Latest / Property Investment & Wealth Creation Australia | The Michael Yardney Podcast / The Negative Gearing Loophole Nobody's Talking About | Dorian Traill
Transcript
- 0:00Right now there are two types of property investors in Australia,
- 0:03those who bought before 7.30pm on 12 May 2026,
- 0:07you know when the budget came out,
- 0:09and those who bought after it.
- 0:10And depending upon which camp you're in,
- 0:13the entire economics of your next move just changed.
- 0:16If you already own an established investment property,
- 0:19you're sitting on something the government has effectively locked in for you.
- 0:22Full negative gearing, the old rules have been preserved.
- 0:26But here's what almost nobody's talking about.
- 0:28What you do with that property from here can either protect that advantage
- 0:32or accidentally throw it away.
- 0:34Can you renovate it without losing your grandfathered status?
- 0:37Can you add a second dwelling on the same block?
- 0:39And when you're looking for finance to do any of it,
- 0:42does your bank even understand what you're trying to achieve?
- 0:45By the end of today's show, you're going to know exactly how to use
- 0:49the property you already own to build more wealth without stepping on
- 0:52the very tax treatment that makes it valuable in
- 0:56the first place. Now my guest today is Dorian Traill,
- 0:58Wealth Planner at Metropole. Dorian works day to day with investors structuring
- 1:03their finance around exactly these decisions and he's going to walk
- 1:06us through what's actually happening in real client conversations now,
- 1:10not just theory. Hi, I'm Michael Yardney and welcome to the Michael Yardney Podcast.
- 1:15After more than 50 years in property investment I've learned that
- 1:18the real risk usually isn't the market,
- 1:21it's getting the structuring wrong.
- 1:23And that's why twice a week I bring you strategies and experts to help
- 1:27you get that structure right. And that's what we're going to do today.
- 1:30So let's get into the show.
- 1:38Dorian, welcome back to the podcast.
- 1:40Thanks, Michael. Always a pleasure to be here.
- 1:41Well, there's been lots of chatter in the media about how the tax changes
- 1:46are going to affect property investors and one of the wealth strategists
- 1:49at Metropole, somebody who specialises in helping them get finance.
- 1:53You've looked at ways that the grandfathering of negative gearing actually gives
- 1:58some investors an unfair advantage,
- 2:02a bit of a loophole. So let's begin with the new rules.
- 2:05What does grandfathering negative gearing actually mean for an investor
- 2:09who already owns an established investment property,
- 2:11Dorian? Grandfathering is where the rules remain the same for an existing property that
- 2:17was bought before seven thirty PM on the twelfth of May,
- 2:20which is when the budget was handed down.
- 2:22That also includes properties that were or contracts that were entered into
- 2:26and dated before that time. And they retain the current negative gearing
- 2:30treatment until they're sold or until you do something that excludes
- 2:34it from the grandfathering, which is theoretically possible.
- 2:37Right. So that's actually created,
- 2:39I guess, two classes of property,
- 2:42two classes of investors, because from July twenty twenty seven losses
- 2:47on established properties bought after the budget time
- 2:51cannot be used against other income.
- 2:54But the tax losses are deferred.
- 2:56So you don't negatively gear them,
- 2:58but you put them off until when the property actually starts bringing
- 3:01in cash flow or you sell the property.
- 3:03On the other hand, new build properties that the government's hoping is going
- 3:07to add to the housing supply still will have access to negative gearing.
- 3:12Now, currently those changes have been legislated,
- 3:15but let us maybe give a disclaimer early in the piece that we're not licensed
- 3:19to give tax advice. So anything we discuss, you should be speaking with your advisor
- 3:24about. And the other thing I think we should remember is these rules can change.
- 3:29Dorian, only a short while ago the government changed the rules about distributions
- 3:34in trusts, didn't they?
- 3:35Yes, that's exactly right. In the budget they brought out one
- 3:39set of rules and after after thinking about it a little while and working
- 3:42out how devastating it was going to be for various businesses,
- 3:45they reversed part of it, although they've still made
- 3:48it extremely difficult from that
- 3:50Yes.
- 3:50perspective. And there's a lot of a lot of self-employed people who still need
- 3:54to think very carefully about what they're gonna do under the
- 3:56new proposed half reversed rules.
- 3:59So they could quite easily do the same thing for grandfathering and/or
- 4:04the new rules for quarantining the investment expenses inside the property.
- 4:09And this is where it gets a little bit complicated because they haven't necessarily
- 4:13written and set everything in concrete at this point.
- 4:16So
- 4:16No.
- 4:16we can interpret it how everybody expects it to come out.
- 4:20however there may be some some changes and some tweaks done depending
- 4:24on the political backlash, and/or if they give it some thought
- 4:28and realise that it's not necessarily going to do what they want it to do.
- 4:31And of course the next election coming up's going to give the opportunity
- 4:34for other parties to change things.
- 4:36But getting back to this then,
- 4:38anyone who owned a property before then can negatively gear it.
- 4:41Does that automatically suggest then that every property owned
- 4:45as an investment before that cutoff date should be kept?
- 4:48You just keep it because of this beautiful tax treatment?
- 4:51Not necessarily. I mean, if it's a poor investment in the first place,
- 4:56then keeping it is not necessarily going to put you in a better position even though
- 5:00it's grandfathered. You've got to think of the opportunity cost.
- 5:02I mean, I had a look at a property for a client not that long ago,
- 5:06which was an inner city high-rise apartment,
- 5:08which does fall under the grandfathered negative gearing
- 5:13rules. However, the long-term capital growth rate of that
- 5:16asset was only two percent. So there's no point holding an absolute
- 5:21dud asset just for the sake of the grandfathering.
- 5:23You really need to have a good hard look at your whole portfolio,
- 5:26and work out what the wider portfolio implications are,
- 5:31and take the necessary action. If you've got a dud property, then quite often moving
- 5:36it on and putting your investment into a much better property will
- 5:40put you in a much better position in the future.
- 5:42Well, I know as a wealth strategist that's what you map out with our powerful software
- 5:47to help clients understand the difference and then make the decision based
- 5:51on evidence, not just gut feel.
- 5:53But tax treatment should influence a sound investment decision,
- 5:57but it's not going to rescue a poor asset,
- 6:00as you said. But there are some concepts that you've come up with that you're
- 6:05helping clients with which actually
- 6:07discuss renovating or developing negatively geared established properties.
- 6:13So I'd actually like to discuss those with you.
- 6:16But if I do change my property,
- 6:18if I renovate it or do add another property there,
- 6:21does that actually change the grandfathering status?
- 6:24No, it shouldn't. And the devil's going to be in the legislation detail,
- 6:28but that the understanding is that if you renovate an existing property that's
- 6:33grandfathered, you effectively can top up the negative gearing benefits.
- 6:38So in some circumstances, actually renovating an existing property might actually
- 6:43be a better strategy than buying another one, until
- 6:45Yes.
- 6:46something happens in the future. And if
- 6:49the opposition government is formed at the next election, they're promising
- 6:53to reverse the whole thing. So that may put things into a different position
- 6:57in a couple of years' time. So renovating an existing property will
- 7:00top up your existing negative gearing benefits by adding to
- 7:03the depreciation and also if you're borrowing money for example
- 7:07or borrowing more money to do the renovation,
- 7:09then that money should become tax deductible because it's the purpose
- 7:12of what the money's used for.
- 7:14Although you do need to be a little bit careful with that,
- 7:17that your structures are set up correctly, so that you're
- 7:20not using your personal money or personal loan money from your your home loan
- 7:25to renovate an existing property, because then it compromises
- 7:29the tax deductibility of the loan.
- 7:30Very much so. So you shouldn't mix non tax deductible borrowings with
- 7:36tax deductible loans. Again, why you need a good smart finance strategist
- 7:41as opposed to just going to the bank.
- 7:43But how can an investor decide whether renovating a grandfathered property
- 7:48is worthwhile? Or maybe how do they stop making mistakes and overcapitalising,
- 7:52Dorian? Well, it's always good to look at the end result and also look at the area that your
- 7:58property is located. And this is quite an interesting
- 8:02one at the moment because with owner occupiers taking up such a large percentage
- 8:06of the market, if you've got a well located owner occupier style property that
- 8:11appeals to owner occupiers, then really you shouldn't have a hell of a
- 8:15lot of problem with the
- 8:17proposed dip in capital growth that we're getting at the moment lasting
- 8:21for very long. If you've got a property that has been built specifically
- 8:25as an investment property and now it doesn't appeal to an owner-occupier market,
- 8:29they're the properties that you're going to have trouble selling
- 8:31Yes.
- 8:32and
- 8:32and moving on in the future. So if you're adding value
- 8:35Or let's say for the sake of the argument,
- 8:37you're taking a cheaply built investment property
- 8:40and turning it into a more owner-occupier friendly property,
- 8:42then you're more likely to be able to get a better resale in the future.
- 8:46but you also don't want to overcapitalize.
- 8:47So sorry to interrupt
- 8:48you. What you're saying is if you renovate it,
- 8:51or even do structural renovations to make it more appealing to a wider audience.
- 8:56Is that what you're saying? Yeah.
- 8:57Yes, that's correct. But you also don't
- 8:59Okay. I guess that gives
- 9:00you higher rent, it gives you a strong valuation,
- 9:02it gives you a wider selection of tenants and probably reduced maintenance
- 9:07and a more appealing property in the long term.
- 9:09Yeah, absolutely. But having said that,
- 9:11you also don't want to overcapitalize.
- 9:13So what you want to do is again coming back to the area that
- 9:16the property is located, you want to have a look at what the resale values
- 9:20are for properties that are fully renovated.
- 9:23And that sets the sort of benchmark as to what the maximum price
- 9:27is going to be. So then you can work back the numbers from there and say,
- 9:30Well, if I spend a hundred, two hundred thousand,
- 9:33five hundred thousand, whatever you plan to spend to renovate the property.
- 9:36Is it going to be at that benchmark or below?
- 9:40So therefore you're not overcapitalising and spending too much money.
- 9:44Well, I guess we all have a borrowing capacity,
- 9:47a limit to what you can borrow. So you've really got to use your funds most
- 9:51productively. And that's again where using powerful software like you
- 9:55and your team use to do the sums is very valuable.
- 9:59It actually shows you, are you getting the best bang for your buck
- 10:02on your borrowing capacity? Do you renovate or do you buy another property?
- 10:07There's not a fixed answer and I guess that's what we're trying to say.
- 10:10There's not a one
- 10:11size fits all answer. Now I know many investors assume when they do a renovation,
- 10:15they can immediately deduct the costs,
- 10:18but that's actually not right, is it, Dorian?
- 10:21No, that's correct. The tax department has various different ways
- 10:25of categorising work that's done to the property.
- 10:28And some of it is tax deductible in the year that you do it,
- 10:31and some of it is known as a capital cost.
- 10:34and that is deductible against the capital gains tax when
- 10:38you sell the property. So they're very distinct differences.
- 10:42The ATO website has
- 10:44a whole bunch of really good examples to try and explain that
- 10:47and obviously you should have a conversation with your accountant about this
- 10:51as to whether it's going to apply to you or not.
- 10:53But the general sort of rule of thumb is that if you're doing maintenance
- 10:57or a general repair, then that is tax deductible in the year that it's done.
- 11:02However, if you're doing an improvement then that's generally considered
- 11:06to be a capital cost and that's
- 11:09treated against the capital gain when you go and sell the property.
- 11:13Well, it's also some of those are deductible over a period of time.
- 11:17Yes.
- 11:17And
- 11:17that's where a quantity surveyor can actually help you and remove some
- 11:21of the doubt about what's tax deductible and over what period you can claim it.
- 11:25So I think what you're saying is the right order is to do the numbers
- 11:30and figures with somebody such as yourself,
- 11:33then speak to your accountant and if you're doing a demolition,
- 11:36sometimes it's worth getting a quantity surveyor in
- 11:40beforehand, because there are sometimes some depreciation benefits
- 11:44you get before you pull things down.
- 11:46Yeah, absolutely. And obviously there's a difference between
- 11:49the two. The interesting part about a demolition is that because that part
- 11:52of the legislation hasn't been produced yet,
- 11:54we're not entirely certain. There's a bit of
- 11:58Yes.
- 11:59a potential problem in that, insofar as if you knock down
- 12:04the original house and build a new one,
- 12:06there's a bit of conjecture that the legislation may then exclude
- 12:10it from being grandfathered.
- 12:12So I get what you're
- 12:13saying, because they're talking about adding value.
- 12:16So if you're adding dwellings, say if you pull down one to put two on,
- 12:20which we'll talk about in a moment,
- 12:21that's very different. We're not certain if you just pull down one house
- 12:25to put just one on, whether that's going to qualify as a new property, will it?
- 12:29Correct. And I wouldn't be doing that until they release the legislation
- 12:32and you find out, because if you do that and it is no longer grandfathered,
- 12:37then you've just caused yourself a whole bunch of problems, because replacing
- 12:41like for like, under the guidelines that the government's given
- 12:45us is deemed not adding to supply.
- 12:47So therefore you don't get the tax benefits for a knockdown rebuild.
- 12:51Okay.
- 12:52So just to make things clear if I understand what you're telling us,
- 12:55if you've got an existing grandfathered property and you keep the bulk of it,
- 12:59but you add to it, you add renovations,
- 13:02you improve it, you've still got the original property and that's negatively geared.
- 13:07But if you totally get rid of it and replace it with a brand new property,
- 13:10that's currently uncertain. Is that what I'm hearing?
- 13:13Yes, that's where we're not entirely certain what's going to happen
- 13:17from that perspective. And obviously you don't want to make a decision
- 13:20and pull the wrong lever and be caught in a world of pain with
- 13:24a non grandfathered property.
- 13:25Well let's talk finance now, Dorian.
- 13:27Once somebody decides, okay, I am going to renovate,
- 13:31how do they actually fund it?
- 13:33There's a couple of different ways of funding it.
- 13:34And again, you need to be very careful about how it's structured, because
- 13:39if you do it the wrong way, you may not get any tax benefits from
- 13:43the negative gearing perspective from the loan.
- 13:47and that would be if you had let's say for the sake of the argument,
- 13:49you had a redraw on your principal place of residence and you used that money
- 13:54to do the renovation.
- 13:55but you didn't set it up as a separate loan split,
- 13:58then the ATO may turn around and say,
- 14:01well, hang on a minute, you've just confused us because you've
- 14:04got some principal place of residence debt and then you've washed some renovation
- 14:08debt through there. So we're not going to let you use that as
- 14:10a tax deduction or use the interest as a tax deduction.
- 14:13So you need to be very clear about having if you're borrowing money,
- 14:17then that money is specifically set aside one way or another.
- 14:21and treated as the renovation portion of the loan.
- 14:24And that would be, let's say for the sake of the argument,
- 14:26you did have a redraw portion,
- 14:28then you would go to your existing lender or if you needed more money,
- 14:32you may change lender or refinance or whatever you want to do.
- 14:35But you would make sure that section that you're going to use is split into
- 14:40a separate loan account specifically for the purpose of renovating the property.
- 14:43So that's very clear to your accountant,
- 14:46it's very clear to the ATO that money is being used for the renovation.
- 14:49Now, having said that, that's one way of renovating property,
- 14:52and that's quite easily done for small renovations,
- 14:56you know, it's $100,000, $150,000,
- 14:57something like that. But if you're going to do a fairly substantial renovation,
- 15:01the other way of doing it, and this can be quite good from
- 15:04a serviceability perspective as well,
- 15:06because if you do the renovation as a construction loan,
- 15:10which is a multiple drawdown facility, as though you were building a new house.
- 15:16you can do a major renovation as a construction drawdown loan.
- 15:21And by doing that, you're giving the bank
- 15:26the full builder's contract. And the lender will take the higher rent that you're
- 15:31going to get at the end of the construction as income for servicing the loan.
- 15:35So from that perspective, if your serviceability is a bit of a challenge
- 15:39and it's a fairly substantial renovation,
- 15:40then doing a drawdown loan may get you a better result as well.
- 15:44And of course, I always recommend having a liquidity buffer because there
- 15:48are variations, there are delays,
- 15:50there are expenses that sometimes the lender won't fund.
- 15:54So that's the other thing to understand whether you're doing a renovation
- 15:58or a new construction, that there are soft costs such as permits
- 16:02or architect's drawings or other things the lender won't lend against, will they?
- 16:06Absolutely. And we can talk about that a little bit later when
- 16:09we touch on development finance, because there are soft costs,
- 16:13which are all the surveyors,
- 16:15the engineers, town planning, all the people putting stuff together,
- 16:19and then there's the hard costs,
- 16:20which is the actual construction of whatever the renovation is or the new dwelling.
- 16:25So generally speaking soft costs can't be funded as part
- 16:29of a construction loan.
- 16:30Whereas if you have equity in an existing property,
- 16:33you can pull equity out providing you've got serviceability and pay
- 16:36for the soft costs out of that.
- 16:38And then it is still tax deductible theoretically,
- 16:40providing you set it up correctly.
- 16:42So again the message is speak to somebody who understands all this
- 16:46and the average mortgage broker who can get a home loan really isn't
- 16:50an expert in these areas, but I know that you are.
- 16:53Dorian, I guess you've been helping people with finance for a couple of decades.
- 16:58So what are some of the things that you found go wrong with construction finance?
- 17:04Well, the actual finance itself is fairly self explanatory.
- 17:07It comes down to the usual lending criteria,
- 17:10which is serviceability, equity,
- 17:11and the general rules. The things that tend to go wrong are things where
- 17:16you have overruns in costs, and they could be for various different reasons.
- 17:20you could have builder insolvency,
- 17:22which is a problem, because if the builder goes broke, then
- 17:25there is legislation in every state in place
- 17:28for that to be dealt with and the HIA will bring in an another builder to finish it.
- 17:34But then you have all sorts of not a lot of builders want to take over somebody
- 17:38else's build because then you have problems with who's responsible
- 17:41for the warranties for the stuff that's already done.
- 17:43How well is the stuff that's already been done been completed,
- 17:47things like that. You can have problems if you need a valuation on completion,
- 17:50the valuation comes in lower than where it needs to be.
- 17:53And this is more for if we're doing a development and you need
- 17:57to refinance it at the end, for example,
- 17:58if you get lower than expected valuations,
- 18:01then you may not be able to achieve the refinance that you need to
- 18:05do to get out of the development.
- 18:08Yeah.
- 18:08Delays, you know. When you're renovating a property,
- 18:12generally speaking, there's no tenant in there,
- 18:13so you're not getting the rental income if there are time blowouts by a month or two or
- 18:19you have dramas, then that can also be a holding cost issue, which
- 18:22is where that buffer that you were talking about can be very important.
- 18:25Okay, so we talked about renovations,
- 18:27but what if somebody wants to go a step further and split their block
- 18:31and maybe keep the existing house and build a second one?
- 18:34And that happens a lot in Queensland.
- 18:36Now I know some people are out there saying,
- 18:39just put a granny flat on the back.
- 18:40That's a whole different argument.
- 18:42I don't even want to get into.
- 18:44At Metropole, we don't believe that's a good investment strategy.
- 18:48But if they're wanting to build a second dwelling.
- 18:52What are your suggestions? What are your thoughts about
- 18:54Well, there's many ways of doing that, and it does change between states
- 18:58and capital cities, and even councils in some situations, as
- 19:02to what you can do and how you can do it.
- 19:04For example, if we're doing a subdivision in Brisbane,
- 19:07then generally speaking you take one big block,
- 19:10you cut it into two smaller blocks and you get title at that point,
- 19:14which can be a game
- 19:15Yes.
- 19:15changer, because that gives you the injection of equity which you may need to
- 19:20allow more borrowing capacity to do the builds.
- 19:22And then obviously when you've got two blocks with two titles,
- 19:24you then build on the properties.
- 19:26In Melbourne, it's a different situation.
- 19:28You generally don't get title until the properties are built.
- 19:32So you have an interesting dynamic where you might have you might have
- 19:36an existing property with a house on it, and it values up at X amount of dollars.
- 19:40But if, let's say for the sake of the argument,
- 19:42you're not going to keep the existing house,
- 19:44you knock it over and build two new ones.
- 19:46When you start doing the construction loan portion of that one,
- 19:49you've just knocked over a house that might be worth one or
- 19:51two hundred thousand dollars of that property value.
- 19:56So you might actually get a reduction in the valuation just before you do the build,
- 20:00which can cause headaches and make the funding a little bit more difficult.
- 20:04if you're keeping the existing property,
- 20:06that's not such a big drama because it's it's still there,
- 20:09it's still got value, and you just do a construction loan for the second.
- 20:12property. But I know we're not doing a big session
- 20:16on granny flats, but one interesting point to make on the granny flats
- 20:20is that under the guidelines of the new rules,
- 20:23granny flats are not treated as adding to supply because they're not
- 20:27on a separate title. So there's going to be, again, devil in the detail when they write
- 20:31the legislation. A granny flat may not be grandfathered, because
- 20:35It's a new build on an existing property.
- 20:36We're not sure how that's going to work,
- 20:38but it certainly won't be negatively geared in its own right.
- 20:42Well, again, the concept is you start with a dwelling and you either keep
- 20:46one and put another separate dwelling on,
- 20:48adding to stock, and the new dwelling would get
- 20:52negative gearing benefits because it is a new additional dwelling,
- 20:56or you could even put two dwellings on,
- 20:59as we said. Now, you talked a moment ago about finance, and we have discussed development
- 21:05finance in previous podcasts.
- 21:07Residential lending is something that many investors understand,
- 21:10but commercial development finance is very different.
- 21:13When do the loans tip over to become commercial lending, and how does that differ?
- 21:19Generally speaking, if you're doing a small lot subdivision where you've
- 21:23got one big block, you're chopping it in half and doing two new houses,
- 21:27that's considered to be residential.
- 21:29and it generally falls under residential funding for most lenders
- 21:32who do construction loans. Not all lenders do construction loans,
- 21:35just out of curiosity. But that sort of thing,
- 21:38most lenders will allow you to have two constructions going at the same time under
- 21:42residential. When you get to three or more, that's when
- 21:45they start to consider it to be more of a commercial deal.
- 21:48And there's lots of different ways that can be funded.
- 21:52The loan to value ratios can come down.
- 21:54There's two different ways of funding them.
- 21:57Some lenders will do it on the hard costs,
- 22:00which is the actual construction costs,
- 22:02not including the soft costs. And there's another way of funding it,
- 22:05which is on practical completion,
- 22:08which can give you a higher valuation at the end,
- 22:12once the properties are completed,
- 22:13which can give you a higher loan to value ratio and a greater amount of money
- 22:16to borrow so that you can absorb the soft costs as well.
- 22:20So when it comes to commercial,
- 22:23there's 101 different ways of putting it together.
- 22:25There's mainstream lenders, there's specialist commercial lenders,
- 22:29there are private lenders, and each one does a different thing in a different way.
- 22:33So once you get into commercial space,
- 22:35it starts to become a lot more complicated.
- 22:38but it can be very beneficial as well.
- 22:41It just depends on what you've got and how you need to fund it.
- 22:44So let's be clear, we're not talking about commercial property.
- 22:47It's just the words the banks use for a different type of lending where,
- 22:52in general, compared to a residential home loan lending,
- 22:56you have lower loan-to-value ratios,
- 22:58the assessment of serviceability changes often from your personal income
- 23:03to how the project's income is.
- 23:05They actually look at the builders and developers' track record.
- 23:09They look at the end values of the property and the total development cost.
- 23:14they usually charge a little bit more and it's over a short term so that
- 23:18at the end of the development you would then refinance to a normal residential loan.
- 23:24Have I got that right, Dorian?
- 23:25Yeah, that's correct. When the commercial lender has a look
- 23:29at the feasibility to do a commercial construction project,
- 23:33they're generally looking at it in a way that they're expecting you
- 23:37to sell the properties on completion.
- 23:39So generally
- 23:39Yes.
- 23:40speaking, they're shorter loan terms,
- 23:42three years, something like that,
- 23:43which gives you enough time to actually complete the construction.
- 23:46And then once the construction is finished,
- 23:48you either need to sell them.
- 23:50or you then need to go and get mainstream lender finance for each
- 23:55of the completed products that you want to keep.
- 23:57Now, that doesn't mean you need to keep all of them.
- 23:59You could sell one or two and keep one or two.
- 24:01It just depends on what the project,
- 24:03how the project works and whether you have the serviceability to
- 24:07be able to refinance them and keep them in your own name as well.
- 24:09Well I guess that brings us also to understanding the end goal,
- 24:13whether you're doing a renovation or a development.
- 24:17I think you've really got to start with the exit strategy even before
- 24:21you start looking at the building,
- 24:23the construction and getting lending.
- 24:26Would that be a fair comment?
- 24:27Absolutely. And this can be quite a minefield from a tax perspective,
- 24:31because if you're doing a development and you're planning to sell one or
- 24:35two and keep one or two, you need to be very clear right from the outset with
- 24:39the ATO as to exactly what you're planning on doing because
- 24:42it has fairly complicated implications with regard to capital gains tax,
- 24:47whether you pay capital gains tax on the sale of the property,
- 24:49whether you can claim capital gains tax on the construction costs.
- 24:54And it's not like, well,
- 24:56you know, we'll we'll do the construction,
- 24:57keep it for two years and then sell it off down the track and the ATO
- 25:01won't figure it out. The ATO will come back at you and say,
- 25:04you sold it too early. We think that you were actually intending to sell it,
- 25:09in which case you should have paid the capital gains tax and the GST
- 25:14and we're going to penalise you. So it's very important that you set up that sort of stuff
- 25:19right from the outset to make sure that you don't fall foul of the ATO.
- 25:23and there are also other considerations.
- 25:26Obviously if you're doing a development with a family member or
- 25:29a friend or something like that and you want to keep one each,
- 25:32then you need to set up that right from the start as well because if
- 25:35you get that wrong, you might be paying stamp duty on a
- 25:38two million dollar finished product.
- 25:39Well, people don't understand that.
- 25:40Now, we do a lot of developments at Metropole.
- 25:43We've been doing it for thirty years with clients, and I've been doing
- 25:47developments for forty years. And we do see a lot of partners,
- 25:50joint venture partners go together and their names are on the title,
- 25:54and they don't realize that if you and I went together,
- 25:56I'd be keeping Unit One, you'd be keeping Unit Two.
- 25:59But at the end of the development,
- 26:01you own half of Unit One and I own half of Unit Two.
- 26:04And so there's stamp duty and capital gains tax implications.
- 26:07All that's got to be prepared in advance and there are ways of doing it.
- 26:11So if you're considering getting involved in renovations or development,
- 26:15we'd love to have a chat with you.
- 26:17And you can hear that Dorian understands the investment strategy component
- 26:23as well as the finance component.
- 26:25If you want to just understand what your options are
- 26:29in these interesting challenging times.
- 26:32Go to metropole.com.au because we always start with a strategy.
- 26:35Property's the vehicle, but strategy is the driver to help you get there.
- 26:40So we've discussed a couple of things that you as an investor
- 26:44who owns an established property could do.
- 26:46Is it right for you or not? No idea.
- 26:48And that's why I suggest you go to Metropole.
- 26:51I'll leave a link in the show notes,
- 26:52metropole.com.au, and have a chat with the team so that we can explain
- 26:57to you what it means for your personal circumstances.
- 27:00Now, Dorian, if listeners want to just take away one lesson from today,
- 27:05what would you like to leave them with?
- 27:07I think it's very important that you have a really good plan and
- 27:10you know exactly what you're trying to achieve before you get started.
- 27:14And there are a lot of things that need to be taken into consideration.
- 27:18You've got the various aspects of the lending,
- 27:20whether that's during the construction or after the construction.
- 27:23You've got a lot of tax implications,
- 27:25so you need to be on board with your accountant and really understand what you're
- 27:28trying to achieve from a tax perspective.
- 27:31we talk about development all the time and you and I have both done developments
- 27:34and it's quite an easy thing for us to do and talk about because we've experienced
- 27:38that sort of stuff. But we also deal with a lot of first time investors
- 27:41or experienced investors that are going into the deeper end of the pool
- 27:45and doing fun stuff like developments.
- 27:47And there's a lot of fear and misunderstanding about you know,
- 27:51how hard it is and
- 27:53whether it's appropriate for them to do it at all.
- 27:55And that's where having a good team behind you who can do the whole process from
- 28:00start to finish, and that's what Metropole does,
- 28:02is if we are going to do developments,
- 28:04then we have an entire team who can do the whole thing.
- 28:07So you don't need to worry necessarily about how do I make this work?
- 28:12How's it going to come together?
- 28:13Because we can do all that stuff for you.
- 28:15The important part is
- 28:17that you have a really good plan,
- 28:19you know you understand what's happening,
- 28:21you've got the right advice from a loan perspective as well
- 28:25as the accounting perspective,
- 28:26and then you can have the team put the whole thing together for you
- 28:30and you can have as little input as you want.
- 28:32So doing small lot developments shouldn't be something that people
- 28:36are really afraid of. We know what the pitfalls are,
- 28:38we know how to get around them, and it can be a great way to create equity and
- 28:43really boost your portfolio.
- 28:44Well, thank you, Dorian.
- 28:46What I've taken away from this is grandfathering may actually create
- 28:49a valuable opportunity for investors who've owned a property before budget date.
- 28:54But the tax rules should sit inside a much broader investment decision.
- 28:59Don't just base it on tax. So improving a property,
- 29:02the right property, will increase your rent,
- 29:05increase the appeal, increase long-term value,
- 29:08and a carefully designed finance structure should still be able
- 29:11to preserve your cash flow.
- 29:13Keep your investment debt clean and leave room for the next step.
- 29:16Because every purchase you make,
- 29:17every step should be thinking about the next step and where you can go.
- 29:21But the message you've clearly given,
- 29:23Dorian, is planning needs to begin before the renovation,
- 29:27before the construction, before the development.
- 29:29That's when you've actually got the most options.
- 29:31And of course, get tax advice.
- 29:34We haven't given you that. If you want to understand how these changes
- 29:37and the finance choices could affect your own portfolio.
- 29:40Why not have a wealth discovery chat with Dorian or the team at Metropole?
- 29:43Now, if you've got some benefit from today's show and you know somebody else who's
- 29:47got an investment property that they've owned before the budget night,
- 29:51please do them a favour and share this show with them as well.
- 29:55And if you don't currently subscribe or follow the show,
- 29:58click the follow or subscribe button.
- 30:00Every podcast app has got that.
- 30:03And the algorithm will know that you like this sort of information.
- 30:06So it will keep bringing to you our most popular shows,
- 30:10the ones with the most views, the ones with the most comments,
- 30:12so you keep up to date as well.
- 30:14Dorian, thanks for your time. I look forward to catching up with you again real soon on another podcast.
- 30:19Always a pleasure, Michael, and happy to get the right information
- 30:22out there to the people so they can make better decisions.
- 30:30More than 20 years ago, I wrote the first edition of my best selling book,
- 30:34How to Grow a Multi-Million Dollar Property Portfolio in Your Spare Time.
- 30:38And since then I've updated it several times as our markets changed.
- 30:41But this year I had no choice but to bring out a new edition because
- 30:45the 2026 federal budget changed some of the fundamentals that serious investors have
- 30:50relied on for years. So this new edition's got new chapters,
- 30:53updated numbers, and some straight assessment of
- 30:56what these changes mean if you're thinking about investing in property.
- 31:00Now to explain it all, I'm holding a series of seminars in Brisbane,
- 31:04Sydney and Melbourne where I'm going to unpack these changes,
- 31:07discuss the opportunities that still exist,
- 31:09and answer your questions. And when you purchase a copy of the new book,
- 31:13your seminar admission is included for free.
- 31:16Now I haven't done anything like this for years and I don't plan to again
- 31:20and we've deliberately kept the rooms small because I want these events
- 31:23to be a conversation.
- 31:25I want to be able to look you in the eyes,
- 31:27hear your questions, and talk openly about what's really happening
- 31:30in property and what the new rules are going to mean for you.
- 31:33Of course, a small room size means there's limited seats,
- 31:36but I'll leave a link for this in the show notes for you to secure your place.
- 31:41A lot's changing in property, and I'd love to discuss it with you live in the room.
- 31:52Each show I like to give you a trivia question and a chance to win
- 31:55one of three copies of my new book,
- 31:57How to Grow a Multi-Million Dollar Property
- 31:59Portfolio in Your Spare Time, and everyone who enters this,
- 32:02leaving their details at propertytrivia.com.au,
- 32:05leaving the answer there, gets a new report as well.
- 32:08Now, true or false question today,
- 32:10if you substantially renovate a grandfathered investment property,
- 32:13like adding a bedroom or extending it,
- 32:15the property loses its grandfathered negative gearing status.
- 32:19True or false? Hey, we discussed that.
- 32:21Go to propertytrivia.com.au, leave us your answer, and even if you're listening a little bit late,
- 32:27doesn't matter, your answer will still count.
- 32:40Today I'd like to share a lesson with you that negative thinking is
- 32:43bad for your health. According to many studies and research findings,
- 32:47humans are their own worst enemy when it comes to how we think.
- 32:50Psychology Today reported that seventy percent of our thoughts are negative.
- 32:55The National Science Foundation did some research on how humans think,
- 32:58and they found that humans had about twelve thousand to sixty thousand thoughts
- 33:04a day, and of those, eighty percent were negative.
- 33:07Even worse they found that ninety five percent of the thoughts we have today were
- 33:10exactly the same as the thoughts we had yesterday.
- 33:13Oftentimes the thoughts we think are negative and that causes us to worry.
- 33:18This leads to stress, which actually causes rising cortisol.
- 33:22Excessive and continued production of cortisol impairs our immune system
- 33:26and opens the door to disease and infection.
- 33:28Now, you don't think you could have bad thoughts?
- 33:31Just think about what you've read just recently on social media or seen in the news.
- 33:36Every day I see people interacting on social media about things that
- 33:39are outside their control. Some of their interactions get heated,
- 33:42and it's clear those things are causing them stress.
- 33:46Because social media knows we react more.
- 33:48In fact, general media knows we react more to negative news than positive news,
- 33:54and that's why the media keeps force feeding us negative news just to get clicks.
- 33:59There's virtually nothing you can do about most of the negative things
- 34:02you read or even the negative things you think about.
- 34:05So when you read or think about negative things you can't control,
- 34:08as I said, it leads you to longer-term stress because you can't change
- 34:12the outcome of those negative things.
- 34:14Those thoughts are going to repeat inside your brain over and over,
- 34:17and for some of us, cause long-term stress.
- 34:19You should only be thinking about things you can control in your life.
- 34:23Focus only on thoughts about things in your life that you've
- 34:26got complete control over. Why?
- 34:28Because you can control actions on those.
- 34:31You can fix what needs to be fixed.
- 34:32And then you move on, allowing those thoughts to go away.
- 34:35So my message to you today is stop thinking about things you can't control.
- 34:39It's a waste of your time and it does actually impair your health.