Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Landlord Relief: Compliance Requirements In “Cash for Keys” Deals Where Landlord with Eli Appel, Sasha Struthers, Howard Gould
Transcript
- 0:02My name is Howard Gould. I'm co -chair for the
- 0:06real estate section of the Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:08Association. I want to welcome everybody. Happy
- 0:12that you could all join us today. We are going
- 0:15to have a very interesting and for us a first
- 0:19time program about cash for keys. how landlords
- 0:24can get relief from underperforming residential
- 0:26units and tenants can have, in a sense, a significant
- 0:31payout potentially if they choose to voluntarily
- 0:35vacate their units. Before we get into the introductions
- 0:38of the program, I want to advise you about what
- 0:41our upcoming programs are going to be. September
- 0:4318th, we're also doing a new program for us,
- 0:47the intersection of intellectual property law
- 0:49and real estate law. You can learn how copyright
- 0:52and trademark violations can occur without you
- 0:55realizing that your client even has a problem.
- 0:59It's interesting situations where copyright and
- 1:03trademark actually do have a big role to play
- 1:08in real estate transactions. On October 16th,
- 1:12we'll be doing a real property taxation program
- 1:15with Chris O 'Neill, who has spoken for us a
- 1:17number of times before. Chris has litigated cases
- 1:20all the way through the California Supreme Court,
- 1:22and he and I have had the pleasure of working
- 1:24together on real property tax issues. November
- 1:28is in the works, and we think it will likely
- 1:30be a program on 1031 tax -deferred exchanges.
- 1:34January, probably the 15th, we're going to have
- 1:38former state bar president Heather Roseng on
- 1:41risk management for real estate lawyers with
- 1:44ethics credit for your MCLE requirements. Heather
- 1:47recently founded her new firm in San Diego and
- 1:50I think is already up to about 17 lawyers. Heather
- 1:55has a long history of assisting lawyers with
- 1:59ethical issues and malpractice issues. February,
- 2:04we anticipate doing our annual review of the
- 2:07prior year's new real estate cases, and March
- 2:09or April, our annual CAR forms program to learn
- 2:13about their changes for 2026. Also want to remind
- 2:17people that if you have questions to post, please
- 2:21put those in the Q &A. In the chat, you can find
- 2:24a link to the program materials, but the Q &A
- 2:27will be used for any questions you want to post
- 2:32during the presentation. Our speaker on the legal
- 2:38requirements for cash for keys is Sasha Struthers.
- 2:41I want to thank Sasha for joining us. She's a
- 2:43California licensed attorney, also a real estate
- 2:45broker, and her practice focuses pretty much
- 2:48entirely on this cash for keys tenant buyouts,
- 2:55which are voluntary transactions. Sasha graduated
- 2:59from Southwestern Law School's SCALE program.
- 3:02She started her career doing employer defense
- 3:06litigation, transitioned into real estate law
- 3:09and founded her own practice in order to help
- 3:12landlords strategically reposition their portfolios,
- 3:15maximize income and increase their equities.
- 3:18You can check out her law practice at www .struthers
- 3:22.legal. Ellie Appel, our second speaker, is a
- 3:26first vice president for investments at Marcus
- 3:28and Millichap in Sino. Ellie has extensive experience
- 3:32selling apartment buildings throughout Southern
- 3:34California, all the way from the Inland Empire
- 3:36through the South Bay, and has a special emphasis
- 3:39in Beverly Hills, where he commands a significant
- 3:41market share. Ellie handles these transactions
- 3:45throughout, including underwriting, marketing,
- 3:48negotiating, and closing escrow. His expertise
- 3:52includes tax -deferred 1031 exchanges, allowing
- 3:55owners of investment properties to buy and sell
- 3:57like -kind property while deferring their capital
- 4:00gains taxes. He's been profiled in LA Business
- 4:03Journal, San Fernando Valley Business Journal,
- 4:07Bizno, and CoStar. His bachelor's degree is from
- 4:10UCLA and he also completed the real estate certificate
- 4:13program with a concentration in investments from
- 4:16UCLA. With those introductions, Can't wait to
- 4:20hear the program. Fantastic. Thank you, Howard,
- 4:24and the Beverly Hills Bar Association for allowing
- 4:27Sasha Shruthers and I to speak about cash for
- 4:30keys. Sasha's going to go through the logistics
- 4:34and the nuts and bolts of cash for keys. And
- 4:36before she jumps in, I just wanted to tell you
- 4:40that when Sasha's done, I'm going to spend about
- 4:4210 minutes to speak through how cash for keys
- 4:46creates win -win. scenarios in the right circumstances
- 4:50for both landlords and tenants. And I'm going
- 4:52to give an example about how, in one particular
- 4:55circumstance, a $30 ,000 buyout created over
- 4:59$400 ,000 in equity. Sasha, please go ahead.
- 5:05Thank you. Thank everybody for having me. I look
- 5:07forward to this presentation. So I'm going to
- 5:10go ahead and get into it. Let me share my screen.
- 5:17So today's presentation is going to be on cash
- 5:19for keys. Just have a disclaimer, like most attorneys.
- 5:23So everything here today is just going to be
- 5:24for general informational purposes and educational
- 5:27purposes. I might have some anecdotes or some
- 5:30real life examples of things that I've experienced
- 5:32in practicing this area of law, but it won't
- 5:36be specific to your client or your situation.
- 5:39So that's not a substitute for getting legal
- 5:41advice or an independent counsel consultation.
- 5:47My run through of my presentation is pretty straightforward.
- 5:50We're going to talk about what cash for keys
- 5:52is. We're going to talk about the difference
- 5:54between buyouts versus relocation. We're going
- 5:57to talk about one relocation required, why buyouts
- 6:00are popular, and at the end we're going to go
- 6:01over some of the buyout requirements in Southern
- 6:03California. So cash for keys in a nutshell is
- 6:09a voluntary lease termination agreement. It's
- 6:11when the landlord and tenant come together They
- 6:14reach an agreement on specific terms Main ones
- 6:17being what the tenant will receive in exchange
- 6:19for turning in their keys or vacating the unit
- 6:22permanently The benefits to both sides is that
- 6:26it creates vacancy decontrol for the landlord
- 6:29So the landlord is able to raise rents or they're
- 6:32able to at least sell the property vacant are
- 6:35mostly vacant depending. You can also increase
- 6:39equity either in the form of refinancing or if
- 6:43you're going to be selling the property. Landlords
- 6:46and tenants both can avoid the costly and lengthy
- 6:49eviction process, the adversarial proceedings
- 6:52of being in an eviction, and quite frankly the
- 6:54uncertainty of it. Landlords and tenants also
- 6:57mutually agree on the money in the move out date.
- 7:00So it's an arm length negotiation. It's not being
- 7:03unilaterally decided for them. The agreement
- 7:07usually involves a release of claim. So the partners
- 7:10are gonna be walking away from one another without
- 7:14any sort of tether to. further liability. And
- 7:17then lastly, the tenants get a lump sum of money
- 7:20that maybe they otherwise wouldn't have and that
- 7:22money can either help them relocate, you know,
- 7:25potentially to a nicer unit, to a new neighborhood.
- 7:28Sometimes people relocate at a state or out of
- 7:30country or just a lump sum of money that the
- 7:33tenant could use maybe for savings or the vacation
- 7:36they've always wanted to go on. So buyout versus
- 7:40relocation. So cash for keys is also called a
- 7:44tenant buyouts and that's sort of the Colloquial
- 7:49term that you use for I'm gonna buy out my tenant.
- 7:51I'm gonna buy the tenants basically tenancy and
- 7:54the term Relocation is often interchangeably
- 7:58used so how buyouts sort of came to be is predominantly
- 8:03in jurisdictions that have rent control. So locally
- 8:07here in Los Angeles, there is several jurisdictions
- 8:10that have their own rent control. LA City has
- 8:14one, LA County Unincorporated, Pasadena, West
- 8:19Hollywood, Beverly Hills, Santa Monica, Inglewood,
- 8:22Culver City, those are sort of the main ones.
- 8:24There's a few smaller ones. In addition to the
- 8:27rent control, which the rent control typically
- 8:30controls how much you can raise the rent on a
- 8:34tenant. It also controls how and when you can
- 8:37evict a tenant. And more and more, these controls
- 8:40are being expanded outside of multifamily or
- 8:44apartment buildings. They're being extended to
- 8:46condominiums or single -family residences that
- 8:49typically in the past did not have these eviction
- 8:52restrictions. These eviction restrictions are
- 8:54called Just Cause No Fault, meaning I have reason
- 8:59to evict but or the tenant hasn't done anything
- 9:02wrong, but I have reason to evict. In those just
- 9:06cause no fault reasons, the tenant would be entitled
- 9:09to what's called relocation. So relocation is
- 9:13the mandatory amount of money a tenant would
- 9:15get because they are being evicted, they're being
- 9:18given a specific eviction notice to vacate the
- 9:21house, the rental unit, and the city has decided
- 9:24by their own formula that the tenant is entitled
- 9:28to a certain amount of money. So typically when
- 9:31you go into buyout negotiations, oftentimes you
- 9:34are either required to offer this amount of money
- 9:37to the tenant, or you use that amount of money
- 9:40as a beginning negotiating point because the
- 9:42tenant will look at, well, if I had to move,
- 9:45I would get this money, right? So even though
- 9:47a buyout is voluntary and relocation is mandatory,
- 9:52you typically use the relocation amount for that
- 9:55particular unit as a yardstick or a guiding post
- 9:58or the kickoff for these negotiations. So when
- 10:04is relocation required? Again, no fault, just
- 10:07cause. No fault meaning the tenant hasn't done
- 10:10anything wrong. For instance, they're paying
- 10:13their rent, they're not violating the lease,
- 10:15they're not causing a nuisance, but the landlord
- 10:18has just cause, they have a reason. Typically,
- 10:21the reason is the owner might owner -occupy or
- 10:25they might LS act, which we'll talk about a little
- 10:27bit later in the presentation. So in these situations,
- 10:30the landlords would be required to pay relocation.
- 10:34They will be required to provide appropriate
- 10:36eviction notices. And typically, they have to
- 10:40file forms with the city, their declaration of
- 10:43intent, sometimes what it's called, why they're
- 10:46evicting this tenant. And then there's typically
- 10:49escrow instructions involved. and specific rules
- 10:52as to when and how you pay the tenant their relocation
- 10:55money. Additionally, these payments do vary.
- 11:01Each jurisdiction has a different way that they
- 11:03come up with a relocation figure. It could be
- 11:07based on the years of tenancy, could be based
- 11:10on the number of bedrooms in the rental, and
- 11:13it also can be increased if there are minor children
- 11:18present or living in the unit, if someone is
- 11:21disabled living in the unit, or someone is older
- 11:24than a certain age, usually 60 plus years, 62
- 11:28plus years. If the tenant... tenancy or the units
- 11:31in the tenant meet that kind of criteria, they
- 11:34are typically entitled to a higher relocation
- 11:36payment. So I'm going to go through some of the
- 11:41common no fault, just cause situations. So the
- 11:44reasons landlords could potentially vacate a
- 11:47tenant, could evict the tenant, but why they
- 11:50tend to be difficult to achieve in the real world.
- 11:54So owner occupancy, um is one of the more common
- 11:58ones some of the cons about it is that the owner
- 12:01might not want to occupy the property either
- 12:04for themselves or the authorized family member
- 12:07and the authorized family member does change
- 12:09depending on the jurisdiction or they want to
- 12:13owner occupy but they don't want to owner occupy
- 12:15for the minimum duration so the minimum duration
- 12:18could be Usually typically one to three years
- 12:21depending on the city and so they might need
- 12:23to owner occupy for six months Perhaps or a year,
- 12:27but they don't want to occupy for the full duration.
- 12:29They want to be able to rent the unit back So
- 12:33they're not going to be able to satisfy the city's
- 12:35requirements The owner also has to file declarations
- 12:40with the city so it's additional paperwork that
- 12:43you have to do on an annual basis where you let
- 12:45the city know, yes, I'm continuing to occupy.
- 12:48If you're not occupying it for the minimum duration,
- 12:52like you're supposed to be occupying it, you
- 12:54could run the risk of civil liability. So a tenant
- 12:58could argue, hey, you wrongfully evicted me.
- 13:01You didn't own or occupy for the length of time
- 13:04you're supposed to. It's sort of a constructive
- 13:07eviction. It was misleading. It was bad faith.
- 13:10So you run the risk of being sued by the tenant.
- 13:13Additionally, the newest tenant is typically
- 13:18the first one to go out. So let's say you need
- 13:21a one bedroom apartment. You don't get to pick
- 13:24which one bedroom necessarily. You have to go
- 13:27to the last tenant that moved in, so the newest
- 13:29tenant, which is likely the market rate tenant.
- 13:32And if that unit is not the unit you want to
- 13:34go after, you have to have a good reason why
- 13:37that unit's not suitable. You know, maybe I needed
- 13:40you know, two bedrooms or maybe it's that unit's
- 13:44upstairs and I need a ground floor unit because
- 13:46I have, you know, accessibility issues for myself
- 13:49or the family member occupying. So you have to
- 13:53do a whole analysis on the tenancy in your property.
- 13:59And also there's the issue of you know, the right
- 14:04of first refusal. Tenants do have potentially
- 14:07right of first refusal to come back to the unit
- 14:10depending on the jurisdiction. Also, if the unit,
- 14:15if there's another vacant unit on site that's
- 14:17comparable, you would have to occupy that vacant
- 14:20unit. You couldn't just go pick another tenant.
- 14:23So if... If you wanted to do this, there's a
- 14:27lot of strings attached to it. And then even
- 14:29if you go through the mental gymnastics of getting
- 14:32the right unit, you have to make sure all your
- 14:35paperwork is done right. And then hope that the
- 14:38tenant actually does vacate. If they don't vacate,
- 14:40then you run the risk that you're going to have
- 14:42to file an eviction to force the notice and to
- 14:47force the tenant out. So even if you have all
- 14:50grounds to do it, it's really up to the tenant
- 14:53if they actually honor that notice. Otherwise
- 14:55you do wind up in eviction court. Another one
- 15:00is approved condominium conversions. Converting
- 15:04apartments to condominiums is difficult in rent
- 15:07controlled properties. There's also several overlapping
- 15:10state laws and local laws that if the units are
- 15:14presently tenant occupied, there's restrictions
- 15:16on if you can do a conversion, if you're able
- 15:20to redevelop the property, and there could be
- 15:22increased relocation fees involved with paying
- 15:25the tenants should you want to be redeveloping.
- 15:28So if you're in the early stages of wanting to
- 15:30do a conversion, you might want to have conversations
- 15:33with tenants about doing a voluntary move -out
- 15:35agreement, as it does take several years potentially
- 15:38to get these approved. And yeah, additional restrictions.
- 15:43as we sort of balance the tenants needs for housing
- 15:47and then owners needs for, you know, hire and
- 15:50spest use of their properties or being able to
- 15:52get a return on their property. Some of those
- 15:55things become someone in conflict or they just
- 15:58become very hard to pull off for you're trying
- 16:00to balance the scales about the landlord and
- 16:02the tenant. And so condominium conversions are
- 16:04one of those things that get more scrutinized
- 16:07giving we do have a present housing crisis. Then
- 16:10we have demolition. There's the Ellis Act. One
- 16:16part of the Ellis Act is that you're going to
- 16:19be demolishing the property. And the next slide
- 16:21will go over Ellis Act itself. But one part of
- 16:23it is you're demolishing the property. Typically,
- 16:26you're demolishing the property because you're
- 16:27going to be redeveloping the property. So in
- 16:30order to do this, you would have to have You
- 16:32know permits and plans and everything gone through
- 16:35plan check so that you have the approved permit
- 16:38to demolish your property that could take years
- 16:41Again, if you're going to be demolishing redeveloping
- 16:44it depending on what you redeveloped tenants
- 16:46might have a right of first refusal to rent the
- 16:49new units If the unit is, if you're demolishing
- 16:53it because the unit was in part destroyed, tenants
- 16:56do still have potentially tenancy rights if it's
- 16:59in a rent control of property. Again, right of
- 17:02first refusal, right to come back. And if you're
- 17:05going to be demolishing it and you want the tenants
- 17:08out, the tenants may qualify for up to a year
- 17:12if they're disabled or they reach their certain
- 17:14age or older. So that also adds to your timeline,
- 17:18your development timeline. The Ellis Act. So
- 17:22the Ellis Act is a state law that allows landlords
- 17:25to go out of the rental business. The other aspect,
- 17:29like we talked about, is you're able to demolish
- 17:31and redevelop, but the Ellis Act, as people tend
- 17:34to know it, is for the prong that you're going
- 17:36out of the rental business and you don't want
- 17:38to rent anymore. So it's typically the option
- 17:42of last resort for landlords. The relocation
- 17:45fees can be very high in jurisdictions. The Ellis
- 17:49Act carries with the property. So even if you
- 17:53Ellis Act it and sell it, the new owner is subject
- 17:55to the Ellis Act. And there's certain milestones,
- 17:59two years, five years, 10 years. If you Ellis
- 18:03Act the property and then you turn around and
- 18:05rent it in a certain time frame, you risk getting
- 18:08sued by the tenant. If you, after I believe two
- 18:12years, you can re -rent the units, but you have
- 18:15to give the tenants a right of first refusal
- 18:17back at their same rent, I believe including
- 18:21applicable rent increases. And then after between
- 18:24the five and 10 year mark, you're able to go
- 18:26back to renting it. You can get market rent,
- 18:29but again, you're able to, you have to give the
- 18:32tenant a right of first refusal. So there's different
- 18:34milestones that get met. So in the long scheme
- 18:38of things, There's a lot of strings attached
- 18:40with it. Additionally, you can't LS act a unit.
- 18:44So you can't go this unit is a not performing
- 18:46unit I'm gonna take it off. You have to LS act
- 18:49the entire property and all the units on the
- 18:51property So it's not a pick -and -choose thing
- 18:54You can't kind of mess with in order to cherry
- 18:56pick tenants that maybe are paying low rent That's
- 18:59not what the LS act is for and it's not permitted
- 19:01So that's the LS act again, it's sort of the
- 19:07option of last resort, but is often one that
- 19:10has to be used, especially if property owners
- 19:14are going to be redeveloping the property and
- 19:17aren't able to reach voluntary move -out agreements.
- 19:19It's the one that does have to get done in order
- 19:22to move forward with that. Another option is
- 19:26a government order requiring the unit to be vacated.
- 19:29These are incredibly rare. I've seen it, it's
- 19:34very hard to get the city or any government agency
- 19:36to mandatory vacate a unit. It usually comes
- 19:41with an order to comply that you have to fix
- 19:43the unit. So even if a unit is destroyed or partially
- 19:46destroyed. depending on the jurisdiction you're
- 19:50in and the pushback you get, you might have to
- 19:52fix the whole unit and then have the tenant come
- 19:55back at their same rent. Again, tenants might
- 19:59have rights of first refusal to come back to
- 20:01the rebuilt unit, the repaired unit. Substantial
- 20:06remodels. So substantial remodel has been virtually
- 20:09removed from most jurisdictions that have their
- 20:13own form of eviction restriction. LA City being
- 20:16one of the most recent, removed it from non -RSO,
- 20:21JCO. Rent control departments, those already
- 20:25were not allowed to have substantial remodel
- 20:26evictions. But now everything that's not rent
- 20:29control but is residential also cannot, you cannot
- 20:33evict a tenant for substantial remodels. So it's
- 20:35been banned in all the residential units in LA
- 20:37city, including houses and condominiums that
- 20:41are only subject to the Just Cause Ordinance.
- 20:45Landlords are not able to necessarily raise rent
- 20:47to market in a lot of these jurisdictions. So
- 20:50if you had to substantially remodel a unit, you
- 20:53wouldn't be able to get market rent for that
- 20:55unit from the same tenant. You might have to
- 20:57just pass through certain charges that are permitted
- 20:59by the city and are typically capped at a certain
- 21:02amount per month. It requires pulling permits.
- 21:05Your permit has to be for electrical, mechanical,
- 21:09plumbing or structural work. You have to use
- 21:11a licensed contractor. The work has to take a
- 21:16minimum duration of time, usually it's 60 days.
- 21:19So between 30 and 60 days, the unit will be uninhabitable
- 21:22for the tenant. Then that would kick in a substantial
- 21:25remodel eviction. However, like I mentioned,
- 21:28it's banned as a grounds to evict a tenant. In
- 21:33most jurisdictions, it's a unilateral. Option.
- 21:36So the tenant if you were to do a substantial
- 21:39remodel and you have all the permits pulled and
- 21:41the tenants gonna have to be out of the unit
- 21:43for the You know 30 60 days the tenant can go.
- 21:47Okay, I will take permanent relocation Which
- 21:49is defined by the city and the tenant can opt
- 21:53for that. But again if the tenant You know wants
- 21:57to stay in their unit, they're not often gonna
- 21:59opt for it. So substantial remodel doesn't happen
- 22:02very often And if it does happen, it's not grounds
- 22:07to evict. It's just because a landlord is required
- 22:10to do some sort of repair. But for most jurisdictions,
- 22:14it's not an option that's used to evict tenants
- 22:16anymore. I would like to just note to people
- 22:20that you can get the link to the program materials
- 22:22in the chat and link from there to the program
- 22:26materials. Thank you, Howard. So why are buyouts
- 22:32popular? For all of the things that I just talked
- 22:34about. So if you're someone who has an apartment
- 22:38building and you don't have a substantial remodel,
- 22:42you don't want to demolish it and redevelop it,
- 22:46you don't want to owner -occupy it, the government's
- 22:48not telling you to vacate everybody, but you
- 22:51have maybe a unit that's underperforming in the
- 22:54sense that the rent is really low and there's
- 22:56a huge delta between what the tenant is paying
- 22:59in rent and what market rent is. landlords are
- 23:03willing to pay tenants to move out and then they'll
- 23:06do upgrades to the units so they can compete
- 23:08on the market for market rate rent and then turn
- 23:11around and rent the unit at a higher amount and
- 23:14then eventually break even on the investment
- 23:16of buying out the tenant and also the cost of
- 23:21renovating the unit so it's market ready. So
- 23:24it's one of those things that both the landlord
- 23:26and the tenant basically get to be Copiloting
- 23:30this this outcome or this situation there are
- 23:33times where landlords do have grounds to evict
- 23:36the tenant But you know landlords don't want
- 23:39to have to necessarily give a tenant a bunch
- 23:41of eviction paperwork and say, here's your check,
- 23:43go. And then the tenant not be happy. Maybe they
- 23:46don't like the relocation amount. Maybe they
- 23:48don't like the move out timeline. Or have increased
- 23:52your odds of actually getting the vacancy. Landlords
- 23:55will try to do a buyout negotiation in advance
- 23:57of that and anticipate it's going to take me
- 24:00time. It's going to take me attorney's fees.
- 24:02I'd rather spend the money. and buy myself the
- 24:06time as the landlord or the developer and give
- 24:09the money rather than potentially to an eviction
- 24:11firm, give it to the tenant to help the tenant
- 24:14move. And so these are arm length negotiations
- 24:16that happen. There's no real. you know, like
- 24:21magic number, like this is the number. There's
- 24:23average numbers, there's numbers that get posted
- 24:25by certain jurisdictions, but they're an opportunity
- 24:28for both sides to come to the table and have
- 24:31a meaningful discussion about, look, this is
- 24:34what I want to do as a landlord and the tenant
- 24:36can come forward and go, look, this is what I'm
- 24:37facing. My rent is this and my market rent is
- 24:40this. So, you know, there's a delta on both sides.
- 24:43There's an upside and a downside respectively.
- 24:46And so that's why, you know, you have these conversations.
- 24:49And it's also an opportunity for a tenant who,
- 24:51I've had many buyouts where tenants use the money
- 24:54to buy a house. I've seen tenants use relocation
- 24:58money from, you know. a 60 -day notice that they
- 25:01got and got relocation money. I've seen them
- 25:03buy houses. So it's an opportunity, maybe this
- 25:06buyout money could be the windfall they need
- 25:08to make that down payment on something. I've
- 25:11also seen tenants who are really, you know, hey,
- 25:14I would like to take a buyout because I've been
- 25:16thinking about relocating. I've had older tenants
- 25:18who want to relocate to be closer to their grandchildren.
- 25:21Maybe they're out of state or, you know... in
- 25:24a different county and that's helped them. I've
- 25:26had tenants that have life changes, you know,
- 25:28they change jobs and they want to move somewhere
- 25:31else and this money helps them. So there are
- 25:33things that, you know, both sides do have an
- 25:36opportunity. Maybe the tenant wanted to move,
- 25:38but otherwise didn't have the means to do it.
- 25:41And now this is an opportunity. So it's both
- 25:44sides are agreeing on it and it removes a lot
- 25:47of the animosity. Doesn't mean both sides are
- 25:49going to get what they want, right? The tenant
- 25:51might. Accept less money than they were like
- 25:53really hoping for our landlords likely gonna
- 25:55pay more money than they were hoping to But it
- 25:58takes out the animosity and people can kind of
- 26:00level with one another and go look This is both
- 26:02of our respective realities And you yourselves
- 26:07are coming to the agreement that landlord in
- 26:10the tenant not necessarily a court or a jury,
- 26:13so to speak, if it were to come down an eviction.
- 26:15So you get to sort of steer your fate in this.
- 26:18And a lot of the times, these agreements are
- 26:20designed to mitigate further liability and risk.
- 26:23So you want to have it drafted by an experienced
- 26:26attorney. You also want to make sure that Any
- 26:29sort of negotiation you upfront or giving tenants,
- 26:32you know the buyout disclosure. So every almost
- 26:35every jurisdiction has a buyout disclosure so
- 26:39it's a list of rules that the tenants are rights
- 26:42that the tenants have rules that the landlord
- 26:44is subject to and Approaching tenants for these
- 26:47that outlines a sort of the city is okay with
- 26:50this thing Of course, they can't stop it, but
- 26:52they want to make sure that tenants have certain
- 26:56rights for themselves and their ability to also
- 26:59not have a unilateral discussion with the landlord,
- 27:02they wanna also know what makes sense for them
- 27:05as well. So we're gonna talk about that here
- 27:09in my big, beautiful buyout requirements chart.
- 27:13So some of the requirements of buyouts are, one,
- 27:18they have to be in writing. Also, as you know,
- 27:21attorney, we want everything in writing. It oftentimes
- 27:25has to be bilingual. So if the tenant is negotiating
- 27:29in a different language or speaks a different
- 27:30language, the agreement needs to be translated
- 27:33in that language. A lot of times, tenants do
- 27:36have a cancellation period, meaning the tenant
- 27:38does have a right to change their mind and back
- 27:42out of the deal. So they can, you know, they
- 27:44have between 30 and 45 days is the most common
- 27:46and they can turn around and change their mind
- 27:49and say, look, I've thought about it. I went
- 27:51and looked at the market and I just can't find
- 27:53anything I can afford. This, you know, this agreement
- 27:55isn't going to make sense for me and they can
- 27:57cancel it. Some jurisdictions have minimums,
- 28:00which we talked about earlier, the relocation
- 28:02amount. So some require that the relocation amount
- 28:05be offered to the tenant and not less than that.
- 28:09San Diego is the only one where their code says
- 28:11you have to offer more than relocation. How much
- 28:14more? A penny, a dollar, a hundred dollars, but
- 28:18it has to be greater than relocation. The buyout
- 28:22agreements do need to be filed with certain jurisdictions
- 28:25if they require it. And there are certain windows
- 28:28of which you have to file it in. And then, of
- 28:30course, you have to give a copy to the tenant.
- 28:33Some of them require that you file a proof of
- 28:35service with the city, that you mail the copy
- 28:38to the tenant. And by and large, buyouts apply
- 28:42to virtually all the residential units, except
- 28:45for LA City. It only applies to their rent stabilized
- 28:49units. So those would be units that are subject
- 28:52to the rent stabilization ordinance that were
- 28:54built pre -1978. So on the cancellation period,
- 29:01so you can't really do one of these in a week
- 29:04or two. It's going to have to be signed. And
- 29:07then I take it that the cancellation period runs
- 29:09from the date that the agreement is signed. Yes.
- 29:12So you could do a buyout where the tenant has
- 29:18their move out date, let's say, is August 31st.
- 29:22And today is August 8th. So they have until what?
- 29:26September 7th to cancel it. And I've had deals
- 29:29where the tenant moves out in a week. And so
- 29:32oftentimes I will have language in the agreement
- 29:35that should you be doing a buyout and I, the
- 29:39landlord, advance money to you tenant, and then
- 29:42you try to cancel the agreement, you can't do
- 29:44it without returning the money. So oftentimes
- 29:47the money is not handed over or a portion of
- 29:52the money is not handed over. Until a cancellation
- 29:55period has expired Typically, it's on hand over
- 29:59until the tenant has moved out So it depends
- 30:02on sort of the trust in this situation if the
- 30:06tenant has turned in key signed a new lease emptied
- 30:08out the apartment said here's the keys and you
- 30:11hand them a check for you know $20 ,000 and then
- 30:15they come back and say just kidding. I want to
- 30:17stay in my apartment They're gonna be on the
- 30:20hook for a new unit this unit and there's an
- 30:23argument that they actually can't because they
- 30:26haven't turned over the $20 ,000. Again, that's
- 30:29something where it gets challenged potentially
- 30:31in court with the judge, but there's language
- 30:34in the agreement that addresses that in the event
- 30:36that it's a quick turnaround, the tenant's ready
- 30:39to go. Can you give us an idea of what these
- 30:47agreements generally look like, how long they
- 30:50are, any sort of special provisions that some
- 30:52people like to see or that tenants have requested?
- 30:56Yeah. So the agreement is about eight pages long.
- 30:59If you're an attorney, not scary. If you're a
- 31:02tenant, it's a lot of homework. It's not written
- 31:08anything very complicated. So tenants read it
- 31:11all the time. They understand it. They'll ask
- 31:13me questions about it. Typically, what's in there
- 31:17is a paragraph about their rights. There's a
- 31:21buyout disclosure. You received it. Should one
- 31:24apply to this buyout? It talks about that the
- 31:28tenant is how my draft agreement is. It's a waiver
- 31:32of all claims as well. So the tenant doesn't
- 31:34have any further disputes about this, that they're
- 31:38going to be relinquishing their unit. The lease
- 31:43is being terminated. They're giving up possession.
- 31:45They're not going to have any right to come back
- 31:47to the unit under the terms of their current
- 31:49lease or any sort of right to return. The owner
- 31:52is free to do what they want. They can want to
- 31:54sell it. They want to rerent it. They want to
- 31:56owner occupy it. You know, they want to demolish
- 31:59it, whatever they want to do. It talks about
- 32:03what the tenants going to get paid, when they're
- 32:06going to get paid, when their term, like their
- 32:09move out date is the lease termination date.
- 32:11In the event that they don't vacate, what options
- 32:15the landlord has, including their right to evict
- 32:18the tenant to enforce the agreement, and then
- 32:21there are specifics in there about, you know,
- 32:24the tenant will forward their mail. The tenant's
- 32:27not going to move in on any other people and
- 32:29they're not going to try to sublet or assign
- 32:32their tenancy to anyone. That's going to be void.
- 32:35So it's typically... the tenants gonna get money,
- 32:39they're gonna move out, the security deposit
- 32:41might be addressed in there as well. And then,
- 32:44you know, typical things that you as a landlord
- 32:46wanna make sure, and they're like, don't have
- 32:49your friend move into the apartment and now I
- 32:51don't have a vacant unit and I'm stuck with that.
- 32:54So they're all very straightforward things that
- 32:55you would expect in a buyout agreement when the
- 32:58owner's trying to get possession back. We have
- 33:01a number of questions. One of the questions was,
- 33:05what about the withdrawal from the rental market
- 33:07just cause? Has that been banned? The Ellis Act
- 33:13has not been banned. There is no ban on it. Now,
- 33:16if you're redeveloping a property, there are
- 33:19restrictions. There might be higher relocation
- 33:23amounts. There's a state initiative to build
- 33:26more housing. So that might conflict with maybe
- 33:29a local ordinance or zoning that would have allowed.
- 33:33maybe going from apartments to condos or something
- 33:36of that nature, but you can at any time exit
- 33:40the rental market. But redeveloping a rent controlled
- 33:44property tends to be where there's a lot of nuance
- 33:48and layers to what is and isn't possible. Someone
- 33:53wanted to know if Beverly Hills has an ordinance
- 33:57about this. Beverly Hills does not have a buyout
- 34:00program of ordinance. They're voluntary agreements
- 34:03between the landlord and the tenant. So that
- 34:06means that you can still do them in Beverly Hills.
- 34:08You just don't have the restrictions of an ordinance.
- 34:11You can do a buyout agreement anywhere. There's
- 34:13just some jurisdictions that have restrictions
- 34:15about it to help protect and level the playing
- 34:18field for the tenant. Yes. Another question.
- 34:21Does the tenant need to be represented by council?
- 34:23The tenant does not need to be represented by
- 34:26council. They have a right to be represented
- 34:29by council. They definitely have a right to call
- 34:31that local housing department and ask them questions
- 34:34about buyouts. But they do not have to be. But
- 34:38if they wish to be, by all means, they should
- 34:40have an attorney. When they are represented by
- 34:43council, do you usually include a signature by
- 34:45council in the agreement? No, I think maybe once
- 34:50or twice we had an approved as to form, but typically
- 34:55it's just the parties that sign it. Someone was
- 34:58asking sort of the business question. If there
- 35:01is no relocation amount minimum, what is usually
- 35:06a good starting point for a minimum buyout amount?
- 35:10I would say typically the relocation amount.
- 35:12If the tenant owes money, So maybe the tenant
- 35:16has arrears and you're like, let me buy them
- 35:19out because I really don't want to go through
- 35:21the eviction process. You might go, hey, your
- 35:24relocation would have been X dollar amount, but
- 35:26you owe me X in rent, so I'll offer you this.
- 35:29Or it's cost me X dollar amount in attorney's
- 35:34fees or repairs because you've damaged stuff
- 35:36or something. Then you might have an excuse to
- 35:38offer less. But typically, you offer the relocation
- 35:42amount. Sally Roshan, who has an escrow company,
- 35:49has been part of our executive committee for
- 35:51this section, asks, what happens in a situation
- 35:54where the tenant has moved out per the terms
- 35:56of the agreement and the landlord does not authorize
- 36:00the release of the funds that the escrow may
- 36:02be holding? There's escrow instructions in that
- 36:09sense of escrow is holding it there's escrow
- 36:11instructions So if the landlord doesn't release
- 36:14the funds the landlord is risking civil liability
- 36:18for the tenant and it depends also You know at
- 36:22what point in time this the tenant moved out.
- 36:25Maybe there's a window where the tenant can cancel
- 36:27the agreement so it doesn't really behoove the
- 36:31landlord to not pay the rent, especially if you
- 36:34have a a biotech agreement that includes a release
- 36:38of all claims, they risk waiving that. And they
- 36:41risk, of course, attorney's fees and civil liability
- 36:44for it. So it does happen. It's a shame. But
- 36:50in that sense, it becomes a civil matter between
- 36:54the landlord and the tenant. How often do you
- 36:57see escrows used in these transactions? I have
- 37:02it. I tried getting escrow companies to sort
- 37:05of help with it and I didn't want anything to
- 37:07do with it. So it's not often that I see escrow
- 37:11companies do it. I sometimes will hold the money
- 37:14in escrow. So if there's a relationship where
- 37:17maybe the landlord and tenant both are like skeptical
- 37:20of one another and like probably rightfully so,
- 37:23then I will hold the funds in my account and
- 37:26then I will issue them out accordingly. And then,
- 37:30you know, should I have what Sally took issue
- 37:33with, I probably would reach out to the state
- 37:37bar and get some sort of guidance on what I,
- 37:39as attorney, should do if I'm holding the funds.
- 37:42But I haven't had it where a landlord doesn't
- 37:45pay the money. They're motivated. In my experience,
- 37:49if they're hiring me, they want to do it right.
- 37:51They don't want to play games. And so they're
- 37:53motivated to give the tenant the money and, like,
- 37:56peace be with all. Have you seen situations where
- 38:00the tenant doesn't move and the landlord actually
- 38:02tries to specifically perform the agreement through
- 38:05the courts? I haven't had that yet. I've had
- 38:10two buyouts where the tenant canceled. One was
- 38:16during COVID and it was a buyout agreement where
- 38:19the tenant was simply, the owner was waiving
- 38:21the rent. It was like $35 ,000 in rent and the
- 38:25tenant was going to vacate. And the tenant at
- 38:29the time was being difficult and agreed to it,
- 38:33but then canceled the buyout. And my client somewhat
- 38:36expected that to happen, but didn't have an eviction
- 38:39recourse because there was a lot of eviction
- 38:41restrictions and the tenant had canceled the
- 38:43agreement anyways. Then I had one where a tenant
- 38:46had canceled the agreement. Again, it was one
- 38:49where he agreed but couldn't move out and wouldn't
- 38:53explain like when his move out. I go, okay. You
- 38:55know, if you can't do this date, tell me what
- 38:57what date could you do? I don't know. So that
- 39:00one got canceled and the tenant did ultimately
- 39:03move out. That's to be resolved. Then there was
- 39:08one where a tenant had done a buyout agreement
- 39:12and he was the main tenant and his brother had
- 39:14lived with him and the brother and him had signed
- 39:17it and the tenant had moved out. But the guy
- 39:21in the unit wasn't the brother. And the tenant
- 39:24had represented to everybody, including the on
- 39:27-site handyman that the gentleman in the unit
- 39:29was his brother. And that gentleman came forward
- 39:32and said, I didn't do a buyout. I'm not leaving.
- 39:35So my client had to, unfortunately, do an eviction
- 39:37in that instance as well. Other than that, it's
- 39:40very rare that these things don't follow through
- 39:45with or don't happen, mainly because when you
- 39:49negotiate at arm's length with tenants, even
- 39:52though it might cost you a little bit more, that's
- 39:55the motivation you need for the tenant to uphold
- 39:56the agreement, because it has to, again, make
- 39:58sense for the tenant. When tenants don't honor
- 40:01agreements, it's because typically they were
- 40:03forced into an agreement that they didn't like,
- 40:05or they were strong -armed, and that increases
- 40:09the chances that they're gonna cancel or just
- 40:11not honor the agreement. but knock on wood, I've
- 40:14yet to have a buyout entirely blow up. What's
- 40:19the most you've seen or heard about some kind
- 40:21of being paid in one of these? The highest buyout
- 40:25that I've ever heard of, I think was 450 ,000
- 40:30in San Francisco. But the highest one that I've
- 40:33ever done was 90 ,000. We have a request and
- 40:37you shouldn't feel pressed to do this But someone
- 40:40wants to know if you'd be willing to share the
- 40:42agreement form that you use I don't typically
- 40:46share it by always if you want to reach out to
- 40:48me or you need an agreement I'd be happy to talk
- 40:52about it and explain sort of the main provisions
- 40:54on it for sure My old friend Bruce Lorman want
- 40:58to know about what escrow you might use and so
- 41:01Bruce you might talked to Sally Rochon it's I
- 41:05believe secured trust escrow and Sally may be
- 41:08willing to do that. She takes on some escrows
- 41:10that other people don't and she's got a legal
- 41:13background so that I think she's more comfortable
- 41:16looking at those things and I know other escrows
- 41:18that send her some transactions that they just
- 41:21don't want to handle. Next question, if the tenant
- 41:28is moved out for the owner to move in and the
- 41:31owner later gets sick and doesn't stay the required
- 41:33period, is there an exception to the penalty
- 41:36or the statutes if they have to move out because
- 41:43of health reasons? There could be. The main concern
- 41:48that the city has are I imagine the judge would
- 41:53or a jury would as well. is the intention at
- 41:56the outset of moving in. So if your goal was
- 41:59to move in because you did genuinely plan to
- 42:01owner -occupy and you did, but let's say you
- 42:05needed to owner -occupy for a year and your health
- 42:09is on a decline and you need to move back into
- 42:11a unit owner -occupied to be closer to family,
- 42:14and six months later you wind up in the hospital
- 42:16bedridden and you can't return to your unit.
- 42:19That would be a good faith argument that like
- 42:22I did genuinely live in the unit and it's not
- 42:24like I Like, I want to be sick, but I ended up
- 42:26in the hospital. So you do have, in that sense,
- 42:30a defense for it. The main thing is that the
- 42:32move -in is in good faith. I mean, you could
- 42:34do a buyout owner. I mean, you could do an owner
- 42:37occupancy and unfortunately pass away six months
- 42:40in. And you know what? It's not like it was a
- 42:43bad faith owner occupancy. So that's mainly the
- 42:46argument. And a lot of times when you do the
- 42:48annual declarations, they'll ask you, are you
- 42:51still living here? And if not, why? I was in
- 42:54the hospital, family member is deceased. We have
- 42:59sort of a negotiation question, which is, what
- 43:01is the appropriate thing to tell a tenant when
- 43:03the landlord wants to sell the property? So it
- 43:06depends on the jurisdiction that you're in. A
- 43:09lot of jurisdictions in here, pretty much all
- 43:14the ones that I have listed, wanting to sell
- 43:17the property is not grounds to give the tenant
- 43:19an eviction notice. So you have to Usually you
- 43:24give the tenant I believe a hundred and twenty
- 43:26day notice Ellie might know but I believe you
- 43:28give tenants notice of like the property is gonna
- 43:30be up for sale if it's a house or Maybe it's
- 43:35a small apartment building and you know the tenants
- 43:38on a first name basis You might want to have
- 43:41the conversation with the tenant go. Hey, I'm
- 43:44looking to sell the property. It's gonna change
- 43:46hands Would you be interested in doing a buyout
- 43:51agreement, a voluntary move out agreement? I
- 43:53would be willing to pay you. And you can open
- 43:56the conversation. And then I would follow up
- 43:59either by dropping off or emailing a copy of
- 44:02the applicable buyout disclosure. But it's always
- 44:05good to like, hey, I want to sell the property.
- 44:08Heads up. Entry is going to have to be permitted
- 44:13as allowed by the law. And also, if you would
- 44:17be interested, I'd be willing to entertain a
- 44:19buyout. So we have another question. What about
- 44:22civil code 1946 .2J in the TPA? The tenant can't
- 44:28waive the TPA. The cash for keys sounds like
- 44:31a waiver. I mean, I don't have the code section
- 44:35memorized, so I don't know what the code section
- 44:37is. OK. But the buyout agreement is the tenant's
- 44:42When they're entering a buyout, they're being
- 44:45paid to end their tenancy. What the TPA says,
- 44:48I'd have to look at it. But typically, you may
- 44:53want to contact Sasha offline for that. And in
- 44:57case people didn't note it in the Q &A, Sally
- 45:00Rochand says she does do these sorts of escrows.
- 45:05You can reach Sally emailing her, sally at secured
- 45:08trust escrow dot com. Nicole asked to post the
- 45:15seminar handout. I think it's in the Q &A. The
- 45:19link has been put in the Q &A above your question
- 45:22on that one. Okay. What are the strategies for
- 45:29negotiation of more than just the statutory amount
- 45:32for the tenant? To go through strategies, it's
- 45:38a very case -by -case and unit -by -unit scenario
- 45:40because every jurisdiction has different laws
- 45:43and then every unit has a very different tenancy.
- 45:47You could have someone who's a single adult who
- 45:49could easily move versus someone who's lived
- 45:52in their unit for 40 years and is wheelchair
- 45:54-bound and can't easily move versus family. with
- 45:58two kids in a really good school district that
- 46:00don't want to move. So it really depends. So
- 46:04the strategy, it's important to have a conversation
- 46:06with an attorney before you go and do this, because
- 46:08your strategy might vary from unit to unit. And
- 46:12the amount you offer might vary. And then it
- 46:14depends on your budget. And do you want to leave
- 46:17room for negotiation? Are you just going to give
- 46:19them this is the number, take it or leave it?
- 46:22There's different ways to go about it. That is
- 46:26a very case by case scenario. One of the questions
- 46:33is, what if you have to move out because the
- 46:35house is uninhabitable for some reason? But I'm
- 46:39not sure exactly where that comes into play in
- 46:41the cash for keys scenario. I don't know. It
- 46:45depends on if there's an order to comply mandating
- 46:48that the unit be vacated, if the tenant is required.
- 46:52It depends on how the government order is written,
- 46:56whether it's a permanent relocation for the tenant
- 47:00or the tenant has to be temporarily relocated
- 47:03while you fix the uninhabitable issues. A couple
- 47:06of these are more general sort of landlord tenant
- 47:08questions, including that one. The rest of it
- 47:11was put in later that there's a fixed term lease
- 47:14of one year, six months. ceiling collapses. They
- 47:18show mold there. But that's not really a cash
- 47:20for keys situation. That's going to be a question
- 47:23for another speaker, I think, on another time.
- 47:27And similarly, it was a question if someone wants
- 47:30to rent out their condo, but only for 18 months,
- 47:33and then the tenant doesn't want to get out.
- 47:35Again, that's not probably going to be a cash
- 47:38for keys situation. It's really a a more general
- 47:41landlord -tenant situation and will depend probably
- 47:45as to how the rent control, rent stabilization
- 47:48affects that right to remove the person, even
- 47:51though it was only a fixed term lease. So in
- 47:56short, there's a bunch of offshoots. You might
- 48:00do a buyout agreement because the unit's unhabitable
- 48:03and the tenant's demanding it. The tenant might
- 48:05go, hey, you need to pay me money to move out.
- 48:07That might be a buyout agreement scenario. And
- 48:10then there, it's basically a settlement agreement.
- 48:12Your unit has some issues with it. You don't
- 48:15want to live in it anymore. You want money. I
- 48:17want to be released of all liability. That could
- 48:19be a buyout scenario for sure. But it all, again,
- 48:23comes down to what exactly is going on, what's
- 48:26taking place, what is the indicators you're getting
- 48:31from the tenant as to what they want. So there's
- 48:34a lot of nuance if you have just a day -to -day
- 48:37disputes with tenants that maybe you just want
- 48:38to do a buyout or the tenant wants to be bought
- 48:41out. So we need to get on to Ellie's financial
- 48:45course on this. If we have time, we may get back
- 48:47to one or two of the other questions after. Thank
- 48:51you. Thank you, Sasha. Thank you, Sasha and Howard.
- 48:56Sasha has helped many of my clients create win
- 48:59-win scenarios for both the landlords and the
- 49:01tenants. I'm going to share my PowerPoint, which
- 49:09is going to talk a little bit about the financial
- 49:13aspects and also how trusted advisors are able
- 49:15to protect downside risk in many circumstances.
- 49:21My PowerPoint is going to go ahead and talk about
- 49:24cash for keys and how it creates value. The cash
- 49:27will break even, an exponential return, forced
- 49:30depreciation, forced depreciation, refinancing
- 49:34sale, and then how the trust advisors protect
- 49:36outside risk. Okay, so I got a call from a trust
- 49:45administrator for an apartment building. They
- 49:49inherited a building, five siblings inherited
- 49:52a building from their father who was a waiter
- 49:54in Echo Park. with his tip money over 40 years
- 49:59ago, he was able to purchase an apartment building.
- 50:02He had the opportunity to create multi -generational
- 50:05wealth for his family with tip money. Ultimately,
- 50:11he passed, which was a terrible loss, but he
- 50:14gave his kids an incredible gift. He gave them
- 50:17something called a step -up in basis, which allowed
- 50:19them to sell the building and have limited capital
- 50:23gains exposure. Ultimately, when we got the call,
- 50:27one of the challenges that we had when we were
- 50:30battling the apartment building is that he was
- 50:32receiving a lot of off -market offers for about
- 50:34$7 .5 million. And the reason why is because
- 50:37the rent, the occupied rents were around $1 ,100
- 50:40a month, which was far below market. We came
- 50:44in, we recognized the opportunity that there
- 50:47could be a cash for keys opportunity after the
- 50:49close of escrow for a buyer. and we went ahead
- 50:53and through the Marcus Millichap platform, we
- 50:56literally listed it. We went live to not just
- 50:59local, but regional, national, and international
- 51:02buyers. We ultimately found a buyer in New York
- 51:05who was familiar with cash for keys, and he was
- 51:07able to increase, after the close of escrow,
- 51:10increase some of the rents in the building. He
- 51:12was able to offer $30 ,000 in... to create win
- 51:18-win scenarios for the tenants who wanted to
- 51:20relocate, and he was able to increase some of
- 51:24the rent by $1 ,700 a month, which is over $20
- 51:29,000 a year per unit. So I'm going to go ahead
- 51:33and demonstrate to you the cash flow breakeven
- 51:36point and the exponential return. So if you have
- 51:41a $20 ,000 a year increase with a $30 ,000...
- 51:45which is a one -time cost. You were able to go
- 51:48ahead and get your money back in 18 months. So
- 51:50the first year is $20 ,000. The half of the second
- 51:53year, you're getting another $10 ,000 as a landlord,
- 51:56and the landlord got their money back in 18 months.
- 51:59What is exciting here is that after another 18
- 52:05months, so three years in, or 36 months, you
- 52:08got all your money back, plus you doubled your
- 52:11return. So, ultimately, you go ahead and get,
- 52:14for a $30 ,000 payout, you were able to get $60
- 52:17,000 back. So, if you thought that was good,
- 52:22or that was exciting, I'm going to go ahead and
- 52:24tell you how it increased the equity in the building,
- 52:27which I call forced appreciation, and which was
- 52:30a tremendous win for the tenant, too, because
- 52:33in their case, they wanted to relocate anyway,
- 52:36and they were able to achieve $30 ,000, which
- 52:40for them was a real economic benefit. So what
- 52:44is NOI? NOI is Net Operating Income. So you take
- 52:47the gross rent of the building minus the expenses
- 52:50that equals the NOI. So we were able to increase
- 52:53the NOI on this building by $1 ,700 a month.
- 52:57With a higher NOI, that's a little over $20 ,000
- 53:01a year. And at a 5 % capitalization rate or a
- 53:04cap rate, that increased the value by $400 ,000.
- 53:09So, what is a cap rate? A cap rate is a buyer's
- 53:12unlevered return or capitalization rate, their
- 53:16unlevered return. If the buyer puts 100 % down
- 53:19in the building, that's their return. There's
- 53:21no loan, so they're able to add up, we could
- 53:25take $20 ,000. What's the formula for a cap rate?
- 53:29It's the NOI, the gross rent minus the expenses,
- 53:32divided by the purchase price. So, with a $20
- 53:36,000 increase, 5 % you got $400 ,000 of increased
- 53:42value. So now I'm going to go ahead and speak
- 53:45through it's a $400 ,000 at a five cap, which
- 53:49literally if you go ahead and have a $400 ,000
- 53:53investment at 5 % return on that, that spits
- 53:55off $20 ,000 extra a year. On a refinance perspective,
- 54:01if you're able to go ahead and get a building,
- 54:03let's say, 70 % LTB or loan to value, if you
- 54:07have a million dollar building and you get 70
- 54:09% out of that, that's 700 grand. If there's a
- 54:1210 million dollar building and the lender's willing
- 54:14to give you 70 % loan on that building, that's
- 54:18seven million dollars. So in this case, if you
- 54:21have $400 ,000 as an increased value, you're
- 54:24able to go ahead and have an equity extraction
- 54:26of $280 ,000. That's under refinance. For that
- 54:33one unit, based off of a 5 % cap rate per sale
- 54:37assumption, and there's five metrics of value.
- 54:40So cap rate is only one of the financial metrics.
- 54:44If you're able to go ahead and get, by buying
- 54:47out this one unit, you're able to create $400
- 54:50,000 of value on a cap rate perspective. Ultimately,
- 54:56I would suggest everybody speak to a trusted
- 54:59broker or advisor to run through all the scenarios,
- 55:03because this doesn't include remodeling costs,
- 55:07downtime, lost rent, and a number of other factors.
- 55:12And here, I'm going to speak a little bit about
- 55:14how trusted advisors are able to protect downside
- 55:17risk. So many of us in this room, or many of
- 55:21you in the room are attorneys, and you're advising
- 55:24owners. advising owners, some like my grandmother.
- 55:27My grandmother survived the camps, she survived
- 55:31the concentration camps in Romania and Auschwitz,
- 55:34and she came here and didn't have any money.
- 55:37But she worked really, really hard and saved
- 55:39real money. And she was able to buy a small apartment
- 55:43building. And with that apartment building, she
- 55:47was able to work because she wanted to, and not
- 55:51because she had to, but there's a lot of owners
- 55:54like her. who live off the income from their
- 55:56billing, that's their retirement. And every single
- 56:01month is important to them, because that's how
- 56:04they live. So sometimes there's cases where there's
- 56:06an eviction. So cash for keys is a scenario that
- 56:09could help expedite timeframes and eliminate
- 56:13the potential lost rent and uncertainty with
- 56:17an eviction, which could take six to nine months.
- 56:20So ultimately, cash for keys, in summary, is
- 56:24a scenario where it could help people like my
- 56:27grandmother, people like the waiter in Echo Park,
- 56:30to go ahead and create win -win scenarios for
- 56:32landlords, but also tenants, because there could
- 56:34be a real economic benefit for them if they're
- 56:37looking to relocate, and they could give money
- 56:41which they may not have had otherwise. Thank
- 56:44you so much. We have another sort of negotiation
- 56:47question that I think is potentially interesting
- 56:50for Sasha. If a landlord is looking to list for
- 56:54sale a residential building and as their counsel,
- 56:57you have to negotiate with all the tenants, are
- 57:00you going to try to do that collectively or separately?
- 57:03Hope the tenants don't all discuss the terms,
- 57:06the buyout amounts with each other. And how do
- 57:09you approach that to avoid paying more than you
- 57:14need to if you're going to try to approach numerous
- 57:18tenants in the building or even all the tenants?
- 57:21So in my experience, before you go and try to
- 57:24list a property for sale, you should approach
- 57:28the tenants for buyouts because that's going
- 57:32to give you the best upside on your sale price.
- 57:35I do this typically by offering all the units
- 57:39that it makes sense to in the building. The reason
- 57:41being, if I focus on one, that one tenant's going
- 57:44to feel like, why am I being targeted? Um, and
- 57:48then two you're putting all your eggs in one
- 57:50basket So if you go cherry pick them it doesn't
- 57:54quite make sense and it decreases the chances
- 57:57right? Statistically speaking if you offer a
- 57:59bunch of people buyouts, you'll probably get
- 58:00one or two I don't really care that tenants talk
- 58:03to each other. That's fine They'll talk to each
- 58:05other. They'll go talk to housing. Maybe one
- 58:08or two will get represented by council Maybe
- 58:10that council will represent more than one tenant.
- 58:12I don't mind that um for the simple fact that
- 58:16No matter if I go, like me and my neighbor live
- 58:19in an apartment building, we're like, we're going
- 58:22to negotiate together as a team. But maybe my
- 58:26rent is closer to market. I don't have any kids.
- 58:30And maybe my neighbor, she's a single mom with
- 58:33two kids. And her rent is 40 % less than mine.
- 58:39At the end of the day, she's going to ultimately
- 58:42realize, look, You could move. It's not that
- 58:45hard for you. But me, I have kids. I like where
- 58:48I'm at. My kids have been raised here. I'm in
- 58:51a great school district. I have to get more money
- 58:53because I got to look out for me. And that happens
- 58:56all the time in buyouts where the tenant goes,
- 58:58don't tell my neighbor what I'm getting. Like
- 59:01they're on their own. This is for me. And that's
- 59:04basically survival instincts. So by all means,
- 59:06they could talk to each other and they can negotiate
- 59:10it up. But I don't negotiate with groups and
- 59:13I'm very upfront with tenants. I go, look, what
- 59:16you tell me is your buyout. Is your negotiation
- 59:19and is I'm gonna take your best points I'm gonna
- 59:21go back to my client with them because my whole
- 59:23job is to get a deal done So if you have some
- 59:25good points, I'm gonna drill those home If you
- 59:28have bad points not gonna help you in this But
- 59:31I'm not gonna negotiate with you and with your
- 59:33neighbor because you guys have two different
- 59:35scenarios And I think you're entitled to your
- 59:37individual negotiation in your privacy But if
- 59:40I'm on the phone with the tenant and her neighbors
- 59:42in there, I can't stop them I'm not gonna let
- 59:45go beat him up. I'm not gonna tear him apart
- 59:47But ultimately, they start maybe unified, but
- 59:51they end up breaking off. Also, I will say if
- 59:56your plan is to buy out to sell, you need to
- 59:59give yourself like months of leeway. And part
- 1:00:02of what happens is I will come into a buyout
- 1:00:05where the tenant loosely or the owner loosely
- 1:00:09started conversations and then they didn't go
- 1:00:12anywhere. So now the tenant doesn't trust the
- 1:00:15landlord, so to speak. Or when I come in and
- 1:00:18I offer relocation, the tenant ignores me. And
- 1:00:21sometimes my client does have a legitimate ground
- 1:00:23to move into one of the units. But it ends up
- 1:00:26becoming difficult because I'm not here to harass
- 1:00:29and strong -arm tenants. I might have a valid
- 1:00:32negotiating point, like, look, my client's going
- 1:00:34to owner -occupy your unit. Or the whole building's
- 1:00:38being LS -acted. And so this is just an opportunity.
- 1:00:42but there's times where it becomes difficult
- 1:00:45for me when I don't always know the big picture
- 1:00:47like oh you three years ago offer tenant buyouts
- 1:00:51and then you got like almost the finish line
- 1:00:53and the whole thing blew up so now I'm coming
- 1:00:55in trying to save face for you but I would negotiate
- 1:01:00with I would present offers to everybody and
- 1:01:03they nine out of ten times I'll go talk to each
- 1:01:06other about them because they'll tell me we all
- 1:01:09know we got offer deals and I'm like yeah all
- 1:01:11right Do you ever have purchasers come to you
- 1:01:15before the purchase to talk about what they think
- 1:01:18you can accomplish for them on a cash for keys
- 1:01:21after they buy? Yeah, I tend to do that. Our
- 1:01:25owners come to me or buyers, sorry, buyers come
- 1:01:27to me during escrow. Sometimes it's part of the
- 1:01:31sale contingency that a unit needs to be delivered
- 1:01:34vacant and it depends on how the purchase agreement
- 1:01:37is drafted. unit to be delivered vacant, but
- 1:01:41it's sellers to deliver it vacant or buyers to
- 1:01:44negotiate the terms of which the tenant will
- 1:01:46vacate. So there's different nuances to it, but
- 1:01:49I've gone in and I represented buyers who are
- 1:01:52purchasing a property or are close to closing
- 1:01:54on the property and they want to get buyouts
- 1:01:56done with the tenants. And someone was asking
- 1:02:05whether you put confidentiality clauses in the
- 1:02:07buyout agreements. I do put confidentiality clauses
- 1:02:10in the buyout agreements. Like all things, they're
- 1:02:16enforceable, they're hard to enforce. It could
- 1:02:19be like I have a buyout and it's somewhat nuanced
- 1:02:23and the tendon threw in my face that the guy
- 1:02:26living upstairs, in the same house but upstairs,
- 1:02:30got a different amount of money and knew exactly
- 1:02:33how much money the guy got. And it was in the
- 1:02:35agreement, the guy was not to talk about that.
- 1:02:37But as an owner, you're like, to some degree,
- 1:02:41like, what am I doing? Go find the guy and sue
- 1:02:43the guy and spend a bunch of attorney's fees.
- 1:02:45Usually what it results in is once you, it's
- 1:02:48really important, your first buyout is like,
- 1:02:52it's the metric, right? It's the yardstick. Because
- 1:02:54no matter how much I could try to play gag order,
- 1:02:57if they talk, they talk. The piece of paper only
- 1:03:00says don't talk. But if they go and talk or they're
- 1:03:03outside smoking a cigarette and they go, I got
- 1:03:0430 grand, like, what are you gonna do? like the
- 1:03:07numbers out there. So when you do your first
- 1:03:09buyout, that's kind of how you gauge the rest.
- 1:03:12Because if they get wind of that number, at least
- 1:03:15you kind of know that's your pain point. Like,
- 1:03:16look, I'll match it, and I'm not going above
- 1:03:18it. So yeah, there's confidentiality clauses,
- 1:03:22but like all things, if they don't honor them.
- 1:03:25So it may be that if there's one tenant that
- 1:03:27you're going to have to offer more money to for
- 1:03:30particular reasons, you may want to make the
- 1:03:32deal with them. after you make it with other
- 1:03:34people in the building, so they are not trying
- 1:03:36to use that as their yardstick. Well, there's
- 1:03:39also an interesting factor, and Ellie and I know
- 1:03:43about this on a building, but certain jurisdictions
- 1:03:46post the buyout numbers online. And they'll go,
- 1:03:50this unit at this address has two bedrooms and
- 1:03:54did a $32 ,000 buyout on this date. because it
- 1:03:58gets filed with them. So the tenant can just
- 1:04:01go online and go, hey, and this happened to me.
- 1:04:03I did a round of buyouts, and I did six units.
- 1:04:06And I filed them with the city, as I'm required
- 1:04:09to. And so the number is populated. So a tenant
- 1:04:12came back to me. And she goes, I want the highest
- 1:04:14buyout. And I'm not moving. And I go, yeah, but
- 1:04:20that tenant has lived here longer, has a bigger
- 1:04:23unit, and had a better situated unit with a better
- 1:04:26view. you moved in a few years ago only have
- 1:04:29one bedroom and you're closer to market rent
- 1:04:31so i'll give you this and the tenant goes okay
- 1:04:34i'll take that so sometimes it helps because
- 1:04:37then well this tenant got this number yeah but
- 1:04:40this tenant has this this this this and this
- 1:04:42going in their favor that you don't have and
- 1:04:45it's like if you want the money we'll talk about
- 1:04:48it but it doesn't always mean that you're going
- 1:04:50to get the highest biggest number because there's
- 1:04:52again factors involved with that We have generated
- 1:04:57in this a lot of questions in today's presentation
- 1:04:59and there are some others but we're about five
- 1:05:01minutes beyond our time and I think we'll have
- 1:05:04to terminate so I'm going to encourage anybody
- 1:05:06who wants to to get in touch with Sasha privately
- 1:05:09to if you want to pursue some of the questions
- 1:05:12there and just remember that she's talking about
- 1:05:16cash for keys not general landlord tenant questions
- 1:05:18but other than that it's been really interesting
- 1:05:21it's the cash for keys is a very interesting
- 1:05:24sort of potentially win -win situation. very
- 1:05:27interesting how the equity can get multiplied
- 1:05:30using cash for keys. As Ellie was demonstrating,
- 1:05:33talking about just one unit for 30 ,000. If you
- 1:05:36had four or five units in a 10 unit building,
- 1:05:38you could really get a lot more on selling that
- 1:05:41building if you get four or five people to do
- 1:05:43cash for keys and can be very powerful. Thank
- 1:05:47you, Sasha. It's nice to have somebody who does
- 1:05:49this all the time joining us. I only thank you
- 1:05:51for the financial perspective from the brokerage
- 1:05:55side of things and thank Thank you to everybody
- 1:05:57who attended this month's presentation from the
- 1:06:00real estate section. Have a great day everybody
- 1:06:03and enjoy the rest of summer.