Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / Not Every Student Behaviour Needs a Consequence
Transcript
- Ilana: What if the best thing you can do when a student does something wrong is absolutely nothing. And what if constantly responding is actually what's making some classroom situations worse? There is a moment in almost every classroom a student does something that isn't quite right. It's not a huge deal, you know, but you notice it. and immediately There's this little decision you have to make as a teacher. Do you address it or let it go? Sometimes, without even realizing it, We choose to address it simply because we saw it. I remember watching a teacher She spent an entire lesson responding to one student out of 27, one student, small behaviors. Nothing was serious, no major disruptions, but every time something happened, that teacher felt like they needed to respond. And little by little, the lesson became less about what the teacher had planned to teach and more about what. One student was doing. And I remember thinking, did any of that actually need to happen? Because I think we've gotten really good at noticing behavior, but I'm not sure we've gotten really good deciding which behaviors actually deserve our attention. And I know that sounds ridiculously simple, but I think it's actually really hard for a teacher because You are a professional noticer. You notice everything around you. The kid tapping their pencil, who's looking out the window, you know, the kid that turns all their worksheets into airplanes, right? You see all. You are the all knowing. but I just think that noticing something doesn't always mean you have to respond to it. And I think that's actually worth practicing. First thing is to remember that not everything is a crisis. Yes, you notice everything, but just because you notice it doesn't mean you need to do something about it. Because sometimes when a student is doing something slightly annoying, or let's face facts, something that is like outside of what you would ideally like them to be doing, and nothing terrible is actually happening in the classroom, the learning is still happening. The class is still moving forward, no one's in danger. So you could just let it go. the second thing is your attention is valuable. You don't want to fall into the attention trap, which will happen when every tiny behavior gets a response, because your students will quickly learn that small behaviors are a very reliable way to get your attention. I'm not saying students are just sitting there plotting against us, although I do think if you've taught long enough, You do occasionally look at a student and think, You absolutely know what you're doing right now. But sometimes we actually accidentally create the cycle ourselves. A student does something small, we respond. They do something else, well, we already responded. We need to respond again, and now it needs to get bigger. And suddenly we're in this strange little like tennis match. Where the student keeps hitting the ball and we keep enthusiastically hitting it back. Except for it's not tennis, it's Tuesday afternoon and you've only got forty minutes left until the bell. And it's also just not as fun as tennis. They've put you into their world and now you're playing the game with them. Okay? So When we get into that space, I think we need to, and this is the third thing, you need to ask yourself a question, is this actually worth your attention? Right? Which is very different question than asking yourself, well, like, are they breaking the rules? Or is this against like the rules? Or do I like I could correct this, couldn't I? I think also one of the biggest things for teachers is you really don't want to ask yourself Would I prefer if the student wasn't doing this? Because yeah, the answer might be yes. But is it really disrupting the lesson, right? Is it actually worth your attention? Does this actually matter right now? You know, or like even just thinking like take the quick second, give it take a breath, look around. Is it is it distracting? Like are people still learning? You know, is it gonna become a bigger problem? You know, if it is, sure, yeah. You might need to deal with it. Use your judgment of course, but if it's really just kind of something you've noticed and it's not bothering anybody else, keep teaching. Keep it going. this brings me to the fourth point. You don't need to solve every problem the second it happens. yes, there is power in letting things go, but really it's more about becoming comfortable with letting the small things go. I understand You care about your lessons and the classroom and the students of course. And you need to care about the bigger learning picture. You know, you need to care so much about the students as a collective and their learning and keeping that flow happening. And every time you do stop your lesson for something small, something insignificant when you look at all of the students in your classroom who are learning. You know, you're making a decision about where the attention for the entire room is going to go. And I think honestly, most of the time the behavior just isn't worth that detour. Do you know what I mean? A student might be tapping their pencil, no one else notices it but you. You don't need to draw attention to it. You don't need to stop the lesson. You can just keep going with it. this takes us to the fifth thought process around this, do not engage in the power struggle, And this is not a permissive stance. I'm not saying that we should ignore behaviors that do need to be addressed, anything unsafe, and there are absolutely times we need to step in. And that's when something's actually affecting the other students or someone's being unsafe, disrespectful, or when a pattern is becoming a real problem, you know, you do deal with it. Once again, it's that professional judgment. You have that as a teacher. but I think there's a huge difference in noticing something sure might annoy you and choosing not to respond because that is a choice and it is a very good professional judgment choice that you can make. You still notice it, you file it away as information, keep an eye on it, and you can decide. Not right now. And it that is a huge skill that every teacher needs to have. And it definitely takes practice Because the most confident thing a teacher can do is to not take the bait. Being a good teacher isn't about catching everything. It's about knowing what's actually worth catching. You've got limited attention. So do your students. And we do have limited time to teach our lessons and get the curriculum across. So make sure you do spend that valuable time of yours on things that actually matter. The next time you notice a small behavior, pause before you react. Ask yourself, Is this actually worth my attention? And if the answer is no, congratulations. You've just given yourself 30 seconds of your life back. It's like in Tadla Ted Lasso, right? Is it is it poopy? Then just let it swim by, right? Like just let it go by. Okay, I want to know what's one student behavior you have finally decided is not worth your blood pressure. Tell me in the comments and if this video made you rethink what actually deserves your attention, hit like and subscribe and stick around because we're going to keep questioning some of the things Teachers have been told we're supposed to do. See you next time.