Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Ata body experience
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:15Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe.
- 0:18Over in minutes, I was shopping earlier today and I saw a slogan like that on rice and I
- 0:25thought it might be a good phrase to say in a podcast.
- 0:28It turns out it doesn't trade mediums that well to this.
- 0:32Anyhow, we do measure this in time, whatever it is we are doing, so no matter how long
- 0:36it takes, it can be measured in minutes and be over in that time.
- 0:39We are your podcast hosts who probably aren't the best at phrasing things like that, but
- 0:44anyhow we're here and we're what you got.
- 0:46Taylor and Chelsea here today.
- 0:48I think this is somewhat a part three of Dr. Greer, but not really, but I'll let Chelsea
- 0:55take it over from here.
- 0:56That's me.
- 0:57What better way to follow up the rear of Steven Greer than the Atacama Skeleton.
- 1:03Ada for short.
- 1:04Yep, I'm really proud of that poem by the way.
- 1:07It actually took a lot of restraint on my end to not put any rhymes in the Steven Greer
- 1:12episode.
- 1:14It's a good rhyming name.
- 1:15Well then, you could have done the whole podcast of rhymes, so now I'm pissed.
- 1:19It could have just been a limerick.
- 1:20You could have just wrapped it.
- 1:23Not enough people do podcast limerick forms.
- 1:25Yeah, no, that is totally true.
- 1:28So we're talking about Ada, the Atacama Skeleton.
- 1:31Who is Ada and how does he relate to Steven Greer because he's following up his rear?
- 1:37In 2003, the skeleton was removed from the Atacama Desert in Northern Chile.
- 1:43And Taylor, feel free to jump in at any time.
- 1:45You may have consumed more Ada material than I have in all your journey.
- 1:51No, funny enough, it's just the one documentary that Steven Greer did and then mysteriously,
- 1:56he doesn't talk about it much anymore.
- 2:00That's why.
- 2:01So we watched that documentary together and I don't recall him giving a backstory on
- 2:06Ada and I'm kind of jumping around a lot here, but it'll take its shape pretty soon.
- 2:11I have faith.
- 2:12He never really gave a true background story of Ada and it's also really hard to find
- 2:18an actual background story of Ada.
- 2:20And when you first see Ada, it does not look real in any way.
- 2:24Maybe I should start by describing it.
- 2:26So he or she is found in the Atacama Desert in Northern Chile and is originally buried
- 2:33in the ghost town of La Noria.
- 2:35It's strikingly small.
- 2:37It measures just six inches or 15 centimeters.
- 2:40So that's about as long as like a freshly sharpened brand new pencil, just to put it
- 2:46into perspective.
- 2:47Slightly longer than a six inch sub from Subway because they were sued for not being their
- 2:52length.
- 2:53So there you go.
- 2:54Okay, I get what you're saying.
- 2:56It is desiccated, but it's a completely intact skeleton.
- 3:00The top of the skull has a distinct conical shape.
- 3:04So it is, you were to say conical and like regular English.
- 3:09It's like almost like a cone head kind of.
- 3:11And it see I'm more so think of it like this is the gull of what I would think a gray aliens
- 3:16head would have in it.
- 3:18You think?
- 3:19A little bit.
- 3:20But it's got more like evil face.
- 3:21Yeah, it does.
- 3:22It does look evil for sure.
- 3:24I think cone head, but maybe you're right.
- 3:26No, you know what?
- 3:27The professor in Nightmare Before Christmas.
- 3:31It's his head.
- 3:32Oh yeah.
- 3:33Okay, I can get behind that.
- 3:34Yeah.
- 3:35It also has 10 ribs.
- 3:37Normal humans have 12 on each side.
- 3:39Four ribs and the skeleton only has 10.
- 3:43Cat scan reveals internal chest organs, lungs and what appears to be the remains of a heart
- 3:49structure.
- 3:50And just to be clear, this is an actual organism.
- 3:54It has DNA that was tested and it does come back as organic and it's not a hoax or anything.
- 4:01So what they find is an organic being.
- 4:04Many UFO enthusiasts around the globe assumed this was the body of a tiny little alien just
- 4:09based on the looks of it.
- 4:10It does look really weird.
- 4:12Other onlookers suggest the bones might have come from a non-human primate.
- 4:16In any event, the specimen soon becomes world famous.
- 4:19And I just bring up too that Steven Greer brings it up in his documentary, which is outside
- 4:25of the Atacama Alien, Eric Skeleton exclusively about aliens.
- 4:29He kind of doesn't acknowledge even like publicly that he thinks it's an alien as far
- 4:34as I can tell.
- 4:36And if you take steps to really say that later on.
- 4:38Yes.
- 4:39And I will go through that.
- 4:42So Lenoria where they find it actually is an abandoned mining town and you can't really
- 4:49go there anymore because it's absolutely abandoned unless you are, you know, have four by four
- 4:55ability to get there.
- 4:56And because it was a mining town, the water sources around there did have arsenic in them,
- 5:02which will tie in in a little bit.
- 5:03Maybe that wasn't the best place to bring it up, but this is where it sits.
- 5:07So at a surfaces in 2003 falling into the possession of a treasure hunter named Oscar
- 5:13Mignoz initially discovered in the Atacama Desert, obviously it's a nitrate mining town.
- 5:19That's what they were mining.
- 5:20I did not know we'd mind that.
- 5:22Yeah, it had to do with around the wars.
- 5:25And then they found a way to synthesize it easier.
- 5:29I was listening to a podcast about it earlier.
- 5:32So most accounts say he dug up the body at a Lenorian burial site, although a few sources
- 5:39claim it was discovered lying on a shelf inside of one of the town's deserted buildings.
- 5:44So a couple of different stories there.
- 5:46Somewhere down the line, the Atacama skeleton was sold to Ramon Navia Asorio, a Spanish
- 5:53Barcelona actually business owner and private collector.
- 5:56He's also the president of the Institute for Research and Exobiological Studies, a prominent
- 6:03UFO organization.
- 6:05Navia Asorio later cross paths with longtime ufologist Stephen M. Greer at a 2009 conference.
- 6:12Greer got permission to take a bone marrow sample from Atas body.
- 6:17Okay, so was this guy into aliens?
- 6:19Like why did he end up at a Stephen Greer thing?
- 6:22Yes, he was.
- 6:23So he was something you just kind of stumbled.
- 6:26So he was the president for the Institute of Research and Exobiological Studies, which
- 6:31is a prominent UFO organization.
- 6:33So that's kind of where he would have crossed paths with Stephen M. Greer.
- 6:37Well, why?
- 6:38He's in Spain, right?
- 6:40Yeah.
- 6:41Okay, so he must have thought Stephen Greer was an important person.
- 6:45Yeah, exactly.
- 6:48So plan was to have the material from Atas body examined for Sirius, which is the documentary
- 6:54we were talking about.
- 6:56Then a microbiologist got in touch with Greer, Stanford University School of Medicine Professor
- 7:01Gary Nolan caught wind of the upcoming film.
- 7:04He became intrigued by a promotional photo showing Atas body.
- 7:08I wonder how much Atta would have cost.
- 7:10I wonder that too.
- 7:11This guy sounds like he just straight up had a lot of money and was like, yep, I want it.
- 7:16I mean, I can't say that I would see something like that and want to buy it.
- 7:20I just don't have the money for it.
- 7:22Oh, if I saw it, I would immediately say this is fake.
- 7:24Why are you trying to sell this?
- 7:25I know, right?
- 7:26This guy probably had his yacht sunk by Orcas off the coast of Portugal.
- 7:31Actually, yeah, we should follow up.
- 7:33Yeah.
- 7:34See how his yachts doing.
- 7:35It's also it's weird that like all the bones are all together.
- 7:39Like bones don't naturally stay together like that.
- 7:42Oh, I should say that it is mummified and that is just okay.
- 7:46So yeah, it's not just you can see the bones, but they're not like the actual upset layer.
- 7:50Okay.
- 7:51It's going to be one of those episodes where I just slowly leak the information to you
- 7:55that you should have the bodies.
- 7:57As you remember, we're supposed to know.
- 7:59You should know this.
- 8:01And that's just purely due to the desert like conditions that it was its home.
- 8:07I don't know how to.
- 8:08Yeah, it jerky thighs jerky bodies.
- 8:12That was it.
- 8:13Because it's super salty and dry.
- 8:15So the conditions are right to mummify it and it mummified with all its organs inside
- 8:21of it.
- 8:22So that's why it looks like that.
- 8:23It's not like decay or anything.
- 8:25It's definitely mummified.
- 8:27That was a huge part of the puzzle.
- 8:29So I apologize for putting this in here.
- 8:33So the public got a sneak preview of Nolan's research in 2013 when Science Magazine ran
- 8:39an article about his team's preliminary findings.
- 8:42Quote, the DNA was modern, abundant and high quality.
- 8:46And quote, he explained at the time, Nolan went on to say that he and his co-authors
- 8:51had revealed the Atacama skeleton, quote, is human and there's no doubt about it, quote,
- 8:57and quote, and quote again, I think, because there's a lot of quotes in there.
- 9:01Much anticipated study was finally published March 22, 2018 in the journal Genome Research.
- 9:09Genomes are the unique genetic codes possessed by all organisms.
- 9:13Using Greer's marrow sample, Nolan and his colleagues were able to carry out detailed
- 9:17whole genome analysis of the Atacama skeleton.
- 9:21When they compared Adda's genetic info to that of various primate species like the chimpanzee,
- 9:27macaque, and of course, homo sapiens, it became clear that the specimen is human.
- 9:32A close look at the chromosomes revealed she is a human female, a fetus who probably died
- 9:38in the womb.
- 9:39But hold on, how can we explain Adda's eye-catching physique, which is a lot of what Stephen Greer
- 9:45points at when he says, I mean, let's face it, he is alluding that it's extraterrestrial.
- 9:52It would be incredibly weird if being the only thing in a documentary about aliens,
- 9:58for him to not be saying it's an alien.
- 10:01Totally.
- 10:02Evidence of several genetic mutations were present in the study, and these would theoretically
- 10:07account for Adda's ribcage and cone shaped head.
- 10:10Nolan's team also stated that her bones could have aged prematurely due to yet another
- 10:15mutation.
- 10:17Given the size of the specimen and the severity of the mutations, it seems likely the specimen
- 10:22was a preterm birth, wrote the scientists in their 2018 genome research paper.
- 10:27Quote, DNA analysis on the premature human fetus identified unusual mutations associated
- 10:34with dwarfism and scoliosis, although other research contested genetic abnormalities, finding
- 10:41that the skeleton showed normal fetal development.
- 10:44There is unfounded speculation by people such as UFO theorist Stephen M. Greer that Adda
- 10:50is an extraterrestrial.
- 10:53Such speculation led to Adda's inclusion in the 2013 UFO film Serious and captured
- 10:59the attention of Stanford University, we already knew Gary P. Nolan, and tea analyze those
- 11:05remains, I don't need to say that to you again, you're all following me I'm pretty
- 11:09sure.
- 11:11So initially, thought to be older, the fetal remains had been dated to as recently as the
- 11:17late 1970s and have been found to contain high quality DNA.
- 11:22Suitable for scientific analysis, the remains have an irregularly shaped skull and a total
- 11:28of 10 ribs as opposed to 12 for adult humans, the potential signs of oxifcephaly.
- 11:37It is also noted that the frontal suture of the skull is very open and the hands and feet
- 11:41not fully ossified.
- 11:43Anatomous and paleoanthropologist William Hungers has suggested that it was a human fetus that
- 11:54was born prematurely and died before or shortly after birth.
- 11:58An alternative hypothesis by Nolan is that Adda had a combination of genetic disorders
- 12:03that led to the fetus being aborted before term and pediatric radiologist Ralph Lochman
- 12:08has said that dwarfism alone could not account for all the features found in the fetus.
- 12:14So big debate, during the DNA analysis by Nolan, the B2MT DNA haplotype group was found
- 12:24in the remains.
- 12:25Haplogroups identify human genetic populations that often are associated distinctly with
- 12:31particular geographic regions around the globe.
- 12:34Combined with the alleles found in the mitochondrial DNA contained in the remains, the findings
- 12:40suggested that Adda is indigenous to the western region of South America.
- 12:45In March 2018, Nolan published additional results stating that the fetus had a rare bone
- 12:51aging disorder as well as other genetic mutations in genes associated with dwarfism, scoliosis
- 12:58and abnormalities in the muscle and skeleton.
- 13:01The researchers identified 64 unusual mutations in 7 genes linked to the skeletal system and
- 13:07they noted that finding so many mutations that specifically affect skeletal development
- 13:13has never been reported before.
- 13:15So there's this whole debate between what's normal and what's not.
- 13:24Please Stephen Greer is pointing to the fact that a lot is not normal and we're going to
- 13:29get into it a little bit more when I talk about Stephen Greer involved with this.
- 13:40Also another reason why I mentioned the arsenic as a byproduct of whatever they were mining
- 13:50up there which would cause a lot of fetal abnormalities should somebody be drinking that arsenic water
- 13:58which was probably everyone hence why it's no longer a inhabited town.
- 14:04So that's much of the debate going back and forth between Stephen Greer and his posse
- 14:10and the scientists saying that it is a human with multiple genetic mutations present.
- 14:19I also really wish Stephen Greer would actually take a position other than just saying that's
- 14:25weird.
- 14:26Yeah we're actually going to go through his statement in full and not that long here.
- 14:32So we're going to see exactly his position.
- 14:35I just thought that I would follow up the rear on that one with you know there is a very
- 14:41differing part of this.
- 14:43They're saying it's mutations and a fetus that obviously.
- 14:48By that you mean scientists who did DNA testing on it.
- 14:51Yeah that's what they're saying Stephen Greer does say something else which is important
- 14:57but not present here so I just ad lib that for you guys so you'll see you'll see it's
- 15:02all here.
- 15:03So everything for a reason in my episode of course it's not an order but we're going
- 15:10to get there it's like a puzzle we're all here together having fun.
- 15:13Ada is very controversial and Skeleton is on the young side she's got well preserved
- 15:19DNA and based on our knowledge of how fast DNA breaks down over time it's safe to say
- 15:25that Ada is under 500 years old as I said they're thinking she's within 40 years old.
- 15:31Oh man Ada should be going through her midlife crisis right now.
- 15:34There's a decent chance that one or both of her parents are still around today.
- 15:39There's a lot of ethical questions around data that is brought up within the scientific
- 15:43community because of what's going on with her.
- 15:46We imagine how either one of the parents might feel if they lived to see their child's body
- 15:50snatch sold and then labelled as a humanoid by UFO gurus.
- 15:55One also has to wonder about how they'd react to scientists drawing international attention
- 16:00to what was for all we know a private family tragedy.
- 16:03The 2018 genome research paper faced a swift public outcry less than a week after the
- 16:09document was published the Chilean Society of Biological Anthropology and the Chilean
- 16:15Association of Archaeologists both issued statements calling the study unethical.
- 16:21Under Chilean law it is illegal to quote carry out archaeological anthropological or paleontological.
- 16:30Help me out how do you say that?
- 16:32I have no idea what words you're trying to say paleontological.
- 16:35Yeah there you go, excavations, end quote, without first getting authorization from the
- 16:39country's Council of National Monument.
- 16:42That probably didn't happen and at his case it most definitely did not as it was just
- 16:47straight up sold to a collector.
- 16:48But to be fair that list did not include treasure hunting.
- 16:51Yeah, it's true it didn't.
- 16:53Which is how he technically got it in the first place.
- 16:57It's true.
- 16:58Norbert and he Chilean researchers evolved in the genome research study which became
- 17:03another bone of legal contention.
- 17:05Wow that was not a nice pun.
- 17:07Especially when they're talking in the ethical section.
- 17:11Some of the studies biological claims were criticized too.
- 17:14A follow-up paper published in August 2018 in the International Journal of Paleo-Pathology
- 17:19chases some hard science words in this.
- 17:22That add a striking appearance could have very little to do with genetic mutations.
- 17:27Instead parts of her skeleton might have been disordered or flat out lost during her birth
- 17:32mummification or burial.
- 17:34Getting back to Nolan, he and one of his co-authors, a tool-bute of the University of San Francisco
- 17:41later penned a statement defending their research, noting that nobody on their team physically
- 17:46touched or even saw the actual skeleton.
- 17:49The two expressed their desire for Adda to be repatriated and accorded proper respect
- 17:54as human remains.
- 17:55I guess in the end it was Steven Kerr that caught all the stamp.
- 17:58We'll hear from him about the samples soon.
- 18:01Genetic mutations identified in Adda's DNA could account for her distinct physical traits
- 18:06such as her small stature, conical skull shape, and reduced number of ribs, suggesting a rare
- 18:12possibly unknown condition.
- 18:14A subsequent study published in September 2018 by an international research team led
- 18:19by New Zealand's University of Otago, associate professor of bio-archeological C.N.
- 18:28Halcro, questioned the March 2018 study by Nolan stating, quote, as experts in human
- 18:35anatomy and skeletal development, we find no evidence for any of the skeletal anomalies
- 18:40claimed by the authors.
- 18:42Their observations of anomalies represent normal skeletal development in a fetus, cranial
- 18:49molding from delivery and potential post-mortem tiphonomic effects, and that the team was
- 18:56skeptical concerning the genomic results.
- 18:59Authors also raised ethical concerns about the work by Nolan, saying that studies such
- 19:04as these that do not address ethical considerations of the deceased and their descendant communities
- 19:09threatened to undo the decades of work anthropologists and others have put in to correct past colonialist
- 19:15tendencies, end quote.
- 19:17The publishers of the early study, Genome Research, responded by stating that the ethical
- 19:22standards did not cover work on, quote, specimens of uncertain biological origins, such as the
- 19:28Atacama Skeleton, end quote, but also stated their intention to review their own policies
- 19:34on such studies.
- 19:35The authors of the Genome Research article published a response acknowledging the ethical
- 19:40concerns and calling for the repatriation of the remains.
- 19:43They distanced themselves from possible ethical missteps by largely claiming ignorance about
- 19:49the handling of the remains and the circumstances of the discovery and nothing that they were
- 19:53presented with roughly a cubic millimeter of bone to analyze.
- 19:58Okay, so here's the part we've all been waiting for.
- 20:02Let's talk about Steven Greer.
- 20:04First off, I find Steven Greer to be very hard pressed to give any background information
- 20:10on adult, like I said at the beginning of the episode.
- 20:13He'll say it came from the Atacama Desert.
- 20:15That's pretty much it.
- 20:16Fair, that's fully within how he's worked this entire time is I can't tell you much
- 20:22about anything in the past.
- 20:24I can give you a vague idea sometimes.
- 20:29That's totally true.
- 20:30But if it's important, no, we'll touch it.
- 20:31That's top secret.
- 20:32We'll touch it at all.
- 20:33He talks about Atta in detail on one of his stupid documentaries, which is serious.
- 20:38What I find hilarious about it.
- 20:40And sorry, I think we should mention serious as in the Star Serious, S-I-R-I-U-S.
- 20:45Not serious as in like this is serious stuff.
- 20:48Yeah.
- 20:49Again, it would be weird to not think it's an alien if you're putting a skeleton that
- 20:56you're biopsying and studying in a show called Serious about another star.
- 21:03What I find hilarious about it is that Greer and this other guy are super excited about
- 21:08the skeleton and they have someone do an analysis of it that does not appear on camera, which
- 21:14is Nolan, I believe.
- 21:15Now I want you to listen for yourself to my favorite part of it.
- 21:19Yeah.
- 21:20Hold on, we're going to add.
- 21:23So one of the first things that Dr. Lachman immediately remarked upon was the shape of
- 21:29the head and the skull.
- 21:31That it was not something that he is accustomed to seeing.
- 21:36Certain aspects of the skull and certain aspects of the potential mutations and syndromes
- 21:41that might account for the specimen were present.
- 21:47But what was remarkable, at least in my discussions with him, that any given syndrome often has
- 21:54co-phenotypes or co-events that would occur.
- 21:59It was quite interesting in some ways, exciting, as he would remark upon a particular feature
- 22:08of the specimen and then find that the associated features that you would expect from a syndrome
- 22:12of that nature were not found.
- 22:14What you also see is that he says it has 10 ribs.
- 22:19That was it.
- 22:20Okay.
- 22:21Okay.
- 22:22And maybe you missed it.
- 22:23I just really like that they are even like at that point establishing it in its human.
- 22:29It just has a lot of abnormalities, which they find weird.
- 22:32But like, here's the thing.
- 22:34Yeah.
- 22:35Okay.
- 22:36Yeah, it's weird.
- 22:37It's like an alien documentary.
- 22:40So I don't know if you caught it.
- 22:42They say it very like they continue talking.
- 22:45But the guy literally says, quote, say certain aspects of the potential mutations and syndromes
- 22:52that might account for the specimen present.
- 22:54Yeah.
- 22:55I know.
- 22:56That's what I was saying.
- 22:57They're like, yeah, these are rare mutations.
- 23:00That's great.
- 23:01It's a human.
- 23:02All of the things that would account for it are there.
- 23:05Yes.
- 23:06They are.
- 23:07So on Greer's website, he has a document out of Kama humanoid still a mystery.
- 23:15Danford University research by Stephen M Greer, April 22, 2013.
- 23:21And I want to find it because I thought that I had it linked here.
- 23:25I did not.
- 23:26I'm going to find it.
- 23:27We're just going to go through it.
- 23:28I swear to God I had a link in here.
- 23:31Where the fuck is this?
- 23:32It's so nice to meet this document.
- 23:34It's a freaking mess.
- 23:35Okay.
- 23:36Where are you?
- 23:37It's the one you sent me.
- 23:39I can see if I can find it.
- 23:40I'm looking for it too.
- 23:42Okay.
- 23:43I really thought it was right on the landing page.
- 23:46I go on a cruise.
- 23:49You're looking for the document I sent you, right?
- 23:51Yeah.
- 23:52Okay.
- 23:53Because he does have a whole like write up on the thing on his web page, but this is
- 23:56not what you're looking for.
- 23:57Oh, I want the document.
- 23:59Why can't I search his web page?
- 24:02Evidence and docs.
- 24:03Oh, it might be in here.
- 24:05He misgenders it in his web page.
- 24:08I know.
- 24:09Gulls of a he throughout.
- 24:10I know.
- 24:11Over here.
- 24:12It is open.
- 24:14Okay.
- 24:15I hope this is it.
- 24:18I'm pretty sure this is it.
- 24:20So it starts out May 14, 2018.
- 24:24Steven M. Grer MD, serious technology, advanced research, LLC.
- 24:28We all know how to feel about that.
- 24:30Two.
- 24:31All these people I don't care.
- 24:33Atacama skeleton.
- 24:34This is clearly an email.
- 24:36I've become aware of the recent publication in genome research of a study on the Atacama
- 24:41skeleton that has now received worldwide media attention.
- 24:45This is the one I was telling you about that says it was human for the record.
- 24:50Neither I nor anyone on my team have ever claimed that Atacama skeleton was alien, but
- 24:56only highly unusual and needed competent scientific investigation.
- 25:01Alas, the study recently published in the genome research makes a mockery of science.
- 25:09Can we just stop right there and acknowledge his tacit statement that he is not capable
- 25:15of that research?
- 25:16Yes, we can acknowledge that.
- 25:22We can bask in.
- 25:24I think that's pretty great that he's saying somebody competent.
- 25:27Yes, somebody competent, let's do it.
- 25:32So, he goes on.
- 25:33You should note that as principal investigator, and quotes PI, on this case that I was neither
- 25:39consulted nor given an opportunity to review Gary Nolan's et al findings prior to publication.
- 25:47This is unfortunate, as any qualified PhD would have found the paper deeply flawed and
- 25:53incompetent.
- 26:00Have looked into this paper and have concluded it is junk science at its worst.
- 26:07Who have written comments after studying the data?
- 26:10No, Chelsea, can we just ponder the statement junk science at its worst?
- 26:16Does that swing the pendulum back to competent again?
- 26:19If it's bad junk science?
- 26:21Yeah, a double negative.
- 26:24A bad bad guy might be a good guy.
- 26:27You're right.
- 26:28Back it good.
- 26:29This is good science.
- 26:30It's a great science.
- 26:31It's bad junk science.
- 26:34It's good science.
- 26:38Have concerned that?
- 26:39Have spent tens of thousands of dollars obtaining the sample at our expense.
- 26:45Danford UCSF and genome research journal have published a false defaming and inaccurate
- 26:52paper that does not substantiate harm to the cause of science and to me personally.
- 26:58I just in picturing him like he was defamed by this.
- 27:01You read it.
- 27:02I've been with one finger so fast.
- 27:05You think just like you would get like 10 taps and then you just get a heavy sigh and
- 27:09then like eight more taps and then a heavy sigh and then the pace.
- 27:14Yeah, I can't see how he would be defamed by this.
- 27:17And then he comes back and he flips the chair around and has to go back.
- 27:21In the end it probably got him more exposure than he regularly has.
- 27:27In my opinion.
- 27:28Aside from the legal and ethical questions of such a paper being published and garnishing
- 27:34worldwide media coverage without my knowledge or advice, there is the damage to the underlying
- 27:40purpose to discover what the Atigama skeleton is.
- 27:51Oh man.
- 27:55It goes on.
- 27:56Oh I know I saw it.
- 27:59Oh we're reading all of this.
- 28:00I need to look at this document with you.
- 28:02I wasn't going to and then I actually looked at it and we have to.
- 28:06The bone samples provided were done so with assurances from Nolan that a thorough and
- 28:12objective study would be made.
- 28:14However, all of the PhD geneticists that have delved into his data and methodology assure
- 28:21me it was done at best incompetently and at worst, and this is their belief, fraudulently,
- 28:29lack of controls, the methods used and so forth were so blatantly incompetent that they're
- 28:36only conclusion is that the study was corrupted from the beginning to obtain a predetermined
- 28:41conclusion.
- 28:43This is not science.
- 28:44It is politics or something else.
- 28:47He has a lot of big stuff.
- 28:51This is trying to think of one more example of what it could be.
- 28:57Oh at that point, at that point there was a heavy sigh of pace and he's like you know
- 29:03what screw it.
- 29:04I'm going to put something else and move on.
- 29:06I'm furious.
- 29:08I really like that he couldn't name the PhD friends that he had talked to who said this
- 29:15was junk science.
- 29:17That wouldn't help my case at all saying who specifically stated that this was bad.
- 29:21Oh no you couldn't do that.
- 29:22You can't do that.
- 29:23You're just too mad.
- 29:24Friend.
- 29:25It's a stream of consciousness thing.
- 29:26No, he's a friend.
- 29:27Yeah, he's too enraged.
- 29:28It's a friend of a friend.
- 29:30God damn it.
- 29:32Finally the study had no controls.
- 29:34It was not a reference free DNA study.
- 29:38Data was cherry picked and key data left out.
- 29:42Example, 360,000 triploid alleles and was done with antiquated technology and methodology.
- 29:51I've been assured that any competent peer review process would have given the paper
- 29:57a zero score and returned it.
- 30:00This has been peer reviewed, correct?
- 30:02Like I think we mentioned that.
- 30:04Yeah.
- 30:05Is that what peers do is market?
- 30:07Yeah, they give you a zero or a higher score than a zero I assume.
- 30:11The assertion that the skeleton is a deformed fetus, allegedly female, which is why he says
- 30:23that on his website, is unfounded by the data and the clinical medical findings.
- 30:29See Dr. Lockman's report attached that there were seven de novo mutations resulting in the
- 30:36scene biological specimen is spurious and without scientific foundation.
- 30:41Others have included that had there been such widespread genetic damage that the embryo
- 30:46would never have been able to divide and develop further.
- 30:51It died in the womb.
- 30:52Like yeah, it seems it got slightly further than he just had, but it died in the womb.
- 30:57To me, that's what makes the most sense.
- 31:00Two PhD scientists with deep knowledge and expertise in DNA sequencing have assured
- 31:05me the study was faked from the very beginning and that the report could not have been properly
- 31:11peer reviewed.
- 31:12Assured.
- 31:13That's an interesting way to put that.
- 31:15Assured.
- 31:16Assured.
- 31:17That's an interesting way to put that.
- 31:18Assured.
- 31:19Assured.
- 31:20Assured.
- 31:21Assured.
- 31:22Assured.
- 31:23Assured.
- 31:24Assured.
- 31:25Assured.
- 31:26Assured.
- 31:27Assured.
- 31:28Assured.
- 31:29Assured.
- 31:30Assured.
- 31:31Assured.
- 31:32Assured.
- 31:33And I say that.
- 31:34I'll just put it here.
- 31:35Assured.
- 31:36Assured.
- 31:37Assured.
- 31:38Assured.
- 31:39That's what he did.
- 31:40Okay, I can totally see that.
- 31:41I am an MD and not a PhD geneticist, so he's incompetent as an editor.
- 31:52He cannot do it. He's not confident.
- 31:54But he can clearly spot the issues of somebody who actually knows what they're doing doing
- 32:00it.
- 32:01He knows it. Yeah, it was done wrong.
- 32:02Mostly because they didn't...
- 32:03Not a page.
- 32:04I just want to put this in here. He's mad that they didn't run it by him first, despite
- 32:09the fact that he fully acknowledges he has no expertise in this area.
- 32:14Okay, just wait. When we get to the end, he has it all in bullet form when he's unhappy.
- 32:19He just... Oh man, he got so fuming, he just couldn't even form structure anymore.
- 32:26I am not a PhD geneticist, however, I can attest that even the statement that we told
- 32:32Nolan the specimen was thousands of years old is false.
- 32:37Clinically and archaeologically, we knew it was from early in the 20th century or the
- 32:42late 19th century.
- 32:44This was reported to Nolan specifically. He asserted it is 40 years old, although there
- 32:49is no evidence for this either.
- 32:52But the strata of ruins in which the skeleton was found is from the late 1900s, 1930 or
- 32:59so.
- 33:00So I'm pretty sure in the documentary he mentioned it several times that it's... it could be
- 33:05hundreds of years old, correct?
- 33:07Yeah.
- 33:08And he's even saying, I agree with what he found that it was in the 1900s and then he
- 33:13shits all over him again.
- 33:17There were also studies showing the specimen was around 6 years of age, a finding nullified
- 33:23by the fanciful idea that it prematurely aged in utero, in brackets progeria.
- 33:30Nolan's own research assistant found a similar creature from 1996 in Russia.
- 33:36See attached email and Russian photos also found in an area of alleged UFO events.
- 33:42Nolan asserted to me that if there were two of these unusual creatures that the likelihood
- 33:46the attic hamam one was a deformed human was nil.
- 33:49Why?
- 33:50Nolan was fully aware of these clinical and historical facts prior to completing this
- 33:55study and report.
- 33:56I don't know why.
- 33:57Why?
- 33:58Doesn't say why.
- 33:59Yeah.
- 34:00Can't say why.
- 34:01He was fully aware that...
- 34:02Otherwise the why would be in there.
- 34:03I really feel like you should explain yourself if you're saying that like, oh, finding another
- 34:08one shows it can't be an abnormality, but does that not add to the likelihood that it's
- 34:14a genetic abnormality that can exist out there?
- 34:17Well in his mind it must add to the fact that it's an alien.
- 34:20But he's also said he knew it wasn't an alien right at the beginning of it.
- 34:25Yeah, he's true to it.
- 34:27And he's started this off saying I knew it wasn't an alien and also I am not an expert
- 34:32in this subject matter and you should not take me seriously.
- 34:35But...
- 34:36We need some more confidence to do this.
- 34:38It has also come to my attention that Nolan received a $3.2 Department of Defense teal
- 34:46award approximately...
- 34:47Did you say $3.2 or $3.2 million?
- 34:50Well it just says $3.2 with a dollar sign, Department of Defense teal award.
- 34:55There's no million or anything.
- 34:58Approximately one month after I provided the DNA samples to him on October 2012, C-Attach.
- 35:05This document is really just like a gold mine.
- 35:07I first opened it up and I was like this is bullshit I'm not even reading this.
- 35:12And then I read a little bit to see what he had to say and I was like holy shit this is
- 35:15a gold mine of amazing bits.
- 35:18Oh yeah I was in the middle of this.
- 35:20It was separate people, the director of the film Sirius and a member of my team who met
- 35:24privately with Tristan Harris, I don't know who that is, have stated that Nolan was induced
- 35:29to say the specimen was a deformed human by federal agents or someone connected to the
- 35:34US government and that is why he reached the spurious scientific conclusion.
- 35:39Scientific was enclosed by the way.
- 35:41If true, if is capitalized.
- 35:45If true, this constitutes fraud and scientific corruption at its worst.
- 35:52We need a full state, federal and academic investigation into this case to determine
- 35:56how this study came to these conclusions whether fraud was committed if federal or state funds
- 36:02were used and why the study published in an obscure journal gained such media attention.
- 36:08Something tells me he's going to be hard pressed to do that.
- 36:11Recently Nolan has become associated with a group called To The Stars Academy.
- 36:18Headed up by a former rock star, this group C attached article is packed with former in
- 36:25brackets question mark current and quote Pentagon and CIA operatives well known for running
- 36:32scams on the US government and American people.
- 36:36See email for senior CIA official written to me attached.
- 36:41Was it this group or there is assets that arrange for global media coverage of Nolan's
- 36:47findings.
- 36:48I'd just like to point out at this time that he is working with Richard Doty, Steven Greer
- 36:53by the way, just in case we weren't clear and David Wilcock.
- 36:56I mean, Doty has the bigger implications.
- 36:58David Wilcock just asked.
- 37:00Oh yeah, that's fair.
- 37:04All of these issues need a full and a partial investigation by academic conduct committees
- 37:09and offices that handle legal and ethical problems.
- 37:12Sorry, I'm laughing because he really does hate to the stars.
- 37:18He really wants to get him.
- 37:21I ask that here are his demands.
- 37:24Number one, you provide me with the peer review comments from the genome research related
- 37:29to Nolan's paper.
- 37:31You return to me any unused DNA materials from the specimen that I provided to Nolan.
- 37:38Three, compensate me for the cost involved in obtaining the sample in the damage to my
- 37:43reputation, travel time and damage to my intellectual property in brackets serious and others and
- 37:51bracket to be determined by arbitration or other means if necessary.
- 37:56Wouldn't you have to go to court for arbitration?
- 37:58No courts a different avenue.
- 38:02But it's very easy to actually file a complaint, an ethics complaint with the university, which
- 38:08I was trying to look up.
- 38:09See if he did it.
- 38:10Like he wants to apparently he sued Fox.
- 38:12I'm just learning this now.
- 38:13He would put it in this fucking report if you wanted to.
- 38:17But I just learned this.
- 38:18Is everything else is fucking in here.
- 38:19He sued Fox News in 2020.
- 38:22What?
- 38:23Stephen Greer sued Fox News in 2020.
- 38:26I just learned this because I was trying to find if he filed an ethics complaint with
- 38:29the university.
- 38:30I don't know what to do with that information.
- 38:31It might be a follow up.
- 38:33Next one launch a full I lost count.
- 38:35I was numbering these by the way he has them bullet point launch a full and impartial investigation
- 38:40headed by competent scientists knowledgeable in sequencing DNA from ancient or old samples
- 38:48to document where the scientific method broke down.
- 38:51Next launch a full and partial investigation to determine if there was a corruption by
- 38:55financial interest governmental and national security interests and the media.
- 39:00Next a full report on who funded the Nolan study and if any state or federal funds personal
- 39:06equipment etc were involved.
- 39:09I should also note that two renowned PhD genetic experts have spoken to me and stated emphatically
- 39:16that they offered their help to Nolan to do the study properly and that he refused their
- 39:20assistance.
- 39:21One of these scientists at the time headed up a company that did state of the art reference
- 39:26free DNA sequencing offered his company services to Nolan.
- 39:30He refused.
- 39:31Sorry.
- 39:32I am at a loss there.
- 39:35People contacted him and said hey you're probably going to screw this up.
- 39:38Can we help Nolan?
- 39:39Yeah.
- 39:40Okay.
- 39:41Yeah.
- 39:42And then they put the person's name in there who offered their help which again he hates
- 39:47details.
- 39:48That's his friend.
- 39:49Yeah.
- 39:50But also he's saying hey your university probably has shit equipment come use our company's
- 39:56equipment for what I'm assuming isn't just going to be out of the goodness of his heart.
- 40:01And he probably didn't even say his name.
- 40:03He was probably like hey I'm Stephen Gruse friend.
- 40:05Yeah.
- 40:06Want to come use my equipment.
- 40:07I told him a name.
- 40:08I'm just a friend.
- 40:09Which you would be right to decline.
- 40:15Both of these scientists have assured me that the study must have been corrupted from the
- 40:19beginning.
- 40:20Sense and competence at this level from Stanford and UCSF is simply not plausible.
- 40:27I do not know.
- 40:28We must get to the bottom of what happened.
- 40:31How and why.
- 40:32Ultimately we need to address what exactly is the Atacoma skeleton.
- 40:37That was such weird grammar in that sentence.
- 40:40This Nolan study muddies the water and brings no scientific clarity to the question.
- 40:45So we are back where we started when I first saw the specimen in 2009.
- 40:50Unfortunately it is unlikely we will obtain another sample of the bone marrow DNA since
- 40:54Nolan's behavior has so disgusted the owner of the specimen.
- 40:58He wishes no further involvement.
- 41:00Isn't that convenient.
- 41:01Who can blame him.
- 41:03This Yasko has damaged my relationship with this person and others.
- 41:08He's such a witty irreparably.
- 41:11You blew your one and only chance.
- 41:19You can't screw up any more than that.
- 41:25So bad that he won't even give more DNA to prove that he was wrong.
- 41:29If this skeleton represents a here to for unknown species.
- 41:35I'm here to for.
- 41:37He could really just said previously but he's in that kind of mood.
- 41:40Yep he is.
- 41:41We have lost a great deal to the advancement of science.
- 41:45We lost our we could have had so many chances but you just did it so bad that was it.
- 41:53We did it good it would have been unlimited chances.
- 41:57I don't think I don't think unlimited.
- 42:00See the skeletons only six inches.
- 42:03But more than one.
- 42:05See the owner of the skeleton is too pissed too.
- 42:09We lost our only chance.
- 42:10Okay never mind it was the only chance based on that.
- 42:15Your review.
- 42:18These are all emails too.
- 42:19They're not even just peer reviews.
- 42:21They're emails.
- 42:22Okay where's the next thing I wanted to discuss with you.
- 42:27Dr. Lachman's letter and full report.
- 42:30Here's Dr. Nolan's report.
- 42:32Thank you very much for the opportunity to examine the radiographic images of the specimen.
- 42:37I've examined in the course of my career many skeleton and other pediatric bone anomalies
- 42:43and dysmorphias especially in the field of skeletal dysplasias and syndromes.
- 42:49The specimen does not fall under any known to me class of disorders or syndromes as
- 42:54I told you during our last meeting when I formally went over the images in preparation
- 42:59for the formal report.
- 43:00There's no known form of dwarfism and that accounts for all the anomalies seen in the
- 43:05specimen.
- 43:06Most interestingly based on knee epiphyseal standards the specimen appears to be six to
- 43:12eight years of age.
- 43:14While there remains a possibility this latter result is due to some form of unknown criteria.
- 43:20The aging syndrome in my opinion this is a low probability.
- 43:24This is the one that is on the documentary.
- 43:27Yeah.
- 43:28So this is where Stephen Greer gets that it's like a six to eight year old.
- 43:33Yeah and crazy how studying it in a different way might give you a different conclusion.
- 43:37Yeah so this is what we see they're looking at this document on the documentary clip where
- 43:43it says definitely all the things that could be wrong with it are there as far as abnormalities.
- 43:50So it just goes through like basically physically what it looks like thorax 10 ribs narrow thorax
- 43:57with otherwise normal ribs elongated clavicles blah blah.
- 44:02Email to Dr. Nolan.
- 44:03Oh no it's not an angry email it's just about the Russian.
- 44:07Oh what does it say it's about the Russian skeleton.
- 44:10Begin forwarded message from Gary Nolan April 10 to Stephen Greer subject a very similar
- 44:16specimen below.
- 44:17I don't even know why these emails are in here from Aaron Simmons to Gary Nolan subject
- 44:24read there's no subject on this one.
- 44:26I just says nice the adjicam is specimen looks a bit like Alexis of kitsch Tim discovered
- 44:34in 1996.
- 44:35Here's the most informative account on Alexis that I found thought the English is poor.
- 44:40It's a link.
- 44:41The video at the end is a highlight.
- 44:43I wonder if you'll get the opportunity to do deep sequencing on Alexis if this is due
- 44:48to a rare mutation then having a second sample might reveal it.
- 44:51Yes.
- 44:52And I'm reading this because he includes some really weird things like this like just afforded
- 44:59email.
- 45:00Oh here's the you know how we said the senior CIA is acknowledgement that the stars are
- 45:07okay.
- 45:08Oh yeah.
- 45:09Sorry.
- 45:10Yeah.
- 45:11It says sent from my iPhone.
- 45:14Again forwarded message from he took out the email.
- 45:17Of course.
- 45:18Date December 31 to Steve Greer regarding subject with no alien DNA.
- 45:23Hi Steve.
- 45:25Glad to hear all is fine.
- 45:26I have watched that rat pack run scams against the US government.
- 45:30Looney billionaires and now average citizens keep up the good work.
- 45:34That's literally that's how he knows.
- 45:37That's it.
- 45:38That's it.
- 45:39That's it.
- 45:40Well that's how you know.
- 45:43Then he has a whole thing in this document to the Scars Academy team and this is basically
- 45:49what we went through when we did the two to stars episode.
- 45:53So it just lists all the people into the stars and like where they come from and what their
- 45:59title is within.
- 46:00He just has this in this document which is just fricking weird and that's the document.
- 46:09This is what he has on his web page that's easily accessible to everybody on.
- 46:14Isn't that a weird document?
- 46:16And he's just throwing to the stars under because Nolan's a part of them.
- 46:20I don't know.
- 46:21I just that's why I had to go through it.
- 46:22I was just like what the fuck was that?
- 46:24Oh man that's great.
- 46:26And I think a pretty good example that our listeners can see of don't send an email when
- 46:33you're angry.
- 46:34Sit on it for at least a day.
- 46:38At least save it as a draft and go back and edit it.
- 46:42Yeah that's what I thought I would end up on.
- 46:46Add as a really strange little alien being.
- 46:50Widely not discredited because it is something.
- 46:56It is agreed on that it is weird.
- 46:58I think I don't think there's anybody who says yep just a normal fetus.
- 47:01Yeah but I mean not everybody stumbles on to what is probably a miscarried fetus every
- 47:09day and is looking at it in the eyes of I've found an alien being.
- 47:15That also Chilly has asked for it to be returned.
- 47:18Yes it said that it would.
- 47:20Yeah and you're Stephen Inker is saying he lost his one and only DNA sample because one
- 47:27never gets a chance to look at it again because it was so incompetently looked at.
- 47:35Giving us all a new answer to what's the worst that could happen.
- 47:40Yeah what is the worst that could happen.
- 47:43Apparently what happened to Stephen Inker is the worst case scenario.
- 47:47But yeah it's a funny story.
- 47:50Ada.
- 47:51Quite sad in the end if you look at it from the eyes of you know the Chilean government
- 47:56trying to get it back because of how ethics were not followed very well given it.
- 48:02But yeah kind of fuzzy.
- 48:04Nobody really knows where it came from.
- 48:05We know where it is right now.
- 48:07And yeah then you just leave it with Stephen Greer.
- 48:11And this is where I think that he's the only person pushing any narrative with it anymore.
- 48:17And he doesn't talk about it that much anymore either.
- 48:20It's more so it's just like I think it builds his rage.
- 48:24And actually it gives some context of why he's calling to the stars out.
- 48:29More than there was.
- 48:30Yeah a little bit.
- 48:31I quite enjoyed that that was in there.
- 48:33And his fricking evidence of it with this one liner email where you don't even put
- 48:39a name in it.
- 48:40Like oh my god.
- 48:41Oh no it would be weirder if he actually put a name in it Chelsea.
- 48:45Yeah.
- 48:46And I actually think.
- 48:47I'm surprised that he puts that email in but he didn't put any of the emails saying well
- 48:52maybe it was in the peer review.
- 48:54Maybe those were his friends because I didn't actually read those with you.
- 48:58But peer review I say that with air quotes around it.
- 49:04But I was going to say oh the things where people were saying that it was so incompetently
- 49:08done was not in there.
- 49:10Maybe I just skipped over it though.
- 49:11Yeah I was actually hoping.
- 49:13The weirdest answer I think could have actually happened was when they were running those original
- 49:18genetic tests and they started talking about the monkeys.
- 49:21Even if it turned out it was a chimpanzee in the middle of Chile from the 70s.
- 49:28But I could see him still being so focused on how it was incompetently done because it
- 49:32was tied back to something on her.
- 49:36Not the other implications of it.
- 49:39And I'll be the first to admit that's why you're here on Journey to the Fringe.
- 49:42It was a little all over the place with me explaining it.
- 49:46But in the end we got to where we needed to.
- 49:48We got the main course and it was served for cold I think.
- 49:51No that wasn't revenge.
- 49:53So it was served sassily.
- 49:55They just chucked onto the table.
- 49:58And then the server left in the huff.
- 50:00Yep he was pissed.
- 50:02Do you have any closing thoughts?
- 50:04I did enjoy this.
- 50:05I do like that different angle on Steven Greer.
- 50:08Because we alluded to that there's this like under the surface like rage that he has against
- 50:14anybody who wrongs him.
- 50:16And however he perceives it being wronged.
- 50:19And I think that letter really shows that that is there.
- 50:23I know.
- 50:24And I'm so glad that in the end I ended up reading it.
- 50:26I tried to make AI read it and it wasn't doing a very good job.
- 50:30So I went back and read it and I was like I just got to read this whole letter.
- 50:33But it's a wonderful word.
- 50:35It is.
- 50:36It's truly some of his best work because we've seen his documentaries.
- 50:40It was.
- 50:41Yes.
- 50:42Then I forgot to say that you had to imagine while I was reading it.
- 50:46Imagine him sitting in the stool and the camera is on the floor and it's looking up at him.
- 50:53And what is to be known as the worst camera angle in existence.
- 50:57Yeah.
- 50:58I actually think they copyrighted it after that because they came up with something special
- 51:02in that documentary.
- 51:04The Greer.
- 51:06But they quickly moved away from ever using again in the next documentaries.
- 51:12You know what we better splurge and buy the tripod for the entire shoot.
- 51:17Oh well thank you for that Chelsea.
- 51:20He is a truly wonderful person to learn about in the worst way.
- 51:24I hope we never have to cross pass with him.
- 51:27We check the email fairly often so I'm just waiting when these episodes come out for the
- 51:31cease and desist letter or for some some weird allusions to how there's podcasts out there
- 51:37who are just evil and spiteful and paid off by the inner workings of the governments.
- 51:42You know what I don't think we can get as worst case scenario was Adam.
- 51:46He pulls everything.
- 51:51Our episodes are so bad that he just removed his online presence.
- 51:57There's nothing there anymore.
- 52:02That is a great place to end.
- 52:04I've been Taylor here with Chelsea.
- 52:07We are Journey to the Fringe.
- 52:08Thank you all for listening.
- 52:09We'll see you next week.
- 52:10Bye.
- 52:11Thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe.
- 52:18If you have liked what you have listened to, please like, share, subscribe or follow depending
- 52:24on what venue you are listening to us through.
- 52:27Also please if possible leave a five star review as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 52:33Should you wish to interact with us please check us out on your social media of choice.
- 52:38I bet you we are there.
- 52:40And if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas for new episodes or tell
- 52:44us that we're wrong and terrible either way please send us an email at journeytothefringeatgmail.com.
- 52:51For now I'll see you in the next episode.