Latest / The Vegan Report / A Deep Dive into Vietnam's Animal Rights Crisis. With Catherine Besch | Ep. 04
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:05If you're vegan for the animals and you care to do more for animal rights, but you're not sure
- 0:12where to start, then this podcast is for you. Every week, let yourself fall in love with
- 0:18passionate animal rights leaders who will inspire you to find your voice, your own special
- 0:25contribution to the animal rights movement, however small or big it is. Today we are going
- 0:33to talk about animal welfare in Vietnam. Vietnam is a land gifted with beautiful scenery, a rich
- 0:40culture and warm people, but it is also a country plagued by the dog and cat meat trade, bad vet
- 0:49care and the growing consumption of animal products. To discuss this topic, I have with me
- 0:56Catherine Besh, a lifelong animal lover and animal advocate. Kat left the US in 2007 and she gave up
- 1:05her life riding horses and managing stables in Virginia. Since graduating from Washington
- 1:12State University with a bachelor's degree in international politics and a master in disaster
- 1:20management focused on animals in disaster, and she wrote about that. I will leave a link to one of
- 1:28her articles in the description below. Kat has lived in several countries around the world,
- 1:34working as an English teacher and traveling in Europe, Asia and South America. Kat started
- 1:41Vietnam Animal Aid in 2013. It is Vietnam's first and only animal sanctuary. In 2016, she opened
- 1:52the first non-profit international vet clinic in Vietnam, which ran for several years before
- 1:59closing due to lack of funding. But the vet project will be reopening in the not so distant future
- 2:07as a mobile vet clinic and anti-species vet training program. Her work in rescue and vegan
- 2:16advocacy on the ground in Vietnam and Europe has given her a first-hand understanding of the
- 2:23political, cultural and economic context of animal rights in the global South. Thank you very much,
- 2:31Kat, for being a guest on this podcast. Thank you. Thanks for having me. Let's dive right in.
- 2:40My first question for you is what circumstances led you to live in Vietnam? It's something that
- 2:48puzzles me a bit. Could you explain? Yeah, it's sort of a strange story. I had no intent. This
- 2:56was all a totally unintended experience to run an animal rescue in Vietnam. Basically, Vietnam is
- 3:03something I've always grown up with, though. My dad was a Marine officer in Vietnam who was shot in
- 3:081966. He and my mother came back in 1971 to 1973. I'm actually a legacy in Vietnam. This is the
- 3:21country I've known about since I was born. My dad used his time in the CIA, my mom in the U.S.
- 3:29embassy, they use it as a shopping trip, essentially, because the government has to bring home all your
- 3:34household goods. My house was surrounded by Vietnamese furniture, Vietnamese art, Vietnamese
- 3:41ceramics, Vietnamese everything. I was the four-year-old who could find Vietnam on a map.
- 3:48It's just always been like that. My parents are quite older, as parents, quite a bit older.
- 3:57I kind of, they were getting older and I had left Mongolia the year before. It was horribly cold,
- 4:04if you're wondering. It's the coldest capital city in the world, Ulaanbaatar. I was like,
- 4:08you know what? I need some sunshine. This is a time in my parents' life where I want them to see
- 4:12what had happened to the country. They loved so much. I wanted to kind of bring that experience
- 4:19to them before they died. We're not real close as a family, but I thought this was something that
- 4:25would bring that to us. I mean, it didn't really work exactly, but I came and I fell in love with
- 4:32the place. I planned to stay only six months. I was doing my master's degree in disaster management
- 4:38online. I could kind of be anywhere in the world and I really wanted to follow international
- 4:42disasters. But Vietnam to me, it wasn't volcanoes and earthquakes, but we have seasonal flooding.
- 4:50I kind of took that as, okay, well, this is my disaster to write about. I got typhoons and
- 4:56flooding. I'm kind of looking at how that works in the developing world and how Global South.
- 5:04And that's just kind of what kept me here initially was that I was able to kind of
- 5:12sustain myself with my master's degree and some freelance writing while I was here. And then poof,
- 5:19I ended up with an animal rescue for the past decade and I never left.
- 5:24Yeah. Oops.
- 5:27I mean, the whole story is amazing. I did not realize how profound your relationship with
- 5:33Vietnam was. My whole life. Yeah. You have this childhood link with the country. Do you speak
- 5:41Vietnamese? My Vietnamese remains bad. Surprisingly bad considering the amount of time I've been here,
- 5:50whereas I could go to Italy for two weeks and speak better Vietnamese or speak better Italian
- 5:55than I speak Vietnamese after a decade. It's just one of those languages that requires quite a bit
- 6:01more effort than others and I've been rather busy. But yeah, I do speak Vietnamese. I, in fact,
- 6:07I say this in Vietnamese all the time. Khoi noi, thang Viet luon luon, yung ma kong hiu,
- 6:12which means I speak Vietnamese all the time. I just can't understand.
- 6:19Because people think it's a small country. I mean, if you really look at the country, it's
- 6:24actually rather large and there's a lot of dialects within there and they change significantly from
- 6:32province to province. And so it's not just as easy as like learning some words. It's like you've got
- 6:38to really understand the accents and that can be quite difficult. Yeah. But no, I'll admit,
- 6:45I haven't spent enough time fixing it. Well, that's a good segue to my next question.
- 6:50For someone who doesn't know much about Vietnam, how would you describe the place?
- 6:58Gorgeous. It's gorgeous. It's a really beautiful and extremely green country. And the food as a
- 7:08vegan is, in my opinion, the best in the world. I haven't been to some countries that I know are
- 7:14known for their vegan food like Ethiopia as well. But I can guarantee you that we have
- 7:20our, you know, we're pretty damn good here. So eating is definitely not a problem. I would say
- 7:28Vietnam is full of extremely friendly people. They call Thailand the land of smiles, which I think is
- 7:34crap. I don't think anybody smiles there. You come to Vietnam and you can see that they're just like
- 7:40a really friendly, outgoing sort of people. I think it's just warm. They're generally just really
- 7:47warm. I don't know. It's kind of, it's diverse. It's a very diverse country and people don't
- 7:55really give it that much credit for being so. I mean, we have four climate zones in the country.
- 8:00So that alone should show you that there is quite a bit of diversity. You know, like in the North,
- 8:07it's typhoon season, for example, you know, and we won't get ours until October. And like, you know,
- 8:12it just kind of varies throughout the year. So yeah, I think the diversity, the mountains,
- 8:19everything are just really different, but it is very beautiful country. And it never,
- 8:23I never stopped being surprised. You know, I think there's always more to discover,
- 8:29just getting on my motorbike and driving into the mountains. And I always feel
- 8:34a sense of wonder here. There's no escape from that. Yeah. I know. Because one of my very best
- 8:43friend, her boyfriend is Vietnamese and she recently visited Vietnam and she showed me
- 8:51some of the pictures of the place. And I was like, I need to visit this place. It's so stunning.
- 8:56It's stunning. There are beaches, there are the food, like you said, looks so yummy. Yeah.
- 9:03And the weather. We don't suffer for food. I can tell you that. Yeah. I mean, like,
- 9:09I don't want to paint a perfect picture though. Okay. Let me, let me, let me wipe the shine off
- 9:14what I just said real fast. Okay. It is a single party state with an, not an independent judiciary.
- 9:23It is highly oppressive to its own citizens. It is heavily censored. There are a lot of things. If
- 9:32you were a Vietnamese citizen, you are not living a great life in all cases. I mean, they are
- 9:38considered one of the happiest people in the world though, which is interesting. But as far as like
- 9:44having any, any, any ability to be part of the democratic process, that's not really a thing.
- 9:52It's very rare to be, to have anybody involved in the political situation here. That's not like
- 9:58a, already a suit. I call them suits, you know, the people, the people in suits, you know. So it's not
- 10:05particularly egalitarian in a lot of ways. I think women, you know, domestic violence is prevalent. I
- 10:10think animal abuse obviously is something that's a problem or I wouldn't be doing this. I think
- 10:18there's a lot of things that are negative about the traffic can be horrible. The honking is annoying.
- 10:23The karaoke makes me want to kill myself. There, you know, like I love to hate Vietnam and I hate
- 10:30to love it. It is my home in every possible sense, but it's not, it's not all shiny and pretty. I'm
- 10:38not going to, I'm not going to lie about that. I live a parallel existence as a foreigner in many
- 10:45ways, because we're kind of to Vietnam, we're a bit of like walking ATMs being that we have a lot
- 10:52of cash to input as foreigners into the system. I have a, I have a fully foreign owned business license.
- 11:00So there, there's a lot of things that give me privileges that I wouldn't have otherwise if I
- 11:06were actually from here. So I don't, I, it's important to recognize the bad with the good.
- 11:12Yes. Well, you know, I had the view of a tourist, basically someone who was, you know,
- 11:23planning my vacation and about Vietnam, but you know, even when I travel and I have traveled in
- 11:32many places around the world, I have every time witnessed a lot of displays of animal cruelty.
- 11:41Sure. Everywhere in the world. Yeah. Yeah.
- 11:44Exotic animals on leashes in South America. I visited Greece and I was...
- 11:52Oh, Greece is awful. Yeah. I was just there two weeks ago. I mean, the cats on the streets.
- 11:58I was shocked by the number of dogs just in Athens, their capital city, welcoming you every time you
- 12:05went on a stroll. And yeah, Turkey and the situation there. You know, I was thinking
- 12:16about my time in Turkey and with the number of cats outside, I wonder how are the birds doing there?
- 12:27You know, right. Not great. Probably not great. Yeah. Yeah. And I mean, I'd say the same for
- 12:33Greece. I mean, those are probably... Italy is the same population, a high population of domestic
- 12:38cats. People are not sterilizing them. I mean, there are a lot of organizations in Greece,
- 12:43at least, because they've got a lot more help because they're in that part of Europe,
- 12:47but... And they have a lot of tourists and they have, you know, still in spite of all of Greece's
- 12:53economic problems, they still have a lot of people that are putting money into those projects,
- 12:58including one of our staff, our director of operations. She lives in Greece and she does TNR,
- 13:04trap, neuter, release of cats. And so she's trying to help with getting that population down, but
- 13:11it's an endless cycle and there's not a lot... I mean, it's just so much work to keep that population
- 13:16down. And I believe those initiatives are the exception and not the rule. Yes. Yes, absolutely.
- 13:22Because there's still so many people... I was out trapping with her. I love cat trapping. I used to
- 13:26do it in Alabama and when I was living there. And it's frustrating because a lot of people think
- 13:34that it's unnatural to sterilize animals. They still have that very traditional and conservative
- 13:38mindset that it's just like, we shouldn't sterilize animals because we are taking away their natural
- 13:44right to give birth. We try to explain to them that we're trying to prevent suffering and whatever.
- 13:49And this just happened, I guess, in the past couple of weeks here as well, trying to sterilize a dog.
- 13:55And the guy was like, no, we just want her to have puppies again and again and again. And I give the
- 13:58puppies to my friend. And so we weren't allowed to... Free sterilization, we weren't allowed to do it.
- 14:04He's not interested in the wellbeing of the animal. He's interested in making sure that he is
- 14:09capitalizing upon another's reproductive system, just like you would in say the dairy industry or
- 14:16any other industry, breeding horses, for example, or breeding dogs. It doesn't really matter. It's
- 14:22all kind of part of the same vein of exploitation. Well, every time I witnessed those displays of
- 14:32cruelty toward animals or just bad, just neglect of the animal population,
- 14:40when we're talking about, like you said, cats or dogs, what frustrated me the most was the feeling
- 14:49of being powerless. I'm not my country. I don't understand this country. I don't know how to help
- 14:58those animals. And even if I had the will to do so, I can't. I'm going to leave in a few days.
- 15:09This is an impossible situation. So I just have to close my eyes, to look away, to just be in denial.
- 15:16It's hard. It's really hard. I live in a tourist town. It's the same thing. We get all these
- 15:21messages from people saying, I found this kitten on the side of the road. I'm leaving tomorrow.
- 15:26What can you take the kitten? No. Well, I mean, we can't because you're one of nine this week
- 15:34that have sent me that message. And I know you feel powerless and helpless and whatever, but like,
- 15:39I don't own an island to put all these cats on. Let's get this straight. There is just no place
- 15:44for them to go. And you have to get used to the idea that you can't help everybody. And I think
- 15:49that's one of the worst parts of being a compassionate and empathetic person is being able to close your
- 15:55eyes and say, I understand the big picture. I'm doing everything I can on a daily basis,
- 16:00particularly as vegans, to eliminate my part in exploitation, torture and murder. And that's
- 16:09bigger than what everybody else around here is doing. So I kind of, you can't help every single
- 16:17individual. There's not the resources or the homes or the space or the veterinarians. And it just
- 16:24isn't like that. I mean, I can say that after 10 years running a rescue, but ultimately it is what
- 16:31led me to run a rescue, this idea of like, I'm not going to stand for this. I won't stand for this.
- 16:38I will do something. I am somebody who can do something. Well, I want to ask you about that.
- 16:45Because contrary to me or others who have visited other countries or stayed there and
- 16:53did nothing about animal suffering, you did something. And I want to know, how did it start?
- 17:02How did the feelings of wanting to do something translated into actions?
- 17:11Yeah. Coffee. Yeah. Coffee. It's extremely strong here. This stuff's like jet fuel. Yeah, no,
- 17:21I mean, it really is. If you just go to your local Asian market, pick up some Vietnamese coffee,
- 17:27and you won't even have to ask that question. This stuff is like, I don't know, it's stronger
- 17:34than your average cocaine. Yeah. It really messes with your idea of like, it makes you feel like a
- 17:40superhero. It's a little bit like, yeah, it makes you feel like you can fly a little bit and start
- 17:47an animal rescue. And for that, I deeply regret that. But no, I mean, at the time, I'd been here
- 17:55six months. I guess I'd been here a year before, almost a year before I started the organization.
- 18:01I lived in one city for six months, and then I came to Hoi An for six months. And I had met some
- 18:05people. I met another girl who was willing to start a rescue with me. I was like, we've got to
- 18:10do something. She had like four cats at the time. And people kept giving me animals. So I ended up
- 18:15with all these animals. And I'm just like, because I'm just somebody who's always taking care of
- 18:18animals. I used to work with horses for 20 years. And then now I've got this whole thing going on.
- 18:27This is just what I do. I'm just the person that people give animals to. I've always been like that,
- 18:31even when I was just a little kid. And so I kind of had this moment. There was this dog,
- 18:39Blair, who's still with us now. And she was on the side of the road. And she was mostly bald.
- 18:46And she just was laying there. And I have this picture of her that I'll never forget. And she
- 18:50was terrified. And I just was like, you know what? No, no, not today. I'm done. I'm done. I'm done
- 18:58looking at this stuff and driving by. I can't do this anymore. And so the reason I started the
- 19:04organization was like, I realized that I couldn't afford a vet bill like that. Like, this was going
- 19:10to be out of control. And we needed to have some sort of public funding for this. So I took her to
- 19:17the vet. She was there for like a week, paid the vet bill. And then within the next couple of weeks,
- 19:24we put the organization on Facebook. And we kind of got started. And then we had a fundraising
- 19:31party and got some money. And just kind of it went from there. I had no idea how far it would go.
- 19:38I had no clue that it would end up just being we would be bombarded with animals over the next
- 19:45couple of years, particularly because we were the only people in the area doing anything.
- 19:51Central Vietnam, there was one foreign owned rescue in Saigon. But there was still none in
- 19:59Hanoi. And there was none in central Vietnam. And we were just like, we were it. And so we just
- 20:08ended up being bombarded with animals, most of them were dying anyway, and the vets were absolute
- 20:14garbage. And so they couldn't help us much. I luckily had worked with vets by working with horses,
- 20:20you know, working with horses is not the same saving kittens, by the way. I mean, the principles
- 20:25are kind of the same. But you essentially have to become a pharmacist slash drug lord, you've got to
- 20:31be able to you've got to be able to and we can get all of our we can get everything over the counter
- 20:36here. You don't have to have a prescription for anything. So we can get our antibiotics. And as
- 20:40long as you've got a formulary for you know, your dosages and can Google it. Basically, I was a
- 20:46Google vet. Because like, there's a lot of things that the veterinarian knew nothing about nothing.
- 20:52No, it wasn't that he knew nothing. It's that he made up shit. And that made it much, much worse. So
- 21:00it was it was horrendous. So within the first year, I was like, we've got to start our own vet project.
- 21:07Because it was just so bad. Well, let's start first about the state of animal welfare in Vietnam.
- 21:12You know, the reason why you felt like you needed to create your organization.
- 21:18So you talked about the care in the health care of animals. Why are the vets in Vietnam
- 21:31not skilled to deal with the current situation or with anything that has to do with, you know,
- 21:38healthcare to animals? Right. So I mean, the connection, we can't ever eliminate that connection
- 21:48between the public health care system and the veterinary industry. Right. People like to divorce
- 21:53the two and they think they're completely separate. And I think that's just ridiculous. We're doing
- 21:57that to our own detriment. So we're like 98th in the world and public health care. It's not a good
- 22:03place to be. It's not a great ranking. Just the general health care of the humans in this country
- 22:09is pretty bad. So when we talk about like being able to have animals get decent health care,
- 22:16you're starting from a horrible system that simply like they just don't understand pharmacology. They
- 22:24just don't. I mean, they'll get we have the second highest antibiotic resistance in the world. It's
- 22:28not, I mean, they'll give antibiotics out like TikToks. I mean, like it's, there's just the
- 22:34basic medicine. For people who don't know what it is. Great. So antibiotic resistance is basically,
- 22:41you know, there's all these bacteria that are becoming used to all the antibiotics that we're
- 22:48giving them. And so they evolve. They evolve to be resistant to them. And if you keep giving
- 22:55antibiotics for all these bacteria, what happens is that you're just going to end up with antibiotic
- 23:00resistance. And that becomes a huge problem for hospitals and for people and for animals and the
- 23:06entire ecosystem for that matter. It's not limited to just humans and doggies and kitties. It goes
- 23:12far beyond that. Particularly when we're talking about farmed animals and going into the food
- 23:17system and all of that. I mean, it's very, very dangerous. You know, that means if you hurt yourself,
- 23:24and it's infected, we can't cure that. Normal treatment will not have any effects because the
- 23:36bacteria is causing the infection are resistant to any kind of drugs we have. It's terrifying.
- 23:42It is absolutely, it's absolutely apocalyptic. You know, people aren't realizing that. And I mean,
- 23:49predominantly the over antibiotic use is in the animal agriculture industries. So, I mean, we do
- 23:55it with people here too, but the animals and they're all getting it way more than the people are
- 24:01even. And of course, that just creates this massive antibiotic resistant, like playground in farms and
- 24:10things like that. So, but it's the only way people know how to cure anything because the conditions
- 24:15are all really dirty. So, basic sanitation is just something they don't understand. When we had our
- 24:20vet clinic, and so eventually what happened was we had to open our own vet clinic. It was just a
- 24:24matter of like time. I mean, I saw a vet give a cesarean section without any anesthesia and I was
- 24:31like, you know what, I'm actually done with this crap. I'm not going back there. This is really
- 24:34fucked up. Pardon my French. So, we went kind of all in on the veterinary project and we hired a
- 24:44veterinary intern who had never learned how to wash her hands, who had never seen the inside of
- 24:51an animal dead or alive, who had been in veterinary school for five years, mind you, had only five
- 24:59years, never seen the inside of an animal dead or alive, never did any anatomy work, never did
- 25:04anything like that, never watched a surgery. She'd never seen a cat neutered, you know, that was
- 25:09never discussed. Did you ever ask her what she did during those five years? Oh yeah. I mean, it was
- 25:15predominantly things like studying chemistry and microbiology. It was kind of like in the US,
- 25:21we have like, you have to get a science degree and then you go to vet school. It was kind of
- 25:25like all those little things, but just books that, you know, like the veterinary books and
- 25:31that were in their veterinary library, which was tiny, it was like smaller than my tiny house.
- 25:36They were all from like decades and decades and decades ago and only one was, I remember looking
- 25:43through her library, there was one that was on canine surgery in English, of course, where
- 25:46nobody spoke any English, which is hilarious. And the book was written in 1955. That was their most
- 25:53recent book on canine surgery, 1955. I don't know about you, but we, I think, I think we can imagine
- 26:01that there's a lot that has changed since 1955 and canine surgery. So, so that was, that was a telltale
- 26:10of like a really poor education system. I've heard now that the better, the better universities are
- 26:17doing things like they have to be able to do a sterilization before they leave, but they have to
- 26:21do a sterilization before they leave the university. But frankly, nobody's learning proper sedation
- 26:26protocols at all. They're just not getting it. Their, their understanding of basic animal anatomy
- 26:34and biology is piss poor, to say the least, but their practical skills, they don't have any animal
- 26:40handling skills. They fundamentally don't believe that pain management is something that should be
- 26:45discussed. And it's not because they're bad people, predominantly the, the people going into veterinary
- 26:52medicine or those that are, that are going to work in the animal agriculture industry. So they're
- 26:56going to be either paper pushers in the animal health department that are putting their stamp at
- 27:02at slaughterhouses, or they're working in the pharmaceutical industry, which is basically just
- 27:08making antibiotics to keep farmed animals alive until we murder them. So you're not really learning
- 27:15like basic care. So it's not even just cats and dogs. I mean, you have to look quite holistically
- 27:20at the veterinary industry and where its failures are. But I think in the beginning, I didn't really
- 27:26understand how bad that was. I knew practically how they were failing. But I mean, they fundamentally
- 27:33didn't, you know, my vet here did not understand the difference between a steroid and an antibiotic
- 27:38and its function and, and applications. And it just, that's a big deal. You know, that's a really
- 27:46big deal. Yeah, it's scary. Because, you know, I have a cat and she's old. And I don't know what
- 27:53I would do if I did not have, you know, her vet. Amazing vets. Yeah. Yeah. And thinking about, you
- 28:01know, the whole animal industry, they rely a lot on the care of vets. And so you have a whole, you
- 28:12know, the frontline, the frontline information is wrong. Yes. So what do you do? And not only that,
- 28:20you have to put it in perspective of how Vietnamese culture works in terms of hierarchy. So they're
- 28:25very much like there's a lot of deference towards people of a higher rank, right. And so they're
- 28:31ranking is like, okay, well, you have a doctor, doctor's degree. So you are the word of God. And
- 28:37I'm not going to question you. Doctors, veterinarians here won't even tell you what medication they're
- 28:42giving your animals. They'll be like, oh, they have a liver infection and they get, and I'm giving him
- 28:45an injection injection of what never know. Right. So they just won't tell you that because that would
- 28:50make them lose face and they don't want to give away the information so that you'll just go to
- 28:55another vet and tell them what they've done. So it is very like, it's really sick in that way.
- 29:01And that's true in a lot of parts of the global South in terms of the, and the public health system
- 29:06is exactly the same. They won't tell you what they're giving you. They won't give you information.
- 29:11They're just like, I am, I am the doctor. This is the word of God. And this is what's going,
- 29:17this is what it comes out of my mouth. And so it must be right. Do not make me lose face by
- 29:23asking any questions or by questioning my ability to provide you with great care.
- 29:29So if nobody's asking you questions and if they do ask questions, they'll just make something up. If
- 29:34they don't know the answer, which is most of the time. So those pet owners, those people that really
- 29:38want to help their animals are not able to help their animals because the veterinarians aren't,
- 29:44aren't capable of providing just that basic care. And their, their information is, is so like, it's,
- 29:51it's the last word. Right. So, so there's, it's kind of a give and take sort of situation that
- 29:57just won't improve until the veterinary industry itself improves. And people are like, you should
- 30:01rescue animals and you should give, you know, help more animals with who, with who specifically,
- 30:07with what vets did you intend for me to rescue all these animals? And so the first few years
- 30:12or two years before we opened the vet clinic was all about just like having all these animals that
- 30:16we were watching die from things that were, that could have been treated because we simply didn't
- 30:22have the veterinarians that knew how to deal with it, could diagnose or talk to us even about what
- 30:28was going on. You know, we had hardly any diagnostics and if you don't have diagnostics,
- 30:34you don't have treatment. Okay. Like it begins with like, you have a blood machine. Well,
- 30:39do you know how much a blood machine costs? No, you don't have a blood machine, but could you do
- 30:45a blood smear? Could you look at it under the microscope and give us some answers? Well,
- 30:49they don't know what they're looking at. They weren't taught that. Right. So you're not going
- 30:53to get it. You're going to get sort of a vague, oh, they got a liver infection. Really? Are you
- 30:57sure about that? How do you know? Can you tell me why you said that? You know, oh, I'm going to give
- 31:02them an injection of B12. Well, B12 doesn't solve everything. Give them B12, atropine, ampicillin,
- 31:08and say, you know, like saline essentially. Those are these things that they just throw at every
- 31:14single animal. And they're like, surprise, animal's dead, you know? And, and we just,
- 31:19it's kind of like a situation you expect at some point to not have your problem solved when you
- 31:25go to the vet. So animal, people bring their animals to a vet knowing that it's probably like
- 31:30the last minutes of their life. So when the animal dies because of veterinary malpractice,
- 31:37it's not really surprising. Their interaction with the healthcare system as humans and with animals
- 31:43is just so negative that there's not like, they don't really expect miracles to happen at a
- 31:49veterinarian, you know, just like they wouldn't expect miracles to happen when their grandma's
- 31:53dying or to get any real help. You know, I was born in North Africa and the culture there is,
- 32:02you know, when I talk with family who still lives there and I tell them about my cat and how I
- 32:09bring her to the vet and the treatment I purchased, you know, for her, for her old age,
- 32:19they feel like it's a joke because it's just a cat. Why are you spending your money on a cat? And
- 32:29you know, an animal doctor, what is that? Right, right, right. Absolutely. I mean,
- 32:34there are people here that I've met that didn't know that a vet was a job. They didn't know that
- 32:40was a thing. So if we're saying like, you know, like the media attention of course is focused on
- 32:47that Asians are cruel to animals. I think we're missing a whole lot of that picture. This whole
- 32:54idea that there's this like savage anti-animal thing is just such a raging line of bullshit.
- 33:01It sells well. It sells well to dumb white people. But I mean, the marketing is excellent.
- 33:09But it's just a lie. It's just like they lack access. It's not like I ran a vet clinic that
- 33:14had predominantly Vietnamese staff, Vietnamese clients for almost three years. I guarantee you,
- 33:21nobody walked into that clinic thinking, I just don't care about this animal. We were
- 33:26constantly busy. You know, this idea that they don't care about animals or cruel to animals or
- 33:32whatever all the time just doesn't make any sense. I would say there's a, it's just stupid. I mean,
- 33:38they're humans, humans and animals have had a close relationship for a pretty long time.
- 33:45Well, you know, I mean, before getting into the cultural differences, and I want to get to that
- 33:50because it's such an interesting discussion. I want you to continue your description of the
- 33:58state of animal welfare in Vietnam. We talked about the healthcare and how it is completely broken,
- 34:06to say the least. What about, and we touched on that, the stray population, you know, stray cats
- 34:14and dogs. Would you say that the country is in a state of crisis in terms of the number of-
- 34:22Great. That's interesting. Yeah. No. No. Do you know why? The dog meat trade, the dog meat trade
- 34:28and the cat meat trade. Yeah. People don't really want to acknowledge what this is. People are all
- 34:33boohooing about the dog and cat meat trade and they forget that that's our population control.
- 34:38The vast majority of animals in this country are called roaming-owned dogs. So we don't have,
- 34:44we don't have a stray population. If we do, it's tiny. It's tiny, you know? And pretty much every
- 34:50dog and cat has a place it goes to get food and shelter from the rain and whatever. Are they
- 34:58taken care of there? Not necessarily, but it's not like a whole bunch of animals roaming. It's not
- 35:05like Cambodia. It's not like Laos. It's not like Thailand. It's not like, you know, it's not like
- 35:10a lot of other countries that have a large stray population where animals just literally exist
- 35:14without a person's direct care. That's not how it is. So we don't have a population control
- 35:26program in the sense that like the reason the animals still aren't lasting more than a year
- 35:32usually is disease, dog theft, animals being sold into the meat trade from people who own them. So
- 35:40it's not, so they have like a medical problem that the people aren't able to fix or whatever,
- 35:45or the animal gets old or the animal bit a kid or something like that. They're going to sell it to
- 35:50the dog meat guy. So that's always going to happen. So that's behavioral medical issues that goes in
- 35:54to the dog meat trade as well. The cat meat as well. Cat meat is quite a bit smaller, but
- 36:00cats are harder to catch to be fair. Dogs are always, cats are a little shifty, you know,
- 36:07but I would say, you know, people aren't looking at the fact that like, if you get rid of the dog
- 36:12meat trade, you have to replace that with a functional population management system. And
- 36:18what's going to happen in Vietnam is that they're going to use culling. If there is no sterilization
- 36:24program that is widespread, the Vietnamese government, no doubt in my mind will cull the
- 36:30animals with strychnine, will shoot them, whatever, which is what other countries like Myanmar have
- 36:35done and Cambodia, they just blanket kill them, you know, Egypt. I mean, there's a lot of countries
- 36:42that cull them like that, right? Because they're dealing with, you know, zoonotic diseases,
- 36:47particularly rabies. And if a kid gets bitten and gets rabies and dies, I guarantee you that entire
- 36:53population of that region is going to be culled, you know? So these are all things that like,
- 37:00we have to consider. Plus there's a lot of infectious disease they get, because animals
- 37:05aren't being vaccinated. So vaccination and sterilization have to come together, right?
- 37:10If we're going to improve the population, or the lives of the population of the existing animals,
- 37:16and prevent more from being born that are going to be born into a horrible life, we have to have
- 37:20sterilization and vaccination. Preventative care is the only care here, right? Otherwise,
- 37:26it's going to be culling and it's the dog meat trade. That's how we manage the population,
- 37:30because stray populations, man, that's how you have a lot of problems with human interaction.
- 37:36That's how you have the bites, and that's how you have the zoonotic transfers. And we just,
- 37:42I want that to be understood very, very clearly about the dog meat trade, that it is our population
- 37:49management system. And if you erase it, if you ban it, which I don't believe is going to happen
- 37:54in a country with such weak rule of law to begin with, but if you ban it and it actually works,
- 37:59then you're going to have a whole lot of strays and it's going to be a different problem. But
- 38:03they're going to die one way or another. It's just, you have to choose which way it happens.
- 38:08Well, this is a strange economical activity, because if there is a dog meat trade,
- 38:14why is there no dog farms? Why are they doing after-stray dogs?
- 38:22Right. It's not really a thing here.
- 38:24After-stray dogs.
- 38:27It's not really straight. I mean, they'll come and they'll steal them or people will sell them
- 38:31or whatever, they'll pick them up. So dog theft is a really big problem for sure. And,
- 38:38but I mean, it's so, I mean, to be clear, there's about, we estimate around 5 million dogs killed for
- 38:44meat every year. And predominantly that happens in the North, but it's really like in every village,
- 38:49the dog catcher, I just saw yesterday, same guy I've seen for the past 10 years, they do the same
- 38:54job. They just drive around slowly in the middle of the day and they can pick up animals that people
- 38:58don't want anymore and they can get, you know. And they're called dog catchers.
- 39:02This is the dog catcher. Yeah. I mean, he's just, yeah. And he'll take it to a restaurant and
- 39:07whatever. So, or they'll put them on a truck to Hanoi, something like that. I mean, the North
- 39:14eats a lot more dog meat than the rest of the country, but still, so 5 million dogs are killed
- 39:19every year, but let's compare that to the numbers in animal agriculture. So 551 million chickens are
- 39:24killed every year. That's a factor of 105 more, right? Yeah. Multiplier, 105. That's not a small
- 39:32amount. 44 million pigs are killed. So we're looking at the, if you, if you look at the whole
- 39:37picture, dogs are actually like 0.7% of the animals killed in this country, not including
- 39:44sea life. It's a tiny, tiny amount. And people just absolutely lose their minds. 5 million is a lot.
- 39:52And if I think of them, you know, like you said, if there was no dog meat trade, we would have 5
- 39:59million dogs in the streets. What? Yeah. Oh, and that 5 million doesn't stay 5 million for very long,
- 40:06does it? You know what they're doing in the streets. They're shagging. Yeah. Yeah. It's not just,
- 40:11they're not just hanging out, not making babies. That 5 million is going to be 25 million within a
- 40:16year. Right? So like you want, and what are they going to do with that 25 million? I guarantee
- 40:21you're going to find a way worse way than the dog meat trade to kill them. Guarantee it. 100%.
- 40:27That's the way the Vietnamese government works. So that's their version of, you know, protecting
- 40:32the public health. So yeah, I mean, it is, I mean, 5 million is a lot. We are a country of 97, 98
- 40:39million people. It's a very large, densely populated country. So if you kind of put it into
- 40:44perspective, I think people, people still are thinking this is a tiny little country, you know?
- 40:49I mean, it's really not. And it's very densely populated as well. So it's Asia. It's Asia. It's
- 40:57Asia. I mean, but we're so much more densely populated. Like Laos has like 6 million people in
- 41:02it and there are neighbors. It's super weird. Nobody lives in Laos. I don't know why I've never
- 41:06been to Laos, but there doesn't seem to have people in it. It's a strange exception to the
- 41:12so weird. So I can't wait to go because maybe it's actually quiet because Vietnam is not.
- 41:19So yeah, I mean, I think, I think people need to put it into the larger perspective of how many
- 41:23animals that is by comparison. Am I saying the dog meat trade is a good thing? And I think this is
- 41:27where it gets confusing. No, I am firmly against the dog meat trade. I have stopped dog catchers
- 41:33myself. I have taken animals from the dog meat trade. I have been to the restaurants. I have
- 41:39been, I've done all of this stuff. I see how they're killed. I see all of this. The dog catcher is
- 41:44in my neighborhood every single day. I don't have to wonder about the dog meat trade. This is a real
- 41:50part of my daily life. I'm not some, you know, talking head in Los Angeles or London. That's
- 41:55like, Oh boohoo, the dog meat trade. Yeah. Okay. Well you were on vacation here at the freaking
- 42:00Hilton for two weeks. You don't know diddly dick about, sorry about the, about the dog meat trade,
- 42:06but it's really true. It's just like they, all the people that cry about it are also non-vegans.
- 42:12Anyway, you can't talk about the dog meat trade. If you've got bacon grease dripping down your chin,
- 42:16I'm sorry. Like I'm just not buying it. Well, if I wasn't on a trip in Vietnam and I saw, you know,
- 42:26a scooter with a dog in a cage and someone, probably lots of them stuffed in it actually is
- 42:33what you would see, which is pretty horrible. Yeah. You know, I would look at that. I would think,
- 42:38Oh, that's what is that? And then that's it. That it's revolting. Well, I would not have,
- 42:45you know, the idea of those are going to a restaurant and people are going to eat them
- 42:52would not even register in my mind because I have this cultural bias of, Oh, the dogs are not for
- 42:58food. Dogs are, you know, our best friends. So yeah, I think there is also this bias of, you know,
- 43:06you don't really notice until you notice until you notice. And it is, it is revolting for the
- 43:13first couple of years of the organization. We talked about dog meat endlessly. I mean, it was,
- 43:18it was something even though I was vegan, I would, but I mean, I was vegan. So it kind of like,
- 43:23I feel like vegans are allowed to talk about a little more. If you're not vegan and you're
- 43:26talking about the dog meat trade, I need you to shut up. Like, it's just, I have no patience for
- 43:32that. But, but I would say, I would say in the first couple of years, it is something that you
- 43:37see and it, and it, and it shakes you to your core. You know, I remember even just in November,
- 43:43I was in Cancun, which is a big city, one of the biggest cities in the south. And, and there was a
- 43:49whole bunch of dogs just packed like there, there's no way they could have put any more in this time,
- 43:55in this small cage that they put on the back of a motorbike. And, and it really is even after all
- 44:01these years, it makes you sick. Even though I have seen, so I've seen one dog truck on the highway,
- 44:08where all the animals were stuffed in cages and they were going north. And in that time, in 10
- 44:14years of watching, of this organization and looking at animals in horrible situations, I've seen one
- 44:22dog meat truck, I've seen lots of dog catchers, but in that time I've seen thousands upon
- 44:28thousands upon thousands upon thousands of chicken trucks, duck trucks, goat trucks, cow trucks,
- 44:34pig trucks, all of these animals that are being slaughtered in such larger numbers than the dogs.
- 44:42And yet the only thing people focus on when we talk about Vietnam and when we talk about animal
- 44:47cruelty and animal welfare in general is the dogs. And you know, the thing is, I'll admit like you
- 44:53see them more. You just see them more. Dogs are such an integral part of human life in every part
- 45:02of the world. Where can you go into the world where there's not somebody with dogs? They're a big
- 45:08part of our lives. So we focus on that and I get it. They are wonderful. I love my dogs. I love dogs.
- 45:14I love animals, you know, but ultimately their suffering is an extension, not an exception. It's
- 45:24an extension of the existing industries of animal exploitation that exist all over the damn planet,
- 45:31everywhere and every country. And in fact, the Vietnamese eat one third of the meat that an
- 45:38American does. One third. That is a fraction of what Americans are producing in dead bodies.
- 45:47Do you mean like an expert?
- 45:52No, consumption. So in consumption. Yeah. So Americans eat three times as many dead bodies
- 45:59of animals that suffered and died for no good reason than the Vietnamese. Right? And I mean,
- 46:05that varies throughout the country, of course, depending on poverty levels and whatever, but
- 46:09still, yeah. Let's get into that because the best friend I mentioned, she, yeah, the food she showed
- 46:18me, you know, it looked really good, but it was also, you know, packed with meat. There was meat
- 46:26everywhere, animal products everywhere. And I was really... Is that different from Canada?
- 46:32Yeah. Well, no. No. Go to a restaurant. I mean, I come back from Alabama and I'm like, where's all
- 46:41that? How am I supposed to eat here? True. You know, like I come down, I go to Alabama and be
- 46:46like, I can't even go to a restaurant because they put butter on every damn thing. They put butter
- 46:50and cheese on steamed vegetables. I just want some steamed vegetables. Throw me a salad that doesn't
- 46:54have cheese and egg in it or chicken on top of it. You know what I mean? Like I would say,
- 46:59I would say it's much worse in other countries than Vietnam. There is a lot of cheese in
- 47:04Western, you know, cooking, but, you know, I saw a lot of meat, just lots of meat.
- 47:12But they're little pieces. Yeah. Okay. Cause you have to eat them with chopsticks,
- 47:18right? So it may look like a lot of meat, but fundamentally, if we're talking about weight,
- 47:23it's actually a tiny amount of meat by comparison to others because we don't use knives here.
- 47:29So here, I mean, in the, in the West, you have big chunks of meat that you cut with a fork and
- 47:35knife, right? Here we have to be able to get these little pieces out with chopsticks. That's right.
- 47:41Yeah. So just like the actual volume is significantly smaller. Is it in a lot of dishes?
- 47:47Yes. But here's the thing about vegan food, because we are a Buddhist country in which the
- 47:52Buddhists here, this type of Buddhism is where they are vegan twice a month, full moon and half
- 47:58moon. Some people are vegan only for two days. Some people are vegan for four days. Some people
- 48:04are vegan for 10 days. And some people are vegan all the time, right? So as a result of that, that
- 48:10is all over the country, those, all of those things that you saw that were meat, they replicate in
- 48:17vegan food, right? So every single dish is made into a vegan version of that to be fed to people
- 48:25on full and half moon. Which are called, I think, upasatha days. But that's where the surprise
- 48:34came from. The fact that, you know, I was not expecting that from Vietnam, because in my mind,
- 48:40Vietnam is a Buddhist country. So why are they eating so much meat? Why are they, you know,
- 48:48exploiting animals so much? Because you look at China and there's this big vegetarian movement
- 48:56in China. And you look at India, same thing. And you can see, you know, the influences of
- 49:03Buddhism and Hinduism and such. So I was expecting the same from Vietnam. But no, not exactly.
- 49:12I think there's a lot of, I mean, as they get richer, then this is true around the world.
- 49:17As, as countries get richer, they are also increasing the amount of dead bodies in their
- 49:24food. That is, that's just the standard graph, you know, like it just goes up together. So Vietnam is
- 49:31becoming wealthier. And they don't have like a vegan movement in that regard. They don't,
- 49:37the Buddhists don't really, I mean, they're all, you know, the all the pagodas are all vegan,
- 49:42you know, all of that. But like, ultimately, they're not like spreading the word of veganism
- 49:46on its own. It's about compassion and whatever. But ultimately, that doesn't mean that they're
- 49:53not raising animals. It doesn't mean, you know, they're not like it hasn't, or their family members
- 49:58or whatever, they're not, it's just a very different version of like the vegan movement from like the
- 50:04UK, for example, you know, but but I don't see it at all in Thailand, frankly, you know, I don't I
- 50:12mean, I mean, as far as vegan food in Thailand, I mean, I'd give a big thumbs down to that. I mean,
- 50:18like, you know, of course, like in Bangkok and stuff, it's fine. And there are lots of places
- 50:22throughout the country, but it's not at all like in Vietnam, where you can get vegan food any place
- 50:27you go. You know, there's always a chai place, chay chai. Yeah. How do you explain that disconnect
- 50:36that, you know, twice a month, they eat vegan for they get it? Yeah. Yeah. Because then all of a
- 50:43sudden, nothing. I don't get it. I don't get it. I don't get it. It makes me endlessly angry. I am
- 50:50constantly pissed off at foodists for being like, I mean, I live in a constant state of like, what
- 50:56are you missing here? Because they get it. It's like full and half. And their food is great. And
- 51:02they're eating the same stuff. And like all these great dishes and this beautiful, you know, the
- 51:08why don't you do it all the time? Exactly. You have the cultural basis, the religious spaces,
- 51:12and you have vegan food, great vegan options. So yeah, why is there no, you know, support? I
- 51:20think a lot of it is nutrition. A lot of people have this idea and are brought up with the idea of
- 51:26just like Americans that you need meat to survive, that meat makes you strong. And without it, you
- 51:31are weak, right? So I think a lot of it is nutrition based. And that's just wrong information,
- 51:38the same wrong information I was given as a child, you know, so the broken healthcare system.
- 51:44Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. And they're like, you know, it's just trying to feed people meat
- 51:50in order to be healthier. And when in reality, it's quite the opposite. But it just doesn't make
- 51:56any sense. I get it. I mean, it makes me really, it makes me really angry. I get pretty pissed off
- 52:02at foodists. Yeah. So how do Vietnamese people perceive your sanctuary? Um, that's complicated,
- 52:11because I live, you know, I live in a tourist town, right? It's a UNESCO World Heritage Site.
- 52:17So it's an old, an old city that was built by the Chinese and Japanese in the 15th century. And so
- 52:23we have this beautiful old town. And so we have a large influx of foreign influence, right? So it's
- 52:31not like I'm some weirdo for doing this. But in the beginning, it's taken a long time for them to
- 52:35to accept it. But they're still like, I'm still about three kilometers from the center, which is
- 52:42like countryside here, which I think is really funny. And, and so there's still a lot of people,
- 52:49the people that live here may have gotten wealthier from from work in town, but their education
- 52:54hasn't changed. And their experience with the world hasn't really changed that much. So I think
- 52:59I think people think it's ridiculous what we do. You know, but, but in general, but then there's
- 53:06a lot of people that really support it as well. You know, I mean, there's a lot of people, a lot
- 53:12of Vietnamese just love doggies and kitties, which is standard around the world. But the idea of being
- 53:18a vegan organization, I've been specifically like anti speciesist is something that is kind of really,
- 53:25really brand spanking new to this country. And we are the only farm sanctuary in the country.
- 53:32We're the only anti speciesist organization, we're the only vegan rescue. So that makes us
- 53:38from being an animal rescue, which they only kind of get anyway, to being a farm sanctuary
- 53:43is is a big leap, you know, and to be like somebody who loves dogs and doesn't eat pigs, like that's,
- 53:50like, why would you do that? You know, like, but that's true in every country. I don't feel like
- 53:56that. We get that same problem. And whether I'm in France or in, you know, Costa Rica, they're like,
- 54:02so wait, you love dogs, and you don't eat other animals? Are you sure that's normal? Are you okay?
- 54:11Yeah, no, I mean, really, so we are freaks in a lot of ways, not just to the local people.
- 54:18Which again, is very strange to me, because if we're talking about the West, I understand from,
- 54:26you know, the Christian Judeo Christian heritage, even, you know, in Islamic countries,
- 54:32the perception of animals has always been, you know, this is food for you. Right. And this is
- 54:39sustenance for you, you know, and there's nothing more to that. And then there are, even then there
- 54:45are a few exceptions, you know, like, who's that St. Francis of? Yeah, of Assisi. Assisi, you know,
- 54:54there are a few notable exceptions to that. And some, and of course, veganism is born in the West.
- 55:02We could say that. But if I think about Asia, and its Buddhist, you know, background, cultural
- 55:10background, and when I think about countries like India, or China, where being vegetarian and caring
- 55:17for the animals is pretty, you know, it's understandable. It's recognized. And yes,
- 55:24and no. Yeah, but yeah. Yeah. Well, you know, my favorite mock meat is Taiwanese, you know,
- 55:31right? Exactly. Yeah, get about beyond meat and the rest, you know, yeah, get my mock meat from
- 55:37a Taiwanese supermarket. They understand, you know, the palette, and they have been doing this for
- 55:46a long time. So, you know, it's so strange to see a country that has all the recipe for expanding
- 55:56their circle of compassion to every animal, exercising that kind of discrimination, you know,
- 56:03you know, dogs and cats in one category and the rest in the other. And we're going to treat
- 56:10one category as food and the other as friends. And yeah, it's just strange. I have this strange.
- 56:18I mean, there are people after all, though. And I mean, I think unfortunately, they're just kind of,
- 56:22they realize that, you know, particularly here, if you have big meat restaurants and hot pot and all
- 56:28of these things, then you get a lot of foreigners to come, you make a bunch of money off that. And
- 56:33that's kind of, you know, you also have to realize that Vietnam hasn't opened up for very long. I
- 56:38mean, it was still just in the mid to early, early to mid 90s, you know, that they finally just opened
- 56:45up after decades closed off from the world. And so they really just kind of focused on where do we
- 56:51make money? And how do we spend our money looking flashy and meat just as part of that as well?
- 56:57But it is crazy that there is sort of this like, ability to kind of separate the two. And I mean,
- 57:02like, look, I'm not going to say that people all treat animals well. I mean, they throw rocks at
- 57:07dogs. I mean, it's a huge, it's a huge difference from how you see people treating animals in other
- 57:12countries in a lot of ways. Particularly men, I would say it all comes down to patriarchal nonsense
- 57:20and that, and that they are very much like men don't do nice things for animals, you know, men
- 57:26aren't like that, you know, men, we throw rocks at dogs, we don't pet doggies, you know, that's stupid,
- 57:32you know, and so that crap just, I can't take that. I can't take any of that. But, but I mean,
- 57:37predominantly, like most of our dogs end up hating Vietnamese men. And there's a good reason for it,
- 57:43you know, I would say kind of your average country bumpkin. It's a lot like in the States as well,
- 57:50though, you know, this is my farm dog. He's my, I'm gonna keep him on a chain and he's gonna
- 57:55protect the property and whatever he's gonna bark when something happens, but I'm not gonna give him
- 58:00any basic medical care and whatever. I mean, this happens around the world and a lot of it is related
- 58:04to like, kind of, you know, socioeconomic status, for the most part, and the culture that goes with
- 58:11that socioeconomic status. Yeah. And we, like you said, we also find that in North America, I knew,
- 58:18I know shelter dogs who don't like men. They just don't, you know, they're scared of men.
- 58:27And, you know, that idea, it's not an accident. It's not an accident. Men have been the abusers
- 58:32in most of our abuse cases. And, and also this idea that if you become vegan and you're a man,
- 58:39you're doing something on manly. Yeah. You know, that we could link that to the treatment of
- 58:46animals you described from Vietnamese men. Absolutely. Yeah. It's very interesting. It's
- 58:51machismo. It's machismo and machismo exists around the world. It's not, it's not something
- 58:58exclusive to Vietnam. It's not something exclusive to Guatemala. It's not something exclusive to
- 59:04Turkey. Machismo is just kind of what is preventing, I think, a lot of otherwise decent men from
- 59:10becoming compassionate, empathetic people unable to understand that we shouldn't harm other living
- 59:17beings. Well, it's, it's interesting to see how, you know, it's like two sides of the same coin.
- 59:24Like you have animal abuse, animal exploitation, and it's common to all cultures, just like you
- 59:30have veganism and people who are compassionate to animals. Absolutely. It goes both ways. Yeah. It
- 59:35takes the form of veganism. It takes the form of Hinduism, Buddhism, all of, you know, multiple
- 59:42practices. And sometimes, you know, it roots itself in the land or sometimes I guess it doesn't like
- 59:49in Vietnam. Sure. But hopefully things will change. I mean, yeah. Yeah. But I mean, yeah, but at the
- 59:59same time, it's like, I think the one thing that has been very clear over the past decade is that
- 1:00:03like I'm a white American woman. I am not going to change this country. I can pick up the mess and
- 1:00:10I can do, I can do the fundraising that gets something to help the veterinary capacity building,
- 1:00:16but ultimately social change is not up to me. It will never be up to me. I think the whole white
- 1:00:22man's burden crap just doesn't play out. I don't have any, any illusion as to my influence in
- 1:00:34Vietnamese people's lives, you know, and the way this country is going to change over the decades.
- 1:00:40I mean, I think, I think I have more of a global reach in that regard for English speakers around
- 1:00:46the world because we write most of our posts in English. And to be like, this is what's going on
- 1:00:52here. And this is my perspective from being a, you know, a vegan in Vietnam who happens to also be
- 1:00:58American, who was the daughter of a, you know, Marine officer and CIA agent, you know, and this
- 1:01:04is my perspective is not like we're the oppressors, you know, like we're the, we were the colonizers
- 1:01:11that they kicked out. I don't have any illusions as to what I'm going to be able to do for this
- 1:01:15country. My goal is to motivate the Vietnamese themselves to create that cultural and social
- 1:01:22change and to be back up and to support them in that change. But I can't do it myself.
- 1:01:29Well, you know, you, you would be surprised because when I first became vegan and I told
- 1:01:36the elders in my family, my grandma, the first thing she said was, oh, you're eating like
- 1:01:41the elders, the ancestors of the family used to eat. Oh, really? Yes. And it was very touching
- 1:01:50to hear that because I understood there that I think part of the reason why in my culture,
- 1:02:00meat and animal products became very common was because of colonialism. You know, North Africa
- 1:02:06was colonized by the French. Vietnam was also colonized by the French. I don't know if maybe
- 1:02:13their food was influenced by the French people. I know. Yes, definitely. Very much. Yes. Well,
- 1:02:18yeah, absolutely. Might be the reason here because I know my native culture, you know, was very much
- 1:02:25in terms of food influenced by the French and a lot of, you know, meat, eggs, butter and things
- 1:02:31like that are not common to and they became common with. Right. Well, I mean, colonialism is one
- 1:02:40start, but like, let's not ignore the FAO, the Food and Agriculture Organization, the UNDP, United
- 1:02:47Nations Development. What am I? Development program? Why do I forget that? It is six o'clock in the
- 1:02:54morning. Oh, it's just like, why, great. I need another cup of coffee at this stage. Sorry. So the
- 1:03:00UNDP, the FAO, all of these organizations that are and universities that are injecting their influence
- 1:03:08and their money into increasing animal agriculture in this country. So the World Bank also has projects.
- 1:03:15You know, these are all people, these are all large organizations that are using animal agriculture
- 1:03:21as a development process and using that as livelihoods development. And I say that with
- 1:03:26air quotes for a really good reason. So I mean, like the idea that you can improve somebody's
- 1:03:31life by giving them an opportunity to exploit and kill somebody else to me is just not. I mean,
- 1:03:37that's that's that's insanity. That's absolute insanity. Well, it's fascinating. I did not make
- 1:03:44this link, but makes me think of it's absolutely international organizations and their development
- 1:03:49process. Yeah. And, you know, in Canada, we had the National Dietary Guide. And then and I remember
- 1:03:58in school, we would learn, you know, the different, you know, kind of groups of food you needed in your
- 1:04:06diet. And yeah, those animal products were there always meat and, and that guide, you know, we
- 1:04:14discovered very recently that it was sponsored by the animal industry. And there was this.
- 1:04:23Same in the US. Yeah. A lot of dietitians, you know, were saying in the country,
- 1:04:29this, this is not scientific. This guide should not should not be taught in school. And
- 1:04:35it just disappeared overnight. And I was thinking, well, this was such a, you know,
- 1:04:41a big part of my education, like, we were lied to. Yeah. And we were lied to. So I can't imagine how,
- 1:04:49you know, that influence must be great in countries where, like Vietnam, where the health
- 1:04:56care system is so broken. So yeah. Yeah. So I mean, we're adding animal products to a country
- 1:05:03in which the health care system cannot handle what happens when you add animal products,
- 1:05:07which is obviously increase in cancer. It's an increase in obesity. It's a, you know,
- 1:05:13they're feeding what they, what their main thing is doing is trying to put dairy into everything.
- 1:05:17The dairy industry is one of the strongest in the world. And in terms of animal agriculture,
- 1:05:22I mean, their marketing is exemplary. If you want to learn about good marketing,
- 1:05:26you learn about how to sell breast milk to an adult, you know, like that's, that's your,
- 1:05:30that's your best example. So they, you know, they're really pushing it on yogurts. They do a lot of,
- 1:05:36like milk teas and all of these things. You're putting milk in like a ton of different products
- 1:05:41that they never did before. And the Vietnamese have a huge lactose intolerance problem. But these
- 1:05:48international companies have come in and they're pushing it and pushing it and pushing it. These
- 1:05:52aren't usually funded by Vietnam. They're funded by international companies. One of them, one of
- 1:05:58the biggest ones is Thai and, and, and it's just, and Dutch and there's just all these sorts of,
- 1:06:05and they're like marketing is like, this is this wholesome, happy dairy cow that's out in the
- 1:06:10fields. And we're just playing, you know, this natural happy family playing, like you should see
- 1:06:16the commercials. It's absolute garbage, but they do it in, in, before a movie, you know, they have
- 1:06:21dairy and they have the dairy company commercials at the cinemas. I mean, it's incredible marketing
- 1:06:29campaign, you know, but they give them to kids all the time. And so these kids are actually becoming
- 1:06:34obese for the first time in the history of this country. You got fat kids all over now. Vietnam is
- 1:06:40the second least obese country in the world. And that's very quickly changing with the new generation
- 1:06:45of children being brought up on high sugar content yogurts, right? All these little things that
- 1:06:51they're, I mean, the Vietnamese put sugar in everything. Okay. Don't get me wrong. They love
- 1:06:54sugar. They're huge sugar fans. Um, but they have just packed that yogurt full of sugar. Why? Because
- 1:07:00that is addictive. They're getting those kids hooked on dairy early because it's sweet, right?
- 1:07:06You're not eating natural yogurt. If you're giving kids plain yogurt, they're not going to,
- 1:07:10they're not going to get excited about it. I can tell you that. Um, so, I mean, it's just this whole
- 1:07:16like push for these things, these animal products that I find it very difficult to stop, you know,
- 1:07:21if we don't have a social, a social cultural revolution, that's like, we've got to stop putting
- 1:07:28animal products in the mouths of all of these people. We have to stop producing it. We have to
- 1:07:34stop importing it. We have to stop eating like this. It's not healthy. We're supporting like
- 1:07:41environmental destruction. Not only that you're having a whole bunch of these like
- 1:07:46CAFOs built concentrated animal feeding operations that are built in places where there's just no
- 1:07:50environmental regulation, right? So all of these things that come with CAFOs, which is the water
- 1:07:56pollution, particularly, which is really bad, especially considering this is a country that
- 1:07:59is a big fishing country. You've got a whole bunch of water pollution. You're going to have dead zones
- 1:08:04up and down this, this coastline. Um, all of these things are coming from these massive investments
- 1:08:10into the dairy industry, particularly, and pig farms that are huge and chicken farms and whatever.
- 1:08:15So we're intensifying agriculture, even though I think it's only about 70% of, uh, 70% of animal
- 1:08:23agriculture in Vietnam right now, 70 to 80% is small holder farms. So that's 20 animals and under.
- 1:08:30So it continues to be like that, but that means most people have an animal.
- 1:08:34Most people have a farmed animal. This is something that you have a couple of cows,
- 1:08:38you have a couple of pigs in your backyard, you always have chickens running around.
- 1:08:42It doesn't mean that that's nicer exploitation. It's just that it's not fully, it's not making a
- 1:08:48whole lot of money. And it's just kind of, you know, the poorest people in the world happen to be
- 1:08:53animal farmers, you know, this idea that we, we are increasing their livelihoods or protecting
- 1:08:59them by ensuring that they're able to have access to the exploitation and murder of another sentient
- 1:09:04being doesn't make any sense to me, you know, with all of the run of the externalities that come with
- 1:09:11that, it's they're shooting themselves in the foot and the FAO is absolutely not going to say anything.
- 1:09:16Um, UNDP, IOM, World Bank, they're not going to do anything because they're run by people who think
- 1:09:20that farming animals is right. And that's how we increase it, you know, economic productivity.
- 1:09:27Yeah. Well, maybe briefly, but we're doing so much other damage and we're harming so many more
- 1:09:32animals. You, you gotta kind of look at the whole picture and those international organizations
- 1:09:37don't do that.
- 1:09:38Well, honestly, Kat, um, if the West is doing such a negative impact right now on Vietnam in terms of,
- 1:09:48you know, introducing animal products, I say, it's good that you're here.
- 1:09:55Yeah. Yeah. Kind of importing something good now. I hope so. Yes. And yeah, so let's talk about this.
- 1:10:06Let's talk about your sanctuary. Who are the residents there and what are your current projects?
- 1:10:13Right. So, I mean, currently we're trying really hard to get our veterinary project restarted,
- 1:10:17but we've been trying for like four to five years at this point. It's very difficult to get the money
- 1:10:22for it because people here veterinary and they just don't think that it's worthy of, um, any funding.
- 1:10:27Um, especially because we're a vegan vet clinic and an anti-speciesist project, which ruffles a few
- 1:10:34feathers, I'm not going to lie. Um, I am, I was built to ruffle feathers. That's kind of what, what
- 1:10:39my whole life purpose is, but, but anyway, it's difficult to get funding for. So we have a sanctuary
- 1:10:45where the only, like I said, the only farm sanctuary in the country, um, as far as we know,
- 1:10:50there is another one, nobody's been able to find it for us. Um, but we, um, so we've got two pig
- 1:10:56residents that are eight and 12, so basically the oldest of their breed in the entire country. Um,
- 1:11:03we've got four chickens who are lovely. They came to us just this spring. Um, come on, we've got nine
- 1:11:10kittens, which is so many. I can hear the one screaming behind me. There's four in the room,
- 1:11:15just behind me. Um, I fed you, be quiet. Um, I wanted them to be quiet during this podcast. Anyway,
- 1:11:23so, and then we've got another five that were just sterilized yesterday. Um, and we've got, I think,
- 1:11:2915 other cats. And then we've got, we're really reducing our number of dogs. We're really working
- 1:11:35hard to reduce the number of animals as much as possible because we need to put all of our funds
- 1:11:40into the veterinary project, which will ideally be a mobile veterinary clinic. So reaching the people
- 1:11:46that don't have access to veterinary care and providing vaccinations and sterilization. So
- 1:11:50ongoing preventative care in the rural regions in central Vietnam, and also being able to train,
- 1:11:57um, Vietnamese veterinarians that are fresh out of graduate or fresh out of school. So we get them
- 1:12:02before they've learned anything really stupid. And then we train them up so that they're being
- 1:12:07trained by our international veterinary staff. So this is a big project we wanted to get started
- 1:12:12in January, 2024. Um, but yeah, at the moment we have something called kitten miss, which is getting
- 1:12:20rid of all the kittens, getting them all re-homed by Christmas. We want all those babies to have
- 1:12:26homes by Christmas. Um, because, you know, people don't realize that every single animal is a real
- 1:12:31drain on our ability to do preventative work. Um, not only on our time, but also on our financial
- 1:12:38resources and physical space. Um, so we really want to get all those babies out as quickly as
- 1:12:44possible to safe and loving lifelong homes, which is far harder than you'd ever imagine it to be
- 1:12:49here. Um, so we can also export, we have, I guess, three animals going in September, um, to the, um,
- 1:12:57to Paris, and then they'll go to the UK. Um, so we do international exports as well. So if you want
- 1:13:02to adopt animals, we, we definitely can do the rabies titer test and microchip them and get them
- 1:13:08sent over within 90 days. Um, yeah, so we're able to get some animals out, but it's just a matter
- 1:13:15of like, that is a hugely expensive process that is so, so inefficient in terms of like the number
- 1:13:23of animals in need here. The biggest problem is that it takes so much. I mean, like I'm happy they
- 1:13:29all have homes. I'm really happy that I've been able to provide that. I just did three last month
- 1:13:33to the UK and Paris, and I'm super happy about that. They, they deserve lifelong loving homes,
- 1:13:40but it took so much money and so much time and effort to get them on those planes and then to
- 1:13:45get them transported. And I had to rent a car to drive across the UK to bring them to Wales in the
- 1:13:51middle of nowhere. I mean, like it was some serious work. Um, I'm super happy they're there, but like,
- 1:13:56we have to be a lot more efficient if we're going to address the problem that exists, right? Like I
- 1:14:01said, 5 million dogs are killed for dog meat every year. If we could sterilize a thousand a year,
- 1:14:07you know, like we're making a huge dent on it, but we can't do that. If I'm, if, if my time and all
- 1:14:13of my staff time is spent just trying to maintain the sanctuary, trying to just keep our heads above
- 1:14:21water in terms of funding our overhead, um, which is just been really hard. Um, and, and trying to
- 1:14:29move forward with a project that's actually going to do the amount of work that we need to do for
- 1:14:33the number of animals that are actually in need. My job is to go out of business, right? And it's
- 1:14:39to, I, I did my whole job. It's to have no more animals to rescue, right? How am I supposed to do
- 1:14:47that? If I'm focused on, on getting a puppy to Paris, you know, how am I supposed to focus on
- 1:14:52that? If all of our time is taking animals and rehabbing them and paying vet bills and then
- 1:14:57putting them on airplanes to someplace else because local adoptions are so rare. Um, yeah.
- 1:15:03You're not actively looking for them. I mean, sometimes come and just
- 1:15:08dump them. Yeah. Yeah. Most of them are being dumped on us. Um, you know, one of the poodle
- 1:15:17that went to, to Wales, she was locked in a, she was zipper tied in a beer crate and left at the
- 1:15:24end of our driveway. The four kittens that we just got right here, they were dumped on, um, at the,
- 1:15:29at the, um, shelter on the other four. They were also dumped. Um, we had to bottle feed them every
- 1:15:35three hours when we got them. That wasn't fun. Um, that takes all of my energy and sanity to do.
- 1:15:42Um, so, so yeah, I mean, like most of them, I mean, there are some that we find for sure. Um,
- 1:15:47there are some that were like, basically most of our animals that came to us came from major
- 1:15:52medical cases. So they were animals that were like in a, like actively dying and we intervened,
- 1:15:59you know, but unfortunately people, people get quite excited about that on the day that they're
- 1:16:03rescued and don't understand that the vast majority of them are going to end up not being adoptable
- 1:16:08or having very major difficulties being adopted, particularly when it comes to cats and that we're
- 1:16:14going to have them for the next 15 years, but paying those expenses for like the existing
- 1:16:18residents in a sanctuary is unbelievably difficult. People do not want to, they want, they're happy to
- 1:16:24be like, Oh, I'm going to help you pay this vet bill for this animal you got today. Okay. Well,
- 1:16:29what about the next 15 years? What are you going to do about that animal? That, um, so ongoing
- 1:16:34expenses tend to be very difficult for all rescues around the world. Um, people, it's just not, it's
- 1:16:40not sexy. Overhead isn't sexy. Um, paying vet bills for a nine year old cat that never got adopted
- 1:16:47when we got him as a kitten, um, not sexy. So, um, so unfortunately just the entire business model
- 1:16:55of sanctuary and shelter and rescue here does not function because locally it's so difficult to get
- 1:17:02adoptions. It's not, we're not in California. We're in Vietnam. Most people here, like I said,
- 1:17:06have owned roaming dogs. So the animals are not safe. We do not adopt to anybody that lets their
- 1:17:11animals roam around. So everybody that has a dog will have to have it safe indoors and in a
- 1:17:17protected garden, which 99% of people here don't have. Um, otherwise that animal is going to get
- 1:17:24stolen and killed, or it's going to end up getting an infectious disease. It's going to end up being
- 1:17:29in a traffic accident. So we don't adopt to people like that, which eliminates the entire
- 1:17:34local population for that matter. Same with cats, cats, we only will adopt to indoor homes,
- 1:17:40but it's a very hot country. Everybody has their windows open. Everybody has doors open all the
- 1:17:44time. So we can only adopt to people living in apartments and those apartment buildings have to
- 1:17:49allow cats. So that is just in general, like our ability to take animals is hampered by the fact
- 1:17:56that they got to go somewhere. You, you can't just take them. It doesn't, it actually doesn't work
- 1:18:02like that. The math doesn't work out, you know, because the amount of animals that need to be
- 1:18:07taken, we simply just don't have the capacity to just keep adding more and keep adding more and
- 1:18:14keep adding more while we're ignoring the preventative work that prevents those more from coming.
- 1:18:20Right. So that balance has to rebalance. It's way off at the moment. Well, local shelters here,
- 1:18:27you know, North America have a hard time finding homes for your residents. So you're in Vietnam,
- 1:18:34you're not in a friendly environment for, you know, animal welfare and you have to do the same job.
- 1:18:42It's 10 times harder. So you have all of my admiration. No, but you're doing some miracles
- 1:18:51here. So it's, I mean, truly amazing. And it's sad to see how, you know, even on the international
- 1:19:03scene, you know, sometimes it feels like Westerners and people in richer countries have like,
- 1:19:12have more values and medias and, you know, everyone pays more attention to what happens in the West,
- 1:19:19even if it's something minor. Absolutely. There's a catastrophe and it's taking the lives of,
- 1:19:25I don't know how many people in a poor country and nobody pays attention. But that,
- 1:19:31that same dynamic applies to animals. There are also animals in Vietnam and in other parts of the
- 1:19:41world who are suffering. And, you know, we're so focused on animals here, which is understandable.
- 1:19:51But what about the rest of the world? Because it's in their community. So it's in your community
- 1:19:55and you're paying attention to the ones there. Well, imagine that you live in a country in which
- 1:19:59nobody pays attention to that. And the people here don't pay attention to it. And the only people
- 1:20:04that pay for us to do this work live like 7,000 miles away. You also have to consider that our
- 1:20:11funding is not coming predominantly from the poor residents of the country that we live in,
- 1:20:15and a community that does not understand or care about the work that we do. Right. So they don't,
- 1:20:22they don't get what's going on predominantly and they don't want to participate in it in terms of
- 1:20:26philanthropy. So, so not only are we ignored by people abroad, because the only thing that people
- 1:20:33think about here is the dog meat trade or the Vietnam war, but we also just don't have access
- 1:20:39to the funds to keep going in terms of like rescue and rehabilitation, rehoming, you know, we just
- 1:20:45don't, I mean, it's very difficult to get people to connect to Vietnam. Most people couldn't find us
- 1:20:50on a map. So we're really in a major disadvantage. And then you add to it, the fact that we are an
- 1:20:57anti-speciesist vegan organization, which pisses everybody off, you know, like we are outspoken
- 1:21:06and absolutely will not stop talking about abolitionism. And I guarantee you that does
- 1:21:11not make us any friends. So you take a giant pool of people that otherwise would support us,
- 1:21:16even amongst the local population, because we're helping animals in general. And a lot of the
- 1:21:20Buddhists find that to be valuable. But then you then you're like, oh, but we're vegan. And they're
- 1:21:26like, oh, I don't know. That's really confrontational for me. Yeah. Why? Because you kill animals? Yeah.
- 1:21:34Yeah, you do. So we actually don't kill anybody. And I'm not going to judge you and be mean to you,
- 1:21:39but I'm not going to lie about it. You know, my son is a pig. My real son is a pig. I know that
- 1:21:46sounds insane, but he is my son. And I love him more than anything in the world. And if you think
- 1:21:51he's edible, you don't support our work and you don't love animals. If that gets you all hurt
- 1:21:57because of the, because of the fact that it confronts you, you need to look at yourself,
- 1:22:01not at me as being somebody judgmental or whatever. You need to step back and be like,
- 1:22:06am I harming animals? Yeah. We rescue animals from you. If you're not vegan,
- 1:22:13that's a hard thing for people to take in. We rescue animals from non-vegans.
- 1:22:20That is mind blowing. You are a sanctuary. What are you protecting your residents from?
- 1:22:28It's right. Local population. People that eat them, which is 98% of the human population.
- 1:22:35Right. So like it's insane that we're like, we're really having to defend ourselves against people
- 1:22:40that think my son is edible, you know, and our chickens belong on a Caesar salad. Yeah. Because
- 1:22:46they couldn't figure out that like plants have protein. I'm like, I don't know. Like stop talking
- 1:22:52to the marathon runner, Ironman Triathlete, who doesn't think that you need to murder an animal.
- 1:22:58You know, like, I'm sorry, we're not in the same boat. So like we do, we are confrontational on
- 1:23:04that degree, but it's like in that regard, I think, but that's just kind of who I am as a person.
- 1:23:09And I'm never going to stop being that. I mean, I was kind of a virulent meat eater before I was a
- 1:23:15vegan as well. I hated vegans. I told people I wanted to put them on an island in napalm.
- 1:23:22Like I just was super anti-vegan. Yeah. I was a fox hunter and I worked for the national Turkey
- 1:23:28Federation in Washington, DC. I was, I worked for the farmer's lobby. I mean, like people change.
- 1:23:33I get it. And I'm just, but people don't change unless you talk about it. So vegans that run
- 1:23:38vegans that run animal rescues that don't talk about veganism, they really upset me the most
- 1:23:43because the animals don't need silent vegans. They need people who are willing to stand up for all
- 1:23:48species. And it's not going to be the ones that are doggy loving pig eating animal rescuers. It's
- 1:23:55not going to be them. It has to be us. And we just have to stand up in it. And I guarantee you're
- 1:24:00going to lose a lot of money doing it, but ultimately we've got what 2.8 trillion animals
- 1:24:05that are unnecessarily killed every year. And I'm pretty sure if they had to choose between
- 1:24:10somebody who was just going to keep their donors happy and somebody who was going to stand up for
- 1:24:14them, they would take somebody standing up for them and taking a hit. Well, you know, at least
- 1:24:19we worked for animals. I don't work for, I don't work for the public. And at least you want to
- 1:24:24support someone who is wholeheartedly in the fight, you know, someone who looks at your sanctuary
- 1:24:34and knows that you're here for the good reasons, you know, and you're not going to,
- 1:24:41you know, this is not something about you. This is not your really, you know, you believe in your
- 1:24:48cause and if I were greedy, this would be a horrible place to be. This would be the worst
- 1:24:55possible job. You do it for the money. Really? Show me the money. Show me. I would love to see
- 1:25:03that. Well, at least people should appreciate it. Did I just forget my pin code to my ATM? Is that
- 1:25:09where the money is? Oh, no, no, no, no. We don't get anything out of this. I guarantee you there
- 1:25:15is no joy in this work. It is all about the animals and we do the best we can. I mean, it kills us all
- 1:25:21the time, but you know, we're trying to improve that. Like I said, people should at least appreciate,
- 1:25:28you know, your feelings, your sincerity in what you're doing. Sure. At the very least, you know,
- 1:25:36they know that you're not bullshitting here. Definitely not. So if listeners want to support
- 1:25:44your sanctuary, what should they do? We definitely can use the funds, but more than funds, I would say,
- 1:25:52you know, like donating is great, but so is helping us get animals adopted so that we can move on to
- 1:26:00the veterinary program. I would say being able to share our work is really nice and to be able to
- 1:26:06say, hey, there is a morally consistent animal rescue in Vietnam who loves and does not kill
- 1:26:13animals. We should support them. I would say also, you know, you can always do fundraising for us,
- 1:26:20which would be really great. Things like running a race, because I'm a big runner or I was until my
- 1:26:26foot fell apart. But I really love it when people do athletic events and they fundraise for us in
- 1:26:32that way, because that's really good for us for not only for the funds, but for marketing in general,
- 1:26:37getting the word out about us. We are in kind of a dark space in the sense of we have very small
- 1:26:45reach for the organization and just getting the word out is really, really helpful so that we have
- 1:26:52a wider reach for our work. And that gives us availability of more resources to do the work that
- 1:26:59we need to do and to get more animals adopted and to be able to get more staff, to be able to get
- 1:27:08the veterinary project rolling again and have just a wider reach to be able to do that is invaluable.
- 1:27:14And the idea of, you know, fundraising for your organization, you know, make it fun,
- 1:27:20make it something, you know, it doesn't have to be, you know, like a whole sporting event. It can be
- 1:27:25just a good fun, but it can be just not everybody like sale. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, exactly. Going
- 1:27:34door to door or having a dinner party, have a dinner party. Yeah. Or a table at the entrance
- 1:27:40of your supermarket, something like that. And, you know, talking with people, you know, gather
- 1:27:46with friends and do a game night and for your sanctuary. So yeah, it can take so many forms and
- 1:27:54it can be so fun. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. So to end this conversation, Kat, did you want to add
- 1:28:02something? Yeah, I mean, there's just one thing that I think people forget is that compassion
- 1:28:09fatigue is a big subject for me. And I think people, I want people to be a lot more compassionate to
- 1:28:15people that work in this field. Because we go through and see a lot of things that we can't
- 1:28:21necessarily always share, and we shouldn't have to share. And it can be very dark and isolating. This
- 1:28:28is an unbelievably isolating job. Even when we weren't, you know, being I think, I think being
- 1:28:37where we are, and being a vegan organization, and all of that makes it very isolating. But I think
- 1:28:42even if you're in California, it can be very isolating if you run a farm sanctuary, or a
- 1:28:46veterinary project or whatever, particularly as vegans. And we see such horrible things. And I
- 1:28:52want people to just really understand where people are coming from and to not be so, I need the peanut
- 1:28:57gallery to shut up. I would say, I would say to acknowledge that people that work in this field
- 1:29:04need days off. Not all of us can be volunteers. To be a volunteer is a financial luxury that the
- 1:29:10vast majority of us that are professional caretakers don't have. I don't have a partner,
- 1:29:16I don't have family money, I don't have, you know, like a big credit card limit. I, you know, like,
- 1:29:22we, I can't be a volunteer, I do take a very small salary. We have a hard time even justifying that
- 1:29:29we pay our staff. And I think that's insane. Not everybody's in the same situation in every part
- 1:29:35of the world. And we have to be really mindful of that. But just in general, like, understand that
- 1:29:40this is a really traumatic job. And when you send people pictures of the dog meat trader, whatever,
- 1:29:45you're constantly re, like, we see plenty of horrors. Like, we don't have any, any lack of that
- 1:29:52in our, in our brains. And it's very, very stressful. And we also have to say no to a lot of animals.
- 1:29:59And that, that sticks with us our entire lives. I mean, I, I remember every time I said no to an
- 1:30:06animal, because I know that certain death. And people get very, very, very pushy online with
- 1:30:11rescues. And it's just like, you have to take this animal, or I'm going to put them to sleep, or this
- 1:30:15person's going to get it and whatever. And sometimes people don't understand the lack of resources.
- 1:30:20Sometimes we just don't have quarantine space. Sometimes we just don't have the staff, or we
- 1:30:23don't have the money, we don't have the vets, we can't help. And we have to acknowledge and accept
- 1:30:28that we can't save everybody. And I think as long as everybody has that sort of understanding of the
- 1:30:34individual humans that do this work that I do, we can all be a lot more compassionate towards them,
- 1:30:41and ensure that they do have real breaks, that they do have a living wage, that they do have,
- 1:30:47you know, adequate staff to make sure that they don't burn out. Burn out, I mean, in the United
- 1:30:52States, the average person working in animal welfare and any sort of rescue is five and a half years.
- 1:30:58I've done double that in Vietnam, I assure you it has taken its toll. Right. So I think people need
- 1:31:03to really understand that this is a burnout job, and to be kind to the people, and not just be like,
- 1:31:09oh, you're an angel, and whatever. But then the moment we want to take a vacation, you're like,
- 1:31:14I can't believe you're taking a vacation. Yeah, well, yeah, I'm gonna, I'm going to museum today.
- 1:31:21What are you gonna do about it? You know, as someone who works in the field of fundraising,
- 1:31:26let me add to what you said, you know, you want the nonprofits, the causes that you,
- 1:31:35you are supporting to be run by professionals that are well paid, and that who have the same,
- 1:31:43you know, standards of employment that you have, because you want the best people behind your
- 1:31:49cause. You don't want, like, anybody coming in, and just doing whatever. This is not how
- 1:31:57things get done. You need professional conditions. And that's something very counterintuitive. And
- 1:32:07intuitive and it comes from, you know, this Christian background of, you know, sacrifice.
- 1:32:13Yeah, you're not doing the God's work or something like that. Right. We're being
- 1:32:20No, we're people that have student loans. Yeah, we're humans that have health insurance.
- 1:32:27We have to, we have to drive something, we have to have friends, we have to,
- 1:32:32we have to participate in the world like everybody else, or our job suppers. And I know that more
- 1:32:36than anybody, because for most of this 10 years, I didn't have any of that. And, you know, for the
- 1:32:41first three years, I didn't take a salary at all, because I was doing my master's, and I had a small
- 1:32:45income from student loans. And then I started my PhD. And so, which I had to quit because I
- 1:32:50didn't have time for. But ultimately, yeah, I got nearly 200 grand in student loan debt. It's not
- 1:32:56like, I'm in deep trouble. I'm in deep trouble for being in this job. But I live far away,
- 1:33:02come and get me America, you know, like I'm not paid it. Don't tell them I'm here. But in general,
- 1:33:12I mean, I think that we need to professionalize the nonprofit world in the sense that like,
- 1:33:17people aren't going to do good if they can't live a normal life while doing good. We can make so
- 1:33:21much more money in the private sector. If I just ran a vegan business, I would be rolling in it
- 1:33:27with the amount of effort and passion that I put into it. But instead, I'm working in a nonprofit,
- 1:33:33and I get nothing and people think I deserve nothing. And that is very frustrating.
- 1:33:39And also, I want people to think about what you are against, you know, the
- 1:33:47industry, but also the big problems that you're going against. You said,
- 1:33:51David versus Goliath situation, I try to get through a day without punching anyone. That's
- 1:33:59actually like if I get to the end of the day, and I'm like, you didn't scream at anybody,
- 1:34:03you didn't pull a knife on anyone, nobody got kicked in the face, you're doing great,
- 1:34:08cat. Keep it up. Well, that's my job here. All the possible, you know, best resources
- 1:34:14behind you, you need everything in your arsenal to go against that big giant. So yeah, amazing.
- 1:34:23So let's stop this conversation here. Okay. And I would like to express truly how
- 1:34:33I respect what you do, and I admire what you do. And I think you're so strong for doing what you're
- 1:34:39doing. And truly, thank you. Thank you for advancing the cause of animal welfare in Vietnam.
- 1:34:48And having taken the time to answer my questions and to explain to listeners,
- 1:34:56you know, what is happening there, and share your insight and experience.
- 1:35:02It's been a valuable 10 years. I learned a lot. Yeah.
- 1:35:05Exactly. You're an expert now on this topic. Yeah, definitely. Your voice on that is truly
- 1:35:12precious. So thank you very much, cat. Thank you for letting me voice that I think it's not it's not
- 1:35:18often I get to express like the things that have happened here and discuss kind of the realities
- 1:35:24on the ground. So I appreciate it. Thank you everyone for listening. Make sure to spread the
- 1:35:29word on the good work of Vietnam Animal Aid by sharing this episode with family and friends.
- 1:35:37Next week, I have a very special episode for you. I'm going to be talking with William Lowry,
- 1:35:45legal counsel for Animal Partizan, an organization labeled as a major extremist group by the animal
- 1:35:54industry, an organization suing the FBI. Subscribe now and don't miss out on this episode, which was
- 1:36:02a lot of fun to record. Finally, you can always reach me on Instagram at vegan report podcast.
- 1:36:11Thank you again, everyone for listening. Take care and see you next Tuesday.