Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: Off the Rails - Why didn't you ask for it?
Transcript
- 0:09This is AV Superfriends Off the Rails,
- 0:11an almost regularly scheduled open
- 0:13discussion on audio and video in higher
- 0:16education.
- 0:17We'll sound off about our most brilliant
- 0:18ideas, our dumbest mistakes,
- 0:20and everything in between.
- 0:21And because this conversation will almost
- 0:23certainly go off the rails at some point,
- 0:25we'll end up covering just about
- 0:26everything else.
- 0:27And now, the AV Superfriends.
- 0:32For October ninth, twenty twenty six,
- 0:34it's the best sounding and most angry
- 0:35podcast in higher ed.
- 0:36This is the super friends off the rails.
- 0:38Episode number one hundred and forty
- 0:40seven.
- 0:40And boy,
- 0:41was that a pre-show discussion there?
- 0:43We show we would have just had if
- 0:45you just would.
- 0:46You guys burn and show content without
- 0:48ever.
- 0:49Oh, we're not even recording.
- 0:49All right.
- 0:50Let me jump into this.
- 0:51Yeah.
- 0:52Broadcasting live across the seven seas,
- 0:54seven continents,
- 0:55seven time zones and seven layers of the
- 0:56OSI model from the seventh circle of hell
- 0:59to the seventh level of Dante
- 1:00certification.
- 1:01That's two Dante jokes there.
- 1:03Where seven years of bad luck is another
- 1:05Friday afternoon.
- 1:06I'm your seventh son of a seventh son,
- 1:07the man with seven deadly sins and
- 1:09absolutely zero professional
- 1:10qualifications.
- 1:11I'm Chris Deckard,
- 1:11tuned in for another Friday afternoon
- 1:13podcast adventure.
- 1:14And I kept saying seven because this is
- 1:16the kickoff of the seventh season of Off
- 1:19the Rails.
- 1:21which you can do the math.
- 1:23That's six years.
- 1:24So we've done seven seasons of this,
- 1:27seven glorious seasons of questionable
- 1:28advice, unsolicited opinions,
- 1:30technical incompetence,
- 1:31and five grown adults who somehow still
- 1:33haven't figured out how to properly
- 1:34operate a podcast.
- 1:36Seven seasons of pushing buttons,
- 1:37pulling cables, blaming the network,
- 1:38and explaining to commercial integrators
- 1:39that turnkey doesn't mean handing us a bag
- 1:42of unconfigured equipment and wandering
- 1:43off.
- 1:44We've survived a pandemic.
- 1:45We've survived supply chain disasters.
- 1:47We now deal with artificial intelligence.
- 1:50And more industry thought leaders than any
- 1:52reasonable person should have to endure
- 1:53have come and gone.
- 1:54So through it all,
- 1:55we maintain our commitment to the highest
- 1:56standards of unprofessional broadcasting.
- 1:59We're seven seasons in.
- 2:00We're still off the rails.
- 2:02And frankly, at this point,
- 2:03there aren't any tracks left.
- 2:05But what do you say?
- 2:06Let's get this shit so started.
- 2:08you know i i uh heard somewhere on
- 2:10the internet that if you say seven enough
- 2:12within a two minute period a wormhole
- 2:14opens around you somewhere i'm sure one
- 2:17did well it's probably going to suck you
- 2:18into it let's say hello to that panel
- 2:25who's just chiming in all over the place
- 2:26there
- 2:30Our first panelist oversees a carefully
- 2:32structured replacement schedule in which
- 2:34every AV system is perpetually seven years
- 2:36away from being refreshed.
- 2:38He's a director of seven-year technology
- 2:40lifecycle deferral from Kansas City Sailor
- 2:42to Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 2:43Hi there.
- 2:45I got nothing, man.
- 2:46I got nothing.
- 2:49Good contribution.
- 2:50Our next panelist coordinates the annual
- 2:52effort to accomplish seven months of
- 2:54classroom upgrades during the seven days
- 2:56before students return.
- 2:57He's an associate director of seven-day
- 2:58classroom readiness from Corvallis,
- 3:00Oregon.
- 3:00Say hello to Mr. Mark Kolosinski.
- 3:02You stretch it out.
- 3:03We'll get it all in there.
- 3:04That sounds like a church.
- 3:06It kind of does sound like a church.
- 3:07Oh, you're right.
- 3:07Yeah, I probably should have changed that.
- 3:09The church of seven-day installation.
- 3:11I got business around here somewhere.
- 3:14Our next panelist maintains a
- 3:15comprehensive seven-tier support model
- 3:17designed to ensure that no technical issue
- 3:20ever reaches someone qualified to resolve
- 3:22it.
- 3:22He's a senior manager of seven-layer bean
- 3:24dip, I'm sorry,
- 3:25seven-layer AV support escalation from
- 3:27Greensboro, North Carolina, Salem, Mr.
- 3:28Larry Darling.
- 3:30Yeah, we've really been shifting left.
- 3:31It used to be a ten-layer.
- 3:33Freaking shift left.
- 3:34Saving money.
- 3:37I picked that one for you, Larry,
- 3:38because you are steeped in ITSM.
- 3:41And our final panelist,
- 3:43he's responsible for announcing the
- 3:44seventh consecutive strategic initiative
- 3:46to fix the same classroom technology
- 3:48problems identified during the first six
- 3:50strategic initiatives.
- 3:51He's a vice president for seventh
- 3:52generation learning environment
- 3:53transformation from Bowling Green,
- 3:54Kentucky, say hello to Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 3:56I think that's true.
- 4:00Now you know how I write these.
- 4:02Of equipment.
- 4:07You're always talking about things that
- 4:08you already did once before and you're
- 4:09doing it again because now it'll be
- 4:10better.
- 4:10You're still running on first-gen
- 4:11equipment.
- 4:12Wait long enough, it's new.
- 4:14Justin,
- 4:14what's your favorite piece of first-gen
- 4:16equipment out there?
- 4:17MPS-D.
- 4:17There it is.
- 4:18Oh, my God.
- 4:19Everyone take a drink.
- 4:23Wait, why?
- 4:26We love the MPS-D here.
- 4:27Why?
- 4:28It doesn't matter.
- 4:29Larry,
- 4:29take the quarter out of the machine.
- 4:31We don't need this game.
- 4:32Don't open that can.
- 4:33I don't know.
- 4:35So on today's show,
- 4:36we're gonna discuss the missing critical
- 4:37operational documentation about system
- 4:39automation and planning.
- 4:41I'm sorry, I misread that.
- 4:42About system automation, comma,
- 4:44which is missing from my document,
- 4:46and planning life cycles for other
- 4:48people's stuff.
- 4:49But first, a little bit of housekeeping.
- 4:51If you're listening,
- 4:52this is recorded MP three.
- 4:53Welcome to season seven of the ABC Super
- 4:54Friends.
- 4:54Six years, seven seasons,
- 4:55and we still haven't figured out how to
- 4:56start on time.
- 4:57Missed it again today.
- 4:59We stream live on about Fridays at about
- 5:00three fifteen on on Friday.
- 5:02It's not about Fridays.
- 5:02We stream live on Fridays at about three
- 5:04fifteen Eastern twelve fifteen Pacific or
- 5:05whenever I'm able to get my road kit
- 5:06set up again,
- 5:07which is we're now in like month seven
- 5:09of this.
- 5:10You can join us live for that on
- 5:11YouTube, LinkedIn and Twitter.
- 5:12If you can't join us live,
- 5:13please follow us on the socials.
- 5:14We're on Twitter, LinkedIn,
- 5:15YouTube and Blue Sky and just go figure
- 5:16it out.
- 5:17You can go find us there somewhere.
- 5:18We're on all that stuff.
- 5:19Please don't forget to spread the word.
- 5:22Share the show with your friends,
- 5:23colleagues, enemies,
- 5:24vendors who desperately need a reality
- 5:25check and that one associate dean who
- 5:27thinks a classroom projector purchased
- 5:29twenty years ago should still be good.
- 5:31Finally,
- 5:31if six years of free entertainment and
- 5:32professional development hasn't been
- 5:33enough,
- 5:34consider throwing a few bucks our way.
- 5:35The donation link is in the show notes.
- 5:38Seven seasons in and we're still operating
- 5:40on the same business model.
- 5:41That is to say, no defined budget,
- 5:43no defined plan,
- 5:43and absolutely no adult supervision.
- 5:46We are not over budget, though.
- 5:48We are not.
- 5:48Actually,
- 5:49we're way under budget talking to Justin
- 5:50the other day.
- 5:51And thanks for sticking with us for seven
- 5:52years.
- 5:53Here's to season seven,
- 5:54another year of solving higher ed's AV
- 5:56problems one complaint at a time.
- 5:57And thank you for your support because we
- 5:59couldn't do this show without you.
- 6:02how is it one complaint at a time
- 6:04we all have about four every time we
- 6:06join well that's usually it's why we're
- 6:08late inside baseball here by the way most
- 6:10of our show just most of our show
- 6:12topics come from one of us complaining to
- 6:14the other four so it's kind of where
- 6:16it starts it's like once it hits like
- 6:18three or four responses in the back
- 6:19channel that's a show topic that's
- 6:21actually true yeah it's actually true as
- 6:24opposed to all the lies we tell yeah
- 6:27We may have been known for that, too.
- 6:30All right.
- 6:30We make stuff up a lot.
- 6:31No, we don't.
- 6:34Everything you say is one hundred percent
- 6:35true.
- 6:35So every commercial that we play is real.
- 6:37It's embellished.
- 6:38Yes, it is.
- 6:40Speaking of which, Jamie,
- 6:42I just realized I'm going to swap out
- 6:43the audio of the commercial,
- 6:44but we don't have a new slate for
- 6:45it.
- 6:46So, OK,
- 6:46we'll figure it out where we're well
- 6:48produced here anyway.
- 6:50How about we do the news?
- 6:51You want to do the news?
- 6:53We'll just put up the dancing banana.
- 6:55All right.
- 6:56Here we go.
- 6:56Justin, sing along.
- 6:57I just did.
- 7:03Uh,
- 7:03today's news comes from tech and learning
- 7:04and from friend of the show,
- 7:05Eric off gang,
- 7:06who's been on the show way back in
- 7:08the, in the, in the day.
- 7:10Um,
- 7:10and this comes from a good friends of
- 7:12the show also high to all you folks
- 7:14out there, uh, you know,
- 7:15Mike and Scott and Donnie and all those
- 7:17folks, um, at UCF, uh, the, the, uh,
- 7:19the headline here is teaching with AI
- 7:23holograms,
- 7:24which hits like three of the four
- 7:25possible, like, uh, um,
- 7:27words of the day that you need.
- 7:28Yeah.
- 7:29I don't think they're doing that.
- 7:31It says right here.
- 7:32They're doing it, man.
- 7:33Yeah, I don't think that.
- 7:36It was written, so it shall be.
- 7:39So short version here is they have one
- 7:41of those, I won't say interactive.
- 7:43That's the wrong term.
- 7:44It's not an interactive display.
- 7:45It's one of those oversized displays where
- 7:46the rear has been taken off,
- 7:48and it's in a box,
- 7:48so it tricks your brain into adding depth
- 7:50to it.
- 7:50Say it.
- 7:53I will when we get there.
- 7:56All right, fine.
- 7:58I did this just for you.
- 7:59So Mark threw this in our news channel
- 8:01as discussion the other day,
- 8:03and he knew just because I would rant
- 8:05about this again,
- 8:06that this is not new technology.
- 8:08And it's my favorite phrase that I like
- 8:09to shout.
- 8:10Are you guys ready for it?
- 8:10Get your drinks ready.
- 8:12Everybody,
- 8:12we wanted to bring this to your ears
- 8:15and not just our own.
- 8:16We want to share the experience.
- 8:18And because...
- 8:20It's Pepper's Ghost.
- 8:22October is spooky.
- 8:24Yes, there it is.
- 8:26We all know the Pepper's Ghost thing.
- 8:28Push that aside for a second.
- 8:29You can't push that aside.
- 8:33That's the whole thing.
- 8:34No, it's not.
- 8:35Where's the AI in this?
- 8:37What NCP server are they running?
- 8:39What model are they running with it?
- 8:42What is the AI?
- 8:43Based on what Mark and I have done,
- 8:45that is not AI.
- 8:45That is not AI.
- 8:49Running on, not Olamo,
- 8:51what's the other one?
- 8:55BLLM.
- 8:56Yes.
- 8:56It's got Hermes as the coordinating agent.
- 8:58Time to first token.
- 9:00I need to know the time to first
- 9:01token.
- 9:01If you don't give me that,
- 9:01we're not going to have a conversation.
- 9:02What's the token usage of said hologram?
- 9:06All right, nerds, bring it back.
- 9:08no we nope bring it back anyway it's
- 9:13first it's first gen ai first gen no
- 9:17it's not it's not ai
- 9:21die on this one okay um i saw
- 9:24this and it's like perfect this is we
- 9:26gotta keep poking chris as much as we
- 9:28can when we get a chance to bring
- 9:30a pepper's ghost in this one drop me
- 9:32because it was that's just half the story
- 9:33we have to yeah and so but the
- 9:35only thing better is if they had goggles
- 9:37walk through this and it's like okay how
- 9:40do we feel about a mystery box at
- 9:42the front of a room with
- 9:44quasi-holographic thing.
- 9:46Yeah, by the way, this thing is,
- 9:47if you've never seen one of these in
- 9:48person, these things are huge.
- 9:49These are massive.
- 9:49These are bigger than, you all have that.
- 9:51They look like a freezer at Burger King.
- 9:52Yeah,
- 9:52you've all got that friend who has the
- 9:54full-size Sub-Zero fridge.
- 9:55Yeah, it is.
- 9:56It's bigger than that.
- 9:57It looks like a freezer at your
- 9:59restaurant.
- 10:00Yeah.
- 10:01It does look like a walk-in.
- 10:02Yeah.
- 10:03So where's the AI in that?
- 10:06So Justin,
- 10:07it says in the article with words that
- 10:09explains this,
- 10:09the patient is an interactive AI hologram
- 10:13from within a lifelike holographic
- 10:14display.
- 10:15What model is it running?
- 10:17A device about the size of a refrigerator
- 10:18that creates the illusion of a three-D and
- 10:19life-size person.
- 10:21And that's weirdly written.
- 10:23So to your point,
- 10:24I suspect the software driving the
- 10:26responses on this is it's using a large
- 10:31language model for the voice input on a
- 10:34local,
- 10:34because I don't think it has a live
- 10:36connection now.
- 10:36It's probably a local set of pre-trained
- 10:41corpus.
- 10:42I don't know.
- 10:43I don't really believe any of that until
- 10:45I actually see the tech specs.
- 10:46Well,
- 10:46it's a good thing that Donnie will invite
- 10:48you down and let you badmouth it in
- 10:50front of him.
- 10:51well we will when we're in info
- 10:52competition we're going to come check this
- 10:54we're going to go down see it actually
- 10:56we could you want a road trip i'm
- 10:59going to road trip doors on hinges larry
- 11:00you're like twenty minutes away from there
- 11:02all the way across country i'm road
- 11:04tripping to see this very hard whole thing
- 11:06so
- 11:08i think it's a lot of pre-programmed stuff
- 11:09to donnie mike and scott um we need
- 11:12more information on this and we need you
- 11:13know an on-site video for it my agent
- 11:15has claimed that it does have existing
- 11:17ties to ev systems like ptz cameras
- 11:19ceiling microphones lecture capture and
- 11:21lms pieces built into this thing as well
- 11:23but there's an additional information i
- 11:25don't know if i buy that i'm gonna
- 11:26do my own research here because but
- 11:30outside of that if you had this big
- 11:32box in the front of your room couldn't
- 11:35that just had been done with a regular
- 11:37display
- 11:38Hey, it's a hologram.
- 11:40Sorry.
- 11:40I got a question.
- 11:41Couldn't it be done with an actual
- 11:42instructor?
- 11:44Hey.
- 11:45We're out of instructors, Larry.
- 11:46Times are tough out here.
- 11:47We're out.
- 11:49not going to pay some hundred thousand
- 11:50dollar instructor and we can buy this
- 11:52thing for five hundred thousand dollars a
- 11:53hundred thousand dollars we don't have to
- 11:56pay this thing um insurance and health
- 12:00insurance and not yet i'm solving all
- 12:04these problems with the part-time adjunct
- 12:06i i would be curious on if it
- 12:08had some some tie-ins and hookups to the
- 12:10cameras and sensors so they could see that
- 12:12a student raised their hand that could
- 12:14interact with the questions that are
- 12:16coming in.
- 12:17Because at that point,
- 12:18it is just a mannequin body away from
- 12:22being Terminator.
- 12:24So you're saying give it arms so it
- 12:26can interact.
- 12:26Put it on wheels so it can drive
- 12:28around.
- 12:29So if we took the...
- 12:30Maybe a phased plasma rifle in the
- 12:37The Elon bots out there.
- 12:38Just put them out there.
- 12:39Just put a display on its face.
- 12:41No.
- 12:42No, I'm not into that.
- 12:43Wasn't there a whole movie on that?
- 12:44I think there was several.
- 12:47And it was like the end of times.
- 12:49And what's old is new.
- 12:51Fleshy humans have to destroy the.
- 12:54I think that happened.
- 12:56Or it was a documentary and we're just
- 12:58reliving it.
- 13:00Maybe you're onto it.
- 13:01You know what?
- 13:01This doesn't say who's the provider behind
- 13:03this thing.
- 13:04Was it portal or something like that?
- 13:09Okay, so we all read the article.
- 13:11Well,
- 13:11I'm scanning for the name of the company
- 13:12because I want to find out to Justin's
- 13:14point, what are they doing with actual AI?
- 13:15So Portal is the company and now they're
- 13:19named Proto and apparently... Dr.
- 13:22Hologram Tech.
- 13:24Founded by David Nussbaum in twenty
- 13:26nineteen for a health care company or
- 13:29health care education, blah, blah, blah.
- 13:31So the only thing that it's doing,
- 13:33I guess it could be AI is the
- 13:36just the speech to text thing.
- 13:38I suspect that's what it is.
- 13:40It's got a local bottle on there with
- 13:42some pre pre canned.
- 13:43Speech-to-text captures a student
- 13:45question.
- 13:45A large language model answer is prompted
- 13:47with the patent persona history symptoms,
- 13:49how to reveal, how to react emotionally.
- 13:52Text-to-speech generates the voice.
- 13:55Emotion straight from a robot.
- 13:57I have built this system.
- 13:59I know what's going on behind this thing
- 14:01now.
- 14:04Look, it's kind of cool, kind of fun.
- 14:05Yes, we're making fun of it.
- 14:07It still very much has that wow factor,
- 14:09that whiz-bang factor.
- 14:10I don't think the hologram piece is what
- 14:12makes this...
- 14:14whiz bang to be i mean that's all
- 14:15nice and good but it's not i think
- 14:16it's the background and like the data
- 14:18stack that makes it fundamentally work
- 14:21right i think you could transpose this
- 14:23over any lms and a video system that's
- 14:25doing generative video you're gonna have
- 14:27the same thing i think the hologram can
- 14:28be peeled out of it i think you'd
- 14:29still have something i'm hopeful because
- 14:31you know this is based on quinn you
- 14:33can hammer on this thing enough it'll just
- 14:34break down start speaking in mandarin
- 14:37Have you guys seen the videos of those
- 14:38things doing that where they just fail and
- 14:40they just roll back to Mandarin?
- 14:41It's awesome.
- 14:44No, I have a strict,
- 14:45once we get off our phone calls,
- 14:46I don't think about AI anymore.
- 14:49That or Hindi, one of the two.
- 14:51So Mandarin.
- 14:53All right.
- 14:54I look forward to many, many,
- 14:55many of these all over schools.
- 14:56And then in five years,
- 14:57just like we all have that room full
- 14:58of old TVs that are there.
- 14:59So soon you'll walk in and there's like
- 15:01a whole bunch of like freezers with people
- 15:02in them.
- 15:03Mark and I can build one of these
- 15:05for two thirds of the fifty.
- 15:08You don't even know what that cost yet.
- 15:11Mark and I.
- 15:12What if they got it on sale?
- 15:14Mark and I can build it for probably
- 15:17half the price and two-thirds less depth.
- 15:23You'll have control over all of it.
- 15:25On wheels with arms.
- 15:27Probably.
- 15:28Well,
- 15:29we're going to use that thing from the
- 15:29Infocomm.
- 15:30Yeah, Aaron,
- 15:30I think these are all made by the
- 15:31same factory in China.
- 15:32Yep, exactly.
- 15:35Anyway.
- 15:35All right, well,
- 15:35look for more holograms coming to kill you
- 15:37soon, apparently.
- 15:37Won't hold my breath.
- 15:38All right, well,
- 15:41we're going to take a quick break.
- 15:43We're going to come back.
- 15:44We're going to talk about missing critical
- 15:46documentation for all our projects,
- 15:48which makes life much more interesting as
- 15:49we're getting through the deployment and
- 15:51commissioning phase.
- 15:52Because how do we know it's actually doing
- 15:53what it's supposed to be doing?
- 15:55But first,
- 15:56a message from our good friends at
- 15:57Computer Comforts.
- 16:01AV technology keeps evolving.
- 16:03Your AV furniture should too.
- 16:05Because somehow,
- 16:06in an industry full of increasingly
- 16:08space-efficient AV equipment,
- 16:10our default answer is still,
- 16:12bolt that in a nineteen-inch rack.
- 16:14Computer Comforts has a better idea.
- 16:16Meet the new PowerLift MOLLE XL lectern.
- 16:19A flexible,
- 16:20accessible solution designed to simplify
- 16:23AV integration, equipment access,
- 16:25and technology management.
- 16:27With a MOLLE mounting pattern and VESA
- 16:29mounting locations throughout the
- 16:31equipment bay,
- 16:32you can put components where they actually
- 16:34make sense.
- 16:35Need traditional rack space too?
- 16:37It can still do that with three RU
- 16:39rack modules for that authentic vintage
- 16:41mounting method.
- 16:43To be clear,
- 16:44the whole rear panel is removable,
- 16:46so you can cram six RU of gear
- 16:48and a twenty-four port patch panel in
- 16:50there.
- 16:51Blame Chris for that one.
- 16:53because sometimes you need rack rails.
- 16:55You just probably don't need them for
- 16:57everything.
- 16:58Cleaner integration, easier access,
- 17:01less nonsense.
- 17:03Learn more at computercomforts.com.
- 17:09You can blame me for cramming six RU
- 17:11of stuff in the back of that thing.
- 17:13Larry,
- 17:13you're like in the pocket on those drums
- 17:15on that one.
- 17:16You can blame the folks at Indiana for
- 17:18the Molly pattern suggestion,
- 17:19and you can blame Jamie for the Vesa
- 17:21pattern suggestion.
- 17:25You know what I didn't get?
- 17:27Residuals.
- 17:28And never will.
- 17:30I know, right?
- 17:31Where's your residual?
- 17:32They're great.
- 17:33What?
- 17:33Chris and I are getting them.
- 17:34You just don't want to spend yours.
- 17:37Dang it.
- 17:38Jamie,
- 17:38we're going to hang on to that for
- 17:39you.
- 17:39We'll put that in a retirement account for
- 17:40you.
- 17:40You can have it when you're six years
- 17:41old.
- 17:41Yeah, thanks.
- 17:42You walked into that one, Jamie.
- 17:45Don't worry.
- 17:46It'll grow.
- 17:47Don't worry.
- 17:47I will say,
- 17:47as somebody who's deployed close to a
- 17:49hundred of that model lectern in the past,
- 17:51it is a very interesting way to...
- 17:53A hundred?
- 17:55Yeah.
- 17:57Only been out for like six months.
- 17:59Not of that model.
- 18:01It's got a new rear panel there for
- 18:02mounting,
- 18:03but of that model over the last several
- 18:04years.
- 18:05It's got a new rear end.
- 18:06How many are you buying of these things?
- 18:08We need to talk to Chris about an
- 18:09addiction problem.
- 18:10It's on the GLP one.
- 18:12Yes, they're all in one room, Justin.
- 18:14I just keep them in there.
- 18:15It's a warehouse full of lecterns.
- 18:17Constant trucks dropping them off.
- 18:18Yeah.
- 18:19More lecterns, please.
- 18:22We need more lecterns.
- 18:23Back them up.
- 18:26We don't build blanket forts here.
- 18:30It's a unique way to hide stuff.
- 18:35Yeah, your floor.
- 18:35Look at all my lectures.
- 18:38All right.
- 18:42They'll be real pleased with that.
- 18:45Anyway.
- 18:46Okay,
- 18:46so to the topic at hand here today.
- 18:50Topic of the day.
- 18:52No, that's a different one.
- 18:53No, come on.
- 18:55You want this one?
- 18:56first one topic one starts now it's topic
- 19:00of the month i didn't do topic of
- 19:02the day i can go get that one
- 19:03but it's wrong now so no you guys
- 19:07brought this up it wasn't my wasn't my
- 19:09topic anyway but like the meeting you
- 19:10didn't attend it was another meeting that
- 19:12i missed apparently you guys having
- 19:13meetings without me i'm going to sit back
- 19:15a little bit for this one all right
- 19:16why we need i know larry has thoughts
- 19:19but you have been screaming to talk about
- 19:21this one for over a year
- 19:24So let me set the stage and you
- 19:25guys can yell at each other.
- 19:27The discussion here is about when working
- 19:31with, let's say, what,
- 19:32outside briefcase experts.
- 19:35Working with anyone.
- 19:36Yeah, I was going to say anyone.
- 19:37In any project.
- 19:38OK.
- 19:39Even your internal staff?
- 19:41Sure.
- 19:41Yes.
- 19:41You shall have proper documentation.
- 19:44We're missing some critical documentation.
- 19:46We focus on the hardware sides of things.
- 19:49We focus on signal flow.
- 19:50We focus on how we want things arranged
- 19:52in an equipment rack or in the back
- 19:53of a really cool lectern.
- 19:54We focus on where we want screens and
- 19:57cameras and TVs and microphones mounted
- 20:00physically in a space.
- 20:02We might give a little bit of
- 20:04documentation on how we want something
- 20:06configured for the network, maybe.
- 20:08But one of the critical things we don't
- 20:09do is appropriate operational flow of how
- 20:15we want a system to operate.
- 20:16We might do a brief scope of work.
- 20:18It's going to do this sort of thing.
- 20:20We don't document how we want the system
- 20:24to work when someone walks into a room.
- 20:27Is there a touch panel, button panel?
- 20:28What are they doing?
- 20:29What is each button doing?
- 20:31What sort of audio processing is going on
- 20:33in the background?
- 20:33What sort of routing is going on?
- 20:35We're kind of skipping all the stuff
- 20:37because, oh,
- 20:37we'll just kind of figure it out when
- 20:38we get there.
- 20:40Is that appropriate?
- 20:40And Mark was holding up his documentation.
- 20:44No, this is not.
- 20:45This is what the Infocom Academy will have
- 20:48you believe that every one of your
- 20:50projects needs.
- 20:51I think that book was out of print.
- 20:54What's the date on that one?
- 20:56Anyway,
- 20:56so is that a fair way to phrase
- 20:58this?
- 20:59The operational documentation,
- 21:01how to actually use and how stuff works.
- 21:03Not the actual operational use,
- 21:04but how stuff is used and what it's
- 21:05supposed to be doing is missing.
- 21:08Touch here to begin.
- 21:11so i think that and also just like
- 21:13what experiences like how is the space
- 21:18what are you trying to achieve by updating
- 21:22this room or building this system like
- 21:24what active learning room larry they're
- 21:25actively learning all are but i'm just
- 21:28what are you trying to achieve in this
- 21:33project
- 21:34Metrics of success?
- 21:35Is that what you're trying to say here?
- 21:37What does this thing need to do if
- 21:38you want to say it works?
- 21:39They often will have that one or two
- 21:41paragraph scope of work explaining in very
- 21:43broad strokes what the room is supposed to
- 21:45be doing.
- 21:46No, they won't.
- 21:47They'll say this is the physical work that
- 21:49we're performing.
- 21:51Yeah,
- 21:52and I think a lot of times it's
- 21:53like, yeah,
- 21:54you'll have a button that turns things on
- 21:55and a button that turns things off.
- 21:57Does it say that?
- 21:57Things.
- 21:58things i may not be defined it just
- 22:00says things i've i've seen very little
- 22:03operational language when especially with
- 22:06outside firms like just to be honest they
- 22:09are very very stuck in like bill of
- 22:11materials here's the scope here's the
- 22:13physical labor we're going to do these
- 22:14people are going to be on site doing
- 22:15this stuff they're pulling this to there
- 22:16and above our boss plugging this in here's
- 22:17your document of all the stuff you're
- 22:18going to get and we'll work with the
- 22:22programmer when you figure that stuff out
- 22:23when it gets
- 22:24Well,
- 22:24oftentimes it comes down to the
- 22:26traditional programmer role to figure all
- 22:28that out.
- 22:28Yeah.
- 22:29They're given a brief description of what
- 22:30should be happening.
- 22:31Here's a list of all your gear,
- 22:33most of which they have probably seen at
- 22:34some point in the past,
- 22:35and they take that information,
- 22:37and that's the context they apply to make
- 22:39the room work to the best of their
- 22:41ability based on how they would use it,
- 22:43but they're not the end user.
- 22:45Or it is, give us your seed file,
- 22:48and we'll take it from there and reprogram
- 22:50it based on your standards.
- 22:54And the closest we might get is here's
- 22:56the GUI of the proposed touch panel and
- 22:58how it's going to work.
- 22:58We based it on the one we saw
- 23:00on your website.
- 23:01Oh, yeah.
- 23:02Or they actually visited one.
- 23:04But, of course,
- 23:05they visit the one that's seven years old.
- 23:07It was the branch campus.
- 23:07It was like the vintage one from two
- 23:09thousand nine.
- 23:10Yeah.
- 23:10The departmental space that hasn't been
- 23:12updated in forever.
- 23:13Yeah.
- 23:15Yeah, there it is.
- 23:16Complete package, right?
- 23:17That's optimum.
- 23:19And then, look,
- 23:20I know internally this happens a lot
- 23:22because, well, we deploy it,
- 23:24so we fix it,
- 23:25so we adjust it as we need,
- 23:26and we kind of know what we want
- 23:27it anyway.
- 23:29But I know that since I don't have
- 23:30a lot of integrators come in and do
- 23:32work, but recently I've had one or two.
- 23:34Do they come in and just hang out?
- 23:36Well,
- 23:37they put in exactly what was asked for.
- 23:39Well...
- 23:40by whatever scope of work they got from
- 23:43consultants and architects and such,
- 23:45right?
- 23:45And it's all there.
- 23:46From three years ago.
- 23:47And I can look at it and say,
- 23:49okay, well,
- 23:49you gave us exactly what was on the
- 23:51drawing.
- 23:52I mean, exactly what was on the drawing,
- 23:56and your best attempt at giving us what
- 23:58features and functions that you thought
- 24:00people would want
- 24:03But I agree with you.
- 24:04There is a missing step in there,
- 24:05and it's usually because the actual users
- 24:09aren't ever the stakeholders in those
- 24:10conversations.
- 24:11So it always comes up, well,
- 24:12we want big sound,
- 24:13and we want big pictures,
- 24:15and we want wireless everything,
- 24:17and can I have a scooter too?
- 24:20And by God, it's all there.
- 24:22I think just at large,
- 24:24all the soft goods, pieces of this,
- 24:26the software, all the configurations,
- 24:29all of that stuff seems very...
- 24:32I barely ever any documentation up front
- 24:35of what's going to happen in those.
- 24:36And I'm not saying give me a DSP
- 24:38design.
- 24:38That's not what I'm asking for.
- 24:39There's never language walking through
- 24:41those things.
- 24:41There's never, I mean,
- 24:42I went through this book and looked at
- 24:43the touch panel piece of it,
- 24:45user manually.
- 24:46It's giving me like a page by page,
- 24:47every single thing.
- 24:48Did you read the dashboard for controls?
- 24:50It's got everything.
- 24:50Yeah, exactly.
- 24:51It's got all of it.
- 24:51Right.
- 24:51And so, but.
- 24:53I very seldom see that in a proposal
- 24:55from...
- 24:56It's usually caught up in some boilerplate
- 24:58language.
- 24:59Oh, that's going to be...
- 25:00A consultant's going to reach out and
- 25:01blah, blah, blah.
- 25:01This, that, and the other thing later on.
- 25:07Justin, you were saying?
- 25:08I don't know.
- 25:11You guys need better documentation.
- 25:13I mean...
- 25:14I think that's what we just said.
- 25:14That's what we're talking about.
- 25:16So... We don't always get it.
- 25:19No.
- 25:21What are you asking for...
- 25:24It's not typically that we asked for it.
- 25:26I think that's the problem.
- 25:30So how is said integrator responding to
- 25:32said request on your campus?
- 25:35Is it from you?
- 25:35Is it from a client that you're
- 25:37intercepting?
- 25:38I'm backing up before the integrator
- 25:42delivers their documentation.
- 25:45What is your documentation to them?
- 25:49But I think there's the question.
- 25:51Where should be?
- 25:52Should we provide them a document?
- 25:54We want all the documentation and
- 25:56deliverable to look like this.
- 25:58Oftentimes,
- 25:58a UI in our project is not seen
- 25:59until the day we're there in the
- 26:02programming.
- 26:02And then it's met with, oh,
- 26:04that's going to be a change order.
- 26:07So that's not really what I meant.
- 26:11We're in the middle of an RFP.
- 26:14And that's a generic thing that's going to
- 26:16last for five years.
- 26:17And part of the RFP is for them
- 26:20to understand that they need to supply us
- 26:24with a very specific,
- 26:27this is how you write your scope of
- 26:28work to us to make sure that the
- 26:30deliverables that we're asking for are
- 26:34understood by you all.
- 26:36And you actually can price it out in
- 26:38your,
- 26:39whatever in your solution and give us that
- 26:42and it's all well defined and so that's
- 26:45going to be an ad hoc per system
- 26:47for example with the cherry hall project
- 26:51that i'm designing it is their expectation
- 26:55to program the systems so that we can
- 26:57punch them out there's no graphics we
- 27:00don't have to worry about anything what
- 27:01does that mean
- 27:02Yeah.
- 27:03That's all defined.
- 27:04Do you want me to explain the four
- 27:06pages on this?
- 27:07With the Cherry Hall and you designing,
- 27:09I want to know about the business school
- 27:12that you had nothing to do with.
- 27:13Yeah.
- 27:14That's the one we're talking about.
- 27:15We don't care.
- 27:15We never saw that.
- 27:16That's the one we're talking about.
- 27:17We don't support that building.
- 27:20the type of things we're talking about.
- 27:21Those things that come on campus.
- 27:23Well, hold on.
- 27:25Everybody's interrupting everybody.
- 27:27So there was no defining request to the
- 27:31AV integrator for the College of Business
- 27:33on,
- 27:34this is your scope of work deliverables
- 27:36that we want to review and approve before
- 27:37we get a price.
- 27:38That didn't happen.
- 27:41So you all are complaining about the same
- 27:43thing.
- 27:43So are you guilty of not setting those
- 27:46expectations to the integrator?
- 27:48But that's a contractual thing in an RFP
- 27:50or bid.
- 27:50They're not abiding by the contracts.
- 27:57But your response to the business school
- 27:58was what?
- 28:00It's not your problem.
- 28:02You're not supporting it, right?
- 28:03We're not involved.
- 28:05Okay.
- 28:05That's what we're talking about.
- 28:07So you're talking about projects that you
- 28:09just got blindsided with.
- 28:10Yes.
- 28:10Okay.
- 28:11All right.
- 28:12So you didn't have an opportunity.
- 28:14No.
- 28:14By the time we're involved, that's done.
- 28:17But the end users complain to us because
- 28:20it doesn't work the way they think it
- 28:22should.
- 28:23It may already be the construction
- 28:24documents.
- 28:24Then you should remind them who to call
- 28:26for support and help.
- 28:28Like remember that integrator that was
- 28:30here?
- 28:30Call them.
- 28:31So Justin,
- 28:32are you defining deliverable as review of
- 28:35proposed code?
- 28:38touch panel to be delivered X amount of
- 28:40weeks,
- 28:40months in advance to make sure it's
- 28:41walkthrough and is,
- 28:42is built to our standard to include join
- 28:45numbers, HTML,
- 28:46like is that level of clarity provided in
- 28:49your document?
- 28:50Uh, yeah.
- 28:51Uh, we don't do join numbers, but yeah,
- 28:52that's whatever.
- 28:53I'm just,
- 28:53I'm just giving people an example.
- 28:54Like do you, but for example, uh,
- 28:57it is defined in the cherry hall scope
- 28:59that I'm to travel down and inspect the
- 29:02racks before.
- 29:04They put all of them together.
- 29:06I'm going to approve one.
- 29:07But what about DSP?
- 29:08Let's just pull up.
- 29:10How are you pre-reviewing the work on the
- 29:13DSP?
- 29:16We don't care in that specific situation
- 29:18because we're doing the work.
- 29:22for the DSP and the programming on that
- 29:23job.
- 29:23Okay.
- 29:25So that's all the knowledge labor is
- 29:26internal yet.
- 29:27So, but again, but okay, let's say,
- 29:30let's say you do it.
- 29:30What is your deliverable package to
- 29:33yourself as documenting that process?
- 29:37And don't say the finished file.
- 29:39What are you asking?
- 29:39If you were going to document it about,
- 29:42but you are your own client,
- 29:44what would you provide as your DSP
- 29:47documentation without handing me a
- 29:49finished file?
- 29:50How would you go about that?
- 29:52Depending on who the client was,
- 29:53if I was the integrator,
- 29:54I would probably mock something up and
- 29:56explain what I'm doing and take a picture
- 29:58of it and send it to them for
- 29:59approvals before I commence doing thirty
- 30:02of them.
- 30:04Okay, and I think that's a valid request.
- 30:06You have to be accountable for your own
- 30:08actions.
- 30:08And so as integrators,
- 30:10if you're wondering, oh man,
- 30:13the university we're working with is very
- 30:15technical and they do their own work and
- 30:17they understand FIAMP and Q-SYS and all
- 30:20the DSPs out there,
- 30:21maybe it's beneficial to us
- 30:25to take a snapshot and have a Zoom
- 30:27call and explain what we're doing and get
- 30:29approvals through submittal process,
- 30:33whatever the case is,
- 30:35and have it documented that, hey,
- 30:38Justin's group actually approved this,
- 30:39so I don't know why you're complaining.
- 30:41Everything's documented and approved.
- 30:42I mean,
- 30:44that's my answer to everything is you
- 30:47proactively communicate, document,
- 30:49get approvals, and move on.
- 30:51So the other side of that equation,
- 30:54You're an integrator.
- 30:55Maybe you're not rexing integrator.
- 30:56Maybe you're just integrator ABC out
- 30:58there.
- 30:58Well, I don't know ABC.
- 30:59I know rexing consulting group.
- 31:01Yeah,
- 31:01but rexing probably has better intentions.
- 31:03Let's just put it that way.
- 31:04Okay.
- 31:05You're doing this work.
- 31:07You have thirteen, fourteen, half dozen,
- 31:10baker's dozens worth of classrooms you're
- 31:11going to do.
- 31:12And you're just going to crank through
- 31:14here and you're like, well,
- 31:16I don't have anything that's asking me to
- 31:17do.
- 31:17So I'm just going to go ahead and
- 31:18do it this way.
- 31:19I would submit an RFI.
- 31:20No, you wouldn't.
- 31:22No, you would not.
- 31:22They would not.
- 31:23They're going to do it, put it there,
- 31:25and they're going to say,
- 31:25you never gave me anything,
- 31:26so therefore I didn't submit anything.
- 31:28That's just asking for more work.
- 31:31And then it's asking for a change order.
- 31:33It's asking for a change order,
- 31:34which comes as a financial ramification.
- 31:36A request for change.
- 31:37yep yeah and and i think a lot
- 31:39of integrators out there are looking for
- 31:41the nickeling diming of a lot of
- 31:42universities when all organizations are
- 31:44working for because they know i'm sure
- 31:46that's the case that change will lead to
- 31:48more money later on universities allow it
- 31:51to happen if universities allow that to
- 31:53happen then that's something no we end up
- 31:55we do we don't allow it to happen
- 31:56we just take what we're delivered and we
- 31:57fix it later on is what we end
- 31:59up doing
- 32:00You need to improve your documentation
- 32:01process.
- 32:02I think that's the whole question.
- 32:03How do you go about doing that?
- 32:04You're saying,
- 32:04have these things called out in an RFP
- 32:07process, but give me the language.
- 32:09Give me the language that I can ask
- 32:12of somebody to say,
- 32:12I would like documentation.
- 32:13Forty to fifty pages in an RFP,
- 32:14it's too much to go through.
- 32:15We've got time.
- 32:17Crack it open.
- 32:18I've got nothing to do.
- 32:21So that's like the DSP we just talked
- 32:22about.
- 32:22Real quick,
- 32:24one thing Justin mentioned there,
- 32:25and I think we're all guilty of this
- 32:26because this is how we fix this process.
- 32:30He mentioned we do it internally.
- 32:31We do the work internally.
- 32:33We want to own the knowledge work,
- 32:34but even on some of these,
- 32:35we want to make sure we're doing the
- 32:37device configuration, the network setup,
- 32:39the programming, the commissioning.
- 32:40We're doing it with internal staff who
- 32:42know how we want things to work,
- 32:44who have that institutional knowledge.
- 32:46which means that that documentation isn't
- 32:48really part of the package because A,
- 32:50the outside entity is not doing it,
- 32:52but B,
- 32:53we are doing it and we know what
- 32:55that information is,
- 32:56which means we're kind of guilty of
- 32:57prolonging this process of poorly
- 32:59documented systems because, oh,
- 33:01we'll just fix it ourselves.
- 33:02We'll just do it ourselves.
- 33:03We know how we want this done.
- 33:04Oh, yeah,
- 33:05just deliver that so the room works.
- 33:06We're going to come back in three months
- 33:07and blow it away anyway.
- 33:08We're going to do it just like start
- 33:09with XYZ room.
- 33:10It's going to be like that for ninety
- 33:11percent.
- 33:12Then we'll change the last bit.
- 33:14I'm guilty of that.
- 33:15That's how you describe every room.
- 33:17Mark describes every project as this is
- 33:18just this with the following twenty-seven
- 33:21changes.
- 33:21And guess what?
- 33:23Everybody's like, okay.
- 33:26As somebody who was on the other side
- 33:27of that conversation, we were not like,
- 33:29okay.
- 33:29Yes, you were.
- 33:31The more that I turn a lot of
- 33:33the jobs I used to do independently over
- 33:36to the staff that I have now,
- 33:38the more I realize that
- 33:40never had to worry about any of this
- 33:42crap because it was one guy it was
- 33:44me doing it yeah it was me and
- 33:45so now i talk to them and they're
- 33:47like we have a you know the post-mortem
- 33:50on the project and they're like well we
- 33:51could have used more documentation oh yeah
- 33:56my first response to that is why didn't
- 33:58you ask for it but that's what that's
- 34:02the point i was just making justin that
- 34:04when
- 34:06More often than not,
- 34:07when those folks find themselves having to
- 34:09deliver something we're talking about,
- 34:11if they don't have the documentation,
- 34:12they just freelance and make up whatever
- 34:13the fuck they want.
- 34:14Just move forward.
- 34:15Just get it done.
- 34:18And so, I just know that...
- 34:20That's going to burn bridges and get you
- 34:22a bad rep and it's not going to
- 34:25be good for anybody.
- 34:26I think it's...
- 34:28I don't know how you propose logic in
- 34:34an RFP.
- 34:35How do you...
- 34:36Build language around that.
- 34:38Tell me your process.
- 34:39Tell me how you're doing it.
- 34:41And what is the file handoff?
- 34:43What does the proposal look like for
- 34:45review?
- 34:47For logic and things of that nature.
- 34:49Outside of just giving me a file.
- 34:50My specific RFP?
- 34:54I mean, number one,
- 34:55there's a lot of layers to this.
- 34:57So obviously you got to mention all of
- 34:59the existing standards out there.
- 35:02Secondly,
- 35:03when we're going through the RFP,
- 35:06In our specific case,
- 35:08there's three sections.
- 35:11There's one for box sales,
- 35:12one for labor only,
- 35:13and then one for a solution,
- 35:14which is what we're talking about.
- 35:16So the solution has a narrative scope of
- 35:22work that is simulated,
- 35:26wrote by a faculty member or instructor,
- 35:29not by IT.
- 35:30So we're grading...
- 35:33the responders based upon how well they
- 35:37can put together a classroom system within
- 35:40those specifications that were wrote by
- 35:43someone that's not technical,
- 35:45given a very specific budget number.
- 35:47So within that section,
- 35:49it refers back to our own standards and
- 35:53our own ways of doing things,
- 35:55which I can go into the weeds on
- 35:56that
- 35:57But there's specific notation and
- 35:59information there that if you are
- 36:01providing DSP configuration files or
- 36:03programming files as a solution,
- 36:06and let's say that the AV group is
- 36:07still here,
- 36:11that would be less than one percent of
- 36:12the cases of projects.
- 36:13Because I'm assuming the AV group is not
- 36:16there anymore if somebody is asking for
- 36:18that solution, right?
- 36:20they ask the solution through us.
- 36:22But nonetheless,
- 36:23they would be responsible for supplying
- 36:25the DSP configurations and the programming
- 36:27files to us in an open format that
- 36:30we can approve before they deploy.
- 36:33That's part of the workflow process.
- 36:34And it's really going back to a submittal
- 36:36process,
- 36:37which everybody understands the submittal
- 36:38process.
- 36:39Here's the spec sheet of what we're
- 36:40supplying.
- 36:42I've caught a lot of errors in the
- 36:44project that I'm managing through the
- 36:46submittal process based upon quantities
- 36:48and types of products.
- 36:51But again, for what we're doing,
- 36:54we don't care what they're putting on the
- 36:56boxes for configuration because part of
- 36:59the workflow built into the project is us
- 37:02coming in and deleting it and putting our
- 37:05configs on intentionally.
- 37:07That's all planned.
- 37:08It's not last minute.
- 37:10We're on the Gantt charts and everything,
- 37:13right?
- 37:13I mean, it's really no more than that.
- 37:16Less of a thing with the smaller project.
- 37:18It's the bigger ones where I see this
- 37:20being a little more challenging.
- 37:21It's actually easier on the bigger ones.
- 37:25I don't know because usually those firms
- 37:26are holding.
- 37:27Or if it's a bunch of unique stuff,
- 37:29right?
- 37:29Like athletic venues,
- 37:31things that have a very complex... Yeah,
- 37:32I mean, that can be out there.
- 37:34And that's where we see like, oh,
- 37:36you know what?
- 37:36This isn't actual.
- 37:37This wasn't...
- 37:39This file, when they came in commission,
- 37:41they actually made a different thing.
- 37:42And we end up chasing a lot of
- 37:43that stuff around.
- 37:44And sometimes we never get them.
- 37:45And also,
- 37:46you can reaffirm this on the back end
- 37:50by putting in there the closeout documents
- 37:53and the sign offs.
- 37:54Like, number one, most important thing,
- 37:56who's doing what?
- 37:58So anybody out there listening to this,
- 38:00if you don't understand the one person or
- 38:03the group of people that signs off on
- 38:04your project,
- 38:05it's probably going to fail because some
- 38:07project manager is going to do it or
- 38:08some financial person is going to do it
- 38:10because somebody's screaming at them to
- 38:11get paid and nobody really knows if it's
- 38:13done or not.
- 38:14So in that closeout documentation,
- 38:17there should be an approval process for,
- 38:19yeah, we've approved this code.
- 38:22We've approved DSP configurations.
- 38:24They actually did gain structure.
- 38:26Congrats.
- 38:27Good job, guys.
- 38:28You did gain structure, right?
- 38:29Something of that nature should be in your
- 38:32approval process as a follow-up to the
- 38:36submittal process,
- 38:38just like you would a piece of equipment.
- 38:43It just makes too much sense to me.
- 38:44I get it.
- 38:47No?
- 38:48I think it's aspirational.
- 38:50Because if we care that much about the
- 38:52programming and configs,
- 38:54we should be able to get a Q-SYS
- 38:56file or whatever and read it and go,
- 38:58oh, hey, no.
- 39:00And then work that out on a Zoom
- 39:01call and whatever.
- 39:04I think everybody wants to be at that
- 39:06level where you have...
- 39:08some process where you have the level of
- 39:11fidelity,
- 39:11where you're tracking through every,
- 39:13every one of these little things,
- 39:14a lot of folks just aren't there.
- 39:16They haven't gotten to that point.
- 39:17And we're worried.
- 39:19Oh, exactly.
- 39:19And it's through that practice and having
- 39:21lived it,
- 39:22you've got to live it on both sides.
- 39:24You've seen it from internal to internal.
- 39:26You've also seen it from the outside.
- 39:28Not everybody has that luxury, right?
- 39:31And I think more often than not,
- 39:33the conversation is usually driven from
- 39:36just raw cost of here's my materials,
- 39:39here's the time.
- 39:41And everything has been completely
- 39:43squished out where there's no additional
- 39:45resources left whatsoever to add any level
- 39:48of clarity for anything else.
- 39:50And deadlines that are unattainable.
- 39:53I don't know.
- 39:54Okay,
- 39:55just breaking it down in reality for me,
- 40:00having a customer approve a DSP
- 40:03configuration in theory should be a
- 40:08couple, three extra hours.
- 40:11Unless you're just egregious at what
- 40:14you're doing.
- 40:15Like you're just terrible at what you're
- 40:17doing.
- 40:17And then you have to rewrite everything.
- 40:18Oh,
- 40:19that's going to cause me another week of
- 40:20work.
- 40:21But I mean, theoretically,
- 40:22if you built a config file and you
- 40:24have thirty rooms and they're all the same
- 40:27and you hop on with a client for
- 40:28an hour hashing the problems out.
- 40:32It should be at least eighty percent
- 40:34correct, I would hope.
- 40:36Now,
- 40:36if we're well below the fifty percent mark
- 40:38on how correct it is,
- 40:40I could see where it starts to add
- 40:41a lot of time.
- 40:42But we're still talking one person working
- 40:45for that company making, I don't know,
- 40:48whatever, one hundred,
- 40:48one hundred twenty five dollars an hour.
- 40:50How long does it take to rework a
- 40:52whole DSP file a day?
- 40:53But you just made an assumption that I
- 40:56don't think is one hundred percent
- 40:56accurate, though,
- 40:58that you said people working for this
- 40:59integrator file or integrator company.
- 41:02I don't necessarily think that's the
- 41:03truth.
- 41:03I think sometimes it's hired freelance
- 41:05programmers and things of that nature.
- 41:08I've seen things like, oh, well,
- 41:09they had to file together so they could
- 41:11cross-check this DSP so it worked with the
- 41:13programmers.
- 41:14So they had to get something there,
- 41:16get some hex in there,
- 41:17get it so the joins can be the
- 41:18same so they can move forward.
- 41:20And guess what?
- 41:20That guy's gone.
- 41:22He's off the job.
- 41:23By the way,
- 41:24free advice for anybody as you work up
- 41:25proposals or RFPs or whatever.
- 41:27Put language in there that says no
- 41:28subcontracting without approval.
- 41:30I was going to say that's another problem.
- 41:31Yeah.
- 41:32And all employees listed,
- 41:34ask for that team who's going to be
- 41:35on the project.
- 41:36I have tossed good proposals because they
- 41:38haven't done that.
- 41:38But put that they must have worked for
- 41:40the integrator or whoever it is for at
- 41:42least a year because they will hire people
- 41:44as a contractor and then dump them,
- 41:46to your point, Mark.
- 41:47But they need to be internal resources
- 41:49because there's too much.
- 41:49I'm okay with...
- 41:50Subcontractors.
- 41:51I am not.
- 41:52Well,
- 41:53based on Mark and I's recent meetings,
- 41:55I can see where subcontractors can be a
- 41:58great thing for integrators because you
- 42:01bring in special expertise on a special
- 42:03system.
- 42:04But to your point, Chris,
- 42:06they should be pre-approved by the
- 42:10customer that, hey,
- 42:11we're going to have to use a
- 42:12subcontractor.
- 42:13This is their role.
- 42:15This is their stakeholder.
- 42:17They're on a chart separately than us.
- 42:19It's all communicated.
- 42:20It's all documented.
- 42:22It's on the up and up and it's
- 42:23transparent.
- 42:24I have a feeling that could work.
- 42:25There's not a whole like there is not
- 42:28a whole lot of pre anything happening.
- 42:31It is being built.
- 42:32That's the problem.
- 42:33It's all on time.
- 42:34It's just on time.
- 42:35Oh,
- 42:35we don't have the time to do this
- 42:37because we didn't we screw this other job
- 42:38up in Phoenix.
- 42:39So we don't have time to go over
- 42:41to Creighton and finish.
- 42:42So we're going to hire a subcontractor.
- 42:44Well, that's not great, you know,
- 42:47because it's a lot of our systems.
- 42:48Let's face it.
- 42:49A lot of our classrooms,
- 42:50a lot of our conference rooms,
- 42:51they're simple.
- 42:54It's not a stadium.
- 42:55It's not a broadcast facility.
- 42:56Didn't we just have a show talking about
- 42:58how we don't need programmers anymore?
- 43:01It's easy to program and it's not a
- 43:03big deal to... No, it's shared.
- 43:05It's a shared responsibility.
- 43:06The work still exists.
- 43:07It's just shared.
- 43:08It's just shared.
- 43:09You shouldn't really have one person
- 43:10anyways.
- 43:12Jamie, go ahead.
- 43:14When you have... Again,
- 43:16I don't have very many integrators come
- 43:18on, but when I do,
- 43:19sometimes I do get the feeling that they
- 43:21operate just like my team normally does.
- 43:23Right?
- 43:24We're just trying to get it in.
- 43:26We know what we're trying to program.
- 43:28We may program it on the fly while
- 43:30we're finishing it up.
- 43:31Like we're finishing it up.
- 43:33There is not a lot of pre-staging
- 43:36happening.
- 43:38because you're trying to turn over fit,
- 43:40forty rooms in the summer.
- 43:42And you know what it is,
- 43:43most of it's copy and paste,
- 43:44so you just kind of go with it.
- 43:46It's copy and paste from someone else's
- 43:47job, too.
- 43:48There.
- 43:49But I think that a lot of times,
- 43:51they're in that same boat.
- 43:53There's not that pre-coordination,
- 43:54because it's not actually being pre-done.
- 43:58And
- 44:00therein lies some of the problems as they
- 44:02come in and say, well,
- 44:02this is what we provide all of our
- 44:04other education institutions.
- 44:05Yeah, but that's not what we- Yeah,
- 44:07I had somebody pull that a couple of
- 44:09months ago on,
- 44:11or maybe it was a couple of years,
- 44:11I can't remember when it was,
- 44:13where someone tried to,
- 44:14they basically tried to buffalo, hey,
- 44:16we want this to do X, Y,
- 44:17and Z, and they were bringing the, well,
- 44:20at other schools, we've done this.
- 44:21I'm like, dude,
- 44:22wrong thing to say when I've got an
- 44:24AVP on the line here.
- 44:25So-
- 44:27One other thing I did want to note
- 44:28is that we often,
- 44:31to the point about approving DSP files,
- 44:33I've never done that.
- 44:34I'm not going to waste my time on
- 44:35that.
- 44:36I will ask an integrator to deploy a
- 44:39system that works,
- 44:41load your basic program,
- 44:42your test program, whatever you want.
- 44:43And I don't care,
- 44:44because I'm going to wipe it out and
- 44:45replace it with my stuff.
- 44:46However,
- 44:46that does not fix the lack of
- 44:48documentation thing.
- 44:49That just means I'm asking them to turn
- 44:50over a functional system, which,
- 44:52by the way,
- 44:53sometimes blows my mind that isn't
- 44:56That's ready for you, is it really?
- 44:58But a functional system,
- 44:59just confirm routing and basic
- 45:01functionality,
- 45:01the mics are working and all the channels
- 45:03are routed and all the rest, that's fine.
- 45:06But I'm going to load my own stuff
- 45:07on there anyway,
- 45:08but then that means I'm now in charge
- 45:10of it and all that institutional knowledge
- 45:12is staying with my team because we know
- 45:14where that is.
- 45:14So it's not addressing that fundamental
- 45:16issue of not getting that documentation or
- 45:18not getting things documented well,
- 45:20because we're as guilty as anybody about
- 45:21not fully documenting that.
- 45:23I do think we need to have a
- 45:24separate discussion on how we put together
- 45:26RFPs,
- 45:26because there's a lot of tips and tricks
- 45:28on this to put them together in such
- 45:29a way that protects you.
- 45:31And the last time I did this several
- 45:33years ago at Wyoming,
- 45:35where I built this out and very
- 45:36successfully delivered over a hundred
- 45:38spaces over a couple of years,
- 45:40The first time we lit that up with
- 45:42an integrator after going through the full
- 45:44evaluation process and all the rest,
- 45:46there was a huge amount of pushback
- 45:47because a lot of things we are discussing
- 45:49right now were in those documents,
- 45:51and they had never seen that before,
- 45:53to that level of control and management of
- 45:56it and oversight.
- 45:57They had never seen that.
- 45:58They're used to coming in, to your point,
- 46:00Mark,
- 46:00they're going from job to job to job,
- 46:02coming in,
- 46:02delivering an operational system that
- 46:03works just fine, it does what they want,
- 46:05it's just how they do it in other
- 46:06spaces,
- 46:07and then on they go somewhere else.
- 46:08They're not worried about delivering
- 46:10specifically what Oregon State needs.
- 46:12They're worrying about delivering what,
- 46:14you know, the room,
- 46:15it works for the room,
- 46:16it works for the space, whatever,
- 46:17but it's the same thing they did at
- 46:18three other schools,
- 46:19so why not just do this?
- 46:20Which means there's a lot of that out
- 46:22there, too.
- 46:23By the way,
- 46:23for those of you who every now and
- 46:24then come across a keypad on your touch
- 46:25panel, try Nineteen Eighty-Eight.
- 46:26It probably works.
- 46:28Just saying.
- 46:30And for us, it's...
- 46:31I mean, the five of us,
- 46:33we're accustomed to being able to like,
- 46:35oh, they screwed it up.
- 46:36We'll blitz it and do it again.
- 46:38Big deal.
- 46:38No problem.
- 46:41Sometimes it's so egregious it is a
- 46:43problem to redo.
- 46:43Well...
- 46:45there but there are there are there's
- 46:47hundreds of thousands of dollars of labor
- 46:49needed to fix a building there are some
- 46:52of our some of our peers that aren't
- 46:56at that level of competencies or they're
- 46:58not able to do these things and i
- 47:01think sometimes these documentation
- 47:03packages are super important for them as
- 47:05well because they're critical to any
- 47:06project but you're right i mean i
- 47:09Again, I've been around for a long time.
- 47:11I know, Chris,
- 47:12you've jumped from place to place to
- 47:13place.
- 47:13Larry,
- 47:13you've jumped from place to place to
- 47:14place.
- 47:14I worked at the same place for twenty-five
- 47:15years.
- 47:16What are you talking about?
- 47:16Right.
- 47:17He's worked for Chris Incorporated for
- 47:19twenty-five years.
- 47:20Independent Amalgamated.
- 47:25But you've walked in and been like, well,
- 47:27why is this doing it this way?
- 47:28How come we have individual on-offs for
- 47:30every single screen?
- 47:31How come we can't just have one?
- 47:34That's on the tech page.
- 47:36It's on the tech page.
- 47:37Why do we even have a tech page?
- 47:39Advanced page B.
- 47:40But I do feel like some of this
- 47:42discussion for those folks who do have to
- 47:44go in and kind of be the owner
- 47:47sign off, the owner representative, like,
- 47:49well,
- 47:49I don't even know what they asked for.
- 47:51And that's where it becomes frustrating.
- 47:53If you're signing off on something that
- 47:54you don't know what was asked for,
- 47:56you're in the wrong place at the wrong
- 47:58time.
- 47:58Justin,
- 47:58I'm going to blow your mind right now
- 47:59and make you angry.
- 48:00I'm going to make Justin physically angry
- 48:01right now.
- 48:02You're assuming there's a sign-off.
- 48:04Right.
- 48:05Because a lot of them, there's not.
- 48:08There's always a sign-off.
- 48:10It may be to the AV and the
- 48:11electrician signs off,
- 48:12and then no one else ever sees it
- 48:14at the university level.
- 48:15But there's always a sign-off.
- 48:17Unless it's just an ad hoc job that
- 48:20they came in.
- 48:20But I'm talking capital construction.
- 48:23There's a sign-off up at the GC level.
- 48:25That's what I'm saying.
- 48:26But you're talking about sign-off from the
- 48:29IT AV people who are signing off on
- 48:31getting delivered what they want.
- 48:34Basically, they walk in and they're like,
- 48:36well, there's a thing.
- 48:36That should be an initial scope of work
- 48:38that who signs off.
- 48:39Define stakeholders and who's doing what.
- 48:41And guess who's often,
- 48:42we talked about this a lot,
- 48:43guess who's often not a stakeholder?
- 48:46Who's not involved until it's too late?
- 48:49Us.
- 48:49Take it in the end.
- 48:51That's a process problem.
- 48:52Yes, very much so.
- 48:53So it is.
- 48:54Yes.
- 48:54That's not a documentation problem.
- 48:56It's a process.
- 48:57And for those of you who are running
- 48:58into that,
- 48:59as I am enjoying now and projects in
- 49:01flight before I got here, that's fine.
- 49:03It happens.
- 49:03It is a multi-year process to get that
- 49:05changed, and we will change it,
- 49:07and it will get fixed,
- 49:08but it is a multi-year process to do
- 49:10that.
- 49:11And even when you think you have it
- 49:12nailed...
- 49:14Like, I just inherited one.
- 49:16Where'd this come from?
- 49:17Right?
- 49:19How did this get to here?
- 49:20What is this?
- 49:21I was talking to someone yesterday about
- 49:23one of the current projects in flight,
- 49:25which has an issue that I'm going to
- 49:26have a meeting right after this to fix
- 49:27because I have a solution for it.
- 49:28I'm not concerned.
- 49:30And he mentioned, oh,
- 49:31and we're also going to be doing this
- 49:32one and this one and this one and
- 49:33this one and this one over the next
- 49:34five years.
- 49:35And I was like,
- 49:36I'm glad to know about that because
- 49:38otherwise I would find out about those
- 49:40every year or so when they bring it
- 49:42up again.
- 49:43So now that I know way out in
- 49:44advance,
- 49:45we can get out in front of that
- 49:46and get some cohesive things put together.
- 49:48By the way...
- 49:50to identify your division,
- 49:50twenty seven stuff.
- 49:52Well, twenty seven,
- 49:52twenty eight and twenty nine now,
- 49:53which is showing up for a lot of
- 49:54people in construction master documents,
- 49:58run that through your facilities,
- 49:59get that as part of their generic bid
- 50:01package.
- 50:01So if nothing else,
- 50:02when that goes out to architects and
- 50:04design firms,
- 50:05they at least are aware of how you
- 50:06like to do things as far as general
- 50:08layouts,
- 50:09but also general operations and how you
- 50:11want things to flow and how you want
- 50:12things to work.
- 50:13So if nothing else,
- 50:14they've seen that and hopefully they will
- 50:15pay attention to that.
- 50:16And that will be reflected in your
- 50:17document.
- 50:18And when they do copy and paste from
- 50:20some other project,
- 50:20they will at least change the name of
- 50:22that project so it doesn't say University
- 50:23of Minnesota.
- 50:26Just seeing that one.
- 50:27That's right.
- 50:29It's a good spot.
- 50:29That's very specific.
- 50:33It is.
- 50:33Well, you know, New Mexico,
- 50:34which one do you want?
- 50:35You didn't have a lot to contribute to
- 50:36the conversation.
- 50:37Justin, you were just going to sit back.
- 50:38You did a great job of just sitting
- 50:40back on this one.
- 50:40Yeah, seriously.
- 50:42Well, it went,
- 50:43it did not go the way I thought
- 50:44it was going to go.
- 50:45It went exactly.
- 50:45It never does.
- 50:47It says the lack of documentation from
- 50:49consultants.
- 50:50And we basically talked about lack of
- 50:52documentation from integrators because,
- 50:56well, I,
- 50:57That's two different things.
- 50:59To be fair,
- 50:59I wasn't on the call and I was
- 51:01making that up.
- 51:02Yeah.
- 51:02So to me,
- 51:04it's still like the consultants may have
- 51:06had the needs analysis meeting.
- 51:08Consultants may have met with whoever the
- 51:10project admin is.
- 51:12Not really the end users,
- 51:14but that capture,
- 51:15that case study didn't get moved down the
- 51:19line.
- 51:19Like there is missing documentation in
- 51:21that handoff.
- 51:23That's a great comment from our friend
- 51:24Teddy.
- 51:26That's a reference to his first comment.
- 51:27Teddy,
- 51:28you can't correct comments that are live
- 51:29on a stream.
- 51:30It doesn't work that way.
- 51:30I missed the first comment from Teddy,
- 51:32so I just see not.
- 51:33This one's more important.
- 51:33This is the most important comment.
- 51:35That changes the whole context of
- 51:36everything.
- 51:36Thanks, Teddy.
- 51:37Thanks a lot.
- 51:37I'm sure he loves it.
- 51:40yeah anyway okay so yeah all right did
- 51:42we solve it are we done no absolutely
- 51:44not we're just bitching about missing
- 51:46listen if you're if you're an integrator
- 51:49just communicate proactively and you'll
- 51:52really get some buy-in from the
- 51:54universities you're working for and you'll
- 51:56probably save a lot of money and headache
- 51:58down the road by doing so free also
- 52:01you're for an integrator
- 52:02find out who the actual like owner of
- 52:04these systems and owner.
- 52:05I don't mean the project sponsor.
- 52:06I don't mean the champion.
- 52:07I mean, who's going to be supporting,
- 52:09who's going to have to maintain that for
- 52:10the next ten years?
- 52:11Go find that team.
- 52:13Go find the manager of that of that
- 52:15group.
- 52:15And don't assume just because you have it
- 52:17in your documentation that, oh,
- 52:18the integrator is going to support it for
- 52:20a year.
- 52:20Yeah, integrators two hours away.
- 52:22Yeah, they're coming on Thursday.
- 52:23And the integrator doesn't want to drive
- 52:26back and forth that much.
- 52:27But I was going to say,
- 52:29go find that AV or that IT team
- 52:31who's going to have to maintain these
- 52:32systems and go make friends with them
- 52:33because they're going to be a good project
- 52:35advocate for you in the future.
- 52:36Finding stakeholders and who's doing what.
- 52:38First step.
- 52:39And they're hearing it, the forum,
- 52:40they're listening, like,
- 52:41I'm not doing that.
- 52:42That sounds like work.
- 52:44That's not in my contract.
- 52:45Do you work now?
- 52:46They already won the bid.
- 52:48Move on.
- 52:48I got to go on site?
- 52:49Can this be a team's call?
- 52:51Maybe?
- 52:52No.
- 52:54Freaking show up on campus.
- 52:55I'm here every day, so are you.
- 52:56All right.
- 52:57We're going to take a quick break.
- 52:59We're going to come back.
- 52:59We're going to talk about,
- 53:00what are we talking about next?
- 53:01I have no idea.
- 53:03It's written down somewhere.
- 53:04Other people's problems.
- 53:05Other people's stuff.
- 53:07Other people's stuff.
- 53:10Not.
- 53:11Not ours?
- 53:12Back in one minute, one minute,
- 53:13twelve seconds.
- 53:15The AV Superfriends are supported by
- 53:17Neutrik Group Americas.
- 53:19And you know what the AV industry needs
- 53:21more of?
- 53:22No, not another cloud dashboard.
- 53:25We need training.
- 53:27Hands-on training.
- 53:28Because before the network,
- 53:30before the room system appliance,
- 53:32before the AI camera that insists on
- 53:35looking out the window, there's layer one.
- 53:38the physical stuff, the connections,
- 53:40the infrastructure,
- 53:42the things that either work or ruin
- 53:44everyone's afternoon.
- 53:46That's why Neutrik is investing in
- 53:48practical education built around
- 53:50real-world skills and repeatable results.
- 53:53Their FAST method creates a simple,
- 53:59memorable workflow for proper termination
- 54:02practices.
- 54:03It's hands-on training for the people
- 54:05building, supporting, designing,
- 54:07and maintaining AV systems in the real
- 54:10world.
- 54:11Because Layer One gets it done.
- 54:14Neutrik.
- 54:15What to use.
- 54:16When to use it.
- 54:18Why it matters.
- 54:20To find out more,
- 54:21email fast.training at neutrikgroup.com
- 54:28I really don't know where this next
- 54:30conversation is going to go either.
- 54:32We're counting on you to step up just
- 54:33as much as you did in the previous
- 54:34one.
- 54:34Justin,
- 54:34you can sit back on this one too.
- 54:35I'm going to to figure out what we're
- 54:37talking about.
- 54:37I see what we're talking about,
- 54:39but I don't know which fork in the
- 54:40road you're going to take.
- 54:42It doesn't work in a ramp model.
- 54:43All right.
- 54:44So, Mark,
- 54:45I think this was also one of your
- 54:46complaints.
- 54:47The concept of how do you...
- 54:48This is actually not a complaint.
- 54:50I guess, no,
- 54:50it's a question because you get asked,
- 54:52what do we do about X, Y,
- 54:54and Z spaces or this building or whatever?
- 54:56Stuff that's not yours.
- 54:57You didn't install it.
- 54:58You don't own it.
- 54:59You don't maintain it.
- 55:00But now they're asking, well,
- 55:01what's it going to cost to replace this?
- 55:02Is that fair?
- 55:03That's the bulk of the question.
- 55:05I think there's a little more nuance in
- 55:07there.
- 55:07I'm going to give you three words.
- 55:08I'll solve all your problems right now.
- 55:09I need specifics too, Mark.
- 55:11No, no, no.
- 55:11I'm solving it.
- 55:12I'm solving it right now.
- 55:13Forty seconds in.
- 55:14Shared Google spreadsheet.
- 55:19It's not technically wrong.
- 55:20You're not technically wrong.
- 55:21Multiple shared Google spreadsheets.
- 55:23Shared tabs.
- 55:25So recently I've been asked from –
- 55:29lots of departments hey do you have
- 55:31anything that just shows us all of our
- 55:33stuff right that definitely that's the
- 55:37blanket all of our stuff is and we're
- 55:39like um we know about a lot of
- 55:42it things we were involved but i don't
- 55:44have a comprehensive list and i'm not
- 55:45keeping a list of all of your stuff
- 55:47right there it is right and it's easy
- 55:52to have that but i was just curious
- 55:53is anybody out there
- 55:55tracking in like a public dashboard area
- 55:59and don't don't you say tell them because
- 56:01that's not that's not the answer that's
- 56:05where you want to go in a public
- 56:06dashboard area like
- 56:09life cycle management of things that are
- 56:10not necessarily wholly your,
- 56:12if your general purpose or common,
- 56:14or do you have such a mechanism in
- 56:16which it's out there that it's literally
- 56:17not go to the thing, click on it.
- 56:20You can see when it was installed.
- 56:21That's not what I'm asking.
- 56:22Something that's intentionally built,
- 56:23like as a life cycle management,
- 56:25your stuff is X years old.
- 56:26It's due at this point in time.
- 56:28Anybody, if I know about it, if,
- 56:31if you know about it,
- 56:32so you do have something,
- 56:33what's it look like?
- 56:33It's a shared Google doc, isn't it?
- 56:35Oh no, it, but yeah, it's a shared,
- 56:36shared spreadsheet, but,
- 56:39Because why would we put any more efforts
- 56:41in that?
- 56:42So we have to.
- 56:46There's been a lot of turnover.
- 56:47There's a lot of turnover in a lot
- 56:48of departments.
- 56:49And so a lot of people don't understand
- 56:50their full domain.
- 56:51Right.
- 56:51Asking for it because they're trying to
- 56:52get budgets in line.
- 56:54And they're like, oh,
- 56:54we're trying to get a jump on it
- 56:55this year for next year.
- 56:56So can you just give us the full
- 56:58thing we want to know?
- 56:58What should we be expecting?
- 57:00This has happened more to me over the
- 57:02last year than it has in a very
- 57:04long time.
- 57:05And mostly because we've had four or five
- 57:09deans turn over.
- 57:11And they come in and they're trying to
- 57:12lifecycle manage.
- 57:13And we have departments out there who have
- 57:15done their own thing, right?
- 57:17Especially, you know,
- 57:17science and engineering.
- 57:18Can I ask a quick question, Jamie?
- 57:20When these deans come in and they're
- 57:22trying to plan lifecycle management,
- 57:23are they actually being proactive and
- 57:26thinking about
- 57:27No, it's just electronics.
- 57:30Yes.
- 57:33Within the last year, yes,
- 57:34because the pricing for computers has gone
- 57:36up.
- 57:37The pricing for things have gone up.
- 57:39They're also finding out that they have a
- 57:40whole bunch of space.
- 57:41And they're pre-aware of this coming in.
- 57:43The deans aren't.
- 57:44They're just tired of getting questions
- 57:45from people.
- 57:46Hearing things are not working.
- 57:48This doesn't work.
- 57:48This room doesn't work.
- 57:50What's going on there?
- 57:51How much does it cost to fix this?
- 57:53I want to replace this.
- 57:54And what these new administrators are
- 57:57finding out is that people are wanting to
- 58:00replace things and get budgeting from
- 58:03stuff that isn't IS supported,
- 58:05but they're trying to get IS to come.
- 58:07So normally we come in and we're like,
- 58:08ah, so...
- 58:10This is a problem.
- 58:11Let's try to figure this out.
- 58:12And now this is when that answer comes
- 58:14up.
- 58:14Well, how much stuff do we have?
- 58:17Well, here's what I have.
- 58:19And you're not on the list because there
- 58:21are things that just pop up.
- 58:23I'm looking here and I'm not seeing the
- 58:27invite.
- 58:28It's like the Santa Claus thing.
- 58:29Nope.
- 58:30So here you're naughty.
- 58:30You don't have to go home.
- 58:32You just can't stay here.
- 58:34But I've had in this last year and
- 58:36most people now they're trying to
- 58:38pre-spend money now.
- 58:41They're trying to spend money right now
- 58:43because they don't want to have a budget
- 58:45in March.
- 58:46They want it gone by January.
- 58:48They don't want to play the end of
- 58:49year money problem.
- 58:51Let's just pretend there's none.
- 58:52Let's start.
- 58:53There's no money.
- 58:54And I know what that's like casting out
- 58:57like multiple years.
- 58:58Like, hey,
- 58:58I need to know where I'm at this
- 59:00year, next year, three years out.
- 59:02So can you give me the comprehensive list
- 59:03of life cycle management so I can make
- 59:05sure I'm earmarking those funds now for
- 59:08them?
- 59:09It's not that there's a magic bundle of
- 59:10money right now they're trying to divvy
- 59:11out.
- 59:11There's none.
- 59:12They've got to make the ask.
- 59:14Real quick question on that.
- 59:16Are they asking –
- 59:18what the current value is of what they've
- 59:21got or what they're asking for,
- 59:23what the replacement cost is for all their
- 59:25stuff.
- 59:26Right.
- 59:27How much technical debt exists and what's
- 59:28it going to cost me to get rid
- 59:29of that debt or replace it?
- 59:31Right.
- 59:32And so,
- 59:33and this has just kind of been generated
- 59:35lately and it always stems from one system
- 59:38and then you find out there's a lot
- 59:39more.
- 59:39And now as we find them,
- 59:41we add them to the sheet or we
- 59:42subtract them from the sheets because
- 59:44again,
- 59:46Justin,
- 59:46you're very aware that some people do
- 59:48their own thing,
- 59:50and then they call you and want you
- 59:51to support it.
- 59:52But I had no idea it even existed.
- 59:54So we do put them in our sheets
- 59:58and stuff and try to keep track of
- 59:59it.
- 1:00:00But man,
- 1:00:00besides just going to kick in every single
- 1:00:02door on campus open,
- 1:00:05I don't know what's out there.
- 1:00:06And honestly, some of it, I don't care.
- 1:00:08Part of it is a cultural thing, too,
- 1:00:10because I have a mechanism that I know
- 1:00:13The age and date of all the systems
- 1:00:15that are on campus,
- 1:00:17even the departmental ones.
- 1:00:18The problem is I have no control over
- 1:00:20what their perceived life cycle is because
- 1:00:23it's the department stuff.
- 1:00:24I'm with Larry.
- 1:00:26And so I can't tell them it's in
- 1:00:27the law.
- 1:00:27You don't have a tag or a flag
- 1:00:28installed on this date and it should be
- 1:00:30technically due on this date?
- 1:00:33I can't tell them what the end of
- 1:00:34life is because they can still walk in
- 1:00:36and hit the extra on power on button
- 1:00:38and touch here.
- 1:00:39It still works.
- 1:00:39Kind of works.
- 1:00:40And so, yes.
- 1:00:42Right.
- 1:00:42And so it's not dead.
- 1:00:43So we're not replacing it in PS one
- 1:00:45hundreds.
- 1:00:45Oh, and these,
- 1:00:47these are the things that get,
- 1:00:48get hidden away sometimes that we're asked
- 1:00:51to come back and resupport or what will
- 1:00:53it cost to fix?
- 1:00:54And those are the ones where we've got
- 1:00:55to put it back in there.
- 1:00:58put it on our list or again,
- 1:01:00maybe it moved.
- 1:01:01We've had that happen too.
- 1:01:03Hey,
- 1:01:03we're going to do this thing in that
- 1:01:04room.
- 1:01:05Oh, I have a whole system in there.
- 1:01:06Oh no, it got moved.
- 1:01:10What?
- 1:01:11So, Chris,
- 1:01:11you had some things queued up here.
- 1:01:14It looks like you're about to show us
- 1:01:15something.
- 1:01:16Oh, Jesus.
- 1:01:16I'm not going to blow your minds.
- 1:01:18No, you're not.
- 1:01:19You're going to show us this
- 1:01:20over-engineered solution.
- 1:01:21I thought this was a podcast.
- 1:01:23What's wrong with this?
- 1:01:23What?
- 1:01:24What is this?
- 1:01:24What are we looking at here?
- 1:01:25So here's how to map an entire campus
- 1:01:28for building your dashboard for end of
- 1:01:31life.
- 1:01:31It doesn't have numbers on it.
- 1:01:32It doesn't have monetary value yet.
- 1:01:36I can do that.
- 1:01:37That sure as hell looks like somebody
- 1:01:39vibed that up.
- 1:01:40damn right I did because the question was
- 1:01:43what exactly that's where that's where
- 1:01:46things are going right and I think that's
- 1:01:47right but but here's so here's my approach
- 1:01:48to this and I'm going to talk about
- 1:01:49this at ETC next week Justin and I
- 1:01:50are going to be presenting on it um
- 1:01:53camera yeah it is damn right it's AI
- 1:01:55I'm not going to write this crap what's
- 1:01:56not any of this well it's produced by
- 1:01:58AI it's actually not AI
- 1:02:00But that's what I'm saying.
- 1:02:02Are you envisioning a public-facing
- 1:02:04dashboard?
- 1:02:04Yes.
- 1:02:05So it's got to land somewhere.
- 1:02:06OK, go ahead.
- 1:02:07Right.
- 1:02:08And I could do a simpler version of
- 1:02:09this for them.
- 1:02:09But what I want to show is it's
- 1:02:10not based on age.
- 1:02:11It's not just because, Larry,
- 1:02:12you mentioned,
- 1:02:12you don't know what the life cycle is
- 1:02:13on that.
- 1:02:14It's based on utilization.
- 1:02:15It's based on how critical is it if
- 1:02:16this system goes down.
- 1:02:17It's based on how complex of a system
- 1:02:20it is,
- 1:02:20which just drives people nuts to go deal
- 1:02:22with.
- 1:02:22Impact on students.
- 1:02:23it that's the that's the criticality one
- 1:02:25that's that category in there and that's
- 1:02:27defined right up here justin you can see
- 1:02:28uh how consequential is failure um it
- 1:02:33talks about doing like modesties or like
- 1:02:35easy wins like hey if i just go
- 1:02:36in and change out like x y and
- 1:02:37z in these rooms i will earn how
- 1:02:39much political capital with that group i
- 1:02:41do that so some of these things you
- 1:02:43can start to build this and track it
- 1:02:45what my point on this is not to
- 1:02:46say this is a comprehensive solution but
- 1:02:48my point on this is
- 1:02:49you can start to put together these tools
- 1:02:50to share this sort of information to make
- 1:02:52to kind of surface some of this to
- 1:02:54make it that much more visible pretty
- 1:02:55straightforward to do um to start tracking
- 1:02:58some of these things even if you don't
- 1:03:00own the system so this is something i
- 1:03:01didn't use talim three to do this i
- 1:03:02didn't do all that now there are more
- 1:03:05tools out there like talim three that do
- 1:03:06a great job of of this sort of
- 1:03:08like more comprehensive tracking to do
- 1:03:10actual financial modeling and all that
- 1:03:12stuff
- 1:03:13I will say at the outset,
- 1:03:14I don't care who owned and Jamie,
- 1:03:15I think you phrase it this way.
- 1:03:16I don't care who owns a space or
- 1:03:17who bought it.
- 1:03:18I am going to go kick down every
- 1:03:19door on campus and I'm going to document
- 1:03:21all of that.
- 1:03:21So at least I know what's out there
- 1:03:23because maybe the opportunity is there
- 1:03:25down the road.
- 1:03:26I'm going to go upgrade my hundred and
- 1:03:28fifty rooms,
- 1:03:28but those other hundred rooms that really
- 1:03:30aren't mine.
- 1:03:30Oh,
- 1:03:30but I have some projectors and there's
- 1:03:32ones over there in the College of Business
- 1:03:33are so lamp based.
- 1:03:34I'm going to put in my projectors in
- 1:03:35there to get those lamps off of campus.
- 1:03:37So I can do some of those things,
- 1:03:38but I need to know what's in those
- 1:03:40spaces.
- 1:03:40So I am very much a fan of
- 1:03:43owning the entire campus.
- 1:03:44I don't care who paid for it or
- 1:03:45what it is.
- 1:03:45I'm still going to own that stuff.
- 1:03:47I think there's,
- 1:03:48you have a lot of nuance in there
- 1:03:49from what you shared, right?
- 1:03:51And I understand that's like beta X,
- 1:03:53like that's,
- 1:03:54you're just envisioning getting ideas
- 1:03:55together.
- 1:03:57That would be way more detailed than the
- 1:03:59casual user.
- 1:04:00Yeah, they don't need that.
- 1:04:01That's my version.
- 1:04:01That's your version.
- 1:04:02That's internal to you.
- 1:04:03What we've asked is like, or been asked,
- 1:04:05sorry, is where is it?
- 1:04:08And one dollar sign, two dollar sign,
- 1:04:11three dollar sign, and when?
- 1:04:14And that would be easy to do from
- 1:04:15that same information?
- 1:04:16That's kind of what it comes down to.
- 1:04:17That's how I shop for food.
- 1:04:18That's what I'm saying.
- 1:04:19It's basically that.
- 1:04:20Yes, you're looking at a restaurant.
- 1:04:21Oh, that's two dollar signs.
- 1:04:22I got liquor.
- 1:04:23I got liquor.
- 1:04:24i don't know and so that that's kind
- 1:04:25of that's the experience and that i'm
- 1:04:27going to add that to that chart right
- 1:04:28now you should but that's what people five
- 1:04:30code the out of that people don't want
- 1:04:31the details this one i know how much
- 1:04:33this is going to cost and when do
- 1:04:34i need to pay it like that's that's
- 1:04:36a lot and now that's what they're thinking
- 1:04:38and they're like i can't do that right
- 1:04:39now so i know i need to do
- 1:04:41it sometime so i'm looking at the menu
- 1:04:43i'd like to have the number two and
- 1:04:45blah blah blah like let's go but
- 1:04:48We haven't really been in a place where
- 1:04:50we're doing these public-facing
- 1:04:51dashboards,
- 1:04:52showing that technical debt out that way.
- 1:04:53So I'm just curious.
- 1:04:55Why do you keep saying publicly-facing?
- 1:04:56I'm curious.
- 1:04:57Is that something you would openly share,
- 1:04:58or is that you would share upon request?
- 1:05:00That's the ask.
- 1:05:00We'd like to have a dashboard in which
- 1:05:02any department can say,
- 1:05:04I can find my stuff and know where
- 1:05:05my debt is.
- 1:05:07Okay.
- 1:05:08Is that going to,
- 1:05:09is the goal there also to kind of
- 1:05:10publicly, and by public,
- 1:05:12I mean to shame people?
- 1:05:13I'm curious to say that.
- 1:05:15No, it's not.
- 1:05:15I would.
- 1:05:16I would.
- 1:05:16Hey, that's not the point.
- 1:05:18I'm with you.
- 1:05:19Hey, School of Humanities,
- 1:05:20your stuff is really old and out of
- 1:05:22date.
- 1:05:22And now as it gets older,
- 1:05:23it's now going to cost you three dollar
- 1:05:24signs to replace.
- 1:05:26Then you've got College of Engineering up
- 1:05:28here.
- 1:05:28Their stuff's pretty new,
- 1:05:29and it's only one dollar sign to replace
- 1:05:31right now because it's in good shape.
- 1:05:32think most of it's also just understanding
- 1:05:35as that leadership rolls over them under
- 1:05:37like having us like oh they need to
- 1:05:38know what they're responsible for spaces
- 1:05:40and they were each costing me twenty
- 1:05:42thousand dollars a piece like oh i had
- 1:05:43no idea most of them have no idea
- 1:05:45until five instructors complained hey i
- 1:05:47was over in xyz hall and it's been
- 1:05:48failing continuously do you know we need
- 1:05:49to replace this like i didn't even know
- 1:05:51we owned that place right and that's
- 1:05:53that's the reality
- 1:05:54I had a very interesting and enlightening
- 1:05:55conversation with a dean of the College of
- 1:05:58Engineering several years ago about
- 1:05:59exactly this, where he basically said,
- 1:06:01I didn't know I was responsible for these.
- 1:06:03I didn't know I owned these.
- 1:06:04I didn't know this was even,
- 1:06:05and why are these so expensive?
- 1:06:07And we talked through it,
- 1:06:07and his background is in electrical
- 1:06:09engineering and computer science.
- 1:06:10And he was like, oh, OK,
- 1:06:12that makes sense.
- 1:06:12And it was like an hour-long conversation
- 1:06:14that he finally like,
- 1:06:15you could see his brain like click, oh.
- 1:06:17Now I see what's going on there.
- 1:06:19Okay, thank you.
- 1:06:19And then to his credit,
- 1:06:21because College of Engineering usually has
- 1:06:23the funds, to his credit, he was like,
- 1:06:24oh, you want to replace that?
- 1:06:25I'll set aside the funds.
- 1:06:26We can't do it this fiscal.
- 1:06:27We're going to start blocking that out.
- 1:06:28And we started knocking those rooms off
- 1:06:31every fiscal year.
- 1:06:32We did a couple more because they
- 1:06:33recognized they needed to do it.
- 1:06:34And they were getting those,
- 1:06:35to your point,
- 1:06:35they're getting those complaints from
- 1:06:36their faculty,
- 1:06:37from their students about these things,
- 1:06:38or students complaining to faculty,
- 1:06:39faculty complaining to the dean.
- 1:06:40on how how are they going to address
- 1:06:42this and now that he knows what's involved
- 1:06:44in that when I said to replace your
- 1:06:45two active learning classrooms and we can
- 1:06:47leave a lot of the infrastructure in place
- 1:06:48but it's going to cost you eighty thousand
- 1:06:49dollars to do both of these their response
- 1:06:51was okay and you add more displays to
- 1:06:54them though I added all the displays I
- 1:06:56took all the ones out of storage and
- 1:06:57they're scattered around it's not the
- 1:06:59display displays in front of the other
- 1:07:01it's not the display that matters it's the
- 1:07:04matrix cross point on the touch panel did
- 1:07:07you get that done
- 1:07:08I gave them the advanced page.
- 1:07:09Actually, we did.
- 1:07:10We piloted an advanced page in there.
- 1:07:12I got forty MPS-one-hundreds I can send
- 1:07:14you.
- 1:07:16Justin,
- 1:07:16I offered to send you NoFool and a
- 1:07:17whole bunch of DM chassis.
- 1:07:19I don't want those.
- 1:07:19No issue, too.
- 1:07:21You want to put those MPSs in front
- 1:07:22of those DM chassis.
- 1:07:24That adds flexibility.
- 1:07:28So my advice on this broad topic,
- 1:07:30because we're all going to get asked this
- 1:07:31question at some point.
- 1:07:32My advice on this broad topic,
- 1:07:34go kick down those doors and document
- 1:07:36everything.
- 1:07:36And if you don't have time to do
- 1:07:37it, I'll just say, free idea here.
- 1:07:39And this is a fantastic opportunity.
- 1:07:40Find the right student who likes
- 1:07:42organizing stuff.
- 1:07:43Just kind of aim them at campus and
- 1:07:45let them go.
- 1:07:45And I will say,
- 1:07:46as someone who's done this,
- 1:07:47this will be my third time now doing
- 1:07:48this.
- 1:07:49it will take two or three students about
- 1:07:51a year to get all this information so
- 1:07:54it is a process but when you're done
- 1:07:56you now have all the things to build
- 1:07:58the complex financial models that you want
- 1:08:00have you seen those like robotic dogs that
- 1:08:02can like go and scan through that that's
- 1:08:03like what we need right we need like
- 1:08:05one we can sit out there i don't
- 1:08:06even know why you guys are doing this
- 1:08:07now i just i just use the wi-fi
- 1:08:09signal great okay yes i just map all
- 1:08:14the rooms with the wi-fi
- 1:08:16Okay,
- 1:08:16did that answer any of the questions?
- 1:08:18No, not really.
- 1:08:19I'm going to show that spreadsheet again.
- 1:08:20I think we're going to see more of
- 1:08:21this stuff in the future.
- 1:08:22I'm just curious how people are
- 1:08:24approaching it because it means different
- 1:08:27things to different people when I'm
- 1:08:29looking at trying to get something off the
- 1:08:30ground.
- 1:08:31Step one is do nothing.
- 1:08:33Check.
- 1:08:34That is one way of handling it.
- 1:08:36A lot of people do that.
- 1:08:37But that's all, people are like,
- 1:08:38that's not my job, just as Cameron said.
- 1:08:39That's not my job description.
- 1:08:41We use Confluence.
- 1:08:42You ever heard of that?
- 1:08:43Yes.
- 1:08:44By Jira.
- 1:08:45Mm-hmm.
- 1:08:47I can tell you're excited about it.
- 1:08:52So anyway.
- 1:08:52It's more for support.
- 1:08:53It is what it is.
- 1:08:53Raul shares a comment.
- 1:08:54There's no problem that money can't fix.
- 1:08:55He's right there.
- 1:08:57Here's a bonus one.
- 1:08:58I like doing this.
- 1:08:59As I upgrade spaces that I'm paying for,
- 1:09:01I then save the good stuff,
- 1:09:02and that rolls down to other people on
- 1:09:04campus.
- 1:09:04They love what I do.
- 1:09:05Well, yeah.
- 1:09:06I do that.
- 1:09:07A lot of people don't do that.
- 1:09:08They will just, like, toss stuff.
- 1:09:09Like, that display is used.
- 1:09:11It used all the pixels.
- 1:09:12It depends on the school.
- 1:09:13I mean,
- 1:09:13there's probably some people listening who
- 1:09:15are like, oh, we just...
- 1:09:17burn through everything.
- 1:09:17If it's good,
- 1:09:18we're not going to replace it to begin
- 1:09:19with.
- 1:09:19We're going to leave it there.
- 1:09:20It's going to just rot in place.
- 1:09:21No.
- 1:09:21Oregon State money?
- 1:09:24No.
- 1:09:24Ohio State money.
- 1:09:24By the way, Mark, to that,
- 1:09:25and I do agree with that on things
- 1:09:26like, say, ceiling speakers.
- 1:09:28Those are good for twenty years.
- 1:09:29If it's not been twenty years,
- 1:09:30why am I taking them down?
- 1:09:31I don't know about twenty.
- 1:09:32You could probably push that.
- 1:09:33Oh, come on now.
- 1:09:34Fifty years.
- 1:09:35justin i will go with that yes but
- 1:09:37i'm saying it's a minimum twenty and i
- 1:09:38want to see like the glue has dried
- 1:09:40up and those cones are falling off and
- 1:09:41hitting the grills then yeah then i'll
- 1:09:43pull them but like you're getting black
- 1:09:44flakes in your hair as students and yeah
- 1:09:46program speakers the same idea
- 1:09:48infrastructure cable plant if that's in
- 1:09:50good shape and we'll still transport what
- 1:09:51i need to transfer well there's a lot
- 1:09:53of people who don't when they plan a
- 1:09:55refresh they're like when we built that
- 1:09:56seven years ago it cost sixty two thousand
- 1:09:58dollars so we i'm like that's not how
- 1:10:00this works but anyway
- 1:10:02Also, free thing I include, whiteboards,
- 1:10:04chalkboards, blackboards,
- 1:10:05any of that stuff.
- 1:10:06If there's a writable surface on the room,
- 1:10:07I'm going to put more in.
- 1:10:10There you go.
- 1:10:11That's a service.
- 1:10:11I just put those in.
- 1:10:12I don't care.
- 1:10:13Stack them up in the corner on top
- 1:10:15of your floor of lecterns.
- 1:10:17I'm the jerk removing them all.
- 1:10:19You want to come to my college of
- 1:10:20medicine and see the rooms with no
- 1:10:22whiteboards in them?
- 1:10:22It's weird.
- 1:10:23That is weird.
- 1:10:24It is very weird.
- 1:10:26All right.
- 1:10:27Any other thoughts on lifecycle planning,
- 1:10:28documentation, or Pepper's Ghost?
- 1:10:31it was a lot but don't do pepper's
- 1:10:32ghost do documentation put that on my
- 1:10:39tombstone yeah all right we're gonna roll
- 1:10:41out of here we'll be back next week
- 1:10:42no wait next week we're at etc so
- 1:10:44uh those of you listening to this show
- 1:10:46probably next monday or tuesday tuesday or
- 1:10:47wednesday we're at etc right now so if
- 1:10:49you're at etc so are we if you're
- 1:10:50in the penn state area come on by
- 1:10:52and say hi
- 1:10:54I don't know if we'll be able to
- 1:10:55do a show next Friday.
- 1:10:57We'll see.
- 1:10:58We'll be traveling and moving.
- 1:11:00I'll be on a plane.
- 1:11:02Maybe a car.
- 1:11:05Maybe a automobile train.
- 1:11:07Press the damn button!
- 1:11:10Maybe a jet ski.
- 1:11:11Jet ski.
- 1:11:12Jet skiing back to Kentucky.
- 1:11:14Yeah.
- 1:11:14Following every waterway he can.
- 1:11:17Dragging it across the highway.
- 1:11:19See him get from place to place to
- 1:11:20place.
- 1:11:21All right.
- 1:11:22Thanks, y'all.
- 1:11:23Back soon-ish.
- 1:11:33Well,
- 1:11:33we've managed to ruin yet another episode
- 1:11:35of AV Super Friends Off the Rails.
- 1:11:37You can contact us with questions,
- 1:11:39topic ideas,
- 1:11:39or general complaints at mailbag at
- 1:11:41avsuperfriends.com.
- 1:11:43If you complain loud enough,
- 1:11:44we might just invite you on the show.
- 1:11:49Nice work, everyone.
- 1:11:51Sharp broadcast.
- 1:11:52Really good.
- 1:11:53Everyone on the floor as well.
- 1:11:55Really a lot of hustle.
- 1:11:56I liked it.
- 1:11:57The opinions expressed by the AV
- 1:11:58Superfriends are solely those of the
- 1:11:59individuals and do not represent their
- 1:12:01respective institutions, organizations,
- 1:12:03companies, or clients.