Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #57: Ideological Labels - What is a Conservative, Liberal, Moderate?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan analysis of politics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:09Today, we're gonna talk about ideological labels and what they mean.
- 0:15If you follow politics even occasionally, you'll see ideological appeals everywhere.
- 0:21This person is a conservative champion.
- 0:23This person is a liberal warrior.
- 0:26This person is a whack job about whatever ideology it is.
- 0:30And the vast majority of the time you hear conservative or liberal, it's given a positive
- 0:35or negative rep.
- 0:37And usually tacked on are words like radical, extreme, ultra, crazy, or something along those
- 0:43lines.
- 0:44So it's hard to find useful, unbiased information on what in the world these
- 0:50ideological labels mean.
- 0:52What exactly is a conservative or a liberal or a moderate?
- 0:57That's what we're diving into today.
- 0:59Included in this discussion is the difference between party and ideology, how we measure
- 1:04ideology, the various definitions people have for conservative, liberal, and moderate, the
- 1:10most basic meanings of conservative and liberal, how ideological labels are used as
- 1:16campaign tools, how moderate is defined, and how you should think about ideological labels.
- 1:22Let's go.
- 1:23First of all, party is not ideology.
- 1:29Now to some people that might sound obvious, but republican is often interchangeably used
- 1:36with conservative, and democrat is interchangeably used with liberal.
- 1:40And my one of my professors from grad school, doctor Craig, is beside himself anytime he
- 1:45hears people confuse the two.
- 1:47Well, maybe not beside himself, but he made sure to make a point of it in our studies.
- 1:52It's a common misconception to just say republican is conservative, democrat is
- 1:56liberal.
- 1:58Although sometimes people deliberately conflate party and ideological labels.
- 2:02Now it is true.
- 2:05Those ideologies typically align with those parties.
- 2:08Most Republicans are conservatives.
- 2:11Most Democrats are liberals, but some Republicans are much more conservative than
- 2:16others, and some Democrats are much more liberal than others.
- 2:20And just saying this person's conservative, this person's liberal doesn't necessarily give
- 2:25a fully accurate, well rounded picture of what exactly they believe.
- 2:30Sometimes it does, but there are still also some liberal Republicans and conservative
- 2:36Democrats, believe it or not, as well as moderates in both parties.
- 2:41But that comes down to self identification, which involves different perceptions of what a
- 2:46conservative or a liberal are.
- 2:48And we're gonna talk about that a little bit more in just a little bit.
- 2:54But the parties have become increasingly associated with these respective ideologies
- 2:59over time.
- 3:00But that being said, you still want to make sure that you don't just interchangeably say
- 3:05Republicans and conservatives, Democrats, and liberals.
- 3:10So how do we measure ideology?
- 3:14There's various ways that we can do that, whether you're talking about elites, which are
- 3:20the people that are in office that are campaigning, that are much more ingrained in
- 3:25politics, and then the regular general public.
- 3:28So especially with public opinion polling, how detailed you wanna go depends on what's your
- 3:34goal for the polling is.
- 3:36Are you simply just trying to understand the electorate as a whole?
- 3:41Like, for example, Gallup or Pew Research Center, and you're doing this for an
- 3:46educational purpose, whether you just generally understand the electorate better or teach other
- 3:50people how the electorate thinks?
- 3:54Or are you trying to win an election and figure out how to tailor your message?
- 3:59Campaigns will tweak their messaging depending on how their poll sample is responding and who
- 4:05campaigns think they that who campaigns think will vote.
- 4:10If they think that more highly conservative people are gonna vote or more highly liberal
- 4:16people are gonna vote, they wanna know who those people are that are very conservative,
- 4:21very liberal, and try to tailor the message so that they can effectively turn them out.
- 4:29Now there is a difference between self reporting and what people say or how they
- 4:35behave because a lot of times, just just in general, not even talking about politics, but
- 4:41just in general, a lot of times we say something and we behave in a way that
- 4:46contradicts what we say what we say we actually believe.
- 4:51You know, it's that whole joke about parents telling their children do as I say, not as I do
- 4:56kind of thing.
- 4:57It's kinda like that.
- 4:59What people self report as can actually be different than what they really are.
- 5:05People can think they are more or less conservative or more or less liberal than their
- 5:11beliefs actually indicate.
- 5:13One of these concepts is what we call symbolically conservative, operationally
- 5:19liberal because people tend to not not necessarily a whole lot of people, but in
- 5:28public opinion polling, people tend to talk in a way that indicates they want less government
- 5:33involvement.
- 5:36But when you try to boil down to specific programs, they start to become a little bit
- 5:42more supportive of government involvement.
- 5:45For example, if you talk about government aid programs in general, or what some people would
- 5:50call welfare, and you talk about those specific, just a general overview of those
- 5:55policies.
- 5:57Some people will say, I don't think that government should be giving handouts to people
- 6:00or whatever it is that they give us the reason.
- 6:04But then if you point to specific programs, like if you said Medicare specifically or
- 6:10Obamacare or Medicaid or Social Security.
- 6:14Now the opinions change a little bit.
- 6:17Some people start to become more supportive of those programs.
- 6:22So it's not just about what people self report versus what they believe, but it also depends
- 6:27on the actual context.
- 6:29Sometimes you need to get a little bit deeper.
- 6:31If you're too broad, you won't necessarily get a fully accurate picture.
- 6:35So it's not just on the people who are responding to these polls.
- 6:39It's also on the pollsters to be able to craft the right questions to get the information that
- 6:45they want.
- 6:48And there's also a difference in, and I mentioned this just a bit ago, how ideological
- 6:53lease are, the politicians, campaigners, versus how the how ideological the public is.
- 7:01Public is much less ideological than elites are.
- 7:04They the public does not think about ideology nearly as much as the elites do.
- 7:10Now I know it can seem like there's a lot more ideological voters in the public, and sure,
- 7:17there there is a decent number of them, but they just have outsized influence.
- 7:22They have an outsized voice because they tend to get the publicity and they tend to be more
- 7:28invested in politics.
- 7:29So you tend to hear them more often, and it gives you a little bit more of a, oh, wow.
- 7:34There's a lot of these people.
- 7:36Not necessarily.
- 7:38So a couple of the ways that we can measure ideology through public opinion polling is
- 7:45through a seven point scale.
- 7:47And this is one, two, three, four, five, six, seven on a continuum.
- 7:51And, usually, one is very liberal, Two is liberal.
- 7:56Three is somewhat liberal.
- 7:57Four is moderate.
- 7:58Five is somewhat conservative.
- 8:00Six is conservative.
- 8:01Seven is very conservative.
- 8:03And some might put it the other way.
- 8:06But typically, that's that's what you see.
- 8:09And it's not a value judgment.
- 8:10One is not better than seven.
- 8:12Seven is not better than one.
- 8:13It's just to show a spatial comparison of people based on how conservative or liberal
- 8:21they say they are.
- 8:23But sometimes it's also shortened to a five point scale, so it might just be very liberal,
- 8:28liberal, moderate, conservative, very conservative.
- 8:32You might also just see a simple liberal, moderate, or conservative question.
- 8:36Pollsters like Gallup use these quite often.
- 8:39Might just simply say, do you see yourself as a liberal, a conservative, or a moderate?
- 8:46Or they might directly ask if you are very liberal, liberal, moderate, conservative, very
- 8:51conservative.
- 8:52Instead of having that multiple choice question, they might just straight up ask you
- 8:57more open endedly.
- 8:59Tell tell us if you are this.
- 9:03Another calculation now moving from polling.
- 9:07And when you move for polling, there's a whole bunch of different ways that people might
- 9:11measure ideology.
- 9:13And one of these ways is a an organization called VoteView, and they measure the ideology
- 9:21of congresspeople over time.
- 9:24And they have a lot of data going all the way back to the very first congress.
- 9:30And they have this special calculation called DW nominate, and that estimates ideology based
- 9:36on roll calls, that is to say votes on bills.
- 9:41So depending on what bills are being voted on, a congressperson may not get to show off their
- 9:46ideological stripes as much.
- 9:48That's why they have a specific article on the VoteView website talks about why Alexandria
- 9:56Ocasio Cortez, Ilhan Omar, Rashida Tlaib, Ayanna Pressley, and more people that think
- 10:03similarly to them.
- 10:04But those four in particular, why early on in their congressional tenure, they were actually
- 10:11rated as moderate.
- 10:13When you hear them talk, they certainly do not call themselves moderates.
- 10:17They are certainly liberal in ideology.
- 10:20But because of what votes were actually up on bills at the time, The way they voted just
- 10:26happened to look moderate.
- 10:30There's also if you simply don't just have it as a basic continuum liberal through
- 10:37conservative.
- 10:38You actually just overall, you often see where there's a divide between economic and social
- 10:47issues.
- 10:47So are you economically liberal, economically conservative, socially liberal, socially
- 10:53conservative?
- 10:55And this if you just want more data, this is obviously the way to go.
- 10:59But there may be reasons that you just can't do that.
- 11:04You just have to ask a general question of whether somebody's liberal or conservative
- 11:09because some people don't necessarily make a distinction on economics and social.
- 11:13They just say that they're liberal, that they're conservative.
- 11:16And also, you add another polling question, if you were gonna ask people if they were
- 11:21economically conservative and liberal or socially conservative and liberal, every
- 11:26question you ask is more time spent on the survey.
- 11:30It's more money that you have to pay to a pollster to actually give out these questions
- 11:35to people.
- 11:36And then these people on the other side have to spend more time answering questions.
- 11:40And some people might get impatient with that.
- 11:44So it partially depends on the funds that you have, the experience of the pollster, who
- 11:52you're reaching out to, what your purpose is for the polling.
- 11:57Sometimes you might just ask a simple, is this person a conservative or liberal?
- 12:03But if you have the ability to, it is always better to try to get more complex if you can.
- 12:09And then, of course, you can be conservative or liberal on very specific issues, but not others
- 12:18within that economic or social distinction.
- 12:24Maybe you think the government needs to be involved in very specific aspects of the
- 12:28economy, but not others.
- 12:30Maybe there's a social view that you're very conservative on, but a social view that you're
- 12:36another one that you're very liberal on.
- 12:39Social, maybe you support same sex marriage, but you don't support transgender athletes in
- 12:49in sporting events, for example.
- 12:52So when you start peeling back the layers, it starts to get obviously more and more complex.
- 13:00But what also makes things more complex is how people variously define conservative and
- 13:07liberal.
- 13:08You asked five different people what a conservative is or what a liberal is, and you
- 13:14can very well get five different answers.
- 13:17In fact, it's very likely you will get five different answers.
- 13:20Some of them might sound similar, but you can still get five considerably different answers.
- 13:27And the definitions of these labels are not always honest and certainly not always devoid
- 13:34of value judgments.
- 13:36You ask somebody who's more liberal to define conservatism.
- 13:41They'll they might say that it's that it's racism that it's sexism that it's restrictive
- 13:46that it's fascist and so on.
- 13:48You ask a conservative what a liberal is and they might say that it's woke, that it's
- 13:53racist, that it's suppressive, that it's socialist, and so on.
- 13:58Now why are there so many definitions of these ideologies?
- 14:01Well, like we said, some people have a vested interest because they have a very ardent bias
- 14:07against those labels, or they have a very positive bias with their own labels.
- 14:12But campaigning tactics have a vested interest in painting ideologies a certain way you want
- 14:18to use labels to elicit a Pavlovian emotional response from people so that they go, oh, I
- 14:25need to vote for this person or oh, I need to not vote for this person.
- 14:28I need to vote for the other person.
- 14:32Plus people just not being educated on the meanings of these labels.
- 14:36Now, that's for a bunch of different reasons.
- 14:39Some people just don't want to research what these labels mean.
- 14:43They want to just stay in their own thoughts about what exactly these labels mean.
- 14:49But it's also, like I alluded to at the beginning, it's hard to find the info on what
- 14:55these labels mean because of how much these meanings are obfuscated by campaigners and
- 15:02politicians.
- 15:04But others who could teach the meanings might also obfuscate the info themselves as well.
- 15:10Maybe they have their own biases, or maybe they don't really know what conservative and liberal
- 15:16is.
- 15:17So there's various definitions not just by the people who oppose a label, but there's
- 15:25definitions from those who self identify as a conservative or a liberal.
- 15:30So if you ask a conservative what a conservative is, they might say it's somebody
- 15:34who's favors small or limited government, a Republican, somebody who wants efficiency,
- 15:42somebody who wants freedom.
- 15:44You ask a liberal what a liberal is.
- 15:47They might say that it's a government that fixes problems, that it's a Democrat, that it's
- 15:52they favor equitable government or that they're open minded.
- 15:56And some of these definitions might have some accuracy, at least for some people and in
- 16:01certain contexts, but they're not the true meaning of these labels.
- 16:06So what is the base meaning of conservative and liberal?
- 16:11Because these words have been defined in many different ways by both supporters and
- 16:16detractors of these labels.
- 16:19So the true meaning of conservative and liberal gets muddied a lot.
- 16:23So the absolute basic meanings in their normal context, just very generally, a conservative
- 16:33favors a traditional role of government, and a liberal favors a nontraditional role of
- 16:39government.
- 16:41And how conservative or liberal you are partly depends on the importance you place on the need
- 16:46for the traditional role of government.
- 16:49It's partly why older people tend to be more conservative.
- 16:53They tend to be more in favor of tradition.
- 16:57They tend to support things that were more like what they had when they were younger.
- 17:03It happens to everybody.
- 17:05Well or it it is a common thing that happens.
- 17:09It's not necessarily right or wrong.
- 17:11It's just how things tend to happen over time.
- 17:16So what do these differences in traditional and nontraditional emphasis look like.
- 17:24So now we're going more into specific examples of what conservative and liberal policy looks
- 17:36like.
- 17:36Traditional, so more conservative views, typically takes a more hands off government
- 17:42approach to the economy.
- 17:44Historically, American government tended to take a more what they call laissez faire
- 17:52approach, less regulations on the economy, fewer restrictions on guns.
- 18:03So they are tend to be more opposed to gun control.
- 18:08Opposition to same sex marriage.
- 18:11Now, conservatives don't necessarily agree with the conservative approach on every single one
- 18:17of these things, but that's what tends to be the more conservative view because those are
- 18:21the more traditional views.
- 18:24Now on the other side, liberals, the more nontraditional view of government, they see a
- 18:31need for more government involvement in the economy.
- 18:34Like, if we talk about FDR, for example, in his new deal, that was a nontraditional approach to
- 18:42the economy when it came came to government involvement.
- 18:45Had a lot more involvement in the economy from the government.
- 18:49More gun control, more support for same sex marriage.
- 18:53Again, not every liberal supports every one of these things, but those tend to be more liberal
- 18:59minded.
- 19:01Conservative tends to be more traditional.
- 19:04Liberal tends to be more nontraditional.
- 19:07And if you look at research into personality traits and how conservatives and liberals tend
- 19:14to estimate on those.
- 19:16Very basically, this is a very general view.
- 19:19It doesn't get into the very nitty gritty, but conservatives tend to rate higher on
- 19:25conscientiousness, which is kind of a large umbrella term, but part of the conscientious
- 19:33label includes the adherence to traditional norms or or adherence to rules.
- 19:41Whereas liberals tend to write higher on the openness to experience.
- 19:45So that's that more non traditional view of things.
- 19:49Again, that's not always the case.
- 19:51Some conservatives will rank higher on openness to experience, and some liberals will rank
- 19:56higher on conscientiousness.
- 19:58But that's just a general rule of thumb that conservatives tend to be higher in
- 20:04conscientiousness on personality tests, and then liberals tend to be higher on openness to
- 20:09experience.
- 20:12And then what is a conservative and what is a liberal can differ by country?
- 20:17So a conservative in Venezuela is not gonna be the same as a conservative in The US.
- 20:24A liberal in Iran is not gonna be the same as a liberal in The US.
- 20:30Now there might be some similarities, but you have to take into account what what exactly is
- 20:37tradition in another country versus The US.
- 20:43Not always gonna look the same.
- 20:45What is a liberal or what is nontraditional in another country is not gonna necessarily look
- 20:50the same as over here.
- 20:52So there may be some commonalities in ideologies between countries, but it's rarely,
- 20:58if ever, a one to one comparison.
- 21:03Now I mentioned earlier that ideological labels are oftentimes used as campaign tools.
- 21:11They are campaign cudgels, if you will.
- 21:16These meanings of these ideological labels are heavily muddied by campaigns because campaigns
- 21:22are trying to win elections, trying not to dunk too much on campaigns here.
- 21:26They're not really so much about educating.
- 21:29They they want they want to tell you about their candidate, of course, but how much of it
- 21:35is truth?
- 21:36How much of his obfuscation?
- 21:38That's well, that's that's kind of out of the purview of this discussion, but it's not really
- 21:42so much about educating people.
- 21:44It's about trying to win elections.
- 21:47So they have a vested interest in painting ideologies in certain ways that they think will
- 21:52maximize their vote totals.
- 21:54So if we go back to some of the things we used earlier with how people variously define
- 21:59conservative and liberal.
- 22:02A conservative campaign who's trying to get you to vote for a conservative, probably gonna say
- 22:10try to suggest to you that it's limited government, that it's efficient, that it's
- 22:14free.
- 22:15A liberal campaign that's campaigning for a liberal, they're gonna tell you that the
- 22:20government is fixing problems, that it's about equitability and open mindedness.
- 22:26Now whether any of those things are true, that's that's up for you to decide.
- 22:31But in any case, conservatives are gonna try to be positive about conservative campaigns and
- 22:39negative about liberal campaigns, and liberals are gonna try to be positive about liberal
- 22:42campaigns and negative about conservative campaigns.
- 22:44And under that whole sphere of positivity and negativity is trying to paint these ideologies
- 22:51in certain ways that will hopefully make you vote for them.
- 22:58And they may also define these ideologies in different ways to different voters they are
- 23:05trying to appeal to.
- 23:07So if a conservative or a liberal is trying to not only appeal to their normal conservative or
- 23:13liberal base, but they're trying to appeal to more moderate people, the ideological appeals
- 23:19probably aren't gonna be as strong.
- 23:22They're probably gonna focus more on they might take those ideological appeals and make them
- 23:29sound more moderate.
- 23:31So if they so they're not gonna say, say, this person's a conservative champion or this
- 23:37person's a liberal warrior.
- 23:38They're probably gonna say they want a government that works, that doesn't get
- 23:43involved in what it's not supposed to get into or that it's fixing problems that needs to be
- 23:49fixed, something like that.
- 23:52They may go hard on the conservative and liberal appeals to one group, but they may not
- 23:57use those appeals at all for another group.
- 23:59It's all about tweaking things to maximize your vote totals as much as you possibly can.
- 24:07And so these ideological labels are often used as scare tactics to rally voters against
- 24:14somebody.
- 24:15Yes, obviously, they want to get people to vote for them.
- 24:19But a lot of times, it's just trying to get people to vote against somebody.
- 24:23And so along with conservative and liberal, you usually see words like radical and extreme used
- 24:32all the time.
- 24:33Whether it's true or not.
- 24:34Nobody thinks they're extreme.
- 24:36There's not there.
- 24:37There's probably a few people that do but you almost never find anybody that says, Oh, yeah,
- 24:42I'm extreme.
- 24:43It's always the other person who is.
- 24:45And maybe they're right.
- 24:47Maybe that other person is extreme, but you can't necessarily just trust their opinion on
- 24:52that.
- 24:52They're trying to win an election.
- 24:54So, of course, they're gonna say the other person is way out there as a complete loony.
- 24:59And then you also hear, and this is one of my pet peeves, you often hear words like fascist,
- 25:09socialist, communist.
- 25:12These are highly favored names for people, and usually, democrats and liberals like to paint
- 25:17opposition as fascists, and Republicans and conservatives like to paint opposition as
- 25:23socialist or communist.
- 25:25In our case, you don't really hear as much, I don't think, but you sometimes hear hear that
- 25:29used by one side or the other.
- 25:32Now maybe once in a while that is true.
- 25:35Maybe there is a fascist policy or socialist or communist policy, but usually taking one
- 25:42specific policy idea and just saying, see, this person's a fascist or a socialist.
- 25:50Like, okay, that's that's one policy.
- 25:53You look at their other policies.
- 25:55Maybe they don't really think like that.
- 25:58Now maybe some people are closet fascist or socialist, but a lot of times these are words
- 26:03that are just used just to try to win elections, and they really just start to lose
- 26:08their meaning.
- 26:09We should be reserving fascists and socialist economists for people who are unequivocally
- 26:15fascist socialist communist, but I digress on that point.
- 26:19And another thing that you often hear is you usually hear leftist and right winger, which
- 26:27inherently have negative connotations.
- 26:29I don't think I've ever heard somebody willingly call themselves a leftist or
- 26:35willingly call themselves a right winger.
- 26:37There's probably somebody who has, but typically, when you hear those, those are being
- 26:42used derisively.
- 26:43So, again, goes back to the that's another way to say radical or extreme or fascist slash
- 26:53socialist.
- 26:55So you might want to take whatever that person says with a grain of salt if they use those
- 27:02kinds of ideological appeals.
- 27:04But though, maybe in some cases, they are right.
- 27:07Maybe that person is way to the left or way to the right.
- 27:10But you have to be careful accepting what they tell you.
- 27:16And then this also gets to now not just what one side is saying about another side, but what
- 27:24one side is saying about their own side.
- 27:26And this comes to the no true Scotsman fallacy.
- 27:30Basically, when somebody gatekeeps and says, oh, this person is not really part of our
- 27:35group.
- 27:36So the more hardcore conservative or liberal that someone is, the more likely they'll see
- 27:43some of their fellow conservatives or liberals as not conservative enough or not liberal
- 27:49enough.
- 27:51That's why you hear the term rhinos and dinos.
- 27:54Rhinos meaning republican in name only and dino meaning democrat in name only.
- 28:00You especially hear rhino a lot because conservatives, the Republican Party tends to be
- 28:05a little bit more uniformly ideological than democrats are, but they're still both very
- 28:11ideological.
- 28:12And, again, it goes back to the whole party is not ideology.
- 28:17Just saying that republican is inherently conservative and democrat is inherently
- 28:22liberal.
- 28:23That's not necessarily people from one party complaining about another party.
- 28:28Sometimes people within a party complain that their party is not ideological enough.
- 28:34Some Republicans think they need to be that the party needs to be more conservative.
- 28:39Some Democrats think their party needs to be more liberal.
- 28:43So when you hear rhino and dino, these are derisive terms to say someone's not a true
- 28:48Republican because they're not conservative enough or that somebody's not a true Democrat
- 28:53because they're not liberal enough.
- 28:55And it's somebody who's more out there who decides that this person is not a true member
- 29:04of the party.
- 29:05So, again, another case of conflating party with ideology, albeit in this case, it's
- 29:12intentional.
- 29:13Some people do it because they think it's the same exact thing when it's not.
- 29:18Again, yes, a lot of overlap, but it doesn't necessarily get into how conservative or how
- 29:24liberal somebody is.
- 29:27And then you these these this whole new true Scotsman fallacy saying somebody's not
- 29:32conservative or liberal enough.
- 29:34It's also meant to keep would be detractors within the party in line.
- 29:41It's these days, it's hard for overtly anti Trump Republicans to compete today in
- 29:49elections.
- 29:50When Obama was in office, for example, it was hard for overtly anti Obama Democrats to
- 29:55compete.
- 29:56When one party has the presidency, that party tends to fall in line there, and you hear a lot
- 30:05fewer people step out of line because if they do, they're probably gonna get primary.
- 30:12But here's the thing.
- 30:14A lot of overly ideological people don't necessarily think they're being overly
- 30:20ideological.
- 30:21I know that might sound weird, but they just think they're being practical.
- 30:25They think they figure things out that everything should be filtered through that
- 30:29ideological lens and that everything can be explained by conservatism or liberalism or
- 30:36whatever ideological label somebody has.
- 30:40And all of these reasons make for why ideological appeals are so effective.
- 30:48We are responsive to simple appeals that activate our emotions.
- 30:53No matter how complex we think we are, no matter how practical we think we are, no matter
- 30:59how much we think we know or think critically about politics.
- 31:06All of us can be taken can be given to these very simple appeals that activate our emotions.
- 31:14Now might not necessarily be ideology, but even those of us who don't consider ourselves very
- 31:21ideological, those emotional appeals, those ideological appeals still can have some effect,
- 31:27some influence on how we view a candidate or a current official.
- 31:35And despite the fact that the general voting public is much less ideological than elites,
- 31:41voters that care more about ideology tend to vote at much higher rates, especially in the
- 31:46primaries.
- 31:47So they tend to have a more vested interest in who wins, and they see elections oftentimes as
- 31:54an existential crisis.
- 31:55So they have an outsized influence on politics because they tend to participate more.
- 32:02Now I talked a lot about conservatives and liberals, but you might remember from the very
- 32:11beginning, I talked about another word, moderates.
- 32:17So conservative is a more traditional role for governments.
- 32:22Liberal is a former more nontraditional role of government.
- 32:26So where does that leave moderates?
- 32:29That's a tricky question for multiple reasons.
- 32:32Again, people have different reasons for calling themselves moderates.
- 32:36Maybe they really are actually more conservative or liberal, but they don't want
- 32:40people to think that they're crazy one side or the other as an that's another problem too.
- 32:48It's just inherently assuming that one side or the other is crazy.
- 32:52So they may just call themselves moderate to have a better appeal.
- 32:56It's like how some people call themselves independents, but some of them are more
- 33:01Republican or Democrat than they care to admit.
- 33:04And also moderate can be used derisively just like liberal or conservative.
- 33:08And to some people, being a moderate is even worse, and they won't respect you because they
- 33:13think, oh, you're just hedging your bets.
- 33:16You're not reacting.
- 33:19You don't want to pick a side.
- 33:21You're being a coward, whatever.
- 33:24So sometimes being a moderate has the connotation of being apathetic, of being not
- 33:31passionate about anything.
- 33:33You're just kind of, yeah, whichever way the wind blows, I guess.
- 33:37I don't care.
- 33:38Now moderates do tend to be less involved in politics, but it doesn't necessarily mean they
- 33:43don't care.
- 33:44Some of them don't care.
- 33:45They don't think at all about ideologies and you say conservative or liberal.
- 33:50They just like, whatever.
- 33:53Some of them might care, but they just don't know enough about either side, and they don't
- 34:01want to align themselves that way or at least say that they align themselves that way.
- 34:08So moderate can also be if we are not careful with it, we can use that as a misnomer too.
- 34:18Somebody might say that they're moderately conservative or moderately liberal instead of
- 34:23just straight up moderate.
- 34:25So how do we measure that?
- 34:28Or they might say they're somewhat liberal or somewhat conservative.
- 34:32So saying somebody is moderate can also be problematic if we don't make it clear what
- 34:41makes them moderate.
- 34:43What are they moderate on?
- 34:44Are they moderate on the vast majority of or all the issues?
- 34:49That doesn't necessarily happen a whole lot where they're just moderate across the board.
- 34:53They might be moderate on few things, but you might they might instead be very conservative
- 35:00on a bunch of things, and then very liberal on a bunch of other things.
- 35:03And technically, that will even out to being moderate, if you measure it that way.
- 35:08So technically, a liberal, or excuse me, a libertarian can be considered moderate in this
- 35:13way, because economically, they're conservative and socially, they're liberal.
- 35:19But they often feel very strongly about their libertarian beliefs.
- 35:24So is that really moderate, or are they moderate in their general approach to politics
- 35:30where they have their beliefs and they might feel very firm in their beliefs, but they're
- 35:37also very open to other opinions.
- 35:39Is that moderate?
- 35:42Are they just not concerned with or don't even think about ideological beliefs?
- 35:46Like I said earlier, the public tends to think about and care about ideology much less than
- 35:54elites do.
- 35:57And do they lean slightly conservative or liberal, but not heavily so?
- 36:03Like I said a moment ago, usually liberal moderate conservative is the simple way to
- 36:11describe.
- 36:13The ideologies in public opinion polling, but.
- 36:18What if somebody wants to say that they're moderately liberal or moderately conservative
- 36:21instead of saying moderate period?
- 36:26Then that starts to get a little bit more complicated.
- 36:28How do you measure that exactly?
- 36:30How deep into the weeds do you wanna get and how detailed do you want to be about people's
- 36:37ideologies?
- 36:39So all that is to say ideology is very complicated if you really want to actually dive
- 36:48into it beyond just the the rhetoric.
- 36:52So how should you view ideological labels?
- 36:57Now, admittedly, this is a little bit more opinionated.
- 37:00I wanna preface it by saying that.
- 37:03But I think these are very useful ways to think about ideological labels so that you don't just
- 37:11fall into campaign traps because these can be useful references.
- 37:16When somebody says they're conservative or liberal, it can give you a sense of what they
- 37:20believe, especially when ideologies are becoming more uniform or groups are becoming
- 37:27more uniform in their ideology.
- 37:30But you gotta be careful not to put too much stock into them, or you'll fall into these
- 37:34campaign traps of biased views on these ideologies.
- 37:40Remember that in a lot of cases, in most cases, I'd even say, the use of conservative and
- 37:49liberal is mostly full for ulterior purposes, not actually informing you about that
- 37:56candidate.
- 37:58People are trying to win elections.
- 38:00They're trying to rally supports or opposition to legislative bills.
- 38:06They're trying to staff off primary challengers who would claim that the incumbent is not
- 38:11conservative or not liberal enough.
- 38:14If someone is giving you a clear positive or negative connotation about what a conservative
- 38:21or liberal is, take that appeal with a grain of salt because there's, they're probably telling
- 38:29you that for a reason.
- 38:31Again, does not necessarily mean that they're wrong, but because there's always, or at least
- 38:39most times, a reason they're telling you that a conservative is good or bad or that a liberal
- 38:44is good or bad.
- 38:47You need to be careful automatically accepting what that person says, especially if there's
- 38:54somebody that you agree with.
- 38:56Because when we agree with somebody, all of us, we tend to be less critical of whatever they
- 39:05say.
- 39:06But when people are trying to win elections or win political battles over bills or try to
- 39:13prevent primary challengers, it's going to affect how they try to appeal to you based on
- 39:21these ideological labels.
- 39:24So ideology is much more complex than a lot of people make it out to be, especially by those
- 39:30who are strongly conservative or liberal, because they have a vested interest in
- 39:34appealing to your emotions in a certain way.
- 39:36And making things sound simpler than they are when you make things when you talk about how
- 39:42complex things are.
- 39:45We all tend to tune out if it's not something we're already interested in.
- 39:50And even if we are interested in it already, sometimes we just want things broken down to us
- 39:55in more simple terms.
- 39:58When you're trying to win elections, usually, nuance does not win you political battles.
- 40:03It's trying to make things as straightforward, clear cut.
- 40:11This person sucks.
- 40:12Our person's good.
- 40:14Just vote for us or otherwise death and misery will follow.
- 40:20So it doesn't really behoove people to say, well, let's talk about what being a
- 40:25conservative is or what being a liberal actually is.
- 40:29It's even if you boil it down to just economic versus social, unless you're a libertarian,
- 40:36libertarians will make note that they're economically conservative and socially liberal.
- 40:41But even then, sometimes they lean more into the conservative side or the liberal side of
- 40:47their views or on specific issues.
- 40:50Usually, people will say, you gotta be conservative on everything here or you gotta be
- 40:55liberal on everything here.
- 40:57And you can't step out of line at all.
- 40:59You can't say, well, I'm conservative on this thing, but I'm liberal also on this thing.
- 41:04Usually doesn't work with people.
- 41:06They're gonna call you sellout coward, a spineless, whatever, that you're you're not
- 41:15standing up for the American people, all that good stuff.
- 41:20So I also wanna make clear that it is okay to have an ideology.
- 41:26I know I've been sounding like I've been lambasting ideologies here or not.
- 41:32It's more of the need for ideological purity that I'm trying to lambaste here.
- 41:38It's fine to have an ideology, And to some extent, you're going to have a little bit of
- 41:43one.
- 41:45It's fine to have some sort of guiding principles.
- 41:49And by a bias is inevitable for all of us.
- 41:53We have to be cognizant of those biases, but they're going to happen in some way.
- 42:00And a lot of times that will be ideological, but it should not get to the point where it is
- 42:06your main identity, where it is your filter for everything.
- 42:10Because too often our worldviews filter everything through that ideological lens.
- 42:15I'm a conservative, so everything that's right is conservative.
- 42:18I'm a liberal, so everything that's right is liberal.
- 42:22Doesn't work like that.
- 42:24Maybe some things that are conservative are right.
- 42:26Maybe some things that are liberal are right.
- 42:28Maybe some things that are moderate are right.
- 42:30But we can't just assume that because they're conservative, because they're liberal, because
- 42:36they're moderate, because moderate is not inherently right either.
- 42:39We can't assume any ideology is inherently right because every ideology has flaws because
- 42:46we're all human beings.
- 42:48And ideology is inherently inhum is inherently human.
- 42:53So we can't just constantly rely on our ideology.
- 42:59We don't really learn as much as we can if we just filter everything through that ideological
- 43:07lens.
- 43:09We don't solve our problems long term if we don't step outside of that ideological lens.
- 43:19So just be careful with how you see ideological appeals, how you hear ideological appeals.
- 43:27Always think about who's the person that is giving this ideological appeal.
- 43:33What do I think?
- 43:35What are the people that are being targeted think?
- 43:38What do people who don't support that ideological appeal think?
- 43:45Try to be a bit more cognizant of all those things.
- 43:48Don't just automatically respond to something because it's conservative or liberal or
- 43:53moderate.
- 43:55But that is gonna do it for today's episode of politics with Paul.
- 43:59As always, thank you so much for listening and or watching.
- 44:04My links in the show notes, my Facebook, LinkedIn, my educational email course, five
- 44:10days on how we can better depolarize American politics because sometimes we do things that
- 44:17accidentally inflame polarization.
- 44:20Why we make those mistakes and how we can fix those mistakes.
- 44:24My book, why independents rarely win elections and how they become more competitive.
- 44:30It's not trying to argue for for independence or against them, just saying the the roadblocks
- 44:35they face.
- 44:37My medium.com profile, my website, paulraider.org, and matchmaker FM profile if
- 44:44you wanna be a guest on this podcast or you want me to be a guest on your podcast or my
- 44:49email, Paul Raider writes at Gmail dot com.
- 44:54But that is gonna do it for today's episode.
- 44:56So, again, thank you so much for listening.
- 44:59Until next time.
- 45:01Take care.