Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 452. The Great Menopause Myth
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Thyroid Fixer podcast, where we dive deep into the world of thyroid and hormones, especially for you ladies navigating perimenopause and menopause, and really for anyone struggling with hypothyroidism. I'm your host, Dr. Amy, thyroid and hormone specialist and CEO of a global telemedicine practice where we prescribe the right thyroid treatment and bioidentical hormones to all 50 states and most of Canada, helping you become that badass human that you're meant to be.
- 0:29So if you're battling weight gain and hair loss, you can't lose weight no matter what you do, your energy levels are plummeting and your libido left town, then you're in the right place and you have found your tribe. Remember, I want you to embrace every inch of that badass woman that you truly are. So if you're ready to dive in and fix things, let's get started.
- 0:51If questions of menopause are swirling around your head and you really just don't know how to tackle this time of life, or you're in perimenopause and you're thinking, should I start hormones? What are these little symptoms that are popping up? Why is my vagina dry? Why am I getting really hot and agitated all of a sudden? Then you need to listen to this episode. We are breaking apart great menopause myths.
- 1:18And this even includes you perimenopausal ladies too, because this is the time where you have to pay attention to your body and know the signs and symptoms and know what to do with it. Is it time to do some lifestyle and nutrition changes or is it time to start looking into hormone replacement?
- 1:35And then myself and my guests, Kristen and Maria, we also dove into our own personal stories of what it was like to enter menopause, what happened to our bodies, and then what did we do about it? So enjoy this episode. This is for all menopause.
- 1:51Matt Perry and Menno ladies out there. Maria and Kristen, thank you so much for joining me today. And I just want to have, you know, the best conversation ever about menopause because I don't think enough women had these types of conversations with their friends.
- 2:08And that's what we're going to do today. And yes, I mean, you wrote a freaking amazing book called The Great Menopause Myth. We were talking off air before we came on. And I was telling you guys how beautifully, amazingly written this is because it is a guide. It is a full-blown, you touch on everything in here that women need to know.
- 2:29guide. So we're going to get into certain things in here that I absolutely love and want to cover. But I want to just start off by talking just as we would if we were sitting down having coffee and and let's bring all the other women listeners into the conversation and let's talk about
- 2:46menopause and what it means and what it's like and all of that. So let's just do that. So thanks for jumping on today. I'll start there. Thanks for having us. You know, I mean, all right. So Maria, let's start with you. How old are you? When did you go into menopause and how did that even feel making that transition? Did you have symptoms? Was it tough? Tell me about that. That's a great question. Thank you for asking. So I'm just turned 56. I would say I was fully menopausal by 47.
- 3:13And I guess I really felt in the throes of perimenopause at around 45 was when it really hit. And, you know, I never had a hot flash. I like to joke and say the only hot flash I had was I was standing in the Austin airport
- 3:29going back to New York city. And I realized that I showed up 24 hours late for my flight. I had a hot flash then. I think that was an anxiety attack. But thank God I didn't have a ton of hot flashes. I think mood, you know, I just started to feel cranky and disconnected, disconnected from my husband, kind of like wanting to isolate, not really caring about being social anymore and sleep for sure. And then surprisingly,
- 3:58Vaginal dryness, like really dumb at like 45, 46. And I was like, what is this? And I mean, I knew what it was, but I was like, wow, that's a very kind of
- 4:10odd manifestation so early in the process. Yeah. So those symptoms started coming on. And then what did you decide to do about it? Like you kind of knew, okay, this is happening. Did your periods get wonky? What were your next steps? Yeah, it's also a really great question. So early on, I kind of turned my nose up at HRT. It was very early in the process. And I was like...
- 4:39I've been a natural girl my whole life. Why would I do that? Very quickly turned around. Very, very quickly. Thankfully, I've had some really amazing mentors. And, you know, just you have this change in almost worldview, right? From natural, why would I do that to holy smokes, I do need to do that. It's not about symptoms. I don't have a ton of symptoms. Like I'm not
- 5:07you know, putting on massive amounts of weight and just like, you know, can't move throughout my day. Like I still was high functioning person, but I just like, I was able to connect to the fact that it's a really significant sea change in a woman's body and her, her health. And I was like, okay, make total sense. It was, you know, it was, it was hormones from about age 48 on for me, HRT, full HRT, estrogen oil.
- 5:35progesterone ended up adding testosterone later, but you know, it's been great. Thanks for being transparent about that because I know a lot of women out there. I've heard it from my patients as well. I don't really want to take a medication. I don't want to be on that the rest of my life or do I have to be on hormones the rest of my life? Now to that, I answer, you're not going to want to go off the hormones.
- 5:58When you feel really good, you don't take that away. That's making you feel good. But I hear that so often. And I'm glad you're kind of bridging that topic because it's so hard to convince women that like, yeah, but hormones aren't like the antidepressant that you're on because your doctor thinks that you need it, but you really need hormones. Like that's the medication that you want to go up and you want to put in the hormones. Yeah.
- 6:25I mean, I still deal with it with my own husband who's supposed to be kind of holistically minded. Like I just about nine months ago got him on testosterone and I think he's doing quite well. And he's like, oh, yeah, you know, OK, I'll do this. But I don't like having to use exogenous substances. And I'm like, just shut up and put it on. Mine's the same way. I get it. I know. I know. Mine's the same way.
- 6:50So, yeah. All right, Kristen, what about you? Like, what was your journey like? Yeah, I mean, it was similar in some of my lack of symptoms, but pretty different from Maria's overall. So I'm 54. I was very hormonally depleted after my third child, which was about 32, and was offered antidepressants, was offered sleep meds, was offered all the things, and ultimately took an IUD.
- 7:15Didn't know any better at the time. You know, if I could go back and reverse it, I would, but I did go with the MyRen IUD, which is we know is a progestin. No, my mom died of breast cancer. So the fact that anyone was offering me and she had it quite young. So the fact that anyone offered me a progestin was just literal malpractice, but we won't get into that.
- 7:32So I didn't have a cycle, right? And on AUD, I don't have a cycle. So I didn't have any of those cycle changes telling me that something was going on. Because I didn't have that as sort of a benchmark, the things that were happening to me never occurred to me that they were hormonal. I literally thought I was just losing my mind. I thought I was losing who I was. For me, it was late, late 30s, like 39 to 43 was an absolute just smack in the face with a brick wall. You know, it was...
- 7:59The foggy brain, it was the sort of flat affect, not really getting up with life and not really getting down with life. Definitely loss of libido, questioning what was wrong with me because I loved my husband, but I just had no, I just had nothing left to give.
- 8:15Couldn't get through my day without lots of lists. And I was at a very high level performing as a rower competitively. And so my sports performance started to decline too, which of course, then you lean into the more is more, meant more training, you know, more adrenal taxation, all the things I shouldn't have been doing.
- 8:33But that was kind of what I was going through. And again, my mom had surgical menopause at 32. So she had nothing to offer in terms of information for me. And because I had no cycle, I had no wherewithal that this was hormonal related. So I was living in Boston at the time, home of conventional medicine, big pharma. And so I'm going to my doctor. I'm like, is it mold? Yeah.
- 8:52Could I have Lyme's disease? You know, I was begging for something to explain why I was suddenly losing my grip of who I thought I was and just how I could perform and function as a mom, as a spouse, as a athlete, as a career person. So of course, I was gaslit. You're too young. No, we're not going to test your hormones. Absolutely refused. And at that time, I was leaning into nutrition as being a very low hanging fruit for sort of addressing some of the things I was dealing with.
- 9:20And I had started, I'd gone back to nutrition school and I started working with women and I'm realizing these women of all shapes and sizes, but all about my age are dealing with the same thing. So what's the one common denominator, right? We're all heading towards menopause. That was kind of the ding, ding, ding for me that this is hormones. And then, you know, I too started like, I got to find solutions. I'm an attorney. So my attitude is like, solve the problem, figure it out.
- 9:45And quickly came to the realization that it was hormones. And I will never forget my first week on HRT. I called I was 48 at the time to I call Maria and I'm like, is this possible that like, everything's working better, especially down there?
- 10:01And she just woke up laughing at me and she was like, yup. And I'm like, it's been like four days. How is that possible? But it went to show the power of those hormones and like how desperately my body was starving for them. So like you just mentioned, I mean, I won't look back. You know, those hormones are now locked in. You're going to pry them from my cold dead hands. But it did improve. It improved my body composition and improved my sleep and improved my mood. Like I feel like I'm engaged with life again, which I felt like there've been years, almost a decade that I wasn't.
- 10:31And, you know, relationship with the hubby is the best it's ever been in 37 years. Sex is great. You know, cognition is wonderful. We're running a very successful business together. It requires a lot of demands on us. And I feel like I'm capable again. And that was the biggest thing for me is like, wow, I didn't lose that self.
- 10:48Yes. Okay. You said something that's very important. I want to touch on it right now. Nutrition. You both FDN, functional diagnostic nutritionist, board certified nutritionist, you guys are both in that nutrition space. You know, the importance of food, you know, the importance of lifestyle.
- 11:06And yet still, so the question is, is change of lifestyle and change of nutrition enough for women going into menopause to get their life back, just like you described, or do we need HRT as well? So I think we're going to have slightly different responses on this, although we literally agree on almost everything in life in general, but let me explain.
- 11:34I was just in Italy for a couple of weeks and I met this woman who moves from Germany to buy a place in Tuscany and she husbands her own animals and grows everything on the farm. And like literally everything is organic farm to table. And you know, her sons all work on the farm. And she was, I would say kind of mid seventies. She was teaching us cooking classes and teaching about the land. And I was like, you know,
- 12:04I don't think she's on HRT. I could be wrong, but if I had to guess, I would say I don't think she's on HRT. I mean, she was full of passion and vigor, and she loved what she did. And I was like, if we could maybe live in a bubble, right? Right, right. The bubble that is the organic farms in Tuscany that were all surrounding her were organic as well. And you love what you do, and you have a supportive partner, and maybe low or no stress from...
- 12:30children that you have. And I was like, she's, she seems like she's doing great. She's not on HRC. So I would concede that it is possible. However, I think for 99% of women who are leading a modern day life, and as much as I don't want to admit I'm leading a modern day life, I live in a subdivision,
- 12:54I probably don't have low VOC paint on my walls. I eat seed oils on occasion in restaurants, what have you. I also do lots and lots of good stuff, filter my water, but it's not enough for me. It's just not. It's just not. And I would say I don't think it's enough for most women either. And I think those that think it's enough, their 40s, maybe early 50s, maybe they are
- 13:24Something on board, whether that's a little bit of adrenal production or just a kind of like a holdover, a little bit of estrogen. But I think you're taking a chance by not using HRT, honestly, by not using it.
- 13:37Yeah. Yeah. And newsflash, I don't disagree with her. Okay. Okay, good. But no, I mean, I think Maria's point is that, you know, we, we lack the nuance to recognize that there are those who live in, you know, beautiful synchronicity with the circadian rhythm and, you know, they offload their stress and they do all these things and that's great. And that might mitigate a lot of things.
- 13:56We don't know how that woman's plaque accumulation may or may not be in her arteries and it may just not be symptomatic yet or whatever. But I do agree that for the vast, vast, vast majority of living a modern lifestyle, not addressing our stress, focused on these symptoms and doing these things. No, it's not. We just don't think it's even safe, honestly, to age without your hormones intact simply because there are so many things happening beyond the obvious symptoms that you cannot identify until they finally make themselves known.
- 14:26And it's usually a little too late to reverse the damage. So, you know, that's just kind of our take is if I think if women understood what the menstrual cycle represented and what those sex hormones represented when we were younger, they would start to question, why do we want to live without them when we're older? You know, we have this celebration around losing our menstrual cycle. And I'm like, do you really understand what that means? Yeah. Right. Right.
- 14:51So what does that mean? Can you, can, yeah. Just for people that are like, and? Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, I mean, if we look at the phases of the menstrual cycle, right, we see this beautiful rhythmic dance. I mean, many women don't realize that they have a rhythmic dance between estrogen and progesterone, that progesterone is really not on board during the follicular phase beyond maybe some adrenal production and tissue production. And so we have this estrogen comes and does its thing on day 12, it peaks, it starts to fall. We have a little bump in testosterone, and then we have...
- 15:19progesterone kick in and another peak. Those aren't just to prepare an egg for fertilization. They aren't just to create an endometrium that's gonna shed and cause a menstrual bleed. That beautiful rhythmic dance and that sort of handoff between the two or three hormones is actually about genomic signaling throughout the body.
- 15:39And everything that we kind of attribute to fertility and menstruation actually should also get credit for bone remodeling, your skin elasticity, your muscle and joint health, literally everything, your liver function, your LDL receptors to clear cholesterol in the liver, like your gut microbiome, the receptors that line the lumen, everything in there is also being impacted and controlled to a large degree by that rhythmic dance.
- 16:08So if we celebrate the loss of the menstrual cycle, we celebrate maybe, okay, I'm done with the risk of having children. What we're also involuntarily celebrating is the loss of that genomic signaling. And I think that's really dangerous for women to kind of overlook or not understand because this is why our bones become porous. This is why our heart disease starts to accumulate. This is why our blood pressure changes. We could go on and on and on. And for every woman, it can be very different. And so we don't have this sort of,
- 16:38straight timeline with expectations of when something's going to fail. And if women just understand that as those hormones are declining, these things are happening to larger or small amounts, depending on the woman, we're all in the same boat, right? So why would we want to get rid of those hormones? Right.
- 16:55No, I agree with both of you on the HRT. Again, you'd have to pry that, pry my hormones out of my dead cold hands, just like you and my thyroid medication. So, because it does so much. Now, my symptoms were not horrendous either, entering into really even in perimenopause. I did not have bad symptoms, a little bit of vaginal dryness.
- 17:15the occasional hot flash, but I always am warmer than everybody else around me anyway. So I didn't even know if it was a flash or if it was just like, can you turn the damn temperature down in this room? Please, thank you. But I also mentioned thyroid. And in your book, you have the term that I always say on here, thyropause. And I had the question the other day. It was posed to me by a male doctor. And I'm actually impressed that he thought of this and said this.
- 17:43He asked me, well, can't we pretty much assume that any woman that is in menopause has a thyroid problem? And I paused and I was like, we're probably at about 99%. I mean, because there is thyropause that happens now. So the first question is, can you guys, can either of you define that term? I've said it a ton, but I want to hear it from you since it's in the book. And number two, do you both have a thyroid issue as well that maybe popped up in menopause?
- 18:11I would say thyroid pose is really kind of similar to what's happening to the ovary. Similar, not exact. It's just a slowing down of the thyroid with age. I think we have to expect that some of these things just happen with age. And, you know, when we lose, again, Kristen just kind of mentioned something. Hopefully people got it about their condition.
- 18:31the rhythmic dance of the two main female hormones, right? And when that goes, it does affect thyroid as well. But yeah, so I look back at my historical labs of 43, 44, 45 years old, and I had beautiful T3 of like 3.5, and I had, I guess my TSH was always between one and two, and Jeepers, I mean, it's just not that way anymore.
- 18:56It's just not, I mean, free T3, if I'm lucky with medicine lately, seems to be 2.7 or 2.8. I know it still needs a little bit of help. TSH is definitely, it's been very slowly climbing over the years. So yeah, we both support thyroid health for sure. Okay, so you are on thyroid replacement. Yeah, I mean, I see the thyroid. It's such a delicate gland, you know, it's just, we've got to really love it. And I think when we look at it's,
- 19:22unique sensitivities to nutrient deficiencies. And then we kind of overlay this change in gut health with menopause and nutrient absorption. We have that, you know, we know that the loss of estrogen affects mitochondrial function across all cells. So if we're going to have a thyropause, we can probably point to some mitochondrial changes happening. So I think there's so much kind of like hand in hand with maybe...
- 19:45the impacts of menopause across these body symptoms that are then triggering these impacts in the thyroid. For me, you know, because I had the IUD, once I had it taken out, I was already menopausal. When I actually hit menopause is anyone's guess, but my physician team believes it was probably in my early 40s, which tracks completely with the severity of my symptoms, how badly the wheels came off for me.
- 20:10I also then pulled, you know, God bless my chart and having the electronic highway for data. I pulled my old labs and I saw that back when I was 42, my TSH was 5.6. Oh, nobody ever said anything to me. So at 48, 49, I'm, you know, well into menopause. I'm on HRT, but there's that like missing link, right? That just even the best HRT wasn't quite helping. Yeah.
- 20:38And when we finally turned my attention to my thyroid, I mean, my free T3 was like two and my TSH was off the charts and nobody had bothered to even check. And God bless my HRT provider who was like, hold the force. You need some thyroid replacement. So I'm on it now. And it literally we keep a spreadsheet. Marie and I are a little bit geeky. We look at our labs every quarter.
- 21:01And I have a spreadsheet that goes back the last six years and it shows when I started HRT and then when I started thyroid on top of HRT. And then the next thing, which was for me actually adding some DHEA, because I know for me, a lot of my problems definitely stem to some adrenal tissues. Yeah.
- 21:17So those three things, like drastic improvements each time. So even the best HRT had its ceiling in terms of improvements for me and taking the thyroid to the next level was like the game changer. So yeah, I think it's really real. And I think women, again, go to that medicalization. Don't tell me I'm deficient. Don't tell me I need medication. I'm going to fast my way into a vaginal lubrication. Who knows what the hell they're thinking, but
- 21:42It's sort of this approach of like rejecting all possible exogenous interventions. And Maria and I are like, why? We would never tell a diabetic, just try and do it without the insulin. Wow.
- 21:54Yeah. Like nobody would say that. Right. So when we look at those things and recognize that disease processes are at risk, why would we not then address the thyroid? Right. Especially if women are catching men and heart disease in their 50s. Do we all not appreciate how relevant the thyroid health is for cardiovascular disease health? So those sorts of things, Marina, are like.
- 22:16Look, you can choose to reject these things now, but you better accept the fact that by 70, you're probably going to have about four or five scripts, if not 10 or 12 that you're taking daily. Right. Absolutely. Yeah. So like, why wait? Why when? Why not take natural medicine that we have at our disposal to address these things?
- 22:35Yeah, 100%. Do you know, I actually heard this the other day, and this is what drives me crazy about these hormone clinics that are literally on every corner. This one woman said, well, I go to this hormone clinic, but the practitioner there said, I don't do thyroid.
- 22:50And I'm like, you can't do one without the other. They go together. You can't. And that just tells me that these clinics are just, they're just throwing out hormones left and right, cookie cutter, cookie cutter. I mean, it just drives me crazy. But thyroid is a huge component as we age. Yeah, I mean, we have the menopause gold rush. We need to have the thyropause gold rush next, right?
- 23:11It's true. And we get people on board. And the thing is, women don't understand that when we, we always have binding proteins in our blood that are kind of doing a delicate dance, controlling the exposure of our receptors to different hormones. But when we use exogenous hormones, usually through HRT, we will have an increase in binding proteins. That's normal. That's a normal response to the body from an exogenous hormone being provided. But what that does for a lot of women is unmasks in a really fast fashion, a slowing thyroid. Yeah.
- 23:40Because suddenly our thyroid hormones are bound up in these proteins as well. And so that's one thing that we think is really a mistake that if your HRT provider can't and doesn't also manage your thyroid, that's a, that's a huge red flag and a huge problem because now they've just got back into that siloed system of they've got one bogey in mind and they're not thinking about the whole system. Yeah. It's no better than conventional medicine. Then you're getting the same treatment, just like you would at the sick medicine doctor. Right. Right. Yeah. Yeah.
- 24:10I want to talk about gut. And in your book, you mentioned estrobilome. And we have not talked about that on this podcast in depth. What I find interesting is so many women, just like we just talked about, so many women have thyroid issues. So many women are gaining weight as they enter menopause. They're like, I haven't changed anything. So we have to look at hormones, thyroid. Thyroid.
- 24:31So many women are like, I'm bloated. I'm bloated all the time. What is happening? And I will also hear that after we start someone on HRT, right? Which, of course, that can happen too. I'll let you talk about that. So what gives with the gut and perimenopause, menopause, hormones declining? We lose microbiome richness and diversity in the presence of low estrogen. And again, nobody makes this connection.
- 24:58No, I have not heard this connection being made often at all. I know. Well, again, back to what we say probably in the beginning of the book is it's really not just about, you know, sex hormones and fertility and, you know, breasts and hips and, you know, all those things. It's literally about the microbiome richness of your gut. So again, in a low estrogen state and that post-menopausal stage of life, like women tend to have poor gut health. Yeah.
- 25:28as one of our kind of amazing mentors say that you will have leaky gut. As a woman who is postmenopausal, it's just part of that aging process. It's hormone loss. And you know how that manifests, obviously the gut kind of branches out to everything in the body, but one very real way that it manifests is a lot of postmenopausal women are dealing with constipation. And I mean, that's just no good.
- 25:56you know, it just has wide ranging implications for, you know, toxicity and detox. And then, you know, talking about like some of these online clinics, right? These women will hear, hear about HRT. It's a bit of a catch 22. It's like, okay, but we, the estrogen can, you know, maybe help unlock that constipation, but if it doesn't, or if it doesn't do it quickly enough, then you risk, you know, not properly circulating that estrogen. So that's where like
- 26:26comes into play as well. Yeah. I think another area that people overlook when it comes to the gut is our digestion. And our digestion is impacted again by our sex form status. We're going to sound like a broken record here, but even the parietal cells in the stomach are highly dependent on sufficient estrogen to release the right gastric secretions in order to properly break down food before we dump it into the small intestine. We all know that if we like pound a meal real fast, we don't digest it well, right? We end up with that bloat or we over drain fluids
- 26:56It's no different. If our estrogen is low, we actually don't get a really robust breakdown of the food in the stomach. The pH level is not quite correct when it drops into the small intestine. That then triggers the cascade or fails to trigger the proper cascade of pancreatic enzyme secretion and, you know, all the different things that are going on, bile acids, etc.,
- 27:15So we have kind of this two-stage problem, right, is this slowing digestion along with then a gut microbiome that lacks the diversity to sort of make up what it needs to, to get the fuels it needs to create different species and whatnot, butyrate production, all of that sort of stuff gets changed. And one of the things that drives us nuts is a lot of women will be told...
- 27:36You have GERD, you need this acid blocker, right? Okay, well, ladies, you have GERD because you actually have a sphincter that's not closing and is allowing gastric secretions up. That's not that you have too many gastric secretions or too much. It's actually you need that sphincter to be better properly controlled. And guess what also has to do that?
- 27:55estrogen, right? And so we maintain kind of the esophagus and this firmness of those structures and elasticity and all that stuff with proper sex hormones. So women then will say, oh my gosh, I have all these stomach problems. And a doctor will say, let's test you for H. pylori. And then they go in and they test them for H. pylori, a bacteria that's totally normal to have. And fun fact is actually required in what we call the estrobilone, which is that basket of bacteria
- 28:24Yeah, but you don't want too much. But so what they'll do is then they'll put them on some protocol, usually antibiotics, but otherwise something like oregano oil for a year. And they try and wipe out these people's gut bacteria that actually is beneficial for maintaining that hormone circulation. So there's this horrible kind of approach to the problem. And if women just understood that...
- 28:45start some HRT, work on your detox in order to actually be excreting it by pooping regularly, ladies, things start to fall back in place. And why women have a shift in bloating when they start HRT is they're having sort of a remodeling of that gut microbiome. The diversity is changing. The quantity is changing. You know, we don't always love the terms like die off and things like that, but there is a shift happening and it will change. You just need to continue to support digestion and support your detox.
- 29:14It levels up. I'm so happy that you said that. Well, there's something else I want to touch on too, and what people do for their gut. But I can't tell you the amount of women that come to me and say, well, I have H. pylori. Shouldn't I take care of that first? Like, no, it doesn't matter. Like you can have that in your gut. Obviously we don't want it in large quantities, but just like you said, small amounts of H. pylori, totally normal to have in your gut.
- 29:41And no, you don't want to treat that first. You want to actually do hormones and get your thyroid in check because that's going to control whether or not you poop every day. And then you can go back and say, okay, do I still have these effects from the H. pylori? The other thing is people are doing functional testing and they're almost basing how they feel on the results of the test. That's true.
- 30:05No, yes. Yeah. And we just had this discussion with some of our mentorship students who are other practitioners kind of going into the space as we said, they all are eager to test, test, test, test, test. And we think functional medicine testing has an absolute place at the right time. Right. But the vast majority of women, if you just go into the trenches with them on lifestyle, stress, nutrition, movement, sleep, you know, pooping, all those things and work on basic interventions, most of them,
- 30:34need some help in those areas. You don't need to test in order to tell them their digestion is up. They're living it. They came to you because they have this belly they can't get rid of and they're burping all the time and they don't sleep and they don't poop. You have what you need to know, right? Right. But I think sometimes there's a lack of motivation unless a woman has like cold, hard data to sort of convince her that she was right. There's something wrong. And we're like, but it's not the data that's...
- 31:00That's the problem. It's the choices you're making every day that are the problem. And we need to address those. All right. Now, what do women do about it? So I always joke about the Jamie Lee Curtis Activia, like all these women are running out and they're eating Activia yogurt to get their probiotics in. Or like we were talking about off air, they'll take the same damn probiotic for years and years. It's so bad. It's so bad. So why is that just not the right way to approach your gut at all?
- 31:30Well, I mean, in terms of your gut, I think the things that Kristen said are all super necessary. They're just like the not sexy stuff. It's just, you know, eating real food and, you know, working on that, getting into parasympathetic mode, which is the just chill out mode, put the phone down, turn off the news, focus on chewing. Like these things are really, really impactful. Keep the ultra processed foods out of the diet or to a very minimum at least, right?
- 32:00And get the HRT on board if you're a candidate, and most women are. You know, the amount of women that are candidates is very high. The amount of women that are not candidates is very low. And then, you know, when it comes to HRT, we say get that on board, but learn first. Don't jump right in. I can't tell you how many women we have that just jump right into HRT, and they just either are underdosed or overdosed or...
- 32:29Or no one's dealing with all those unsexy things. And that's, I loved your rant recently about online clinics, because this is something that we see happening. And our attitude is sort of, that's fine. Take those women, you know, we might end up losing them as clients, but they're going to come back. And the reason they're going to come back is because nobody's working with them on the whole body.
- 32:48Right, nutrition, mindset, what to expect, you know, when you do onboard HRT. Well, I'm pretty sure Defy Medical is not asking their clients if they're pooping. I'm pretty sure that's not in their intake form, right? Not standing in the back.
- 33:04But that piece of it needs to be in place. And we tell women all the time, if you had hormonal irregularities when you were younger, we can all usually go back to, you know, poor lifestyle, poor nutrition, drinking too much, not sleeping, you know, all the things. And then we clean it up and then voila, the cycle is a wonderful place, you know, and happy event each month. The same thing applies to HRT. We need to be a healthy host, whether we're making our hormones or we're taking our hormones.
- 33:33Are there some interventions that are perfectly reasonable? Yes, they should be targeted and short term, whether it's providing your gut certain nutrients, you know, whether it's you need zinc carnosine, or you need some sort of glycine and glutamine. I mean, there's different ways to approach it. Each one is different. But a lot of times, it's just basically dialing down the stress. I mean, how many of us eat at our kitchen island, or God forbid eat in the car, or you
- 33:58If you still have children at home, it's like kind of a tense environment at dinner because the teenagers pushing the buttons or, you know, whatever. But like just starting to build some awareness about your engagement with food. Is it kind of under the optimal conditions? Is it the right food? Are you eating too often? So many people do not realize the digestive system needs a break.
- 34:18And these women who are kind of following these metabolic eating patterns, they're eating every two hours, you know, five, six times a day. That's a problem. You know, we need to address that. Are we eating within a few hours of bedtime? Also a problem. Are we eating kind of against our circadian rhythm and light cycles? That's a problem. So basic things that can be instituted to sort of address that health. And a lot of times with women, we're like, you just chew your food to the point of applesauce. Like I don't even tell them
- 34:4610 chews or 30 chews or chew for a minute or anything, just put your fork down and do not swallow until that food is applesauce. They'll be like, oh my God, my bloating went away. I'm like, and then it creates that cascade, right? They're digesting. The gut starts to be happier. The poop starts flowing and that's the perfect environment for hormones.
- 35:09That's so good. That is so good. Well, it's also important to, to be pooping every day, like you said, for the estrogen metabolism and, and just for overall detox. I mean, you know, we, yes, we're going to get to the liver. We want to love on the liver.
- 35:26But everything that we're exposed to, we're in such a toxic environment. And that toxic environment is pounding our hormones as well. Most likely contributing to early menopause and needing for surgical intervention to basically push someone into an early menopause. But we need to somehow get our bodies to the place where...
- 35:50it acts like it should. Like we are meant to poop after a meal. Now I'm not a gastroenterologist, so I don't know how many hours it's supposed to be, but I do know that every time I eat at some point in time, shortly thereafter, it shouldn't be two days from now that that comes back out. And that's part of detox. You know, a lot of people don't care. Oh yeah. You know, I asked that question. How often do you poop? Oh, you know, like every other day, every third day. I'm like,
- 36:17Oh no, that's horrible. So all of those toxins, how are the toxins affecting our entire body and directly our hormones? We have this buildup of an enzyme called beta-glucuronidase, which what happens is it will kind of, so estrogen is either made or taken, right? So made and or oversaken kind of has to signal at the receptor and then it has to,
- 36:44detox out of the body, it eventually kind of ends up in, you know, feces and urine, right? But during that process, you know, it gets bound to bile and it's the, the glucuronidin acid is actually good. I'm sorry. It's Tony's friend, but I'm going to fix that. So the beta-glucuronidase is an enzyme that we don't want too high because it can kind of, it just kind of decouples the bile with the toxins and it allows it to recirculate. So-
- 37:13And can reactivate too, right? It can go from a deactivated estrogen through the process of detoxification to a reactivated estrogen. So it's, you're circulating suddenly no longer metabolites, but almost this reactivated estrogen. If you're still taking it or you're still making it, or you're taking high doses of it. Now it's almost like for lack of a better term, kind of a double dose, right? Because it's, it's still in the system. You've got now got this extra tissue exposure.
- 37:39And so we tend to see that high enzyme that we don't want too high in women that are constipated. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So common. And then she'll move into estrogen dominance, even in a menopausal state, she can move into estrogen dominance because she's not actually getting rid of that excess estrogen. Yeah. That's the, not like a true estrogen like dominance, but just sort of like almost an imbalance with the top, you know, like an, you know, an overload of,
- 38:07more kind of xenoestrogens. Yeah. Toxic estrogens, yeah. And then she'll still get symptoms from that, right? Because I'll hear that from women that, oh, I think I'm estrogen dominant because, and then they'll list all the different symptoms that absolutely could be tied to estrogen dominance, but is it the xenoestrogens or is it that maybe she's going to defy and getting too low of a progesterone dose and she really is estrogen dominant
- 38:37toilet. Well, it can be either that, or it can be something that this will probably blow some minds. We actually, so we're going to just use the word receptor, right? Our hormones are signals. They act at a receptor on the, on the cell. And that's what kind of sends off the actions in the
- 38:53What people don't realize going back to that dance of our beautiful rhythm of hormones over a 20 day cycle is that that peak of estrogen actually is responsible for producing receptors for progesterone. And so what we often see is these women are told they're estrogen dominant. They're given boatloads of progesterone because that must be there to offset the estrogen. But their estrogen levels are super low. Yeah.
- 39:17dance, they don't have the receptors for that progesterone. And what ends up happening is usually bloats and water weight gain, breast tenderness, moodiness, anxiety, all of these things. And the doctor's attitude is like, you must need even more progesterone. And so they keep, and we'll see these women on these like tiny little patches and like 400 milligrams of progesterone. And they're like, but I sleep great. I'm like, that's because it's knocking you out. That's actually not sleep. That's called unconscious. And you have to sleep
- 39:43You have too much progesterone now at this point. And you're still not pooping, by the way, because you still don't have enough estrogen. Right. And so now you've got kind of this backlog of both hormones. And it's just really tragic that that system is not kind of acknowledged and honored in traditional HRT right now, because these women are being told you must be progesterone intolerant.
- 40:07And Maria and I say in 99% of the instances, you're actually so estrogen deficient that you can't take and handle the progesterone because you have no receptors for it. Okay. So is there a way to enhance receptors? I've heard some, I mean, really well-respected doctors in this space and they have their own supplement line. And I've heard some say that they have, it's basically like a,
- 40:33Hormone receptor cleanup, right? I mean, who knows? I think there's still a lot we don't know about receptors. And I think receptors is going to come down to living a daily detox life as you are able to. And nutrition is important.
- 40:49Nutrition and digestion, because you have to absorb the nutrients that you're eating. And I would say the one thing we do know about receptors is your mineral status matters in a big, big, big way. And there is to me this wild zinc deficiency happening. We're seeing it in all the women that we're working with. And of all micronutrients, the one most critical for all hormone receptors, thyroid and sex hormone is zinc. Pulls it into the receptor. Yeah.
- 41:16Yeah. And it's difficult to get enough because if your gut is impaired, your gut is going to suck that zinc up big time. And now you don't get the blood serum circulation of zinc that you need to sort of heal or whatever you want to call it, rehabilitate those receptors to come back online. Yeah.
- 41:32And a lot of women don't want to accept that, you know, the use of birth control pills or, you know, IUDs that they were told were local but actually have systemic effects. They don't want to address the fact that that nutrient depletion might have left them without really great receptor status. And so they're on ramp with HRT may need support that's sort of outside the realm of the five medical.
- 41:54where they're not dealing with the gut issue, they're not dealing with the absorption issue, and they're not dealing with supplemental micronutrients if they in fact need that for the receptors.
- 42:04Yeah, no, I like that. I like that. Yeah, zinc deficiency is huge. And zinc is even imperative in that T4 to T3 conversion. Absolutely. That deficiency is going to have widespread effects on the body. Widespread. And just pouring more hormones into that body is not going to help if you don't address that underlying issue, right? Right. Right.
- 42:24Yeah, and I know we're all in favor of using the hormone dose that you need, but you don't want to keep doing that if you're not addressing the receptors and not addressing your deficiencies that you might need to look at. Totally agree.
- 42:39So I want to shift this a little bit to libido and sex, because this is such, I can't even tell. Listen, I did a full podcast called All About Libido. I tried to hit every single reason why a woman may have low libido. And I don't even know if I hit them all because there's so many different reasons. I want to get your take on this, especially as in the book, talk about it. So what is your take on this drastic,
- 43:06decline in libido where women will say, you know, and it's one thing if you need a spouseectomy. I mean, that is totally different. If you're married to an asshole, then that's something different. Yeah. But we will say this to the outset, not for lack of testosterone, ladies. Okay. Not for lack of testosterone. Right.
- 43:28Yeah, I mean, libido is so, so, so multifactorial. And it's again, it's one of those things that we've decided as a society to simplify it straight down to you must be hormonally deficient if you don't have a libido. And I'm like, I don't know, are you happy in your relationships? Do you have community? Do you sleep? Because I don't know about you, but when I'm tired, and I hit the bed, and it's like, I just want to be horizontal, and someone else wants to get frisky. I'm like, it's got to sleep me alone. I just want to sleep, right? Right.
- 43:54So, you know, is it, is it all of these other things? And I think we're not recognizing our stress, that stress impairs our hormone uptake, whether again, we're making it or taking it. And so these clinics that are just trying to shoot a pellet in a woman's rear end and jack her testosterone to super physiologic levels so that she's at risk of getting an Adam's apple and a voice box change. Guess what folks, it still doesn't help your libido. And these women
- 44:24And of course they crash and burn. You know, what women don't appreciate is it's actually estrogen that impacts libido the most. And we have, unfortunately, a crisis of low dosing estrogen in this country, largely driven by the medical societies that are the conventional physicians sort of, you know, guide. So afraid of estrogen. Yeah.
- 44:44They're still afraid of it. And why then now we have this upswell, groundswell of these NAMS practitioners who are saying testosterone shouldn't be denied from a woman. And we're like, but you're denying them estrogen. Like you're denying them physiologic levels of estrogen.
- 45:01Right. And so suddenly estrogen is this thing that we want to kind of treat with kid gloves and be like all gentle and little bit lowest doses and short time. But we're going to now raise the flag for testosterone. That makes zero sense to us. Testosterone is not what makes us a feminine woman with sexual desire. It is estrogen that makes us a feminine. And it's enough. It's it's enough. Estradiol. Enough estrogen. As Kristen alluded to, it's
- 45:28The typical kind of HRT that's out there being kind of talked about by a lot of doctors is doing a great job of raising awareness, but they're really keeping women in what we call very late stage perimenopausal, or in some cases, women with postmenopausal levels of estradiol, even though they are on HRT. So those women, you know, if it is in fact the estrogen that is going to kind of ignite their libido, notwithstanding the
- 45:56kind of spousectomy or just general health status, those HRT regimens that they're doling out that are so popular right now, ain't gonna help. Not gonna help, no, uh-uh. We say there's a great podcast, doesn't compete with yours, so I feel like it's okay to say it, but no, Maria, the name of it just went completely out my-
- 46:17Foreplay. Foreplay Radio. Okay. All right. And it's a sex therapist and a marriage therapist or relationship counselor. And I find it fascinating because they cover all these things that I think a lot of us overlook as sort of getting in the way with libido. And a lot of it comes down to communication and stress and being able to find the love language that we need in order to have our needs met while also honoring our partner's needs. And...
- 46:44That I think is what honestly is the biggest crisis. And there's times where we've said to women, we can't fix this for you. I don't think this is an estrogen issue or a testosterone issue or any of those things. Peruse these and look at these things. And it's shocking how when we finally want to sort of address that,
- 47:00sex is a choice. Libido is a choice to a certain degree. It's not just something that kind of overtakes us and boom, you know, it happens, but that we have to engage with it and we need to be responsible for it. And so that's going to require communication, self-awareness, et cetera, meeting each other's needs. If you're not getting your needs met, let's say on the weekend and you're driving the kids around everywhere or the spouse is off, you know, on his boat sailing and leaving you behind or whatever. Yeah.
- 47:27It's not a shock that come Monday, you don't feel like getting in bed with each other. Right. And, and, but no one wants to, and you might love him. He might not be someone that you need a spousectomy from. Right. But again, if your needs aren't being met on an emotional level, you're probably not going to be willing to deliver on a physical level. And I think women sort of fail to see that because I remember once the book, what is it? Men are from Mars, women are from Venus, right? Yeah.
- 47:51It came as a roadshow play years ago. My husband and I have been together 37 years. So it was decades ago, but it came as a roadshow play. And I remember cackling, watching this and realizing that men are able to be like emotionally intimate after they've had sex. Women are able to have sex after they've been emotionally intimate. And that's 90% of the problem for most people who are lacking libido is they've just kind of hit disconnect hard and we just need to deal with it.
- 48:21we don't want to gaslight the women who have tight vaginal tissues, dry vaginal tissues. We've had clients who literally exercising in the gym results in vaginal bleeding because their tissues are so delicate. Yeah. We had a woman who needed a transvaginal ultrasound and they couldn't even get an imaging device up, not even the traditional wand, but they, something that they use like a flex sigmoidoscopy scope. And we're talking, that's a pediatric scope for the colon. They couldn't even get that used in her vaginal canal. That's
- 48:51an absolute failure of hormones. That is a lack of hormones. And so are there women for whom libido is lacking because it is painful and it is difficult? Absolutely. And those women need systemic hormones. Quick solution or quick way to address it would be topical vaginal hormones as well. But I mean, that didn't happen overnight. And that's why Marie and I are kind of constantly banging this drum about pay attention, you ladies in Perry, right?
- 49:20Because that actually, those genital urinary symptoms and those changes are happening in perimenopause. And so all of a sudden a woman gets postmenopausal and she blames lack of sex hormones or lack of period for not wanting or not being able to have sex. We're like, that actually started almost 10 years ago.
- 49:37Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, it does. It does. And that's why, I mean, I'm a huge advocate. I'll ask you both as well. Start the hormones in perimenopause. Start them when they start to go off the cliff. That might be at 35 when your progesterone tanks, and then at 40 when your testosterone tanks, and maybe you're not ready for estradiol till 45. That's fine. But be ready to add it in as soon as it starts to decline or catch it even in the decline.
- 50:07So we are absolutely fans of that. I know I said earlier that I was fully menopausal by about 47 or 48. Can't remember exactly, it's been a while, but I wish I had started full replacement at 45. And as far as testosterone goes, like our take on that is if you're a 40 year old, most of the times it's again, it's a libido or whatever, and they go and they get a testosterone prescription. We would just really, ashtore is your primary hormone, not saying you need it necessarily at 40,
- 50:37But we would really caution women to look to lifestyle and, you know, eating enough protein, ideally animal protein, weightlifting, you know, getting morning sun, sleep.
- 50:48because you should be able to have a pretty good, you know, adrenal production of testosterone, I'd say 40 years old. So that's just our take on it. We're not anti-testosterone, but we do kind of want to bring that. There's just this trope going around. Like it's your most abundant hormone. Yes. Volume wise, but that doesn't mean it kind of holds that same significance in what it does for you as a woman. Yeah. Yeah. I, this, I,
- 51:14Pendency to give 40-somethings the testosterone is just so concerning because the 40-somethings we see are so depleted adrenally. They're just pushing hard. And, you know, they're hanging on to that 30-year-old body. They're cross-fitting five days a week for Orange Theory Fitness. They're not eating as well. They're leaning hard into intermittent fasting because they feel the body composition changes from the changing hormones. And all of this stuff impacts their...
- 51:39testosterone production adrenally. And how many of these doctors are diving into the lifestyle of this patient who's presenting as low testosterone and may in fact even have low testosterone production. But is it because of the normal decoupling of the hypothalamus and the gonads? Or is it actually because they are depleting themselves? Right? And so we think we've seen it, we've just seen it all too often, where women are all of a sudden, like, wow, all
- 52:08slowed down, ate enough, stopped working out too much, stopped my intermittent fasting, et cetera. They tend to not necessarily need the testosterone if they can at least commit to those lifestyle changes. Yeah. Now I agree with you there. The only thing I would, I would just not even disagree, but, but add in.
- 52:28would be, I know for me in my 40s, that's when I started testosterone because I am a type A driver running a business. I like working out. I want to have muscles. I want to be strong, like go, go, go. And I always call testosterone the get shit done hormone. When that goes down, it's like,
- 52:46Oh, maybe I can do one interview today. All right. I go out to the gym and I'm like, why can I only do four pushups when I can do 10 before? And I literally was looking in the mirror at my muscles deflating. It was like somebody popped a balloon. Have you ever looked into DHEA?
- 53:05Yeah, it doesn't. So all of my research on DHEA, like speaking with people that research this, it's not strong enough to push testosterone to an optimal level. Like, yeah, it's a precursor, but it's just not strong enough. I don't disagree with that, but don't you think from a vitality standpoint,
- 53:23point. So using DHEA can sort of give women that drive that they suddenly felt fell off and is missing with their testosterone. I mean, it may not have, let's say the muscular effect, right? Because we're not getting that signal in the muscle tissue. But I do think from like a vitality, sort of mood affect, performance, all of that stuff, DHEA might be this first intervention for some women before they're ready for testosterone. So they work on those lifestyle things.
- 53:52You know, that probably wasn't your issue in terms of lifestyle stuff, but let's be honest. You came into this phase of life much healthier than most people and aware of kind of your daily interventions impacting those things. And we just see these young 30, late 30 somethings, early 40 somethings. And we're like, you need to slow the frick down. Yeah. Like slow down and take a breath. And then all of a sudden they're like, oh my gosh, less is more. I'm only strength training three days a week and I'm sleep.
- 54:20sleeping we're like well shocking you know yeah yeah sleep can grow your muscles too sleep yeah sleep is gonna do a lot yeah it's gonna do a lot oh my god i love i love talking to you guys i'm looking at the clock we're over an hour i'm like i can just keep going i could keep going but i've got to be respectful of your time i have another interview but this is just absolutely amazing thank you it's amazing
- 54:43And like I said in the beginning, and I am not just blowing smoke up your ass at all. This is, it's a manual. It's a manual. Now, this is out now for people to get, correct? September 10th. September 10th. Okay. So September 10th, the great menopause myth. I mean, they cover everything.
- 55:03I was so impressed when I read this. Cause you know, I mean, just like you mentioned earlier, menopause has almost become a buzzword like functional medicine, right? And everybody and their brother's a menopause expert and everybody and their brother is writing a freaking menopause book, which is driving me that shit crazy. All other hour about that. That's all, yeah, that's a whole other thing. People who two years ago didn't practice in menopause space medicine or HRT have bestselling books, yeah. Thank you, yes, thank you.
- 55:31And I pick up these books and I'll read a chapter and I'll put it down. I'm like, forget it. But I was riveted. I was like, oh my God, they covered everything. I love this. They covered it all. Like they hit this too. I highly, highly, with all of my heart, recommend that people get this book.
- 55:50Thank you. It's fantastic. That means a lot coming from you. It means the world to us. Thank you. Thank you for writing it because this is what we need. We don't need the 10 other menopause books out there. We need a guide. We need a guide. We don't disagree.
- 56:06We need one that's like, that's talking to us like this. Yeah. You know, just, just woman to woman, you know, you're, you're going through some shit, right? Okay. We get it. We've been there, done that. Let's talk about it. And that's what this book is. Yeah. Thank you. Appreciate it. Absolutely. So finally, can you tell listeners how they can find you? And obviously we'll put all the links in the show notes as well. Yeah. So our Instagram is, we, we try to be educational on Instagram and that's just wise and well, if they put that into the search bar.
- 56:35And then our website is wiseandwell.me. And yeah, we've got a free online community because let's face it, Instagram's kind of sound bites to a certain degree. So we wanted a place where we could do a little bit more long form content. Women could kind of peruse research without feeling like they needed to look at ads and political statements on social media. So we have-
- 56:55A mighty network that you can look up. I think it's in our Instagram bio links, but we'll get you that link for that too. And it's free to join and just kind of another safe place without a lot of noise that women can kind of find out they're not alone on this journey. I love that. Well, thank you both for your time today and your wisdom and for writing the book. I greatly appreciate it. Thank you. Thanks for having us. Yeah, thank you.