Latest / Identity at the Center / #208 - Identiverse 2023 Preview with Andi Hindle
Transcript
- 0:01This is identity at the center. If it has anything to do with I
- 0:08am this is the go-to podcast. So if you're a beginner or an
- 0:14expert or anyone in between you've found your new home
- 0:18welcome to Identity at the center now your host Jim
- 0:23McDonald and Jeff Steadman Welcome to the identity of the
- 0:29center podcast. I'm Jeff.
- 0:31And this is my co-host, Andy. Hi Andy.
- 0:34I Jeff. I seem to have been upgraded to
- 0:36co-host. That's rather exciting.
- 0:37Yeah, we have a guest spot for you today.
- 0:39Jim is on assignment as we like, to say in the business.
- 0:42So we're fortunate to have you back here.
- 0:44Welcome back to the show. Andy, thank you.
- 0:46It's always a pleasure to be on. So, people who aren't familiar
- 0:49with Andy handle, he is the identity verse conference chair.
- 0:52He's also a board member with Kent, our initiative board
- 0:55member with ID Pro and also So people may not know this.
- 0:59A real live identity and access management consulting by way of
- 1:03hindle Consulting, who's joining us all the way from England.
- 1:06So, thank you so much for being part of this conversation today.
- 1:09No, that's a pleasure, and if you listen carefully, you can
- 1:11tell that I'm a long way away, right?
- 1:13That's the miracle of modern audio.
- 1:15It is crazy. So you're coming from England
- 1:19and I'm going to be in London, in June to watch the Cubs play,
- 1:24the Cardinals and to go to a pink concert.
- 1:27I'm not much of a baseball. Fan.
- 1:28I'm not much of a pink fan but I'm going for the story and as a
- 1:31makeup for my trip which was cut off for canceled, really from
- 1:34the pandemic back in 2020. I'm going to be staying
- 1:37downtown. I don't know if that's what one
- 1:40calls it, but I'll be in London City proper and we're going to
- 1:42try to get together hopefully for tea or dinner or something.
- 1:47He where should we go t-west go? Well there's lots and lots of
- 1:52stuff to see, right? Have you been sleepin to the
- 1:56teakettle so if we get, no, I No, I've been to Heathrow and
- 2:00then I've been to Framingham and Windsor, that's it.
- 2:02Well, the best places. So yeah, so look if you if you
- 2:07wanted to do kind of the quintessential, you know,
- 2:10English high tea experience which always makes me laugh
- 2:12because literally Nobody Does that.
- 2:14But if you did want to do it I would suggest you know there are
- 2:18some there are some super famous places to go right.
- 2:20There's the rates I guess which is classic nice claridge's which
- 2:26is classic. So there are definitely some
- 2:28Some options. And yeah if you're if you're
- 2:30around let me know what dates and we'll we'll try and get
- 2:32together and do something fun. Yeah, that'll be pretty cool.
- 2:35So looking forward to that, I'm also looking forward to
- 2:37identifiers which is coming up and that's really kind of the
- 2:39reason that we're having this conversation today.
- 2:43I guess, for those who aren't familiar with identify verse,
- 2:46what is it? What is it?
- 2:48That's a good question. Is this like a meta verse you
- 2:51know, are we in the VR, what's going on here?
- 2:54So, you know, identify this has been around now for about 14
- 2:58years, I guess this year started out as a conference focused
- 3:03Cific Cleon Cloud identity. In fact, it used to be called
- 3:06Cloud, identity Summit, and then it grew over the years.
- 3:11And we realized I want to say, like five six years ago, that it
- 3:17was, it was more than just Cloud identity, right?
- 3:19And so, we renamed the thing to identify verse and, and so
- 3:23that's that's what it is, right. It's an annual conference and
- 3:27trade show. So, so we've got a big show
- 3:29floor as well, and lots of sponsors that really focuses on
- 3:34Digital identity in its broadest sense.
- 3:37And so we've got lots of material that's aimed at, you
- 3:42know, your technical digital identity, professional rates,
- 3:45authorization authentication provisioning, use a life cycle
- 3:50AGA, like all of those wonderful things we evidently touch on
- 3:56the, the, to sort of big adjacent Industries and so, that
- 4:00would be cybersecurity where there's some overlap and
- 4:05privacy, right? Where there's some, some evident
- 4:08intersection as well. And everyone I suspect is
- 4:11familiar with several iterations of what I think was originally
- 4:15Eve, mailers, quote-unquote, Venn diagram, that kind of shows
- 4:18those those three things together, right?
- 4:20Identity security, and privacy, or privacy.
- 4:24For those of you that like the English pronunciation from the
- 4:27English roots and then what we started to do, Little bit over
- 4:34the last couple of years and which I think will be an
- 4:36increasing Trend as an addition to, that materials are not
- 4:39replacing it or changing it. But just adding along the side
- 4:43of it is some slightly more business-focused material rate.
- 4:46So one of the one of the questions that comes up a lot is
- 4:49you know look I'm running on a Downy project in a large
- 4:52business. It's really hard to get budget,
- 4:54it's really hard to get funding. It's really hard to defend the
- 4:57size team that I need. It's really hard to get the
- 5:00investment in professional development that I need.
- 5:03Like why is that? And in my view and I think other
- 5:07people share this perspective, part of the problem at least is
- 5:11that helping the business? Understand what the value to the
- 5:15business is is a little tricky and it quite often has come down
- 5:19to how do I protect things right and so and yet we all know in
- 5:25the identity industry that it's about a lot more than that.
- 5:27A lot of cases it's about how do I make this project happen?
- 5:30How do I make the experience for customers better?
- 5:33Why protect my customers better, which is a value, add to the
- 5:36customer, right? Whether that's a consumer or,
- 5:39you know, part of my supply chain or whatever it might be,
- 5:44that is starting to change. And so, I think there's a role
- 5:47for a donor verse to play Beyond, just that sort of core
- 5:51material that we've had for a long time in in helping the
- 5:55business side of the, the equation to kind of understand
- 5:59what it is that we do and why that's important to them.
- 6:03And for me I think that starts with helping digital identity
- 6:05professionals, explain what it is that we do, you know?
- 6:10And then over time hopefully starting to get some more of the
- 6:14business owners project managers project leads, you know, digital
- 6:19identity, sorry, digital transformation directors.
- 6:23Those kinds of folks to come along and kind of get a real
- 6:27understanding, okay? This is how this helps, you
- 6:29know, fundamentally Drive the business forwards.
- 6:32I love that idea. Because they think this is an
- 6:34area that a lot of identity folks really need help with is
- 6:39articulating to non-identity people.
- 6:43What the hell do we do, right? Why is it important?
- 6:46You know, why does it cost so much money?
- 6:48Why do we need so many people to do this identity thing and to do
- 6:52it right? And I'm happy to see that.
- 6:55Yeah, it's interesting. You know, it's something we've
- 6:57touched on on and off over the years at the conference and it's
- 7:02absolutely I'm a bigger challenge.
- 7:05It's actually very, very similar to what happened.
- 7:08I think in in the cybersecurity industry, a while back, you
- 7:12know, it took a little time but you know, eventually
- 7:16cybersecurity became a thing that had a seat at the, you
- 7:20know, at the sea level and it's a topic that gets talked about
- 7:24in boardrooms, you know, at that level as well privacy over the
- 7:28last few years has been through that very much that same
- 7:31Journey, mostly not Entirely, but mostly probably driven by
- 7:35some of the regulatory landscape changes.
- 7:37But again, you know, you look at the way that Apple approaches
- 7:40privacy and data standard example.
- 7:43But there are absolutely others and it's becoming a USP, right?
- 7:48It's a proposition to the customer and say, look, we look
- 7:51after your dad. Now I don't want to get into a
- 7:52conversation about whether that's true or not, right?
- 7:55But from a pure sales perspective and for those of you
- 7:58who can't watching as it were, Jeff is laughing.
- 8:00Hysterically in the background, I said that but You know, it's
- 8:05it's clearly become a thing that certain companies choose to kind
- 8:10of compete around. And so I think, you know, we're
- 8:12probably at the beginning of that Journey for identity and in
- 8:15fact, one of the things that we've got that identity versus
- 8:19is a friend and colleague of mine and I know he's been on the
- 8:22show a few times more than a few times.
- 8:24I think Jeff. Ian Glaser is going to do a
- 8:26panel with a couple of other folks to talk exactly about has
- 8:30it time that we had a sea level. Roll that identity kind of rolls
- 8:35up to and there are pros and cons to that, to that argument,
- 8:38right? But I think having the
- 8:39conversation is, you know, the fact that we're even even a
- 8:44point of having the conversation, says an awful lot
- 8:46about, you know, kind of where the industry is today and where
- 8:50it needs to get to tomorrow. Yeah, Ian's awesome.
- 8:53He's like, such a good speaker. I'm, I'm interested to see if
- 8:56this concept of this c-level executive level identity person.
- 9:01I think the most important thing.
- 9:03That we need to do around this is to make sure that it's
- 9:05branded appropriately. What do we call it, right?
- 9:09Is it Chief digital identity officer?
- 9:12Can we have like a cool nickname like CDO, like C-3PO?
- 9:16Like, that's the most important thing that we've got to really
- 9:18solve. It doesn't matter what they do,
- 9:19as long as the name is cool. It's the way I feel.
- 9:21Yes, it's just occurring to me that if you drop the officer off
- 9:24and you just make it Chief identity.
- 9:26Then you have said, answer, it's important.
- 9:32We've got to have, we've got to have good.
- 9:33In here. Yes.
- 9:35You know, I think the other thing too is, so the conference
- 9:37begins May 30th and, you know, and you've been really a great
- 9:41friend for the show. You're the reason we have a
- 9:43discount code for people to, you know, who are listening to this
- 9:46to be able to get a discount to go.
- 9:48So for those who aren't familiar, right?
- 9:50We've got 20% discount code off your identify, this reservation
- 9:53that registration easy for me to say the code will be in our show
- 9:56notes, but I'll say it here as well.
- 9:58ID V Dash icen 23, it gets 20% off.
- 10:03We've got the early bird is still going on until I believe
- 10:06April 27th. So there's just a little bit of
- 10:09time left. You want to take advantage of
- 10:10the last early bird discount but hopefully people can combine
- 10:13that with our discount code. But seriously man, thank you so
- 10:16much for you know, helping us. Get that in place for listeners.
- 10:19Hopefully we've got, you know, some people who be able to take
- 10:22advantage of it and be able to attend in in Vegas with us.
- 10:26Yeah, no. It's a real pleasure and look,
- 10:28you know, I'm obviously biased right?
- 10:31Like I've been involved with the show.
- 10:33It's my show, obviously Andres your and up paying found it
- 10:37years ago and then CRA to could over just before the show last
- 10:41year, but I've been involved with it for a long time.
- 10:45Like I say, I'm evidently biased but I really think that people
- 10:51get an awful lot out of it from a professional standpoint and
- 10:54so, you know, anything that I can do to help that sort of
- 10:57professional development Journey.
- 11:00I'm I'm happy to do, right, like I've gotten a lot, Out of the
- 11:03industry. And so to the extent that I can
- 11:05help, but stuff back, I'm delighted to do it.
- 11:09It's very cool. And so I booked my flight a
- 11:12couple days ago, I'll be there, the show will be there were
- 11:14planning on doing some recording.
- 11:16I think we're all starting to line up, maybe some guests.
- 11:18So there's some interesting things that were working on
- 11:20that. I don't think we're quite ready
- 11:21to get it out there in the public yet.
- 11:23But some ideas we've got. We'll see what comes through.
- 11:26You mentioned the new ownership CRA.
- 11:29I was not able to attend. Last year.
- 11:31I was in a middle of a move sort of across the country kind of
- 11:34sort of and I think Jim was in the same same boat.
- 11:38So I guess. Are there any noticeable
- 11:41differences between the new ownership CRA versus Ping when
- 11:45it came to the conference before?
- 11:46Because one of the things that I think I always felt about this
- 11:48conference was one, it's a great conference.
- 11:51Definitely one of the ones you should be attending if you need
- 11:53any space, but he also felt like when it was owned by ping.
- 11:57They did a really good job of being really inclusive for a lot
- 12:01of identity talk competitors. You know, vendors wasn't sure it
- 12:05was a pink conference, but it didn't feel like I was going to
- 12:07a pink conference. It felt like, Was going to and
- 12:10identity conference has there been any noticeable differences
- 12:13or what should I expect? Is my first time going to a CRA
- 12:17run. I dunno.
- 12:18Verse compared to the last one that was probably had a couple
- 12:21years ago. Yeah, that's a.
- 12:24That's a really interesting question Jeff.
- 12:26And I reminds me, I think we talked about this, you know, a
- 12:31few podcast episodes back. But the conference was always
- 12:37always, you know, when it was originally Only set up.
- 12:39And the way it's always been wrong has been as an industry
- 12:42conference. And in fact I worked for paying
- 12:45a long time ago, but my involvement with the conference
- 12:48in the role that a time that I've been in for gosh, eight
- 12:52years now, actually has not been as an employee either of paying,
- 12:57or in fact to CRA, right? So, I do this work externally
- 13:01and that helps to some extent for us to kind of keep the
- 13:05agenda that's as clean as we reasonably can.
- 13:09Can write. And in fact, we've got a fairly
- 13:13rigorous process. I don't want to go so far as to
- 13:16say, well, I can academic conference because we're really
- 13:18not, right? There's a whole much much deeper
- 13:21sort of set of things that goes around the, the academic
- 13:25conferences, but we do have a process of reviewing material
- 13:29that comes in through, call for presentations and then reviewing
- 13:31that material before it gets published.
- 13:34We've got a whole content committee.
- 13:36A number of whom have been on board for a while.
- 13:39That you know, we refresh that on a on an ongoing basis as well
- 13:44partly because you know frankly people do it for a few years and
- 13:46they're like I'm done thank you very much.
- 13:48But you know we also have new voices coming up.
- 13:50We have new technologies emerging.
- 13:52We have new markets to talk about so it's always been run
- 13:56that way and you know I I sort of hesitate to answer the
- 14:01question that you've asked as bluntly as I'm going to the
- 14:05question, you know, the initial question was, is anything change
- 14:08and kind of the Answer is no right and deliberately.
- 14:10So in fact, as you said, you know, the acquisition CRA made
- 14:18last year was announced. I want to say in December
- 14:23January in the run-up to the conference in June and then
- 14:27Andre and CRA CEO. A Dogma Tony actually stood on
- 14:32stage and had a conversation in front of everybody in the
- 14:34audience and kind of you know, helped everybody understand sort
- 14:37of what the future was going to look like.
- 14:40So we really haven't changed very much.
- 14:42In terms of the basics of the event rate, your gender is still
- 14:45constructed the same way, the Expo floor still looks like Expo
- 14:49floor. The quality of the overall
- 14:53experience, which is something that's always been a focus for
- 14:56us, right? Is still very much the same.
- 14:59Having said all of that, the industry is growing right.
- 15:03And we talked about this at the top of the show, the way that we
- 15:06need to talk about the industry is changing.
- 15:08The people that we need. To talk to it about is changing
- 15:12Technologies are changing. And so it's the right thing for
- 15:18us to look at okay, keeping the core as the core.
- 15:23What else do we need to do to start to grow in support of the
- 15:28industry? That we serve right.
- 15:30And so yeah, there are going to be some things that will change
- 15:34a little bit. We're adding some stuff into the
- 15:37agenda, we're starting. Process this year and it will
- 15:41be, it will, you know, continue into into next year and the year
- 15:44after particularly around, you know, some of the business side
- 15:49of things, some of the more strategic sort of stuff, in
- 15:52fact, CRA just, I want to say a few weeks ago and I might be out
- 15:56by n weeks, but announced a relationship, a strategic
- 16:01relationship with liminal the consulting firm so, liminal
- 16:06amongst other things used to run.
- 16:09The no identity conference. And so you know CRA of developed
- 16:15a strategic relationship with liminal you'll see them around
- 16:17at the show they've got you know some interesting perspectives to
- 16:21add to the to the overall kind of Melting Pot which I think
- 16:25will be really interesting and very valuable.
- 16:27And I think there are other you know, consulting firms other
- 16:36vendors from not necessarily your core identity.
- 16:39Space that we'll start to see emerging.
- 16:41And again, a lot of that is reflective of what's happening
- 16:44in the industry, right? If you go out and look at, you
- 16:47know where investment is flowing in the industry, you look at
- 16:50where some of the new technologies are coming.
- 16:54Yeah there's absolutely movement in what you might consider to
- 16:57the traditional I'm doing air quotes but traditional you know,
- 17:01kind of kind of core. I am technology but there's also
- 17:04a bunch of stuff going on around the edges of that in new areas,
- 17:07right? You look at some of the stuff
- 17:08that's Is happening from a verified any perspective you
- 17:12know attribute exchange is all the regulatory stuff that's
- 17:16going around mdl and in verified identity in a number of
- 17:20countries you know the stuff that's flowing from that into
- 17:24things like wallets. I we haven't you know that isn't
- 17:30that isn't something that traditionally we think all those
- 17:32core I am. Right.
- 17:33Digital identity wallet. Oh okay.
- 17:35But maybe it is something that we need to start thinking about.
- 17:39So, back to the original question, not a lot, has changed
- 17:44at a fundamental level, the experience will still be much
- 17:48the same different better like it is every year, right?
- 17:53But we're starting to add some of that additional stuff around
- 17:56the edges, which I think will be really important for people.
- 17:59And then, you actually asked a second question, Jeff right at
- 18:02the end, which was a, what's the experience for somebody that's
- 18:05coming new to the show? Now that's a hard one for me to
- 18:08answer. is it because I haven't been new to the show for a
- 18:11really long time but we spent a little bit of time last year
- 18:18talking to some folks who were new to the show and You know,
- 18:26when I say we me couple of folks on the content committee, some
- 18:29folks from ID Pro, some folks, from women and identity and
- 18:32we've got, you know, relationships with with those
- 18:34organizations as with many others and one of the things I
- 18:39think that comes across is people find it incredibly
- 18:45valuable to have lots of names that they recognize from the
- 18:51industry, right? So we already talked about Ian,
- 18:55But Vittoria Bertolucci, right? Or Brian Campbell or even mailer
- 19:01or you know, people whose names they've seen on specifications,
- 19:07or that have stood up at other big conferences that they've
- 19:11heard about all they've read blogs away, you know, that's
- 19:15fantastic. And they're there and they get
- 19:17to hear them. And in theory, they get to go
- 19:20and talk to them and we all do, right?
- 19:24But it's It's a little intimidating, if it's your first
- 19:26time. And some people are very
- 19:30comfortable with that and they weighed in and they get to know
- 19:32folks and that's wonderful. But lots of people are not built
- 19:35that way. And in all honesty I'm not
- 19:37right? Like I like to have somebody
- 19:39introduced me to somebody else and then I can have a
- 19:41conversation with them, but it's taken a long time for me to get
- 19:45over that sort of walk into a room, there's 300 people.
- 19:49Then there's someone whose name I recognize but do I really want
- 19:52to go up and like start a conversation?
- 19:54That's hard. So one of the things We're going
- 19:58to do this year in conjunction with ID program with weird is
- 20:02for those folks that are new to identify us.
- 20:04We're going to do a session right up front on the Tuesday,
- 20:07which is the day that we start before the main agenda starts,
- 20:14which is going to help cut out. Help people get more out of the
- 20:20week help people navigate the week.
- 20:24It's not that it's a scary event to attend, right?
- 20:27It's really not. It's actually very friendly
- 20:29event. The question is okay, with in
- 20:31that friendly welcoming context, how do I get to talk to the
- 20:35people that I want to get to talk to you?
- 20:37How do I figure out which things to attend?
- 20:39What are the tips and tricks for me to get the most out of that
- 20:42week, right? I think the other I would say
- 20:47for anyone that's coming to it. New is it's a lot more than just
- 20:51the conference, right? So we talked about obviously big
- 20:54agenda and it is a big agenda, will have somewhere between 150
- 20:58and 200 speakers this year, which is a lot, it moves fast,
- 21:03right? So, you got to kind of keep up
- 21:04with day a little bit. We've got a big show floor,
- 21:07it'll be the biggest we've ever had lots going on there as well,
- 21:13right? There's some, some content
- 21:15that's going to be running around the edges.
- 21:17The of the trade show for as well.
- 21:18So, for those folks that need to understand sort of what's
- 21:21happening in the product landscape.
- 21:24There's there's all of that and then there's all the other stuff
- 21:27that goes around it, right? So we've had lots of traditions
- 21:29that identity verse four years and some of them continue and so
- 21:32on them change. But things like, you know, yoga
- 21:35and boot camp sessions in the morning, the welcome reception,
- 21:38which has some, you know, some stuff that goes on around it,
- 21:42we've got, you know, the closing party which traditionally has
- 21:45been, you know, one of the big focuses Focuses for the week and
- 21:49a whole variety of other sort of activities that happen around
- 21:53the edges show. So, I think, for a lot of people
- 21:56that have maybe attended more, let's say, traditionally run
- 22:01conferences. Yeah, we do that stuff.
- 22:05But there's other stuff too, right?
- 22:07And I think that's worth bearing in mind and then, hey, we're in
- 22:10Vegas this year. So not my choice.
- 22:13But I am given to understand that some people Like that
- 22:17experience. And so there's all of that to go
- 22:19explore as well. If you want to, I am a fan of
- 22:22Vegas. I feel like it's a very
- 22:25polarizing Choice. Some people are Vegas.
- 22:29Some people hate Vegas. I don't know anybody who's in
- 22:31the middle. It's like, yeah, there's the two
- 22:35extremes out there. I'm a fan of it.
- 22:36I think it's I think it's a great spot to have it.
- 22:39One of the things that you mentioned there and it just was
- 22:42as you're talking and say kike The conference seems fresh and I
- 22:46think that's the most important part of putting together.
- 22:50Any sort of agenda, topic speaker structure, you know, all
- 22:53this stuff goes into. This is, how do you keep it
- 22:55fresh year over year over year? And I think that is the great /.
- 23:00Fun / hard thing about identity, is that things change a lot even
- 23:05just within a year, right? Trends, new technologies, new
- 23:09threats, right? That we have to be kind of be
- 23:10concerned about. And that freshness, I think it's
- 23:13something. That you know, every conference
- 23:15probably strives to inject into that as I go.
- 23:18Okay, well, I went last year, why should I go again this year
- 23:21and maybe some people are on Cycles?
- 23:22You know, I know, I know a couple people who was like, okay
- 23:24well I go like every two years or every three years to see
- 23:26what's going on. I'm a fan of going to as many as
- 23:30I can, you know, that the content is great.
- 23:33But the thing that I find the most invaluable are the hallway
- 23:36conversations, I was at Gartner just a few weeks ago and I don't
- 23:41think I was able to attend very many sessions.
- 23:43I had a cute. I've had a couple key notes.
- 23:45I had a couple of sessions with like Becky and Enrique and stuff
- 23:48like that from Gartner analyst side of things.
- 23:50And those were great, but I spent a lot of time just talking
- 23:54with people and I think that's the one thing that I really
- 23:56appreciate about this identity. Space is, people are very
- 24:01welcoming. So if you see people having a
- 24:03conversation, if you see people out there is like, hey, there's
- 24:05Vittorio and his Italy, you know, gorgeous main, I want to
- 24:10go talk to him and find out what is using for shampoo and
- 24:12conditioner. You know, go do it because
- 24:15people are cool man. I mean, they're very receptive
- 24:18to going walking off. Introducing this other stuff
- 24:20like that. I feel like it's I'm the same
- 24:22way. It's a little bit, you know, if
- 24:23you're more of an introvert you kind of have to get out of that
- 24:26bubble and just walk up and say hello which can be tough and I
- 24:28get that find someone to make an introduction, you know, I think
- 24:31it's that's another area that's like hey if you're going with
- 24:33somebody else, you know there's strength in numbers or maybe if
- 24:36you know someone who's Going to there.
- 24:37Maybe they know someone and they can help make an introduction.
- 24:40I always find it really awkward when you like, you know, this
- 24:44isit. This actually happened at a
- 24:45fennec eight last year. In Seattle, was the torrio Ian.
- 24:49And I think it was Dean maybe from AWS, we're all kind of
- 24:56standing around kind of Talking Like These are Heavy Hitters in
- 24:58the identity space to do a lot of talk talks and presentations
- 25:02of like that. And I had kind of known you
- 25:04know, Vittorio Indian but didn't really know Dean so much and I
- 25:07just kind of I walked up and just kind of stood there
- 25:08awkwardly like oh and I just kind of joined the conversation
- 25:11right? But it was cool right?
- 25:13A oh that's not an opportunity that you get especially when you
- 25:16are remote all the time or if you're not attending
- 25:19conferences, that to me is the most valuable part.
- 25:22Yes, the content is good. Meet people.
- 25:25Go talk with people have conversations.
- 25:26I think there's a lot of value in that as well.
- 25:29Yeah, I think that's really good advice, Jeff and I agree, right?
- 25:33I like I say, it's hard for me to judge identify us anymore.
- 25:36Any because I'm I'm, you know, I'm there as it were and I've
- 25:39been there for a long time, but, all right, it is an incredibly
- 25:44welcoming industry and it's it, maybe feels a little
- 25:48disingenuous for you and I to be sitting hearing and we're
- 25:50throwing these names around right that people recognize and
- 25:53yet it's worth saying that, you know, for all that were involved
- 25:58in a pretty Deep Way in the industry.
- 26:00There are still lots of people that we don't know, right?
- 26:03And so it's not at all uncommon for me to have to, you know, to
- 26:07have exactly the experience. You just described of, oh, wait,
- 26:12there's this person whose name I vaguely recognize who I don't
- 26:16know. Looks after identity regulation
- 26:19for the UK government. Right?
- 26:21Okay. Well, I should probably go get
- 26:23to know that person and I have I'd like where do you start with
- 26:26that? Hi, I'm Andy, I ride
- 26:27anniversary. Okay.
- 26:29Yeah. It's not obvious but it is an
- 26:33incredibly welcoming industry. And I felt that from very early
- 26:38on like I didn't I didn't kind of grow up in this industry.
- 26:40Some people did write it was their first career out of school
- 26:42and that's and that's what they did.
- 26:43That wasn't my case thought. But yeah, really really
- 26:49welcoming industry and I think your observation that it's a
- 26:55rapidly changing industry, it has been True and continues to
- 27:00be true. In fact, so Ida Pro for a number
- 27:05of years. Now has run a skills and program
- 27:08survey we added some, some diversity components to that a
- 27:12few years ago as well. And really, the purpose of that
- 27:14is to help help ID Pro, but also to help the industry.
- 27:19Understand what shape. The professional industry is.
- 27:23Right? And honestly, nobody knew,
- 27:26right. Nobody had any idea.
- 27:27Well, Questions. Like, how long does it take you
- 27:31to feel proficient, right? And you can go and, you know,
- 27:36kind of look at the last four years, five years results on the
- 27:40only Pro website, but basically the number of people that say, I
- 27:44still don't feel proficient. And if you correlate that with
- 27:47the folks who've been in the industry for a long time, you
- 27:50get this weird sort of inverted curve, right, where people start
- 27:55off and they're in the industry one or two years and I don't
- 27:58feel profession. Aunt.
- 27:59And then you get folks in the middle who are like between say
- 28:02three and about seven or eight years who are like I got this.
- 28:07Then you get the people like you know, who've been in the
- 28:10industry for 10 12, 14, 16 years, you're like no, I have no
- 28:15clue what's going on anymore and that has been true, right?
- 28:20Those results have been pretty consistent for a number of
- 28:24years. Now, in fact, will occasionally
- 28:28Danvers the eye. Pro Crowder stood up and kind of
- 28:30talked about that in some detail this year, we'll go through it.
- 28:34I think there's a couple of sessions will all go through it
- 28:36at a slightly, higher level, and probably with a bit more
- 28:40reference to, you know, sort of what is the professional
- 28:43development Journey look like. And what are some ways to think
- 28:46about? You know, the way that we
- 28:49develop our, our careers in what is increasingly a sort of quote
- 28:54unquote, professionalized it ministry, right?
- 28:57But I invest some really, really Interesting stuff in that.
- 28:59One of the other things that's interesting, is the number of
- 29:04new people that are now emerging in the industry, right?
- 29:07Like again, it's growing and it's growing very rapidly and
- 29:13you talked about freshness. So, one of the things that that
- 29:17we look at and I talked about this on the main stage, quite a
- 29:20lot of identity is actually, but we we obviously look at an
- 29:25inclusivity across the agenda, and it's hard, right?
- 29:28It's And in this industry, as it is in any other.
- 29:31We know that there are that there are challenges there and
- 29:35we do our best to address them. I will say that.
- 29:38I don't think we do as well as I would like us to.
- 29:41But I'm proud of the fact that at least we're trying.
- 29:44Right. One of and part of that is, how
- 29:50do you define inclusiveness? And so for us it's always been a
- 29:55very broad definition and part The reason I bring it up in this
- 29:59context is one of the dimensions that we look at is the number of
- 30:07new voices across the speakers write the number of new voices
- 30:12versus the number of people who've spoken at a den of us
- 30:14before. For exactly that reason, right?
- 30:18You want to hear from different people?
- 30:21And yeah, there's some added value there in terms of helping
- 30:24people, you know, have some career progression opportunities
- 30:27and demonstrate all the stuff that they can do in worst of it.
- 30:30So we typically run somewhere between, you know, any given
- 30:34year 40 to 60 percent of the, you know, overall speaker makeup
- 30:39is new speakers, new presenters to the conference and that's
- 30:44been consistent now. At least five years if not
- 30:50longer. I personally and I would say
- 30:56this, right? I think that's really important.
- 31:00I would be fascinated to know what other people think, right?
- 31:03So you know if you're listening to this and you go to identify
- 31:05verse and you get the little survey question ever afterwards
- 31:07or even if you're in a session, right?
- 31:09Do the in session survey it just asks you know like did you enjoy
- 31:13the session or whatever? But Provide that feedback,
- 31:17right? Let us know because it's always
- 31:20that thing. It's not like we know any better
- 31:22than anybody else and if we don't get the feedback from
- 31:25people about, yeah, this topic was good.
- 31:27This topic wasn't great. This presented was clearly knew
- 31:31and they need to find their voice but they had some really
- 31:33interesting things to say, and that's the other thing I'd
- 31:35encourage, if you are giving feedback, what there are ways to
- 31:39make it positive, right? Like, you don't have to be
- 31:41grumpy in the survey feedback, okay?
- 31:43You suck. Get off stage, you know.
- 31:46Like let's avoid that but constructive criticism, that's
- 31:50well-meant well-intentioned, I think is incredibly helpful.
- 31:55So I would really encourage people to kind of engage with
- 31:58that. You know, if you are attending,
- 31:59let us know what you think. That's super helpful.
- 32:03I love that idea. I think, you know, be fair with
- 32:06that kind of thing. Getting on stage is not easy,
- 32:08right? You're putting yourself out
- 32:10there. Think about that, right?
- 32:12From your perspective, like you're sitting in the chair
- 32:13listening. You're not up on stage, so Maybe
- 32:16someday it'll be you and I think that that feedback does help
- 32:19right? Is understanding.
- 32:20And yeah maybe it is the first time, you know, you're hearing
- 32:23from somebody and, you know, maybe they knock out of the
- 32:25park. Maybe there's a couple things
- 32:26work on. That's cool.
- 32:27They took the step of getting on stage and putting themselves out
- 32:31there, which I think is the first step towards.
- 32:33Yeah. Keeping that freshness, keeping
- 32:34that that, that conversation alive.
- 32:37I love the idea of have a new speakers out there and, you
- 32:39know, kind of hearing it's out there because at some point,
- 32:42right? There's going to be a Changing
- 32:44of the Guard and it's a constant.
- 32:46Refresh in a cycle, right? At some point there will be new
- 32:49sort of you know leaders in the space that are out there giving
- 32:52opinions or coming up with new ways of doing things that I
- 32:55think people need to hear about you.
- 32:57And I were talking a couple days ago about, you know, who are
- 33:00some of these new speakers and maybe trying to get them on the
- 33:03show here making and you know, Andy, can you make an
- 33:06introduction for me and Jim Wright, they go have a
- 33:09conversation, you know, with these folks and see if they'd be
- 33:11interested in being on the podcast and things like that.
- 33:13So yeah, I'm excited to be that. And that's a really fun idea and
- 33:18already valuable idea. And, you know, maybe one of the
- 33:21things we're not brainstorming live on the podcast, but, you
- 33:24know, maybe 120 doings that. Yeah.
- 33:26So maybe one of the things we do is, you know, you guys are going
- 33:29to be there in Vegas, in a couple months time and, yeah,
- 33:35you know, I can go through the agenda and try and say, well,
- 33:37you should go to this and this and this, but you guys are going
- 33:38to be that, right? So, I would do a little bit of
- 33:40divide and conquer and go and go and listen, right currency
- 33:43while, you know, who's out there that saying, some stuff that You
- 33:46know, that's a different perspective.
- 33:48That's a different take that, you know, maybe is a couple of
- 33:51years into their career that you know we need to hear from and
- 33:57it's occurring to me that there may well.
- 33:59Be some folks, you know, listening to this who are in
- 34:01that group of hey this is my first identify a person like
- 34:04well, you know, and so yet the Obama show, we're friendly.
- 34:08I swear if we take good care of people, exactly.
- 34:12But actually, it's true, right, we get feedback.
- 34:14So, like, I say, we've got a process For this, that's that's
- 34:17again, not perfect, but, reasonably well, established,
- 34:20over over a number of years. Everything that gets presented
- 34:24in the main agenda goes through this.
- 34:26This content review, process with the content committee and
- 34:28actually goes through a two-step process and it is absolutely
- 34:32designed to be a supportive helpful constructive process
- 34:35process, right? It's not a case of the content
- 34:38committee trying to editorialize.
- 34:39What we're trying to do is to make sure that speakers have as
- 34:43good an experience as they can and we are Some really nice
- 34:47feedback last year. This didn't come to me directly.
- 34:50It came through one of the content could members but
- 34:54someone who actually is an experienced presenter, right?
- 34:57And they speak at conferences fairly technical conferences
- 35:00around the world and have done for years and their commentary
- 35:04was like I have never had the amount of constructive feedback
- 35:09through a Content review. Then I got that identifies to
- 35:13the extent that it actually led to some improvements in the
- 35:16Nation that they were writing right now that isn't going to
- 35:18happen for everybody but you know folks that are new
- 35:24absolutely. A Gonna Get, You know, here's a
- 35:27way to think about constructing this material in a more
- 35:31effective way. Or have you considered putting a
- 35:33summary slide at the end because that'll help people remember
- 35:36what you said. Or, you know, sometimes it's the
- 35:39basic things. You've got a 20-minute
- 35:40presentation unless you rem Glaser 121 slides is not going
- 35:45to work. Right?
- 35:49And and we can help with that. And there are lots of people
- 35:51even within the community who are willing to help.
- 35:55So if you happen to be a member ID Pro, you know, I would reach
- 35:58out and select Channel there and say, hey look, I'm I'm preparing
- 36:01my deck and I'd love to get some pointers and people will help,
- 36:04right? They'll absolutely help.
- 36:07Yeah. It's a it's a fun thing to be
- 36:10involved. In is all I can say.
- 36:11Yeah. The creative process is
- 36:13interesting. I think back to like our first
- 36:15episode of me in my basement with a very echoey microphone
- 36:18and now here we are. The audio quality is gotten
- 36:21better as a contact gun better. I don't know.
- 36:23I feel like we've been relatively consistent, but we
- 36:25get feedback all the time. Too much banter upfront.
- 36:27You took too long to get to the topic, right?
- 36:29You're talking about things that don't make sense to me.
- 36:31Maybe they make sense of someone else, you know?
- 36:33And we take that out, you know? And I think that's part of that
- 36:35same process, right? Is you can get smarter over
- 36:37time. Our time, it's okay to evolve
- 36:39adapt iterate, right? Because a lot of times and maybe
- 36:43I'm maybe I'm peeling back a little bit of the conference
- 36:46circuit tour. Is you develop you know, a talk
- 36:49or presentation and you might give it one, two, three, ten
- 36:52times. And you will take feedback as
- 36:56you go on the way to say, oh, okay, here's another way that I
- 36:58can kind of do this or make it more specific to the type of
- 37:01audience is going into. So, you know, it's interesting
- 37:05to see the first time someone presents.
- 37:07And then to see it maybe a year or two later when they're
- 37:10presenting again at a different, you know, venue for people who
- 37:12maybe haven't seen it before and to see what's changed.
- 37:15And that's a result of that feedback.
- 37:16They probably got behind the scenes.
- 37:18Yeah, that's a really interesting observation Jeff and
- 37:20you up, you're absolutely right. You know, the the way that talks
- 37:24evolved over time is, is fascinating, and it actually
- 37:28leads me to a thought, which is, you know, for those people that
- 37:32do have the opportunity to do that, that's fantastic.
- 37:35Equally if you're turning up at a Conference and this is the
- 37:38first run right? Whether it's identifies or any
- 37:41other conference, I would highly highly highly recommend finding
- 37:46a couple of friendlies and doing a full run-through of like
- 37:52properly presented maybe even two or three times just to help
- 37:59hone it a little bit. So that actually the first time
- 38:02you do it and particularly, if presenting isn't a thing that
- 38:06you do on a regular The first time you do, it isn't the first
- 38:10time you did it. And it's funny because I fell
- 38:13into exactly this trap actually not with the presentation, but
- 38:17with a podcast and it wasn't this one, it was a different one
- 38:24that wasn't specifically focused on identity, but it was the
- 38:26first one that I ever done. And I assumed that given that I
- 38:34present and I do that, you know, like freely without About notes
- 38:38and I make stuff up and it's fine because I know stuff and
- 38:40that's okay, right? And I'm used to it.
- 38:42I just assumed that I could get on a podcast and it would be
- 38:46fine. And you know what?
- 38:50It's not. And so I learned and this was
- 38:54what like two years ago. So not a long time ago, this is
- 38:57recent and I make notes. Now for podcasts of here are the
- 39:05things that I want to talk about and here are some key facts that
- 39:09I don't want to forget halfway through and then you know when
- 39:13Jeff asks me a question, I'm like I'm going to make a note of
- 39:16that somewhere, very quietly so that the sound doesn't come
- 39:19through the microphone. I'm Thudding.
- 39:20See, Jeff. Thank you.
- 39:21Thank you. And you know, so that I know
- 39:24that I can come back around to it later and it it's a constant
- 39:28learning experience. And so I go for the new people,
- 39:31I'd absolutely say, you know, even the folks that are standing
- 39:33up on that big stage and identify verse or Gartner or you
- 39:37know, RSA, whatever it is. Everybody is still learning how
- 39:41to get better at this, right? Yeah, I think you bring up a
- 39:45really good point there too, but the rehearse it right,
- 39:48understand it? No.
- 39:49The content. Here's my Pro tip.
- 39:52Don't read a slide, there's nothing worse than being than
- 39:56having a slide full of text and you're literally just reading it
- 39:59to the person I could have done that.
- 40:01I think the challenge for a lot of people is when they're
- 40:04finding their voice is not being afraid, to let their personality
- 40:07show be dynamic, right? Let some of your personal to go
- 40:10through. Yeah.
- 40:11Identity. You know, may not be the most
- 40:13exciting Topic in the world. I hate to say it, but there are
- 40:16ways to still make it entertaining, engaging, you
- 40:19know, no, you don't want to be the monotone voice saying
- 40:22everything in the same tone, and just kind of reading a voice,
- 40:24write a robot, that kind of thing is take a moment, right?
- 40:28You don't have to fill dead air, right?
- 40:30You can have Thoughtful pauses, as you're going through the
- 40:34conversation. So I know it's a skill.
- 40:36I mean you mentioned, you know taking notes we do that for all
- 40:39of our shows here is we put together sort of here's the idea
- 40:43for the topic and let's come up with like three to five
- 40:45questions so that Jim and I don't ramble, you know too far
- 40:49off the beaten path sometimes we do sometimes Jim goes a downer
- 40:51path and I have to pull them back to the light.
- 40:54You like come on let's go let's go let's bring it back up but
- 40:57you know that's just part of the process so yeah I think I think
- 41:01it's a great idea. Is to make sure if, especially,
- 41:03if it's your first time presenting this year, if you're
- 41:04listening to this, I'd be happy to listen to it.
- 41:06You know, feel free. You know, we do that for our
- 41:09friends and, you know, everybody identity space that I come
- 41:11across has been very friendly and happy to do that too.
- 41:13So I want to shift gears a little bit because you mentioned
- 41:17a couple things like women, and identity and ID Pro, it seems to
- 41:21me that ID pro has sort of made identify verse sort of the whole
- 41:25conference for them. And I wonder about, you know,
- 41:28relationships between some of these organizations like, women
- 41:31identity, like Like ID Pro like others.
- 41:34What is though, what does that type of relationship with the
- 41:38conference itself? Is their influence on?
- 41:41What are some of the tracks or topics?
- 41:43You know. Are there Events maybe they get
- 41:45kind of set aside you know for some of those folks, those types
- 41:48of things. Yeah, that was a thoughtful
- 41:52pause. Just then, folks.
- 41:54So yeah, we do. We absolutely have those
- 41:59relationships with a number of organizations, and I think the
- 42:02nature of those relationships to some degree.
- 42:06Mmm, dictates is, maybe not the right word.
- 42:08But influences, you know what the impact is?
- 42:11So we'll start with ID Pro, just because I think you started with
- 42:15it, so I'll start with it Ida Pro, and it was founded in.
- 42:20Well, a little bit before 2017, but it was the 2017 conference,
- 42:25which was in. He says, racking his brains.
- 42:28I want to say Chicago Chicago. Yep.
- 42:30Good. I'm glad so glad I got that
- 42:32right? You have never played it Ian and
- 42:34Sarah, very happy with you as an adult.
- 42:36One of the things I wrote down in advance.
- 42:40Yeah. So in Chicago and we actually
- 42:41announced, you know, the the formation of it Pros, a
- 42:45standalone, nonprofit entity, you know, on the main stage and
- 42:49one of the things that we announced at Time.
- 42:51Was that identify us was the home show for ID Pro and that's
- 42:54been true ever since. Now some of that with with an ID
- 42:58Pro Hat on at the time, was a little bit self-serving in the
- 43:02sense that look, there's this big conference that most of the
- 43:05identity professionals go to. So, why would we go and make
- 43:08another one? Hey, here it is.
- 43:12But what we've done over time is slightly formalized, that
- 43:16relationship. And so yeah, there has been for
- 43:19a number of years now. A professional development sort
- 43:23of topic area or track show which really focuses on war of
- 43:28the soft skills. So, we've had topics, like, like
- 43:31we mentioned top of the show, right?
- 43:33How do I pitch my project? How do I get budget?
- 43:36How do I manage a team? How do I hire an inclusive way?
- 43:40Right? How do I deal with stress in?
- 43:44You know, instant response is actually one of the talks this
- 43:46year which I'm really looking forward to, you know, the Just a
- 43:51short flight of that stress when I started interrupt, but I hope
- 43:55that horse person that just has like a picture of a liquor
- 43:57bottle and I, all right, talk over and it's like 30 seconds
- 44:00and as I just kidding, like there's more things, but I think
- 44:02that would be hilarious. We'd open it up, but I digress.
- 44:04Please continue the, let's fly you digress as much as you like,
- 44:08Jeff, any talks. Yeah.
- 44:11So, so, that is a topic area that is kind of curated within
- 44:17the overall construct of the show, but is is curated And
- 44:20assisted by folks, you know, within ID Pro and then, you
- 44:27know, typically they'll be, you know, some material up the front
- 44:32of the show. So there's the introduction to
- 44:34Identity that we've run for a long time.
- 44:36We get an interesting mix of people and that one, we get
- 44:38people who are just starting their careers.
- 44:40And we also get, you know, the the fifteen-year-old sort of
- 44:44expert kind of folks, the convergence sitting in the back
- 44:51I think I'm talking about is desperately trying to catch up
- 44:54or, or just want to Heckle. So that one's always fun to go
- 44:57to, right? But actually, I mean,
- 44:59personally, I always find it useful, 8.
- 45:01I really get to go to these things, so I get to see all this
- 45:04stuff in review up front. But I always find that one
- 45:07incredibly useful because it reminds me of you know, bits of
- 45:11the industry that maybe I'm not directly involved in right now
- 45:16that I forgotten about. And it also keeps me up to date
- 45:19usually with some new stuff. That's coming along, just just
- 45:22enough, so that, you know, I know enough to be dangerous,
- 45:25right? Which for me is is perfect and
- 45:29then there's quite often a social event as well, right?
- 45:32So I do, I don't know exactly when it's going to be, but I
- 45:35expect that ID Pro will probably have some kind of happy hour or
- 45:38gathering whether its formal or informal.
- 45:40There will be a thing that coalesces right.
- 45:43In fact I talked about the The sort of newcomers session that
- 45:51we're going to do this year that emerged in part from the
- 45:56conversations that we had in the in the learning the feedback we
- 45:59took but it also emerged in part from a Grassroots effort that
- 46:02took place last year when we were in Denver.
- 46:05When I do pro kind of went. Hey you know we think there's a
- 46:07bunch of new people here. We should try and get together.
- 46:09Some kind of you know, newcomers breakfast.
- 46:12It's very last minute, very Community Driven effort, you
- 46:16know. Pretty good that it happened.
- 46:18And so sort of you know it's nice to be able to take that and
- 46:21evolve it a little bit and wrap it into the show.
- 46:23Women and identity are going to help us with that as well this
- 46:26year. And so, you know, that brings me
- 46:28to Wed rate. We've had a close relationship
- 46:30with weird for a long time that relationship tends to be a
- 46:33little bit less sort of formally built into the agenda and some
- 46:37of that is reflective of, you know, the differences between
- 46:41between those two organizations. But you know, will quite often
- 46:44have conversations with worried about.
- 46:46Look, you know that particular speakers we can we can bring in.
- 46:51They've done quite a lot of work on some of the inclusivity
- 46:56impact of the identity systems that we build, right?
- 47:01So this isn't about the hiring question or the professional
- 47:04development question. It's about the availability of
- 47:09the systems that we've created to ought to allow, you know,
- 47:11access for everybody. And so we've, you know, we've
- 47:15had sessions. That material in the pasta, and
- 47:18that will be similar work going on this year.
- 47:21I imagine identify this as well. The other thing that we've done
- 47:25with both organizations that we did up front this year and arm
- 47:29is, we did a session in this case, specifically aimed at
- 47:33women and it was reasonably successful.
- 47:36And so, I'm considering whether there are ways we can extend
- 47:38that going into next year about okay.
- 47:41How do you put a proposal into a cfp because Cuz if you've never
- 47:47done that before, that can be a little bit daunting, and it's
- 47:53made least favorite part, right? Like, it's not easy.
- 47:57I mean, like, I put proposals in, on my own behalf to other
- 48:00conferences, I won't name them on a fairly regular basis and
- 48:05it's, you know, it's nerve-racking, it's like, is
- 48:08this going to work? Am I doing the right thing?
- 48:09So, if I answer the right questions the right way, have I
- 48:12have, I optimized my chances of being selected, right?
- 48:16As A human reading it or is some a I sort of just don't know.
- 48:20We can get into that conversation a bit but you know,
- 48:23it's it's tough, right? And so we thought, well look and
- 48:26this was an initiative that really came out of of ID Pro.
- 48:29And we're together saying, look, you know, we'd like to try and
- 48:32do something that's, that's aimed at that audience.
- 48:34So let's, you know, let's put something together.
- 48:37Let's do a presentation. Let's try and see if we can
- 48:39improve that experience. Like, I say this year,
- 48:42particularly for, for women Wanting to put proposals it and
- 48:48then we'll look and see if there are ways that we can extend that
- 48:50going to next year. Now, there are, of course,
- 48:54plenty of other both industry associations and professional
- 48:58organizations that we have varying degrees of relationship
- 49:02with. And the way that they get
- 49:04embedded into the event, then, you know, varies depending on
- 49:09who they are how they operate, what they're you know,
- 49:12relationship with the industry is what the relationship the
- 49:14show is all of those things. Things, right?
- 49:16So and that ranges from, you know, the sort of obvious
- 49:20standards or at least technical organizations, like Fido like oh
- 49:25IDF like Cantara, like away X, and so on, I'd be remiss if I
- 49:32didn't mention the idsa, which is a little different.
- 49:35But again, you know, very involved, very present in the
- 49:39industry. I think.
- 49:42Every single one of those organizations is going to be
- 49:45identical. Us this year.
- 49:46But more importantly we engage with them, not just for the
- 49:50conference, but actually right through the planning process
- 49:52through the year. And that some of those
- 49:54conversations is what then helps inform rate.
- 49:57What do we need to be thinking about in the agenda?
- 49:59What are we looking for in the cfp?
- 50:01Are there some things that just don't have a place to live in
- 50:05the way that we currently construct the agenda that we
- 50:08need to add or extend or consider for the main stage in
- 50:11some way because they don't that they're not there yet but we
- 50:14need to get there over time. Time kind of thing.
- 50:19So like I say it's flexible and varied and I think there are
- 50:25other organizations that will increasingly start to build
- 50:28relationships with. In fact, you know, we talked
- 50:32actually, we didn't talk about professional certifications,
- 50:36right? So that's obviously a space that
- 50:39it Pros increasingly playing in, but lots of people in this area
- 50:43have got one of the is e squared.
- 50:45Certifications right? Lots of people have one of the
- 50:49Privacy ones from the IEP. So actually Claire also use the
- 50:53CEO the executive director over at AC Squared is going to be on
- 50:57the stage this year. And you know talking a little
- 51:02bit about some of her perspectives in in connection
- 51:05with that, you know, what is the chief identity officer look like
- 51:09conversation, right? So I think that will be really
- 51:11interesting to get that perspective.
- 51:13We've got a number of Of folks involved both on the committee
- 51:18and in the agenda who've got privacy.
- 51:20Qualifications of fact, I do. And so I expect that that's
- 51:24relationship, that will continue to develop with the IPP over
- 51:27time. We've had, you know, I sort of I
- 51:33made a note that I then ignored upfront to say and I will now
- 51:37say it, which is, I was slightly hesitant to start naming
- 51:40organization so I'm bound to forget somebody, right?
- 51:43So it's our, if it's a hazard of a Of the medium, right?
- 51:46It is, you know, it's a little bit like the Oscars acceptance
- 51:49speech, isn't it? But that's what we try and do,
- 51:55right? It's a big tent.
- 51:58Everybody is welcome. And then from an agenda,
- 52:02standpoint, and it sort of strategic direction for the show
- 52:05standpoint. We try and I say, we, you know,
- 52:09The Advisory Board in the content committee.
- 52:10Try and Garner as much input as we can from all of those sources
- 52:14whether I named Add them, or not to try and make sure that we are
- 52:19as directionally representative as we can be whilst recognizing
- 52:25that we've only got four days and it's not possible to run the
- 52:30thing for 24 hours. So, you know, it's kind of, its
- 52:34kind of limiting but we try, maybe that's the next big idea
- 52:39of some sort of like, identity, circus, or theme park or
- 52:42something. It's open year-round.
- 52:44All the vendors from Are there everybody can kind of come and
- 52:47go as they please? I imagine it'd be maybe a maybe
- 52:50it's you know, a VR theme park or some sort.
- 52:52I don't know if that'll be all primary topic for next year.
- 52:55The identity circus, I can I can see it.
- 52:57Now, the last time we talked identify verse was with you was
- 53:03episode 149 and we asked you a question?
- 53:06What's the difference between digital identity?
- 53:08And I am and that spawned into one of our most?
- 53:13I do fun / controversial. /. I don't know what to call it
- 53:16episodes which is episode 51 where we took that question?
- 53:21And we asked a whole bunch of people in a lot of people who
- 53:24are listeners of the show you know kind of names industry that
- 53:27kind of thing. What is the difference between
- 53:29digital identity and identity and access management?
- 53:31We got a whole bunch of different answers and you know I
- 53:34want to give credit where it's due.
- 53:36It started here when a conversation with Andy and you
- 53:38know what does that mean? I'm curious.
- 53:41How do you define the two? Now that we're a year later?
- 53:44And I don't know if you've had a chance to go.
- 53:45Go back and you know listen what other people have said, you tell
- 53:50me since you're the one who started this problem, what is
- 53:53the difference between digital identity and identity and access
- 53:56management? Is another thoughtful, pause
- 54:00there for everyone. Thank you.
- 54:02That's, I'm good at that. It's just don't say anything for
- 54:05a minute. Um, so yeah, you know, I for
- 54:10one, I'm kind of amused about, I don't know whether to be amused
- 54:13or gratified, or embarrassed that I seem to have started a
- 54:16thing. I didn't necessarily mean to
- 54:18start a thing. But, II.
- 54:22Don't think that my perspective has necessarily changed, right?
- 54:26So, I saw some of the back and forth about this and I take it
- 54:31as ever been British. I take, I think everybody's
- 54:33right, right. But I do think that there is A
- 54:39breath that is emerging to the industry that I don't think
- 54:47we've necessarily thought about before, right?
- 54:50So for me I am tends to be focused on what I would call a
- 54:58set of Infrastructure capabilities, right?
- 55:04And I say that absolutely in a broad and positive sense, right?
- 55:14It encompasses all sorts of things like authorization
- 55:18authentication and Federation and SSO and Wham and you know
- 55:24what didn't I just say provisioning and IGA and all of
- 55:29those things. Things.
- 55:30Right. What's emerging again from my
- 55:38point of view, in my perspective is that there's a whole bunch of
- 55:42stuff around. The the identity verification
- 55:49identity, you know, trusted tributes.
- 55:53I'm going to say trust Frameworks.
- 55:55I don't know if we're playing a drinking game yet, but that
- 55:58feels to me like it's going to replace blockchain as being a
- 56:02thing where you have to take a drink every time.
- 56:03Somebody says it, right, trust framework off we go.
- 56:07But, you know, it's it's a thing and they have value and schemes
- 56:11and all of those sorts of things you look at what's happening
- 56:14with mdl, you Look at what's happening with, you know, that
- 56:18the wallets. Sorry, that's this is hard to
- 56:21say as words as opposed to having it sort of written down
- 56:25so you can see where the apostrophe is.
- 56:27So the various wallet initiatives.
- 56:29There we go. And a lot of that is not stuff
- 56:37that would traditionally fall into that that the scope the
- 56:41Ambit of I am right in my mind. Digital identity is a little
- 56:48broader than that and I think it's increasingly important for
- 56:53us as I'd only professionals to recognize that and back to an
- 56:58observation that you made you know, towards the top of the
- 57:02show jeff which Chiz. Understanding that we need to
- 57:09increasingly talk to people and engage with people who do not
- 57:14have identity as a background or even don't have a technical
- 57:18background, right? And help them understand where
- 57:22we fit into their world, right? That's the shift that I think
- 57:28needs to happen. In fact, I've been involved in a
- 57:32project in with my, you know. Me as a consultant hat on for
- 57:37the last. I want to say three months or so
- 57:41and it's one of those things where predictably I can't talk
- 57:44about the details. I'm going to have to hand wave
- 57:46virtually and and orally around some of the topics.
- 57:51But you know, essentially a project to help some folks you
- 57:55know kind of understand where some of these these broader
- 57:59scale digital identity initiatives, you know, verified
- 58:03anywhere, that kind of thing. Uh is going to fit into their
- 58:05world and had lots of great conversations with the technical
- 58:10folks that was fine. And then we got a couple of
- 58:12folks in the room. If you did not come from a
- 58:13technical background, didn't come from, I'd any background in
- 58:16particular, smart people, but they hear a word like You know,
- 58:25authentication user arrived at the site and they authenticated
- 58:29and in their head, what that means is that the service
- 58:35provide a new who the person was.
- 58:39Now. We know he says gesticulating
- 58:43wildly at Jeff on the screen, we know that that isn't what
- 58:48authentication means. But were increasingly having to
- 58:53be very clear when we go talk to people about what it does mean.
- 58:59And so I think for me that's really what this is about is
- 59:02digital identity. Is more than just the
- 59:04infrastructure, it's a whole bunch of new things and a whole
- 59:08bunch of new audiences that we got to go and engage with And I
- 59:13think we need to recognize that. Understanding the context in the
- 59:17audience I think is a big part of that conversation.
- 59:20I've noticed a shift in just the way that I even I talked about
- 59:24any management over the last few years where I felt like a few
- 59:29years ago you could be maybe a little looser with your
- 59:32language. Okay.
- 59:32We're kind of talking about this thing and you know, it's kind of
- 59:35nebulous and we're kind of that. I find myself having to be a lot
- 59:38more precise with my language based on who I'm talking to you.
- 59:41Because if I, if I say okay well yes they authenticate it and I'm
- 59:44talking to Scott McPherson. I'll have to happen but they do
- 59:46what were the factors but a little.
- 59:47All right, I'm talking to a CIO or an executive or someone
- 59:51without, you know, that kind of context background.
- 59:53They probably don't care, right? They don't.
- 59:56Was it secure? Did it happen was the customer
- 59:58was the employee happy where they would go through a lot.
- 1:00:00Great, I don't even know the details on that side.
- 1:00:03So I have seen that that shift over the years.
- 1:00:06You mentioned a fennec 810 occasion and I want to start to
- 1:00:09wrap things up here because I've been really generous with your
- 1:00:11time. I feel like we've solved with
- 1:00:14education. We fixed it.
- 1:00:15We're done. House keys are a thing Fido has
- 1:00:17done a great job of getting all the major players on.
- 1:00:20We don't have to worry about anymore.
- 1:00:21So what I'm thinking next is, what is our next
- 1:00:24thought-provoking conversation? Very much along the lines of,
- 1:00:27you know, the difference between a digital identity identity
- 1:00:29access management. So what is something that you're
- 1:00:32thinking about like from a next perspective that we should be
- 1:00:34asking the questions? Yeah that's it.
- 1:00:37That's a really good question. I'm sitting here thinking get
- 1:00:39with an equation is dead low-middle Federation.
- 1:00:41Um so so like I I take your point Absolutely right.
- 1:00:46I think, you know In fairness. Yeah, there's a lot that we've
- 1:00:52quote-unquote sold, authentication, getting it
- 1:00:54deployed, getting it out there. Getting people to use these new
- 1:00:59systems and be comfortable with them is a journey, right?
- 1:01:06I'm not great at predictions. That's one of the reasons why
- 1:01:10going to Vegas, doesn't really work for me because I am not
- 1:01:12going to be gambling, but but the food is good.
- 1:01:15Yeah. Yeah, but I it's at least in my
- 1:01:20view a five-year problem if not right?
- 1:01:23So and I think it's also fair to say that there are still lots of
- 1:01:26conversations going on about some of the details underneath
- 1:01:29things like passkey, right? We're okay.
- 1:01:33Yeah, for this 80% use case, it's great.
- 1:01:35Here's a twenty percent use case that actually kind of matters
- 1:01:37because it's in a regulated industry.
- 1:01:39And how do we deal with that? And what is the user experience
- 1:01:42look like? What is the user experience?
- 1:01:43Look like if you're, you know, No, on an old device versus one
- 1:01:48of these shiny new things, you know, what's the user
- 1:01:51experience. If you drop your phone in your
- 1:01:53beer, you know, that kind of thing, right?
- 1:01:55So there's a lot still to be done, but it's very you get
- 1:01:59suspicion. Suspiciously specific example in
- 1:02:02what I just never happened to me, but I've seen it happen to
- 1:02:04other people heard about it, right?
- 1:02:05Yeah, okay. So, you know, I think there's a
- 1:02:10lot still to talk about there and in fact, we've got, you
- 1:02:12know, as it happens. And honestly, dear listener,
- 1:02:16this was not a fed question, right?
- 1:02:18But we do have a number of sessions on exactly those topics
- 1:02:20that identifies. Having said all of that, I think
- 1:02:25a shift that I think, and I think a number of people on the
- 1:02:30content committee thought that we'd started to see not just in
- 1:02:34the call for presentations but actually in some of the
- 1:02:36conversations that we're having around the edges of stuff is
- 1:02:39that authorization which has been like hesitate to say this
- 1:02:45and get a bunch of people bent out of shape, but a little
- 1:02:48static for a while, right? I think we're starting to see a
- 1:02:53sudden. Even sudden is not the right
- 1:02:57word, eight gradual, but increasing.
- 1:03:05Focus on. That area, right?
- 1:03:11It's almost as if now I figured out good ways and safe ways to
- 1:03:16get people in the front door. Now, I've got that put to bed,
- 1:03:22let me make sure that they can only get into their own hotel
- 1:03:27room. He says, stretching the analogy
- 1:03:29to Breaking Point and not into anybody else's, right?
- 1:03:33I think there's some interesting activity going on there.
- 1:03:36I think there's a bunch of interesting questions to be
- 1:03:39asked maybe a standards level but particularly our product
- 1:03:43level around, how do we integrate things like Verifiable
- 1:03:51credentials into those flows. There's a real thinking that
- 1:03:57needs to get done there. And the other one that's come up
- 1:04:01in that regard is Some of the mmm, more challenging use, cases
- 1:04:09around delegation with real-world identity, right?
- 1:04:14So in a lot of places, a lot of countries around the world,
- 1:04:19we've now got a bunch of stuff going on with age, estimation
- 1:04:22age verification, right? Very sensible.
- 1:04:26Very good, very fine. But a lot of the legislation and
- 1:04:35the regulation that's being developed quite understandably
- 1:04:38as sort of slightly shied away. From the complexities of, I'm a
- 1:04:44say a parent or Guardian managing this and access on
- 1:04:48behalf of a child who is of age XYZ, right?
- 1:04:52How does that? Now, these are questions that
- 1:04:54we've been talking about in the industry.
- 1:04:55A long time, but back to the previous sort of segments of
- 1:04:59conversation. Not everybody else has, right?
- 1:05:02And so it turns out that there's a little bit of Education that
- 1:05:05we probably need to do. But there's also probably some
- 1:05:07things that we haven't thought about all that aren't yet baked
- 1:05:10into the technology. And I think that's really gonna
- 1:05:13hit us particularly in in that authorization space.
- 1:05:18So I mean, that's where it gets critical.
- 1:05:22So there's right for me, I think that's going to be really
- 1:05:26interesting getting into into next year.
- 1:05:29I agree. I think this is another
- 1:05:31Universal topic, right? Everybody struggled with
- 1:05:33authentication, is it fixed? No, I was being kind of
- 1:05:35tongue-in-cheek before but it's getting better, right?
- 1:05:37We're starting to see really significant progress and making
- 1:05:41it a better more secure user experience.
- 1:05:45The authorization is another one that a lot of organizations
- 1:05:47struggle with, I don't know how many companies that I talk to.
- 1:05:49They're like, oh yeah, we're trying to do row base.
- 1:05:52Access Control. Oh my gosh.
- 1:05:53Okay, congratulations. And I'm sorry, it is very
- 1:05:57difficult to do that. And we've seen a whole bunch of
- 1:05:59the use, like, you know, X BAC, right?
- 1:06:02Roll are back a back P back. I don't know, there's probably a
- 1:06:07one for each kind of back that's out there.
- 1:06:09Now we're standing see things like zero standing privileges,
- 1:06:12right? All this is doing with
- 1:06:13authorizations and things like that.
- 1:06:15So I think it'd be interesting to see how the market the
- 1:06:19industry and sort of the thing. Around this starts to fine-tune
- 1:06:24that I love that analogy, right? We've got a front door.
- 1:06:26I'll take it instead of the hotel.
- 1:06:28Like, okay, now we've got him in the house.
- 1:06:30How do we make sure that I go and get my medicine cabinet?
- 1:06:32All right, we're going to the liquor cabinet or if they are
- 1:06:34allowed, you know, can they get is that sorts of things?
- 1:06:37I think that's really kind of a natural evolution of that.
- 1:06:40All right, we're running over an hour now, but I want to, I want
- 1:06:43to end on a lighter note. And here's my question for you.
- 1:06:46This is not indicative of our guests any way, shape, or form.
- 1:06:49But let's just pretend End. You are a thief that steals only
- 1:06:55things that caused a minor inconvenience to your victims.
- 1:06:58What do you steal? So this isn't we're talking,
- 1:07:01we're not talking like Grand Theft, you know homicide.
- 1:07:05But I like that it's got to be something that's very you know
- 1:07:09very inconvenience is like oh that's super annoying.
- 1:07:12What's the thing that you steal? This is Jeff trying to end the
- 1:07:16light in them first so you know, that's that.
- 1:07:22It's an interesting one, I think.
- 1:07:26I can think of all sorts of things but I think the one that
- 1:07:29would that's small but would work me.
- 1:07:32Certainly I have run into this, not not through Steph but
- 1:07:35through let's call it user error.
- 1:07:37So if you're a, if you're a Mac Book user, you may remember, or
- 1:07:43in fact, have yet again, the wonderful magsafe power
- 1:07:47connector and they switch from like a 4-pin to a 6 pin or a
- 1:07:526-pin 25. I can't remember which way
- 1:07:54around it was and you could get this Fantastic.
- 1:07:57Little adapter, right? That solved.
- 1:07:59All your problems and meant that you could use the old charger
- 1:08:01with the new thick. Yeah, I would steal that.
- 1:08:07If you found there the the gaping hole in the armor of the
- 1:08:10Maco world and dongle life is, as we like to call it.
- 1:08:14I think that's a good one, you know.
- 1:08:15I thought about this question myself is kind of sit here
- 1:08:17recording. And, you know, I think of things
- 1:08:20like, you know, stealing someone's chapstick, I'm
- 1:08:24thinking of something a little more nefarious, a very specific,
- 1:08:28I'm going to take a couple pieces of a Lego or a puzzle set
- 1:08:33or something like that that you cannot finish whatever it is,
- 1:08:37you're trying to build without that piece, that's evil that
- 1:08:42went to see. And the worst thing about that
- 1:08:44is I actually know how to solve for it as well.
- 1:08:46Which would require me to go buy a 3D printer, right?
- 1:08:49Exactly. Oh yeah.
- 1:08:53How many people have come across?
- 1:08:53Right? You're doing a puzzle, you're
- 1:08:55playing a game or something, right?
- 1:08:56And there's just that One piece missing or two or three, you
- 1:08:59know, and here's the thing. As I wouldn't take the last
- 1:09:02piece, I would take like those. The piece that's like five or
- 1:09:06six away from the end and really make a devious, that's the way I
- 1:09:10would do it. Yeah.
- 1:09:11Now that's, that's, that's Machiavellian.
- 1:09:14I think in its quality job. Thank you.
- 1:09:16Thank you very much. I will take that as a compliment
- 1:09:19and how it's not every day that I get to use the word
- 1:09:20Machiavelli and so this is true. I think that might be the first
- 1:09:23time actually on the show. So that'll be a tidbit for
- 1:09:26Jeopardy, when When will you become a Jeopardy question at
- 1:09:29some point, the future and even really great.
- 1:09:32If your time, I'm gonna go ahead and wrap things up here.
- 1:09:34I dunno versus coming up, May 30th to June 2nd.
- 1:09:37It's at the Aria Resort and Casino in Las Vegas.
- 1:09:41I will be there and you'll be there.
- 1:09:43Jim, theoretically be there, so we're hopeful, you know, come on
- 1:09:47up, introduce yourselves. You know, we love to engage with
- 1:09:50folks out there and talk and just have a conversation about
- 1:09:54whatever could be about Identity or it can be about, you know, my
- 1:09:57Terror. Ville stealing of Lego and
- 1:10:00puzzle pieces. That would really, you know,
- 1:10:02piss people off. Don't forget about our identity
- 1:10:05versus registration code. The discount 20% off its ID V
- 1:10:09Dash icen 23, it'll be on our show notes, you can always
- 1:10:14reference there. Thank you again.
- 1:10:15Andy and CRA for hooking us up with that and hooking our
- 1:10:17listeners up that. So hopefully people are able to
- 1:10:19take advantage of that we'll have links to identify first.com
- 1:10:23in our show notes, hindle consulting.com, connecting, Andy
- 1:10:28LinkedIn, and obviously can connect with Jim.
- 1:10:31And I, whenever you want, we're on the web.
- 1:10:33Idac podcast.com, or on Twitter at, idac podcasts, run,
- 1:10:37Mastodon. Even at idac podcast at infosec
- 1:10:41got exchanged. So, don't forget to check us out
- 1:10:43there and be sure to like subscribe, write a review, all
- 1:10:45that stuff, totally helps us and really keeps us encourage you
- 1:10:49keep putting out content. Real quick question for Andy.
- 1:10:51What are your thoughts on Mastodon?
- 1:10:52Are you on Mastodon yet? I am, I have just like two days
- 1:10:56ago set. Myself up to not ask me what my
- 1:11:00thing is, I'll give it to you afterwards, and you can stick it
- 1:11:02in the, in the show notes. I honestly can't remember.
- 1:11:06But yes, I am, I think, you know, it's, it seems like a
- 1:11:12healthy place to be for. Now, I'll be honest and say my,
- 1:11:17you know, I'm not a huge social media person, right?
- 1:11:20I do LinkedIn, a little bit more than anything else, but, yeah,
- 1:11:24I'm there. I know, lots of people are as
- 1:11:26well. Yes, I shall.
- 1:11:29I shall lick you up and we can we can connect and toot at each
- 1:11:34other or whatever it's called. It is a very weird thing.
- 1:11:38Yeah I'm glad you mentioned the the difficulty in Reading.
- 1:11:40That's my biggest problem with Macedon is is I don't feel like
- 1:11:43it's a very user-friendly experience.
- 1:11:46You have to know not only now that, you know the name but
- 1:11:49which server are you on? It just makes it another.
- 1:11:53Another problem to be solved at some point anyway.
- 1:11:56Okay, there. I go digressing again.
- 1:11:58All right, we're going to go ahead and wrap it up.
- 1:12:00Thank you very much. Andy for being special, guest
- 1:12:02co-host with me. This week will have Jim back on
- 1:12:05in the future. Don't worry, he's not going
- 1:12:06anywhere. He's just on assignments.
- 1:12:09So thanks for listening. And we'll talk with everyone in
- 1:12:12the next one. Thanks, everyone bye.
- 1:12:16You've been listening to Identity at the center.
- 1:12:19We hope you've enjoyed the show, make sure to like rate and
- 1:12:23review and we'll be back soon, but in the meantime hit the web
- 1:12:27Site at identity at the center.com and find us on
- 1:12:31Twitter at, idac podcast. See you next time on identity at
- 1:12:38the center