Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Electric Surge and the Tesla Retreat in Europe
Transcript
- 0:10OK, let's just dive right in, because if you've been paying
- 0:12even the slightest bit of attention to the roads lately,
- 0:16you know something massive just happened.
- 0:18Oh. Absolutely.
- 0:19We're talking about a real historic moment.
- 0:21Right, December 2025, for the first time, I mean the first
- 0:25time in the history of the car battery electric vehicles, BES
- 0:29didn't just compete with petrol cars in Europe.
- 0:31They outsold them. They actually outsold them.
- 0:33The petrol era is, well, feels like it's officially over.
- 0:36It's a moment historians are going to look back on.
- 0:38Yeah, sure. We have crossed the, I mean, the
- 0:40data is just crystal clear. Yeah, petrol is in decline,
- 0:44diesel is collapsing and electric is taking the crown.
- 0:47But, and this is where the story gets really, really interesting
- 0:49for a deep dive today, while the EV market is celebrating this
- 0:52huge win, like the company that basically invented the modern EV
- 0:56market, Tesla, well, they're not exactly popping champagne corks.
- 1:01No, it's the central paradox of 2025, isn't it?
- 1:04The overall market is booming. I mean, up 51% in December
- 1:08alone, and yet Tesla is facing what analysts are literally
- 1:12calling a total bloodbath. A bloodbath.
- 1:15I mean, you don't use that word lightly in a financial report.
- 1:18So that's our mission today, to unpack what on earth happened.
- 1:22We are looking at a changing of the guard, a massive
- 1:25geopolitical shuffle and a year that just completely redefined
- 1:29who owns the European roads. And to really get it, we have to
- 1:32look past the sales numbers. We need to look at, you know,
- 1:34trade deals, factory culture, which is a story in itself, in a
- 1:40very specific agreement that was signed just two weeks.
- 1:43Ago OK, so let's start with the the shrinking elephant in the
- 1:46room, Tesla. We have the full year data for
- 1:492025. Now how bad was it?
- 1:51Really it's, it's statistically startling.
- 1:53So if you look at the whole European block, EUUK, all of it,
- 1:57Tesla's total volume dropped from about 326,000 cars in 2024
- 2:02to just over 235,000 in 2025. Whoa, it's a drop of what,
- 2:07almost 28%? 27.8.
- 2:08Percent. In a market that's growing like
- 2:09crazy, that feels like free fall.
- 2:11You're losing 1/3 of your business while everyone else is
- 2:13booming. And it gets worse when you zoom
- 2:14in. Yeah, let's talk about Germany,
- 2:15the biggest car market in Europe.
- 2:17And, you know, home to Giga Berlin.
- 2:19You'd expect a home field advantage.
- 2:21Sure. No shipping costs made in
- 2:23Germany, all that. Instead, Tesla registrations in
- 2:26Germany crashed by 48.4%. Wait, hold on.
- 2:29Almost half their sales just vanished.
- 2:31Vanished. And it wasn't just Germany.
- 2:34Sweden down almost 6 to 7%. Belgium down 53%.
- 2:38France down 37 1/2%. This is a continental retreat.
- 2:41OK, I want to get to the Y in a second, especially on France
- 2:43because I know a rule change there.
- 2:45But I have to play devil's advocate for a minute.
- 2:47I saw one green spot on the charts.
- 2:51Norway sales were up 41% there. Isn't that a good sign?
- 2:55The Norwegian exception. I'm glad you brought it up
- 2:57because it is a classic data trap.
- 2:59It's what economists call a demand pull forward.
- 3:02OK, what does that mean in simple terms?
- 3:03So Norway announced they were changing their tax incentives
- 3:06starting in 2026, basically making expensive EVs like
- 3:10Tesla's way more expensive. I see, so it's the Black Friday
- 3:13effect. Everyone rushed to buy before
- 3:15the price went up. Exactly, It was panic buying,
- 3:18not organic growth. They sold six months worth of
- 3:21cars in 1/4, which means they've created this demand Cliff for
- 3:242026. There's nobody left to buy one
- 3:27in January. Right.
- 3:28So if you take Norway out of the equation.
- 3:30The picture is almost uniformly grim.
- 3:32Got it. It's artificial inflation.
- 3:35So back to France, down 37%. Was that also tax related?
- 3:39It was France changed its bonus ecologique, the big EV subsidy.
- 3:45They started calculating the carbon footprint of the car's
- 3:48production and shipping. Oh, that's clever.
- 3:50And since the Model 3 is largely imported from China, it lost its
- 3:54subsidy overnight. Suddenly it was thousands of EUR
- 3:57more expensive than its rival. So policy is definitely a
- 3:59factor, but you can't lose 30% of your business just because of
- 4:03subsidies. There's got to be more to it.
- 4:05It's a mix of things. Product fatigues, a big one.
- 4:08The Model Y and Model 3 have been around for a while.
- 4:10The competition just has fresher, newer cars on the lot.
- 4:13It does feel like the Model Y went from being special to just
- 4:15being everywhere. It's not the cool new thing
- 4:18anymore. Precisely.
- 4:20But then there's the the sauce factor.
- 4:22Analysts are now explicitly mentioning CEO toxicity.
- 4:26You mean Elon Musk? His political statements, His
- 4:29polarization, it has alienated a segment of the European buyer
- 4:32base that, you know, tends to be more socially conscious.
- 4:36It's the classic problem when the brand becomes the man.
- 4:38And that friction isn't just with the buyers, right?
- 4:41I read some bizarre stories coming out of Giga Berlin.
- 4:43Oh, the internal culture clash, yes, between Silicon Valley move
- 4:47fast and break things and German industrial labor.
- 4:50Tell me about Muggate. This story is just wild.
- 4:53It sounds so trivial, but it's symbolic.
- 4:56Apparently 65,000 coffee mugs disappeared from the Giga Berlin
- 5:00cafeteria. 65,000 That's not theft, that's a logistics
- 5:03operation. Where do they even go?
- 5:05Nobody knows, but management made this huge deal out of it in
- 5:09staff meetings, using it as an example of a lack of discipline
- 5:12for German workers who are used to very formal Labor Relations.
- 5:15It just came across as petty and insulting.
- 5:17And then they tried to fix morale with a rap concert.
- 5:21They did. They hired a German rapper, Cool
- 5:25Savas, to perform on the back of a cyber truck inside the
- 5:29factory. A cyber truck, The car you can't
- 5:31even legally sell in Europe. Not really, no.
- 5:34Pedestrian safety rules, sharp edges, all that.
- 5:36So just picture it. A wrapper on a truck they don't
- 5:39build and can't buy. Trying to hype them up against
- 5:41unionizing while management is yelling at them about coffee
- 5:44mugs. It sounds like a scene from a
- 5:46bad corporate satire. The reports use the word cringe.
- 5:49It just shows the massive disconnect.
- 5:50OK. So while Tesla is dealing with
- 5:52missing mugs, drugs and an identity crisis, someone else is
- 5:55eating their lunch. And their breakfast.
- 5:57And their dinner. Let's talk about BYD.
- 5:59The BYD search. Right.
- 6:01So while Tesla shrank by 27%, BYD grew its European
- 6:05registration somewhere between 228% and 270%. 270% that's not
- 6:10growth, that's an explosion. It's going from a who to a major
- 6:14player in, what, 12 months? They started 2025 with about .4%
- 6:18of the market. They ended it with roughly 1.4%.
- 6:22Now that might sound small, but gaining a full point of market
- 6:24share in one year is massive in this industry.
- 6:27And where does that put them relative to Tesla?
- 6:30They've effectively caught up. Tesla's share is shrinking to
- 6:32around 1.8%. In fact, in Germany, in the UK,
- 6:36in the last couple months of the year, BYD actually registered
- 6:39more cars than Tesla did. Wow OK that's a headline BYD
- 6:44outselling Tesla in Germany. How is it just that the cars are
- 6:48cheap? Price is a huge part of it for
- 6:50sure. Models like the dolphin, the
- 6:53seagull, they're undercutting everyone.
- 6:55But it's not just price, it's strategy.
- 6:58Tesla only sells cure EVs right? BEVS, right.
- 7:02BYD sells hybrids too, and in 2025 plug in hybrids made-up
- 7:06almost 35% of the entire European market.
- 7:09So BYD is playing the whole field while Tesla is stuck in
- 7:12one lane. Exactly.
- 7:13They're meeting customers where they are.
- 7:15If you have range anxiety, they have a hybrid for you.
- 7:17If you want a cheap City car, they've got one.
- 7:19They have a whole portfolio. And they're not just shipping
- 7:21them in from China anymore, are they?
- 7:22They're putting down roots. This is the really smart part.
- 7:25Takeover plan. They're building a factory in
- 7:27Hungary. They've announced another for
- 7:29Turkey and are looking at a third in Spain.
- 7:32Hungary's in the EU. Turkey has a customs union with
- 7:35the EU. By building there they bypass
- 7:38any future tariffs. They become a European
- 7:41manufacturer. It completely changes the game.
- 7:44Speaking of tariffs, we have to talk about that big deal.
- 7:47It looked like the EU was about to slam the door with huge, like
- 7:5135% tariffs on Chinese cars. But that didn't happen, no.
- 7:56On January 12th of this year, just two weeks ago, the EU and
- 7:59China reached what they call a price undertaking agreement.
- 8:03A price undertaking? What does that actually mean?
- 8:05In a nutshell, instead of a trade war, the Chinese
- 8:08manufacturers agreed to set minimum import prices for their
- 8:11cars. So we promise not to sell them
- 8:13too cheap. Pretty much.
- 8:14It's a soft landing. It avoids a massive trade war
- 8:17that would have hurt German carmakers in China, but it still
- 8:20allows BYD to expand. It legitimizes them.
- 8:23It means they are here to stay. It really feels like a whole
- 8:26different ball game than just a year ago.
- 8:28But it's not just Tesla versus China, right?
- 8:30Where do the legacy guys like Volkswagen fit in?
- 8:33Volkswagen is still the king of the hill in terms of sheer
- 8:36volume. They have about 21% of the total
- 8:38market. They have the scale, the
- 8:40dealers, the loyalty. They are the benchmark.
- 8:43And what about Stalantis? They own Peugeot, Fiat, all
- 8:46those brands. Stalantis is fascinating.
- 8:48They're #2 with about 16% share, but they did something really
- 8:52clever. They realized they couldn't beat
- 8:54the Chinese on cost, so they joined them.
- 8:57How so? They partnered with another
- 8:59Chinese brand, Leap Motor, to sell their affordable EVs in
- 9:02Europe. It's a classic if you can't beat
- 9:04them by a stake in them, strategy.
- 9:06Smart. It really seems like the big
- 9:08theme of 2025 was democratization.
- 9:11It's not just for wealthy tech fans anymore.
- 9:13That is the absolute key shift. We've moved from early adopters
- 9:16to the mass market. Look at France's social leasing
- 9:19program. They offered EVs for €100 a
- 9:22month to low income households. €100 a month, that's less than
- 9:25my phone bill. That's incredible.
- 9:27And it got 50,000 families into electric cars.
- 9:29That changed the whole demographic.
- 9:31It's a utility now, not a luxury.
- 9:33And the infrastructure is finally catching up.
- 9:35I saw that number 1.2 million public charge points now in
- 9:39Europe. Correct.
- 9:40And critically, the walls are coming down.
- 9:44Over 70% of Tesla's Superchargers are now open to
- 9:47everyone. They've had to pivot from using
- 9:50their network as a Moat to protect sales to using it as a
- 9:53gas station, a revenue stream. Because they have to.
- 9:56If you're driving that new BYD, you might be charging it at a
- 9:59Tesla station. Exactly, and the innovation
- 10:02isn't stopping. Did you see that pilot on the
- 10:04A10 motorway in France? Wireless charging thing, yeah.
- 10:07Dynamic wireless charging, charging trucks while they
- 10:09drive. I mean, it's still just a pilot,
- 10:11but it shows where we're going beyond just plugging in.
- 10:13OK, so let's look ahead. That was 2025.
- 10:15We're in January 2026. Now what does this year look
- 10:19like? Well, the growth continues.
- 10:20Global EV sales are projected to hit 21.3 million.
- 10:24But for Tesla, 2026 can be a pivot year.
- 10:27They know the hardware game is getting tougher, so they're
- 10:29petting to software. And there's a big deadline
- 10:32coming up, isn't there? Valentine's Day.
- 10:33February 14th, Tesla is officially halting direct sales
- 10:37of the Full Self Driving Package.
- 10:39You won't be able to buy it outright anymore.
- 10:40It's moving to subscription only.
- 10:42Subscription only. It's the Netflix model for your
- 10:45car instead of 1 Big cash injection.
- 10:48When they sell the car, they want that stable recurring
- 10:51monthly revenue. But that puts immense pressure
- 10:54on the software to actually work right.
- 10:56Huge pressure. If people are paying monthly,
- 10:58they can cancel monthly. If it doesn't deliver or it, you
- 11:01know, tries to drive them into a curb, the churn will be brutal.
- 11:05So to wrap this all up, the market has matured.
- 11:07It's no longer about will EVs take over?
- 11:10The answer is yes. The question now is who's going
- 11:13to make them and who's going to make money on them?
- 11:15And Tesla is struggling to make that leap from a luxury
- 11:18disruptor to a mass market manufacturer in Europe, and BYD
- 11:23and VW are just rushing to fill that void.
- 11:26The Wild West days are over. It's industrial warfare now.
- 11:29We've crossed the Rubicon. Petrol is declining, electric is
- 11:32winning, but the brands leading the charge are completely
- 11:35shuffling. The Tesla Retreat and the BYD
- 11:38surge defined 2025. And if I can leave you with one
- 11:41final thought to Mull over. Please do.
- 11:43Look at the trends BYD and other Chinese companies are building
- 11:48the physical hardware, the factories, the batteries, the
- 11:51cars on European soil. At the same time, Tesla is
- 11:55pivoting to become a subscription software company.
- 11:58OK. Are we looking at a future say
- 12:00in 20-30 where the European auto industry means people driving
- 12:04Chinese made hardware that runs on American made software?
- 12:07That is a slightly terrifying but very plausible vision.
- 12:12The car as the new smartphone, manufactured in the East,
- 12:16programmed in the West. It raises some really big
- 12:19questions about what it even means to be a car maker in the
- 12:22next decade. Well, on that note, we'll wrap
- 12:24it up. It's a complex, fast moving
- 12:26story, but I hope we've made it clear where the road is heading.
- 12:29The electric transition is here, it's happening, but the drivers
- 12:32are changing seats. Absolutely a fascinating time.
- 12:35We want to say a huge thank you to all of you for listening.
- 12:37We know your time is valuable and we really appreciate you
- 12:40spending it with us. Thank you for listening and
- 12:42we'll catch you on the next deep dive.
- 12:44Thank you everyone.