Latest / The Line Podcast / The Line Podcast: Carney is winning the vibes war
Transcript
- 0:00it's the line podcast mark carney doesn't go to washington he
- 0:03stops a bit further
- 0:04north he goes to new york jen's got some questions about that
- 0:08we'll get into them
- 0:09in a minute we're going to talk the big weird plains i'm gonna
- 0:12have to explain what
- 0:13that means but don't worry we will jen and i are going to kick
- 0:16around a couple of
- 0:17ideas around the state of alberta the referendum and whether or
- 0:21not i should say
- 0:22SPEAKER_00: anything about it plus why cities piss me off it's the line podcast
- 0:37This episode of The Line podcast is brought to you by
- 0:40Electro-Federation Canada.
- 0:42Canada's clean electricity grid gives us a competitive edge in
- 0:45attracting global investment.
- 0:46But to maintain that advantage,
- 0:48our system needs to break down barriers and unlock the grid.
- 0:52SPEAKER_00: Aging infrastructure,
- 0:53SPEAKER_00: supply chain constraints,
- 0:55and outdated regulations threaten our ability to expand and
- 0:58modernize the grid,
- 0:59SPEAKER_00: essential components of meeting future capacity needs.
- 1:03Electro Federation Canada has developed a research back roadmap
- 1:07for grid readiness
- 1:08focused on smart policy and regulatory alignment visit
- 1:11maketheswitch.electrofed.com
- 1:17I don't sleep as much as I used to which is a fun way to start
- 1:20a podcast and I roll
- 1:21over in bed last night and I'm awake and I grab my phone which
- 1:25I shouldn't and I
- 1:26check it and time zones in your defense Jen time zones are
- 1:30working against us a bit
- 1:32but at like two in the morning you're like what do we think
- 1:35about Mark Carney's
- 1:36trip to New York sorry about that sorry you didn't you didn't
- 1:42wake me up it's not
- 1:43what woke me up but it was I'm not trying to wake anybody up
- 1:46it's just like my
- 1:46brain starts going sometime between like 10 and midnight and I
- 1:49start firing off
- 1:50questions and the more that I wake up in the morning and the
- 1:53questions are answered
- 1:54so it's perfect for me well I chose not to I just put my phone
- 1:58back down um
- 2:00And yet when i woke up the answer was there was it was it's
- 2:03great um so i'm
- 2:05mountain standard time matt i i did want to talk about this
- 2:07let's just get into the
- 2:08news firstly so mark carney goes to um uh the to the united
- 2:12states to to america to
- 2:14go deliver some speeches particularly he gave a speech at i
- 2:17believe the economic
- 2:18SPEAKER_01: club in new york
- 2:20and interesting speech in and of itself taken as a whole I
- 2:24don't think the speech
- 2:25was a fire burner by any a barn burner by any stretch but there
- 2:30was one line in
- 2:30particular that stood out online and that was something to the
- 2:34effect of a strong
- 2:35SPEAKER_01: Canada will help make America great again and
- 2:41So it struck a more conciliatory tone like this was not like
- 2:44there's a giant
- 2:45rupture between the United States and Canada and we're more
- 2:48into the territory of
- 2:49well sure there are certain areas where we can develop some
- 2:53some partnerships and
- 2:55SPEAKER_01: alignments.
- 2:56I think this also follows on a previous speech that Carney gave
- 3:00where he was
- 3:00started talking about fortress North America which is very much
- 3:03American language
- 3:05SPEAKER_01: on the matter of the renegotiation of Kuzma Uzmika
- 3:11which I purposely mispronounce every single time just to make
- 3:13sure I'm being balanced.
- 3:17And I wanted to ask you a question about this in particular and
- 3:20then I want to get
- 3:20into the actual statement itself because it's really amazing to
- 3:23me how it has
- 3:23SPEAKER_01: pissed every single person off and no one off at the same time.
- 3:27SPEAKER_01: It's a very Canadian statement.
- 3:29SPEAKER_01: But first I wanted to ask you this one question from your perspective.
- 3:34Are both sides on the American and Canada side toning it down
- 3:38ahead of real
- 3:38SPEAKER_01: negotiations on kumuzgma?
- 3:41SPEAKER_01: Or are you reading this as a sign that Canada's capitulated?
- 3:47SPEAKER_00: I would actually say neither.
- 3:49SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 3:50SPEAKER_00: Sure.
- 3:51SPEAKER_00: So, like, I would pick a third option.
- 3:54SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 3:55SPEAKER_00: Well, you can't do that.
- 3:56SPEAKER_01: That's not what... No, I'm kidding.
- 3:59SPEAKER_00: Just watch me.
- 4:01SPEAKER_00: I wouldn't describe it as a toning down because...
- 4:06I think we're going to talk about the big weird planes later so
- 4:09that I think was a
- 4:11message we sent to Washington and it was not a toned down
- 4:14message we'll get to that
- 4:15later I do think what we're doing is moving into a different
- 4:19phase and I think that
- 4:24what the Prime Minister said we haven't even said what he said
- 4:26yet but I don't
- 4:27remember the exact wording but it was something like a strong
- 4:30Canada will help make
- 4:31SPEAKER_00: America great again I think that's what he said and
- 4:36When i saw that statement and then i also saw the response by
- 4:40uh pete uh extra the
- 4:41um uh u.s ambassador to canada i think i'm the only canadian
- 4:45that likes this guy
- 4:45but i actually do like him and no i think he's on his way to
- 4:48becoming an actual
- 4:49anti-folk hero and i think we're going to be singing sea
- 4:51shanties about the man nor
- 4:52in in newfoundland in 20 years i actually think there's
- 4:55something kind of the state
- 4:57SPEAKER_00: of newfoundland um yeah exactly um
- 5:02his response to it was basically I think this is a very welcome
- 5:06message and I think
- 5:07it would be received really well when I view this I don't view
- 5:11this as toning it
- 5:11down and I don't view it as capitulation I do view it as us
- 5:15moving into the actual
- 5:16bargaining window because I think you know the deadline if I
- 5:21remember is July 1st I
- 5:23think it's been well reported there have not been a lot of
- 5:25talks going on between
- 5:26SPEAKER_00: Canada and the United States I think that's going to start changing
- 5:31SPEAKER_00: And I think both sides are trying to show a little good faith.
- 5:36SPEAKER_00: Do we define that as toning it down?
- 5:38SPEAKER_00: Yeah, maybe.
- 5:39SPEAKER_00: Maybe I'm just quibbling with how you described it.
- 5:41SPEAKER_00: But my read on this overall was basically, oh, okay, it's game on.
- 5:47SPEAKER_00: It's time.
- 5:48SPEAKER_00: Now the actual bargaining will begin.
- 5:50SPEAKER_01: Okay, so here's what I want to do.
- 5:51SPEAKER_01: I want to talk about the statement itself and how people responded to it.
- 5:55I also want to talk about the whole idea of Fortress North
- 5:58America in as much as we
- 6:00can know about it because of course we're journalists we're not
- 6:03at the trade table
- 6:04no one's leaking us point by point details about where things
- 6:07are at the trade
- 6:08table and I'm not going to pretend like the opposite is true we
- 6:14have a general
- 6:14sense of what's probably going on in a very big picture way but
- 6:17that's whatever but
- 6:21SPEAKER_01: first I want to talk about the statement itself strong Canada makes
- 6:26Make America Great Again of course a lot of people on the left
- 6:29were going to cotton
- 6:30on to that because of course the Make America Great Again is
- 6:33Donald Trump's
- 6:33SPEAKER_01: catchphrase so what in the hell is Mr.
- 6:36Elbows Up Mark Carney doing using that phrase in that context
- 6:41and so you have a
- 6:42SPEAKER_01: people I think on the left who are going to respond badly to that.
- 6:45SPEAKER_01: And I also think,
- 6:46SPEAKER_01: ironically,
- 6:46you're going to have people on the right respond badly to that
- 6:48because they're
- 6:48SPEAKER_01: going to say to the effect of,
- 6:50SPEAKER_01: oh,
- 6:51SPEAKER_01: Mr.
- 6:51SPEAKER_01: Elbows Up,
- 6:52SPEAKER_01: you're flip-flopping now,
- 6:54SPEAKER_01: this isn't what you promised us,
- 6:55SPEAKER_01: blah,
- 6:55SPEAKER_01: blah,
- 6:57SPEAKER_01: blah.
- 6:58SPEAKER_01: And I want to talk about both of those reactions.
- 7:02SPEAKER_01: But firstly,
- 7:04I think that my general takeaway from all of this is I want to
- 7:09remind people,
- 7:10SPEAKER_01: or from my perception,
- 7:11SPEAKER_01: why Carney got elected.
- 7:13Kearney from my perspective during the election wasn't elected
- 7:18to strike a deal
- 7:19SPEAKER_01: with the Americans or to not strike a deal with the Americans.
- 7:22SPEAKER_01: From my perspective,
- 7:23Kearney was elected by the people of Canada because the people
- 7:25of Canada trusted
- 7:26SPEAKER_01: him more than Pierre Polyev to manage the relationship.
- 7:31SPEAKER_01: And I don't think that he's being held to an objective standard.
- 7:35SPEAKER_01: I don't think he's being held to a
- 7:37SPEAKER_01: The Line theline
- 8:01SPEAKER_01: Which,
- 8:01SPEAKER_01: by the way,
- 8:01I understand why the Conservatives would be pissed off about
- 8:04that because that's
- 8:04SPEAKER_01: not a fair standard,
- 8:06SPEAKER_01: right?
- 8:06Like,
- 8:07do Canadians perceive him to be managing this relationship well
- 8:11or not?
- 8:12And I think the polling is pretty indicative that they do think
- 8:15he's managing the
- 8:16SPEAKER_01: relationship well.
- 8:17But he's not being held to a standard that's like,
- 8:20okay,
- 8:20he managed to reduce tariffs 5%.
- 8:22SPEAKER_01: That's a win.
- 8:24or you know he managed to preserve the auto sector that's a win
- 8:28or um uh he he he
- 8:31got a really bad deal on softwood wood softwood lumber tariffs
- 8:36therefore he's
- 8:38failed as our prime minister like I just don't think that's the
- 8:41bar for him right
- 8:41now so on vibes on on vibes alone Matt how do you think
- 8:46Carney's doing managing
- 8:47this relationship understanding that we're kind of
- 8:50conservative-ish right people
- 8:53Do we feel that he is managing this relationship well or are we
- 8:57noticing that
- 8:58SPEAKER_01: there's a lot of flip-flopping happening?
- 9:00Are we noticing that we're going from elbows up to make America
- 9:07great again?
- 9:07SPEAKER_01: Is that discordant messaging?
- 9:12SPEAKER_00: You know, it's funny.
- 9:14SPEAKER_00: Good question.
- 9:15SPEAKER_00: And I found myself...
- 9:18SPEAKER_00: The Line
- 9:39was whether or not Carney is only going to be assessed on vibes
- 9:44and now what I'm
- 9:45doing is I'm questioning how I've been assessing him oh okay
- 9:49good so I think I have
- 9:54tried to assess him not on vibes I think yes but you're a
- 9:57weirdo yeah no I know but
- 10:00I understand your assessment of him isn't going to be on vibes
- 10:02so I'm saying the
- 10:03SPEAKER_01: general assessment no but I think assessment
- 10:06SPEAKER_00: But I wonder, Jen, and this is what I'm thinking about.
- 10:08So I've been out pretty hard and early going,
- 10:12he's not getting the stuff done.
- 10:14SPEAKER_00: Like he's not doing the things.
- 10:16But I also think if you were to ask me a question on the
- 10:18US-Canada relationship
- 10:19SPEAKER_00: specifically,
- 10:20SPEAKER_00: I actually think I would give him a good grade.
- 10:22SPEAKER_00: And now I'm wondering if it's just because of vibes.
- 10:25Like I'm actually wondering now,
- 10:26for the first time,
- 10:27I'm actually maybe thinking about
- 10:30like when it comes to major projects offices stuff military
- 10:33procurement internal
- 10:34trade barriers domestic unity which we'll talk about later like
- 10:38there are a lot of
- 10:39things we can kind of objectively look to and go he's doing
- 10:41good he's doing bad
- 10:42yeah I don't know how I would assess his performance yeah how
- 10:47do we objectively
- 10:48assess his performance especially in a scenario where we can't
- 10:52ever argue the
- 10:53SPEAKER_00: counterfactual like yeah maybe it's almost inherently political
- 10:58SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 10:59SPEAKER_01: it's this inherently vibe-based,
- 11:01SPEAKER_01: subjective vibe-based performance review,
- 11:03SPEAKER_01: because it's not like if he comes back with a deal tomorrow,
- 11:06SPEAKER_01: saves Kuzmika,
- 11:10and manages to preserve some kind of special carve-outs for
- 11:13like five or six
- 11:14SPEAKER_01: different sectors,
- 11:15SPEAKER_01: which I think is probably a reasonable outcome.
- 11:18If he comes back with that deal tomorrow,
- 11:20what do we base that performance against?
- 11:23SPEAKER_01: Like,
- 11:23would that be a better or worse outcome than a Pierre Polyev
- 11:26government would have
- 11:27SPEAKER_01: received?
- 11:31SPEAKER_01: It's recursive.
- 11:32SPEAKER_01: You wind up back in the same place.
- 11:33SPEAKER_01: You're still measuring not fundamentally the objective outcome.
- 11:38You're measuring whether or not you trust him to manage that
- 11:41relationship better
- 11:42SPEAKER_01: than the alternatives.
- 11:44Yeah and the more i think you're right about that and now i'm
- 11:47still kind of
- 11:47thinking this through in real time the uh the video listeners
- 11:50are getting a real
- 11:51the video viewers are getting a real thrilling experience of
- 11:54seeing matt's
- 11:54thoughtful face um which i don't think looks that much
- 11:57difference from any of my
- 11:58other faces um because i think some of your i think you're
- 12:02quite correct that like
- 12:03when you're when you're talking this through and i'm listening
- 12:05to you i keep
- 12:07SPEAKER_00: defaulting to that hypothetical poly of government
- 12:12and i wasn't planning on mentioning this today um it like it
- 12:16wasn't on our topic
- 12:17list but i don't know if you saw this but like our q1 economic
- 12:20numbers have been
- 12:21revised and they're not great and now we're in a technical
- 12:24recession and i
- 12:27immediately saw like an attack tweet by polyev and i am more
- 12:34ideologically in line
- 12:35SPEAKER_00: with conservatives than liberals
- 12:38SPEAKER_00: But for the last 18 months,
- 12:41SPEAKER_00: almost,
- 12:42SPEAKER_00: I think the conservatives have just not found a coherent position.
- 12:48SPEAKER_00: And I looked at what Polyev was saying today, and he's right, factually.
- 12:54SPEAKER_01: Well, what did he say?
- 12:55SPEAKER_00: Oh,
- 12:56SPEAKER_00: it was something like,
- 12:57SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 12:57Mark Carney has steered us to be the only G7 country in a
- 13:00recession or something.
- 13:02SPEAKER_00: And that's like, I think, technically accurate.
- 13:05SPEAKER_01: Mm-hmm.
- 13:05but I also just cannot imagine anyone who's not already like
- 13:10ridiculously excited
- 13:12to mark their ballot for the conservatives giving a shit yeah
- 13:16and you know and also
- 13:17the other question starts to be it's like okay and in the
- 13:19current environment where
- 13:21SPEAKER_01: we're dealing with what we're dealing with
- 13:23would I trust Pierre to like not have us in a recession so like
- 13:26he's always being
- 13:27Mark Carney on this file is always going to be graded on a
- 13:29curve and I'm saying
- 13:30that's actually not fair to the conservatives and I agree that
- 13:33it's not fair to the
- 13:33conservatives but I think it's also the reality of the world
- 13:37we're in today yeah no
- 13:42that's interesting so you've made me all thoughtful I don't
- 13:44know if I'm giving
- 13:45SPEAKER_00: great podcast content now I do think
- 13:48you and I have talked about this privately and publicly that
- 13:52there is a lot of
- 13:53frustration and anger among conservatives who are looking at
- 13:57their poll numbers
- 13:57declining like the conservatives aren't in free fall or
- 14:00anything but they're
- 14:00drifting kind of back down to their baseline level of support
- 14:03in the low 30s and
- 14:05SPEAKER_00: all of the gains that Polyev was able to open up
- 14:10compared to Trudeau are just gone I'm not I'd have to look at
- 14:15this I'm not even
- 14:16convinced right now the conservatives are as high as they got
- 14:18at times under Scheer
- 14:20and O'Toole they're kind of really sinking back down to the low
- 14:2330s and I know
- 14:25conservatives are frustrated about this and I have seen
- 14:28conservative MPs on panels
- 14:30or on social media or in little video reels they've released
- 14:33I've seen them making
- 14:34SPEAKER_00: like really
- 14:36Good Effective Criticism Of Specific Issues Or Government
- 14:39Policies But I Don't
- 14:41Think They Have Yet Found A Workable Meta Narrative And I Think
- 14:45The Liberals Meta
- 14:46Narrative And It's Not Even A Slogan They're Using I'm Going To
- 14:49Sum It Up It's
- 14:50Basically We're Going To Protect Canada Like That's Like Almost
- 14:54Everything That
- 14:54They've Done Over The Last 18 Months Even The Shit I Don't
- 14:58Agree With They Can Go
- 15:00Well That's Us Protecting Canada And I Think What The
- 15:02Conservatives Have Done Well
- 15:05have come up with really good,
- 15:07specific criticisms,
- 15:09but they don't have a meta-narrative.
- 15:12SPEAKER_01: They don't have a meta-narrative.
- 15:13SPEAKER_01: The narrative is, I think, exactly right.
- 15:14The other thing I would just say is you had a conversation with
- 15:18Phil Lagasse on the
- 15:20SPEAKER_01: line this week,
- 15:21SPEAKER_01: and there was something that you brought up that I wanted to expand on,
- 15:23and that was the idea of the conservatives were never actually
- 15:26going to fix a lot
- 15:27of the structural problems until both conservatives and
- 15:29liberals come to a kind of
- 15:30SPEAKER_00: grand bargain.
- 15:32and you were talking about that in the context of defense right
- 15:38but I think there's
- 15:39a broader one and that is the conservatives can potentially tie
- 15:42their meta
- 15:43narrative to it they need to come to a grand bargain with the
- 15:46liberals on the
- 15:48US-Canada relationship and the trade strategy and I think that
- 15:51Carney has tried to
- 15:52do that by creating the US-Canada panel that he did where
- 15:56there's the advisory
- 15:57SPEAKER_01: panel so I think that there's the beginning of an attempt to create that
- 16:01But having a situation where you have like three quarters of
- 16:05the country grading
- 16:07Mark Gurney on a curve on this particular topic and one quarter
- 16:11of the country
- 16:12screaming about how they're doing everything wrong and
- 16:15undermining confidence in
- 16:17SPEAKER_01: our trade approach from within.
- 16:20SPEAKER_01: Firstly,
- 16:21SPEAKER_01: That doesn't allow Canada to come at this from a strength position on the
- 16:29bargaining table because it means a quarter of the country is
- 16:31being chipped against
- 16:32SPEAKER_01: the other two-thirds.
- 16:33SPEAKER_01: And secondly,
- 16:34it makes the Conservatives look like assholes and sometimes
- 16:37useful idiots at times,
- 16:39SPEAKER_01: which undermines their position with the rest of the country.
- 16:41So I think there's actually dual incentives for Conservatives
- 16:46and Liberals to sit
- 16:47SPEAKER_01: down and be like,
- 16:48SPEAKER_01: okay,
- 16:48SPEAKER_01: on the US-Canada trade file,
- 16:50We need to come up with a grand bargain and we need to present
- 16:53a unified voice in
- 16:53public and the conservatives don't actually benefit from
- 16:58undermining the liberals
- 16:59on this particular file and the liberals don't benefit from not
- 17:02listening to the
- 17:02SPEAKER_01: conservatives on this file.
- 17:04So I think there's actually we need to get beyond I know I'm
- 17:09going to sound like a politician.
- 17:10SPEAKER_00: God,
- 17:12I've been on the advocacy front for two goddamn weeks and I
- 17:14already sound like one
- 17:15SPEAKER_01: of these people.
- 17:16SPEAKER_01: But we need to get beyond politics as normal.
- 17:19SPEAKER_01: Jesus!
- 17:21Christ have we optimized the synergies wow wow that happened
- 17:28fast huh anyway i'm
- 17:32just i'm just throwing it out there that the incentives are in
- 17:35line for a grand
- 17:36bargain here on more than just defense well which isn't to say
- 17:40which isn't to say
- 17:40that the liberals shouldn't be criticized for their approach or
- 17:45shouldn't be
- 17:45SPEAKER_01: approached
- 17:47and encouraged to sort of have a dissenter or to have some
- 17:51dissenting views in the
- 17:52SPEAKER_01: room in terms of how they're going about this.
- 17:56But the conservatives aren't being effective and the
- 18:01conservatives aren't making any gains.
- 18:03And I think that if the conservatives were seen more to be sort
- 18:06of effective
- 18:09SPEAKER_01: adversaries as opposed to
- 18:11Just People Who Are Like Carrying Water For The Americans Which
- 18:14Is Kind Of How How
- 18:15They'Re Coming Off A Little Bit Right Or Wrongly They Would
- 18:18Benefit By That And I
- 18:20Think That The Liberals Would Benefit By Having Some People In
- 18:22The Room Who Don't
- 18:23Look Aren't Like Them Don'T Think Like Them And Can Potentially
- 18:26Challenge Some Of
- 18:26Their Assumptions That'S Again My Outsiders Read I'M Not Inside
- 18:31These Rooms Right
- 18:33I'm uh later in the podcast if I hope we have time because I
- 18:36want to unload some
- 18:37existential frustration on the notion of Canadian municipal
- 18:40governance one of the
- 18:42things one of the things you're talking about there and I know
- 18:43this is going to
- 18:44sound like a very off-topic comment but what you're describing
- 18:47there brought to
- 18:47mind what it has been like living in Toronto while we try to
- 18:50build out our subway
- 18:51SPEAKER_00: network because what happens is like a mayor
- 18:55a would-be mayor candidate will campaign and we're going to
- 18:57build this and then
- 18:59they'll get elected and then they'll start bargaining with the
- 19:01feds and the
- 19:02provinces for like a cost splitting and then the engineers will
- 19:05do studies and then
- 19:06nothing will happen because everything takes a million goddamn
- 19:09years in Canada and
- 19:10then someone else in the next election or the one after that
- 19:13will run against that
- 19:15and this plan sucks we're going to do this and then they win
- 19:18and the whole plan
- 19:19gets torn up and kind of what ends up happening is that nothing
- 19:23gets done yeah
- 19:25SPEAKER_00: and other countries out there.
- 19:28And when Phil and I were talking on the line a few days ago,
- 19:32we were talking about Australia.
- 19:34SPEAKER_00: Australia is a country that is very, very far away from its friends.
- 19:38SPEAKER_00: And their strategic environment is not ours.
- 19:42SPEAKER_00: Australia agrees in the big picture on national defense.
- 19:47SPEAKER_00: The parties hold each other accountable for execution.
- 19:50SPEAKER_00: But when one party, like when the liberals defeat labor, I think,
- 19:55SPEAKER_00: you don't have like a 180 policy change that just resets everything
- 19:59bureaucratically like they're like okay we're still doing this
- 20:02or more or less
- 20:03Canada has never had that culture because to be honest we have
- 20:07treated a lot of a
- 20:09lot of the things that are for other countries are existential
- 20:12for us have been
- 20:13attack lines right right like other countries fuck up military
- 20:17procurement their
- 20:18neighbor conquers them we fuck up military procurement the
- 20:21conservatives go up two
- 20:22SPEAKER_00: points in the polls and they get a good fundraiser
- 20:24SPEAKER_01: Or not even that,
- 20:25we just get chastised by an American president who knows that
- 20:28there's really no
- 20:28SPEAKER_01: political capital in being mean to the Canadians.
- 20:30SPEAKER_01: Until there was political capital in being mean to the Canadians.
- 20:34SPEAKER_01: Right?
- 20:35SPEAKER_00: Life comes at you fast.
- 20:36SPEAKER_01: Life comes at you fast.
- 20:37So if you're making the argument that we need a grand bargain
- 20:40on our politics,
- 20:41SPEAKER_00: I don't think I'd disagree with that.
- 20:43SPEAKER_01: No, not on our politics.
- 20:45SPEAKER_01: Just on some specific issues.
- 20:47SPEAKER_01: Defense being one of those specific issues.
- 20:49SPEAKER_00: And I think that in terms of the Kuzma Uzma Kamuzkavaka
- 20:53But there's one thing I'll just notice here And then I'll move
- 20:56on to my next point
- 20:57And that is When Aaron O'Toole was assigned to the US-Canada
- 21:00advisory panel He got
- 21:02SPEAKER_01: attacked by other conservatives Right?
- 21:06And I'm sitting here going like Do you understand how unserious
- 21:10that makes you look?
- 21:11That the liberals gave a conservative and I realize that the
- 21:15conservative movement
- 21:16has its own purity tests around who it considers conservatives
- 21:18but like the
- 21:19liberals actually opened the door to people from alternative
- 21:22perspectives into an
- 21:23advisory panel and you attacked the one of your own former
- 21:27leader for taking that
- 21:29seat as opposed to saying okay great really glad to have a
- 21:33conservative perspective
- 21:34SPEAKER_01: in that room
- 21:35It just undermines their capacity to come across as serious on
- 21:40this file.
- 21:41SPEAKER_01: And that gets me back to the original point.
- 21:43SPEAKER_01: Carney's not being judged on objective outcomes.
- 21:46SPEAKER_01: He's being judged on how people trust him to manage the relationship.
- 21:49So if they continue to trust him to manage the relationship
- 21:52better than they can
- 21:53SPEAKER_01: trust you,
- 21:54then he gets to win by default no matter what he brings to the
- 21:57actual table.
- 21:57SPEAKER_00: A couple of weeks ago,
- 21:59SPEAKER_00: and you're going to think I'm nuts for about the next 15 seconds,
- 22:02SPEAKER_00: but then you're going to understand it.
- 22:04yeah okay but you're talking to me here like like we embrace we
- 22:08embrace the nuts at
- 22:08the line a couple of weeks ago I was waiting for a meeting to
- 22:13start at a restaurant
- 22:15and I was sitting next to what I'm pretty sure was a first date
- 22:17by like teenagers
- 22:19and I just don't mean first date for the two of them like I'm
- 22:21not convinced that
- 22:23either of them had ever been on a date before adorable it was
- 22:26so adorable they were
- 22:28SPEAKER_00: so earnest and nervous and polite gosh and watching
- 22:33the two of them try to figure out how to go on a date reminded
- 22:39me of Canadian
- 22:40senior officials having meetings about like important issues of
- 22:43national security
- 22:44and consequence they know they kind of know what they're
- 22:50supposed to be doing like
- 22:52they understand that this is what their job is but they're
- 22:56pretty inexperienced at
- 22:57SPEAKER_00: it um
- 23:00what you were saying a minute ago is do the conservatives know
- 23:03how unserious this
- 23:04makes them look they do not they do not well okay um look we're
- 23:09probably heading
- 23:10into a snap anytime now so I but I'm not convinced I worry
- 23:20sometimes that we have
- 23:22layer upon layer of a layer of so-called leadership in this
- 23:25country whether it's
- 23:26SPEAKER_00: elected or appointed or bureaucratic or whatever
- 23:30that have only really ever understood what their job is by
- 23:34watching someone else do
- 23:35SPEAKER_00: it on Netflix.
- 23:38And we kind of avoided devastating consequences for a while
- 23:42because Canada's lucky.
- 23:45SPEAKER_00: But now all of a sudden we're facing real existential threats.
- 23:47Like just think back six years ago to the pandemic where it was
- 23:50very clear that
- 23:51SPEAKER_00: these people who were in charge of very vital social state functions,
- 23:58SPEAKER_00: societal and state functions,
- 24:01their level of awareness of a pandemic preparedness and public
- 24:05health and stuff is
- 24:05they had read a briefing memo once and I'm looking at it so I
- 24:11think we're running
- 24:11into those problems economically in terms of internal trade in
- 24:14terms of defense but
- 24:16I also think our political culture is not good and a recurring
- 24:19theme that you and I
- 24:20have been talking about for weeks and I think we might talk
- 24:22about it a bit later on
- 24:24is how in Alberta the federalist forces are disorganized
- 24:27because there's no
- 24:27SPEAKER_00: experience of these people working together
- 24:30That's not quite how I would phrase it,
- 24:32but we're going to get into that in the third segment.
- 24:34SPEAKER_01: I think it's actually worse than that.
- 24:39SPEAKER_01: They have lots of people who are used to working together.
- 24:42I think they struggle to get it through their head that they're
- 24:46going to have to
- 24:47SPEAKER_01: attack people who they work together.
- 24:49SPEAKER_01: That's the harder thing.
- 24:51SPEAKER_00: and i think could there be a version of that federally for liberals and
- 24:55conservatives right now the one you know what the one
- 24:57counterpoint to all this
- 24:58though jen we almost had a version of this a couple of weeks
- 25:02ago or months ago now
- 25:03SPEAKER_00: when polyev was doing his tour of america and going on rogan and stuff
- 25:08he reportedly they both talked openly he was coordinating that
- 25:12with the prime
- 25:13minister that's that's actually correct and he did well on
- 25:17Rogan he did well on
- 25:19Rogan but also like there were the reports that like Poliev
- 25:22spoke to Carney before
- 25:23he went and then a couple of weeks later you can't have
- 25:27conservatives doing the
- 25:28tour like conservatives can be really valuable in terms of
- 25:31reaching out to certain
- 25:32kind of conservative networks and nodes in America but you
- 25:35can't have them doing
- 25:36SPEAKER_01: that and queering the pitch at the same time
- 25:38right so a couple of weeks later uh jameel javani conservative
- 25:41mp was i don't
- 25:43remember he was down in washington for something and like then
- 25:45the prime minister
- 25:46had to come out and be like no only one person speaks for
- 25:48canada and it's him so i
- 25:50think like for a couple of weeks we might have almost got it
- 25:54right yeah but then we
- 25:56forgot yeah well you know it's hard to keep more than one
- 25:59thought in mind this one
- 26:00thing at the time speaking of which i'm gonna magpie here um
- 26:04because i want to get
- 26:04SPEAKER_00: back you mangled that saying it's hard matt to have more than
- 26:08yeah more than one oh dear you know look I mean you don't
- 26:12nobody comes to the line
- 26:13podcast expecting polished perfection this is where you get the
- 26:16unfiltered reality
- 26:17here um the other thing I want to talk about is Fortress North
- 26:21America so this is
- 26:23this is kind of American phrasing that we heard um Mark Carney
- 26:28repeat a couple of
- 26:28weeks ago basically saying look there are a couple of areas
- 26:30where we can create
- 26:31SPEAKER_01: this quote-unquote Fortress North America um my
- 26:35general understanding of it is like it's okay so America is
- 26:38going to protect us
- 26:39we're going to contribute to that protection I mean you said it
- 26:42with like I say in
- 26:44a kind of auxiliary fashion tariffs will still be enacted on us
- 26:49with probably some
- 26:49sectoral carve outs where it strategically makes sense for
- 26:52America like that seems
- 26:53to be the fortress North America idea and it seems to me as
- 26:57well that Carney is not
- 26:58totally opposed to starting from that position as well like
- 27:01there's that's probably
- 27:02SPEAKER_01: going to be some version of that is what we're going to get
- 27:05SPEAKER_01: And do you want to know why I hate this metaphor Matt?
- 27:08Because that's not a fortress You don't That's not a fortress
- 27:13That's a castle with
- 27:15a slightly Dilapidated appendage on the side Like that's not
- 27:18how a fortress works A
- 27:19fortress works by creating like Mutual interest and unity Among
- 27:24the entire polity
- 27:27Or What you have is A kind of vassal state appendage That's
- 27:32perpetually weakened
- 27:34SPEAKER_01: Which
- 27:35doesn't serve American interests because a vassal state that's
- 27:38perpetually weakened
- 27:39SPEAKER_01: is a forever liability and strategic weakness for you.
- 27:43If you're creating a situation where the smaller weaker nation
- 27:47is perpetually
- 27:48SPEAKER_01: tariffed to the gills in order to fulfill the egotistical desires of your
- 27:55SPEAKER_01: president,
- 27:56that means that we are financially and economically less
- 27:59capable of putting the
- 28:01SPEAKER_01: money required into defense
- 28:04It means that you have a population that's perpetually turned
- 28:07against you and
- 28:08SPEAKER_01: doesn't trust you.
- 28:11And that just creates an opening for your adversaries to come
- 28:14in through the side.
- 28:15SPEAKER_01: I'm picturing in my head a really strong castle,
- 28:19but then a very weak little outhouse out back where you're just
- 28:25creating your own
- 28:27SPEAKER_01: weakened entry here.
- 28:28You're creating a space where your enemies can come in through
- 28:31the back because you
- 28:32SPEAKER_01: haven't successfully
- 28:35SPEAKER_01: extended the castle walls out high enough or far enough.
- 28:39SPEAKER_01: And I think that that's my issue.
- 28:41SPEAKER_01: Maybe I'm leaning too much on the metaphors.
- 28:44SPEAKER_01: But look,
- 28:46you either have a fortress North America in where Canada is
- 28:51considered to be an
- 28:52important partner and you don't tariff the hell out of it and
- 28:56you see your benefit
- 28:58SPEAKER_01: as being mutually intertwined with an economically
- 29:04strong capable ally on your continent right that's a fortress
- 29:11or you create a
- 29:11system where 40 million people are perpetually economically and
- 29:16politically
- 29:16disadvantaged and you think that that's not going to hurt you
- 29:22in the long run and
- 29:25also I would just say also a fortress requires trust between
- 29:28everybody who live
- 29:29SPEAKER_01: within it so
- 29:33what you're talking fortress but they're actually creating two
- 29:37solitudes and one of
- 29:39these solitudes is perpetually weaker than the other more so
- 29:42than would be by dint
- 29:44SPEAKER_01: of population size and economic reality right like
- 29:51Canada will always be vulnerable to political infiltration from
- 29:56bad actors.
- 29:57SPEAKER_01: It will always be more vulnerable to military infiltration by bad actors.
- 30:02It will always be more vulnerable to getting picked off by
- 30:05stronger economic actors
- 30:08SPEAKER_01: if you don't actually truly extend the castle walls around it.
- 30:12SPEAKER_01: You can't have it both ways.
- 30:13You can't have a two solitudes position where Canada is
- 30:18perpetually undermined and
- 30:19tariffed while still being expected to carry more than its
- 30:23weight militarily.
- 30:24SPEAKER_00: And then call that a fortress.
- 30:29SPEAKER_01: Am I explaining this right?
- 30:31I just sort of think what's being described and what's being
- 30:34put on the table
- 30:35really looks more like Fortress America with Canada as a useful
- 30:39vassal state.
- 30:41And I just look at that and I just say okay but you are aware
- 30:43that by doing that
- 30:45you turn Canada into not only a liability but also a potential
- 30:49strategic weakness
- 30:50for you forever I believe and we'll talk about this more when
- 30:53we talk about the
- 30:53planes that the Americans are operating from what they think is
- 30:59a plan I think
- 31:02SPEAKER_00: their plan is self-defeating and intellectually incoherent
- 31:06SPEAKER_00: The Line theline
- 31:23and I think the Americans are still struggling with that where
- 31:26they are rich and
- 31:27powerful enough to attempt to impose their will on us and
- 31:32others but even if they
- 31:33succeed it's not going to work because they're trying to create
- 31:36something that's
- 31:37unstable and stupid right so they're successfully imposing
- 31:41their will into creating
- 31:43SPEAKER_01: an inherently unstable dynamic and
- 31:52when it comes to the metaphor of the fortress you might have
- 31:56been leaning a bit too
- 31:57much on the metaphor but like I'll run with it just for a
- 31:59minute and I'll say it's
- 32:03a little bit like having a fortress we all agree we're going to
- 32:06be inside the
- 32:07fortress but we're we haven't finished bargaining yet how much
- 32:11of the time we're
- 32:12SPEAKER_00: going to spend shooting at each other
- 32:14SPEAKER_00: It's like if you're going to agree to go inside a fortress of someone,
- 32:17SPEAKER_00: you should pretty much all be clear on being on the same side.
- 32:23and having an organized continental auto parts strategy or
- 32:28steel manufacturing
- 32:30SPEAKER_00: policy or harmonized tariffs on Chinese imports and exports,
- 32:34SPEAKER_00: things like that.
- 32:35And these are things that come up in the Fortress North America
- 32:37discussions.
- 32:38SPEAKER_00: Not even talking about the literal fortress stuff,
- 32:42SPEAKER_00: which is air defense and coastal sea approach monitoring,
- 32:45SPEAKER_00: things like that.
- 32:47I think if you're going to actually be having those kinds of
- 32:51conversations...
- 32:53you need to have resolved the other major issues because it's
- 32:57sort of like you you
- 32:59SPEAKER_00: are trying to pick a wedding venue with your fiancee when you haven't yet
- 33:03determined if you're going to live together or ever have kids
- 33:06like some of these
- 33:07that you can only have certain conversations after you've had
- 33:10the other ones and it
- 33:11feels like to me we're trying to build this plane in the air a
- 33:14little bit if I
- 33:16SPEAKER_00: trusted the Americans to act coherently and predictably
- 33:20I would be intellectually open to a fortress North America
- 33:23conversation with them.
- 33:25SPEAKER_00: Until they settle the fuck down, I'm not.
- 33:29SPEAKER_00: And when we get back to talking about vibes here,
- 33:31SPEAKER_00: maybe for Carney,
- 33:33SPEAKER_00: maybe he just has to rag the puck with these guys.
- 33:35SPEAKER_00: And I don't know if that's a great long-term strategy,
- 33:37but why would we pursue deeper economic integration with
- 33:43someone who's as likely to
- 33:45SPEAKER_00: use that as leverage against us as they are an opportunity to benefit us?
- 33:50SPEAKER_00: Do you loan money to the guy who's threatening your life?
- 33:55You can't have a fortress where half the fortress is tariffed
- 33:59against the other
- 34:00SPEAKER_01: half That's not a fortress Either we're both Okay,
- 34:05so there's two options Either we're both strong and fully
- 34:07independent We're
- 34:10SPEAKER_01: interdependent and both strong But you can't have a situation where we're
- 34:13SPEAKER_01: interdependent and then one of us is weak
- 34:17SPEAKER_01: That's because if we're interdependent and one of us is weak,
- 34:20SPEAKER_01: then you've just introduced weakness to yourself.
- 34:23SPEAKER_01: This is the point I'm trying to get across here.
- 34:24SPEAKER_01: I don't know if I'm getting it across,
- 34:26SPEAKER_01: Ray,
- 34:26SPEAKER_01: but like,
- 34:28SPEAKER_01: this is like saying,
- 34:29SPEAKER_01: okay,
- 34:29SPEAKER_01: so I'm going to put this in an American context.
- 34:31This is like saying,
- 34:32okay,
- 34:33California is a member of our union and it's a really powerful
- 34:37state.
- 34:37SPEAKER_01: It's a state of 40 million people.
- 34:38SPEAKER_01: It's a huge economic powerhouse, but we're going to tariff California.
- 34:43and we're just going to um it's it's kind of part of our
- 34:47fortress but it's also
- 34:48kind of not we're going to tariff california um because that
- 34:53will make the union
- 34:53stronger yeah you know what i mean like like it's either in or
- 34:58it's out you've got
- 35:00you kind of can't you can't be half pregnant here um and i say
- 35:04i would also give
- 35:05SPEAKER_01: some credit to to the u.s here and i give some credit to to trump
- 35:09There is no dispute that Canada has allowed itself to become
- 35:13weak psychologically,
- 35:16SPEAKER_01: militarily,
- 35:16SPEAKER_01: and economically.
- 35:18SPEAKER_01: We've done that to ourselves.
- 35:19SPEAKER_01: America didn't do that to us.
- 35:20SPEAKER_01: We did that to ourselves.
- 35:22SPEAKER_01: Our political class is weak.
- 35:24Our intellectual culture is increasingly state-run,
- 35:27state-funded and weak.
- 35:30SPEAKER_01: Our military has gone to shambles.
- 35:32Economically,
- 35:33we've allowed virtue politics to overwhelm practical realities.
- 35:39I think that Donald Trump in the long run might be the absolute
- 35:42necessary kick in
- 35:43SPEAKER_01: the ass that we needed to get smarter and get better.
- 35:49SPEAKER_01: What's going to happen now,
- 35:50SPEAKER_01: I think it is a rupture,
- 35:51SPEAKER_01: it is a challenge,
- 35:52it fundamentally changes how we function and how we think about
- 35:54ourselves in the
- 35:55SPEAKER_01: world.
- 35:56SPEAKER_01: All of that was really necessary.
- 35:58SPEAKER_01: So if the effect of Trump is to actually force us to get smart,
- 36:03SPEAKER_01: I welcome it and I say thank you.
- 36:09But it still doesn't undermine the fundamental problem America
- 36:15has the ability to
- 36:16impose its will on us but it has to decide whether or not its
- 36:18will is best served
- 36:19by us being weak or strong and if its best interest is served
- 36:24by us being strong
- 36:26then it can't simultaneously try to undermine us while it's
- 36:31trying to make us
- 36:31SPEAKER_01: stronger that I think is the incoherence of the Fortress North America
- 36:37metaphor and the incoherence of the position i do think you
- 36:40articulated that well
- 36:42okay i it took me a while to get there but i came around i
- 36:45figured it out and it
- 36:46brought to mind an article i read uh by a very smart guy uh who
- 36:51also made very
- 36:53smart personal life decisions because he married you your
- 36:57husband well you know
- 36:58SPEAKER_01: wait the timeline's not over so far so good um
- 37:07he wrote a piece maybe a year ago time flies when you're doing
- 37:12whatever the fuck
- 37:13I'm doing he wrote a piece where he kind of described the
- 37:19various tribes of mega
- 37:22and he identified that kind of the traditional neoconservatives
- 37:25and the national
- 37:26security conservatives would be the ones Canada could cut a
- 37:29deal with because they
- 37:31SPEAKER_00: would have a fairly consistent coherent
- 37:34set of asks and they would also be prepared to deal like they
- 37:38are the people we
- 37:39could negotiate with right but I think the problem is and I
- 37:42think you I'm not
- 37:43accusing you of this because you I know you're not but part of
- 37:46what you were saying
- 37:47a minute ago was drifting a little bit towards making what what
- 37:51others have made
- 37:51particularly in the United States which is the positive case
- 37:54for Trump which is
- 37:55basically disruptor change agent needed kick in the ass blah
- 37:59blah blah and I'm I
- 38:02SPEAKER_00: actually think
- 38:04you can almost make that argument for Trump so long as you
- 38:08don't know anything
- 38:09about Trump because like I believe you can have disruptors
- 38:14change agents corrective
- 38:16forces kicks in the ass whatever you want to call it but they
- 38:19have to be at least
- 38:20reasonably predictable and ideologically coherent to function
- 38:23effectively Trump
- 38:25isn't and I think this is one of the things the Americans have
- 38:29done that have under
- 38:30SPEAKER_00: undercut themselves in a massive strategic way
- 38:34there is the version of America first rock ribbed conservative
- 38:39mega Donald Trump
- 38:40that some of his advocates like to pretend is the only version
- 38:43of him the guy who
- 38:45showed up and lectured the Japanese and the Canadians and the
- 38:48Europeans about we're
- 38:49through defending you guys and we're terrifying you to get our
- 38:52money back I still
- 38:54think that would have been nuts but it would have been coherent
- 38:57the problem is we
- 38:58SPEAKER_00: get that we get that version of Trump maybe a quarter of the time
- 39:03and the other 75,000 of the time who knows it's the
- 39:06transactional there this great
- 39:08SPEAKER_00: story jen you probably saw was the u.s.
- 39:10had a brigade of troops going to poland and then it was
- 39:13canceled and it was
- 39:15canceled because pete hegseth was apparently angry at the
- 39:17europeans and then trump
- 39:19was like no i like poland so now not only are they sending the
- 39:224,000 troops they're
- 39:23SPEAKER_00: adding a thousand right how are we supposed to be in a fortress with that
- 39:30we can't and and look I'm not I'm not trying to make the
- 39:34positive case for Trump
- 39:34because I'm not trying to assign others have tried to make no
- 39:36that's fair and like
- 39:38also I think that you can be a disruptive agent while at the
- 39:40same time not
- 39:41ascribing agency to the disruptor right so he can just be a
- 39:46crazy lunatic and this
- 39:47is all counterproductive but we have to respond the same way
- 39:51whether or not this
- 39:52person is a rational actor or a non-rational actor right he's a
- 39:55he the effect on us
- 39:58SPEAKER_01: it will be the same
- 40:00SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 40:00SPEAKER_01: That's kind of the point I'm trying to make with that one.
- 40:02So,
- 40:02no,
- 40:02I mean,
- 40:03look,
- 40:05I think it does come down to a question of like what.
- 40:08SPEAKER_01: Yes, we know America is strong enough to impose its will.
- 40:11SPEAKER_01: Does America see its best interest served in a strong,
- 40:13capable Canada or does America see its best interest served in
- 40:17a weakened vassal
- 40:18SPEAKER_01: state?
- 40:19SPEAKER_01: And to be honest with you, you're going to make my case.
- 40:22SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 40:22SPEAKER_01: I'm self-interested,
- 40:23but like Canada as a weakened vassal state doesn't serve
- 40:26American interests.
- 40:28that is not that just creates a perpetual um how should I say
- 40:32this weakness in the
- 40:35in the castle wall that's what your neighbor yeah exactly so
- 40:40that that that's just
- 40:41my position on this one um we're going to come back to this I
- 40:44think in a bit we
- 40:45want to talk about what's the next thing we're going to talk
- 40:47about I think this is
- 40:48a good segue to talk about the the planes yeah let's talk about
- 40:51Swedish planes and
- 40:52SPEAKER_01: then we're going to talk a
- 40:53SPEAKER_01: That's us,
- 40:54SPEAKER_01: check us out www.readtheline.ca Like and subscribe,
- 40:58SPEAKER_01: do like and subscribe And just like us generally We're fun,
- 41:02we're cool We're great at parties Great at parties This episode
- 41:07of The Line Podcast
- 41:09SPEAKER_00: Is also brought to you by Dominion Dynamics
- 41:13SPEAKER_00: Canada has never had true sovereign awareness of our North.
- 41:17SPEAKER_00: Vast parts of our country are a blind spot.
- 41:19SPEAKER_00: And when you can't see your own territory,
- 41:21SPEAKER_00: you can't defend it,
- 41:23SPEAKER_00: secure it,
- 41:24SPEAKER_00: or respond when threats emerge.
- 41:26SPEAKER_00: Dominion Dynamics is changing that.
- 41:29Dominion Dynamics is building a sovereign command and control
- 41:32capability that lets
- 41:33SPEAKER_00: Canada and its allies see,
- 41:35SPEAKER_00: respond,
- 41:36SPEAKER_00: and defend across every domain.
- 41:38SPEAKER_00: Dominion is starting in the Arctic,
- 41:40SPEAKER_00: where extreme conditions demand technology no one else can deliver.
- 41:44SPEAKER_00: Defend the Dominion.
- 41:46SPEAKER_00: Dominion Dynamics.
- 41:48SPEAKER_00: Learn more at defendthedominion.com All right,
- 41:54SPEAKER_01: Matt,
- 41:54SPEAKER_01: you and I kind of popped off there,
- 41:56SPEAKER_01: as we're prone to do.
- 41:57SPEAKER_01: So I'm going to get us...
- 41:59never happens it's not like you and I tend to talk too much
- 42:02that's just not a
- 42:03problem that we have um correct look I want to ask you about
- 42:08the Swedish planes can
- 42:10you explain to me the news about the Swedish planes and explain
- 42:13it to me like I
- 42:14ain't never seen no sports ball uh okay let me okay yes but I
- 42:19am going to ask you a
- 42:20question first do you want to know what the planes like what do
- 42:22you want do you
- 42:22want me to explain what the planes are or do you want me to
- 42:24explain what the deal
- 42:25SPEAKER_01: means no I first explained to me what the planes are
- 42:29Okay,
- 42:29they're basically AWACS and AWACS is,
- 42:32I hope I'm going to get the acronym right,
- 42:34Airborne
- 42:37SPEAKER_00: airborne early warning and control system.
- 42:40SPEAKER_00: I think I could be getting that wrong.
- 42:42SPEAKER_00: Basically, it is a plane.
- 42:45SPEAKER_00: Normally,
- 42:45SPEAKER_00: a passenger plane can be large or small,
- 42:47but the same plane as a large passenger plane that has been
- 42:51modified to carry a
- 42:53SPEAKER_00: flying radar dish or radar system.
- 42:56And the inside of the plane is filled with technical equipment
- 43:00and personnel who
- 43:01SPEAKER_00: are good at operating it.
- 43:03the reason for this is it allows you to bring a powerful
- 43:06sophisticated radar and a
- 43:08lot of powerful computers wherever you want it to go and it's
- 43:11very good at
- 43:12detecting incoming threats missiles planes drones which is good
- 43:18particularly in a
- 43:18country as large as Canada where you know a lot of our
- 43:22territory is very sparsely
- 43:24populated we don't have a lot of just huge radar stations in
- 43:28the middle of nowhere
- 43:29SPEAKER_00: and AWAC can bring one with them.
- 43:31So they just basically show up and they monitor the airspace
- 43:34and they're mobile.
- 43:35SPEAKER_00: Like they're literally a plane.
- 43:36SPEAKER_00: They go where we need them to go.
- 43:38SPEAKER_00: Makes sense.
- 43:39SPEAKER_00: And during battle,
- 43:42SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 43:44SPEAKER_00: I've never done it myself,
- 43:45but I'm given to understand that flying a fighter jet at
- 43:47supersonic speeds in the
- 43:48SPEAKER_00: middle of an aerial battle is complicated.
- 43:51And it's very difficult for pilots to,
- 43:54on the one hand,
- 43:55be keeping their eye on
- 43:57their own plane their own instruments the guys they're shooting
- 44:00at the guys they're
- 44:01shooting at them without losing the bigger picture if you have
- 44:06an AWAC and you put
- 44:07it a few hundred kilometers away from the battle area your guys
- 44:11on that are
- 44:12basically your coaches they call the game they can tell that
- 44:15your pilots okay
- 44:17that's it you've taken out all the local ones you've got four
- 44:20more coming in low to
- 44:21SPEAKER_00: the east and it's a way of basically like for our pilots
- 44:26there's someone friendly in their ear telling them where the
- 44:29threats are and then
- 44:30that allows them to to respond so having an AWAC on your side
- 44:35is a very very
- 44:37important part of air battle but the west hasn't fought a major
- 44:41air battle in a
- 44:41generation and Canada doesn't have any AWAC capability because
- 44:45in recent years our
- 44:47SPEAKER_00: our air force has been patrolling which is important
- 44:50But we've been occasionally dropping bombs on ISIS or blowing
- 44:54up a Serbian bridge or something.
- 44:56SPEAKER_00: We weren't fighting massive air-to-air battles.
- 45:00SPEAKER_00: We're thinking about that now.
- 45:01SPEAKER_01: So AWACS are great.
- 45:03SPEAKER_01: That's because of drones, right?
- 45:05SPEAKER_00: AWACS can use drones, for sure.
- 45:08SPEAKER_00: Or they can detect and guide.
- 45:10SPEAKER_00: But I think just in general,
- 45:12SPEAKER_00: we're looking around and we're going,
- 45:13SPEAKER_00: ooh,
- 45:14SPEAKER_00: a lot of our assumptions about the end of history were wrong.
- 45:17SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 45:19SPEAKER_01: and again,
- 45:19SPEAKER_01: going back to the conversation you have with like I say,
- 45:21but also he made this interesting point where if we were if we
- 45:24were fighting in
- 45:24SPEAKER_01: Afghanistan today,
- 45:25we'd have to assume that we'd be fighting an air war because
- 45:29the Taliban have
- 45:30access to drones that they don't have that they didn't have
- 45:33access to back then.
- 45:34SPEAKER_01: So all of a sudden,
- 45:36SPEAKER_01: some kind of capacity to track aerial traffic becomes really crucial,
- 45:40SPEAKER_01: even in like a low level asymmetrical kind of warfare situation.
- 45:44SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 45:45SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 45:45SPEAKER_01: Understanding that.
- 45:46My on the line episode was a two-parter Phil Lagasse in the
- 45:49first and Laser Berman
- 45:50SPEAKER_00: from the Times of Israel.
- 45:51SPEAKER_00: He was my second guest.
- 45:52And the Israelis are fighting on their northern frontier
- 45:56against Hezbollah.
- 45:57SPEAKER_00: And wouldn't you know it, Hezbollah now has an air force.
- 46:00SPEAKER_00: Mm hmm.
- 46:01It's drones and hezbollah is defeating advanced israeli systems
- 46:07with cheap drones
- 46:08right so 100 if we were back in afghanistan now the taliban
- 46:13would have an air force
- 46:14right and we have no idea how to deal with this so an awack is
- 46:19overkill for
- 46:20SPEAKER_00: low-level drone warfare
- 46:22But if we had like a thousand Russian drones coming over the
- 46:25Arctic fanning out
- 46:26SPEAKER_00: towards our hydro transformers,
- 46:28SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 46:28SPEAKER_00: we might want an AWAC.
- 46:29SPEAKER_00: So this is a capability the Air Force has wanted for a while.
- 46:33SPEAKER_00: We have participated in American and NATO AWAC programs.
- 46:38SPEAKER_00: So NATO has a fleet of AWAC planes.
- 46:41SPEAKER_00: Canada would provide trained crews.
- 46:44And we've often just plugged our personnel into American AWACs
- 46:48to basically like,
- 46:49SPEAKER_00: hey,
- 46:50SPEAKER_00: we're contributing.
- 46:51SPEAKER_00: Here's
- 46:52here's frank and frank's gonna fly with you today um but no we
- 46:57want that capability
- 46:58to be sovereign so that's what an AWAC is and that's what it's
- 47:01for it's a five
- 47:02billion dollar program do you want me to now get to not just
- 47:06what the planes are
- 47:07but what it means what does it mean yes there were three
- 47:12relative you know i'm not
- 47:13gonna pick a fight with the aviation nerds i had to block an
- 47:16aviation nerd this
- 47:17SPEAKER_01: week just we're just getting too much too much man
- 47:22but there were three different aircraft that Canada could
- 47:27choose from two of them
- 47:29were American the Air Force had already signaled its preference
- 47:33for one of the
- 47:34American ones there was a third option it was Sweden we went
- 47:39with the Swedes and I
- 47:41SPEAKER_00: don't see
- 47:44any way that we can look at this as other than a very
- 47:48deliberate signal being sent
- 47:50to the Americans we can choose and we don't have to choose you
- 47:56and that's a five
- 47:57billion dollar contract that you don't get so what I'm curious
- 48:04about and I don't
- 48:05know and you're not going to know either but I'm going to
- 48:07phrase it we're going to
- 48:08SPEAKER_01: speculate anyway just for funsies
- 48:11So we just went out of our way Oh and also just to mention this
- 48:15The Prime Minister
- 48:16showed up at the CANSEC conference in Ottawa He wasn't on the
- 48:20schedule It was a
- 48:21surprise announcement To announce that we were handing a
- 48:25European ally a 5 billion
- 48:27SPEAKER_00: dollar check That's political That's 100% political So
- 48:36but we're kind of playing it with both hands at the same time
- 48:38because we're doing
- 48:39on one hand we're doing like okay we're going to buy the
- 48:41Swedish planes and then
- 48:42we're going to go to New York and say Canada strong makes
- 48:45America great again
- 48:47butter wouldn't melt like what here's my question are we are we
- 48:51being really
- 48:52passive aggressive Canadians right now like is this are we
- 48:54embracing asshole Canada
- 48:56is it happening I don't think I don't think we're quite that
- 49:00far yet but there are
- 49:01SPEAKER_00: two possible reads of this and I don't know yet which one is true
- 49:06PMO friends text me please tell me and it might surprise people
- 49:12to know that
- 49:13sometimes me saying that actually does work two ways this could
- 49:20go one of them
- 49:21could be this is a signal of the new order that we will
- 49:26continue to make large
- 49:28purchases from European and Asian allies and we will continue
- 49:32to snub American
- 49:33SPEAKER_00: contractors possibly
- 49:37SPEAKER_00: Another possibility is that this was a warning shot.
- 49:41SPEAKER_00: It's a relatively small contract.
- 49:45SPEAKER_00: The three planes on offer.
- 49:46SPEAKER_00: And again, I'm not going to fight with the aviation nerds.
- 49:49SPEAKER_00: They're all capable planes.
- 49:51SPEAKER_00: Like we didn't really have a bad option here.
- 49:56SPEAKER_00: Having made this decision
- 50:00Does Carney now feel like he can go sign some bigger contracts
- 50:05with American companies?
- 50:06SPEAKER_01: Such as the F-35s?
- 50:09SPEAKER_00: Among other examples, but yeah.
- 50:11So this basically gives him political cover to go make the
- 50:14necessary purchases,
- 50:15SPEAKER_01: the necessary big American purchases,
- 50:17SPEAKER_01: while still claiming that he's going elbows up.
- 50:19SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 50:20SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 50:20SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 50:21SPEAKER_00: And when... And I don't know.
- 50:24SPEAKER_00: I honestly don't.
- 50:25SPEAKER_00: And so if we go out tomorrow...
- 50:27and if we announce that we bought like billions in American
- 50:30artillery or missiles
- 50:31or whatever and people go what about elbows up you get a
- 50:36liberal on the Sunday
- 50:37morning shows because yeah but come on hey I like yeah look we
- 50:40we continue to value
- 50:41our relationship with the Americans but also look at the
- 50:42billions of dollars we
- 50:43just handed to Sweden our new European friend you know what I
- 50:48mean so I'm wondering
- 50:50if that's what we're doing but there's one other little
- 50:52possibility as well
- 50:54we don't have a ton of bargaining leverage with the Americans
- 50:57like we're the
- 50:58smaller economy they have more leverage over us than we do on
- 51:00them but we did just
- 51:03show we're willing to hand billions of dollars to a contractor
- 51:07from another company
- 51:10that is not bad bargaining leverage both in terms of the
- 51:13upcoming trade talks but
- 51:15also with Boeing and L3 Harris and the other US large
- 51:20contractors we can say to
- 51:21SPEAKER_00: them yeah look we got options you're gonna have to like
- 51:25SPEAKER_00: The Swedes offered us great industrial benefits.
- 51:27SPEAKER_00: We're going to build.
- 51:28SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 51:28we were already building the planes in Canada because they're
- 51:30Bombardier planes,
- 51:31SPEAKER_00: but then we're going to do the military conversion work here.
- 51:34SPEAKER_00: The Swedes have said Canada can build these planes for Saab,
- 51:38SPEAKER_00: the company,
- 51:39SPEAKER_00: for export to third parties,
- 51:41SPEAKER_00: other allies.
- 51:42So some other ally could contract with Saab for these planes,
- 51:47a Swedish company.
- 51:49SPEAKER_00: We could build them.
- 51:50So the Swedes drove a hard bargain here I can feel the liberal
- 51:55swelling of happy
- 51:58SPEAKER_01: feelings at the thought of that Look,
- 52:01SPEAKER_00: I had a happy feeling or two
- 52:04so i don't know is this a rupture with the united states and
- 52:07are we going to follow
- 52:08this up with one order after another for other for french
- 52:12planes german submarines
- 52:14korean artillery and armored vehicles like these are all things
- 52:18that are on offer
- 52:18here or did we just buy ourselves the political cover to go buy
- 52:22a bunch of f-35s i
- 52:23don't know i don't i really wish i did and if anyone on the
- 52:27inside wants to tell me
- 52:28SPEAKER_00: i would be grateful
- 52:30SPEAKER_01: Thank you very much, and you know our numbers.
- 52:33SPEAKER_01: All right, we want to talk a little bit about Alberta.
- 52:35I don't want to necessarily overemphasize the plane stuff
- 52:39needlessly because,
- 52:41SPEAKER_01: again,
- 52:41it seems like this is more of a watch this space than a
- 52:44definitive conclusion.
- 52:45Can I do my municipal rant first and it'll only take me a
- 52:48couple of minutes?
- 52:49SPEAKER_01: Okay, go for it.
- 52:49SPEAKER_01: This is a good time.
- 52:50SPEAKER_00: I really want to get this off my chest.
- 52:51SPEAKER_00: Get it off your chest.
- 52:53SPEAKER_01: Make you feel better.
- 52:56When you were starting in journalism,
- 52:58I think you started with very local stuff,
- 53:01right?
- 53:01SPEAKER_01: Yeah, my first job in a major newsroom was Toronto Star Radio Room.
- 53:06SPEAKER_00: I thought so.
- 53:08SPEAKER_00: I had a weirder career path into journalism,
- 53:12SPEAKER_00: but even so,
- 53:15SPEAKER_00: you learn the ropes doing local coverage.
- 53:18SPEAKER_00: And I did local municipal coverage.
- 53:22SPEAKER_00: And one of the things, Jen, and I'm sure
- 53:26SPEAKER_00: I would be happy if I never had to think about a bike lane again.
- 53:31SPEAKER_01: You can only cover, you can only raise so much about bike lanes.
- 53:34SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 53:35And I think Jen,
- 53:36like Jen and I have talked about Alberta as an example of it.
- 53:41SPEAKER_00: We're like,
- 53:42SPEAKER_00: I guess it's a little bit different now,
- 53:44SPEAKER_00: Jen,
- 53:44SPEAKER_00: for reasons we'll get into in a couple of minutes,
- 53:46SPEAKER_00: but
- 53:47You were getting tired of writing about the same Alberta
- 53:49political story over and
- 53:51SPEAKER_00: over and over.
- 53:51SPEAKER_01: And the same Alberta political actors.
- 53:53SPEAKER_01: And it's like you get existentially bored with a beat.
- 53:56SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 53:58One version of that hometown story for me is that I never want
- 54:03to talk about it
- 54:04SPEAKER_00: again is the island airport.
- 54:09SPEAKER_01: All right.
- 54:10SPEAKER_01: Because here we go.
- 54:11SPEAKER_01: We're going to go.
- 54:12SPEAKER_01: We're getting in.
- 54:13SPEAKER_00: Let me actually make the serious point for a minute.
- 54:15SPEAKER_01: All right.
- 54:18SPEAKER_00: I ran for many years an editorial section at a newspaper.
- 54:24SPEAKER_00: And when you work with your internal roster of writers,
- 54:28SPEAKER_00: but also your stable of freelancers,
- 54:30SPEAKER_00: people who don't work for you,
- 54:31SPEAKER_00: but who contribute on a regular basis,
- 54:33SPEAKER_00: you get very good at determining the personality types.
- 54:37There's the policy wonks who write about stuff that they find
- 54:41interesting.
- 54:42And then there's the culture warriors who will write about
- 54:45anything that happens to
- 54:46SPEAKER_00: be in the news and take a very predictable stand on it.
- 54:49SPEAKER_00: One that pleases the tribe that they have identified with.
- 54:53SPEAKER_00: You need those people.
- 54:56You got to have them in your in your orbit because every once
- 54:58in a while there's a
- 54:59SPEAKER_00: story and you're like,
- 55:00SPEAKER_00: oh God,
- 55:01SPEAKER_00: I hate this,
- 55:02SPEAKER_00: but it's hot right now.
- 55:03SPEAKER_00: People will read it if we publish it.
- 55:05SPEAKER_00: Who do we got who can go write the predictable 700 words?
- 55:11but my god I did not like those articles I hated reading them I
- 55:15hated writing them
- 55:16and I hated commissioning them because I find so pardon me
- 55:21because you're a nerd
- 55:22but also I just find it wearying okay it's uh okay like ever
- 55:28like you look at a
- 55:29headline you look at the byline and you don't bother reading
- 55:32700 words because you
- 55:34know what it's gonna say yes anyway what's the point what are
- 55:37we talking about
- 55:38SPEAKER_00: we're talking about the island airport
- 55:40SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 55:42SPEAKER_00: And Doug Ford has secured the airport.
- 55:47SPEAKER_00: He has uploaded it from the city.
- 55:50He has made it a provincial asset and now he's going to
- 55:53retrofit it so that it can run jets.
- 55:56SPEAKER_00: I feel like I've been talking about this for 30 years,
- 55:58SPEAKER_00: but it's going to be retrofitted for jets.
- 56:01there's actually a fascinating nerd story there why do we it's
- 56:06kind of like the
- 56:06major projects office but we're getting a provincial version of
- 56:09it why do we need
- 56:10special economic regulations to retrofit an airport this is
- 56:15isn't that what we
- 56:15should be talking about why do we need special provincial
- 56:18legislation but what are
- 56:20we talking about I don't I don't follow this story what are we
- 56:23talking about
- 56:24SPEAKER_00: basically in order to operate jets the runways need to be extended
- 56:28Okay and the island airport people because the Toronto's island
- 56:33people are weird
- 56:34SPEAKER_01: hippies are like don't extend the airport is that the story?
- 56:36Combined yes combined with a bunch of mainlanders who hate Doug
- 56:40Ford hate planes
- 56:41hate everything and they're actually I think there's a
- 56:44genuinely fascinating story
- 56:46SPEAKER_00: buried in here and it reminds me of the major projects office
- 56:49I think the story is why do we need special economic zones to
- 56:53do routine things?
- 56:55But we're not going to have that story because everybody is
- 56:57going to argue about
- 56:58whether or not we should be building a bigger airport because
- 57:02it's bike lanes.
- 57:03SPEAKER_00: It is the bike lanes of the sky.
- 57:06We have lobotomized ourselves as a society because we just have
- 57:11the stupid culture
- 57:12SPEAKER_00: war arguments over and over and over and we miss the real stuff.
- 57:14SPEAKER_00: And it pisses me off.
- 57:16How many political careers have been spent arguing about
- 57:19bullshit over and over and
- 57:20SPEAKER_00: over until the pension kicks in?
- 57:22SPEAKER_01: Well, on that note, I think that we need to talk about Alberta again.
- 57:27SPEAKER_00: I am so pissed off about the island airport and bike lanes, but fine.
- 57:31SPEAKER_00: We'll talk about your stupid province.
- 57:32SPEAKER_00: Actually, I love it.
- 57:33SPEAKER_00: Stay in Canada.
- 57:36SPEAKER_01: Like and subscribe.
- 57:37SPEAKER_01: www.readtheline.ca
- 57:42okay matt i'm gonna pull you out of a conversation about the
- 57:46toronto island airport
- 57:47because i don't have the bandwidth to care about that right now
- 57:50i'm so angry no i
- 57:52am also so angry so alberta we got to talk a little bit alberta
- 57:59the order in
- 57:59council came down no do we do we uh the order in council came
- 58:03down uh uh this week
- 58:05SPEAKER_01: so we are going to have a referendum on a referendum
- 58:09SPEAKER_01: I am a part of the Vote to Stay campaign,
- 58:12which is a really new and interesting place for me to be
- 58:14because I'm not used to
- 58:15SPEAKER_01: working in advocacy.
- 58:16SPEAKER_01: I'm used to being the uncontrollable grenade lobber from the sides.
- 58:22SPEAKER_01: I think I'm still the uncontrollable grenade lobber,
- 58:24SPEAKER_01: but now I'm at least part of the conversation a little bit on the inside,
- 58:29SPEAKER_01: which is a really weird place to be.
- 58:31SPEAKER_01: Also,
- 58:31SPEAKER_01: I believe this week we launched the Leave Not Leave initiative,
- 58:34SPEAKER_01: which the line is going to be a bit of a partner with.
- 58:37This is a bunch of policy wonks who are coming up with concrete
- 58:43policy that can
- 58:45SPEAKER_01: make Confederation better.
- 58:47SPEAKER_01: Just demonstrate that,
- 58:48SPEAKER_01: look,
- 58:49SPEAKER_01: being part of a complicated nation is difficult,
- 58:52SPEAKER_01: and it's work worth doing,
- 58:54SPEAKER_01: and it's putting forward ideas and policy ideas that will
- 59:01further confederation make it stronger make it more capable
- 59:05this is part of Alberta
- 59:07in particular Alberta's mandate like it's part of what we do in
- 59:10Canada and it's
- 59:11hard work and it's worthwhile work so that's kind of the big
- 59:14picture stuff that you
- 59:16and I had a really interesting conversation and I'm about to
- 59:18finish a column on
- 59:19this and that is how do non-Albertans talk about Alberta right
- 59:25this is a difficult
- 59:25SPEAKER_01: and complicated conversation because I've made this point
- 59:30on twitter and elsewhere if you don't live here and don't have
- 59:33a history here you
- 59:35have to be kind of conscious of your positionality or position
- 59:39and the way that
- 59:40your words can be used against you by separatists to further
- 59:45their perception of
- 59:46cultural alienation and grievance and I think a really
- 59:50excellent example of this
- 59:53was Abby Lewis so Abby Lewis came out today and basically said
- 59:56the worst thing that
- 59:57you could possibly say if you're a national leader and that was
- 1:00:00Quebec separatism
- 1:00:01is legitimate and Alberta separatism isn't which okay so you've
- 1:00:07you've established
- 1:00:08SPEAKER_01: two-tier citizenship here at this point because
- 1:00:12So that was a really classic example of what not to say don't
- 1:00:13do that shit.
- 1:00:34SPEAKER_01: Look,
- 1:00:35we've created a legal system Where if one province gets to
- 1:00:38separate All of them get
- 1:00:39to separate My preference would be to have none of them get to
- 1:00:42separate That's
- 1:00:43SPEAKER_01: crazy town But okay,
- 1:00:45this is the legal structure That we've established And
- 1:00:48Alberta's following in
- 1:00:49Quebec's lead Or thinks it's following in Quebec's lead In
- 1:00:52terms of trying to
- 1:00:53establish a better deal for itself Vis-a-vis confederation I
- 1:00:56think it's suicidal
- 1:00:58behavior But I think it's suicidal behavior When I see
- 1:01:01Quebecers do it too
- 1:01:03SPEAKER_01: This hasn't benefited Quebec in the long run.
- 1:01:05SPEAKER_01: This hasn't created a stronger,
- 1:01:07SPEAKER_01: more economically competent polity to go through this type of politics,
- 1:01:11SPEAKER_01: okay?
- 1:01:13SPEAKER_01: So that's an example of how not to do this.
- 1:01:16Then there's examples of people weighing in ways that I think
- 1:01:19are controversial but
- 1:01:21SPEAKER_01: constructive.
- 1:01:22And one thing I'm going to say here is I thought Wab Canu did a
- 1:01:24really good job.
- 1:01:25SPEAKER_01: Manitoba Premier did a really good job today.
- 1:01:27He called out Daniel Smith for some of the comments that she
- 1:01:31made around duty to consult.
- 1:01:32SPEAKER_00: And
- 1:01:33above and beyond whether or not Daniel Smith or Webb is right
- 1:01:37about the nature of
- 1:01:39SPEAKER_01: duty to consult and whether that has the clarity in law that it ought to.
- 1:01:42SPEAKER_01: Let's put that conversation on a shelf for a minute.
- 1:01:46SPEAKER_01: Hearing Webb Canu come out and say like,
- 1:01:48SPEAKER_01: look,
- 1:01:48I'm doing this because I'm defending Canada because I love
- 1:01:50Canada and watching sort
- 1:01:53of First Nations communities in Alberta fight the petition to
- 1:01:57put a succession
- 1:01:57SPEAKER_01: referendum to a succession vote to the ballot.
- 1:02:01SPEAKER_01: Again,
- 1:02:02the question of whether or not that was tactically wise of them
- 1:02:04or not again i'm
- 1:02:05putting that on a shelf listening to first nations communities
- 1:02:09come forward and
- 1:02:10make strong passionate federalist cases for canada to me is
- 1:02:16civically so healthy
- 1:02:18and it really prompts in me a real mind shift a mind shift and
- 1:02:23i'll explain that a
- 1:02:24little bit because on the conservative side we are constantly
- 1:02:27inundated with this
- 1:02:28SPEAKER_01: idea of like is this reconciliation or revenge
- 1:02:32It's First Nations communities versus settlers Every type of
- 1:02:36land deal or treaty
- 1:02:37deal like Musqueam or Cowichan or any of this is a threat to
- 1:02:40sort of property
- 1:02:41SPEAKER_01: rights.
- 1:02:42SPEAKER_01: It's a threat to foundational aspects of what Canada is.
- 1:02:45SPEAKER_01: Like that's kind of where the conversation is.
- 1:02:48So when I move over to hearing First Nations leaders and
- 1:02:50community leaders say,
- 1:02:52SPEAKER_01: no,
- 1:02:52SPEAKER_01: I'm fighting for Canada.
- 1:02:54SPEAKER_01: It's important that we fight for Canada.
- 1:02:55It's important that we fight for our history and it's important
- 1:02:58that we fight for
- 1:02:58SPEAKER_01: our place here.
- 1:02:59SPEAKER_01: That forces a total mind shift set for me.
- 1:03:02And it makes me go,
- 1:03:03okay,
- 1:03:04we have disagreements,
- 1:03:05but we're still part of the same polity.
- 1:03:07SPEAKER_01: We're still part of the same team.
- 1:03:08And we can work through disagreements if we're started part of
- 1:03:11the same polity,
- 1:03:12SPEAKER_01: if we get rid of the us versus them framing.
- 1:03:16So I think that Wab Canoe's sort of approach to this has been
- 1:03:19on the whole quite positive.
- 1:03:22to be honest with you I have I take as an Albertan I take no
- 1:03:25issue with anything
- 1:03:25Mark Carney said on this Mark Carney's criticized this he said
- 1:03:28Albertans didn't
- 1:03:29vote for this they didn't this is not helpful to investment
- 1:03:33it's not he was
- 1:03:34overheard on I think on a hot mic saying speaking to Minister
- 1:03:37Robertson that it was
- 1:03:38that it was he gave Daniel Smith an off ramp and and said this
- 1:03:42was stupid he she
- 1:03:43did have an off ramp and this is stupid and it is destructive
- 1:03:46he's saying exactly
- 1:03:47SPEAKER_01: the same things that I am
- 1:03:49And i gotta be honest with you when i hear conservatives from
- 1:03:52the east okay alberta
- 1:03:54sort of quebec sorry um ottawa montreal toronto conservatives
- 1:04:00tut tutting prime
- 1:04:01minister carney for saying exactly the same things that i'm
- 1:04:04saying like i get a
- 1:04:06little pissy because i'm like you're doing exactly the same
- 1:04:08thing that you're
- 1:04:09you're accusing your opponents of you're trying to set the
- 1:04:12frame of the debate from
- 1:04:13SPEAKER_01: the east
- 1:04:16Right like that's my issue with it so like on one hand i'm
- 1:04:19saying yeah i think you
- 1:04:21need to be super conscious of your positionality i think you
- 1:04:23need to be super
- 1:04:24conscious of the way that your words can be used against you in
- 1:04:27order to set a
- 1:04:28frame and on the other hand i'm like but there is a balance
- 1:04:31here and there is a
- 1:04:32role for people outside of albertans outside of albertan to be
- 1:04:35playing here
- 1:04:36provided they're doing it intelligently in an in an empathetic
- 1:04:39and informed way and
- 1:04:43SPEAKER_01: expecting them not to weigh in on this isn't realistic.
- 1:04:46SPEAKER_01: I don't think that that is a realistic expectation or goal.
- 1:04:55SPEAKER_00: That was a lot.
- 1:04:56SPEAKER_00: And I don't mean that as a person.
- 1:04:58SPEAKER_00: No, no, no.
- 1:04:58SPEAKER_00: Not in a bad way.
- 1:04:59SPEAKER_00: What do I respond to first?
- 1:05:00We can stop the tape and we can rebook this if I tried to cram
- 1:05:06too much in one
- 1:05:08SPEAKER_01: seven minute ramble here.
- 1:05:10No,
- 1:05:10I thought it was good,
- 1:05:12but I just don't know what to respond to first.
- 1:05:14SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 1:05:14SPEAKER_00: A couple of quick points.
- 1:05:18I would honestly be fascinated if we could translate your seven
- 1:05:22minutes there
- 1:05:23SPEAKER_00: directly into French and show it to Quebecers.
- 1:05:28And I honestly would be genuinely curious how good a job either
- 1:05:33you or I have done
- 1:05:36SPEAKER_00: talking about Quebec in our careers.
- 1:05:39I don't even try to talk about Quebec Quebec's not my lane
- 1:05:46Here's where I get
- 1:05:47SPEAKER_01: pissed off at Central Canadians like yourself I'm like,
- 1:05:50SPEAKER_01: could you seat the floor for once?
- 1:05:53SPEAKER_01: Does it have to be an all-Central Canadian panel talking about Alberta?
- 1:05:57Because I don't feel the need to be on a panel talking about
- 1:06:00Quebec separatism In
- 1:06:03SPEAKER_00: fact,
- 1:06:03SPEAKER_00: no one would ever think
- 1:06:07to put Jen Gerson from Calgary on a panel about Quebec
- 1:06:10separatism why is Chantal
- 1:06:12Hebert on every single Alberta separatism panel like you know
- 1:06:16what I mean the
- 1:06:16answer to that Jen is easy and you know it it's because she's
- 1:06:19on every day at that
- 1:06:20time no and I do know it but I'm saying like but think about
- 1:06:24how that comes across
- 1:06:26no I know that that's just kind of what I'm wondering but why
- 1:06:29is there never an
- 1:06:31SPEAKER_01: Albertan on every panel that you're on every day
- 1:06:34SPEAKER_01: There should be.
- 1:06:35SPEAKER_01: Or a BCer or a Saskatchewaner.
- 1:06:38Do you honestly think that the talent is that concentrated in
- 1:06:42such a small place or
- 1:06:44SPEAKER_01: have you stopped looking outside of those places?
- 1:06:46SPEAKER_00: You actually don't want me to answer that.
- 1:06:49SPEAKER_01: Well, no, because I know the truth.
- 1:06:50SPEAKER_01: I know the truth of that answer.
- 1:06:51I make this same conversation when people talk about diversity
- 1:06:55and hiring from a
- 1:06:56SPEAKER_01: racial or ethnographic point of view.
- 1:06:59and I say like look it's not about checking a box or it's not
- 1:07:02about putting
- 1:07:03somebody who's not white into a position of leadership on
- 1:07:05principle it's that if
- 1:07:07you're looking around your table and all you're seeing are
- 1:07:11faces that look and
- 1:07:12think and sound just like you that tells me that you're missing
- 1:07:15talent you have not
- 1:07:17found talent you have overlooked talent because there is no way
- 1:07:21that talent is that
- 1:07:23SPEAKER_01: heavily concentrated in people from
- 1:07:27The Same Background The Same Class Background The Same
- 1:07:29Geographic Background The
- 1:07:30Same Ethnographic Background So What Talent Are You Not
- 1:07:34Bringing To The Table And
- 1:07:35What Opportunities Are You Missing By Failing To Bring
- 1:07:39Alternative Voices And
- 1:07:40Talent To The Table There Is Something Though Jen And I Don't
- 1:07:43Disagree With You But
- 1:07:45I Do Think You Might Have A Little Bit Too Much Steam Worked Up
- 1:07:49There You Want To
- 1:07:50SPEAKER_00: Know Something That'S Unusual About You Oh Pick Your Pick
- 1:07:58You are a very talented writer who has not moved to Toronto I
- 1:08:04did move to Toronto
- 1:08:04and then I moved back You're somewhat obscuring my point with
- 1:08:10literal truth The
- 1:08:12media in this country has a gravitational pull that brings a
- 1:08:18lot of people to
- 1:08:19SPEAKER_00: central Canada
- 1:08:20they move here for jobs at the bigger papers the bigger TV
- 1:08:23stations the bigger
- 1:08:24radio stations right and I think and I and I'm definitely not
- 1:08:29saying this to
- 1:08:29provoke a national unity crisis because the last thing I need
- 1:08:32because I'm going to
- 1:08:33piss off Alberta and Quebec simultaneously but as a guy who
- 1:08:38used to actually
- 1:08:39SPEAKER_00: actively look for good writers and good broadcasters in
- 1:08:45distributed regions of the country I could easily find great
- 1:08:49Quebec writers and
- 1:08:51great Alberta writers and they all live south of Bloor there
- 1:08:56was this pole that's
- 1:08:58true so I said I'm not expecting perfect parody here okay and I
- 1:09:02said I don't I
- 1:09:03understand enough about how the media work having lived and
- 1:09:05worked in Toronto uh no
- 1:09:07I do and having worked in for all of these major outlets I do
- 1:09:11understand the talent
- 1:09:12SPEAKER_01: problem and the talent
- 1:09:13distribution problem okay there are actually hundreds of media
- 1:09:17workers in Alberta
- 1:09:18guys like hundreds there's no shortage of talent who can come
- 1:09:22on and speak to your
- 1:09:23panel like we're part of the work that I'm doing right now is
- 1:09:26putting those people
- 1:09:27in front of those cameras okay but who are the ones who are the
- 1:09:31ones the Toronto
- 1:09:32SPEAKER_01: producers know who are the ones the Toronto and I'm one of them and I can
- 1:09:36distribute those requests out to other people who are perfectly
- 1:09:39capable and
- 1:09:39SPEAKER_01: competent to speak to this stuff okay so
- 1:09:43SPEAKER_01: I do get this.
- 1:09:44SPEAKER_01: I do understand the concentration of talent problem here.
- 1:09:47SPEAKER_01: It's not as concentrated as you think it is.
- 1:09:50There's still talent here who can speak to some of these issues
- 1:09:53in an intelligible way.
- 1:09:55So I do find,
- 1:09:57yes,
- 1:09:57you're right,
- 1:09:57but that's also a pretty convenient excuse sometimes too.
- 1:10:03SPEAKER_01: And I think that also bluntly,
- 1:10:05if you're looking around the table and everybody around you
- 1:10:07looks and sounds and
- 1:10:08SPEAKER_01: thinks like you,
- 1:10:10SPEAKER_01: I think both of these things can simultaneously be true.
- 1:10:13SPEAKER_01: But
- 1:10:32SPEAKER_01: I just want people to be conscious of that.
- 1:10:35I want people to be conscious of the degree to which they're
- 1:10:37framing the debate
- 1:10:38SPEAKER_01: from the outside and how ineffective that can actually be.
- 1:10:41SPEAKER_01: I mean, look, I'm going to get personal here.
- 1:10:44And that is,
- 1:10:46I am not super comfortable moving from a journalistic space to
- 1:10:49an advocacy space.
- 1:10:51SPEAKER_01: My position on this was,
- 1:10:54SPEAKER_01: one,
- 1:10:56if it's going to be a real career killer for me to advocate for
- 1:11:00separation is bad,
- 1:11:02well to me that's like advocating for like puppies or puppies
- 1:11:07and rainbows you know
- 1:11:08like really is this really going to be the thing that kills me
- 1:11:12but if it is so be
- 1:11:13it but I felt a duty to step into that space and it wasn't a
- 1:11:17desire because I don't
- 1:11:18have any desire to be in politics but I did feel a duty and the
- 1:11:22reason why I felt a
- 1:11:23duty was because my positionality put me in almost a totally
- 1:11:29unique position right
- 1:11:30SPEAKER_01: like
- 1:11:32I'm an Albertan I was born in Calgary I gave birth to my son in
- 1:11:34the same hospital
- 1:11:35that I was given birth to given born in there we go you know
- 1:11:40I've been here for 16
- 1:11:41years I've covered the politics of this place for 16 years no
- 1:11:45one can argue that I
- 1:11:47have carried water for the liberals that's insane I've been
- 1:11:49very critical of the
- 1:11:50SPEAKER_01: liberals and their approach over the last 16 years I understand the
- 1:11:54the grievances that people are talking about I've covered
- 1:11:56separatism on and off for
- 1:11:58more than 10 years now so like I have I have this like 16 year
- 1:12:02history that no one
- 1:12:03I don't think that people can really attack and on top of that
- 1:12:07I'm co-owner of an
- 1:12:08SPEAKER_01: actual independent media company that doesn't take money from the feds
- 1:12:12SPEAKER_01: All right.
- 1:12:13SPEAKER_01: So we are genuinely independent.
- 1:12:15The only way we get money is through subscribers like and
- 1:12:18subscribe and or through
- 1:12:20SPEAKER_01: transparent advertising that we disclose is advertising.
- 1:12:22SPEAKER_01: OK, so we're totally above board.
- 1:12:25SPEAKER_01: There's no dirt on me.
- 1:12:27SPEAKER_01: You can't buy me.
- 1:12:28You can influence me,
- 1:12:30but you can't buy me and you can't and you can't intimidate me.
- 1:12:33SPEAKER_00: There's a little dirt on you, but I say that affectionately.
- 1:12:36like what though like what that I'm a weirdo like everyone
- 1:12:39knows it's fine but I'm
- 1:12:41just saying like all of these things have combined to make me
- 1:12:44this like one of one
- 1:12:46person who had a unique capacity and credibility to speak to
- 1:12:50these issues and
- 1:12:51criticize them from a kind of conservative-ish perspective I'm
- 1:12:56not beholden to the
- 1:12:57SPEAKER_01: UCP I'm not beholden to the provincial government I'm not beholden to the
- 1:13:00conservatives I'm not beholden to the liberals I can say what I
- 1:13:03actually think in a
- 1:13:04SPEAKER_01: way that
- 1:13:05at this point I think very few people in this province can and
- 1:13:08by the way I don't
- 1:13:10think that's a good thing I don't want to be the one of one
- 1:13:12okay there should be 20
- 1:13:14SPEAKER_01: of me there should be 20 of me capable of doing this of this kind of work
- 1:13:19editorially there's only one person in the universe who can
- 1:13:22actually constrain you
- 1:13:23and it's me and I don't bat a thousand well I'm not even sure I
- 1:13:31bat 300 like I
- 1:13:32SPEAKER_00: don't think I'm getting into the hall of fame
- 1:13:34we constrain each other and that's healthy and that's healthy
- 1:13:37and like I wouldn't
- 1:13:38have wanted to to do this to start this business alone and I
- 1:13:41don't think you would
- 1:13:41have wanted to do this six years ago we made a strategic choice
- 1:13:43to design a company
- 1:13:44around avoiding the Substack problem of writers becoming
- 1:13:47indulgent because they had
- 1:13:48no editor well and also the audience capture problem right so
- 1:13:51we we brought each
- 1:13:52other on to this board for a reason and I think that that was a
- 1:13:55good decision for
- 1:13:56both of us but like the point I'm trying to make here is that
- 1:13:59all of these things
- 1:14:01SPEAKER_01: the fundamental immune system of the of of
- 1:14:04Alberta is so weakened that it put me into this like one of one
- 1:14:08position and from
- 1:14:09that one of one position I was like it's not really a choice to
- 1:14:13step up it's a duty
- 1:14:13to step up and it's a duty to advocate for this because if I
- 1:14:17don't and if I don't
- 1:14:18help create a permission structure for conservatives to oppose
- 1:14:21this then we might
- 1:14:23have a significant problem that will hurt ordinary Albertans
- 1:14:26like it was it was a
- 1:14:27SPEAKER_01: genuine sense of civic duty that required it
- 1:14:31and you know i may have torched my journalism career in normal
- 1:14:34space forever as a
- 1:14:35result of it well whatever i know more than i did before i
- 1:14:38guess but it's also an
- 1:14:42honor and a privilege to do that like i'm at like we find
- 1:14:47meaning in our work and
- 1:14:50for the next six months i know the assignment and that's that's
- 1:14:53an honor and a
- 1:14:53privilege and i'm grateful for it we um but the point i'm
- 1:14:59trying to make here is
- 1:15:00SPEAKER_01: like
- 1:15:03credibility and positionality here on an issue like this really
- 1:15:08matter and I'm not
- 1:15:13saying that people from the east shouldn't weigh in I'm not
- 1:15:16saying that but I do
- 1:15:18think they have to be more careful about how they choose to
- 1:15:20weigh in I don't
- 1:15:24disagree with you but I am going to for the sake of argument
- 1:15:29I'm going to make you
- 1:15:30SPEAKER_00: show your work okay
- 1:15:34Everybody who adopts the role of the censor will insist that
- 1:15:42that's the last thing
- 1:15:43SPEAKER_00: they're doing.
- 1:15:44SPEAKER_00: They're just ensuring that the debate is fair.
- 1:15:47SPEAKER_00: They're just preventing bad actors from abusing the process.
- 1:15:53SPEAKER_00: You're going to seldom meet someone who is like,
- 1:15:56SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 1:15:57SPEAKER_00: I'm gatekeeping out the opinions I don't agree with.
- 1:16:01SPEAKER_00: in a weird way our declaration a week ago that we were going to take a
- 1:16:05pro-federalist position was unusually honest in that regard but
- 1:16:09I think what you
- 1:16:10might end up struggling with here is trying to for your own
- 1:16:15comfort hold two
- 1:16:18contradictory ideas at once one of them is of course my fellow
- 1:16:23Canadians have every
- 1:16:23SPEAKER_00: right to speak on an issue of national concern
- 1:16:26and also but they've got to do it in a way that we're going to
- 1:16:29approve of here I
- 1:16:30would get rid of the word got and I would get rid of the word
- 1:16:33approve they don't
- 1:16:34SPEAKER_01: have like I'm not a censor I don't have that power
- 1:16:38SPEAKER_01: The Line theline
- 1:17:08I don't have that authority all I can say offer here is a moral
- 1:17:13appeal and that is
- 1:17:16of course you are weighing in on a position of national concern
- 1:17:19I'm asking you I'm
- 1:17:21asking you not demanding I'm asking you to be conscious
- 1:17:25conscious of the way you
- 1:17:26might come across and the way your words might be weaponized
- 1:17:29against your own
- 1:17:30interests or against your own argument even it's a total
- 1:17:35hypothetical okay
- 1:17:38SPEAKER_00: One thing,
- 1:17:38and I'm going to break the fourth wall and I'm going to tell
- 1:17:40the audience something
- 1:17:41SPEAKER_00: that Jen and I do.
- 1:17:42SPEAKER_00: Jen and I are very,
- 1:17:43very good at disclosing biases to each other and also any
- 1:17:47possible conflicts.
- 1:17:49SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 1:17:50there was a time when I had to send something on to Jen for the
- 1:17:53simple reason that
- 1:17:54SPEAKER_00: I really disliked the person who had sent it.
- 1:17:57SPEAKER_00: And I'm like,
- 1:17:58I don't think I can judge this piece on the merits because I
- 1:18:01think the author is a
- 1:18:02SPEAKER_00: dink.
- 1:18:03and ultimately jen god bless you you said this piece is
- 1:18:06terrible and i thought it
- 1:18:07was too but i didn't know if that's just because i thought the
- 1:18:09author was a dink
- 1:18:11here's a fun hypothetical let's say i'm not around i'm off i've
- 1:18:16gone fishing and
- 1:18:18you get a piece that is an absolute banger it is a wonderfully
- 1:18:21written engaging and
- 1:18:22thoughtful column that you know will enrage the separatists do
- 1:18:27you want to run it
- 1:18:28SPEAKER_01: Yeah, potentially.
- 1:18:29SPEAKER_01: It just depends.
- 1:18:30SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 1:18:30I think in those sorts of situations where you feel that I have
- 1:18:33a conflict,
- 1:18:33SPEAKER_01: and this is an ordinary editorial discussion that we would have.
- 1:18:38SPEAKER_01: If we're talking about something in which you think that I'm conflicted,
- 1:18:41SPEAKER_01: then we have to bring in a third party,
- 1:18:43SPEAKER_01: and we have third parties we can bring in in order to do that.
- 1:18:47SPEAKER_01: So I don't think that's a problem, to be honest with you.
- 1:18:50SPEAKER_00: I don't think it is either, because I trust you.
- 1:18:54I would also say if you and I have had this pre-existing
- 1:18:59conversation where we've
- 1:19:00SPEAKER_01: said,
- 1:19:00SPEAKER_01: look,
- 1:19:01SPEAKER_01: Jen,
- 1:19:01you're obviously conflicted on this issue because you don't
- 1:19:04want to break the
- 1:19:05SPEAKER_01: country,
- 1:19:05SPEAKER_01: which I guess is unreasonable.
- 1:19:08SPEAKER_01: Um,
- 1:19:10If you get a column,
- 1:19:12you have to get it passed by someone who's a bit more impartial
- 1:19:14than you.
- 1:19:15SPEAKER_01: Again, we have editors on deck who we trust to be a second pair of eyes.
- 1:19:21SPEAKER_01: Who cares?
- 1:19:23SPEAKER_01: That's fine.
- 1:19:26SPEAKER_00: I confess,
- 1:19:27and I teased Jen earlier that I didn't want to get a job
- 1:19:31performance review on the
- 1:19:33SPEAKER_00: air.
- 1:19:35One of the things that I find that people may or may not find
- 1:19:39interesting,
- 1:19:39SPEAKER_00: the way I write is I bang out a first draft and I do it really quickly.
- 1:19:44SPEAKER_00: Then I ignore it for an hour or two.
- 1:19:46SPEAKER_00: And then I sit down and I fix a few typos.
- 1:19:49SPEAKER_00: And normally I'm pretty good at it.
- 1:19:50Like it is very rare for me that a second draft is radically
- 1:19:54different than a first.
- 1:19:56SPEAKER_00: And I know writers who are different.
- 1:19:59who's who's kind of like they have to kind of do an iterative
- 1:20:01process to get
- 1:20:02something from like first idea to publishable i do it very
- 1:20:05quickly but i've been
- 1:20:06struggling to write a column about alberta this week because i
- 1:20:09just don't know what
- 1:20:09to say i know what the idea i want to communicate is but i am
- 1:20:14self-consciously in
- 1:20:15my own head and that's unusual for me normally i don't give a
- 1:20:19shit which is part of
- 1:20:21SPEAKER_00: my charm or an explanation for some of my personal failures
- 1:20:26normally I don't give a shit but I am in my head because I
- 1:20:30actually think I have
- 1:20:31something worth saying on the matter of national unity and I do
- 1:20:36not know if a voice
- 1:20:37from Toronto is going to be helpful and my editorial response
- 1:20:41to you in that column
- 1:20:42was I didn't love the column and that wasn't because there
- 1:20:44wasn't a nugget in there
- 1:20:45that I thought was worth you saying but that my problem was
- 1:20:48that you'd made it
- 1:20:49about you right you hadn't the nugget of the column and if you
- 1:20:53want me to disclose
- 1:20:54SPEAKER_01: it
- 1:20:54that I think was worthwhile was writing was was effectively the
- 1:20:58grievances that
- 1:20:59Albertans are responding to and the feelings that they're
- 1:21:00responding to are
- 1:21:01actually universal Canadians are just as frustrated on all of
- 1:21:05these on these on
- 1:21:06these areas as Albertans are and that I think is a totally
- 1:21:10worthwhile column to
- 1:21:11write where I think your column and this is the editorial
- 1:21:15feedback I gave you where
- 1:21:16I think it start stopped working was when you made yourself
- 1:21:20central to that column
- 1:21:22And you talked about how you're in your own head about wanting
- 1:21:24to write about
- 1:21:25SPEAKER_01: national unity and how you were also,
- 1:21:27SPEAKER_01: I think,
- 1:21:27SPEAKER_01: in some ways,
- 1:21:29egoically kind of pushing back against the idea that you can't
- 1:21:32write about it.
- 1:21:33SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 1:21:34SPEAKER_01: So I was like, that is not that's not serving anything.
- 1:21:38SPEAKER_01: That's not that's not serving your column.
- 1:21:39SPEAKER_01: It didn't actually serve the column or the or the argument very well.
- 1:21:44SPEAKER_01: It wasn't constructive to the actual conversation or the overall debate.
- 1:21:48it actually overshadowed I thought what was the nugget of the
- 1:21:52actual column there
- 1:21:53SPEAKER_01: which was strong and worthwhile to write and I just didn't think it
- 1:22:01and also the fundamental problems that I knew wearing my
- 1:22:04Alberta hat the way people
- 1:22:05were going to receive it wasn't like you know what he's right
- 1:22:07the rest of Canada
- 1:22:08actually is feeling the same way we're feeling about it instead
- 1:22:11they were going to
- 1:22:11respond to it with Jesus fucking Christ another guy in Toronto
- 1:22:15another guy in
- 1:22:16Toronto is making this about him like can't we just can central
- 1:22:20Canada not seed
- 1:22:21even a little bit of the stage just for goddamn once like that
- 1:22:25was going to be the
- 1:22:26Albertan response to that column so do I not want you writing
- 1:22:29that column no I want
- 1:22:30SPEAKER_01: you writing that column
- 1:22:32you have in that in the draft you sent me like you have the
- 1:22:37centrality of an actual
- 1:22:38SPEAKER_01: really good useful valuable column that stands on its own merits but the
- 1:22:45positionality was something that needed to be addressed and
- 1:22:48that I think is the
- 1:22:49point I'm trying to make here so it's not shut up that's not
- 1:22:53the point and in fact
- 1:22:54I think that the rest of Canada the federalist movement would
- 1:22:57be poorly served by
- 1:22:58SPEAKER_01: the rest of Canada shutting up
- 1:23:00And the federalist movement will be poorly served by the rest
- 1:23:02of Canada not being
- 1:23:03honest and straight I'm always a big fan of honesty and
- 1:23:06straightness But I think
- 1:23:08what the federalist cause does need Is a degree of
- 1:23:11self-awareness And a degree of
- 1:23:13self-consciousness And not only in terms of how they come
- 1:23:16across and how things are
- 1:23:17going to be weaponized But also the degree to which a lot of
- 1:23:20the unstated habits of
- 1:23:21this country Have contributed to the problem Two comments I
- 1:23:24would make One of them
- 1:23:25SPEAKER_00: is that positionality
- 1:23:28can be a road paved with good intentions that leads people to a
- 1:23:31dark place because
- 1:23:32it can evolve into eventually you have no right to speak at
- 1:23:35this that is our word
- 1:23:36and I don't think that's my I don't think that's the argument
- 1:23:39I've made or I'm
- 1:23:40making but I think no one starts there no but I but but but
- 1:23:44let's not get to suit
- 1:23:45to a slippery slope fallacy either I'm not starting are
- 1:23:48slippery yeah well yeah but
- 1:23:50I'm not starting there and that's not the position I'm making
- 1:23:52okay well I hope
- 1:23:54SPEAKER_00: everyone there proves as wise and restrained as you're promising to be
- 1:23:59um the other issue and this is the one that might be more
- 1:24:04controversial you are
- 1:24:09doing you you were working really hard and you've taken a
- 1:24:11position that i really
- 1:24:12admire the way you've been doing i'm not buttering you up
- 1:24:15before dropping a harsh
- 1:24:16truth on you i really admire the position you're taking and all
- 1:24:18and all the
- 1:24:19platforms you've been on because you've been doing podcast
- 1:24:21interviews you've been
- 1:24:22SPEAKER_00: doing radio interviews tv hits you've been tweeting and
- 1:24:24which I have mixed feelings about but like Jen Jen's out there
- 1:24:28and one of her
- 1:24:28arguments and I think it's accurate is that she is a journalist
- 1:24:32in the line as a
- 1:24:33publication is not obligated to take a neutral position between
- 1:24:37smart and stupid
- 1:24:39SPEAKER_00: yeah and I agree with that but I also wonder
- 1:24:48I have told you before that Albertans have a normally charming
- 1:24:52habit of falling
- 1:24:54SPEAKER_00: into their own belly buttons 100% 100% How useful might it be,
- 1:25:02SPEAKER_00: or counterproductive,
- 1:25:03SPEAKER_00: because it could be either,
- 1:25:05SPEAKER_00: to have someone on the outside call bullshit on bullshit?
- 1:25:09SPEAKER_01: Depends on how they do it
- 1:25:11and it depends on and honestly it depends on like look are you
- 1:25:14making this about
- 1:25:15the national unity crisis are you making this about honesty for
- 1:25:19honesty sake or are
- 1:25:20SPEAKER_01: you making it about you right like like I um
- 1:25:33I don't know if it's possible to do it in a way that will not
- 1:25:35be turned into it
- 1:25:36SPEAKER_01: being about the war on you.
- 1:25:39SPEAKER_01: I actually think it is possible to write that column basically like,
- 1:25:42SPEAKER_01: guys,
- 1:25:43SPEAKER_01: you're up your own asses.
- 1:25:45SPEAKER_01: I mean, I wouldn't have a problem writing that column.
- 1:25:49SPEAKER_01: But it's easier for me.
- 1:25:50It's easier for me to write that column than it is for you to
- 1:25:52write that column.
- 1:25:53SPEAKER_01: I think there should be nothing off the table
- 1:25:58all I think I'm asking for here is a degree of self-awareness
- 1:26:02that's it like look
- 1:26:04what is the purpose of writing the column what are you trying
- 1:26:06to achieve by writing
- 1:26:07SPEAKER_01: the column and are you achieving that goal by writing it this way
- 1:26:14SPEAKER_01: I can't be a judge of that for everybody.
- 1:26:18SPEAKER_01: I'm not the censor.
- 1:26:19SPEAKER_01: I can't be a judge of that.
- 1:26:20Those are just questions that as a writer advising other
- 1:26:25writers outside of
- 1:26:26SPEAKER_01: Alberta,
- 1:26:27those are the questions that I would be asking myself when I'm
- 1:26:30thinking about how
- 1:26:30SPEAKER_01: to approach a thesis.
- 1:26:33What I would say is that the reason I was so copacetic with
- 1:26:40Jen's feedback on my
- 1:26:42SPEAKER_00: column is because my column was bad.
- 1:26:44I didn't like my draft either and I threw it out to our
- 1:26:48colleagues here for
- 1:26:49feedback specifically because I was like I didn't even bother
- 1:26:53putting a headline on
- 1:26:54it or putting a photo in it like I didn't think it was working
- 1:26:58either but I also
- 1:27:01think we should not get overly focused on the idea of a writer
- 1:27:07in a column it could
- 1:27:09SPEAKER_00: be anyone outside of Alberta using any platform in any medium
- 1:27:15and I honestly do not know in the era we live in this don't
- 1:27:19don't take this
- 1:27:19personally Jen I don't want you to feel defensive about this we
- 1:27:23live in an era
- 1:27:24where if I go out there and say how much I love pancakes I'm
- 1:27:27gonna have some
- 1:27:28asshole saying why do you hate waffles and I don't know if it's
- 1:27:36gonna be possible
- 1:27:38for there to be an external voice that could be reasonable
- 1:27:41measured positional and
- 1:27:42SPEAKER_00: good faith enough
- 1:27:44to not get weaponized that's quite totally possible but that
- 1:27:48doesn't absolve us of
- 1:27:50the responsibility of being responsible in our own
- 1:27:52communications so as I said like
- 1:27:54this is why I got kind of pissy with conservatives this week
- 1:27:57because Mark Carney
- 1:27:58was making comments about separatism that are basically
- 1:28:01identical to the comments I
- 1:28:02would make about separatism and the point that I was trying to
- 1:28:05make is Mark Carney
- 1:28:06is actually speaking for the majority of Albertans here when he
- 1:28:09makes these
- 1:28:10SPEAKER_01: comments and I thought his comments were pretty measured
- 1:28:15And what happened is that he got attacked by a bunch of
- 1:28:18conservatives from the east
- 1:28:20SPEAKER_01: who were like,
- 1:28:20SPEAKER_01: how dare you inflame the flames?
- 1:28:25SPEAKER_01: Because, of course, they benefit not by defending federalism.
- 1:28:28SPEAKER_01: They benefit by attacking Mark Carney.
- 1:28:30SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:28:31And one of the frustrations that I have is that I think federal
- 1:28:35conservatives,
- 1:28:35SPEAKER_01: and I think,
- 1:28:36SPEAKER_01: again,
- 1:28:37SPEAKER_01: credit to Pierre Polyev,
- 1:28:38who has said federal conservatives will be marshaled to the
- 1:28:42forces of federalism in
- 1:28:43SPEAKER_01: Alberta.
- 1:28:43SPEAKER_01: Thank you very much.
- 1:28:44SPEAKER_01: I think that was the correct answer.
- 1:28:46But one of the frustrations I have is I want them on the ground
- 1:28:49making the case for
- 1:28:50SPEAKER_01: Canada,
- 1:28:51not on the ground claiming they're making the case for Canada
- 1:28:54while picking apart
- 1:28:55SPEAKER_01: the prime minister's tone.
- 1:28:57Right like that's not a constructive dynamic right like let's
- 1:29:01just have them here
- 1:29:02making the case for Canada and if they think they have a better
- 1:29:04approach or a
- 1:29:05better tone then let's see it show me show me a better example
- 1:29:10then by only I'm
- 1:29:11open to instruction man show me how to do this better so I
- 1:29:17think your point is
- 1:29:18correct I think your point is correct is that that it's really
- 1:29:21easy to weaponize
- 1:29:22SPEAKER_01: just about any voice here
- 1:29:25SPEAKER_01: But this is also why I circle back to,
- 1:29:28SPEAKER_01: and again,
- 1:29:28SPEAKER_01: I don't want to make this by myself,
- 1:29:29but this is also why I circle back to the idea that I felt the
- 1:29:31duty to step up
- 1:29:32SPEAKER_01: because no one can attack me for being an outsider.
- 1:29:35SPEAKER_01: No one can attack me for taking federal money.
- 1:29:37SPEAKER_01: No one can attack me for being in the tank for anybody.
- 1:29:40Everyone knows,
- 1:29:41I mean,
- 1:29:41everybody in Alberta more or less knows that I say what I
- 1:29:43think.
- 1:29:45SPEAKER_01: And I say what I think and I criticize everybody.
- 1:29:48SPEAKER_01: I'm not nice to anyone.
- 1:29:49SPEAKER_01: It's something I'm working on.
- 1:29:52SPEAKER_00: Work harder.
- 1:29:53SPEAKER_01: Work harder.
- 1:29:54I know but that gives me a unique credibility to be able to
- 1:30:00then go to my fellow
- 1:30:01Albertans and be like you guys are being parochial and up your
- 1:30:07own asses and I can
- 1:30:09say that in a way where they can't attack me as being an
- 1:30:12outsider as a result of
- 1:30:13that and like look on any other issue I don't think these
- 1:30:16strictures apply right on
- 1:30:18SPEAKER_01: any other policy issue I don't think it matters
- 1:30:21SPEAKER_01: But on this one,
- 1:30:22when we're dealing with questions not of policy but of
- 1:30:25fundamental identity that
- 1:30:26SPEAKER_01: threatens to divide the polity against itself,
- 1:30:30SPEAKER_01: on this one issue,
- 1:30:33SPEAKER_01: where you physically stand in the polity makes a difference.
- 1:30:37SPEAKER_01: And it does.
- 1:30:40SPEAKER_00: I've been watching you argue with Albertans.
- 1:30:46SPEAKER_00: I find it intriguing.
- 1:30:48SPEAKER_01: Mm-hmm.
- 1:30:50SPEAKER_00: I have seen,
- 1:30:51SPEAKER_00: and I'm sure you've seen some of this too,
- 1:30:54SPEAKER_00: I've seen you dismissed as Laurentian of the mind.
- 1:30:57SPEAKER_00: Oh, sure, she's from here.
- 1:30:59SPEAKER_00: She lives here.
- 1:31:01SPEAKER_00: But she's gone native.
- 1:31:03SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 1:31:04SPEAKER_01: Well, native in Calgary, of course.
- 1:31:05SPEAKER_01: And of course,
- 1:31:06then they're going to attack me for being a Calgarian and
- 1:31:08therefore not a true
- 1:31:09SPEAKER_01: Albertan,
- 1:31:10SPEAKER_01: right?
- 1:31:10SPEAKER_01: But to me, those kinds of attacks...
- 1:31:14Only further a federalist position because they show just how
- 1:31:17narrow these people's
- 1:31:19SPEAKER_01: versions of Albertan actually is.
- 1:31:21SPEAKER_01: To me,
- 1:31:22those types of attacks demonstrate that what these people
- 1:31:24actually want isn't a
- 1:31:26SPEAKER_01: thriving state in which people of diverse viewpoints can live in harmony.
- 1:31:31What these guys are actually looking for is a conservative
- 1:31:34monoculture in which
- 1:31:35SPEAKER_01: everybody agrees with them.
- 1:31:37SPEAKER_00: Oh, the match has looked pretty openly on that front a couple times.
- 1:31:40SPEAKER_01: Well, that's right.
- 1:31:41SPEAKER_01: But I mean,
- 1:31:41SPEAKER_01: to me,
- 1:31:42those types of attacks are actually constructive and useful
- 1:31:44because they're
- 1:31:44SPEAKER_01: demonstrating that.
- 1:31:46SPEAKER_01: If I don't meet your standard for Albertan,
- 1:31:49SPEAKER_01: which,
- 1:31:49SPEAKER_01: by the way,
- 1:31:49SPEAKER_01: polling shows that I'm in the majority on a lot of these issues,
- 1:31:52SPEAKER_01: not the minority,
- 1:31:53SPEAKER_01: guys.
- 1:31:55SPEAKER_01: All right?
- 1:31:55SPEAKER_01: So if I don't meet your standard for Albertan,
- 1:31:59SPEAKER_01: then your standard for Albertan isn't really Albertan.
- 1:32:04SPEAKER_01: Your standard for what you're counting as Albertan
- 1:32:07SPEAKER_01: is like a minority position that's largely rural.
- 1:32:12SPEAKER_01: And there's nothing wrong with having a minority position that's rural.
- 1:32:15SPEAKER_01: There's no disrespect or dislike.
- 1:32:17SPEAKER_01: Cool, that's fine.
- 1:32:18SPEAKER_01: But I'm trying to highlight something through the contrast.
- 1:32:22SPEAKER_01: Right?
- 1:32:23SPEAKER_01: But again,
- 1:32:24SPEAKER_01: my positionality,
- 1:32:25SPEAKER_01: my credibility allows me to do that in a way that other people can't.
- 1:32:29SPEAKER_00: I'm going to ask you a big picture question before we wrap this up.
- 1:32:32SPEAKER_00: But I do have a comment to make.
- 1:32:33And I just want to get your quick response on it before I ask
- 1:32:35you the big question.
- 1:32:37So one of the things that you have articulated really well over
- 1:32:41your career,
- 1:32:42SPEAKER_00: and I give full credit to you on this,
- 1:32:44I think you articulated it once in a way that helped me
- 1:32:47understand something in my
- 1:32:48SPEAKER_00: brain.
- 1:32:50SPEAKER_00: Sometimes you know things intuitively,
- 1:32:51SPEAKER_00: but then someone else describes it perfectly and you go,
- 1:32:54SPEAKER_00: that's it.
- 1:32:55You have described repeatedly over the years that one of the
- 1:32:59problems Alberta runs
- 1:33:01SPEAKER_00: into is that it's a very small,
- 1:33:02SPEAKER_00: closed ecosystem.
- 1:33:04SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 1:33:07How mindful of you are you of that now when you're talking I'm
- 1:33:11acutely conscious of
- 1:33:12it now look I should I said I should not be one of one guys
- 1:33:17like there should be a
- 1:33:19half a dozen in totally independent commentators activists
- 1:33:22whatever who feel
- 1:33:23totally empowered to speak to this stuff from a place of total
- 1:33:27credibility and in a
- 1:33:28healthier democratic ecosystem there's I would be perfectly
- 1:33:32content to stick stick
- 1:33:33SPEAKER_00: back on the sidelines and continue to be a journalist
- 1:33:36It speaks something about how closed and incestuous this
- 1:33:38ecosystem is that the duty
- 1:33:40SPEAKER_01: for me to step up was apparent.
- 1:33:44SPEAKER_00: Yes, but I don't think that's exactly what I was asking.
- 1:33:47I think you were someone who has generally understood that one
- 1:33:50of the things that
- 1:33:50would have benefited Alberta over the years was a greater
- 1:33:52exposure to stuff from
- 1:33:54SPEAKER_00: outside of Alberta.
- 1:33:55SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 1:33:57I don't accuse you of hypocrisy because I think you've
- 1:33:59articulated this very responsibly.
- 1:34:01SPEAKER_00: You're also cautioning non-Albertans about how to do that.
- 1:34:05And i'm wondering where's the tension there like how do you
- 1:34:07balance great tension
- 1:34:09well look half the half the people who live in alberta were
- 1:34:11born outside of alberta
- 1:34:14right so the idea that yes that it is a bit of an incestuous
- 1:34:17closed eco like
- 1:34:18political culture it's actually a pretty cosmopolitan not the
- 1:34:21province yeah it's a
- 1:34:22it's actually a pretty cosmopolitan province with a pretty wide
- 1:34:26diversity of of
- 1:34:27SPEAKER_01: political views perspectives and and backgrounds
- 1:34:30So again,
- 1:34:30again,
- 1:34:31kind of poking a hole in some of the separatist propaganda on
- 1:34:34this stuff.
- 1:34:35The idea that Albertans all fit this one model and this one
- 1:34:39model is universally
- 1:34:40SPEAKER_01: aggrieved by the state of Canada.
- 1:34:44SPEAKER_01: That's pretty narrow too, guys.
- 1:34:47And I think I've enormously benefited from working in other
- 1:34:52parts of the country.
- 1:34:53I've enormously benefited from my time working in Toronto and
- 1:34:56working in other media ecosystems.
- 1:34:58it's that's that broadens the mind so like look Albertans
- 1:35:02actually a pretty
- 1:35:03SPEAKER_01: cosmopolitan place and separatism is a is is a is a movement and it's an
- 1:35:09interesting movement but it's not actually representative of
- 1:35:11the province as a
- 1:35:12whole and I think that it's a mistake to conflate Albertan
- 1:35:15grievance or western
- 1:35:16alienation with Albertan separatism which is a very specific
- 1:35:18and actually pretty
- 1:35:19narrow movement so those things in mind and as I said I would
- 1:35:23just encourage like
- 1:35:24SPEAKER_01: look I understand that and I I get that but I'm saying
- 1:35:29SPEAKER_01: Toronto's no less closed.
- 1:35:31SPEAKER_01: Oh no, well much worse.
- 1:35:32SPEAKER_01: Like Ottawa's no less closed, right?
- 1:35:35And I think that one of the things that we need to address here
- 1:35:39as we move into
- 1:35:40several successive succession crises here is that we're going
- 1:35:44to have to start
- 1:35:45talking to each other across these kind of cultural bubbles in
- 1:35:48a much more
- 1:35:49SPEAKER_01: effective way.
- 1:35:50SPEAKER_01: And I hope we can do that.
- 1:35:53SPEAKER_01: No, no, I have to go.
- 1:35:53SPEAKER_00: Oh, are you, you hit time here?
- 1:35:57SPEAKER_01: I hit time.
- 1:35:59literally or can I get one more minute at it you tell me no
- 1:36:02dude I gotta like I the
- 1:36:04bell rings in two minutes that's too bad five minute car so I'm
- 1:36:08already three
- 1:36:08minutes behind I gotta go like and subscribe like and subscribe
- 1:36:12www.readtheline.ca
- 1:36:14I will find another way to ask Jen the question I want to ask
- 1:36:17her have a great
- 1:36:18SPEAKER_00: weekend thanks for tuning in