Latest / Politics with Paul / What is Democracy—And How is it Working in America? | Politics with Paul #69
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08Hope you all had a great Thanksgiving.
- 0:12Today's about democracy in America and is it working?
- 0:17Democracy in America is naturally always a hot topic in politics, and it should be.
- 0:23And oftentimes, you hear about it being under attack, usually by candidates trying to win
- 0:28elections or activists trying to get the policies they support implemented.
- 0:34But while there is a lot of heavily biased rhetoric about the ways we save our country,
- 0:40Our freedoms are fragile and we must strive to protect them.
- 0:44And that requires knowing what the core of the American system of government is about.
- 0:49However, there are some misunderstandings and debate about what the American system of
- 0:56government is and what it's supposed to be.
- 0:58Not only that, but there are some concerning beliefs from many Americans that it is not
- 1:04functioning the way it is supposed to.
- 1:07So the concern is not only about civic knowledge about the American style of
- 1:12government, but how Americans perceive its efficacy.
- 1:16So what exactly is democracy?
- 1:19And is The United States a democracy?
- 1:21Where do we see democracy in this country?
- 1:23What are the ideals of democracy?
- 1:25How have Americans felt about democracy in America in the past and how do they feel about
- 1:30it now?
- 1:32And lastly, how do we uphold democracy in America in the face of threats?
- 1:39All this and more is on tap for today's episode.
- 1:42So let's get right into it.
- 1:44First of all, what exactly democracy?
- 1:48It's a word that's thrown around a lot.
- 1:49Lots of words get thrown around a lot in politics regardless of their meaning.
- 1:54So before we define democracy, we need to talk about how we determine what system of
- 1:59government any country can be called in the first place.
- 2:03So you have to think of things like, how is the government structured?
- 2:07Is there a president like here in The United States, or is there a prime minister like in
- 2:11The UK?
- 2:13Are there monarchs?
- 2:14Is there a dictator?
- 2:17What other positions are there?
- 2:19Are there multiple branches of government like how in The US there are three?
- 2:22There's the executive, legislative, and judicial.
- 2:26Or is it really just one branch and the other two are basically at the whims of the other,
- 2:32typically the executive.
- 2:34Are there national, state, and local governments?
- 2:37How subnational do those governments get?
- 2:42How local and sub local do governments get?
- 2:47For example, you have towns and cities, but how do you get below that?
- 2:51Like special districts or universities or HOAs?
- 2:55Another question to think about, what is or rather where is power vested in?
- 3:00Is it with the people?
- 3:02Is it with the government?
- 3:03Is it with the government by consent of the people?
- 3:06Is it a mix?
- 3:08Is power more centralized or spread out across subnational units like states over here,
- 3:14provinces in Canada.
- 3:15Russia has what are called oblasts.
- 3:18There's cantons in, I think it's Switzerland, departments in France, which are more or less
- 3:23the same kind of thing, but they just have some little differences, not necessarily little,
- 3:28sometimes big differences in how exactly they operate.
- 3:31Is power invested or vested in the people, but only certain people?
- 3:36So is it by class where it's only the rich?
- 3:39Is it by race so that the predominant race in a country?
- 3:43Is it by gender where only men can vote?
- 3:46All those are things to think about where power is vested in to think about how exactly or what
- 3:52exactly the system of government is.
- 3:54And then there's also what is the role of citizens?
- 3:56So do they just elect government officials?
- 3:59Which officials do they decide on and which ones are appointed?
- 4:03Because over here in The US, for example, there's a lot of officials that are just
- 4:09appointed rather than voted on, especially in the federal government, and then states vary
- 4:14considerably in what offices can be voted on.
- 4:17Do citizens get to directly participate on any legislation, like with ballot measures, which
- 4:23we'll talk about in a little bit?
- 4:24How much of a role do socioeconomic characteristics play in power distributions?
- 4:29Is it rule by nobility or the masses or is it somewhere in between?
- 4:34Or is it only by the most elite of the elite?
- 4:37So not just wealthy, you have to have
- 4:38a certain echelon of wealth.
- 4:42How much impact do the most wealthy have on governments?
- 4:45Even if it's technically not ruled by the nobility or by the rich, do they have an
- 4:51outsized influence on what government does?
- 4:55And then lastly, how do decisions ultimately get made?
- 4:59So if the people vote on legislation or even if the government does, is it
- 5:05just a civil majority rule in all circumstances?
- 5:08What power does the minority have in the face of the majority?
- 5:14So those are some of the biggest questions to think about when you're talking about the
- 5:17system of government.
- 5:18And then you can get even more granular in defining systems of government.
- 5:22So for example, there are multiple types of democracies, and some of the more basic
- 5:27subgroups or subtypes of democracies is you got a direct democracy where people have the
- 5:34authority to deliberate and make decisions on legislation themselves.
- 5:38And then there's also representative democracy, which is where people elect government
- 5:43officials to make decisions on legislation.
- 5:46And then there are a bunch of other types that get really technical and specific, depending on
- 5:52how technical you want to be.
- 5:55Identifying governments is not always objective or concrete, nor are they always mutually
- 6:01exclusive.
- 6:03For example, if we support democracy but not the party in power, our bias often leads us to
- 6:10say that this country is not a democracy or that it's not acting democratically.
- 6:15We let our partisan or ideological biases affect how we perceive democracy in in
- 6:22government.
- 6:23We're gonna talk about that, of course, some more later on.
- 6:26Words like fascist, socialist, anarchist, communist, these are words that get thrown
- 6:32around all the time with reckless abandon.
- 6:34And a lot of times,
- 6:36not they they are kind
- 6:38of used as euphemisms for undemocratic or just basically, this is not something I agree with,
- 6:45so therefore, it's it's this.
- 6:47Just like how we talk about something's not democratic a lot of times purely based on
- 6:52whether we like that person who's making that action.
- 6:56And then there's some difference in perspectives on how much power the wealthy have
- 7:01and should have in this country.
- 7:04So what exactly is a democracy?
- 7:08So the literal definition of the Greek word that democracy comes from means rule by the
- 7:16people.
- 7:17Beyond that, that's where the exact definition of democracy can differ.
- 7:21So how the rule of the people works can vary because of the aforementioned considerations
- 7:27that we just talked about.
- 7:28But typically in a more quote unquote pure democracy, the people have considerable direct
- 7:35decision making power.
- 7:36So not just they they elect people to make their decisions for them, which is
- 7:42representative democracy, but they have a lot of direct power on decisions as well.
- 7:48You get into these technical definitions versus the ideals of democracy.
- 7:54So even if you technically don't have a democracy, there are still a lot of ideals that
- 8:02come from democracies that can and should be upheld, and we're going to talk about some more
- 8:07of those ideals shortly.
- 8:09Just as a few, for example,
- 8:11we have the freedom of speech and religion and the right to personal property, but how we
- 8:18value those can differ from democracy to democracy.
- 8:22Oh, one of the big questions here,
- 8:24is the American system of government a democracy?
- 8:27You have probably heard some people say that it is not a democracy.
- 8:32This partly depends on how technical and some people might say pedantic that you want to get.
- 8:39To some extent, is a matter of technical definitions versus ideals.
- 8:43So do we functionally have a democracy?
- 8:46Or is it just aspects of a democracy that you find in this country even without actually
- 8:51being a democracy?
- 8:54And so if you want to get super technical and strict, the very technical definition of the
- 9:02American system of government, we are not a democracy Because democracy for several
- 9:08reasons.
- 9:09One, democracy often implies majority rule all the time, or at least most of the time that
- 9:13everybody gets an equal voice in government, which does not happen in every case.
- 9:18Some people will point to the electoral college, for example, as a non democratic
- 9:22aspect.
- 9:23It's an indirect election of the president.
- 9:24It's actually done through the states, even though the states are largely based on people's
- 9:29vote, but you can win without the majority of the popular vote as president.
- 9:34Equal US senate representation is not democratic because no matter how big your state
- 9:39is, each state gets two US senators.
- 9:42It's the US house that's that is based on the population.
- 9:49Then there's also constitutional limits on what can be done, so it's not just straight up
- 9:53democracy all the time.
- 9:55Many offices are appointed and not elected.
- 9:59So you could point to a whole bunch of different reasons why we're technically not a
- 10:03democracy.
- 10:04And the people also have limited ability to directly make decisions on policy.
- 10:09Now, you have a bit more of a representative democracy because we have other people making
- 10:13our decisions, but even then, we have limited ability to directly make decisions on policy
- 10:19because there's still a lot of officials that are not elected and they have a lot of impact
- 10:25on policy.
- 10:26And if you read the Federalist Papers and other works by the framers of the constitution and
- 10:32founding fathers, there was some apprehension about too much democracy because they were
- 10:36afraid of primarily what they call the tyranny of the majority where the majority would just
- 10:41run roughshod over the minority and the minority can't say anything and the majority
- 10:47can do whatever it wants.
- 10:49So a lot of founding fathers, not all of them, but not all of the framers of the constitution
- 10:54were a little wary of quote unquote true democracy.
- 11:01But it's kind of pedantic to be like, oh, we're not a democracy.
- 11:05Yeah, we're not.
- 11:07But a lot of times people just say that just to be a little bit pretentious and know it all.
- 11:12And I'm gonna admit, I've been guilty of that in the past.
- 11:17So, yes, we're not actually a democracy.
- 11:21By pure definition, what we are actually are is a constitutional federal republic.
- 11:27So take each of those words.
- 11:29Constitutional, we have a constitution that is the supreme law of The US, and it provides the
- 11:34framework for how government is structured and limits on that government's power.
- 11:39And then the constituent states also have their constitutions, but the US constitution is the
- 11:44ultimate authority.
- 11:45So whatever the state constitution says, as long as it's not contradicting directly the US
- 11:50constitution, it's fine.
- 11:52If it is contradicting the US constitution at any point, it is not fine.
- 11:55It is unconstitutional.
- 11:58The federal part comes from the fact that power is shared between the national or central
- 12:03governments and the state governments.
- 12:06So federal and national are two words that are often used interchangeably, and for the most
- 12:11part they mean the same thing, But to be fully accurate, we are a federal government, not a
- 12:17national.
- 12:18Because national indicates that it's a unitary state where states and provinces hold little to
- 12:25no authority.
- 12:26States in The US actually have a lot of power, and that is a point of contention.
- 12:31How much power do they have and should they have?
- 12:34And then the federal power is derived in large part from the states.
- 12:38It's where we get the term federalism from as there are some powers that are specific to the
- 12:42federal government.
- 12:43There are some specific to the states, and then there are some powers shared by both the
- 12:47federal and state governments.
- 12:49And then the republic comes from the fact that while the people hold power, they elect
- 12:54representatives to exercise that power.
- 12:56So for example, we have a congress for the federal government and we have state
- 13:01legislatures for these states.
- 13:04However,
- 13:05of course, we do see aspects and ideals of democracy at work, which is the vast majority
- 13:12of what we are talking about today.
- 13:15So where exactly do we see this democracy in America?
- 13:20Regardless of our definition of democracy, there are plenty of examples of its ideals at
- 13:26work in America.
- 13:28Unfortunately, though, America has
- 13:30not always lived up to its democratic ideals, namely from the fact that suffrage or the right
- 13:37to vote used to be highly restricted and in ways that some people don't realize.
- 13:43Even early in the republic's history, only white propertied males could vote.
- 13:50So not even every white guy could voice their opinion about government.
- 13:55Now those property restrictions were the first really big one to go in regards to restricting
- 14:01the right to vote.
- 14:03So even though property requirements would be phased out, racial minorities still couldn't
- 14:08vote.
- 14:09And different racial minorities got the right to vote at different times.
- 14:13The eighth amendment in 1870 granted the right to vote to some but not all ities.
- 14:19Ones that were considered citizens of The US.
- 14:21So at that point, obviously, African Americans.
- 14:25But the ones like those of Asian descent didn't get it at that point.
- 14:31Native Americans didn't get it at that point.
- 14:33They didn't get until later.
- 14:34And I forget which episode of the podcast it is, but I actually talk about that in an
- 14:39earlier episode about basically the history of voting rights in this country.
- 14:47And then even when racial minorities were still getting the right to vote, women didn't have
- 14:53the right to vote until the eighteenth century in 1920.
- 14:56Though there were some states that had already allowed them to vote, even if it was only for
- 15:01certain offices before that point.
- 15:03So that is actually why Wyoming is called the equality state because they were the first
- 15:08state to grant women the right to vote.
- 15:11We have generally become more democratic over time.
- 15:15Now how democratic we are is still somewhat subjective.
- 15:20Some activists and politicians argue that laws, for example, that prevent ex felons from
- 15:26restoring their right to vote are anti democratic because they did their time, they're
- 15:33out, why are we delaying the restoration of their right to vote?
- 15:36And then some people will say, well, they
- 15:40harmed society, this is their penance even if they're out of jail.
- 15:44And there are even a couple of states that, I believe Vermont's one and I
- 15:49think there's one other one, that lets people currently in jail vote.
- 15:56So is that democratic?
- 15:58Another one to consider is, are term limits antidemocratic?
- 16:03Now term limits tend to
- 16:04be a pretty popular sentiment, but there are one of the big opposing arguments to term
- 16:12limits is people say they're antidemocratic because you're basically telling voters that
- 16:17even if they want to support this longtime elected official, they can't anymore because,
- 16:25at least in the minds of people who are against term limits, they have this arbitrary limit
- 16:30placed on them, for example, eight years or twelve years or sixteen years.
- 16:34So they'll say that it's actually anti democratic to have term limits because you're
- 16:38not letting people decide to vote for that official.
- 16:43Now some people will come back and say, well, actually, the fact that they are still in
- 16:47office is antidemocratic because they have a lot more resources at their disposal and are
- 16:52able to use the encompassing advantage, and that gets into a whole other can of worms.
- 16:57We've actually talked about term limits for several times on this podcast, including early
- 17:02on, so I don't wanna get too much into it.
- 17:04But I wanna bring it up in the context of whether US democracy is working as it should
- 17:10because that is an argument that has had is that term limits are not a democratic
- 17:16institution.
- 17:17And then but then some people say it is democratic.
- 17:19So that's that's for you to decide.
- 17:22But clear cut examples of democracy in America, just some of
- 17:28them to talk about is ballot measures.
- 17:31This is probably
- 17:33no.
- 17:33It's not necessarily the the most obvious example.
- 17:36I mean, voting in general is the most obvious example of democratic ideals, but ballot
- 17:41measures are the most direct way for voters to make their voice heard.
- 17:46Now how these ballot measures work differs by state.
- 17:51For example, the basic types of ballot measures, you have citizen initiated measures,
- 17:56you have legislative really referred initiatives, and then ones that I'll just say
- 18:01are more miscellaneous.
- 18:02Get to them in a second.
- 18:0326 states allow for some form of citizen initiated measures.
- 18:09So not only do citizens vote on a policy to implement in their state statutes or their
- 18:15constitutional amendments or their city's charter, they also can propose that policy in
- 18:23these 26 states.
- 18:25Now, they don't all work the same way in terms of what kinds of initiatives you can bring up
- 18:31and how exactly you have to construct those initiatives.
- 18:34Like for example, some of them have single subject rules where only one subject can be
- 18:39discussed in that initiative.
- 18:41So if it's marijuana, or if it's guns, you can't have marijuana and guns in the same
- 18:48initiative if it's a single subject rule.
- 18:50But there is some not leeway, but there is some interpretation to be had about what exactly
- 18:57constitutes a single subject.
- 19:00But then you also have the legislative legislative Lee referred initiatives, And every
- 19:07state except Delaware has those.
- 19:09These are ones where instead of citizens proposing an initiative, or a ballot measure
- 19:14that gets on the ballot, it's actually the state legislature that says this is what we
- 19:19support.
- 19:20Now you guys get to decide.
- 19:21So then they put it to the voters that way.
- 19:24Every state except except Delaware requires that for these legislatively referred measures.
- 19:32I don't know why Delaware is the odd one out in that regard, but they are.
- 19:35Other unique circumstances, this miscellaneous category I mentioned a little bit ago, you have
- 19:39automatic ballot referrals, which are so these are ones that are not you don't have to
- 19:45specifically go through a petition process to get this amendment put on the ballot.
- 19:51This is one that automatically comes up every ten fifteen, maybe a different timeframe,
- 20:00depending on the state.
- 20:02So you don't have to actually do anything to make it get on the ballot.
- 20:06You also have ones that are commission referred.
- 20:08So if there's a unique commission, like there there's a constitutional revision commission
- 20:14from in Florida.
- 20:17There's a I think Arizona has a specifically a tax related commission that can put forth
- 20:24ballot measures.
- 20:26You have certain other commissions like that, several other states.
- 20:29And then you have conventions where like if there's a
- 20:31state constitutional convention, they can refer initiatives
- 20:37to or ballot measures to the ballot.
- 20:40So those are the three big categories.
- 20:42And then you also have a lot of local measures that are voted on each year as well.
- 20:48So things like bonds or raising a half cent sales tax typically for schools, but it might
- 20:55be for something else as well.
- 20:57All sorts of other things that that a local measure could be about.
- 21:00So they might work fairly similarly to the state level ballot measures, but they are, of
- 21:07course, for a specific locality like a county or a city.
- 21:11And then how they can pass differs as well.
- 21:13So typically, ballot measures only need a simple majority, which is a 50% plus one vote.
- 21:20And that's that's when you talk about democracy, you typically think just simple
- 21:25majority.
- 21:25But Florida and Illinois require 60% for citizen initiated constitutional amendments.
- 21:32Around it needs 55%.
- 21:34And then Arizona needs 60% for tax related measures specifically.
- 21:39Now, when you talk about democracy, there's another debate to be had.
- 21:42Does democracy have to be a simple majority?
- 21:4660% anti democratic?
- 21:49Because if you have 55% of people say, for example, or 53%, you have a majority of people
- 21:56saying that, but it's not a simple majority rule.
- 21:59You have to have
- 21:59a super majority like 60%.
- 22:02So is that antidemocratic?
- 22:05Maybe it is, maybe it's not.
- 22:07That's another thing for you to decide.
- 22:09Another thing that is democratic
- 22:13is, of course, how we vote on state level officials.
- 22:17So some states elect more state level officials than others do.
- 22:21Alaska, for example, only has governor and lieutenant governor that has voted on.
- 22:26They have other state executives, but they're appointed.
- 22:28North Carolina, meanwhile, I think has like 10 state executives that are voted on that in
- 22:34different years.
- 22:34But some states also might have elected state supreme court judges or intermediate appellate
- 22:40court judges.
- 22:41Other states, they are simply appointed or they have a unique way to elect them where, like,
- 22:47they've not necessarily chosen through an election at the beginning.
- 22:50They might be appointed by the governor, but then to retain them, the voters then choose
- 22:57whether to re retain them or to say, bye bye.
- 23:00Get out of here.
- 23:01So, obviously, it's more democratic to have more people voted on, but which state
- 23:10executives, which state level judges should be voted on as a requirement of democracy?
- 23:15Is it necessarily anti democratic to say we can't vote on state supreme court judges?
- 23:21Some people will say it is anti democratic.
- 23:23Some people will say it's not.
- 23:25Some people will say it's probably anti democratic, but these are positions not
- 23:29necessarily for state Supreme Court, but maybe like an education commissioner, for example,
- 23:33they'll say maybe it's anti democratic, but these are things that other people need to
- 23:38decide on.
- 23:39So government officials and that's a whole other discussion.
- 23:42But you also have in the vast majority of elections, candidates only need a plurality of
- 23:48the vote to win.
- 23:49So that simply just means they have the highest percentage of the vote compared to the other
- 23:53candidates.
- 23:54However, there are certain cases in some states where candidates need a majority.
- 24:01If they don't win a majority of the votes, they gotta go to a runoff between the top two vote
- 24:07getters in a couple of weeks.
- 24:09And there are some places like California, for example, where it doesn't matter how much of
- 24:13the vote you get, you have to win or you have
- 24:16to go to a general they have it at whereas a top two primary where top two vote getters in
- 24:23the primary go on
- 24:24to the general election.
- 24:25And no matter how many votes or what percentage of the vote you got in that primary, if if
- 24:31you got 99% of them, you go to the general election.
- 24:36So how democratic or antidemocratic are those stipulations of needing
- 24:44a runoff?
- 24:47Is ranked choice voting more democratic than a normal plurality or normal majority vote?
- 24:53So where you have a whole bunch of candidates and you rank them first place choice, second
- 24:58place, or second preference, third preference, fourth preference, however many voters they
- 25:03are, and then you go through that rigmarole until you get to a majority of people choosing
- 25:09a specific candidate.
- 25:10Is that inherently more democratic than a simple plurality vote or a majority vote?
- 25:16A lot of questions that we have to ask ourselves.
- 25:19But I think it would behoove us right now to then get further into the actual ideals of
- 25:25democracy.
- 25:26So by technical definition, no, we are not a democracy, but we clearly have democratic
- 25:31aspects at work.
- 25:33So different democracies have different ideals they specifically look to protect, or they have
- 25:39similar ideals, but they have different levels of protection and specific laws and
- 25:44regulations.
- 25:45So for example, in a country that actually values democracy, not one that's that pretends
- 25:53that its elections mean anything.
- 25:55Many countries value the freedom or many of these countries value the freedom of speech,
- 26:01but they do it to different degrees.
- 26:03It's not not quite the same level as it is in The US.
- 26:07There might be some restrictions there.
- 26:10Like for example, in Germany, for example,
- 26:13you have a lot of regulations as to Nazi imagery and what it can
- 26:20be used for and predominantly can only be used for educational purposes.
- 26:24You don't quite have that in The US where, for example, the KKK
- 26:29is not just only restricted to educational purposes.
- 26:34Unfortunately, they can still assemble as as a group and and do their thing as
- 26:42long as they're not actually
- 26:43threatening people.
- 26:46And it's one of those things where,
- 26:49yes, obviously, this is something we don't want them to do.
- 26:52And ideally, they wouldn't be doing it, but freedom of speech requires that we let them do
- 26:59that as long as they're not infringing on other people's rights and they're not threatening
- 27:03people.
- 27:04So, obviously, you can't do that.
- 27:06There are even in America, there are still some restrictions on your freedom of speech that
- 27:13have been reformulated or not reformulated, but
- 27:16they have been revised over time.
- 27:20But it like we said a moment ago, just because you can vote doesn't mean your elections are
- 27:26democratic.
- 27:27So you have some authoritarian based countries that have voting, but it's it's a sham.
- 27:32Like, for example, in Venezuela, Nicolas Maduro is not a democratically elected ruler of
- 27:39Venezuela.
- 27:40Technically, yes, he is just because they had election, but the elections were rigged.
- 27:44And, unfortunately, there are quite a few countries that have similar situations.
- 27:52But that being said, there are common ideals of democracy that you do see in America, and the
- 27:59Bill of Rights is Exhibit A, especially when it comes to the First Amendment freedoms of
- 28:05speech, religion, press, assembly, and petition.
- 28:09Those are probably the most core parts of a democracy, particularly the free speech part,
- 28:16the consent of the governed because it's you're talking about the rule by the people and power
- 28:21being vested in the people.
- 28:23You see that directly in the preamble of the constitution.
- 28:27We, the people of The United States, in order to create a more perfect union, etcetera,
- 28:32etcetera.
- 28:33Right there is the consent of the governed.
- 28:35You can see it's in the supreme law of the land right at
- 28:39the very beginning.
- 28:41Voting rights,
- 28:42we just talked about that.
- 28:43Of course, we unfortunately had very anti democratic restrictions on that early on in
- 28:50American history, and it's taken a long time for those to be whittled down.
- 28:55Now we have racial minorities can vote, women can vote, the minimum people who don't have
- 29:03property can vote.
- 29:04The minimum age required to vote was lowered from 21 to 18 in the nineteen seventies as a
- 29:13result of the Vietnam War and especially with that sentiment that's old enough to die, old
- 29:19enough to vote.
- 29:20So the argument was if people can get drafted, and they have to go off to die, then they
- 29:27should at least be able to to vote.
- 29:29And that's another thing too.
- 29:30Drafts can be considered very anti democratic because the people don't have a say in whether
- 29:38we have
- 29:38a draft.
- 29:40That's what you saw in World War two, World War one, Vietnam War, older wars.
- 29:48So that's another case of anti democracy there.
- 29:54Protections against government intrusions are another ideal of democracy.
- 29:58For example, the protection against illegal searches and seizures in the
- 30:01Bill of Rights.
- 30:02The Declaration of Independence, the most well known phrase from that is life, liberty, a
- 30:10pursuit of happiness.
- 30:12They were heavily influenced by one of the most particularly influential philosophers in that
- 30:17specific regard was John Locke and his philosophy about the right to personal
- 30:22property.
- 30:23And then minority rights.
- 30:25And this this can be a bit of a tricky topic when it gets to democracy.
- 30:31Because in a in its purest form, democracy doesn't really regard minority rights.
- 30:38It's simply just majority rule.
- 30:40If you're in
- 30:40the minority, tough crap.
- 30:43You you have to deal with it.
- 30:45And like we
- 30:47said before, founding fathers or a lot of the founding fathers, not all
- 30:51of them had this worry, but a lot
- 30:53of them were weary of democracy for this very reason calling it tyranny of the majority.
- 31:00But then even people who are very supportive of democracy will oftentimes lament a minority
- 31:07being obstructive.
- 31:09You hear about it all the time in Congress where people who support the majority party in
- 31:16power, whether it's Democrat, whether it's Republican, they'll say that the minority is
- 31:21being obstructive and purposely causing gridlock,
- 31:24even if they normally are very supportive of democracy.
- 31:28So then it's that gets into the, how much do you protect the right of minorities and how
- 31:35much does it then what's the dividing line where it then becomes just obstructionist?
- 31:40And there's no real easy answer in that regard.
- 31:44Or or whether the obstructionism is a threat to democracy.
- 31:49That is one of the many debates surrounding it.
- 31:52And then of course, one of
- 31:54the biggest ideals of democracy is the idea of pluralism, where a whole bunch of interests can
- 32:00come and compete in a marketplace of ideas to have influence.
- 32:06Now how pluralistic we are is a another is another matter of debate.
- 32:12And actually, my guest next week will we will be talking about pluralism in particular, and I
- 32:18will get her thoughts on the matter of hyperpluralism.
- 32:21So stay tuned for that.
- 32:23But pluralism, having a whole bunch of
- 32:25people competing for influence and trying to share their ideas, having that freedom of
- 32:31speech and petition and assembly and everything like that.
- 32:36That is another core aspect of democracy.
- 32:40So how have Americans felt about democracy historically in America?
- 32:46Obviously, with voting rights having to be expanded over time, there are countless
- 32:51philosophical writings about the lack of democracy in America at different points in
- 32:56history, whether it's from racial minorities like a Frederick Douglass or a Thurgood
- 33:01Marshall, the first black chief justice of the US Supreme Court.
- 33:07Frederick Douglass, a former slave, then eventually became freed and was one of
- 33:14the most influential thinkers of the Civil War era and the post Civil War era.
- 33:21There have been a
- 33:22lot of instances of concerns about democracy at various points in time throughout history,
- 33:27especially from, well, including the founding fathers and their concerns about democracy.
- 33:33Even after The US constitution is ratified and several decades rolled on, of those founding
- 33:40fathers and framers of
- 33:41the constitution rethought what they felt about democracy.
- 33:46But some of the most obvious examples of people seeing US democracy as or Americans or seeing
- 33:57the country coming up woefully short of its democratic ideals.
- 34:01Most obvious examples are slavery and Jim Crow laws.
- 34:05Jim Crow laws being the Reconstruction era and especially post Reconstruction era laws that
- 34:12basically tried to recreate the environment and rules of slavery without actually reinstituting
- 34:22slavery.
- 34:22So technically, they could say, oh, we're not actually putting African Americans in chains,
- 34:28but they're still heavily restricting all sorts of other things like whether they can use the
- 34:33same facilities as white people or whether they can vote.
- 34:37And a lot of nefarious ways that they use to restrict the right to vote for African
- 34:42Americans, not the least of which was through sheer intimidation, but you had things like
- 34:48poll taxes.
- 34:49A lot of times, black voters were in large part because of just coming out of slavery, very
- 34:56poor.
- 34:57And a lot of
- 34:57them worked as sharecroppers, for example.
- 35:00And so a lot of times they couldn't pay the poll tax to go and vote or they couldn't pass
- 35:05literacy tests because they weren't allowed to be taught how to read and write as slaves or at
- 35:11least they were very, very restricted in how they could do that.
- 35:15So there was a lot of ways that they weren't allowed to vote even though they technically
- 35:21had the right to vote or could get themselves registered to vote.
- 35:25And another way that they got around that's for white people.
- 35:30So there are still plenty of poor, illiterate white people then.
- 35:35But the way that a lot of these, especially Southern states, got around that is they used
- 35:39something called a grandfather clause where, basically, if your grandfather was allowed to
- 35:44vote, then you could get past all those restrictions.
- 35:48So poor, illiterate white people wouldn't have to deal with poll taxes and literacy tests, at
- 35:53least not to the same degree that black people did.
- 35:57So, obviously, that is very anti democratic.
- 36:01And then, of course, women not being able to vote or at least not every American woman being
- 36:07able to vote until the nineteenth amendment being ratified in 1920.
- 36:12You also had sedition laws.
- 36:14So the Alien and Sedition Acts during John Adams' presidency, that was a very
- 36:19controversial measure related to democracy, especially because they were particularly
- 36:24targeted to it was a federalist law that was targeted at Democratic Republicans.
- 36:30You had the Espionage Act during Woodrow Wilson's presidency in World War I.
- 36:36The draft in World War I, World War II, Vietnam War, those were certainly concerns about
- 36:43democracy as well because people didn't have a say as to whether the draft was a legitimate
- 36:50means of or that they didn't have any say as to whether the draft was they had any consent to
- 36:57being drafted.
- 36:58Now, obviously, don't have the draft anymore, but it technically could be reinstituted at
- 37:04some point in time, in which case then it would become another major concern about democracy if
- 37:09that happened.
- 37:11And then if we look at more quantitative measures of how people feel about democracy,
- 37:18Gallup has some polling on satisfaction with US democracy, though they haven't done it
- 37:23consistently over time.
- 37:25They started in 1984.
- 37:26They did then they did some of the 1990s, and then they didn't do it again till the 2020s.
- 37:31There were some other port pulling organizations that did it like CNN, for
- 37:36example.
- 37:37But just for the sake of consistency, we're just going to keep it with Gallup, because
- 37:44organizations pulling organizations can have differences in how they sample their
- 37:49populations or how exactly they word their questions, which can have a major impact on the
- 37:56results.
- 37:57So we'll just use Gallup for consistency.
- 38:00It'll be a little bit hard to paint a picture, but it kind of plummeted from the nineteen
- 38:07eighties or it went to the nineteen nineties.
- 38:09It was okay.
- 38:10And then during the nineteen nineties, it went down considerably up until the very end of the
- 38:15nineteen nineties, it went up.
- 38:16And then in the twenty twenties, it went down.
- 38:18So specific numbers for people who were satisfied with the way that US democracy was
- 38:24working in the country 61% agreed in 1984.
- 38:28And went slightly down 60% in 1991.
- 38:31So there was a seven year gap, then went to 48%, and then 36% in 1992.
- 38:37So they actually pulled it twice in 1992.
- 38:39And it's shut down precipitously 50% in 1994, then 46% in 1995.
- 38:47Then it went up a
- 38:48little bit 52% in 1998.
- 38:51Then you
- 38:51get to the 2020s.
- 38:52And people feel not they do not feel good about democracy in America.
- 38:58There's 35% of people were satisfied with it in 2021, and then it hit its low point in 2023,
- 39:05which was 28%.
- 39:06And last year, it went up a little bit, 34% in 2024.
- 39:12Now how do they feel about it in 2025?
- 39:16So opinions on how democratic America is now can depend way too much on whether we support
- 39:24the party in power.
- 39:26If you're a republican and the government is republican, you probably think we're more
- 39:32democratic than democrats do.
- 39:35And if it's a democratic democratically controlled government or democrat controlled
- 39:40government,
- 39:42you probably think the government is more democratic than lowercase d than Republicans
- 39:47do.
- 39:48Unfortunately, our party affiliations color a lot about how we think about the level of
- 39:54democracy in this country or how we how much we support a specific person, namely the
- 39:59president.
- 39:59So if we are the same party, yeah, democracy is working fine, or at least we tend to think that
- 40:05more.
- 40:05And if it's not the same party, then we tend to
- 40:08think, oh, democracy is under attack.
- 40:11Some people, though, regardless of
- 40:12that, they have accused The US system of still not truly being democratic.
- 40:18Now, one prominent point of contention in that regard is the power of the wealthy, especially
- 40:24with the Citizens United case, the ruling from that by the US Supreme Court, which enabled
- 40:32these independent expenditures that can spend unlimited amounts of money on elections.
- 40:37It was considered a matter of free speech for them.
- 40:40As long as these organizations don't coordinate with the campaigns they support.
- 40:47Now, if you do that, you will go to jail.
- 40:50But if these organizations don't directly coordinate with these campaigns,
- 40:57they are legally okay.
- 40:59That is a major point of controversy for a lot of people and people see that as one
- 41:06of the examples of the wealthy having too much power in American politics.
- 41:12And then some activists would argue that voter ID laws are racist and therefore undemocratic
- 41:18and they say they unfairly target racial minorities who have less access to those IDs
- 41:24that would be needed to vote.
- 41:25Now, I'm
- 41:26not saying that I agree or disagree with those sentiments.
- 41:30It's just examples I'm trying
- 41:32to bring up of people who say that we are not so democratic or at least as democratic as we
- 41:37should be.
- 41:38And these are several of the reasons that they bring up.
- 41:42But for another quantitative measure of how people feel about democracy in America, there's
- 41:48a joint venture between the Kettering Foundation, which is involved with democracy
- 41:52initiatives around the globe and Gallup, and it's called the Democracy for All Project.
- 41:58And they did this in-depth study of how Americans experience democracy.
- 42:03So like most polls, this has some positive and some negative takeaways
- 42:08for us to look at.
- 42:10And some of
- 42:11the positive takeaways, 80% of respondents agreed that political leaders should compromise
- 42:16with the other party to get things done, even if they don't like some parts of the
- 42:20compromise.
- 42:2283% agreed that it is never okay for people to use violence to achieve a political goal,
- 42:28which you would hope that was a 100%, but of course, it's almost never a 100%.
- 42:35But using political violence to achieve goals is inherently anti democratic.
- 42:40A refusal to compromise is not necessarily anti democratic, but refusing to hear out what other
- 42:49people have to say at any point in time,
- 42:52that is pretty antidemocratic.
- 42:54You're not really letting people put their voice out there.
- 42:5884% agreed in this poll that The US is stronger as a nation because it has people from
- 43:04different races, religions, and cultures.
- 43:07We've talked about democracy.
- 43:09One of the big things is including more and more people in the process.
- 43:13So it is antidemocratic to exclude people based on based on race, religion, and culture.
- 43:21Bringing them in, is more democratic.
- 43:2483% of people in this poll agreed that wealthy individuals and businesses should be limited in
- 43:29how much they can advance political candidates or causes they support.
- 43:33Now, of course, how much should you think they should be limited?
- 43:38Gets maybe a little bit murkier and that might be more there might be more specific debates
- 43:44about democracy when you talk about how exactly they should be restricted.
- 43:4988% of people in the poll agreed that there are facts and there are opinions.
- 43:55Now, maybe that's not necessarily a democratic ideal.
- 43:59Well, you would hope that people are educated about how to tell when there's a fact and when
- 44:05there's an opinion.
- 44:06Unfortunately, though, as we've talked about several times on this podcast, and has been
- 44:10talked about elsewhere, plenty of times is the ability of many people to tell the difference
- 44:17between a fact and an opinion is a little concerning, but you would hope at least in a
- 44:22democracy people know the difference and are willing to accept facts.
- 44:27And then lastly, the last positive takeaway that I'll bring up in this episode, large
- 44:34majorities of people supported compromise, rejection of political violence and
- 44:40multiculturalism, regardless of age group, whether they graduated from college or not, and
- 44:45across party identifications.
- 44:47Fantastic.
- 44:48There's a lot of really good stuff there.
- 44:50Obviously, some of those things you'd like to see 100%, but once again, you're almost never
- 44:54going to get 100% in a poll on anything.
- 44:58However, I did say that there were some negative takeaways from this poll.
- 45:03And a few of the biggest ones here, only 67% believe democracy is the best form of
- 45:10government.
- 45:11So while that is a large majority, and it's arguably still positive, I'd argue that we
- 45:16should see much more than two thirds of Americans supporting it.
- 45:19Now, refer back to early in this episode, we talked about the technical definitions of
- 45:25democracy versus the ideals of democracy.
- 45:28So that could also be playing a role in here.
- 45:32There's one when we ask people if democracy is the best form of government, and I'd have to go
- 45:37into the poll again to see the exact wording.
- 45:40We're talking about democracy versus non democracy, and we're still not sure if we
- 45:46support democracy as the better form of government.
- 45:50That is a bit concerning, but some people might be thinking of democracy versus a
- 45:55constitutional federal republic, like we just talked about how The US is by strict
- 45:59definition.
- 46:00Another concerning finding in the poll is that just 24% of the people that were surveyed are
- 46:07satisfied with the way democracy is working in The US.
- 46:12Dissatisfaction with various political barometers like this or others like whether the
- 46:18country is quote unquote on the right
- 46:19track, Unfortunately, they tend
- 46:22to be pretty low quite often.
- 46:25But just because it is a common sentiment doesn't mean that it's not concerning or that
- 46:30it's
- 46:30not something that we should address.
- 46:32It is something we need to address.
- 46:3351% of the respondents rated US Democracy as performing
- 46:39poorly or very poorly.
- 46:42That is quite troubling.
- 46:44Obviously, we need to actually have democracy performing well, but it also is a big deal
- 46:50whether people think it is performing well.
- 46:53And then lastly, as Gallup writes, the data also revealed discord over how democracy should
- 46:59function, including how much power the majority should have, tolerance of radical voices in
- 47:04politics, and the pace of cultural change.
- 47:06People's political orientation, age, education, and in some cases, income are associated with
- 47:12deep societal divides over how to become a better union.
- 47:16So that speaks to the point about how we can disagree about specific policies, but we do
- 47:24need a unifying purpose.
- 47:29This trying to become the strongest union that we possibly could, bringing in as many voices
- 47:35as possible.
- 47:37But clearly, the Kettering slash Gallup poll here shows a lot of divide in that regard.
- 47:46So and and that that's not to say that I'm not trying to necessarily put forth my opinion
- 47:51about how much power the majority should have or specific voices that should get a seat at
- 47:57the table or anything.
- 47:58But the point is, these are
- 48:00serious concerns and things that we need to discuss so that we can make US democracy the
- 48:08best it can be.
- 48:10Speaking of which, we do clearly have a lot of threats to democracy moving forward.
- 48:17Even without that poll, you can see threats to democracy.
- 48:21As I've
- 48:22said before, it's not just about whether our democratic ideals are objectively working.
- 48:27We have to feel that they are working too.
- 48:30Perception is oftentimes just as important as the reality.
- 48:36Otherwise, the legitimacy of these institutions is threatened.
- 48:39And so I'm gonna talk about several of the biggest threats to democracy moving forward,
- 48:46and not that they're the only ones by any means, certainly not, But they are ones that we
- 48:53really have to think long and hard about, about how we're gonna actually fix these points.
- 48:59Because if we don't fix
- 49:00these points, democratic ideals are at stake.
- 49:05So first one,
- 49:07and one I talk about a lot, of course, is political polarization, especially affective
- 49:14polarization, affective relating to how we feel about people.
- 49:19So when we encounter people that think differently than us, and we feel anger, hate,
- 49:25disgust, fear, that indicates higher levels of effective political polarization.
- 49:31And so when we have high rates of polarization, particularly effective polarization, it leads
- 49:37us to perceive threats to democracy, conveniently only from people we don't agree
- 49:42with.
- 49:44We think that because these people think differently, that they're an existential threat
- 49:47to not only us, but what we think The US is supposed to be.
- 49:53And a lot of times, it is purely based on the policies that we want, not that we actually
- 50:00think that they are threats to democracy.
- 50:04And this effect of polarization leads us to hate and be angry with people who don't share
- 50:09our views.
- 50:10And so we start to be okay with trampling over their viewpoints.
- 50:13And this brings up the right of the minority.
- 50:18How much power should the majority have?
- 50:21Well, at some point, if
- 50:23you give them too much power, they're going to trample over minority viewpoints.
- 50:27And so it also leads us to believe that these quote unquote, others don't belong.
- 50:34And this conflict over who belongs in our democracy is its own threat to democracy.
- 50:40We need to bring as many people as we possibly can in here.
- 50:45Because this is not just my country.
- 50:47This is not just your country.
- 50:49This is our country.
- 50:51Another big threat to
- 50:54democracy moving forward is the it's gonna sound like two, but really they're both rolled
- 51:01into one is the delegitimization of political institutions and the lack of public trust in
- 51:07institutions.
- 51:08There are a lot of people who profit off of dissension and anger, and they make a lot of
- 51:16they get a lot of social clout and make a lot of money off of making people angry about
- 51:21institutions, especially when they call into question election results simply because they
- 51:26lost.
- 51:26Now, before people make assumptions about who I'm talking about, this is something that both
- 51:32parties have done and especially with the 2016 and twenty twenty elections.
- 51:38I try not to directly criticize people unless I think I can criticize across the board,
- 51:45and this is absolutely something that can be criticized.
- 51:48In 2016, Democrats, a lot
- 51:52of them did not want to believe that they legitimately lost the election, and Republicans
- 51:57told them to suck it up and quit crying.
- 51:582020 rolls around, and then Republicans say that the election results are illegitimate, and
- 52:03then Democrats tell them to suck it up and quit crying.
- 52:06We can't just accept election results when they're ones that we like.
- 52:12Doesn't mean that you can't criticize certain aspects about it, but when we just constantly
- 52:17talk about elections as being rigged because they didn't go the way we wanted them to.
- 52:22That is a very serious problem.
- 52:25And voting is just the most obvious of political institutions that we have.
- 52:30We have to believe that democratic institutions are legitimate and serious, but lately people
- 52:37have been questioning them, not not genuinely.
- 52:42Criticisms of institutions are fine because nothing is above reproach.
- 52:46We've seen through American history how that is the case and things have had to be refined over
- 52:50time.
- 52:52And there are still plenty of things that need to be refined, but they have to be made with
- 52:55the right intentions in mind.
- 52:57If you're doing it purely just to gain social clout or to win elections, that is not a
- 53:04legitimate excuse.
- 53:05I mean, that should be obvious, but unfortunately, it's not obvious.
- 53:10And public trusting government has cratered since the days of Eisenhower and JFK, where it
- 53:16was well into the majorities of people who thought that government or they trusted
- 53:22government to do what is right just about always or most of the time.
- 53:26With Pew Research Center data,
- 53:29we can look at 1958 through 2024, this polling about this very question.
- 53:38Pew Research Center said they found that the percentage of people that they polled who say
- 53:45they trust government to do what is right just about always or most of the time was 24% in
- 53:522024.
- 53:54That is abysmal.
- 53:55And it hasn't been appreciably higher than that since the early 2000s.
- 54:00Even before that, when you saw public trust crater precipitously, it happened across both
- 54:07Democratic and Republican administrations.
- 54:10So it's not a one party thing.
- 54:12And it doesn't help that public trust is also partially influenced by our party affiliation
- 54:20where just like we think institutions are more legitimate when we happen to agree with the
- 54:26people who are running them,
- 54:27the general trust in government is largely influenced by whether we support the party in
- 54:34power, and that's not how it should be.
- 54:36That is a huge threat to democracy because then we think that only our opinions are the
- 54:44legitimate ones and that other opinions need to be stamped out or otherwise they're gonna stamp
- 54:48us out.
- 54:50It's this get them before they get you mentality that people have that really needs to
- 54:56change.
- 54:58Other threat to democracy going forward is economic inequality.
- 55:05This is not a point about capitalism versus socialism.
- 55:10I want to make that very clear right now.
- 55:12I'm not here to argue about what economic system is better.
- 55:15Just like anything else, they all have their flaws.
- 55:18I know we want to think that a lot of times our worldview is 100%, We've all been there.
- 55:24They're not.
- 55:25But this is I'm not arguing about which one is better.
- 55:28A lot of people on both sides want to make this argument about economic inequality a matter of
- 55:35politics because they're more concerned about winning political battles and arguments, not
- 55:39about actually fixing things.
- 55:42But that being said, undeniably, economic inequality has widened considerably over the
- 55:47decades.
- 55:48It was a major threat to democracy during the Gilded Age as well, which was the end of the
- 55:53nineteenth century.
- 55:54Was referring to the fact that on the surface, everything looked great.
- 55:57Economic expansion was happening and the overall economy was booming, but it covered up
- 56:04a lot of economic and political corruption at that time.
- 56:07Hence, the gilded part.
- 56:09It was a veneer.
- 56:10And so you have this economic inequality of these days as well.
- 56:14Now, how do you fix that?
- 56:15I'm not going to get into that because that is outside the purview of this discussion and that
- 56:20is beside the point here.
- 56:22The point is economic inequality is a threat to democracy.
- 56:27Why is it an issue?
- 56:28A couple of the biggest reasons are when the non wealthy have less and less capability of
- 56:33making their voice heard as money interests drown them out, it's you start to push out a
- 56:38lot of those viewpoints, and you don't bring in as many people to make their voice heard, which
- 56:44is antidemocratic to shut out those opinions, even if you're not intending to do that.
- 56:51And not only that, but voters just become preoccupied with their immediate economic
- 56:57concerns, like feeding their families, working long shifts to even think about and research
- 57:03political institutions or issues, excuse me, and will often just sit out elections.
- 57:09They they just throw their hands up in frustration.
- 57:12They say, you know what?
- 57:13Nobody's nobody's working for me, so I'm just not gonna deal with it, which is another threat
- 57:18to democracy.
- 57:20This voter apathy and lack of participation in elections when people are not making their
- 57:26voice heard and not necessarily because they're being prevented from doing so, but they feel
- 57:31like there's no point or they just don't care.
- 57:35We have a serious problem, and I will refer back to my episode 50 about voter apathy.
- 57:41And then one of my guests I had on here, Shaka Mitchell, we talked about voter apathy further
- 57:47and how to potentially fix that as well.
- 57:51But if people don't care, then certain interests that are not as concerned about
- 57:56democracy are going to squeeze out other people's opinions.
- 58:00And if we're only having a small percentage or a not necessarily a small percentage, but
- 58:06you're only having a percentage of people participating in the process when a whole lot
- 58:11more can participate, You're not getting a really representative government, you're not
- 58:16really having everybody's voice be heard.
- 58:19And I would encourage you to to look into that episode some more as well.
- 58:24And I hope to do more projects about political apathy as well.
- 58:28But it is a very serious problem we have facing democracy if we don't get more people to care
- 58:36about what's happening, regardless of what they what their actual opinions are.
- 58:40We need more people to pay attention and to get
- 58:43invested.
- 58:45And then the last point I want to cover about the threat to democracy is we have a very
- 58:51serious issue with worshiping political candidates.
- 58:57We've gradually seen more and more cults of personality around candidates of all political
- 59:03stripes,
- 59:05Republicans, Democrats, independents, conservatives, liberals, moderates, fascists,
- 59:10communists, socialists, anarchists, whatever the
- 59:14case may be.
- 59:15And our support of these specific figures, not even not just the parties,
- 59:20but of specific figures becomes a core part
- 59:24of our identity.
- 59:25And so when someone criticizes these particular people, we see it as a threat to ourselves,
- 59:31like, Oh, they're not just attacking this person I really support, they're attacking me.
- 59:36That is a very serious blurring of the lines between the simple support of a candidate and
- 59:43praise of a candidate.
- 59:45Supporting candidates, that's perfectly fine, that's making your voice heard.
- 59:49We all have people that we support.
- 59:52But when you start to become fans of people
- 59:57that are in politics, I think that's a very serious issue that we have on our hands.
- 1:00:05It should never get to a point where you're treating it like
- 1:00:07sports.
- 1:00:09You have a favorite team.
- 1:00:10You have a favorite athlete.
- 1:00:12And, I mean, in the context of sports, that can also obviously get way overboard too.
- 1:00:17But at
- 1:00:17least there, ultimately, what happens in sports doesn't truly matter in the
- 1:00:22grand scheme of things.
- 1:00:24And there it can actually be fun in that regard.
- 1:00:27That's not the case with politics.
- 1:00:29This is not something that we should be treating like a sport where we are fans of
- 1:00:34somebody, fans of a brand, whether as a person or a party, but especially in this case, at
- 1:00:42least when I say specific individual.
- 1:00:44We should not be fans of somebody.
- 1:00:46I don't care who it is.
- 1:00:47I don't care if it's me.
- 1:00:49I don't I I mean, I obviously, I really appreciate the support that you give by tuning
- 1:00:55in and and and liking and commenting and sharing.
- 1:00:59But I hope I never get to that point where there's a cult of personality around me because
- 1:01:03then I can also, I don't want that to
- 1:01:05get to my head.
- 1:01:06And that's another thing is not just for the people who are becoming worshipers of
- 1:01:14candidates, the
- 1:01:15people who are being worshiped, who have a fandom around them, they start to think,
- 1:01:19Oh, you know what?
- 1:01:19I'm pretty cool.
- 1:01:20I'm pretty great.
- 1:01:21I don't need to listen to other people.
- 1:01:23It does get to people's heads.
- 1:01:26There's countless examples of that.
- 1:01:27And they may not have been so conceited before, but you get enough adoration and people that
- 1:01:34are not willing to hold you accountable.
- 1:01:36You start to think you can slide with a lot a lot more and that you're not that people aren't
- 1:01:42gonna say anything or that you can still achieve your ultimate goals.
- 1:01:45And that's not a point we should ever get to.
- 1:01:48Because when you're a fan of some somebody or something, you tend to be a lot less critical
- 1:01:53of it.
- 1:01:54Or you might be critical within your chosen circles, but never with the, quote unquote,
- 1:01:58outside the other side.
- 1:02:00You're never gonna
- 1:02:00be critical of of your team or your person in the midst of other people, which is its own
- 1:02:09issue.
- 1:02:10But just like institutions are not above criticism,
- 1:02:13neither are people, arguably even more so.
- 1:02:16When we start to treat people, specific people, as the only cure to the ills of government and
- 1:02:22society, and we unthinkingly support everything they do, that's when you start to see those
- 1:02:29people try to
- 1:02:33erode democratic ideals because they start to believe that they're above reproach and that
- 1:02:40they don't need to hear other people's beliefs.
- 1:02:45And that is one of the I have a lot of concerns about politics in this country, and that is one
- 1:02:53of the greatest is these cults of personality that we see that I think we've seen a lot more
- 1:02:59of in more recent years.
- 1:03:02And I would ask people to if you start to feel yourself being a little too unthinkingly
- 1:03:09supportive of somebody, if you think you're a fan of somebody, I'd ask you to take a step
- 1:03:13back and think about, am I going too far with this?
- 1:03:17Support is fine.
- 1:03:19Being a fan, I'd argue, is not.
- 1:03:21So some things to think about as we move forward with these democratic
- 1:03:29ideals that we that we need to uphold.
- 1:03:31Now, of
- 1:03:31course, we do have or we
- 1:03:34need to have discussions about how to preserve them and and what what point is going too far
- 1:03:39and what point is not going far enough.
- 1:03:42Those should be conversations to have and how we improve things because we should always be
- 1:03:47striving to improve.
- 1:03:49But when you're sowing distrust in specific people and institutions because you're trying
- 1:03:57to win political battles and arguments, that is a threat to democracy.
- 1:04:03So
- 1:04:04some things to leave you with to think about, but that is going to wrap things up for today's
- 1:04:10episode.
- 1:04:10Been quite a while since I've done a an episode just by myself.
- 1:04:14It was kind of kinda neat, but I, of course, always enjoy having actual guests on, and I'm
- 1:04:19gonna have a guest on next week as I mentioned earlier Pluralism.
- 1:04:23So you'll see her on the next episode.
- 1:04:25But anyways, thank you so much for listening and watching.
- 1:04:29Please like, comment, and subscribe and share with all the people you know.
- 1:04:33This podcast, my links are in the show notes, my Facebook, my LinkedIn profile, mymedium.com
- 1:04:40profile I run on from time to time.
- 1:04:42My five day educational email course you can sign up for just just five days of the five
- 1:04:49biggest mistakes made when we try to depolarize politics that can accidentally actually make
- 1:04:55polarization worse.
- 1:04:57My email and my website, Paul Raider dot org.
- 1:05:02My email is PaulRaiderwrites@Gmaildot.
- 1:05:05That is it for today.
- 1:05:07So thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.