Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 247- Peerless with Author Kurt Jensen
Transcript
- 0:02Hello everyone, and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcast and memories of Yesteryear.
- 0:07My name is Doug has and if you're tuning in Forgotten Hollywood for the
- 0:10first time, what I do on this podcast is take you on a journey
- 0:13back in time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may
- 0:17not know about. And today, very special guest with us on this episode
- 0:22Kurt Jensen, and he is here to talk about his book Peerless, Ruben
- 0:28Mammullion, Hollywood and Broadway. That was easy for me to say, but
- 0:34Kurt, welcome to Forgotten Hollywood. Well, thank you well, thank you
- 0:39for spending a few minutes of your busy day to be on this podcast with
- 0:44us and to talk about your book Peerless. And the question that I always
- 0:48start off with all my guests, especially the authors, is tell us a
- 0:52little bit about this book and what it's about and how it came about.
- 0:58Well, it came about because I was casting about for a subject to write
- 1:04about. I had recently been the researcher and interviewer for a book by Michael
- 1:11Schrego Victor Fleming, an American movie master, a biography that was written entirely
- 1:19without the benefit of a collected papers, because Fleming did not leave any behind.
- 1:26And so it's a book don almost entirely on interviews, which is a
- 1:32little like going up the face of l CAPI tan with your fingernails. And
- 1:40so I'd asked the cultural historian at the library at Congress. It was very
- 1:51nice, and I said, there's got to be something easier, and she
- 1:56said, the Mammalian papers we've had official since the end of two thousand and
- 2:01three, but we had to treat them extensively because of the cat urine.
- 2:09Not only just the aroma, but some of those papers had been soaked through
- 2:14because they were in a part of his house that where's the end of his
- 2:19life. He had forty cats. He and his wife had forty cats running
- 2:21around, most of them fearal. Wow. And they treated his living room
- 2:25like a sandbox. It just was awful. And she said, I can
- 2:32let you look at him while they're still being processed, and I said,
- 2:36yes, please. So that's where that started. That started actually in twenty
- 2:39nine and it takes them and it had taken them that long to get it
- 2:44in any kind of shape. And then they finally published the Finding Aid in
- 2:51twenty eleven and Mammonium left very good papers, including diaries, and diaries and
- 3:02correspondence are the spine of any good biography. And he didn't start keeping the
- 3:12diary regularly until right after his biggest nineteen twenty seventh success, a play called
- 3:17Porgy years later became the basis of Porgy and Fetz. And sometimes his diary
- 3:25was just sort of a calendar for whatever year it was, and other times
- 3:34he wrote down quite a lot of information, mostly while he's working on the
- 3:38movies. It's very unusual to see a director of a Broadway play, particularly
- 3:46a Broadway musical, to keep kind of a daily diary. It's just that
- 3:52stressful, right, And so he didn't do that for the Broadway shows he
- 3:58directed from nineteen twenty seventh through nineteen fifty, but he did record almost everything
- 4:04that ever happened to him on a movie set. And so you take that
- 4:12detail and run with it and try to you explained along the way what these
- 4:18plays were. A lot of them are not well known today. Some of
- 4:24them are undeserved. Some of them are like Saint Louis Woman, are undeservedly
- 4:30obscure. It's kind of it was very racial, but not in the not
- 4:36in a highly offensive way, the way that you could look at Porgy and
- 4:43even in the original Porgy invest and and he had his final Broadaway musical with
- 4:50a thing called Arms and the Girl, which had it was an adaptation of
- 4:58a play that had been successful in the nineteen thirties. But when they made
- 5:02the musical adaptation they gave they made they gave Pearl Bailey the part of a
- 5:09sardonic runaway sleigh who offers romantic advice. And you look at it and goes,
- 5:15oh, that one's never that show's never going to see day a lot
- 5:18again. So there's a lot of that. Absolutely, you know, I
- 5:23have to be completely honest with you. Until I came across this book,
- 5:28I didn't know a lot about Reuben. It's kind of one of the reasons
- 5:32why I picked it because I think it fits or he fits very well into
- 5:38the theme of our show Forgotten Hollywood, and that unfortunately, he's a name
- 5:42that a lot of people have kind of forgotten about. Yeah, his reputation
- 5:47rests on his first six films, all of the pre code films from Applause.
- 5:51In nineteen twenty nine, Very Queen Christina that was released in nineteen thirty
- 5:56four. But his historical importance does not come from that, but comes from
- 6:01his stage work, because he directed the original productions of Porgy and Besque,
- 6:08Oklahoma, and Carousel. Those three alone, you know, secured his reputation
- 6:15in the theater as somebody who could make a lot of money. Absolutely,
- 6:23he had difficulties. Well, the only reason he was left he left Paramount
- 6:29was Paramount went into receivership and so they just didn't I didn't tell him he
- 6:34was fired. They just didn't pick up his option. Yeah, and so
- 6:40he was. He'd done Queen Christina on loan at MGM and then kind of
- 6:47bounced around for a while and sort of took took a lot of one picture
- 6:51deals, which included Becky Sharp, which is the first full length Technicolor movie,
- 7:00And somehow his agent got him back to Paramount with a musical called High,
- 7:03Wide and Handsome, with lyrics and music by Jerome Current and Oscar Hammerstein.
- 7:15And you would think, well, that's a short fire hit, and
- 7:17then you watch it and realizing, oh, this is not working at all.
- 7:25Somehow from there he got a one picture deal with twentieth Century Fox to
- 7:31make the Mark of Zoro still still the defining Zoro film, and that made
- 7:40money, and so out of that he got a two picture contract. But
- 7:44a second film at Fox was Blood and Sand, the bullfighting Saga. And
- 7:53anytime Emolian was working with Technicolor, he had his own ideas about what looked
- 7:58good in Technicolor, including spring furniture and flowers black. At certain points,
- 8:09it's just a lot of a lot of excess. And although there was a
- 8:16the movie made a profit, it didn't make what the profit was supposed to
- 8:20have been because he ran into overtime. And his next picture after that,
- 8:26Rings on Their Fingers, was a b picture, bottom of the bill,
- 8:30black and white, and that was pretty much the not quite the end of
- 8:35him at Fox. He ended up on the basis of his Broadway hits.
- 8:39He could still get film work, and he was on Laura for a while,
- 8:46and then he got bounced out of that, and somehow he ended up
- 8:54at MGM again for Arthur Freed, making a musical adaption of Eugene O'Neil's only
- 9:01comedy Wilderness, which the adaptation was called Summer Holiday, which is a chopped
- 9:09up film now because test audiences you can see where audiences in nineteen test audiences
- 9:16at the beginning in nineteen forty seven would be indifferent to Mickey Rooney. It
- 9:22turns out the test audiences just hate hated him. Well, yeah, that
- 9:28was like more than in different You've got to really have bad test screenings to
- 9:33shelve a mood for an entire year, which is what an MGM didn't release
- 9:39until nineteen forty eight, chopped out almost half of musical numbers. It's very
- 9:45it's watchable now you can see that. You look at it for the elements
- 9:48in it, but as it was not a commercial success, and that in
- 9:56nineteen fifty six another offer from Arthur Freed, but far less money because after
- 10:05the war, producers were independant units within the studio, so Boumolium was getting
- 10:09paid out of Arthur Fried's money, not MGM's money, and so for about
- 10:15a third of what he had earned on High, Wide and Handsome, he
- 10:20got the film adaptation of the Broadway musical Self Stockings, which is a musical
- 10:26adaptation of the film in the Natchka. That didn't make money either. As
- 10:35nice nice as it is, it was just that was sort of the end
- 10:37of that era. You know, people weren't going to flock to the movie
- 10:41just because Fredistaire and Centuries were in it right and Janis Paige you just passed
- 10:48away And somehow his dream project was always to make the definitive movie Orgy and
- 11:00Bess, and he and Sam Goldwyn clash from the beginning, usually over mcmollian
- 11:09having his own publicists, which was seen as d class a at the time.
- 11:13Having your own publicist was something that Jane Mansfield did successfully at the time,
- 11:20but for a director to have his own publicist, it was just something
- 11:22to be for a studio chief to be annoyed about, because that meant that
- 11:28he could not control all the information that would go out about a movie.
- 11:33Sure, and after the studio fire, which meant that mcmollian was, under
- 11:43the terms of his contract, was working for free, and he complained about
- 11:48that, but gold will let him go on that, replacing him for the
- 11:52second time with Auto Premature, who had replaced him on Laura fourteen years before,
- 12:00and Mamonium was just white hot with his anger. After that, went
- 12:07to the director's guild to see if he could get a double a dual credit
- 12:13on the movie, and the word was you at least had to have directed
- 12:18scenes that appeared in the picture, and so they said he couldn't get the
- 12:22double credit. Somehow, after this, in nineteen fifty nine, again through
- 12:31I think the producer Walter Wayinger, he got back to Fox, which was
- 12:37after Darryl Zanni had left an independent production and they were going to make a
- 12:45historical film of Cleopatra based on this guy's book. That started out it's kind
- 12:50of a modestly budgeted historical picture at a nice little cute thing with perhaps Joan
- 12:58Collins or Dana Winter, one of those two stars. But they had an
- 13:03inkling that they could get Elizabeth Taylor then, at the absolute height of her
- 13:09negotiation powers. She knew how to drive a deal, and when she came
- 13:16on that became this sort of the big budget behemoth. But the arguments on
- 13:22that were all over a single scene called the carpet scene, where she arrives
- 13:28I guess behind the military lines and gets smuggled into meet juliaus Caesar, and
- 13:35that argument went on for weeks and weeks and weeks and weeks, and Mamolian
- 13:41and his diary it is clear he never blamed Elizabeth Taylor for anything he should
- 13:46have, but he didn't have the cloud to tell her to not do what
- 13:50she was doing. Right. Finally, and when the picture and he couldn't
- 13:56do any shooting of her, he didn't shoot any scenes with her, and
- 14:03the British authorities through what was called the edy Levey. The eed Levee was
- 14:09a surcharge on tickets in Britain and with the money from that, the British
- 14:16government would lure American filmmakers make your pictures in Britain. And so they had
- 14:24one of those deals, and they started shooting in London in the fall of
- 14:30nineteen fifty nine. No, no, that fall in nineteen sixty and winter
- 14:35it was a blusteret autumn and they turned into a very cold and wet and
- 14:41rainy autumn, and so they couldn't do much shooting outside. And finally things
- 14:50just there were these constant arguments over the script, and finally, in January
- 14:54sixty one, Mamorian said, Okay, I'm out of here, and he
- 15:00never made a movie again. He didn't direct that, he brought away shows
- 15:03again. Although he had offers, he had good offers. He had a
- 15:07semi solid offer to direct what became Hello Dolly, Oh Wow. If he
- 15:13had really expressed interest. He could have been the director of Filler on the
- 15:16roof Wow, I know, but at that point he was not so interested.
- 15:24He didn't He was a creature of a theater guild, of the original
- 15:28deal people who ran it from the nineteen twenties on, and when those people
- 15:33were not in the picture that he didn't really trust anybody that he hadn't known
- 15:41for a long time by then. So that's his career condensed about as much
- 15:48as I could make it. Yeah, absolutely, correct me if I'm wrong.
- 15:52But I was trying to do some research obviously when I got the book
- 15:56and knew that we were going to be doing this recording. But as far
- 15:58as I can tell, this is really the the research the book on Ruben's
- 16:06life. There's not a lot of books out there regarding him. Is that
- 16:11correct? Or Am I wrong? Now? That was the idea was to
- 16:15do a real biography people. He's very accessible because he talked so much.
- 16:22He gave oral histories and interviews. And from nineteen sixty one on, when
- 16:29filmmakers of his era started to get, you know, the acclamation that they've
- 16:33always thought that they wanted, but the acclamation went to them and not the
- 16:37studios for where they were sure, and he gave. He talked to dissertation
- 16:45writers who asked him some very piercing intelligent questions about his theories of movement in
- 16:55the theater, not so much about details about his film hm and so people
- 17:03have done little bits of stuff about elements of what he has done, particularly
- 17:11in movies, but yeah, this is the first. It's usually. It
- 17:15helped that he had diaries, sure, sure, because you could track him
- 17:19throughout his life and letters to his parents and a whole lot of stuff like
- 17:26that. So I was real, I was real pleased. I mean,
- 17:32it took a long time, and the ending of his life is very sad
- 17:38because his wife is Adia, who was an alcoholic, developed dementia and he
- 17:45didn't put her in a home. He took care he had cancer. By
- 17:51the time his prostate cancer was diagnosed, it was pretty far along and so
- 17:56there wasn't like a surgical treatment of available that would have taken care of That
- 18:02was late in his life, like about nineteen eighty five, and then lifetimes
- 18:06spun out of control for the last three years with the fearal cats running all
- 18:11over the house and them running out of money, and he eventually got put
- 18:17into the Los Angeles conservatorship. And I had asked the editorial director at the
- 18:23University of Wisconsin Press when I was discussing it, I said, just so
- 18:30you understand, this book has a very sad ending, right, And he
- 18:34said, why does every ending have to be happy? It's a biography.
- 18:41Sure, And I knew how he had found the right publisher at that at
- 18:48that point, because the versions of this book had knocked around for a while
- 18:52before Wisconsin started paying attention to it late in twenty nineteen. And that's great
- 19:00that you had somebody that wanted to kind of be true to the story.
- 19:07Yeah, and to figure out where Mamolian was telling the truth and which is
- 19:18always in the theater. He was truthful with motion pictures. You just you
- 19:22don't expect anybody all the time, not not certainly if his error the silent
- 19:29director, the silent Ara directors were even worse. They were just they knew
- 19:33how to improve his story so that when they told one, yeah, Alan
- 19:37Duan was did that a lot. Uh. And to sort of see if
- 19:47Mammolian took any giant missteps. I don't think he would have lasted on Porgy
- 19:55and Best no matter what. Because of the way that Sam Goldwin was at
- 19:59the time, he could have probably saved himself directing Laura in nineteen forty four.
- 20:11But he was always the outsider getting edged aside by the studio insider,
- 20:15which is what Auto Premengure always was. And he was very but his bitterness
- 20:22about Premenger didn't come to the four until after the Porgy and Best film.
- 20:29But I mean it just really really consumed him. All these letters and all
- 20:33these notes and referring to Premature as the methetic scum and imagine getting that angry
- 20:41over Auto Premonger. Wow. Yeah, when he held a grudge, he
- 20:48held a grudge, right, Yeah, but he was I only had to
- 20:55concentrate on the original Broadway productions of Porgy and Bess and Oklahoma and Kears,
- 21:04which saves a lot of time. You just have to see what he did.
- 21:10And he has certain things like the saucer funeral in Poory in nineteen twenty
- 21:18seven. He reproduced that about three or four times, including in a couple
- 21:23of his films, and his idea of synchronized street sounds. He called it
- 21:33the symphony of Noise, he repeated, and his film Loved Me Tonight,
- 21:37which is undoubtedly his best film, as almost as virtually a perfect musical with
- 21:45the the scores. You know, there's always music to go with the movement,
- 21:52and that was not always done in nineteen thirty two, and that was
- 21:56Richard Rodgers and Loren's heart mh. And he repeated looking at his nose,
- 22:04he repeated some of the staging and the poor you even when he was doing
- 22:07Carousel. Uh yeah, so he had. He was very much respected for
- 22:18the for Oklahoma and Carousel. So somebody like Arthur Freed would have been hopeful
- 22:23that, oh he can make magic with this too. Although with Summer Holiday,
- 22:30which is perfectly nice, and most of the score is out there,
- 22:36you can get recording with most almost all of the cut numbers. It's perfectly
- 22:41fine. It's just the audiences didn't care for Mickey Rooney at that point.
- 22:45Sure, yeah he didn't. You know. It wasn't indifference. It was
- 22:49like, wow, they hated it, So you try to. I don't
- 22:57have a lot of movie stories because movies were so long ago. I didn't
- 23:04have nearly as many interviews. I did find a dancer from Silk Stockings who
- 23:10talked about being unable to handle sid Cherice's power, so we accidentally dropped their
- 23:15ones. There weren't a lot of Fred Astaire stories because Fred and Herme's pen
- 23:25came into the project with their own ideas about what they were going to do
- 23:29and what they were not going to do. And as a result, the
- 23:32one pure Manmoralian touched with silk stockings is said Cherie, and the lingerie that
- 23:38was I know, that's the whole thing is entirely Mamalian's idea, and it's
- 23:44wonderful and it's graceful, and said Cheris knew when that film came out that
- 23:48was probably her best work effort. Well, Kert, we're unfortunately out of
- 23:56time here, but I want to thank you for coming on to talk about
- 24:00your book Peerless into our audience. I strongly would encourage you to go out
- 24:06and get a copy of the book Peerless. Ruben Mamoon's Hollywood and Broadway.
- 24:14This is the type of story that why we started this podcast over three years
- 24:18ago, is to try to bring about some knowledge about some of these stars
- 24:23that unfortunately are no longer thought about in the way that they should be.
- 24:30Oh, I'll leave you with one cool story, all right, great,
- 24:34because it's a Greta Garbo story. Okay, Garbo is the marketable element and
- 24:41the book I figured out not so much other people. After Queen Christina Wrap,
- 24:48he and Garbo went on a road trip and it was written about in
- 24:52all the papers when they got to the Grand Cany. But he took snapshaws
- 24:59along the way like anybody else takes take would take vacation snapshots. He had
- 25:04those developed the same way anybody else had their vacation snapshots developed at the time.
- 25:11Took them to the drug store, you know, that's that's where you
- 25:15used to take your your pictures, and he had had them developed there.
- 25:22I don't know what the poor kid in the dark Rond was thinking when he
- 25:25saw who it was in the photo, But the photos proved that there was
- 25:30more to the trip. They were in Laquinta, California, and Teaz,
- 25:33New Mexico before they got to the Grand Canyon. So even though nobody knows
- 25:40whether that relationship ever got to the romantic stage, it was about a whole
- 25:45week longer than anybody ever knew about. Wow, that's that's Garbo. As
- 25:51she wanted to keep a secret, she kept absolutely absolutely well again, Kurt,
- 25:57thank you so much for coming on spending a few minutes, well glad
- 26:00to do it. And please to the audience, please go out and get
- 26:03a copy of Peerless. I don't think you're going to be disappointed. And
- 26:07a curt good luck on the success of the selling of this book. Well,
- 26:11thank you very much. Wait pass some events coming up, not so
- 26:18much about probably more movie events than live performing arts events because those get to
- 26:25be very expensive. But sure, I'm going to be very patient, absolutely
- 26:33absolutely well. Best wishes to you and in your success of the book.
- 26:37And again, thank you and thank you for listening to this episode of for
- 26:40Goarding on Hollywood. Just search for Doug Hester Forgot on Hollywood. You can
- 26:42also find me on Twitter or Instagram at hes doug fourteen. If you listen
- 26:47to this podcast on iTunes and another podcast service, please subscribe, rate and
- 26:51review this episode. Tune in next time for little episode of for gott on
- 26:53Hollywood. Thank you for listening and we will see you then.