Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Accessibility Laws and Trends with Matthew S. Kenefick
Transcript
- 0:05Let's introduce today's speaker, Matthew Kennepeck.
- 0:08Matt is a partner of Jeffer, Mark Mangels, Butler,
- 0:11and Mitchell Alapiti. He has an extensive law
- 0:14practice, which includes litigation, real estate,
- 0:16and compliance matters. Mr. Kennepeck represents
- 0:19a variety of industries, including manufacturers,
- 0:22financial institutions, retailers, real estate
- 0:24developers, wineries, and the hotel industry,
- 0:28among others. Mr. Kennepeck is the hiring partner
- 0:30for JMVM San Francisco office. And now let's
- 0:33get started, Matthew. Over to you. Great. Thank
- 0:36you, Hillary. Hello, everybody. Pleasure to meet
- 0:38you virtually. Thank you for taking the time.
- 0:41I'm here to talk about today accessibility laws
- 0:44and trends. So I have a PowerPoint slideshow,
- 0:49which I will share here and go ahead and get
- 0:58the screen shared. Give me one second here. There
- 1:02we go. Okay. All right. So now everybody, you
- 1:07should be seeing my PowerPoint presentation for
- 1:10today and put some presentation mode. There we
- 1:16go. All right. So, all right. So we're going
- 1:24to talk about the Americans with Disabilities
- 1:27Act, which is commonly referred to as the ADA
- 1:30and some correlating state laws in a variety
- 1:32of contexts. So let's talk about the history
- 1:36of the ADA. So it's the Americans with Disabilities
- 1:40Act of 1990, although it does have effective
- 1:44dates of January 26, 1992 and 93. It's titled
- 1:50for 1990. And it's a civil rights protection
- 1:54act. And that's important to note because Civil
- 1:58rights acts are construed broadly, as you know.
- 2:03Courts will look at it as a remedial act and
- 2:06remedial measures and try to construe the laws
- 2:09broadly towards compliance and accessibility.
- 2:13And that basically, the benefit of the doubt
- 2:16goes in favor of access. The idea is to provide
- 2:21a full and equal opportunity to persons with
- 2:23disabilities to participate in society. prior
- 2:28to the ADA and before Accessibility Focus, we
- 2:31have a lot of people who were unable to participate
- 2:35in what we would consider just daily life activities.
- 2:39people who are unable to go to a restaurant,
- 2:41by way of example, because they use a wheelchair
- 2:45for mobility and maybe that restaurant has a
- 2:48set of stairs. Maybe people are unable to go
- 2:51to a movie theater with family members because
- 2:54of other barriers and issues. The idea is to
- 2:56allow everybody to have full participation. And
- 2:59certainly that is a noble cause and a noble idea,
- 3:02especially given that a large percentage of our
- 3:05veterans, by way of example, have disabilities.
- 3:08As our population gets older, we see more people
- 3:11with disabilities. Certainly, you would want
- 3:14to be able to participate in daily activities
- 3:19with your loved ones, and that's a noble cause.
- 3:21We will also talk about some abuses of the laws
- 3:25or perceived abuses in forms of litigation. There
- 3:32are many sections of the ADA. Title I, that pertains
- 3:37to Employment, Title II, government agencies,
- 3:41public services. Title III, which we're going
- 3:43to focus on today, is public accommodations.
- 3:47Title IV, we have telecommunications, basically
- 3:50telephone relay services, things like that. We
- 3:54can talk about that as well. It's communicative
- 3:57access. And Title V, which is miscellaneous provisions.
- 4:02So Title III of the ADA requires public accommodations.
- 4:06to provide full and equal access to goods, services,
- 4:11privileges, and facilities. Now public accommodation
- 4:14is generally any place that does business with
- 4:17the public. Examples that the statute includes
- 4:22goes from hotels and places of lodging to food
- 4:26service establishments, the places of entertainment,
- 4:29places of gathering, stores, services, you know,
- 4:35health spas, bowling alleys, golf courses. Often,
- 4:40we will find that even some places which are
- 4:42not generally open to the public, such as private
- 4:49clubs, do transform into public accommodations
- 4:53when they're used for public purposes, such as
- 4:58maybe a wedding. Maybe there's a political gathering
- 5:01or event that's used or open, and then we will
- 5:05transform what would ordinarily be a private
- 5:07club or a private place into a public accommodation.
- 5:11But as you can see, this is a very broad list.
- 5:14And the idea, of course, is to extend to anything
- 5:18that basically would affect people trying to
- 5:25use. or take advantage of the privileges that
- 5:28are available to persons without disabilities.
- 5:31So what is required? Well, one aspect of the
- 5:36ADA is physical access. Physical access refers
- 5:40to physical construction features that we would
- 5:44see in a place of public accommodation, something
- 5:47that would affect persons maybe using devices
- 5:52for mobility, maybe certain things such as signage
- 5:56for people who need any braille signage, etc.
- 6:00And so the idea is, is that a new facility that
- 6:05is something that's built after the enactment
- 6:08of the ADA after January 26, 1992, that must
- 6:12be constructed in compliance with new construction
- 6:18standards. Now we have different construction
- 6:21standards. They're actually pretty straightforward.
- 6:24They're housed in the Code of Federal Regulations.
- 6:31And what we have is the 1991 Americans with Disabilities
- 6:38Act Accessibility Guidelines. And then we have
- 6:41a 2010 Americans with Disabilities Act Accessibility
- 6:45Standards. And Those are the federal standards.
- 6:51They're pretty straightforward. Like I said,
- 6:53they'll give you maximums and minimums for ranges
- 6:56for dimensions, etc. The key is, is there is
- 7:00a lot of case law that that does say that a maximum
- 7:05dimension is truly meant to be a maximum. A minimum
- 7:08is meant to be a minimum. They need to be strictly
- 7:10observed. However, there is a little bit of wiggle
- 7:14room on that. for dimensional tolerances for
- 7:17field conditions. Some things just cannot be
- 7:21achieved with the precision that's required to
- 7:24meet these standards. By way of example, an asphalt
- 7:28pavement or asphalt area, that may not be as
- 7:33able to be as smooth as a concrete piece of paving.
- 7:38And under that, you may very well find You know,
- 7:43I can 2 % cross slope for asphalt. You may have
- 7:47a little bit of dimensional tolerances for field
- 7:49conditions, maybe a 1 .9 or 2 .1. You know, as
- 7:55opposed to something that has lesser tolerances,
- 7:59like I said, like a concrete area. Now, this
- 8:03includes alterations, meaning any altered element,
- 8:07the entire altered element needs to be brought
- 8:10into compliance. And there's a lot of discussion
- 8:13about this in case law. So what is an alteration?
- 8:17That's a modification which affects usability.
- 8:20So I could have a pre -existing facility and
- 8:22then I could alter, let's say by way of example,
- 8:25a transaction counter. The entire altered element,
- 8:29the transaction counter, would need to be brought
- 8:32into alignment with the new standards. Whereas
- 8:36if it's a pre -existing facility, we'll talk
- 8:39about that in a second, we have readily achievable
- 8:41access barrier removal. So you'll see here there's
- 8:45a bullet point for Title 24 of the CBC. Title
- 8:5024 of the CBC is the California Building Code,
- 8:53and it's section 11 of that relates to accessibility.
- 8:57So while the ADA only requires new construction
- 9:06to be in compliance with the guidelines and we
- 9:12have readily achievable access barrier removals
- 9:15talked about for pre -existing facility. The
- 9:19California Building Code, as you hear the term
- 9:23grandfathering, what that means is you must comply
- 9:26with the then applicable version of the CBC,
- 9:30the California Building Code, when you construct
- 9:32or alter an element or a facility. That's updated
- 9:36tri -annually. The building code's updated every
- 9:39three years. And that is important because the
- 9:44California building code, in certain respects,
- 9:46we'll talk about in a second, they're more stringent
- 9:49in some respects than the ADA. And the law is
- 9:53you must comply with the more stringent of the
- 9:55two regulations. And keep in mind, a violation
- 9:59of the California building code could trigger
- 10:01other types of California laws which then could
- 10:04trigger an ADA violation. So when you alter an
- 10:08element, you're not only going to have to, or
- 10:10you do a new construction, you're not only going
- 10:12to have to comply with the ADA guidelines, but
- 10:14also the building code. We see this manifest
- 10:18in facilities that are based on a national prototypical
- 10:24design. So by way of example, let's say I have
- 10:28a brand that has maybe 1200 stores throughout
- 10:31the country. They want consistent branding, of
- 10:35course, consistent trade dress. So what ends
- 10:38up happening is these facilities, they will have
- 10:42one set of architects do the designs, and they
- 10:47build it, generally speaking, with the accessibility
- 10:51of the federal standards in mind. What happens,
- 10:55though, is if they don't have a site adapt architect
- 11:01who is licensed in California or familiar with
- 11:04the California laws, there's a chance that they
- 11:06may miss some of these California nuanced issues.
- 11:09I worked on a very large stadium remodel once.
- 11:14And during the plan review, the site adapt architect
- 11:18had found many changes that they needed to make
- 11:20for accessibility that were not previously incorporated
- 11:24by the national design team. So it's really important
- 11:27to look at it from a California perspective because
- 11:31there's little nuances and the plaintiff's bar
- 11:35is very well aware of those nuances and it's
- 11:37usually the first thing they go after. The next
- 11:40thing is the readily achievable access barrier
- 11:43removal. So what this is, is if you have a facility
- 11:46that predates the ADA, That means it was built,
- 11:52constructed is the term before the ADA. The constructed
- 11:55term could either refer to certificate of occupancy
- 11:59or final building permit sign off. But if you
- 12:03have that situation, then you only have to remove
- 12:06barriers when it can be accomplished without
- 12:09great difficulty or expense. That's the standard.
- 12:13And it takes into consideration the overall financial
- 12:15well -being of of the public accommodation. You
- 12:20also get to take into consideration safety and
- 12:23security measures. By way of example, it may
- 12:25not be readily achievable to do something to
- 12:29make a change if it's going to create a safety
- 12:32hazard. But generally speaking, we see that this
- 12:36is, for the most part, is construed pretty broadly.
- 12:40By way of example, in New York, in the southern
- 12:43district of New York, we have a lot of legacy
- 12:48buildings, legacy facilities that have big stoops
- 12:52or steps to enter into retail facilities. It's
- 12:56an issue. So how would you deal with that? Well,
- 13:02one way you could deal with that is you could
- 13:04create a policy by way of example that allows
- 13:07the the staff to come down and meet the customer
- 13:12at the street and bring them goods and services
- 13:14that way. And because you could argue that it's
- 13:17not readily achievable to alter or change those
- 13:21stairs. But some courts in the Southern District
- 13:24of New York have held that it's readily achievable
- 13:27to require a stair lift to be put in place. And
- 13:31some of these stair lifts can cost a lot of money,
- 13:35up to $100 ,000, sometimes more. And that's been
- 13:38held to be readily achievable. So it really depends
- 13:41on where you're at. But the argument you'll usually
- 13:44hear from the plaintiff's bar is, look, the ADA
- 13:46has been around for 30 plus years. Your client's
- 13:50had a lot of time to get its facility into compliance.
- 13:57And all those investments can be amortized over
- 14:00the years. looking at what is required. We also
- 14:07see that there's a policy and procedure element
- 14:10of the ADA. And what we see there is that public
- 14:16accommodations must make reasonable modifications
- 14:19to their policies, practices, and procedures
- 14:22when reasonably necessary to provide full and
- 14:24equal access. This is a catch -all. We see the
- 14:28DOJ latch onto it a lot because This could pretty
- 14:33much encompass just about anything that you're
- 14:35looking at. So if somebody makes a request for
- 14:41a policy modification, the facility must grant
- 14:45it when it's reasonable. So that's a determination.
- 14:49The term is reasonable. But you can very well
- 14:51see that manifesting in a lot of different ways.
- 14:54By way of example, that the The stoop issue that
- 15:01I was just talking about in in New York So we're
- 15:05under the ADA when something's not readily achievable.
- 15:08You can provide Equivalent facilitation using
- 15:12alternative measures. That was the policy I was
- 15:15talking about but you very well could have a
- 15:18customer saying I want as your policy modification
- 15:20to to provide You know provide me services at
- 15:26the street if it's not readily achievable for
- 15:28you to to make the entrance accessible. That
- 15:31would have to be determined whether it's reasonable,
- 15:34and then it would have to be issued. We've seen
- 15:37this go back. One of the famous cases that went
- 15:41to the United States Supreme Court, it was the
- 15:43Casey Martin PGA case, where he wanted to use
- 15:48a golf cart as opposed to walking. So another
- 15:53area that we see that's required under the ADA
- 15:56is a communicative. Area this is auxiliary aids
- 16:00and services Another something that could be
- 16:03another category that could be used as a catch
- 16:05-all and what it is is a public accommodation
- 16:10must effectively communicate with its Guests
- 16:14and patrons. So the effective communication is
- 16:18that is the key term and when auxiliary aids
- 16:21and services are required the public accommodation
- 16:26must provide those auxiliary aids and services
- 16:28reasonably necessary to achieve that effective
- 16:31communication at no cost to the patron or guest.
- 16:35Examples could be a braille statement. You could
- 16:37imagine somebody who's a braille reader requiring
- 16:41or requesting braille statements for their bank,
- 16:45qualified interpreters, somebody to interpret
- 16:47a conversation or a presentation, note takers.
- 16:51video text displays, screen reader software,
- 16:55et cetera. Now, the public accommodation gets
- 16:59to make the decision. However, if this were a
- 17:04government agency, such as Title II, of the ADA,
- 17:11they must give primary consideration to the requested
- 17:13auxiliary aid and service. There's a lot of companies
- 17:16who provide a lot of auxiliary aids and services
- 17:19out there. As technology matures, we're seeing
- 17:22less and less reliance on this. Most people have
- 17:26just about every auxiliary aid and service that
- 17:29they need available in their smartphone or tablet.
- 17:33But we still see these requests often. So then
- 17:38we talked about California laws, and it's important
- 17:42to juxtapose the federal law versus California
- 17:44law, not just because we're in California, but
- 17:48because there are very important differences.
- 17:51One of the differences we'll see is the UNRWA
- 17:55Act, which is the California UNRWA Civil Rights
- 17:59Act, that has under Civil Code 51F an incorporation
- 18:06of a violation of the ADA. So you'll often see
- 18:10in the complaints an allegation that the defendant
- 18:15violated. When I say complaints, I mean lawsuit
- 18:17complaints. They violated a section of the ADA
- 18:22that triggers a violation of the UNRWA Act. And
- 18:27therefore, as a result, they're suing under the
- 18:31UNRWA Act. And that's important to note. plenty
- 18:35of attorneys have tried removing cases over the
- 18:38years and have successfully removed cases that
- 18:41were filed in state to federal court. However,
- 18:44there is ample case law or precedent, at least
- 18:50at the district court level, especially in the
- 18:52central district of California, which is Southern
- 18:55California or Los Angeles area, where many judges
- 18:58have found that a 51F violation is not does not
- 19:04support a removal or federal question jurisdiction.
- 19:07So what does the UNRWA act afford? It affords
- 19:11a minimum of $4 ,000 per incident of statutory
- 19:16damages. That's a minimum. Incident is defined.
- 19:22basically to be a visit to a facility. It can't
- 19:26be every single barrier that somebody encounters.
- 19:29You can imagine somebody goes to use the restroom
- 19:32at a restaurant, they encounter 30 different
- 19:34violations of law. That's not 30 incidents. But
- 19:38that $4 ,000 is a minimum. And the highest I've
- 19:43seen was $150 ,000 for one incident. It was a
- 19:48case that went to trial. And I believe it was,
- 19:52I think it was Central District of California,
- 19:55Santa Ana Division. And it was over a policy
- 19:58that was facially neutral, but had discriminatory
- 20:02impact. At least that's what the jury found in
- 20:06the ADA case. which does raise an issue. There's
- 20:14traditionally not a jury afforded under the ADA,
- 20:16but there are other statutes that do get you
- 20:20a jury. But anyway, that case was $150 ,000 for
- 20:23that one incident plus the attorney's fees, which
- 20:26I understood were in excess of $200 ,000. Now,
- 20:30for physical barriers as opposed to policy or
- 20:34communicative barriers, California has added
- 20:37that there is a requirement that the plaintiff
- 20:40can demonstrate that they suffered difficulty,
- 20:43discomfort or embarrassment, or they were deterred
- 20:47from visiting the facility by reason of knowledge
- 20:50of the barrier. And what that means is that it
- 20:53turned, they'd actually have to say that on a
- 20:55specific date, they would have went to the facility,
- 20:59but for their knowledge of these barriers, the
- 21:02difficulty, discomfort, embarrassment, there
- 21:04is a superior court precedent and also district
- 21:10court precedent, lower level precedent, not appellate
- 21:14precedent that holds that the difficulty discomfort
- 21:18or embarrassment needs to be more than just a
- 21:23hypothetical injury. There needs to be some type
- 21:26of manifestation of physical or emotional harm.
- 21:30One case by way of example, the Monday through
- 21:33pro case. the individual could not see the reflection
- 21:38in a mirror. And if I recall correctly, a gas
- 21:41station, it was mounted too high. So, but they
- 21:45ultimately were able to see the reflection in
- 21:48another reflective object and fix their hair
- 21:52or whatever they were trying to do. And that
- 21:54didn't rise to a level of difficulty this time
- 21:56for embarrassment. There was another case, I
- 21:59believe it was the plaintiff was strong. And
- 22:02I think this was a Southern District of California
- 22:05federal case. And it was found that a plaintiff,
- 22:10the striping and the path to travel in the parking
- 22:13lot was not correct. Didn't have a correct path
- 22:17to travel. But the plaintiff nevertheless was
- 22:20able to successfully traverse the parking lot.
- 22:24And as a result, that didn't give rise to the
- 22:27difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment. There
- 22:29are a variety of conditions that for certain
- 22:34types of businesses that can show there's a presumption
- 22:39that difficulty, discomfort, embarrassment was
- 22:42not met, such as faded striping, if I recall
- 22:46correctly, or signage wording being a little
- 22:49bit off. All that's housed in Civil Code Section
- 22:5355 .56. Now, we see the Disabled Persons Act.
- 22:58That's a little bit different. It gives $1 ,000
- 23:02per instance statutory damages. There is an interesting
- 23:06case out there, a California Supreme Court case
- 23:09on it, in fact, that held that if a plaintiff
- 23:13seeks their attorney's fees as an element of
- 23:19damages, which they're entitled to under the
- 23:21ADA, the UNRWA Civil Rights Act and the Disabled
- 23:24Persons Act. But if they seek it under the Disabled
- 23:25Persons Act and they lose the case, then the
- 23:29defendant could obtain their attorney's fees.
- 23:31So you'll usually see the attorney's fees prior
- 23:34only under the ADA or the UNRWA Act. So I talked
- 23:40briefly about the differences between the California
- 23:44Building Code versus the Americans Disabilities
- 23:48Act. We'll see by way of example. Counter height,
- 23:52very common one. The federal standard is 36 inches
- 23:57above finish floor for a transactional counter.
- 24:01We have 34 inches as the California standard.
- 24:05That catches a lot of people. We have ATM scoping
- 24:08by way of example. That's the number of accessible
- 24:10ATMs per location that's being required. California
- 24:14uses westernized braille. which is a different
- 24:16type of Braille than the federal system. Although
- 24:19less and less people are using Braille these
- 24:21days. It used to be primarily people were congenitally
- 24:24blind, people born with blindness, but now just
- 24:27due to the massive availability of auxiliary
- 24:31aids, you know, we have screen reader technology.
- 24:33Most people have phones that can help with accessibility.
- 24:37There's less of a reliance on Braille. Now the
- 24:41unreact, unlike the ADA, is not limited to public
- 24:45accommodations. It extends to business establishments
- 24:48of every kind whatsoever. It's intended to be
- 24:54interpreted as broadly as possible. One thing
- 24:57to note that this does apply to the sale and
- 25:00rental of housing. UnReact also, by way of example,
- 25:07has a broader definition of disability. The federal
- 25:10standard is a substantial limitation on daily
- 25:12life activity. The state definition is just a
- 25:18limitation on your ADL, your activities daily
- 25:21life. And that can be construed very broadly.
- 25:26It does not take into consideration people who
- 25:32use AIDS. So by way of example, if somebody is
- 25:35able to walk with a cane, but they're unable
- 25:38to walk without a cane. The way the law constitutes
- 25:42whether or not a person qualifies as having a
- 25:45disability sufficient to impact daily life activities,
- 25:49they look at it without the assistive device.
- 25:54So one thing that's very popular is websites.
- 25:59We see website accessibility is a very hot issue
- 26:04in litigation. We see that a lot in California,
- 26:08a lot in New York. Some of the most prominent
- 26:11filers are in New York. Florida used to be pretty
- 26:16dominant, and that's gone away a little bit just
- 26:19because of some of the case law changes, but
- 26:23it's still present. We see it in Pennsylvania.
- 26:26There's a couple law firms who specialize in
- 26:28website accessibility. They file in Pittsburgh.
- 26:33plaintiff's favorable process in Pittsburgh,
- 26:36the federal court there. So we see it all over
- 26:39the place. So generally, many courts have considered
- 26:44websites to be places of public accommodation
- 26:47with a lot of precedent going on towards this.
- 26:52Depending where you're at, depending on the jurisdiction,
- 26:55some courts require some type of connection between
- 27:00the between the public accommodation and the
- 27:08physical place of the public accommodation and
- 27:12the website, whereas other places, other jurisdictions
- 27:15have real pure internet only websites, something
- 27:19that only exists in cyberspace, it constitutes
- 27:22a public accommodation. And obviously the state
- 27:27laws that we're talking about, such as the Human
- 27:29Civil Rights Act, get bootstrapped. So people
- 27:32say, all right, well, your website's not accessible.
- 27:35And you owe us $4 ,000 minimum per incident for
- 27:39the website. There is a standard out there. It's
- 27:46unlike the physical standards that we have, which
- 27:48are pretty clear. We have conceptual guidelines
- 27:51put together by a private organization called
- 27:54the World Wide Web Consortium. They come up with
- 27:57these web content accessibility guidelines. These
- 28:02are not federally adopted for public accommodations,
- 28:07but the justice, Department of Justice has relied
- 28:11on it heavily. A lot of judges have adopted it.
- 28:13In California, it has been held to be evidence,
- 28:19persuasive evidence of noncompliance with the
- 28:22ADA, showing basically that a website is not
- 28:25accessible to persons with disabilities. a manifestation
- 28:29of that by the failure to comply with the WCAG.
- 28:32Right now, 2 .2 is the standard. There's three
- 28:35different success criteria factors, level A,
- 28:40double A, triple A, triple A being the most stringent,
- 28:43single A being the most lenient. AA is pretty
- 28:48much what most people go for. What happens with
- 28:50AAA is the websites, the functionality gets significantly
- 28:54decreased and nobody wins that way. But we also
- 28:58have found that, or some courts have found that
- 29:00it's well within their equitable powers to order
- 29:03remediation to the WCAG standards as part of
- 29:07their injunctive relief. Website claims. They're
- 29:15easy to file. We get a lot of people to serve
- 29:17demand letters, some people who actually file
- 29:20suit. You know, California has restrictions on
- 29:23certain types of demand letters that can be made.
- 29:28Some attorneys have gotten in trouble. The primary
- 29:31restrictions do relate to physical access, but
- 29:34for website access, some of the concepts still
- 29:38pervade. By way of example, there was one attorney
- 29:41in connection with physical access who had his
- 29:45admission to practice in the central district
- 29:48suspended, I believe for one year because in
- 29:52his demand letters, it was found that he was
- 29:54giving legal advice to the defendant or the target,
- 30:00basically saying, look, you should settle with
- 30:02me. You shouldn't involve a defense attorney
- 30:06who's probably just gonna make a big deal out
- 30:08of the case. And you know you have a losing case
- 30:12you should just settle something along those
- 30:14lines generally speaking and or found that to
- 30:17be improper And like said the physical demand
- 30:21letters, you know, if they seek money It's supposed
- 30:23to you know, they're not supposed to seek money
- 30:24and supposed to be recorded with the judicial
- 30:26counsel So it usually ends up happening as most
- 30:29people file suit first Now the the website access
- 30:35cases are really easy to find imagine suing somebody
- 30:37over a physical facility If somebody's seeing
- 30:41a pseudo or a physical facility, you have to
- 30:43go there. Somebody with a disability may not
- 30:46be that mobile. Getting them over to the facility
- 30:52and having them actually encounter the facility
- 30:55as a true legitimate consumer with the intention
- 30:59to return, which is important for Article III
- 31:02standing if they intend to sue for injunctive
- 31:05relief. For that, that's a lot more difficult
- 31:09than just clicking on a website. The websites
- 31:12are, generally speaking, we see a lot of automated
- 31:17testing. So what does that mean? So there's a
- 31:19lot of automated tools out there that can be
- 31:24used to determine whether or not a website complies
- 31:28with some of the WCAG standards. The automated
- 31:33testing, has flaws. Nothing's perfect in this
- 31:36world, including automated testing. They get
- 31:38a lot of false positives. They also miss some
- 31:41things, and there's a lot of different tests
- 31:42out there. That's used a lot by the plaintiff's
- 31:48bar. In fact, I often recommend to my clients,
- 31:51if you're looking strictly to minimize litigation
- 31:56exposure on your website, run the automated testing
- 32:00and run the free ones that are more likely than
- 32:03not to be used by the plaintiffs' attorneys.
- 32:05You don't want to use the most sophisticated
- 32:08one that they're not using. Your goal, certainly
- 32:11you may have the goal to make your website accessible,
- 32:13but if you're also looking at minimizing litigation
- 32:16exposure, the key is you want to be looking into
- 32:19the same lens that the... that the plaintiff's
- 32:24attorneys are. And that means that if you find
- 32:27false positives on that automated testing, fix
- 32:30those false positives. Even if your website is
- 32:33accessible, fix those false positives, or you
- 32:36may end up getting sued and having to pay an
- 32:38attorney like me to deal with convincing a plaintiff's
- 32:42attorney that there is a false positive. And
- 32:46the plaintiff's attorneys are not that easy to
- 32:48convince. So once they, you know, they are very
- 32:52creative, most of them will settle for a commitment
- 32:57to remediate the website and a settlement value
- 33:01that costs less than what a nominal defense of
- 33:05the lawsuit will be. So it makes it very easy
- 33:08to settle with them. We often find that plaintiffs'
- 33:12attorneys will target an entire enterprise, a
- 33:15business enterprise, because it's very simple.
- 33:17you find a problem with one website, it's probably
- 33:19going to be on the sister websites because there's
- 33:22a common development team. One of the problems
- 33:24we do see is a lot of offshore development teams
- 33:29and contractors who may not have a focus on the
- 33:34accessibility component. And one thing that's
- 33:38very positive is most development teams these
- 33:41days, historically they have lacked the the capacity
- 33:47to achieve conformity, and we see that. But most
- 33:50development teams these days, accessibility is
- 33:52getting on the radar. And if you provide them
- 33:56some automated testing, or a plainest report,
- 33:59preferably you're proactively doing with automated
- 34:01testing, or use case testing of your own, that's
- 34:04where you have a person with a disability using
- 34:06a screen reader technology, they go and they
- 34:09try to use your website and they tell you what's
- 34:11wrong. If you provide them a lot of teams, more
- 34:14development teams these days, are able to help
- 34:17you with that. Like I said, we usually have claims
- 34:23that are bootstrapped with damage claims. New
- 34:25York and California have damage claims. The New
- 34:28York statute's much smaller in damages, but California
- 34:31does have damages as well. One of the things
- 34:35that comes up for retailers is holiday code block.
- 34:38We see a lot of retailers that once they get
- 34:40towards the holiday season, nobody touches that
- 34:43website. You're not going to be able to fix that
- 34:46website until after holiday season has passed.
- 34:52It's a big piece of their revenue. E -commerce
- 34:54is huge. You're not going to be able to go potentially
- 34:59crash a website. by making accessibility changes.
- 35:02Most people do a pilot anyway in a closed environment,
- 35:06but still code lock is an issue. Third party
- 35:10content procurement is another issue. Not all
- 35:13the content you'll find on websites is developed
- 35:16or hosted for that matter by... by the public
- 35:21accommodation. Some of it is linked or deep linked.
- 35:23Some of it's embedded. Some of it, such as, you
- 35:26know, pay transaction, point of sale transaction
- 35:30aspects, that's created by third parties. And
- 35:33the issue with that is, is there software, is
- 35:36there a website component? You may not have the
- 35:39ability to make the alterations yourself. One
- 35:43thing that's important is do a public -facing
- 35:45website accessibility policy. A lot of people
- 35:48get dinged on that. Every Department of Justice
- 35:51consent decree I've looked at has always requested
- 35:54and required that. So it's really important to
- 35:57do that. And basically, it's just stating a commitment
- 36:01and stating the company's commitment or restating
- 36:06the company's commitment to accessibility to
- 36:08the public and equally fundamental. giving some
- 36:12type of channels to be able to make any type
- 36:20of complaints or requests for accessibility issues.
- 36:25That's an important issue as well. I think it's
- 36:27important to track any complaints because it's
- 36:32a great way to prove a negative. If you have
- 36:34an accessibility complaint channel and somebody
- 36:38comes to you and sues you over website access,
- 36:43and you can show that, look, we track every single
- 36:46complaint, and we've never received any complaints
- 36:49over the issue you're talking about. That's good
- 36:52persuasive evidence. It's not conclusive evidence,
- 36:55but it's persuasive evidence. And one of the
- 36:57things we have seen is in Department of Justice
- 37:01enforcement, we have seen that first thing they
- 37:05ask for is, Tell me about all the complaints
- 37:07you received over your website or over whatever
- 37:11component you have of your accessibility. And
- 37:15again, it's a good way of proving a negative.
- 37:18The last bullet point here, remedial access vendors.
- 37:21I mentioned up above, a lot of development teams
- 37:25historically have lacked the capacity to achieve
- 37:29website conformity. And that's where there are
- 37:33website specialists or medial access vendors
- 37:36who specialize in helping you bring your website
- 37:41into compliance. We talked about the W3C that
- 37:47creates the standards. We also talked about the
- 37:51WCAG. Again, it's more of a conceptual guideline.
- 37:54It does have very specific... issues with some
- 37:57guidance for some specific issues, but still,
- 38:01it goes on the principles of perceivable, operable,
- 38:06understandable, and robust. A lot of things we
- 38:10find that it's not as cut and dry on how to achieve
- 38:15access under the WCAG as you would with the physical
- 38:19access, or just as, look, your transaction counter
- 38:22needs to be 34 inches above finished floor. So
- 38:26there are a lot of free tools you can do to assess
- 38:30your website's accessibility. These are those
- 38:32automated tools. Again, playing as far as use
- 38:36these, the WAVE tool. This can also be used as
- 38:39a plugin for your Chrome browser. A checker,
- 38:45accessibility checker, the company deque, that's
- 38:48D -E -Q -U -E. They have a tool called the AXE,
- 38:55the AXDEV tools. I like that tool a lot. They
- 38:59have a free version and a paid version. So it's
- 39:02for a little bit more sophisticated of a user.
- 39:05You can open up the development panel in your
- 39:08browser and you can use that tool to specifically
- 39:12identify offending code, give you... WCAG references
- 39:17and suggested fixes. It's a very powerful tool
- 39:21for the more sophisticated users. Again, these
- 39:25are automated tools that if you truly care about
- 39:29achieving accessibility, use case testing is
- 39:33very important. So some low hanging fruit issues
- 39:38we see on websites. It starts off with just an
- 39:42understanding of what's happening here is Where
- 39:46I use a mouse, I use a graphic interface on my
- 39:50computer. Somebody who is blind, low vision,
- 39:55or has other types of disabilities which impairs
- 39:58their ability to use and navigate, the computer
- 40:01may not have access to or ability to use a graphic
- 40:05interface. So imagine going through a screen
- 40:09or a website without a mouse. And what happens
- 40:13is they have screen reader technology. that will
- 40:17read highlighted or focused on portions of the
- 40:22website. So you change focus to headings, other
- 40:26items, right? And that will read out loud to
- 40:29the person who doesn't have use of their screen.
- 40:33That's the screen reader technology. It's one
- 40:36of the many tools that WCAG's intended to make
- 40:42websites accessible to be used with. And so when
- 40:45you have this screen reader technology, people
- 40:47are navigating with the arrows or the tab button.
- 40:51One of the things they go to is the heading structure.
- 40:53Heading structures are very important to organize
- 40:56content for screen readers. So it's important
- 40:59to have appropriate heading structures. Alternative
- 41:02text for images. So what alt text means is when
- 41:06I see a picture by way of example of a tennis
- 41:09shoe on a website that I may like and I may want
- 41:13to purchase it or just know that I'm looking
- 41:14at it. Somebody who doesn't have the ability
- 41:18to see that screen, how do they know that the
- 41:23focus is on a tennis shoe? Well, you have meaningful
- 41:26descriptions, alternative text that will say,
- 41:31This is a picture of a brown Nike tennis shoe
- 41:36or whatever is there. That's alternative text.
- 41:38And it's important to have meaningful alternative
- 41:40text. Often we'll have categorical description.
- 41:45You could say, by way of example, it could be
- 41:48a retail item as opposed to a tennis shoe or
- 41:52a lipstick or something along those lines. And
- 41:55we do find this can be a challenge. It can be
- 41:58a real challenge for websites that have a lot
- 42:01of products or changing products. Websites can
- 42:04often be updated daily, multiple times a day.
- 42:07And if you have a retail website that may have
- 42:09thousands of items on it, certainly all text
- 42:12can be a challenge. Color contrast is another
- 42:16issue. They'll see a lot of high contrast on
- 42:19here where it's like it's black text on a white
- 42:23background. But you can imagine if this was a
- 42:26gray text on a white background, or a silver
- 42:30text on a gray background, that contrast would
- 42:33be very light and be very hard for people who
- 42:36have low vision to read. Color contrast is something
- 42:40we see a lot of in in complaints. Of course,
- 42:46the counterpoint is, is somebody who is blind.
- 42:53probably should not have standing to assert a
- 42:57color contrast complaint because they're not
- 43:01seeing the screen at all. Again, we want to make
- 43:05sure the screen is navigable by a keyboard. And
- 43:10then we talk about, and this is another one,
- 43:12it's another slide, but captioning for videos
- 43:15for people who are deaf or have hearing impairments.
- 43:20These are just some low hanging fruits that we
- 43:22see people, fruit items that we see people sue
- 43:25over a lot. So, you know, another way of reducing
- 43:34liability is, you know, we like to conduct regular
- 43:36accessibility testing. Some companies will automatically
- 43:39test for you if you set up on a testing interval.
- 43:42You could also do it yourself just using the
- 43:46tools we talked about. Just make sure that your
- 43:49website remains in compliance. Just because it's
- 43:52in compliance today doesn't mean it will be tomorrow.
- 43:54Things do change. So another thing is you can
- 43:59bring in third party consultants to give you
- 44:02advice on how to bring your website into accessibility.
- 44:08Anytime you alter a website, you should make
- 44:11sure all new content follows the WCAG. Another
- 44:16thing is you should, if you do have on -site
- 44:19development teams, make sure there's training.
- 44:21Make sure there's development guidelines that
- 44:23are memorialized. It's a good idea to have somebody
- 44:26who has ownership of the accessibility features
- 44:29of your website. You may not need to hire an
- 44:33accessibility coordinator, although most consent
- 44:36decrees do require that. Nevertheless, you should
- 44:41have one person of your development team who
- 44:43ultimately has ownership and responsibility of
- 44:46that. It creates a good defensible policy for
- 44:52accessibility. A lot of websites, they use templates,
- 44:58meaning that one page of your website is going
- 45:01to be on the same template as another one. And
- 45:09the importance of this is make sure you waterfall
- 45:12the changes throughout all your templates. And
- 45:15if you have problems identified, just know that
- 45:18you should check your other templates, especially
- 45:20if you're using similar templates across an enterprise.
- 45:24Some pitfalls to avoid, software overlay. So
- 45:27there's a lot of brands out there who level access,
- 45:30access to the audio IDQ. They do provide these
- 45:36wonderful tools which are software overlay. Overlays
- 45:38right now, basically it's a widget or a tool
- 45:41that goes into your website that will create
- 45:46code to interact between your website and a screen
- 45:50reader technology. It's a great idea. Some of
- 45:54them work better than others. The problem is
- 45:57twofold. They're not perfect. There are problems.
- 46:01And it's truly considered right now by the plaintiff's
- 46:05bar not to be a substitute for creating an accessible
- 46:09code. In fact, some plaintiff's attorneys specifically
- 46:14target websites that use overlays. So people
- 46:20may go to a website overlay company getting promised,
- 46:24you know, that they're going to never be sued
- 46:26again, just to make themselves a bigger litigation
- 46:28target. I have had interaction with some of the
- 46:32overlay companies over my clients getting sued,
- 46:36and I have not found tremendous support from
- 46:40them in responding to lawsuits. Basically, you're
- 46:45still on your own. So I've heard a lot of salesy
- 46:48pitches. I've seen a lot of them from some of
- 46:50these overlay companies. Again, the technology
- 46:53is developing and it's just not there yet from
- 46:56what I understand. I would be aware of when you
- 47:01use third party development companies who just
- 47:04design your own website like Shopify, things
- 47:07like that. You just got to make sure that when
- 47:09you're doing that, that you take ownership and
- 47:13responsibility for the accessibility. That, of
- 47:17course, can be a problem. We talked about alt
- 47:19text and color. Alt text is an issue that we
- 47:23often see. Color alone can be an issue because
- 47:28there are colorblind users, so it's always a
- 47:32good idea to use additional indicators like asterisks
- 47:34or text labels. Again, color contrast. One issue
- 47:39we see a lot is this forms. Fillable forms. We
- 47:44often find problems with that. Fillable forms,
- 47:46like I said, is often third party content that's
- 47:48either embedded or licensed to a website. But
- 47:51we do see issues with fillable forms, meaning,
- 47:54by way of example, I'm checking out a website
- 47:56and I want to enter my address or something like
- 47:58that. That can be an issue. So that's a hotspot
- 48:03to check for. That could often be what's considered
- 48:06a hard stop. on a website. So often we'll find
- 48:10barriers that may impair the user's ability,
- 48:15but they're still able to consummate a transaction.
- 48:19An inaccessible fillable form could be a hard
- 48:21stop. Again, we like the testing on it. I talked
- 48:25about this earlier. I touched on it. Pre -recorded
- 48:30content is a... is an important issue for audio.
- 48:37So if you have prerecorded content, you should
- 48:40have captioning, unless you can legitimately
- 48:45say that it's just an alternate presentation
- 48:49of information that's otherwise on the website.
- 48:55If you don't have... audio component of pre -recorded
- 49:01video content. The best practice is to use a
- 49:05statement such as no sound is used in this clip.
- 49:08Otherwise, captioning is required. Now, keep
- 49:12in mind that for live content, you're not required
- 49:15to have captioning because it's not pre -recorded.
- 49:21Other things is if you have materials and information
- 49:26on your website, That should also be accessible.
- 49:30PDFs should be created. If you have PDFs that
- 49:34can be downloaded, et cetera, they should have
- 49:36logical structure for screen readers. Video should
- 49:39have captioning and transcripts. Excuse me, there
- 49:46is a lot of... legacy content out there as well.
- 49:52That by way of example, you can imagine somebody
- 49:54who has old contracts or documents in PDF form
- 49:58on their website, such as an insurance company,
- 50:01maybe right, you can have your own policy documents.
- 50:04That's a pitfall, you could definitely be facing
- 50:07some people coming after you on that. So you
- 50:10may want to convert to something that is accessible.
- 50:13We talked briefly about policies. It's important
- 50:18to have policies that promote accessibility.
- 50:21Keep in mind, policies don't just help you memorialize
- 50:26and train people off of the policies, but it
- 50:29also creates a defensible infrastructure to somebody
- 50:33who's suing you. One of the things that we do
- 50:36see a lot in lawsuits is if it's a federal lawsuit
- 50:41and it's only seeking injunctive relief, something
- 50:44that we see outside of California, An easy way
- 50:48to deal with it would be to try to moot the lawsuit,
- 50:53meaning that if you fix the item that they're
- 50:56suing over, they can't enjoin you to do something
- 50:59you already have done. It renders it moot. In
- 51:02fact, in the southern district of Florida, one
- 51:05of the magistrates has a policy that says, look,
- 51:07if you file a lawsuit as an ADA plaintiff to
- 51:10defend it, can... can, before their answers do,
- 51:16they can confess and say, look, okay, our facility
- 51:19has a problem, or our website has a problem,
- 51:22but we agree to fix it. And then what the judge
- 51:24will do is the judge will stay the case, in that
- 51:28case, that judge is standing first, will stay
- 51:30the case for a period of time. And when you come
- 51:35back, if you prove that it's fixed, the judge
- 51:37will give the plaintiff's attorney a reasonable
- 51:39fees, but just for preparing and filing the case,
- 51:42as opposed to keeping the meter running throughout
- 51:45litigation. That specific policy has been challenged
- 51:49in the 11th Circuit. I handled that. I handled
- 51:54that appeal to the 11th Circuit, and we were
- 51:57successful. The 11th Circuit upheld that as being
- 52:01within the discretion of that magistrate. But
- 52:04keep in mind that the way that people went off
- 52:07a little bit of tangent, but the way that a plaintiff's
- 52:09attorney can overcome mootness is by arguing,
- 52:13OK, well, I'm not targeting the fact that the
- 52:16facility is in compliance or the website is in
- 52:19compliance. I'm targeting the lack of policies.
- 52:23for compliance. They try to say your policies
- 52:26need to be remediated. Well, if you have a defensible
- 52:28policy, they can't expand it that way. Again,
- 52:31we talked about complaint channels. We talked
- 52:35about training. It's a good idea to train off
- 52:39your policies. And certainly, when I create a
- 52:42policy, I like to think about if it was viewed
- 52:45by an outside person, what message would it send?
- 52:48Would it demonstrate the business's commitment
- 52:52to accommodating its customers with disabilities?
- 52:54Is it going to send the right message? We're
- 52:59running out of time, but I'll just go over this
- 53:00real quickly. Emotional support animals, in March
- 53:042025, I'm aware of a lawsuit that was filed in
- 53:07Southern California over an open house service
- 53:09animal. They asserted Disabled Persons Act claims,
- 53:12UNRWA Civil Rights Act claims, FIHA and FHA claims.
- 53:17I don't know the status of the lawsuit. I think
- 53:19it may have been resolved. But the issue is we
- 53:22have service animals. And service animals are
- 53:25any dog or under federal law, a miniature horse,
- 53:28that is individually trained to do work or perform
- 53:32tasks for the benefit of an individual with disability.
- 53:36Compare that to an emotional support animal.
- 53:39An emotional support animal is just an animal
- 53:42that provides comfort to a person with a psychiatric
- 53:44disability. and the animals not individually
- 53:47trained. We also see guide dogs, signal dogs,
- 53:52and service dogs are all covered not just under
- 53:55federal law, but we also see it under California
- 53:58law. Dogs and miniature horses are under the
- 54:01ADA. You're allowed to ask some questions. You're
- 54:04not allowed to ask others. I usually advise clients
- 54:07not to have any inquiry about this and not to
- 54:11have their staff do any inquiry. Either A, they'll
- 54:14get it wrong, or B, they'll get heard wrong,
- 54:16and a plaintiff will sue you, claiming that you
- 54:19asked the wrong questions. Basically, you can
- 54:21ask whether or not they need the animal because
- 54:23of a disability. You can't ask for proof of training
- 54:26or a license. You can't ask them to explain their
- 54:29disability. That's private. You can ask what
- 54:33tasks the animal has been trained to perform.
- 54:36You can't charge a pet fee or a cleaning charge.
- 54:39They certainly can charge for actual damage.
- 54:42And if there's an animal that's violent and not
- 54:44under the control of its handler, you can have
- 54:47that animal removed. Under California law, it
- 54:51is a misdemeanor to misrepresent an animal as
- 54:54a service animal when it is not one. We often
- 54:57see people get these vests. The issue is who
- 55:00provides the training? There are A lot of controversy
- 55:05over this issue, a self -trained animal can be
- 55:10considered a service animal. So certainly you
- 55:13could have a service animal that may not be the
- 55:16best service animal because it's self -trained
- 55:19as opposed to professionally trained. The professional
- 55:22trainers obviously take great issue with this
- 55:24because They spend a tremendous amount of time,
- 55:28money and effort in training the animals. A lot
- 55:31of the programs I'm aware of actually lose money
- 55:33on training the animals, but they do it as a
- 55:38service and they're wonderful animals. An emotional
- 55:42support animal we talked about is not trained
- 55:44and we see this not in a public accommodation
- 55:47setting, but in a housing set. and also an employment
- 55:51setting. So under the Fair Employment and Housing
- 55:54Act and the Fair Housing Act, we see that there's
- 55:59an interactive process that's required when somebody
- 56:03makes a request to have an emotional support
- 56:07animal. That could be a whole nother presentation
- 56:11in and of itself. responding to claims. Basically,
- 56:16what a lawyer can do is we identify the barriers,
- 56:19determine if there's any protections, don't retaliate
- 56:24against the plaintiff. There's a lot of local
- 56:26rules that apply. Central District of California,
- 56:30by way of example, you can get a stay and a mediation.
- 56:33Northern District, we have our general order
- 56:3556 up here, which basically stays a lawsuit and
- 56:39has the parties. try to resolve it. I like to
- 56:44run in two tracks. The first track is fix the
- 56:49issue. Concurrently, the second track is to try
- 56:52to resolve the lawsuit, put out the fire, so
- 56:56to say. There's a big risk of copycat lawsuits.
- 57:00It's very simple for another plaintiff to know
- 57:03whether or not. your clients, you know, are willing
- 57:06to make a quick settlement. They see a request
- 57:09for dismissal with prejudice. So, so that's,
- 57:13you know, can put your client on the mark. One
- 57:17of the issues too is, is we do see that the plaintiffs
- 57:21do switch firms, attorney switch firms. I say
- 57:24plaintiff switch firms, literally one plaintiff
- 57:26be represented by one law firm and then switched
- 57:29and be represented by another law firm. So this
- 57:31institutional knowledge will be shared. You just
- 57:34have to presume that if you pay too much or settle
- 57:37too quickly, there's a chance your client's gonna
- 57:40get sued again. Often what I will do is a strategy.
- 57:44If I have a small client never been sued before,
- 57:47that's one approach. But if I have a larger client,
- 57:51has a lot of businesses, a lot of exposure, and
- 57:55they've been sued a bunch, then we're going to
- 57:57try to send the message that we're not a soft
- 57:59target. And that means not settling quickly.
- 58:03Disrupt the plaintiff's business model. Make
- 58:05them earn their money. They make a lot of money
- 58:08in ROI off of refiling the same exact lawsuit
- 58:12over and over again or saying the same demand
- 58:14letter over and over again and getting quick
- 58:16settlements. But if you make them do some work,
- 58:21then that disrupts our business model. So certainly
- 58:26slowing down and paying less helps. And disabled
- 58:30access strategy, we're talking about identifying
- 58:33compliance issues, identify action items, certainly
- 58:39prioritizing. Certainly you want to do the low
- 58:42-hanging fruit items first. Some things are are
- 58:45more tractable, more difficult to repair, then
- 58:48you identify certain items. I've had clients
- 58:51who say, look, it's going to cost us way more
- 58:54to fix than our litigation exposure is. We'll
- 58:57do the best that we can to make this element
- 59:00compliant, but we're not going to tear down our
- 59:02building or whatever. And that would be an acceptable
- 59:07risk that they decide. It's a business decision.
- 59:11Certainly create an action plan. And that is
- 59:15the end of our presentation right at 1 .30, which
- 59:18I think is the end of our time here. And we can
- 59:22take any questions if there are any. I'm actually
- 59:26not seeing any questions at this time. So with
- 59:29that, I'll go ahead and say that this concludes
- 59:32today's presentation. Thank you so much, Matthew,
- 59:34for your time. And thank you so much to our audience.
- 59:37Have a great day, everybody. Actually, look at
- 59:38this. Ah, Nadine Lewis asks, what is the test
- 59:42for reasonableness as it relates to policy? Yeah,
- 59:46that's a good question. So, you know, certainly
- 59:50a policy needs to be something that is intended
- 59:53to memorialize and further a culture of compliance.
- 1:00:00Right. The idea is, is you're trying to prevent
- 1:00:03future recurrence violations. So reasonableness
- 1:00:08of that. certainly is a case -by -case basis.
- 1:00:13Again, I would think it would be something that
- 1:00:15I would try to ensure that it's going to be interpreted
- 1:00:23in a way that makes sense to the average viewer
- 1:00:28or reader or user, whether that intended audience.
- 1:00:31is an employee, whether it's a person who's going
- 1:00:36to be trained off of it. Usually we like to have
- 1:00:38our policies, something that's onboarded and
- 1:00:41then resides in your LMS if you have a learning
- 1:00:43management system. But certainly, we're also
- 1:00:49going to want to make sure that if it's viewed
- 1:00:51by an outside agency or a plaintiff, that it
- 1:00:55demonstrates a commitment. to achieving it. There's
- 1:01:01a lot of counterintuitive things that go into
- 1:01:04policies. Certainly, there's an interaction etiquette
- 1:01:08that most people need to be trained on if they
- 1:01:11are going to be dealing with persons with disabilities.
- 1:01:14By way of example, one of the big issues, I think,
- 1:01:18is they call it a person -first culture. And
- 1:01:22that is you focus on the person. It's a person
- 1:01:24with a disability. It's not a disabled person.
- 1:01:27The disability doesn't define them. Different
- 1:01:30is not less. So it's important to focus on that
- 1:01:34and focus on what they can do in assisting them
- 1:01:37in a respectful and meaningful way. There is
- 1:01:42a false etymology about the origin of the term
- 1:01:45handicap, and that can be... a sensitive word
- 1:01:50for some people. We do see the term still in
- 1:01:52our legislature, handicap. Some people falsely
- 1:01:55believe that it originates from somebody holding
- 1:02:01a cap in their hand for handouts and that referring
- 1:02:05to persons with disabilities. I've heard that
- 1:02:07a lot from persons in the disability access community.
- 1:02:11I've heard people talk about how negatively they
- 1:02:14view the term. But if you look it up, it actually
- 1:02:16has nothing to do with that. It actually originates
- 1:02:20from, at least from what I've read, horse racing
- 1:02:23and livestock. But nevertheless, it's negatively
- 1:02:28associated, whether it's correct or not. And
- 1:02:32therefore, again, that's something that would
- 1:02:34be in a policy. If you're training people how
- 1:02:38to have interaction etiquette with persons with
- 1:02:40disabilities. Likewise, if we're talking about
- 1:02:44website accessibility, the policy would be something
- 1:02:48that would suggest that you have a commitment
- 1:02:51to promote accessibility and that you're also
- 1:02:55going to, on a regular basis, take reasonable
- 1:02:58steps to ensure that your website is accessible
- 1:03:01and remains accessible. Again, I've written a
- 1:03:05ton of these policies over the years. In fact,
- 1:03:08I have a whole set of elements that I go through
- 1:03:12on a checklist. They're primarily based on what
- 1:03:15I've seen in settlements and in the community.
- 1:03:18But I'll see it in, like I said, you really just
- 1:03:21look at historical Department of Justice consent
- 1:03:23decrees to see what people are looking for. So
- 1:03:27that's, unfortunately, it's reasonableness. So
- 1:03:35we see another one under the UNREACT covering
- 1:03:41rentals. Well, it's not public accommodation
- 1:03:47context. UNREACT applies to business establishments,
- 1:03:50but it does apply to the sale and rental of housing.
- 1:03:58It does cover... senior living, but we also see
- 1:04:02that extending beyond, we do see that extended
- 1:04:09beyond the issue of just senior housing. The
- 1:04:16question is, could a family renting out a single
- 1:04:19home be subject to... to the UNRRAC. Remember,
- 1:04:22it's not public accommodations for UNRRAC. It's
- 1:04:24business establishment. But yeah, absolutely.
- 1:04:28You could imagine a situation. The UNRRAC proscribes
- 1:04:31discrimination based upon just about any identifiable
- 1:04:35characteristic. It goes beyond just disabilities.
- 1:04:38So you could absolutely see somebody who is discriminating
- 1:04:42against somebody. Say, look, I had a bad experience
- 1:04:46when I was a kid with blind people. So blind
- 1:04:49people are not allowed to rent from for me. You
- 1:04:52know, it's my house. I'm not going to do that.
- 1:04:54They're certainly going to get sued over that.
- 1:04:56And that is that is what we saw in a in a single
- 1:05:01family home that was offered for sale in a rental
- 1:05:08context where the listing agent are not rental
- 1:05:12context, residential context, where the listing
- 1:05:14agent said, look, I'm not allowing you to bring
- 1:05:19your service animal into this house. Now, keep
- 1:05:22in mind, just because you're subject to the unreact
- 1:05:26or the ADA doesn't mean the answer is always
- 1:05:29yes. There's a lot of reasons why a service animal
- 1:05:35may not be allowed into a facility. There's a
- 1:05:39lot of case law out there about when a service
- 1:05:42animal is allowed in a pool, by way of example.
- 1:05:46There are situations where it's just not safe.
- 1:05:49There's a lot of situations where you're not
- 1:05:52going to be required to make any facilities.
- 1:05:58So it's not an absolute, but definitely it's
- 1:06:02subject. So we see another question from Lanwin
- 1:06:06and it's... For a deaf person who requests an
- 1:06:09interpreter, is there required response time,
- 1:06:12for example, at a music venue? That's a very
- 1:06:14good question, and I've dealt with this extensively.
- 1:06:19One of the issues is you're supposed to achieve
- 1:06:24effective communication, right? And that's the
- 1:06:28auxiliary aids and services. So ASL, American
- 1:06:32Sign Language, is not English. and in certain
- 1:06:36types of transactions, if somebody is requesting,
- 1:06:41let's say, a qualified sign language interpreter,
- 1:06:46under those circumstances, you may not have one
- 1:06:48available. And you can imagine, if it's a class,
- 1:06:52a school, a financial transaction, something
- 1:06:54like that, you're gonna need that. So that's
- 1:06:56where the reasonableness of the request comes
- 1:06:58in. And the reasonableness of the request means
- 1:07:01reasonable lead time. Somebody shows up on site
- 1:07:03for a, An event that's occurring in two minutes
- 1:07:06and they say, look, you know, I want a qualified
- 1:07:10interpreter or I want a real time display. It
- 1:07:14may not be a reasonable request just because
- 1:07:16the lead time. I often suggest that you know
- 1:07:20that you include any materials, you know any
- 1:07:24request channels and if you if you do a little
- 1:07:27bit of research, find out from your local agencies.
- 1:07:29If you're putting on a big event. Find out your
- 1:07:32local agencies. how long it's going to take to
- 1:07:34get the common resources that are requested,
- 1:07:38such as an interpreter. And then put the lead
- 1:07:41time. Look, we need 48 hours advance notice,
- 1:07:44something like that. If you can't come up with
- 1:07:46the advance notice, the actual amount, it just
- 1:07:49has to be reasonable. But certainly, we have
- 1:07:52encountered this where people have. have tried
- 1:07:55to figure out what is the appropriate advance
- 1:07:57notice and of course it depends on the circumstances
- 1:08:00certain areas by way of example you talk about
- 1:08:03disneyland i mean disneyland's in anaheim orange
- 1:08:06county got a lot more we probably have a lot
- 1:08:08more resources available a lot more people who
- 1:08:10come out and work for you than if let's say by
- 1:08:13way of example you're in some rural part um you
- 1:08:16know or some remote isolated area where you're
- 1:08:19you know you're not going to have you know there
- 1:08:20may only be one interpreter for the whole town
- 1:08:24So certainly it's a reasonableness of the request
- 1:08:27and lead time is absolutely acceptable. But that
- 1:08:33definitely, you know, that goes into the qualified
- 1:08:35or the auxiliary aids and services, which we
- 1:08:39do see a lot. And along that line of the communicative
- 1:08:44access, I will just mention, I touched on it
- 1:08:47briefly, but I didn't really go into it. I know
- 1:08:50I'm going a little bit over, but it's the the
- 1:08:53TRS, Telecommunications Relay Services. It's
- 1:08:57a different section of the ADA, but it was a
- 1:09:02very hot topic about 10 years ago. What it is,
- 1:09:05is we have, so for persons who are deaf, have
- 1:09:10a hard time speaking, hard hearing, they often,
- 1:09:13they'll communicate with text, either through
- 1:09:16a teletype device or through a chat, just like
- 1:09:18we're using here today. So, when they want to
- 1:09:22talk to somebody through a telephonic channel,
- 1:09:27that can be a challenge. If you're deaf, how
- 1:09:29do you call somebody? If you're deaf, how do
- 1:09:31you... If you have a speaking disability, how
- 1:09:36do you make a phone call? Well, we've all heard
- 1:09:37about the teletype devices, which basically looks
- 1:09:40like an old school speak and spell when you type
- 1:09:44it in. And that's one channel. But there's another
- 1:09:47channel. The other channel is 7 -1 -1. It's a
- 1:09:50service provided by the FCC. And what it is,
- 1:09:54it provides telephone relay services. So the
- 1:09:56person either through a computer chat or a teletype
- 1:10:01device contacts the agency. And what they have,
- 1:10:05it's a governmental provided agency at no cost
- 1:10:08to US citizens. So that's people who are residing
- 1:10:11in the US. maybe not citizens, but U .S. residents,
- 1:10:13people reside in the U .S. or people who are
- 1:10:16abroad who are U .S. residents, and they give
- 1:10:21advance notice that they're going to be traveling
- 1:10:24abroad. And the issue is they can contact and
- 1:10:28communicate with this person who's a communication
- 1:10:32assistant. It's basically an operator. and they're
- 1:10:35talking to them via the text message, just like
- 1:10:37I was reading that question. They read the questions
- 1:10:40and then they make the phone call for you. The
- 1:10:44problem is, is you could imagine the anxiety
- 1:10:49that a call center operator receives. Imagine
- 1:10:52you work for a bank and somebody calls you up
- 1:10:55and says, look, I'm actually not your banking
- 1:10:57client. I am a third party communications assistant
- 1:11:02and I'm calling you on behalf of this person.
- 1:11:07And any verification or authentication questions
- 1:11:11you have, you post to me, give me a little bit
- 1:11:14of time. I'll type it to them. They'll type it
- 1:11:16back to me and I'll give it to you. You want
- 1:11:18that pin? Sure, I'll give it to you. It's going
- 1:11:20to wait a second. All kinds of fraud alerts go
- 1:11:23off. The DOJ in enforcing those roles, they said
- 1:11:31the fraud falls on the the public accommodation,
- 1:11:35you have to deal with the fraud risk, you can't
- 1:11:37turn away, you can't turn away and shut down
- 1:11:40telephone relay services. Wells Fargo was one
- 1:11:43of the ones that got hit pretty hard. I believe
- 1:11:47they ultimately were, their penalties were between
- 1:11:5115 and 20 million dollars that they had to pay.
- 1:11:54and then make major changes. So that is something
- 1:11:58else that's out there. It's a little bit more
- 1:12:00obscure these days because most companies prefer
- 1:12:03to use chat communication channels as opposed
- 1:12:09to telephonic channels. But if you do have a
- 1:12:11customer or client or a contact or even yourself
- 1:12:15that uses a telephonic channel exclusively, that
- 1:12:21is an ADA risk. All right. Well, I think we ran
- 1:12:27out of questions. I appreciate everybody's time
- 1:12:29and patience, and we tried to get through all
- 1:12:32the slides. You may be eligible for CLE credit
- 1:12:35in your state. Visit bhba .org slash podcasts
- 1:12:39for more information.