Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Earnout Clauses in Acquisitions
Transcript
- Lucas: If you're running a public company that went public in the last five years, and you want to buy a private competitor, you've almost certainly considered an earnout clause. Luna: And I think a lot of listeners have heard the term, but maybe aren't totally clear on how it actually works in practice. Lucas: Right. So an earnout is essentially a contingent payment. The buyer agrees to pay the seller extra money — in cash or stock — if the acquired business hits certain performance targets after the deal closes. Revenue, EBITDA, user growth, whatever the two sides negotiate. Luna: If today was actually useful to you, the way these stay ad-free is listener support — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, genuinely. If you're getting something out of these deep dives, that link is how we keep the lights on, no ads, no sponsors. Luna: Alright, back to it. So why do post ipo companies in particular lean on earnouts? Lucas: Big reason: valuation uncertainty. When a public company uses its own stock as currency, and that stock has only been trading for a year or two, the price can be volatile. You don't want to overpay in stock that might drop, and the seller doesn't want to sell too cheap if the stock moons. Earnouts bridge that gap. Luna: Let's make it concrete. Which deal comes to mind for you? Lucas: Shopify's acquisition of Deliverr in 2022 is a textbook case. Shopify agreed to pay about $2.1 billion, but a big chunk was contingent on Deliverr hitting revenue targets after the close. The exact terms weren't fully public, but analysts estimated the earnout was worth several hundred million dollars. Luna: And Shopify was about four years post ipo at that point. So still early, stock was volatile. That year it went from around $1,200 down to about $300. Lucas: Exactly. So both sides had a strong incentive to use an earnout. Shopify didn't want to issue a ton of stock at a depressed price, and Deliverr's founders didn't want to take a haircut if the stock rebounded. The earnout let them align around a shared goal: grow Deliverr's revenue to unlock the full payout. Luna: And that's the key — earnouts are supposed to align incentives post-close. The seller's team stays on, works to hit the targets, and the buyer gets the growth it paid for. In theory. Lucas: In theory. But they can also create perverse incentives. If the targets are too aggressive, the seller might take excessive risk. Or if the earnout is based on a metric the buyer can manipulate — say, shifting accounting allocations — you get disputes. Luna: There's a famous example from the biotech world. I think it was Celgene and Juno Therapeutics. The earnout was tied to a drug approval timeline, and when it got delayed, there was a huge legal fight. Lucas: Right, and that's a risk for public company shareholders too. Earnouts create contingent liabilities on the balance sheet. Under US GAAP, you have to estimate the fair value of the earnout every quarter, and changes flow through earnings. So a volatile earnout can add noise to reported profits. Luna: And for post ipo companies that are already under scrutiny from analysts, that noise is the last thing they need. Lucas: Exactly. So the question becomes: when does an earnout make sense? I'd say when there's genuine uncertainty about the acquired business's standalone trajectory, and when the seller's team is critical to achieving that trajectory. If you're buying a business for its technology or customer list, earnouts are less useful. Luna: So for a post ipo software company buying a small AI startup with a hot team and no revenue, earnout might be perfect. But for buying a mature SaaS business with recurring revenue, just pay the price. Lucas: Right. And there's a structural tradeoff: earnouts typically have a cap. So the seller's upside is limited. That can demotivate the team once they hit the cap, or if they fall behind early. Some deals use a 'collar' structure where the payout adjusts between a floor and a ceiling. Luna: We're seeing more creativity in earnout design. I read about one deal where the earnout was tied to a combination of revenue and employee retention. That makes sense — if the team leaves, the revenue probably doesn't materialize anyway. Lucas: Another trend: using stock as the earnout currency. If the buyer's stock goes up, the seller gets more value, which keeps them aligned with public shareholders. But if the stock drops, the seller gets less, which can feel unfair if they did everything right. Luna: So it's a balancing act. And for post ipo companies, the stakes are higher because the market is watching every deal. Lucas: Absolutely. Look at the data from the last few years. A study by SRS Acquiom found that about 40 percent of private-target deals included earnouts in 2024, up from around 25 percent a decade ago. And tech deals are even more likely to have them. Luna: Part of that is the sheer number of post ipo companies doing M&A. Companies like Snowflake, Unity, Palantir — they're all acquisitive, and their stocks are volatile. Lucas: Palantir, ticker symbol P-L-T-R, is up about 1.8 percent over the past five days as of July 19, 2026. But it's been a rollercoaster. Their stock has a beta well above 1. So earnouts help them do deals without overcommitting equity. Luna: And we should talk about the tax angle. Earnout payments are typically treated as additional purchase price, which means they're taxable as capital gains when received. But if the earnout is paid in stock, the tax treatment can get complicated. Lucas: Right. And if the earnout is structured as compensation for services, it could be taxed as ordinary income. That's a huge difference. So sellers need good tax advice. Luna: So for a post ipo company's CFO, what's the checklist? Evaluate whether earnout aligns incentives, model the accounting impact, negotiate clear metrics, and get tax counsel. Lucas: And communicate it to investors. If you've got a material earnout liability, the market needs to understand how it works. Otherwise, when earnings take a hit from a fair-value adjustment, you get angry calls. Luna: All right, so earnouts are powerful but nuanced. One last question: are they becoming more common because post ipo companies are doing more risky deals? Lucas: I think it's partly that, and partly that the ecosystem has gotten more sophisticated. Law firms and investment banks have standard templates now. It's easier to negotiate. But the core reason is the same: when you can't agree on price, you find a way to make the price depend on the outcome. Luna: Which is what markets do best — allocate risk to the parties best able to bear it. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why earnouts are here to stay for post ipo acquirers.