Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Who Owns You When You Die A Deep Dive into Post-Mortem Publicity Rights
Transcript
- 0:03Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to today's
- 0:05program, Who Owns You When You Die, a deep dive
- 0:07into post -mortem publicity rights. My name is
- 0:10Teal Schoonover. I'm a co -chair of the BHBA's
- 0:12Trust in a State's Law section. Before we begin,
- 0:14I'd like to take a moment to introduce Nancy
- 0:16Sanborn and Brian Joy of the Sanborn team. Nancy
- 0:19and Brian have been the official sponsor of this
- 0:21section since 2006. Please say hello, Nancy and
- 0:24Brian. My goodness, every time you say that,
- 0:292006, that's a long time. Anyway, one of the
- 0:33issues that we're seeing more frequently is the
- 0:36sale of tenant -occupied properties. Many people
- 0:40still think tenant protection only applies to
- 0:42apartment buildings. But today, Single -family
- 0:45homes are also covered under California's tenant
- 0:48protection laws. One of the first conversations
- 0:51we have with the producer that we're working
- 0:53with is really about setting realistic expectations.
- 0:58Even if a lease has expired or the tenancy is
- 1:00month -to -month, the tenant has significant
- 1:02rights that could affect the sale. We've recently
- 1:06dealt with tenants refusing photos, limiting
- 1:09showings, delaying inspections and buyers expecting
- 1:12to have the property delivered vacant. These
- 1:15types of issues can impact pricing, marketing,
- 1:18and buyer interests and the escrow timeline.
- 1:21Our advice is simple. Identify tenant issues
- 1:25early, review the tenancy with counsel, and make
- 1:28sure that everyone understands the legal realities
- 1:31of the occupant before the property goes on the
- 1:34market. Setting expectations upfront helps avoid
- 1:38surprises and keeps the transaction on track.
- 1:41Have a great meeting. It sounds like a wonderful
- 1:43topic. Thank you so much, Nancy and Brian. In
- 1:48addition to the Sanborn team, the Trust and Estate
- 1:49section is also sponsored by Bond Services of
- 1:52California, Liberty Mutual Charity, California
- 1:54Title Company, and Pickford Escrow Company. Now
- 1:57I'd like to turn things over to Laura Zoldnikoff
- 1:59to provide this month's legal updates. Thank
- 2:03you, Teal. Hello, everyone, and thank you for
- 2:05joining us. Today I'd like to briefly discuss
- 2:08the tongue trust matter. It's a recent case out
- 2:11of the California Court of Appeal arising from
- 2:14a Los Angeles County Superior Court decision.
- 2:17This case concerns the application of California's
- 2:20anti -lap statutes. In this case, the settler's
- 2:23son, who was a name trust beneficiary but pre
- 2:26-deceased her, and left three children. The trust
- 2:29contained a standard provision stating that any
- 2:32beneficiary who failed to survive the settlor
- 2:34by 30 days would be deemed to have predeceased
- 2:37her. The trustee argued that this language caused
- 2:40the son's gift to lapse. The court of appeal
- 2:43disagreed, holding that a standard survivorship
- 2:46clause alone is not enough to show the clear
- 2:49intent required to override the anti -lapse statutes.
- 2:52Because the trust did not expressly condition
- 2:55the gift upon the survival or exclude the son's
- 2:58descendants, his children inherited. The key
- 3:01takeaway is that the boilerplate survivorship
- 3:04language does not defeat California's anti -lap
- 3:07statute. If a settler intends a gift to lapse,
- 3:10the trust must say so clearly and explicitly.
- 3:13Thank you so much, and I'll now turn it over
- 3:15to Jordan Parr. Thanks, Laura. I'm delighted
- 3:19to introduce today's speaker, Chong Che. Mr.
- 3:22Che is a partner at Withers in the private client
- 3:25and tax practice area where he advises celebrities,
- 3:28estates, and high net worth individuals on the
- 3:31planning and administration of their assets.
- 3:33His particular expertise includes counseling
- 3:36clients on the disposition and valuation of post
- 3:39-mortem publicity rights and handling the related
- 3:42tax implication. Work that has included advising
- 3:46estates in disputes with the IRS, notably around
- 3:49valuation questions. So please welcome Mr. Chong
- 3:53Che. Thank you very much, Jordan. It's a pleasure
- 4:00to be with the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 4:03once again. I was once a co -chair of the trust
- 4:07and estate section, so I know how much work Jordan
- 4:11and everyone else does for the Beverly Hills
- 4:14Bar. I'm always a little nervous about doing
- 4:21these webinars in part because I never know how
- 4:25much time to give for the laughter to die down.
- 4:28So I'll keep my humor and remarks to a minimum.
- 4:34I don't know if we'll have enough time to answer
- 4:38the questions in the chat, but if I don't get
- 4:41to your answers or your questions, then please
- 4:44feel free to contact me and I'm more than happy
- 4:48to share with you my knowledge. So I'm going
- 4:55to share, I have a slideshow presentation. So.
- 5:02My firm and I just, along with my partners at
- 5:08my old firm, joined Withers early last year.
- 5:12But over the last couple of decades that I've
- 5:16been with the firm, we've had a pretty good practice
- 5:20with respect to entertainment clients. And so
- 5:22the right of publicity, which is better known
- 5:24as name, image, and likeness, has always been
- 5:28an issue. And so I wanted to talk about this.
- 5:32One of the things that's changed over the past
- 5:35years is that the entertainment industry has
- 5:39changed quite a bit, not just in the movie and
- 5:42television industry where streaming services
- 5:45like Amazon and Netflix has gained a much more
- 5:48prominent role, but you see it in music, where
- 5:51you've got all these different... you know, organizations
- 5:57that stream music. And, you know, and the way
- 6:01that celebrities monetize their name, image and
- 6:05likeness has changed over the years as well.
- 6:07And that's what we call this right of publicity.
- 6:10And so one of the ways that I illustrate this
- 6:14is, let's see. is that you can sort of see it.
- 6:20This may be a couple of years ago, but you can
- 6:23see how social media has impacted the way that
- 6:27people sort of advertise and also in terms of
- 6:31how they monetize their name and likeness. You
- 6:35know, you have a couple of examples of like Kylie
- 6:37Jenner who, I guess, you know, brought about
- 6:43a billion dollar business with their own advertising
- 6:46in essence. And then you have superstar athletes
- 6:49like LeBron James who have significantly monetized
- 6:53over the superstar athletes in the past. And
- 6:58I will talk a little bit about NIL and what that
- 7:04does for the college athletics. But you can also
- 7:08see, based on some of these figures, how college
- 7:12athletes have been able to monetize their name
- 7:15and likeness. It's a little different, and I'll
- 7:18explain that later. But I think it's changed
- 7:21the landscape of college athletics, both in terms
- 7:24of how these athletes can stay in college longer
- 7:29because of the way that they're gaining their
- 7:32wealth, but also in terms of how recruiting and
- 7:35Everything else is handled in that manner. So
- 7:41as an introduction, right of publicity, again,
- 7:44is the right to control the commercial use of
- 7:46name, likeness, and image. And there's a famous
- 7:49Tops chewing gum case, which dealt with baseball
- 7:53cards. And in that case, Judge Jerome Frank said,
- 7:57the right of publicity recognizes independent
- 8:00right to protect economic interests from unauthorized
- 8:03commercial appropriation. And so. Right of publicity
- 8:10really started out in terms of with right of
- 8:14privacy. And it's evolved from that and right
- 8:18of privacy is a personal and emotional interest.
- 8:21Whereas right of publicity is a property right.
- 8:24And you can see how this property right really
- 8:27manifests itself because of the way that damages
- 8:30in right of publicity cases are determined. They're
- 8:33determined in part by fair market value of celebrities
- 8:36identity. profits of the person infringing on
- 8:42that right and the damage to the celebrity's
- 8:44licensing opportunities. In many states, these
- 8:49rights are transferable and descendable, which
- 8:52means that you can have it passed on to your
- 8:55heirs or beneficiaries. On the other hand, right
- 8:58of privacy essentially dies with the death of
- 9:01the celebrity. So I did this a number a couple
- 9:06years ago. So I hope that these numbers still
- 9:09are reflective of today, but Approximately 36
- 9:14states recognize the right of publicity But only
- 9:1825 of those states recognize a post -mortem right
- 9:22of publicity means that it continues upon the
- 9:26death of the celebrity and notable states that
- 9:30have this include, California Florida, Illinois,
- 9:35New York, and the like. One of the things, because
- 9:49right of publicity is basically regulated by
- 9:52the states, there's variances in state rights.
- 9:56On the one hand, you have a state like Utah,
- 9:59which actually has a condition to be able to
- 10:03basically have this descendable right of publicity.
- 10:06So Utah requires the celebrity to have commercially
- 10:09exploited the right during his or her lifetime
- 10:12in order for that to be descendable. You can
- 10:16see also how states vary in terms of what rights
- 10:20they actually protect. So in California as an
- 10:24example, under our civil code section 3344 .1,
- 10:29it says beneficiary's heirs have the right to
- 10:32control the exploitation of deceased personalities,
- 10:34name, voice, signature, photograph, or likeness.
- 10:38New York, and New York, by the way, only enacted
- 10:42their statute, I believe, in 2020 to be effective.
- 10:45in 2021, and under New York Civil Rights Section
- 10:4951, the rights are limited to the personality's
- 10:52name, portrait, picture, or voice. Indiana's
- 10:57statute, which is actually very similar to California's,
- 11:01but they've extended their rights to include
- 11:03distinctive appearance, mannerisms, and gestures.
- 11:07So when you have a personality like David Letterman,
- 11:10who famously is from the state of Indiana, you
- 11:13know, he may to be able to protect his mannerisms
- 11:16and gestures. So the other thing that varies
- 11:20from state to state is the duration of the enforcement.
- 11:25So it can be like Washington, it can be as short
- 11:29as 10 years, but Washington bifurcates its duration.
- 11:34So Washington has a 10 year statute after the
- 11:38death of the individual, if there was no commercial
- 11:40value, and they extend it to 75 years if there
- 11:44was commercial value. So basically, you know,
- 11:47if they had exploited during their lifetime.
- 11:49And in New York, it's 40 years, Indiana and Oklahoma
- 11:53was a couple of the longer. durations, which
- 11:56is 100 years. Tennessee has this unique situation
- 12:00where it can be enforced indefinitely so long
- 12:03as the state continually exploits the celebrities'
- 12:07attributes. In California, it's 70 years. But
- 12:10remember, California, you can reach back to celebrities
- 12:14who died on or after January 1, 1915. And this
- 12:18was in response to Marilyn Monroe case, although
- 12:21Marilyn Monroe, I believe, was a resident or
- 12:24domiciled in New York at the time. So in Illinois,
- 12:28it's 50 years, but it applies only for celebrities
- 12:32who died after the enactment So the other variance
- 12:39with states is what is the requirement to be
- 12:43able to exercise these rights? In California,
- 12:47it requires the deceased celebrity to have been
- 12:50a California resident. New York requires the
- 12:55person to have been domiciled in California.
- 12:58In essence, it's their permanent primary residence.
- 13:02Indiana, again, Indiana is kind of unique in
- 13:05many of these respects. And they require only
- 13:07that the act or event occurred within Indiana,
- 13:11regardless of the celebrity's domicile, residence,
- 13:14or citizenship. There is a caveat, though, unless
- 13:18the celebrity died in testate without any surviving
- 13:22heirs. Washington has a broad statute. And I'll
- 13:28explain this. And Hawaii and Nevada have similar
- 13:31sort of broad statutes, which doesn't require
- 13:33necessarily the residency or being domiciled.
- 13:38But Washington's statute was challenged in a
- 13:41recent case involving Jimi Hendrix and his company,
- 13:45or a company that was dealing with Jimi Hendrix's
- 13:48experience. And there... uh it was uh you know
- 13:53the the party uh i forget which party but the
- 13:56party challenged the washington statute as being
- 14:00overly broad and unconstitutional. The lower
- 14:06court upheld that because in essence, what they
- 14:09were trying to do is they were trying to get
- 14:12a situation because Jimi Hendrix, I believe,
- 14:15was a New York resident at the time of his passing.
- 14:18They were trying to be able to invoke Washington
- 14:21statue to be able to, in essence, be able to
- 14:26protect the attributes without having a nexus
- 14:30to Washington. And so we'll see what happens
- 14:33with this statute. But, you know, with Washington,
- 14:36Hawaii, Nevada, you know, those you may not be
- 14:40able to use those unless you have, you know,
- 14:44that residency or domicile requirement. Satisfied,
- 14:51that is. There is a restatement dealing with
- 14:56unfair competition. I won't read that. So how
- 15:00do you protect these rights? So when you're dealing
- 15:04with the celebrities or the like in terms of
- 15:07how do you plan for these rights to be able to
- 15:10utilize them? One of the issues is that oftentimes
- 15:14these celebrities will have a business manager,
- 15:18they'll have an entertainment lawyer, they'll
- 15:19have an agent that handles all of these issues.
- 15:23And more than likely, they want those same individuals
- 15:27to be able to continue exploit the name and likeness
- 15:30even after they're passing. And so if you're
- 15:33in that situation and you're trying to be able
- 15:37to provide for that, then oftentimes we'll have
- 15:39a name and likeness trust that holds all of these
- 15:43IP interests. And we might name the business
- 15:47manager or the entertainment lawyer, whoever
- 15:49it is, to be able to be the trustee of that trust,
- 15:53to be able to continue to exploit the name and
- 15:56likeness, and to be able to advantage the beneficiaries
- 16:00in a sort of trust -like parameters. So one thing
- 16:08that you should note is that if there isn't a
- 16:11specific provision in the trust or will, then
- 16:14the name and likeness rights essentially pass
- 16:16to the residuary provisions of the will or trust.
- 16:19If it's an intestate situation where they didn't
- 16:22have a will or trust, then the rights pass to
- 16:24the statutory heirs. One of the big issues that
- 16:30comes about with name and likeness is its value.
- 16:33So, valuation of these publicity rights. So,
- 16:38the key provision or the key thing to understand
- 16:42is that the name and likeness is to be valued
- 16:45at the moment of death with knowledge of death,
- 16:49but without regard to post -death events. So,
- 16:52you know, you see it in many situations. You
- 16:55know, you see it in artists where the moment
- 16:57they pass away, there's a bump up in their value
- 17:00because they can't, you know, they can't draw
- 17:02anymore. or they can't do the art anymore. And
- 17:06the same thing with other celebrities. But it's
- 17:10without regard to post -death events. And this
- 17:13will be key in terms of the Michael Jackson matter
- 17:16or the Michael Jackson case that I'll talk about
- 17:19in a little bit. In most situations, you know,
- 17:24most celebrities have fairly nominal value because,
- 17:28you know, one, you know, they won't be making
- 17:30public appearances after they pass away and they
- 17:33won't be making the films, the TV shows, the
- 17:36recordings, all those things. Now in this age
- 17:39of, you know, AI, things might be a little different
- 17:43and I'll talk a little bit more about that later.
- 17:47But so that's the most cases and you could sort
- 17:50of see it, you know, in terms of how people exploit
- 17:53their name and likeness. They may not, even if
- 17:55they're famous, they may not be doing commercials
- 17:58or anything like that. And so there are certain
- 18:01exceptions, obviously. Elizabeth Taylor with
- 18:08her product, Elizabeth Arden, is such an example
- 18:12where there's certainly value in that. And one
- 18:17of the things in terms of valuing of these publicity
- 18:20rights is you do need a qualified appraiser.
- 18:24They do a discounted cash flow model basically,
- 18:27in essence sort of a graph that shows that initially
- 18:30there is that huge bump up, but then And over
- 18:33time, it decreases. So let's turn our attention
- 18:41to the case of Michael Jackson. And just for
- 18:47full disclosure, my partner Paul Hoffman represented
- 18:51the executors of the estate of Michael Jackson.
- 18:54So he was obviously very involved in the entire
- 18:57case. I wasn't involved really at all. And I
- 19:03didn't really consult him in terms of my take.
- 19:05So these are purely my observations in terms
- 19:08of what I know about the case. So Michael died
- 19:12on June 25th, 2009. The estate tax return was
- 19:16filed on September 23, 2010. The audit in essence
- 19:21ran from 2011 to 2013 and the petition was filed
- 19:27in 2013. There was appeals through 2015 and the
- 19:32trial ran most of 2017. You can see how long
- 19:35this case was taking. The decision didn't come
- 19:40about until four years later. There is still
- 19:44some unresolved matters with some of the figures
- 19:47and the judge has yet to deal with that. So what
- 19:54are the issues before the tax court? Most of
- 19:59the issues, just so you understand, were resolved
- 20:02in audit or at appeals. So there were essentially
- 20:07four issues that were before the tax court in
- 20:12this case. The biggest one was name and likeness.
- 20:18You know, this is where I know there's a whole
- 20:21bunch of news media and people sort of joke about
- 20:24how Michael Jordan, I mean, Michael Jackson's
- 20:27name and likeness was initially valued at $2
- 20:30,000. And I'll explain why that was the case.
- 20:33And there's a legitimate and reasonable explanation
- 20:37for that. The IRS on the other hand, thought
- 20:41that Michael's name and likeness was actually
- 20:45worth nearly half a billion dollars. The IRS
- 20:49lowered their value to about 161 on its brief
- 20:54and the estate raised its value to about three
- 20:58million on its brief. And the tax court decision
- 21:02came in essence in favor of the estate at about
- 21:06$4 million. There was a valuation of Sony ATV,
- 21:14which in essence was Michael's holding of some
- 21:18of the Beatles catalog. You can see the figures
- 21:23on the PowerPoint there. My Jack music, which
- 21:27is Michael's own music, also was at issue, but
- 21:33those weren't as big of an issue as the name
- 21:36and likeness. One of the important decisions
- 21:40that certainly affected our firm was that the
- 21:43court, the IRS was trying to obtain penalties
- 21:47in terms of undervaluation reporting and everything
- 21:52like that. But the tax court held that there
- 21:55were no penalties since valuations were reasonable.
- 22:03So what are the factors in the tax court's decision?
- 22:07So let me start out explaining why Michael's
- 22:12name and likeness was initially valued at $2
- 22:15,000. So there's something, and I don't know
- 22:19if it's done anymore, but there used to be something
- 22:22called Q scores. And in essence, the Q scores
- 22:27measured how well -known the celebrity was. and
- 22:32it also measured how favorable or negative that
- 22:36celebrity's reputation was to the general public.
- 22:41And so Michael obviously over the years of his
- 22:45career had a pretty favorable Q score, but towards
- 22:49the end of his life, he actually had negative
- 22:52Q scores. And in fact, it was so bad, and obviously
- 22:56that was due to all the allegations of child
- 23:00molestation and everything like that. And then,
- 23:03so he actually had negative Q scores for a number
- 23:06of years prior to his passing. And it was so
- 23:10bad. that the industry didn't even ask for his
- 23:14Q scores to be recorded two years prior to his
- 23:17passing. So the IRS expert, and I'll talk about
- 23:24him in a little bit, a little more, considered.
- 23:28what he called these foreseeable opportunities,
- 23:33because he was sort of projecting, you know,
- 23:36what are the things that's going to happen with
- 23:38the Jackson estate, you know, post his passing.
- 23:41And he listed things like theme parks and restaurants,
- 23:46a Broadway musical. Now there was a Cirque du
- 23:51Soleil, there was a movie and everything that
- 23:54did occur, but Tax court, in essence, rejected
- 23:59the IRS expert as analysis, as a fantasy. That
- 24:12not only did he value the wrong asset, meaning
- 24:16that he valued sort of combined some of the other
- 24:21IP interests like copyrights and other things,
- 24:24and didn't just isolate the name and likeness.
- 24:27He also took into account unforeseeable events
- 24:31and overstated the asset's value. So the other
- 24:36thing that was interesting in terms of the tax
- 24:39court's decision was this asset value versus
- 24:42management. And what the court said was, you
- 24:46have to separate out the publicity rights, actual
- 24:50value versus effective management. So one of
- 24:54the executors was an entertainment lawyer or
- 24:57is an entertainment lawyer by the name John Branca.
- 25:01And he had represented Michael during his life.
- 25:04and was named one of the executors. And he was
- 25:07very instrumental in being able to exploit Michael's
- 25:11name and likeness through, you know, the Cirque
- 25:13du Soleil, the movie, excuse me, and a bunch
- 25:17of other things. And so, you know, and this was,
- 25:22I think, a very key analysis by the tax court
- 25:27judge, Judge Holmes, who said that, you know,
- 25:34We can't always assume that everyone's name and
- 25:38likeness is going to be exploited the same way.
- 25:40If you have an effective manager of that name
- 25:43and likeness, then there's additional value that
- 25:46has to be set aside to the effective management
- 25:50as opposed to the actual name and likeness. And
- 25:53so that's what the judge was doing. Although
- 25:56it's a difficult task, but he understood that
- 25:59not everyone can exploit it in the same way.
- 26:01The other thing that came about in terms of another
- 26:05factor is this synergy or bundling of rights.
- 26:09And what I mean by that is Michael at the time
- 26:12of his passing not only owned his copyrights,
- 26:16and he might've owned his masters and recordings
- 26:19and everything, but he also owned his name and
- 26:22likeness. And so there was an argument by the
- 26:26IRS expert that because the estate in essence
- 26:30had everything that there would be a premium
- 26:34added to any exploitation because you didn't
- 26:37have to go to separate people, one party who
- 26:41owned the copyrights, one party who owned the
- 26:43masters, one party who owned the name and like
- 26:45this, you could go to the same party to do everything,
- 26:49like that Cirque du Soleil, which involved music,
- 26:52some images and other things. But the tax court
- 26:56didn't didn't buy into it exactly and the key
- 27:02was that the tax court judge didn't add additional
- 27:05value to that right because it was held by a
- 27:12single entity. So this IRS expert, his name is
- 27:18Wes Anson. I remember Paul telling me that there
- 27:23was a sort of a Perry Mason moment, sort of gotcha,
- 27:28and where Mr. Anson actually perjured himself
- 27:32on the stand. And one of the things, there was
- 27:37a quote from the tax court judge who said, as
- 27:42the commissioner's only expert witness, And since
- 27:44credibility was an especially important part
- 27:47of the case and it suffered greatly at trial.
- 27:51And, you know, there was no really reason for
- 27:55him to lie about this. I think he was trying
- 27:57to lie to say that he wasn't really doing a whole
- 28:00bunch of work for the IRS and therefore he was
- 28:03an unbiased appraiser. But, you know, I think
- 28:06everyone knows that there's appraisers that appraise
- 28:09on both sides and it wouldn't have undermined
- 28:12his credibility aside from the fact that he didn't
- 28:14have to lie. So the conclusion, you know, and
- 28:21I like to quote this part from the tax court
- 28:25judge, but in essence, I think what he's trying
- 28:28to say is that, you know, celebrities come and
- 28:30go. And even though you might remember them fondly
- 28:34at one time, you know, their memory does fade
- 28:37as new generations come. And so that's sort of
- 28:40the conclusion of name and likeness and how its
- 28:43value sort of diminishes over time. And these
- 28:48were other factors that I sort of mentioned before.
- 28:55So again, in talking about planning with name
- 28:59and likeness, what are the things that you can
- 29:01do? And so one of the things I did mention is
- 29:05that the value of it sort of decreases over time.
- 29:09So if you could stretch out what the taxable
- 29:12value is over time, then the better you are in
- 29:15terms of minimizing its value. So if you do have
- 29:19a surviving spouse, you could possibly have it
- 29:23pass to a marital trust, which means that obviously
- 29:26it's going to be, you know, subject to the marital
- 29:29deduction. So there's no tax on first passing,
- 29:32meaning the passing of the celebrity's death,
- 29:35but that it could be, you know, years after,
- 29:39you know, when the surviving spouse passes away,
- 29:43which has a way to be able to minimize the value
- 29:46of the name and likeness. And obviously, you're
- 29:48going to have years of exploitation numbers to
- 29:52be able to back that up. you can leave it to
- 29:54a charitable foundation. Again, you know, with
- 29:58the charitable deduction, which would, you know,
- 30:01zero out the value of the name and likeness.
- 30:04There's a famous case in terms of Robin Williams,
- 30:08the comedian. who famously left his name and
- 30:13likeness to a foundation with the restriction
- 30:18that there can be no exploitation of his name
- 30:21and likeness for 25 years. The tricky thing about
- 30:25this situation is, you know, what do you value
- 30:29on the estate tax return in terms of name and
- 30:32likeness? And what kind of charitable deduction
- 30:35are you sort of getting for the gift to the charity?
- 30:41And so if they don't match, then you're going
- 30:44to have an estate tax problem. And so the key
- 30:47here is that hopefully they will match, meaning
- 30:50that you'll be able to value the name and likeness
- 30:54with this restriction. And that's, in essence,
- 30:57what the charity got. It's kind of an analogy
- 31:01of somebody who has a million dollar Ferrari
- 31:07and says, I'm going to be buried in this Ferrari.
- 31:12And so how do you value the Ferrari? Do you value
- 31:14it as its normal Ferrari value, or do you value
- 31:18it as an expensive coffin? So you do have to
- 31:22make sure that the values sort of align in order
- 31:26so you don't have an estate tax problem. and
- 31:30my partner, Paul, give him credit for this because
- 31:33he did this in another situation. Basically,
- 31:36you just fix the portion of the taxable gift.
- 31:40Let's say you want $50 million to go to the only
- 31:45child, and then you leave everything else to
- 31:48the foundation. It fixes the estate tax value
- 31:53at that $50 million mark, and therefore, you
- 31:56can value the name and likeness in different
- 32:00ways. And if there's no requirement that the
- 32:04child received $50 million in cash, then you
- 32:08could ultimately distribute other assets with
- 32:10the value that you've indicated on the estate
- 32:13tax return without worrying about necessarily,
- 32:17without worrying about increasing the estate
- 32:20tax payable. Because we've dealt with celebrities
- 32:32over the years many, many times, we've dealt
- 32:36with a lot of IRS audits involving these celebrities'
- 32:40estates. you know, it's really interesting how
- 32:45the IRS sort of processes these things. Now,
- 32:48again, I think this is what occurred a couple
- 32:52years ago, and I'm not sure how this is being
- 32:55impacted by the fact that there's less and less
- 32:57people working at the IRS now, but there are
- 33:02valuation issues that you may have to deal with
- 33:04when you're... when you're dealing with a state
- 33:08tax audit with the IRS. In the Michael Jackson
- 33:13case, the auditor was focused in on post -death
- 33:17earnings. Obviously, Michael was making nothing
- 33:21basically prior to his passing. In fact, he was
- 33:25having a hard time just trying to sell his name
- 33:28and likeness and doing any endorsements or anything
- 33:31like that. prior to pay is passing again, that's
- 33:34why it was valued at $2 ,000 that is passing.
- 33:39But in another situation, and it was interesting
- 33:43enough, we were dealing with the same auditor
- 33:45as the initial auditor on the Michael Jackson
- 33:48case. But in that case, they were focused in
- 33:51on pre -death earnings, basically saying, oh,
- 33:55there was performance royalties, and it was so
- 34:00exorbitant that certainly the name and likeness
- 34:03was very high. And so it's interesting what with
- 34:07the IRS, obviously IRS is gonna focus on what's
- 34:11more favorable to their situation, but there
- 34:14is an inconsistency in terms of whether they're
- 34:17going to be looking at the actual values of the
- 34:20exploitation pre -death or whether they're just
- 34:22gonna wanna see what's happened post -death.
- 34:26And there's two aspects of the IRS audits in
- 34:31terms of where this has become sort of a slippery
- 34:35argument. So even in situations where you may
- 34:41have a celebrity who didn't exploit their name
- 34:45and likeness, at all during his or her lifetime,
- 34:49the IRS may make other arguments. One, they might
- 34:53say, well, it wasn't because they couldn't exploit
- 34:56the name and likeness. it's only that they chose
- 35:00not to. And that's a difficult argument because
- 35:03where do you get the value? Where do you get
- 35:05the numbers if there was really no exploitation
- 35:09prior to passing? So that's a difficult one.
- 35:13And then the other thing is what I said about
- 35:17in terms of one of the factors in terms of effective
- 35:20management of the name and likeness. How do you
- 35:24deal with that? If the IRS comes and says, well,
- 35:27you're Your exploitation figures for name and
- 35:30likeness is very small because you didn't have
- 35:33an effective manager who could have exploited
- 35:35in a much greater capacity. That's a difficult
- 35:40argument to refute because it's really speculative.
- 35:44How do you argue for something that didn't occur
- 35:49and it's hard to speculate what that value might
- 35:54be? Just to talk a little bit about the reach
- 36:02of name and likeness cases, I wanted to highlight
- 36:07three very interesting cases that occurred in
- 36:14the past. One was the Michael Jordan versus Juul
- 36:18food stores case. I think it was like 2009, Michael
- 36:25Jordan was being inducted to the Basketball Hall
- 36:29of Fame. As most people might know, Michael Jordan
- 36:33was from, I mean, he grew up in North Carolina,
- 36:36but he actually played for the Chicago Bulls
- 36:40and was in Chicago for a long time. I don't know
- 36:45if they were Chicago -based grocery store, but
- 36:48they were in Chicago. And they had taken out
- 36:51an ad in Sports Illustrated basically congratulating
- 36:55Michael. And they didn't even use his name. All
- 36:58they did, I believe, was a print ad that showed
- 37:02Michael sort of... similar shoes as the Jordan
- 37:06brand shoes with the number 23 and just said,
- 37:12congratulate another Chicagoan on his Hall of
- 37:19Fame induction. And Michael Jordan and his advisor
- 37:25sued and was able to get a settlement. But it
- 37:29shows that even if you don't actually use the
- 37:32name, you don't Have something it's enough to
- 37:37be able to indicate that there was a infringement
- 37:40on his name and likeness rights. There's another
- 37:43case called Vanna White versus Samsung Electronics
- 37:46America. And Samsung did sort of look to the
- 37:51future of what the future might look like. And
- 37:54so what they did was they dressed up a robot
- 37:57with a blonde wig turning, you know, letters
- 38:01on the wall, kind of like the Wheel of Fortune
- 38:03type guessing. And Vanna White sued Samsung for
- 38:10this, saying that that also infringed upon her
- 38:13name and likeness, and she was victorious in
- 38:16that suit. And then the last one is this case
- 38:20called Carson versus Here's Johnny portable toilets.
- 38:25you know, obviously there can be a lot of statements
- 38:27about this, but basically it was a company called
- 38:31Here's Johnny Portable Toilets and Johnny Carson,
- 38:35I don't remember if it was him or his estate,
- 38:38sued them for basically, you know, that's the
- 38:41signature sort of introduction for Johnny Carson,
- 38:45who was an old time late night host. And, you
- 38:50know, the court decided that it was an infringement
- 38:54because of the public association of the phrase,
- 38:58here's Johnny. So I think all of these cases
- 39:02show that, you know, it's not always the situation
- 39:07where it's a clear infringement, but even the
- 39:11ones that sort of look like it can be used to
- 39:16infringe upon a celebrity's name and likeness,
- 39:19you know, that would be deemed an infringement
- 39:22of their rights. So, I wanted to shift gears
- 39:27and talk about college NIL. full disclosure,
- 39:32I don't do too much. I don't have too many clients
- 39:36and other cases involving college NIL. But I
- 39:40think it's interesting how the institutions have
- 39:45approached this situation with college athletics.
- 39:49In 2021, the Supreme Court ruled that the NCAA
- 39:52rules limiting education -related compensation
- 39:55violated the Antitrust Act. you know, go went
- 40:00on further. And there was a famous case of a
- 40:05UCLA basketball player, Ed O 'Bannon, who I famously
- 40:10I think sued NCAA because I think his sort of
- 40:16image or his number on a jersey and player was
- 40:20on one of the old time NCAA basketball game,
- 40:24video games, and was able to be victorious in
- 40:30that. And so I think that also led to all of
- 40:35this legislation. So currently, I think 39 states
- 40:40have passed or proposed or plan to propose NIL
- 40:45legislations. And I think it was a stated that
- 40:49where states didn't enact the NIL rules, the
- 40:54schools were left to their own devices to enact
- 40:57their own rules. California law, this SB 206,
- 41:09has a blueprint for how a lot of this legislation
- 41:12works. So what the legislation says is that colleges
- 41:16can't prevent student athletes from playing sports
- 41:19or revoke the scholarships for earning NIL compensation.
- 41:23Athletic conferences and NCAA can't prevent the
- 41:26athlete from earning NIL compensation or punish
- 41:29the schools with such athletes as they've done
- 41:32in the past. Colleges can't provide prospective
- 41:35athletes with NIL compensation or getting an
- 41:38agent. And athletes can enter into NIL contracts
- 41:42that conflicts with the school team's contract.
- 41:47So there's two disallowances by the NCAA. One,
- 41:51they can't pay the athlete for the performance.
- 41:54You know, you can't say, well, you have to score
- 41:56a certain amount to get the money. And there's
- 41:59no quid pro quo for attending certain school.
- 42:03That part, I don't know if it really works on
- 42:07a practical basis because clearly the boosters
- 42:11who have these contracts, they definitely recruit
- 42:18these athletes and sort of entice them to come
- 42:21to their school. So how do the athletes make
- 42:24the money? They appear in ad campaigns or sell
- 42:27ads on social networks. They sell merchandise,
- 42:30including signed memorabilia. They start their
- 42:34own business or sports camps. They make paid
- 42:37appearances, deliver speeches or sign autographs.
- 42:40Now, one thing you can't do is you can't have
- 42:43clips. of sports games, you know, because that's
- 42:46something separate. And then there's something
- 42:49called NIL Collective, and that's a company that
- 42:53collects the money, you know, more than likely
- 42:56from the boosters and directs them to the athletes.
- 43:01There's one last thing. I guess I may have some
- 43:04time to look at the chat, but there's One other
- 43:08thing I wanted to talk about is in terms of trademarks
- 43:12and where things are going in today's modern
- 43:18world with AI, this artificial intelligence.
- 43:23It's sort of scary in terms of what's happening
- 43:28because I think somebody had told me once that
- 43:33they only need you to say like a sentence or
- 43:35something like that. And AI can basically generate
- 43:39an entire conversation using your voice. And
- 43:43obviously we all know that there's images that
- 43:47are created by AI of celebrities and other people.
- 43:51And it's interesting to know like how that's
- 43:55gonna affect, you know, name and likeness rights
- 43:58and... what celebrities will do in the future.
- 44:02And so there are some celebrities of our clients
- 44:05who are undertaking trademarks, which is slightly
- 44:10different. And I think... You know, the main
- 44:14difference is that NIL protects, again, the individual's
- 44:18personal identity from unauthorized commercial
- 44:21use, whereas a trademark is supposed to protect
- 44:25consumers from confusion about the source of
- 44:27goods and services. And so there are now celebrities
- 44:32who are trademarking their name, image, likeness,
- 44:38their voice. their statements, you know, if they
- 44:42have sort of catchphrases or other things. And
- 44:46it'll be interesting to see if that becomes more
- 44:50and more common phenomenon and how that's going
- 44:54to affect, you know, how name and likeness is
- 44:59utilized and protected in the future. I'm not
- 45:02sure exactly, you know, how prevalent it is,
- 45:07but that is That is, it does appear that that
- 45:12is where we're going. So I did have some, sorry,
- 45:22let me unshare this. I was trying to see if there's
- 45:41any questions. Yes, Chuck, it looks like we do
- 45:49have two questions within the Q &A. OK. One of
- 45:53them from Daryl Thompson asking, recording artists,
- 45:56in essence, Taylor Swift, Backstreet Boys, Lionel
- 45:59Richie, et cetera, are trademarking their voice
- 46:02to protect this right in the age of AI. Can you
- 46:04discuss the potential benefit? So I think what
- 46:11trademarks will protect is it protects the brand
- 46:15names, the logos, slogans and trade identifiers.
- 46:22different, you know, obviously, whereas name,
- 46:26image and likeness is sort of automatic, although
- 46:29people should understand that in California,
- 46:33you do register name and likeness for and, you
- 46:38know, when you're handling estates, you should
- 46:40register the name and likeness for the estate.
- 46:44But But trademarks, they require registration
- 46:50with the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
- 46:55So I think it does take a little bit more. but
- 47:00I'm not sure exactly how that'll differ in terms
- 47:07of the protection, but I think it's just an additional
- 47:10mechanism and it may be more easily enforceable
- 47:18because of the specific protection that it provides.
- 47:27Great. I did have a follow -up question from
- 47:29a different person asking about post -death.
- 47:35I'm guessing celebrities post -death in the context
- 47:37of that. Okay, let's see. I have another question
- 47:44here. My understanding is that the creative use
- 47:46of name image -like -ness of a celebrity can't
- 47:49be restricted by a celebrity if living or an
- 47:52estate if the celebrity is deceased. Examples
- 47:55would be biographical films such as the Marilyn
- 47:58Monroe or Taylor Swift using the name image -like
- 48:01-ness on a product such as a cereal box or a
- 48:03t -shirt is illegal. Is this correct? I'm not
- 48:09sure exactly the parameters of that. I'm not
- 48:13sure if, again, while the person is living, it's
- 48:20a right of privacy that is being protected upon
- 48:25their passing. I guess there is a right of publicity,
- 48:31sorry. But I'm not sure. I'm not sure the extent
- 48:36of that question. what it's asking specifically.
- 48:45All right, let's see. Here's one. If you could
- 48:50add one provision to every estate plan for a
- 48:53client with commercially valuable name and like,
- 48:56name and likeness rights, what would it be? So
- 48:59I think I mentioned a couple things. One is just
- 49:04in terms of management. Oftentimes, if you have
- 49:08a celebrity that has IP rights, then we will
- 49:14have a specific IP trust in order to have a singular
- 49:19management of it and exploitation and to be able
- 49:23to benefit numerous parties. I think the other
- 49:26thing that you really have to talk about is,
- 49:29and I sort of mentioned this also, is valuation.
- 49:32Is valuation sufficiently of an issue where you're
- 49:38going to you're going to want to try to avoid
- 49:44the valuation issues. And like I said, if there's
- 49:48a surviving spouse and you're fine with the surviving
- 49:51spouse receiving the benefits of the exploitation
- 49:54of the name and likeness, then certainly you
- 49:57can use a marital trust if you have a foundation
- 49:59or some charitable trust that you'd like to be
- 50:02able to donate the name and likeness to. post
- 50:07-passing, that can also reduce any sort of valuation
- 50:12issues. So I think that's the sort of conversation
- 50:16that you'll have to have in terms of dealing
- 50:22with celebrities and what they would like to
- 50:25see out of the name and likeness. Great. Let's
- 50:38see, it's Ralph Lemmer -Randy in context of the
- 50:43creative use question about the t -shirt. It's
- 50:47saying, I was referring to the Ginger Rogers
- 50:49suit where she sued for portraying her in a Fellini
- 50:52film she lost at the Supreme Court on a right
- 50:54of publicity claim. Yeah, that I'm not as familiar
- 51:00with, so sorry about that. Let's see. Should
- 51:13college athletes with meaningful NIL income be
- 51:16considered trusts or other asset protection structures
- 51:19much earlier than traditional clients? Should
- 51:22they be considering? So one of the things that
- 51:26I am not as familiar with is how far the NIL
- 51:32contracts extend post the college athletes careers.
- 51:40So, you know, my general understanding is a lot
- 51:45of those contracts are limited to their time
- 51:48in college. And so, you know... It's hard to
- 51:54determine whether that's the best way of planning
- 51:59for the name and likeness, or whether it's the
- 52:04NIL collectives or other agreements that they
- 52:07might have directly with the boosters that will
- 52:13determine the extent of their name and likeness
- 52:17rights. post -college, those things carry out.
- 52:24And I think, you know, if they are an athlete
- 52:27that has their own endorsements post -college,
- 52:31then I think they ought to be thinking about
- 52:33the same sort of issues that we normally deal
- 52:36with celebrities. So. All right. Let's see. I
- 52:44have another one. Can a brand use name and image
- 52:46likeness without a license from the estate post
- 52:48death? Can you repeat that question? Can a brand
- 52:53use? Can a brand use NIL without license from
- 52:58the estate post death? I don't think so. I mean,
- 53:02again, so this is an interesting question, because
- 53:06I think if you're dealing with a state that has
- 53:10a descendable right of publicity, then I think
- 53:14you're sort of limited to what that estate will
- 53:20allow in terms of exploitation of the name and
- 53:23likeness. There's an interesting case in terms
- 53:26of the other famous musician that passed away
- 53:30recently, Prince, who passed away in Minnesota.
- 53:35It was interesting because I don't believe Minnesota
- 53:39has a statutory right where the right of publicity
- 53:44is descendable. I think they might have a they
- 53:49might have a common law, right? And it's interesting
- 53:55because I was talking with one of the attorneys
- 53:57from that estate and it was interesting because
- 54:02they could have taken the approach that there
- 54:05was no descendable right of publicity and they
- 54:09could have valued the estate's, the name and
- 54:13likeness value for Prince at zero. But instead,
- 54:17I think they chose to deal with it as a common
- 54:23law right. And they did end up settling with
- 54:26the IRS. I want to say they settled for somewhere
- 54:29between one and two million in terms of its value.
- 54:33But those are the types of things that I think
- 54:37practitioners will have to determine depending
- 54:40on what state you are, your celebrity is part
- 54:44of and whether. you can utilize that to your
- 54:49advantage. But then again, maybe the estate would
- 54:52have liked to view it as having the ability to
- 54:57determine its exploitation post death. And that's
- 55:01where what I was saying about. Washington and
- 55:05Hawaii and Nevada, if those broad statutes can
- 55:10be utilized for people who didn't have any nexus
- 55:13to those states, then that would give additional
- 55:17enforceability. But we'll see what happens with
- 55:21that Jimi Hendrix case if there's going to be
- 55:25further fallout from that. I have another attendee
- 55:32asking if you could go a little bit deeper or
- 55:34explain the Lanham Act. Explain what? The Lanham
- 55:40Act. That I'm not as familiar with that. Okay.
- 55:48Let's see what else we have here in our help
- 55:50desk. For clients who have connections to multiple
- 55:57states, how much planning can realistically be
- 56:01done to optimize which state's publicity rights
- 56:04statute applies? Are they asking it? I guess
- 56:11you don't know because that's the question. I'm
- 56:14not sure. if the question is, can you sort of
- 56:18pre -plan these issues in terms of residency
- 56:22or otherwise, if that's the question. Certainly,
- 56:30I think when we have celebrity clients, we certainly
- 56:34talk to them about these issues. And one of the
- 56:37things is that you know, before New York enacted
- 56:42their statute, we'd have clients who were bi
- 56:45-costal, and we would certainly let them know
- 56:48that New York did not have a descendable right
- 56:51of publicity prior to 2020. And therefore, that
- 56:55was, you know, they can do with it whatever they
- 56:58wanted, you know, in terms of whether they wanted
- 57:01to change their residence to California and to
- 57:04be able to take advantage of the California statute
- 57:07or otherwise. I don't know if that's the question
- 57:11being asked here. Have you observed an increase
- 57:22in cease and desist letters involving social
- 57:24media influencers rather than traditional celebrities?
- 57:29I haven't. I don't represent too many influencers,
- 57:34but yeah. Unfortunately, I don't have too much
- 57:38experience in that regard. All right, and let's
- 57:47see. All right, looks like we have just one last
- 57:53question here. In practice, are most right of
- 57:56publicity disputes resolved through litigation,
- 57:58settlement, or licensing negotiations? I guess
- 58:04I'm not sure if this is a question regarding
- 58:08two civil parties or if it's involving the IRS.
- 58:14from the context because I don't really deal
- 58:16with the sort of private parties issues. But
- 58:20from the IRS perspective, I think the IRS, it
- 58:26depends. It's interesting because you don't know
- 58:32what sort of auditor you might get. You know,
- 58:35we had a famous musician who, one of the auditors,
- 58:40I think the auditor was a fan, and so was wondering,
- 58:43you know, why guitar picks weren't included in
- 58:47the valuations as if each guitar pick had some
- 58:50sort of significant monetary value. But, you
- 58:54know, those are the types of issues that you
- 58:56may get in terms of auditors. And so, you know,
- 59:00maybe the auditor knows about the celebrity or
- 59:03maybe maybe does those types of things. And so
- 59:07it's interesting how far this extends. We had
- 59:12another famous music client who asked, does that
- 59:16mean that I can't throw out pots and pans? Because
- 59:20there's some intrinsic value to those just because
- 59:23I cooked my eggs on it or something like that.
- 59:26But I don't know if that's the normal case. you
- 59:31know, what valuations we undertake oftentimes
- 59:35is with the sort of celebrity memorabilia and
- 59:41those types of things. But, you know, we're not
- 59:44going to be sitting there valuing every sock
- 59:46in the sock drawer and stuff like that, so. If
- 59:56anybody has any more questions, you know, feel
- 59:58free to contact me. So I'm sorry I couldn't answer
- 1:00:02everyone's questions. Well, thank you so much,
- 1:00:06Chong. That concludes today's program. Thank
- 1:00:10you again for an excellent presentation. Our
- 1:00:13next program takes place on August 18th with
- 1:00:16Mr. Robert Barton, and we hope to see you all
- 1:00:19there. And thank you for joining us this afternoon.
- 1:00:23Thank you.