Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 08/27/26 EPISODE 019: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN - 2026 STAR HILL FARMS + COMPARISON TO 2025 RELEASE
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: Welcome back, everybody, for another episode on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. Got my buddy Giancarlo in the room. How you doing, sir? Again. Good, good. ⁓ and you know, I thought I got I just picked this bottle up recently. ⁓ and I thought what what a great opportunity to give our thoughts on the latest release, the 2026 release of Star Hill Farms. this is the second year it's come out, and so wanted to ⁓ dive into that and give a little history on on Star Hill Farms. What is it? ⁓ for those that aren't are unaware, it's a Maker's Mark brand. And ⁓ and it's the first time in over 70 years that Maker's Mark released something other than their basic recipe that they use. Nice. Which is crazy. I like where this is going. So, what is Star Hill Farms exactly? So ⁓ Starhill Farm is a is ⁓ the historic eleven hundred acre estate in Loreto K Kentucky ⁓ that serves as the home of Makers Mark Distillery. ⁓ and for 70 years it has only used the mashville 70% corn, 16% soft red winter wheat, 14% malted barley, ⁓ to ensure cons absolute consistency for their bourbon. ⁓ so last year, 2025 ⁓ The launch of Star Hill Farms Whiskey series represents ⁓ or last year when they launched it, it represented the first time in the distilleries entire history that they completely altered their grain recipe. Instead of ⁓ instead of a bourbon, they created an ultra premium American wheat whiskey, ⁓ by completely dropping corn from the mash bill, which is wild. I think there's a lot of wheat whiskeys on the market that still have corn in the in the recipe. ⁓ but this one has no corn. ⁓ furthermore, this series serves as a liquid showcase of the distilleries' push into regenerative agriculture, utilizing grains grown locally via sustainable no till farming methods, and it's the first globally recognized whiskey to carry the official estate whiskey certification from the Estate Whiskey Alliance. Don't know a lot about that. It sounds important. yeah, so I So unlike the stand under like the standard consistent releases, the Star Hill Farm line changes radically every year, which I didn't know last year. ⁓ and so we've got here both editions 2025 release and the just released 2026 release. So 2025, the inaugural were ⁓ inaugural release, ⁓ the concept for that was to set out and isolate. ⁓ and elevate the signature grain of maker's Mark Bourbon, which is the soft red winter wheat, without masking it with any of the sweetness of corn. ⁓ last year it released at a hundred and fourteen point seven proof cask strength, non-chill filtered. And the mash bill ⁓ was a precise blend of two distinct whiskey recipes, one consisting of 70% soft red winter wheat and 30% malted barley, married with a second batch made with 100% malted soft red winter wheat. ⁓ and then it was aged for roughly seven to eight years, released in 2025, to a lot of fanfare, and and it eventually won World's Best Wheat Whiskey at the World Whiskey Awards. ⁓ the profile ⁓ the profile is known for being incredibly rich, heavy-hitting, and slightly dark, featuring domin dominant notes of dark raspberry, chocolate-covered cherries, gingerbread, and an assertive dry oak finish. So this year. 2026 release. And I didn't realize they were going to switch up the mash bills on us, but they did. And so instead of copying the first iteration, ⁓ Master Distiller Blake Layfield and Robert Samuels pivoted to explore how different varietals of wheat change the spirit. They moved away from just soft red winter wheat and layered in hard red and hard white wheat wheat grains. ⁓ the proof went up a little bit. It's now at 116.4 instead of the 114.7. It's at cask strength. And the mash bill, heavily altered from the previous year, composed of 62% malted wheat, 27% unmalted wheat, 11% malted barley, ⁓ alongside a s a small selection of experimental test barrels. ⁓ so the profile on this one, the addition of the hard White and heirloom red wheats completely transformed the whisking make whiskey, making it a tale of two cities compared to the twenty twenty five bottle. It traded the dark berry and heavy oak astringency for a much more vibrant, bright, mellow profile. The twenty twenty-six release lint leans heavily f into fresh strawberries, honeyed apricot, peach marmalade, vanilla custard, and soft cinnamon spice. ⁓ so while the 2025 edition relies on dark fruit and deep barrel char for an immediate heavy punch. The 2026 edition uses grain diversity to create a softer, more complex, and lively wheat whiskey. Both bottles ⁓ have established the Star Hill Farm label as a premier testing ground for American grain innovation. Pretty interesting. Other little fact that they don't mention in there that I happen to notice is 2025, the bottle released at a 750 ml bottle. 2026. We lost fifty mls. It is in a seven hundred ml bottle. Where's where's our extra fifty ml, Star Hill Arms? I don't know. A little cheapness. I think the price on these MSRP on both of these was $100. Okay. So it didn't go up. Didn't go up. Shrinkflation happened on us. Exactly. ⁓ let's get this twenty I've got the twenty five already poured up. Let's pop the twenty twenty-six for the first time. Huh? Big old pop. Good old side by side. It does. It does this one looks a little darker. It does. Twenty twenty six looks a little darker than the twenty twenty five. Give them give ⁓ both a shot on the nose a little bit, let this twenty six open a little bit. And I really enjoyed last year when this twenty five came out. Smells nice. I bought a couple bottles of it. This I'm still working on the first one. Nice sweetness though. I get a lot of vanilla, but not like vanilla bean or I'm getting like a custardy vanilla. You know what is like cherry vanilla custard. Or like a like a vanilla pudding with like a cherry sauce on it. Yeah, on the nose. Very vanilla custardy to me. On the twenty twenty six cherries? I don't I got a little bit of dark cherry on it. Or dark yeah. Dark cherry, maybe dark berries. You know what I'm getting? What's that? Poached a poached apple. Okay. Not like a That's a note I would never call out. Like an apple that's been cooked. Yeah. Like a poached apple. So I would ⁓ I would always say that's like a apple pie filling or you know, where they slice up shinnaman sugar kind of on it. But I like the poached apple call out. Nice fruity notes on it though. Definitely. On the twenty twenty six let's let's change gears. Ooh. need that to open up more. It does. It hasn't opened up. Nope. It hasn't. I'm gonna roll it around in the glass a little bit. Very similar nose, but it was less it was more muted initially. May need may need a little more air on it. This be considered a neck pour? This it would be a neck pour. ⁓ Fresh crack neck pour inbound. Yeah, I get a little more like orchard fruits, like peaches, nectarines, versus that berry. Yeah, it's different hills for sure. Yeah, I get that. A little bit of light honeyness, honey sweetness in there. Interesting. Less definitely for me less vanilla. More honey sweetness. I don't have I don't get baked apple in this. I get more of a Apple juice almost? Yeah, that apple note, now that I've I've gone from this year twenty twenty six back to the twenty twenty five, the apple note's way more prevalent there on the twenty five. I don't get a whole lot of the apple on twenty six. Yeah. ⁓ I'm gonna dive in and taste the twenty five, try to remind myself what it tastes like. It's been a few months since I've had this. I like the nose better on the twenty five. That's just me. I like that vanilla custard nose. ⁓ let's I went for a let's get a little pull here. Ooh. 25's got a little like. Well that drinks different than what I thought it would drink. Yeah. Spicy. Mm-hmm. Yeah, a little lot of cinnamon. A little bit of like a little tannic oak on the finish. Almost drying. Yep. Very tannic. ⁓ not very, but definitely tannic on the back end. But punchy. Mm-hmm. So this is the lower, the lower proof one, 114.7. So the other one's I can feel the warmth. I'm gonna taste it again before I go to the six. It's still got second sip, still got the like dark fruits up front. That that vanilla custard. The vanilla isn't as sweet as the the nose was. Yes. But it has like a like almost like a creamy texture to it. Mid palette. And then it Yeah, I see that. Then it blasts into that cinnamon Yeah, you get a lot of spice at the spice finish. Yeah. Late mid palette to finish. Bunch of spice and tannic drawing. Sure, it's from the oak, but it's interesting. It's tasty. Wheat whiskeys feel like they made like a there were a bunch of different wheat whiskies that came out last year. You had the Heaven Hill Heritage Collection, nineteen year old wheat whiskey. You had this come out. Bernheim obviously from Heaven Hill. They always drop their wheat whiskeys. They just dropped I think it was this year though, twenty twenty six, the ten year wheat whiskey from Bernheim. But like you said, a lot of those still have corn in ⁓ Correct. Yeah, I don't know of I don't know if any of those have any like that are just pure wheat. And wheat and barley, I guess. Missing for at least for me. The sweet sweetness from the corn. Yeah, I do like a little bit of corn sweetness in it. Yeah. ⁓ it's a it's a different take on a whiskey. ⁓ I liked last year. I'm interested in this year. Go back and nose this one more time. Starting to open up some more. I'm still getting still more on the Yeah, more orchard fruits there. Peaches, nectarines on the nose. Palette for me though. Getting spice. ⁓ damn. Warm spices on this. Almost like apple pie ish kinda for me. Apple pie? Mm-hmm. And the on you said on A or on 2025. Twenty twenty-six. On the nose. On the nose. Gotcha. Gotcha. ⁓ yeah. That's that tastes better. It's a softer, sweeter It's a much sweeter. Profile. ⁓ it doesn't have that bold cinnamon punchy spice. A little less tannic. Yes, for for sure. But I did think they said because of the hard red wheat and white wheat. That it would add more sweetness. Yeah, what did they say? ⁓ should be much more vibrant, bright, and mellow. Mellow, that's what it was. A lot more mellow. It's tasty. Definitely add those two weeds added the sweetness that I was missing from the twenty twenty five. Yeah. They're which y you know, reading the mash bill on this, I was a little concerned that I might not like it at all. It's sixty two percent malted wheat. That's probably where this wheat's coming from too, when you malt something. And softer. I mean, I'm not a huge, you know, scotch or malted whiskey or American single malt. Me either. Not a big fan. ⁓ this is this is really good. Yeah, this is good. I I actually think I loved the twenty twenty five when it came out. I thought it was something different. I thought it was a really cool expression. I thought it was cool that it had been seventy years since Maker of Smart did anything. Did something different. Did something disparate other than their standard mash bill. ⁓ and I think this twenty six version is worth a buy. It's definitely a a a more approachable, I would say, drinkable, crushable version of what came out last year. Yeah, I prefer the twenty twenty six over the twenty twenty five. Yeah. If you're looking for something new and different, I think it hits those those marks. ⁓ especially if you're coming from like a lot of bourbon and you're looking for that corn sweetness, the twenty twenty six is Yeah, I think it it drinks it drinks yeah, you're I think you're right. It drinks more like a bourbon. Less punchy. ⁓ which crazy. More proof now. More proof, yeah. Yeah, it's a hundred and sixteen point. Definitely doesn't drink its proof. Point four. ⁓ It's got a little heat to it, but it's definitely softer and sweeter. Yeah. I enjoyed it. Interesting. It's nice. Different something different. What we're we're used to drinking. Typically. Yeah. Typically having. Yeah. So final thoughts here. I I think it's worth a buy. If you haven't got one, if you can get it for a hundred bucks, I think it's a buy. I don't think it's worth the one fifty, two hundred dollars sometimes that I see ⁓ on secondary pricing. I would not I'd get it at MSRP. Yeah, don't don't go paying. It's not worth it like that. At MSRP, like, hey, you want to try something different? This is pretty good. Yeah. Why don't you give that a try? And the packaging on it's cool. Like the I I showed you earlier the the cork stopper is almost like this it's probably fake, but almost feels like a granite. Granite it does. Like a stone. Like the ⁓ the bottle. I love the like the hammered ⁓ hammered glass texture of the inside of the bottle there. That looks really cool too. If your old lady tossed that at you, it would hurt. Yeah. Don't get in a fight with the old lady near a bottle of stall starms. You don't want to be catching that cork. You lose some teeth on that one. very cool. But I guess let us know in the comments have you dived into the Star Hill Farms ⁓ products? Are you a makersmark fan? I think I think makersmark is a little bit polarizing. Some people love it and then some people are like Don't love it. I think if you like makers mark, you should try it. Like it's it's something different. And if you're kind of in between, like, yeah, definitely the twenty twenty six. If you're like liking bourbons, and if you want to try something new, get yourself a twenty twenty six expression. Find it. It's on shelves now. I'm not sure if you'll find the twenty five out there anymore. ⁓ which is okay. So it sounds like maybe next year we get a whole different mash bill variation in twenty twenty seven. We'll see. We'll see. Yeah. ⁓ but ⁓ let us know in the comments is this a bro product that you're interested in? Have you tried it? Have you have you been able to do the comparison between twenty five and twenty six? ⁓ they look the same in the bottle, but the liquid is substantially different. So if you tried the twenty five and you liked it and you're like, ⁓ I don't need a bottle of twenty six, it's different. It's the same thing, just a year older. I It's it's radically different. I think it's worth a worth a try. It's not like you're gonna go buy, you know, two two identical makers marks from different years. No. very cool. I appreciate you coming here trying this with me, buddy. ⁓ for all you listening and watching, we'll see you soon for another episode on the podcast. Cheers.