 4:26yourself against. But if you wade into the fine
- 4:29print on these plans, as we did, you'll often see some really big
- 4:33red flags about payout limits. So, for example, a sample
- 4:36contract, we reviewed for one company said that the company
- 4:39caps reimbursement, for heating and air conditioning equipment.
- 4:42Repairs and Replacements at $1500, and that same limit
- 4:47applies if you have a leaky roof.
- 4:49So another company, we saw its payout limit for Electrical
- 4:53Plumbing and appliance repairs was only five hundred dollars.
- 4:57So those limits, they're not going to protect you then I'm
- 4:59going to bring You peace of mind against large repair Bills, new
- 5:03furnaces cost, 4,000 dollars and up new refrigerators can cost
- 5:06$2000 and up. So homeowners who are buying
- 5:09these plans? Because they've been promised
- 5:11that they're going to be protected against really big,
- 5:14you know, repair bills or having to replace, you know an
- 5:16expensive home component and now they're really not getting the
- 5:19coverage at all. That the home warranty companies
- 5:21are a warning about and here's something I don't think a lot of
- 5:23people know and they learn the hard way despite what all the
- 5:26marketing materials might indicate these policies.
- 5:28Don't cover everything. Nothing.
- 5:30Nope, right. I mean, most homeowners biggest
- 5:33nightmares in terms of expensive repairs and problems.
- 5:36You either leaky roofs and wet basements.
- 5:38Those are the things that are really going to cost you a lot
- 5:40of money if you have a problem. But most of these home warranty
- 5:43plans, they only pay for limited roof repairs, not not for a full
- 5:47new roof. And also if you have a basement
- 5:50water problem, which is a big problem around here, where I
- 5:53live, I know you'll have to deal with that on your own.
- 5:55These plans don't cover that type of problem.
- 5:58A lot of them, exclude water. Heaters from coverage.
- 6:02I don't know why. Maybe it's because water heaters
- 6:03break down a lot or you need to replace them every 10 years.
- 6:06They don't cover that. If you have trouble with a home
- 6:09security system or solar panels or smart home devices, these
- 6:13plants, typically, exclude all those things.
- 6:15So these companies, what they're doing often is they're
- 6:18identifying problems. That tend to go wrong things
- 6:21that tend to break down and things that might be expensive
- 6:23to fix or replace and often, they're excluding them from
- 6:27their coverage plans. So let's talk a little bit more.
- 6:29About that because these companies make these policies
- 6:32sound so good. But as you point out, there are
- 6:35ridiculous limits and even exclusions for Stuff the plans
- 6:38do cover. Yeah, even for things they do
- 6:40cover, there's often fine. Print that really, you know,
- 6:43diminishes the value of what you can get out of the these
- 6:46companies if you have a problem. So, for example, most home
- 6:49warranty companies, the advertised that they fully cover
- 6:52appliances. If there's a breakdown, or you
- 6:54need a replacement, but some of them, many of them hide in.
- 6:57Find print that they'll reimburse you.
- 6:59Be up to the depreciated. Value of your dead refrigerator,
- 7:03dishwasher, whatever. If it needs replacement, and
- 7:07most homeowners are going to find that payout, very
- 7:09disappointing. And even for covered repairs,
- 7:12you might find your claim is denied.
- 7:13If you don't have records to prove that you performed the
- 7:16manufacturers recommended maintenance or the problem was
- 7:19caused by something other than normal wear and tear or like a
- 7:22power surge. We found in select home
- 7:25warranties, it's another big Home Warranty company and its
- 7:28sample service. Tracked, terms and conditions
- 7:31that the company declares that it, quote reserves the right and
- 7:35may request prior years, three years, maintenance records, and
- 7:39or pictures without proper maintenance records and
- 7:43pictures. The maximum payout on any system
- 7:45or Appliance is up to $150 in quote.
- 7:50Even I'm not sure what professional maintenance is
- 7:53required for all the appliances in my home.
- 7:55I'm not aware that I'm supposed to do anything at all for most
- 7:58of them. I mean, this, Lee is an attempt
- 8:00by select to provide cover to the dial lot of claims and
- 8:04companies also can deny claims that they decide the problem was
- 8:07caused by a product defect or pre-existing condition that
- 8:11predated your coverage. And from what I hear from
- 8:13people, a lot of these companies really do deny coverage, they
- 8:17have to try to complain to a consumer agency to get help that
- 8:20seems to be very common practice to deny the claim upfront.
- 8:23Oh yeah, I mean, you consumer agencies receive tens of
- 8:26thousands of complaints each year about home warranty
- 8:28providers and a Common gripe is about tonight claims and, of
- 8:32course, for every complaint that is made every official
- 8:35Complaint. That is lodged.
- 8:36There are many more people who didn't bother to complain.
- 8:39Some warranty companies have been targeted by government
- 8:42actions. So in 2015 Choice, Home Warranty
- 8:46and its principal Executives. They agreed to pay nearly
- 8:48800,000 dollars to settle a lawsuit, brought by a New Jersey
- 8:52that accuse them of using creative and deceptive means to
- 8:56deny their customers claims. And there's no wonder given that
- 8:59the Fine. Print.
- 9:00I just write off is pretty silly.
- 9:02In terms of the Hoops, you need to jump through in order to
- 9:05qualify to have your claims paid for lots of different things in
- 9:08your home that you thought would be covered.
- 9:10The complaint in New Jersey among the other problems.
- 9:13It said that it required customers to provide maintenance
- 9:16records, even when technicians reported that an item had been
- 9:19properly maintained or that lack of Maintenance didn't cause the
- 9:22problem, you know, there's one more big reason may be the most
- 9:25important. Why checkbook gives a big thumbs
- 9:27down to home warranties it has to do with With who does the
- 9:30repair work, we're going to explain that straight ahead.
- 9:33This is consumer pedia, powered by checkbook.
- 9:35Dot-org. If you like what you hear, we
- 9:38hope you'll consider being a consumer PDS supporter by using
- 9:42the link at the bottom of the show notes to make a small
- 9:44contribution each month. This is consumer pedia.
- 9:49Okay? So these home warranty plans are
- 9:51expensive for what you get. They deny a lot of claims.
- 9:54Even when they do pay claims, they often limit the amount so
- 9:56they don't have to really fully cover the customers biggest
- 9:59problems. Despite all that Kevin you say
- 10:01they're still an even bigger problem with these products.
- 10:04Yeah, I mean, my biggest issue with these plans is that you the
- 10:07homeowner do not get to pick the company.
- 10:09That does the repairs instead? The home warranty companies,
- 10:14send someone out, that is agreed to contract with that company,
- 10:17to provide Diagnostic and repair services.
- 10:20And from what we can tell, they absolutely do not pick the best
- 10:24repair outfits, we called 25 HVAC contractors all of which
- 10:28receive checkbook. Stop writing for quality and
- 10:31none. Zero of them told us that they
- 10:34participated in any home warranty programs, these
- 10:37contractors. They overwhelmingly disdain
- 10:39these plans, those who have worked with home warranty
- 10:42companies in the past said that we stopped doing.
- 10:44So because these companies deny a lot of claims and then the
- 10:48repair business, they're the ones who get blamed for it.
- 10:51When they have to tell the homeowner, I'm sorry, I'm not
- 10:53going to repair this for free and so, yeah, they basically
- 10:56just said this is just too much of a headache for the low pal.
- 10:59Set are offered and in give it all the claims that they deny.
- 11:03So here's the thing. You so you buy a warranty and
- 11:06you pay that bill every month to keep your coverage in effect,
- 11:09and then when you have a problem, you call that Warranty
- 11:12company and it assigns a company to deal with.
- 11:15You want it, right? You don't get to pick any
- 11:17company, they send it to you that repair business.
- 11:20It works for the warranty company.
- 11:22It's not working for you and it's getting paid by the
- 11:24warranty company. Except for this copay, you have
- 11:26to throw out, right? Hmm, so that company.
- 11:29Might feel you. No more reasons to deny your
- 11:32claims or side on behalf of the warranty company.
- 11:35If it argues that your claim isn't valid, and as we've
- 11:37already said, they deny a lot of claims.
- 11:39Sometimes, for ridiculous reasons, what we also found is
- 11:42that even when companies do approve claims and allow the
- 11:46repair to happen way too many home owners complain about
- 11:49repairs not being done correctly or that it's taking weeks just
- 11:53to get simple repairs done. Right often what we see is that
- 11:56repair business will come out, diagnose, the problem and Have
- 11:59to make multiple return trips to get it fixed, even if they can't
- 12:03fix. In, a lot of cases, the
- 12:04complaint say, I'm still having the same problem.
- 12:07They weren't able to fix it because they don't know what
- 12:08they're doing the warranty company.
- 12:10Say, oh, we carefully screen them and they're the best.
- 12:13But these warranty companies, they won't share lists of
- 12:15companies with us so that we can look and see who they're doing
- 12:17business with you. The homeowner you don't get a
- 12:20say and based on the complaints, we see, they're not doing very
- 12:23good work at all. And really, the biggest problem
- 12:25is, let's say you have a warranty and something goes
- 12:27wrong with the repair. They make the L'm worse.
- 12:30They break your furnace to the point to where it doesn't
- 12:33operate anymore. We talked to one homeowner who
- 12:36had a plumber come out under one of these plans to snake her
- 12:39drain and he screwed up so badly.
- 12:41She had to have the entire drain assembly replaced under warranty
- 12:44company. They weren't willing to pay for
- 12:46that either. And the reason is that, if you
- 12:48read these warranty contracts, they specifically say that the
- 12:52warranty companies themselves are not responsible for the
- 12:55quality of work that's performed and this part is astonishing to
- 12:59me. So homeowners they don't get to
- 13:01pick, who's going to do the repair and their home.
- 13:04That's something the warranty companies themselves do.
- 13:07But then the warranty companies absolve themselves, of any
- 13:10responsibility, if something actually goes wrong, what if
- 13:13they wire something incorrectly and create a fire?
- 13:16The warranty companies based on these contracts, won't bear any
- 13:18responsibility for that problem. You're going to have to deal
- 13:21with. Hopefully, the insurance company
- 13:23or the repair company or your own insurance company or tried
- 13:25me, you know, squeeze a good repair or out of that company to
- 13:28clear up the Damage they've done.
- 13:30You know, I'm just getting so, angry listening to you talking
- 13:33about this because people have no idea, all these exclusions
- 13:38And gotchas, when they see the advertisements or their soul,
- 13:41this product. Nobody reads all the fine print
- 13:43where they put all this stuff before they sign on the dotted
- 13:46line. It's why checkbook exist.
- 13:47But it's just, it's like they don't want to live up to what
- 13:49they're promising. People, it's not surprising that
- 13:52these plans have so many exclusions and that they have
- 13:55payout limits, and they have so much fine protecting themselves
- 13:59against you. Existing problems and product
- 14:01defects, because what they're doing is, they're insuring all
- 14:04the stuff in your home, but it's not like they're sending an
- 14:06inspector out to see if it's in good condition to begin with.
- 14:10They're charging a lot for these plans, you know, six hundred
- 14:13dollars a thousand dollars sometimes more, but they're
- 14:16doing it blindly right. There are offering you basically
- 14:19a service contract against problems.
- 14:21You might have in your home, but then they have no idea what
- 14:25problems you might have. It, it's not like an auto
- 14:28insurer or Holman sure where they have a lot of data and they
- 14:32have a lot of Actuarial models and life insurance companies can
- 14:35figure out based on your medical history in your age when you're
- 14:38likely to die and then write their rates accordingly know
- 14:41these warranty companies are doing it blindly and so it's
- 14:44really no wonder that they have so many fine print.
- 14:46Exclusions to protect themselves against big expensive problems
- 14:50but I think you have to know going in that all these
- 14:53exclusions exist, that these things.
- 14:55They seem like great deals. They're preying on our what I
- 14:58call loss aversion. It's he's right.
- 15:00It seems horrible if I'm going to have this problem and I'd
- 15:03like to be able to plan for this, and a lot of these plans,
- 15:06they advertise that you're basically paying for all the
- 15:09repairs, you might have in your home on a budget, it's going to
- 15:12cost you $50 a month to cover yourself against these problems.
- 15:16But when you actually look into them, know there's way more
- 15:18added expenses that you could have the things that these plans
- 15:21promise to protect you against these big expensive repair
- 15:24bills. They don't really full.
- 15:26You protect you from those and often.
- 15:28If you do have a problem there, Just going to deny your claim.
- 15:30So is there a smart way for you? The homeowner to protect
- 15:33yourself from Big unexpected repair bills.
- 15:35We're going to talk to Kevin about that.
- 15:37Next, this is consumer pedia powered by checkbook.
- 15:40Dot-org consumer PDF, fast facts.
- 15:45Home appliances don't last forever.
- 15:47The median, life expectancy for a new refrigerator is about 10
- 15:50years according to member surveys.
- 15:52Done by Consumer Reports. Nearly a third of all
- 15:55refrigerators will require repairs after five years, most
- 15:58major, Say you can expect your washer and dryer to last at
- 16:02least a decade. However see ours member surveys
- 16:05show that 20% of washing machines and 16% of dryers broke
- 16:08or stopped working within 10 years of purchase a new HV AC
- 16:12system costs, thousands of dollars according to the Carrier
- 16:15Corporation a well-maintained furnace can last at least 15 to
- 16:1920 years. Same for a well-maintained
- 16:21central air conditioning system. So, you might be saying to
- 16:25yourself by now, well, as with a lot of things.
- 16:28Buying one of these products is buyer, beware.
- 16:30You just have to do your homework, to make sure you sign
- 16:32up with a good plan. Kevin.
- 16:34Is that right? Yeah.
- 16:35And often, when I'm doing interviews on this topic, I'm
- 16:37asked well, which, you know, which companies are good home.
- 16:40Warranty companies is there must be some that are worth buying
- 16:42and don't deny a lot of claims and stuff like that.
- 16:45And what I'm saying to you is that none of these plans is good
- 16:49and you can't always even review the coverage.
- 16:51You're going to get before you buy them with some home.
- 16:54Warranty companies that we checked out, we couldn't find
- 16:56the actual contracts on their websites for us to review, even
- 17:00for companies that make them available.
- 17:02We usually found them loaded with hard to understand
- 17:04technical terms and legalese. In some cases, we couldn't
- 17:07determine whether common problems would be covered at
- 17:10all. But what we do know is that
- 17:13these companies generate tens of thousands of complaints each
- 17:16year, often for the things we've already talked about their
- 17:19really as far as I know. There isn't, you know, one Home
- 17:22Warranty company out there, that's doing a good job.
- 17:24In terms of providing solid coverage and not looking to deny
- 17:28claims whenever it gets the chance.
- 17:30So as a homeowner, I can tell you that we're always worried
- 17:33about big expenses. So Kevin, what's your advice, is
- 17:36there a smart way to protect ourselves from unexpected repair
- 17:39bills? Yeah, I do this.
- 17:40I mean, I myself worried about Big Repair bills with my house,
- 17:43I'd love to find a way to protect myself against maybe,
- 17:47you know, having to put in a new furnace or another, you know,
- 17:49freaking eight thousand dollar heat pump.
- 17:52But, you know, this home warranty, Companies, they will
- 17:55not protect you from those really big and scary repair
- 17:59bills. They just won't.
- 18:00You have to think of these things as insurance coverage.
- 18:04I mean, they're really service contracts, but I think it's wise
- 18:07to look at these things as insurance coverage that you have
- 18:09to decide whether or not to purchase it, but know that there
- 18:12really lousy insurance coverage, there's lots of deny claims and
- 18:17lots of payout limits and most homeowners.
- 18:19They don't need to insure against such relatively small
- 18:22risks. We are Often here at Chuck book.
- 18:25We write that insurance is for catastrophes for risks that are
- 18:29just intolerable and we'd be catastrophic to your finances
- 18:32like house, fires, auto accidents and medical problems.
- 18:37The risks covered by home warranty companies, the risks.
- 18:40They actually cover in terms of what you might have to pay, they
- 18:43might be unpleasant but for most homeowners you know, replacing a
- 18:47dishwasher or fixing refrigerator it's not going to
- 18:49be financially catastrophic and in fact, most repairs covered by
- 18:54these Policies or pretty inexpensive.
- 18:56I mean, the most common costs of a HVAC or appliance repair.
- 19:00Even a plumbing repair, you know, it's not between 150 to
- 19:03300 dollars and these plans, you already and have to pay 75 to
- 19:07$100 is a copay. They're really not covering that
- 19:10much when you do have common problems and when you have a
- 19:13really big problem, again, they usually have payout limits that
- 19:17cap, what they have to pay. And so your you may still have
- 19:20to end up shelling out six thousand dollars plus for a new
- 19:23heat pump. Four thousand dollars plus for a
- 19:26new central a/c or furnace. I think that's a big takeaway
- 19:29here. If you have a house there's
- 19:30going to be unexpected expenses, you need to have an emergency
- 19:33fund, a case, something happens. So take that money.
- 19:35You were going to give to the Home Warranty company and stick
- 19:37it in a savings account and you'll have it there.
- 19:39If you ever have a problem, I need to pay for something.
- 19:41Yeah. And then when you actually need
- 19:42a repair, you get to decide which company to hire, you can
- 19:46pick among the best rated companies, for example, and
- 19:49consumers checkbooks lists and make sure that you're getting
- 19:52good repairs. And then you're not just being
- 19:54Taken for a ride. And if you want to read more
- 19:56about this, just go to our website.
- 19:57Check book dot org and put in the word home warranties and
- 20:00it'll be able to read all about it.
- 20:01They article that Kevin wrote Kevin excellent advice.
- 20:04I don't know if it was an advice or a rant but I'm glad we
- 20:07covered this topic. So before we go a fraud alert
- 20:10about a home warranty Letter People in various parts of the
- 20:13country have been getting it claims.
- 20:14Your home warranty is about to expire or has already expired.
- 20:18Even when you've never purchased one, the letter is designed to
- 20:21look like the bogus Warranty company is affiliated with
- 20:24Mortgage company or the county deed Records Office.
- 20:27They are not the letter threatens negative consequences
- 20:30if you don't respond within a week or so scammers always use
- 20:34high-pressure tactics like that. So how do these con artists know
- 20:37the name of your mortgage company?
- 20:39Well, some information about mortgages such as the name of
- 20:42your lender and servicer are public record information, that
- 20:45can be found online by using that information.
- 20:48The fraudsters make their litter appear to be legit.
- 20:50Don't take the bait. Well, that's it for this
- 20:53episode. Odd of consumer pedia, you can
- 20:55subscribe to us on Apple or Google podcasts Spotify,
- 20:59Stitcher, or wherever you listen to your podcast.
- 21:01That way you won't miss an episode.
- 21:03Remember we release new ones, every other Thursday, another
- 21:06way you can support this show is to follow us on consumer, pedia
- 21:09on Facebook and Instagram and at my consumer pedia on Twitter,
- 21:14I'm her wise Fang. Thanks for listening consumer.
- 21:17Pedia is a public service of checkbook, dot-org.
- 21:20We're unique nonprofit that helps you save money and make
- 21:23smarter choices. You can count on checkbook to
- 21:25help you find the best services and avoid the worst with local
- 21:29ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 21:32If you live in or around these Seven Cities and have enjoin
- 21:35checkbook, yet check us out. Boston.
- 21:37Chicago Philadelphia Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis st.
- 21:42Paul and Washington DC to get your free 30-day subscription.
- 21:46Go to check book dot org. Slash consumer PDF if you like
- 21:50what you've heard, we hope you'll become a supporter by
- 21:52using the link at the bottom of the A show notes to make a small
- 21:55contribution each month consumer pedia, empowering consumers to
- 21:59save money and make smarter choices.