Latest / Her Chapter: Women, identity, culture & modern life / The Quiet Storm: Navigating Menopause Without a Map | Her Chapter
Transcript
- I got the promotion three days after she was diagnosed with early-stage cancer, and for a month, every time my phone buzzed, I flinched. It wasn’t just guilt; it was a profound, confusing sense of betrayal that I couldn’t explain to anyone. We tell ourselves that friendship is this beautiful, open-ended thing. That we show up for each other in joy and sorrow alike. But let’s sit with that for a second. Because sometimes, there is an unspoken contract written in the fine print of our shared history. And when one person starts thriving while the other is drowning, that contract feels less like a bond and more like a test you didn’t study for. I remember sitting on my floor that week, staring at the text message from her doctor. The screen was bright, almost blinding in the dim light of my apartment. I had just signed the new employment contract. The salary number was real. The health insurance was real. The future I had spent five years carving out with sheer willpower was suddenly, terrifyingly tangible. And she was reading a biopsy report. It’s complicated, isn’t it? To feel happy about your own life when someone you love is losing theirs. Society doesn’t give us a script for this. We’re told to be supportive, to listen, to bring casseroles. But nobody tells you how to handle the sharp, jagged edge of your own relief. The relief that your life is still turning, even if theirs has stopped. Here’s what I’m noticing... we perform our empathy so well that we often forget who we are performing for. At first, it was me. I wanted to look like the perfect friend. The steadfast rock. So I muted my work Slack channel. I stopped posting about my weekend plans. I made sure my responses to her texts were immediate, long, and deeply concerned. But inside, something else was happening. A quiet, shameful celebration. When she said, 'You deserve this,' I meant it. But part of me also thought, 'See? I did it. I made it out.' This is the part we don’t talk about in women’s circles. The idea that our successes are tied to our suffering. If my best friend is struggling, maybe I don’t have the right to take up space. Maybe my joy is too loud. So I shrunk myself. I spoke in whispers. I treated my own milestones like intrusions in her timeline. I started canceling coffee dates because I felt like my energy was 'polluting' hers. I began to believe that my growth was somehow an act of aggression against her stagnation. It’s a ridiculous notion, logically speaking. Her illness had nothing to do with my career. But emotionally? Emotionally, it felt like the universe was keeping score, and I was winning the wrong game. There’s another layer here, one that’s harder to admit. When someone close to us falls behind, or falls apart, it holds up a mirror to our own fragility. Seeing her struggle reminded me of how easily things can unravel. How thin the line is between stability and chaos. I used to think I was invincible. I built my identity around competence, around being the one who had it together. But watching her face the unknown shook that foundation. If she could get sick, despite all her healthy choices, then what was the point of my hustle? What was the point of my discipline? This realization brought a different kind of guilt. Not the guilt of being happy, but the guilt of having been arrogant. I looked back at my twenties, chasing promotions and accolades, thinking they were shields against bad luck. Now, those titles felt hollow. They couldn’t protect her. They couldn’t even protect me, really. They just delayed the inevitable conversation with mortality. So I found myself resenting my own success, not because I hated it, but because it felt irrelevant. In the face of her reality, my achievements seemed like trivial games. I wanted to tear them down. I wanted to say, 'None of this matters. None of it mattered.' And that resentment was toxic. It poisoned the well between us. I stopped celebrating her small victories because they highlighted my large ones. I became bitter, not because I wished her harm, but because I couldn’t reconcile two truths: that I was lucky, and that she was suffering. We grow up believing in a kind of shared fate among our inner circle. That we rise and fall together. That our stories are woven into a single tapestry. But modern womanhood teaches us, often cruelly, that we are on individual tracks. One of us gets the corner office. One of us gets the diagnosis. One of us finds love; one of us finds loneliness. Accepting this separation is painful. It requires us to hold two conflicting emotions at once: deep sorrow for their pain, and genuine pride for their survival. Or in my case, deep sorrow for her illness, and genuine excitement for my opportunity. For weeks, I carried these emotions like stones in my pockets. Heavy. Cold. I thought that by suppressing my joy, I was honoring her pain. I thought silence was solidarity. But it wasn’t. It was isolation. It created a wall where there should have been a bridge. I realized that by hiding my light, I wasn’t making room for her darkness. I was just making everything darker. Friendship isn’t about equalizing the load. It’s about witnessing each other’s lives, however uneven they may be. It’s about saying, 'I am here, and I am glad I am here, even though I know you are hurting.' The turning point came on a Tuesday. I was on a Zoom call with my team, laughing at a joke a colleague made. I caught my reflection in the black screen of my laptop. I looked tired. I looked guilty. I looked like I was apologizing for existing. That night, I called her. Not to check in on her symptoms. Not to offer advice. Just to hear her voice. And when she answered, I didn’t put on the mask of the stoic supporter. I told her I was scared. I told her I was confused. I told her that I was proud of her strength, but I was also overwhelmed by my own momentum. She laughed. A real, clear laugh. She said, 'Karina, you don’t have to mourn your life to honor mine.' Those words broke something open inside me. It was permission. Permission to be human. Permission to be messy. Permission to hold both truths without judgment. From that day on, I stopped trying to balance the scales. I started showing up differently. I celebrated her good blood test results with the same enthusiasm as my new job announcement. I let her see me cry over my project deadlines, and I let her see me dance in the kitchen when the sun hit just right. We stopped competing for victimhood and started sharing presence. Now, months later, the dynamic has shifted again. She is in remission. I am deeper into my role. The crisis has passed, but the lesson remains. Life is asymmetrical. Our seasons do not align. Sometimes you are the giver; sometimes you are the receiver. Sometimes you are thriving; sometimes you are surviving. And that’s okay. It’s not fair. It’s not equitable. But it is true. The goal isn’t to synchronize our lives. The goal is to remain connected across the distance of our differences. If you are listening to this and feeling that familiar tug of guilt, I want you to know you are not alone. You are not a bad person for feeling joy. You are not selfish for needing support. You are just a woman, navigating the beautiful, brutal complexity of being alive alongside others. Let yourself feel it all. The love. The envy. The fear. The hope. Don’t curate your emotions for the sake of comfort. Let them be raw. Let them be real. Because in that authenticity, you’ll find the connection you’ve been missing. Not the perfect, polished version of friendship, but the real, gritty, enduring kind. Thank you for letting me into your day. I’m Karina Keoghan, and this has been Her Chapter. Until next time, be gentle with yourself.