Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Run a One-on-One That Actually Helps
Transcript
- Lucas: So I was talking to a friend last week, senior director at a mid-size tech company, and she told me she has twelve direct reports. Twelve. And she said her biggest frustration is that her one-on-ones feel like a waste of time for everyone involved. Luna: Oof. Twelve one-on-ones a week, if she meets weekly. That's basically a full day of meetings. Lucas: Exactly. And she's not alone. I've heard this from so many managers. The one-on-one is supposed to be the most important recurring meeting on your calendar, but most of them are just status updates or venting sessions. And the problem isn't the format — it's the structure. Luna: So what's the fix? What does a good one-on-one actually look like? Lucas: I think the best framework I've seen comes from a former Googler turned coach — she calls it the three-bucket agenda: tactical, strategic, and personal. And you need to cover all three in every single one-on-one. Luna: Alright, unpack that. Start with tactical. Lucas: Tactical is the stuff that usually takes over the whole meeting: What's the status on project X? Any blockers? Anything I need to unstick? That's maybe five to ten minutes max. The mistake is letting it bleed into the entire thirty minutes. Luna: Right, because then you never get to the bigger stuff. Lucas: Exactly. So bucket two is strategic. This is where you talk about the person's growth. Are they working on the right things for their career? Is there a skill they want to build? A project they want to lead? This is also where you ask the question that I think is the single most powerful one-on-one question. Luna: I'm ready. What's the question? Lucas: It's: 'What's one thing you wish we were doing differently as a team, or that you think I'm missing?' Luna: That's good. It's specific enough to get a real answer, but open-ended enough to surface something they might not have said otherwise. Lucas: Exactly. And the third bucket is personal. Not prying into their personal life, but checking in on how they're actually doing. Burnout, workload, morale. A simple 'How are you, really?' can go a long way. Luna: I love that. And I think the personal bucket is often the one that gets skipped because it feels awkward or soft. But if you don't build that trust, the tactical and strategic conversations are hollow. Lucas: Right. And the structure only works if you prepare. The biggest mistake I see is managers walking into the one-on-one cold, asking 'So, what do you want to talk about?' and then the direct report has to carry the entire meeting. Luna: That's a huge pet peeve of mine. If the manager isn't prepared, it signals that this meeting isn't important. Lucas: Exactly. So the rule I follow is: I spend five minutes before each one-on-one jotting down a few notes. What did I notice this week? What feedback do I want to give? What question do I want to ask? And I share an agenda with the direct report at least 24 hours in advance, asking them to add their own items. Luna: That shared ownership is key. It's not the manager's meeting or the direct report's meeting — it's their meeting. Lucas: Exactly. And I would also say: the best one-on-ones feel like a conversation, not an interrogation. If you're doing all the talking, you're doing it wrong. Luna: Yeah, the direct report should speak at least 70 percent of the time. The manager is there to listen, coach, and remove obstacles. Lucas: Totally. And one more thing: take notes during the one-on-one. Not on your laptop — that's a barrier. A notebook. Write down what they say, what you committed to, and then follow up. Nothing kills trust faster than a manager who says 'I'll look into that' and never brings it up again. Luna: That's such a simple practice, but it's amazing how many managers don't do it. I've been on the receiving end of that, and it's demoralizing. Lucas: So to wrap that part: structure your one-on-ones with three buckets — tactical, strategic, personal. Prepare beforehand. Let the direct report lead the conversation. And take notes and follow up. That alone will transform the meeting from a chore into the most valuable hour of your week. Luna: Alright, but let's talk about frequency. How often should a manager meet one-on-one with each direct report? Lucas: I think weekly is ideal for most situations, especially if your team is moving fast or if the person is new or struggling. For a seasoned high-performer, every two weeks might be fine. But I'd say never go longer than two weeks. Monthly one-on-ones are basically useless for building real rapport. Luna: Agreed. And the length — thirty minutes? Sixty? Lucas: Thirty minutes is enough if you're disciplined. But if you have a lot to cover, sixty is fine. I'd rather have a focused thirty than a rambling sixty. Luna: Yeah. And I think a lot of managers worry that if they don't fill the full hour, it's a waste. But sometimes a twenty-minute one-on-one where you really connect is better than an hour of awkward silence. Lucas: Exactly. And if you finish early, you can always end early. That's a gift to your direct report. Luna: Alright, I want to pivot to something you mentioned earlier — the question 'What's one thing you wish we were doing differently?' That's a brave question for a manager to ask. What if the answer is something critical about you? Lucas: Then you thank them and you take it seriously. The worst thing you can do is get defensive. If they say 'You micromanage,' don't explain why you don't. Say 'Thank you for telling me. I'm going to work on that.' And then actually work on it. Luna: And if you don't change, they'll stop giving you honest feedback. That's the real cost. Lucas: Exactly. So that's the framework. I think if every manager started using the three-bucket model and asking that one question, the quality of one-on-ones across the entire business world would go up dramatically. Luna: Honestly, if that one tip — asking 'What's one thing you wish we were doing differently?' — helps you become a better manager, then this episode was worth a coffee. And if you found it valuable, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It keeps us ad-free and helps us keep making episodes like this. Lucas: Yeah, we really appreciate that. And it's not a big ask — just if the episode gave you something useful. So back to that question: if you're a manager, try it in your next one-on-one. Just ask it. See what happens. Luna: I'm going to try it with my own manager next week. Let's see if they're ready for it. Lucas: I love that. Report back. Alright, that's it for this episode of Manager Mondays. Thanks for listening.