Latest / Columbus' Morning News / We remember the life and legacy of Robert Redford, plus more on the Jimmy Kimmel controversy
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Over to the Legacy Retirement Group dot com phone line.
- 0:02He is a professor of pop culture and TV at
- 0:05Syracuse University. I mean, the guy watches TV for a living,
- 0:09for crying out loud, and there's probably nobody better qualified
- 0:12to talk about the situation going on with the ABC
- 0:15and Jimmy Kimmel, Bob, good morning. I'm sure you've been
- 0:18reading up on this, and I have a my take,
- 0:20it is super boring. It's a lot of people want
- 0:23to make a lot of things out of this, pick
- 0:25your side of the aisle, as it were.
- 0:27Speaker 2: But I think it comes down to me just to
- 0:32a simple business decision made by Disney.
- 0:34Speaker 3: What do you think, Well, I mean it was a
- 0:37business is I think virtually every decision that Disney makes
- 0:40is a business decision. I'd be hard pressed to find
- 0:43a single thing they've decided to do over the past.
- 0:47I don't know, ever, it wasn't a business decision, true,
- 0:51but it's the nature of the business decision that I
- 0:54think has got a lot of people alarmed. And that's
- 0:59and I guess basically the equation is this, Yes, the
- 1:03President has been you know, fussing about the late night
- 1:07comics for a long time, But I don't think that
- 1:09specifically is the main element here. What happened was the
- 1:14FCC chair Brendan Carr, And in fact, the FCC can
- 1:19you know, gives out licenses and if they don't, you
- 1:21can't operate a station anymore. He makes these pretty aggressive
- 1:29claims about complaining about Jimmy Kimmel and that people might
- 1:33not get their licenses renewed and that should be investigated
- 1:38if he stays on the air. Then you've got these
- 1:41big owners of stations who need to have their license reviewed.
- 1:46And Next Star was the first who also want the
- 1:49FCC to approve a big acquisition of stations they want
- 1:53to do, which they can't because it would make them
- 1:55having a total of too many stations. They want the
- 1:57FCC to change that, so big huge business decisions there.
- 2:03They decide to announce that they're not going to show
- 2:07Kimmel anymore, and then Sinclair Broadcasting, another huge owner of stations,
- 2:11says the same. That's the point where ABC said we're
- 2:15not going to play him, and you are absolutely right
- 2:18that was a business decision because if ABC Network has
- 2:23their stations not show their shows, they are not a
- 2:26network anymore. A network by definition is a collection of stations.
- 2:31So it was that threat to pull for those all
- 2:35those stations which make up the ABC network or many
- 2:39of them, to pull that program in that ABC made
- 2:43that decision in the middle of the week to suspend
- 2:46a show that had the audience being brought in for
- 2:50the taping at the time it was suspended.
- 2:51Speaker 2: Wow.
- 2:52Speaker 1: Yeah, And it's the FCC's involvement is where it does
- 2:56get a little money for a lot of folks, Bob
- 2:58and you know, but outside of that, I mean, and
- 3:01what's being I think underreported is Disney is also in
- 3:05the process of trying to buy the NFL network.
- 3:07Speaker 3: And oh and yes, you are very right. That's another
- 3:11reason why this.
- 3:11Speaker 2: Was a big business decision.
- 3:13Speaker 1: And the last hurdle that they need to overcome is
- 3:16to get the regulatory approval from the Trump administration, from
- 3:20the DOJ for you know, the sort of the anti
- 3:24competition and all of that. So, you know, I think, honestly,
- 3:29I think Bob Iger is done going to war with Trump.
- 3:33I mean, he he had just had to pay out
- 3:35what sixteen million because of the Stephanopolis thing with the
- 3:39Egen Carroll he sort of misspoke or maybe it was intentional.
- 3:43Speaker 3: I don't know.
- 3:44Speaker 1: He apologized for that, saying that Trump was liable for
- 3:46raping Egen Carroll. That's not true, paid out sixteen million
- 3:50to Trump. You got the Gina Carano situation where you know,
- 3:54she was on The Mandalorian and she was removed from
- 3:57that show from Disney before controversial. So social media posts
- 4:01there was a settlement there between Disney and her. So
- 4:04I think ABC is tired of settling and paying fines
- 4:08and lawsuits.
- 4:09Speaker 2: They're just they didn't want to stay. This was a
- 4:11hot potato for them.
- 4:12Speaker 3: No, And I think this is what you're saying is
- 4:15true of all of the big network media. They are
- 4:19no longer. You know, it used to be we thought
- 4:21of these networks that would they put stuff on and
- 4:23they would fight tooth and nail. Remember when NYPD Blue
- 4:27came out and it had some nudity. It's the first
- 4:29network show to have nudity. Yes, stations coming right, including
- 4:33the one here in Syracuse, said we're not going to
- 4:36show that, and ABC said, well, we're sorry, but we're
- 4:39gonna We're going to show it anyway, and if you
- 4:42guys don't want to play it, fine, And it became
- 4:44a huge hit. The networks are not. You're right. They
- 4:48no longer want to be fighting about any of this stuff.
- 4:52And part of it is they are such huge, integrated organizations,
- 4:57so much of their future there's success and growth and
- 5:01all the rest of it depends on these big acquisitions
- 5:04and all of this kind of things. So they've got
- 5:06to stay on the good side of people who make
- 5:10those who can make those decisions not happen if they
- 5:14want to. And I don't think any of these networks,
- 5:18You're right, they have given up any desire to fight
- 5:22these battles. So what's going to happen, I think is
- 5:25that the likes of Colbert, who's going to be gone
- 5:30in May, Kimmel, who I really doubt is going to
- 5:32be back, and ultimately I think Seth Myers, they're going
- 5:36to go elsewhere. It used to be there was no
- 5:38elsewhere to go, but now there's substack, there's YouTube channels,
- 5:43set off the network for forever, so they'll go elsewhere.
- 5:48And my guess is the last one standing will be
- 5:51The Tonight Show, which was the first one standing. It
- 5:53started seventy one years ago in nineteen fifty four. It
- 5:57wasn't controversial, it didn't do a lot of you know,
- 6:03political satire to just told jokes for thirty years. Carson
- 6:08was very amiable, so was Leno, and so is Fallon.
- 6:11And I think he will be taking that seventy one
- 6:14year old franchise into the future of network late Night
- 6:18all by itself within not too long for now.
- 6:20Speaker 1: Well, and that's the template, right, I mean, Jimmy Fallon,
- 6:23it's he is an equal opportunity offender.
- 6:26Speaker 2: His jokes are light.
- 6:27Speaker 1: He picks on everybody, just like we talked about We've
- 6:29talked about this a million times.
- 6:31Speaker 3: Boy, if he's on everybody, he didn't pick out anybody too.
- 6:34He doesn't do political sat tire. He does jokes, set up.
- 6:39Speaker 1: Knock it down, set him up, knock him down, exactly right,
- 6:42right old school joke jokes, just like Johnny Carson and
- 6:45Letterman and Leno used to do. And that seems like
- 6:47that's the that's the model, that should be the blueprint,
- 6:51because you know, we talk about Kimmel and you wonder
- 6:54why he was even on the air if his ratings
- 6:56were worse than his ratings were worse than Colbert.
- 7:00Speaker 3: Yeah, well, and depending he did something in the beginning
- 7:02of the year he was doing really well among eighteen
- 7:06to forty nine year olds, which is of course what
- 7:08you can get the most money for. But you know,
- 7:11all the ratings were down for all of those and
- 7:14those people will do very well and they'll make a
- 7:16ton of money elsewhere. But it's another sign that network
- 7:20television isn't the place for the controversy, the excitement, the innovation,
- 7:26all that kind of stuff. You know, the networks that
- 7:29once brought us the Smothers, Brothers and all in the
- 7:32Family and all of that that isn't happening on network
- 7:35TV now. All that kind of stuff is happening on
- 7:37streaming and all of these other technological things. And you know,
- 7:42just like the way people watch movies going to theaters,
- 7:46that was changing fast anyway thanks to streaming, but COVID accelerated. Yeah,
- 7:52the network television as a model, as an ability, you know,
- 7:58to do controversy, fell stuff for anything is in the
- 8:03wayne anyway, and this kind of thing just really really
- 8:07accelerates it. You know, we're a lot of the stations
- 8:10are showing reruns of celebrity family Feud at the eleven thirty.
- 8:17Speaker 2: Steve Harvey ABC.
- 8:19Speaker 3: You can hate Kimmel all you want, but I'm not
- 8:22sure that that's that we've made a vertical up in that.
- 8:27Speaker 2: I mean, unless you're going to bring back the old
- 8:28Richard Dawson versions of.
- 8:30Speaker 3: It, then oh yeah, I've got to go over well
- 8:33with him.
- 8:34Speaker 2: Smooching with this and everybody, it's right.
- 8:37Speaker 1: Speaking with doctor Bob Thompson, Professor of Pop Culture, Syracuse University.
- 8:41The other story I wanted to get to before we
- 8:43let you fly, Bob, is we lost an icon, Robert
- 8:46Redford earlier this week. Of course, Oscar winning actor and director,
- 8:51eighty nine years old, and some great films on his
- 8:54and his resume.
- 8:55Speaker 3: Oh breathtaking. I don't think we can possibly overestimate what
- 9:00how huge of a guy this was as an actor,
- 9:04of course, and the list goes on and on and on. Yeah,
- 9:07I'm sure you've been talking about this over the week,
- 9:10then as a director, and then as a mentor with
- 9:13that Sundance Institute of a list of directors that we
- 9:18wouldn't even know the names of if it hadn't been
- 9:20for Redford. We could talk for hours about this. I'm
- 9:23showing in my tribute screening Monday some of his television work,
- 9:31an episode of the Twilight Zone, he did really early,
- 9:34but he was working. The last thing he did on
- 9:38camera with a cameo appearance in a show he's executive
- 9:42producing for AMC called Dark Winds, shot in New Mexico,
- 9:46Native Writers, Native Directors. If you haven't seen that, I
- 9:50would check it out. It's a third season has wrapped
- 9:53up and it was his real passion project for him.
- 9:57He executive produced it and and it was you know,
- 10:02it was something that meant a lot to him. But
- 10:04he executive produced it with none other than George R. R.
- 10:08Martin from the creative Game of Thrones.
- 10:10Speaker 2: Wow.
- 10:11Speaker 3: And the final on camera appearance, the final acting thing
- 10:16that Redford did was in a April twenty twenty five
- 10:18this past April episode cameo in Dark Winds where he
- 10:23is in one jail cell and George R. R. Martin
- 10:26is in another jail cell and they're playing chess through
- 10:29the through the bars.
- 10:32Speaker 2: That's funny.
- 10:33Speaker 3: Dark Redford's final appearance. But anyway, check out that that
- 10:38was a product win. Really the meant a lot to
- 10:41him and it was the last thing he was doing
- 10:44what he died.
- 10:44Speaker 1: It's on the list Dark Wins. That's a great tip.
- 10:46Thanks Bob, so we were talking camping and I were
- 10:49talking off the air before you came on, and we
- 10:52you know, Butch Cassidy and the Sun Dance Kid, The Natural,
- 10:54all the President's Men.
- 10:56Speaker 2: My favorite Redford film was The Sting.
- 10:59Speaker 1: And that's a movie that I think I'm not sure
- 11:02why it hasn't been redone with, you know, a more
- 11:05of a modern twist. I mean, you talk about George
- 11:07Clooney and maybe Brad Pitt coming in and playing those
- 11:10guys with that twist at the end.
- 11:12Speaker 2: I'm surprised that hasn't been.
- 11:13Speaker 3: Remade, you know now that you mentioned it, I am too,
- 11:16because that was and that was perfectly structured. You're at
- 11:19that end. I mean, not a second of that film
- 11:22wasn't perfect. But that lists you in between nineteen sixty
- 11:26nine Butch Cassidy and maybe nineteen seventy nine. That that
- 11:33that run he was doing sometimes three movies a year,
- 11:37all of which were memorable. Butch Cassidy, this thing the
- 11:41way we were, and then his directing ordinary people. First
- 11:45time he directed, he got enough through it. Remember that
- 11:50the fly fishing quiz show he directed about the quiz
- 11:55show thing. So yeah, it's hard. Whenever I just want
- 11:58to make lists. Whenever we talk about it, I will,
- 12:02I will try one more thing. Okay, so I give
- 12:03you the Dark Winds tip. One of his most hated
- 12:07films of all time was when he played Gatsby in
- 12:11The Great Gatsby, and I would like to suggest that
- 12:14that wasn't nearly as terrible as everybody seems to say
- 12:16it was.
- 12:17Speaker 2: Okay, he was.
- 12:19Speaker 3: The big argument is he's just too pretty, and there
- 12:25may be a there may be a point there.
- 12:27Speaker 1: But if you have to have a fault, if you
- 12:30have to have a downside and a criticism, you're just
- 12:32too good looking, I think, Okay, we'll take it.
- 12:34Speaker 2: I'll take it. That's that's your only ding on the movie.