Latest / Politics with Paul / Are We Truly Rational When We Vote? | Politics with Paul #112
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:08Today, we're going to answer the question, are we really rational when we vote?
- 0:15We all like to imagine ourselves as wholly reasoning individuals when we cast our vote and
- 0:21that we've come to a decision by logically evaluating all the candidates running and their
- 0:26platforms When we're being socialized growing up and being taught about our political system,
- 0:32the picture is often painted that we all come together and reasonably hash out who we think
- 0:39are the best candidates like we're just sitting at a table talking about things also
- 0:43reasonably.
- 0:44But just how truly rational are we when we vote?
- 0:48There have been tons of academic and less scientific inquiries into the subject.
- 0:55And as is often the case in politics, the full picture is complicated.
- 1:01It's not a simple matter of are we rational or not, but rather how rational we are and when
- 1:09are we rational.
- 1:11And who tends to be more rational?
- 1:13No matter what point it is in an election cycle, it's important to reevaluate not only
- 1:18what our vote choices are, but how we are arriving to those conclusions.
- 1:24So let's dive into what it means to be a rational voter and just how much rationality or
- 1:30lack thereof influences our decisions.
- 1:32And you may even be surprised at some of the factors that make an impact.
- 1:37And first, it makes sense to talk about what rational voting even is in the first place.
- 1:42And I've talked about it before on this podcast.
- 1:44It's always important to have a clear definition when you are in political science or
- 1:48when you're just discussing things in general.
- 1:50You wanna have everybody be on the same page in discussions, and when you're doing empirical
- 1:54studies, it makes things more cohesive and consistent so other people could study it as
- 1:58well and say, okay, that makes sense.
- 2:00Let me build on that, or say, well, actually, I don't think this definition makes quite total
- 2:05sense.
- 2:05Let me change things up.
- 2:07The dictionary definition of rational is simply that your thinking is governed by reason and
- 2:13logic, not emotion and impulse.
- 2:17And in the context of politics, it's one of those words that both is and isn't obvious to
- 2:23define.
- 2:24Because in voting theory and analysis, political scientists more or less mean that
- 2:28rational means you're using reasoning and logic to make the vote choice that most aligns with
- 2:34your preferences.
- 2:34You take the things that you're looking for in a candidate and you quote unquote correctly
- 2:40apply it to the candidate that most resembles your preferences.
- 2:44Preferences.
- 2:44And a voter would probably agree with that decision, but their biases may make them think
- 2:48other people's choices are not logical.
- 2:50A lot of times, even if we don't consciously think it, we subconsciously think, I'm a I'm a
- 2:56logical person.
- 2:56These other people that think differently than me, they don't think logically.
- 3:01Republicans often think Democrats aren't logical.
- 3:03Democrats think Republicans often aren't logical.
- 3:06People in both parties think independents aren't logical, and independents will say
- 3:09Democrats and Republicans aren't logical.
- 3:12Really, nobody thinks that they're an irrational person when they vote.
- 3:15They might not necessarily be confident in their vote, but they don't necessarily think
- 3:19that they're irrational.
- 3:21And they might also think that if they're thinking other people are irrational, they
- 3:27might think that they are doing their beliefs or morals a disservice if they see other
- 3:31people's opinions as anything even approaching rational and reasoned because people tend to
- 3:37think their side is the rational and fact based one, and the other side is emotional and
- 3:42opinionated, if not outright lying.
- 3:45But assessing whether we are truly rational is quite complicated.
- 3:49And while we may use rational mechanisms to come to a vote choice, the logic and the
- 3:55reasoning we can actually use to get there might be faulty.
- 3:58We might not actually applying those things the way that they should be.
- 4:03And by that, I'm talking about heuristics.
- 4:07Heuristics are mental shortcuts that we use to help make all sorts of decisions.
- 4:13We see we think about what food we're gonna get.
- 4:16We have a heuristic that says Chinese, Mexican, American, Thai, Japanese, French food, Italian,
- 4:27any sort of food that you want is just an example.
- 4:30But in the context of voting, everybody uses heuristics, these mental shortcuts to help them
- 4:37assess how they will vote.
- 4:38And they use it no matter when they make their choice or how much they think about their
- 4:43choice.
- 4:44No matter what actually drives them to make that choice, we all use heuristics.
- 4:51Because when we're researching candidates and casting our ballots, we can only keep so much
- 4:56info in our heads at one time.
- 4:58So we use heuristics to make voting and figuring out who to vote for less mentally
- 5:04taxing.
- 5:05We're trying to go easier on our brains, which isn't inherently a bad thing.
- 5:09We should be able to challenge our brains a little bit, but there's only so much that any
- 5:13of our brains can take.
- 5:14And our short term memory is what we are most often using in our choice, which typically
- 5:19holds about seven plus or minus two things in our heads at one time.
- 5:24So five to nine things typically are gonna be held in our short term memory, and that's what
- 5:29we're accessing when we're at the ballot box.
- 5:31And there's all sorts of heuristics that you can point to.
- 5:34There's some of just the most common ones, though, are the party label.
- 5:39Are they Republican?
- 5:39Are they Democrat?
- 5:40Are they independent?
- 5:41Are they a third party?
- 5:43Are they no party at all?
- 5:45Ideological label, are they conservative?
- 5:47Are they liberal?
- 5:48Are they moderate?
- 5:49Are they capitalist, socialist, communist, fascist?
- 5:52Whether we're actually applying those labels correctly or not is a different discussion.
- 5:57Gender, are they male, female, or if you are somebody who obviously, is a very touchy
- 6:04subject, but if you adhere to nonbinary, that might be a heuristic that you use.
- 6:11Race, their physical attractiveness, their organizational affiliations, their
- 6:16endorsements, their issue platforms, their occupation, all sorts of other demographic
- 6:21characteristics, like their education.
- 6:25And pro and anti ads for any candidate, they work to instill heuristics in your head, just
- 6:31these simple mental shortcuts so you think, oh, this candidate is great.
- 6:34Oh, this candidate sucks.
- 6:36They're doing that to make your choice simpler.
- 6:39And by that, I mean, they're trying to influence you to vote a certain way.
- 6:42And heuristics are usually rational in the sense that you are trying to use these mental
- 6:48mental shortcuts to help you reason and use logic to come to a decision.
- 6:53But you have to use these heuristics correctly.
- 6:55That is to say, you vote for the candidate that most closely reflects you and your beliefs.
- 7:01And we don't always do that.
- 7:02We may think, oh, this candidate supports this side of an issue, and we really think that, but
- 7:08we actually made an incorrect assumption.
- 7:12Or that candidate put out an ad that says, oh, that they're they actually support that thing,
- 7:16and they really don't.
- 7:18But regardless of what heuristics you use, when we try to more empirically analyze voting
- 7:27behavior.
- 7:29In political science, we have a bunch of different kinds of voting behavior models and
- 7:33theories that are used to explain why people vote the way they do.
- 7:37Now note this is not the same thing as the quote unquote funnel of causality.
- 7:42That's something we've talked about before on this podcast.
- 7:45That's basically all of the factors going on in your life and in the election that affect who
- 7:52you vote for.
- 7:53That's not what I'm trying to that's not the thing I'm talking about.
- 7:56That's just simply taking all the factors that affect your vote choice, not necessarily what
- 8:00you are consciously evaluating, though it might also include that.
- 8:06And each model of voting behavior might use some of these factors in the funnel of
- 8:11causality, though they don't necessarily always do that.
- 8:15And none of these models are infallible or apply to everyone nor are they necessarily
- 8:21meant to.
- 8:21And these theories don't have to be mutually exclusive either.
- 8:25So the four common models of voting behavior that we'll look at here along with how rational
- 8:32decision making may come into play as well as some of strengths and weaknesses of each.
- 8:38We'll talk about rational choice model, party line model, retrospective voting, and
- 8:44prospective voting.
- 8:45And the strengths of these are in terms of how it makes sense to describe how we vote and
- 8:51where the rationality comes in and shortcomings being what it doesn't explain and where
- 8:57rationality falls short.
- 9:00And so easy way to remember that is these four is that two of them start with an r and two of
- 9:05them start with a p.
- 9:06So first of all, rational choice voting, rational choice theory.
- 9:11Obviously, it has rational in the name, so it has something to do with rationality.
- 9:15It's not the only one that deals with it though.
- 9:16It's just the most obvious one of using those heuristics.
- 9:21And voters in this model, voters take the issue stances that candidates espouse and evaluate
- 9:28what most closely aligns with their own views, and that's where that supposed logic and
- 9:32reasoning comes in.
- 9:33So it most obviously deals with those heuristics compared to the other models of
- 9:37voting choice and can deal with a lot of the ones that we talk about.
- 9:40So the strengths in terms of how it deals with rationality is rational is in the name, and
- 9:45arguably, most voters engage with this in this model to some extent because we all attempt to
- 9:50be rational whether we are being rational or not.
- 9:53But a lot of people try to research these candidates and evaluate all their models.
- 9:58Not everybody is paying attention to politics with every waking moment and every breath they
- 10:06take.
- 10:07A lot of people have other things going on in their lives.
- 10:10So sometimes they have to research, and they're gonna be trying to use all these heuristics,
- 10:15and so they're trying to engage in rational voting.
- 10:18However, emotions and irrational thinking affect a lot of votes, and all of us are
- 10:24affected by it to some extent, some people more than others.
- 10:27And this model also assumes that heuristics are being used, quote, unquote, correctly.
- 10:32Correctly.
- 10:32That is to say, used to vote for the candidate that most reflects them.
- 10:36Again, not everybody uses them correctly.
- 10:39Some people might think a candidate is pro data centers and establishing data centers when they
- 10:45actually aren't.
- 10:46And then candidates themselves can also make it difficult to tell what heuristics correct
- 10:51because they have an unpopular position, and the voter isn't aware of that.
- 10:56So being pro data center right now is a very, very unpopular position amongst people across
- 11:03the political spectrum.
- 11:04It's not simply conservative or liberal or moderate.
- 11:07Lots of people, both Republicans and Democrats, as well as independents are not fans of data
- 11:13centers.
- 11:14And so a candidate may actually be pro data center, but they try to find ways to make you
- 11:19think that they're not pro data center, or they just evade that subject.
- 11:25And so that's part of the process that you have to use.
- 11:29Now are you are you starting to think rationally about, well, is this candidate
- 11:32really what they say they are?
- 11:34Are they trying to pull the wool over my eyes and so on?
- 11:39So that's the rational choice model.
- 11:40Now we have the party line model, and that's simply support for candidates based on their
- 11:45political party and your affiliation with them.
- 11:48If they're Republican, you and you're a Republican, you vote for them.
- 11:52If they're Democrat and you're Democrat, you vote for them.
- 11:54And it's seeing those people who engage in what we call straight ticket voting as opposed to
- 12:00the split ticket.
- 12:00Straight ticket voting means you're just voting for everybody that's that party.
- 12:05And that heuristic that you most commonly use is obviously party label.
- 12:09And to some extent, use ideology as well, but not always because ideology is not the same
- 12:14thing as party.
- 12:16Conservatives tend to be Republicans.
- 12:18Liberals tend to be Democrats, but it doesn't always work like that, and there are degrees as
- 12:23to how conservative or liberal people are.
- 12:27And that's not to mention the fact that a lot of people don't think in ideological terms at
- 12:32all.
- 12:32They just simply think about the party.
- 12:34And so the strengths of this model is it's rational in the sense that a lot of people's
- 12:39logic is if they are this party, then yes, I'm voting for them.
- 12:42If they are that other party, then no, I'm not gonna vote for them.
- 12:45That's technically using logic and reasoning because you have attached yourself to that
- 12:50party so strongly that anybody who's outside that party, you're not voting for.
- 12:57And over time, more people have been voting straight ticket, and party identification is
- 13:03the most common indicator of somebody's voting choice.
- 13:06So this model explains how a lot of people vote.
- 13:10But it's also fairly simplistic.
- 13:14It's there's also the question of, is it really rational to just simply vote for one party no
- 13:23matter what they do even if they do something that objectively does not benefit you?
- 13:27Though it can be hard to say when that is being objective.
- 13:32But if you're just sticking with the party regardless of what they do, is that really that
- 13:37rational?
- 13:38It's rational in the sense that, oh, well, they are that party, so I'm going to vote for them.
- 13:42They are republicans, so I'm voting for them.
- 13:44They are democrats, so that I am voting for them.
- 13:46But if you're just sticking with that no matter what, is that really sound reasoning and logic?
- 13:52And also a lot of people's emotions or a lot of people's attachment to a party is based on
- 13:57emotions and moral values that aren't inherently rational.
- 14:02People get such a strong attachment to the party because of however it makes them feel and
- 14:11perhaps more so how it makes them feel when they see the label of the other party.
- 14:15And a lot of times, it's not a rational thought process that really drives them then.
- 14:23And there are still people who occasionally step outside of their party even when they
- 14:27often vote that way, Or there may just happen to be one or two candidates they vote for that
- 14:32are the opposite party for whatever reason.
- 14:34It might just be somebody that they know personally that happens to be in the opposite
- 14:37party, and they really like them.
- 14:40So they might have 16 people that they vote for that are republican, and then they vote for one
- 14:45democrat or vice versa.
- 14:47And independents also complicate things because they are not allied with the republican or
- 14:53democratic party at least in name.
- 14:54Now some independents are more Republican or Democrat than they want to admit, and they
- 14:59often vote one party or the other, but they still identify as an independent.
- 15:04So it still throws a little bit of a wrench in the party line model.
- 15:12And then the third model that we look at is retrospective voting, and that's simply
- 15:17evaluating whether a candidate or a party in power should be reelected based on the recent
- 15:23past, their track record.
- 15:25Is the economy doing good?
- 15:26That typically is the thing that people look at when it's retrospective.
- 15:30Is the economy good?
- 15:31Then I'm going to reward the party that's in power.
- 15:34And the and a lot of times, especially if the president is of that party.
- 15:40Is the economy doing poorly?
- 15:41Then I'm going to punish the president and his party.
- 15:44And the heuristics often include these economic views since retrospective voting is so often
- 15:50heavily based on pocketbook issues and recent events and that candidate's or party's response
- 15:57to those events, like if there's a natural disaster and tying that candidate or that party
- 16:02specifically to that event is a form of retrospective voting.
- 16:07Now whether that president or that party is truly responsible, that's beside the point.
- 16:12But strengths of this is that most people would say they look to the past.
- 16:16Even if people aren't really being as retrospective as they think they are, people
- 16:22still look at the record and see that as an indication of who they should vote for.
- 16:28And presidential approval rating is often a helpful indicator of how people are feeling
- 16:33about him or his party, especially if they are the party in power.
- 16:36And you especially see it in midterms because the midterms are so often harsh to the party in
- 16:45power.
- 16:46But even when it comes to retrospective voting, several people can look at the same exact
- 16:51factors for evaluation and come up with completely different interpretations.
- 16:55There's no real objective way to say this is the interpretation you should come up with.
- 17:00And there are a ton of elected officials who directly and indirectly represent us.
- 17:04So who do we attribute the responsibility to?
- 17:09Because the attribution of blame and credit is a lot more complicated than we give them credit
- 17:14for.
- 17:15Obviously, political ads try to make it sound as simple as possible.
- 17:19Say, oh, everything is good is because of us.
- 17:21Everything bad is because of these the other guys.
- 17:24What if we blame the president, but it's for something that the governor is responsible for
- 17:29or a state legislator or a mayor or maybe it's the other way around.
- 17:32We blame one of those more local or state level politicians when it's the president that should
- 17:37be blamed.
- 17:38Usually, it's the other way around.
- 17:39Usually, you blame the president for everything, whether they should be or not and
- 17:43regardless of who the president is.
- 17:46And what if it's something that is largely outside any politician's control?
- 17:50Maybe it's not actually any of their faults, but we put it on them anyways.
- 17:55And something that emotionally impacted you in the recent past can sway your vote even if it
- 17:59isn't necessarily tied to politics, which we'll talk about towards the end here.
- 18:04And our retrospective evaluation can still be influenced by biases like party and ideology.
- 18:09So if the party in power is somebody that we identify with, we are often going to be more
- 18:17inclined to think that they are doing a good job.
- 18:19And if there are somebody that is if the party in power is somebody that we don't typically
- 18:25align with, then we're probably gonna think that everything bad is because of them.
- 18:29Even if something good is happening, we're gonna say it's not because of them.
- 18:33It's because of our party.
- 18:37We're just trying to hold the line even though we're the minority in power.
- 18:41And who's right?
- 18:42Who's wrong?
- 18:43That's that's that's hard to say just from a general standpoint.
- 18:49And then lastly, you have prospective voting, and that's instead of retrospective, which
- 18:55looks towards the past.
- 18:56Prospective looks towards the future.
- 18:57It looks towards the prospects of an election's results.
- 19:02So you evaluate a candidate or party based on how you expect they will perform in the future.
- 19:07And heuristics often include the relevance of that candidate's credentials and issue views to
- 19:13their job or what are the biggest issues going on.
- 19:16So things like your occupational background or your demographic similarity.
- 19:22If the candidate is a racial minority or a member of a racial minority group and you are
- 19:27also a member of that racial minority group, a lot of times you will see them as a better
- 19:31advocate for your racial group than somebody who is not part of that group.
- 19:35Your level of education.
- 19:37If people think there's a lot of complicated things going on, maybe they're gonna be more
- 19:41inclined to vote for somebody that has a lot more academic credentials, especially if it's
- 19:47relevant to the most important issue going on.
- 19:51Like, if it's health care, people might be more inclined to vote for a doctor or a nurse.
- 19:58And another way might be if a current war is a big issue, then being a veteran might be seen
- 20:04as a more relevant trait.
- 20:05And hot, salient topics may influence people's appraisal of certain parts of a candidate's
- 20:11platform depending on current events.
- 20:12So people might appraise abortions abortion stances differently following the from a few
- 20:20years ago, the overturning of the Roe v Wade ruling back from the seventies through the
- 20:26Dobbs versus Jackson ruling.
- 20:28So now people might look at those abortion stances of candidates differently following
- 20:33that because now it's a much more salient topic.
- 20:35So the strengths of this model is that, well, everybody wants to vote for somebody who they
- 20:40assume is going to do a good job or the best job at office.
- 20:46I mean, what what what would be the point of voting for somebody that you don't think is
- 20:51gonna do a good job?
- 20:53Although, get to that in a moment.
- 20:55And you also have to at least attempt to be rational to reason who is going to have the
- 21:01highest performance in office for the next term.
- 21:03So you would expect that somebody's going to try to be at least somewhat rational.
- 21:09Shortcomings, though, are regardless of our political views and how we evaluate the
- 21:14prospects of a candidate, we elect crappy politicians all the time.
- 21:18Now we don't always agree on who those are, but everybody would agree that a lot of politicians
- 21:23just suck.
- 21:24And this again assumes that we are correctly applying reasoning and logic to who will
- 21:28perform the best.
- 21:29Politics is complicated.
- 21:30We and it's not necessarily our fault that we vote for somebody bad.
- 21:36Sometimes it's just really hard to tell who's going to be good and who's going to be bad, but
- 21:41sometimes, a lot of times, politicians and voters have to take some responsibility.
- 21:47And politicians also turn back on their word all the time whether you should have seen it
- 21:51coming or not.
- 21:52Now, it might not just because, oh, they're insincere or they're liars.
- 21:56Maybe they're the political realities of the job, they realize I have to in order to get
- 22:02certain things done, I might need to hold off on some of these promises I made, especially
- 22:08when you start getting into foreign policy.
- 22:11And our prospective outlook can still be influenced by biases like party or ideology.
- 22:17If we are a republican, we're probably gonna be more likely to think that our prospects are
- 22:21better with republicans.
- 22:22And if we're democrat, we're probably gonna be thinking that our prospects are better with
- 22:26democrats.
- 22:27And it's not actually because we truly think that they're going to be better.
- 22:30It's simply because of our biases.
- 22:33And there's also this engagement in strategic voting that we've talked about in the last
- 22:37episode that may lead us to vote for not who we think would perform the best, but who we can at
- 22:43least stomach that we think would perform okay enough or that we think would perform less
- 22:48awfully.
- 22:48It's that idea of voting for the lesser of two evils.
- 22:53And so each of these models, each of these four, the rational choice model, the
- 22:58prospective, the retrospective, and the party line model, they all have some level, at least
- 23:04ostensibly, rational thinking.
- 23:07We think that we're being logical or irrational depending on which of those methods we engage
- 23:13in, but the logic and the reasoning isn't always sound.
- 23:18And as humans, we are still often impacted by our emotions, our biases, and other irrational
- 23:24thought processes.
- 23:26Even the most sound minded among us are not immune to it.
- 23:32And it's not reasonable to think that any of us are above being emotionally manipulated, and it
- 23:38doesn't even have to come from a specific person or group either.
- 23:41It might just be just the way we normally react to things, and nobody's actually trying to
- 23:47twist a certain way.
- 23:48Sometimes we're just predisposed to to react in a certain way.
- 23:53Now it might have been because we were conditioned by that specific politician or
- 23:57group to react that way, but it doesn't necessarily have to be directly from them each
- 24:04time.
- 24:04But anybody who thinks that they can't be emotionally manipulated is fooling themselves.
- 24:08It's that's a lack of self awareness.
- 24:10I'd love to think that I can't be manipulated, but that is not true.
- 24:14I can be just like anybody else.
- 24:16And fear is arguably the most effective emotion at driving vote choice and influencing our
- 24:23voting choice.
- 24:26Many people vote out of fear of what, quote unquote, the other side will do rather than the
- 24:31good that they think their side will do.
- 24:33And the power of fear is even more pronounced in people with very strong opinions.
- 24:37That is to say, polarized people.
- 24:40If they are very strongly against abortion or for abortion, if they're very strongly pro gun
- 24:45control or anti gun control, or if they are very much pro Medicare for all or against
- 24:54Medicare for all.
- 24:57And negative campaigning makes considerable use of this emotion.
- 25:01It often preys on fear.
- 25:02It's like, oh, you know, if this person gets in office, everything's gonna go to hell.
- 25:06Everything is going to be bad, and we need to make sure that doesn't happen.
- 25:11Vote for our guy instead, our person instead.
- 25:15And fear can be obvious or subtle.
- 25:16That's an obvious way it can be done, but a subtle way that you see it is, for example, in
- 25:22incumbent retention rates.
- 25:24A lot of why we see high incumbent retention rates is because people are worried about the,
- 25:32quote unquote, the devil they don't know.
- 25:34And even if they don't necessarily like their incumbent, they might not feel strong enough
- 25:39that they're thinking, you know what?
- 25:41Screw this person.
- 25:42I'm going to vote for their challenger.
- 25:44Doesn't necessarily always work like that.
- 25:47And, of course, there are a lot of districts that are so heavily Republican or so heavily
- 25:53Democrat that they're not gonna vote the other way anyways no matter how much they may be
- 25:56dissatisfied with that candidate.
- 26:01And so that election will often be decided in the primary instead.
- 26:06Not not de facto, not factually as in, of course, they're still gonna have a general
- 26:12election, but whichever candidate comes out from the minority party, they're not gonna win
- 26:19because the majority party just has such a strong advantage.
- 26:25And fear is, of course, often irrational.
- 26:27That does not necessarily mean though that it's not justified.
- 26:31Sometimes we should be afraid of what a candidate would do.
- 26:35Now it's not necessarily an objective thing.
- 26:39Some people think that we should be afraid of Donald Trump, and some people think that we
- 26:43shouldn't be.
- 26:44And some people think that we should be afraid of whoever Democrats put up, and some people
- 26:48think that we shouldn't be.
- 26:51But it is very easy or relatively easy at least to prey on people's fears.
- 26:57It happens to all of us.
- 26:59Again, fear is not always unjustified, but it often is irrational.
- 27:06But, of course, there are a lot of other irrational and emotional ways that our vote
- 27:11choice is impacted, if not outright manipulated.
- 27:14Disgust is another powerful emotion.
- 27:17One study, for example, found that bad smells in a room made people temporarily more likely
- 27:22to shun certain minority groups.
- 27:25That sounds baffling.
- 27:26How do we get to that?
- 27:28Well, it's not it's not a rational thought process, but it does sometimes make just a
- 27:34little bit of a difference in how people vote or how people think about certain political
- 27:39views.
- 27:39And down the line, it might have a more long term impact.
- 27:42Our our personality traits are often correlated with how we vote too.
- 27:47And the most common personality trait measurement that we see is there's an acronym
- 27:53called OSHA.
- 27:54Standing for openness to experience, c standing for conscientiousness, e standing for
- 27:59extraversion, a agreeableness, and n neuroticism or like your predisposition to
- 28:06feeling anxiety and similar other emotions.
- 28:09And liberals who tend to vote democratic tend to rank higher on openness to experience
- 28:15because liberals want a nontraditional form and policy for government.
- 28:21They want something new.
- 28:23Whereas conservatives tend to rank higher on conscientiousness, and one of the traits of
- 28:28conscientiousness is an adherence to tradition.
- 28:31Conservatives tend to be more reverenced toward tradition and traditional policies for
- 28:38government.
- 28:39So you'll find that people who tend to rank higher on openness to experience, they tend to
- 28:46be more liberal, and so they tend to vote democratic more often.
- 28:50And then conservatives who tend to rank higher on conscientiousness, they tend to vote more
- 28:56Republican.
- 28:57Doesn't mean people that are conscientious won't vote Democrat, and people who are open to
- 29:01experience won't vote for Republican.
- 29:03It's just the typical thing that you see.
- 29:07And even that is a little bit overly simplified, but it is a very common thing that
- 29:13you see.
- 29:14Another irrational way our vote is impacted is there's a US study that showed that back in
- 29:212014 and showed that people who felt unwell during an election were more likely to favor
- 29:29attractive candidates over less physically appealing opponents because they saw the
- 29:35attractive candidate as something that made them feel better.
- 29:37When we see pretty people, we tend to feel better.
- 29:41Obviously, not every pretty person we like, but in general, we see people that are physically
- 29:47attractive tends to make us feel good.
- 29:50And so people who felt unwell, less likely to choose the person that they found physically
- 29:56unappealing or at least less physically appealing.
- 29:59Negativity bias.
- 30:00We are wired to put more emphasis on negative information and emotions.
- 30:04We not necessarily that we don't ever feel positive emotions, but we tend to remember the
- 30:08negative things much more often.
- 30:11And so you see a lot of what we call, quote, unquote, negative campaigning even though that
- 30:16term is kind of nebulous, But you do see a lot of campaigns that most people would
- 30:20characterize as being negative, and a lot of times they engage in fearmongering.
- 30:25And lastly, voters can punish politicians over bad things that happen to themselves that have
- 30:33nothing to do with politics.
- 30:34Absolutely zero.
- 30:36Bad weather, you were in a snowstorm, you were in a there was a hurricane going on.
- 30:44That can influence people's emotions, and they might vote against the incumbent, for example.
- 30:50Unfortunate results of games for favorite sports teams.
- 30:54There was a 2010 study that showed that wins for a local college football team led to a
- 31:00little bit more favor for the incumbent politicians as if the incumbent politicians
- 31:05were responsible for that team winning.
- 31:08And I gotta tell you, boy, if I were that influenced by unfortunate results of my
- 31:13favorite sports teams, I would be punishing a lot of people for the shortcomings of the teams
- 31:19that I root for.
- 31:21I can tell you that much.
- 31:22And so all of these factors can affect us in different ways based on which model of voting
- 31:27behavior we look at.
- 31:28So for example, if we're being retrospective, we might look at the bad weather.
- 31:36If there was a string of bad weather, even if we think we're being rational, we might still
- 31:41look at that and be like, wow.
- 31:43There's a lot of bad weather here.
- 31:45I'm not voting for the incumbent.
- 31:47It's it's not gonna be that simplistic, but it'll be like that subtle like, you think
- 31:51you're looking back at all the the record of the person that you're looking at right now and
- 31:59of the party in power, but something else actually influenced your retrospective views or
- 32:07your prospective views or your rational choice appraisals of all these other heuristics, or
- 32:14maybe you actually decided to step outside of your your typical party line model because
- 32:20things just have not been going well for you lately.
- 32:23All sorts of different ways that all these things to different degrees can impact your
- 32:29votes.
- 32:29There's no no real way to say this person is on a scale of one to ten, eight being and 10 being
- 32:38rational, one being irrational.
- 32:40They're an eight.
- 32:41Can't it's not really possible to do.
- 32:45So how rational are we?
- 32:47It's not about whether we are or aren't rational.
- 32:50It's about when we are and how much and who is more rational and irrational.
- 32:57Every single one of us is capable of being somewhat or highly irrational when we vote, and
- 33:04some people are more irrational than others and tend to be more irrational than others.
- 33:09And some people are more capable of using reason and logic than other people are.
- 33:14They have the mental tools to be able to do that much more effectively.
- 33:18And even simple things that shouldn't affect us and our vote choice sometimes do even when we
- 33:23don't realize it.
- 33:25But even when we are using reason and logic, we are not always doing so soundly.
- 33:30We don't always apply heuristics correctly.
- 33:33We not all of us have a rigid cohesive set of beliefs, which isn't necessarily a bad thing,
- 33:39and sometimes it's actually a good thing.
- 33:42Now you should have some level of core values.
- 33:46You shouldn't just be going with the wind, but you also need to be able to step outside of
- 33:52your typical worldview.
- 33:54It's always good to reevaluate how you view things.
- 33:59And we all have biases, which you could actually argue are semi rational, quote
- 34:04unquote.
- 34:05It's they're rational in the sense that our predispositions can be used to deduce which
- 34:09candidate makes most sense for us to vote for according to our beliefs.
- 34:13So if we are somebody who is pro abortion or pro gun control or pro data centers or pro
- 34:21Medicare for all or anti any of those things, we might use those predispositions to correctly
- 34:27deduce which candidate we would vote for or we should vote for based on our views.
- 34:34But it's irrational in the sense that those same biases are susceptible to emotional
- 34:38appeals and manipulation, and we don't often critically reevaluate those biases even if we
- 34:45notice them.
- 34:47And more than anything, this is really about being wary of how rational or irrational we can
- 34:54be rather than just simply calling for us all to be rational when we vote.
- 34:59That's that's a pipe dream.
- 35:01It's not reasonable to expect anybody to be 100% rational all the time when they vote
- 35:07because none of us are that way.
- 35:09We're all humans.
- 35:11Now we should try to be as rational as much as we can be, but our emotions and our feelings
- 35:17are still important.
- 35:18We're not robots.
- 35:19We are human beings.
- 35:21Our emotions tell us a lot about who we are, and there are some things we see and hear from
- 35:25politicians and groups that should make us feel some sort of way.
- 35:29If we see somebody say something super incendiary and like objectively incendiary,
- 35:35like it's racist or sexist or targeted to a specific political group unfairly, we should
- 35:44have an emotional reaction to that.
- 35:48People who are purposely being divisive for the sake of being divisive, we should have a
- 35:53negative reaction to that.
- 35:55But we also need to be careful not to let our emotions and feelings overwhelm us or our
- 36:01choices.
- 36:03And it's important to understand the why of voting in the first place, which may or may not
- 36:08be irrational.
- 36:09And that's what's gonna be explored in the next week or so.
- 36:12But that's gonna end things for today's episode of politics with Paul.
- 36:16As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 36:17Please like, comment, subscribe, share this podcast.
- 36:21My links in the show notes, including my other works, like my five day educational email
- 36:25course about how we can all be more effective at depolarizing politics and dealing with
- 36:32toxicity because a lot of the ways that we do it actually aren't effective, and we, in fact,
- 36:36can accidentally make polarization worse.
- 36:39My book on political independence and why they so often struggle in elections and how they
- 36:45could possibly turn around those fortunes on Amazon in ebook and paperback format, and my
- 36:52other writings on medium.com.
- 36:54Then my other links, my LinkedIn profile that I write on frequently, my facebook.com page, my
- 37:02email, paulraiderwrites@gmail.com, and my website paul raider dot and that's gonna wrap
- 37:07things up here.
- 37:08So again, thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.