Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Tad Smith: The Fed Pivot & AI Forces Driving Bitcoin’s New Regime
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK.
- 0:27I say when we sell. OK, we are back the last trade.
- 0:37Tad Smith, it's a pleasure to have you back on the show.
- 0:40I see you have the orange scarf on.
- 0:43Was that because you joined a Bitcoin podcast today or was
- 0:46this unrelated? Well my choice today on scarves
- 0:50was red for Christmas or orange for Bitcoin.
- 0:53And the truth is I was up and down 5th Ave. this morning with
- 0:56my wife doing like Christmas shopping and I wore red.
- 0:59But for you guys I put on orange.
- 1:00Seemed appropriate. It sure does.
- 1:03Yeah. You know, I I love it.
- 1:05It's you can say it's so festive, right?
- 1:08It's early December. Almost.
- 1:09Oh, it's totally festive, yeah. You know, like festive.
- 1:12It's still autumn, depending on where you are in the world.
- 1:17And I love you. Autumn, loosely construed.
- 1:19It's kind of cold out there. Yeah, you know it.
- 1:23It does depend. But Tad, it's nice to have you
- 1:26back on the show. We're joined as well by Brian
- 1:29Cabela's, the Quant, the house view of On Ramp and Liam Nelson.
- 1:35Liam's joining us from Early Riders in place of Michael
- 1:38Tanguma. Liam, thanks for joining us.
- 1:40How are you doing? I'm doing wonderful.
- 1:42Excited to be here today. Lots to talk about.
- 1:45Yeah, there is a lot to talk about.
- 1:46We we're about to record our entire podcast.
- 1:49So I figured let's hit the record button and we'll start
- 1:52talking about what's happening in the market.
- 1:54So Ted, we got to take a step back for just a moment here.
- 1:58We had you on the show May 2nd. You may recall we were dealing
- 2:03with some turbulence in the markets in April as it related
- 2:06to the tariffs. The Bitcoin price was 96 K
- 2:11Today. We're sitting at 901K.
- 2:14I think expectations for this asset class were much higher
- 2:18this year than where reality set in.
- 2:22And I'm curious, if you just take a moment to gather your
- 2:25thoughts, why do you think that is?
- 2:28Why do you think that perhaps Bitcoin has been a little bit
- 2:32less exciting than the market expected it to be at the start
- 2:35of 2025? And why do you think it's
- 2:38underperformed every other major asset class this year?
- 2:42Yeah. So as we record this sort of
- 2:46mid-december, it's been overwhelmingly a disappointment
- 2:54in this calendar year. Bitcoin has and you know I can,
- 2:59I can point to a lot of different reasons and and maybe
- 3:03we'll go into a few in just a minute.
- 3:05But in my experience with it, and there are a lot of people
- 3:08with more experience, but I have intense experience over the
- 3:10period. I have Bitcoin can surprise you
- 3:15and disappoint you over and over and over again.
- 3:18It has, you know, this is one of those markets that is uniquely
- 3:20designed to take our species and frustrate it.
- 3:25And when we entered this, remember the the boom we had
- 3:29after Trump was elected, everything was amazing.
- 3:31And you know, we can we can talk about results being pulled
- 3:34forward. We can talk about liquidity
- 3:36promises, we can talk about all that stuff.
- 3:39But the plain fact of the matter is it never seems exactly to
- 3:44perform the way we expect. And I would say the expectations
- 3:47coming in were very, very high. On the other hand, on the other
- 3:51hand, we have to look back and say, you know, absent the
- 3:55performance year to date, the performance of Bitcoin overall
- 4:00has been relatively strong. And moreover, the Fed and the
- 4:07particularly the US liquidity hasn't been particularly great
- 4:10this year. It's been, you know, it's, you
- 4:13know, chugged along, but it hasn't done much.
- 4:17And that's sort of held things back.
- 4:20And moreover, the narrative on Bitcoin has been sort of very
- 4:23dull, honestly. I mean, all the energy has been
- 4:25in AI, frankly, and AI stocks and quantum stocks and all the
- 4:29other stuff. So there's been a lot of things
- 4:32that have just been like, you know, wet pillow or wet blanket
- 4:35that's been kind of hanging over Bitcoin.
- 4:38That said, what's exciting to me now is that Bitcoin, you know,
- 4:45as I said, knows how to take our species and turn its mind inside
- 4:48out. And there's, you know, while
- 4:50there, there's a lot of bearish sentiment right now, there a lot
- 4:53of people that are, you know, moving on to other things.
- 4:55There are a lot of people thinking it's sort of a dead
- 4:57cat. We know whatever.
- 5:00I feel pretty good about that setup, and I feel particularly
- 5:04good about the Fed meeting yesterday, and I feel
- 5:08particularly good about how things are setting up from a
- 5:12macro perspective going forward. So, yeah, disappointing year.
- 5:17Yeah, you could have taken a, you know, a dart and thrown it
- 5:20at any of the S&P 500 and probably done a little better
- 5:23than Bitcoin this calendar year. But no, no, it's not the end of
- 5:27the world. Things look good.
- 5:29Loyal listeners of the last trade, I hope you are enjoying
- 5:31this episode with Tad. Really enjoyed it myself.
- 5:34I wanted to let you know, get you in on the inside scoop here
- 5:37that we're piloting out flat based pricing, which means that
- 5:39your fees do not increase the price of Bitcoin in that you get
- 5:43multi institution custody, inheritance, insurance, IRA,
- 5:47lowest cost Bitcoin buys in the industry all in one place.
- 5:50And better yet, we have an end of your incentive.
- 5:52There's only a few more weeks left in 2025.
- 5:55It's the best deal we can offer. e-mail me direct Jackson at on
- 5:59rampbitcoin.com and just put in the subject line end of year or
- 6:02EOI and I'll get back to you. Enjoy the rest of this episode.
- 6:07Well, there's a lot of different directions we can go in.
- 6:10I gave you a lot to work with, didn't?
- 6:12You did. You made my job easy, Tad.
- 6:14Thank you. One, one thing I did want to
- 6:16pick your brain on, because we talked about it and it ties
- 6:19directly into what you're describing around the narrative
- 6:21with Bitcoin compared to the narrative with tech AI.
- 6:26Oh, in space by the way, don't leave Rocket Lab in Palantir.
- 6:29Palantir is obviously AI, but don't leave Rocket Lab out fair.
- 6:32Look at that stock bang. And we, we were talking about
- 6:36narrative, particularly in the context of asset classes that do
- 6:40not generate cash flows. We were talking about art, gold,
- 6:45Bitcoin. I'm curious, you know, when you
- 6:48said the narrative has been dull in Bitcoin this year?
- 6:53Gold, the one of the other major actually the.
- 6:56Largest inherently dull gold. Let's just say, let's call it
- 6:59what it is. Gold has no narrative.
- 7:02It's inherently dull, and it's dull until it really isn't.
- 7:07And when it isn't, it's crazy. And by the way, even when it is
- 7:11isn't dull, it's eclipsed by silver, which is even even more
- 7:15interesting narrative. That's even crazier.
- 7:17So gold is like the middle child.
- 7:20Gold is totally a middle child. It's got Bitcoin on one side and
- 7:23silver, I guess on the other. That doesn't make any sense what
- 7:25I said. But it's like if your two
- 7:26siblings are silver and and and Bitcoin and you're gold, you're
- 7:30the dull student. You're completely You're the
- 7:32best student in class, and you're absolutely the dullest of
- 7:34the siblings. Well, the you know, the gold
- 7:37bugs are laughing at us today, US Bitcoiners.
- 7:40But like. In town gold.
- 7:42So I, you know, I'm, I'm laughing.
- 7:44I. Guess I'm not laughing at my
- 7:45Bitcoin position, which I am fiercely attached to.
- 7:48Thank you very much. OK.
- 7:49Well, so then if narratives, you know, if narratives are one of
- 7:52the big reasons why these asset classes, particularly art, gold,
- 7:56Bitcoin, non cash flow, productive asset, productive
- 8:00assets, what do you make of the divergent between the two?
- 8:05Like is it? Is there any, is there any
- 8:08damage to bitcoins narrative longer term based on the short
- 8:11term performance this year? And the second piece on the gold
- 8:14component is well you said there's really no narrative.
- 8:16It's kind of a dull asset class. What do you make of the 50% or
- 8:20so year to date return there? OK, so two things.
- 8:23One is I was being cheeky on the gold narrative point.
- 8:27So I'm going to retract that, but but I'll I'll put some some
- 8:29beat on that bone in just a minute.
- 8:31Let's do your your really provocative question about
- 8:34Bitcoin. First.
- 8:37Bitcoin, let me let me step back one point.
- 8:40Art is in a different category in terms of narrative versus
- 8:43price. We'll come back to that in just
- 8:44a minute, but where there are trading markets, price I think
- 8:50typically leads the narrative, meaning the price does
- 8:53interesting things and then the narrative follows it to try to
- 8:56explain it or to propel momentum or to take the the the foam off
- 9:00the top one of those things. So that's why I think arts a
- 9:03little different because they don't necessarily mark to market
- 9:06very easily, but but we can talk about that in a SEC with respect
- 9:09to Bitcoin, it's very hard to craft a favorable narrative when
- 9:17the price is giving you no love. It's just really hard.
- 9:20And so you look for all the narratives that explain why the
- 9:23price is giving you no love. And there's a lot, there's a
- 9:27whole lot confusion, liquidity, tariffs, AI gold.
- 9:33Gold is the real thing, not Bitcoin.
- 9:36You know, bitcoins too tied to the QQQ it you know, or
- 9:40something. I mean, 100 little narratives to
- 9:42explain why it doesn't is it isn't working.
- 9:45Or by the way, altcoins, you know, it's really time for alt
- 9:48sees. Any of those things are good
- 9:49reasons why Bitcoin can be in the doldrums, but they typically
- 9:54follow the price action with respect to gold.
- 9:58That's a different situation. The narratives typically chase
- 10:02the price also, but there's a structural bid for gold right
- 10:06now and you can see it in the math, which is the central banks
- 10:10are buying and they're buying a lot.
- 10:12And they, I, I think that the last numbers I saw and I was a
- 10:17week or two old, it looked like they've done up to 1100 tons or
- 10:20something last year and this year they even year to date they
- 10:23were like 7 or 800 million tons, 7 or 800 metric tons, some huge
- 10:27number crazy. Those are approximately numbers.
- 10:29And what that's telling me is that the central banks quietly,
- 10:34relentlessly are definitely increasing their buying.
- 10:38So they've got a very large structural bid that Bitcoin had
- 10:44with the treasury companies and had with some moments of time,
- 10:50but doesn't have at the moment. And so with that, gold has a
- 10:55narrative, but I'm going to stick with the middle child and
- 10:58say it's not a sexy narrative, but it does work like that price
- 11:02action. Yeah, Ted, that's, that's very
- 11:04well said. And you're exactly right.
- 11:06Because that's, that's basically what happened, right?
- 11:08Like gold started to run and then you started to see the
- 11:11narrative become the debasement trade.
- 11:13Right on all the talking heads on CNBC start talking about the
- 11:17debasement trade, which is frankly like that is the Bitcoin
- 11:20thesis. If you were to ask any any real
- 11:23Bitcoin or like, yeah, the dollar is being debased and you
- 11:25need to own hard assets, but I'm curious, like, you know, there
- 11:30is this divergent, but at the same time you have, you know,
- 11:33the Harvards of the world making allocations to I bit and doing
- 11:37it in tandem, interestingly, with a gold allocation.
- 11:40So there is some understanding that these two things are
- 11:43similar. Now, the year to date
- 11:45performance doesn't show you that they're, you know, exactly
- 11:48in in line or in tandem, but that's typically not how they
- 11:51work anyway. They're sort of hand offs in
- 11:53performance in in gold and Bitcoin running.
- 11:55But what do you make of the smaller, Yes, they're they're
- 11:58toe dip allocations for the most part.
- 12:01But like, what do you make of Harvard or even like Abu Dhabi
- 12:04sovereign wealth fund that are making these allocations to
- 12:07Bitcoin? And, you know, in my mind, they
- 12:09are viewing it as digital gold. This is the, you know, the
- 12:12digital form of sound money. And so if they're going to be
- 12:15stacking gold, they might as well also be stacking some
- 12:17Bitcoin. Yeah.
- 12:19So let me separate Harvard from Abu Dhabi sovereign wealth for a
- 12:26minute. Harvard's endowment is one of
- 12:33the, and it has been true for literally decades.
- 12:36I remember it in the 80s and 90s, one of the most advanced
- 12:42hedge funds in the world. They're really amazing.
- 12:45So the way I interpreted that, but when I saw it was that
- 12:52they're doing some sort of locked in funding rate trade on
- 12:58the spot versus the the futures market and that that's a very
- 13:02sophisticated and very safe financial strategy for them and
- 13:07they're not taking naked spot positions.
- 13:10To be clear, I have not the slightest fact to support that,
- 13:15but it just struck me that that's the kind of thing that
- 13:19they're so smart and they would be interested in doing.
- 13:21And that's because they operate as a giant.
- 13:23I mean, it really is a, it's a hedge fund, it's a capital fund,
- 13:25a private equity fund and a growth equity fund and they're
- 13:28all sort of stapled together. And that's really, so that's
- 13:31slightly different. Abu Dhabi's sovereign wealth
- 13:33fund is equally sophisticated in some respects, but there's a
- 13:37slight difference which is they will take long term strategic
- 13:42bets for the literally for the country.
- 13:47Well for certainly for the emirate.
- 13:49And in that case, for them, it would be wise for them to have a
- 13:56large collection of Bitcoin on a spot basis just parked.
- 14:03And so I, it's possible they're doing the same thing, but I, I
- 14:06didn't read it quite that way. So my guess is the Abu Dhabi
- 14:11sovereign efforts are Bitcoin spot and that the Harvard is a
- 14:15slightly different looking beast.
- 14:17And, you know, I think something I think was Larry Fink actually
- 14:19did an interview in the last week or so and he was talking
- 14:21about, he said that on stage sovereigns are buying and, and
- 14:26it was plural. And that makes sense.
- 14:29And I don't think he would say that if they're buying and
- 14:31selling at the same time. Yeah, just, it's just just kind
- 14:34of strange. No, it's a great point.
- 14:36And specifically on the Harvard thing, like I, I think you could
- 14:39totally be right and I probably would have thought.
- 14:41But I have no facts. For sure and neither do I, but I
- 14:45would have thought the same thing if it if it wasn't in
- 14:49tandem with the gold position like those both being disclosed
- 14:53at the same time was interesting to me in that it is sort of a
- 14:56sound money allocation now, but you could be right.
- 14:58They could just be doing some sort of basis trade with the
- 15:01Bitcoin, particularly because it's a it's a large position.
- 15:03Yeah, I wouldn't, I wouldn't give up on your point quite yet.
- 15:06Not that you were. That's that's evidence that says
- 15:10I'm wrong. So I get it.
- 15:13But I'll, I'll tell you one thing.
- 15:15It's nice to see them doing it, frankly.
- 15:18Even if it was just the basis trade like that's still.
- 15:20Interesting. Yeah, it's Yeah.
- 15:22Because by the way, they don't just take the even the basis
- 15:24trade lately lightly, meaning, you know, they've got to make a
- 15:27decision because they know it's going to be publicly reported.
- 15:29Do they really want to associate Harvard with Bitcoin?
- 15:32I mean, think about that. I mean, we we think that's it's
- 15:34such a completely uncontroversial issue that, you
- 15:36know, you don't even really think twice about it.
- 15:39It's not because it gets beamed all over the world.
- 15:42Think about all the Harvard grads in the whole world, all
- 15:45the alumni, everybody else, and they see Harvard, my alma mater,
- 15:51is putting money in Bitcoin. What?
- 15:55So it's not. It's not exactly
- 15:57uncontroversial, which again adds credence to your point.
- 16:00Yeah, totally agree. There was that great article in
- 16:03the Institutional Investor. I don't know if you saw it a
- 16:05week or two ago. It was basically saying exactly
- 16:07that, that, you know, it's Harvard, Brown, Emory, a few
- 16:10others that have these sort of toe dip positions, but that
- 16:14they're not talking about it at all.
- 16:15Like there's no silence. Yeah, they're, they're being
- 16:18very, very quiet about it, which makes total sense because you
- 16:21have, you know, peers, colleagues, alumni to your point
- 16:25that just don't understand Bitcoin.
- 16:26And they, you know, a lot of them probably just perceive it
- 16:29as a Trump thing, which I think is added to the the lack of
- 16:32narrative this year as well, is that a lot of people who don't
- 16:36like Trump have associated Bitcoin and crypto with Trump at
- 16:39this point. And so it's kind of an easy out
- 16:42for them to not be intellectually rigorous about
- 16:44the asset and just say, I don't know, it's not for me.
- 16:47Well, very astute again. I mean, Brian, when you think
- 16:51about it, buying Bitcoin and having it disclosed at Harvard
- 16:59in this environment just invites scrutiny, invites noise, invites
- 17:04the press. And it's so easy just to not do
- 17:09it right. It's so easy, which tells you
- 17:13something. It tells you either that that
- 17:16funding rate play that I'm talking about is just
- 17:19irresistible, or it would have to be really irresistible.
- 17:24The more you're the more you're talking about, the more you're
- 17:26convincing me. It's actually more interesting
- 17:28than what I was suggesting initially, frankly, because it's
- 17:31just not worth the noise. I mean, there's so many things
- 17:33they can put their money into. Why would they choose Bitcoin
- 17:36unless they actually really wanted it?
- 17:38Yeah, so well, well done. Do you have any other examples
- 17:42of that TAD and in your professional experience where
- 17:46institutional investors would rather not participate in NASA
- 17:50class just for avoiding controversy, even if there's
- 17:54meritone in it? Well, you mean shall we exclude
- 17:59the S&P 500? Tell me more, shall we?
- 18:04Well, I mean, how many companies?
- 18:08Publicly traded entities just don't think it's worth even
- 18:14putting 1/2 of 1% of their excess cash into Bitcoin by the
- 18:20way, many of them same point for gold.
- 18:22Let's let's put gold on there it gold also by the way, has drama
- 18:27narrative issues. You know, gold, it's a, you
- 18:30know, all that stuff. And and you could say that there
- 18:36are reasons why they do that. That one is they may
- 18:42authentically believe it's a scam and a pet rock or whatever
- 18:44they believe, but there's a whole weight of evidence that it
- 18:48isn't. And interestingly, there's a
- 18:51weight of evidence that they are actually not doing the best by
- 18:54their shareholders by not putting at least some allocation
- 18:57there. And you don't have to listen to
- 18:59little old Tad, listen to Larry Fink.
- 19:02I mean, let's start with him. So I would say the weight of
- 19:08evidence for people that are managing excess cash when I say
- 19:12excess, meaning excess and above what they need to run the
- 19:15business sitting in T-bills is there's a prima fascia case that
- 19:21one can say that that's now this is probably too strong, but I'll
- 19:25make it, I'll try to soften it a bit that if you're sitting in
- 19:30T-bills and you don't need the cash in the short term, you are
- 19:34being abundantly conservative with your shareholders money.
- 19:38Maybe that's a nice way to say it.
- 19:41And if you're sitting on long term cash and you're just
- 19:43rolling them over in T-bills, you could, you could really
- 19:46wonder whether that's the best for the shareholders.
- 19:49And so back to your question, Jackson, I, I think you could
- 19:51say that it's meaning the list of people who are examples is
- 19:54much longer than the list of people who aren't examples.
- 19:56How's that for an answer? Right.
- 19:59Yeah. No, that makes a lot of sense
- 20:01and I may have just not phrased my thought correctly.
- 20:05I was curious. That that insight was helpful.
- 20:08I was also curious just outside of Bitcoin, you know, we talked
- 20:12about how there's simplization controversy around owning
- 20:15Bitcoin and that your point extends to S&P 500 companies to
- 20:19institutional. Investors.
- 20:20Oh sure, you meant Are there other asset classes that are as
- 20:23controversial as Bitcoin? Exactly.
- 20:25OK, well, let's take every single altcoin, every single
- 20:28non. We'll do that.
- 20:30Let's add that to the list. All crypto currencies.
- 20:34Shall we toss in large fossil based energy companies?
- 20:40Shall we toss in companies that are based in, I don't know,
- 20:44places in the world that are politically complicated or dicey
- 20:48or raise issues? Should we take should we toss in
- 20:52companies that are perceived to be transparently unsustainable
- 20:58or have some other thing with them?
- 21:00All of those things are areas where people will not, for
- 21:07financial reasons, make decisions about just you know,
- 21:10life's too short. I why do that?
- 21:12Right, Yeah, No, that that makes sense.
- 21:16And I hear you that certainly have seen quite a bit of that in
- 21:20the Wall Street days before working in the Bitcoin industry
- 21:24and I and I can understand where people are coming from.
- 21:27One thing, you know, maybe to move in a different direction
- 21:30here because I know it's something that all of us wanted
- 21:33to discuss was the recent decision by the Federal Reserve
- 21:36to cut interest rates third consecutive time and start
- 21:39expanding the balance sheet. So, you know, for the listeners
- 21:42who are unaware, we've been in more of a tight, tighter
- 21:46monetary policy, especially relative to the past 15 or so
- 21:50years post great financial crisis.
- 21:52You know, we saw the fastest rate hike by the Federal
- 21:55Reserve, I believe in history following COVID early 2022 to
- 22:01was it 24 at some point when that when that ended that point
- 22:05aside, we saw Bitcoin, you know, to tie Bitcoin back in here and
- 22:09maybe just brought our asset classes.
- 22:12There's been this perception that Bitcoin has a four year
- 22:15cycle and we'll figure out if that's true or not in the coming
- 22:20months. I mean, you can make evidence
- 22:21that maybe we've already found the answer out that the four
- 22:25year cycle no longer applies. But one thing that's really
- 22:29important to call out is the distinction between where policy
- 22:33was, where monetary policy was at the end of the last Bitcoin
- 22:36cycle in 2021, where we're entering into tightening
- 22:40compared to now, where you'd think based on historical
- 22:44precedence the Bitcoin price would be going down.
- 22:47But you have monetary policy that's becoming more supportive
- 22:51of risk assets, even if we don't think bitcoins are risk asset.
- 22:54That's currently how it's categorized.
- 22:56So I'm curious, Tad, before getting into perhaps the Bitcoin
- 23:00side of the question, just what do you make of the Fed's
- 23:02decision yesterday and broadly speaking this year in terms of
- 23:07easing? You know, there's some
- 23:08controversy. Is it the right thing to do
- 23:10because labor softening, but inflation is still above target
- 23:15level. So how do you think about that
- 23:16as as an investor? So two things.
- 23:20One is the Fed is a hard job and I don't I I'm supportive of a
- 23:27change in direction in the Fed, meaning I think they have been
- 23:32too tight, too data dependent and too rigid in all, all
- 23:37several of those respects. And I think the situation with
- 23:42the balance sheet, as one example, set aside, the rates
- 23:45was becoming more and more and more apparent.
- 23:48And the fact they were slow walking, the, any sort of
- 23:53movement on the balance sheet was beginning to put stress on
- 23:56the system. And I think at the end of the
- 23:58calendar year, as you know, the banks have to clean up a lot of
- 24:00their reserves. And I, it wasn't obvious to me
- 24:02that the reserves, although ample were satisfactory to do
- 24:06that. So the level of risk in the
- 24:08system was just look, it wasn't high, but it was beginning to
- 24:12get into, you know, a slightly higher level.
- 24:16So I'm, I, I think that the Fed has not been doing particularly
- 24:19well in the last couple of years.
- 24:21I, and I think we are, I think we're suffering for it.
- 24:26Now, the people who I think are really suffering for it are, are
- 24:29folks who are often young people trying to buy a house, trying to
- 24:34own assets, doing all those things.
- 24:35I don't, I don't think that I, I think that's where you're,
- 24:38you're feeling real pain. So this whole affordability
- 24:41meme. So as an investor, I am broadly
- 24:48speaking encouraged about the future.
- 24:51I think we're going to have a very an exciting tax framework
- 24:56beginning in 2026, which is good.
- 24:58Remember, the one big beautiful bill takes effect.
- 25:01I think we're going to have an improved Fed situation, which is
- 25:06encouraging. I think the balance sheet relief
- 25:08that began this week isn't going away in April.
- 25:11You heard it here first or probably didn't hear first,
- 25:13probably heard it on Twitter for the last 24 hours.
- 25:15But if you didn't see it on Twitter in the last 20, you
- 25:17heard it here first. It isn't going away in April and
- 25:19you're going to get a more combinative Fed and I, I think
- 25:23as long as we don't have black Swans, I think things are going
- 25:26to look pretty good for investment.
- 25:29Yeah, it's an interesting time just given that Powell at this
- 25:33point is effectively a lame duck.
- 25:34Like it's it's known that he's going to be replaced in the new
- 25:37year. And so in my mind, it's like it
- 25:39kind of doesn't matter what happens over the next few months
- 25:41because we kind of know the trajectory once he's replaced.
- 25:46And so, you know, to your point, like they've very much slow walk
- 25:50to this sort of transition. First it was tightening is over
- 25:53on December 1st or whatever it was, and now we're, you know,
- 25:57expanding the balance sheet, but it's just for stabilization.
- 25:59It's, you know, it's quote UN quote temporary.
- 26:01It never really is. And so it's, it's just kind of
- 26:04this interesting spot where everyone kind of sees the
- 26:07writing on the wall, but it's still going to take a few months
- 26:10for, for it to really start to kick in.
- 26:13And, and to, to Jackson's original point, like, I think
- 26:16that's the biggest thing that people are missing with the, the
- 26:18whole cycle theory and, you know, predicting whether, you
- 26:21know, Bitcoin's going to enter a bear market.
- 26:23It's, it's completely devoid of any critical thinking around
- 26:28what those circumstances were in past, quote UN quote, bull bear
- 26:31cycles for Bitcoin. Yes, yes, the having had an
- 26:33impact more of an impact earlier on, but that impact deteriorates
- 26:39over time. It's just, you know, less of a,
- 26:41a magnitude of an impact. And what really has, you know,
- 26:45created these cycles over time is liquidity in the business
- 26:47cycle. And and so now that we're
- 26:50entering basically the the exact opposite of what we saw in 2122,
- 26:54it would support that, yeah, Bitcoin is likely to go up from
- 26:57here in 26 as opposed to enter some prolonged bear market.
- 27:01And you add on top of that, ETFs exist, the market structure
- 27:04exists, banks are getting into custody, they're now allowed to.
- 27:07All of these things matter in terms of like what the next 12
- 27:11to 24 months look like. Because, you know, I've been
- 27:14harping on this for a while, but it's like the ETFs arrived, I
- 27:17guess close to two years ago now.
- 27:19And Vanguard just two weeks ago gave access to their clients.
- 27:24So it's like this stuff is happening, but it's slow in
- 27:26terms of the plumbing and the access.
- 27:28And so you know the the ETFs, the market structure of the
- 27:31banks getting in all of those are going to be huge tailwinds
- 27:34in addition to the macro and liquidity environment into 26.
- 27:37So two things on that. The one thing I would add and to
- 27:41supplement what you're saying is we forget that when you look at
- 27:45the manufacturing index, it's been in the doldrums for years,
- 27:49literally years. And we get that kicking up into
- 27:54the mid and upper 50s, you're going to start seeing the
- 27:57velocity of the money move through the system much, much
- 28:00faster. And so reserves won't just be
- 28:03sitting on bank balance sheets even though liquidity goes up.
- 28:05You're going to get more activity in the GDP, which is
- 28:08what you really want to see as well.
- 28:10The other thing I would say just as a a respectful nod to Jay
- 28:14Powell again, who is a hard job if we put ourselves in his
- 28:18shoes, he knows he's a lame duck.
- 28:21He realizes that he did his rate thing.
- 28:25He got the rate thing through this week and there isn't going
- 28:28to be any other rate mess. He's not going to mess with the
- 28:31rates until, you know, the new chair comes in.
- 28:35But he realizes that the system right now of doing nothing has
- 28:40an unusually a slightly more than usual, which is always low,
- 28:44to be clear, low, but slightly less low or slightly higher
- 28:48elevated risk because of the liquidity.
- 28:52One could argue and I remember I just criticized the Fed, but let
- 28:55me say that one could argue that the elegant thing to do was to
- 28:59put in place a temporary liquidity provision to bridge
- 29:05the Fed from now until the new chair comes in and then position
- 29:10it as temporary. So you don't tie up the new
- 29:13chairs flexibility in doing what the new chair wants to do with
- 29:16liquidity. Because the new chair, by the
- 29:18way, if it's a Miran type, Steven Miran type person may
- 29:21want less on the balance sheet and lower rates.
- 29:25It could. It could a lot of.
- 29:26So you could, you could take the point that Jay Powell
- 29:31orchestrated a transition yesterday in a way that he may
- 29:36not Look, I'm just making this up that he may not be getting
- 29:39full credit for, which is if he had done nothing on liquidity,
- 29:43the probability that they would have to ride to the rescue over
- 29:46the next four months is probably higher than they wanted.
- 29:49And if they had to run to the rescue, that's going to look a
- 29:52lot more like the Silicon Valley Bank situation where they had to
- 29:56ride to the rescue with a multi $100 billion thing and then they
- 30:00would tie the new chairs hands with the inheritance of that
- 30:04part of the balance sheet. So just keep in mind the
- 30:07possibility is there that again, I'm not a fan of the recent Feds
- 30:10actions that this was a well thought through elegant
- 30:14solution. Yeah, I think that's a great
- 30:18point. And as we go closer to the next
- 30:22few months, we're likely going to see who the next Fed chair is
- 30:25and more eyes will be on him rather than Jay Powell.
- 30:29And he's likely going to be publicly posturing what his
- 30:32views are and just his background personally will be
- 30:36able to show where rates are going to go, their view on the
- 30:40Fed's balance sheet over time and can give the market a little
- 30:45bit of a heads up what they should be expecting in 2026 as
- 30:48well. So I think Powell's, you know,
- 30:51as as Brian mentioned, like almost further than a lame duck
- 30:54at this point, as all, all eyes will certainly be on whoever is
- 30:58named is is the next Fed chair. Yeah, unless there's a, unless
- 31:02there's something that comes up and then he will not be a lame
- 31:04duck, right. He'll be, he'll be a very active
- 31:07chair, I'm sure. So.
- 31:09When it comes to holding Bitcoin securely, Peace of Mind starts
- 31:11with architecture. On Ramps multi institution
- 31:14custody distributes control across three independent
- 31:17regulated key holders in a two of three quorum.
- 31:20No single point of failure, no pooled or omnibus exposure
- 31:23segregated client titled faults. You retain full legal ownership
- 31:28while On Ramp coordinates security, compliance and
- 31:30operational work flows behind the scenes.
- 31:33It's strength of many delivered through the simplicity of 1
- 31:37multi institution custody is the foundation for everything.
- 31:39We build sound infrastructure that distributes counterparty
- 31:41risk and provides fault tolerant resilience with clear audits and
- 31:44institutional controls. And now on Ramp is piloting flat
- 31:49predictable pricing, making best in class Bitcoin custody and
- 31:53financial services more accessible now than ever.
- 31:56On Ramp strengthen many simplicity in one.
- 31:59To learn more, check out on rampbitcoin.com.
- 32:02Tad, you are, I think you handled that nuance very well
- 32:07and and you put it quite nice compared to the Treasury
- 32:10Secretary who more recently said at the All in Summit that the
- 32:14Fed was turning into universal basic income for PhD economists.
- 32:18What do you think of the relationship between the, the
- 32:22Treasury and the Fed currently? Because, you know, I think the
- 32:27Bitcoin or view, or at least my view has been that The Mirage of
- 32:30independence has always been kind of a mirage.
- 32:33At some points, the Fed acts more independent than other
- 32:36points. But I tend to think that the Fed
- 32:41and the United States government, the Treasury move
- 32:44more in lockstep than maybe they want to admit.
- 32:47And I'm curious if you disagree with that, if you agree and what
- 32:52your assessment is of the relationship between the two
- 32:55right now where it seems that, you know, the Trump
- 32:57administration is pressuring the Federal Reserve, maybe because I
- 33:01have to because of the fiscal position.
- 33:03But I did want to get your thoughts on that.
- 33:07Well, you guys, correct me if I'm wrong.
- 33:10I don't remember, and this is just maybe my recollection.
- 33:14I don't remember Secretary Besant criticizing Jay Powell by
- 33:19name at any point. No.
- 33:22Yeah. No, I do recall he's rather and
- 33:26very and including the situation that you just described rather
- 33:30hilariously lampooned the policies of the Fed and and on
- 33:38multiple occasions. And then by the way, also very
- 33:40directly said it's off track, it's not doing the right thing,
- 33:43etcetera, etcetera. And the reason that's important
- 33:46is because that's consistent with what you were implying a
- 33:48minute ago, Jackson, which is to say what these two have to get
- 33:52along. It doesn't need to be personal.
- 33:56It's doesn't, doesn't need to parent what his boss says.
- 34:01And they probably meet or have lunch or whatever breakfast,
- 34:05whatever it is once a week. And they have to work together
- 34:07because it's that's the way that's the way it's going to be.
- 34:10And my guess is they, you know, have significantly overlapping
- 34:16interests with significantly not overlapping interests as well.
- 34:21And they work on the areas where they can overlap almost like,
- 34:24you know, Republicans and Democrats.
- 34:26I don't mean to make it political, but people that are
- 34:28just trying to work through and find areas of common interest
- 34:30that will advance an interest. And I suspect they're both
- 34:33working toward what they conceive to be the national
- 34:35interest. At the same time, they come from
- 34:37very different perspectives and have very different views.
- 34:40So it's very easy for me to agree with Bassett to say, you
- 34:44know, it is a work program for pH DS.
- 34:48I don't think he quite said that, but you know what I mean.
- 34:51And because PhDs are sort of fossilized in a backward
- 34:55looking, data dependent, relatively conservative, small
- 35:02C, very conservative mindset. I mean, think about how
- 35:08conservative again, small C, not politically conservative.
- 35:12Think about how conservative the Fed has to be, life tenure type,
- 35:19pH, DS, you're in there. You don't rock the boat.
- 35:23You were talking earlier at the top of the at the top of this
- 35:25podcast about how bold a company or an endowment has to be to
- 35:31take on Bitcoin as a risk. Think about the mindset and the
- 35:37institutional taking all the sharp edges off that must go on
- 35:41inside the Fed to rise within that organization.
- 35:44By the way, long tenured people, very steeped in traditional
- 35:49finance and Jay Powell sits on top of that.
- 35:55So there you go. So I think they work for
- 36:01institutions that are not 100% aligned and they're at, I think
- 36:04they work together as rather well.
- 36:07Yeah. No, that's good perspective just
- 36:09because it's kind of the perspective that I've missed
- 36:13over the past several years, at least in my career where I
- 36:16started in the larger bureaucratic type organizations.
- 36:19And what you described about the Federal Reserve would be more
- 36:22true in those type of? But you worked in for profit
- 36:25institutions. Right.
- 36:26Yeah. So it's even different.
- 36:27You didn't even work in the government.
- 36:29Now the Fed is obviously quasi government.
- 36:32We know that I I'm not. And of course they have a
- 36:34balance sheet and all that other stuff, but it's run like the
- 36:36government. It's right.
- 36:38It is so. So one of the comments you did
- 36:42make about just you said the younger generations are being
- 36:45hurt by higher interest rates is how I perceived you said that.
- 36:49But I'm going to give you the opportunity to kind of clarify
- 36:51your point. So going into 26, we just
- 36:55discussed the shift that's happening pals out new Fed chair
- 37:00in currently have liquidity provisions in place.
- 37:03Interest rates likely go lower in 2026.
- 37:06One of the things we wanted to talk about, Tad, that you
- 37:09brought up head of recording was the labor market.
- 37:12And I think this is a particularly interesting time to
- 37:15to be looking at what is happening in the labor market.
- 37:20And it's not that I have a great perspective on it or a unique
- 37:24perspective on it. It's the fact that we're in a
- 37:27position now that technology is really posing, at least many
- 37:32people perceive that technology is posing a threat to their
- 37:35career. One of the things you mentioned
- 37:37was specifically white collar work younger, you know, younger
- 37:41people coming out of college looking for a career
- 37:43opportunities. I see this already.
- 37:46I'm like on the lower end of a millennial millennial, but I
- 37:49know friends that have younger siblings that are around college
- 37:53age and they're already kind of coming into a labor market
- 37:57that's weaker than what I saw in the 20 tens late twenty 10's.
- 38:03And So what, how do you think about just the opportunity or
- 38:07the threat that AI actually poses?
- 38:09Let's say, let's stick to maybe white collar labor because
- 38:13there's a lot of different tangents we could go down.
- 38:15And how do you think about like what, what advice might you have
- 38:18for younger generations? And we're going to talk about
- 38:20your course, the the art course that you're teaching.
- 38:24It's. Actually a Business School
- 38:25class, but we'll come to that in a minute.
- 38:27You're right, it's I don't mean to contradict you, it is about
- 38:29art, but we'll come to that in a SEC.
- 38:31Yeah. So twofold question the impact
- 38:33on the labor market and then advice, career advice for
- 38:36younger generations in this new labor market.
- 38:39Jackson, you mind if I lean in a little bit on the first on your
- 38:41premise before we turn into the questions?
- 38:43Sure. So before I answer, I want to
- 38:49say I am the oldest Gen. X that there is, born in 1965.
- 38:54So I'm 60 and so I'm not technically a boomer.
- 38:58I'm one inch away from a boomer. Literally not even an inch, half
- 39:02an inch. Six months from boomer.
- 39:07What we Boomers and older Gen. XS have left you guys is
- 39:15absolutely disastrous. Completely disastrous.
- 39:22Let's be clear. I'm talking about all three of
- 39:23you and all of your cohorts. We first of all ran up the bills
- 39:29over decades, printed piles and piles and piles of money to try
- 39:35to pay for them. We did enormous programs that
- 39:38had no end, insight one after another after another, no way to
- 39:43pay for them except printing more and more and more money.
- 39:46We then by the way, create wild subsidies for college and we
- 39:52make it virtually impossible for anyone who doesn't have a
- 39:55college degree to get on a track toward higher income, at least
- 39:58in white collar work. Still some opportunities in a
- 40:01non white collar work or blue collar work, but those are those
- 40:04are tougher. We then by the way, enter into
- 40:06trade deals that push manufacturing jobs offshore.
- 40:10So taking away more and more blue collar work.
- 40:12We then by the way, enter into trade deals that do that
- 40:15accelerate that. We also, by the way, start
- 40:18creating some of the most productive manufacturing.
- 40:20Manufacturing, manufacturing operations in the world here
- 40:22onshore. Only problem is we did it with
- 40:24automation. So we have fewer and fewer jobs
- 40:27actually producing things. And then we tell you guys, you
- 40:30have to go bankrupt yourself, even using public schools to get
- 40:35your college degree to get your ticket punched.
- 40:37So you pile up piles and piles and piles, thousands and
- 40:42thousands, 10s of thousands, sometimes hundreds of thousands
- 40:44of debt to get to be medical degrees, law degrees, college
- 40:47degrees, MBA degrees, whatever it is.
- 40:50And finally, finally, oh, and then we shack up the rates to
- 40:55correct all of this so that you can't buy a house.
- 40:57Anyone who has assets to that. If you don't have assets and
- 41:00you're only selling your labor, you're in a highly elastic
- 41:02supply curve and you don't get any money for it.
- 41:05And then by the way, finally, you guys have survived all of
- 41:08that without pitchforks. I don't know how.
- 41:13And then we come along and say, hey, the most powerful
- 41:16technology that's ever been invented has just come along and
- 41:18it's going to take all your jobs away.
- 41:20So that, oh, and by the way, we're going to fire up the money
- 41:23printer to make all of this work.
- 41:26Oh, and by the way, we have no plan for what you're going to do
- 41:30without having your job, what you're going to do with your
- 41:32student loan and what you're going to do to own a house and
- 41:34what you're going to do with your family because you guys are
- 41:36at the ages where you're starting families.
- 41:38That is absolutely inexcusable, period.
- 41:43It's inexcusable. And, and is it surprising to me
- 41:47that Mamdani wins? No, it's not surprising to me.
- 41:50Is it surprising to me that the right flank of the Republican
- 41:54Party would be angry? No, it's absolutely not
- 41:57surprising. It's surprising me that the
- 41:59youth would feel disaffected and feel this is completely jammed
- 42:02up. Is it surprising to me that they
- 42:04would go after Bitcoin or gamble or go, You know, no, It's all
- 42:09perfectly sensible when framed that way.
- 42:13And the truth is, I haven't even really thrown a punch.
- 42:17I've just talked about kind of what is and what everybody looks
- 42:20at and says, yeah, that's kind of the way it went.
- 42:23There it is all out there, all plain and clear.
- 42:26Thanks, Ted. So if you ask me, is there a
- 42:31bonafide threat to labor from AI?
- 42:34Regrettably, anybody who doesn't think so hasn't been paying
- 42:37attention. Regrettably, anybody who doesn't
- 42:42think they need to be tailoring their messages to their nephews,
- 42:45their nieces, their children, their grandchildren about what
- 42:48the world looks like hasn't been paying attention.
- 42:53Yeah, I mean, that was a great recap, but I'm so I'm so
- 42:58optimistic actually and I I'll tell you why actually.
- 43:01I am too. I mean tremendously optimistic,
- 43:03but but we have to be sober and clear on the reality and
- 43:08wherever we need to be sober and clear that on whose
- 43:11responsibility is reality and it is ours, not yours.
- 43:17And so on that just on the the last point that you made while
- 43:21kind of walking us through the situation, the younger
- 43:25generations. What a situation analysis
- 43:27exactly? Yeah, exactly.
- 43:30So the final point you made was any, I forget exactly you'll put
- 43:33it, but anyone who says otherwise about AI, anyone who
- 43:37doesn't think AI is a threat to their career is not paying
- 43:40enough attention. And I think one of the great
- 43:42data points that you could point to more recently was the October
- 43:462023 layoffs. That was the biggest month of
- 43:50layoffs in the US in 22 years. It's also conveniently a a month
- 43:55where the government didn't publish any jobs data.
- 43:57But that's that's OK. Yeah, you mean you mean 2025,
- 44:00but yeah. But yeah, but oh, so then 2003
- 44:03compared to 2025. Right, Right.
- 44:05That's right. Exactly.
- 44:08Yeah. So that's, yeah, I think that's
- 44:10a great data point just for people to pay attention to.
- 44:12Why I'm optimistic is I? At the same time, everything
- 44:16that you said is clearly true. It's also clearly true that now
- 44:21is a great time to be a high agency person.
- 44:25I think the. It's not only a great time, it's
- 44:28incumbent Jackson, right? So it is.
- 44:30So let me just add one. What I said is my generation is
- 44:34responsible to the mess, but that does not absolve your
- 44:38generation from having agency to clean up your situation 100%.
- 44:44So I I'm 100% with you. Keep going.
- 44:47Right. So I mean, at any point in
- 44:50history, if you're a high agency person, then you're creating
- 44:53opportunities for yourself. You're probably better off than
- 44:57the people who are not doing that.
- 44:58I think it's particularly true now compared to the past few
- 45:02generations because of everything you just described,
- 45:07where 40 years ago the the winning move was to join a
- 45:11company, be loyal to the business, have a pension, do
- 45:16good work, work hard, climb the corporate ladder.
- 45:19But that status quo has been completely flipped on its head
- 45:24in the past 40 years. Now.
- 45:26I think that is the losing strategy.
- 45:28Actually, it it really, you know, it kind of bothers me how
- 45:32that is still perceived to be the winning strategy.
- 45:34I have a good friend who has a younger brother and he was
- 45:39talking about his younger brother is working for a city, a
- 45:43municipality. And the idea was he'll work here
- 45:47and he'll get a pension in the future.
- 45:48And I didn't have the heart to say to him at the time that the
- 45:52pension's probably not going to be there.
- 45:54And even though that might have been a good career choice 40
- 45:57years ago, you know, for, for many people, it's probably not
- 46:00the best career choice now because so much of that work is
- 46:04just going to be replaced. The flip side is if you're high
- 46:07agency and you're curious and you want to learn these new
- 46:10technologies and you want to, you know, maybe you're in
- 46:13Business School and you're in Ted's course and you're learning
- 46:15about these new technologies, there is so much opportunity to
- 46:19use these two further skill sets and advanced careers unlike any
- 46:23time before, right? You don't need to, you no longer
- 46:26need to necessarily follow the conventional career path.
- 46:28You don't need to follow the conventional education system.
- 46:32Everything is at your disposal to create the opportunities that
- 46:37you want. Not to say it's going to be
- 46:38easy, it's not going to be, but I'm just convinced as well, like
- 46:43simultaneously, we have a really bad situation on our hands.
- 46:46But at this, you know, we also have one of the best
- 46:49opportunities, I think, for entrepreneurs, for people
- 46:51building businesses and people who are creative.
- 46:56I think that's the most important thing we will say in
- 46:58this entire podcast, what you just said, Jackson.
- 47:01And, and let me, let me just take it 1 notch farther if I
- 47:04could. It's a great time to be alive.
- 47:08It's a great time to be a millennial.
- 47:09It's a great time to be Gen. Z.
- 47:11These, these technologies can make you do anything, can give
- 47:14you the opportunity to do anything, absolutely anything.
- 47:19And by the way, one corollary of there being abundance and
- 47:25traditional jobs being fewer is that the possibility of I mean,
- 47:31Elon said this actually a week ago, whenever it was, you know,
- 47:35he very much views work as going to be an optional exercise in a
- 47:39matter of a decade or 20 years or something.
- 47:42And what that means is Liam, Brian Jackson, you guys can
- 47:48really chart a course with your own agency.
- 47:51It requires agency. It requires financial planning,
- 47:53which is why it's so important. But you guys are doing it on
- 47:56ramp. It requires thinking about the
- 47:57world, but it but it is to me an inherently positive thing.
- 48:01And if you want to add on to that, think about what AI is
- 48:06doing to give you healthy lives that could be more another
- 48:10century. Think about what AI is doing to
- 48:13make it possible for you to have no entry barriers to anything
- 48:17because you can learn it so fast or go anywhere or do anything.
- 48:20And we haven't even begun to talk about things, You know, we
- 48:24talked before we before the recording started about travel.
- 48:26We haven't even talked about really, really special travel
- 48:30literally in low Earth orbit or other kinds of things.
- 48:32So from my perspective, you guys have a great century in front of
- 48:37you and it's going to be fantastic and incredibly
- 48:40positive. It's got a little bit of change
- 48:42and you're inheriting some of a little bit of, you know, a
- 48:44little bit of noise from me and your other parents and
- 48:47grandparents. But I love what you said because
- 48:51what it means is you guys can chart a future that nobody has
- 48:55ever even dreamed of. And by the way, you're going to.
- 48:58Here's the conversation no one wants to have If something
- 49:01happened to you tomorrow, could your family access your Bitcoin?
- 49:04Really think about it. The C phrase hidden in your
- 49:06house. The hardware wild and the safe.
- 49:08That complex multi 6 setup you understand it, but does your
- 49:12spouse do your children? Billions in Bitcoin are already
- 49:16lost forever because people did not plan for this moment.
- 49:19On Ramps inheritance solution is built into our multi institution
- 49:22custody from day one, 3 institutions, clear beneficiary
- 49:26designation and professional succession planning.
- 49:29No technical knowledge required from your heirs.
- 49:34And with our new flat tier pricing starting at $250
- 49:36monthly, your family won't face surprise custody costs just
- 49:40because Bitcoin appreciated the same predictable fee.
- 49:43Whether Bitcoin hits 200K or 2 million, don't leave your
- 49:47family's future to chance. There's strength in many.
- 49:50Visit on rampbitcoin.com/inheritance.
- 49:53That is on rampbitcoin.com/inheritance.
- 49:56It's well said. I, I want to go back to one
- 49:58thing you said when you were characterizing the, the reality
- 50:00of the situation and you said there's.
- 50:02Both are, by the way, the first time and the second time they're
- 50:05both true. And you, you said something to
- 50:08the effect of there's no plan, right?
- 50:10Like there's no plan to help. There's no plan on this.
- 50:13Right. Yes, that's what I mean.
- 50:15And I was going to say like, I can guess what the the eventual
- 50:19plan will be. It's to print money.
- 50:20And and I think while yes, people have the ability to be
- 50:23high agency in this new world, a lot of people won't.
- 50:26And that's just the reality. And then there will be the
- 50:28pitchforks in the street at some point when AI really does start
- 50:31to displace jobs, that people will be screaming for some form
- 50:35of Ubi, and they probably won't call it that, but they're going
- 50:37to have to print a ton of money. So, well, well, first of all, we
- 50:40kind of know what's going to happen, right?
- 50:41I mean, the threshold for Medicaid will go up, way, way
- 50:45up. So let me say it differently.
- 50:47The qualifying facts will go way down.
- 50:49It'll be much more permissive and it'll be much more generous.
- 50:52Medicare will be much more generous.
- 50:54The threshold age for it will drop.
- 50:57The Social Security will become more generous, and that's the
- 51:00age threshold. And the restrictions on it that
- 51:02we've been doing will become more generous.
- 51:05We don't even need to get to universal basic income or
- 51:08universal the high income, however you want to phrase it,
- 51:10because we have a whole host of programs already.
- 51:14Aid to Families with Children will get more generous.
- 51:17We can just tune all these different things up.
- 51:20Unemployment will get more generous.
- 51:21It'll become permanent by the way, it'll be think about that.
- 51:25It'll be permanent. It'll be a permanent subsidy.
- 51:27We don't even by the way. But those people realize
- 51:29politically the words Ubi are non starter.
- 51:32So nobody will ever start with them.
- 51:33They're complete non starter. Or maybe they'll be a shibboleth
- 51:35for the left or something. I don't know.
- 51:37What's more likely to happen is we just make everything more
- 51:39generous. Just make it make it easier to
- 51:41qualify. And then you know, because the
- 51:43social safety net is already there.
- 51:45It's just at the moment not protecting you 3 but it is there
- 51:52and all we have to do is tune it up and and believe me, a little
- 51:57pressure at the ballot box and we're going to tune it.
- 51:59Up 100%. That's very well said.
- 52:01And this doesn't refer to you, but one of my friends previous
- 52:06to this call a few hours ago sent me an article on total
- 52:10boomer luxury communism, which is a, an idea that was put out
- 52:16or an article that describes how the amount of capital that goes
- 52:21into Medicare, Medicaid and all other Social Security for those
- 52:26who essentially have all the assets today, because it's
- 52:30getting more and more difficult for young people to save capital
- 52:33is also being used for the average individual can get
- 52:37$60,000 a year from Social Security alone.
- 52:40And Medicare pays for things that you know, you wouldn't
- 52:43imagine like golf balls, greens fees, social club memberships,
- 52:47horseback riding lessons, pet food, etcetera.
- 52:51So I think obviously people will continue to, or the government
- 52:55will continue to cater to their largest and most loyal voting
- 52:59blocks, even if it's at the the service of others in the
- 53:03population. And so I think we're we're going
- 53:06to kind of only accelerate that in the future, unfortunately,
- 53:09and that that may eventually drive out some of the
- 53:12pitchforks. Well, you'll know that universal
- 53:14basic income has arrived when articles that reveal the
- 53:18examples you just gave no longer raise an eyebrow.
- 53:22Exactly. That by the way, that's when you
- 53:23know that it's happened. That's it.
- 53:25And, and by the way, if let's be clear, if AI puts significant
- 53:32stress on jobs, and by the way, even if you think that your job
- 53:35is resistant to it, it doesn't mean that as more and more
- 53:38people become hit the labor market with no jobs, that
- 53:41pressure will go down on all wages.
- 53:44Don't don't think that there are certain pockets where the the
- 53:47rages are going to be resistant. That's not going to work.
- 53:50So the reason I say that is all of the things that you just
- 53:54described. Wait until they provide, you
- 53:59know, golf lessons as well as golf balls.
- 54:02Soon, Tad. All right, Jackson, you want to
- 54:05get us back on? Track No no I.
- 54:07I can see it. It's all over your face.
- 54:09You're like, come on, Tad, you're talking about golf balls.
- 54:12That was Liam to be. Fair, I had it the golf balls,
- 54:14but. I know I brought up a golf
- 54:16swing. We'll do golf swing.
- 54:17Go ahead. Everybody will live in Palm
- 54:19Beach. What can I say?
- 54:20Here's what keeps Bitcoiners. Awake, you're still securing
- 54:23millions of dollars the same way you secured thousands that
- 54:27hardware. Wallet in your drawer.
- 54:29Your family's entire future depends on you not losing it for
- 54:32getting the pin or something happening to you on ramps.
- 54:36Multi institution custody removes that burden.
- 54:38Three independent institutions hold your keys.
- 54:41No single point of failure. No seed phrases to protect.
- 54:44No explaining complex recovery processes to your spouse.
- 54:48And now we're offering flat tier pricing.
- 54:51One predictable monthly fee starting at $250.
- 54:55Other Bitcoin is at 100K or 500K plus with on ramp buyer raise.
- 55:00You get the same institutional security with tax advantage
- 55:02growth. This is how smart investors
- 55:05protect generational wealth without the weight on their
- 55:08shoulders, their strength in many learn more at on
- 55:11rampbitcoin.com. I had a question there.
- 55:14Just giving your background and serving as CEO at public and
- 55:19private companies, what and on the same thread, what are some
- 55:23of your peers, what are those conversations look like with
- 55:25your peers at C-Suite level as they think through artificial
- 55:30intelligence for their businesses, right?
- 55:33Like not only just about replacing workers, but
- 55:36strategically growing the business, adding more value to
- 55:39shareholders, adding more value to their customers.
- 55:43Let's talk about some of the good that businesses are going
- 55:45to do with the technology. Well, the vast majority of
- 55:49businesses have labor as their single largest expense.
- 55:55And all the CE OS that I know and probably all the CE OS that
- 56:04are responsible to their shareholders are asking
- 56:07questions about how do I take advantage of this moment in time
- 56:14to end this incredible new technology in ways that will
- 56:18make us more productive, generate more revenue per
- 56:21person, generate more revenue per unit dollar labor expense.
- 56:25Because if you're not and all your competitors are, well, then
- 56:30you got a real problem. And what's that line?
- 56:32You know, your labor expenses. My opportunity.
- 56:36That's pretty sobering. That's how they're thinking
- 56:38about it. I actually wanted to hear your
- 56:41thoughts on this ties directly into what you just said.
- 56:45We talked about the K shaped economy a little bit.
- 56:48How do you parse the fact that what you just described is true?
- 56:51Artificial intelligence replaces some labor cost at companies
- 56:56ultimately that could be accretive to share prices and to
- 57:01the, you know, to the stock at the same time.
- 57:04By the way, you're seeing it right?
- 57:05You look at what happened with Eli Lilly and Corning Glass
- 57:08works in the last a couple of months.
- 57:11So, so you do not have to believe me.
- 57:14One's a great big pharma company and one's, you know, a majority.
- 57:17Vista did a wonderful piece on it a week or so ago on Corning,
- 57:21which has been a dead you know, it's been a dead manufacturing,
- 57:24dull business until Bang AI comes along and suddenly it's
- 57:27next level. Right.
- 57:28And, and so I think that's fascinating because you have
- 57:32artificial intelligence able to help the equity prices, but the
- 57:37equities are owned by the demographics we just discussed.
- 57:40The flip side is though, if the people who are losing their jobs
- 57:45are unable to consume at the same level they have previously
- 57:49because they don't have the same reliable income that they once
- 57:53had. How do you parse out the fact
- 57:56that it could be great for the AI, could be great for share
- 57:59prices, but also there the United States economy is so
- 58:04dependent on consumption. At some point, AI replacing
- 58:07labor hurts consumption and so like how do you how do those two
- 58:11factors play out if you thought about that?
- 58:13Well, you know, Jackson, you're, you've got 2 minds on the topic
- 58:16because you, you have me completely enchanted by your
- 58:19optimism. And then you bring up a
- 58:21relatively cloudy question like this one, which is a very astute
- 58:24question. So I, I, you've got a little
- 58:26whiplash, but here's what I'll say.
- 58:29I think that when the ballot box starts feeling pressure, and I
- 58:36mean real labor pressure at the moment, we're not feeling it.
- 58:38Yeah, yes, Brian, we were talking a little bit about your
- 58:43a couple of your friends and we're talking about the college
- 58:47graduate trouble and getting jobs and things like that.
- 58:51Yeah, there's a little bit of pressure around the edges.
- 58:54There's no question, but you're not seeing sharp changes yet.
- 58:59What you're seeing is like a frog in a pot that's not even
- 59:03warm yet, but it's gone a little north of room temperature.
- 59:07But it's not warm, it's just a little new north of room
- 59:10temperature. That's where we are.
- 59:13When it starts getting uncomfortably hot, you're going
- 59:16to see real fast changes. In my prediction, the government
- 59:20will be very responsive and very quick.
- 59:24It's just not there yet. At the moment, we can laugh at
- 59:27the, you know, golf falls as part of Medicare.
- 59:30We can be outraged by that won't last long.
- 59:33Right. Yeah, that's true.
- 59:34I mean many people, I think the four of us and your students,
- 59:40Tad, which I want to talk about now are probably kind of in the
- 59:43minority still where people, people are actively using these
- 59:46new technologies. I think a lot of folks still
- 59:49haven't materially engaged with LLMS or, you know, artificial
- 59:57intelligence in any sort of significant way.
- 1:00:00And so to your point, it's like, yeah, these the trend is in.
- 1:00:04The trend is clear. It's clear where it's going over
- 1:00:07the longer term, but we haven't actually gotten to a point where
- 1:00:09the pain is broadly felt enough in the economy.
- 1:00:13So if I get us back on track, let's get back into the
- 1:00:15optimism. Let's talk about the course that
- 1:00:19you that you teach. Art meets machine.
- 1:00:23Let me make sure I get this clear.
- 1:00:24Art meets machine. Innovation and creativity from
- 1:00:28the 20th century to AI. Could you tell us more about
- 1:00:33what prompted you to want to create a course?
- 1:00:36I think you created it right. I did.
- 1:00:38I created it. I created it entirely from
- 1:00:40scratch. By the way, you guys are not
- 1:00:42just the minority, you're the vanguard.
- 1:00:44So I just want to point that out.
- 1:00:45You keep that in mind with respect to the class.
- 1:00:49My daughter is a junior at college and last May she called
- 1:00:54me up. She almost never calls me.
- 1:00:56And she says, dad, I need to talk to you.
- 1:00:58Sure. Why?
- 1:00:59And she says, well, AI is banned at my school, OK.
- 1:01:05And I had to do a paper and anyone who gets caught using AI
- 1:01:08is going to get flunked. I said, OK, what's the question?
- 1:01:12And she says, well, I put, I wrote my paper and I put it
- 1:01:15through the AI detector and it was only 97% human.
- 1:01:19And I said, wait, what? First of all, I'm like, what's
- 1:01:21an AI detector? But whatever, you know, we get
- 1:01:23to like what? What?
- 1:01:25And she says, no, daddy, it says it's only 97% human.
- 1:01:28I said, well, did you use AI? She says, no, I said, turn the
- 1:01:30paper in, it's going to be fine. So Are you sure?
- 1:01:32I don't want to, you know, I said, turn the paper in, you're
- 1:01:34going to be fine. And I knew that I was coming off
- 1:01:37hiatus. I'd been on a couple of years
- 1:01:38hiatus. I took a brick for my class, but
- 1:01:41I was already talking to NYU Stern about going back in the
- 1:01:44fall. So it's the second year MBAs
- 1:01:46that I teach, by the way, at the Business School at NYU Stern.
- 1:01:49And I came away from that experience thinking my daughter,
- 1:01:55you know, we talked a little bit of longevity a few minutes ago,
- 1:01:57but my daughter's got another 100 plus years of life and all
- 1:02:02of it healthy and exciting, God willing.
- 1:02:04And how is it possible She's going to this fantastic school
- 1:02:10and AI is banned. The most important technology
- 1:02:13that will shape her future is simply banned.
- 1:02:15Now I understand why there are good reasons to moderate the use
- 1:02:20of AI. Yes, but I'm like, really?
- 1:02:23So I said, but, and here I'm about to go teach and I'm about
- 1:02:26to go teach in exactly the same way.
- 1:02:27So I went to see my department chair and I asked him what
- 1:02:30they're thinking about AI and it's left up to the professors.
- 1:02:32And he points to this stack of blue books.
- 1:02:34Now you guys are too young to know what a blue book is, but I
- 1:02:36got to tell you what it is is what I used to do an exam on in
- 1:02:39the early. 80s I know blue books I'm used to.
- 1:02:42Blue Books, exactly Blue books, Blue books have made a comeback.
- 1:02:46Well, OK, that to me caused my head to explode and look, I love
- 1:02:50this chair. So he's a great guy.
- 1:02:52But and so I started showing what are we doing with AI at
- 1:02:57that moment? I said I'm going to do my going
- 1:03:01to redo my class. I'm going to 1 use AI to create
- 1:03:04the class #2 I'm going to require require all students to
- 1:03:09use AI for the class. Number three, I'm not going to
- 1:03:12request or require anything other than the use of AI for the
- 1:03:16class #4 I'm going to redesign the class.
- 1:03:20Not around lectures, not around reading assignments, not or any
- 1:03:23of those things on presentations and debates and discussions
- 1:03:27prompted by AI. And moreover, I'm going to have
- 1:03:32AI complete the entire syllabus for me and of course I'll curate
- 1:03:35it. And then so the class was 3
- 1:03:37hour, 363 hour seminars. The first hour was every student
- 1:03:42for every single class, every week for six weeks would come in
- 1:03:45ready to a 5 minute presentation on a topic of their choice
- 1:03:48within a genre of things. They would have to get up in the
- 1:03:50front of the room and present and they never knew whether they
- 1:03:53were going to get called. So they had to do presentations,
- 1:03:55ready presentations every single week, not knowing whether
- 1:03:58they're going to give a speech that week or not.
- 1:04:00Second part, we would take some of the key themes in the
- 1:04:02presentation. We divide them into debates and
- 1:04:04we'd split the class into quarters and the first one would
- 1:04:06be 1 issue and the second will be another issue and one group
- 1:04:09would be pro. One group would be conned for
- 1:04:11each, and then we would break the class up, give them 5 to 10
- 1:04:14minutes, 12 minutes Max to be prepared to do a debate, and
- 1:04:18they would come back in and publicly debate.
- 1:04:20Now, this sounds crazy with no preparation.
- 1:04:22When you have an IQ of 160 tools sitting in your superpower, you
- 1:04:27can do this really easily. And then we would have guest
- 1:04:29speakers evaluating some of this and come back in and answer
- 1:04:32questions at the end. And do you know everything
- 1:04:35changed, The students changed, the use of AI changed.
- 1:04:38My role as professor change. I used to be Socratic method.
- 1:04:42All I had to do was curate this and stay out of the way.
- 1:04:45And I learned a ton. The students all learned a ton.
- 1:04:48It was superpower. And then I had the trouble of
- 1:04:50what do I do with an exam? Because if students are required
- 1:04:54to use AI, try giving them a take home exam that uses AI.
- 1:05:00That will be able to sort the group.
- 1:05:03Well, of course, AI is much smarter than I am.
- 1:05:06I had to use AI to come up with an exam.
- 1:05:08So I then did take home exam with five questions.
- 1:05:10They could pick one and then they had to answer it.
- 1:05:13And of course, the grades. I consulted AI on the grades.
- 1:05:17Now, I ultimately kept the grade, the final grade, and the
- 1:05:20oral participation grade to myself because AI can't do that.
- 1:05:23But getting AI's advice on the grades of the papers was
- 1:05:28extraordinary. It accelerated the level of
- 1:05:32class at A It's almost hard to get your mind around.
- 1:05:36And my grading got better, my teaching got better, their
- 1:05:42learning got better, their teaching of each other got
- 1:05:45better, their teaching of me got better.
- 1:05:47Everything got better. So actually let's let's be clear
- 1:05:53here then there's a lot of good that comes from artificial
- 1:05:56intelligence. And we've all been, I think
- 1:05:58we've all been clear, but some people think it's all doom and
- 1:06:02gloom. But you just told us it had
- 1:06:04tremendous impact for your course, which was created by AI.
- 1:06:09Yeah, a human created by AI in the way that, you know, some
- 1:06:12pieces I've I've collect art that is also a mix of human and
- 1:06:16art generative AI around here. And so yeah, art, it creates art
- 1:06:20too. So yes, I'm, I'm an AI bull.
- 1:06:23I'm very, very, very, very strongly in favor of the new
- 1:06:27technology. I think that it has tremendous
- 1:06:30power for good and it needs to be managed well.
- 1:06:33And we could talk about, you know, it's maybe some other
- 1:06:36time, how to make sure it remains safe.
- 1:06:39But I think people your age are living at the greatest time ever
- 1:06:42and I I think you guys have a bright future.
- 1:06:45I appreciate you sharing that, Ted.
- 1:06:46That's, that's absolutely fascinating.
- 1:06:48And yeah, just impressive that you did that one and and two it
- 1:06:52it's like, you know, I think the worry and why, you know what
- 1:06:56prompted them the school banning AII think you know, there was
- 1:07:00that report from. Another school, by the way, not
- 1:07:02my school. My school's, yeah.
- 1:07:03NYU Stern, where I teach is much more flexible.
- 1:07:06It leaves it up to. And by the way, also as an
- 1:07:08internal group, that's a lab that's taking best practices and
- 1:07:12sharing them around. I, I find them doing very
- 1:07:13innovative things. Yeah, No.
- 1:07:15That makes sense, but I was going to say like the MIT report
- 1:07:19from months ago that was like AI is making people Dumber
- 1:07:23effectively was. Following them out.
- 1:07:24Yes. And so I think that's the fear
- 1:07:26that prompts a rule like that. But what you did, and what
- 1:07:31sounds like you did is you really flipped the entire model
- 1:07:33on its head and said, no, you have to use it.
- 1:07:36And I'm actually going to force you to do things that you can't
- 1:07:38do with AI, but you can use the AI to prep.
- 1:07:41So debate presentations. Like I think that's absolutely
- 1:07:44brilliant because you can't just rely on it, right?
- 1:07:46Like if you just did the status quo class and said you guys have
- 1:07:49to use AI, everyone would just get a hundreds on the test and
- 1:07:51like it wouldn't do anything. So kudos to you.
- 1:07:55That's absolutely brilliant. And I expect a lot more shifts
- 1:07:59in just the broader education space that look a lot like what
- 1:08:02you've done. Well, I'm, I'm optimistic about
- 1:08:05it. I think the students received it
- 1:08:08very well and I learned a lot. I think they learned a lot.
- 1:08:12And you know what? It's real life.
- 1:08:14One of the things that's interesting though, is when you
- 1:08:16have AI, you can do and, and, and, and actually the three of
- 1:08:19you brought this up again at the top of the podcast.
- 1:08:22When you have AI, you could do things that are superhuman.
- 1:08:27We were talking about that, right?
- 1:08:28And the same is true in class. The same is true in class.
- 1:08:32You can do, to be able to bring 5 people together on pro or con
- 1:08:37on a debate of a topic you've never heard of before, the issue
- 1:08:41you've never discovered, you've done no research whatsoever and
- 1:08:44have a really robust debate about that topic with five to
- 1:08:47seven minutes of preparation. What, what I mean, I I was in
- 1:08:54competitive extemporaneous speaking when I was a teenager,
- 1:08:59and I have to say we would prepare quite a long time.
- 1:09:03We'd have at least 30 to 40 minutes, as I recall, to prepare
- 1:09:06for a topic of speech. And it was, it was just, so this
- 1:09:11is completely next level. And by the way, that was just,
- 1:09:14all I had to do was convince me. You're talking about getting 5
- 1:09:17or 6 MBAs together to convince themselves what's going to be
- 1:09:20the plan? How are you going to organize
- 1:09:21and everything? And they've never heard the
- 1:09:22topic before and they only have 5 to 10 minutes to do it.
- 1:09:25That is hard. And by the way, they're going to
- 1:09:28get quizzed by their other side and graded for it.
- 1:09:32Oh, did I mention that And we graded for it?
- 1:09:35Yeah, I think. Superpowers.
- 1:09:37Those those certainly are superpowers.
- 1:09:39And I certainly wish I could have taken that class.
- 1:09:41I am just thinking about 11 computer science class that I
- 1:09:45took in college and computers were actually banned, if you can
- 1:09:48believe that. So it was a, it was a computer
- 1:09:52science class that was all by hand.
- 1:09:53And that just seemed so silly to me because, you know, obviously
- 1:09:58in the real world, that's never going to be the the case.
- 1:10:00And yes, like there is definitely an aspect where you
- 1:10:06want to have the real knowledge and wisdom and be able to
- 1:10:09understand how to interact in certain situations, but you
- 1:10:13always will have other tools and not knowing how to use the tools
- 1:10:16will put you at a significant disadvantage.
- 1:10:19And humans or AI, at least today, are not really end to
- 1:10:23end, right? You had to come up with the plan
- 1:10:27and then you use the AI to help you craft that as well as that's
- 1:10:32kind of how I see businesses likely going to interact with
- 1:10:35the and people at this time to interact with AI that will allow
- 1:10:40them to solve greater and different problems and they're
- 1:10:43looking at today. But in the end of the day,
- 1:10:46people really have to understand what the problems are and what
- 1:10:49the they're at least looking for in a solution.
- 1:10:51And then the tool can help them get from A to B similar to
- 1:10:55Bitcoin too, right? Like Bitcoin is going to be the
- 1:10:58end all, be all that you want to die with and etcetera.
- 1:11:02But it's a really a tool in order for everybody to be able
- 1:11:06to create the, the better life for themselves of what they
- 1:11:09actually want, right? Like you can't live in your
- 1:11:12Bitcoin, you can't eat your Bitcoin.
- 1:11:14And so it's it's really just a greater thing you want in your
- 1:11:18toolbox. Liam, I'm old enough to remember
- 1:11:22college without computers Now. There was a big mainframe and we
- 1:11:28had the opportunity to buy a discounted IBM laptop or
- 1:11:31something, as in our first year there, as I recall, but you
- 1:11:33actually didn't have to buy it. So I had a couple of years of
- 1:11:36college without it, and I'm even old enough to remember learning
- 1:11:39arithmetic before calculators were widely available.
- 1:11:42I think the first one was like, it looks like a Casio calculator
- 1:11:46or something. It was like the early, early
- 1:11:4870s, and it had some orange top on it.
- 1:11:50I just, I don't know. So yeah, it's amazing.
- 1:11:55Well, Ted, we are very grateful for your time today.
- 1:11:58Jackson, thank you. I've enjoyed all of your
- 1:12:00questions and and also your discussion and I love the
- 1:12:02optimism. I think you guys do great things
- 1:12:05for the space and it's really an honor to be here.
- 1:12:08Thank you For anyone who is not has not followed you before, is
- 1:12:13there a place you want them to get in touch or are there any?
- 1:12:15If you have like 1 main take away that you want people to
- 1:12:17take away from the podcast, what would it be?
- 1:12:20Oh, this is a great time to be alive.
- 1:12:23It's a great time to be have the agency you talked about.
- 1:12:27It's a great time to fulfill all sorts of exciting dreams.
- 1:12:32But but the responsibility to learn about Bitcoin, to learn
- 1:12:38about how to manage yourself through this transition is
- 1:12:43really upon each individual. And, and thankfully, people have
- 1:12:49the opportunity to listen to you guys, help them for it, help
- 1:12:53them do it. And, but they have to, they have
- 1:12:56to invest, they have to actually get involved and, and what you
- 1:12:59guys are doing and making it possible.
- 1:13:01But it's this is not a time to be afraid.
- 1:13:04This is not a time to be scared. This is a time to be optimistic
- 1:13:07and lean in. I love it.
- 1:13:10Words of wisdom. Thank you, Tad, we really
- 1:13:12enjoyed the conversation. Bye guys, I really enjoyed it.
- 1:13:15Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:13:17If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:13:19episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:13:22app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:13:24today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:13:27Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:13:29for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 1:13:32nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:13:35Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:13:38to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com Contact
- 1:13:41to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:13:44advisors.