Latest / Kentucky Tonight / K-12 Education in the Commonwealth
Transcript
- 0:01[♪♪]
- 0:10>> Renee: GOOD EVENING WELCOME
- 0:11TO "KENTUCKY TONIGHT" I'M RENEE
- 0:13SHAW AND WE THANK YOU SO MUCH
- 0:14FOR BEING WITH US THIS EVENING.
- 0:16OUR TOPIC TONIGHT, K-12
- 0:18EDUCATION IN KENTUCKY.
- 0:20ON SEPTEMBER 11TH, THE SUPREME
- 0:22COURT HEARD ARGUMENTS ABOUT
- 0:24CHARTER SCHOOL FUNDING AND
- 0:25ADVOCATES SAY THE STATE SHOULD
- 0:26BE SPENDING $718 MILLION A YEAR
- 0:29ON EDUCATION.
- 0:31BUT HOW MUCH SUPPORT DOES THAT
- 0:32IDEA HAVE IN THE KENTUCKY
- 0:34GENERAL ASSEMBLY?
- 0:35THERE ARE JUST A FEW MONTHS LEFT
- 0:37BEFORE STATE LAWMAKERS CONVENE
- 0:39IN FRANKFORT TO HAMMER OUT A
- 0:41SPENDING PLAN.
- 0:42A COUPLE WEEKS AGO, PUBLIC
- 0:44EDUCATION ADVOCATES ANNOUNCED
- 0:45THEIR FUNDING REQUEST WHICH WAS
- 0:47THREE QUARTERS OF A BILLION MORE
- 0:49THAN WHAT THEY RECEIVED IN THE
- 0:50LAST BUDGET.
- 0:52OUR JUNE LEFFLER HAS MORE.
- 0:53>> PROTECT OUR SCHOOLS KY IS THE
- 0:56GROUP THAT SUCCESSFULLY FOUGHT
- 0:58AMENDMENT 2, THE 2024 BALLOT
- 1:00MEASURE THAT WOULD HAVE ALLOWED
- 1:03PUBLIC DOLLARS TO GO TO PRIVATE
- 1:04AND CHARTER SCHOOLS.
- 1:05NOW THE GROUP IS ASKING FOR MORE
- 1:07MONEY WHEN LAWMAKERS PREPARE A
- 1:09TWO-YEAR BUDGET IN THE NEW YEAR.
- 1:11>> EVERY DOLLAR WE INVEST IN
- 1:13EDUCATION TODAY IS A DOLLAR THAT
- 1:14WE ARE INVESTING IN OUR
- 1:16WORKFORCE OF TOMORROW.
- 1:18>> KENTUCKY'S BASE PER PUPIL
- 1:20FUNDING IS MORE THAN $4500.
- 1:23ALONG WITH SCHOOL TRANSPORTATION
- 1:26AND MATCHES TO LOCAL FUNDING
- 1:27THAT COSTS THE STATE $3.3
- 1:30BILLION A YEAR.
- 1:31>> WE ARE ASKING LAWMAKERS TO
- 1:35INVEST $718 MILLION INTO PUBLIC
- 1:39EDUCATION.
- 1:39THAT IS JUST A LITTLE OVER 3% OF
- 1:43KENTUCKY'S TOTAL BUDGET.
- 1:46THIS INVESTMENT WOULD EQUATE TO
- 1:47AN INCREASE IN 1161 PER EACH
- 1:54KENTUCKY STUDENT.
- 1:54THIS WOULD ALLOW US TO RAISE
- 1:57SEEK FUNDS BY 14%.
- 2:00FULLY FUND SCHOOL
- 2:02TRANSPORTATION.
- 2:04AND INVEST $38 MILLION TOWARDS
- 2:07PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT,
- 2:09TEXTBOOKS AND CLASSROOM
- 2:10TECHNOLOGY.
- 2:11>> THE GROUPS ASKS ANALYSIS FROM
- 2:15THE LEFT LEANING KENTUCKY CENTER
- 2:17FOR ECONOMIC POLICY THAT SAYS
- 2:19RECORD-HIGH EDUCATION FUNDING
- 2:20FROM THE STATE HAS NOT KEPT PACE
- 2:22WITH INFLATION.
- 2:22>> IN 2020 A CHROME BOOK
- 2:25PURCHASE FOR A STUDENT 0 COST
- 2:28$373.
- 2:29THAT SAME DEVICE TODAY COSTS
- 2:34$565.
- 2:35AN INCREASE IN $200 PER STUDENT
- 2:39FOR EACH DEVICE.
- 2:41WHILE KENTUCKY'S LAST BUDGET WAS
- 2:44THE HIGHEST THAT WE HAVE SEEN IN
- 2:46TERMS OF RAW DOLLARS, IT STILL
- 2:50FALLS SHORT OF THE INVESTMENT
- 2:52LEVELS IN 2008 WHEN THAT IS
- 2:55ADJUSTED FOR INFLATION.
- 2:56>> REPUBLICANS IN KENTUCKY'S
- 2:58STATE HOUSE HAVE ALREADY PUSHED
- 3:00BACK ON THIS INITIAL REQUEST.
- 3:02IN A STATEMENT, THE SPEAKER OF
- 3:03THE HOUSE WROTE QUOTE FAR TOO
- 3:06MANY KENTUCKY CHILDREN DON'T
- 3:07READ OR UNDERSTAND MATH AT GRADE
- 3:09LEVEL IT IS PASTIME FOR THE
- 3:12EDUCATION BURE ROCKSY TO STOP
- 3:14DEMANDING MORE MONEY INSTEAD
- 3:16FOCUS ON THE CLASSROOM AND
- 3:17HELPING STUDENTS REACH THEIR
- 3:19POTENTIAL.
- 3:20THE CHAIR OF THE SENATE BUDGET
- 3:23COMMITTEE WROTE QUOTE THE
- 3:25GENERAL ASSEMBLY WAS PRAISED FOR
- 3:27PASSING THE BEST EDUCATION
- 3:28BUDGET IN A GENERATION NOW WE'RE
- 3:30BEING HANDED A HYPER PARTISAN
- 3:32REQUEST THAT DOESN'T MERIT
- 3:35SERIOUS CONSIDERATION FROM
- 3:36LAWMAKERS.
- 3:37ASIDE FROM PER PUPIL FUNDING,
- 3:40REPUBLICANS TOUT FUNDING THAT
- 3:42CHIPPED AWAY AT TEACHERS PENSION
- 3:44LIABILITY.
- 3:45DEMOCRATS AND PUBLIC EDUCATION
- 3:47ADVOCATES SAY THOSE INVESTMENTS
- 3:48DO NOT TRANSLATE TO THE
- 3:51CLASSROOM.
- 3:52FOR "KENTUCKY TONIGHT" I'M JUNE
- 3:53LEFFLER.
- 3:54>> Renee: THANK YOU, SO MUCH
- 3:55JUNE.
- 3:56WE'LL TALK ABOUT THAT AND MORE
- 3:58WITH FOUR GUESTS IN OUR
- 3:59LEXINGTON STUDIO.
- 4:00WE HAVE WITH US, GUS LAFONTAINE,
- 4:02FOUNDER OF THE LAFONTAINE
- 4:05PREPARATORY SCHOOL AND
- 4:05LAFONTAINE EARLY LEARNING
- 4:06CENTER.
- 4:06RHONDA CALDWELL, CHIEF EXECUTIVE
- 4:09OFFICER OF THE KENTUCKY
- 4:10ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL
- 4:12ADMINISTRATORS.
- 4:13ANDREW MCNEILL, PRESIDENT OF
- 4:15KENTUCKY FREE, THE KENTUCKY
- 4:17FORUM FOR RIGHTS ECONOMIC AND
- 4:19EDUCATION AND WE HAVE WITH US,
- 4:21ROB CLAYTON SUPERINTENDENT OF
- 4:23WARREN COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND
- 4:25PRESIDENT OF THE COUNCIL FOR
- 4:26BETTER EDUCATION.
- 4:27WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU
- 4:28TONIGHT.
- 4:28YOU CAN SEND US YOUR QUESTIONS
- 4:31AND COMMENTS BY X AT PUB AFFAIRS
- 4:34KET.
- 4:35SEND AN E-MAIL TO KY TONIGHT AT
- 4:39KET.ORG OR USE THE FORM AT
- 4:42KET.ORG/KY TONIGHT OR YOU MAY
- 4:44CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 4:49WELCOME AND THANK YOU FOR BEING
- 4:50HERE WITH US.
- 4:51FIRST TIME FOR YOU Mr.
- 4:54LAFONTAINE WE APPRECIATE YOU
- 4:55BEING HERE WITH US.
- 4:56WE WILL START WITH THIS SIDE.
- 4:59WE HEARD KERRY WITH ROCK CASTLE
- 5:02COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 5:03SUPERINTENDENT SAY THAT THEY
- 5:04WANT AN INCREASE OF 1100 PER
- 5:07STUDENT.
- 5:08WHAT COULD BE DONE WITH THAT
- 5:10MONEY THAT IS CURRENTLY NOT
- 5:11BEING DONE?
- 5:13>> SUPERINTENDENT CLAYTON?
- 5:14>> WELL, I THINK THERE'S MANY
- 5:17THINGS THAT NEED TO BE
- 5:18CONSIDERED WHEN WE LOOK AT THE
- 5:19FUNDING IS REALLY REQUIRED TO
- 5:21ENSURE THAT OUR STUDENTS ARE
- 5:23SUCCESSFUL.
- 5:24AND THE NUMBERS DON'T LIE.
- 5:26WE'RE ASKING FOR A BUDGET
- 5:29SIMILAR TO WHAT WE WERE
- 5:31RECEIVING BACK NOW 17 YEARS AGO
- 5:33WHEN ADJUSTED FOR INFLATION.
- 5:36AND THE NEEDS THAT WE SEE
- 5:38AMONGST OUR STUDENTS HAVE
- 5:40SIGNIFICANTLY INCREASED.
- 5:41BUT YET, WE'RE SEEING THE FLAT
- 5:44BUDGET.
- 5:45WE'RE APPRECIATIVE CERTAINLY OF
- 5:46THE RECORD INVESTMENT LAST YEAR
- 5:49LAST BUDGET CYCLE.
- 5:50BUT THE REALITY IS WITH
- 5:51INFLATION EVERYTHING'S A WRECK.
- 5:54OUR BUDGETS ARE RECORDS.
- 5:56WHEN YOU CONSIDER THE INFLATION.
- 5:58BUT THEN WHAT IS MOST IMPORTANT
- 5:59IS LOOKING AT THE NEEDS OF OUR
- 6:01STUDENTS AND THE REALITY IS JUST
- 6:03IN ONE EXAMPLE, IN WARREN COUNTY
- 6:07PUBLIC SCHOOLS WE'RE SPENDING
- 6:09$24 MILLION OUT OF THE GENERAL
- 6:11FUND ON THE BACKS OF OUR LOCAL
- 6:13TAXPAYERS, BECAUSE NOW WHEN YOU
- 6:14LOOK AT THE BUDGET COMING FROM
- 6:18THE STATE, WHAT USED TO BE
- 6:20ROUGHLY 60% WAS COMING FROM THE
- 6:23STATE COFFERS AND 40% LOCAL,
- 6:27THAT'S FLIPPED OVER THE LAST
- 6:28DECADE PLUS TO WHERE JUST HERE
- 6:32IN WARREN COUNTY WE'RE LOOKING
- 6:34AT A 46% IS COMING FROM THE
- 6:36STATE AND 54% NOW IS COMING ON
- 6:38THE BACKS OF OUR LOCAL
- 6:40TAXPAYERS.
- 6:41WE'RE FORTUNATE, BECAUSE A LOT
- 6:43OF OUR TAXPAYERS ARE IN OUR
- 6:45SCHOOLS OUR BUSINESS AND
- 6:47INDUSTRY COMING TO OUR SCHOOLS
- 6:48THEY ARE SUPPORTIVE OF BOTH
- 6:49SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
- 6:50AND BECAUSE OF THAT, WE'VE BEEN
- 6:53ABLE TO ENSURE THAT OUR PROPERTY
- 6:55TAXES HAVE BEEN INCREASED EVERY
- 6:58YEAR WITH THE EXCEPTION OF COVID
- 7:00IN TERMS OF GENERATING NEW
- 7:03REVENUE.
- 7:04THIS YEAR WE'RE GOING TO KEEP IT
- 7:06FLAT BECAUSE WE HAVE AN INCREASE
- 7:07IN THE ASSESSMENTS.
- 7:09MY POINT IS THAT WE'RE RELYING
- 7:12ON OUR LOCAL TAXPAYERS TO PICK
- 7:13UP THE DIFFERENCE.
- 7:15AND I THINK ANOTHER KEY POINT IS
- 7:17WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE PROGRESS
- 7:20SINCE THE PANDEMIC, THE STATE OF
- 7:21KENTUCKY WHICH, AGAIN, I WOULD
- 7:23CHALLENGE HOW MANY OF OUR
- 7:25LAWMAKERS KNOW THIS, THAT
- 7:28KENTUCKY IS IN THE TOP 10 IN
- 7:30READING AND MATH RECOVERY SINCE
- 7:32THE PANDEMIC MOST NOTABLY SIXTH
- 7:35IN READING AND EIGHTH IN MATH.
- 7:37SO THAT TELLS YOU THAT SCHOOL
- 7:39DISTRICTS HAVE REALLY RALLIED TO
- 7:41TRY TO MITIGATE THE FUNDING
- 7:44SHORTFALL AND ALSO THE PANDEMIC.
- 7:47>> Renee: BACK TO THAT POINT,
- 7:49SUPERINTENDENT CLAYTON.
- 7:50Dr. CALDWELL, BECAUSE HE IS
- 7:52CORRECT THAT THERE HAVE BEEN
- 7:55STEADY GAINS OR PROGRESS MADE
- 7:56WHEN IT COMES TO FOURTH GRADE
- 7:58READING AND EIGHTH GRADE THEY
- 8:00HAVE INCREASED BUT MATH AND
- 8:02READING SCORES FOR 12TH GRADERS
- 8:05REACHED A 20-YEAR LOW ACCORDING
- 8:07TO THE REPORT CARD.
- 8:08THE NEW LOW REFLECTS A DECADE
- 8:11LONG NEGATIVE TREND IN HIGH
- 8:13SCHOOL LITERACY AND MATH SKILLS.
- 8:15WHEN YOU HEAR THERE ARE GAINS
- 8:16HERE AND LOSSES HERE, SQUARE
- 8:21THAT AND WHY MORE INVESTMENT IS
- 8:23NEEDED AND SOME SAYING THE
- 8:25CURRENT INVESTMENT ISN'T DOING
- 8:26WHAT IT NEEDS TO DO.
- 8:29>> THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO
- 8:31BE HERE.
- 8:31THE CLASSROOM TEACHER IS THE
- 8:33NUMBER ONE PREDICTER FOR A
- 8:36CHILD'S SUCCESS HERE IN THE
- 8:37CLASSROOM SETTING IN OUR PUBLIC
- 8:39SCHOOLS TODAY.
- 8:42AND OUR WE'VE BEEN FACE A
- 8:44TEACHER SHORTAGE FOR QUITE
- 8:45SOMETIME.
- 8:46AND TODAY, OUR CLASSROOMS ARE
- 8:48FILLED WITH WHAT WE CALL
- 8:49TEACHERS WHO BRING ALTERNATIVE
- 8:52CERTIFICATIONS TO US.
- 8:53SO THESE TEACHERS WHILE WE ARE
- 8:55SO GRATEFUL FOR THEM, THEY ARE
- 8:57COMING TO US SAYING I WANT TO
- 8:59TRYOUT TEACHING, I THINK I CAN
- 9:01DO THIS.
- 9:02BUT WHAT WE'RE FEIGNING IN MOST
- 9:05CASES THIS DOESN'T WORKOUT.
- 9:07AND MOST OF OUR CLASSROOMS NOW,
- 9:09ACTUALLY I CHECKED WITH 12 OF
- 9:11OUR SCHOOL DISTRICTS TODAY
- 9:12EARLIER TODAY CHECKED IN WITH
- 9:14THOSE SUPERINTENDENTS, AND
- 9:15ASKING THEM ABOUT THE LANDSCAPE
- 9:18OF THEIR VACANCIES.
- 9:19AND WHAT I LEARNED FROM THEM
- 9:22EACH OF THEM HAD ONE TO TWO
- 9:24VACANCIES IN ALL CASES WHETHER
- 9:26THEY WERE HIRING 11 TEACHERS, 20
- 9:29TEACHERS, POSSIBLY 30 TEACHERS,
- 9:31MOST OF THOSE ARE ALTERNATIVE
- 9:34CERTIFICATION.
- 9:36SO THAT TRANSLATES IS THE FACT
- 9:38THAT WE HAVE TEACHER IN THE
- 9:40CLASSROOMS WHO THEY BRING SOME
- 9:41LEVEL OF EXPERTISE BY WAY OF A
- 9:45BACHELOR'S DEGREE OR SOME
- 9:47COMBINATION OF EDUCATION BEHIND
- 9:48THEM.
- 9:49BUT THEY DO NOT BRING --
- 9:53THEY ARE UNABLE TO MANAGE A
- 9:54CLASSROOM.
- 9:55UNDERSTANDING HOW TO
- 9:57DIFFERENTIATE LEARNING.
- 9:58I MIGHT HAVE 24 THIRD GRADERS OR
- 10:0132 HIGH SCHOOLERS, AND I NEED TO
- 10:03UNDERSTAND HOW EACH OF THEM IS
- 10:04GOING TO LEARN DIFFERENTLY.
- 10:06AND BE ABLE TO TEACH THEM.
- 10:09AND SO WHAT HAPPENS ONCE WE HIRE
- 10:12THEM, WE TAKE ALL OF OUR
- 10:13RESOURCES SO THE ENTIRE SCHOOL
- 10:16NOW IF WE HAVE A STAFF CERTIFIED
- 10:18STAFF OF 30 AND LET'S SAY 50%
- 10:22HAVE ALTERNATIVE CERTIFICATIONS,
- 10:23SO YOU HAVE THE ENTIRE SCHOOL
- 10:26AND WHATEVER RESOURCES THAT YOU
- 10:27HAVE AT THE CENTRAL OFFICE OR
- 10:30DISTRICT OFFICE LEVEL NOW
- 10:31WORKING TO ONBOARD AND
- 10:35ASSIMILATE THESE TEACHERS SO
- 10:36IT'S THE ENTIRE VILLAGE CONCEPT.
- 10:39BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY, WE
- 10:40ARE STRUGGLING FOR PROGRESS AT
- 10:42ALL LEVELS.
- 10:44STARTING AS EARLY AS
- 10:45KINDERGARTEN PRESCHOOL.
- 10:48BECAUSE WE DO NOT HAVE THE
- 10:49STRONG PIPELINE THAT WE NEED AT
- 10:51THE TEACHER LEVEL.
- 10:53AND WE DO NOT HAVE THAT STRONG
- 10:56PIPELINE NOW WHICH THE TEACHER
- 10:57PIPELINE WOULD TYPICALLY FEED
- 11:00OUR PRINCIPALSHIP PIPELINE AND
- 11:01THAT NEEDS A LOT OF
- 11:03STRENGTHENING AS WELL.
- 11:04>> Renee: YOU ARE SAYING THAT
- 11:06BETTER TEACHER PAY WOULD ATTRACT
- 11:09FOLKS WHO HAVE GONE THE ACADEMIC
- 11:12LINES TO BECOME TEACHERS NOT
- 11:15JUST BECAUSE THEY HAVE EXPERTISE
- 11:16IN A PARTICULAR FIELD?
- 11:17>> SO WHEN I PICKED UP ON THE
- 11:20COMMENT EARLIER IN TERMS OF THE
- 11:22INVESTMENT DOESN'T TRANSLATE
- 11:23INTO READING AND MATH SCORES.
- 11:25IF YOU LOOK AT LAST YEAR, OUR
- 11:29LOWEST AVERAGE STARTING TEACHER
- 11:30PAY LOWEST PAY WAS $35,000.
- 11:34FOR A CLASSROOM TEACHER IN
- 11:35DIFFERENT PARTS OF OUR STATE.
- 11:38NOW, OUR AVERAGE RIGHT NOW IS UP
- 11:40AROUND $40,000.
- 11:42WE'RE MAKING PROGRESS.
- 11:44BUT OUR TEACHERS NEED TO BE ABLE
- 11:45TO LIVE.
- 11:46THEY NEED TO BE ABLE TO PAY
- 11:48RENT.
- 11:48THEY NEED TO BE ABLE TO OWN A
- 11:50CAR, TO TRANSPORT.
- 11:51AND THEY NEED TO BE ABLE TO
- 11:53FOCUS ON THE CLASSROOM DAY IN
- 11:55AND DAY OUT.
- 11:56AND BECAUSE OF THESE LOWER PAY
- 11:58LEVEL WHAT IS WE FIND IS MANY OF
- 12:00OUR TEACHERS ARE WORKING SECOND
- 12:01AND THIRD JOBS.
- 12:03BUT COMING BACK TO THE QUESTION
- 12:04AROUND THE RESEARCH DOES SHOW US
- 12:08WHEN TEACHERS ARE PAID MORE,
- 12:10STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT INCREASES.
- 12:12AND I WANT TO GIVE AN EXAMPLE WE
- 12:15LOOK AT THE COUNTRY OF FINLAND
- 12:17QUITE A BIT AND SEVERAL YEARS
- 12:19AGO I WAS ABLE TO COMPLETE A
- 12:22EDUCATIONAL TOUR AND STUDY AND
- 12:23TALK WITH TEACHERS IN THE
- 12:25CLASSROOMS.
- 12:25WHAT I LEARNED FROM THOSE
- 12:27TEACHERS NUMBER ONE, THEY ARE
- 12:29PAID ON PAR WITH DOCTORS.
- 12:32AND I ALSO LEARNED A LOT OF
- 12:34THINGS IN THEIR CLASSROOMS IN
- 12:36TERMS HOW THEY APPROACH IT, BUT
- 12:38I ALSO LEARNED FROM A RETIREMENT
- 12:41PERSPECTIVE THEY ALSO EXPECTED A
- 12:43NICE RETIREMENT ONE THAT THEY
- 12:45HAD CONTRIBUTED TO OVER TIME.
- 12:47AND EARNED OVER THE YEARS.
- 12:50AND THEY WOULD WORK LONGER THAN
- 12:52OUR TEACHERS.
- 12:53BUT BEING PAID ON PAR WITH
- 12:55DOCTORS, ALSO BRINGS A LEVEL OF
- 12:58RESPECT INTO THE PROFESSION
- 13:00WHICH WE ARE STRUGGLING FOR
- 13:03TODAY.
- 13:03>> Renee: AND ANDREW THERE IS A
- 13:04LOT TO CHEW ON.
- 13:06PAYING TEACHERS MORE.
- 13:07WE DON'T KNOW WHAT A DOCTOR IN
- 13:10FINLAND MAYBE MAKING AND DEPENDS
- 13:12WHERE YOU ARE.
- 13:13THE STANDARD OF LIVE UNWILLING A
- 13:15COUNTY MAYBE 30,000 IS DOABLE
- 13:18OPPOSED TO FAYETTE COUNTY WHERE
- 13:19THE STARTING SALARIES ARE HIGHER
- 13:22THAT WOULD NOT BE A LIVABLE
- 13:24WAGE.
- 13:25WHAT IS YOUR THOUGHTS ABOUT
- 13:26WHERE WE ARE WITH EDUCATION
- 13:27FUNDING?
- 13:28WE HEARD REPUBLICAN LAWMAKERS
- 13:30TALK ABOUT RECORD LEVEL OF
- 13:32INVESTMENT AND HOW PERHAPS IT
- 13:34ISN'T TRANSLATING TO THE RESULTS
- 13:36THEY SHOULD BE SEEING.
- 13:37>> WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE
- 13:39STATEMENTS FROM SPEAKER OSBORNE
- 13:42AND CHAIRMAN McDANIEL IT'S
- 13:44EASY TO SEE THAT THERE IS A
- 13:46SENSE OF FRUSTRATION, I BELIEVE.
- 13:48I THINK THE FRUSTRATION IN THEIR
- 13:51REMARKS IS THAT THE GENERAL
- 13:54ASSEMBLY DEALS WITH A LARGE
- 13:57NUMBER OF COMPETING DEMANDS UPON
- 14:00A LIMITED SET OF RESOURCES.
- 14:03THE BUDGET IS AN ENORMOUS
- 14:05NUMBER, BUT THERE ARE A WIDE
- 14:07VARIETY OF NEEDS IN THIS STATE.
- 14:10THAT EVERY TWO YEARS, ACTUALLY
- 14:13EVEN DURING THE INTERIM, VARIOUS
- 14:15GROUPS ARE COMING AND MAKING
- 14:17THEIR CASE FOR ADDITIONAL
- 14:20FUNDING, NEW FUNDING.
- 14:22AND THE WORK THAT THEY HAVE DONE
- 14:24OVER THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS, IS
- 14:27TO COMMIT TO STEADY INCREASES IN
- 14:31EDUCATIONAL FUNDING.
- 14:34AND WHAT HAPPENS AFTER THAT
- 14:37EFFORT IS CONSISTENT FROM THE
- 14:40EDUCATION COMMUNITY, IT'S THANK
- 14:41YOU BUT WE NEED MORE.
- 14:45AND AT TIMES, I ACTUALLY WANT TO
- 14:50GIVE QUITE A BIT OF CREDIT TO
- 14:53EDUCATION ADVOCATES IN THIS UP
- 14:55COMING SESSION BECAUSE IT'S THE
- 14:57FIRST TIME THAT WHEN THE
- 14:58QUESTION HAS BEEN POSED, WHAT
- 15:00EXACTLY IS THE NUMBER?
- 15:02WHAT IS THE FIGURE THAT WOULD
- 15:05FULLY FUND EDUCATION OR
- 15:07ADEQUATELY FUND EDUCATION?
- 15:08THIS IS REALLY THE FIRST TIME IN
- 15:11MY TIME IN FRANKFORT THAT
- 15:12THERE'S BEEN A NUMBER PRESENTED.
- 15:15USUALLY IT'S WELL, WE NEED MORE
- 15:17THAN WHAT WE'RE CURRENTLY
- 15:19GETTING.
- 15:21SO THERE WAS A LOT TO UNPACK
- 15:23THERE.
- 15:23WHEN YOU ARE THINKING OF
- 15:26STARTING SALARY OF $35,000,
- 15:29WE'RE TALKING ABOUT SOMEBODY I
- 15:31WOULD ASSUME YOUR AVERAGE
- 15:34TEACHER BEGINNING THEIR CAREER
- 15:36IS IN THEIR MID-20s.
- 15:40LOOK AT THE TOTAL PACKAGE OF
- 15:46COMPENSATION.
- 15:46WHICH IS AND INCLUDES A REALLY
- 15:51SOLID HEALTHCARE PLAN, THE
- 15:53AMOUNT OF RESOURCES THAT THE
- 15:55GENERAL ASSEMBLY HAS DEDICATED
- 15:58TO ENSURING THAT THAT PENSION
- 16:00SYSTEM THE TEACHERS PENSION
- 16:03SYSTEM IS NOT TEETERING ON
- 16:07FINANCIAL INSOLVENCY HAS BEEN
- 16:09ENORMOUS.
- 16:09WE ARE TALKING BILLIONS OF
- 16:12DOLLARS.
- 16:13SO I UNDERSTAND THE FRUSTRATION
- 16:15FROM OUR POLITICAL LEADERSHIP.
- 16:20WHEN THEY ARE ROLLING UP THEIR
- 16:21SLEEVES AND MAKING NEW MASSIVE
- 16:24COMMITMENTS, BALANCING THE
- 16:26BUDGETS AS PART OF THAT.
- 16:30EMBRACING SMART TAX POLICY AND
- 16:32PRO GROWTH TAX POLICY.
- 16:34AND THEY CONTINUE TO HEAR FROM
- 16:37EDUCATORS AND ADMINISTRATORS
- 16:39WHAT YOU HAVE DONE IS NICE, BUT
- 16:42IT JUST ISN'T ENOUGH.
- 16:45AND SO I DON'T KNOW HOW WELL
- 16:48THIS MESSAGE IS GOING TO BE
- 16:49RECEIVED IF THAT IS ANY
- 16:51REFLECTION HOW THE CAUCUSES FEEL
- 16:54ABOUT THIS REQUEST.
- 16:55SEEMS LIKE THERE'S GOING TO BE
- 16:58SKEPTICISM ABOUT EXACTLY THE
- 17:00AMOUNT OF THE REQUEST.
- 17:03AND YOUR INITIAL QUESTION,
- 17:04RENEE, WAS VERY IMPORTANT AND
- 17:07I'M NOT SURE I HEARD OF
- 17:09SPECIFICS WHAT IS THAT MONEY
- 17:10GOING TO GO TO?
- 17:13BECAUSE THERE IS A NEED IN MY
- 17:16OPINION TO QUIT FOCUSING
- 17:19EXCLUSIVELY ON HOW MUCH WE'RE
- 17:21SPENDING ON EDUCATION, TO WHAT
- 17:23IS THAT EDUCATION DOLLAR GOING
- 17:26TOWARDS?
- 17:26WHAT IS IT THAT WE'RE SPENDING
- 17:29ON?
- 17:30WHAT STRATEGIES ARE WE ADOPTING
- 17:32TO ENSURE THE KIDS ARE GETTING
- 17:34INSTRUCTED PROPERLY IN THE
- 17:35CLASSROOM AND THERE NEEDS TO BE
- 17:37MORE SCRUTINY ON THAT QUESTION
- 17:39AND MORE PRECISE ANSWERS
- 17:41PROVIDED.
- 17:42>> Renee: Mr. LAFONTAINE YOU
- 17:44ARE A CHARTER SCHOOL ADVOCATE
- 17:45AND THE SECOND PART OF OUR
- 17:47CONVERSATION ABOUT THE KENTUCKY
- 17:49SUPREME COURT WHO HEARD
- 17:51ARGUMENTS ABOUT THAT AND PERHAPS
- 17:53THERE WILL BE A RULING ON
- 17:55CHARTER SCHOOL FUNDING.
- 17:56WHEN YOU HEAR WHAT EDUCATION
- 17:59ADVOCATES ARE PROPOSING, WHAT DO
- 18:01YOU THINK?
- 18:02>> YES, SO I PICKED UP ON Dr.
- 18:05CALDWELL'S COMMENTS ABOUT
- 18:06TEACHER PAY AND CERTAINLY
- 18:08TEACHERS SHOULD BE REWARDED FOR
- 18:10THE GREAT JOB THEY DO IN THEIR
- 18:12CLASSROOMS.
- 18:13COMPENSATION GOES IN MANY
- 18:14DIFFERENT WAYS.
- 18:16SOMETHING THAT WE'VE INNOVATED
- 18:18AT OUR SCHOOL IS TAKE THAT
- 18:19TEACHER INTO ACCOUNT AND CREATE
- 18:22A SYSTEM THAT SUPPORTS THEM.
- 18:24WE START THAT WITH SMALL CLASS
- 18:27SIZES.
- 18:27OUR CLASS SIZES ARE TWO-THIRDS
- 18:28OF THE STATE REQUIREMENT.
- 18:31WE GIVE THEM A FULL PLANNING
- 18:33DAY.
- 18:34NOT JUST SOME PLANNING TIME OR
- 18:36PLANNING BLOCK BEAUTIFUL
- 18:37PLANNING DAY IN THEIR WEEK THEY
- 18:40WORK FOUR OR FIVE DAYS SO THEY
- 18:42DON'T TAKE WORK HOME TO TRY TO
- 18:45SUPPORT OUR STAFF.
- 18:45IT IS AN EMOTIONALLY CHALLENGING
- 18:48JOB AND I WORK CLOSELY WITH THE
- 18:50TEACHERS ON A DAILY BASIS.
- 18:52AND THE COMPENSATION IS
- 18:53CERTAINLY AN IMPORTANT PART OF
- 18:54THAT BUT THERE'S THINGS WE CAN
- 18:56DO IN THE CLASSROOM THAT ARE
- 18:58INNOVATIVE THAT WILL SUPPORT THE
- 18:59TEACHERS TO SEE THAT THEIR JOB
- 19:02AND HELP STUDENTS SUCCEED IN
- 19:04THEIR COURSE WORK.
- 19:06>> Renee: TELL US ABOUT YOUR
- 19:06SCHOOL.
- 19:07IT IS A PRIVATE SCHOOL.
- 19:08>> WE ARE A PRIVATE SCHOOL
- 19:10MADISON COUNTY IN OUR 15TH YEAR.
- 19:12I GAINED A DEGREE FROM EKU AND
- 19:16MASTERS DEGREE AND I TAUGHT FOR
- 19:18A COUPLE YEARS IN LOCAL SCHOOLS.
- 19:20AND THEN A DEPLOYMENT TO
- 19:23AFGHANISTAN BROKE MY TEACHING
- 19:24SERVICE AND I DECIDED TO OPEN A
- 19:26PRE-K WITH WIFE AND FRIENDS AND
- 19:28WE'RE GROWN A GRADE AND CAPPED
- 19:30AT FIFTH GRADE AND PILOTING
- 19:33SIXTH GRADE STUFF RIGHT NOW.
- 19:34AND WE SERVE ABOUT 175 STUDENTS
- 19:37THE THAT LOCATION.
- 19:38AND PRESCHOOL AND CHILDCARE, AND
- 19:41WE DO NATURE SCHOOLS ONE IN
- 19:43LEXINGTON AND ONE IN MADISON
- 19:44COUNTY.
- 19:45WE SERVE ABOUT 600 FAMILIES IN
- 19:47THE MAD TON COUNTY AREA.
- 19:49AND WE SEEK TO INNOVATE AND BE
- 19:51AT THE TIP OF THE SPEAR WHEN IT
- 19:53COMES TO BEST PRACTICES AND IT
- 19:55IS A FUN SETTING TO DO THAT AS
- 19:58AN EDUCATOR THAT IS ALL I WANTED
- 20:00TO BE ALWAYS IN MY LIFE AND TO
- 20:02BE ABLE TO DO THAT IN MY OWN
- 20:05LABORATORY WITH LIKE MINDED
- 20:06PEOPLE AND ONE DAY WE CAN EXPAND
- 20:09THAT WORK AND TO SERVE MORE
- 20:11FAMILIES.
- 20:12>> Renee: AND THE EDUCATIONAL
- 20:12OUTCOMES ARE THE STUDENTS HIGH
- 20:15PERFORMING?
- 20:15>> WE DON'T PARTICIPATE IN STATE
- 20:17TESTING.
- 20:17>> Renee: HOW DO YOU KNOW?
- 20:18>> BY OUR INNER METRICS WE FEEL
- 20:21THEY ARE SUCCESSFUL.
- 20:23IF THE PARENTS DO NOT FEEL THE
- 20:25CHILDREN ARE SUCCESSFUL THEY
- 20:26HAVE THE OPTION TO LEAVE AND
- 20:28THEY CAN EXERCISE THAT OPTION
- 20:30FOR ONE REASON OR ANOTHER.
- 20:32I THINK OUR PARENTS ARE
- 20:33SATISFIED BECAUSE THEY OPT INTO
- 20:35OUR SYSTEM.
- 20:35THEY MAKE AN INVESTMENT.
- 20:39>> Renee: WE GOT A CHANCE TO
- 20:41CATCH UP WITH THINK TANK FOLKS
- 20:43BOTH FROM DIFFERENT SIDES OF THE
- 20:46IDEOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVE.
- 20:46WE HAVE JASON BAILEY FROM THE
- 20:49KENTUCKY CENTER FOR ECONOMIC
- 20:50POLICY AND JIM WATERS FOR THE
- 20:54BLUEGRASS SOLUTIONS HOW MUCH
- 20:56MONEY SHOULD GO TO PUBLIC
- 20:57SCHOOLS AND IF $718 MILLION ASK
- 21:00IS ON POINT?
- 21:01>> STATE LAWMAKERS CUT PUBLIC
- 21:04SPENDING WHEN THE 2008 RECESSION
- 21:07HIT.
- 21:07PUBLIC EDUCATION FUNDING HAS NOT
- 21:09REBOUNDED SINCE THEN SAYS JASON
- 21:12BAILEY IT.
- 21:13WILL COST ABOUT 1.3 BILLION TO
- 21:16GET BACK TO THE LEVEL OF FUNDING
- 21:18WE HAD BACK THEN.
- 21:20SO WE NEED TO FIGURE OUT WHERE
- 21:22WE CAN START.
- 21:23AND THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY HAS
- 21:26CLEARLY IDENTIFIED THAT IT COULD
- 21:29SPEND $718 MILLION ON REDUCING
- 21:32THE INCOME TAX.
- 21:33THEY'VE DONE IT THREE TIMES NOW
- 21:34JUST IN THE LAST FEW YEARS.
- 21:37SO IF $718 MILLION CAN GO FOR
- 21:40TAX CUTS, THROUGH THREE ROUNDS
- 21:43NOW THEN SURELY ONE ROUND OF THE
- 21:45SAME AMOUNT OF MONEY COULD GO
- 21:46INTO OUR SCHOOLS.
- 21:47>> BAILEY POINTS TO SPECIFIC
- 21:50FUNDING THAT DISAPPEARED IN
- 21:51RECENT YEARS.
- 21:51>> AND THERE'S EARMARKED ITEMS
- 21:54LIKE FUNDING FOR TEXTBOOKS AND
- 21:57FUNDING FOR PROFESSIONAL
- 21:58DEVELOPMENT THAT GOT ZEROED OUT.
- 21:59>> AND HE SAYS THE STATE IS NOT
- 22:02MEETING ITS STATUTORY OBLIGATION
- 22:05TO FULLY FUND TRANSPORTATION.
- 22:07>> THE COST OF TRANSPORTATION
- 22:09HAS GONE WAY UP IT'S MORE
- 22:11EXPENSIVE TO BUY A BUS NOW AND
- 22:13HARDER TO ATTRACT AND RETAIN BUS
- 22:16DRIVERS WHO DON'T MAKE A LOT OF
- 22:18MONEY THEY CAN MAKE MORE DRIVING
- 22:21FOR U.P.S. OR THE PRIVATE
- 22:22SECTOR.
- 22:23IF WE CAN'T GET KIDS TO AND FROM
- 22:25SCHOOL THEN WE CAN'T HAVE
- 22:27SCHOOLS.
- 22:27>> MUCH OF THE MONEY DISTRICTS
- 22:30RECEIVE IS FLEXIBLE AND LOCAL
- 22:32SUPERINTENDENTS AND SCHOOL
- 22:33BOARDS TO SET THEIR PRIORITIES
- 22:35SAYS JIM WATERS OF THE BLUEGRASS
- 22:37INSTITUTE FOR PUBLIC POLICY
- 22:39SOLUTIONS.
- 22:39>> THE LOCAL DISTRICTS HAVE
- 22:43GOTTEN PRETTY MUCH LUMP SUMS OF
- 22:46FUNDING TO DO WHAT THEY WISH TO
- 22:47DO WITH.
- 22:48AND THAT'S, I THINK, AN ATTEMPT
- 22:51BY LAWMAKERS TO SAY THE LOCAL
- 22:53DISTRICTS YOU'RE THE BEST
- 22:55DETERMINER OF WHAT IS NEEDED IN
- 22:58YOUR DISTRICT.
- 22:59YOU ARE THE BEST ONES TO DECIDE
- 23:01DO YOU NEED TO GIVE TEACHERS A
- 23:03RAISE?
- 23:04DO YOU NEED CAPITAL PROJECTS?
- 23:06DO YOU NEED OTHER PROGRAMS?
- 23:08>> THE RECENT KY POLICY REPORT
- 23:11CALLS FOR FUNDING TO HIRE MORE
- 23:13STAFF.
- 23:14SPECIFICALLY TEACHERS, BUS
- 23:16DRIVERS AND COUNSELORS.
- 23:18WATERS WORRIES DISTRICTS SPEND
- 23:19TOO MUCH ON POSITIONS OUTSIDE
- 23:21THE CLASSROOM.
- 23:22>> WE'VE HAD A TREMENDOUS
- 23:24INCREASE IN THE CENTRAL OFFICE
- 23:27BUREAUCRACY AND PAYING
- 23:29NONTEACHING PERSONNEL WHAT KIND
- 23:31OF RETURN ON INVESTMENT DO MOST
- 23:34TAXPAYERS THINK THAT IS?
- 23:35>> WATERS CALLS FOR TRANSPARENCY
- 23:38AND ACCOUNTABILITY.
- 23:39HE POINTS TO FAYETTE COUNTY
- 23:40PUBLIC SCHOOLS, WHICH HAS
- 23:43DEPLETED ITS CONTINGENCY
- 23:45ACCOUNT.
- 23:45>> BEFORE WE SPEND MORE DOLLARS
- 23:47ON K-12 EDUCATION IN KENTUCKY,
- 23:49WE NEED MORE ACCOUNTABILITY ON
- 23:50WHERE THE DOLLARS HAVE GONE.
- 23:53>> FOR "KENTUCKY TONIGHT" I'M
- 23:55JUNE LEFFLER.
- 23:56>> Renee: THANK YOU.
- 23:57I WANT TO PICK UP THERE.
- 23:59AS WE SPEAK RIGHT NOW, FAYETTE
- 24:01COUNTY THE SCHOOL BOARD IS
- 24:02MEETING PERHAPS THEY HAVE
- 24:03WRAPPED UP AT THE TIME OF OUR
- 24:05BROADCAST.
- 24:05BUT THEY WERE MEETING TO DEAL
- 24:07WITH THE BUDGET DEFICIT OF $16
- 24:10MILLION SHORTFALL AND THERE'S
- 24:12BEEN CONVERSATION TODAY IN THE
- 24:13SOCIAL MEDIA SPACE ABOUT THAT.
- 24:14WE KNOW THAT THERE HAVE BEEN
- 24:16SOME CALLS BY SOME HIGH RANKING
- 24:19STATE LAWMAKERS FOR THE
- 24:21RESIGNATION OF THE FAYETTE
- 24:22COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 24:23SUPERINTENDENT, Dr. DEMETRUS
- 24:24LIGGINS.
- 24:25AND THE BOARD CHAIR TYLER
- 24:27MURPHY.
- 24:28WITHOUT GOING INTO DETAILS
- 24:30BECAUSE WE ARE NOT IN THE BOARD
- 24:31MEETING TO KNOW WHAT IS BEING
- 24:33DONE TO DEAL WITH THAT
- 24:35SHORTFALL, SUPERINTENDENT
- 24:36CLAYTON, WHAT KIND OF MESSAGE
- 24:38DOES IT SEND WHEN STATE
- 24:40LAWMAKERS CALL FOR THE
- 24:41RESIGNATION OF A DISTRICT LEVEL
- 24:43SUPERINTENDENT AND THE BOARD
- 24:44CHAIR?
- 24:45>> WELL, I THINK FIRST OF ALL IT
- 24:48SPEAKS TO THE TIMES WE'RE IN.
- 24:50FOR LONG TIME, EDUCATION WAS
- 24:54NONPARTISAN.
- 24:55AND THAT HAS COME AND GONE SO IT
- 24:58DOESN'T SURPRISE ME THAT
- 24:59LAWMAKERS WOULD WEIGH-IN.
- 25:01I THINK REALLY WHAT IS MOST
- 25:03IMPORTANT IS THE LENS YOU ARE
- 25:04LOOKING AT WHEN YOU DISCUSS THE
- 25:07BUDGET, YOU DISCUSS HOW FUNDING
- 25:09HAS NOT KEPT UP.
- 25:10AND REALLY WHAT WE TRY TO FOCUS
- 25:13IN ON ARE THE FACTS AND REALITY
- 25:15IS, WE'RE NOW LEANING MORE
- 25:19HEAVILY ON OUR LOCAL TAXPAYERS
- 25:22FOR ENSURING THAT PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 25:25HAVE THE FUNDING NECESSARY TO
- 25:28NOT JUST ONLY TRANSPORT STUDENTS
- 25:30BUT ENSURE THEIR SUCCESS.
- 25:31I LOOK AT OUR LOCAL SITUATION
- 25:33JUST IN THE LAST DECADE OUR
- 25:35SPECIAL EDUCATION FUNDING HAS
- 25:38MORE THAN DOUBLED.
- 25:39AND NONE OF THAT IS
- 25:41ADMINISTRATIVE.
- 25:42IT'S ALL INTO THE CLASSROOMS.
- 25:44SO THE NEEDS THAT WE SEE FROM
- 25:45OUR STUDENTS ARE VASTLY GREATER
- 25:49THAN WHAT WE'VE EXPERIENCED IN
- 25:51THE PAST.
- 25:51I LOOK AT EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 25:55EDUCATION FOR A LONGTIME IT WAS
- 25:57NOT FUNDED AT THE STATE LEVEL.
- 26:00WE'VE SEEN PROGRESS THERE.
- 26:01WE ARE SPENDING $2.2 MILLION OUT
- 26:04OF OUR GENERAL FUND ALL ON THE
- 26:06BACKS OF OUR LOCAL TAXPAYERS
- 26:07PART OF THAT 24 MILLION.
- 26:09TALK ABOUT TRANSPORTATION, THAT
- 26:11IS AN INEQUITABLE EXPENSE ON
- 26:14EVERY DISTRICT.
- 26:14WE HAVE 550 SQUARE MILES.
- 26:18WE HAVE LED 24 MILLION OVER THE
- 26:20LAST DECADE OUT OF OUR GENERAL
- 26:22FUND TO OFFSET WHAT IS BY
- 26:25STATUTE SUPPOSED TO BE 100%
- 26:27COVERED AT THE STATE LEVEL.
- 26:29WEIGH DID SEE SOME INCREASES
- 26:31THIS PAST YEAR AT 81% TO THE
- 26:34TUNE NOW WE'VE GONE NORTH OF 4
- 26:37MILLION TO 2.5 MILLION OUT OF
- 26:39OUR GENERAL FUND AGAIN ON THE
- 26:42BACKS OF OUR LOCAL TAXPAYERS.
- 26:43WE DON'T HAVE COMMUNITIES ACROSS
- 26:45THE COMMONWEALTH THAT CAN
- 26:47CONTINUE TO ABSORB THAT HIT.
- 26:48WE HAVE BEEN FORTUNATE.
- 26:50IT'S BEEN A CHALLENGE.
- 26:52BUT IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE
- 26:54RECOGNIZE THE EXPECTSES HAVE
- 26:56GONE UP SIGNIFICANTLY.
- 26:57AND THIS RECORD FUNDING TAKES
- 26:59INTO ACCOUNT DECADES OF
- 27:01UNDERFUNDING A VIABLE PENSION.
- 27:03AND I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT FOR
- 27:05OUR VIEWERS TO KNOW THAT TRS IS
- 27:07ONE OF THE STRONGEST PENSION
- 27:09SYSTEMS IN AMERICA.
- 27:10>> Renee: THE TEACHER RETIRE.
- 27:12IT IS A FACT.
- 27:13SO STRONG THAT IT'S BEEN ABLE TO
- 27:16WITHSTAND TWO DECADES PLUS OF
- 27:18UNDERFUNDING UNTIL OUR MOST
- 27:20RECENT LEGISLATORS DID STEP IN
- 27:22AND WE'RE APPRECIATIVE VERY
- 27:24THANKFUL.
- 27:25THE COMMENT ABOUT NEEDING MORE,
- 27:27WELL, THE REALITY IS WE CAN'T
- 27:29GET BACK TO 2008.
- 27:31AND IN 2008 IT WASN'T ADEQUATE.
- 27:33AND NOW WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE
- 27:36INCREASED NEEDS.
- 27:36I WILL GIVE YOU ANOTHER EXAMPLE.
- 27:39ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNERS.
- 27:40EVERY STUDENT IS DIFFERENT TO
- 27:42EDUCATE IN TERMS OF EXPENSE.
- 27:44IT'S MUCH MORE EXPENSIVE TO
- 27:48EDUCATE OUR SPECIAL POPULATIONS.
- 27:50SOME DISTRICTS HAVE A
- 27:51SIGNIFICANT NUMBER, SOME HAVE
- 27:53VERY FEW AND THAT IS WHY IT'S SO
- 27:55IMPORTANT TO LOOK AT WHERE THE
- 27:57NEED IS AND THEN COMING TOGETHER
- 28:00AS A GROUP.
- 28:01BECAUSE HERE IS THE REALITY FOR
- 28:02ALL OF US.
- 28:03WE'RE GOING TO HAVE PUBLIC
- 28:04SCHOOLS.
- 28:05THEY ARE ALWAYS GOING TO BE
- 28:06HERE.
- 28:06THEY ARE GOING TO GET BETTER OR
- 28:08THEY ARE GOING TO GET WORSE AND
- 28:10IT'S GOING TO DEPEND ON US AS AN
- 28:13ENTIRE COMMUNITY AND ENTIRE
- 28:16COMMONWEALTH TO VALUE PUBLIC
- 28:18SCHOOLS.
- 28:18IT'S GREAT FOR ALL KIDS.
- 28:20WE DON'T EDUCATE ALL STUDENTS
- 28:22BUT THERE IS A CERTAIN
- 28:24PERCENTAGE OF OUR STUDENTS IF
- 28:25NOT FOR US THERE WOULD BE NO
- 28:27ONE, NO HOME SCHOOL, NO PRIVATE
- 28:29SCHOOL THERE TO EDUCATE THE
- 28:31STUDENTS AND GIVE THEM THE SAME
- 28:33OPPORTUNITY THAT WE'VE ALL BEEN
- 28:35AFFORDED.
- 28:35AND THAT IS WHERE OUR PASSION
- 28:37COMES IN FROM PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 28:39ADVOCATES WE JUST WANT THE
- 28:41RESOURCES AVAILABLE OKAY TO
- 28:43ENSURE WE CAN MEET THE NEEDS OF
- 28:45OUR STUDENTS AND WE CAN START
- 28:47TALKING ABOUT CHARTER SCHOOLS
- 28:49AND TALKING ABOUT MORE TAX CUTS.
- 28:50BUT UNTIL WE ENSURE THAT WE HAVE
- 28:53WHAT IS NECESSARY, IT'S GOING TO
- 28:54BE A CONTINUING THEME FROM ALL
- 28:57EDUCATORS WHO SEE DAY IN AND DAY
- 28:59OUT WHAT IS HAPPENING IN OUR
- 29:01SCHOOLS.
- 29:02>> Renee: Dr. CALDWELL ABOUT A
- 29:03POINT WE HEARD JIM WATERS FROM
- 29:06THE BLUEGRASS INSTITUTE FOR
- 29:08PUBLIC POLICY SOLUTIONS SAY
- 29:10ABOUT THE PAYING NONTEACHER
- 29:12PERSONNEL.
- 29:13AND THERE IS A COMMON THREAD OR
- 29:16NARRATIVE THAT WE HEAR ABOUT
- 29:18BLOATED ADMINISTRATIVE SALARIES.
- 29:20PARTICULARLY IN YOUR TWO LARGEST
- 29:23SCHOOL DISTRICTS JEFFERSON
- 29:24COUNTY AND FAYETTE COUNTY.
- 29:25SPEAK TO US ABOUT THAT AND IS
- 29:27THAT A TRUE ASSESSMENT THAT
- 29:30NONTEACHING PERSONNEL ARE
- 29:32COMPENSATED AT HIGHER
- 29:34DISPROPORTIONATE LEVELS THAN THE
- 29:36CERTIFIED TEACHING PERSONNEL.
- 29:37>> THANK YOU FOR THAT QUESTION.
- 29:39THAT IS ACTUALLY A TOPIC WE
- 29:40LOOKED AT LAST YEAR AND AGAIN
- 29:42THIS YEAR, MOST RECENTLY BECAUSE
- 29:44WE HEAR THAT QUITE A BIT.
- 29:45BUT WHEN YOU GO BACK TO THE VERY
- 29:49OEA DATA THAT --
- 29:51>> Renee: OFFICE OF EDUCATIONAL
- 29:53ACCOUNTABILITY.
- 29:53>> OFFICE OF EDUCATIONAL
- 29:55ACCOUNTABILITY YOU DON'T SEE
- 29:57THOSE TYPES OF NUMBERS.
- 29:59OFTEN WHAT HAPPENS IS IF I'M NOT
- 30:01A CLASSROOM TEACHER OR A DON'T
- 30:03HAVE A SPECIFIC SCHOOL FUNCTION
- 30:06PERHAPS I'M SERVING ALL OF THE
- 30:09SCHOOLS BUT, YET I'M TAGGED WITH
- 30:10MAYBE A DISTRICT OFFICE LEVEL
- 30:13POSITION, BUT I TRULY AM SERVING
- 30:15ALL CHILDREN WITHIN THE DISTRICT
- 30:17OR I MIGHT BE ALLOCATED TO ONE,
- 30:19TWO OR THREE SCHOOLS, THESE
- 30:22NUMBERS CAN OFTEN GET CONFUSING.
- 30:24BUT THE BLOAT IS JUST NOT THERE.
- 30:26WE ARE NOT SEEING IT IN THE
- 30:27NUMBERS.
- 30:28WE ARE NOT SEEING IT WHEN WE
- 30:30TALK WITH OUR DISTRICTS SKRAOS
- 30:33THE --
- 30:33ACROSS THE STATE.
- 30:34WE CAN LOOK AT DISTRIBUTES ON
- 30:36THE SMALLER SIDE WHERE THE
- 30:38SUPERINTENDENTS ARE DRIVING
- 30:39SCHOOL BUSES AND COVERING
- 30:41CLASSROOMS ON A REGULAR BASIS AS
- 30:43WELL ASPIRINS.
- 30:45IT'S ALL RESOURCES ALL HANDS ON
- 30:47DECK.
- 30:47>> Renee: WHAT DO YOU THINK
- 30:49ABOUT THAT?
- 30:50>> IF YOU HAVE THE SCHOOL
- 30:51DISTRICT WHERE THE
- 30:52SUPERINTENDENT IS DRIVING A
- 30:54SCHOOL BUS, THERE IS A SERIOUS
- 30:57QUESTION OF THE VIABILITY OF
- 30:58THAT SCHOOL DISTRICT.
- 30:59WE DO HAVE 173, 175 SCHOOL
- 31:04DISTRICTS.
- 31:05>> Renee: 171.
- 31:05>> IN A STATE WITH 120 COUNTIES.
- 31:09BUT, RENEE, THERE'S ACTUALLY A
- 31:13STRONG BODY OF RESEARCH FROM
- 31:17STANFORD UNIVERSITY, THAT TEASES
- 31:19OUT THIS QUESTION OF WHETHER OR
- 31:21NOT THERE IS A CLEAR CAUSAL
- 31:25RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN INCREASING
- 31:27FUNDING FOR EDUCATION AND THAT
- 31:31NECESSARILY LEADING TO HIGHER
- 31:33STUDENT OUTCOMES.
- 31:35WE'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT THE
- 31:37BASE.
- 31:38CLEARLY YOU HAVE TO HAVE A
- 31:41FOUNDATIONAL LEVEL OF FUNDING TO
- 31:44ENSURE THAT OUR SCHOOL SYSTEMS
- 31:48CAN OPERATE AND PROVIDE A
- 31:51SETTING THAT ALLOWS FOR TEACHING
- 31:54AND EDUCATION TO OCCUR.
- 31:56BUT I WANT TO GET BACK TO THIS
- 31:59POINT OF HOW FUNDS ARE SPENT IS
- 32:02ACTUALLY MORE CRITICAL THAN HOW
- 32:05MUCH IS SPENT.
- 32:07AND WE SEE THIS IN THE STATE OF
- 32:11KENTUCKY THROUGH LITERACY.
- 32:15KENTUCKY IS NOT ALONE.
- 32:18MOST STATES ARE FACED WITH THE
- 32:20FACT THAT A VERY SMALL NUMBER
- 32:23SMALL PERCENTAGE IN KENTUCKY
- 32:25IT'S THREE OUT OF 10 KENTUCKY
- 32:28STUDENTS CAN TEST PROFICIENTLY
- 32:32ON THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR
- 32:34EDUCATIONAL PROGRESS, NAEP FOR
- 32:39MINORITY STUDENTS THAT NUMBER IS
- 32:41MUCH LOWER.
- 32:44AND WHAT WE HAVE FOUND OR WHAT
- 32:46DID THE COURIER-JOURNAL FIND A
- 32:47COUPLE YEARS AGO WHEN THEY DID
- 32:49AN INVESTIGATION OF THE
- 32:53STRATEGIES BEHIND HOW TO TEACH A
- 32:55YOUNG CHILD TO READ.
- 32:57AND WHAT THEY DISCOVERED WAS
- 33:00THAT IT'S BECOMING CLEAR IT HAS
- 33:02BEEN CLEAR TO OTHER STATES LIKE
- 33:05MISSISSIPPI AND LOUISIANA,
- 33:08THAT'S GOOD OLD-FASHIONED
- 33:11PHONICS IS THE BEST WAY TO TEACH
- 33:15A CHILD HOW TO READ.
- 33:17THE STATE HAD BEEN CONTRACTING
- 33:19THROUGH THE UNIVERSITY OF
- 33:21KENTUCKY WITH AN ORGANIZATION
- 33:23THAT COLLABORATIVE CENTER FOR
- 33:25LITERACY, I BELIEVE, THAT WAS
- 33:27PROMOTING A MODEL CALLED READING
- 33:30RECOVERY, THAT SIMPLY WASN'T
- 33:32ADEQUATE.
- 33:33IT WASN'T CAPABLE OF SETTING THE
- 33:38BUILDING BLOCKS FOR A CHILD TO
- 33:40BE ABLE TO LEARN HOW TO READ AT
- 33:44GRADE LEVEL.
- 33:45AND THERE'S NO AMOUNT OF MONEY
- 33:47THAT COULD HAVE BEEN THROWN AT
- 33:49AS A MATTER OF FACT, HUNDREDS OF
- 33:51MILLIONS IF NOT BILLIONS OF
- 33:53DOLLARS HAD BEEN SPENT ON A
- 33:56STRATEGY THAT WAS INCAPABLE OF
- 33:58DELIVERING RESULTS.
- 34:01THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AFTER
- 34:05WORKING TO UNDERSTAND THE
- 34:07PROBLEM, HAS NOW BEGUN TO
- 34:10EMPHASIZE GOING BACK TO THE
- 34:12BASICS, GOING BACK TO PHONICS,
- 34:15AND THAT'S THE TYPE OF
- 34:17CONVERSATION THAT I THINK WE
- 34:19NEED TO HAVE ACROSS THE BOARD.
- 34:23WHICH IS WHERE ARE THESE DOLLARS
- 34:25GOING CURRENTLY?
- 34:26WHAT MODELS ARE BEING EMPLOYED
- 34:29TO REACH CHILDREN?
- 34:33AND BEFORE WE GET INTO A
- 34:35QUESTION OF MORE MONEY, LET'S
- 34:38FIGURE OUT WHAT IT IS THE MONEY
- 34:39IS CURRENTLY BEING SPENT ON, WHY
- 34:42IT'S TAKING SO LONG TO FIGURE
- 34:44OUT SOMETHING AS CRITICAL AS THE
- 34:48USE OF PHONICS AS OPPOSED TO A
- 34:51READING RECOVERY APPROACH, AND
- 34:54SEE IF WE CAN DRIVE RESULTS BY
- 34:57FOCUSING WHERE OUR MONEY IS
- 34:58SPENT, HOW IT IS SPENT, BUILD
- 35:01SOME CONFIDENCE AROUND THAT AND
- 35:04THEN PERHAPS AT SOME POINT WE DO
- 35:07SERIOUSLY BEGIN TO HAVE THE
- 35:08QUESTION OF IS MORE MONEY
- 35:11NECESSARY?
- 35:11OR CAN WE MAKE PROGRESS WITH THE
- 35:14CURRENT SET OF RESOURCES IN
- 35:16PLACE.
- 35:16>> Renee: AND WE KNOW THE
- 35:18KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY READ
- 35:19TO SUCCEED ACT AND WE HAVE DONE
- 35:22PROGRAMS ABOUT THAT THE SCIENCE
- 35:23OF READING WHICH IS THE PHONICS
- 35:26APPROACH HAS BEEN ADOPTED AND
- 35:27YOU HAVE TO TRAIN TEACHERS TO
- 35:29TEACH THAT WAY TO TEACH READING
- 35:31IN A WAY THAT THEY HAVE NOT BEEN
- 35:33DOING AND THAT WOULD REQUIRE
- 35:35RESOURCES AS WELL.
- 35:37IF YOU HAVE A WHOLE NEW
- 35:38MECHANICS OF HOW YOU ARE DOING
- 35:40IT, IT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT
- 35:42HAPPENS.
- 35:43THEY HAVE TO BE TRAINED HOW TO
- 35:44TEACH KIDS TO READ.
- 35:47Mr. LAFONTAINE TO YOU BEFORE
- 35:51WE TALK AND TIME GETS AWAY
- 35:53BEFORE WE TALK ABOUT CHARTER
- 35:55SCHOOLS WHEN YOU HEAR THE
- 35:57CONVERSATION ABOUT MORE MONEY,
- 36:00TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND
- 36:02HAVE A CONVERSATION ABOUT
- 36:03CHARTER SCHOOLS BEING PUBLIC
- 36:05CHARTER SCHOOLS, YOU KNOW, DO
- 36:06YOU THINK IT'S MONEY WELL SPENT?
- 36:08OR DO YOU THINK THAT PERHAPS YOU
- 36:11FOLKS LIKE YOU SHOULD GET A
- 36:13BIGGER PIECE OF THAT PIE?
- 36:14>> YEAH, LET ME START OFF BY
- 36:17SAYING I'M IN NO POSITION TO
- 36:20COMMENT WITH ANY KIND OF
- 36:22PROFICIENCY ABOUT HOW PUBLIC
- 36:23SCHOOL DISTRICTS SPEND THEIR
- 36:25MONEY.
- 36:26I'VE NEVER WORKED IN THOSE
- 36:27OFFICES AND I DON'T MANAGE THE
- 36:29BUDGETS.
- 36:30AS A SMALL BUSINESS PERSON WHO
- 36:32WORKS IN SCHOOLS WE HAVE TO
- 36:34STRETCH A DOLLAR INTO 10.
- 36:35WE HAVE TO THREAD THIS NEEDLE OF
- 36:37KEEPING OUR TUITION AS LOW AS
- 36:39POSSIBLE TO MAKE IT AS
- 36:42ACCESSIBLE AS POSSIBLE TO
- 36:43FAMILIES AND ALSO PAY OUR
- 36:44TEACHERS AS MUCH AS WE CAN AND
- 36:46CREATE THE ENVIRONMENT THAT THEM
- 36:47AND STUDENTS CAN SUCCEED IN.
- 36:49>> Renee: ARE YOUR SALARIES
- 36:51COMPETITIVE WITH THE COST OF
- 36:52LIVING?
- 36:52>> WE AIM FOR 90% OF OUR LOCAL
- 36:55SCHOOL DISTRICT.
- 36:56SO WE THINK THAT'S COMPETITIVE
- 36:58COMBINED WITH THE THINGS I
- 36:59MENTIONED LIKE SMALLER CLASS
- 37:01SIZES AND GENEROUS PLANNING
- 37:03TIME.
- 37:04BUT I KNOW WE HAVE TO MAKE
- 37:07PAYROLL.
- 37:07AND THAT IS A LOT OF PRESSURE.
- 37:09AND WE HAVE TO MEET OUR
- 37:12FINANCIAL OBLIGATIONS TO
- 37:14PERSONALLY.
- 37:14I AM A PERSON GUARANTOR ON MANY
- 37:19THINGS.
- 37:19AND IT IS A LOT OF PRESSURE THAT
- 37:21CREATES A LOT OF CREATIVE
- 37:23THINKING TO STRETCH THAT DOLLAR
- 37:24INTO 10.
- 37:26SOME OF THE PRESSURES I'M NOT
- 37:28TRYING TO SAY THAT OUR
- 37:30COUNTERPARTS IN THE PUBLIC
- 37:31SCHOOLS DO NOT FACE THE
- 37:33PRESSURES.
- 37:33NOT AT ALL.
- 37:34BUT I CAN SPEAK TO THE WAY THE
- 37:37PRESSURES CREATE CREATIVE
- 37:38SOLUTIONS FOR US TO STRETCH A
- 37:40DOLLAR INTO 10.
- 37:41>> Renee: WE HAVE VIEWER
- 37:42COMMENTS THAT WE'LL SHARE.
- 37:44THIS FROM AN UNNAMED VIEWER
- 37:46TEACHER VACANCIES ARE A HUGE
- 37:48PROBLEM ESPECIALLY IN MATH AND
- 37:50SCIENCE THEY ARE FILLED WITH
- 37:53PERMANENT SUBSTITUTES I'VE GIVEN
- 37:54UP MY PLANNING PERIOD TO TEACH
- 37:56AN EXTRA CLASS.
- 37:57TEACHERS NEED TO EARN A LIVING
- 37:59WAGE SO THEY DON'T HAVE TO TAKE
- 38:02A SECOND JOB AND YOU MENTIONED
- 38:04THIS.
- 38:05SUPERINTENDENT CLAYTON ANYTHING
- 38:06TO ADD?
- 38:06>> AGAIN, I THINK IT IS A MATTER
- 38:08OF THE LENS YOU ARE LOOKING AT.
- 38:10AND NUMBER OF QUESTIONS WE HAVE
- 38:11TO ASK OURSELVES...
- 38:13IS THE TEACHING PROFESSION A
- 38:16MIDDLE CLASS PROFESSION?
- 38:18FOR IT'S IT'S YES OR NO.
- 38:20AND IF THE ANSWER IS YES YOU
- 38:21HAVE TO ASK YOURSELF IS THE
- 38:23PROFESSION BEING COMPENSATED
- 38:26COMMENSURATE WITH THE MIDDLE
- 38:28CLASS.
- 38:29>> Renee: IN WARREN COUNTY DO
- 38:30YOU FEEL IT IS A MIDDLE CLASS
- 38:32PROFESSION?
- 38:32>> I THINK IT IS AN UPPER CLASS
- 38:35PROFESSION BUT FOR THE SAKE OF
- 38:37ANALOGY LET'S CALL IT MIDDLE
- 38:39CLASS PROFESSION AND THE NEXT
- 38:41QUESTION IS SHOULD IT BE
- 38:44COMPLICATED COMMENSURATE WITH
- 38:45THAT?
- 38:45AND AGAIN THAT ANSWER WOULD BE
- 38:47YES BUT IN REALITY IT'S NOT AND
- 38:49WE FOR THAT.
- 38:50LOOK AT THE PUBLIC SERVICE
- 38:53POSITIONS NOW, LAW ENFORCEMENT.
- 38:55A DECADE AGO LAW ENFORCEMENT
- 38:58EDUCATION PROFESSION
- 38:59COMMENSURATE NOW THE GAP IS
- 39:00SIGNIFICANT.
- 39:01WHY IS THAT?
- 39:01THERE WAS A CRUNCH AND WHEN IT
- 39:03COMES TO PUBLIC SAFETY OUR
- 39:05COMMUNITIES DEMANDED THAT IT BE
- 39:07ADDRESSED AND OUR GOVERNOR DID.
- 39:09AND THEY DESERVE IT AND THEY
- 39:11DESERVE MORE.
- 39:11BUT, AGAIN, YOU ARE SEEING THAT
- 39:13GAP.
- 39:13YOU HAVE TO ASK YOURSELF DO WE
- 39:15WANT OUR TEACHERS WORKING A
- 39:18SECOND JOB DURING THE SKAL YEAR?
- 39:21I'M NOT TALKING ABOUT DURING THE
- 39:23SUMMER WHEN THEY HAVE SIX TO
- 39:24EIGHT WEEKS WHERE THEY ARE NOT
- 39:26REQUIRED TO BE IN SCHOOL WORKING
- 39:28WITH STUDENTS.
- 39:28ALTHOUGH MANY OF OUR BEST AND
- 39:31BRIGHTEST CONTINUE TO PLAN AND
- 39:33PREPARE FOR THE UPCOMING SCHOOL
- 39:35YEAR.
- 39:36AND, AGAIN, A SIMPLE QUESTION:
- 39:38DO WE THINK THAT IS APPROPRIATE?
- 39:39WHEN WE TALK ABOUT THE
- 39:41ACHIEVEMENT IT'S ALSO IMPORTANT
- 39:42TO ASK YOURSELF ARE WE TALKING
- 39:45ABOUT THE ACHIEVEMENT IN
- 39:46CATCHING UP?
- 39:47OR TALKING ABOUT THE ACHIEVEMENT
- 39:49THAT IS COMMENSURATE WITH THE
- 39:50PEERS.
- 39:51WHEN THE REALITY IS MORE THAN
- 39:53HALF OUR STUDENTS COME TO US NOT
- 39:55PREPARED FOR SCHOOL.
- 39:56LIVING IN ONE OF THE HIGHEST
- 39:58POVERTY STATES ACROSS THE
- 39:59COUNTRY WHAT RESULTS WOULD YOU
- 40:02EXPECT?
- 40:03GIVEN THAT THAT'S THE
- 40:04INGREDIENTS AND THE REALITY IS
- 40:06WE DO A TREMENDOUS JOB ACROSS
- 40:08THIS COMMONWEALTH IN ENSURING
- 40:11THAT STUDENTS CONTINUE TO
- 40:12PROGRESS BUT OUR CHALLENGE AND
- 40:13WE DON'T HAVE THE ANSWER TO THIS
- 40:15IS HOW DO WE MOVE A STUDENT THAT
- 40:17IS TWO, THREE, GRADE LEVELS
- 40:20BEHIND COMMENSURATE WITH YOUR
- 40:21SON OR DAUGHTER?
- 40:22THAT IS WHAT WE TRY TO DO.
- 40:23WHEN I LOOK AT JUST THE MOST
- 40:25RECENT EXPENSES WITH OUR SPECIAL
- 40:27EDUCATION POPULATION, THEY ARE
- 40:30HIGH NEEDS.
- 40:31IT IS A SIGNIFICANT EXPENSE TO
- 40:33ENSURE THAT THOSE STUDENTS HAVE
- 40:35THE RESOURCES AND THE
- 40:37OPPORTUNITIES THAT WE WOULD WANT
- 40:39IF THAT WAS OUR SON OR DAUGHTER.
- 40:41SCHOOL DISTRICTS ACROSS THE
- 40:43COMMONWEALTH ARE FINDING WAYS TO
- 40:45TRY TO MITIGATE THOSE FUNDING
- 40:48CHALLENGES.
- 40:49BUT IN SOME CASES IT'S
- 40:51INSURMOUNTABLE FOR MANY
- 40:53DISTRICTS AND THAT IS WHO WE
- 40:55NEED TO BE THINKING ABOUT ARE
- 40:56THE STUDENTS LEFT BEHIND IF WE
- 40:58DON'T INVEST IN EDUCATION AND
- 40:59THE STATISTICS ARE CLEAR.
- 41:01YOU INVEST NOW OR LATER.
- 41:02WHAT WE'RE ADVOCATING FOR IS
- 41:05LET'S INVEST NOW.
- 41:06EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION THERE
- 41:07IS NOBODY THAT DISPUTES THAT
- 41:10THAT IS NOT FULLY FUNDED IN OUR
- 41:12COMMONWEALTH THAT IS THE
- 41:13QUESTION RIGHT THERE.
- 41:14I WILL SAY IT ONE MORE TIME.
- 41:16NO ONE IS IN DISPUTE HOW
- 41:18IMPORTANT THAT IS.
- 41:20BUT, YET, WE'RE NOT RECOGNIZING
- 41:22IT AS A COMMONWEALTH.
- 41:23IT IS A PROBLEM.
- 41:26>> Renee: I WONDER, THOUGH, IS
- 41:28EVERYBODY IN A CONSENSUS ABOUT
- 41:30THE IMPORTANCE OF EARLY
- 41:31LEARNING?
- 41:32AND THE PAY FORS FOR IT WHO
- 41:34SHOULD PAY FOR IT AND HOW MUCH?
- 41:35>> WELL, I THINK EVERYBODY
- 41:38RECOGNIZES THERE ARE BENEFITS TO
- 41:40HIGH QUALITY EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 41:42EDUCATION FOR THOSE STUDENTS WHO
- 41:44CAN ACCESS IT, I THINK IN TERMS
- 41:48OF HOW TO GO ABOUT THAT, AND THE
- 41:52AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT HAS IN
- 41:55PREVIOUS SESSIONS BEEN PROPOSED
- 41:57FOR THAT PURPOSE IS WORTHY OF
- 42:01DEBATE.
- 42:02BUT I WILL SAY THAT WITH GUS AND
- 42:05OTHERS, I PARTICIPATED IN THE
- 42:08KENTUCKY CHAMBERS PROCESS TO
- 42:09LOOK AT EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 42:11EDUCATION HAD INPUT ON THE
- 42:13DISCUSSION AND THE REPORT.
- 42:16THAT SEEMED TO FIND IT SOUGHT
- 42:21AND I BELIEVE FOUND SOME REALLY
- 42:23MORE PRACTICAL STEPS THAT CAN BE
- 42:27TAKEN THAT CAN IMPROVE THAT
- 42:29ECOSYSTEM IN A WAY THAT IS
- 42:33TARGETED TOWARDS SEEING
- 42:34MEANINGFUL RESULTS.
- 42:36BUT ALSO, NOT ESSENTIALLY
- 42:39CREATING A STATE SUBSIDIZED
- 42:41SYSTEM FOR EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 42:43EDUCATION.
- 42:45SO IF THE CONVERSATION IS
- 42:47TARGETED, IT'S FOCUSED, WE ARE
- 42:50WORKING WITH PARTNERS LIKE GUS'
- 42:52ORGANIZATION AND OTHER
- 42:54ORGANIZATIONS THROUGHOUT THE
- 42:55STATE THAT CAN DELIVER QUALITY
- 43:00INPUTS FOR THOSE YOUNG CHILDREN,
- 43:03I'VE NEVER DISPUTED THE VALUE OF
- 43:05IT.
- 43:06EXACTLY HOW TO GO ABOUT IT AND
- 43:08WHAT THE EXPENSE LOOKS LIKE HAS
- 43:10BEEN WORTHY OF DEBATE.
- 43:12AND WE'VE BEEN POUD TO RAISE
- 43:15THOSE QUESTIONS AND MAKE SURE
- 43:16THAT THE DEBATE HAPPENED.
- 43:18>> Renee: THIS QUESTION A PIVOT
- 43:19FROM WHAT WE'RE DISCUSSING THIS
- 43:21QUESTION FROM MASON COUNTY, A
- 43:23STATEMENT WE NEED TO PAY
- 43:25ATTENTION WHO WE VOTE FOR ON THE
- 43:27SCHOOL BOARD AND THE SCHOOL
- 43:29BOARD MEMBERS.
- 43:30HOW IMPORTANT IS THE SCHOOL
- 43:32BOARD?
- 43:32AND WHO IS ON THE SCHOOL BOARD?
- 43:35Dr. CALDWELL?
- 43:38>> I WILL RESPOND BASED 0 ON MY
- 43:41OWN COMMUNITY.
- 43:41THE SCHOOL BOARD IS SO IMPORTANT
- 43:43THOSE ARE OUR ELECTED OFFICIALS
- 43:46WHO PROVIDE COUNSEL AND
- 43:48OVERSIGHT TO OUR SUPERINTENDENTS
- 43:49TO OUR DISTRICTS.
- 43:50THEY PLAN OUR BUDGETS AND THEY
- 43:53ALLOCATE OUR SPENDING.
- 43:54BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY, AS A LOCAL
- 43:58COMMUNITY, THEY DETERMINE WHAT
- 44:00THAT SCHOOL COMMUNITY SHOULD
- 44:01LOOK LIKE.
- 44:02AND WHAT THE PRIORITIES ARE.
- 44:05AND ACTUALLY WHAT LEARNING LOOKS
- 44:07LIKE BY THE TIME A STUDENT
- 44:10GRADUATES.
- 44:10AND THERE ARE A NUMBER OF
- 44:11SYSTEMS AND SUPPORTS IN
- 44:13MATERIALS OF WHAT THAT LOOKS
- 44:15LIKE FOR THE COMPLETE EDUCATION
- 44:19PROCESS.
- 44:19BUT OUR SCHOOL BOARD THOSE ARE
- 44:21THE FOLKS WE GO TO THE BALLOT
- 44:23AND WE CAST OUR VOTES FOR THEM.
- 44:26PAUSE WE BELIEVE --
- 44:27BECAUSE WE BELIEVE THEY ARE WELL
- 44:29POSITIONED TO LEAD OUR
- 44:31DESCRIPTION.
- 44:31AND WE TALK A LOT ABOUT LOCAL
- 44:34CONTROL.
- 44:34AND AT THE END OF THE DAY, THEY
- 44:36ARE THE LOCAL CONTROL MAKING ALL
- 44:39OF THESE DECISIONS ABOUT HOW
- 44:41DOLLARS ARE SPENT, HOW THEY ARE
- 44:44DIRECTED AND I KNOW THEY
- 44:46STRUGGLE AND GRAPPLE BECAUSE
- 44:48JUST LIKE OUR LEGISLATURE, THEY
- 44:50HAVE A CERTAIN ALLOCATION OF
- 44:54FUNDING AND THERE ARE MORE NEEDS
- 44:56THAN WE COULD EVER BEGIN TO
- 44:59ADDRESS.
- 44:59>> Renee: TO YOUR POINT
- 45:01SUPERINTENDENT CLAYTON ABOUT HOW
- 45:02THE LOCAL TAXES ARE GOING
- 45:04DISPROPORTIONATELY MORE TO HELP
- 45:06YOUR SCHOOLS IN YOUR DISTRICT
- 45:08THAN STATE.
- 45:09BUT MANY PEOPLE SAY HOME RULE
- 45:11WORKS BOTH WAYS WHY SHOULDN'T
- 45:13THE LOCAL COMMUNITY PAY FOR WHAT
- 45:15THEY WANT EDUCATIONALLY?
- 45:16>> AND I WOULD ENCOURAGE THEM TO
- 45:18LOOK AT THE SEEK FORMULA.
- 45:20BECAUSE THE REALITY IS WARREN
- 45:23COUNTY SCHOOLS SOME OF YOUR
- 45:24TAXES IS GOING ACROSS THE
- 45:25COMMONWEALTH TO LIFT UP OTHER
- 45:27SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND WE DO THAT
- 45:28WITH PRIDE.
- 45:29WE GET IT.
- 45:30WE UNDERSTAND WE'RE ALL IN THIS
- 45:34TOGETHER.
- 45:34OUR SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS ARE
- 45:36CRITICAL.
- 45:36THEY ARE ABSOLUTELY CRITICAL IN
- 45:40EITHER SUPPORTING AND HELPING
- 45:42IMPROVE OR IN SOME CASES, THEY
- 45:44CAN HOLD YOU BACK.
- 45:45AND I'VE BEEN BLESSED FOR 13
- 45:47YEARS TO HAVE A SCHOOL BOARD
- 45:49THAT IS SOLELY FOCUSED ON WHAT
- 45:52IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF OUR
- 45:54STUDENTS.
- 45:56THEY SHOW THAT WITH THEIR VOTES
- 45:58BUT IT'S DIFFICULT FOR THEM AND
- 45:59THEIR COMMUNITIES LIKE ALL
- 46:01SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS ACROSS THE
- 46:03COMMONWEALTH WHEN THEY RAISE
- 46:04THAT PROPERTY TAX BECAUSE THEY
- 46:06SEE THE DISINVESTMENT COMING
- 46:07FROM FRANKFORT.
- 46:08AND AGAIN THESE ARE FACTS.
- 46:10THE NUMBERS DON'T LIE.
- 46:12SO IT'S UP TO THE SCHOOL BOARD
- 46:14WITH THE COMMUNITY, TO HELP
- 46:16OFFSET THAT SIGNIFICANT EXPENSE.
- 46:18I WILL GIVE YOU ANOTHER EXAMPLE,
- 46:20RENEE.
- 46:221.8 MILLION DOLLARS RIGHT NOW IS
- 46:23GOING TO FUND OUR SRO PROGRAM.
- 46:27>> Renee: SCHOOL RESOURCE
- 46:30OFFICERS.
- 46:30>> OUR GOAL IS TO GET ONE IN
- 46:32EVERY SCHOOL THE SIGN OF THE
- 46:33TIMES.
- 46:34THEY PROVIDE A TREMENDOUS VALUE
- 46:36BEYOND WHAT MOST PEOPLE THINK OF
- 46:37IN TERMS OF THE SECURITY.
- 46:40THEY BUILD STRONG POSITIVE
- 46:42RELATIONSHIPS WITH OUR STUDENTS
- 46:43AND HAVE A TREMENDOUS IMPACT ON
- 46:45THE SCHOOL CULTURE BUT AT A
- 46:46COST.
- 46:47AND WE'RE FUNDING THAT
- 46:48COMPLETELY.
- 46:49AND NEXT YEAR IT WILL BE ALL ON
- 46:54WARREN COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 46:56WE NOW HAVE A NURSE IN EVERY
- 46:58SCHOOL.
- 46:59THAT IS ANOTHER EXPENSE.
- 47:00AND SO IT'S IMPORTANT TO
- 47:02UNDERSTAND THE NEEDS HAVE RISEN,
- 47:05THE RESOURCES WE'RE PROVIDING
- 47:07LOCALLY WITH THE DECISION MAKES
- 47:09HAS INCREASED SIGNIFICANTLY, WHO
- 47:11HAS PAID THE PRICE?
- 47:12I WILL TELL YOU IT'S OUR STAFF.
- 47:14WE ARE 82% OF OUR OPERATIONAL
- 47:17BUDGET IS FOR STAFFING.
- 47:19BUT THE REALITY IS WE MOVED OUR
- 47:20STARTING SALARY TO NORTH OF
- 47:2445,000 BUT 13%, 13% OF THOSE
- 47:29SALARIES GOES TOWARD THAT
- 47:30RETIREMENT THAT PENSION THAT NOW
- 47:32HAS BEEN CHANGED FOUR TIMES IN
- 47:34MY CAREER.
- 47:35AND EACH TIME, THE BENEFITS ON
- 47:37THE BACK END HAVE BEEN DECREASED
- 47:39WITHOUT ANY INPUTS ON THE FRONT
- 47:41END.
- 47:42AND I SAT IN FRANKFORT AND
- 47:44MENTIONED FROM THE BEGINNING IF
- 47:45YOU ARE GOING TO NEGATIVELY
- 47:47IMPACT THE RETIREMENT SYSTEM YOU
- 47:49HAVE TO GIVE THESE FOLKS
- 47:51SOMETHING ON THE FRONT END LIKE
- 47:52YOU WOULD SEE IN THE PRIVATE
- 47:53SECTOR.
- 47:54ASK ANY PRIVATE SECTOR BUSINESS
- 47:56PERSON AND IF THEY HAVE A
- 47:58WORKFORCE SHORTAGE THEY WILL
- 47:59RAISE THE PAY 100%.
- 48:01100%.
- 48:02WE CAN'T DO THAT.
- 48:04WE GOT TO HAVE THE FUNDING.
- 48:06>> Renee: LET'S TALK ABOUT
- 48:07FUNDING IN A DIFFERENT WAY.
- 48:08I MENTIONED THE KENTUCKY SUPREME
- 48:10COURT IS CONSIDERING CHARTER
- 48:12SCHOOL FUNDING AND THIS DATES
- 48:14BACK A WHILE 2017 CHARTER
- 48:16SCHOOLS WERE LEGALIZED AND 2022
- 48:18WHEN THERE WAS A HOUSE BILL 9
- 48:20THAT PROVIDED THE FUNDING FOR
- 48:22THAT AND IT'S BEEN HUNG UP IN
- 48:23THE COURTS FOR SOMETIME.
- 48:25YOU WOULD APPLY TO CONVERT YOUR
- 48:27SCHOOL THAT IS A PRIVATE TUITION
- 48:30BASED SCHOOL TO A PUBLIC CHARTER
- 48:33SCHOOL THAT WOULD BE TUITION
- 48:34FREE.
- 48:35TELL US ABOUT THAT AND YOU ARE
- 48:38ALSO OF COURSE APPELLATE IN THIS
- 48:40CASE JUST AS Mr. CLAYTON WITH
- 48:43THE COUNCIL FOR BETTER EDUCATION
- 48:44WE HAVE THE TWO IN THE KNOW
- 48:46TALKING ABOUT THIS TONIGHT.
- 48:49WHY WHAT IS IT I KNOW WHAT YOU
- 48:50WANT THE SUPREME COURT TO DO BUT
- 48:52WHY IS IT SO CRITICAL THAT IT BE
- 48:55DONE?
- 48:55>> I MENTIONED EARLIER ALL I'VE
- 48:58WANTED TO DO IS BE AN EDUCATOR.
- 49:00AND GOING INTO THAT PROFESSION
- 49:02HAS BEEN SO REWARDING.
- 49:04AND I LOVE IT SO MUCH.
- 49:05AND I LOVE THE JOB I HAVE RIGHT
- 49:07NOW SO MUCH.
- 49:08BUT THE ONLY THING THAT I WISH
- 49:10COULD BE DIFFERENT ABOUT THE JOB
- 49:11I HAVE NOW WOULD BE TO EXPAND
- 49:14ACCESS TO ALL THE FAMILIES AT
- 49:15THAT TIME WANT TO PARTICIPATE IN
- 49:17THE SCHOOL THAT WE'VE BUILT.
- 49:19AND CHARTER SCHOOLS COULD BE A
- 49:21METHOD TO ALLOW THAT.
- 49:23AND INCREASE ACCESS FOR MORE
- 49:25FAMILIES THAT WANT TO EXERCISE
- 49:27CHOICE OVER THEIR CHILD'S
- 49:28EDUCATION.
- 49:29THAT'S WHY I AM INVOLVED IN THIS
- 49:34CASE AT THE SUPREME COURT.
- 49:35IT'S WHY WE'VE BUILT OUR SCHOOL
- 49:38AS WE HAVE FOR THE MANY, MANY,
- 49:40MANY YEARS NOW HOPING ONE DAY WE
- 49:42COULD OFFER IT TO MORE FAMILIES.
- 49:44AND IT'S WHY I'M HOPEFUL WE FIND
- 49:46SUCCESS AT THE KENTUCKY SUPREME
- 49:48COURT.
- 49:48>> Renee: YOU KNOW THE ARGUMENTS
- 49:50THAT HAVE BEEN MADE AGAINST
- 49:52CHARTER SCHOOLS THAT THEY HAVE
- 49:54LESS ACCOUNTABILITY THEY DON'T
- 49:55HAVE TO PLAY BY THE SAME RULES
- 49:57WITH CURRICULUM AND INSTRUCTION
- 49:59EVEN WHO THEY ACCEPT.
- 50:01WHAT YOUR PREPARATORY SCHOOL
- 50:02TAKE ON KIDS THAT MAYBE HAVE
- 50:04HIGHER NEEDS WHETHER SPECIAL
- 50:07NEEDS OR UNDERREPRESENTED GROUPS
- 50:08THAT HAVE STRUGGLES IN ACADEMIC
- 50:10AREAS?
- 50:11>> YES, AS A MATTER OF FACT LAW
- 50:14WOULD DICTATE THAT WE SERVE ALL
- 50:16POPULATION.
- 50:17AS AN EDUCATOR I WOULD WANT TO
- 50:19SERVE THAT GROUP.
- 50:20WE CURRENTLY SERVE THAT GROUP IN
- 50:22OUR PRIVATE SCHOOL AND THEY ARE
- 50:23ATTRACTED TO COME TO THE SCHOOL
- 50:26BECAUSE WE HAVE SMALL CLASS
- 50:27SIZES AND SPECIALIZE IN CERTAIN
- 50:29AREAS.
- 50:30AND WE CAN PULL THEM OUT MORE
- 50:32THAN THEY WOULD IN OUR
- 50:35COUNTERPART SCHOOLS.
- 50:36I WOULD REALLY ENJOY TO SERVE
- 50:38MORE OF THAT POPULATION AND MORE
- 50:39OF A WIDER VARIETY OF A
- 50:42DEMOGRAPHIC IN MADISON COUNTY.
- 50:44>> Renee: THERE HAVE BEEN SOME
- 50:46STUDIES THAT SAY THAT STATES
- 50:48THAT DO HAVE CHARTER SCHOOLS
- 50:49MOST OF THE KIDS AND THE PARENTS
- 50:51WHO SEND THEIR KIDS WERE ALREADY
- 50:54PART OF THE PRIVATE SCHOOL
- 50:55SYSTEM AND IT IS A TAX BREAK FOR
- 50:58THEM.
- 50:59REFUTE THAT IF YOU WILL?
- 51:00>> YEAH, I MEAN, I WORK WITH
- 51:03FAMILIES RIGHT NOW THAT AREN'T
- 51:05OF THAT DEMOGRAPHIC THAT YOU
- 51:07DESCRIBED.
- 51:08AND THEY WANT NOTHING MORE FOR
- 51:11THEIR CHILDREN THAN TO HAVE THE
- 51:12BEST EDUCATION THAT THEY DEEM
- 51:14POSSIBLE.
- 51:15AND THERE ARE MORE FAMILIES LIKE
- 51:16THAT OUT THERE THAT ARE ANXIOUS
- 51:18TO TAKE CHARGE OF THEIR CHILD'S
- 51:21EDUCATION.
- 51:21I AM A BELIEVER IN THOSE PARENTS
- 51:23REGARDLESS OF THEIR INCOME
- 51:25STATUS.
- 51:25I KNOW THAT A PARENT'S LOVE
- 51:28TRANSCENDS SO MUCH OF THAT AND I
- 51:30WORK WITH THE FAMILIES THAT WANT
- 51:32THAT OPPORTUNITY.
- 51:33AND SO, AGAIN, CHARTER SCHOOLS
- 51:35COULD BE A METHOD TO BRING THAT
- 51:38INTO KENTUCKY.
- 51:39WE'RE ONE OF THE ONLY STATES
- 51:40REMAIN THAT DOESN'T HAVE IT
- 51:42EVERY STATE THAT TOUCHES
- 51:44KENTUCKY HAS ROBUST CHARTER
- 51:46SCHOOLS.
- 51:47I'M EXCITED AT THE PROSPECT THAT
- 51:49KENTUCKY FAMILIES COULD HAVE
- 51:50THOSE SAME OPTIONS THAT OTHER
- 51:53STATES HAVE; IS THAT CORRECT AT
- 51:53THE HEART OF THIS DISCUSSION, IS
- 51:56THIS WHOLE IDEA OF THE COMMON
- 51:59SCHOOL, THE CONSTITUTION'S
- 52:00DEFINITION OF A COMMON SCHOOL.
- 52:02WHAT IS THAT?
- 52:04SUPERINTENDENT CLAYTON OR Dr.
- 52:06CALDWELL WHY IS IT SO IMPORTANT
- 52:07AND THE CRUX OF THE ARGUMENTS
- 52:09THAT WE HAVE SURROUNDING THIS
- 52:11ISSUE?
- 52:11>> WELL, OUR FORMER LEADERS
- 52:14REALIZED THAT IT'S IMPORTANT FOR
- 52:16EVERY STUDENT IN THE
- 52:17COMMONWEALTH TO HAVE ACCESS TO A
- 52:19QUALITY EDUCATION.
- 52:20SO THAT'S THE PREMISE BEHIND THE
- 52:23WHOLE PIECE.
- 52:24BUT WHEN WE START LOOKING AT THE
- 52:26CHARTER SCHOOLS AND CHARTER
- 52:28SCHOOL FUNDING WHEN WE MAKE IT
- 52:30VERY CLEAR THAT WE'RE NOT
- 52:32RECEIVING ADEQUATE FUNDING RIGHT
- 52:34NOW, MY QUESTION WOULD BE FOR
- 52:36ANY CHARTER ADVOCATE AND THAT IS
- 52:38IF YOU TOOK OVER WARREN COUNTY
- 52:41PUBLIC SCHOOLS TOMORROW WHERE
- 52:42WOULD YOU FIND THE 13.5 MILLION
- 52:47DOLLARS THAT IS BEING PROVIDED
- 52:49BY OUR LOCAL TAXPAYERS TO COVER
- 52:52THE EXPENSE OF EDUCATING OUR
- 52:55SPECIAL NEEDS POPULATION?
- 52:57WHERE WOULD YOU FIND THE $4
- 52:58MILLION TO EDUCATE OUR EL
- 53:01POPULATION.
- 53:01THE 2.3 MILLION OUT OF THE
- 53:03GENERAL FUND TO TRANSPORT THESE
- 53:05STUDENTS.
- 53:05AND THE ANSWER IS YOU WON'T.
- 53:07BECAUSE IT'S NOT THERE.
- 53:09SO THEY WON'T BE EDUCATED IN
- 53:11THESE CHARTER SCHOOLS.
- 53:12SO WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE DATA
- 53:13FROM THE OTHER STATES, THESE ARE
- 53:16FACTS, YOU CAN LOOK AT WHO WAS
- 53:18IN A PRIVATE SCHOOL AND WHO HAS
- 53:20MOVED TO A CHARTER AND BACK AND
- 53:22FORTH IT'S NOT SPECULATION AND
- 53:23WHAT YOU WILL SEE IS THE SAME
- 53:26STUDENTS WHO ARE STRUGGLING IN
- 53:27THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS DO NOT FIND
- 53:31THEMSELVES THE VAST MAJORITY IN
- 53:32THESE PRIVATE OR CHARTER
- 53:35SCHOOLS.
- 53:35IT IS A FACT.
- 53:36AGAIN IT IS NOT SOMETHING TO BE
- 53:38DEBATED.
- 53:39DO PEOPLE CAN STUDENTS HAVE
- 53:41POSITIVE EXPERIENCES IN SCHOOL?
- 53:44ABSOLUTELY.
- 53:44WE HAVE STUDENTS BEING
- 53:45SUCCESSFUL IN A VARIETY OF
- 53:47AREAS.
- 53:47BUT WHEN WE LOOK AT THE GREATER
- 53:49GOOD FOR THE COMMONWEALTH AND
- 53:51EDUCATING ALL STUDENTS, THE
- 53:54REALITY IS WE NEED ADDITIONAL
- 53:56FUNDING IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 53:57BEFORE WE ENTERTAIN FUNDING
- 54:00OTHER MECHANISMS THAT, AGAIN,
- 54:03WILL NOT BE SERVING THE TOTAL
- 54:05POPULATION.
- 54:06IT IS A FACT.
- 54:07>> Renee: WE KNOW THAT KENTUCKY
- 54:09VOTERS A COUPLE YEARS AGO VOTED
- 54:10ON THIS AND TWO-THIRDS
- 54:14STATE-WIDE REJECTED CONSTITUTION
- 54:14AT AMENDMENT NUMBER 2 THAT WOULD
- 54:17HAVE ALLOWED FOR THIS PUBLIC
- 54:20FUNDING TO GO TOWARD THESE
- 54:21SCHOOLS.
- 54:22SO THE PEOPLE HAVE SPOKEN SHOULD
- 54:24THE SUPREME COURT FOLLOW SUIT?
- 54:27>> THE SUPREME COURT HAS A
- 54:29DIFFERENT MANDATE IN TERMS OF
- 54:31INTERPRETING A STATUTE ON THE
- 54:33BOOKS AND WHETHER OR NOT IT IS
- 54:35CONSTITUTIONAL.
- 54:36AS YOU SAID WE MAY HAVE AN
- 54:37ANSWER TO THAT QUESTION SOMETIME
- 54:40IN THE COMING MONTHS PERHAPS
- 54:43BEFORE THE END OF THE SCHOOL
- 54:44YEAR.
- 54:44I WAS IN GOVERNOR MATT BEVIN'S
- 54:47ADMINISTRATION IN 2017 WHEN THIS
- 54:51CHARTER SCHOOL AUTHORIZATION
- 54:53LEGISLATION WAS PUT TOGETHER.
- 54:55I WAS NOT DIRECTLY INVOLVED.
- 54:57BUT I WATCHED PEOPLE LIKE
- 55:01REPRESENTATIVE CARNEY, EDUCATION
- 55:04SECRETARY HAL BEHINDER, THE
- 55:06COMMISSIONER OF EDUCATION WAYNE
- 55:09LEWIS, VERY DEDICATED, VERY
- 55:12CONSCIENTIOUS PEOPLE, TRYING TO
- 55:14CRAFT ABSOLUTELY THE BEST
- 55:18POSSIBLE STRUCTURE TO ENSURE
- 55:19THAT THERE BE ACCOUNTABILITY,
- 55:21THAT THERE WOULD BE OPEN DOORS
- 55:24AND OPPORTUNITY.
- 55:27SO I'M CERTAINLY HOPING THAT THE
- 55:29SUPREME COURT RULES IN FAVOR OF
- 55:30CHARTER SCHOOLS AND WE CAN START
- 55:32SEEING THAT OPTION AVAILABLE TO
- 55:35FAMILIES.
- 55:35QUICKLY, I WANT TO BE
- 55:38SYMPATHETIC TO THE
- 55:41SUPERINTENDENT'S EXPERIENCE WITH
- 55:42UNFUNDED MANDATES.
- 55:44IF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY IS GOING
- 55:47TO MANDATE CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS
- 55:49UPON OUR LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS,
- 55:52THEY SHOULD PUT THE MONEY BEHIND
- 55:53IT.
- 55:54SO I THINK THAT IS SOMETHING
- 55:56THAT IS A LEGITIMATE REASON TO
- 55:59RAISE THOSE QUESTIONS AND TO
- 56:01HAVE THAT CONVERSATION.
- 56:03>> Renee: WELL, TIME GETS AWAY
- 56:04FROM US WAY TOO QUICKLY ON THIS
- 56:06PROGRAM.
- 56:07AND CERTAINLY IT IS AN ISSUE WE
- 56:10WILL REVISIT.
- 56:10THANK YOU FOR COMING HERE
- 56:12TONIGHT TO TALK ABOUT K-12
- 56:14EDUCATION.
- 56:15THE WELLNESS SHIFT KET FORUM
- 56:17JOIN US FOR THAT PROGRAM.
- 56:20AND WE HAVE "KENTUCKY EDITION"
- 56:21EACH WEEKNIGHT AT 6:30 EASTERN
- 56:245:30 TO KEEP YOU INFORMED AND
- 56:27CONNECTED.
- 56:28I'M RENEE SHAW THANK YOU FOR
- 56:29WATCHING AND I'LL SEE YOU
- 56:30TOMORROW NIGHT.
- 56:31TAKE GOOD CARE.