Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Domestic Violence on Reality TV
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. Today's episode is actually an audio version of a video
- 0:04that I posted on YouTube a little bit ago. Sometimes when I make a
- 0:09video for the YouTube channel, I think that it would be good to also
- 0:13share with the audio podcast listeners. So in this episode, I'm talking about
- 0:18intimate partner violence. Of course, it carries with it a pretty heavy trigger
- 0:22warning. There's an't graphic details, but if you have any sort of trauma
- 0:27reactivity PTSD included related to intimate partner violence or domestic violence, then you should
- 0:34be careful listening to this episode because it's a lot of talking about it.
- 0:38So for those of you who watched Ultimatum Queer Love, then you know who
- 0:42Tiff is and you might have even watched this video when I posted it on
- 0:46YouTube. For those of you who don't know the reality TV show called Ultimatum
- 0:51Queer Love, then let me just give some background. So there's a reality
- 0:55TV show called Ultimatum, and they on their second season had a lot of
- 1:00queer individuals, which was great for representation. And we posted an episode me
- 1:06and Rebecca talked about it not too long ago. And in this episode that
- 1:11I'm about to present to you is someone named Tiff and they were on the
- 1:15show and it seemed as though their partner, Mildred, was abusive, and
- 1:23that is the allegation from Tiff, and we saw some limited presentations that pointed
- 1:29in that direction. And so after the show concluded, Tiff posted their own
- 1:36video on YouTube talking about their experiences, just kind of speaking off the top
- 1:42of their head. So in this audio episode, I am reacting to Tiff
- 1:49as they talk about their relationship with Mildred. So let's just get to that.
- 1:53Hey, deserve listeners, a lot of you have been asking me to
- 1:56watch this video put out by Tiff. Let's watch. My name is doctor
- 2:00Kirk Conda. I'm a therapist and a professor. And keep in mind that
- 2:04everything I say in reaction to this is off the top of my head and
- 2:08also speculative. Often I can't really know the situation. So let's watch until
- 2:14you're out of it. And let's be clear, both parties of a relationship
- 2:19can be toxic, but research has shown over and over again that a majority
- 2:24of cases, there always only tends to be one abuser in the relationship that
- 2:30dominates power and control. And in mind, okay, so let me talk
- 2:35about mutual abuse and I want to say from the outset that the way that
- 2:38it looked to me was well, the way I would phrase it is given
- 2:43the way that the show is edited, and given the way that the cast
- 2:46members presented on the show, and there wasn't that much data to inform us
- 2:52as to what was actually happening behind the scenes with Tiff and Mildred. But
- 2:55given the data, the top hypothesis I would have if I was asked to
- 3:00assess the couple was that Mildred was the primary abuser, and that Tiff might
- 3:07occasionally use words in an abusive manner, but the overall coercion, the overall
- 3:14sense of unsafety, the overall rigidity, was being perpetrated by Mildred. I
- 3:20don't know the degree of that. We couldn't really tell. We didn't hear
- 3:24a lot of reports of violence. Beyond that, maybe Tiff, we'll get
- 3:29into it here. I'm guessing that they will. I would suspect that given
- 3:34my experience with treating perpetrators. I treated perpetrators who were convicted of intimate partner
- 3:40violence domestic violence and were forced into my program. I worked alongside domestic violence
- 3:47treatment professionals as the therapist, the psychology oriented individual and would work with the
- 3:53perpetrators in a year long program that was designed to essentially deprogram them from the
- 4:00mindset and the personality that will be the main factor behind future intimate partner violence
- 4:06acts. People who commit intimate partner violence they have personality issues, They have
- 4:13attachment issues, They have modeling issues, meaning that violence was often modeled to
- 4:17them. They often have misogynistic and sexist attitudes when it comes to male perpetrators
- 4:23and head of sexual relationships. So I worked with them. I worked with
- 4:26the families. I worked with the victims. Of course, in my private
- 4:30practice, I have treated many victims and perpetrators in my practice. So my
- 4:34point is is that the way that Mildred was talking, the way that she
- 4:39was acting, the way that she would overpower and shut down Tiff, looked
- 4:44like there might be a bigger issue there. We can't really tell. A
- 4:47lot of people on the internet were sure of their speculations, and even after
- 4:54Tiff gives us more information, it's just hard to know. As a person
- 4:59who actually works ground level with individuals, I can tell you that I have
- 5:02been wrong, even though I have a lot of data, I have people
- 5:06telling me data from several different angles. I might talk to the Mildred,
- 5:10I might talk to the Tiff, I might talk to the kids, I
- 5:13might talk to the neighbors, I might talk to other professionals involved in the
- 5:15family, and have a pretty clear picture, seemingly, and we'll draw some
- 5:20conclusions, only later to find out that I was completely wrong because I wasn't
- 5:27being told this detail, or I was biased about this detail. It's just
- 5:30one of those things we like to feel like we can figure things out.
- 5:34It's really hard for us humans to deal with uncertainty, and so we just
- 5:39have to take a deep breath and understand that we might not ever know what
- 5:43was what really happened here. That doesn't mean that we disbelieve Tiff or Mildred
- 5:47for that matter, but it does mean that we just have to be careful
- 5:50about the conclusions that we draw about that sort of thing. But, like
- 5:54I said, the way that it looked, it looked like Tiff was being
- 5:57victimized as a pattern. Actually, at the reunion, as Tiff and Mildred
- 6:01were escalating, Mildred became almost more calm in her approach and in her bulldozing,
- 6:08and at some point she's like, shut up, I don't like the
- 6:10sound of your voice. That's a huge tick in the column of that.
- 6:14Mildred is the aggressor and the perpetrator. And also Tiff, as it was
- 6:17escalating, started to have more of a fight or flight reaction seemingly in their
- 6:21body. They ran off, the crying outside. The disregulation of emotion seems
- 6:29indicative of a victim. Now, could a perpetrator run away because they know
- 6:33they're on camera? Could they manipulate the crowd? Yeah, it didn't look
- 6:36that way to me, So I just want to say that from the start.
- 6:40So now let's get to the topic of mutual abuse. There are two
- 6:43main topics we need to hit on, and there's a lot of discussion here.
- 6:46There's a lot of nuance, there's a lot of research. But to
- 6:49talk about the first topic is that perpetrators will claim that it's mutual when they
- 6:56are caught or they're found out to engage in violence or verbal abuse, emotional
- 7:01abuse or financial abuse, these kinds of things. Then and they can't wiggle
- 7:06their way out of it, they will often resort to claiming that while we
- 7:12both do those that we're both violent. Last week she hit me or last
- 7:16week he called me a bunch of names, that kind of thing, and
- 7:19perpetrators will use this as a smokescreen claiming that, look, we both do
- 7:25those things. Yeah, we have difficulties in our relationship that we both need
- 7:28to work on, instead of the perpetrator a meaning that they have a problem.
- 7:31Now, sometimes perpetrators, because of their personality issues and their distortions,
- 7:36they literally don't think of themselves as a perpetrator. So that's another thing.
- 7:41But anyway, some perpetrators will throw up that smoke screen and say, hey,
- 7:44it's mutual and they're not lying when they say that. The person they're
- 7:47victimizing will be violent, sometimes will call them names. Sometimes sometimes the perpetrator
- 7:54in front of other people will manipulate situation and push the victim into having a
- 8:00reaction like that so that they can use that against them as a way of
- 8:05more control over the victim. And so when you hear perpetrators claiming mutual abuse,
- 8:11there's a problem with that obviously, and the victims are further victimized if
- 8:16anyone believes the perpetrator in that it is mutual. Okay, So when we
- 8:22learned about that, and when society started to learn about that claim from perpetrators
- 8:28that they will claim mutual abuse when it isn't really happening. The temptation is
- 8:31to claim that mutual abuse does not exist at all. But that is simply
- 8:37not the case according to research, and not the case according to my anecdotal
- 8:41experience. But how do we define it? So in the research, they
- 8:43have a lot of different terms on a lot of different definitions, And the
- 8:46problem is on a number of levels. One is we're almost always relying on
- 8:52self report. We're asking the individuals, We're asking Tiff, We're asking Mildred,
- 8:56were you abused? Did you abuse? Were you violent? Was someone
- 9:01violent with you? Did you feel unsafe? Did you make someone feel unsafe?
- 9:05Were there police reports? This kind of thing? So it's hard to
- 9:09gather the data because some people don't tell the truth, or they don't remember
- 9:13things, or they don't feel entitled. Victims often are afraid to tell the
- 9:16truth. Also, how do you define abuse exactly? As a common example,
- 9:20a lot of couples will call each other names sometimes, you know,
- 9:26maybe not extreme names, but they might say, oh my god, you're
- 9:28such a jerk. Okay, well that's a name. Is that abusive?
- 9:33Was that person being abusive in that moment? Where do you draw the line?
- 9:35So how do you define it? Do we look at the behavior?
- 9:39Do we look at and ask the victim how they felt when they were being
- 9:43treated that way? Because you could potentially be called a lot of names by
- 9:48your partner and not really feel unsafe. You're just like, well, they're
- 9:50having a meltdown, and yes the behavior is abusive, but I don't feel
- 9:56abused, Okay, So how do you figure that out? How do you
- 10:00define it? Does the unsafe victim know that they're unsafe? Because a lot
- 10:03of unsafe victims will have been gas lit by their partner, maybe even by
- 10:09their family beforehand, such that they don't even know what they feel. They
- 10:13don't feel entitled to those feelings. So how do we gather the data?
- 10:16How do we define it? But the gist of it, when you look
- 10:20at thousands of research papers from various different angles, the way that it looks
- 10:26is that there are a number of couples where at first glance, it's hard
- 10:31to tell who the victim is and who the perpetrator is, meaning that when
- 10:35you observe or you hear reports, you hear violence going both ways, and
- 10:39you hear verbal abuse and emotional abuse going both ways. Which one is more
- 10:43which one is less hard to gauge because you could have a severe one time
- 10:50event that happens one time a year that sufficiently will victimize the victim for the
- 10:56rest of the year because the victim is in constant fear of that happening again,
- 10:58Or you can abuse the victim every day to a lesser extent. Plus
- 11:03what is abusive what is not, We've already been over that. So at
- 11:07first glance, a lot of couples where there is abuse clearly happening, it
- 11:11seems to be going both directions to some degree. Having said that, there
- 11:16are many couples where it's not. There are many couples where the perpetrator will
- 11:18claim it's happening when it never did. There's also couples where neither one of
- 11:22them will claim it goes both ways, where everyone agrees the perpetrator is the
- 11:26only one doing it. But there are some couples where they will report it
- 11:31going both ways. For a majority of those cases, there is a perpetrator
- 11:35and there is a victim. When you actually look at the pattern, the
- 11:39way it is experienced, how intense it is, then you clearly say see
- 11:45that although there are abusive behaviors going both directions, one person is clearly dominating
- 11:50the other person, and the victim occasionally will fight back or occasionally will stoop
- 11:58to the level of the abuser and call names or whatever. So in those
- 12:01situations, again we're still looking at a majority of those cases one person as
- 12:05the perpetrator. There is a subset, though, of bidirectional intimate partner violence
- 12:11couples where it is found after a lot of investigation that both are perpetrators and
- 12:18both are victims. Professionals that know what they're doing are very hesitant to land
- 12:24on that conceptualization. It's a conceptualization of last resort because of the risk of
- 12:31categorizing a couple like that. When there is a clear perpetrator and a victim,
- 12:35there's a lot of damage that you can do as a professional. If
- 12:37you're like, yeah, it's going both ways, you're really taking a huge
- 12:41risk when you make that conclusion for the victim, because if you label the
- 12:45victim as a perpetrator, then the abuse might be prolonged much longer than needs
- 12:50to be right in order for safety. Because the primary thing when professionals are
- 12:56first in contact with a couple with partner violence is getting the victim, say,
- 13:00getting the victim to a place where they can be protected from the abuse.
- 13:03Then you can start working on all the other things. And if you
- 13:05label the perpetrator, then that's going to set that back potentially. So it's
- 13:09a conceptualization of last resort for that reason. But it is a conceptualization,
- 13:13and I've seen it before. I can never really know for sure, of
- 13:16course, but after a lot of time assessing and hearing stories and hearing both
- 13:24of them tell me their experience one on one, you have to make sure
- 13:28you talked with each person alone, have a good relationship. That for some
- 13:31couples, they because of their upbringing, probably they learn a lot of abuse
- 13:37growing up. It's how they deal with being upset at their partner. When
- 13:41their partner hurts their feelings or concerns them, then they have a very quick
- 13:48emotional reaction of extreme pain and fear and then extreme anger and control. And
- 13:56they will alternate and they will both perpetrate and in those moments, and it
- 14:03depends on the situation. But when one of the partner is perpetrating, the
- 14:07victim actually feels like a victim. They feel unsafe, they feel terrified,
- 14:11they're worried of doing the wrong things. They're walking on eggshells. That might
- 14:16last for an hour, it might last for a couple of weeks until things
- 14:20stabilize again, and then a trigger happens to the victim, and because of
- 14:26the way they're raised, then they go after and now the other person is
- 14:31now being victimized. In these scenarios, the victimization is usually, in my
- 14:35anecdual experience, not as severe because of it being more equal. I suppose.
- 14:43Also, when you have a clear perpetrator, in the classic perpetration sense,
- 14:48it is so prolonged and so all encompassing that the victim loses power.
- 14:56They're gas lit over time, they start believing in them, they stop believe
- 15:00themselves. They're cut off from their family and friends, they don't have any
- 15:03power in the home, in finances, you know, they just become this
- 15:07slave essentially, Whereas when you have mutual abuse, there's a lot less likelihood
- 15:13of that happening for a victim, Which makes sense right now. Is it
- 15:16a big deal when people come forward and state even experts that mutual abuse doesn't
- 15:22exist. It doesn't really matter to me. It's not a hill that I
- 15:26care to die on, because the consequence of it isn't that severe, because
- 15:35there's not that many couples that are like that, and it probably does more
- 15:39good than bad to be more rigid about that, because whenever you hear someone
- 15:45claiming multiple mutual abuse, in all likelihood, it is a perpetrator that is
- 15:48throwing up a smokescreen when the vortex that I didn't even know it was happening
- 15:54in real time, and as a lot of people who have survived these kind
- 15:56of relationships, you can see again and again and the same patterns and the
- 16:00same behaviors most of the relationship, I actually felt bad for her. I
- 16:06was constantly being showed out like a fraction of what your soul on the stage
- 16:08called hundreds and hundreds of names. But we'll always softly guilt tripped and shamed
- 16:15into believing her bad behavior was my fault. Okay, that was consistent with
- 16:21what we saw what Tiff is saying there, and I tend to believe that
- 16:26that it was a pattern the comfort level in those conversations, not only with
- 16:30Tiff but also with Assie. That's another detail that we have available to us,
- 16:36is that it wasn't just Mildred and tiff, it was Mildred and Assie.
- 16:41It was Mildred. Mildred is the common denominator there. Mildred is the
- 16:45one who does those things, regardless of who she is with. It's the
- 16:49way she reacts, It's the entitlement that she feels. It's the distortions perhaps
- 16:55that are driving her behavior, her overreactivity. And the thing I want to
- 17:00mention is that Mildred told us that she went through a very very difficult childhood
- 17:04I believe, abandoned by both of her parents, and then she was raised
- 17:07by one of her grandparents, who died when Mildred was twelve. I believe,
- 17:11and I don't know, but I have speculated that Mildred went through a
- 17:15lot more than even that, because typical every time that I have heard of
- 17:19someone being abandoned by both of their parents at that age, it is because
- 17:22both parents were suffering from severe addiction, and of course addiction not only can
- 17:27lead to abandonment of a child. Because of the disorder, they become solely
- 17:33focused on fueling their addiction at the expense of their children, and then eventually
- 17:37they either voluntarily give up their kids. You know, a lot of times
- 17:40the grandparents will be like, you're not taking care of your kid, how
- 17:42about I take care of the kid, or CPS gets involved and removes the
- 17:45child from the home. So not only will drug addiction affect one's parenting,
- 17:51but it also can affect who you bring into the house, perhaps even the
- 17:55abuse you inflict on the child, this sort of thing. So I don't
- 17:59know, I wouldn't be surprised if Mildred had one of the most difficult childhoods
- 18:03that anyone could ever have in the history of mankind. Honestly, I mean,
- 18:07it's a horrific childhood to endure. And so along these lines, a
- 18:11lot of the perpetrators that I treated had difficulties in early childhood that resulted in
- 18:17them having a lot of emotional dysregulation, a lot of modeling that would they
- 18:22saw a lot of things that were severe and for themselves, they're not as
- 18:27bad as their parents, and they're patting themselves in the back, and they
- 18:30should for that reason, but they don't realize that they're kind of in that
- 18:34direction. They're not as bad as their parents. So they're like, well,
- 18:37I should be good, right, But they don't realize that they're still
- 18:40out of the healthy limits of behavior. Also, for individuals like this,
- 18:47they have severe physical pain when they are being rejected or when there are signs
- 18:53of rejection, and when they feel that pain, they feel like they're being
- 18:57wronged, and then they come swinging literally, so they feel justified because of
- 19:02the way that it feels to them. Right, So, anyway, it
- 19:04looked like that might have been the case for Mildred. But yeah, so
- 19:08Tiff is describing something that it did look like that way that Mildred was very
- 19:14sure in the way that she was approaching Tiff, and Tiff was trying to
- 19:19work with it at times, trying to be flexible, being softer, letting
- 19:23Mildred talk, trying to reason, and then Mildred would just keep berating,
- 19:30guilt tripped, and shamed into believing her bad behavior was my fault. Right,
- 19:36so blaming Tiff for everything, never taking responsibility. Yeah, we did
- 19:41at least see that in the edit. It's the victim complex. And because
- 19:45I didn't love her enough, or because she was always afraid of me leaving
- 19:49her, I felt so horrible for everything she was going through that I started
- 19:52to lose my own boundaries in that relationship. Yeah, So the way the
- 19:57Internet will frame that Mildred is that it is a conscious choice. This narcissistic
- 20:04abuse. That so much identification of people on the show being narcissistic, And
- 20:11I just wish people would say self centered because that's what they're referring to,
- 20:15or psychopathic, which I think is also but no one should be diagnosing from
- 20:18afar anyway. But what Tiff was talking about right there, I'm guessing what
- 20:22that means is that there were times when Tiff would draw a boundary and they
- 20:27broke up. They said once every one or two weeks, And it's possible
- 20:33that there were times when Tiff left and said I can't do this anymore,
- 20:36and then Mildred would come back to Tiff and cry and say, I don't
- 20:41want to lose you, and you know my childhood and you're triggering my abandonment
- 20:45feelings and trauma. Don't do this to me. And if you're Tiff and
- 20:51you have a heart and you care about Mildred, which Tiff did and maybe
- 20:55still does, then it's tempting to go back right and you feel bad.
- 21:00You might feel later on that you were being guilt tripped. So on one
- 21:02level, the analysis is that Mildred knew what she was doing, and she
- 21:07was psychopathically or as the Internet would call covert narcissism or I don't know.
- 21:11There's this all sorts of miss labeling and misuse of these terms. And they
- 21:17will say that Mildred did it on purpose, and it's possible, but more
- 21:21often than not, and I've treated perpetrators of various different types, they more
- 21:26often than not they are acting from a place where they feel justified based on
- 21:30modeling to them and also based on the way things feel to them, and
- 21:33also based on their distortions. None of us see reality. None of us
- 21:37are objective observers of reality, and especially when it comes to conflict, right
- 21:45and for people that have these kinds of traumas, they're much more prone to
- 21:48seeing things that most people would not see. So for Mildred, she could
- 21:55have really believed, Look, Tiff is making me feel horrible. Tiff is
- 22:00really mean to me, and thus I need to really make sure that Tiff
- 22:04understands that they can't be mean to me like that. And so I'm going
- 22:08to be mean back, but only temporarily, but from the outside. And
- 22:11if you're Tiff and you're looking at it, all you see is Mildred being
- 22:15mean, and you see Tiff trying to accommodate. But the way it feels
- 22:18to Mildred is it feels balanced, it feels fair, it feels just to
- 22:22them. That is usually the case. So the treatment for perpetrators is complicated,
- 22:29but a major portion of it is to address these distortions, to address
- 22:33the indoctrination they had growing up into this mindset, to address the attachment reactivity,
- 22:40to address corrective experiences for them so that they feel stable and they can
- 22:42regulate, to address their emotional regulation problems. Anyway, so I think that
- 22:48Tiff is referring to that that Mildred would never admit that she was wrong,
- 22:52would blame, and Tiff would draw boundary, and then Mildred would open up,
- 22:56which would be which would have a guilt tripping effect on Tiff, and
- 23:00then over time Tiff would slowly demote their priority of boundaries wherever. Because you
- 23:07do that, you draw a boundary. The first time that had happened with
- 23:10Mildred, I'm guessing TI drew a pretty firm boundary and then they engage in
- 23:14that process and maybe for a while Mildred was better, but then reverts back,
- 23:18and then over time Mildred gets worse. But as it gets worse,
- 23:22Tiff is like, well, I forgave Mildred last time, and I don't
- 23:27know what's happening. It can have a gaslighting effect because you don't know what's
- 23:33normal, you don't know what's okay, you don't know what's acceptable. And
- 23:37you start thinking, well, she does have a lot of these traumas,
- 23:41and if I care about her, I would a comedy for that, right,
- 23:45And every couple has its problems and there's always fighting sometimes, so you
- 23:49know we'll get through this and things do it better and Mildred is reached.
- 23:53You end up tricking yourself into staying in a relationship when there are real no
- 23:57signs that things are going to get me better. It sounds like Tiff is
- 24:00referring to them, for example, rather than saying to myself, I'm constantly
- 24:04being called names. I don't deserve this. The manipulation of a vulnerable narcissistic
- 24:11traits say we'll leave one thinking she must have gone through so much in her
- 24:15life she feels the need to call me names. Yeah, Tiff knows Mildred
- 24:18a billion times more. Than I do. But I'm just going to take
- 24:22a guess and say that if I were assessing Mildred, I would not identify
- 24:26it as narcissistic. The Internet, it seems to be getting worse. Honestly,
- 24:30this misuse of the term. If you're just going to talk about being
- 24:33self centered, or if you're going to talk about self entitlement or even a
- 24:38grandiose sense of self, or someone who thinks too highly of themselves, or
- 24:42someone who lacks empathy, just use those phrases because those can be associated with
- 24:48a lot of things or none of the things in the DSM, and this
- 24:52misidentification of those traits are all indications of narcissistic personality or even just the term
- 25:00narcisism, because you know, I think narcissism narcissists looked at himself in the
- 25:03pond and fell in love with his own image. So it's kind of far
- 25:08afield from the way it's being used today. The way it's being used today
- 25:12is just this term for lack of empathy and entitlement and believing your own crap
- 25:19or something, or just not taking other people's feelings any consideration. It's not
- 25:23necessarily narcissistic. Personality as I've already been over. But so I'm just going
- 25:26to assume what Tiff is referring to is lack of empathy, lack of remorse,
- 25:33lack of concern, lack of consideration, that kind of thing. And
- 25:36that's horrible to be in a relationship with someone where you believe you're a bad
- 25:38person the entire time, And people who haven't experienced that before say, why
- 25:44don't you just leave? And this is where the manipulation comes into play,
- 25:48and so many people can nod their heads with me and say, you know
- 25:51what, I have been there too. Yeah, And good for Tiff for
- 25:56raising awareness about victimization and perpet partner violence. And Tip is referring to that
- 26:02phenomenon where the victim will feel like they're wrong, like they're bad. They
- 26:07start believing that what's being said to them. And we saw an example of
- 26:12the interaction style that can result in that, where Mildred is very sure of
- 26:18herself and at least in the edit, never backs down, never admits that
- 26:22she's wrong. And in the beginning, when you first start experiencing that,
- 26:27even if you have a very robust sense of yourself, a good sense of
- 26:32self esteem, positive upbringing a lot of a two minute in your life.
- 26:36You spend enough time with someone, you eventually start to call into question all
- 26:40those things because we have this heuristic. I think none of us are completely
- 26:45sure that we're a good person. None of us are one hundred percent sure
- 26:48that generally speaking, we're good and we're usually on the right page. None
- 26:53of us are sure that at best, you're nine sure of that you're around
- 26:59someone who was a one hundred percent sure that you're wrong all the time,
- 27:02and that there's something wrong with you and you're a bad person. We have
- 27:04this heuristic of well, I'm pretty sure, but they're more sure, and
- 27:08they are pointing out a lot of you know, That's the other thing about
- 27:11perpetrators is due to the way that they saw relationships when they were young,
- 27:17it was modeled to them, and they're highly motivated to control because they believe
- 27:21it's the only way for them to get any sort of attachment securities. They
- 27:25believe it's the only way to be able to relax. We saw that with
- 27:30Mildred when Ossie and Mildred were starting getting into it. Mildred started resorting to
- 27:33that stuff and Aussie was just gone, and you saw the floor fallout from
- 27:38underneath Mildred. At first she was just like, I'm okay, everything's fine,
- 27:42I'm not affected by it. Then she starts criticizing Ossie, Well,
- 27:47Aussie could have put this laundry basket somewhere else, I mean, why is
- 27:51it right in front of the dresser, and starts to get a little bit
- 27:53more annoyed and then has a full emotional meltdown. I think it's understandable given
- 28:00Mildred's history. But the way that perpetrators that present like Mildred will operate is
- 28:06if they don't have someone close to them, ie, if they're not controlling
- 28:11someone, then they are faced with that pain of I'm worthless, no one
- 28:15will ever love me, And they fundamentally also don't believe that someone would love
- 28:19them for who they are. So there's a lot of reasons why they feel
- 28:22like their only road to happiness is to control. And then they justify it
- 28:26to themselves because they can't really live themselves as an abuser, so they brainwash
- 28:32themselves essentially into believing that they're okay to do all those things. And so
- 28:37the perpetrators typically will have had a lifetime of developing skills at control. They
- 28:44are very good at what they do because of practice and trial and error,
- 28:48and they're highly motivated. Given the profile that I was saying earlier, Not
- 28:52all abuse of people are like that. You have psychopathic, statistic abusers who
- 28:56are just trying to control and con you because they don't care about your feelings.
- 29:00Those people exist, but they're rare and they're real, and they're abusive
- 29:03and they're awful. But I've treated them before and it's you know, it's
- 29:07a thing and it's intense. But for the vast majority of abusers that I've
- 29:12worked with, they're this other type that are generally good people on the inside,
- 29:17but they are so desperate and they learned a particular coping style for that
- 29:22desperation, and it is victimization of other people doesn't make it okay. But
- 29:26they're very good at what they do because of trial and error. And so
- 29:29for you, as a victim, in all likelihood, you haven't spent your
- 29:32whole life trying to figure out how to gain a relationship. You probably come
- 29:37from the very least a regular sort of history of relationships where you know you
- 29:42can kind of trust the other person and trust yourself. Not all the time,
- 29:48but most of the time things usually work out. So you can't be
- 29:52expected to no matter how well you've been raised, you can't be expected to
- 29:56withstand the certainty and the way in which users will get under your skin emotionally.
- 30:02You know they will tear you down. They can. I've personally and
- 30:06professionally been around these folks, and within half a second they can rip me
- 30:11to shreds. And I was raised well, but I don't have defenses against
- 30:15that. I don't see it coming. I generally trust people, and so
- 30:19when it starts to happen, it's hard. And even if you manage to
- 30:25deflect or center yourself or get support some of the time, it probably won't
- 30:30work in a long term. So what I think Tiff is referring to is
- 30:34that that over time, Tiff actually started to believe what Tiff was being told.
- 30:40That Tiff was a bad person, And it's something a lot of people
- 30:42cannot understand until they're actually walking in those shoes. And at the time she
- 30:47broke up with me, at least fifty times you see me talk about it
- 30:49on the show, not the other way around, you know, like it
- 30:52wasn't me that was constantly breaking with her was her that was breaking up with
- 30:56me all the time. And after researching this, oh, I understand I
- 31:00would have thought that Tiff would have broken up with her some of the time.
- 31:04So according to TIFF's account, Mildred was the one breaking up with Tiff
- 31:08a lot. Okay, that's interesting. Interesting. Regardless of what any person
- 31:14does or whatever, the reasons are, breaking up with someone fifty times and
- 31:19taking them back and discarding them and bringing them back and discarding them is abuse
- 31:26in itself. Yeah, it depends. I mean, can someone break up
- 31:30with someone repeatedly and have it not be abusive? Yeah, but it can
- 31:36absolutely be abusive. The other example that we've seen on reality TV is with
- 31:41Big Ed and Liz. We can't know if that's edited that way, we
- 31:42can't know if it's played up for cameras. We can't even really know if
- 31:45what's being presented to us as a representative of their relationship. But what we
- 31:49have heard from the two of them is that he Big Ed will break up
- 31:55with Liz often, and the way that it looks, it looks that Ed
- 31:59is the one with those historical issues of trauma and this deep pain and then
- 32:06a very self assured attacking coming from all sorts of angles to Liz, and
- 32:10then when Liz is broken down and drawing a boundary, eventually he's just like,
- 32:16okay, I'm done with you. And we heard that infamous phone call
- 32:21if you're familiar, where Liz drove a male coworker home even after asking Ed
- 32:27if it was okay, Ed said it was okay, which she shouldn't have
- 32:30to ask him for permission to do that anyway. But then after Liz dropped
- 32:35him off the phone call presumed allegedly was after that point, and Ed's really
- 32:39going after Liz and calling a lot of names, and Liz's crying and saying,
- 32:44please, don't you say that about me. And I think that was
- 32:46one of the times that Ed would have broken up with her. So absolutely,
- 32:50abusers can use breaking up as a tool as a way of controlling the
- 32:53other person. And if you've been sufficiently brainwashed and gas lit, and you
- 32:59might have your own historical attachment issues when that happens, especially as it will
- 33:04happen so quickly there it can be this vacuuming effect, like sucking effect of
- 33:08just like no, no, no, don't leave, and then you end
- 33:10up scrambling as a victim was like, Okay, I'll be better. I'll
- 33:13do whatever you want, and it sounds like maybe something like that happened with
- 33:16Tip here. I come back around thinking everything is my faults, and I
- 33:21try and I try even harder just to get discarded again. Yeah, And
- 33:28if this is even close to accurate Tips account, it becomes part of the
- 33:31repertoire of the abuser. If the victim tries to assert themselves in any way,
- 33:37then it can become a way of eliminating that asservedness in the victim of
- 33:44saying, you know, how come you're doing this to me? The perpetrator
- 33:46will say that, like, you know how I feel about those sorts of
- 33:50things. It's like you don't even love me anymore. And as a victim,
- 33:53in the beginning, you might start out and say, it's okay for
- 33:55me to assert myself. All I'm asking is to hang out with my friends
- 33:59on Saturday night. What's the big deal? And over time it's just easier
- 34:04to give in. You're saying, you know, it's such a headache to
- 34:07go, even though I kind of know I'm right, it's just such a
- 34:10bother. I mean, it'd be great to see my friends but it's so
- 34:14much worse. I have to deal with a partner that's for three weeks holding
- 34:16it over my head and ruining our lives. Fine, I'll just won't see
- 34:21my friends. And then you start even potentially convincing yourself, Oh maybe I
- 34:24am kind of selfish, and then the abuse cycle goes down that road.
- 34:29No matter what I did, it was never enough. I was never enough,
- 34:34And I do believe that relationships tend to mirror what we go through as
- 34:37children, as all of us though, So Sam gave me insight into realizing
- 34:42this during our trial marriage, that I am enough no matter what I do.
- 34:46Yeah. I didn't comment on that at the time because I wasn't really
- 34:51sure if that's what I was seeing, But hearing Tiff say this makes sense
- 34:54that the trial marriage for Tiff was liberating in that for Sam seemingly being a
- 35:00lot more differentiated, one of the most differentiated people on the show. I
- 35:05think hard to tell, but looked that way to me that Sam was assertive
- 35:09but not abusive. Sam would say, hey, I don't you know the
- 35:14whole dog conversation. We were shown the main fight between the two of them,
- 35:20but then we heard later on that they did manage to make up and
- 35:23had a fine platonic trial marriage for three weeks. And so for Tiff,
- 35:30they might be like, oh, so, even though I was overreacting me,
- 35:35I think Tiff might have even said that I am seeing that it's okay
- 35:38for me to be that way, like Tiff might have. Actually, I
- 35:43don't think i'd Obviously I wouldn't have known this at the time, but Tiff
- 35:45might have come out swinging, so to speak, not physically, but really
- 35:50strong reactivity against Sam because there was an indication that maybe Sam might not like
- 35:57TIFF's dog, and Tiff felt like they needed to really, you know,
- 36:00fight fire with fire, predicting that fire was going to happen, and then
- 36:05Sam was not fire. Sam was more differentiated and caring and compassionate while being
- 36:10assertive. You know, Sam didn't back down and said, Hey, I
- 36:14can't tell you how I'm going to feel about the dog. That's that's all,
- 36:15my boy. I'm not saying I don't like the dog. I'm just
- 36:17saying I have feelings and that's okay, and that's that's not a threat to
- 36:21you. It just is what it is. It seems like maybe over time
- 36:24Tiff was like Oh wait, so I don't have to fight fire with so
- 36:30other people can be respectful while being assertive. And Sam's treating me differently than
- 36:36the way Mildred. Wow, this is different. Maybe I'm not so crazy
- 36:40like I believed from Mildred's abuse. Maybe I do have rights, Maybe I
- 36:45do have freedom and huh, what's going on? And it's interesting to think
- 36:51about. I didn't ever thought about on this show that you would have that
- 36:54opportunity for victims to contrast a relationship as a way to liberate themselves. Sounds
- 37:00like that's what happened for Tip. But unfortunately I was still in a toxic
- 37:05vortex and couldn't see myself out of this vicious cycle continue. Oh but sounds
- 37:09like Tip was saying I was still in the brainwashed state. But maybe later
- 37:16on Tiff started to or maybe it planted a seed. It's what we often
- 37:22talk about in therapy. When I first started as a therapist, I worked
- 37:25with a lot of people. We called them multi problem families, meaning that
- 37:30not only did the child have depression or PTSD or ADHD, but you also
- 37:37had the child suffered from something else, also, the child's being bullied at
- 37:39school. Also the family was suffering from poverty. It was a single parent
- 37:45family. They were having trouble getting healthcare. There were three kids that were
- 37:49fighting against each other. The community was unsafe, school problems, problems with
- 37:54the system, lots of issues. And so with these kinds of family,
- 38:00with some of these individuals, it was a lot to ask for therapy to
- 38:05take hold right away because in their life they were continuing to incur trauma and
- 38:09difficulty and stress. So what we would talk about often amongst ourselves was that
- 38:15we're planting seeds that might grow in the future, and sometimes we would stick
- 38:20with families long enough that we would actually see those seeds grow into something.
- 38:24It's a way of reassuring yourself as a helper that you're actually helping when there's
- 38:30no evidence that you're helping, because sometimes there wasn't a lot of times you'd
- 38:32see families individuals get worse over time, not because of you, but seemingly
- 38:37it's hard to know, but it didn't seem like it was because of our
- 38:39therapy. It was because things in their life. We're getting worse and it
- 38:45was taking a toll. So for Sam and Tiff, that relationship might have
- 38:52planted a seed that later grew for Tiff going to be in these relationships where
- 38:55you keep on getting discarded, gasolt, disposed, harmed by words, guilt,
- 39:01tripped, and controlled. It forms complex PTSD and does damage to the
- 39:06brain. It's a real thing. It's abusive. Yeah, Complex PTSD is
- 39:10a real thing, and it does theoretically and all likelihood change one's neurology over
- 39:17time. There are some limited studies demonstrating what TIP is referring to, but
- 39:23not for everyone, and it's hard to measure because our technologies and measuring neurological
- 39:28change and identifying even what that change means is extremely limited at this stage of
- 39:34our technology. But as stand as a reason that over time, habitually,
- 39:40if you're in a state, then it's much easier to engage in those thought
- 39:45processes. If you're in a constant state of being afraid and trying to accommodate
- 39:52and not acknowledging your feelings because you're not safe to then over time, with
- 39:55repetition, eventually that just happens automatically. Even if you're not in the face
- 40:00of danger. You might be with a new person who is actually like Sam,
- 40:05who isn't an actual threat, but you engage and in the fear,
- 40:07and then the response as a as a habit, because neurologically, you have
- 40:13those well worn paths in your thinking, in your automatic responses, and in
- 40:19your interpretation of things. So absolutely and trauma from domestic violence from a partner
- 40:25violence often will result in legit PTSD, whether we call it complex or not.
- 40:30Like a common example is that the perpetrator comes home from work and closes
- 40:36the door a little harder than other times, And because as a victim you're
- 40:39so attuned to the mood of the perpetrator, you notice those things. If
- 40:45you're not in a situation like that, you might not note, at the
- 40:49very least consciously, how loud someone closes the door when they get home.
- 40:52So the victim is reading a book, door shuts a little faster, maybe
- 40:59even you pick up on the pace that the perpetrator is walking at, and
- 41:02instantly your body is thrown into fight or flight. And then later on,
- 41:08even if you're not in the relationship anymore, you hear a door shut a
- 41:13little loud and your body goes in the fighter flight. That's evidence of potential
- 41:17for PTSD. Could just be a regular trauma reactivity. But what happens over
- 41:22time is if you have frequent fight or flight reactions to stimuli and you're being
- 41:30abused, eventually you start to shut down a lot of things. PTSC is
- 41:32a very complicated disorder, I believe from last time I checked. It has
- 41:38the most descriptors, the most criteria, It takes up the most pages in
- 41:44the DSM, and it's complicated. So it's not just reactivity, it's a
- 41:49lot of other things that occur within the personality in response to the constant triggers.
- 41:54When you know, because if you have these constant triggers, eventually and
- 41:57there's no way out of that, you have to develop ways of coping with
- 42:00that. Some people will shut down. Some people will shut themselves off from
- 42:04the world. Some people will be hyper vigilant and constantly looking around trying to
- 42:08put out fires before they happen, And so that the whole syndrome with PTSD
- 42:13will look like that. And you know, I wouldn't be surprised if Tiff
- 42:16did develop that as tiffa stating, all right, let's take a break,
- 42:20and when we get back, let's continue watching tis video. My dogs are
- 42:23barking. It's abusive, and I was constantly in a state of defending myself,
- 42:31always in fight, flight, freeze, or fall mode. No matter
- 42:36what I did, I did not have a safe space. As if I
- 42:38left, I was shamed. We saw how that played out in the ultimatum
- 42:42once Aussie left Sam, and she turned the negative around and blamed Aussie and
- 42:49victimized Aussie. Yeah, yeah, again. I want to check in for
- 42:53a second and say that I've been around the block enough times clinically and personally
- 42:58to know that if I were to investigate the entire situation, talk with Mildred,
- 43:04talk with third parties, that I would have a more rich description all
- 43:08of that future unknown data might align with what Tiff is saying, and some
- 43:13of it might not, and I might discount the non alignment of data,
- 43:17or I might incorporate it and say, oh, okay, So I just
- 43:21want to be clear that I can't tell what's really happening. There's a lot
- 43:24of signs, and I use this platform as a way of jump, using
- 43:29it as a jump jumping off point. I certainly support Tiff absolutely in speaking
- 43:35their voice, and especially if Tiff is accurate in identifying themselves as a victim,
- 43:40then absolutely Tiff deserves a lot of credit a lot of support. Tis
- 43:45very courageous for speaking out, but I've been around the block enough to know
- 43:47that I just can't tell from public statements from public figures and when. Although
- 43:54Alsie has childhood trauma who work on as we all do, as was also
- 43:59expressed boundaries, something I did not have during the show. In fact,
- 44:04I developed such a thick skin because I had to, because I had to
- 44:08go through the blunt enforce of Mildred all of the time to apart to a
- 44:13point where I started to become numb. Yeah, it sounds credible, right.
- 44:19It doesn't look like Tiff is distorted or lying. So it's a lot
- 44:22of data in the column demonstrating what Tiff is talking about, supporting what Tiff
- 44:28is talking about, and so what Tiff I think is pointy two right now
- 44:32is Look, Ossie has the ability to draw boundaries in a way that I
- 44:37had. Maybe I originally did, but due to my ongoing chronic experience with
- 44:44abuse, I had lost that ability to draw a boundary, and a part
- 44:49of that was because I was numb. I was so often what's happening for
- 44:53victims in the situation is they're not technically numb they're actually they are being harmed.
- 44:58But often when we have a feeling, like think about if you had
- 45:01chronic pain. Often, if you've never had a pain, like let's say
- 45:06right now, you've never had a pain in your spine, and all of
- 45:08a sudden you get a sharp pain in your spine, it would really distract
- 45:13you. If it was sufficient, you would be well, what's going on?
- 45:15And you would have a hard time paying attention at work or watching a
- 45:21TV show. You just be like, oh, what is going on?
- 45:22You extend it over time, and the pain you're diagnosed, You go through
- 45:30treatment and the physicians say, yeah, there's really nothing we can do that
- 45:34kind of thing. So you're now living with this pain and it's frequent.
- 45:37It's still painful and demoralizing over time, but it doesn't alert you because you're
- 45:43used to it. It's something that it's like, well, there's that thing
- 45:45again. It's depressing, honestly to feel the pain. It's not alerting.
- 45:50It doesn't wait, what's going on. So when you are first experiencing abuse,
- 45:55hey, what's going on? Fight or fight let's fix it. Over
- 45:58time, you're body and mind just become like well here it happens. So
- 46:04what's the point in feeling the feelings. It's just going to bother. There's
- 46:07no sense in acting like I can change it, because I can't. It
- 46:09might even be all my fault. So you know, let's just not pay.
- 46:13And the numbness is one ignoring the feelings to the point where they might
- 46:19even not be consciously aware of the feelings, but the feelings are still there.
- 46:22It's not like they're not afraid. They're not being harmed, they don't
- 46:25feel they are all likelihood are being harmed. There is dissociation, which is
- 46:30another thing, and there are different definitions of it. There's clinical dissociation,
- 46:34there's like the psychoanalytic version, and I guess what I'm describing as more of
- 46:38the psychoanalytic version, but the clinical version can actually result in one distancing themselves
- 46:45from victimization such that they don't necessarily encode the memories or experience the things anyway.
- 46:51So Tiff is talking about them, and you wonder why I acted the
- 46:55way I did towards Sam right away. But there she'd went, introducing me
- 47:00a gentle energy. I didn't have to have a guard up, have a
- 47:05guard up because in the relationship with Mildred, I constantly had a guard.
- 47:08Yeah, so Tiff is confirming what I was suspecting earlier, because Tiff was
- 47:15referring to that art up all the time, because I never knew what to
- 47:17expect within living within her chaotic life. One of the biggest things I've learned
- 47:22post relationship in my healing journey is that one person can tell who is the
- 47:29abuser is by seeing that the abuser is constantly provoking fights. Yeah, it
- 47:36depends. It's hard to know. You could see a scenario where you have
- 47:39a legit perpetrator and victim, and in that snippet of time you absolutely see
- 47:45the victim provoking. You can't see that. But generally speaking, the victim
- 47:50is trying to survive. They're not trying to start a fight. They might
- 47:54participate in the fight, they might even escalate the fight, but they're not
- 47:58looking to fight. They're terrified of fights. Often their entire life is oriented
- 48:01around pleasing the perpetrator, not provoking the perpetrators, So they're not particularly interested
- 48:08in provoking, right, Whereas the perpetrator is much more comfortable with that much
- 48:15freer, feels much more entitled, and they use provocation. It depending on
- 48:22the profile, but seemingly if Tiff is being accurate here, the Mildred type
- 48:28of abuser will use provocation again as a way of controlling, as a way
- 48:32of beating someone down. The way to think about it, the way I
- 48:36see it, if Tiff and Mildred did have an abusive relationship, and Mildred
- 48:42was being abusive to Tiff, is that the way to think about it is
- 48:45that there'll be these little indications to the Mildred's of the world that the TIFFs
- 48:52of the world are disapproving or moving away. The abuser is often driven by
- 49:00trying to manage abandonment, trying to manage rejection. And it sounds weird,
- 49:06but you can have very mild conversations like you can even have this. So
- 49:09this happened to me personally. I don't think I've ever talked about this.
- 49:14It was a long time ago, but I was talking with a friend and
- 49:19I was just kind of brainstorming different lifestyle changes that I might make in my
- 49:23life. And I remember saying something like I want to cut back on red
- 49:29meat or something like that, and I just, you know, I was
- 49:31just saying, you know, maybe I should cut back on red meat.
- 49:35Or maybe not eat meat at all or something, And pretty quickly my friend
- 49:40or acquaintance started to attack me, started to point out all these reasons why
- 49:46I shouldn't stop let's just say red meat, that I should eat red meat.
- 49:51You know, I don't know what she said, but it would have
- 49:52been in the camp of something like, well, you know, you can't
- 49:53get all your nutrients unless you have read meat, and you know red meat
- 49:58is really good, and you know you like red meat and everything. It'll
- 50:00be fine, and just very frantic arguing against my just random brainstorm. And
- 50:07also I'm thinking, what is it to you? You seem personally interested in
- 50:14me not making this change. It doesn't impact. What's the problem here,
- 50:17Okay, I hypothesized later on, given a lot of other data points at
- 50:22the individual was threatened by what I had said. They had perceived it as
- 50:28a potential road to rejection because she ate red meat. And it doesn't make
- 50:32any sense logically. But when you have a nitchy trigger finger on the interpretation
- 50:40of rejection and then the solution of control, then you see rejection where it's
- 50:45not really happening. Me saying I don't want to eat red meat. I
- 50:49don't even remember that's what it was. Something like that. She interpreted as
- 50:52well, that's one less thing we share in common. I'm already teetering on
- 50:59the fee that he's going to reject me, and this is I have to.
- 51:04So I feel a feeling of like, oh no, what if we
- 51:07can't share that together? And it was so far. It wasn't we didn't
- 51:10bond around whatever it was, it's had nothing to do with our relationship.
- 51:15It was just different from her right, and so she felt that fear I'm
- 51:21hypothesizing. And then her solution was control because that was model to her trial
- 51:25and error. She learned that's the only way or whatever, and so she
- 51:29was trying. And I remember as we were talking about my just random brainstorm
- 51:35that I was coming up with over brunch. I remember I started to feel
- 51:38afraid. As she's starting to get me to do this, I'm thinking,
- 51:42why is my heart pounding? Why amn't? Who cares? Okay, fine,
- 51:45I'll eat red meat. You know, it's that kind of dynamic.
- 51:47You amp that up, or you project that down the road a couple of
- 51:51years, and you have someone that has done that over and over and over
- 51:54again and has effectively eliminated all of my free will and my agency, and
- 52:02has full control over everything, what I eat, who I hang out with,
- 52:06what I say, how I dress, everything, because every perceived threat
- 52:10to attachment, every perceived rejection sign is instantly react to with control and with
- 52:17all these attacks. Right so the outside or even from the victim side,
- 52:22it just kind of looks like the perpetrator loves to provoke, they want to
- 52:29be in fights, and that's not the way to look at it, because
- 52:32if you are fully obedient, you know, you hand yourself over completely to
- 52:37the perpetrator, then in all likelihood the provocation will stop. And that's the
- 52:44temptation for the victim. It's like, Okay, I can try to fight
- 52:47back, which won't work, and we'll just escalate the abuse and my own
- 52:52confusion. And I also don't want to be rejected. I have my own
- 52:54attachment needs that this person fills, so I don't want that. And or
- 53:00I can put aside my personality, which sucks, but the abuse will go
- 53:05away, will have nice times, she'll be nice to me again, and
- 53:08everything will be fine. Okay, I'll I'll just let go of who I
- 53:12am, whether you consciously know that or not. Now for the rare psychopathic
- 53:16perpetrator of intimate partner violence. They might wake up in the morning and literally
- 53:21say, I'm going to provoke my partner because I want to, because I
- 53:23don't care about their feelings and I want to manipulate them. There are those
- 53:27people. They're rare, though, Okay, that most people are the way
- 53:30I'm describing where they feel, they have a reaction, and then their solution
- 53:34is to abuse and control. A typical tactic that these kind of people do
- 53:37is they smear campaign you and throughout every single possible bomb they can to make
- 53:44you look like an absolute horrible person before you tell your truth, so the
- 53:49world can be distracted from a miserable reality of who they really are. Yeah,
- 53:53this is not universal, of course, but it is common for abusers
- 54:00because they have more agency and they see their writing on the wall. Sometimes
- 54:07that the victim is maybe starting to talk with other people or someone else gets
- 54:12involved. A common example, A common profile this isn't universal, of course,
- 54:16but one that I've seen a lot is the perpetrator will go too far
- 54:21with the victimization. They might literally punch the victim in the face so that
- 54:27there's a lot of bruising, A lot of visible evidence of the abuse,
- 54:30and the perpetrator might even feel bad about it. That can happen. Perpetrators
- 54:36can feel shame. The way that perpetrators are framed on the Internet is not
- 54:40that way. And I'm not saying you're supposed to feel compassion for perpetrators,
- 54:45and I'm not saying you're supposed to go back to the perpetrators. A lot
- 54:49of times. Again, I should be clear because some of the time people
- 54:52will email me and say, Wow, your conceptualization of some perpetrators has helped
- 54:58me to have compassion for my abusive spouse. But I don't know what to
- 55:01do because I don't want to stay with them, but I know that they're
- 55:06only doing it because of their traumas this sort of thing. And what I
- 55:09want to be clear is that just because you can conceptualize in a compassionate way
- 55:15as to why the abusers being abusive, does not mean you need to stay
- 55:19with the abusive person. I am an expert when it comes to perpetration of
- 55:22abuse. I give me enough time with someone, I'll probably be able to
- 55:27confidently hypothesize as to which type it is, whether it's the type that might
- 55:32provoke some compassion for the person. It's based on their traumas and distortions.
- 55:36It's not really a choice that they make. I mean, they make choices
- 55:39and they're responsible for it, but there's some emotional trauma reasons as to why
- 55:46they are interpreting the world that way and why they're doing things like that.
- 55:50So I can tell the difference, or I can confidently hypothesize between that and
- 55:53between a psychopath anti social person who literally wakes up in the morning and gets
- 56:00off on harming other people. Not all psychopaths are like that, but some
- 56:04are. So I can tell the difference. And when I have encountered these
- 56:08people in my personal life, and I've encountered people on both sides, I
- 56:14will do everything in my power to get away from these people. I don't
- 56:16stick around these people. If I'm treating them, I stick around them,
- 56:21But I have a professional boundary. I have power in that relationship, right,
- 56:25I have the ability to terminate with them. I also have the power
- 56:30of my clinical license and my clinical expertise. If push came to shove and
- 56:37the police were called, my account would probably hold more weight depending you know.
- 56:43So I know that, and the perpetrator knows that and so I don't
- 56:47feel victimized. I don't feel unsafe generally speaking, because clients can make you
- 56:52feel unsafe sometimes. But but in my personal life, as soon as I
- 56:57detect it, and I have detected it in my life, I will see
- 57:00it from a mile away because of my experience with it. I'll be like,
- 57:04oh, wait, that person that I'm getting close to, or that
- 57:07person I'm working with, or that person that is a friend of a friend,
- 57:12they have some red flags there. I don't know, but it kind
- 57:15of looks this way. And as soon as I have little tests in my
- 57:17mind, it's like, okay, keep an eye and if this happens,
- 57:21then run. And if this happens, then maybe you weren't right. And
- 57:24over time I will start to see things more red flags, and I will
- 57:29very quickly and very definitively, without any question in my mind, without any
- 57:32guilt, I will distance myself from that person if I can help it.
- 57:37I don't go after the person and say you're abusive, get out of my
- 57:40life, because that doesn't usually extract me from them. That will just potentially
- 57:46entwine us more. And we could imagine what could happen from after that that
- 57:51wouldn't engage me more. What I do is I Gray Rock. If you've
- 57:55heard of that technique where you basically just become non interesting to the abusive person.
- 58:01You essentially you remove yourself from their radar. You're not a problem in
- 58:07their life, but you're also not really there, and you're not really manipulatable,
- 58:12but you're not actively opposing, which gives them something to push against.
- 58:15You're basically just nonexistent, and over time they stop targeting you, and they
- 58:22stop needing you, they stop wanting you for anything because you're not meeting their
- 58:25needs either direction, either to meet their needs attachment wise or to meet their
- 58:32needs to oppose someone. You know, they have those needs of contact.
- 58:36Right if if I can't contact you in a good way, I'll contact you
- 58:38in a bad way. And so if they can't contact you at all,
- 58:43and it's hard, you have to be you know, I'm an expert on
- 58:45this, not only in my professional life, but one could argue that I've
- 58:50I've gotten good at it in my personal life as well, because I've I've
- 58:52had a number of years on this planet. And when you're an expert on
- 58:54this sort of thing, because I specialized in treating perpetrators when I was twenty
- 59:00seven years old and beyond. So it's been since then. And nothing will
- 59:06teach you about domestic violence and my partner violence more than actually treating the perpetrators
- 59:10and hearing the stories from their victims. People who are actually convicted, the
- 59:15police were called, they go to court, they're convicted. These individuals usually
- 59:19have had a whole lifetime of abusing people by the time they actually get the
- 59:23police called on them, and by the time they actually get convicted. So
- 59:27you'll learn a lot. And boy did I learn a lot. It really
- 59:30is complicated and there's so many nuances to it. Anyway, so I've had
- 59:34a lot of practice, and you know, for me, it's not easy.
- 59:37It has a lot of uncertainty. But I do not stick around,
- 59:40and I have compassion for them. I'm like, oh, yeah, sometimes
- 59:45I know exactly where their traumas come from. I might even know who traumatize
- 59:47them growing up. I might have even been there when we were younger.
- 59:52I don't know, and I'll say, oh, it breaks my heart,
- 59:55and it's not my job to stick around with these people. I only get
- 59:59one time this planet. I'm not going to stick around being abused. I'm
- 1:00:01not going to be stressed out. I got better shit to do. And
- 1:00:06it sucks that the universe is organized in a way that those individuals who are
- 1:00:10traumatized, the most abandoned, the most harmed, are the most plagued emotionally
- 1:00:16and thus causing the most damage around them. They're causing a lot of damage
- 1:00:21around them. They didn't, you know, they didn't choose that childhood.
- 1:00:23Mildred didn't choose to have that childhood. It's a it's a crime on humanity
- 1:00:28that those kinds of things happen to begin with. Right, we can do
- 1:00:30a lot more to alleviate those and to mitigate those and reduce those, minimize
- 1:00:36those kinds of problems by having programs that tax dollars pay for to help parents,
- 1:00:40young parents or new parents, and help people with drug addiction, help
- 1:00:45people with trauma. Having talking about a crime on humanity, the fact that
- 1:00:51we have so many people suffering from trauma and literally there's no access to treatment
- 1:00:55or they don't have access to a competent treatment professional who knows what they're doing
- 1:01:00when it comes to trauma. So you want to talk about a crimou amunity,
- 1:01:02And if we did that if we allocated the tax dollars had those programs.
- 1:01:07And I'm not talking about whatever bill was passed recently in our national federal
- 1:01:10government of like ten billion or something dollars. It needs to be way,
- 1:01:15way more than that, and the benefits monetarily would be great because the effects,
- 1:01:22the downstream effects of trauma are so pervasive in our society. The amount
- 1:01:25of dropouts from school, the amount of future intimate partner violence, the amount
- 1:01:30of crime, the amount of child abuse. If we can nip it in
- 1:01:32the bud when the child is being raised, we can end the cycle of
- 1:01:37abuse that happens throughout the generations. Right, So you know, I'm just
- 1:01:42a little rant there, But so I want to be clear that when I
- 1:01:45present a compassionate hypothesis which I can't know about Mildred, I am not saying
- 1:01:52that Tiff should stay with Mildred if Mildred is abusive, and I have compassion
- 1:01:58for Mildred, and maybe Tiff have compassion for Mildred. If I were in
- 1:02:01TIFFs shoes, I would run and I would say, no, I got
- 1:02:06better shit to do with my life. I'm not Mildred's therapist. And even
- 1:02:12if I was I'm not going to stick around and be abused and wait twenty
- 1:02:15five years for some recovery. Even if Mildred was really dedicated to it,
- 1:02:20it might take a long time. So yeah, I just want to be
- 1:02:22clear about that. And you can see that when I was talking about Shiloh
- 1:02:27and her surgery, and out of nowhere she asked what the dates were and
- 1:02:31then went in very very hard before I couldn't even get a word out about
- 1:02:37my dog at that point, for God's sake, no less. Yeah,
- 1:02:39I don't know, but I would imagine that my previous model of understanding those
- 1:02:46provocations by the abuser was at play in that there was something about Tiff having
- 1:02:52to pay attention to the dog. It could literally just be that for Mildred,
- 1:02:57when Tiff is even loving the dog and liking the dog, just talking
- 1:03:01about the dog is a threat to Mildred's attachment security, and then that causes
- 1:03:07the deep pain and the deep worry and then the solution of control and bulldozing
- 1:03:12and trying to gaslight and beat someone down verbally. So we don't know,
- 1:03:19but I would imagine something like that was happening for Mildred. Go back to
- 1:03:23the day of where she got arrested. And here's what I mean by victim
- 1:03:29mentality, and again recognize the patterns because I know my fellow survivors are watching
- 1:03:32this right now and they're nodding their heads because it hits home. You cannot
- 1:03:37feed. Yeah, I'm going to take a guess and say that it's very
- 1:03:40true. Tiff has already talked about how a lot of victims have reached out
- 1:03:45and said, oh my god, I resonate with your story, please use
- 1:03:49your platform to talk more about it, or watching you or hearing your story
- 1:03:52has helped me to recover or helped me to leave my relationship or Yeah,
- 1:03:57so regardless of what has really happened, the way that Tip is talking is
- 1:04:01so quintessentially that of a recovering victim that undoubtedly it is helping others. It's
- 1:04:09really unfortunate that with all the content on the Internet or on your TV,
- 1:04:15that there's not enough of this. Clearly. It's always surprises me kind of
- 1:04:21because in my world, this is what we talk about all the time,
- 1:04:25and we have been talking about it for a long time. It's very much
- 1:04:29on our radar. The fact that intimate partner violence exists and the way that
- 1:04:32it looks, and that victimization is continuing to happen. Clients continue to come
- 1:04:39into my office and it's just a part of my life, right, But
- 1:04:44for everyday people it's not. And for those everyday people, they might be
- 1:04:49victimized and haven't been reminded that here are the science, here's what it looks
- 1:04:56like. You have rights this kind of thing, and so we need more
- 1:05:00of this, And good for Tiff for putting it out there. Okay,
- 1:05:02well let's take a break and when we get back, we'll continue watching tips
- 1:05:06video. Gay personality. You can push it like a rubber band, just
- 1:05:15like how some people can push their personality to act a certain way around their
- 1:05:18in laws during Thanksgiving, But then as soon as they come home and back
- 1:05:21to their baseline personality, they're like, that was a lot. So eventually
- 1:05:27these people will show them for who they are, and that's what it is.
- 1:05:31So going back to the day she got arrested, here's what I mean
- 1:05:34by victim mentality. Yes, she threw a dog a heavy dollgate at me
- 1:05:39at the top of the huge stairca case, and yes she admitted to hitting
- 1:05:42me and following me. It got to a point where my own safety was
- 1:05:45an absolute immediate question because we know and never starts with the big things,
- 1:05:51And as soon as I called the police, from my experience, she immediately
- 1:05:57stopped throwing things at me in that moment. Okay, we're getting more details.
- 1:06:00I don't know if I showed the clip, but Tiff disclosed that Tiff,
- 1:06:04of course knew about the arrest and this event prior to the reunion.
- 1:06:10It sounds like it happened between the shooting of the show and the reunion,
- 1:06:13right and Tiff said to production, had a long conversation with the production saying,
- 1:06:18I don't want to talk about it because I don't know where I'm at
- 1:06:23with it. I don't know what to do with it. I don't want
- 1:06:26to get into it. I don't want to throw people under the bus.
- 1:06:28And maybe even Tiff is saying now, I wasn't really where I am now.
- 1:06:31I even hypothesized about that during the reunion. I was wondering if Tiff
- 1:06:36had recovered somewhat from the abuse. Has Ungas lit themselves to some extent,
- 1:06:43but not fully because we heard when Tiff ran outside having a fight or flight
- 1:06:49reaction understandable a lot of triggering happening with Mildred, and then Sam followed Tiff
- 1:06:57out, and Tiff was immediately trying to justify themselves to Sam's like, and
- 1:07:02Sam is like, you don't have to justify yourself, which is really great
- 1:07:05that Sam said that. I was just really really intuitive. And Sam's like,
- 1:07:10Hey, you don't have to. You don't justify yourself. You're good.
- 1:07:14You know, I believe you, I'm with you, And trying to
- 1:07:17justify yourself implies that somehow I'm on the fence about this or that other people
- 1:07:23are. No, You're good, And so at the time, I was
- 1:07:25hypothesizing that Tiff was still in that mindset of not really knowing. There's a
- 1:07:30part of Tiff that was saying, I deserve better treatment that is abusive,
- 1:07:35but maybe I'm wrong, and maybe Mildred is right, maybe I am stupid
- 1:07:40and I do deserve it, and was in that transition zone, as evidenced
- 1:07:44by TIFF's language and further down the road by the time Tiff makes this video,
- 1:07:48which could be several months even after the reunion, I don't know Tiff
- 1:07:53is now saying, no, I am not ambivalent anymore about what I went
- 1:07:58through, and I'm any intrusive thought that somehow I'm to blame or I deserved
- 1:08:03it is very quickly dealt with or might not even emerge in me anymore because
- 1:08:08I've done enough recovery. I talked about it enough, I've educated myself enough,
- 1:08:12I have a lot of support, I've established a lot of secure relationships,
- 1:08:16I've gotten centered, I've got a lot of therapy, that sort of
- 1:08:18thing. And so Tiff was saying that Tiff was talking to the producers about
- 1:08:24the arrest and saying, I don't know if I want to talk about it.
- 1:08:27In fact, I'm pretty sure I don't want to talk about it.
- 1:08:28And maybe it was because of that ambivalence that was still at play for Tiff,
- 1:08:32and or Tiff was like, I don't want to talk about as I've
- 1:08:36extracted myself from Mildred and if we get into it, it just will engage
- 1:08:41Mildred and then I might enact more abuse after the reunion, I just want
- 1:08:45to get away from the situation, so I don't want to bring it up.
- 1:08:48Interestingly, Mildred was the one that brought it up, right, which
- 1:08:53is I don't It's interesting did Mildred bring it up because Mildred thought that Tiff
- 1:08:58would, so Mildred want to get wanted to get out ahead of it.
- 1:09:00We did see in the reunion that when Mildred did bring it up, immediately
- 1:09:06was throwing up a smokescreen that seemed to work on Tiff actually by talking about
- 1:09:12a completely different subject blaming Tiff. She Mildred brought it up, which was
- 1:09:16this huge bomb and then proceeds to completely dominate and then eventually as telling Tiff
- 1:09:24to shut up because she doesn't like the way Tiff talks, she doesn't like
- 1:09:27the sound of her voice or something. So we heard that, and then
- 1:09:30we're also hearing now more details according to Tiff, that Mildred was at the
- 1:09:34top of the stairs throwing a heavy dog door gait it sounds like down the
- 1:09:38stairs at Tiff, and then Tiff left and Mildred followed. So that's very
- 1:09:45indicative of it if you're a victim, if you're claiming as Mildred being the
- 1:09:49victim, and this is exactly, this is indeed what happened. Victims typically
- 1:09:54don't chase. They can chase at times, especially if they're afraid, or
- 1:09:58you can push a victim to lose their temper at times, and they can
- 1:10:01end up chasing. It just kind of depends, but typically on average,
- 1:10:06the perpetrator is the chaser and the victim is the runner, which makes sense,
- 1:10:13right. So we're hearing that, and then Tiff called the police and
- 1:10:15according to Tiff, Mildred immediately calmed down. So this is a sign of
- 1:10:21an abusive individual. So Tiff keeps bringing up all these memes and quotes about
- 1:10:30narcissistic abuse. I wish that people would just say abuse, because that's a
- 1:10:34strong enough word and it might not necessarily derive from narcissism abuse. I feel
- 1:10:41like in today's world, certain words have lost their power. And when I
- 1:10:45was coming up to say that someone was abusive was a huge bomb to drop.
- 1:10:49Now, since people throw that word around so much, it has lost
- 1:10:54its power. So I think people feel like they have to add an adjective,
- 1:10:58some sort of clinical, clinical power to it, so they say narcissistic
- 1:11:01abuse. What is narcisistic abuse? We don't really have a clear set of
- 1:11:05criteria for that, but generally speaking, in the literature, narcisistic abuse is
- 1:11:10when someone with narcissistic personality disorder, which is a very rare and particular kind
- 1:11:15of disorder when they have their narcissistic defensive structure threatened, which I won't go
- 1:11:23into use on my episodes and deep dives on that, then one style of
- 1:11:29dealing with that threat to their narcissistic structure. And they use narcistic defenses as
- 1:11:34a way of protecting themselves from a deep sense of not knowing who they are
- 1:11:38and hating themselves. And they are heavily convinced even themselves of the narcissism that
- 1:11:44they're better than others anyway. And so when you threaten that, then some
- 1:11:47of them will abuse you in a variety of ways, all the ways that
- 1:11:50you can imagine, to get you to stop from threatening their ability to remain
- 1:11:56in the delusion that they're superior and better than everyone else. So they will
- 1:12:00abuse people. That's what we might call narcissistic abuse. I have never used
- 1:12:04the term narcissistic abuse in my writing and my speaking and my clinical I don't
- 1:12:09even think along those lines. But for some reason on the Internet it's a
- 1:12:13thing, and I think what people contextually, I can think that they're what
- 1:12:17they're thinking about narcissisic abuse. They're talking about psychopathic abuse, meaning that someone
- 1:12:24sets out to harm you they wake up in the morning like I'm going to
- 1:12:26get that person and or they're just talking about abuse. Abuse of people are
- 1:12:30very sure themselves, they feel very entitled. They show a lack of empathy,
- 1:12:33they show a lack of remorse. Whether or not they actually lack empathy
- 1:12:38or actually lack remorse is it depends on the situation. Someone can show a
- 1:12:43lack of remorse and show a lack of empathy, but actually they are capable
- 1:12:46of empathy and remorse, but issues get in the way of That doesn't justify
- 1:12:50it, of course, But I think what people are talking about to say
- 1:12:53narcissis they're just saying abuse. We should try to bring that word back from
- 1:12:59people who have misused it and say abuse is a very big deal, regardless
- 1:13:04of whatever any additive words to it. You can just say that person is
- 1:13:09abusive and that should be a big deal. But I feel like it's lost
- 1:13:13its power because people use it so much. Gaslighting is becoming that way.
- 1:13:15And my world, gaslighting was a big deal. It was a part of
- 1:13:18an abusive relationship. Now people use gaslighting when your friend is trying to convince
- 1:13:24you not to go to McDonald's when you want to go to bird King.
- 1:13:27It's like, well McDonald's is better. Hey, you're gaslighting me. I
- 1:13:29mean literally, I'm not even joking. People will claim that that's gaslighting and
- 1:13:33language is language, but yikes, just say you're trying to convince me,
- 1:13:39you're lying to me. But because of persuasion and lying and deception, these
- 1:13:45words becoming just thrown around everywhere. People feel like that the resort to a
- 1:13:49stronger word. But we should just take back our words from people who misuse
- 1:13:54it and really emphasize that deception and trickery is horrible in a moral it's wrong
- 1:14:00to lie flat out anyway. So let's rewind because I we're hearing some details
- 1:14:05from Tiff regarding the incident, the big things, and as soon as I
- 1:14:10called the police, from my experience, she immediately stopped throwing things at me.
- 1:14:16In that moment, I just keep interrupting about this is such a great
- 1:14:19video that Tip is making. It gives me a lot of opportunity to use
- 1:14:23it as a jumping off point. So for abusive individuals, they are kind
- 1:14:29of in control of their behavior, which makes it seem like it's psychopathic,
- 1:14:32because psychopaths aren't necessarily emotionally reactive. They can be, but often when they're
- 1:14:39conning or lying or manipulating, they're not necessarily emotionally provoked. They just use
- 1:14:44other people. They don't care about other people. But the vast majority of
- 1:14:46abusers are not that. When people came to our program having been convicted of
- 1:14:51domestic violence intimate partner violence, the first thing we had to do was run
- 1:14:56an assessment of a pretty involved assessment, and a major finding from that assessment
- 1:15:00was trying to figure out whether or not the person was a classic DV abuser,
- 1:15:05a classic intimate partner violence abuser or fits within that category, or someone
- 1:15:11that had an anger management problem, and people that have anger management problems might
- 1:15:15occasionally be abusive to their partners. And for those people, they didn't need
- 1:15:20to go through the full year long program of animate partner violence. What they
- 1:15:25needed to do was learn how to emotionally regulate. For people with intimate partner
- 1:15:30violence problems, it's basically a personality disorder or an indoctrination into a way of
- 1:15:35believing and thinking and perceiving that it's really hard to deprogram someone of that.
- 1:15:42You and the beauty of this group format was that more advanced participants who were
- 1:15:46convicted and were say eleven months into the program, typically had seen the light
- 1:15:53and realized how they were deluding themselves earlier on. That was perpetuating the abuse
- 1:15:58because at the time the perpetrators would enter our group and would say, I
- 1:16:02didn't do anything wrong, and the police are biased against men, or it
- 1:16:06was mutual abuse, you know, all that kind of stuff, and over
- 1:16:09time we would disabuse them of that notion. And so the more advanced participants
- 1:16:16would very plainly talk to the more novice participants in a way that we didn't
- 1:16:26or couldn't professionally and ethically, and they would really go after him. Now,
- 1:16:29if it was getting out of hand, we would, you say,
- 1:16:31people use the ground rules. But they were just much more reactive to the
- 1:16:36novice participants and just be like, that's some serious bullshit. I used to
- 1:16:41be like that too, but that's bullshit what you're thinking right there. And
- 1:16:44it was also helpful because the more novice participants. It's one thing to get
- 1:16:48it from a professional, right, a professional that's like, well, you're
- 1:16:51a professional, you don't really know my world and you're supposed to say this.
- 1:16:56It's another thing when another participant who was also convict did of a very
- 1:17:00similar crime that you were and telling you that there's another way to think about
- 1:17:05it and that you're wrong right. It had a lot of power to it.
- 1:17:10It was a really excellent element. It was a very useful effective element
- 1:17:15of that form of treatment. Anyway, My point is is that you had
- 1:17:18the anger management folks who had a general problem with anger in that in every
- 1:17:25situation, regardless of the context, when they were provoked to anger or threat,
- 1:17:30it could even literally just be PTSD that they're suffering from, and they
- 1:17:33need treatment for that. That They react very quickly because they have a very
- 1:17:39quick fight or flight response, and they need ways of managing that the trigger
- 1:17:43is that kind of thing. But they don't have the mindset of an abuser.
- 1:17:45They do have empathy, they do care. These people, typically after
- 1:17:50the event of being violent with their partner would feel a lot of remorse,
- 1:17:55be like I don't know, I just saw red or I don't even remember
- 1:17:57what happened. Sometimes they literally be asking for help, can you help me.
- 1:18:00That's a lot different than the perpetrator. The perpetrator come in like I
- 1:18:02didn't do anything wrong. I'm the victim here. So for the perpetrators,
- 1:18:08they did not have an anger management problem. Typically they were able to manage
- 1:18:12their emotions, not extremely well, but they weren't like completely flying off the
- 1:18:16handle. They weren't completely out of control. They could be sometimes you would
- 1:18:20have both, but at least what Tif's talking about is that Mildred was not
- 1:18:24that type and that as Mildred was being triggered, I'm guessing around some sort
- 1:18:30of rejection goes after Tiff with abuse. Tiff is probably drawing more boundaries.
- 1:18:34At this point, Mildred is escalating more and more and more. Maybe it's
- 1:18:39extended over a period of time. Mildred doesn't usually resort to violence, but
- 1:18:43does when Mildred feels like Tiff is having power or getting away, maybe even
- 1:18:48Tiff was leaving the house, I don't know. Mildred picks up the dog
- 1:18:51door throws it at Tiff, and then Tiff caused the police, and in
- 1:18:56that moment, Mildred isn't completely out of control, is able to at least
- 1:19:00get it kind of under control. And I talked about this during the reunion
- 1:19:04that for abusive people, they have kind of a superpower or a villain superpower
- 1:19:12where under stress it's so familiar to them and they are the ones driving the
- 1:19:18bus there. You know, often the abusers will start the problem right,
- 1:19:21they will provoke, they will escalate it that they feel comfortable and it's not
- 1:19:29as stressful. It's stressful to them, but not as stressful, nearly as
- 1:19:32stressful as it is for others. When I've experienced that, when people have
- 1:19:35been abusive with me, I have a particular I don't know. I didn't
- 1:19:39grow up with any of that. My parents were not abusive. I never
- 1:19:43saw abuse growing up. It was pretty late in life, well in my
- 1:19:47twenties, when I started to oh, what's this? And so for me,
- 1:19:50I'm not comfortable with it at all, And a little bit goes a
- 1:19:54long way with me, and I skyrocket my heart and I can't think,
- 1:20:00and I'm freaking out and I wouldn't be able to calm myself down. You
- 1:20:03know. Sometimes that'll happen, Even to this day, something will happen and
- 1:20:08I'll be distressed and disregulated and kind of worn out emotionally for days and I
- 1:20:15just feel like I need to vege on the couch that whole time, just
- 1:20:18being like, oh, I can't do anything today, and so It's not
- 1:20:21very often, but it happens. So for victims and are non abusive people,
- 1:20:29we tend to be more affected by conflict depending you know, there's other
- 1:20:31reasons that will mitigate that and subdue that, like dissociation or something. But
- 1:20:35for the perpetrator, this is where they live half the time, and they're
- 1:20:42comfortable, so in some ways they might even calm down allt it a little
- 1:20:45bit, particularly if they're gaining control, because that does calm them, that
- 1:20:50does make them feel safer. They're in a very twisted way, they're trying
- 1:20:55to achieve safety, but at the very least they just feel very calm,
- 1:20:58so when the police are called, the abusers have the ability to just calm
- 1:21:03down or at least not present in an abusive way or in a way that's
- 1:21:08out of control. Some abusers will literally even amp up they're out of controlness
- 1:21:12as a way of trying to intimidate the other person, right, they'll pick
- 1:21:15up the chair and throw it a crossroom, and they know they're doing it
- 1:21:19for an effect. Other people with an angry management problem might just be so
- 1:21:25out of control that there and then afterwards like what I do. Whereas the
- 1:21:29abusive person might be mostly involved in that decision, and thus when the police
- 1:21:35are called and it serves them to stop doing those things, they have the
- 1:21:40ability to turn it off. She sat down started screaming and crying and she
- 1:21:45told me this, look at what you did. They're going to take my
- 1:21:50son away from me. Again. I was shamed. Yeah, so that's
- 1:21:57what perpetrators will do, right that they're on a mission to break you down.
- 1:22:01And now that you have the upper hand because the police are coming and
- 1:22:04they know it. They know that when the police come, there's a chance
- 1:22:10that they're going to lose power and thus they're going to lose their safe place,
- 1:22:14right, so they need to do everything they can. And one of
- 1:22:16the things they will resort to is to try to smoke screen and try to
- 1:22:21guilt trip and say, look what you're doing. You're going to take my
- 1:22:25child away from me? How dare you? And if you're in TIFFs position,
- 1:22:29you might be like, oh, yeah, I don't want that to
- 1:22:30happen, and yeah, that'll happen. A lot. Victims of ongoing abuse
- 1:22:34will have a lot of stories in this camp. The perpetrator will convince the
- 1:22:39victim of consequences that will happen for them or the family. Another one is
- 1:22:44they'll say, you know, if you call the police, I will kill
- 1:22:47you, or I will take your kids away from you. You know that
- 1:22:50will happen. I have dirt on you. I have a file in my
- 1:22:55safe of pictures of you doing things like smoking, crack or whatever, something
- 1:23:00to implicate I will ruin you, or I possess all the power because I've
- 1:23:05sufficiently eliminated your ability to power and money. So I have all the power
- 1:23:10and money, and I have a team of lawyers, believe me, or
- 1:23:13my cousins a lawyer and he hates you. You know that, and you
- 1:23:17do not want to cross me. So it's possible that Mildred is kind of
- 1:23:21in that camp, trying to manipulate Tiff and hopefully have Tiff call the police
- 1:23:27off or something. For protecting myself. I immediately felt horrible for protecting myself
- 1:23:32and calling for help over my own safety. This is how much she has
- 1:23:38spent years manipulating me to the point where it became so second nature because I
- 1:23:43did not establish strong boundaries in the beginning of the relationship. Another thing that
- 1:23:47we've seen on this channel, when I was reacting to Amaranth was for the
- 1:23:51perpetrator to use the dogs, to use the pets. Tiff loves the dog
- 1:23:58right as most good dog owners do, including myself, and Mildred could have
- 1:24:03done that, we don't know. But with Amaranth's husband, we did hear
- 1:24:08that right that he I think literally threatened to kill the dogs if Amaranth the
- 1:24:15wife didn't succumb and obey him. So that's another thing that could be used.
- 1:24:19Also the kids. Right now, it's not TIFF's child, but if
- 1:24:23say it was their child, then perpetrators will often resort to that, will
- 1:24:28say don't fight in front of the kids as a way of trying to control,
- 1:24:31or if you leave me, you'll never see your kid again, or
- 1:24:36if you leave me, then I'm going to get the kid. I'm going
- 1:24:40to throw the kid off a cliff or literally people will say stuff like that,
- 1:24:43and sometimes it literally happens where perpetrators will kill the kids, will kill
- 1:24:48the victim. And she were eyeliner in our relationship, and on top of
- 1:24:51that, I also wear eyeliner. So as far as the sex board games
- 1:24:57go, I broke up with her in September of twenty twenty two, and
- 1:25:00I'm guessing she's talking about this right here where I ordered off of Amazon in
- 1:25:03October after I broke up with her and I was going on dating apps and
- 1:25:08dating other people. Here you can see I purchased that around the time of
- 1:25:11the breakup. So I'm guessing you're trying to semear campaign and twist the narrative
- 1:25:15even more of some sex board games when all it really was just a deck
- 1:25:19of cards and getting to know someone you're dating. Okay, yeah, well
- 1:25:25I suspected it was something along these lines when Mildred was saying those things.
- 1:25:29I couldn't know. But even if what Mildred said was accurate, I think
- 1:25:33I said at the time, it doesn't matter if Tiff ordered or bought a
- 1:25:40sex board game, because if you're broken up and Tiff and you are dating
- 1:25:45other people, or at least the expectation is that you can, then what's
- 1:25:51the difference what Tiff is buying online. Tiff could have bought and purchased all
- 1:25:57sorts of things in that direction. That's not an ointment on Tiff. It's
- 1:26:00an indictment on you that you're pointing it out. But Tiff reacted like,
- 1:26:04what are you talking about sex board game? And then you didn't see it
- 1:26:08on my screen, but it was a deck of cards that it just I
- 1:26:11think it just said dating on it, and it were it was fifty questions
- 1:26:15that you would, you know, draw from the deck and I'm guessing questions
- 1:26:18like what's your biggest dream in life or something like that, and it's a
- 1:26:24it's a and maybe there's some sexual questions in there, who knows. But
- 1:26:28I wouldn't call it a sex board game. You would call it a dating,
- 1:26:31get to know each other card game. So yeah, interesting. Now
- 1:26:34maybe Mildred can say no, no, no, I know, I know
- 1:26:38it was this and it was that, but again it doesn't It was all
- 1:26:42part of that that seeming smokescreen that Mildred was trying to put up as a
- 1:26:46way of deflecting from the arrest that Mildred was disclosing. Tiff has gone over
- 1:26:54a lot of other details, refuting a lot of other things that Mildred was
- 1:26:58saying, seemingly indicating it. You know, if Tiff is being accurate here,
- 1:27:01that Mildred was trying a lot of things to try to discount what Tiff
- 1:27:08was saying, trying to protect Mildred's image, So that would be in line
- 1:27:13with what an abusive person would do. For those of you out there who
- 1:27:15have been in a prolonged abusive relationship with a partner, it can go so
- 1:27:21much more beyond this, even right when you have kids together, when you
- 1:27:26own a house together, when your families know each other, when your occupations
- 1:27:32are intertwined. The extent to which an abuser will go after you for the
- 1:27:38rest of your life is you know, extreme abusers will just continue. They
- 1:27:44won't let it go. Partially, I think, because it depends, but
- 1:27:47I think some of the times they're actually trying to get the victim back and
- 1:27:51they want again. As I was saying in an earlier video, they'll take
- 1:27:55good contact, but if they can't get good contact, they'll take bad contact.
- 1:27:59They just want contact because they lack secure attachments in their life, so
- 1:28:03you know, they'll take what they can get. And if they can just
- 1:28:05get you to engage with them negatively, even if you're screaming at them telling
- 1:28:10them to go away, at least it's some contact, so they might do
- 1:28:14it for that reason. Another reason, as perpetrators might be deeply wounded,
- 1:28:17they will feel wronged by the victim because the victim left and so they will
- 1:28:23feel humiliated and they feel like they need to right that wrong. They also
- 1:28:28will try to use it as a way of garnering attention and sympathy from others.
- 1:28:32It's amazing how well a perpetrator can convince everyone around the relationship that the
- 1:28:40perpetrator is the victim and that the victim is the perpetrator, or at the
- 1:28:44very least that the victim wronged the perpetrator. You know. And the other
- 1:28:49complicating factor is that the perpetrator comes from a family where in all likelihood there
- 1:28:54was a lot of chaos and abuse there as well, and so there's a
- 1:28:58lot of confusion and a lot of a matchment worries within that family. And
- 1:29:01so you can find a perpetrator that will get their entire family behind them for
- 1:29:06various different toxic reasons. And it's a whole other part of it. You
- 1:29:12can effectively extract yourself from a relationship like this with support and treatment, and
- 1:29:16you have potentially the law behind you and other systems of power. That's usually
- 1:29:23what you need to effectively get away. And even then, after you do
- 1:29:27everything perfectly and you get out of the relationship, the perpetrator still has the
- 1:29:30ability to harangue you and hound you and bother you and ruin your life.
- 1:29:38It's really really awful. And when it comes to that kind of behavior,
- 1:29:42unless it crosses some legal boundary, but even then sometimes there's almost nothing a
- 1:29:47victim can do. They just have to take it, especially when you have
- 1:29:50kids with the abuse of individual and you have to share custody, which is
- 1:29:56usually what happens. It is a lifetime of pay, a lifetime of annoyance.
- 1:30:01You as a victim might start dating someone or being serious with another person,
- 1:30:08may be engaged, maybe married to another person. And you might even
- 1:30:11have to hide those details from your former partner who was abusive, even though
- 1:30:15you broke up with them fifteen years ago. It's really and then you can't
- 1:30:18go on Facebook because if or you can't be public about things, and you
- 1:30:23have to tell your partner, look, don't post pictures of us. You're
- 1:30:26in a constant state of being controlled. And the perpetrators gets away with it
- 1:30:30because according to the law it doesn't cross any lines. It should that should
- 1:30:35be changed. Stocking a lot of stocking behaviors, and you could argue this
- 1:30:40is in that category is not illegal. People get away with it that needs
- 1:30:45to stop. I hope in a number of years in the future we will
- 1:30:48wake up to this fact and we will have an effective It's a harder line
- 1:30:53to draw legally, right when someone kills another person, it's pretty discreet right
- 1:30:59that their person was alive before they were shot, and now they're dead after
- 1:31:01their When it comes to defining the line between just conflicts between former spouses and
- 1:31:09harassment, it's hard to tell. But the fact is is that a lot
- 1:31:15of people are being harassed, and traditionally anyway, the victims of harassment were
- 1:31:19women. And because our society doesn't care about women's voices and is willing to
- 1:31:25say, well, you know, just move on, then as a society
- 1:31:29and as a legal structure, we don't take action. We don't have If
- 1:31:34old white men were being regularly harassed in the same way that the way that
- 1:31:39I'm describing, I'm going to take a guess and say that something would have
- 1:31:42changed a long time ago. But as things start to change in terms of
- 1:31:45power structure, a lot more older white men are being abused this way,
- 1:31:49and so the end we have a lot of other people taking power and through
- 1:31:57activism saying maybe other people should have power not just old white men. And
- 1:32:02so you start to see these movements and these awarenesses and the possibility that these
- 1:32:09kinds of laws will be changed. I'm not a legal expert on this.
- 1:32:13Maybe in some jurisdictions there are some minor laws about this, but I do
- 1:32:17know from experience that and we almost have this normalize. It's like, well,
- 1:32:21it's just someone being a jerk face. You can't make that illegal.
- 1:32:25The problem is is that when you have a systematic abuse and harassment from AFAR,
- 1:32:30even if the perpetrator never sees the victim, but if they send enough
- 1:32:34messages and enough letters, and enough fear essentially is induced within the victim,
- 1:32:42then that's abusive, and that's wrong. It's morally wrong. And it's also
- 1:32:45I would argue it's morally wrong for a society to do nothing about it and
- 1:32:49to not have measures in place, at the very least some sort of program
- 1:32:54that will give people the resources to get away from you. And there are
- 1:33:00intimate partner violence domestic violence programs that can help with this. All right,
- 1:33:03Well, it's been a while since we took a break, so let's take
- 1:33:05a break right now. And if that's so, and this is indeed what
- 1:33:14you're referring to, which pretty much adds up. Then it means that you
- 1:33:18just admitted on national television of opening my mail without my consent. That is
- 1:33:24a felony. Let that's sinking. She also admitted to throwing a doggate on
- 1:33:28me, and in the police report you'll see her making a statement of mentioning
- 1:33:30anything nothing about a doggate. Instead. Her first testimony upon arrests says that
- 1:33:35she hit me multiple times, and then in the second testimony she got cuffed,
- 1:33:40she said that she did not hit me, that I'm too strong for
- 1:33:43her to hit and that doesn't Okay, this is interesting and trigger warning obviously,
- 1:33:46this whole series of episodes, but maybe this particular passage. I think
- 1:33:51this is a police report allegedly that Tiff is publishing quotes from Mildred. I
- 1:33:58didn't want to be around her anymore, so I pushed her away from me.
- 1:34:01She began to hold my arm and tried to calm me down. Okay,
- 1:34:05she began to hold She began to hold my arm and tried to calm
- 1:34:09me down. Well, that's interesting, but this first instance, I didn't
- 1:34:13want to be around her anymore, so I pushed her away from me.
- 1:34:15So according to Mildred, Mildred was trying to get away from Tiff, and
- 1:34:20then Tiff grabbed Mildred's arm and said, calm down. And then I pushed
- 1:34:27her off of me because I didn't want her to hold me anymore. She
- 1:34:30got out of bed and told me I was a trash mother and walked away.
- 1:34:34I followed her out of the room, and once again she called me
- 1:34:38a trash mother. So, by the way, I don't know if I
- 1:34:41showed this clip that Tiff admitted and stood by the statement that Mildred because Mildred
- 1:34:45during the review to say Tiff called me a trash mother, and we didn't
- 1:34:48hear any response from Tif at the time. But Tiff is now saying,
- 1:34:50yeah, I did occasionally call, or at least once called Mildred a trash
- 1:34:57mother or indicted her parenting skills because Mildred would often do a lot of things
- 1:35:02in front of the kids fighting. For example, I would often tell Mildred
- 1:35:06to stop that, and so, yeah, I would criticize her parenting,
- 1:35:11and yeah, I imagine that that was a part of it. You know.
- 1:35:15I could also imagine even if you are being victimized, that you might
- 1:35:18be occasionally a jerk face about someone else's parenting. It doesn't mean that you're
- 1:35:23not a victim. So who knows. But now, what are the ways
- 1:35:27that one can convince someone to pay attention to parenting more? Just calling someone
- 1:35:33a name isn't necessarily the best way. But you know, under the circumstances,
- 1:35:36we can imagine that things would escalate to that point going on, So
- 1:35:41in another statement, sounds like maybe later according to tiff Mildred provides another statement
- 1:35:46to the police. I did not hit Tiffany out of anger today, So
- 1:35:50admitting hitting, I did not throw a dog fence at her. It was
- 1:35:55really heavy. I wouldn't throw that. I never punched Tiffany in her should.
- 1:36:00I threw my own phone, but I never threw her phone. I
- 1:36:04never pushed her against the wall. I can't push her. She's too strong
- 1:36:08for me. This doesn't make sense, Okay, Well, I don't know.
- 1:36:11I don't know what to make of these accounts. Could Mildred be lying.
- 1:36:15If Mildred is a perpetrator, then yeah, they typically will lie when
- 1:36:20the police shut up. Could Mildred and tiff have different memories, and there's
- 1:36:26some truth to what Mildred is saying here, maybe, but it doesn't really
- 1:36:30change the overall look. And that's really one of the main things that I
- 1:36:33want to establish here is that you can't tell from one or it's hard to
- 1:36:39tell from one instance, even if someone is being violent with another person,
- 1:36:42you can't tell the overall pattern abuse. That word is used in a lot
- 1:36:45of different contexts, but typically when we're talking about an abusive relationship, or
- 1:36:49we're trying to determine if someone is a victim of abuse, or we're trying
- 1:36:54to determine if someone is a perpetrator of abuse, we're talking about ongoing.
- 1:36:59We're talking about a pattern. We're talking about a breaking down of someone's of
- 1:37:02the victim's sense of safety, in their sense of agency. We're talking about
- 1:37:06a prolonged relationship where there's a progression typically, and that's what we're talking about
- 1:37:14when we're talking about the cycle of abuse or what we're trying to end.
- 1:37:16When we say end abuse, now, of course we would also be potentially
- 1:37:21saying, let's end individual abusive acts. But there can be an abusive act
- 1:37:26within a relationship and not the overall pattern of abusive behavior that would cause a
- 1:37:30victim to feel ongoing victimization. So when we even go over the details of
- 1:37:36this police report, we can't really know what that means to the overall relationship.
- 1:37:43A lot of data is given to us on camera, and I guess
- 1:37:46now from Tiff that points much more. You know, let's say in this
- 1:37:51in this police report that Mildred is completely accurate, that if there was a
- 1:37:56video camera, everything or most of the things that Mildred is saying here is
- 1:37:59accurate. That doesn't mean that Tiff wasn't a victim of ongoing abuse. So
- 1:38:03I don't know if it really matters what we think of this police report.
- 1:38:09There has power and control over them, not just physically but emotionally. It's
- 1:38:13contradicting, and as always, things are twisted to the point where she can't
- 1:38:16keep up in a desperate attempt to fit her narrative. And as far as
- 1:38:20the rent situation goes, when you're being gaslet for so long to back in
- 1:38:25the reunion, I essentially became so confused and I was thinking of eight or
- 1:38:28nine other accusations she laid on me and shifting it right to another accusation,
- 1:38:32which again is abusive, and I get to a point where I become so
- 1:38:36confused and flustered that I barely even know what I'm talking about this point.
- 1:38:41Yeah, it did look like that, And that gets back to what I
- 1:38:45was seeing in an earlier video that victims and shall we say, non perpetrators
- 1:38:50in general, when you are in a conflict and a debate, there's at
- 1:38:55least some semblance of trying to be logical or trying to be reasonable, trying
- 1:38:59to a debate on good faith that the other person is also at least kind
- 1:39:04of open. Now, in most conflicts that's not necessarily true. But the
- 1:39:09problem with that assumption for non perpetrators is that when the perpetrator just throws a
- 1:39:15lot of stuff at you, and they're so sure themselves, and they've been
- 1:39:20often rehearsing these things because through trial and error, and they're a bit obsessive
- 1:39:25about this using this AMMO, they have rehearsed it in their head. They
- 1:39:30have a solid argument that they're going to make the argument. None of the
- 1:39:33points of the argument might hold any water, all of it might be ridiculous,
- 1:39:39but they have it all kind of laid out and they're throwing it at
- 1:39:42you, Whereas you have not been rehearsing, and you don't have ammunition at
- 1:39:46the ready, because that's not how you're oriented. And so all of this
- 1:39:50is coming at you and you try to respond and you start wait, and
- 1:39:57you also it's natural to forget. Also, your fighter is kicking in,
- 1:40:00your brain isn't working quite right, and you start to think, wait,
- 1:40:03so maybe are they right about that? Did that? And it just keeps
- 1:40:06coming and coming, and the effort on the part of the non perpetrator to
- 1:40:14try to work something out is used against the victim because the perpetrator is not
- 1:40:19there to work anything out. They're there to control, and so the only
- 1:40:24solution often to these interactions is to just not engage. Now. The problem
- 1:40:30is, though, if you are a victim, especially currently but in the
- 1:40:35future, you need to have a lot of measures in place depending on the
- 1:40:40level of danger. But let's just always assume there's a much higher level of
- 1:40:45danger than even you would think, because sometimes it is that way that you
- 1:40:48need to have a lot of measures in place, a lot of support,
- 1:40:51a lot of treatment, a lot of power, a lot of people on
- 1:40:55your side, a lot of resources, a lot of options, Like you
- 1:41:00have a way out of the house, you have a go bag, you
- 1:41:02have keys, to the car, you have a friend that you can call,
- 1:41:06and you know that you're going to be at a certain place to pick
- 1:41:10that. You know there's all these systems a place. Because even if you're
- 1:41:14going to do anything like this, like you're gonna not engage, as I
- 1:41:17said earlier, the perpetrator will not like that. To not engage with a
- 1:41:24perpetrator when they are shotgunning and machine gunning a lot of things at you will
- 1:41:30be a threat to them, and they will escalate because if that doesn't,
- 1:41:34you know, usually that will work to discombobulate you and or at least keep
- 1:41:39you engaged where you're just like no. And we saw a bit of that
- 1:41:42with Tiff and Mildred when they were in front of the fireplace right that Mildred
- 1:41:47was just throwing all sorts of stuff, and you see Tiff trying to trying
- 1:41:51to refute certain things and at no point, I mean, Mildred did eventually
- 1:41:57kind of soften up. So we'll give credit work credits to do there.
- 1:42:00But anyway, so when that's happening to you and you push back, you
- 1:42:04say I'm just not gonna participated, that will very much provoke a perpetrator because
- 1:42:10one, you're taking away their power, which is the way to safety for
- 1:42:15them often, and they will perceive that as you pulling away from them and
- 1:42:21you gaining your own power. There's a lot of implications there, right,
- 1:42:26meaning that not only do you have a choice to not engage, which is
- 1:42:29a huge threat to the abuser, Also it shows that you have your own
- 1:42:32mind, that you have your own thoughts and without especially if the abuser is
- 1:42:39that style of abusive person, that's very threatening and it's very scary to them,
- 1:42:44and it's dangerous to you as a victim. So you can't just do
- 1:42:47what I was saying earlier unless you have a lot of measures in place to
- 1:42:51react if it escalates, right. So I'm not saying that's what you should
- 1:42:57be doing, depending on the situation. I've been in situations where I was
- 1:43:01being abused, but I wasn't under their thumb. I wasn't married to them,
- 1:43:05for example, So I had a very easy ability to extract myself for
- 1:43:11the most part, And so I could draw a boundary like that knowing that
- 1:43:15I didn't need a lot of measures in place to protect me because the abuser
- 1:43:17didn't have that much control over my life. The actual scene between Mildred and
- 1:43:23I lasted around fifteen minutes, not the five minutes that you saw. It
- 1:43:28kept going and going and going, and it would not stop. Yeah,
- 1:43:32I don't doubt that it looked that way. Mildred was bulldozing, was very
- 1:43:39rigid, very sure of herself, and just throwing all sorts of stuff,
- 1:43:42and you saw Tiff trying to react, and even physically. You see Mildred
- 1:43:46standing tall and very pointedly, very squared up against Tiff and going after them
- 1:43:53verbally, and you saw Tiff just and then panic and run off. So
- 1:43:58yeah, I don't doubt that they cut that out. Why did they cut
- 1:44:00it out, We don't know. Maybe they cut it out because they're trying
- 1:44:03to make Tiff look bad. I don't think so, though, because there
- 1:44:09was enough there to make Mildred look like a bulldozer look abusive. So I'm
- 1:44:14guessing they just cut it for time. It was actually kind of weird how
- 1:44:17short the reunion was. My impression is they're shooting the reunion for several hours.
- 1:44:23By the time Tiff walked outside, it was dark outside. I think
- 1:44:26they were in southern California, typically dark around six seven, eight o'clock or
- 1:44:30something depending on the time of year, and I'm guessing that they were there
- 1:44:34early in the morning, so they have a lot of footage, and they
- 1:44:38only showed a small portion, and they only touched on a small portion of
- 1:44:43topics. And honestly, when I think about it, I think it's just
- 1:44:45the general guideline that this production company follows Love's blinds, the ultimatums that they
- 1:44:53don't want to be like other reality TV shows where they have a lot of
- 1:44:58detail given. They want to make it as short and sweet as possible because
- 1:45:02you want people wanting more, you don't want them getting bored watching shows like
- 1:45:06ninety Day Fiance. They'll take a pretty simplistic storyline and really string it out,
- 1:45:14literally for thirty episodes. They'll have a reunion that lasts for four episodes.
- 1:45:18Each episode is two hours long, and there will be slow moments,
- 1:45:23right, So, I think part of the success of these shows is how
- 1:45:26condensed it is. So it was probably just that because they could have easily
- 1:45:30cut that whole scene out right, or they could have cut it to make
- 1:45:32Tiff look overreactive. It didn't, at least it didn't look that way to
- 1:45:36me. But yeah, I don't doubt that what Tiff is saying here is
- 1:45:41accurate. That it was three times as long and more involved than what we
- 1:45:45saw being gas little national television like over your morals is something I can't even
- 1:45:51comprehend to this day. And when it came to the rent situation, I
- 1:45:57actually thought that she was talking about utility use at that point, because when
- 1:46:00you are thinking of accusation one, two, three, four, and you
- 1:46:03don't even know what the fuck is reality anymore, pardon might Okay, well
- 1:46:09that's the end of that video. I am really glad. Well, okay,
- 1:46:15so it looks like Tiff is telling the truth, and if so,
- 1:46:19then I highly commend Tiff for putting this out there. And I'm so happy
- 1:46:27that if Tif is telling the truth, what it looks like they are that
- 1:46:30Tiff it was able to extract themselves and not only get out of the relationship,
- 1:46:36but also to extract their mind, to return to a stable sense of
- 1:46:43self and knowing right from wrong and not being gas lit anymore. It looks
- 1:46:47like Tiff has arrived there, which is a big deals. It could take
- 1:46:51a long time. I'd be curious as to what helped Tiff to recover in
- 1:46:55that way. Maybe I'm guessing a lot of support. Who knows. If
- 1:46:59Tiff is being which it looks like they are, then this is a happy
- 1:47:02ending to a sad story. So there's that. Also, I commend Tiff
- 1:47:08for putting this out there. A lot of people have benefited from watching this,
- 1:47:13A lot of people have reached out to Tiff, from my understand and
- 1:47:17I'm guessing some lives were saved, some relationships were saved, some people were
- 1:47:21saved, some children were saved by Tiff speaking out, and I guess by
- 1:47:27extension the show showing us what this can look like, right, Although I
- 1:47:30wonder what the overall consensus was for people watching. Because I live in this
- 1:47:35world and a lot of y'all live in this world too, it was easy
- 1:47:40for us to see that something was amiss, that there was some signs,
- 1:47:45there were some signs of intimate partner once just from watching this show, even
- 1:47:47before their reunion. So for us, that's perhaps what we saw and it
- 1:47:53was clear. But I don't know if the general public would have seen that.
- 1:47:57In fact, I'm going to take a guess to say that they didn't,
- 1:48:00that they just thought it was conflict. They might have even seen Tiff
- 1:48:03as the problem. Often people will frame things financially, and Mildred accused Tiff
- 1:48:11of mooching off of Mildred not paying rent, that kind of thing. Tiff
- 1:48:15went into it and actually was explicit and saying I did pay half the rent.
- 1:48:19There were just some other things that I don't know, but that doesn't
- 1:48:25matter. Even if Tiff didn't pay their rent, that doesn't mean that it's
- 1:48:29okay for Mildred to be violent and to abuse Tiff. So I don't know.
- 1:48:34I worry that the portion of the audience watching it would be really focused
- 1:48:41on that mooching accusation because during the show, Tiff didn't provide any evidence against
- 1:48:47that. I think because Tiff was being gasolt and confused, and they also
- 1:48:51edited in a certain way because I've seen that before, Like on Day Fiance,
- 1:48:55for example, there will be a lot of talk in the viewership that's
- 1:49:00really centered around money and who is scamming who for money, And certainly that
- 1:49:06can be a thing that happens on the show, and it's pretty egregious,
- 1:49:11but sometimes I feel like the viewership is applying that criterion and focusing on that
- 1:49:17when there's a lot more detail being presented to us right, and so I
- 1:49:23don't know. Of course, it makes a lot of sense. There's a
- 1:49:25lot of people who are struggling financially and that's what they're thinking about day to
- 1:49:30day, hour to hour, and so that's what they're focusing on because first
- 1:49:34things first with survival is being able to pay your bills, roof over your
- 1:49:41head, food for your kids, and yourself. So I imagine it's an
- 1:49:45outgrowth of that. I don't know, or it's just an easy thing to
- 1:49:48attack people for. I don't know. I'm just worried about the general public's
- 1:49:54interpretation of what happened, or even just even noticing. So that's another reason
- 1:49:59why it's really great that Tiff brought this up. If Tiff is being accurate,
- 1:50:01which it looks like they are, but I can't know. I've been
- 1:50:06wrong before. I've as a couple therapist. I will hear stories from couples
- 1:50:13and I at first will hear one version and it seems very believable, and
- 1:50:17then I hear the other version. I'm like oh, and then I investigate
- 1:50:20more and it's a third story that I end up planning on. So you
- 1:50:24know, I can't know, but you know, it definitely looks credible,
- 1:50:27does it not. There's a lot of things pointing that direction. So I
- 1:50:31commend for coming forward putting this out there. You know, there'd be a
- 1:50:35lot of reasons why Tiff wouldn't want to put this out there, would just
- 1:50:40want to move on with their life, would perhaps not want to piss off
- 1:50:45Bildrid. I don't know, but it's possible that Tiff even knows that this
- 1:50:49could activate Mildred even more abusive people. If Mildred is abusive, they can
- 1:50:57sometimes become obsessed. If this video is out there, the abuse of people
- 1:51:00will sometimes this will set them off for ten years of a campaign of digging
- 1:51:06up dirt, fabricating accusations, and publishing those two Because when you manage to
- 1:51:15gain some control over the abuser, their tactic is to not only meet fire
- 1:51:20with fire, meaning that they don't just reciprocate, They will do it tenfold,
- 1:51:26one hundredfold to make sure that you never do it again. And because
- 1:51:30of their obsessiveness about this sort of thing and the level of anger that they
- 1:51:33feel, it will drive them for years of trying to get rid of you,
- 1:51:39to try to counter it and to convince everyone how wrong you are.
- 1:51:44So just really putting themselves in the crosshairs. If Tip is being accurate about
- 1:51:48this, so that's brave. Also, the Internet can be a really horrible
- 1:51:54place for variety of reasons, not only to victims, but also to queer
- 1:51:58people, So there's that. I mean, I wouldn't doubt that there are
- 1:52:01anti queer people who are going after Tiff just because they're queer and saying really
- 1:52:06awful things. In fact, I'm quite sure of that. So just putting
- 1:52:12yourself out there as a queer person as a risk, even if you're just
- 1:52:15talking about something non controversial like puppies or something. So it's brave of Tiff
- 1:52:20to do that as well, So, you know, good for them,
- 1:52:25I guess. Another aspect to this is that traditionally, in the rare instances
- 1:52:30where we do talk about intimate partner violence, it's most often discussed when you
- 1:52:35have a head or such couple and the husband is the perpetrator. But we
- 1:52:41know because it's obvious, and it's also shown with research and clinical experience that
- 1:52:46it doesn't matter the orientation, sexual orientation, or the gender. Anyone can
- 1:52:51be abusive. Anyone can be abused. So it's perhaps another educational aspect to
- 1:52:58this that okay, even queer relationships can involve in partner violence. That is
- 1:53:03also possible for some people. I could imagine they would literally think that will
- 1:53:09wait, women can't be abusive. Literally a lot of people believe that they
- 1:53:13will be. Well, that's not possible. Or they would look at Mildred
- 1:53:16and Tiff and say that Tiff looks stronger, and thus how could Mildred abuse
- 1:53:23Tiff when Tiff seems to have more physical power. We don't even know if
- 1:53:26Tiff does. I think Mildred was claiming that to the police. But that's
- 1:53:30also ridiculous. You can be abused by someone who is very small and would
- 1:53:35never be able to physically harm you. The thing is, though harm can
- 1:53:40take many many forms. Also, all you need is a knife or a
- 1:53:44gun, and you could be tiny and kill someone. So it's not a
- 1:53:47matter of your muscle mass to threaten someone and make someone feel unsafe. So
- 1:53:55that's another aspect to this that is, I guess helpful to the general society.
- 1:54:00And you know, this show seemed to be watched by a wide variety
- 1:54:03of folks, people that might not have exposure to this order because you know,
- 1:54:09it's in my world. Everything I'm saying right now is obvious and often
- 1:54:14discussed and researched and well understood. So sometimes I forget that a lot of
- 1:54:19people, especially when you consider around the world. The ideas that are presented
- 1:54:25to us on the show and by Tiff now are very novel and mind blowing
- 1:54:30and really require paradigm shifts that I might have made when I was a lot
- 1:54:33younger, you know what I mean. So we can't assume that everyone gets
- 1:54:36that just along designs just a little tangent. When I was a student in
- 1:54:43graduate school, I noticed that some of the professors, because they had learned
- 1:54:48so much, you know, the professors were so far beyond my knowledge level
- 1:54:54that when they were given a chance and they had the power to do so,
- 1:54:59they would design asses or lectures that were more interesting to them but way
- 1:55:03over my head. And that will happen sometimes where it's hard for us to
- 1:55:12We can get bored, any of us can get bored talking about fundamentals,
- 1:55:15things that is obvious to us because we learned them a long time ago,
- 1:55:19or we just know them, and it's tempting as educators or people online to
- 1:55:26speak from that place of just like, well, we don't even need to
- 1:55:28touch on that because it's obvious. There's a good chance that a lot of
- 1:55:32those things that we take for granted, a lot of those things that are
- 1:55:34obvious to us, are extremely mind blowing for a lot of people around the
- 1:55:40world, especially when it comes to anything related to queer people. So it
- 1:55:45was perhaps really helpful not only to have this example, but really everything that
- 1:55:50was portrayed on the show, that queer people can fall in love, that
- 1:55:54there's gender fluidity, that queer people have all the same ups and downs,
- 1:56:00as you know, they have very relatable experience as they fall in love.
- 1:56:02Some of them, like mal or Zander, seemed to be pretty differentiated,
- 1:56:06others not so much. Wow, there's a wide variety. They have a
- 1:56:10wide variety of looks and presentations. And instead of stereotyping and pigeonholing, you
- 1:56:15know, to me, it's just normal. You know, I have a
- 1:56:18lot of queer friends, have had a lot of queer friends. I have
- 1:56:20queer people in my family and have for a long time. So to me,
- 1:56:26it's in Seattle anyway, it's just obvious, right, But to a
- 1:56:30lot of people it's not. I mean, sometimes I have to remind myself
- 1:56:34that the fact that I'm Asian American and I'm fourth generation my grandparents, my
- 1:56:41Japanese grandparents were born in the United States and didn't speak Japanese is extremely novel
- 1:56:47to build way. So you don't see your Japanese, but you don't speak
- 1:56:50and I of course for me that's obvious. But there's a lot of the
- 1:56:57lack experience or something, or they have biased or they haven't gone through courses
- 1:57:02that dismantle stereotype and talk about it. So yeah, sometimes we have to
- 1:57:06just start from the beginning. So the show being a mainstream show, which
- 1:57:14it is arguably I think did a lot of work there and you know,
- 1:57:17so I'll commend that. Are there some problems, sure, but overall I
- 1:57:20think it's a wonderful thing. And since it was successful as a show,
- 1:57:26it shows that marketers, because that's all it comes down to is making money,
- 1:57:29they are like, oh, we need the next queer love, right,
- 1:57:31we need what they're probably in the works right now. There's other competitor
- 1:57:36reality TV show programs going like, oh we need more of this content.
- 1:57:42Look, look how much it's look how well it's doing. And someone has
- 1:57:45to be that first four way to put a good quality show out there so
- 1:57:49that it can be demonstrated that there is a market for them, and so
- 1:57:53you know, I'm really happy about that. So anyway, I guess I'm
- 1:57:57wrapping up the whole thing, as I imagine this might be the last episode
- 1:58:00that I make, because I'm not planning on watching more interviews and that kind
- 1:58:04of thing, mainly because I just I might watch them, but I don't
- 1:58:10know if I can add value by spending the time and making videos about it.
- 1:58:14And also I'm trying to transition work to other things deep dives for the
- 1:58:19audio podcast, that kind of thing. So I guess this is a wrap
- 1:58:24up for that. I feel like I already kind of wrapped it up when
- 1:58:27we watch the end of the reading, but I would do it again briefly
- 1:58:30and say, what a ride if you've if you're watching this, in all
- 1:58:32likelihood, you were there throughout the whole thing. And I value that a
- 1:58:39lot. I follow certain YouTube channels of myself and you know, I'm sitting
- 1:58:45here alone in a room, and you're probably sitting alone in a room or
- 1:58:47maybe with your partner or something, and it, you know, it feels
- 1:58:51like an intimate thing. You're having your reaction, commenting below maybe or yelling
- 1:58:57at the screen or something, and I reacted, and so it feels kind
- 1:59:03of intimate, like a close relationship to me. I depend on knowing how
- 1:59:11you feel about things, and also you watching, because I wouldn't be doing
- 1:59:17this if people weren't watching. So it's been a journey, you know,
- 1:59:23like some kind of excursion together that we've gone on, like we've ventured into
- 1:59:29the wilderness, not knowing where we were headed. And then we do a
- 1:59:34full loop and come back home and we are saying that our goodbyes until next
- 1:59:41time, and we're saying, okay, well, I was wow, what
- 1:59:44so many memories, so many experiences we had together, and good night,
- 1:59:48hug. I'll see you tomorrow and we'll go on another adventure. And until
- 1:59:53then, everyone please take care of yourself because you deserve it. You really
- 1:59:55really do. Very