Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Maximizing Arbitration Efficiency with Aaron Gothelf
Transcript
- 0:07Welcome to the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:09monthly ADR section meeting. As we know, ADR
- 0:13is one of the hot topics of interest in our profession,
- 0:16and deservedly so. And the title of today's presentation
- 0:19is Maximizing Arbitration Efficiency. I'm Robert
- 0:23Cohen, co -chair of the section, and I'm delighted
- 0:25to introduce today's guest speaker, Aaron Gotthelf.
- 0:29Aaron is the regional vice president of the American
- 0:33Arbitration Association's commercial division
- 0:35for California. He serves as the national chair
- 0:39of the AAA's entertainment practice. He is the
- 0:42ambassador for the AAA ICDR foundation and is
- 0:46a council member of the ABA's dispute resolution
- 0:49section where he formerly served as an educational
- 0:53programming officer. He is chair of the ABA's
- 0:57forum on the entertainment and sports industries
- 0:59and also with regards to the motion picture and
- 1:02television division. He is a member of the ADR
- 1:06committee for the litigation section of the California
- 1:09Lawyers Association and is rotating host for
- 1:13the ABA podcast series resolutions. So I must
- 1:17comment. I don't know where you get the time
- 1:19to do all this, Aaron, but we're thrilled to
- 1:21have you here and let's get started. Well, thank
- 1:24you very much, Bob. You make me sound a lot more
- 1:27impressive than I really am, but I'll take it.
- 1:30Okay, so folks, I'm going to share my screen
- 1:33so we can start the presentation. All right,
- 1:41Bob, does it look okay? Do you see the title
- 1:43slide there? Yeah, it looks great. It looks totally
- 1:46great. Fantastic. Well, welcome everybody to
- 1:49Maximizing Arbitration Efficiency. This is a
- 1:52program that I put together a few years ago,
- 1:55and I certainly update every couple of years
- 1:57based on my experience being at the AAA now,
- 2:00the last six and a half years and prior experience
- 2:03with other ADR providers, trying to restore the
- 2:09promise of arbitration, which is supposed to
- 2:11be a faster, more cost -effective way to resolve
- 2:14disputes than court. It's particularly important
- 2:17now to kind of follow some of those ideals as
- 2:20the costs of arbitration have significantly risen
- 2:24and it's not necessarily always the arbitrator's
- 2:27fault. Sometimes the parties are really going
- 2:29at each other and creating a lot of billable
- 2:32work but whether you're an arbitrator listening
- 2:36in today, or you're an advocate, I think there's
- 2:40takeaways that both groups can get to streamline
- 2:43their arbitrations and hopefully get them done
- 2:47a little quicker and certainly save some money.
- 2:50I will advance my next slide. Has arbitration
- 2:55become general litigation? Now, as we mentioned,
- 2:58arbitration is not supposed to be general litigation.
- 3:00This is supposed to be a faster, more cost -effective
- 3:02way to resolve disputes. And that's the goal.
- 3:05But we've seen over the last couple of years,
- 3:08at least with some cases at AAA, and this might...
- 3:11observation of cases in general that advocates
- 3:15are starting to bring in a lot of what they use
- 3:19in the courtroom into arbitrations and that's
- 3:22starting to slow down the process and make things
- 3:24more expensive. The single most expensive kind
- 3:30of longest period in a lot of arbitrations these
- 3:32days is actually the discovery period. It used
- 3:35to be the evidentiary period. evidentiary hearing
- 3:37period and that's because the amount of discovery
- 3:41these days being asked for in cases is pretty
- 3:45significant and mirrors kind of the amount of
- 3:47discovery that one would ask for typically in
- 3:50court. I always say and I speak from experience
- 3:56that a well -drafted arbitration clause is the
- 4:00basis for a cost -efficient cost -efficient,
- 4:06effective arbitration. For those of you, and
- 4:10maybe a tiny handful of you that actually still
- 4:12do transactional work and clause drafting or
- 4:15whatnot, these are things that you'd want to
- 4:17pay attention to. I always say a poorly drafted
- 4:21arbitration clause is like you're driving down
- 4:23the highway and you get a little pebble hits
- 4:26your windshield and there's a tiny crack. Well,
- 4:29it's not a very big deal. It's just a tiny crack.
- 4:31You don't have to worry about it for the time
- 4:33being, but over the Life course or the life cycle
- 4:36of a contract, that crack is going to get bigger
- 4:38and bigger and bigger, and when it finally comes
- 4:40to the point where there's a dispute, the windshield
- 4:42is going to fail, right? And so it becomes a
- 4:45bigger deal. Poorly drafted arbitration causes
- 4:48often result in a couple different things. So
- 4:50the first one is to failure to meet the party's
- 4:52expectations. Well, the reason people draft arbitration
- 4:55provisions into contracts in the first place,
- 4:57as opposed to just leaving it blank and heading
- 4:59to court for all their disputes, is a faster,
- 5:01more cost efficient way to resolve disputes.
- 5:03Well, if that's no longer the case, what's the
- 5:07point of having an arbitration provision? Some
- 5:09people might say confidentiality and there's
- 5:10a couple of other advantages to it, but really
- 5:12the reason people are doing this is to resolve
- 5:14disputes quickly and efficiently. Costs that
- 5:17spiral quickly out of control with the advantage
- 5:21going to the side that has more money spent on
- 5:22the process. So what I mean by that is Arbitration
- 5:26over the last couple of years has basically become
- 5:28weaponized, if you will, by the side that has
- 5:33more money, as we say, to spend on the process.
- 5:37And that was never the goal of arbitration. Arbitration
- 5:41is supposed to be a completely neutral, fair
- 5:45process to both sides. So what I mean by that
- 5:49is the side that has more money to spend on the
- 5:51process is going to start filing kind of silly
- 5:56motions that don't make sense, asking for exotic
- 6:00types of discovery like forcing the arbitrator
- 6:03to do a site visit, let's say a site visit isn't
- 6:06necessary, demanding the arbitrator sign hundreds
- 6:11of subpoenas to do hundreds of depots and crazy
- 6:15stuff like that, and for relatively sometimes
- 6:18small disputes. And the whole end game of all
- 6:21that is to force the other side into throwing
- 6:25their hands up saying, all right, I can't afford
- 6:27this process anymore. I give up. Let's settle.
- 6:31And you're forcing them into a less than desirable
- 6:33settlement agreement. When we evaluate arbitrators
- 6:38here at AAA and we evaluate them on a couple
- 6:40of different aspects, two areas that are commonly
- 6:45attacked are, do you feel that basically the
- 6:51amount that you paid for the arbitration, the
- 6:53number of hours that say the arbitrator billed,
- 6:56was proportional to the size of the dispute?
- 6:59And unfortunately, a lot of arbitrators who tend
- 7:01to let discovery and things like that get out
- 7:03of control score very poorly in that category.
- 7:06And another thing that we rate arbitrators on,
- 7:09when I say rate arbitrators, I mean we send surveys
- 7:11to the parties at the end of a completed arbitration,
- 7:14is do you feel that they effectively managed
- 7:16the case from appointment to conclusion? And
- 7:20sometimes when things are getting really expensive
- 7:22and drawn out, arbitrators score poorly in those
- 7:25categories. And oftentimes, you'll find this
- 7:28probably interesting. A lot of folks think, well,
- 7:33if I get slammed in an arbitrator survey, it's
- 7:35going to be coming from the side that lost the
- 7:37arbitration. And they're just sour grapes, right?
- 7:42Naturally, they're going to be biased. They lost
- 7:44their arbitration. They're going to slam me in
- 7:46some sort of review. These days, we actually
- 7:48get a lot of negative surveys back from the winning
- 7:51side or the side that got the settlement. So
- 7:56technically, if you got a settlement, I'm not
- 7:58saying that's the same as winning an arbitration,
- 8:00but if you got a number you're okay with, you
- 8:04should have nothing but glowing things to say
- 8:05about the arbitrator, but sometimes even those
- 8:07folks throw the arbitrator into the bus. Unnecessary
- 8:11court intervention. Now this is something that's
- 8:14not discussed a whole lot in arbitration programs,
- 8:17but let's talk about when the court steps in.
- 8:20So we talked about arbitration being a faster,
- 8:22more cost -effective way to resolve disputes.
- 8:24Another reason people choose arbitration is the
- 8:27whole confidentiality of the process. Faster,
- 8:31more cost -effective way at resolving a dispute
- 8:33and confidentiality both go completely out the
- 8:36window when the court has to step in. You see
- 8:40this, unfortunately, more than it should happen,
- 8:42especially in California. some aggrieved side
- 8:45at any stage in the arbitration process is going
- 8:48to file a TRO in court. They are going to sometimes,
- 8:52as defendants, name the arbitrator, sometimes
- 8:56name the arbitral institution. Heck, I've seen
- 8:58case managers named in these lawsuits, right?
- 9:02they're going to ask a judge to stop the whole
- 9:04process because something they don't agree with
- 9:07that the arbitrator or the institution is doing
- 9:09is going on. That's always a bad situation. And
- 9:13I noticed that there seems to be a higher percentage
- 9:17of these situations when an arbitration clause
- 9:20that is poorly drafted or ambiguous or has conflicting
- 9:24terms within it finds its way into a contract.
- 9:29Never ceases to amaze me. I'll look at a contract
- 9:32that could be 100 pages long, and the arbitration
- 9:36provision is one sentence buried somewhere on
- 9:40page 89, section 2e or something like that. You
- 9:46say to yourself, someone spent a ton of money
- 9:50and a ton of time drafting this very elaborate
- 9:52contract with all these contingencies and things
- 9:54like that, and they put a one -sentence arbitration
- 9:58provision in it. buried towards the back. It
- 10:01really makes you think, for those of you that
- 10:03draft arbitration clauses, why are we not drafting
- 10:06more stronger arbitration clauses, but clauses
- 10:10that really make things more clear? Because nobody
- 10:14wants to, when you're entering into a contract
- 10:16with somebody else, nobody expects the contract
- 10:19to be breached or something bad to happen, but
- 10:21we really have to be prepared for that possible
- 10:23eventuality. All right. The arbitral process
- 10:27itself being blamed for the unfortunate result
- 10:29not the poorly drafted arbitration clause. Again,
- 10:33when we get surveys back on arbitrators and arbitrators
- 10:38receive poor results, it might have had nothing
- 10:42to do with the arbitrator in the first place.
- 10:44It might have just been the arbitration clause
- 10:47was so poorly drafted that a number of bad things
- 10:50happened during the life cycle of the arbitration
- 10:52that wouldn't have happened had the arbitration
- 10:55clause been more clear on points. All right,
- 10:59drafting arbitration clause options. All right,
- 11:01so we have the arbitration rules to apply in
- 11:04the arbitrator selection process. So I just want
- 11:06to make this very clear. There are providers,
- 11:11whether it's AAA GMs or other providers, have
- 11:14tons of different sets of rules, right? So there's
- 11:17no such thing as the American Arbitration Association
- 11:20rules, right? We've got We've got commercial
- 11:23rules, we've got construction rules, we've got
- 11:25consumer rules, we've got all sorts of different
- 11:27rules. If you don't say the specific type of
- 11:30rule set that you want to use from the provider,
- 11:34that can cause a lot of problems when a case
- 11:37might kind of fall into... two sets of rules.
- 11:42And now an arbitrator has to make a decision,
- 11:45or the institution has to make a decision which
- 11:48track to put an arbitration in. And this is the
- 11:51first thing that people can fight about. Not
- 11:53too long ago, I had a case where it was technically
- 11:58a partnership dispute, which would fall under
- 12:01the AAA commercial rules. But the partnership
- 12:04dispute was over a partner being essentially
- 12:09wrongfully terminated from the company, which
- 12:14had a number of employment issues, the reasons
- 12:17why this person was terminated. And there was
- 12:19a big fight about whether this was going to proceed
- 12:21under the commercial rules or the... employment
- 12:24rules because the clause didn't say commercial
- 12:27or employment, and the results could have been
- 12:29very different depending on what sets of rules
- 12:31you go with. For example, with the employment
- 12:34rules, typically the employer pays for the costs
- 12:36of the arbitration. So in this case, the claimant
- 12:40didn't have a lot of money again to spend on
- 12:42the process, but if the respondent was paying
- 12:44for everything, maybe they might have had a different
- 12:46result. Who knows? Arbitrator qualifications.
- 12:50Now, I think it's always great to kind of put
- 12:52in some guidelines and what type of arbitrator
- 12:54you want to hear the case. So I mentioned that
- 12:57I am the entertainment chair for AAA's entertainment
- 13:03practice nationally here at AAA, just based by
- 13:06the fact that I'm a regional vice president located
- 13:08in California. So let's say we have a profit
- 13:14participation dispute or something like that.
- 13:18We have a case where you'd obviously want an
- 13:23arbitrator that's experienced in film and television
- 13:25profit participation disputes. So you might put
- 13:27into the arbitration clause must have a minimum
- 13:30of 10 years experience with profit participation
- 13:33disputes or something like that. I think this
- 13:36is really important for things that are more
- 13:38technical like engineering cases or some of our
- 13:42more complex intellectual property cases. you
- 13:46know there are people that are like that will
- 13:47always say um just you know put together a rank
- 13:50and strike list of folks available in my area.
- 13:53I'd like to see a combination of retired state
- 13:56and federal judges and attorney arbitrators and
- 13:57all that. And I'm less concerned necessarily
- 13:59about the technical experience or their background
- 14:01as far as the cases they hold. But that's pretty
- 14:04rare. And my warning against using somebody that
- 14:07already doesn't have some technical expertise
- 14:08and the dispute type is that's going to get really
- 14:12expensive really quick. When you have somebody
- 14:14that doesn't understand the subject matter, a
- 14:17lot of these arbitrators are oftentimes going
- 14:18to bill bill you the client for the time it takes
- 14:21for them to kind of learn the subject matter
- 14:24area, and they might ask for a lot of excessive
- 14:26extra briefing and things like that on things
- 14:28so they can learn as they go along. Single arbitrator
- 14:32or a panel of three arbitrators. All right, a
- 14:36three arbitrator panel is going to be four to
- 14:39five times more expensive than a single arbitrator
- 14:42panel. And you might say to yourself, well, Aaron
- 14:45wouldn't probably on average be like three times
- 14:48more expensive. And the answer is no, because
- 14:50typically the chair is going to have to bill
- 14:54a lot of additional hours just for the privilege
- 14:57of supervising the wings and the work that they
- 14:59do. So very expensive, very costly. I'm not a
- 15:05huge fan of three arbitrator panels for a lot
- 15:10of disputes unless we're talking about a tremendous
- 15:14amount of money and controversy. We're talking
- 15:17about tens of millions of dollars, or $100 million,
- 15:22or $1 billion. When you're dealing with numbers
- 15:23that big, sure, have a three arbitrator panel.
- 15:27It's a relatively minor cost compared to the
- 15:29size of the contract. But when I see a three
- 15:33arbitrator panel, over the course of an arbitration
- 15:36billing $600 ,000 or $700 ,000 in arbitrator
- 15:40deposits for a million dollar reward. And there
- 15:45isn't a cost shifting provision, meaning the
- 15:47party that wins the arbitration isn't entitled
- 15:49to recoup the costs of attorney's fees and arbitration
- 15:52costs and that kind of stuff. It really makes
- 15:54me scratch my head at whether this was a faster,
- 15:57more cost efficient process. All right. governing
- 16:01law, not only substantive law, but also the procedural
- 16:04law, the FAA or State Act. In California, we
- 16:07have the California Arbitration Act. So if you're
- 16:11dealing with contracts with parties in two different
- 16:14states, you're going to really want to be specific
- 16:16about this. If you're not specific about it and
- 16:19you have parties in two different states, they're
- 16:21going to have to spend excess money, extra money
- 16:25briefing the arbitrator on their positions, which
- 16:28state's laws govern. The losing side in that
- 16:31decision might not like that and they might run
- 16:32to court to try to get a judge to reverse the
- 16:35arbitrator's decision. Again, makes things very
- 16:38expensive. Locale of the arbitration. So the
- 16:42location of the evidentiary hearing is sometimes
- 16:43called the seat of the arbitration. This, again,
- 16:49should be one city, one state. If it's international,
- 16:54one city, one country, one city, one province,
- 16:57whatever, prefecture, I don't know which terms
- 16:59you want to use internationally. I do occasionally
- 17:03see this left out of arbitration provisions and
- 17:10it becomes a huge deal, right? Because typically
- 17:12the parties can't agree necessarily on the location.
- 17:15We have an internal committee at AAA called the
- 17:18Administrative Review Council that hears disputes
- 17:21like this, at least initially, requires the parties
- 17:24to submit briefing on their positions on both
- 17:26sides. And this is, again, extra expense for
- 17:29your clients paying you for the time preparing
- 17:32the briefing on these types of issues. And again,
- 17:35if the losing side in this decision doesn't like
- 17:37the decision that the AAA Administrative Review
- 17:39Council has come up with, they're going to file
- 17:41a lawsuit in court. That's just, again, going
- 17:44to make things more expensive and take more time.
- 17:48Confidentiality. Will the award be made public?
- 17:50Any issues like security disclosures? All right.
- 17:53Well, the general presumption is arbitration
- 17:55is supposed to be a confidential process, right?
- 17:59But there are always going to be situations where
- 18:01the law requires the results to be made public.
- 18:04So for example, we had a situation where large
- 18:09publicly traded company got a hundred million
- 18:13dollar reward, award written in their favor.
- 18:18That amount of money cannot simply come into
- 18:21a publicly traded company without some sort of
- 18:23SEC disclosure or disclosure to the shareholders,
- 18:27right? And so that became kind of a big issue,
- 18:29right? And an arbitration provision could have
- 18:31really spelled that out a little better. The
- 18:34discovery process. I've seen all sorts of exotic
- 18:37things written into Arbitration provisions on
- 18:40the discovery process, everything from limiting
- 18:43the number of depots that can be taken or outright
- 18:46prohibiting any depots from being taken or tying
- 18:50the amount of discovery into the amount in controversy.
- 18:53I think sometimes tying the amount of discovery
- 18:55allowed into the amount in controversy makes
- 18:57a lot of sense. Remedies, including emergency
- 19:00relief. Emergency arbitrations happen pretty
- 19:04rarely, but sometimes if there is a procedure
- 19:08added to the arbitration provision that explains
- 19:10what happens when a party needs a decision like
- 19:12right now and can't go through the whole typical
- 19:16life cycle of an arbitration, what should happen
- 19:18in those situations. Assessment of attorney's
- 19:21fees and other costs in a prevailing party is
- 19:22sometimes referred to as a cost -shifting provision.
- 19:25And you're going to really want to be specific
- 19:28here. We get this all the time. Arbitration provision
- 19:34says that parties are entitled to recover their
- 19:41costs. And the provision says attorney's fees.
- 19:50So what does the party do? The winning party
- 19:52submits an award application for attorney's fees.
- 19:57arbitration costs, basically everything from
- 20:00the deposits that were paid to the arbitrator
- 20:02to the costs of their hotel room to their meals
- 20:05to all sorts of things, right? Well, you should
- 20:09be specific here. Do you just mean attorney's
- 20:12fees are recoverable in a cough -shedding provision
- 20:14or do you mean the entire cost of the arbitration?
- 20:17If you're not clear, the arbitrator might not
- 20:20have the authority to award you everything that
- 20:22you're looking for if it doesn't say so in the
- 20:24arbitration provision. And then last, the type
- 20:27of arbitration award sought, standard reasoned,
- 20:30a simple award, etc. If it's a sizable case,
- 20:34it probably makes sense to have a reasoned award
- 20:36where everything is clearly spelled out. But
- 20:39for a small case, maybe a couple thousand dollars
- 20:43in controversy or something like that, doesn't
- 20:46make any sense for an arbitrator or arbitrators
- 20:48to draft a 20 or 30 page reasoned award. All
- 20:53right. If you're an advocate that still drafts
- 20:57arbitration provisions and you learn nothing
- 20:59else from my presentation today, pay attention
- 21:02to this slide. an unlimited number of things
- 21:07into an arbitration provision. Literally, you
- 21:09can put whatever you want, but at a very bare
- 21:11minimum, you have to have these five items. Why
- 21:14did I choose these five items? Well, these are
- 21:17the five items that are most commonly fought
- 21:18over, right? So the first one is the rules to
- 21:20be used. I don't care if it's jams or AAA or
- 21:23whoever it is that you're using. You need to
- 21:26be specific about the rules. So in this case,
- 21:29I wrote AAA commercial rules, because that's
- 21:31a specific rule set within AAA. And I work in
- 21:33the commercial division, right? So those are
- 21:35the rules I'm most familiar with. Location of
- 21:37the evidence hearing sometimes referred to the
- 21:39seat as the arbitration. Again, one city, one
- 21:42state. I see too many times. two different cities
- 21:46listed as options in two different states and
- 21:48no explanation as to who gets to choose which
- 21:53of those venues. Now there's a general presumption
- 21:56that the filing party gets to choose in that
- 21:59situation, but if that's not explained in the
- 22:01arbitration provision, that's something that
- 22:02people can fight over. Will the arbitration be
- 22:05heard by a single panel or a panel of three arbitrators?
- 22:08And I always want to say this, be specific. use
- 22:14the term single or panel of three arbitrators.
- 22:17Do not rely on the word arbitrator or arbitrators
- 22:21in the plural to convey this, because there have
- 22:23been courts that have ruled that the word arbitrator
- 22:28in the singular can refer to a single arbitrator
- 22:31or the actual panel itself. So you don't want
- 22:33to get into that mess. The states whose laws
- 22:36will govern the arbitration, especially important
- 22:38when you have people in two different states.
- 22:41So you want both contract law as well as procedural
- 22:44law. And then does the arbitrator have the authority
- 22:47to award attorney's fees and costs in the arbitration
- 22:49of the prevailing party? And what constitutes
- 22:51those costs? So you're going to want to be really
- 22:55specific and break down exactly everything a
- 22:58prevailing party is entitled to. If the entitled
- 23:01party, if it's your intention that the prevailing
- 23:04party is entitled to nothing, you should simply
- 23:07explain that in the provision that both sides
- 23:10are responsible for their own costs and that
- 23:13there is no cost shifting provision to the prevailing
- 23:15party. Just be specific about it. Okay. I'm not
- 23:21going to read this entire thing to you because
- 23:23when I do presentations, I don't like just to
- 23:25sit here and read. But this is a sample AAA commercial
- 23:30arbitration clause that I created with a service
- 23:34called ClauseBuilder .org, which is a website
- 23:37that you can go to and basically draft arbitration
- 23:41provisions that you can draft into contracts.
- 23:43We also at AAA have something called ClauseBuilder
- 23:45.ai that we're testing. I encourage you to play
- 23:51around with that as well. providers' rules you
- 23:57use should pretty much look the same. This is
- 24:01an example of a contract that has basically an
- 24:05arbitration provision that has all five things
- 24:06that I discussed within it. I was doing a presentation
- 24:10at the University of Washington School of Law,
- 24:16so I guess I left over the old arbitration provision
- 24:19here because it has a lot of stuff related to
- 24:20Washington in it, but just replace that with
- 24:22California. All right, selecting the right arbitrator.
- 24:29So the right arbitrator for your case is the
- 24:30arbitrator with the correct subject matter expertise.
- 24:33That's pretty straightforward right there. And
- 24:36we talked about this. The less subject matter
- 24:41expertise they have in a particular subject matter
- 24:43area, the more time they're going to have to
- 24:46spend learning the subject matter area and the
- 24:49greater chance that they don't understand it
- 24:51and they make a misapplication of law. Think
- 24:55beyond the rank and strike list. And if you have
- 24:57a good working relationship with opposing counsel,
- 24:59why not select the arbitrator together? This
- 25:00is something that's not discussed enough. And
- 25:02let's just talk about rank and strike lists for
- 25:04a second. I have a lot of arbitrators in my panel,
- 25:07especially arbitrators, let's say, that don't
- 25:09get a ton of arbitrations. And they simply think
- 25:12that if they get listed on more rank and strike
- 25:16lists, somehow that's going to lead to an increase
- 25:18in the number of cases that they get. And the
- 25:20truth is, there's actually no correlation between
- 25:22the number of rank and strike lists you're listed
- 25:24on and how many cases you might get in a given
- 25:26year. I can show you somebody who was listed
- 25:2810 times that got nine appointments out of that,
- 25:31and I can show you somebody that was listed 120
- 25:33times that got three appointments. There's no
- 25:36connection there. The truth is, for large complex
- 25:40cases, in my experience, more and more we are
- 25:43seeing parties decline the option to receive
- 25:46a rank and strike list. They are wanting to select
- 25:49the arbitrator on their own. And that can be
- 25:52anything from as simple as me providing an arbitrator
- 25:55search link and them kind of looking through
- 25:58all the arbitrators we have nationally and resumes
- 26:01and who might work well. Sometimes we have situations
- 26:04where it's a party appointed arbitrator situation
- 26:07and the parties already know who they want and
- 26:12then those two party appointed arbitrators select
- 26:13the chair and the party appointed arbitrators
- 26:16work together in the process, there's a lot of
- 26:18different ways you can go about it. But the best
- 26:21results are going to be if you do have a collegial
- 26:25relationship with opposing counsel to kind of
- 26:27sit down and say, hey, let's You've used arbitrators
- 26:32in the past. We've used arbitrators in the past.
- 26:34Kind of like, what have your experiences been
- 26:36with X, Y, and Z, and then just kind of working
- 26:39together on that. Utilize the ADR provider staff.
- 26:43Remember that case managers are experts in identifying
- 26:46the best arbitrators for your case. They spend
- 26:48a lot of time putting together arbitrator lists,
- 26:50so don't hesitate to be specific about what you're
- 26:52looking for. Just because a certain area of expertise
- 26:57might not be on an arbitrator's resume doesn't
- 26:59mean it doesn't exist, is what I always say.
- 27:01So if you have a resume of an arbitrator in front
- 27:04of you, and you say to yourself, huh, this person
- 27:08looks really good, but man, they're missing this
- 27:11one critical area of expertise that I think is
- 27:14relevant to our case. Before you strike that
- 27:18arbitrator or cast their resume away, it might
- 27:21make sense to reach out to the case manager and
- 27:23say, hey, can you talk to the arbitrator here
- 27:25and see if they have experience with this particular
- 27:28area. I'd be interested in possibly learning
- 27:32a little bit more about them and they're more
- 27:34than happy to reach out to the arbitrator and
- 27:36get a statement on that. And then one area which
- 27:40I don't think is used enough at all is at least
- 27:43at AAA and I'm sure other providers will do this
- 27:46for you as well. There is the option of jointly
- 27:50interviewing a potential arbitrator candidate
- 27:53before deciding to select them. These interviews
- 27:56are going to be conducted jointly with both sides
- 28:00on the call or the video conference, whatever
- 28:03it is, along with the case manager. Remember,
- 28:07these are not opportunities to argue your case
- 28:11to a potential arbitrator and kind of try to
- 28:14figure out which way they would go on stuff,
- 28:16this is more just an opportunity to ask them
- 28:19about their experience and their subject matter
- 28:22expertise within your particular type of dispute.
- 28:25Again, both parties or all parties, if it's more
- 28:29than just two parties to an arbitration, need
- 28:32to be on the interview call jointly to avoid
- 28:34any kind of Ex parte communication, so both sides
- 28:39can make sure that the other side's not somehow
- 28:43baiting the arbitrator or putting ideas in the
- 28:46arbitrator's head that would affect the arbitration.
- 28:50All right, what steps can the parties take before
- 28:53the preliminary hearing to promote efficiency?
- 28:54So for those of you that are not experts in arbitration
- 28:57or never done one before, the preliminary hearing
- 28:58is going to be the first time that the arbitrators
- 29:02actually Arbitrator or arbitrators interact with
- 29:07the parties. This is the meeting where we go
- 29:11over the discovery process. We pick evidentiary
- 29:15hearing dates. Everything that needs to go into
- 29:19the initial scheduling order is discussed. Some
- 29:23arbitrators are going to have a checklist that
- 29:26they're going to ask be sent to the parties in
- 29:29advance of the plenary hearing. They're going
- 29:31to require the parties to meet and confer. and
- 29:35kind of fill all the information on their little
- 29:37checklist. And if there are things that the parties
- 29:39can't agree to, then at the preliminary hearing,
- 29:42that's when the arbitrator is going to basically,
- 29:45I don't want to use the term rule on those disputes,
- 29:48but let's say even out those disputes. All right,
- 29:51length of final hearing in two or three mutually
- 29:53convenient sets of dates. Okay, so you typically
- 29:56don't necessarily know the arbitrator's availability.
- 30:01Prior to the polluter hearing, you can certainly
- 30:03ask their case manager just kind of for a general
- 30:05idea of that. But it's good to have a couple
- 30:07of sets of dates to match the arbitrator or arbitrator's
- 30:10schedule. It is extremely important to understand
- 30:15third party, not only say third party, but other
- 30:18people's availability outside of counsel and
- 30:20the arbitrator. So for example, in this case,
- 30:23witnesses, witness availability. If your clients
- 30:27are going to be part of the evidentiary hearing
- 30:29or want to attend the evidentiary hearing. You
- 30:31don't want to get their schedules all that kind
- 30:33of stuff. Confidentiality and protective order
- 30:36requests. I think the best practice on any of
- 30:38this is to have the protective order requests
- 30:40already kind of agreed to up front and just ready
- 30:44for the arbitrator's signature at the preliminary
- 30:47hearing. That's going to save a lot of time.
- 30:51Again, sometimes there are fights over protective
- 30:54orders and people can't agree to what should
- 30:57be in it. In that case, yes. Our trader needs
- 31:00to step in and make a decision on that. Cybersecurity
- 31:03issues and how electronic stored information
- 31:04will be transferred stored. Again, cybersecurity
- 31:07ESI information very important. There should
- 31:09be some protocol discussed in advance. You know,
- 31:13what file sharing service you're going to use
- 31:15and what the security settings are and all that
- 31:17kind of stuff. You should always have a discussion
- 31:20with the other side about clawback protection
- 31:23and what would happen if there was some sort
- 31:26of inadvertent disclosure and how that would
- 31:29be handled. The type of award you expect. So
- 31:32I use the example of a reasoned award, but you
- 31:35can also have simple award or concise finding
- 31:38of facts, all sorts of different types of awards.
- 31:42Again, for relatively smaller cases, might not
- 31:44require a reasoned award, but I would say for
- 31:46any dispute where the anticipated award is at
- 31:49least a million dollars or above, you probably
- 31:51want some form of reasoned award so you can kind
- 31:53of look through it. Again, I'm not ever suggesting
- 31:58a losing party an award if there's no basis to
- 32:04vacate an award. But let me just say this. If
- 32:07you want to vacate an award, or even if you're
- 32:10the winning side and you want that award enforced
- 32:12in court, it does tend to help to have that reasoned
- 32:16award available for the judge to review so they
- 32:18have some idea to how the arbitrator arbitrators
- 32:21came to that conclusion. All right. What states
- 32:27laws govern the choice of law provision that
- 32:28we discussed? Very important. Sometimes, if that
- 32:31is missing – and again, we don't have – we have
- 32:35parties in two different states – it's best to
- 32:37have the parties, before they get to the preliminary
- 32:39hearing, already have this argument between themselves
- 32:42as to which state's laws would apply both substantially
- 32:45and procedurally. You'd actually be surprised
- 32:49at how many times that can be worked out before
- 32:50it goes to an arbitrator. And then, are there
- 32:54any jurisdictional issues to proceeding in the
- 32:57arbitration? In the AAA rules, in most provider
- 33:02rules, the arbitrator has the authority to rule
- 33:04on their own jurisdiction. This has been backed
- 33:06by the courts. There was case law that supports
- 33:08this. If one side really feels that they're not
- 33:14a party to a contract, or let's say it's a situation
- 33:17where the respondent is almost more of a third
- 33:21party respondent, not a first party respondent,
- 33:24and that's always very controversial. It would
- 33:27be a good idea for the parties to kind of have
- 33:30a discussion about that going into the preliminary
- 33:32hearing, just so everybody knows. what's on board
- 33:36as far as next steps go. Sometimes, you know,
- 33:40if a respondent really feels they're not part
- 33:42of a party to an arbitration, they might say
- 33:45outright, like, listen, I'll play along with
- 33:47this process for a little while, but if the arbitrator
- 33:50doesn't let me out of this arbitration on some
- 33:53sort of disposin motion or something like that,
- 33:55I am going to go to court, file a TRO to stop
- 33:57this arbitration and get a judge to reevaluate
- 33:59the arbitrator's decision. Okay, other things
- 34:03to meet and confer on is the case proceeding
- 34:06under the correct rules. Again, we use this example
- 34:08when you don't say which type of provider specific
- 34:11rules within a provider set to use, there's going
- 34:13to be an argument about that. Can the scope of
- 34:17the arbitration be narrowed? You'd be surprised
- 34:19if you sit down with the other side, how many
- 34:22things you can actually narrow, and that's going
- 34:25to make your arbitration a whole lot more efficient
- 34:27and cost a whole lot less. Are there any issues
- 34:30that can be resolved prior to the preliminary
- 34:31hearing? Again, a lot of people file arbitrations
- 34:35with no intention of ever going to an evidentiary
- 34:37hearing. I've got to tell you, I don't case manage
- 34:41a lot of cases these days. The handful of cases
- 34:46that I do manage are all 7, 8, 9 figure cases.
- 34:55In my experience, at least cases that I've managed,
- 34:5780 % of those have never even gotten close to
- 34:59an evidentiary hearing, let alone an award. So
- 35:01a lot of things can be resolved relatively early
- 35:04in the process, including sometimes the entire
- 35:06case can be wrapped up prior to the preliminary
- 35:08hearing. And that way, you'll get some money
- 35:10back, usually. Has an early neutral evaluation
- 35:16session taken place? So an early neutral evaluation,
- 35:19or E &E, something I highly recommend. having
- 35:23an expert come in and kind of sit and give you
- 35:26both sides their opinion of the case and say
- 35:29listen you can spend all this money on the arbitration
- 35:31but in my experience I've seen exactly the dispute
- 35:33happen dozens of times and this is kind of what
- 35:35the value of the case is worth. Some people also
- 35:41do an early mediation. Early mediation is fine
- 35:45as well. What I would recommend with an early
- 35:47mediation is Do not do the mediation unless both
- 35:51sides have done at least some sort of limited
- 35:53discovery between each other because, in my experience,
- 35:56early mediations tend to fail when neither side
- 35:59actually knows the true value of their case.
- 36:02And you'll sometimes see in arbitration provisions
- 36:04that require a mediation as a step prior to even
- 36:07the filing of an arbitration being allowed. The
- 36:12times where that is successful are going to be
- 36:14when there's actually been some discovery that
- 36:16have taken place. All right. Will a counterclaim
- 36:19be filed? If I'm the claimant, that's going to
- 36:21be really important information for me to know.
- 36:24So you should just flat out ask the respondent.
- 36:26A lot of times respondents will be dodgy about
- 36:28that. They'll say, well, I don't know. I've got
- 36:29to talk to my client. Maybe we will. Maybe we
- 36:31won't. As you know, a lot of counterclaims are
- 36:34filed purely in a defensive mode. They might
- 36:37not actually even have any value behind it, but
- 36:39it's going to add money to the cost of the process,
- 36:42especially if you're going to try to knock out
- 36:44their counterclaim on some sort of type of deposit
- 36:47in motion. The next line right there, is the
- 36:50motion for summary disposition likely to be sought?
- 36:52That's important to know because that's going
- 36:54to be something that's going to be taken care
- 36:55of relatively early in the process, but it will
- 36:58also make the process longer so you might have
- 37:00to kick out your evidentiary hearing dates. Will
- 37:03there be subpoena requests and will those be
- 37:07challenged? I think it's important before even
- 37:10the preliminary hearing for you to sit down with
- 37:11the other side and talk about witnesses and who's
- 37:14getting subpoenaed and are we doing depots? Are
- 37:17we just doing this via interrogatory? All that
- 37:19kind of stuff. So you can have a concise list
- 37:23of bullet points during the preliminary hearing
- 37:24to say, hey, we sat down with the other side.
- 37:27We plan on doing this type of discovery and subpoenaing
- 37:31these people on this and that, and we talked
- 37:33to their side about this. We met and conferred,
- 37:35and they've said yes to the following people,
- 37:38and they've said no to the following people unless
- 37:40we'd like to discuss the folks that they said
- 37:42no to. Again, there might not be time to do all
- 37:45this in the preliminary hearing. There might
- 37:46have to be a second follow -up hearing specifically
- 37:50on subpoena requests that are being challenged,
- 37:52but it's important to have this discussion up
- 37:55front. Has a mediation be scheduled? If so, when?
- 38:00Again, I recommend early mediations if there's
- 38:02been some sort of type of limited discovery.
- 38:05Once you've had the preliminary hearing or at
- 38:08the time during the preliminary hearing, a good
- 38:10arbitrator will always set a mediation cutoff,
- 38:14a deadline for mediation to take place. Claims
- 38:21in excess of $100 ,000 we have in our rules,
- 38:23it was the commercial rules, construction rules,
- 38:26the requirement that the parties make a good
- 38:28faith attempt at holding a mediation prior to
- 38:30the evidence you're hearing to hopefully wrap
- 38:32up their case a little bit early, save them some
- 38:35money and whatnot. Unfortunately, either party
- 38:38can stipulate out of the requirement. I don't
- 38:42like that part of it. And sometimes it happens.
- 38:44Sometimes the party is saying, no, we don't think
- 38:47a mediation would be useful. The other side is
- 38:48being completely ridiculous. I don't want to
- 38:50waste my time. I don't want to waste my client's
- 38:52money on a mediation. When that mediation is
- 38:56being scheduled, you should pay particular attention
- 39:00to the cancellation periods for your arbitrator
- 39:03or arbitrators to make sure the mediation takes
- 39:06place enough time enough weeks or days ahead
- 39:12of that cancellation period and with a buffer
- 39:17between when the mediation is taking place and
- 39:20when you go into their cancellation period. There's
- 39:22nothing worse than the mediation is successful,
- 39:26but it took the parties a couple of weeks after
- 39:29the mediation to kind of reach a settlement.
- 39:33and you're too close to the date of the evidence
- 39:35you're hearing. So now the evidence you're hearing
- 39:37can come off calendar, but you still have to
- 39:39pay whatever cancellation fees are attached to
- 39:42whichever arbitrator. And for the arbitrators
- 39:45that are actually on this presentation today,
- 39:47especially the arbitrators starting out, this
- 39:49is why I recommend having a cancellation period
- 39:52as short as possible, like a seven -day cancellation
- 39:56period or a 14 -day cancellation period. If your
- 39:59cancellation period is 30 days, or 60 days or
- 40:0290 days, especially when you're starting out,
- 40:05you're not going to get selected for cases. amazing
- 40:09state or federal judge that's just coming off
- 40:11the bench that everybody loves. Maybe in that
- 40:13case you can get away with it. But an attorney
- 40:15arbitrator never in a million years because when
- 40:18it's coming down to selecting folks and I can
- 40:20tell you like this is one of the things that
- 40:22they look at because a lot of times parties are
- 40:25going to settle disputes right up until like
- 40:28as close to the evidentiary hearing as possible
- 40:30just because they're busy working other stuff
- 40:32and they're going back and forth. A lot of times
- 40:34they're using the evidentiary hearing as a threat.
- 40:36to force one side into a settlement. So this
- 40:38is just one thing to keep aware of. And then
- 40:43draft a proposed joint scheduling order if possible.
- 40:46So at AAA, and I'm pretty sure at JAMS and other
- 40:48providers, the case manager will send out in
- 40:52a PDF or an editable Word document just a blank
- 40:56general scheduling order with fill in the blank
- 40:58kind of sections and all that kind of stuff.
- 41:01If you can fill all that out or as much of that
- 41:03as possible prior to the preliminary hearing,
- 41:05get that off to the... Arbitrator or arbitrators,
- 41:08you're going to have a really fast, efficient,
- 41:10quick preliminary hearing. During the preliminary
- 41:14hearing, the first thing you want to do is discuss
- 41:17page limits on any briefing. If you don't have
- 41:20page limits on briefing, and we have parties
- 41:23that are submitting 50, 100, 200 page briefs
- 41:27and thousands of pages of exhibits, that's going
- 41:29to be very expensive. One way the arbitrator
- 41:32or the panel can cut down on costs is to have
- 41:36page limit some things. For those of you that
- 41:39are advocates, if your legal secretary keeps
- 41:42your calendar, they absolutely have to be on
- 41:44the call with you. There's nothing bigger than
- 41:46a waste of time where we go through this entire
- 41:48process and then we're discussing dates and the
- 41:51arbitrator says, okay, what dates do we want
- 41:53to do the seven -inch hearing? And the attorney
- 41:55goes, I have no idea when I'm available. My legal
- 41:57secretary keeps my calendar. That's a cop -out.
- 42:00That's an excuse. That's completely unacceptable.
- 42:03If you're going to throw your legal secretary
- 42:05under the bus, make sure they're on the call
- 42:06with you. If you want to get really exotic, awesome,
- 42:12and your clients are going to need to be available
- 42:14for the evidentiary hearing, you can also invite
- 42:16them to the preliminary hearing if you feel that
- 42:17that would be useful. Award uninviting clients
- 42:22and possible witnesses to – that might be possible
- 42:25witnesses to preliminary hearings or any type
- 42:28of meeting with the arbitrator or the panel of
- 42:30arbitrators. Do not invite clients that have
- 42:35a hard time not saying things during these calls
- 42:39that might get them in trouble or create some
- 42:43sort of bias in the mind of the arbitrator. Remember,
- 42:47the arbitrator is your judge. They will be making
- 42:50decisions. If you have a hothead client that
- 42:53likes to yell or say random things that could
- 42:57damage their case, just unannounced, then you
- 43:00don't want them any time on any of these calls
- 43:02with the arbitrator. Set the preliminary hearing
- 43:06within a reasonable time frame, even if dispositive
- 43:08motions are planned. Yes, I get this all the
- 43:10time. The respondent says, we can't discuss evidentiary
- 43:19hearing dates today because I plan on filing
- 43:22a dispositive motion. I'm pretty sure I'm going
- 43:24to win. That's fine. Just you can build that
- 43:27into the timeline. push the evidence of your
- 43:29hearing dates out, but in the off chance you
- 43:30don't win and get the case disposed of on your
- 43:32MSJ or whatever it is, you want to have all those
- 43:34hearings set so we don't have to have a second
- 43:36preliminary hearing all over again. Discovery
- 43:39should be tailored to the complexity of the issues,
- 43:42right? So it's typically much more limited arbitration
- 43:44than court. We all know that. Let's not have
- 43:467 ,000 depots being taken, a million pages of
- 43:48interrogatories, and all that kind of stuff really
- 43:50still be small things. All right. Nearing the
- 43:53scope of the hearing, I'm going to go a little
- 43:54quicker because I notice I'm taking a long time
- 43:56on these first slides. And you want to set a
- 43:59reasonable deadline for filing a dispositive
- 44:00motion. It's not always the threat of doing it,
- 44:02and then the dispositive motion filing ends up
- 44:05happening on the eve of the evidentiary hearing.
- 44:06That is absolutely ridiculous and unacceptable.
- 44:09Consider a joint stipulation of facts, what both
- 44:11sides agreed to, and then set hearing limits
- 44:13and a mediation cutoff earlier in the process,
- 44:15as we discussed. All right. save a lot of money
- 44:18here, the Streamline 3 Arbitrator Panel for large
- 44:20complex cases. My understanding is all providers
- 44:23offer this option, but certainly AAA does. All
- 44:26right, so the option one, essentially, you can
- 44:30have basically just simply appoint the chair,
- 44:34right? And the chair hears all discovery disputes
- 44:40and everything leading up to the evidentiary
- 44:41hearing. And then you can appoint the wing arbitrators
- 44:43later in the process. It's going to save a ton
- 44:46of money and a ton of time if you don't have
- 44:48three people reviewing and ruling on discovery
- 44:51issues. Other option would be to appoint all
- 44:55three folks up front. They all attend the preliminary
- 44:58hearing. But then either the chair or one of
- 45:00the wings is appointed to hear all the discovery
- 45:02disputes. And then we re -panel or unpanel. all
- 45:05three together if it actually goes to an evidentiary
- 45:07hearing. So the two things that are going to
- 45:09save a lot of time and a lot of money are either
- 45:11of these. All right. Video hearings in the time
- 45:15of COVID and beyond, just here's the thing. Video
- 45:18hearings are the way, since COVID are very common
- 45:21now, I would say... In my experience, the majority
- 45:26of the evidentiary hearings that I handle, even
- 45:29though COVID is over, are still being either
- 45:31handled entirely via a video conference, or at
- 45:34least the witnesses and folks outside of council
- 45:38and the arbitrators are hybrid, if you will,
- 45:41appearing via video hearing. COVID is over, so
- 45:44we're going to talk about regulations and things
- 45:46like that for being a thing and testing and masks
- 45:48and all that kind of stuff. If COVID ever comes
- 45:51back and you're deciding whether to do something
- 45:53in person or via video hearing, ask yourself
- 45:57a couple of questions. So for example, as an
- 45:59arbitrator, can I judge veracity if someone is
- 46:04testifying and their face is behind a COVID mask?
- 46:06It's kind of hard if you can't see facial expressions
- 46:08and things like that, right? So in that sense,
- 46:11you might just want to do the whole thing on
- 46:12video conference. Issues that should always be
- 46:15discussed. Is it going to be recorded? Is there
- 46:17going to be a core reporter? If you're simply
- 46:19just going to record the Zoom session, who's
- 46:20going to have access to that recording, right?
- 46:23Is it going to be video hearing or hybrid hearing?
- 46:26It's always important if you're doing things
- 46:29via video conference to have fail safe in case
- 46:31the video fails during the process. What happens
- 46:35if someone's video fails? Do we stop the entire
- 46:37arbitration at that point? Is there a backup
- 46:39conference line that people can dial into at
- 46:42that point? You should always provide hard copies
- 46:45of all the exhibits and all that for the arbitrator,
- 46:47the arbitrators, as well as opposing counsel
- 46:52so they can flip through things if for some reason
- 46:53there's some sort of failure there. And then
- 46:56of course, there's a lot of core reporting companies
- 46:59and depot companies that are now providing really
- 47:01fancy video hearing services. it should be discussed
- 47:04in advance who exactly is paying for that video
- 47:07hearing if it's not going to be split. Because
- 47:09it can get pretty expensive actually. All right,
- 47:12drafting effective pre -hearing filings and briefs.
- 47:14Again, you want to set the stage for your case.
- 47:16You want to begin with a succinct preliminary
- 47:18statement. You don't want to over -promise. You
- 47:22want to tailor it to what you're going to be
- 47:23presenting. And you should definitely learn from
- 47:25this positive motion rulings. If you lost a couple
- 47:28of these along the way, try to figure out why
- 47:31you lost them and try to see that as a positive
- 47:34as far as how you can help that with your case.
- 47:36Obviously, you want to provide e -links for any
- 47:38cases that are cited in your cases. That's going
- 47:40to be important. There's nothing worse than making
- 47:43your arbitrator at your expense, going back in
- 47:47and having to, you know, jeopardize or go to
- 47:50Westlaw or Lexis and relook up all these and
- 47:54consider in lemonade motions, right? Presenting
- 47:57witnesses and evidence again. considering a joint
- 47:59stipulation of undisputed facts, decide with
- 48:04your fact witnesses whether they're going to
- 48:06be offering direct testimony and either by live
- 48:10or sworn statements. Obviously, if you're going
- 48:13to make them come testify live, there's going
- 48:17to be an added expense for that. But on the other
- 48:19hand, it's really harder to kind of cross -examine
- 48:23if it's just going to all be done on sworn statements.
- 48:26Expert witnesses consider hot -tubbing. For those
- 48:28of you that don't know what hot -tubbing is,
- 48:30it's basically having all of the experts there
- 48:32together, so questions can be fired off at the
- 48:35mall as a group, as opposed to scheduling different
- 48:39experts for different days one at a time. That
- 48:42really adds a lot of extra days of evidentiary
- 48:44hearing and can get really expensive really quick.
- 48:47Using a witness's deposition for submitting double
- 48:50experts and impeachment. I mean, the depots are
- 48:53already done, right? So this is something that's
- 48:56going to add to efficiency. And then arbitrary
- 48:59questioning of witnesses. Some arbitrators will
- 49:02directly question witnesses, some arbitrators
- 49:05won't. Some judges in a bench trial might question
- 49:07a witness, some won't. It all depends on who
- 49:11you get. I know in court it's very rare for this
- 49:13to happen, but I would say with arbitrators it's
- 49:15kind of 50 -50 in my experience, whether they're
- 49:18comfortable directly questioning a witness or
- 49:20having a witness clarify something that they
- 49:23might not understand. Remember, arbitration is
- 49:25supposed to be less formal than court. Kind of
- 49:28don't go with always the same rules, right? Whether
- 49:32a hearing is remote or live, be sure all exhibits
- 49:34are legible and manageable for the arbitrator
- 49:36both and during the hearing. Obviously makes
- 49:38sense. Discuss whether you want to do joint or
- 49:41separate exhibits. Obviously, joint. Exhibits
- 49:44are going to be a lot faster for the process
- 49:46We don't have to have two separate exhibit books
- 49:48all that kind of stuff people flipping through
- 49:49books and this and that all just adds to time
- 49:52and then consider the wholesale admission of
- 49:54exhibits as opposed to Just individually one
- 49:57by one challenging things that have been put
- 49:59into evidence, which takes a lot of time and
- 50:01costs a lot of money All right Closing arguments
- 50:04and issues of interest costs and attorney's fees.
- 50:07Again, we talked about this in a well -drafted
- 50:10arbitration revision. You should really spell
- 50:13out upfront exactly what constitutes arbitration
- 50:16costs, what constitutes attorney's fees, are
- 50:19they entitled to both, et cetera, et cetera.
- 50:22You, it should be discussed as an instruction
- 50:25from the arbitrator exactly what they would want
- 50:28an attorney fee application to look like. So
- 50:31extra stuff isn't thrown in there, just adding
- 50:33to the costs of the process. Closing arguments,
- 50:37again, my recommendation for you is be succinct
- 50:41and direct. And obviously, this is not your opportunity
- 50:47to enter in things that weren't discussed prior
- 50:51at the evidence sharing, things that can't be
- 50:54necessarily cross -examined. This is not your
- 50:56time to bring up completely new legal theories
- 51:00and things like that. You'll have your opportunity
- 51:02in post -hering briefing to add some of that
- 51:05in because the other side can issue a response
- 51:07to anything that you write in your post -hering
- 51:08briefing. Essentially cross -examine what you
- 51:11just said in their own briefs. Post -hearing
- 51:15briefs, again, you want to focus on the strengths
- 51:17of your case. Just whatever you think that you
- 51:22did well in the evidence you were hearing. If
- 51:24there is something you forgot to bring up, again,
- 51:26you can add it into your post -hearing briefing
- 51:27because the other side is going to have a chance
- 51:29to respond to what you write. But I find making
- 51:34them succinct as succinct as possible. If you
- 51:39submit a 50 page you know, post -hearing briefing
- 51:42with hundreds of pages of exhibits and this and
- 51:45that, at a certain point the arbitrator's eyes
- 51:47are just going to glass over and they're going
- 51:50to start to lose track of exactly what you're
- 51:51talking about. So, sync this best. Attorney fee
- 51:55applications, as we said, the instructions should
- 51:58be given at the end of the evidentiary hearing.
- 52:02Please pay attention to what the arbitrator says,
- 52:05what they want to see in the application and
- 52:07what they don't. whether there's going to be
- 52:10an interim award issued or a final award. So
- 52:12in my experience again with most large complex
- 52:15cases where the winning side is entitled to some
- 52:20form of attorney's fees and or arbitration costs,
- 52:24an interim award is going to be issued. So we'll
- 52:27find out who wins and what they get and then
- 52:29at that point the arbitrator will ask for attorney
- 52:33fee applications and whatnot. And those will
- 52:36be submitted. The other side will have an opportunity
- 52:38to challenge those. And then the arbitrator will
- 52:41decide upon a number of what's going to be given
- 52:44to attorneys fees and costs and add that to the
- 52:46final award. And lastly, should the parties draft
- 52:50a model final award together after the interim
- 52:53award is issued? This is, again, something that
- 52:57only really works if both sides are getting along,
- 53:02because oftentimes the parties one party is pretty
- 53:06upset after they get the interim award, right,
- 53:09and they see that they've lost. But it'll save
- 53:12a lot of time and a lot of expense if the parties
- 53:16can agree to as many things that should kind
- 53:18of go in the final award as possible. I mean,
- 53:21I've had silly situations, everything from I
- 53:25had a party that wanted specific language that
- 53:32the award was to be paid to the attorney's trust
- 53:36account and not paid directly to their client,
- 53:38right? Probably because their client owed them
- 53:41some money or something like that, right? And
- 53:44you know, that became a big issue. right, between
- 53:46the two sides. And the other side was challenging
- 53:49it just to be difficult. Let's be honest there,
- 53:51right? So if things like that is the kind of
- 53:54thing that you would kind of add into an award,
- 53:57if you want in the final summary of the award
- 54:00not just the monetary issues discussed, but also
- 54:06equitable relief and things like that that are
- 54:09discussed elsewhere in the award to just make
- 54:11it clear for a judge that might have to read
- 54:13this down the line to enforce it or if it's going
- 54:16to be some sort of vacature motion. Let the like
- 54:19decide that with the other side right and let
- 54:21the panel know that first because it's very hard
- 54:25once the final award is issued to modify a final
- 54:28award. AAA it's a big elongated process right
- 54:31so you want to make sure that That interim award
- 54:36is as close to what you'd like to see as a final
- 54:39award as possible, right? So it goes in there.
- 54:43All right. If you guys have any questions, I've
- 54:46provided my email address here. Godelphi at ADR
- 54:49.org. I'm always happy to talk mediation, arbitration,
- 54:52any questions you might have. And I've left,
- 54:55looks like, five minutes here for questions.
- 55:00So let me stop my share here. Okie doke. And
- 55:07let me see here in the Q &A, we've got some questions
- 55:10here. All right. All right. So we have a question
- 55:18here. Is AAA desk arbitration actually being
- 55:21used? Why is it not allowed even in seven -figure
- 55:24larger cases if parties expressly agree? All
- 55:27right. So a desk arbitration which I believe
- 55:32would be referred to as a paper arbitration where
- 55:34there's not an actual evidentiary hearing. I'm
- 55:36not sure if that's what you mean by that, Jack,
- 55:39but different arbitrators allow different things,
- 55:42and that's just gonna be at the discretion of
- 55:45the arbitrator. We've done paper arbitrations
- 55:47at AAA for up to any amount in controversy, so
- 55:51I don't necessarily, that wouldn't be an accurate
- 55:55statement. Okay. We had a question of what a
- 56:07clawback provision is. A clawback provision is
- 56:10what happens when information that's presidential
- 56:13to one party is accidentally released and how
- 56:15that would be treated in the arbitration. That's
- 56:17what that is. All right, what are the reasons
- 56:22for specifying FA or the California Arbitration
- 56:24Act? Do either of those conflict with AAA or
- 56:26JAMS rules? All right, so within the AAA and
- 56:29the JAMS rules, there's always a rule that says
- 56:31if any of of the provider's rules conflict with
- 56:36state or federal rules. State or federal rules
- 56:38control the arbitration. All right. So that's
- 56:41basically our fail safe in those types of situations.
- 56:45You should specify FAA or California Arbitration
- 56:48Act just because they're different, right? And
- 56:51while they're drafted very similarly, there are
- 56:54advantages and disadvantages over each. I could
- 56:56do an entire presentation on what those advantages
- 56:58or disadvantages are. that's why you should be
- 57:03specific. And again, when you're dealing with
- 57:05parties from two different states, it's really
- 57:08important to specify that. How do you handle
- 57:15pre -arranged consent awards? So that's a good,
- 57:18great question. So first of all, let's talk about
- 57:20what a consent award is. At a certain point during
- 57:24the arbitration, usually right before the evidentiary
- 57:27hearing or sometimes even during the evidentiary
- 57:29hearing. You might be two days into an evidentiary
- 57:32hearing and the parties both put up their hands
- 57:34and they say, stop. We've worked out an arrangement
- 57:37with the other side to create a consent award.
- 57:40A consent award is where both parties essentially
- 57:43agree to the award, the award amount, how the
- 57:45awards get to be drafted and all that. You simply
- 57:48draft the consent award with the other side and
- 57:53present it to the arbitrator for signature and
- 57:56it's basically entered in as the award. It happens
- 57:58all the time. There are certain situations in
- 58:01a consent award where the parties might ask for
- 58:04the arbitrator to retain jurisdiction until whatever
- 58:08relief in the consent award has been provided.
- 58:12I don't always recommend that because We can't
- 58:16technically close our case file if you're asking
- 58:20the arbitrators to retain jurisdiction. And if
- 58:23we, for example, owe the money back to one side
- 58:27or the other, let's say there are unspent arbitrator
- 58:29deposits or whatnot, we can't return those arbitrator
- 58:32deposits until the parties both say, OK, the
- 58:35terms of the consent award have been completed.
- 58:37We no longer need the services of the arbitrator,
- 58:39which is why I'm not a big fan of that. Thank
- 58:47you, Andrew. I appreciate the comment. All right.
- 58:57How do you suggest the arbitrators handle the
- 59:00tension between following the party's lead on
- 59:02what discovery is necessary versus acting as
- 59:04the gatekeeper when it looks like the cost may
- 59:07not be in proportion to the amount of dispute?
- 59:11A lot of arbitrators, especially with the introduction
- 59:14of SB 940 and the changes to the Code of Civil
- 59:18Procedure and evidentiary rules, are very concerned
- 59:20about limiting discovery these days. if they
- 59:25limit discovery too much, the losing side or
- 59:28the side that's most upset about the process
- 59:29is going to run to court and get their award
- 59:32vacated or something like that because a certain
- 59:34amount of discovery wasn't let in. Again, this
- 59:36is me giving personal advice here. I'm not speaking
- 59:38on behalf of the AAA. I'm just speaking with
- 59:40what I've noticed. And it's too early to kind
- 59:44of see how SB 940 is affecting this. Courts are
- 59:49generally aligned with If a judge has the power
- 59:53to limit discovery, an arbitrator has the power
- 59:55to limit discovery. And I would always err on
- 59:59the side of limiting discovery more than letting
- 1:00:02in excessive discovery. And as an arbitrator,
- 1:00:05I think you should flat out call out the parties
- 1:00:08when they're doing something that is really simply
- 1:00:12just increasing the cost of the arbitration.
- 1:00:15It might not necessarily be I see arbitrators
- 1:00:20all the time deny discovery requests simply because
- 1:00:24they feel that it's excessive and it won't provide
- 1:00:28any additional information relative to the process.
- 1:00:31And once you say that to the parties, they'll
- 1:00:32usually back off on that position. Again, in
- 1:00:36my experience, award vacature happens because
- 1:00:39the arbitrator had some sort of... failure to
- 1:00:44disclose issue that wasn't disclosed in the initial
- 1:00:48disclosures and they failed to submit a supplemental
- 1:00:51disclosure necessarily where it came up. Almost
- 1:00:54never is an arbitration award vacated because
- 1:00:57a certain amount of discovery wasn't let in or
- 1:01:01misapplication of the law or the providers rules
- 1:01:04weren't followed to the T. that kind of stuff.
- 1:01:08So those types of situations are quite rare.
- 1:01:13Okay, we have one last question, I think, here.
- 1:01:22If the Zoom link wasn't given to one of the parties
- 1:01:25for the initial pre -hearing conference, how
- 1:01:27prejudicial is that to the evidentiary hearing,
- 1:01:29if the evidentiary hearing goes forward anyways?
- 1:01:32OK, so this really shouldn't happen, but occasionally
- 1:01:36we have situations where one side decides they
- 1:01:41don't want to participate in the arbitration
- 1:01:43provision. So let's say you're the claimant.
- 1:01:44You've served the respondent. The respondent
- 1:01:47never responds to any inquiries from the arbitrator,
- 1:01:51from the provider. We've tried to reach out to
- 1:01:53them a million times, whatnot. That doesn't stop
- 1:01:56an arbitration from going forward. It just means
- 1:01:58that we have a non -participating side. So a
- 1:02:01preliminary hearing will happen. It'll happen
- 1:02:02with the arbitrator. a member of the provider's
- 1:02:06staff and whichever party decides to participate,
- 1:02:10that's not considered ex parte communication
- 1:02:13or anything against the rules because any time
- 1:02:16a AAA staff member is part of a discussion or
- 1:02:18on the call, that breaks the ex parte communication
- 1:02:22situation. Is it prejudicial? Yeah, it probably
- 1:02:27is prejudicial on some level. But again, that's
- 1:02:29really the side of the non -participating side's
- 1:02:32fault. If you're talking about a situation where
- 1:02:35the arbitrator or the other side or the provider,
- 1:02:39like on purpose or something like that, didn't
- 1:02:42invite one side to participate in the preliminary
- 1:02:44hearing and didn't provide the link on purpose
- 1:02:46or something like that, that's a very serious
- 1:02:49situation. And I would say that's extremely prejudicial,
- 1:02:51and that should be raised with the provider.
- 1:02:58Okay, we had some questions here about repeated
- 1:03:10player bias and about how CCGV1284 .3 discusses
- 1:03:16that. With some of our consumer caseload especially,
- 1:03:23there's going to be situations where the same
- 1:03:26arbitrator has had the same claimant or the same
- 1:03:32respondent appear before them a couple of times.
- 1:03:34This is always disclosed upfront. The parties
- 1:03:37are given an opportunity to object to it at that
- 1:03:41point. You know, we do keep track of awards and
- 1:03:48we kind of look at how folks are ruling on things.
- 1:03:51And while we would never step in and change an
- 1:03:53arbitrator's decision or something like that,
- 1:03:55because that's not our place, if we notice internally
- 1:03:58that any type of bias or, you know, the arbitrator
- 1:04:02always rules a certain way for a certain client
- 1:04:04or law firm or party, that kind of stuff is brought
- 1:04:09up with the arbitrator to make sure there isn't
- 1:04:10an issue of bias internally. But I can't speak
- 1:04:12about specifically to the act how that would
- 1:04:16necessarily apply. Well, Aaron, I think you've
- 1:04:22given us a deep dive into maximizing arbitration
- 1:04:25efficiency. And obviously, we could go on for
- 1:04:27hours talking about this. And I've enjoyed it
- 1:04:31very much. I know our panel, I mean, our audience
- 1:04:33has too. We thank you for being here and providing
- 1:04:37such an incredibly in -depth overview. And I
- 1:04:42have many things to think about myself, and I'm
- 1:04:44sure everybody else does, too. Yeah, there's
- 1:04:46a lot of questions here. Just, yes, it's OK if
- 1:04:49you want to follow up with me. If you have questions,
- 1:04:52answer that. There was one. question here just
- 1:04:55really quickly. How does AAA deal with hybrid
- 1:04:58clauses where equitable relief is carved out
- 1:05:00for litigation and all monetary relief is set
- 1:05:03for arbitration and a plaintiff files suit on
- 1:05:05both and a defendant files a AAA demand that
- 1:05:10the plaintiff ignores? That's super specific
- 1:05:12right there. That would come down to a decision
- 1:05:16that the arbitrator is going to make. So that's
- 1:05:19how I would answer that. That's it. Thank you
- 1:05:26all for joining me. And again, for questions
- 1:05:29that I wasn't able to get to, you can shoot me
- 1:05:32an email. And I'd like to thank Bob for inviting
- 1:05:35me to be a speaker today. Everybody have a great
- 1:05:37rest of your day. See you. Thank you. Bye -bye.
- 1:05:40Bye. You may be eligible for CLE credit in your
- 1:05:43state. Visit bhba .org slash podcasts for more
- 1:05:47information.