Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You've Only Been Six Months
Transcript
- Lucas: Listener Emily writes in from Portland. She is six months into a marketing coordinator role at a B2B SaaS company, and she is already running campaigns her predecessor never touched. Her boss keeps handing her more responsibility — she owns the entire lead-nurture sequence now, she's managing the vendor relationship with their email platform, and she's producing results. A 22 percent increase in lead to mql conversion, and a 14 percent reduction in cost per lead. Measurable, attributable, real. Luna: And she wants a raise. But every article she reads says wait a year. Lucas: Exactly. Her exact words were, 'I feel like I'm being greedy or entitled if I ask now. But I'm literally doing a different job than the one I was hired for.' And that is the key distinction. This isn't about tenure. This is about scope creep. Luna: Right. The 'wait a year' advice is aimed at people who are performing the same role they were hired for. If your job has changed, the clock resets. Lucas: That is the framing Emily needs. She is not asking for a raise because she wants more money for the same work. She is asking for a raise because the work has changed. Companies adjust compensation when roles evolve. That is standard practice. The question is how to present it without sounding like you're keeping score. Luna: So what does the actual conversation look like? Walk us through the prep. Lucas: Step one: document the delta. Emily should write down her original job description — the one she was hired against — and then write down what she actually does now. Not in a complaining tone. Just the facts. 'I was hired to execute email campaigns. I now design the strategy, manage the platform vendor, and report directly to the VP on lead-conversion metrics.' That is a promotion-level change in responsibility. Luna: That also protects her if her manager says 'we don't have budget.' It shifts the conversation from 'give me more money' to 'this role is now more senior, so the compensation should reflect that.' Lucas: Precisely. Step two: quantify the impact. Emily already has the numbers — 22 percent lift in conversion, 14 percent lower cost per lead. She should put those on a single sheet of paper. Not an email. A printed page or a shared doc. Something her manager can look at in real time. Luna: And what about the tenure objection? The 'you've only been here six months' pushback. How does she handle that? Lucas: She acknowledges it directly before her manager can. Something like: 'I know six months is early in a typical timeline. But I believe the role has expanded significantly beyond the original scope, and I want to make sure my compensation aligns with the value I'm delivering now — not the value I was hired to deliver.' That reframes the entire conversation. Luna: That's good. It takes the objection off the table. It says 'I've thought about this, and here's why it's different.' Lucas: And then she needs to name a number. She should have a specific figure in mind — ideally one she can justify by market data for the actual role she's doing, not the one she was hired for. She can check sites like Levels.fyi or Glassdoor for marketing manager or senior coordinator salaries at comparable SaaS companies. Luna: What if her manager says 'let's revisit this at your one-year review'? That's a common stall tactic. Lucas: She can say, 'I'm happy to revisit then, but I'd like to set a midpoint adjustment now given the scope shift. Could we do a six-month performance check-in in December and tie any increase to hitting specific targets?' That turns a no into a conditional yes. It also shows she's thinking long-term. Luna: I also think it's worth her asking whether her title can change even if the salary can't move immediately. A title change — say from coordinator to specialist or manager — sets her up for a bigger bump at the next review cycle. Lucas: That's a smart play. And it's easier for a manager to approve a title change mid-cycle than a salary change, because titles don't hit the budget the same way. But it does create a paper trail that she's operating at a higher level. Luna: Exactly. And if she gets the title, she can use that externally in six months if the salary still hasn't moved. Lucas: One more thing — timing. She should not schedule this conversation during a busy period. Not the week before a product launch, not during end of quarter crunch. She should ask for 30 minutes on her manager's calendar with a subject line like 'role evolution check-in.' Neutral, professional, not alarming. Luna: And she should practice the conversation out loud. At least twice. It sounds silly, but it makes a huge difference in how confident you sound. Lucas: Totally. One thing we hear a lot from listeners is that they freeze when the manager says something unexpected. Practicing helps you stay in control of your narrative. Luna: Yeah. And speaking of listeners — a quick honest thing. A handful of you chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that support is literally what keeps this show ad-free. If Office Hours has helped you navigate a career move like this, we'd love to have you join that group. No pressure, just gratitude. Lucas: It really does make a difference. We're able to spend the time researching and answering questions like Emily's because of that community. Thank you if you're already part of it. Luna: Alright, back to Emily. One more thing — what if her manager is defensive? What if she gets a 'you're being too aggressive' reaction? Lucas: That's a signal about the culture. If a manager penalizes an employee for asking to be paid fairly for expanded work, that's a red flag. But Emily should stay calm and reiterate that she's raising it because she wants to continue growing in the role, not because she's unhappy. She can say, 'I really love the work and I want to keep delivering at this level. I just want to make sure we're aligned on the value.' Luna: And if the answer is still no — no raise, no title change, no commitment to revisit — then she has a data point. She knows this company doesn't reward scope expansion. And she can start looking. Lucas: Exactly. The ask itself is a piece of information. If the answer is a flat no without any path forward, that tells her something about her future there. But the odds are good — if she presents it the way we've outlined, most reasonable managers will at least negotiate. Luna: Emily, you've got the results and you've got the scope. You're not being greedy. You're being professional. Go make the ask. Lucas: And let us know how it goes. We'll follow up in a future episode.