Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Trump Demands 10% Credit Card Rates: Can He Do This?
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker: Hey everyone, this is Mark TriCal with another
- 0:04episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:05Happy 2026.
- 0:07I'm recording this on January 11th.
- 0:09Went to bed last night.
- 0:10The Green Bay Packers were up 21 to three, woke up and they'd lost.
- 0:15But I'm a Viking fan, so I don't care if the Bears are Packers won that game
- 0:19as long as they lose the next game.
- 0:21All right, that one's for Todd.
- 0:23But it is 2026 again, recording this January 11th two days ago was
- 0:29Friday, January 9th, also known as the second Friday of January,
- 0:34also known as Quitter's Day.
- 0:36So I haven't quit my new Year's resolutions yet.
- 0:39I hope that yours are still on track.
- 0:43And while I'm trying to look at social media less as one of my.
- 0:48One of my new Year's resolutions.
- 0:51I did see something yesterday that maybe wanna do a podcast today, and
- 0:55that was from President Donald Trump who said on the White House press release.
- 1:02And also I saw it on XAKA Twitter.
- 1:06It says, please be informed that we will no longer let the American public be
- 1:11ripped off by credit card companies that are charging interest rates of 20 to 30%.
- 1:18And even more, which festered unimpeded during the sleepy Joe Biden administration
- 1:24affordability, all in caps, exclamation point, and then highlighted in yellow.
- 1:29Effective January 20th, 2026, I as president of the United States
- 1:34am calling for a one year cap on credit card interest rates of 10%.
- 1:39Coincidentally, the January 20th date will coincide with the one year
- 1:43anniversary of the historic and very successful Trump administration.
- 1:47Thank you for your attention to this matter.
- 1:49Make America great again.
- 1:51President Donald J.
- 1:52Trump.
- 1:53I'm not gonna get into the politics of all that, although calling for
- 1:57is different than implementing.
- 1:59And why is that?
- 2:00Because he really doesn't have the authority or the power, but this
- 2:04cre, this action would create.
- 2:08Have many unintended consequences.
- 2:10And this morning I got up and looked at my Wall Street Journal.
- 2:14There has an article on it titled Trump calls for 10% cap on interest on credit
- 2:19card interest rates with a subheader of previous proposals to cap interest rates,
- 2:24haven't gained much traction in Congress.
- 2:27And then on my Bloomberg subscription, the title of the.
- 2:33Article is Trump's call for 10% credit card cap aims at banks, crown jewels.
- 2:39And anyway that article was a little bit better, had a little bit more depth to
- 2:44it, and then I put some thoughts together.
- 2:46From those two and my general thoughts on how this could impact credit unions for
- 2:50the podcast that I have for you today.
- 2:53So again, what does it really mean when President Trump is
- 2:57calling for a 10% credit card cap?
- 2:59Why is he doing it?
- 3:00And again, what are the parameters of what he's saying?
- 3:03He's saying a one year 10% cap on credit card interest rates.
- 3:07The articles point out that the average card a PR today is 21%.
- 3:12By the way, obviously if you're a federal credit union in particular you know that
- 3:16the Federal Credit Union Act caps rates at 18% caps at lower than its two A has
- 3:22to renew the 18% but it is capped at 18%.
- 3:26So credit union members by definition already get a better.
- 3:31A better rate at the max than is the average elsewhere.
- 3:35Something that is something that makes me proud to be in the credit
- 3:39union industry in the movement.
- 3:41So this targets one of the most profitable products in banking, although for
- 3:45credit unions, it's probably not as.
- 3:48Profitable as it is for the big banks just because of the volume and the challenges
- 3:53of having a huge, big program like that.
- 3:55Similarly, they can do a lot more with their program than a lot of
- 3:58credit unions do, and a lot of credit unions have sold their portfolios.
- 4:02But it's a politically popular message.
- 4:04Why?
- 4:05Because it helps consumers who are quote unquote drowning in interest.
- 4:09But is it financially op, financially and operationally doable?
- 4:13That would be very complicated.
- 4:16So as a primer, why are credit card so profitable?
- 4:20Credit cards obviously are unsecured debt.
- 4:23There's no house, no, no car to repossess charge off rates are
- 4:27historically much higher than mortgages.
- 4:29Post-crisis cards charge off rates are 10% versus mortgages, which
- 4:34are substantially lower than that.
- 4:36Banks and credit unions price in defaults.
- 4:38They price in fraud.
- 4:40They price in reward programs, they price in servicing at compliance costs.
- 4:44And as you see, as we layer on, as better than I as you layer on all the
- 4:49things that you have to factor into the cost, it becomes very difficult
- 4:53to make money at a 10% limit.
- 4:56Now, an example would be JP Morgan's card portfolio data.
- 5:01I pulled off the web must be accurate, right?
- 5:03Maybe it's accurate, but JP Morgan's card portfolio, roughly $200 billion in loans.
- 5:08Their net yield after everything is 9.7%.
- 5:11They off of $25 billion in revenues and oh, by the way,
- 5:15they charge off $7 billion.
- 5:18So there is a margin and it's not.
- 5:22All profit if you go at 10%.
- 5:24So that's where the misnomer is.
- 5:25That's where this is more of a political Yeah, it would be great.
- 5:29I'll throw this thought out there so people think that I'm doing something
- 5:33good for them, which is my take on what president Trump is doing.
- 5:37Do I think it will happen?
- 5:38No.
- 5:38Do I think he thinks it will happen?
- 5:40No.
- 5:40Is he just making a headline?
- 5:42Yes.
- 5:43But let's walk through why the whys of this not making sense now?
- 5:50The other challenge is if if such a cap was going to go in place, you'd
- 5:54see credit tightening, you'd see fewer approvals, you'd see lower
- 5:58lower credit limits, so smaller loans to everybody or to most everybody.
- 6:04Closure of riskier accounts and fed data estimates that 14.3
- 6:09million people could lose access to credit.
- 6:12Again, these are from the articles.
- 6:1514.3
- 6:15million people could lose access to credit if this went into place.
- 6:19There would be a re-engineering of products, right?
- 6:22So there'd be higher minimum payments, there'd be fewer grace
- 6:24periods, fewer promotional 0% offers.
- 6:27So every action has a reaction and all these other things.
- 6:31Theoretically, if a 10% cap was to go into place, these other
- 6:34things could come into play.
- 6:36Credit card rewards would get cut.
- 6:38I'm a big fan of credit card rewards.
- 6:40The cards I'm loyal to.
- 6:41I really enjoy getting the perks.
- 6:43Whether that's for flying, whether that's for gift cards for restaurants,
- 6:46whether that's for discounts at other organizations, et cetera, et cetera.
- 6:51A 10% cap doesn't leave a lot of leeway for the funding of rewards programs.
- 6:57And again, it would be those.
- 6:59Low income, middle income people would be hit higher than the people
- 7:04at the other end of the spectrum.
- 7:05And it also then would impact the profits because the people at the higher
- 7:11income levels pay off their loans.
- 7:13And it gets into more of an interchange income thing than it
- 7:15making money off the interest.
- 7:17So who would get who could get hit the hardest?
- 7:20Not, not all.
- 7:21Lenders would be impacted evenly.
- 7:23Some banks do more than others.
- 7:27Some credit unions do more than others.
- 7:29You've got Capital One, you've got Synchrony, which is store cards.
- 7:33Those could be impacted big least affected would be prime borrowers,
- 7:37high-end consumers, and people who pay their balances in EV every month.
- 7:41Now, the irony oftentimes when you see people taking actions that.
- 7:46You think will help people on the lower income spectrum?
- 7:50It has the exact opposite.
- 7:51And the reality is that this is supposed to help those folks and they're the ones
- 7:56most likely to lose access to credit if such a action were to come into play.
- 8:01Now, the un another unintended con consequence would be the
- 8:04payday loan program problem.
- 8:06If main mainstream credit dries up, consumers don't stop
- 8:10needing money, they shift their.
- 8:12Requests their desire to go get those loans to payday lenders,
- 8:16to pawn shops, to rent, to own.
- 8:18And that's not good for anybody.
- 8:20So the policy trade off becomes, is a 10% card cap better than someone moving
- 8:25into vastly more expensive alternatives which can range up to 300% for some of
- 8:30those programs that I mentioned there.
- 8:31The reality is there is no free lunch.
- 8:34And the 10% cap would co it cause far more problems than it might create.
- 8:41So the political and regulatory reality check, how could this even be implemented?
- 8:45Congress has debated this for years.
- 8:47Sanders and a LC have proposed a 15% cap.
- 8:51Sanders and Holly have proposed a 10% cap.
- 8:54None of these have passed.
- 8:56The Trump tool set right now is public pressure, regulatory persuasion,
- 9:00but not a clear statutory authority.
- 9:03As I said, credit unions under the Federal Credit Union Act can go up to whatever,
- 9:07NCA approves up to 18%, and it's been 18%.
- 9:11Since at least 1986 when I started in the credit union industry.
- 9:16Banks are also si simultaneously seeing capital rules, ease, stress
- 9:21tests softened and a general deregulatory posture overall, which
- 9:26is what credit unions are also seeing.
- 9:28Those things are pro bank and this credit card movement would
- 9:32be anti-bank or credit union.
- 9:34Now the challenge that credit unions.
- 9:37Would have.
- 9:38And there's I saw in an email that America's credit unions is doing a
- 9:41conference call on this tomorrow, but they've already come out and
- 9:43called a 10% cap devastating.
- 9:46Many credit unions couldn't offer cards at that rate at all.
- 9:49I'm sure some of you listening might actually offer that to your
- 9:52top end people, and that's great.
- 9:54And it will ultimately in their opinion force some credit
- 9:57unions out of the card business.
- 9:59And they'll have members pushed to non-regulated lenders.
- 10:01So it's not just an issue of Wall Street.
- 10:04It's a main street issue.
- 10:06Now the.
- 10:09What theoretically could help consumers if the goal is affordability
- 10:13without killing access some would argue that there'd be some consumer
- 10:17compliance type things that could be done better disclosures, et cetera.
- 10:20I wouldn't go down that rabbit hole.
- 10:22So the big picture takeaway on this is the proposal taps into a real frustration.
- 10:27People hate paying 20% and balances that are at a record level.
- 10:32But blunt tools create blunt damage.
- 10:35There'd be less access, there'd be higher fees, there'd be fewer choices.
- 10:38There'd be more fringe lending.
- 10:40And while it's good politics and it's good headlines, it's dangerous
- 10:44to be contemplating putting this in place because it would, again,
- 10:47have many unintended consequences.
- 10:49So that's my take on the 10%.
- 10:51Trump, desire to change rates.
- 10:53I'm looking forward to some exciting episodes we've got coming up.
- 10:57As I said, this is January 11th this past Thursday.
- 11:01Had NCA been planning a board meeting this coming Thursday, they would've
- 11:04had to announce what the agenda was.
- 11:06And I did not see that come out in my emails.
- 11:09I did not see it on their website.
- 11:11They're skipping a January meeting and as they did last year with only one board
- 11:16member with not a lot of regulatory.
- 11:19Desire from the administration and from board Chairman Kyle Halman.
- 11:24They're just skipping this board meeting.
- 11:26I am hearing rumblings that NCUA has told their staff that there's material
- 11:30changes coming to the structure of NCUA possibly dissolving the Office
- 11:35of National Exam and Supervision, possibly dissolving some other offices.
- 11:40That will ultimately impact credit union.
- 11:42I am really looking forward to when NCA is gonna be transparent about
- 11:45this and tell the industry about it.
- 11:47And it, they just deserve the right to do that.
- 11:50These things should be done in the sunshine and the fact that it's being
- 11:53talked about in NCA, it should be talked about in the public, but they're
- 11:57not having a board meeting this week.
- 11:58Don't expect it in January, possibly in February.
- 12:01Maybe there'll be some big reveal before they go to the America's.
- 12:04Credit unions.
- 12:04GAC.
- 12:05I'm planning on going to GAC again this year as a member
- 12:09of the press for the podcast.
- 12:10So if you go there and wanna catch up, you let me know.
- 12:14And again, 2026, hard to believe.
- 12:16We're in the second week of it.
- 12:17Very excited to have this first episode of the year up and running.
- 12:21And we'll see you again here soon.
- 12:24As always, I wanna thank you for watching.
- 12:26For listening, this is Mark Kel signing off with flying colors.