Latest / Politics with Paul / Blame, "Both Sides-ing," and Whataboutism: When Are These Appropriate? | Politics with Paul #84
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul Podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:08I was gonna wear this hat here because the University of South Florida is going to the
- 0:12NCAA tournament for men's basketball, but it's kind of screwing up with the lighting.
- 0:16But I just had to get that out of the way because I, as a huge fan of my undergraduate
- 0:20alma mater sports, am super excited for that, and we've got March Madness upon us.
- 0:25Anyways, today we're gonna talk about blame, both sidesing, and what about ism.
- 0:32These interrelated concepts are things I think about often in these lines of work of civic
- 0:39education and depolarization.
- 0:42The vast majority of political disputes often center on these issues.
- 0:47And no matter what political issue is at hand or group or party is being talked about, at
- 0:54least one of these concepts of blame and both sidesing and what about ism crop up.
- 1:00Whenever we come across problems we're trying to solve, we naturally wanna find some source
- 1:05that is at fault and blame it for all of our ills.
- 1:08And if we just fix that source and it almost always seems to involve a nefarious person in
- 1:14our minds, we'll fix that problem and everything will just be hunky dory.
- 1:18Whenever we are invested in an argument and strongly believe we are right, we often get mad
- 1:24at an outside source trying to give credence to other viewpoints, and we accuse such sources of
- 1:30quote unquote both sidesing a debate where two sides of an argument are given a false
- 1:36equivalence.
- 1:37And whenever somebody accuses us of being at fault for something or doing something wrong,
- 1:42we often turn around and say, Yeah, but what about when you did that same thing that one
- 1:47time?
- 1:48Whether we admit faults but our pride is hurt, or we believe that the accuser is wrong, It's a
- 1:55very common thing that happens in politics.
- 1:57But here's the thing, these aren't necessarily always wrong attitudes to engage in.
- 2:04Sometimes there is one thing or person that is primarily, if not solely to blame for a
- 2:10problem.
- 2:11An accusation of both sidesing an issue might be true because one side may not have a leg to
- 2:17stand on and we're just being centrist for the sake of being centrist.
- 2:21And what aboutism might be reasonable if the accuser is a complete hypocrite in what they
- 2:27are complaining about.
- 2:28But even so, blame accusations of both sidesing and whataboutism sometimes aren't the right
- 2:36approach, or they may be justified but still unhelpful.
- 2:41So when do you know that one of these things is the right thing to do?
- 2:48That's a very difficult line to draw and there's a lot of subjectivity to it.
- 2:54But these are problems that we need to address because I believe they are prominent reasons
- 2:59for the stark divide we see in politics today.
- 3:03So I want to explore that some today and hopefully contribute to a solution down the
- 3:08road.
- 3:08This is admittedly a much more philosophical topic than a lot of the episodes we have of
- 3:14Politics with Paul, but the philosophical and the practical are both critical to engage in.
- 3:20So let's get into it and see where this goes.
- 3:23First of all, the blame game, the propensity for pointing fingers.
- 3:27Whenever we see a problem, whether this is real or perceived, our natural inclination is to
- 3:33want to try to fix it.
- 3:34There's nothing inherently wrong with that.
- 3:36If there's a problem, we don't want it to be a problem anymore, so we're going try to figure
- 3:40out what's causing that issue.
- 3:42But sometimes we're not even concerned about why the problem is there.
- 3:46We just see a problem or what we think is a problem and we go and try to solve it.
- 3:51And so, that's natural human inclination as a huge source of why we see a lot of blaming in
- 3:58politics because blaming is everywhere in politics.
- 4:02Maybe it's the only constant that there has ever been in politics no matter what factions
- 4:08or parties crop up, whatever political issues at hand, there's always somebody to blame for
- 4:12something.
- 4:12Somebody else is always the problem.
- 4:15It's always somebody else.
- 4:16It's never us.
- 4:17It's never people that think like us unless they step out of line in some way in our minds.
- 4:22So maybe it's Republicans always complaining about Democrats.
- 4:25Democrats always complaining about Republicans.
- 4:27Maybe independents are complaining about both Republicans and Democrats, and maybe
- 4:31Republicans and Democrats are complaining about independents.
- 4:34And in a similar vein, it might be conservatives and liberals going at each other,
- 4:38and then they complain about people that are considered moderates.
- 4:42Really, you can just come up with any sort of partisan ideological or issue faction at hand,
- 4:48and you can see that there's some sort of blame game going around.
- 4:52But sometimes, just blame isn't enough.
- 4:55We have to say that the source, often a person or a group of people, cabal even, they're evil
- 5:02and they want to destroy everybody.
- 5:04It's not about, oh, that they think that this one thing might be right.
- 5:07No, they're just stupid and dumb and evil and it just can't be trusted.
- 5:13So, you see that all the time, and blame is often fraught with biases.
- 5:20We believe so strongly that we are right, that we can't possibly be wrong, and it's
- 5:26uncomfortable to even admit we could be wrong, let alone when we are wrong.
- 5:32And look, it happens to all of us.
- 5:35I don't necessarily like admitting that I'm wrong.
- 5:38We want to be right.
- 5:40And there's not anything inherently wrong with that, but sometimes that goes too far.
- 5:44And it drives a lot of our interactions and politics, and we try to quote unquote win at
- 5:49everything.
- 5:50And we're also not inclined to look at nuance.
- 5:53It's an either or proposition always for us because nuance takes a lot more brainpower to
- 5:59think about, and usually it's not conducive to winning because people don't want to think that
- 6:02hard.
- 6:03They just want to say, this thing is wrong.
- 6:06This thing is right.
- 6:07I like this thing that is right.
- 6:09And it's also the the fact that humans naturally engage in in group out group
- 6:13dynamics.
- 6:14There's always our in group, our people that they always get everything right.
- 6:18And if one of them steps out of line, oh, that's just an exception to the rule.
- 6:21They're not really one of us, some other sort of excuse.
- 6:24And then if somebody in the out group happens to do something right, well, they're an
- 6:28exception to the rule or they're they're one of the good ones, as you sometimes will hear.
- 6:33Now, there's nothing inherently wrong with wanting to be part of a group because it's
- 6:38natural for humans to do that we want to belong to something.
- 6:41And so we we create these dividing lines, which often go too far, but we create these dividing
- 6:48lines of, well, this group is more like me.
- 6:50I feel safe with them.
- 6:52I we all wanna find people that have common interest to us even outside of politics.
- 6:57But, again, this in group out group dynamic often is very problematic.
- 7:02The out group is always a problem.
- 7:04It's not the in group.
- 7:05There might be certain individuals that buck the trend or the exceptions to the rule, but
- 7:11they're few and far between.
- 7:13And when it comes to blame, we're not really incentivized to say, was wrong or I could do
- 7:20better or my group is wrong or my group can do better unless we absolutely have to.
- 7:25Like, if it if it's conducive to us winning elections or policy battles.
- 7:31But oftentimes, admitting some sort of fault even if you're not taking full blame, it's
- 7:37usually not conducive to winning elections because most hardcore voters who are having an
- 7:42outsized influence on politics are the very partisan or the very ideological.
- 7:48They're the ones who participate at outsized rates.
- 7:50They're the ones who are having an outsized impact on politics.
- 7:53So sometimes it feels like people are much more partisan or ideological than they actually are
- 7:59because the people who are less given to a party or an ideology, they don't participate
- 8:04nearly as often in elections.
- 8:07And so because of this issue of the most rabidly partisan and ideological and
- 8:15opinionated having this outsized impact, it makes us not just those voters we're talking
- 8:23about, but people who are trying to court those voters far less likely to accept any blame or
- 8:29responsibility and far more likely to want to find blame elsewhere.
- 8:33So it's always, quote unquote, the other side, or maybe it's even the faithless members of our
- 8:40in group.
- 8:40So a lot of times you hear Democrats complain or Democrat, yeah, Democrats complain about
- 8:45Democrats in name only or dinos, and you hear Republicans complain about Republicans in name
- 8:50only or rhinos.
- 8:53It's those are the you know, it's that no true Scotsman fallacy.
- 8:57Oh, they're not they're not really part of us.
- 8:58They're they're actually making things more problematic.
- 9:02They are working against our own goals even though they say that they want our our
- 9:07interests at heart.
- 9:09And it's it's part of this whole problem with the obsession with winning, and we can't even
- 9:15give up an inch to consider that we might be at fault is anathema to us.
- 9:21It might even be considered immoral because a lot of very partisan or ideological people have
- 9:27highly moralized attitudes where they not only think they're right, but they think that they
- 9:33are morally just and that's even step outside just a little bit would be immoral of them to
- 9:41do so because they have figured out everything.
- 9:43They have figured out everything that is right and just in this world.
- 9:48But look, it's not realistic to expect anybody to never once blame somebody else.
- 9:56So when it comes to this question of whether we should engage in blaming, it's gonna happen at
- 10:01some point.
- 10:03Because again, finding a source to blame is a very human thing and it's not in of itself
- 10:08wrong because sometimes there is a source to blame for something.
- 10:13Might be multiple sources to blame.
- 10:16Blaming is not always a problem, and sometimes it is warranted.
- 10:21The real problem, however, is that we do it basically all the time.
- 10:26We can't go like a single conversation.
- 10:30I say general we obviously, I'm not saying every single person does this, but the real
- 10:36problem is that we just want to blame something all the time.
- 10:41We are just perpetually angry and wanting to find the source of all our ills.
- 10:47And that's that's obviously not the way to go about things.
- 10:50You can't just constantly find something else to blame and never accept responsibility
- 10:55yourself.
- 10:56The trick though is finding out when blame is appropriate and then whether or when another
- 11:03approach is actually warranted.
- 11:05Because sometimes there is truly a specific source to blame for an issue, like if if a
- 11:11politician says something very horrible and violent, objectively so, we should be calling
- 11:16them out for it.
- 11:17Nobody else made them say that thing.
- 11:19They are responsible for what they said.
- 11:21Just as one example.
- 11:23Sometimes it really is one person, one political party, one interest group, one
- 11:28ideology at fault for a given situation.
- 11:32But too often, our blaming of someone is couched in the fact that they think differently
- 11:37than us, not because we legitimately think they are wrong.
- 11:41So a Republican complaining about a Democrat or a Democrat complaining about a Republican and
- 11:44independent complaining about the parties or the parties complaining about independence.
- 11:48It's a lot of times not because, oh, we actually think they did something wrong or we
- 11:54may think they legitimately did something wrong, but we're still only complaining about
- 11:57it because they have different political views than us.
- 12:01And if you're always solely blaming somebody else, you're always blaming other people.
- 12:07You're always, it's always only the other side quote unquote or people that are that are not
- 12:14truly part of your in group as you've deemed it.
- 12:18Tow that they're not towing some line that you made up in your head.
- 12:22If it's always somebody else that's causing the problem, it might be time to take a look in the
- 12:27mirror because it's not always gonna be somebody else's fault.
- 12:31At some point in time, because we're humans and because we are naturally flawed, we're always
- 12:37gonna be at fault or we all have at least something that we're at fault for.
- 12:42It's just how it is.
- 12:44We have to be a lot more self aware about that.
- 12:47But even when we are justified in blaming people for something, it's not always helpful
- 12:53because oftentimes it just makes a situation worse because people don't like being blamed
- 12:58for things and people don't like being yelled at, which is a lot of times the form that blame
- 13:03comes in.
- 13:04Usually, it's not like, hey, I think you did this wrong though.
- 13:07It's like, you're so stupid.
- 13:09Why would you do this?
- 13:10It's a lot of times it's like that.
- 13:12We usually aren't calm when we blame people for things.
- 13:16So in a lot of cases, even when blame might be justified, it still is often better to focus on
- 13:24contribution instead of blame.
- 13:26And this is an idea that comes from, and I talked a bit about it with my guests, Guy and
- 13:32Heidi Burgess of the Conflict Information Consortium back in episode 51 of this podcast.
- 13:39This dichotomy between contribution and blame and how to solve these intractable conflicts
- 13:44that a lot of times have blame at their center because it's one side saying the other side is
- 13:49wrong.
- 13:50That other side saying no, no, no, that side is wrong.
- 13:53So how do we get past that?
- 13:55Well, one of these ways is we talk about this difference between contribution and blame.
- 14:00And what are those differences look like?
- 14:02Well, on one hand, blame focuses on one side, but contribution on the other hand focuses on
- 14:09both sides.
- 14:10So as blame is just, well, it's just this one side that did it all wrong.
- 14:14They usually don't admit that they could have done something wrong.
- 14:18But contribution says, okay, you and I both can do better about this.
- 14:24So let's try to work towards a solution.
- 14:27Blame also looks backward while contribution looks backward and forward.
- 14:32Blame is not really actually trying to solve something.
- 14:35It's just trying to dunk on people and say, you caused all these issues, but it doesn't
- 14:41actually talk about moving forward and fixing things.
- 14:44Contribution is looking at it as, okay, well, here's the things that led to this problem.
- 14:48Now, here's the things that can actually fix this problem.
- 14:52Blame is also focused on judgment.
- 14:55Contribution is focused on understanding.
- 14:58Blame also typically doesn't actually try to find out what went wrong or all the ways that
- 15:04something could have gone wrong except for whether the other side was at fault for it.
- 15:08But contribution actually does try to fix that ultimate source of the problem for long term.
- 15:16And also blame leads to an escalating spiral when contribution doesn't.
- 15:22Now, these don't actually have to be mutually exclusive is not the right word.
- 15:27It's not a very necessarily a black and white thing like contribution and starts and ends
- 15:32here.
- 15:32Blame starts and ends here.
- 15:34No.
- 15:34There can be a little bit of blending between the two.
- 15:38But generally speaking, there is a pretty stark difference between contribution and blame.
- 15:45And contribution is also much easier to discuss with people than blame because the latter is
- 15:50uncomfortable to deal with because usually blame is focusing on one person, and people
- 15:55don't want to assume that they are completely at fault for something.
- 15:59Even though they might, they it might again, it could be a situation where it is just one
- 16:03person that's at fault for something, but it's not always the case.
- 16:08So some questions to ask yourself when it comes to blaming.
- 16:11So before you engage in blaming somebody or somebody tries to blame you, whatever the issue
- 16:18is, some sort of bad policy or something horrible that a that somebody did or at least
- 16:25that you think that they did, some scandal, whatever the case may be.
- 16:28Before we get to blaming somebody, ask ourselves these questions.
- 16:32Six questions specifically.
- 16:34One, am I blaming somebody just because they have a different point of view?
- 16:37Again, even if that other person is wrong about something and they're completely wrong about
- 16:42something, a lot of times we're just doing it because they're a different party, different
- 16:47ideology, different interest group, or they just have even a slightly different opinion
- 16:53than we do.
- 16:54Question two, even if somebody is at fault, were they genuinely trying to do the right
- 16:59thing?
- 17:00Because a lot of times when we blame somebody, we assume that there's something nefarious
- 17:04going on, that they're trying to screw other people over, when that's not necessarily the
- 17:07case.
- 17:08They might have been genuinely trying to make a good policy.
- 17:11They might have just been trying to do what they thought was right, but it ultimately
- 17:15didn't lead to good things.
- 17:18It led to worse policy or a worse situation of some other sort.
- 17:24It might be the case, but they could still have been genuinely trying to do the right thing
- 17:28because a lot of times we like to think that what we believe is right is objectively
- 17:33correct, but some other people obviously think that their sense of things is right.
- 17:40Maybe it's not as clear cut and dry what is the correct course of action on something.
- 17:46Question number three, even if somebody else is mostly at fault, is there something I could
- 17:52have done better?
- 17:53So maybe that one person did make a very bad policy, but maybe there was something I could
- 18:00have done where I could have brought up a potential unintended consequence.
- 18:05There might have been some sort of unintended consequence that I missed out on that I could
- 18:09have told them about that might have actually convinced them, hey, this policy is bad.
- 18:14Or maybe they were trying to put through this policy, they were voting on this bill, and I
- 18:19lashed out at them because I felt so strongly about my side and that just turned them off to
- 18:25wanting to hear any sort of criticisms about their bill that they supported.
- 18:29Maybe if I was more approachable and wanting to actually engage with them genuinely, maybe they
- 18:38could have actually heard something out and made a better policy.
- 18:41Doesn't stop them from making a bad policy or being at fault for that bad policy, but it
- 18:47still goes to show, okay, well, there's still something I could have done better.
- 18:51Question four, could I approach blaming somebody else with different language or a
- 18:56different attitude?
- 18:56Like I said, blaming oftentimes takes the form of yelling at somebody and saying that they're
- 19:00so dumb and terrible for doing something.
- 19:03But what if we said like, look, man, this is our woman or whoever.
- 19:08If we go to them and say, look, you could this is not the way to handle things.
- 19:16Here's what you should have done instead.
- 19:17You technically are blaming them, but you're trying to do it in a much more approachable,
- 19:23non aggressive fashion than a lot of times the form that blame takes.
- 19:29Question five, even if I didn't contribute much to a problem, could I at least consider ways I
- 19:36contributed to a misunderstanding or different expectations that led to a problem.
- 19:41So you might not have they could still be mostly at fault and you might have had the
- 19:46right approach of trying to tell them, hey, this thing is not the right thing to do, but
- 19:50maybe the way you said it was in a way that they misunderstood.
- 19:56Maybe you had a reasonable misgiving about a bill they wanted to vote on, but you didn't
- 20:03really do as good of a job of explaining why you had that misgiving, And so they didn't
- 20:10really understand what it was you were trying to say.
- 20:13That could be part of the problem.
- 20:14That's not necessarily saying, oh, well, you are actually the one who screwed up.
- 20:18No, it's just saying that there was something you still could have done better.
- 20:21And in question six, could perhaps nobody be at fault, but rather it's the ways we communicate
- 20:27or set expectations or structure an organization that created a problem or
- 20:32prevented a solution.
- 20:33So maybe the policy itself wasn't bad, but the ways we implemented it were bad.
- 20:41Or another organization implemented it was bad.
- 20:44Or we both talked past each other and we didn't really understand what the other side was
- 20:50trying to say.
- 20:51So we didn't ultimately come to the best policy, the best bill we possibly could have
- 20:56come up to.
- 20:58Or maybe we didn't tell them exactly what it was we were looking for in that policy.
- 21:03And so there was just a miscommunication there and we didn't really realize what the other
- 21:10person was ultimately looking for.
- 21:13Again, these are a lot more nuanced questions and we don't necessarily want to deal with
- 21:18nuance cause it can be very uncomfortable, but it it these are questions that we really need
- 21:22to ask ourselves and each other.
- 21:25Now, how about both sidesing and how often does that happen?
- 21:29So in a lot of debates, in the interest of being impartial and nonpartisan and non
- 21:34ideological, you wanna strive to talk about what both sides believe in as in as level a
- 21:41manner as possible.
- 21:43Now, of course, not everybody wants to do that because some people are very gung ho about one
- 21:48side of an issue or one side of a policy or or a debate.
- 21:53But in cases like mine, for example, whenever I talk about debates on this podcast, I try to
- 22:00give both sides and what they think as much credence as possible without actually
- 22:05supporting one side or another.
- 22:08And I might have opinions on these debates that I brought.
- 22:12Like, example, should we have age maximum age limits on our elected officials or should there
- 22:20be term limits on these officials or should we change the timing of elections and make them
- 22:27more uniform where they're all the general elections are happening in November of even
- 22:32numbered years, for example.
- 22:33I have some opinions about these things, but I try to keep them out as much as possible and
- 22:38just say, hey.
- 22:39Look.
- 22:39This is what side a thinks about the issue and here's what side b thinks about the issue.
- 22:44And you'll see that a lot in media that is trying to talk about an issue.
- 22:49Now, sometimes they're still biased and you could still see that bias leaking out.
- 22:53But in a lot of cases, you still see them try to say, well, here's what somebody else thinks.
- 22:59Here's what this other person thinks.
- 23:01And so you try to get as much of a balance as possible when you're talking about the veracity
- 23:07of said arguments.
- 23:09But when you try to stay balanced, you sometimes run into accusations of what's called
- 23:13bothsiding, where basically both sides of an argument are given a false equivalence.
- 23:18That can manifest a couple of different ways.
- 23:20Maybe the arguments themselves are being given a false equivalence, and one side may be
- 23:26subjectively or objectively completely wrong or much more wrong than the other side is.
- 23:32Or the actual people behind the arguments are being treated with equivalence when one group
- 23:38or the other is mostly or completely wrong.
- 23:41And a lot of times these accusations of both sidesing are illegitimate or just based in
- 23:47people's biases because they already have a very staunch opinion on something.
- 23:52Some people, especially when they get heavily invested in a political issue, are just so
- 23:56blind by bias that they can't accept that anybody else may even have a valid point, let
- 24:03alone that they're possibly correct to some extent in their opinion.
- 24:07It's kinda like that meme of, you know, worst person you know just made a great point.
- 24:12Yeah.
- 24:12Sometimes even the people we hate most, every once in a while they can say like, you know
- 24:17what?
- 24:18I didn't think about that.
- 24:19That's that's a good point that you brought up.
- 24:21It happens.
- 24:22Many people also can't distinguish between a fact and an opinion, and they think that they
- 24:28and only they have all the facts while the other side only has opinions if not outright
- 24:34false info.
- 24:35And there have been quite a few studies that I've shown and I've highlighted a couple in
- 24:40previous episodes of this podcast, studies that have shown that many people are poor at
- 24:44distinguishing fact from opinion statements.
- 24:48And people think that what they believe is inherently correct and that they found all the
- 24:53evidence that shows that even if they're cherry picking all of this supposed evidence that
- 24:58gives them or their side credence.
- 25:01And it also both sidesing ignores a lot of cases where there are two or more or more than
- 25:07two sides to an argument.
- 25:09It's another one of those instances where we don't like where we're not given towards
- 25:15nuance.
- 25:16We have to work to want to understand nuance.
- 25:18Sometimes there are three sides to an argument, maybe four or five, could be more than that.
- 25:23But problem is we're often incentivized to group every even slightly opposing view into
- 25:29one giant conglomerate of wrong because it's easier for us to think that way and also
- 25:35because we're trying to win elections and policy battles.
- 25:38So it behooves us to try to make things that simplified so we can try to generate support
- 25:45for our side of the issue.
- 25:47And then so maybe then both sidesing will turn into all sidesing where it's everybody's given
- 25:54a false equivalence or at least in our eyes, they're given a false equivalence.
- 25:58And also some people resort to accusations of both sidesing because they treat being only
- 26:07partially right as being fully wrong and they cannot stand being potentially wrong at all.
- 26:13It's like what I talked about with the moralized attitudes where people think it's
- 26:17immoral to even give an inch, let alone completely change their opinions.
- 26:25So they think it's just that they shouldn't ever just like how they don't want to accept
- 26:31any sort of possible blame for something, they might just want to never acknowledge that the
- 26:36other side may have a point about something.
- 26:38And so they'll say that you, oh, well, you're both sidesing an issue because they don't have
- 26:44any legitimate arguments on their side.
- 26:47If they did, I wouldn't think the way that I do, which it sounds silly when you say it like
- 26:51that, but that is really how a lot of people think.
- 26:53And you know what?
- 26:54It happens to all of us.
- 26:55I'm not gonna pretend that I haven't done that.
- 26:57It happens to all of us.
- 26:58But for some people, it's a very chronic attitude.
- 27:01And also some people, quite frankly, just don't want to be accountable for their actions.
- 27:06They want others to be accountable for their actions, but forbid that we take any
- 27:10responsibility for anything we say or do.
- 27:13Like, for example, when people only acknowledge violence from one side of the political aisle,
- 27:18and saw it a lot with this with the with the past year with the killing of Charlie Kirk or
- 27:24the killing of Melissa Hortman when Melissa Hortman was assassinated, a lot of people said,
- 27:29boy, those Republicans and conservatives sure are violent, not us Democrats and liberals.
- 27:34And then when Charlie Kirk was assassinated, there were a lot of people that said, boy,
- 27:37those liberals and Democrats sure are violent, not like conservatives and Republicans.
- 27:41Very conveniently, we decided that we were only gonna focus on one side's transgressions, never
- 27:47our side.
- 27:48And that happens all the time with all parties or even people that are not of a party or every
- 27:54ideology.
- 27:55It it happens quite a bit.
- 27:57And, you know, it it it both the blaming can look a lot like both sides in an issue where
- 28:04you're saying, well, no.
- 28:04It's only them that are at fault.
- 28:06You can't give them any sort of credence whatsoever.
- 28:09But it is true that there are some debates where one side is just completely or almost
- 28:15entirely wrong.
- 28:16And so complaints about both sidesing are valid.
- 28:21And a lot of times it's still couched and biased, but it is true that there are instances
- 28:28of both sizing and that both sidesing has no place and should be called out.
- 28:35For example, when one side is objectively bigoted, like they call for the extermination
- 28:40of an entire race of people or an entire ethnic group or putting down an entire demographic
- 28:46group in some way with some sort of vicious insult or the advocacy of using terrorism and
- 28:52political violence to achieve goals.
- 28:55There is no both sides in that.
- 28:58One side is just wrong for doing that.
- 29:00There's also a case where you can complain about both sides and not be a legitimate
- 29:05complaint when there is a statistical preponderance of evidence for one side of an
- 29:11argument, such as if you say this candidate said this particular quote and it is
- 29:16objectively a terrible thing to say, and they deny that they ever said that.
- 29:21Or you have a primary source for certain data that says whatever it is that the data you
- 29:26said, like the unemployment rate, for example, is 5%, 10%, whatever.
- 29:31Primary sources, though.
- 29:33We're not talking about secondary sources because secondary sources are not the ones that
- 29:36are ultimately getting that data.
- 29:39They're the ones reporting on that data.
- 29:41So we have to be careful about taking what those secondary sources say.
- 29:44You want to go to that primary source if you absolutely can, like certain government
- 29:48agencies or nonprofits that are actually studying this info.
- 29:53And then there's also another case where you can chastise both sides and it be a legitimate
- 29:59complaint when we're just being centrist for the sake of being centrist instead of trying to
- 30:04foster a real discussion or avoiding legitimate criticism.
- 30:08For example, maybe you're arguing that one branch of government should be calling all the
- 30:12shots and everything should run through them instead of promoting the separation of powers
- 30:16and the checks and balances system, or you're not condemning riots if they are conveniently
- 30:22aligned with your side of the political aisle.
- 30:25You can't just be centrist for the sake of being centrist there.
- 30:28That's that's another thing too.
- 30:29And I'm sure some people will accuse me of doing that where I'm being centrist.
- 30:33No, it's not being about being centrist.
- 30:35I don't inherently believe centrism is right.
- 30:38I try to take my own opinion out as much as possible, but that's not being centrist.
- 30:42Being a centrist is saying just finding a direct midpoint between two sides and saying,
- 30:48Oh, okay, the right thing to do.
- 30:50The truth is always somewhere in the middle.
- 30:52No, that actually is not always true.
- 30:54Just because you're impartial or you try to be as impartial as possible does not mean you
- 30:59think always think that the truth is always somewhere in the middle.
- 31:02What you acknowledge is that because of your biases that naturally come with being a human,
- 31:08you might not always recognize when something is factual.
- 31:12So you try to not directly take a stance on something.
- 31:16You try to give credence to somebody else's arguments.
- 31:20But if you are centrist for the sake of being centrist, that's not critical thinking either.
- 31:24That's basically doing the same thing as somebody who is very extremist to their side
- 31:29and will only stay in that extreme point of view.
- 31:32It's a similar kind of entrenchment.
- 31:35Just being centrist for the sake of being centrist does not solve anything.
- 31:39It has to be towards actually fostering a discussion, or trying to get people to come to
- 31:46the table so they can at least talk about their differences and opinion.
- 31:51But the problem is a lot of those situations can seem like obvious instances of both
- 31:56sidesing when they're not actually obvious.
- 32:00It's our biases telling us because we have figured everything out.
- 32:04We are so right.
- 32:05That other side has no legitimate arguments.
- 32:07And if somebody tries to act like we both have legitimate arguments, they're just both
- 32:11sidesing things.
- 32:12They just don't want to step on anybody's toes.
- 32:15They want to avoid legitimate criticism.
- 32:17Problem is, a lot of times we don't really recognize when that's happening, at least not
- 32:22from an objective standpoint.
- 32:24Sometimes we think that there's bigotry when there isn't, or accusations of bigotry are used
- 32:31for political gain, or somebody else is being unintentionally bigoted and not thinking about
- 32:35how they come across that way.
- 32:38Now does not mean that those people aren't that they don't want criticism.
- 32:44They do because they're still saying something bigoted, but you might also try to take a
- 32:49different approach and say, look, man, this is not this that's you.
- 32:53That is not the way to think about something because of X, Y, and Z.
- 32:57And maybe you can actually convince them and they'd say, I never thought about about it that
- 33:01way.
- 33:02I didn't mean to make anybody feel like they were being targeted.
- 33:06And so they might correct their behavior instead of perpetuate that behavior down the
- 33:11road.
- 33:12Sometimes we're convinced that our interpretation of statistical evidence is
- 33:16right, even when it could be flawed.
- 33:18And one way you can look at that is if you look at unemployment rates, we'll use that again and
- 33:26you say, oh, 4% or 5%.
- 33:29That that's pretty good.
- 33:31But like a year ago, was 3% and so it's gone up.
- 33:36But maybe you're you're just thinking about that specific number and you're trying to argue
- 33:41against somebody who's saying that the unemployment rate's getting worse.
- 33:45Or or maybe they're looking at a different calculation for unemployment rate because there
- 33:49are different calculations for unemployment rate.
- 33:51There's some that take into account people that have stopped looking for work and they just
- 33:56have given up, and some unemployment rates don't look at those people.
- 34:00Or you might be not focused enough on underemployment where people are employed, but
- 34:05they're not employed in something that is equal to their educational attainment or their
- 34:11experience in the workplace previously.
- 34:15Or if you look at unemployment versus employment rate, if I looked at it were, let's
- 34:22say it's 8% unemployment, that's not good.
- 34:26But if you flipped it around and looked at it, oh, well, it's 92% employment.
- 34:29That sounds great.
- 34:31But that's why we usually look at it through unemployment rate.
- 34:34A, because we focus on the negative overwhelmingly compared to the positive, but
- 34:38also because of that whole standardization of we wanna look at it through unemployment rate
- 34:45the whole time instead of employment rate.
- 34:47But people can twist data around to say whatever they want to say.
- 34:52Statistics might not ever lie, but they can definitely mislead and be misinterpreted.
- 34:57And then other cases where both sidesing might seem obvious when it's not.
- 35:03Sometimes when we complain about centrism for centrism sake, it's not actually centrism for
- 35:08centrism sake, but it's trying to actually foster an environment where we legitimately
- 35:12discuss something and come to a conclusion.
- 35:15Even if that person trying to be centrist really does have staunch opinion one way or
- 35:20another, but they might be trying to put their bias aside and say, look, let's actually come
- 35:25to a some sort of discussion and agreement here so that we can actually move forward.
- 35:31That's not in here.
- 35:32That's not necessarily both sidesing something.
- 35:35But in any case, questions you should ask yourself when it comes to both sidesing or
- 35:40whether you want to claim somebody is both sidesing an argument.
- 35:44Number one, ask yourself, could my side be much more on the right while still having some
- 35:48faults in a situation?
- 35:50Now it can that sounds a little similar to what we talked about with the blaming, but it's
- 35:54still looking at it from the lens of, well, both sides have some merits, not necessarily
- 35:59saying somebody's at fault for some or something, but just that somebody is much more
- 36:03right while somebody else is much more wrong.
- 36:07But just because you're saying, well, this the wrong side did have some points, so it doesn't
- 36:12mean you're both sizing an issue.
- 36:14You might not actually be applying an equivalence to the arguments.
- 36:18You might just be saying that there is some good point that that other side made, but it's
- 36:24not necessarily a false equivalence.
- 36:27Question two, you could ask yourself, could there be multiple sides to a situation and thus
- 36:31both sides and complaints are more nuanced and convoluted?
- 36:36Because again, we like to say everybody that doesn't think like us is one monolith and
- 36:41everybody that thinks like us is all objectively correct and that we're we're we
- 36:46don't have factions in our group, even though a lot of times we do.
- 36:51So you might have multiple sides to a conversation and to a debate.
- 36:56And so trying to give credence to all of them is I mean, that can also be very difficult, but
- 37:01you're still trying to understand everybody else's arguments about something, but you're
- 37:06not trying to say, oh, they're all equivalent.
- 37:08You're just you're not focusing on you're not giving everybody the same value on all their
- 37:14arguments, but you are saying that they that this is what they believe.
- 37:18And so that's a lot different when you're saying like, look, this is what this side
- 37:22believes versus saying this person's got a point because of this and then this other
- 37:26person's got a point because of this.
- 37:28That's those aren't quite the same thing.
- 37:30Question three, do I really believe it's a one-sided issue or do I just not want to take
- 37:36accountability for my action or the actions of my side?
- 37:41So maybe we just we say, oh, you know, people are just they're just that's just a both
- 37:47sidesing.
- 37:47They're they're they're not being genuine about their arguments.
- 37:52They're trying to give a false equivalence.
- 37:53Or is that the case?
- 37:55Or is it really just we don't we don't want to take accountability for our actions or we don't
- 37:59really want to critique our opinions because that means we might have to admit that we are
- 38:02partially wrong.
- 38:04And so that that we find that a threat to ourselves for some reason, because we think
- 38:11we've already achieved the pinnacle.
- 38:13But that, you know, this this idea that theoretically, realize, oh, they could always
- 38:19get better.
- 38:20But when it comes to politics, a lot of times the attitude seems to come across that we
- 38:24already think we've achieved our best and are completely correct and have figured everything
- 38:30out.
- 38:30We've researched everything and our biases are not coming into into play here.
- 38:34A question for is one side factually wrong, or is my perception of wrong really due to biases
- 38:40and opinions?
- 38:41So if I'm a Democrat that that looks at a Republicans and says says they're wrong or a
- 38:46Republican that looks at Democrats and says they're wrong, and I think anybody trying to
- 38:51give credence to the other side is just being both sides are.
- 38:56Well, is that necessarily true?
- 38:58Is that did I really find is everything I believe factually correct, or is it something
- 39:03that I've ultimately come to the conclusion of based on my interpretation of something it's
- 39:09correct, but I could still possibly be wrong.
- 39:13And then lastly, could the other side have a point even if they are mostly or fully wrong?
- 39:19That's not both sidesing.
- 39:21A lot of times in many cases, even when one side is mostly right, there is still something
- 39:27that they are a little bit blind to.
- 39:30And the other side, even when they're mostly wrong, might have a point about.
- 39:35It happens.
- 39:36Rarely is somebody a 100% right on something.
- 39:40And certainly nobody is right a 100% right a 100% of the time.
- 39:45So lastly, I'm gonna talk about what about ism.
- 39:51What about ism is the deflection of criticism from an initial accusation by counter accusing
- 39:57that opponent of a similar or worst case of wrongdoing.
- 40:02And now sometimes that wrongdoing is relevant to the original accusation.
- 40:07When one side is accused of political violence, for example, and they and they throw back.
- 40:12Yeah.
- 40:12But your your examples of political violence are worse.
- 40:16It's about the same thing, but you're trying to debate about which side is worse about that
- 40:23issue.
- 40:24Or it might be something that is completely irrelevant to the original accusation.
- 40:28So you might criticize one party's scandal, but then you're countered with a complaint about a
- 40:35scandal about something completely different.
- 40:38Like maybe you're talking about, oh, well, you know, this person here on in party a were they
- 40:45were convicted of embezzling funds.
- 40:47And then that other side says, well, yeah, but your guy was convicted in a sex scandal.
- 40:52I mean, that those are two very different things.
- 40:54And both might be very valid complaints, but they're two very different things, and it's
- 40:59really just about whataboutism.
- 41:01It's not actually about correcting anything.
- 41:05And this whataboutism is a very heavily favored tactic by politicians of all political stripes
- 41:12to try to win, quote unquote, arguments.
- 41:17But like with other logical fallacies, you're not actually winning anything.
- 41:21Even if the other side doesn't have a comeback to your counter accusation, to your
- 41:25whataboutism, does not mean you won anything.
- 41:28It just means that you're both being kind of petulant here or at least one person is being
- 41:33petulant here.
- 41:34And usually this whataboutism just keeps going back and forth without trying to address
- 41:38problems and leads to this culture of one upmanship that we constantly see where it's
- 41:43just your side is worse.
- 41:44No.
- 41:45Your side is worse, but your side also did this.
- 41:47No.
- 41:47Your side also did this, and it's just gonna keep going back and forth, back and forth
- 41:50without any end in sight.
- 41:52It's not actually trying to fix anything.
- 41:54And you also see this happen a lot in international relations, in relationships
- 42:00between countries.
- 42:01Common one is one country complaining about the other having a bloody history, and then that
- 42:06other country, country b, complains about country a saying, well, your history is
- 42:10bloodier.
- 42:10This was a very, very this was one of the favorite tactics of the Soviet Union during the
- 42:15Cold War.
- 42:15They like to say that that, oh, well, you know, United States had all these issues with race
- 42:20and such.
- 42:21While a valid criticism, but Soviet Union really just did that just to deflect criticism
- 42:26of its own vast human rights violations.
- 42:29It wasn't actually, you know, trying to trying to take a moral high ground without actually,
- 42:35like, correcting anything.
- 42:37So and that's just one example.
- 42:40We see it all the time between all, you know, pretty much every country has engaged in that
- 42:45kind of tactic with another country.
- 42:48No, not not pretty much every every country is engaged within that tactic with some other
- 42:52country at some point.
- 42:55And you see it happen a lot in domestic relations too between parties, between interest
- 43:02groups, between specific politicians, where they say, oh, yeah, you know what?
- 43:07Your your stuff was worse.
- 43:08And that's I mean, that's that's that's not actually solving anything.
- 43:13That's not winning an argument.
- 43:15A counter accusation really does not disprove the initial accusation nor does it absolve the
- 43:23initially accused of any accountability.
- 43:27But we use it as a tactic to try to not take accountability for something because we find
- 43:32taking accountability is either scary or that it's politically not helpful to us.
- 43:37But another problem with whataboutism is what exactly is considered worse wrongdoing?
- 43:45Because whataboutism is usually predicated on the fact of, yeah, well, your thing is worse
- 43:50because hypocrisy is at the center of what aboutism because you're usually saying that the
- 43:56person who initially accused you of something is also doing the same thing or at least
- 44:00they're they've done something else that is horrible too, that is of equal or worse
- 44:07stature.
- 44:09But what exactly is worse wrongdoing, especially if the initial encounter accusations
- 44:15are about completely different things?
- 44:18But if they are about similar things, are there actual hard statistics and numbers?
- 44:23Or you say, oh, well, you know, the Republican Party has a whole bunch of scandals, and then
- 44:27somebody else comes and says, well, no, the Democratic Party has more scandals.
- 44:31Do you have any actual statistics and numbers on that?
- 44:35And even if you do have numbers on that, does it really matter who's doing it more?
- 44:41I mean, if these things we're accusing each other of are just that bad, does it really
- 44:45matter who's actually more at fault for it?
- 44:48So it really doesn't seem like it's actually about who's doing things wrong.
- 44:53It's really just about us taking a moral high ground.
- 44:56Now that being said, it does not mean that you should never respond to criticisms with what
- 45:02about ism and that you can't ever highlight the faults of the opposition.
- 45:08You're not you're not expected and it's not reasonable to expect somebody to just never
- 45:14respond to any criticisms against them.
- 45:17And people who are hypocritical about things should be called out even when they are the
- 45:22initial accuser.
- 45:24Because hypocrisy is quite common in politics.
- 45:27It's at the very heart of what aboutism in the first place.
- 45:30It's one side trying to say, the other side is hypocritical about something, whether it's the
- 45:35initial accuser of wrongdoing or the counter accuser of wrongdoing.
- 45:39You're initially complaining about somebody oftentimes with accusations that you or your
- 45:45side are just as guilty of as the initial accuser, or you are complaining about somebody
- 45:50by saying that they are more guilty of the problem that they just complained about or
- 45:54worse about being problematic in general.
- 45:56So, you're not really is there really a moral high ground there if, you know, both sides are
- 46:01being hypocritical about it?
- 46:03But at the same time, does not mean that you should not ever respond to criticisms and say,
- 46:09Wait a minute, didn't you do this one thing?
- 46:11There are reasons to argue for that, but a lot of times it's not actually about trying to
- 46:16correct behavior, it's just about moral grandstanding.
- 46:19Because most times whataboutism isn't actually trying to fix anything.
- 46:24But it could be used in certain circumstances if it is couched in self awareness.
- 46:29Like if somebody who's if person B who's already accused of some sort of wrongdoing
- 46:34turns to person A and says that, look, I know I've done these things wrong, but this is not
- 46:41relevant to the situation at hand.
- 46:45So you're not just accepting the accusations, but you are also saying, look, man, I don't
- 46:50wanna hear this from you because you've also done it too.
- 46:53I mean, that could still be problematic.
- 46:56It could still be what about ism, but it's at least a lot better when you're still
- 47:02acknowledging, Hey, I've done things wrong too.
- 47:05And also, if you're willing to criticize your own side without being prompted about it, while
- 47:11you're still criticizing the other side saying, Look, my party has done a lot of these bad
- 47:17things.
- 47:18That party has done a lot of these bad things.
- 47:21We need to both work on these problems.
- 47:25That's a lot better than just directly accusing the other side and never acknowledging your own
- 47:29faults or deflecting criticisms of your own faults.
- 47:34Obviously, it could be better, but that's a much better way to handle what about ism.
- 47:38But one perfect example of what about ism and one that is particularly grinding my gears
- 47:44because it's a very recent thing, and this might ruffle some feathers.
- 47:50So here, I'm not gonna be centrist for the sake of being centrist, but and I'm gonna be more
- 47:54directly critical of a couple of groups, which I'm not typically or I typically try to avoid.
- 48:00But there's this BS defense in the arguments about mid decade redistricting, which both the
- 48:06Republican and Democratic parties are doing.
- 48:10Both parties are arguing that the other side is trying to rig elections, that is trying to
- 48:13gerrymander and cut the other party unfairly out of representation in Congress, which is
- 48:19true.
- 48:19Republicans are trying to do it to Democrats.
- 48:21Democrats are trying to do it to Republicans, but they're completely ignoring the wrongdoing
- 48:26of their own side or worse, they're trying to find a justification for it.
- 48:32So no, you did not get screwed out of seats that are quote unquote rightfully yours, so you
- 48:38don't get to just upend the current system of redistricting just to benefit yourselves and
- 48:43try to circumvent law.
- 48:45But at the same time, you also don't get to just engage in the same gerrymandering tactics
- 48:50as the opposition and justify it by saying, well, I'm just trying to defend myself.
- 48:54That's what a lot of people say when they engage in political wrongdoing.
- 48:59They try to say, Oh, well, you know, the other side started this, so I'm going to do this just
- 49:03to defend myself.
- 49:04I'm trying to, you know, prevent the other side from taking power.
- 49:09Yeah, that's a very convenient excuse that we often come up with.
- 49:13You notice that typically Republicans are conveniently only complaining about states like
- 49:18California or Illinois gerrymandering districts, while Democrats are conveniently
- 49:22only complaining about states like Florida or Texas gerrymandering their districts and trying
- 49:28to make things as beneficial to their party as possible.
- 49:32No.
- 49:33If one state is doing it, it's wrong when any other state is doing it.
- 49:36I don't want to hear any nonsense about, well, you know, we are entitled to these seats
- 49:41because of this mid decade rise in census populations.
- 49:47No, you have to wait until the end of the decade.
- 49:49That's how it works.
- 49:50And you can't also just say, oh, well, you know, we're doing it to counteract what the
- 49:54other party's doing.
- 49:55No, that's not how it works.
- 49:57If it's wrong when they do it, it's wrong when you do it.
- 49:59So I don't wanna hear either party try to make these excuses and say, well, what about when
- 50:04this party does it?
- 50:05No, you're both doing it.
- 50:07And it's not justified in any way.
- 50:10This is something that both parties did during the civil war and in the Reconstruction era
- 50:15right after the civil war where they were trying to make these districts as lopsided
- 50:22towards one side or the other or towards their side as much as they possibly could.
- 50:28So we're this is an instance of repeating history that we are conveniently ignoring or
- 50:35we're only saying, well, you know, this party, how typical, they did this way back when, now
- 50:40they're doing it again.
- 50:40Oh, yeah, but your party is also doing it.
- 50:43So that sounds a lot like what aboutism, but really, it's something that both sides are very
- 50:49guilty of, there has to be somebody else that comes in and says, wait a minute, you both are
- 50:54doing this.
- 50:55You both are terrible about this.
- 50:57Neither one of you has any ground to stand on when it comes to this.
- 51:02We should not be condoning it in any way, shape, or form.
- 51:05If you really want to be able to do mid decade redistricting, then you better try to
- 51:10legitimately change the law so that you can do the census every five years or whatever it is
- 51:16that you want to do.
- 51:17But don't just try to do it any way you want and then pretend that you're trying to uphold
- 51:23the law when you're only doing it against the opposition, whether you're Republican trying to
- 51:29do it against Democrats or Democrats trying to do it against Republicans.
- 51:33I don't want to hear it.
- 51:34But that is a perfect example of what about ism is this mid decade redistricting garbage.
- 51:41And also, you hear it a lot of times, unfortunately, for cases of political violence
- 51:46or the suppression of people's freedom of speech and opinion.
- 51:51What aboutism happens a lot in that case in the form of, Well, you know, that side was violent
- 51:57first, so I'm just trying to get them before I get got.
- 52:01Or you're saying, well, they suppressed my freedom of opinion, so I'm gonna suppress
- 52:06theirs.
- 52:07That doesn't solve anything.
- 52:09That just keeps going back and forth.
- 52:10And then so when the pendulum swings the other way, the other side retaliates.
- 52:15And then when the pendulum swings back that way, the other side retaliates.
- 52:19We don't actually fix anything.
- 52:20We just keep on spiraling, not actually fixing anything.
- 52:26So questions to ask yourself when it comes to what about ism.
- 52:30Even if the other side, side B, is just as guilty of what they accused my side, side A, of
- 52:37doing, do they have a point about my side's faults?
- 52:41Just because they're being what about ism or what about ist doesn't mean that, okay, well,
- 52:46you know what?
- 52:46They do have a point, but also they don't just get to deflect criticism either.
- 52:51That doesn't mean that they don't get to be accountable, but both sides have to be willing
- 52:55to acknowledge that they're both accountable for their actions.
- 52:58Question two, is my counter accusation of whataboutism a legitimate criticism or is it
- 53:05just a self defense mechanism?
- 53:07Are we actually legitimately incensed that somebody is going to complain about what we're
- 53:15doing and they're just as guilty of that problem, whether it's a scandal or trying to
- 53:20suppress people's rights or engaging in political violence, they're just gonna
- 53:27completely ignore that.
- 53:28But am I actually criticizing them for a legitimate reason or is it just a self defense
- 53:35mechanism where we're trying to protect ourselves and try to say that, well, we are
- 53:40right because of this whatever reason.
- 53:44Is it really just to make you feel good about yourself or do you really want to fix a
- 53:47problem?
- 53:48Question three, am I actually trying to correct bad behavior through counter accusations or
- 53:56saying that side of that accused me of something, I'm trying to actually make them
- 54:01better.
- 54:02Or am I just trying to win an argument or feel good about myself?
- 54:06I think that's a question, one of those questions that in particular makes us
- 54:11uncomfortable to think about because we really have to dig down and think about our motives.
- 54:17And a lot of times, of course, we all wanna think our motives are pure.
- 54:22But a lot of times, especially when it comes to politics, we're not actually doing things for
- 54:27the right reasons.
- 54:28Our arguments are not actually for the right reasons.
- 54:31Not always the case, but a lot of times it's it is the case.
- 54:35Another question.
- 54:37Can I explicitly acknowledge the counter accusers point, but state that is it is
- 54:42irrelevant to the current discussion?
- 54:44So if side a complains about side b's scandal and side b complains about side a's scandal,
- 54:50another scandal that may or may not be similar.
- 54:54Side a can say, look, that's a good point, but that is irrelevant to the discussion at hand.
- 54:58We'll talk about that at a different point in time.
- 55:01Now, again, that can still be a deflection because you really just, you know, that you
- 55:07can't actually argue against that point, but you still just want to focus on the other
- 55:11side's transgressions that can still be a different way to engage in what about ism.
- 55:18But it's a lot better than just saying, well, what about when you did this?
- 55:21And then just never saying anything about what what you're guilty of too.
- 55:26And then lastly, can I call it out the other side's wrongdoing without it being a deflection
- 55:31from their initial accusation?
- 55:33Where I can say, yeah, but you did this wrong too.
- 55:36I'm not saying that I did this right, but you did this wrong too.
- 55:40Are you doing that as a way to deflect from the initial accusation or are you really trying to
- 55:45acknowledge, okay, look, I messed up.
- 55:48You messed up too.
- 55:49Let's both fix our behavior.
- 55:51Unfortunately, we don't see a whole lot of that.
- 55:53But moving forward on how to deal with blame and both sidesing and what about ism, These are
- 56:01obviously not easy things to fix because most things in politics are not easy things to fix.
- 56:07A lot of times also whether they are happening can be subjective.
- 56:10Is somebody really both sidesing a debate?
- 56:13Is somebody really engaging in hypocritical?
- 56:16What about ism?
- 56:17Is somebody really trying to blame somebody else for something and not take any
- 56:21accountability?
- 56:22That isn't always a very easy thing to to point out objectively.
- 56:27And so this talk was kind of more of a it's more of a starting point of how to address
- 56:32these issues.
- 56:33I'm not naive or arrogant enough to believe that this single podcast episode is going to be
- 56:38the solution to these problems and that it's gonna fix all these issues with political
- 56:43discourse.
- 56:43Of course not.
- 56:44But I do hope that it at least contributes to a solution to these problems or at least makes
- 56:52these problems of blame and both sizing and what about ism.
- 56:56It at least makes these problems a little less of a problem, helps alleviate these issues that
- 57:02arise from it and that make political discourse more toxic.
- 57:07Hopefully, it fixes those issues or helps contribute to fixing those issues, I should
- 57:12say.
- 57:13But ultimately, if there's one thing that this episode is all about, it's this: Are we
- 57:19actually trying to fix an issue or are we just wanting to be right?
- 57:24Are we really trying to make a problem not a problem anymore or are we just morally
- 57:29grandstanding?
- 57:30Are we just trying to win an argument?
- 57:32And a lot of politics involves that question.
- 57:35In many cases, we tell ourselves that we're trying to fix the problem when we engage in
- 57:39blaming and both sidesing or complaining about both sidesing or what about ism when it's
- 57:46really just about making ourselves feel better.
- 57:48And I'm not gonna pretend that I haven't done that.
- 57:51I've definitely gone in conversations where I got my feelings and then I wanted to try to one
- 57:57up somebody and then they did the same thing or maybe I it was just me that was at fault the
- 58:04entire time.
- 58:05Maybe it was the other person that was at fault the entire time.
- 58:07It's look.
- 58:08We're all humans, and we all can make these mistakes.
- 58:12We can give each other a little bit more slack than we normally do.
- 58:17Because a lot of times we think the worst of each other when we're engaging in debates when
- 58:25really we're just misunderstanding each other or we're getting our egos bruised and we're not
- 58:34actually trying to help solve a problem.
- 58:37So moving forward, let's ask ourselves those questions I mentioned throughout the episode
- 58:43and more.
- 58:43And this a point of advice for me to follow as well.
- 58:49I have to practice what I preach and I have to be held accountable for it as much as possible
- 58:54too.
- 58:55It's okay to admit that you're wrong though, even if it's not incentivized to admit that you
- 59:00are wrong or that you could possibly be wrong, let alone are when you are wrong.
- 59:06But we could solve a lot of our problems by acknowledging that we could be wrong or when we
- 59:12are wrong or when somebody else has a point about something.
- 59:17We could do that a lot more often, and I think you'd see a lot better political discourse if
- 59:23we started to engage in those things.
- 59:24If we engaged less in blaming, we complained less about both sidesing even when we really
- 59:31think that our side is right or engaged less in what about ism.
- 59:37But I think we could all do a lot better in trying to find where that dividing line is if
- 59:41we talk to each other a lot more and and we're more willing to honestly engage with each
- 59:48other.
- 59:49So let's all try to strive to be better in those regards.
- 59:53So that's gonna do it for today's episode of the podcast.
- 59:58This is kind of a one of those things that I kinda had a, like, not a working theory, but it
- 1:00:05was just kinda something I'm trying to work through in my head and sort of workshopping in
- 1:00:08this podcast episode and and see what people think and if there's any good feedback that
- 1:00:14could come out of this.
- 1:00:16I mean, of course, there's gonna be good feedback that that'll come out of this.
- 1:00:18Any feedback on it is is appreciated.
- 1:00:22So that's gonna wrap things up for today's episode of the podcast.
- 1:00:25As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 1:00:26Please like, comment, share, and subscribe to the podcast.
- 1:00:30It's on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcasts, and maybe we'll be on more platforms in the
- 1:00:34future.
- 1:00:35And my links in the comments, my Facebook, LinkedIn, medium.com profile, I'm gonna start
- 1:00:41running on Substack soon.
- 1:00:44My five day educational email course about how we can all better depolarize politics, and my
- 1:00:49websites and my email address that you can reach out to me at.
- 1:00:53So we're gonna cut things off here.
- 1:00:55As always, thank you all so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.