Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #2: Applying the CSR to the 2025 CFB season
Transcript
- 0:18Hello and welcome back to the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 0:22Here in episode two, I will be recapping the twenty twenty-five college football season and applying the Common Sense rankings methodology to all of the games played throughout each week.
- 0:32If you did not listen to the first episode of the CSR podcast, I did dive deeper into the methodology behind it, but I will summarize it for those of you who are too lazy to go back to listen to episode one.
- 0:43The CSR bases its rankings on wins and losses.
- 0:47Not strictly just who has more wins and who has fewer losses, it is based off opponent strength as well, and that opponent strength is determined by the conference of the opponent.
- 0:59So if you were to play a Big Ten team and the Big Ten was judged as the best conference, you would get more t- points for beating that Big Ten team.
- 1:06Conferences are judged based on how many other conferences they have a winning record against.
- 1:11So if you have a winning record against more other conferences, a win against a team in your conference will garner more points, and if you had a winning record against fewer conferences, a win against a team in your conference would gain fewer points, and the opposite is true for the negative points.
- 1:26We're also going to use the transitive property.
- 1:29So if team A is better than team B and team B is better than team C, therefore team A is supposed to be better than team C.
- 1:36So we'll use that one degree of separation as well.
- 1:39Um, that will be considered opponent win points and opponent loss points when you are looking at the CSR.
- 1:45Now, before we get started, every con- e- every conference with a full allotment of members plays each of the other conferences at least twice during the twenty twenty-five college football season.
- 1:53That is a bit rare.
- 1:55Uh, there are usually some geographic issues as far as getting conferences to play each other.
- 1:59But also with more conferences playing more conference games, the room for inter-conference matchups is slim.
- 2:06However, in the twenty twenty-five season, there are head-to-head matchups between each conference, and I will be sure to point these out, uh, as we go along through each week of the season.
- 2:16If you wanna see all these numbers written down, you can go to commonsenserankings.com, where I have the most recent five college football seasons, as well as the most recent three college basketball and women's college basketball seasons as well.
- 2:29Moving on to the 2025 college football season.
- 2:32In week zero, we had several teams play, including Iowa State beating Kansas State over in Dublin, Ireland.
- 2:37But we also had teams that were going to play two games against FBS opponents in week zero and week one.
- 2:43Those three teams were Hawaii, Fresno State, and Sam Houston.
- 2:47Due to the relative difficulty of their schedule in those week zero and week one matchups, each of those three teams had the opportunity to be atop the CSR after week one because they could theoretically have two wins against FBS teams.
- 3:01Other noteworthy games including South Florida downing Boise State.
- 3:05Ohio State beat Texas.
- 3:07That is the first of three Big Ten-SEC matchups throughout the season.
- 3:11Because the Big Ten won the first, they now have a leg up on the SEC before their final two matchups.
- 3:17LSU took down Clemson.
- 3:18Florida State surprised Alabama.
- 3:21Miami beat Notre Dame on Sunday, and then TCU beat Bill Belichick and UNC on Labor Day night.
- 3:27Something to point out, too, FCS wins mean nothing in the CSR.
- 3:30So the nine AP preseason ranked teams that faced an FCS opponent in week one, you're not getting touched by the CSR.
- 3:36You will gain no points for that.
- 3:39In addition to the Big Ten and SEC getting their first matchup out of the way, the ACC and the Mountain West only play three times throughout 2025, the first of which being Hawaii's win over Stanford.
- 3:50The Mountain West is currently one and O against the ACC, giving them a leg up on one of the Power Four conferences going into week two.
- 3:58The Big Ten and the American played twice in week one and were not scheduled to play at all the rest of the season, so one conference needed to win both games in order to have a winning record against the other.
- 4:08Unfortunately, for both conferences potentially, Maryland beat Florida Atlantic, but Tulane beat Northwestern, guaranteeing that those two conferences would have a.500 record against each other, and nobody could guarantee that they were better than the other based on on-the-field performance Once the dust settled in week one, the SEC and the Big Ten both had winning records against five conferences, making them the best in the country.
- 4:30So the top four teams are going to be the four teams that beat a Big Ten or an SEC team.
- 4:36So you got Ohio State, who beat Texas, Florida State, who beat Alabama, and then you got Utah and Tulane rounding out the top four.
- 4:44So you got four different conferences representing those top four slots and would therefore get the byes in the hypothetical college football playoff bracket after week one.
- 4:53Something I want to note, Arizona beat Hawaii in week one and Hawaii had already beaten Stanford.
- 4:58So Arizona gets the first opponent win points of the season.
- 5:01They are in the five spot.
- 5:02And then Kansas similarly beat Fresno State in week zero and then Fresno State beat Georgia Southern in week one.
- 5:09So Kansas has a win over a team that also has a win over a team.
- 5:12So they are number six in the first iteration of the CSR.
- 5:16If we're looking at those first round matchups in that hypothetical college football playoff bracket, number five Arizona would play number 12 LSU.
- 5:23Number six Kansas would face number 11 South Carolina.
- 5:27Number seven Penn State would face number 10 Washington.
- 5:29And number eight Tennessee would take on number nine Michigan.
- 5:32All those rankings, of course, being the CSR.
- 5:35Through week one, the AP poll ranked 11 of the same teams from the CSR top 25.
- 5:40That's less than half.
- 5:42I got to say that's not very good.
- 5:43The biggest miss was Tulane.
- 5:45Somehow teams that had not won a game or beat an FCS school were deemed better than a team that beat a Big Ten school.
- 5:51What are we doing?
- 5:52And the biggest reach were both Alabama and Notre Dame who lost to ACC schools.
- 6:00As we look at the week two matchups, we see that the only conference that will not have played another is the Big 12 and the Sun Belt, so we have a lot of inter-conference records to go off of already.
- 6:1011 of the previous week's top 25 in the CSR rankings played an FCS team in week two, and a 12th TCU had an early bye, which guaranteed a lot of turnover in the top 25 of the CSR, and that includes three of the top four teams.
- 6:25Ohio State, Florida State, and Utah each have an FCS school scheduled for week two, which means they will almost certainly fall down the rankings.
- 6:3481 of the 136 teams in the FBS have already played an FCS school to this point.
- 6:40Again, this is insane how often these big teams are just getting positive reinforcement from the committee members because they are beating schools from a lower division.
- 6:51A few group of five teams that could launch themselves forward based on the opponents they would have played through week two, you have Tulane, who's already ranked number four.
- 6:59You've got South Florida, who beat Boise State and now have Florida in week two.
- 7:03You got Central Michigan, who beat San Jose State in week one and are playing Pittsburgh in week two.
- 7:08And then you've got Utah State, who've already beaten UTEP and play Texas A&M in week two.
- 7:14So a lot of opportunities for those smaller schools to beat up on Power Four teams.
- 7:21Week two also features the first of three matchups between the ACC and the Big Ten.
- 7:26Michigan State beat Boston College to give Big Ten the starting 1-0 record and a positive, uh, results against the ACC this early in the season.
- 7:37After Ohio State beat Texas in week one, we have our second Big Ten-SEC matchup with an Oklahoma win over Michigan that ties those two conferences at one win apiece.
- 7:47The week three matchup between Wisconsin and Alabama will determine which conference has a leg up on the other for the entirety of the season.
- 7:55SEC takes the lead after all of the games in week two.
- 7:58They are now better than six different conferences in head-to-head records.
- 8:02The Big Ten remains second with five.
- 8:04The ACC and Big 12 are now tied with four, followed by the American and Mountain West with three each.
- 8:12Because the SEC went from being better than five conferences to being better than six, wins against the SEC, whether they happened in this past week or previously, think Ohio State over Texas, now mean more.
- 8:24So as teams' quality increases throughout the season, we go back and reassess the wins that happened early in the season before they garnered that positive boost.
- 8:35The American Conference is really holding the line at this point for the group of five.
- 8:39They've won exactly half their games against the SEC, Big Ten, and Big 12, preventing each of those three conferences to advance farther up the conference rankings After all the Week 2 games, the number one spot now goes to Iowa State.
- 8:52They have wins over Kansas State and Iowa, in addition to an FCS school.
- 8:56So a win over a Big 12 and a Big 10 team is going to get you that number one spot.
- 9:00If we're creating a bracket, the top four teams getting a bye, Iowa State goes to the first seed.
- 9:07South Florida would get a bye, who did end up beating Florida after beating Boise State.
- 9:11You also have Ole Miss, who beat Kentucky to start SEC play.
- 9:15Again, the SEC being the top conference in head-to-head results.
- 9:18You're getting the most points for beating an SEC team.
- 9:21And the four seed would be NC State, with wins over East Carolina out of the American, and then Virginia out of the ACC.
- 9:27So you have four different conferences among the top four again.
- 9:31Filling out those first round match-ups in the hypothetical college football playoff bracket, you have five Texas A&M versus CSR number 12 Penn State.
- 9:39You have six LSU versus 11 Mississippi State.
- 9:42You have number seven Auburn versus number seven Tulane.
- 9:45And then UNLV is actually the eight seed, that fifth auto bid, against number nine Nebraska.
- 9:52The AP poll is improving.
- 9:53They got 13 of the top 25 correct.
- 9:56Their biggest miss was NC State.
- 9:58Again, how we're still ranking teams who have not yet won a game over a team that has beat an American and an ACC team, I am not sure.
- 10:06And then the biggest reach is Notre Dame, who is still sitting at 0-1, whose only result thus far was a loss to Miami.
- 10:13That is nothing against Notre Dame in the slightest.
- 10:16It is a slight on the AP poll voters, however, that they are not taking the results on the field seriously.
- 10:25Moving on to week three, every conference has now played each other, with Arizona State's win over Texas State to kick off the Big 12 Sun Belt season.
- 10:33So we do have data now to assess every conference's ability against all of the others.
- 10:39The Big Ten-ACC matchups would conclude with two more matchups here in week three.
- 10:44The Big Ten just needed to win one of them to ensure that they had a winning record against the ACC at the end of the season.
- 10:50And while California, the ACC did beat Minnesota, we had Illinois beat Duke, giving Big Ten that leg up.
- 10:57That Illinois versus Duke matchup ended up meaning a lot at the end of the season when the college football playoff committee was making their final decisions.
- 11:05The SEC continued to separate themself in week three, as they now have a winning record against all of the other eight conferences.
- 11:12So a win against the SEC is already at the maximum number of points that you can earn under the CSR.
- 11:19This is both applying to games that had already happened, so Ohio State's win over Texas looks even better, and two games that are still to be played.
- 11:28The Big Ten and Big 12 are still tied at five each.
- 11:31The ACC is fourth in the conference rankings with four conferences against which they are better than.
- 11:37And then the American and Mountain West are still sitting at three conferences each, with the American still being at a.500 record against the Big Ten and Big 12.
- 11:46South Florida had Boise State and Florida against which they went 2-0, and they had a chance to beat Miami in week three, which would send them to the top of the CSR.
- 11:54And then other matchups we were looking forward to in week three included Ole Miss versus Arkansas, NC State versus Wake Forest, Texas A&M versus Notre Dame, LSU versus Florida, and Tulane versus Duke.
- 12:07Ole Miss, courtesy of their 2-0 start to the SEC season, move into the top spot after the week three games.
- 12:14LSU, courtesy of their three FBS wins, including Clemson and Florida, is at number two.
- 12:19NC State moves up a spot to number three after they defeated Wake Forest.
- 12:23And Texas A&M, after beating Notre Dame, makes the top four buys.
- 12:29The rest of the college football playoff matchups through week three are number five, Iowa State versus number 12, Oklahoma.
- 12:35Number six, USC versus number 11, Miami.
- 12:38Number seven, Tulane, who's still hanging around, is against number 10, Vanderbilt.
- 12:42And number eight, Auburn against number nine, Ohio State.
- 12:45Ohio State is currently number one in the AP polls, but they are number nine in the CSR.
- 12:51As of right now, there are still only undefeated teams in the top 25 through week three.
- 12:56So all those 3-0 or potentially 2-0 teams, but we will start getting some one-loss teams here as their wins outdo their losses.
- 13:05The AP poll continues to improve.
- 13:07I got to give credit to the voters.
- 13:08They now have 16 of the top 25 right.
- 13:12Slight kudos to them, I guess.
- 13:13The biggest miss is still NC State.
- 13:15Still not sure how they're not ranked after three wins.
- 13:18And then the biggest reach is still unfortunately Notre Dame, who have only proved to this point in the season that they are not as good as two other teams, and yet NC State has proven that they are better than teams, yet they are still unranked.
- 13:30Something doesn't add up.
- 13:32AP poll voters, do better As we enter the week four games, most conferences are now entering conference play exclusively, which means there will be less change to the interconference records week to week.
- 13:47Two conferences did change after the week four games, however.
- 13:50The Mountain West picked up a fourth conference against which they were better than, the ACC, coincidentally, the conference that they are tied with as far as value goes.
- 13:58And then the s- Sun Belt is now better than two conferences, which puts them slightly ahead of the MAC and Conference USA.
- 14:05Meanwhile, the SEC is still sitting better than all of the conferences, while the Big Ten and the Big 12 are better than five, but not better than three.
- 14:13That is a much larger discrepancy than in most seasons.
- 14:16Typically, it's one conference is better than six, one is better than five, a couple are better than four.
- 14:20But the SEC being so much stronger, again, in interconference record, is going to create some disparity between the teams in the AC- SEC as well as the Big Ten and Big 12 Only two top 25 CSR matchups occur in week four.
- 14:37You've got CSR number one Ole Miss against n- CSR number seven Tulane, and then you've got CSR number eight Auburn taking on number 12 Oklahoma in an SEC matchup.
- 14:47After all the games are played, Ole Miss did defeat Tulane, keeping them in the number one spot.
- 14:52USC jumped up from number six to number two with their win over Michigan State, and then Oklahoma and Miami would each get a hypothetical bye if we were building a college football playoff bracket with results through week four.
- 15:05AP number one Ohio State still sits at CSR number 19, and then AP number five Georgia is just below them at CSR number 20, which proves what I was explaining in episode one, they care less who you beat.
- 15:18They care more who you are and what conference you're a part of.
- 15:22Hypothetical first round college football playoff matchups through week four.
- 15:25You've got number five Missouri versus number 12 Memphis, which makes it five teams included in the college football playoff.
- 15:32You got number six Texas A&M versus number 11 Indiana.
- 15:34It's the first time the eventual national championship shows up.
- 15:38Number seven Georgia Tech versus number 10 Iowa State, and number eight LSU versus number nine Vanderbilt.
- 15:44We had our first one-loss teams make the top 25 in the CSR.
- 15:48You got Michigan at CSR number 19, and then Tulane after their loss to Ole Miss dropped down to number 23.
- 15:54The AP poll continues to improve, but only slightly.
- 15:58They got 17 of the top 25 correct this time.
- 16:01Their biggest miss was Memphis at number 12, and then their biggest reach is still Notre Dame.
- 16:05They had a win over Purdue in week four, which is helping them pull closer to the ranked CSR teams.
- 16:11Again, this is nothing against Notre Dame.
- 16:13It is just the AP poll voters I am trying to call out Moving on to the week five games, there are no changes to conference strength.
- 16:24The SEC still stands alone, followed at a distance by the Big Ten and Big 12, and then finally the ACC and the Mountain West are equal based on inter-conference play.
- 16:36The Notre Dame right, right now has played one ACC, two SEC, and one Big Ten team so far, putting them ahead of all of the conferences as a whole, except the SEC.
- 16:47So Miami and Texas A&M, having beat Notre Dame, are getting a lot of points for that win.
- 16:53CSR top 25 matchups in week five include number one Ole Miss versus number eight LSU, and then number 10 Iowa State against number 25 Arizona.
- 17:03Ole Miss, of course, beating another SEC team, moving to three and zero.
- 17:06Taking down LSU retains the number one spot.
- 17:10Texas A&M, they have wins over Auburn, Notre Dame, and Utah State, which may not sound like great, that Utah State game.
- 17:16However, we have to remember that the Mountain West is being treated the same as an ACC team at this point.
- 17:21They're in the number two spot.
- 17:23Indiana continues to improve, taking the number three seed, and the hypothetical bye, that last one would go to Vanderbilt as the four seed.
- 17:31So we do have more one-loss teams entering the rankings at this point, but the top one-loss team is actually still Tulane, with their only loss coming to Ole Miss, and two of their wins are over the ACC and Big Ten.
- 17:42They are number 15 after the week five games.
- 17:46The hypothetical college football playoff first round games are number five Iowa State against number 12 North Texas.
- 17:52They are both of their conference's champion in this case.
- 17:55Number six Missouri against number 11 Miami.
- 17:58Number seven Oregon, the AP number two team, against number 10 Ohio State, the AP number one team, and then number eight Georgia Tech against number nine Oklahoma.
- 18:09The AP poll voters are still improving.
- 18:11Good for them.
- 18:12The biggest miss was North Texas at that CSR number 12 spot.
- 18:16Then their biggest reach is Penn State at AP number seven, which they have wins over the Mountain West, okay, not bad, a CS- CUSA school, which is tied for the worst, FCS, and a loss to the Big Ten.
- 18:28They are ranked number seven in the AP poll Moving on to the games that occur in week six, s- conference strength is going to remain stagnant.
- 18:38The SEC is still quite a bit ahead.
- 18:40Then you got the Big 10 and Big 12 tied, then the ACC and Mountain West below them.
- 18:45The top matchups according to the CSR in week six were CSR number four Vanderbilt against number 25 Alabama.
- 18:52I wanna specifically point out Alabama because they just handed UGA their first loss to move into the CSR rankings.
- 18:59They've got undefeated Vandy here in week six.
- 19:02They've got a CSR-ranked Missouri team in week seven, and then a ranked Tennessee team in week eight.
- 19:07And being all games against the SEC, which is, according to inter-conference records, far and away the best conference, Alabama is going to start picking up spots in chunks coming up.
- 19:19The other CSR top 25 matchup is number 16 Houston, who is not ranked in the AP, against 17 Texas Tech.
- 19:28Ole Miss, the previous CSR number one, had a bye, allowing for some people to catch up, which is what, uh, Texas A&M did by jumping them for a w- with a win over Mississippi State.
- 19:38So Texas A&M slides into number one.
- 19:40Ole Miss falls to number two, which makes sense after having a bye.
- 19:45Miami jumps up to number three courtesy of their win over Florida State, and they then get points also for Florida State beating Alabama.
- 19:52And then the last bye in the 12-team college football playoff bracket would be number four Ohio State, who is still the AP number one team following their win over Minnesota.
- 20:04The first round hypothetical matchups for the CFP through this point would be number five Memphis, who is 6-0, versus Texas Tech, number six Oklahoma versus number 11 Missouri, number seven Indiana, they dropped after having a bye week, against number 10 Alabama, who is the first one-loss team to appear in a CFP projection, and then number eight Georgia Tech against number nine BYU.
- 20:27The AP poll is finally catching up to the CSR.
- 20:32They now have 21 of the top 25 teams correct.
- 20:35The highest ranked team in the CSR that the AP poll missed is North Texas at CSR number 16, and then they have still reached by ranking Florida State ahead of a lot of other more deserving teams.
- 20:47We're gonna keep an eye on BYU, who is currently 4-0.
- 20:50They're ranked down at the number 23 in the AP, however they are ranked in the CSR by f- number 14.
- 20:56We'll keep an eye on the Cougars as we would keep an eye also on the Crimson Tide and see what happens to them over the next handful of weeks.
- 21:03As of right now, through week six games, there is still no two-loss team in the CSR top 25 And we continue to move on, this time to week number seven games.
- 21:16The only fluctuation from the value of wins and losses, again, because most conferences are entering conference play exclusively, is now happening in the independents in the Pac-12.
- 21:26Notre Dame, their value is now judged to be slightly above the Big Ten and the Big 12, again, based on all the conferences they've played and the averages of those conferences.
- 21:36UConn is the other independent.
- 21:38They're hovering down between the Sun Belt as well as the MAC and the Conference USA.
- 21:42And then the Pac-12 with their two teams actually have slightly more value than the ACC, so they are between the ACC and the Big 10 and Big 12 as far as value of a win and loss go.
- 21:54There are a lot more high-profile match-ups coming into week seven.
- 21:57You got CSR number one, Texas A&M plays Florida, allowing them the opportunity to remain first.
- 22:04Number two, Ole Miss plays Washington State.
- 22:06Having just mentioned that the Pac-12 is seen, again, based on interconference record, as better than the ACC, that is going to potentially give Ole Miss a lot of points.
- 22:17CSR number four, Ohio State, plays number 15, Illinois.
- 22:21The Red River Rivalry, of course, between Oklahoma and Texas.
- 22:25You've got Indiana at CSR number seven who plays number 13, Oregon.
- 22:29Oregon was ranked number three in the AP poll at this point, while Indiana was surprisingly correctly ranked at number seven.
- 22:36You've got Alabama, who's in the 10 spot, facing number 14, Missouri.
- 22:41You've got Michigan playing USC.
- 22:43You've got number 16, North Texas, playing number 24, South Florida as well.
- 22:48After beating Florida, Texas A&M retains the top spot, now sitting at 6-0.
- 22:53Ole Miss, with that non-conference win over Washington State, stays at number two.
- 22:57Ohio State moves up to CSR number three while retaining their number one spot in the AP poll.
- 23:03Then Indiana jumps back up and gets that fourth hypothetical bye after their win over Oregon.
- 23:09So those four teams are top four in the CSR, and they're each in the top five of the AP.
- 23:14So again, the AP is clawing their way back to some sort of standard of excellence that they claim to have.
- 23:21The first round match-ups, number five, Alabama.
- 23:24We've talked about how they are in a, just in an SEC gauntlet of teams that are either undefeated or have one loss.
- 23:29They continue to rise up the CSR.
- 23:31They are the five seed.
- 23:32They would face number 12, Tulane.
- 23:34Number six, Texas Tech, would face number 11, Georgia.
- 23:37Number seven, BYU, against number 10, Memphis.
- 23:41And finally, number eight, Georgia Tech, against number nine, Miami.
- 23:44Miami is currently sitting at the AP number two spot The AP got 21 of the top 25 correct.
- 23:51They are getting much, much closer.
- 23:54Three of those misses were non-Power Four teams, so goes to show again that they are over-ranking teams based on what conference they are a part of and under-ranking teams strictly based on conference affiliation.
- 24:07The biggest miss was Tulane at number 12, but Navy, yes, Navy, is the surprise at CSR number 13, and UNLV of the Mountain West is at CSR number 14.
- 24:17None of those three teams are ranked by the AP.
- 24:19Their biggest reach was Texas, who's sitting at 4-2, is number 21 in the A poll, P poll, but is 35th in the CSR Two two-loss teams are creeping toward that top 25 in the Common Sense rankings.
- 24:33That is Notre Dame, who currently sits at CSR number 27, and Illinois is at 28, while Michigan is at number 31.
- 24:42Moving on, week eight matchups between top 25 teams.
- 24:45You've got number two Ole Miss against number 11 Georgia.
- 24:48Number five Alabama continues their insane run against number 17 Tennessee.
- 24:53You got CSR number seven BYU against number 19 Utah.
- 24:5515 LSU against 25 Vanderbilt.
- 25:01S- number 16 USC takes on Notre Dame just outside the top 25.
- 25:05And then number 21 Washington, ranked in the CSR, they're the only Power Four team that is ranked in the CSR that is not ranked in the AP.
- 25:13They face Michigan, the second-best, or excuse me, the third-best, oh, two-loss team up to this point.
- 25:20So we mentioned Alabama and BYU a few weeks ago.
- 25:23Let's revisit, uh, where they are sitting.
- 25:25They've shot up-- Alabama has shot up from number 25 to number five in just two weeks.
- 25:30They're currently 3-0 in the SEC with wins over Georgia, who is 3-1 in the SEC, against Vanderbilt, who's an overall 5-1, and Missouri against f- overall 5-1.
- 25:41Each of those three teams' only loss is to the Alabama Crimson Tide.
- 25:46So not only do they get d- direct wins over three SEC teams, which earns them the most because the SEC is better than all other conferences in head-to-head matchups, but they are also getting a lot of points from their opponents' wins as well.
- 26:01This is offsetting some of the negative points that they got from losing to FSU and then FSU continuing to lose games up to this point.
- 26:08Meanwhile, BYU is still shown very little respect by the AP.
- 26:12They have them at number 15, but the Big 12 is on the same level as the Big Ten when we look at inter-conference records.
- 26:19So BYU is more an example of what all Big 12 teams should be arguing for, which is a more equitable ranking to Big Ten teams following a conference win This is becoming a bit of a norm with Texas A&M retaining the number one spot following another SEC win.
- 26:37Ohio State retains their AP number one, but moves up to the CSR number two after beating Wisconsin.
- 26:43Alabama is now up to number three after, uh, their next SEC win, so they get a bye in the hypothetical college football playoff.
- 26:53And then the last bye goes to Indiana at number four.
- 26:55So two SEC and two Big Ten teams in that top four.
- 27:00Those four teams are also the top four, slightly different order, in the AP poll, so obligatory shout out to the AP for doing the right thing.
- 27:09The other college football playoff first round matchups according to the CSR rankings, you got number five BYU versus number 12 Texas Tech, who suffered their first loss this season in this past week.
- 27:20Number six Georgia Tech, who is at 7-0 against number 11 Vanderbilt following their big win against LSU.
- 27:27Number seven Ole Miss is still ranked ahead of UGA even though UGA just defeated them.
- 27:33They are number seven.
- 27:34They face number 10 Oklahoma.
- 27:36And then there's number eight Georgia against number nine Tulane.
- 27:40Seven of the top 12 teams here in the poll this week have a loss.
- 27:44Notre Dame is the only two-loss team, uh, to meet the top 20.
- 27:49They are at number 16, but Michigan is also in the CSR top 25 at number 21.
- 27:54The AP poll saw a slight decrease in the correct number of teams they ranked after the week eight games.
- 28:00They are now at 20 out of the top 25 with the biggest miss being Tulane still not ranked even though they are at number nine in the CSR.
- 28:08And then they have the biggest reach at Illinois who they ranked 23rd while the CSR has them at 34.
- 28:14Interestingly, even though they played in week one, Notre Dame is one spot ahead of Miami, similar to Ole Miss over UGA.
- 28:22One of the-- Just one of those idiosyncrasies of CSR calculations.
- 28:25It takes into account the whole of the resume versus the results of just a single game.
- 28:33Moving on to week nine, there are several high-profile CSR matchups.
- 28:38The first is number one Texas A&M against 26 LSU.
- 28:41You have number seven Ole Miss against number 10 Oklahoma.
- 28:46You have the CSR number 11 Vanderbilt against Missouri.
- 28:50CSR number 13 South Florida takes on American foe Memphis, and then CSR number 22 takes on Arizona State, who is just outside the top 25 in the common sense rankings.
- 29:01Ohio State, who is the second-ranked team in the CSR, has a bye in week nine, which could lead to them falling down the rankings.
- 29:08Again, we're not basing it off of averages, so if you've played more games and you've won them, you will look better than a team that has already had their byes.
- 29:17After the games, A&M retain their top spot and have really opened up quite a bit of a lead on the rest of college football in the common sense rankings.
- 29:25Alabama moves up to number two, having started five and O against their SEC opponents, the SEC being a dominant conference with winning records against every other conference.
- 29:35That is going to push that seven and one Alabama team against several eight and O teams who have wins against inferior conferences.
- 29:42Indiana moves up a spot to number three, and BYU out of the Big 12 takes advantage of Ohio State's bye and moves up to number four and would theoretically get a bye in this iteration of the college football playoff bracket.
- 29:55Ohio State in the AP poll remains number one after their bye, but Texas A&M, Alabama, and Indiana are the other top four teams, but the BYU is number 10.
- 30:05So AP poll got some of it right, but we're still under-ranking the Big 12.
- 30:12The college football playoff first round matchups after week nine would be number five Ole Miss against number 12 Texas Tech.
- 30:18Number six Ohio State versus number 11 Michigan, which raises a lot of eyebrows given their rivalry.
- 30:24Michigan is the first two-loss team to make a college football playoff, uh, bracket as well.
- 30:29Number seven Georgia Tech against number 10 Navy.
- 30:32Navy, who is seven and O and five and O in the American, which is just a step below the Mountain West and ACC as far as conference strength goes.
- 30:41And then number eight Georgia off their bye, uh, against number nine Vanderbilt As far as teams that do eventually make the college football playoff at the end of the 2025 season, Miami has already gone through their two byes, which will temporarily penalize them, but they are sitting at CSR number 15, so just outside a playoff spot.
- 31:01Oregon, who still sits at number six in the AP poll, is all the way down at number 17 in the CSR.
- 31:07And while they will continue to win games against the Big Ten, they are four and one already in that conference.
- 31:12Plus, they have wins over the Oklahoma State from Big, the Big 12 and Oregon State, with the Pac-12 still getting quite a bit of credit.
- 31:18But each of those teams has not had much success, so they are getting fewer opponent win points compared to the other teams in the-- higher in the CSR.
- 31:28Notre Dame, following their second bye week of the season, is still in the top 25.
- 31:32They sit at CSR number 23, and the AP poll reaches a new high as far as getting, uh, the re- correct teams in the top 25.
- 31:41They got 23 out of 25 after this week.
- 31:44They're so close.
- 31:44Look at them.
- 31:45The biggest miss was Navy at CSR number 10.
- 31:48The other team they missed was Tulane at number 14, and their biggest reach was USC, where they voted 23 but are at 34th in the CSR Moving on to the Week 10 games, let's take a look again at how Notre Dame and the Pac-12 stack up against the conferences.
- 32:06Remember that their values are continuing to fluctuate based on the conferences they play.
- 32:11So Notre Dame is hovering right around the value of a Big Ten or a Big 12 team, while the Pac-12 is hovering at the ACC s- and Mountain West level.
- 32:22This is the first week after which the CFP c- Selection Committee will be announcing their rankings, so now instead of comparing to the AP poll, we will compare to the CFP Selection Committee poll.
- 32:32The key match-ups going into Week 10, both Texas A&M and Alabama, the top two teams in the CSR, have byes, as does number four BYU, so there may be some changes coming at the top of the rankings.
- 32:44Number nine Vanderbilt plays number 20 Texas.
- 32:47Both of those teams surprisingly are ranked similarly in the AP poll.
- 32:51Undefeated Navy at CSR number 10 plays North Texas, who is just outside that top 25.
- 32:58We have CSR number 13 Cincinnati playing number 24 Utah, remembering of course the Big 12 and the Big 10 are equal as far as direct win values go.
- 33:06And then lastly, Oklahoma, uh, plays Tennessee, both teams that are just inside that top 25 number.
- 33:13I had mentioned that Texas A&M is starting to separate themselves.
- 33:16They stay at number one, but Indiana, the eventual national champion, moves up to number two.
- 33:22Ole Miss, recovering from their loss to UGA, sits at number three, and Ohio State, while still number one in the AP poll, is back up to number four following their win over Penn State.
- 33:33So the SEC and the Big Ten get the four byes in the hypothetical bracket.
- 33:37The other match-ups in the college football playoff, we've got number five Alabama against number 15 North Texas.
- 33:43That's right, number 15 North Texas, a reminder that five different conferences have to be represented, and North Texas fits that bill.
- 33:51They take the place of Michigan, who is ranked number 12.
- 33:55Number six BYU is the lowest, uh, ranked undefeated team.
- 33:58They face number 11 Oklahoma.
- 34:01Number seven Georgia against number 10 Virginia, who would get the ACC's bid.
- 34:05And then number eight Texas Tech plays number nine Texas, who is the top two loss team after Week 10.
- 34:13Future college football playoff team Tulane sits at number 26 in the CSR, while James Madison, another, uh, future CFP team, sits at number 29, uh, in the CSR.
- 34:25The College Football Playoff Committee got 10 of the top 12 right, the misses being Oregon and Notre Dame being over-ranked, while Virginia and Michigan sitting at number 12 are under-ranked.
- 34:36Overall, the CFP Selection Committee got 20 of the top 25 right, the biggest miss being North Texas at number 15, and the biggest reach being Iowa at the Playoff Committee's rankings of number 20, while at the CSR, they are number 37.
- 34:54As we continue to fly through the twenty twenty-five college football season, we will see some teams separate themselves, therefore they give themselves room to be less impacted by a loss.
- 35:04Key matchups in the Week Eleven games include number one Texas A&M against Missouri.
- 35:09Number three Ole Miss is playing an FCS team, so they will not gain any points.
- 35:12Number five Alabama has their yearly meeting with LSU.
- 35:16Number six BYU comes off a bye to play number eight Texas Tech, and this game will prove very important both in the CSR and the college football playoff picture come the end of the season.
- 35:26CSR number eighteen Oregon plays Iowa, who is overrated.
- 35:30They are in the college football playoff top twenty-five, but it's another way the committee makes Oregon look good by having them face a, quote-unquote,"ranked opponent." So they are fluffing a little bit the teams that they obviously want to be seen as better than they actually are.
- 35:46CSR number nineteen Memphis will play Tulane, and then CSR number twenty Notre Dame gets lucky by playing a Navy team that is having a very good year.
- 35:55Future college football playoff team Miami s- currently sits at CSR number twenty-five, but they are eighteenth in that first CFP poll.
- 36:02And then Tulane and Madison, again, both teams that make the college football playoff are just outside the top twenty-five of the CSR.
- 36:09They are at number twenty-six and twenty-eight.
- 36:12Texas A&M continues to build their resume.
- 36:14They are number one.
- 36:16Indiana is at number two, but Alabama jumps back up into that bye spot at number three with another SEC win, and then Ohio State remains number four even though they are number one in the AP and the CFP committee polls.
- 36:29Ole Miss' win over that FCS school, they were number three last week.
- 36:33They dropped them three spots to number six.
- 36:35Again, we're not giving out p- wins or win points to teams that face FCS schools, so Ole Miss is going to drop there.
- 36:43Hypothetical first-round matchups, number five Georgia against number seventeen Tulane.
- 36:47They take the place of number twelve Notre Dame because we need five conferences represented.
- 36:52You've got number six Ole Miss against number fifteen Georgia Tech, who takes the place of number eleven Oregon as the ACC's lone representative.
- 37:00Number seven's Texas Tech's big win over BYU against number ten Texas, and number eight BYU against number nine Vanderbilt, who although they just lost to Texas, is still ranked ahead of them because they are eight and two compared to Texas' seven and two.
- 37:16The playoff committee gets twenty-one out of twenty-five correct this week, which, shocker, they missed three group of five teams plus Houston.
- 37:24They missed Tulane as the leader of the American Conference, and they reached again for Iowa, who somehow went up four spots after losing to Oregon.
- 37:33Make it make sense So we have SEC with six teams in the top 12.
- 37:39We've got, uh, Big 10 with three and the Big 12 with two.
- 37:43Notre Dame sits 12th, but they would have to get the boot for a conference champ.
- 37:48Navy, an improbable college football playoff hopeful just a couple weeks ago, has fallen out of the top 25 after two consecutive losses.
- 37:57Moving on, Vanderbilt and Houston are the only top 25 teams in the CSR that have a bye in week 12, so they'll likely both take a hit.
- 38:05You've got CSR number three, Alabama, taking on 14, Oklahoma.
- 38:09You got number five, Georgia, against number 10, Texas.
- 38:12You've got number 16, USC, against that CFP selection committee darling, Iowa.
- 38:17You've got number 19, Virginia, who plays Duke, which will take up a huge part of the CFP committee discussion come decision time.
- 38:26And then you've got number 25, South Florida, playing Navy, who still sits hovering just outside that top 25.
- 38:33The biggest results as far as CSR rankings go is Oklahoma's win over Alabama, which hurt Alabama more in the human polls than in the CSR.
- 38:41In the CSR, it took them down from third to sixth Texas A&M stays at number one, Indiana at number two, and Ohio State at number four, but Georgia actually jumped up ahead of Ohio State following their win over Texas.
- 38:55So Georgia is at number three.
- 38:58The first round hypothetical this week, number five Ole Miss versus number 17 Tulane.
- 39:03Michigan rolls their eyes because we have to have five conferences.
- 39:06Number six Alabama versus number t- 14 Georgia Tech, who kick out number 11 Notre Dame, because again, rules.
- 39:13Number seven Texas Tech against number 10 Oregon, who are finally in the projected CSR playoff after wins over Iowa and Minnesota.
- 39:21And lastly, we have BYU at number eight, taking on number nine Oklahoma fresh off their win over Alabama.
- 39:28The College Football Playoff committee got 22 of the 25 teams correct, but you guessed it, they missed three group of five teams, but Tulane finally got a ranking, so we will take what we can get.
- 39:40Their biggest miss was North Texas at number 19, and their biggest reach, not bad, Tennessee at number 20.
- 39:45However, in the CSR they are at number 30.
- 39:49The eventual College Football Playoff team Miami sits at number 21 in the CSR after this week, one ahead of another CFP team in James Madison at CSR number 22.
- 39:59In our bracket we had the SEC with five teams, the Big Ten with three, the Big 12 with two, and then the lone representative from both the ACC and the American.
- 40:11Heading into the penultimate week of the 2025 college football season, we have serious CFP hopefuls who have a very late season bye in Indiana, Ole Miss, Texas Tech, Virginia, and Navy.
- 40:23And lots of top teams also have their cupcake games before rivalry week, with Georgia facing Charlotte and Alabama playing an FCS team.
- 40:32Key matchups, uh, include Texas A&M, who has still separated themselves.
- 40:36They do play an FCS team but have built up enough of a lead that unless they lose, they will still be number one.
- 40:42Number nine Oklahoma plays Missouri.
- 40:44Number 10 Oregon plays number 13 USC.
- 40:47And with the Pac-12 still hovering around the ACC and Mountain West level, you've got James Madison playing Washington State, which will be key in James Madison's quest for a CFP berth.
- 40:59When the dust settles, Texas A&M remains atop the heap, but they still sit at number three in the AP poll.
- 41:05So we got the AP misjudging folks again.
- 41:07Ohio State moves up to number two, and Indiana slips to number three.
- 41:11Georgia retains their bye position but do lose ground by slipping to number four.
- 41:16In the first round CFP matchups, you've got number five BYU, who sits at number 11 in the CFP rankings, against number 17 Miami, that ACC rep who gets in over Notre Dame coincidentally since they played earlier in the season.
- 41:30You've got number six Ole Miss versus number 14 Tulane, who get in over number 11 Michigan because five conferences must be represented.
- 41:38Number seven Oklahoma against number 10 Oregon and number eight Alabama against number nine Texas Tech, who sit slightly behind BYU even though they do have that head-to-head win.
- 41:48We're talking resumes, not specific results.
- 41:50You get it.
- 41:51The College Football Playoff committee gets 21 out of 25 correct.
- 41:54They miss North Texas at number 16.
- 41:56They also miss James Madison and two Mountain West schools and UNLV and San Diego State.
- 42:02Their biggest reach is Pitt at College Football Playoff ranking number 22 but at CSR number 34.
- 42:10With one week to go in the regular season, we can assume there are five locks at this point according to the CSR for the playoff, Texas A&M, Indiana, Georgia, Ohio State, and Ole Miss, the top five teams in the poll.
- 42:22Texas Tech with a week 13 bye is borderline Going into the last weekend of the season, how a team's opponents have fared is now mattering just as much how teams have performed on the field themselves.
- 42:36So the, uh, transitive property wins and losses value is catching up to the direct wins and losses value.
- 42:44Thanksgiving weekend, rivalry weekend, we got Texas A&M versus Texas, Ohio State-Michigan, Georgia-Georgia Tech, Oklahoma versus LSU, Oregon versus Washington, Notre Dame versus Stanford.
- 42:55But the ACC is the worst of the Power Four teams on a level with the Mountain West, so this is not going to boost Notre Dame's resume as much as they were hoping.
- 43:04Vanderbilt plays Tennessee and Miami, who sits in that l- 12 spot in the playoff committee, but number 17 in the CSR, takes on Pittsburgh, who did manage a CFP ranking but sits a little bit lower here in the common sense rankings.
- 43:19The ACC having so many rivals, rivalries with the SEC could theoretically win all of those games and flip the script on the SEC, who again currently sits better than every other conference on head-to-head records.
- 43:31It didn't come to fruition, but that is something to look forward to in future years if the SEC and ACC records are close going into that final weekend, which conference could flip the script?
- 43:42Texas upsets Texas A&M, moving Texas A&M down to number four.
- 43:47Ohio State finally has their spot in the CSR that matches their ranking in the AP and the CFP polls.
- 43:54They move up to number one.
- 43:55Georgia is at number two at 11 and 1, and Indiana sits at number three at an unblemished 12 and 0.
- 44:03The college football playoff first round matchups based on CSR would be number five BYU against number 16 Miami, who gets in over number 12 Vandy because we need to have five conferences.
- 44:13Number six Ole Miss versus number 15 North Texas, who kick Notre Dame out of the playoff.
- 44:18Number seven Oklahoma versus number 10 Texas Tech.
- 44:21And number eight Alabama versus number nine Oregon.
- 44:25While BYU is at number five in the CSR, they are at number 11 in the CFP rankings, making it a very important game against Texas Tech, who's flip-flopped.
- 44:34They're number 10 in the CSR, but number four in the AP.
- 44:37Those two teams facing off in the Big 12 championship is crucial for both teams.
- 44:42Texas is the top three loss team after beating the former number one team Texas A&M, and the best four loss team in the CSR ranks just outside the top 25 at number 28 in Arizona State.
- 44:55To the playoff committee's credit, they did get 22 of the top 25 teams correct with, you guessed it, three group of five teams being left out, Navy, UNLV, and South Florida being their misses.
- 45:07They continue to rank four loss Iowa, which is the lone CFP team with four losses, therefore giving them a boost to Oregon, who should be borderline going into conference championship week, but they sit at number five in the conference in the CFP rankings.
- 45:24There are nine locks according to the CSR.
- 45:27You've got Ohio State, Georgia, Indiana, BYU, which I say that fully knowing they are a number 11 in the CFP, and a loss would doom them.
- 45:34But in the CSR, they would be in.
- 45:37And then you've got Ole Miss, Oklahoma, Oregon, and probably Alabama, which leaves just three spots up for grabs, two of which have to go to conference champions from the ACC, American, and Sun Belt.
- 45:50So conference championship week, you know the drill.
- 45:52Ohio State versus Indiana, Georgia versus Alabama, BYU versus Texas Tech, North Texas versus Tulane, Virginia plays Duke in the ACC.
- 46:01A lot of people are watching that one closely because of the CFP implications.
- 46:05And then James Madison plays Troy in the Sun Belt Championship.
- 46:10The only qualms I have after conference championship week with the CFP top four is the order in which they were ranked.
- 46:16Indiana in the CSR is number one as well as in the College Football Playoff Committee rankings.
- 46:21Georgia is number two in the CSR, whereas they are ranked number three by the committee, flipping with Ohio State who should have been number three but were in fact number two.
- 46:30And then Texas Tech with their big win in the Big 12 Championship should have locked up the number four spot.
- 46:34I agree with the CFP committee on that.
- 46:38But the matchups for the first round should have been number five Texas A&M against number 15 James Madison as the fifth conference champion.
- 46:48They take Notre Dame's spot, who is sitting at number 12.
- 46:50Number six Ole Miss versus number 11 Tulane.
- 46:53Number seven BYU versus number 10 Alabama, and number eight Oklahoma versus number nine Oregon.
- 47:01Now, I say all this be- knowing that Miami made the national championship, hindsight being 2020.
- 47:08But given their resume, I would argue that BYU deserved to be in the playoff more than Miami.
- 47:15So I will assess the CFP committee getting 11 out of 12 as solid.
- 47:20They did miss Miami, again based on resume, not on future results, and they missed BYU getting in the playoff Other things to note, the Mountain West had too many good teams.
- 47:32They all split wins against each other.
- 47:34They just didn't have any great teams.
- 47:35So only Boise State getting to seven conference wins, they doomed the Mountain West, who was as good as the ACC in comparison to the other conferences in 2025.
- 47:45It also shows me that a 12-1 Sun Belt team in James Madison is in the same general ranking area as a nine and three SEC school in Texas, a ten and two Big 12 school in Utah, and a ten and two Miami out of the ACC, which to me feels about right, giving me more confidence in the CF- CSR rankings.
- 48:05But going into 2026, that slate is wiped clean.
- 48:08Nothing from 2025 matters going into the 2026 season.
- 48:12So we'll erase the whiteboard, either digital or actual depending on your age, and we will start fresh here coming up in late August.
- 48:20Thank you for joining me on this recap of the 2025 college football season.
- 48:24As you're going about your day-to-day, use some common sense