Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Trespass By Water, Insurance Duties, And Late Amendments To A Civil Claim
Transcript
- 0:13Adam Stirling: Am I reading this correctly?
- 0:19Adam Stirling: Psychological injury.
- 0:21Michael Mulligan: Is that type of well so probably and could have been inserted in there, but those are both the interesting concepts here.
- 0:29Michael Mulligan: This concept of trespass by water and the possibility that it might cause psychological injury.
- 0:35Michael Mulligan: And so the background of this case that uh just came out, um, it involves a uh claim up in Campbell River.
- 0:42Michael Mulligan: And uh the uh claim uh involves a couple of single-family uh homes, um, and the uh claim amounts to uh damage, it sounds like to one of the homes resulting by water that's alleged to have come over onto the property from the adjacent lot, right?
- 0:58Michael Mulligan: That sounds sort of straightforward.
- 1:00Michael Mulligan: Uh now there are a few elements to it.
- 1:03Michael Mulligan: First of all, uh this uh decision involves the how uh what's called the notice of civil claim works.
- 1:09Michael Mulligan: And so what a notice of civil claim is is that if you want to sue somebody for uh civilly, right, for some damages, you would set out why you want to do that on the basis upon which you're claiming they owe you money in exactly that, a notice of civil claim.
- 1:23Michael Mulligan: And you would serve it on the other side, and then the other side would have a chance to reply to the notice of civil claim.
- 1:29Michael Mulligan: And those documents sort of frame, you know, what is this all about, right, for the trial to go ahead.
- 1:34Michael Mulligan: Um, and in this case, the the homeowners that I guess were the water recipients that were suing, uh, were suing both the neighbors who they allege caused the water to come onto their property, uh, and an insurance company, I think their insurance company, claiming that they wrongfully failed to pay their claim.
- 1:52Michael Mulligan: Now, I'll pause here for a moment just so listeners know, it's not uncommon for uh like home insurance policies to exclude things like flooding.
- 2:01Michael Mulligan: And the reason flooding is often excluded is that of course everyone at the bottom of the valley wants all the flood insurance they can get.
- 2:09Michael Mulligan: And everyone at the top of the valley wants, of course, none, which makes it not really insurance, and so uh it it uh is not something usually included.
- 2:19Michael Mulligan: Uh and that sort of like flooding from outside would be distinguished from like a pipe burst bursting inside a home, which can happen to anyone.
- 2:25Michael Mulligan: So that that may be what's going on with the insurance company.
- 2:28Michael Mulligan: But in any case, uh this claim was filed, and it has to do with uh allegations that go back just a couple or three, maybe three years or so.
- 2:37Michael Mulligan: Uh but then uh there was an application to change uh the or amend that notice of civil claim.
- 2:45Michael Mulligan: And what the plaintiffs were looking to do were were really two things.
- 2:49Michael Mulligan: One, they wanted to add this uh uh tort of trespass by water, which I'm sure many people have not heard about, and they also wanted to add a claim for various psychiatric uh uh damages of their claiming, including alleged anxiety, depression, uh substance use disorder, and an aggravation of PTSD on the basis that the uh that those things were caused either by the water getting into their house or by the insurance company not paying.
- 3:18Michael Mulligan: Uh and so they brought this, they asked to change their um notice of civil claim to add those things.
- 3:25Michael Mulligan: And when the other side doesn't agree to that, there then has to be a hearing for a judge to decide, can they change what they're asking for, you know, kind of after the fact.
- 3:34Michael Mulligan: And the reason the after the fact is significant is that most claims, including these ones, have a limitation period.
- 3:42Michael Mulligan: Like you can't just wait around for 15 years and then just decide to sue your neighbor over the alleged water on the property.
- 3:49Michael Mulligan: Uh and so while the claim was started within the two-year period, right, of when you would sort of have the basis to start that, it was now outside of the two-year period when they're asking to add these things.
- 4:00Michael Mulligan: And so the judge had to wrestle with the issue of but you know, should this be allowed?
- 4:04Michael Mulligan: Should they be able to add these things?
- 4:06Michael Mulligan: And there are a bunch of considerations that a judge has when they're deciding that, and it's sort of this non-exhaustive list of things, like is the change necessary to determine the real issues?
- 4:16Michael Mulligan: What's the reason for the delay?
- 4:18Michael Mulligan: Is there some prejudice cause?
- 4:20Michael Mulligan: That kind of thing.
- 4:21Michael Mulligan: And so when doing that, the the judge had to sort of explore some of those things like, for example, can could this be trespass by water, that concept, which is a real thing.
- 4:32Michael Mulligan: Um, and that comes from the fact that trespassing can occur in a number of ways, like in a civil context when you're suing for uh money.
- 4:40Michael Mulligan: Trespassing itself, by the way, is not a crime, but it can be the basis of a civil claim, and there's some provincial legislation about it, but it's not a criminal code thing.
- 4:50Michael Mulligan: Um and so trespassing from a civil in a civil law context can include when somebody like enters upon other property, that's kind of obvious, right?
- 4:58Michael Mulligan: That's what most people would think is trespassing.
- 5:01Michael Mulligan: But it can also include remaining on somebody's property.
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: Hey, I'm setting up here, I've I don't know, constructed a building on your land or something.
- 5:09Michael Mulligan: Um, but it can also include uh the concept of projecting an object onto other land.
- 5:15Michael Mulligan: So, like if your let's say your neighbor is constantly throwing garbage into your yard, right?
- 5:20Michael Mulligan: Um, well, that could be a civil claim, right?
- 5:23Michael Mulligan: It has to be some basis to prevent that sort of conduct.
- 5:25Michael Mulligan: And objects could include water, but water has to come directly onto the land.
- 5:31Michael Mulligan: It can't be some indirect mechanism, like you know, let's say you had a pipe burst in your house and the water seeped into the ground and kind of made it under the ground and it came up in your neighbor's yard causing some damage.
- 5:41Michael Mulligan: Well, that might be something, but it wouldn't be trespass, right?
- 5:45Michael Mulligan: But on the other hand, I don't know, let's say your neighbor decides to get their garden hose out and just start spraying it at you or spraying it on into your yard constantly, right?
- 5:54Michael Mulligan: Or spraying it onto your house, uh something like that.
- 5:56Michael Mulligan: That could amount to a trespass upon your land by projecting that water onto your property.
- 6:03Michael Mulligan: And so the judge said, Well, look, you know, that that's arguable whether that occurred here or not, but from the point of view of a pleading, what has to be what's looked at when you're looking at like is this an acceptable thing to have in your notice a civil claim?
- 6:16Michael Mulligan: You can only say no that can't be in there if it's referred to as like bound to fail.
- 6:20Michael Mulligan: Like if you're making some claim that's just that's just hopeless, right?
- 6:23Michael Mulligan: You know, the water's bubbling up through your basement or something, how could that be directly put onto your property?
- 6:29Michael Mulligan: But here the judge dealing with this said, well, it's sort of arguable, right?
- 6:33Michael Mulligan: And you know, it may be that the judge decides that the you know, the other way this was already framed was like nuisance or you know, claims of that sort.
- 6:41Michael Mulligan: And that may be more appropriate, but here the judge said, no, it's not bound to fail, and it doesn't cause any real prejudice, because everyone is well aware of what this is all about, and so adding that element isn't really prejudicial.
- 6:55Michael Mulligan: Now, the next thing the judge had to analyze in terms of this proposed change was the plaintiff wanting to add the psychiatric or psychological injuries, wanting to sue the um neighbors, I guess, for the claiming that the depression or anxiety or increased substance use disorder was caused by this water coming onto their property.
- 7:16Michael Mulligan: And then they were also looking to sue their insurance company by adding the a claim that their uh decision to deny insurance coverage amounted to what's referred to as a breach of the duty of good faith.
- 7:28Michael Mulligan: And that concept comes up a lot in like insurance claims, uh, because an insurance company has a duty to act in good faith towards a person they've insured.
- 7:37Michael Mulligan: And the flip side is true.
- 7:38Michael Mulligan: Like when you're an insured person, you have an obligation to like help out your insurance company and tell them about what actually happened and so on.
- 7:45Michael Mulligan: And so they were claiming that look, because they allegedly, the insurance company allegedly breached that, that that may have caused this substance use disorder or depression.
- 7:53Michael Mulligan: I don't know if the person was drinking or using more drugs or whatever it was, uh, but that's what they were claiming.
- 7:59Michael Mulligan: And so the judge had to go through sort of a weighing of, look, is there some prejudice to adding this like at a late stage?
- 8:05Michael Mulligan: Uh and ultimately the judge weighed it up, and interestingly in that regard, both the plaintiffs, like the the family that or the person whose home got the water into it, was claiming that they hadn't realized they should have told their lawyer about the psychological problems uh until close to an original trial date.
- 8:25Michael Mulligan: Uh on the other hand, the lawyer also seemed to take some responsibility, saying that it was his fault uh for not uh more carefully interviewing his client to find out whether these things might have existed.
- 8:36Michael Mulligan: So they were both saying, well, maybe it's my fault.
- 8:38Michael Mulligan: Uh but ultimately the judge concluded that there wasn't really any prejudice because the trial had already been adjourned for other reasons and isn't until 2027 where it's expected to take some 15 days already, which boy, that's a lot of time and expense.
- 8:52Michael Mulligan: But the judge concluded, well, look, there's lots of time to look into the psychological injury thing.
- 8:57Michael Mulligan: It won't cause the trial to be adjourned anymore, it won't take any more time.
- 9:01Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so there isn't any real prejudice uh in terms of adding that.
- 9:04Michael Mulligan: And so the judge allowed that to be added as well, or that amendment to be made as well.
- 9:08Michael Mulligan: However, the judge said, look, you know, this should have been uh ferreted out earlier, either in the form of the uh plaintiff telling the lawyer about it, or the lawyer more carefully exam, you know, interviewing their client to find out about it.
- 9:21Michael Mulligan: And so the judge did say, well, they're gonna allow both these things to get added, the trespass by water and the psychological injury claim.
- 9:29Michael Mulligan: The uh plaintiff is going to have to pay the costs for this uh hearing, regardless of what the outcome is.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: So whether they win or lose, they're gonna be on the hook for paying the uh legal costs uh incurred by having to have this argument about whether the trespass by water uh and the psychological injury claim could be added uh kind of late in the process.
- 9:49Michael Mulligan: So that's the outcome, and I thought it was uh worth uh knowing about, both in terms of how those um notices of civil claim work, that concept of trespass by water, and the sort of things that a judge would need to think about when deciding whether they were going to allow somebody to add something uh kind of after they started.
- 10:06Adam Stirling: So that's the latest from the uh BC Supreme Court.
- 10:13Adam Stirling: In fact, it's always why Michael Mulligan Barrister with Mulligan defense lawyers, Michael, it's a reactive covenant, a resort hotel, and error defective.
- 10:24Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 10:26Michael Mulligan: So this is a decision just out of the BC Court of Appeal, uh, and it has to do with a covenant registered against uh a whole bunch of properties, uh like uh condo units, effectively, um, in a uh West Kelowna uh resort, which was uh essentially one of these things where they sold off each of these hundred and fifty units to individual owners.
- 10:48Michael Mulligan: And then the concept was that it would operate as a hotel, and there would be a management company, I think, associated with the original uh developer.
- 10:57Michael Mulligan: Uh, and uh then uh the if you wished to rent out your unit, it had to be in this uh rental pool.
- 11:03Michael Mulligan: Now, the way that was set up here, it involved a uh covenant being put on all of these properties to restrict the uh uh owners of them from doing things, including renting out the units on their own.
- 11:17Michael Mulligan: They had to, according to this covenant, uh only if they were to rent them to anyone, uh, rent them through this management uh company.
- 11:26Michael Mulligan: Now, uh covenants are kind of like uh contract, but it kind of runs it runs with the land, right?
- 11:31Michael Mulligan: And so traditional uses of that might include things like, I don't know, a developer might put covenants on a uh, let's say, uh residential development saying, you know, no uh modifications to any of these properties shall be over a certain height or shouldn't get uh any closer to the neighbors, things like that, right?
- 11:48Michael Mulligan: With the idea that uh if it was just a contract with the buyer, it wouldn't uh be uh enforceable if they sold it and somebody else bought it.
- 11:55Michael Mulligan: But a covenant that's registered on title kind of runs with the land.
- 11:59Michael Mulligan: That's kind of the idea there.
- 12:00Michael Mulligan: Now, this particular resort has been the subject of it looks like a fair bit of past litigation, which is what uh arose here as a set uh issue in this case.
- 12:11Michael Mulligan: There was previously a challenge brought to these uh covenants uh by uh a few of the owners back about uh five or six years ago in a case called uh Anderson.
- 12:23Michael Mulligan: Uh that case was decided actually a bit more than that, 2015.
- 12:25Michael Mulligan: The decision came out from the Court of Appeal.
- 12:28Michael Mulligan: And back then, the Court of Appeal found that these restrictive covenants, which said that you could only rent out your units if you signed on to this rental agreement with the particular company and were prohibited from doing that any other way, found them to be uh uh uh unenforceable uh on the basis that they were it was uh unclear what exactly was required uh by that.
- 12:52Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the Court of Appeal uh back then found that uh because it let those covenants lacked the required degree of certainty, because they didn't say in the covenant what had to be done, it just said you could only do it through this uh rental pool pursuant to a management agreement which wasn't listed there.
- 13:11Michael Mulligan: And then what happened is after the people bought these units, uh the management company wound up losing a whole bunch of money because right, of course, they'd be on the hook for things like you know paying for the hotel staff and cleaning and the you know reception desk and all those kinds of things.
- 13:27Michael Mulligan: And the original agreement when this thing started out uh involved a 60-40 split, so the management company would get to keep 40 and the owner of the unit would get to keep 60.
- 13:37Michael Mulligan: But because they were losing money, they just decided to change the uh terms of the agreement so they would get half of the money that was being collected.
- 13:46Michael Mulligan: And then they took the position that look, if you don't sign the new agreement with us, you're we're the only thing you can uh use to rent out your unit, you're just out of luck, so sign it or no rental at all.
- 13:56Michael Mulligan: And so that got challenged back in 2015, and the owners that brought the claim at that point, they won.
- 14:03Michael Mulligan: Uh and then uh after they won, several other owners, I think it was a total of maybe just over a dozen of them, went to the management company and said, Well, we want these conditions removed from our units.
- 14:13Michael Mulligan: And they initially started doing that, but then refused to continue with.
- 14:17Michael Mulligan: So there were more than a hundred units left which still had these conditions, and they were trying to stop the owners from being able to rent them out.
- 14:25Michael Mulligan: And so, as one might expect, uh the uh affected uh owners that were now paying this higher fee and were prohibited from uh being able to rent the units out on their own, no private rentals, you couldn't use any other system, you had to use this uh setup where the management company took half the money, uh they went to court and they said, Look, uh, we'd like to just have the same thing happen.
- 14:47Michael Mulligan: This was already decided by the BC Court of Appeal in 2015.
- 14:51Michael Mulligan: Well, maybe surprisingly, the uh chambers judge, like the Supreme Court judge uh hearing that most recent application, said no.
- 15:00Michael Mulligan: Uh and the judge's reason for doing that was interesting.
- 15:03Michael Mulligan: The judge said, Well, I've got some different uh uh evidence here before me than what existed back when this was uh decided by the Court of Appeal in 2015.
- 15:13Michael Mulligan: For example, the management company included uh a copy of a draft covenant and a draft rental pool agreement uh that some of the people might have been given when the units were originally sold.
- 15:25Michael Mulligan: And so the judge hearing it thought, well, this seems like a different evidentiary basis.
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: I'm I don't feel that I'm bound by what the uh Court of Appeal decided in exactly the same complex with exactly the same covenant back in 2015.
- 15:40Michael Mulligan: And so the uh uh counsel or counsel for the uh uh people that were trying to get rid of the covenant now argued that first of all, stereodisus decisus, the idea that, you know, once the thing's decided, and particularly by a higher court, right, it's kind of it's a hierarchy, right?
- 15:57Michael Mulligan: They were saying, look, this has already been decided, you've got to do the same thing for us.
- 16:02Michael Mulligan: And moreover, argued that the effort by the management company to now bring different uh evidence like the uh uh draft agreement and sort of the draft uh conditions and so on, they argue that that amounted to an abuse of process uh and amounted to an effort by the management company to relitigate the issue, which had been thoroughly litigated, went all the way to the court of appeal, and they lost in 2015.
- 16:27Michael Mulligan: Now, that didn't hold water at the uh original uh hearing in the in chambers by the BC Supreme Court judge.
- 16:35Michael Mulligan: The BC Supreme Court judge said, Well, I'm aware of this previous case, I know it has to do with the same covenant at the same property, uh, but I've got some different evidence here and I think I can make a different decision.
- 16:45Michael Mulligan: And so they did.
- 16:47Michael Mulligan: And that issue, that decision was just went up again to the Court of Appeal.
- 16:52Michael Mulligan: Well, the BC Court of Appeal, I guess no other way to put this, would have none of it.
- 16:57Michael Mulligan: Uh they looked at the fact that that this uh judge had found a way to uh come to a different decision, saying, well, look, yes, they had different evidence uh before them, for example, uh, but found that that effort by the uh management company to put different evidence in front of the judge to kind of re-argue that decision that issue, which had been decided back in 2015, did amount to an abuse of process.
- 17:23Michael Mulligan: And that concept of that sort of abuse of process um is part of the inherent jurisdiction of the court to try to avoid sort of the court's process being uh sort of undermined.
- 17:35Michael Mulligan: And the uh it also has its its roots in things like the concept of uh judicial economy.
- 17:42Michael Mulligan: And the idea there is that once you've thoroughly litigated something uh and you've had a reasoned decision on it, you shouldn't be allowed to just come back and just try again.
- 17:52Michael Mulligan: Uh because that would lead to not only potentially inconsistent results, but it it's also kind of a waste of resources.
- 17:59Michael Mulligan: It's sort of like look, you uh have your case, you argue it, you have a decision, you shouldn't get back get to come back and try again.
- 18:06Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal pointed out that yes, it's true uh that the management company decided to put some different evidence before the judge on this occasion, uh, but found that look, that was just a strategic decision on their part.
- 18:20Michael Mulligan: That same evidence would have existed back in the case that was decided in 2015.
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: Uh they may have made a strategic decision about whether it made sense to put in the show the judge the draft agreement or uh things of that sort, uh, and so found that uh a decision now to kind of try again by putting different evidence in really what amounted to the same fact patterns, the same entities, they're just different units in the same big building, uh, did breach that those concepts of things like uh judicial economy, not like wasting time doing something twice.
- 18:53Michael Mulligan: Uh other principles like there should be consistency and finality, um, and through the concept of the integrity of the administration of justice, all bound up uh in that concept of an abusive process uh to prevent kind of the misuse of the court's process by doing things over and over to see if you might get a different result, uh, or those same kind of things could occur, like let's say somebody uh was trying to litigate uh things in two different cases with the same fact pattern in front of like different judges to see if you could come up with a more favorable decision from one than the other.
- 19:27Michael Mulligan: Uh that might also be captured by that concept.
- 19:30Michael Mulligan: And like in that case, you might have a judicial decision saying, look, these things are gonna be heard together.
- 19:35Michael Mulligan: We're not gonna have two people, uh two judges hearing the same fact pattern in two different cases, like two different rental units or two different uh condo units saying, look, we're not gonna hear two different trials on two different fact sets of evidence to see whether uh one or the other might come out differently.
- 19:52Michael Mulligan: And so uh as a result of that, found that yes, this was an abusive process.
- 19:57Michael Mulligan: That concept of stere decisis uh did apply, right?
- 20:00Michael Mulligan: You've got a uh, you know, future decisions have to be consistent with previous ones.
- 20:04Michael Mulligan: That's kind of the cornerstone of the common law uh system, right?
- 20:08Michael Mulligan: So we can all live in an orderly world, right?
- 20:10Michael Mulligan: That's kind of what underlies all of that, right?
- 20:13Michael Mulligan: You should live in a world where it's possible to look at a previous decision on the same fact pattern, decided by particularly like the Court of Appeal, and you should be able to order your life accordingly, right?
- 20:25Michael Mulligan: You should be able to say, hey, this has been decided, right?
- 20:27Michael Mulligan: Uh it shouldn't be that every single, you know, condo unit owner has to go and relitigate the thing uh with the management company to see what kind of random different decision might come out of the process on slightly different versions of the evidence being put before the uh trial judge.
- 20:45Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the uh Court of Appeal found that the uh judge that heard this uh made an error in not applying that uh core principle that this did amount to an abusive process, uh, and that uh despite uh an effort to put uh slightly different evidence before the judge, uh, that uh was uh not uh a basis upon which the judge had discretion to do something else, the judge was bound to follow the previous decision from the Court of Appeal.
- 21:12Michael Mulligan: And so the net result is that the uh all of the other uh owners that were suing here are going to have these restrictive covenants removed uh from their title, uh, and they will be completely they'll be free to rent them out privately or use a different management company or whatever it might be.
- 21:27Michael Mulligan: Uh they're not uh bound uh by uh the requirement to either go with them or not do it at all.
- 21:33Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest in the BC Court of Appeal on starry decisis uh and uh abuse of process and how we should uh have a bit more of a legal, uh legal predictive world than uh might result if those principles didn't apply.
- 21:45Adam Stirling: Michael Ball again, thank you so much.
- 21:46Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 21:48Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 21:48Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 21:49Adam Stirling: All right, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 21:52Adam Stirling: Quick break, news next.