Latest / Building Brand Gravity: Attracting People Into Your Orbit / The Specifics Matter: Reinforcing Credibility in a Multi-Stakeholder Environment
Transcript
- 0:06You are listening to Building Brand Gravity Attracting People into your Orbit, a GNS
- 0:12Business communications podcast. This is a show for communications pros across industries looking to
- 0:19gain an inside of you into industry influence. You're about to hear a conversation
- 0:24with leading industry professionals talking about the importance of building business impact through sound brand
- 0:31strategy. Let's get into the show. Hi, and welcome to the latest
- 0:36edition of Building Brand Gravity. I'm Steve Halsey, Principal and Chief Growth Officer
- 0:41of GNS and your host of Building Brand Gravity. With me today are two
- 0:45renowned communications experts. I want to first welcome back to the show. Rob
- 0:50Yeclec, Managing director of the Harris Pole. Rob is a world renowned expert
- 0:55on reputation, brand and insights, and he's a leader at the iconic Harris
- 0:59pol Welcome back to the show. Thanks for having me, Steve, glad
- 1:03to be here. We're also joined by Elliott Mizrahi. He's VP of Strategy
- 1:07and Content for Page. In that role, Elliott works with the world's top
- 1:11CEOs, agency executives, academics, and other leaders supporting the C suite.
- 1:18He's actively gleaning their insights, and he's using that to create compelling thought leadership
- 1:23content that helps today's chief communication officers navigate an ever more complex world. Elliott,
- 1:30welcome to building brand gravity. Thank you, Steve so Hey, let's
- 1:34get let's get started. It's going to be a great discussion today, and
- 1:38it's not going to be a light discussion. You know, when you think
- 1:42about what we're facing the world right now, the context around and the expectations
- 1:47of business is anything but stable. You got seismic forces of change, you
- 1:52got mass disruption, you got geopolitical unrest, economic headwinds, disinformation, polarization
- 1:59and the need for personalization are the norm today, right, just a couple
- 2:02of small things for us to deal with, you know, and Rob can
- 2:06bring that into greater light in terms of what he's what they're seeing at the
- 2:08Harris Pole and from where Elliott sits. In this environment, today's chief communication
- 2:15officers are being asked to not just lead the communications function, but to help
- 2:20their companies, their markets, and even society manage some kind of positive transformation
- 2:25in the face of these disruptive forces. So in today's podcast, we're going
- 2:30to explore what's on the mind of CEOs, what the research tells us we're
- 2:35going to talk about two big issues that chief communication officers cannot afford to ignore,
- 2:40and how this moment in time is going to forever change the role of
- 2:44the CEO and all of this is going to be discussed within the context of
- 2:49how it can impact the brand's gravity. So Elliott Page recently pulled thirty eight
- 2:54members CEOs in North America, Europe, and the Middle East to see what's
- 2:59on their mind. What did you find out? Well, a little bit
- 3:01of the history before he gets to the finding. Steve. So, We're
- 3:04a membership association for chief communication officers and one of the things that we have
- 3:08been trying to do lately is have more of a voice and more of a
- 3:12presence in business conversations, and we for the last couple of years have had
- 3:16a presence at Davos, and to prepare for that, one of the things
- 3:20that we wanted to do is reach out to members and get a sense for
- 3:23what was on their mind. I often like to think about the CEO as
- 3:28the organizational antenna. You know, we have site lines and views into what's
- 3:32happening around the organization around the world with stakeholders, and this lets CEOs be
- 3:38early detectors of risk, and so we did two things in our research.
- 3:43We spoke to CEOs, which I'll talk about, and we also worked with
- 3:46Rob to speak with the public and understand what their expectations are around issue management.
- 3:52And Rob will share a little bit of those findings in a moment.
- 3:54What we found when we asked CEOs, what are the things that you're thinking
- 3:59about, what are the risks that you see coming up in the year to
- 4:01come, forty five percent said that it was geopolitics and elections. And I
- 4:08don't know if you know this, About half the planet is going to be
- 4:12going to the polls in democratic elections this year. It is an enormously consequential
- 4:17year for democratic politics, and it's happening at a time that there is enormous
- 4:21polarization and divisiveness. And in fact, twenty nine percent of CEOs said that
- 4:26that's their second greatest risk, the polarization, divisiveness, the eroding societal fabric.
- 4:31And so when I think about these two things together, I'm thinking your
- 4:35CEO is their job is in many ways to protect the social license to operate,
- 4:40and when you are dealing with a world that is fragmented and decisive,
- 4:44and where constructive dialogue is breaking down, it becomes more challenging to do that
- 4:48to find those forms of common ground. We look at blowback on ESG and
- 4:53DEI, things that many would agree are forms of responsible business management, but
- 4:59they've become wrapped up in sort of political language and rhetoric, and it's challenged
- 5:02CEOs and their ability to lead their enterprises on those sorts of issues. So
- 5:06Elliott quick question off that are they are they optimistic or are they pessimistic as
- 5:12they think about the current situation. We didn't ask, so your guest would
- 5:15be as good as mine. But my experience with CEOs honestly is that,
- 5:19considering the challenges they face day to day, they are a strangely optimistic bunch.
- 5:27And so I think there's a lot of opportunity that sits within these challenges.
- 5:31There's a lot of opportunity that lends itself to this unique skill set of
- 5:34the CCO to foster constructive dialogue and fine common ground. And I think just
- 5:40I'll add these two quick points. Fourteen percent felt that misinformation and disinformation were
- 5:45also huge risks this year, and all of that stuff goes to the heart
- 5:48of this earning and building and maintaining trust. On the positive side, we
- 5:53asked what are the opportunities that you see for the function coming up in the
- 5:56coming year. Thirty two percent said that it was about allusion to the function
- 6:00itself, more personalization, more speed, more scale, a greater ability to
- 6:04demonstrate real tangible value. Twenty six percent talked about AI, which anyone would
- 6:10agree is probably a mixed bag, but tremendous opportunity to deepen the relationships that
- 6:15we have with stakeholders and have a greater impact. And so I think to
- 6:18your point, Steve, even though these are enormous societal challenges, CEOs have
- 6:24greater opportunities than ever before to be positive influential forces in their organizations and outside
- 6:30as well. And what are you seeing as you talk to them about just
- 6:33how the skill set's expanding? I mean everything you covered, geopolitics, AI,
- 6:40changing role, dealing with elections, all of these things to try and
- 6:44shepherd the brands, I mean, how are they keeping up with this?
- 6:49How are they thinking about their teams in that environment? Well, I would
- 6:54like to think that one of the ways that we do it is by participating
- 6:57in page events and consuming our content. But the bottom line is this,
- 7:01I think the expectation of the CEO to have the broadest purview possible is really
- 7:06significant today. And I think that business acumen, that's understanding of world events
- 7:13and how they affect the enterprise. I think that's probably the most important thing
- 7:16that CEOs are focusing on, just so they have a really rich understanding of
- 7:21the context and an ability to provide valuable strategic advice. That's interesting and Rob,
- 7:28I know you guys worked with him. As you said, I'm kind
- 7:30of the qualitative part part of this, But the Harris pol also recently worked
- 7:35with Page to field a global public opinion survey really asking about the confidence and
- 7:41business. You garnered responses from more than eleven thousand individuals across ten markets.
- 7:46What did you find out? Thanks Steve. I really enjoyed Elliott's setup.
- 7:51And I think your question Steve that the CEO of Psyche I can't hold back
- 7:58from kind of jumping in. I think, you know, I think I
- 8:01would agree, like the a lot of CEOs. I think the tolerance or
- 8:05maybe appetite for kind of complexity and maybe borderline pain is an impressive trait would
- 8:13I would say that because people know what they're getting in for and they keep
- 8:16coming back more for more of it. It's a survival trait. Oh but
- 8:20it's not just survival, right. I Mean, I think a lot of
- 8:22people, there's a lot of people that I have the opportunity to deal with
- 8:24that are in senior communications roles. I mean they could be doing a lot
- 8:28of different things across the business, right and in many cases they've opted and
- 8:31really selected to be running communications. So again, I think it's a very
- 8:35certain persona that does it and really kind of such an invaluable skill to the
- 8:39points that both of you were making. And really what a lot of the
- 8:43research that I'll talk about indicates it's, you know, being that antenna and
- 8:46being that guidepost for for how things are changing. Is it's just so much
- 8:52and critical because companies today have larger blind spots and more quickly emerging blind spots
- 8:56than they've ever had before. So the research that we did with Paige,
- 9:01and again I will give Elliot kudos here he was he was certainly kind of
- 9:05the instigator and brainchild behind getting this we've you know, he prompted us along
- 9:11to really kind of sprint towards the end of last year, and it was
- 9:15really a brain trust of Elliott, the Page team and as well as a
- 9:18number of Page members that contributed to to the survey. So it covers ten
- 9:22global markets kind of across the board, from from North America to Latin America
- 9:28to to across Europe and Asia. A little lighter this round on the Middle
- 9:33East and Africa, but we'll address that in a future wave. But I
- 9:39think a really interesting set of insights when you're when you're talking to over eleven
- 9:43thousand members of the of the global public right and really starting to get your
- 9:46head around, you know, what are the issues that that matter most?
- 9:50And the two core questions that we focused in on are first, what are
- 9:54the issues that the public expects business to make an impact on which are most
- 9:58important? And the second one is around how confident are they that business actually
- 10:03can deliver positive value? Right? So you're and it plays very very well
- 10:09with some of those the thematics that Elliott alluded to. First, I'll start
- 10:13with some of just maybe a couple kind of core insights around key issues.
- 10:16But the you know, the politicization and polarization is such an apparent trend in
- 10:22the in the research I'll talk maybe a little bit about the US, where
- 10:26it's maybe the point and the gap is particularly wide. But it's very noteworthy
- 10:31that you're seeing these gaps across the board, right, So as you're tracking
- 10:35some of these elections, whether they're you know, more at the national level
- 10:39or more at the regional level, or more at the municipal level. Like
- 10:41there's countries like the UK where you've had certainly some some what people would say,
- 10:45some startling results in terms of people who are who are now in parliament.
- 10:48Right, I think you've had some similar trends across a number of European
- 10:52markets. But back to the overall data, right, So the as you're
- 10:56looking at you know, this whole idea of confidence and importance of issues.
- 11:03First and foremost, the issues that we picked are highly salient to the public.
- 11:07And again I put a lot of this back to to the brain trust
- 11:09that helped support over eighty percent of the global public on average said the fifteen
- 11:16issues that we dug into were highly important for business to work on. So
- 11:20all the issues within the study, some of them might be higher, some
- 11:22of them might be lower, are all very salient when it comes to the
- 11:26public. The current reality is that the gap between kind of importance, which
- 11:33call of that around eighty as the global average versus versus confidence is pretty substantial.
- 11:39It's at twenty six points, you're at fifty four to fifty five in
- 11:43terms of looking at the level of confidence. So many issues of high importance
- 11:48confidence substantially lower. So reinforcing this whole idea of a confidence gap and rob
- 11:54just to reinforce for our listeners, importance is what the audience viewed of the
- 12:01ranking of the issue and confidence? Was there confidence? And how business would
- 12:05address that? Yeah, I mean it's it's you know, pretty pretty literally.
- 12:09It's you know, when you look at each one of these issues such
- 12:11as you know, economic stability and growth, or income inequality, or gender
- 12:15equality or polarization in society, to what degree would you say it's important for
- 12:20business to make a positive impact on it? And then secondarily, how confident
- 12:24are you that positive that business can make an positive impact on it? Ok,
- 12:30so very business centric, not just personally are these issues in the world
- 12:33important to you? But we very much brought that direct business lens on it.
- 12:35Right, Is this something that you feel business should be addressing and you
- 12:39believe that business can address it or not, great, thank you. So
- 12:43globally, what's what's noteworthy is that there are two issues that really stood out
- 12:48as kind of the bedrocks for engagement. And the reason I say that is
- 12:52that both these issues stood out as being both the two most important as well
- 12:56as amongst the highest on confidence. Right. Those two issues are economic stability
- 13:03and growth, right, so the degree to which you can have a positive
- 13:05impact on the economy and enable growth. And the second one is job creation
- 13:11and workforce skills development, right, so very much around the workforce, accelerating
- 13:15job creation, but also really looking at your workforce and the degree to which
- 13:20you can improve its skills looking forward. Both of those were very close to
- 13:24ninety percent of the public saying very important in terms of the global public across
- 13:30those ten markets. And there you have the confidence numbers in the load to
- 13:33mid sixties, right, so substantially higher than the average and really kind of
- 13:39two standout items. So those are and what's particularly noteworthy is those two issues
- 13:45across every market and across every key kind of demographic cut very consistently stay as
- 13:50the bedrock, if you will. That's fascinating, giving you all the changes
- 13:56within geographies and you know, Elliott was talking about all of the elections and
- 14:00you know, the polarization of liberal, conservative, young, old, urban,
- 14:03rural. Those are definitely interesting findings that I want to want to come
- 14:07back to, and Elliott, I want to turn to you for a little
- 14:11bit. I mean, you know, Rob is sitting there saying, hey,
- 14:13universally around the globe, there's these two issues. Actually there's fifteen issues
- 14:18that ranked pretty high, but there were two that were up near ninety percent,
- 14:22the economic stability and growth, job creation and workforce skills. So two
- 14:28part questions for you, and then as we get later in the podcast,
- 14:31we'll come back here. First, given everything Rob just covered in terms of
- 14:35the findings from the CEOs you talk to, how do they reconcile it all?
- 14:41And Second, with so much of the day to day focus in the
- 14:43news, at least here in the US and a lot of Western Europe on
- 14:48what divides us, how can CEOs help their companies and their key publics get
- 14:54aligned around their brand's core values and business outcomes in this environment. Yes,
- 14:58Steve on your first question, how do they do it? It is not
- 15:03easy. You know. One of the things that we've been tracking really closely
- 15:07since the beginning of twenty twenty, as COVID came about, we started getting
- 15:13members together to talk about what they were going through and share knowledge with each
- 15:16other. And it just seems like the expectations and the issues that they're dealing
- 15:20with and trying to manage have grown beyond their budgets and teams, and so
- 15:26they're spread really thin. Their remits are expanding. We find CEOs whose responsibilities
- 15:33have come to include brand and marketing, ESG, sustainability, in some cases,
- 15:41human resources, culture and so what we see as a real evolution of
- 15:46the nature of the function. And to be honest, Steve, I think,
- 15:50like you know, any growing pains. It's been challenging for CEOs to
- 15:56keep up with all of these issues. But what I will say, just
- 16:00on the kind of diffsiveness, one of the things the page has said for
- 16:04many, many years is when you think about the basis of the CEO's role,
- 16:10it is rooted in this idea of corporate character that every organization has character,
- 16:15a set of values and beliefs, a unique and differentiated identity that govern
- 16:22everything that it is and does and says. And the CEO's role is to
- 16:26define what that character is and to help align the organization around it. And
- 16:32sometimes that's an ongoing process of refinement when there's a really strong sense of what
- 16:36that is. In other cases, that could mean that there's an existential reality
- 16:40around the company that requires what our friend John Awata at Yale recently described as
- 16:45refounding moments, moments where you need to step back and say, this company
- 16:48needs to be something entirely different. And so building a shared belief around what
- 16:53is happening around the company and what needs to happen or to move it forward
- 16:57is really essential. We did an executive education program with Yale based on their
- 17:03approach to stakeholder capitalism and pages research on the topic, and one of the
- 17:08things that we talked about was assessing materiality. You know, companies, even
- 17:12though they might there might be an expectation from some stakeholders to engage on a
- 17:17whole host of issues. As Rob's research shows us, some of those issues
- 17:21are more material than others, things like economic growth and job skills. These
- 17:26are things that people expect of companies more than some other issues. And so
- 17:30the role for the CEO here is to be a unifying figure, to be
- 17:36at the center of kind of integrating various perspectives to find common ground with stakeholders
- 17:42and to be a force for ensuring that that corporate character is constant and pervasive,
- 17:48that it's ever evident in everything that a company does and says. And
- 17:52that's a big job. Yeah, that certainly is a big job. And
- 17:56Rob, I want to get to you in a second about you know,
- 18:00the impact of AI and some some unique things you had there. But kind
- 18:03of reacting to what Elliott said there is he was talking about the challenge of
- 18:07the CEO. I thought this was really interesting in your research because Elliott was
- 18:12talking about those acronym ESG, D, E, and I and what I
- 18:18thought was interesting And you may have like a broader perspective on this outside of
- 18:22this study, but what was interesting was you hear that and you see that,
- 18:26and it's like reflected in a lot of the financial news. Alan Murray's
- 18:30thing is he's really struggling with that, you know, back and forth.
- 18:33But then when I look at the actual survey you have and the way you
- 18:37ask questions, when you break them out of the acronym you know, how
- 18:41important is racial minority equity or quality that's at like seventy eight percent, income
- 18:48inequality like eighty one percent. You're seeing a lot of these things, gender
- 18:53equality at like seventy seven percent. What was interesting to me is when you
- 18:57break them out of the acronym, how high they actually score in importance.
- 19:03But then there's a mix on confidence, and I just wasn't sure if you
- 19:06had any perspective on people's viewpoint. Once you break it out of the acronym,
- 19:10it seems like they generally support, you know, these big concepts that
- 19:14businesses chacked is basically challenged to manage. Yeah, I think you're you're very
- 19:19squarely getting to one of the one of the biggest risks kind of across the
- 19:22board, i'd say, especially if you're sitting in a US boardroom right now.
- 19:26One of the biggest risks of reputational risks, which again I think right
- 19:30now are higher on the board agenda than they've ever been, is very much
- 19:33around this kind of polarization and politicization of issues. One of the things that's
- 19:37become very apparent is if you have a term and one of your terms is
- 19:42like three different things that are very kind of none of which really indicate any
- 19:48sort of a benefit, but are just kind of functional descriptions. The level
- 19:53of jargon is substantial, and the ability for people to turn that term into
- 19:59whatever they wanted to be is is quite high. Right. And in contrast
- 20:03to that, to the point you're getting at, Steve, and I think
- 20:04you can get even more detailed, is as you look at a lot of
- 20:07the underlying elements. If you ask you know, the public or other stakeholders,
- 20:11right, is it important for for companies to have a positive impact on
- 20:15the environment or not a negative impact on the environment, to improve the communities
- 20:18where they where they work and operate and their employees live, to have very
- 20:22strong governance practices? You have overwhelming yeses. Right. But along those issues,
- 20:30they're they're certainly you know, if you if you laddered up to something
- 20:33called the SG or other terms like D and I, they've they for sure,
- 20:36like most people don't even understand what those things mean, right, But
- 20:37there's people that have told them that they're they're horrible, and they're like the
- 20:41end of capitalism, they're the end of civilization, et cetera. But so
- 20:45you turn it from kind of a concrete conversation on what we're doing to showcase
- 20:49progress to kind of very much a philosophical jargoning, highly heated emotional debate.
- 20:56Right. So, yeah, the specifics matter when you look at when you
- 21:00look within the research, even on those issues, right, I think it's
- 21:03it's it's particularly noteworthy we look at the data split a lot of the different
- 21:07ways, like, for example, by age, by political leaning, by
- 21:11urban by urbanicity like urban rule, and you see you do see some pretty
- 21:17substantial differences, right. So, but in terms of importance, you have
- 21:19a lot more consistency. You know, the confidence numbers do do differ substantially
- 21:23if you're looking at, for example, globally liberal versus more conservative in the
- 21:29US, very specifically democrat versus versus Republican. But also to the point you're
- 21:34getting at steep, none of those numbers they didn't drop to like twenty percent
- 21:37importance or something, Right. So, I think one of the biggest takeaways,
- 21:42you know, one of the one of the big privileges of working with
- 21:45Paige and especially on this project is we've had a chance to talk with a
- 21:48lot of Page members in different countries on this, right, And one of
- 21:51the main takeaways is is not, oh like we should just stay silent on
- 21:55everything except those two issues. That's not the case, right, it's more
- 21:57so saying we need to with those two issues. If we don't reinforce our
- 22:02credibility and our confidence on those things and jump over to other issues, then
- 22:06people might question where our priorities are and like are we actually good at the
- 22:10foundation of what we do or not? Right Versus, if we're able to
- 22:14move off of those very quickly and ideally showcase through our business, through our
- 22:18hiring how we're actually improving a lot of these issues and being very specific about
- 22:22that progress, there's a huge opportunity, right. So, and that's I
- 22:26think that's one of the things that when we look at the you know,
- 22:27CCOs, especially over the last two three years, you know, there's for
- 22:32sure been coming out of many boards an emphasis on like we really shouldn't just
- 22:36talk about any of these things, right versus you know what most of most
- 22:38of the research of but indicate is we just need to be much more specific
- 22:41about what we're saying, right, If this is something we really believe in,
- 22:45how are we showing that we're actually that we've made progress on it versus
- 22:48just talking about it being something that is broadly important. So, so Elliott
- 22:52in the conversations you're having with chief communication officers around the globe, is that
- 22:57what you're hearing that they're really looking at, how do we illustrate and isolate
- 23:03these key issues, start a little bit at the common ground and then get
- 23:07into more specifics in terms of what the brand is doing. I think what
- 23:11I would say is we're starting to see more methodical approaches to deciding whether and
- 23:18how to engage on these issues. You know, there was I think,
- 23:22you know, around the time of George Floyd and in the you know,
- 23:25eighteen months after, it felt like there was just an expectation that if there
- 23:30was there was an issue, companies needed to have a position and to be
- 23:33vocal on it. That that was just the new norm. And I think
- 23:36since a couple of instances where that's going awry, companies have been understandably more
- 23:42judicious about it. What we see CCOs doing is being more methodical about interpreting
- 23:49the relevance of an issue, both the relevance of an issue to the organization
- 23:55and at stakeholders, but also the relevance of the organization and at stakeholders to
- 23:59the issue, and whether or not there really is a place and an impact
- 24:03that they can have and so I think it's not a question of you know,
- 24:08trying to do less or kind of duck your head. It's it's a
- 24:11question of having a really reliable, repeatable, consistent process of making decisions about
- 24:18what is our posture on these different issues, what actions can we take to
- 24:22make progress on those issues? And we see CCOs stepping up to use data
- 24:26and input from various stakeholders to make better decisions along those lines. Well,
- 24:32that's great. Now, the one thing you missed, Ellie, you didn't
- 24:34say AI. How can we have a conversation without bringing in in the word
- 24:38AI? And Rob you know you mentioned to me the other day that you
- 24:44see these two dueling trends of like one of the economic stability and two that
- 24:48job creation and skills development as a huge opportunity for brands, specifically as it
- 24:55relates to an area like talent development. So given the over lay of AIS
- 25:00dramatic impact on seemingly well everything, you know, you've got like there's a
- 25:06myriad of you, but there's you know, one side is is you know
- 25:10purely dystopian scenarios, you know, predicting computers are going to take over Allah
- 25:15the terminator. That's it. We're done, we released you know ae AI.
- 25:18You have others that are out there really fearing about the loss of jobs
- 25:22and becoming obsolete. And what I find interesting, and you're seeing it daily
- 25:27in the business media, is that there are roles that were highly skilled,
- 25:33that were traditionally somewhat insulated, you know, specialties like law, like accounting,
- 25:38even investing, that are now facing AI. And you know, are
- 25:42those individuals even needed anymore? And then there's another view of this that basically
- 25:48says, no, no, no, AI is going to be a positive
- 25:51game changer in productivity and innovation. All those rote tasks that both blue collar
- 25:56and white collar workers were doing are going to be taken care of by AI
- 26:02so they can focus on higher value tasks. So within that myriad of things
- 26:07and those often conflicting viewpoint, you know, you had kind of a viewpoint
- 26:11of what you saw as an uncharted opportunity for brands and corporation as it as
- 26:17it relates to the workforce. Do you mind sharing a little bit of that?
- 26:21Yeah, So I'll do two things. One is I'll point to a
- 26:22couple of pieces of the data and then I'll pivot off that quick right.
- 26:26First, one of The first things I would say is when when you're looking
- 26:30at AI and especially some of the in terms of the research, is some
- 26:33of the negative impacts of it, Right, The negative impacts of AI was
- 26:37one of the things that trended higher. I will say, it's interesting that
- 26:41this has come through in conversations we've had in places like China versus the UK,
- 26:45versus the US. The negative impacts of conversation is also very different in
- 26:48different markets, right. It is if you're living in Canada or the US
- 26:52or the UK, it is so prevalent, right, versus in other markets,
- 26:56like AI is more of just kind of like a that's there, and
- 27:00and many people have maybe more confidence being it's dealt with. I think the
- 27:06bigger and more important in the in the point that you're you're you're laddering up
- 27:11to is what when you look at the intersection and those two issues, we're
- 27:14very drawn to that. The second aspect of that second issue, right,
- 27:17which is around skills development, right, and I think it's like one of
- 27:19one of your massive opportunities right now is is very much around you know,
- 27:23how is how does AI kind of enable a culture shift? Right? What
- 27:29are the skills that that are required, right, versus just a sprint to
- 27:33embed as much AI as possible. Right, I think very quickly, like
- 27:37if if you look at most companies and the amount of dollars that they're putting
- 27:40into kind of developing new kind of AI programs versus overall kind of like improving
- 27:45skills and talent for for the next generation, the level of investment in one
- 27:51versus the other is substantial. Right. So as we're looking at companies,
- 27:56and we're looking at for for most companies, still your intellectual capital is your
- 27:59your number one asset. You know, if if you're looking forward, the
- 28:02companies that can really win on on employees are going to win in the in
- 28:03the marketplace. I think that and that skills piece is a massive opportunity and
- 28:08across a lot of different research we're doing, but this the research here highlights
- 28:12it is, you know, our ability to tell a story about and through
- 28:15our employees about the future and showcase that through how our business operates is like
- 28:22massive and it's a very human story too, right. I think that's one
- 28:25of the one of the key things that you know, as as communicators and
- 28:27as storytellers, human stories work much better than jargon y technical stories. So
- 28:34Elliott, you definitely have your thoughts on AI, and as you're talking to
- 28:40CEOs around the globe and what Rob was really talking about the challenges or the
- 28:45opportunities, What's what's the viewpoint from CEOs. You really kicked the horneus nests
- 28:48with me. I really could go on. I thought long and hard about
- 28:52what I wanted to say, just to keep it contained. There's a few
- 28:55things that I would say. I think, uh, certainly CEOs, just
- 29:00like any function today, they are thinking really hard about how to capitalize on
- 29:06the advantages that AI can present. And I've got some thoughts about how all
- 29:10that's going to unfold. I think maybe that's a conversation for another day.
- 29:14But one of the issues that relates to the research that Robin Harris did is
- 29:18there's a really concern about job displacement and this idea that AI is going to
- 29:25disrupt, you know, labor markets and the ability to people to work.
- 29:29I think it's more likely that AI, like a lot of technologies that came
- 29:32before it, are going to transform the way that we work. But expectations
- 29:37will increase, so it won't be that you only need one person to do
- 29:41the work. That five people did before. It is that those five people
- 29:44will be able to do different forms and higher value of work, and it
- 29:48takes time to get there. It reminds me of Brittany Paxman, who's the
- 29:52principal at Point six hundred. She often uses this example of the vacuum cleaner
- 29:56that when it was introduced in the fifties, you know, house lives everywhere
- 30:00rejoiced that this is going to create so much more free time for them because
- 30:03it'll be so much easier to clean the house. But what actually ended up
- 30:07happening was the expectations of home cleanliness increased, and so they found themselves busier
- 30:11rather than less busy. And I wonder if that'll be the same here in
- 30:17terms of what I think the positive developments of AI and managing the negative potential.
- 30:25I think one of the things that organizations really struggled with, they struggled
- 30:27with always is there's so much knowledge that's locked within the community of the organization
- 30:33and little pockets of specializations and expertise, and it's really difficult to make that
- 30:37knowledge accessible across the entire organization. I think companies will begin to develop their
- 30:42own proprietary AI models that are a combination of chat, GPT plus all their
- 30:47own data. So no matter where you sit in the organization, you can
- 30:51have a chatbot and you can find the information of the data, the policy,
- 30:53whatever you're looking for, all of that stuff will be already available.
- 30:56And I think that creates a huge opportunity for people to be more productive and
- 31:00impactful. But I think for CCOs, one of the things that's flying under
- 31:04the radar that I think is really important is AI is dumb. People don't
- 31:10realize it is a machine. It is garbage in, garbage out, and
- 31:12it operates on the basis of what we choose to train it on and those
- 31:17are human decisions. That's why we see so much bias in AI. It's
- 31:21not because the AI is flawed, it's how we're training it. And so,
- 31:25you know, there's this thought experiment around the paper clip that if you
- 31:27told AI, you know, maximize the production of paper clips, it would
- 31:30kill us all because it knows nothing else to maximize the production of paper clips.
- 31:36What I think CCOs need to do is think about this reality that you
- 31:41need to have a moral and ethical and a responsible adoption of AI, one
- 31:45that minimizes its potential for harm and maximizes its opportunity to create value. And
- 31:51I think a lot of that is going to come down to CEOs who have
- 31:53you know, the reputation and brand safety as part of their emit. You
- 31:56know, nobody wants to be the company that's caught in some major kerfluffle because
- 32:00they didn't think through the implic implications of AI. And so I think this
- 32:06is the beginning of a really long transition period where a lot of these issues
- 32:09will reveal themselves and CCOs are going to help help their organizations navigate through them
- 32:15well. And I think part of the challenge of that with CEOs is to
- 32:17remain innately human. Right, there's certain aspects of really the communications function or
- 32:23the expanding REMIT where it sits that that understanding of context, that understanding of
- 32:30emotion, that understanding of timing, you know, are very difficult to be
- 32:34done by the machine. So it's going to be interesting to see how those
- 32:37are done in tandem. Steeve, sorry, I was going to add on
- 32:40top. I apologize for jumping in, but like the I mean, it's
- 32:44just also the whole point that ELI made at the beginning, right, Scarce
- 32:47Resources, Like, although there's these bigger things, right, organizational change.
- 32:52If cons teams don't get on technology and AI fast, it's a huge mess,
- 32:57right. I mean, there's just so many like basic neighblers that it
- 33:00provides right now, because to the point I think you're making there at the
- 33:04end is human context and insights are still very human things, right, Like
- 33:08we do a lot of insights work, and we do we use tons of
- 33:13AI now to accelerate processes, but you never have AI giving you the insight
- 33:16at the at the end of the chain, right, it's always a set
- 33:20of humans and interpretation and context and the humans they're delivering to well. And
- 33:23what I think thinks interesting about that point, Rob is is I feel like
- 33:29the human context is constantly evolving, you know, at individually, at a
- 33:34family level, at a community, at a national level. I think things
- 33:38are not static. And some of you know the research I've seen you present
- 33:44that ten years ago, certain attitudes and viewpoints you would have assumed would be
- 33:47the US context, republican nature in terms of confidence and view on corporations are
- 33:54now more of a democratic viewpoint, and things that ten years ago where is
- 33:58a democratic viewpoint could be a republican viewpoint. So you know, that's also
- 34:02important as you think about what you were talking about, of those human insights,
- 34:07the contexts and emotions. We're not a static species as much as as
- 34:12as some folks might might think we are. Yeah, exactly, don't very
- 34:15clear. It's one hundred and eighty degrees on kind of how different political branches
- 34:20in the US think about business. So i'd added, it's just a really
- 34:23quick another of that. Have either of you heard of the Turkey problem?
- 34:28You know what that is? Nope, I've not heard of that. It's
- 34:30maybe a little too American. But the Turkey problem is the idea that if
- 34:35your turkey, you wake up every day, you get fed, you stand
- 34:37on the sun every day, is wonderful. You've got nothing to worry about.
- 34:38Until one day in November. That day is very different for you,
- 34:43and you didn't see it coming because your experience up to that point had been
- 34:45the same every day. And I think that this goes to the point about
- 34:49the human elements that the systems, if they're trained on all the data in
- 34:52the world, everything that's been written up till today, you know, they
- 34:55know what's known, and they can maybe extrapolate and interpret and really powerful but
- 35:00I think human's ability to be more creative about the possibilities is always going to
- 35:07be an essential supplement to what what you know the technology can do to supplement
- 35:12it. So, you know, the Turkey problem is something that's always going
- 35:15to be the case. And I think CEOs, as leaders, as antennas,
- 35:20we've got that broad purview and an opportunity to help the organization see more
- 35:23broadly than maybe historical data can show us. But as you both kind of
- 35:29talked about that, I guess it really struck me a lot of this really
- 35:31takes it to the core of the CEO's job and remit from what it's been
- 35:38since the CEOs were created, which is how do you blend the art and
- 35:42science right? And I think when you're talking about the impact of AI and
- 35:45these type of things, the science part of it and the ability to aggregate
- 35:50create new things, there's more science than ever that they have to deal with,
- 35:54But there's also the art of how do you how do you put this
- 35:58together in a meaningful way that is true to your brand, true to your
- 36:01values, true to what you're seeing with the with the landscape you know,
- 36:06and you and you hope you get it right. So you know, a
- 36:08couple of questions. I could. I could talk to you guys for hours
- 36:13on these topics, but I want to kind of bring us back to a
- 36:16lot of what we've covered here. You know, Elliott, you really started
- 36:20talking about you've got this expanding remit of chief communication officers. Half the world,
- 36:25at least half the democratic world, is an election this year, but
- 36:30those that aren't democratic. Doesn't mean that there's not geopolitical issues or challenges that
- 36:34are being created around the world. You've got technology, You've got innovation.
- 36:39You know, you've got the research that you guys did with the Harris Poll.
- 36:43We're really talking about economic stability, growth, job creation, workforce skills.
- 36:49That's an awful lot. So what closing advice does page have for chief
- 36:53communication officers and senior communications professionals on how to make the most out of this
- 37:00moment of time. I think, if I were in narrow it, this
- 37:01is my advice. The first is businesses operate in a much more multi stakeholder
- 37:09environment today, and what I mean by that is the risks associated with not
- 37:15engaging with understanding and orienting the organization around the interests and concerns of all of
- 37:21their stakeholders present greater challenges today. Stakeholder capitalism is a thing today because various
- 37:29publics have expectations of business that they need to fulfill. And CCOs are the
- 37:34multi stakeholder function. We have the broadest purview across the stakeholder universe, and
- 37:39so I think navigating those realities and making sure that there's a balance across stakeholders
- 37:45is really essential. And as I said earlier, there's the second piece of
- 37:50advice. There's more methodical approaches to doing that. I think communications functions today
- 37:54they're synthesizing data and input and just the reality of events of the world,
- 38:00and they're able to develop a point of view about the balance of the organization
- 38:05to certain issues and activities, but also the valance of those activities and issues
- 38:09to the organization. And I think having a consistent, repeatable process that's reliable
- 38:15becomes really important because once you set a precedent, it's hard to kind of
- 38:19back off of that. The third thing I would say is, and this
- 38:22sounds a little airy fairy, but I mean it genuinely. Business has this
- 38:29kind of goes to the multi stakeholder view. Business has a unique opportunity to
- 38:31make the world better. Nobody started a business purely because they wanted to make
- 38:35money. They started a business because they saw a problem, a way to
- 38:38create value, a way to make life better. Our lives better. And
- 38:43the better companies can connect to that core purpose, that animating purpose and accentuate
- 38:49it and amplify it, I think, the more likely it is that they
- 38:52will be able to build lasting, positive relationships with stakeholders. And again,
- 38:55CEOs are at the center of that. You think about corporate character, the
- 39:00purpose is often at the center of that identity of the organization. Why we
- 39:02get out of bed every morning and go to work to do the work that
- 39:06we do. Why employees want to stay with our companies and remain engaged in
- 39:09their work, it's because they feel and they see and they know that the
- 39:15work that we're doing is somehow making the world a better place. And for
- 39:19communicators, it's about telling that story, certainly, but it's about making sure
- 39:24that you also have that story to tell. And that's about organizational change.
- 39:29And what we see as CCOs today is the communications are you know the last
- 39:32mile right, the twenty five point two miles that come earlier in the marathon
- 39:38are about organizational change. To make sure that you are consistent on ESG.
- 39:44That you are consistent on issues, that you are operating in accordance with your
- 39:49values and your beliefs and your brand. And so you know, Steve,
- 39:52I kind of go back to the top of your point, which I think
- 39:54is interesting around brand gravity. You know that brand gravity is in many ways
- 40:01the relationship, the magnetism between I have a relationship with this organization because I
- 40:07understand what it does. I believe in what it does, and I can
- 40:09see that evidence. And I think CEOs a lot of what they do today
- 40:14is about finding a way to convey that in a way that's that's clear and
- 40:17compelling. Do good, run the marathon, build brand gravity. I like
- 40:21that. That's that's great advice. And and Rob, you know you you
- 40:24said you've got a really unique point that you sit my friend in. You
- 40:31know, the access you have to the data and to the research. But
- 40:36but not only that, it's like, every time I go to talk to
- 40:38you, I don't know where in the world you're going to be, Middle
- 40:40East Europe. I mean you're getting that context and that real time counsel with
- 40:46CEOs using all that insights at the Harris Pol leans. As you're counseling CEOs
- 40:53around the world, as you're listening to them, what's your advice to CEOs
- 40:59on the path? Three things? So the first and foremost, the most
- 41:05successful companies that either we work with or that we've been able to analytically model,
- 41:10they balance two things extremely well, right, And that's a the ambition
- 41:16of the company, right, So it's growth, prospects, its vision,
- 41:20it's products with its character. Right, it's very much around kind of the
- 41:23culture or the ethics the citizenship behind it. And you need to have both
- 41:27of those elements. So if you're a company that's only ambition, no character,
- 41:31you're gonna be there's gonna be a lot of potholes. It's gonna be
- 41:34a bumpy ride, right, even if you make some money. Flip side
- 41:37is, if you're a company that's all character, no very low ambition,
- 41:43or the ambition is not working, it's going to be very problematic. You're
- 41:45either not a for profit company, or you're out of or you're bankrupt.
- 41:51Right, that's the first thing. And just even having that simple lens,
- 41:54you know analytically you want more depth, you want a lot more stable.
- 41:58There's a lot more in markets but that's like it's a simple for work.
- 42:00The second is, when you're thinking about telling that story of ambition and character,
- 42:05you know, what are the two or three examples from your organization that
- 42:07really tell that story right? Where? Where can you see that clear intersection
- 42:12between what you do in your business and how you do your business right?
- 42:16And then the third thing is the number of blind spots that we still see
- 42:22for companies today is remarkable, especially as companies are looking at there as you
- 42:27look at companies digital footprints and the changing nature of reputational risk. And I'm
- 42:30not talking just like what's on Twitter or social media. I'm talking about like
- 42:34you know, the digital landscape at large, like if you're searching for a
- 42:37company, there are massive blind spots for for for most companies, and they're
- 42:40only getting bigger if if people aren't addressing them. So it's it's those three
- 42:44things together, I think are the main takeaways. That's that's that's really really
- 42:49sound advice and what a fascinating discussion. So I want to thank Rob Yekelek
- 42:53of The Harris Pole, Elliott ms Rahi of Page for today's fascinating discussion.
- 42:59And I also want to point out the research that we're talking about is available
- 43:02on page dot org and hopefully we gave you plenty of insights today that will
- 43:08help you create positive brand gravity for your own brands and the brands you serve.
- 43:15So tune in next time to hear more conversation and insights from tremendous leaders
- 43:20and thought leaders like Elliott and Rob. I'm Steve Halsey. Thank you for
- 43:25joining us on this episode of Building Brand Gravity. We are GNS Business Communications.
- 43:31We are a team of media strategists, storytellers, and engagement experts who
- 43:37meet you at the intersection of business and communications. To learn more, visit
- 43:42gscommunications dot com. You are listening to Building Brand Gravity attracting people into your
- 43:50orbit AGNs Business Communications podcast. Keep connected with us by subscribing to the show
- 43:55in your favorite podcast player. If you like what you've heard, please rate
- 44:00the show that helps us to keep delivering the latest in industry influence. Thanks
- 44:05for listening. Until next time.