Latest / Gaming The System - The Feminist Gaming Podcast / Banning Under 16s from Social Media : Protection, or Politics? (Episode 290)
Transcript
- 0:02matt (2): they don't care about kids.
- 0:04matt (2): They just don't care.
- 0:09matt (2): That's, the rage that I feel whenever I see anything about the politicians claiming to care about the British people when they don't.
- 0:20Jem (2): I don't really want to exclude young people from social media, because I think there's a lot of benefits to interacting with other people.
- 0:28Jem (2): How do you make friends if not by talking to strangers?
- 0:31Alex (2): children today very much are.
- 0:34Alex (2): They're born into the digital world.
- 0:36Alex (2): They have digital things around them from birth, basically.
- 0:40Alex (2): I've seen, friends who are young parents, with their babies, and their babies are constantly paying attention to and watching them on their phones.
- 1:06Jem: Hello, and welcome back to another episode of Gaming the System, the podcast where three intersectional feminists examine gaming and games through a feminist lens.
- 1:16Jem: I'm your host for today.
- 1:17Jem: I'm Jem, and I'm here with my friends Alex and Matt.
- 1:22Jem: So before we get started, if you want to support us, you can subscribe to our Patreon at patreon.com/gamingthesystem for some exclusive content, or you can send a f- us a one-off donation via PayPal to our email address, wearegamingthesystem@gmail.com
- 1:44Jem (2): On the 15th of June, 2026, the UK government announced that it will ban under 16s from using social media platforms such as Snapchat, TikTok, YouTube, Instagram, Facebook and X.
- 2:02Jem (2): This is hot on the heels of Australia doing something similar, back in 2024, they're planning for all of this to kick off next year, early next year.
- 2:18Jem (2): And it follows a consultation which was called Growing Up In The Online World, and had 116,000 responses, nine out of 10 parents responding backed the ban That's the first time I've read that figure, and I find that hard to believe actually.
- 2:42Jem (2): Because I know quite a lot of parents who Would back it in theory, but there's issues around, the actual practicalities of it.
- 2:51Jem (2): But we'll come into that, I'm sure.
- 2:53Jem (2): So off the back of that consultation, the government is looking to enact a secondary legislation rather than having to go through a new act, which means they can run this all through quite quickly.
- 3:12Jem (2): So that's one of the things that a lot of the news coverage has talked about is that they feel that it's being rushed through and it's not being properly thought out.
- 3:24Jem (2): And so as a result, they're reckoning it will come into force in spring 2027.
- 3:31Jem (2): They're looking at banning under 16s.
- 3:37Jem (2): Restricting the ability for young people, to interact with strangers, and live streams.
- 3:49Jem (2): So that's going to affect 16 and 17-year-olds, that's to avoid there being a sort of cliff edge.
- 3:56Jem (2): So to avoid it just being like,"Oh, you get to 16 and then it's fine," but instead you'll get to 17 and then it's fine.
- 4:04Jem (2): They've also announced that AI romantic companions, chatbots are to be restricted to over 18s.
- 4:14Jem (2): They're looking at overnight curfews and limits on infinite scrolling for under 18s large platforms are going to be targeted for enforcement, so they will have multimillion-pound fines if they don't comply, which will be handled by Ofcom.
- 4:36Jem (2): And at the moment, the impact on gaming and social gaming sites is not known.
- 4:45Jem (2): They're basically avoided, an outright ban.
- 4:48Jem (2): They've avoided sort of talking about it very much at I have, uh, an 18-year-old daughter, she has been using online communication for quite a long time.
- 5:03Jem (2): But I would say she wasn't on social media certainly before was 15, 16.
- 5:11Jem (2): So, were quite strict about that.
- 5:14Jem (2): She didn't have Instagram.
- 5:16Jem (2): She did have TikTok, but, there were very strict rules around, who she could and couldn't add.
- 5:22Jem (2): We had rules about, only adding friends that you know in real life and things on certain platforms.
- 5:29Jem (2): It was kind of a constant back and forth, and we were very hands-on with regards to that.
- 5:37Jem (2): But we're very tech-savvy, so it wasn't difficult for us to do that.
- 5:44Jem (2): I mean, let me not, gloss over that.
- 5:45Jem (2): It was difficult, but it wasn't technically difficult for us to manage it.
- 5:50Jem (2): So before we get into the gaming angle on this, which I do want to talk about, I just wanna get your initial reactions to idea of a social media ban, the idea of whose responsibility is it to keep kids safe in these environments, and are there any other ways that we could approach that?
- 6:15Alex (2): It's interesting, isn't it?
- 6:16Alex (2): I think at this stage, I would argue that it's still quite theoretical because I think it's politically motivated, because Keir Starmer is trying to save his skin, and fight off a leadership race,
- 6:30Jem (2): yeah
- 6:31Alex (2): it might not happen.
- 6:33Alex (2): We don't know.
- 6:34Alex (2): But to answer your question properly, I think it's, In principle, I think it's a nice idea in that, you know, the internet's not a nice place a lot of the time, and it can be very addictive when we think about doom scrolling, and it can be very negative.
- 6:54Alex (2): And for some parents, it has led to some very, difficult and sometimes, fatal situations for the lives of their children.
- 7:07Alex (2): And of course, you can understand where they're coming from when they, approach for this ban.
- 7:13Alex (2): There are several questions it raises though, definitely.
- 7:17Alex (2): One I have is, you know, how's the age checking going to be enforced?
- 7:25Alex (2): Because it's all very well and good saying,"Oh, you can't go on it if you're under 16," but how often have we lied about our age to get into certain things or, you know, even if we're, in pubs or in shops or whatever, trying to get alcohol or, all sorts of stuff.
- 7:43Alex (2): It's been done and will continue to be done by young people for many thousands of years probably.
- 7:51Alex (2): You know, I mean, if anyone can use a VPN, you know, how's, how are they going to counteract that?
- 7:59Jem (2): I've not, I've not
- 8:00Alex (2): Ja
- 8:01Jem (2): the, word VPN used quite so much as I have over the last few days.
- 8:05Jem (2): I think there's a whole bunch of people that are now educated in the ways of VPNs that hadn't h- hadn't even thought about it before.
- 8:13Jem (2): And I think that may, that may be a, a big issue in itself.
- 8:20Jem (2): And I think there
- 8:21Alex (2): it.
- 8:21Alex (2): I...
- 8:21Jem (2): concern, isn't there, about the, who...
- 8:25Jem (2): what happens to that data.
- 8:27Jem (2): The, because the, the way that they're verifying age at the moment is the kids are either having to use their passport information.
- 8:38Jem (2): I mean, my daughter had to do that recently.
- 8:42Alex (2): I've done that as well.
- 8:43Alex (2): It's pretty wild, isn't it?
- 8:44Jem (2): Mm-hmm.
- 8:44Alex (2): You know, that you put it on your phone and your phone somehow magically knows that it's your passport and gets all those details out of it.
- 8:52Alex (2): It's a digital ID thing, isn't it?
- 8:54Alex (2): It's like the government's one ID thing.
- 8:59Alex (2): So a lot of people are saying this is really bad because it's just a gateway to get everyone to get digital IDs.
- 9:06Jem (2): Yeah.
- 9:07Jem (2): I mean,
- 9:08Alex (2): so
- 9:08Jem (2): Fundamentally, I don't have an issue with the concept of digital IDs, but I do have a problem with it not being properly managed.
- 9:17Alex (2): Yeah
- 9:18Jem (2): when you combine that with the fact that Palantir have been given, you
- 9:23Alex (2): Yes.
- 9:24Alex (2): Yeah, completely
- 9:25Jem (2): all of our NHS data and things like that, and you just think, yeah, this is becoming very dystopian very quickly.
- 9:32Jem (2): The other way that they're, aging people is they get them to do a facial scan, so they sent, a photo.
- 9:40Jem (2): And, this is notoriously, unreliable, and plenty of the kids are getting put into the wrong age groups.
- 9:50Alex (2): Yeah.
- 9:51Jem (2): that's happened.
- 9:52Alex (2): Yeah
- 9:53Jem (2): you know, that's frustrating for the kids.
- 9:56Jem (2): It's also problematic.
- 9:58Jem (2): If suddenly a 20-year-old gets put in with the 13-year-olds, then, you're not helping anyone.
- 10:04Jem (2): You're not achieving what you're trying to, avoid.
- 10:08Jem (2): So I think it feels like there's a lot of questions, and I think it's also important to say that one of the key things is that obviously this has already been in place in Australia for a while, so we can see how that's worked.
- 10:22Jem (2): And apparently it isn't working very well, and lots of the kids are actually kind of circumventing, a lot of the checks.
- 10:31Jem (2): And as you said, Alex, we used to have fake IDs when we were younger and, that there's...
- 10:38Jem (2): where there's a will, there's a way.
- 10:40Jem (2): So Matt, what do you think about all of this?
- 10:48matt (2): That's basically what's been going on in my head all day, and I've been trying to, funnel it into writing some shit down so my head doesn't explode.
- 10:59matt (2): to preface this bit that I want to say have either of you read The Iliad?
- 11:07Alex (2): I have attempted to translate some of it
- 11:11matt (2): it's
- 11:11Alex (2): in university, yes
- 11:14matt (2): book story of all time.
- 11:16matt (2): It's fucking wild, absolutely amazing.
- 11:20matt (2): Achilles hates Agamemnon than I've seen anyone hate anyone in history.
- 11:28matt (2): It's the most poetically stunning representation of pure and rage against someone who has done someone wrong.
- 11:42matt (2): That's how I feel about Keir Starmer.
- 11:46matt (2): That's what he
- 11:47Jem (2): not where I thought you were going, but
- 11:49Alex (2): I didn't expect that either, but yes
- 11:51matt (2): That's what he is to me.
- 11:55matt (2): a, d- a massive long, like eight-minute speech in the Iliad when Agamemnon sends Odysseus to go and convince Achilles to stop being angry and join the, join the Greeks again.
- 12:12matt (2): And Achilles s- goes to Odysseus and says,"I'm gonna stop you there," and then talks for eight minutes about how much he hates Agamemnon and how he'd never do it before.
- 12:22matt (2): could do that at any time about Keir Starmer.
- 12:25matt (2): So this is a perfect opportunity for me to come in and go,"Oh, Keir Starmer's doing this thing." And the, the label on it is Keir Starmer wants to do X to protect children from the evils of social media.
- 12:42matt (2): But mainly it's protect children, that's the goal of this.
- 12:46matt (2): I want to take us back in time to 2017.
- 12:52matt (2): The Labor Party manifesto pledged to raise the minimum wage to 15 pounds, and back then it was less than 10 pounds, so that would've been an over 50% increase people's wages, people working, working minimum wage jobs, and that would've increased the wages of everyone'cause that's how wage increases work.
- 13:15matt (2): And the plan was to nationalize all the ce- necessities of life, water, energy, always have access to good food and healthcare and places to live.
- 13:26matt (2): All the financial burdens of life, there is an option that you...
- 13:33matt (2): There will always be a safety net for everyone, so that no one would ever need to choose between heating and eating ever again.
- 13:42matt (2): And do either of you remember the interview with the child who said,"You just get used to being hungry"?
- 13:51Alex (2): I don't remember it specifically, but
- 13:53matt (2): It
- 13:53Alex (2): yeah, that was horrible
- 13:54matt (2): me.
- 13:54Jem (2): Ja.
- 13:55matt (2): haunted me ever since I saw that.
- 13:57matt (2): It was a campaign by Hunger, End Hunger UK, and just this video in twenty fifteen of a child saying,"Well, you just get used to being hungry, I guess, and then you think that's normal." So that was two years before this.
- 14:11matt (2): So the Labour Party manifesto, raise minimum wage, everyone can afford food, nationalizing, access to food and drink.
- 14:22matt (2): So that, solved.
- 14:24matt (2): Solved.
- 14:25matt (2): No child will ever have to say,"Oh, I just got used to being hungry eventually." And then twenty seventeen, Labour lost the election.
- 14:33matt (2): Twenty nineteen, Labour badly lost the election.
- 14:36matt (2): Jeremy Corbyn leaves, and then Keir Starmer runs for the leader of the Labour Party.
- 14:44matt (2): And he was-- he ran on going,"This manifesto, I'm gonna do absolutely everything in this manifesto.
- 14:50matt (2): We're not gonna lose step.
- 14:51matt (2): We're gonna do everything in this manifesto." And then the Labour Part-- the, the people of Labour elected him.
- 14:59matt (2): And then the first thing he did was purge everyone out of the party leadership who had supported that manifesto, proscribed countless people, including the leadership of the, youth part- youth wing of the Labour Party, purged all of them and sort of ran-- then threw the,"Right, fuck the manifesto.
- 15:22matt (2): That's gone." And that's the party that he's created now.
- 15:27matt (2): That's who he is and what he is.
- 15:30matt (2): And so purely by, if you just say taking the minimum wage and not doing that, if he'd done everything else in the thing and, but hadn't raised the minimum wage, then that has done-- is part of all the damage that's been done to children and to their families, because he could have children's lives better immediately, tangibly, the minimum wage, and that's the simplest thing that you can do.
- 16:06matt (2): And because the Labour Party is now aligned with the right wing and the corporations and the billionaires, are the ones that are the danger to children to people in general.
- 16:21matt (2): And because he is on their side, it doesn't matter what he says he's wants to do or is trying to do.
- 16:29matt (2): If he cared, he would have carried on with these manifesto pledges.
- 16:33matt (2): That would have made tangible, permanent improvements to the lives of children.
- 16:40matt (2): And- So he...
- 16:44matt (2): And, and that's the problem with this kind of Labor Party.
- 16:48matt (2): It's just like with America.
- 16:49matt (2): You've got the insane conservatives and then the corrupt Democrats.
- 16:56matt (2): The Democrats rely on the insane party being so insane that they go,"Right, we can't vote for them again immediately," like with Trump.
- 17:06matt (2): And then the Democrat or Labor government is so terrible and doesn't do anything for people's lives that they immediately go back to the insane option next, for the next election.
- 17:19matt (2): so this is exactly where the Democrats were, doing the exact same sort of thing.
- 17:27matt (2): And so of all the people on the planet, I hate Keir Starmer the most, genuinely.
- 17:38matt (2): He, to me, he is the fulcrum of...
- 17:44matt (2): In the United Kingdom, he is the point where if he'd been different, we could have been in an entirely different world.
- 17:55matt (2): But because of his decisions to be who he is, we're where we are now.
- 18:02matt (2): No one had a bigger chance to make where we are right now unbelievably better, and he took that from us.
- 18:15matt (2): And so him doing this now is just another big fuck you to everyone'cause they don't care about kids.
- 18:26matt (2): They just don't care.
- 18:30matt (2): That's, the rage that I feel whenever I see anything about the politicians claiming to care about the British people when they don't.
- 18:41matt (2): So so it's a shit policy, a shit unworkable policy if it was coming from the right place.
- 18:48matt (2): because it's not coming from the right place either, it's just shit and unworkable and disingenuous.
- 18:55matt (2): Yeah.
- 18:57matt (2): fuck
- 19:00Jem (2): I hear what you're saying, Matt, and I think it's very disappointing where we find ourselves right now with regards to the current political situation in the UK.
- 19:12Jem (2): I think that's probably the most, generous statement I
- 19:15Alex (2): Yeah
- 19:16Jem (2): It's just very disappointing.
- 19:23Jem (2): can we see if we can work this through in a positive way and what would, a good of protecting young people from the dangers and the harms that are present for social media and, online life, what would that look like?
- 19:47Jem (2): Because I think, you know, it feels to me a little bit like how we approach smoking, you know?
- 19:56Jem (2): We knew that smoking was bad for us for a very, very long time, and we sort of said,"Oh, okay, well, we're gonna ban smoking for kids under 16." But, plenty of kids under 16 started smoking, and yeah, I remember getting friends to go and buy cigarettes for me or buying cigarettes when I was under 16.
- 20:20Jem (2): I don't smoke anymore.
- 20:21Jem (2): I haven't smoked for, like 25 years.
- 20:24Jem (2): But, it wasn't unsociable to smoke 20 years ago, well, 30 years ago.
- 20:33Jem (2): It absolutely wasn't, even though we had known the significant dangers of tobacco for such a long time.
- 20:43Jem (2): I feel like this is the same sort of argument.
- 20:46Jem (2): We know that social media, when it is not managed properly, and I don't mean managed by the individuals, I mean managed by the corporations.
- 20:58Jem (2): When content is allowed to just be whatever people choose to put on and there's no, I'm gonna say moderation, and I know moderation is a red flag to a lot of people.
- 21:10Jem (2): But I think, you know, there has to be an element of moderation as to what do we want to be allowed here.
- 21:16Jem (2): When somebody those lines, that should be removed instantly.
- 21:22Jem (2): There shouldn't be faffing about.
- 21:24Jem (2): People should be very clear about that.
- 21:27Jem (2): what's happening is that young people are being exposed to harmful content.
- 21:33Jem (2): I heard, an interview with the man who invented the kind of forever scrolling, and he said he had not realized how it was going to be used, and he is horrified.
- 21:47Jem (2): He feels a little bit like, the inventor of the, nuclear bomb, because he's...
- 21:52Alex (2): Yeah
- 21:52Jem (2): "Oh my God, I created this thing." And then, but at the time there wasn't things like social media, so it didn't...
- 22:00Jem (2): It was just like,"Oh yeah, we can do a thing that lets people just keep scrolling down the page," but nobody's gonna wanna keep scrolling forever, so it's, you know, it was gonna be self-limiting.
- 22:09Jem (2): But of course it isn't.
- 22:11Jem (2): And I know they have made changes now already,'cause I've seen,
- 22:15Alex (2): I've seen it, yeah.
- 22:16Alex (2): On my Instagram sometimes it'll say,"Do you think you've done enough for now?
- 22:20Alex (2): Do you want to stop?" And I'm like,"I could." And then I will actually usually stop within a couple of minutes of seeing that.
- 22:27Alex (2): So I think it is having an effect.
- 22:29Alex (2): But, it's the same as the Wii.
- 22:31Alex (2): Did you ever play on the Wii where for however many hours and then it was like,"You should go and take a break outside.
- 22:39Alex (2): Do you want to turn me off and go and be outside?" And then you never pay attention to it anyway.
- 22:44Alex (2): But, yeah.
- 22:45Alex (2): Yeah.
- 22:47Jem (2): So I'm
- 22:47Alex (2): It's funny
- 22:48Jem (2): What would a safe for people, vulnerable people look like without excluding...
- 23:01Jem (2): I think, my personal position is that I don't really want to exclude young people from social media, because I think there's a lot of benefits to interacting with other people.
- 23:11Jem (2): How do you make friends if not by talking to strangers?
- 23:15Jem (2): We don't want kids that are only interacting with, people in their families and their immediate friend circle.
- 23:23Jem (2): I don't think that's going to be very good for children either.
- 23:26Jem (2): So do we create a safe environment for kids in these spaces?
- 23:32Alex (2): I think it's important to acknowledge as millennials, we grew up with the birth of the internet, so to speak.
- 23:40Alex (2): When we were very young, we didn't have-- we weren't digital natives.
- 23:44Alex (2): But kids today, children today very much are.
- 23:48Alex (2): They're born into the digital world.
- 23:50Alex (2): They have digital things around them from birth, basically.
- 23:54Alex (2): I've seen, friends who are young parents, with their babies, and their babies are constantly paying attention to and watching them on their phones.
- 24:04Alex (2): They're already being exposed to it from a very young developmental age.
- 24:09Alex (2): Again, it's the same as saying, when we said about AI, it's here to stay.
- 24:14Alex (2): Being around technology and digital interfaces is here to stay.
- 24:19Alex (2): So I don't think we should ban children outright because this is the world they are born into.
- 24:26Alex (2): They don't know any different.
- 24:27Alex (2): But we should be mindful of the impact that it is having on us as a human race, I think.
- 24:36Alex (2): Similar to smoking, we need to be able to have those protections in place.
- 24:40Alex (2): You can certainly impose, preventative measures like, time limitations.
- 24:47Alex (2): We all have those settings on our phone where we can set screen time for...
- 24:51Alex (2): or take a look at how much screen time we've been using our phone for and see exactly where we've been spending the most time.
- 24:58Alex (2): I get weekly summaries of mine come up as well.
- 25:03Alex (2): So we have information available to tell us about our habits, and I think if we can use that in a creative way, to curb some of the worst of those, the ones that are having a more negative impact on us.
- 25:17Alex (2): Actually realizing when something has turned from being positive into negative, the impact and being aware of how that feels within us as individuals is important as well, because sometimes it's not easy to recognize when we've gone over the limit, so to speak.
- 25:35Alex (2): We as individuals can certainly harness those, bits of knowledge.
- 25:40Alex (2): But as we have said also, it is down to the massive corporations and, people that run these social media companies to impose more structure, more controls, and actually take ownership and be accountable and look after people on these platforms more.
- 26:01Alex (2): How they do that is, open for discussion, but, I think that's my two pence on it at this point
- 26:07Jem (2): I think it is about a balance, and I think we have the tools to deal with it because we're mature.
- 26:15Jem (2): But I think, a seven year old doesn't...
- 26:17Jem (2): they're not gonna care.
- 26:18Jem (2): They don't appreciate the harm that staying up all night watching YouTube is gonna do to them.
- 26:24Jem (2): They're not the ones that have to deal with their grumpy little asses the next morning, you know?
- 26:29Jem (2): And I think it is really challenging, especially, when at the same time we're making parents work their butts off and, finances are challenging and times are hard and, the last thing you want to do is have a row with your kids because you're not letting them use, YouTube or, Roblox or go on TikTok.
- 26:55Jem (2): And so there is a real challenge there, and I think you're right, Matt, to highlight the political element underlying this because it's so easy to miss that and I think that's one reason why I started thinking about the tobacco industry because of course that was so political and the reason why it was such a long time before it was even talked about banning was because the government was making huge amounts of money off the tax of people buying cigarettes, and it's so immoral to tie income to something that's so addictive.
- 27:35Jem (2): It's just has so many problems associated with it that it's just crazy and yet, that is what happened.
- 27:44Jem (2): I'm interested, Matt, in what do you think would be a practical solution to this?
- 27:49Jem (2): Let's say Keir is replaced and the next person to come along
- 27:56matt (2): Eh, eh, eh, I, yeah.
- 28:01matt (2): I don't know what the answer is to having a safe internet.
- 28:07matt (2): I'm sorry.
- 28:09matt (2): sorry that this will come
- 28:11Alex (2): We were relying on you, Matt.
- 28:12Alex (2): We were relying on you.
- 28:14matt (2): To know that this isn't the way because this is perfect.
- 28:19matt (2): 'Cause if you say, like, like this conversation we're having now, you're going,"We want children to have a relationship with social media and technology that they are in command of, they have maximum agency about how they interact with these things," so that when they look at Instagram and they see the different types of like, say, female body shapes, you go, an entire, like, gamut of female body shapes.
- 28:50matt (2): These aren't the objective visions of beauty, and very rarely are these things actual...
- 28:55matt (2): The realities of these people's lives, it's just..." So as long as you know that, you can go on there and look at your favorite sports stars, your favorite tennis stars, and use it the way that you want to use it.
- 29:09matt (2): That's the digital literacy that we need to be teaching children throughout their lives.
- 29:15matt (2): what this is doing is going,"Social media is a scary and dangerous place that can have a bad impact on people's lives." And we go,"Yes, I agree with that.
- 29:25matt (2): That's true." What are we gonna do about that?
- 29:28matt (2): Are we going to regulate things?
- 29:30matt (2): Are we going to, have stricter government regulations and international regulations and fines and courts and an entire new government office dedicated just to keeping these digital places in line?
- 29:46matt (2): Or we're gonna say we won't do anything to the social media and the internet itself.
- 29:53matt (2): We're gonna say we're not gonna touch that.
- 29:55matt (2): We're just going to not let people do it under the age of 16.
- 30:00matt (2): But when they get to 16, they just get pushed out into it and go,"Oh yeah, they'll be fine managing it now." Which is just like with America and drinking.
- 30:11matt (2): You go,"Right, you can't drink until you're 21." But everyone starts drinking before then anyway, when it is confusing and illicit like this will be,'cause everyone's response to this is gonna be,"That doesn't really make sense," and,"How are you gonna enforce it?" And so even if they do pass it, going to be circumvented, and it's just gonna be a mire, so it's not gonna solve anything We're almost out of time.
- 30:44matt (2): Like to talk at some point about government recognizing what the, the ills of society are because when you say,"Yes, social media is, can be bad for people's mental health," you can say that and go,"Yep, that's just true across the board." But then you have to say, right, which specific parts of it bad?
- 31:09matt (2): And one of those things is going to be the manosphere and the radicalization of men to hate women.
- 31:19matt (2): That is something that is just purely bad society and children.
- 31:28matt (2): But in order to fix that, the-- Keir Starmer would have to come out and say,"Radicalizing men to hate women is bad." And then the entire right wing everywhere across the world would go,"Ah, you can't say that.
- 31:46matt (2): That's insane.
- 31:46matt (2): You can't do that." And in order to fix problems, we need to decide exactly what the problem is, unless governments are prepared to do that, then it's not gonna, it's not gonna be fixed
- 32:01Jem (2): No, I think that's depressingly correct,
- 32:05matt (2): Eh
- 32:06Jem (2): I wanted to get on to talk about, how this might impact online gaming because, that's a really positive, place, and I feel like it will trickle into that area because online games are social spaces, But obviously we've run out of time to do that today.
- 32:22Jem (2): I did also want to say that I did hear someone, talking about research that had been done into the positive and negative influence of social media on young people.
- 32:35Jem (2): And there's more compelling evidence to say that overall it is a positive, force than a negative force.
- 32:47Jem (2): There is some evidence to say that it does have negative effects, and I think what Matt's saying is spot on really because it's about Recognizing where the negative and the positive areas are, and tackling those.
- 33:06Jem (2): But that's a much bigger project.
- 33:08Jem (2): And, you know, we've got people like Elon Musk running social media platforms and tech platforms and all the other guys who are just, looking at it from money, who are coming at it from, the sort of patriarchal capitalist background, I think it's baked in, isn't it?
- 33:33Jem (2): This harm, all these harms are baked into the systems, and it's gonna take a lot to unpick it.
- 33:41Jem (2): What I do hope, I just want to sort of finish on a, slightly positive note, is what I do hope is that this will sharpen, the conversation and sharpen the minds of the people who are working in these areas, and that over the next six months or so we're going to see an increase in discussion about these issues and that that might have...
- 34:06Jem (2): Positive stuff might come out of that.
- 34:08Jem (2): I think you're right, Alex.
- 34:09Jem (2): I think definitely reason to not assume that this is going to go through.
- 34:16Jem (2): Certainly not in the form that it's been announced this week.
- 34:20Jem (2): So I suppose what I'm hoping is that it's a warning shot, a shot across the bow, and that perhaps, people with more sane and less personal gain can maybe talk about these topics and come up with better solution, a better solution than this, or better solutions I think is probably the right thing.
- 34:47Jem (2): either of you have anything you wanted to add before we
- 34:50Alex (2): Not for today, I don't think.
- 34:52Alex (2): But yeah, thank you for the discussion.
- 34:54Alex (2): It's been great
- 34:55Jem (2): Thank you both very much.
- 34:56Jem (2): And I, as I said, I wanted to talk about gaming, so I think we'll probably come back and talk about that, in a future episode.
- 35:03Jem (2): So if anything in this episode has you fired up, if you've got any thoughts that you want to share, if you've got any ideas on how we protect our young people whilst not locking them into, padded rooms.
- 35:21Jem (2): That sounds worse than I meant it, you know?
- 35:25Jem (2): Wrapping them up in cotton wool.
- 35:26Jem (2): Let's not do that.
- 35:27Jem (2): Let's, let's show them how to survive in this brave new world.
- 35:31Jem (2): Then please comment and, we'd love you to like and share and follow.
- 35:36Jem (2): And we're here every Thursday on your favorite podcasting platform, and you can also see our videos on YouTube, and we are also streaming quite a lot at the moment, so you might find us on Twitch, and we also share those videos on YouTube as well.
- 35:55Jem (2): So you can find us wherever you want to look for us, really.
- 36:01Jem (2): Thank you both very much, and we'll see you next time.