Latest / Comeback Journey: Real stories of courage & reinvention / Why Your Art Doesn't Need an Audience to Matter | Comeback Journey
Transcript
- I burned my first novel in a trash can behind the laundromat because I was terrified of being seen, and I suspect you have a similar ghost hiding in your creative closet. Let’s breathe into that. Really let it settle in your chest before we go further. There is a specific kind of loneliness that comes with creating something beautiful and keeping it entirely to yourself. It feels like holding a secret that is too heavy for one person but too fragile for anyone else to touch. You wake up with this idea humming in your veins, bright and electric, and you pour hours into it. Maybe it’s watercolor on thick paper that bleeds at the edges. Maybe it’s a playlist of songs that sound like the rain hitting your windowpane last Tuesday. Or maybe it’s just three pages of journal entries written in a font so small only you can read them. And then, you close the notebook. You tuck the sketchbook under the bed. You delete the draft from the cloud folder labeled 'Private.' You do this not because you are ashamed, but because you are protecting it. You are guarding the purity of the act itself from the messy, noisy world outside. I know this instinct well. Before I left the corporate crisis management world, I spent twenty years fixing other people’s disasters. My job was to make things look polished, to spin narratives until they sounded like triumphs. I learned how to perform competence. But in the quiet moments, when the office lights were off and the city was sleeping, I would write poetry. Terrible, awkward, honest poetry. And I never showed it to a soul. Not my husband, not my closest friends, certainly not my colleagues. If someone had asked, I would have laughed it off. I would have said I didn’t write anything. Why? Because in that world, vulnerability was a liability. Exposure was a risk. So I kept my art in the dark, where it was safe. Safe from criticism. Safe from judgment. Safe from the possibility that someone might see the raw, unedited version of my heart and find it lacking. What did it cost me? Well, it cost me the joy of connection. It cost me the chance to be known by someone who loved the weird parts of me. But mostly, it kept me alive in a way that felt manageable. We live in a culture that is obsessed with the finished product. We are told that if it isn’t published, performed, or posted, it doesn’t count. We are led to believe that creativity has a purpose only when it serves an audience. That is a lie. A very expensive, very draining lie. The truth is that the act of creation is its own reward. It is a form of prayer. It is a way of saying to the universe, I am here, and I am paying attention. When you create purely for private joy, you are reclaiming your inner life from the economy of attention. You are deciding that your satisfaction matters more than their applause. This is radical. It is quietly rebellious. Think about the last time you cooked a meal just for yourself because you wanted to taste the herbs, not because you wanted to take a photo for Instagram. You ate it alone, maybe even standing over the sink. Did it taste any less delicious? No. In fact, it probably tasted better because there was no pressure to curate the experience. Your art deserves that same grace. It deserves to exist simply because you made it. In our last episode, we talked about why hiding your joy feels safe. We discussed how we minimize our successes to avoid standing out. But there is a difference between minimizing your success and keeping your creative process private. Minimizing is about fear—fear of envy, fear of failure, fear of being seen as arrogant. Keeping your art private can be about preservation. It can be about honoring the intimacy of the moment. When I hid my poetry, I wasn’t trying to hide my worth. I was trying to protect the sanctity of the feeling. I needed a space where I could be messy without consequence. Where I could write lines that didn’t rhyme, or images that didn’t make sense, or emotions that were too sharp to share. That space was mine. And that is okay. You don’t owe the world your process. You don’t owe anyone the rough drafts of your soul. Sometimes, the most profound acts of courage are the ones no one ever sees. They are the stones you lay in the foundation of your house, unseen but essential. So why does this feel so hard? Why do we feel this tug toward visibility? Because we are wired for community. We want to be witnessed. We want to say, look what I made, and hear back, wow. That desire is natural. It is human. But it can become a trap if we tie our self-worth to the response. If the only reason we create is to get liked, then we are not creating for joy. We are creating for validation. And validation is a fickle friend. It leaves quickly. It changes shape. Private joy, however, is steady. It stays with you. It grows in the dark like roots. When you commit to creating for private joy, you are building a reservoir of strength that no algorithm can drain. You are learning to trust your own taste. You are learning to sit with the discomfort of not knowing if it will ever be shared. And in that sitting, you find a deep, abiding peace. You realize that you are enough, even if no one else ever knows you wrote the poem. You are enough, even if no one else ever sees the painting. The value is in the making, not the showing. I want to give you permission today. Permission to make something that will never leave your hands. Permission to sing in the shower without recording it. Permission to knit a scarf that you will keep for yourself. Permission to write a letter to someone and then burn it. These acts are not wasted energy. They are acts of self-love. They are ways of saying, I matter. My feelings matter. My imagination matters. Let’s breathe into that. Feel the weight lift off your shoulders. You don’t have to perform anymore. You don’t have to prove anything. You can just be. And in that being, you might find that the creativity flows easier, lighter, freer. Because it is no longer a burden to carry for others. It is a gift you give to yourself. And that is the greatest gift of all. You are allowed to start again. You are allowed to begin something new, and end it quietly, and walk away with a full heart. That is a comeback story too. One that only you will ever tell. And that is perfect. Thank you for letting me into your day. Take a deep breath. You’re doing better than you think. I’ll be right here next week. Until then, create beautifully, in secret, and with love. Goodbye for now.