Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #20: Recapping a Bananas Week 7, another AP Poll audit, and a look at Week 8
Transcript
- 0:14Hello and welcome to another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast, where we rank the resume, not the expectation.
- 0:21This is episode number 20, and in this episode, we need to recap an absolutely bananas week seven.
- 0:26I'll put a couple of teams' resumes side by side to compare them.
- 0:30We'll check in again with our 69 AP poll voters, and another week of football starts Tuesday night, so we're jumping right back into it for week number eight.
- 0:40There were 121 FBS teams that took the field in week seven.
- 0:44Three of those teams faced FCS competitions, while the remaining 59 games were between FBS schools.
- 0:5017 teams took a week off, including Southern Cal, Iowa, Boise State, and Arizona from last week's CSR top 25.
- 0:59The CSR takes a holistic look at a team's results, not the average of games played, so taking a bye typically results in teams near the top losing ground, so we'll see what happened to those teams on bye later in the episode.
- 1:13While we'll get to the insanity that occurred to teams near the top of last week's rankings, there was one inter-conference matchup that impacted the Common Sense rankings.
- 1:21South Florida beat Kent State 29 to two in the final matchup between the American and the MAC this season.
- 1:27That put the season series at two and two and lowered the value of the MAC in the CSR, as they now fail to have a winning record against any other conference in 2026.
- 1:38Any team that has beaten a team from the MAC to this point now receives slightly less credit for that victory Now, this is not typically an X's and O's podcast, but at the end of the season, there's no doubt week seven is going to be circled as the one that changed everything.
- 1:54So bear with me as I dive into the timeline of this past week.
- 1:59The insanity started Friday night when the favorite in the American, the Memphis Tigers, fell to Tulane thirty-one seventeen.
- 2:06While Memphis was certainly not the favorite to make the college football playoff, if certain results happen elsewhere, that could put a lot of question marks on who will be the group of six representative come December.
- 2:17On Saturday, Fox's big noon kickoff led into a top five AP matchup between Ohio State and Indiana.
- 2:24Ohio State lost quarterback Julian Sayin in the fourth quarter, and Indiana put the pressure on late, but the Buckeyes stood fast to hand Indiana their first home loss under Kurt Signetti.
- 2:35Meanwhile, in the noon window on ABC, the Texas Longhorns were hosting the Florida Gators.
- 2:40Florida rallied after a tough start to take down the Longhorns, heading back to Gainesville with a twenty-seven twenty-four victory, while Texas is left licking its wounds after two straight losses.
- 2:49So for those of you counting at home, we have both the AP number five and AP number seven losing early on Saturday.
- 2:57In the mid-afternoon window, four more top ten teams took the field.
- 3:01Ole Miss dismantled Missouri, making me feel extremely dumb after saying I was going to back the Tigers last week.
- 3:07Texas Tech also flattened Arizona State to remain unbeaten.
- 3:10There were, however, two more games that left audiences stunned.
- 3:14The AP number one Georgia Bulldogs fell at home to an unranked Auburn Tiger team, quite literally fumbling their chance to win the game late in the fourth quarter.
- 3:22That makes three of the top seven in the AP poll losing so far.
- 3:26But the mid-afternoon still wasn't over because Alabama was facing Tennessee in Knoxville.
- 3:31The Vols handed Alabama their second consecutive loss, something that hasn't happened to the Tide since twenty thirteen.
- 3:37So give us a fourth top seven team to fall before night settled over the East Coast.
- 3:42But the day still wasn't over.
- 3:45Kentucky continued to win, this time over Oklahoma.
- 3:47Houston defeated Oklahoma State in a ranked Big Twelve matchup, and UCLA remained undefeated, spoiling Wisconsin's West Coast trip.
- 3:55In the most southern part of Florida, Miami hosted Florida State in an in-state ACC rivalry.
- 4:01In double OT, down eight, Florida State looked to have secured a touchdown on a Hail Mary, but the play was called back for questionable holding.
- 4:08And after seemingly completing a second Hail Mary, that too was ruled in favor of Miami, keeping the Hurricanes undefeated and allowing the AP number three to escape with a win.
- 4:21In Provo, Utah, site of the day's college game day, Notre Dame was visiting BYU.
- 4:26Notre Dame had a chance at the end, but the pass fell incomplete as time expired.
- 4:30Or did it?
- 4:31There were some camera angles that had a second left on the clock, and the Big 12 has since commented that the ending should have been handled differently.
- 4:38But Cougar fans can still be heard celebrating days later.
- 4:42Down goes AP number two.
- 4:44In the late-night games, Wake Forest obliterated Cal, while Colorado hung with Utah, but the Utes did manage to hang on and stay undefeated.
- 4:51Add it all up and the AP numbers one, two, five, six, and seven all lost on the same day, causing absolute anarchy for anybody trying to evaluate teams not using a predetermined formula With another week of games behind us, we have a dancing plethora of new data points to put into our common sense rankings formula.
- 5:12Teams have their direct results as well as the wins and losses from each of the teams they had previously played.
- 5:17The conference rankings this week only had one change, and it was at the bottom.
- 5:21The aforementioned Kent State loss put the MAC behind Conference USA and tenth of ten conferences this year in the CSR.
- 5:29With the SEC having a winning record over every conference and the MAC having a winning head-to-head against zero conferences, both direct wins and opponent wins over the SEC are worth twice the value of direct and opponent wins over the MAC.
- 5:42On the flip side, a loss to a MAC team is twice as detrimental to a team's resume as a loss to an SEC school.
- 5:51All right, next, it's blind resume time.
- 5:53Let's take a look at two resumes to this point and see which is more impressive.
- 5:58Our first resume puts Team A at six and O.
- 6:01They are four and O in the ACC with a win over the MAC as well, which just lost ground in the Common Sense Rankings formula.
- 6:08They also have a dominant win over an FCS team.
- 6:11Their opponents have tallied 15 FBS wins, including nine over Power Four teams.
- 6:17Team B is similarly undefeated, six and O.
- 6:20They are four and O in the Big Ten, which is statistically more impressive than four and O in the ACC.
- 6:26They also have a win over the ACC and the Pac-12, giving them six total FBSWs.
- 6:32Their opponents have 13 FBS wins with eight over Power Four teams.
- 6:37Team A and Team B's opponents to this point are contributing similar amounts to their resumes, but in the CSR, four Big Ten wins will be more valuable than four ACC due to the Big Ten's out-of-conference success, giving Team B a better resume to this point.
- 6:52Even if you don't agree, we can come to the conclusion that these teams are at least comparable as far as resumes go, but not to AP poll voters.
- 7:01Forty of the 69 voters had Team A, Miami, as their number one team, while UCLA, Team B, is down at number nine, significantly lower for a team that has played in a harder conference and won against more FBS teams through week seven Our second blind resume test is between two six and one teams in the Big Ten.
- 7:21Team A started three and one in conference with a Pac-12, Sun Belt, and Mountain West win also under their belt.
- 7:28Their loss is to a four and two Big Ten team.
- 7:31Their six wins are over opponents with 17 FBS wins as well as two Power Four victories.
- 7:37Team B also started three and one in the Big Ten with other FBS wins over the American and Conference USA.
- 7:43Their loss is to a six and one Big Ten team.
- 7:46The five teams they have defeated have fewer FBS wins at just 14, but more Power Four wins with six.
- 7:53This is another situation where the resumes are at the very least comparable, but the AP judges one to be significantly better than the other.
- 8:01Team A is USC who is on bye in week seven but managed to maintain their hold on the number four ranking in the CSR while the AP has them at number 16.
- 8:11Indiana is team B and they sit almost opposite, number six in the AP and 17 in the CSR.
- 8:18The biggest difference between resumes to this point is the six FBS wins that Southern Cal has compared to the five that Indiana has had so far this season.
- 8:27With FCS schools meaning nothing in the CSR because it is just an entirely different level of competition, that sixth FBS win that USC has is setting them apart from the Hoosiers in the CSR.
- 8:41Let's do one more resume comparison.
- 8:44Team A is five and one.
- 8:46They're three and one in the ACC, which is statistically the weakest of the Power Four conferences, and they have one more win this season over Conference USA.
- 8:54Their loss is to a four and three ACC team.
- 8:57The teams they've beat have eight FBS wins, with five being against Power Four competition.
- 9:02Team B has started seven and O, four and O in the Sun Belt, which is statistically tied for the strongest Group of 6 conference.
- 9:09All six FBS wins are over Group of 6 competition, and of their opponents' fourteen FBS wins, all fourteen of them are over a Group of 16.
- 9:19So the question we're asking: what is the separation between a Power Four conference and a Group of 6 conference?
- 9:25Because the voters seem to think that gap is huge.
- 9:28Team A snuck into this week's AP Top 25.
- 9:32The SMU Mustangs are number 23, while they are unranked in this week's CSR.
- 9:37James Madison, meanwhile, is Team B.
- 9:39They are still undefeated yet still unranked in the AP poll, while they are still number 12 in this week's Common Sense rankings Based strictly on wins and losses and the wins and losses of those opponents, here is this week's Common Cents Rankings top 10.
- 9:57UCLA has yet to be ranked anywhere near where their resume warrants, and they're comfortably at the top of this week's CSR.
- 10:04They are the last remaining undefeated team in the Big Ten, the second-best conference in the country.
- 10:09The Bruins have the most direct win points from their wins of any team in the ranking, so while their opponent victories haven't quite amounted to the same level as other teams, the value of their six victories are carrying them to this week's number one spot, and they are a good amount ahead of number two.
- 10:25At number two are the Heart Attack Wildcats of Kentucky.
- 10:28I am fully aware of their loss to Alabama, fully aware, so let's dig into why they rank number two in the formula this week.
- 10:36I've talked extensively about why winning games in the SEC nets you the most points in the CSR compared to winning against other conferences.
- 10:44Kentucky has four of those SEC wins.
- 10:47They're also repping a win over the Sun Belt.
- 10:49Those opponents have 15 FBS wins, including five over the SEC and seven total Power Four wins.
- 10:56The strength of their wins and those opponent wins outweigh the loss to the Tide on their resume to this point The number three team was the winner of last week's game day matchup, the BYU Cougars.
- 11:07Sporting a spotless six and zero record and starting three and zero in conference gives the Cougars the third-best resume so far.
- 11:13What's keeping BYU behind the Bruins and the Wildcats is the out-of-conference strength of the Big Twelve.
- 11:20A win over the Big Twelve is worth slightly less than the Big Ten and is worth quite a bit less than an SEC win.
- 11:26So BYU's direct value of wins doesn't quite match up with the teams around them.
- 11:31The teams they have defeated, though, have racked up victories, putting them tied for sixth in opponent win value this season.
- 11:38Number four stayed stagnant from last week, the USC Trojans.
- 11:42Still one of the few teams that have six FBS wins to this point, they're among the top three in win value in the common sense rankings.
- 11:49While their Big Ten wins thus far haven't proved as fruitful, where they're picking up opponent win points is the relative success of both Fresno State and Louisiana, which is fueling USC's resume through seven weeks.
- 12:02Number five is the second team from the SEC, the Georgia Bulldogs.
- 12:05Similar to the Kentucky Wildcats, the Dogs are four and one in the SEC, so the value of their four SEC wins and the wins of those teams is overcoming the loss to two-loss Auburn in week seven.
- 12:16It's important to note too that several teams have a loss to a two-loss SEC team, and that's hurting every team equally.
- 12:23Those teams include Kentucky, Georgia, Ole Miss, Ohio State, Tennessee, and UTSA.
- 12:30The rest of the top ten in the CSR at number six is last week's number one, the Notre Dame Fighting Irish.
- 12:36Notre Dame's direct wins is second in the country behind only US- UCLA, but their loss to a Big Twelve team is hurting them worse than the teams above them.
- 12:44Number seven is the Ole Miss Rebels, who is the first five-win team in the rankings.
- 12:48They play an FCS team later into the season, so five FBS wins is carrying them currently.
- 12:54Number eight is Ohio State, whose win over Indiana gets them into the CSR top ten.
- 12:59Number nine is the Tennessee Volunteers, who had a big win over Alabama this past week.
- 13:04We round out the top ten with the Miami Hurricanes, who have the rest of the ACC to blame for their lack of success out of conference.
- 13:12Going through the rest of the top 25, we have the top two-loss team at number 11, that's Alabama.
- 13:18Number 12 is the best Group of 6 team, James Madison.
- 13:2113 is Wake Forest, the second ACC team.
- 13:2414 is Texas Tech.
- 13:2615, Utah.
- 13:2716 is Houston, so three Big 12 teams in a row.
- 13:3017 belongs to Indiana.
- 13:3218 is Florida.
- 13:3319, Texas.
- 13:3420, LSU.
- 13:3521 is Auburn.
- 13:3722, Iowa.
- 13:3823, Missouri.
- 13:3924 is our second Group of 6 team, UTSA, and 25 is Mississippi State.
- 13:46An interesting stat here, there are seven two-loss SEC teams in the rankings, the only conference that got a two-loss team into the top 25 of the CSR.
- 13:55The SEC right now in our formulas is actually benefiting from their circular pattern of destruction until all of these teams continue to play each other.
- 14:03Our top 25 has a slightly concerning 11 SEC teams, five from the Big Ten, four Big 12, only two ACC, plus Notre Dame, UTSA from the American, and James Madison from the Sun Belt How do those conference affiliations compare to the AP poll?
- 14:21Well, the SEC has two more teams in the CSR compared to the AP as it judges both Mississippi State and Auburn to have a top 25 resume.
- 14:30The AP poll has one too many Big Ten teams as Northwestern doesn't have the juice.
- 14:35We also have one fewer Big 12 team in the CSR.
- 14:38That would be Arizona.
- 14:40SMU still manages to hold a top 25 spot in the AP, so the AP has one too many ACC teams.
- 14:46Notre Dame is legit, but UTSA and James Madison are both more deserving than Boise State based on resumes to this point.
- 14:55So if we're looking at a hypothetical college football playoff bracket based on the common sense rankings, our buys go to UCLA, Kentucky, BYU, and USC.
- 15:05The first-round matchups would feature Georgia facing the group of six representative James Madison in Athens.
- 15:11Notre Dame would welcome Alabama to South Bend.
- 15:15Number seven Ole Miss would host the ACC rep number 10 Miami, and the first round would conclude with number eight Ohio State hosting number nine Tennessee.
- 15:24The teams just on the outside looking in this week are Wake Forest, Texas Tech, and Utah.
- 15:30Our 69 AP poll voters held steady week over week, correctly identifying 21 of the top 25 resumes in the sport.
- 15:38BYU appropriately is in the top three.
- 15:41Their only two loss ranked teams are in the SEC, and Georgia and Notre Dame dropped an appropriate amount given who they lost to.
- 15:48Meanwhile, we're still not seeing the James Madison Dukes with a number next to their name.
- 15:52UTSA didn't get a vote at all, and Miami's resume just isn't the best through seven weeks this season.
- 16:01Let's next dive into the nitty-gritty of individual voter ballots to see who had a ballot that compared favorably to the Common Sense Rankings formula.
- 16:09UCLA is the clear CSR number one this week but are down at number nine in the AP.
- 16:14Of all the voters, Steven Means had the Bruins the highest in his ballot at number three, behind BYU and Ohio State.
- 16:22Similar to the Bruins, the Kentucky Wildcats aren't getting the respect their resume deserves, coming in at number 12 in the AP this week.
- 16:29The highest any voters had the Cats was eighth, and those voters are Brian Howell, Dave Preston, Eric Hanson, and Murray Evans.
- 16:37James Madison and Auburn were the two teams highest in the CSR that were unranked this week in the AP.
- 16:42Dave Preston, David Briggs, Eric Johnson, Trevor Hass, and Zach Klein all had both the Dukes and the Tigers in their top 25 of this week's poll Among the questionable ballots, Texas Tech got a first place vote.
- 16:57They're number eight in the AP, but even further down at number 14 in the CSR through seven weeks.
- 17:02Chris Murray is the voter that delivered that first place vote.
- 17:05So Chris, I am asking you to do better.
- 17:09There were four teams that are ranked that shouldn't be according to the CSR.
- 17:12Those are SMU, Boise State, Arizona, and Northwestern.
- 17:17An unfortunate 19 voters had all four on their ballot, so bear with me as I shame these individuals.
- 17:22Andy Yamashita, Bob Asmussen, Brett McMurphy, Chelsea Brown, Dave Preston, David Jablonsky, Greg Luka, Harry Greenstein, Jamal St.
- 17:31Cyr, John Wilner, Josh Furlong, Kate Rogerson, Leah Asamakalopolis, Louis Vacker, Mike Griffith, Randy Johnson, Scott Hamilton, Steven Means, and Zach Klein, consider yourselves shamed.
- 17:44As we look ahead to week eight, there are six teams in this week's CSR top 25 that are taking their bye: Georgia, Notre Dame, Ohio State, Wake Forest, Florida, and Missouri.
- 17:54The other 19 members of the top 25 play a conference opponent.
- 17:58There are no matchups this week that could impact our CSR conference standings.
- 18:02A reminder that the value of a win is based on the success each conference has against each of the other conferences in non-conference play.
- 18:09The rankings for the 2026 season are just about set in stone.
- 18:15This upcoming week has three CSR ranked matchups.
- 18:18College game day will be back in Utah, this time in Salt Lake City for Utah's game against Houston.
- 18:23That's CSR number fifteen versus number sixteen, but both are ranked slightly higher in the AP with Utah at ten and Houston at fourteen.
- 18:31That game will be the late-night game, ten fifteen start on ESPN.
- 18:35The Big Twelve is still pushing for multiple teams in the CFP this year, and the winner of this one would likely have the second-best resume in the Big Twelve behind the undefeated BYU Cougars.
- 18:45The second CSR ranked matchup is number seven Ole Miss versus number nineteen Texas at seven thirty PM Eastern on ABC.
- 18:53The Rebels have the third-best resume in the SEC and can likely handle another loss before their CFP hopes are on life support.
- 19:00Texas, meanwhile, have lost their last two, and a third would likely kick them out of the CFP picture this season.
- 19:06The final CSR ranked matchup is likely a CFP elimination game.
- 19:10LSU is number twenty in the CSR, and their opponent, the Auburn Tigers, are just a spot below them at number twenty-one.
- 19:17Auburn is coming off one of the biggest wins in recent memory, taking down Georgia in Athens last week, while LSU and the Lane train are coming off a shutout of Mississippi State in week seven.
- 19:26Whichever team loses would suffer a third SEC loss, and based on how teams at the top of other conferences are playing, it would doom them to another season without a CFP berth.
- 19:38We've reached the end of another podcast episode.
- 19:40We're quickly getting to the point in the season where we have almost half the data points for each team with the other half still to come.
- 19:46Thank you for listening to another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 19:50Each week, I point out on X how games will impact the CSR, so you can follow me at commsenseranking.
- 19:57You can also see the full one through 138 ranking at commonsenserankings.com.
- 20:02I update those throughout the week as games finish.
- 20:05I'll see you again next time.
- 20:06But please, as you go about your day-to-day, use some common sense