Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Personality Assessment: Objective, Projective, & Implicit Tests Explained
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Psychology Undergrad. Hey, everyone.
- 0:02So you are officially the third member of our
- 0:05study group today. Pull up a chair. We need the
- 0:07help. Yeah, seriously. Because we have a major
- 0:11problem to solve before our final exam. It's
- 0:15basically how do you measure something that's
- 0:17actively trying to lie to you? Which is the whole
- 0:19struggle of chapter three, right? Personality
- 0:21assessment. Exactly. We are doing a deep dive
- 0:25into chapter three and trying to capture the
- 0:27entire landscape of someone's thoughts, feelings,
- 0:30behaviors, and like their goals. It's incredibly
- 0:34messy. Oh, totally messy. So to make this stick
- 0:37for the exam, let's use this philosophical, almost
- 0:40theological framework I was thinking about. Okay,
- 0:42lay it on me. Let's think of personality assessment
- 0:45as the three pillars of the soul. I like that.
- 0:47It sounds intense. Right. So pillar number one
- 0:49is the mirror. That's what we explicitly say
- 0:51about ourselves, which the text calls objective
- 0:53tests. Got it. The mirror. And then pillar number
- 0:55two is the hidden soul. That's what we hide,
- 0:57measured by projective and implicit tests. OK.
- 1:00And the third? Pillar number three is the physical
- 1:02evidence, like what we actually do, which is
- 1:05tracked by behavioral measures. Framing it as
- 1:08the three pillars actually makes a lot of sense
- 1:10because it solves the core tension of the chapter.
- 1:14What do you mean? Well, Different psychological
- 1:17theories fundamentally disagree on the nature
- 1:20of human beings, and because of that they require
- 1:23completely different tools. Oh right, like the
- 1:26humanistic approach versus the psychodynamic
- 1:28one. Exactly. If you're operating from a humanistic
- 1:31perspective, you assume people are Basically
- 1:34rational, right? Yeah, like they know their goals
- 1:36and they actively strive for them, right? So
- 1:38the tools obvious you just ask them you just
- 1:40hand them a survey Yeah, but if you take a psychodynamic
- 1:43approach you assume the conscious mind is mostly
- 1:46just a PR firm for the unconscious a PR firm
- 1:49That's a good way to put it. People are completely
- 1:51blind to their real motives So asking them directly
- 1:55is well, it's worse than useless. It's actually
- 1:57misleading Which brings up a huge philosophical
- 2:00problem. Are we even capable of seeing ourselves
- 2:03as we truly are? That's a million dollar question.
- 2:06I mean, it's like asking a fish to describe water.
- 2:09Wait, how so? Well, the fish doesn't know it's
- 2:11in water because it has literally never experienced
- 2:14anything else. Right. It's just their baseline
- 2:16reality. Exactly. So how can we objectively evaluate
- 2:20our own baseline levels of, say, anxiety or extroversion
- 2:25when we are perpetually trapped inside our own
- 2:28subjective experience. Yeah, that subjective
- 2:31trap is exactly why we need that first pillar,
- 2:34the mirror or objective tests. Though we should
- 2:38definitely flag a major trap on the exam regarding
- 2:40the word objective. Oh yes. Good catch. Yeah.
- 2:44When psychologists use the term objective here,
- 2:46they are definitely not claiming the person's
- 2:48answers are a perfectly objective reflection
- 2:50of reality. Right. They are solely talking about
- 2:53the scoring mechanism. Exactly. A true or false
- 2:55questionnaire or like a one to five rating scale,
- 2:58it has a predetermined standardized storing key.
- 3:01Meaning the psychologist doesn't inject any of
- 3:03their own personal interpretation into the score.
- 3:06A four is a four. Precisely. And the most common
- 3:08version of this is the self -report measure.
- 3:10Oh, man. We have all done these for extra credit.
- 3:13So many times. You sit in a computer lab, answer
- 3:16200 repetitive questions about the Big Five.
- 3:18Let's review those for the exam. The Big Five
- 3:21or the FFM. That's neuroticism, extroversion,
- 3:25openness, agreeableness, and conscientiousness.
- 3:28Right. And you answer the questions and generate
- 3:30a profile. And since we know solidity is all
- 3:33about a test disability to predict real -world
- 3:35outcomes, the crazy thing is how powerfully these
- 3:39self -reports actually predict the trajectory
- 3:41of human life. Wait, really? Just the self -report.
- 3:44Oh, the predictive validity is actually staggering.
- 3:47Let's look at the mechanisms behind it. Something
- 3:50like self -rated conscientiousness predicts not
- 3:52just college GPA or job performance, but actual
- 3:55mortality risk decades later. Mortality risk,
- 3:58like how long you live. Yes. And it isn't magic.
- 4:02Think about it. Conscientiousness measures a
- 4:04person's tendency to be organized, responsible,
- 4:07and forward -thinking. Okay, so how does that
- 4:09keep you alive? Because in the real world, that
- 4:11translates to thousands of cumulative micro -decisions
- 4:14over a lifespan. Oh, I see. The highly conscientious
- 4:17person remembers to take their blood pressure
- 4:20medication, they choose to wear a seatbelt, they
- 4:23avoid that fourth drink at the bar, and they
- 4:26actually schedule their preventative doctor's
- 4:28appointments. Wow. Those micro decisions really
- 4:31compound over time. They do. The text also notes
- 4:34that self -ratings of neuroticism, which is the
- 4:37tendency to experience negative emotions, are
- 4:40strongly linked to clinical syndromes like anxiety
- 4:43and depression. Yeah, they map onto each other
- 4:45really closely. So the mirror is undeniably powerful.
- 4:48But, and here's where it gets tricky, mirrors
- 4:52can be distorted. especially when human ego gets
- 4:55involved. Oh, the ego ruins everything. It does.
- 4:57If we link this back to that moral framework
- 4:59we mentioned, think about the sin of pride. The
- 5:02textbook formally calls this the self -enhancement
- 5:04bias. Right, the self -enhancement bias. That's
- 5:07the psychological drive to downplay our flaws
- 5:10and heavily exaggerate our virtues. Because we
- 5:12are highly motivated to see ourselves as the
- 5:15hero of our own story. Exactly. And this bias
- 5:17completely warps the mirror, especially during
- 5:19high -stakes testing. Like a job interview. Yes.
- 5:23Imagine you are applying for a highly competitive,
- 5:26super lucrative job. And the personality test
- 5:29asks, do you occasionally snap at coworkers when
- 5:32stressed? There is zero chance I'm answering
- 5:35yes to that. Right. The overwhelming internal
- 5:38pressure is to present the idealized version
- 5:40of yourself. You answer based on who you wish
- 5:43you were. or who the company wants you to be.
- 5:46Instead of who you actually are on a stressed
- 5:47out Tuesday when the printer is jammed. Exactly.
- 5:50We end up claiming I am a perfectionist instead
- 5:53of confessing I am actually deeply disorganized.
- 5:56So pride is a huge factor. But beyond pride,
- 5:59there's also an environmental distortion we need
- 6:01to memorize, the reference group effect. Think
- 6:04of this as the big fish in a small pond illusion.
- 6:06We never evaluate ourselves in an absolute vacuum.
- 6:10We just don't have that capacity. We constantly
- 6:12calibrate our self -perception against our immediate
- 6:15socio -cultural surroundings. Right. So if you
- 6:17are comparing your study habits to a roommate
- 6:19who routinely sleeps until 2 p .m. and skips
- 6:22all their lectures, then managing to study for
- 6:24just two hours makes you feel incredibly disciplined.
- 6:27Exactly. You will confidently rate yourself as
- 6:30highly conscientious on an objective test. But
- 6:33if we pluck you out of that dorm room, and dropped
- 6:35you into a cohort of surgical residents pulling
- 6:3880 -hour weeks. Your baseline shifts entirely.
- 6:41Suddenly, you feel incredibly lazy. And your
- 6:44actual behavior hasn't changed a single bit.
- 6:47Right. But your self -reported personality score
- 6:49swings wildly because the water you were swimming
- 6:51in changed. Again, back to your fish analogy.
- 6:54Yep. So since the mirror is so easily distorted
- 6:56by pride and these fluctuating reference groups,
- 7:00psychologists turn to the second half of the
- 7:01first pillar. which is informant ratings. Right.
- 7:04If you can't trust the person, you ask a witness.
- 7:07You basically give the exact same standardized
- 7:09questionnaire to a spouse or a parent, a close
- 7:13friend, or even a boss. These informant ratings
- 7:16are crucial when the subject simply cannot self
- 7:18-report. Like, you can't ask a three -year -old
- 7:20to accurately assess their own emotional stability
- 7:23on a Likert scale. No, that would be a disaster.
- 7:25And you definitely shouldn't blindly trust a
- 7:28CEO candidate taking a test to secure a massive
- 7:31financial package. Oh, for sure. So informants
- 7:33are great there. And interestingly, informant
- 7:37ratings frequently outperform self ratings when
- 7:40it comes to highly evaluative traits. Like what?
- 7:43Things like intelligence, charm, and creativity.
- 7:47The mechanism behind this is actually super fascinating.
- 7:49Okay, lay it on me. Well, traits like charm don't
- 7:53exist purely in the mind of the individual. They
- 7:55exist in the interaction between people. Oh,
- 7:57that makes sense. You don't necessarily feel
- 7:59your own charm. Right. You just feel the effort
- 8:01you're putting into the conversation. But the
- 8:04informant experiences the actual impact of your
- 8:07charm. So witnesses often provide a much more
- 8:10valid prediction of how someone will actually
- 8:12perform in a socially demanding job. Or whether
- 8:14they might face early discharge from the military,
- 8:16stuff like that. Wow. But let's subject the witness
- 8:19to the exact same scrutiny we gave the mirror.
- 8:22Informants are heavily biased too, right? Oh,
- 8:25incredibly biased. I mean, if I'm applying for
- 8:27a job and I get to nominate the informants who
- 8:29will read my personality, I am obviously picking
- 8:32my biggest fans. Right. The textbook categorizes
- 8:35that specific bias as the letter of recommendation
- 8:38effect. Because they already like you. Exactly.
- 8:40The individuals selected to be informants already
- 8:44like the subject, which skews the data positively
- 8:47right from the start. In fact, informants can
- 8:50sometimes produce ratings that are even more
- 8:53unrealistically favorable. than the person's
- 8:56own self -enhancement bias. That's hilarious.
- 8:58They're lying for you better than you lie for
- 9:00yourself. Basically. And that bias reaches its
- 9:03absolute peak with the honeymoon effect. Oh,
- 9:06love is blind. Totally blind. If you ask a newlywed
- 9:09to rate their spouse's personality, you aren't
- 9:12going to get a scientifically accurate psychological
- 9:14profile. You are going to get a glowing, flawless,
- 9:17romanticized illusion. And the text cynically
- 9:20points out that this effect steadily vanishes
- 9:21as marrable satisfaction declines over the years.
- 9:24The honeymoon ends. And the informant ratings
- 9:26crash back down to a much harsher reality. Yikes.
- 9:29So speaking of informants, there is another bias
- 9:32we need to cover, especially if you have siblings.
- 9:34Oh, the sibling contrast effect. This is a big
- 9:36one for parents. Right. It's essentially a highly
- 9:39localized version of the reference group effect
- 9:41we discussed earlier. So imagine a family has
- 9:44three kids. Right. And the older two are wildly
- 9:47obnoxiously extroverted. Like bouncing off the
- 9:50walls. Yeah. The parents establish that chaos
- 9:53as the baseline for normal behavior. So if the
- 9:56third child is perfectly average in their sociability,
- 9:59the parents will experience that average behavior
- 10:01as extreme introversion. Exactly. They will rate
- 10:05that third child as painfully shy, which fundamentally
- 10:09exaggerates the true magnitude of the personality
- 10:12differences between their kids. The parent's
- 10:14baseline is just totally warped. OK, before we
- 10:17move to the next pillar, let's quickly review
- 10:19test classification. objective tests vary drastically
- 10:22in their comprehensiveness. Right. Sometimes
- 10:24a researcher might only care about one highly
- 10:26specific attribute. So they use a targeted tool.
- 10:29The text gives the example of the Toronto alexithymia
- 10:32scale. Yeah, alexithymia is the inability to
- 10:35identify and describe one's own emotions. So
- 10:38that entire test zeros in on that single specific
- 10:41deficit. Contrast that with the massive omnibus
- 10:44inventories like the NEO -PI3 or the Hexoco -PIR.
- 10:49Those are beastly tests. Yeah, they are designed
- 10:51to map the entire personality. They don't just
- 10:54measure broad traits like extraversion. They
- 10:57break those traits down into specific subcategories
- 11:00called facets. And that granularity is essential.
- 11:03Extraversion is just too blunt of an instrument
- 11:05to be practically useful in many contexts. Give
- 11:08me an example. You could have two people who
- 11:10both score extremely high on extroversion, but
- 11:13they look totally different in reality. How so?
- 11:15Because the NEO -PI3 separates extroversion into
- 11:19facets like gregariousness and assertiveness.
- 11:21Oh, I see. So one extrovert might be high on
- 11:24assertiveness. They naturally dominate boardrooms,
- 11:26they take charge, but they are low on gregariousness,
- 11:29meaning they actually hate small talk and large
- 11:32parties. And the other extrovert might be the
- 11:33exact opposite. They love parties but hate taking
- 11:36charge. Exactly. Omnibus tests capture those
- 11:39vital nuances. OK, so that covers the first pillar,
- 11:42the mirror and the witness. But what if both
- 11:44the self and the witness are operating in the
- 11:47dark? Ah, going back to the psychodynamic theorists.
- 11:50Right. What if they're completely right and our
- 11:54deepest, truest motives operate beneath the floorboards
- 11:57of our conscious awareness? That requires the
- 12:00second pillar of the soul, what we hide. Projective
- 12:03and implicit tests. Essentially methods of confessing
- 12:07the hidden soul. Since you can't ask a direct
- 12:09question to an unconscious mind you have to bypass
- 12:12the conscious defenses entirely. Enter the projective
- 12:15hypothesis. It's the idea that if you present
- 12:18someone with a totally ambiguous stimulus, like
- 12:21something with no inherent meaning, their brain
- 12:23cannot tolerate the ambiguity. The brain hates
- 12:26a vacuum. Exactly. To make sense of it, the brain
- 12:28will project its own unconscious needs, hidden
- 12:31anxieties, and suppressed impulses onto the stimulus.
- 12:34The Rorschach inkblot test is the most culturally
- 12:36famous example of this. Oh yeah, the inkblots!
- 12:39The subject looks at a symmetrical inkblot and
- 12:41is asked to describe what they see. However,
- 12:43for the exam, we absolutely must note the severe
- 12:46criticism regarding the Rorschach's validity.
- 12:48Oh yeah, the text kind of tears it apart. Even
- 12:50with complex, standardized scoring frameworks
- 12:53like Exner's comprehensive system, critics argue
- 12:56the Rorschach provides terrible incremental validity.
- 12:59Let's define that. Incremental validity meaning?
- 13:02Meaning it takes a massive amount of time and
- 13:04specialized training to administer and score
- 13:07an inkblot test. And at the end of it, you haven't
- 13:10learned anything useful that a simple 10 -minute
- 13:12self -report questionnaire wouldn't have already
- 13:14told you. So it's a lot of work for basically
- 13:17zero new information. Pretty much. But the text
- 13:20does pivot to a projective test with a much stronger
- 13:23track record, the TAT, or the thematic apperception
- 13:26test. Right. Instead of meaningless inkblots,
- 13:29the TAT uses ambiguous, slightly surreal pictures
- 13:33of human situations. The subject is asked to
- 13:35invent a narrative, like... What led up to this
- 13:38moment? What are the characters thinking and
- 13:39feeling? And how does the story end? OK, you
- 13:41guys picture this T .A .T. image from the text.
- 13:44You see an elderly woman with her back turned
- 13:46to a young man. Right. And the young man is looking
- 13:48downward with a deeply perplexed, conflicted
- 13:51expression. Yeah. So what story does your brain
- 13:54automatically generate? Is he feeling intense
- 13:57guilt because he just lied to his mother? Or
- 14:00is she turning away in cold disappointment? Or
- 14:02maybe she is leaving forever and he is terrified
- 14:05of surviving without her. The point is the narrative
- 14:08you construct has nothing to do with the ink
- 14:10on the page and everything to do with your internal
- 14:12psychological landscape. There's another image
- 14:14mentioned too. A man being clutched from behind
- 14:17by three disembodied mysterious hands. Oh, that
- 14:21one is so creepy. Right. Does your mind immediately
- 14:24invent a story about a violent kidnapping? Or
- 14:27maybe it's an intervention by caring friends
- 14:29pulling him back from the brink. Or some kind
- 14:31of supernatural attack. The text points out that
- 14:34the TAT is remarkably effective at measuring
- 14:37implicit motives. Particularly things like the
- 14:40need for achievement or the need for power. These
- 14:42are profound driving forces in a person's life
- 14:45that they literally cannot consciously articulate.
- 14:48They lack the vocabulary to explain these motives
- 14:51on a standard self -report. And modern psychology
- 14:53has evolved this concept into computerized implicit
- 14:57tests. Right, moving away from subjective stories.
- 15:00Exactly. Instead of interpreting stories, these
- 15:03tests measure automatic neural associations using
- 15:06reaction times. Reaction times. Okay, break that
- 15:09down for me. Think of your unconscious mind like
- 15:11a dense forest. Over the course of your life,
- 15:15repeated experiences create well -worn paths
- 15:17between certain concepts. Okay, I'm with you.
- 15:20Implicit tests measure how quickly your brain
- 15:22travels down those paths. So you're staring at
- 15:25a screen with your fingers on the keyboard and
- 15:27you are asked to sort words as fast as physically
- 15:29possible. Yes. And if the concept of me and the
- 15:33concept of assertive are deeply unconsciously
- 15:36linked in your brain, you will sort those words
- 15:38together fractions of a second faster than if
- 15:41you had to sort me. shy. Wow! It's essentially
- 15:44testing the psychological equivalent of muscle
- 15:46memory. Exactly. And the brilliance of this mechanism
- 15:49is that it outsmarts the conscious brain's ability
- 15:52to lie. Because it's too fast. Right. Even if
- 15:54your self -enhancement bias really wants to portray
- 15:57you as perfectly agreeable, you simply do not
- 15:59have the reaction time speed to fake the automatic
- 16:02neural associations. The validity evidence for
- 16:05these implicit measures shows they can predict
- 16:08spontaneous unfiltered behavior in ways that
- 16:11conscious self -reports totally miss. Which is
- 16:14pretty amazing. That brings us to our third and
- 16:17final pillar of the soul. What we do. Behavioral
- 16:21and performance measures. By their fruits, you
- 16:23fail know them. Exactly. Words are deceptive.
- 16:26Witnesses are biased, and interpreting unconscious
- 16:29associations is really messy. Let's just look
- 16:33at the physical reality of a person's actions.
- 16:36Direct behavioral observation completely sidesteps
- 16:38the ego of the self -report, and it sidesteps
- 16:41the subjective interpretation of the projective
- 16:43tests. Like that study by Funder and Colbin.
- 16:45Right. They brought pairs of strangers into a
- 16:47laboratory and recorded them having a simple
- 16:49five -minute getting -acquainted conversation.
- 16:51And then independent raters watched the footage
- 16:54and coded their personalities based on observable
- 16:57physical actions. Things like eye contact, fidgeting,
- 17:00speech patterns. No self -reporting involved.
- 17:02But doing this in a sterile lab is one thing.
- 17:05Mel and his colleagues took this into the wild
- 17:06using the EAR, the electronically activated recorder.
- 17:10This one blows my mind. Participants wore this
- 17:12small device during their normal daily lives
- 17:15for two days. And the EAR was programmed to turn
- 17:18on randomly and record brief snippets of ambient
- 17:21audio. Think about the mechanics of that. It
- 17:23captures an entirely unfiltered audio documentary
- 17:26of your natural habitat. Right. The researchers
- 17:29didn't rely on subjects estimating how social
- 17:32they were. They simply quantified the audio.
- 17:34They measured the exact frequency and duration
- 17:37of the participants talking over those two days
- 17:39and found it strongly mapped onto observer ratings
- 17:42of extroversion. Okay, but my favorite behavioral
- 17:45measure is Gosling's study. I affectionately
- 17:48call it the creepy dorm room study. Yes. Gosling's
- 17:52team bypassed the subjects entirely. They literally
- 17:55sent observers into college students' bedrooms
- 17:57and rated the students' big five personality
- 17:59traits purely by analyzing the physical space.
- 18:02The mechanism here relies on two key terms for
- 18:05the exam, behavioral residue and identity claims.
- 18:08Okay, behavioral residue. That's the physical
- 18:10fallout of your repeated actions. Right. Exactly.
- 18:13Like a meticulously color -coded closet versus
- 18:16a floor covered in old coffee cups and crumpled
- 18:18laundry. Guilt is charged, and identity claims
- 18:21are the deliberate ways we broadcast who we are.
- 18:23Like hanging a provocative political poster directly
- 18:26across from the door so everyone sees it. And
- 18:29the results were undeniable. Observers accurately
- 18:31assessed personality traits without ever speaking
- 18:34to the student. Neater, organized rooms, heavy
- 18:37on the positive behavioral residue, strongly
- 18:39correlated with high conscientiousness. While
- 18:42rooms featuring a wide eclectic variety of books,
- 18:45magazines, and art correlated with high openness
- 18:47to experience, your bedroom is basically a physical
- 18:50footprint of your soul. It really is. But the
- 18:54data is compelling. Yes, however, we must interrogate
- 18:57the severe disadvantages of behavior. measures.
- 19:00But there are always disadvantages. First off,
- 19:02the sheer logistics. It's a nightmare, categorizing
- 19:04thousands of hours of ambient audio or rigorously
- 19:08scoring the specific messiness of 100 dorm rooms.
- 19:11It's incredibly labor -intensive compared to
- 19:13just handing out a survey. So labor -intensive.
- 19:15And wait, aren't we just judging a book by its
- 19:17cover here? What do you mean? Well, what if I
- 19:20am genuinely a highly conscientious person, but
- 19:24the researchers happen to observe my dorm room
- 19:27during final exam week? Ah, I see. Like I'm running
- 19:29on three hours of sleep, I've been living on
- 19:32energy drinks, and my room looks like a disaster
- 19:34zone. The researchers would code me as completely
- 19:37disorganized. You're hitting on the primary vulnerability
- 19:40of behavioral measures. While they do capture
- 19:43authentic reality, they are only sampling tiny,
- 19:46isolated slices of time. Right, a snapshot. A
- 19:49five minute conversation or the state of your
- 19:51bedroom on a Tuesday afternoon is highly susceptible
- 19:54to transient influences. Transient influences
- 19:57meaning? Meaning an acute stressor, a physical
- 19:59illness, or a lack of sleep can severely distort
- 20:02your behavior. Making that specific snapshot
- 20:05wildly unrepresentative of your actual long -term
- 20:08baseline. Makes total sense. Okay, we are coming
- 20:11up to the end of our session. Let's make sure
- 20:13we have the core exam concepts locked in before
- 20:15we close chapter three. Sounds good. The entire
- 20:19debate around these three pillars hinges on two
- 20:21massive concepts, reliability and validity. Reliability
- 20:26is fundamentally about consistency, right? Yes.
- 20:28If a tool is reliable, it produces the same result
- 20:31under the same conditions. If you take a personality
- 20:33test today and score high on extraversion, you
- 20:36should score high on that exact same test next
- 20:39month. That's test -retest reliability. Exactly.
- 20:42And this is key. A test can be perfectly reliable
- 20:46and completely invalid. Oh, absolutely. Because
- 20:48validity is about accuracy and real -world prediction.
- 20:52Does the test actually measure what it claims
- 20:54to measure, and does it predict outcomes like
- 20:56job performance, divorce, or mortality? Right.
- 20:59And the ultimate conclusion of the chapter is
- 21:01that there is no psychological silver bullet.
- 21:03Every single method is flawed. Every single one.
- 21:06The Mirror of Objective Test provides incredible
- 21:08volume and internal insight, but it is heavily
- 21:11distorted by pride, ego, and shifting reference
- 21:14groups. Then the hidden soul of projective and
- 21:16implicit tests attempts to bypass those conscious
- 21:19defenses, but scoring them is complex, and the
- 21:22incremental validity is highly debated. And finally,
- 21:25the physical evidence of behavioral measures
- 21:27provides an authentic look at reality, but it
- 21:30is highly vulnerable to the transient stress
- 21:33of a single bad day. Therefore, the responsible
- 21:36psychologist must integrate. Triangulate the
- 21:39truth. Exactly. To achieve a comprehensive understanding
- 21:42of human personality, you have to use a diversity
- 21:45of approaches. You gather the self -report, cross
- 21:48-reference it with informant ratings, look for
- 21:50underlying implicit motives, and anchor it all
- 21:53with behavioral observation. It's a massive puzzle.
- 21:56Alright, before we pack up our notes and call
- 21:58this study session complete, I want to leave
- 22:00you with a final thought to ponder. Lay it on
- 22:01us. Imagine volunteering for a massive comprehensive
- 22:05study. The researchers use the EAR and observe
- 22:08your bedroom. And the physical behavior evidence
- 22:11says you are chaotic, disorganized, and messy.
- 22:14OK, not looking good. Then you take the computerized
- 22:16sorting test, and your implicit reaction times
- 22:19reveal you deeply unconsciously crave dominance.
- 22:22Yikes. But then you fill out a self -report questionnaire,
- 22:25and your conscious ego paints you as a generous,
- 22:29highly agreeable angel. And finally, they ask
- 22:32your newlywed spice to rate you, and thanks to
- 22:34the honeymoon effect, the informant rating says
- 22:37you are absolutely flawless. So they are all
- 22:40completely contradicting each other. Right. If
- 22:42all these scientifically validated assessments
- 22:44fiercely disagree with each other, which one
- 22:46is the real you? Or is personality just a convenient
- 22:49illusion entirely shaped by the specific tool
- 22:52we use to measure it?