Latest / Automotive State of The Union / FTC Red Flags In Reviews, Hybrids Surge In May, Ram’s AI Oops
Transcript
- 0:00Just- Good morning, it is Thursday. What month is it? June 4th. [laughs] It's the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. It's Kyle Mats here.
- 0:09Today we're talking about why we think maybe the FTC flagged who they did from some data analys- analysis from our friends at Wide Whale. Hey. Hey. It's a pretty wild one. I love the reverse engineering here.
- 0:20Also gonna talk about hybrids in May and, uh, little, little, uh, overuse of AI by the, by the Ram creative team. I, I got to see this one, like, right as it happened- [laughs]... actually.
- 0:33And I probably should- Oh, yeah... have flagged it. We probably should have run the story- It's all good... but it was, it was, it was, it's an absolute mess, man. The story's in the email today, actually. Yeah.
- 0:39Story's in the email today. The story is in the email. So if you wanna go read the email before we get to minute 10, go do it. And see the picture. [laughs] Yeah, just spoiler. It is. It's great. Spoiler. Uh- Spoiler...
- 0:47all the ASOTU CON sessions are starting to go live. These are all the quick shot 15-ish minute podcasts we do on the floor- Oh, these are good... at ASOTU CON.
- 0:55I'm excited because these are the ones that I put, I listen to the whole playlist 'cause I only got to experience one. I only did one ASOTU CON session this year. Did you do any?
- 1:07Well, I did, I mean, it was a 40-minute session, so I did three podcasts, but- Okay... only one session, I guess, if you call it that, you know. I think I only- Yeah... I think I- I'm excited about them.
- 1:19I hope they're all- I maybe did two... So my next flight, I love listening to these on a flight- Yes... at, like, one and a half speed. Yes. My next... Are we talking about next Wednesday? Can we talk about that yet?
- 1:30Are we allowed to talk about that? Hold on. I don't know. Hold on. I'm, I'm- Should we leave- I'm just trying to remember what I'm doing next Wednesday. I don't think so. You don't remember what you're doing?
- 1:38We're going to Florida. Oh, I do. [laughs] What's in Florida, Paul? I have so... [laughs] Well, the next week I was thinking there's, like, two things that I
- 1:46can talk about one, but not about the other one next week- [laughs]... 'cause it's got an embargo, right? [laughs] It's like, man, I'm starting to feel like- That's perfect...
- 1:52maybe we'll make great, I don't even know what, what time. Uh, yeah, I think we could, I mean, do we talk about it? Yeah. We're going to hang out with, with Yossi. Yes. We're going down to hang out with Yossi at HQ.
- 2:02We may or may not be recording some content. I don't know. [laughs] We'll, we'll talk more about it, but you can follow along. But why did you bring that up?
- 2:07But I hope, I hope all of the sessions are live by then, 'cause that's my plane time. Oh, that's your next flight? I got two and a half hours on a flight down there. I'm gonna rip through them all. [laughs] Nah.
- 2:15See, yeah, yeah. See, I have a drive into work that takes about 15, 20 minutes. Oh, what a dream. So I could... I, it really is the best. You can fit two in. I know. I can fit four a day. Wow. Four a day.
- 2:24But by the end of the day, I'm usually pretty cooked, so- I can't do podcasts at the end of the day... End of the day- There's no way... I'm like, it's, like, music only or silence.
- 2:31If you listen to this podcast at the end of your day, kudos to you. You know what? We hope we, we hope it gives you some happiness. You know what?
- 2:36We need to even give a shout-out right now to Joel Bassam because he sent me a picture- Every day... at the end of the day.
- 2:42At the, he said, "Just catching up on podcasts," and he sent me a picture of the Airport Extreme. It was the device I was trying to... It was called the Airport Extreme. Oh, yes.
- 2:52It's the big, it's the router with the hard drive storage in it. Yes. He literally sent me a picture of it. He was like, "Just catching up." Dude, Joel is so good. Thank you, Joel.
- 2:58That brother keeps us on, on, on task with the podcast- He really does... I'll tell you that. He really does. Hey, this is actually... Well, okay, okay, okay. Well, no, we're not even going over this one today.
- 3:07Dang, damn it. [laughs] I've- Go ahead, talk about it. Whatever. [laughs] Well, uh, uh, y- you even messaged it. I thought we were going over the Carvana slate thing. Nope. Not today. Okay.
- 3:18[laughs] Just Joel's, Joel, someone put this in somewhere. Maybe I'll talk to Chris about writing it up, but nobody's talking about it. Carvana quietly, just quietly, poof, processing fees all gone. And they had them.
- 3:32They had some processing fees, but they are just- Whoa... whoop, no longer existing. So if you wanna know what- Ooh, paying attention... they're paying attention to on what's happening with this first story- Wow...
- 3:43you might, you know, just start thinking about that- Oh my gosh... 'cause they're selling a bunch of new cars. This is like it's- They also, they also won the... Man, we got, there's so much that we could talk about.
- 3:53[laughs] They also, uh, reportedly sold over almost 650 new Stellantis vehicles in their Phoenix location, which everybody was like, "Holy cow, how did, would they do that? They did 300 or so before, the month before."
- 4:10Just so you know, Tempe air is only, Arizona, only about 25 minutes away from Phoenix, is where they have a massive call center. So I don't know, there might be a tie into their- Oh my gosh...
- 4:22some employee deals on those Stellantis cars. Oh, maybe we should get to... Okay, let's talk about today's stories. There's a lot going- Let's do it... a lot going on right now. Goodness. Uh, this is so interesting.
- 4:30When the FTC warned dozens of dealerships about potentially deceptive advertising practices, it wasn't out of left field.
- 4:36A new study found that those same stores were generating significantly more customer complaints about- Wow... pricing, advertising, and trust issue than the industry average.
- 4:46So, uh, fr- our friends at Wide Whale analyzed Google reviews from dealer groups that received the warning letters and found that they did, as a whole group, right, they didn't isolate any, so there's averages at play.
- 4:57But as an average, generated more complaints tied to pricing, advertising, and trust. Overall ratings, uh, didn't tell the whole story.
- 5:03The FTC-targeted stores, uh, the ones the FTC targeted, still average 4.34 stars, only slightly beh- below the industry average of 4.49. So still pretty strong, right? Strong ratings.
- 5:16Um, but maybe is m- masking a few concerns. Reviews mentioning pricing were 44% more likely to be negative at a dealership that received an FTC letter- Whoa...
- 5:27while complaints about honesty and transparency were also notably immeasurably higher.
- 5:31The biggest gap showed up in advertising and bait-and-switch complaints, customers mentioning those issues more than twice as often as reviewers across the broader industry.
- 5:41[whistles] Wide Whale Director of Marketing Jake Hughes said, quote, "This is an early warning system.
- 5:45There are signals here they, that say these issues the FTC cares about are showing up, and it might be worth looking into." I'm, I'm actually bullish- Data...
- 5:55on the fact that I bet you the FTC utilized publicly available reviews. Well, they will be now if they weren't before. No, they, they 100% did. If this is a trend- What else are they gonna use?
- 6:04What else are they gonna use? Yeah. They got a little auditor going around to 17,000 dealerships in the country? No, absolutely not. Big auditor. You, that's what we, we flagged it the other day.
- 6:12They, they-On this list are single rooftops. There's no auditor at the FTC going through and being like, "I wonder how to price and calling." Like, they lo- they use publicly available review data.
- 6:23Well, in two- I guarantee it... in two weeks, um, likely going to be on the ground in Washington, DC at the CBT, uh, event that is talking about this. That's right.
- 6:34I'm gonna ask an F- if I'm there, I'm gonna, like, do the old walk up with a microphone and ask the FTC guy, like, "Are you using reviews to flag the dealerships?" Yo, do it.
- 6:44And I'll just m- I'll just make you- Just Friday next week... confirm or deny. Confirm or deny. Confirm or deny. No, but a friendly face. It's always a friendly face. It's not a gotcha moment either. No.
- 6:51We just want the facts. We just wanna know. No, but just- It's just a question... look, I think that if anything, if, if, like, look at your reviews. This is easy. It's actually quite easy.
- 7:01If that's the data set, then it's, I mean, just pay, we've been talking about paying attention to reviews forever, but people have a special attention.
- 7:05Yo, just quad go look at your reviews and be like, "Yo, are we, are we at risk of, like- Yes... our customers?" Yes. Done.
- 7:13And I'm sure, I'm sure our friends at Y Well will be happy to help you do this as well, and I think- I'm sure they will...
- 7:17uh, super thankful that they brought this correlation up because, like, again, people wanna be compliant. We wanna know what's up, and this is an accountability mechanism that'll help people to- Absolutely...
- 7:28be compliant and raise the bar in the industry and not have so many of those negative complaints, which makes this an industry people wanna fight to join. Come on.
- 7:35Want people to be like, "Why can't more businesses- Bring that around... be like the car dealers?" That's what they're gonna say in the future. Why can't more businesses be like car dealers?
- 7:43That's what they're gonna say- That is... in the not too distant future. There you go. Speaking of the current, though. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Not the future. It's happening right now.
- 7:51EV momentum is cooling down a little bit, but gas prices going up. Hybrids having a major moment. Rising gas prices- Yes...
- 7:57averaging over 4.26 a gallon are pushing shoppers with that fuel efficiency question top of mind. Hybrids are up 33% in May compared to last year, while overall new vehicle sales are down 4.4% through May. Wow.
- 8:12Subaru's hybrid Forester and Crosstrek are outperforming their gas-only counterparts, despite only, uh, a few thousand dollars in additional cost. Automakers are leaning in. Toyota's RAV4 is now hybrid only.
- 8:24Jeep is bringing back the Cherokee with a hybrid option and, uh, a no gas own- and no gas only version. You buy the hybrid. That's it.
- 8:32Brands like Nissan and Volkswagen are also trying to, as best they can, to get hybrid, uh, offerings expanded.
- 8:37Subaru of America VP of Sales, Troy Posten said, quote, "We see this as a growing trend, not only this year, but every year moving forward." Someone please pull up the receipts. No, we got them on this.
- 8:49We got them on this. [laughs] I, look, we've been calling out Toyota as, as the entrant to say hybrids are the one to, to win.
- 8:56Two years ago at their dealer council, they talked about how they can basically produce a hybrid vehicle at the rate of 1,000 to one, uh, of an EV on the battery, battery capabilities, and then they've been doing it since the late '90s.
- 9:07Mm-hmm. And now a lot of manufacturers are scrambling to try and figure that out. You see, and then you see gas prices, and the moment to capitalize on that is the 33% hybri- hybrid sale.
- 9:18If you're not putting those out front, talking about what hybrids you have, putting out videos about hybrid capabilities, what the differences are between their gas counterparts, you, you are missing out- Give the people what they want...
- 9:29on a critical opportunity. Give the people what they want. Give them what they want. Oh my gosh, this comment's got me good. Hold on. Oh, my. Chris Reeves on our team says, "Paul J.
- 9:38Michael Moore daily" about me walking up asking questions. Totally not true at all. That is not, that's the furthest thing. I'm- That's not how it's gonna go...
- 9:45I'm gonna be more like that School of Hard Knocks kid, James whatever his name is, who's like the nicest kid ever. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. I'm just gonna walk. I'm like, "Sir, sir, is this your FTC department? Oh, it is?
- 9:54Well, [laughs] how many regulations did you f- find violations for last year? Wow, that's a lot. What would you say to the next generation of people that wanna find violations of regulations?
- 10:03Would they look at reviews maybe on Google?" Maybe. That's, that's how I'll ask the question. [laughs] Yeah. Speaking of asking questions. Hey. Hold on. Stop. Segway. Time.
- 10:15[upbeat music] Lots of people were asking questions of this one because even though AI is supposed to save time, it's definitely not supposed to create an accidental brand crossover.
- 10:25RAM found itself in an awkward spot after merchandise sold through its official online store appeared to feature a Toyota Tacoma- Mm-mm... disguised as a RAM alongside a mathematically challenged American flag.
- 10:37I mean, just the stars. [laughs] I didn't even see that part of the story. I don't know if you've seen the stars there. We got, yeah, five by nine. We got Green- we got Greenland in there.
- 10:46We got- We're d- How many are in there? No, we're down to like 45, uh- Oh, we lost a few. Yeah, we lost a few. Five. Which ones did we lose? I think it's five by eight. We, we, we, we dropped down.
- 10:53What were we willing to give up? Yeah. I don't know. Well, Texas already left. They're already headed out, so. [laughs] Maybe a Texan made this. May- maybe a Texan made this, for sure.
- 11:01No, they wouldn't have messed up the Tacoma part. That's right.
- 11:04[laughs] Uh, so if you haven't seen it, basically there's a RAM badge on, if you know cars, what looks almost identical to a second generation Toyota Tacoma.
- 11:15Uh, the issue showed up on multiple products, including this T-shirt, a large banner, and, uh, at least one of the items, the T-shirt, was removed from sale. Yeah.
- 11:24The artwork also included an American flag with 40 stars instead of 50. [laughs] The mistake obviously sh- uh, is a growing trend of AI-generated imagery that people aren't taking a double look at.
- 11:36I mean- And this one stormed the Reddit threads, and then, and the good, the, the, the fun, uh, the fun notes. This is on carscoops.com, but- I feel like-... what a genius... I feel like- What a crazy thing...
- 11:48this is somebody's boss being like, "Fine, I'll do it," right? 'Cause they were like- Ugh... "I have Gemini." You're so right. And they were like- Didn't go through a review process. No. It did- no.
- 11:59No, like, professional creative is gonna not see that, especially the stars. Psh. You know? So I don't know. They're not offset like they're supposed to. I mean, it's just wild. It's all, it's all, it's all...
- 12:12I mean, [laughs] I'm starting- Fam, check your creative... well, listen. Well, listen. Please check your creative.
- 12:16Now, so now, you know you had the em dash thing, then, then we talk about, well, like, well, actually, is, like, another tell, right? Honestly. It's honestly, it's not this, it's this, or all the word tells.
- 12:27But now, like, all the visual tells are starting to happen, right?
- 12:29Like, now, like, if someone designs a one-sheet or a banner and it's got, like, the well-organized icons, it has too many words on it if it's a visual thing, right?
- 12:38But if you're not, like, used to making things that communicate visually, you're gonna look at it and you're gonna be like, "Oh, this is great." Yeah. Like that, that part in Happy Gilmore.
- 12:44He's like, "I'm the sm-" or what is that? Not Happy Gilmore. Billy Madison. He's like, stands up, "I'm the smartest man alive," right? He spelled couch or something, right? [laughs] And so, uh, yes. Yes.
- 12:53Check, check your creative. Just check your- Especially- Check your words... if you're a multi, multi-billion dollar publicly traded brand, like- Ugh. Brutal...
- 13:01don't, don't, don't save the $100 on the hours for the creative, if you know what I'm saying. Make, let someone make the real thing. [laughs] Let someone make the real thing.
- 13:09Although they could lean into the memeification of that if they were to spun it a certain way. If they're smart, they're leaning all in. Yeah, I don't know. We'll see what happens, but I hope you had fun today.
- 13:17Get out there and, uh, serve some people, huh? [laughs] [upbeat music]